iRAP Indonesia Demonstration Project Technical Report _IndII_.pdf

8/11/2019 iRAP Indonesia Demonstration Project Technical Report _IndII_.pdf

1/67

iRAP DEMONSTRATION

PROJECT:

TECHNICAL REPORT


2/67

I I I (III),

A G I

, .

AI A G.

III D, . +62 (21) 2306063, +62 (21) 31902994. :

....

()

A . A . A

:

I

, ,

.

A FIA F A

F.

G , D A (A),

, (AA A) L ,

E (A), I I I (III),

AAID, A I D .

M I

E D G H, III , AA

A AB G . A

.

G

A D, A

J, J 2011


3/67

C ()

A ..................................................................................................................................................3

E ..................................................................................................................................4C 1: ............................................................................................................................6

AAD ................................................... ........................................................... .. 7

A ..................................................... ......................................... 8

........................................................................................................................................... 8

C 2: .........................................................................................................................9

C 3: D ......................................................................................................................................10

C ..................................................... ........................................................... ......... 10

.................................................................. ........................................................... .......... 13

B ( ) ............................................... ....................................... 14

............................................................ ........................................................... ......... 15

15

.................................................................................................. 16

E .......................................................................................................17

D .............................................................................................................18

D .......................................................................................18

E ................................................... ....................................... 18

C ........................................................ ........................................................... ......... 19

D .......................................................................................................................................... 19

C 4: D C ....................................................................................................20

C 5: ...........................................................................................................................24

.......................................................................................................................... 24

................................................ ........................................................... ......... 25

....................................................... .......................................................... ................... 27E ................................. ........................................................... ............................ 29

C 6: ...........................................................................32

89 ( $10 ) .................................................................. 33

2.9 ( $350 ) ............................................................... 37

C 7: C A .............................................................................40

..................................................................................................... 40

3 23 ...... 40

................................................... .................... 41

................................................. .......................................................... 44

C 8: C ..................................................................................45

....................................................... .......................................................... ................... 45 ............................................................................................................................... 45

..................................................... ........................................................... ............................ 46

................................................................................................................................ 46

A ..................................................................... ........................................................... ......... 49

D 49

B ...................................................... ........................................................... ............................ 51

D A ................................................................................ ........................................ 51

E .......................................................................................................... ............................ 53

................................................................................................................ 55

..............................................................................................................................................65


4/67

C ()

1: .................................................................................4

2: A .................................................... .......................................12

3: ..................................................... .................................................15

4: ....................................................... ........175: A .................................................................18

6: ...................................................... ...........................................................25

7: ............................................ ...........................................................26

8: 89 ( $10 ) ...........34

9: 89 ( $10 )

( 20 ) .................................................................35

10: 2.9 ( $350 )

......................................................................................................................................37

11: 2.9 ( $350 )

( 20 ) ........................................................................................38

12: 1 2 ( 5) ........................................4013: C A ...............................................42

F 1: A ....................................................................................................................6

F 2: A , , ..............7

F 3: A : ( A2).....................................................9

F 4: .......................................................11

F 5: A A D (AAD) ............................................... .......................................13

F 6: B A. .....................................14

F 7: B ................................................................14F 8: ( 100 ) ...................................................... ........16

F 9: .......................................... .............................20

F 10: C .................................................... ..............................24

F 11: B ...............................25

F 12: ................................................. .......................................27

F 13: .............................................. .................................................28

F 14: ................................................. .................................................28

F 15: ..................................................... .................................................29

F 16: D ( 89 / $10 ) ...............36

F 17: D ( 2.9 / $350 ) .................39

F 18: C A ( ) ................................................... ........43

F 19: E ..............................46

F 20: ........................................................47

F 21: 100 ............................................... ..........................................................48

F 22: C

F 21 .......................................................................................................48

A 1: D .........................................................................................51

A 2: A A .............................................................................................................56

A 3: C C ..........................................................................................................61


5/67

:

3 40

AAD A A D

AAD A G

DG D G

A A

E E


6/67

:

4 40

H 37,438 I

2007, 61% (H, 2009).

I 6% ,

.

I, A

AAID, I I I (III), D G

H (DGH) .

836 J L J ( C C J),

.

I 6,897 J L

J , $550 .

.

,

50 100 ,

J L J 1 2 ( 5),

. A , (43%)

1 2 . 2

(72%), (66%) 2 . 17% 1 2

.

1:

()

836 2% 15% 34% 36% 14%

836 11% 32% 26% 29% 2%

836 0% 72% 28% 0% 0%

B * 836 0% 66% 14% 9% 0%

* 12% .

A 31% 4 5 , 43%

,

( ) . A (34%)

1 2 .

. 41%

; 44%

.

I , :


7/67

:

5 40

A 89 ( $10 ) 142

, 23% . 20 ,

14,000 ( $1.6 )

.

A 2.9 ( $350 ) 313 , 50% . 20 ,

31,000 ( $3.6 )

.

1.

:

, .

I , A

. F

,

;

; . C

I (CI), III,

A .

J L J A

.


8/67

:

6 40

A

. ,

2.4 2030.

, .

A ,

.

H 37,438 I

2007, 61% (H, 2009).

I 6% ,

.

L , ;

, . .

,

. D

. D

.

B A (A)

(EA, AA A)

, AB G (A), L ( K),

M I ( ) MI (M), A ( F 1).

1:

I, A

AAID, I I I (III), M

, D G H (DGH),

(2009) : A.

://../////.

1.

.

2.

.

3.

.

4. 70

.


9/67

:

7 40

. A 2 4

J L J, .

I ,

F 2. A 50

100 . , ; 418,000 .

. A ,

.

2: , ,

A (2008) AAID I

:

;

,

, ;

;

, ;

,

,

.

F , III

E (E) DGH, A C

. A III DGH M A

A .


10/67


11/67

:

9 40

J L J J (

C C). 1,300

:

I

,

. A ,

A

J L J A

H 2 (AH2), F 3.

3: : ( 2)

I , 836,

J L J. (

C 3).


12/67

:

10 40

A (

) ,

, (

I ).

. M A M

:

: A M

I : A M

E ../..

M I

E (IE) AB G H A.

A . 2009

2010, :

20

G

.

A ( ,

A ), AB G

. H, . A ,

, 836.

AB G :

,

,

,

.

.

. I

.

AB G IE :


13/67

:

11 40

.

D 1.

AB G . F 4 AB G H

, 2

A (

2).

4:


14/67


15/67

:

13 40

A

.

D DGH (B D) 5,684 () ( ) 295,966 ( ),

F 5 . 35,779

.

5: ()

; .

: B ( ).

. I

:

15% 82%

10% 80%

0% 49% 0% 19% .

C

( ,

, , G ).


16/67

:

14 40

( )

B ( )

A

. A F 6 7 ,

. D B , 3 14,000 .

6: .

7:

; .

: B ( ).

A : , , .

3 A .


17/67

:

15 40

3:

0

1 100

101 500

501 +

F 7

.

.

.

A

.

D .

, : , ,

. I , .

. I,

A .

, , ,

:

.

.

. A

.

85

.

C C:

.

A . :

://.//31613/..


18/67


19/67

:

17 40

E J L J

. ,

.

B

4 . ,

.

A .

4:

20062009 2008 20082009 20082010

B 3

B 4 C

C 8 1 B

4 C

10 278 59 3

/ 69

1

1 9 4

78 18 C

: B ( ).

B , 460 J L J.

0.34 .

H, C III

. E, C J

585 1,150 J L

J (III, 2011). , , 1.19

. 0.61

1,150 .

III .

A D B (ADB) H (H)

: A D B (ADB)

2004 30,464, 3.5 8,762

(ADBAEA, 2004)

H (H) 37,438

2007, 2.7 16,548 2007 (H,

2009)

B K J (

) 1,000 C

C (1,300), 0.77 ,

2.2 ( 4).

F , 0.75 .


20/67


21/67


22/67

:

20 40

A . M ,

, A

(..).

:

58%

( )

65%

( )

99%

41%

44%

.

F 9 836 .

9:

() %

5001 10000 41.4 5

10001 15000 151.2 18

15001 20000 119.3 1420001 40000 309.3 37

40001 60000 130.7 16

60001 80000 9.5 1

> 100000 74.6 9

(% ) () %

11% 20% 83.4 10

21% 40% 366.3 44

41% 60% 379.3 45

61% 80% 7 1

() %

/ 100.1 12

274.5 33

96.3 12

365.1 44

() %

/ 62.9 8

279.1 33

459.8 55

34.2 4

() %

209.1 25

495.8 59

131.1 16

() %

222.9 27

30.5 4

253.4 30

329.2 39

() %

220.2 26

48.5 6

236.3 28

331 40

() %

366.9 44

391.3 47

77.8 9

() %

832.8 100 3.2 0


23/67


24/67


25/67

:

23 40

1.0

5.0163.2 20

3.1 0

531.2 64

14.3 2

() %

178.8 21

276.1 33

381.1 46

() %

(..

)836 100

() %

787.4 94

48.6 6

152

230

7978


26/67

:

24 40

F ,

() 100 A

( ). A

, , .

(, , I ).

:

://.//9573/504.04..

. A F 10. I

. I

( 100 ) , ,

5.5. A 100200 ,

, 3.5.

.

,

. , I

.

10:

F 11 () 100

B J L J ( ,

). I

( ). ,


27/67

:

25 40

. C

A ...

11:

6. I

J L J, :

, 17% 1 2

, 43% 1 2

, 72% 2

, 66% 2.

6:

()

*

836 0% 2% 15% 34% 36% 14%

836 0% 11% 32% 26% 29% 2%

836 0% 0% 72% 28% 0% 0%

B 836 12% 0% 66% 14% 9% 0%

* .


28/67

:

26 40

7 . I

:

48% 1 2

43% 4 5

69% 1 2

69% 1 2 .

7:

()

10,052 * 1% 15% 34% 36% 14%

4,098 ** 8% 26% 23% 39% 4%

10,052 * 0% 69% 31% 0% 0%

B 10,052 * 0% 67% 13% 13% 0%

* A

**


29/67

F 12 15

,

12:

:

27 40

.

,


30/67

13:

14:

:

28 40


31/67

15:

G

,

.

:

29 40

,

. I :

,

.

,


32/67


33/67

:

31 40


34/67

:

32 40

I

. , A

70 ,

( A

: ://..).

I I D

( :

../..

I , .

1. E

,

100

. A , 621

J L J

.

( ,

), 100 .

() (

, ).

H, 1 ( )

, .

A

, 10 .

MM D (2008).

2.

F 100 ,

.

( )

. F ,

, . ,

.

A . F :


35/67

:

33 40

.

H,

100

( )

600

( 2+1 ) .

H

. F :

( )

( , )

(

) .

3. E

E (BC)

. C BC 1

. H, BC

.

( 4% ).

( 100

) , .

C 3.

( $10 )

A ,

. F ,

: 89 ( $10 )

2.9 ( $350 ), 1 .

8. I , 89

33,950 20 , 25%

. 14 ( $1.6 )

. F A

(..).


36/67


37/67

:

35 40

89 ( $10 )

9.

9: 89 ( $10 )

( 20 )

/

( )

( )

( 000)

410 15,070 6,789,640 30,870 2,048 220

D 320 5,430 2,445,560 11,050 667 221

20 3,120 1,406,630 17,880 5,725 79

10 2,380 1,073,790 8,150 3,420 132

20 2,070 930,450 7,520 2,166 124

B 130 910 408,050 3,980 4,392 103

6 790 355,400 2,480 3,139 143

20 550 247,220 1,780 1,064 139

B 3 340 152,360 1,910 5,656 80

1 180 81,390 1,210 3,998 67

C 20 140 61,460 960 4,169 64

C 10 140 60,970 550 2,399 112

/ 5 90 42,460 400 2,511 107

3 40 17,060 210 3,338 80

A 1 30 11,320 130 5,015 90

31,270 14,083,750 89,070 2,848 158

: =

C (

) 2 ,

.

: D 1 = D 8,541 (18 2011).


38/67

:

36 40

F 16 J L J

89 ( $10 ) . B

15 20 . A

,

( , , ).

16: ( 89 / $10 )


39/67

:

37 40

2. ( $350 )

, 1

, 10. I , 2.9 (D $350

) 68,890 20 , 50%

. 31 (D $3.6 ) . F A

(..).

10: 2.9 ( $350 )

2,978 348

(20 ) 31,030 3,631

B 10

D ( )

B 627

A 314

313

D (20 )

B 137,940

A 69,050

68,890

50%

C 43 5,100

: D 1 = D 8,541 (18 2011).

2.9 ( $350 )

11.


40/67

:

38 40

11: 2.9 ( $350 )

( 20 )

/

( )

( )

(000)

880 25,290 11,391,770 710,770 28,102 16

300 8,020 3,613,840 211,530 26,364 17

D 380 5,420 2,439,410 14,100 853 173

150 5,190 2,338,440 69,170 13,316 34

B 360 4,290 1,932,670 161,550 37,649 12

110 4,250 1,916,060 74,270 10,392 26

D 50 3,600 1,619,210 587,480 163,417 3

C 2940 2,970 1,338,550 320,340 95,422 4

8 2,310 1,041,450 358,720 155,140 3

B 50 1,770 795,790 43,560 24,653 18

70 1,490 669,900 61,500 24,611 11

180 980 441,770 179,410 182,917 2

80 910 411,690 35,280 38,601 12

A 40 740 332,320 72,640 98,453 5

140 540 241,620 16,980 10,377 14

()60 310 140,000 29,820 57,100 5

C 40 200 91,490 1,350 3,966 68

40 180 82,420 3,600 11,715 23

20 120 53,840 11,550 57,536 5

/ 10 110 49,240 690 3,768 71

C 3 90 40,100 2,730 30,698 15

()50 60 26,010 10,080 103,864 3

B 1 50 22,470 1,100 13,131 20

68,890 31,030,070 2,978,230 43,229 10

:

=

C (

) 2 ,

.

: D 1 = D 8,541 (18 2011).


41/67

:

39 40

F 17 J L J

2.9 ( $350 ) . B

15 20 .

J L J.

17: ( 2.9 / $350 )


42/67

:

40 40

A III C , C I (CI)

E K J. CI

31 J L J E, C

J. 20,

.

A CI A .

.

3 23 .

I ,

A CI:

A

, , ,

.

CI

.

3 23

E J CI 20 J L J

. I 2008, 30 33

. ,

.

A ,

12 .

12: 1 2 ( 5)

% 1 2

5%

85%

62%

B 100%


43/67

:

41 40

CI J L J E, C J

:

(.. )

,

( / )

.

A . F ,

A 73% 836 J L J

53% . ,

A.

13 ( F 18)

J L J 3 23

( / CI ).

:

CI ,

, A

100 .

A

CI . A ,

, . CI

. A

,

.


44/67


45/67


46/67

44 17

A C . ( A)

.

A :

. A ,

C

.

C ,

, / .

C ,

,

.

C.

C :

A

,

A

, .

A .

, , D C , 100 . D ,

. ,

1020 . A A

C.


47/67

45 17

, A

.

,

:

(

)

,

.

C (C)

7 A

.

A

.

(://..)

.

,

.

,

(440 ). ,

, . ,

. A ,

.

,

/

.

.

. ,

/ .

, 274

. , ,

.


48/67

46 17

.

A . ,

.

150 .

, ,

, .

.

.

A . A ,

.

, :

(.. , )

, 40/

70/

.


49/67

47 17

A A

() .

,

.

A 3.5 , (50/ 70/ ). ,

, A

. ,

,

.

,

.

10/ 10/ ( 20).

10/, 1 2 43% 59%. 10/,

1 2 43% 18%.

100 ( 21).

,

. , :

( 05 )

.

22.


50/67

48 17

. .

.

, 70/ 2 . ,

80/, 1. A,

60/, 3.

120/ 4 ,

. A

5.


51/67

49 17

.

,

.

, .

,

A

.

,

.

A

.

. C

, .

,

. ,

(BAC, 2009).

. (

) .

,

, ,

, . .

,

( , ) .

. (..)

C (, 2009)

.

A ,

. A ,

,


52/67

50 17

, .

(2010) .


53/67

51 17

D : (), D

(D) : 25 2011

: , D, A A

A : , C, AB

A D ,

( C C)

D (D) (). AB A.

A ( ,

A ), AB

.

,

A .

1

1280 960

.

2 160 180 ( ).

.

3 A 100

20

I 10 20 . D AB H

.

4 C

A 840 1000

.

. :

.

I

.


54/67

52 17

5

A .

I B . A ,

6

,

.

.

7 I

I H .

8 C ()

,

.

,

.

, .

.

9

,

. I

.

10 I

()

.

11 C

()

.

12 C

()

.


55/67


56/67

(

(: 1028

54 17

: 0228040 )

04311 ())


57/67

55 17

AB

:

.


58/67

56 17

C C A

C B

/

D

F

100%81% 99%

61% 80%

41% 60%

21% 40%

11% 20%

6% 10%

1% 5%

0%

B F H

/

F C H

/

F A H

/

A

F

/

> = 120/

110/

100/90/


59/67

57 17

80/

70/

60/

50/

1 3

>3

ECDED

A

> 1 3

>3

ECDED

C


60/67

58 17

D

C

D

H

G

C

A

A

F

D B

B

B

B C

D 05

D

D 510

C

D >10

F

D

IH

IH

IH

IH

C

D 05

D

D 510

C


61/67

59 17

D >10

120/

110/

100/

90/

80/

70/

60/

50/

20

A (.. )

A D H D

D

A ( )

C

D 05

D

D 510

C

D >10

( )

C

D 05

D

D 510

C

D >10

( )

I 4 ()

4 ()

4 () 3 ()


62/67

60 17

C ( )

4 ()

3 ()

3 ()

3 ()

( )

( )

( )

( )

C A ( / )

( )

C

C G

J

I

I H >= 10,000

>= 1,000 < 10,000

< 1,000

/

C

C

C

1

15

510

1020

H

>20

A (.. )

C I H

C C


63/67


64/67


65/67


66/67


67/67

. 1.

, . , 2005.

(2011),

(200)

//./..

, , , (2010) . ../.

, . , . (2008)

. //./..

(200)

//./..

(200) . .

(). . . 8

2011. //..////.

iRAP Indonesia Demonstration Project Technical Report _IndII_.pdf

Documents

Transcript of iRAP Indonesia Demonstration Project Technical Report _IndII_.pdf