Intersections (Vol. 4 Spring 2012)
-
Upload
intersections-mcgill -
Category
Documents
-
view
229 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Intersections (Vol. 4 Spring 2012)
IntersectionsVolume IV Spring 2012
!"#$%&'())$*+,#-.-/,0/1#$!"#$%&'()*+,-$'(.%*$/,-'0-12-%3/4(5"+/%32
!"#$%&'())$*+,#-.-/,0/1#$234#+56$710,(#6$8+1#-,(6&(9)(+/-:$;30-+/)$
<3)04#$8<$79-(+.$=>?=
8+1#-6#&1(3+6
%&'8@@$*A8<BC78!D$%EA!CBF@G$H*BIBJG$JFAFKF
67.89:)
%/,(23+$4#(/5(&3)#$4#3+/-,5(6($%/-(3+73"/++#$8/-&"/8-(1($8/1#)'/9-(#))#$8#-#:0#7#)#+/$;1/+63<(&=>()?$*-9/+26($
!"#$%&'%(&L*+1(1)#,M$N:$</)#-(#$'/01"(#-
K#/-$C#/,#-G
F6$1"#$8+1#-,(6&(9)(+/-:$234#+56$710,(#6$;30-+/)G$30-$.3/)$(6$13$9-3431#$,(/)3.0#$/+,$&-(1(&/)$1"30."1$O(1"(+$1"#$%&'())$&34P
93#1-:G$/+,$/-1O3-Q$&3+1/(+#,$O(1"(+$1"#6#$9/.#6$N01$/)63$#+./.#$O(1"$1"#4$(+$/$O/:$1"/1$#R9/+,6$/+,$#+"/+$:30-$/O/-#+#66$3S$
2#$/-#$#R&(1#,$1"/1$8+1#-6#&1(3+6$&3+1(+0#6$13$.-3OG$/+,$1"#$
2"()#$O#$&#-1/(+):$"/,$30-$O3-Q$&01$301$S3-$06$+#O&34#-6TS3-$
S0+,-/(6(+.G$/+,$)#/-+(+.$F,3N#$8+K#6(.+TO#$O#-#$/N)#$13$O3-Q$
1"/+Q$/))$3S$30-$&3+1-(N013-6G$90N)(6"#,$/+,$0+90N)(6"#,G$S3-$609P
S-34$1"#$%&'())$K/():G$/+,$13$%/-Q$J"/)"30NG$O"3$N31"$"#)9#,$
7(+&#-#):G
!"#$B,(13-6
$
U
L2/-1(4#$234/+"33,V$;0+(3-$/+,$7#+(3-$W361#6#6$/1$X
?Y
;/4#6$J/4#-3+56$!"#$#% ZZ
[[
[\
\=
\Z
L]A/4/61#:$J/+/,/5V$!"#$849/&1$3S$J0)10-/)$A/1(3+/)(64$3+$8+,(/+$234#+$(+$1"#$K(/693-/$N:$
U[
X\
7
@%30-+(+.$83-1-/(1A$
9?$B2/9#)$40&#
8
)*%(+,$&)",*-.""/0&12-+"%&*-/&3$-+"%&4"5($55$5&*(&637&8*-9$5&+-&))::
%(&"#))#$W/:4/+$
/+,$ (+,061-(/)$ O3-Q#-6G$ N31"$ O(1"(+$ 1"#$ *+(1#,$ 71/1#6$ /+,$
9/-1+#-6G$ O"()#$ 6#+(3-$ "361#66#6$ S0+&1(3+#,$ /6$ 60--3./1#$
/))3O$ (+6(."1$ (+13$ 1"#$ &3+61-0&1(3+$3S$.#+,#-$+3-46$,0-(+.$/$9#-(3,$O"#+$(+&-#/6(+.$+04N#-6$3S$O34#+$O#-#$#+1#-(+.$
90N)(&$69"#-#G$1"#$-3)#$3S$"361#66#6$(+$1"#$*7E$O/6$,#9#+,#+1$
13$&3+1-3)$1"#(-$"361#66#65$S#4(+(+(1:$-#9-#6#+1#,$/$&3+[$3S$
$ %0&"$ 3S$ 1"#$ "(613-(&/)$ ,(6&30-6#$ -#./-,(+.$O34#+56$
9
1"#-#$O/6$ /$ 6"(S1$ N/&Q$ 13$ ,34#61(&$ -3)#6$ S3-$O34#+$ (+$ 1"#$
.3$S-34$61-#+.1"$13$O#/Q+#66G$O3-Q#-$13$6#R931G$406&)#6$13$4/44/-:$.)/+,6$(+$60&"$/$6"3-1$9#-(3,$3S$1(4#^M?$D#1G$/6$1"#$
&'()*+,()-,)&+.(/)-,)0-/+()0+"($(%),#43+61-/1#6G$ 1"#$906"$S3-$LO34/+93O#-M$O/6$3S1#+$N/6#,$3+$+31(3+6$3S$&3+1(+0#,$,34#61(&(1:$ /+,$ 3+):$ /$ 1#493-/-:$ (44#-6(3+$ (+13$ 1"#$
J/+1##+$ O/6$ O"/1$ 8$ &30),$ ,3G$ 8$ -#/)):$ O/6$ +31$ C36(#$ 1"#$=$ <3)0+1##-(+.$ /))3O#,$ 1"#6#$ O34#+$ 13$ #+1#-$ 1"#$
$
-3)#$3S$6#+(3-$"361#66#6$(+$"#-$/-1(&)#$#+1(1)#,$L]!3$%/Q#$1"#$
L6#+(3-$ "361#66#6$ -#(+S3-&#,$ 1"#(-$ 9-(4/-:$ 9#/(4#$ -3)#6$
!"!"#$%%&'()&%*+',-%.%./%$0&1'-)20%3'456%$7020&1'8."1%2')9':).%&'0&':)$;5':"$'88<'0&'!"#$%&'#()*&+,$-.*/$-&*01$-.*$22$.+1$3'#*45.+$6&54#,78$%5='>%&&%7?'@"#;'ABC$0%&'"&5'D*&&'(='@"$2)&2'EF)&&%G70G#73'H$%%&I))5'@$%22+'JKKLM+'NO#"P''!%1?"&':0&G?%;;+'9&&1$94*0:8$9&&1$)&&18$9&&1$);+$EF?"Q%;'(0;;3'R&06%$207*')9'S)$7?'F"$);0&"'@$%22+'PTTNM+$J#
10
Z$ 7#+(3-$"361#66#6$O#-#$ 6##+$ /6$4#-#):$#R1#+,(+.$ 1"#(-$ L+/10-/)M$ 431"#-(+.$ -3)#6$ (+13$ 1"#$ 90N)(&$69"#-#G$6(40)1/+#306):$&3+S3-4(+.$13$/99-39-(/1#$+31(3+6$3S$
$ 7(+&#$1"#$O3-Q$3S$6#+(3-$"361#66#6$O/6$&3+Ύ/)(_#,$/6$/+$#R1#+6(3+$3S$O34#+56$-3)#6$(+$1"#$"34#G$1"#6#$O34#+$
*7E$ &/+1##+6$ &3+S3-4#,$ 13$ /$ +31(3+$ 3S$ O34#+56$ )/N30-$
#&3+34(&$N/&Q.-30+,6G$1"#$0+9/(,$+/10-#$3S$1"#$O3-Q$O30),$
[$234#+$-#)(/+1$3+$#/-+(+.$O/.#6$
+31(3+$3S$1"#$6#+(3-$"361#66$/6$1"#$(,#/)$3),#-$S#4/)#$&(1(_#+$O/6$ )(4(1#,$ 13$ 1"36#$ 3S$ 1"#$4(,,)#$ /+,$ 099#-$ &)/66#6$O"3$
$ !"#$ -#)/1(3+6"(9$ N#1O##+$ 1"#$ *7E$ /+,$ S#4/)#$
`
O#-#$N/++#,$ S-34$#+1-:$ (+13$ 1"#$ )3&/)$71/.#$K33-$J/+1##+G$$":0&G?%;;+'UV%&0)$'()27%22%2+B'JKJ="W':0&G?%;;+'UV%&0)$'()27%22%2+B'JKO="%"!"$*"&&'D)6%;"G%+',X"G0&1'F?"&1%'0&':"$70.%'@?0;"5%;Q?0"3'Y?%'V7)$*')9'7?%'@?0;"5%;Q?0"'RVA+<'!"#$<#++:70=.+4.$>.?.@4+#$&A$%4:,&*7$.+1$B4&?*.C"7+'6);='JPO'EJKKKM3''JKT#"
11
\$,(,$
O#))$/6$1"#$*7E56$&3+61-0&1(3+$3S$O34#+$/6$+0-10-#-6G$)(4(1#,$/99-39-(/1#$S#4(+(+#$)/N30-$13$1"/1$O"(&"$O/6$,34#61(&$/+,$
F4#-(&/+6$O(1"(+$ 1"#$ *7E$ 1"/1$ &-#/1#,$ -/&(/)(_#,$ (,#/6$ 3S$
U$ $ 2"(1#$ "361#66#6$ O#-#$
1"#4$ 1"#:$O#-#$ 13$ N#$ &30-1#306$ 13$ "(4$ /+,$,(9)34/1(&/)):$"/+,)#$ 1"#$ 6(10/1(3+G$ #R9)/(+(+.$ 1"/1$ a1"#:b$ "/,$ &3)3-#,$
XF$ 6(4()/-$(+&(,#+1$ /)63$ 3&&0--#,$ (+$ I3613+$ ,0-(+.$ 1"#$O/-$O"#+$ 1"#$
I0,,(#6$I/:$71/1#$J)0NG$(+$-#693+6#$1"#$/11#+,/+&#$3S$N)/&Q$Y
6 D)6%;"G%+'JKT= 7 D)6%;"G%+'JZT='N'D)6%;"G%+'JZJ#"9 -#11;%2'V7$%%7'F%&7$%='
12
?>$!"(6$(+&(,#+1$,#43+61-/1#6$1"/1$1"#$-/&#$N/6#,$93)(&(#6$O#-#$ 3S1#+$ /6$40&"$ 1"#$ -#60)1$ 3S$ )3&/)$ /11(10,#6$ /6$
) &'()1-.(23%-4$)5#%6)"/6$ /-.0#,$1"/1$ 1"#$ &3+61-0&1(3+$ 3S$ 1"#$ 0+(1:$ 3S$ 1"#$ F4#-(&/+$ 9#39)#$
??$!"#$ &3+61-0&1(3+$3S$ 1"(6$ (4/.#$3S$0+(1:$ &/+$
O"#+$*+,()7#8#9+4(
?=$!"#-#$(6$+3$4#+1(3+$3S$1"#$,#6#.-#./1#,$&)0N6G$N01$(1$(6$&/-#S0)$13$6"3O$
90N)(&/1(3+6$1/-.#1#,$/1$!,%+:#4)!.(%+:#4/G$/+,$3S1#+$O-(11#+$N:$ FS-(&/+$ F4#-(&/+6G$ 60&"$ /6$ 1"#$ FS-/4#-(&/+$ 234#+56$;30-+/)G$ #49"/6(_#,$ 1"#$ (493-1/+&#$ 3S$ 1"#6#$ &)0N6$O(1"301$
?Z$8+61#/,G$1"#:$ #49"/6(_#,$ 1"#$ 3993-10+(1:$ S3-$ FS-(&/+$ F4#-(&/+$
!&":0&G?%;;+'9&&1$94*0:8$L[#"!!$>%&&%7?'@"#;'ABC$0%&'"&5'D*&&'(#52)&'@"$2)&2+',8&7$)5#G70)&+<'0&'!"#$%&'#()*&+,$-.*/$-&*01$-.*$22$.+1$3'#*45.+$6&54#,78$%5='>%&&%7?'@"#;'ABC$0%&'"&5'D*&&'(='@"$2)&2'EF)&&%G70G#73'H$%%&I))5'@$%22+'JKKLM+'W "!'",RVA'0&'Q%"G%'"&5'I"$'07'?"2'Q$)6%&'072'I)$7?<'D4A#$>.?.@4+#+'\#&%'PK+'JKWP+'ZP='!$$,S%1$)':).%&'0&'7?%'R=V=A=+<'0&'3'#*45.+$-&'#+$4+$.$-&*01$.,$-.*$%5='\#5*'C"$$%7'D07)99'"&5']"605'F='V.07?+'E:0;.0&17)&+']^3'V-'C))_2+'JKKZM+'J[O "
13
-#&3.+(1(3+$S3-$1"#(-$-3)#6G$N01$1"#:$O#-#$61())$+31$&3+6(,#-#,$
?Y[=$#,(1(3+$3S$*+,()7#8#9+4($3+):$ 1O3$301$3S$ 1"#$Z=$ (4/.#6$
;$#8()<--%)=#4$((4$/+,$A3-4/+$C3&QO#))56$&/-133+$5+>>+()?+>>+/)#$)$'()@;ABC
&3+61-0&1#,$/+$(4/.#$3S$1"#$9#-S#&1$O/-1(4#$O34/+$/6$O"(1#$
$ !"#$*7E$ &-#/1#,$ /+$ (4/.#$ 3S$ -#69#&1/N()(1:$ S3-$ N31"$
.(-)6$ O#+1$ 1"-30."$ /$ 61-#+0306$ 6#)#&1(3+$ 9-3B$ N/6#,$ 3+$?`$ !"(6$
6#)#&1(3+$ 9-3B$ O/6$ 06#,$ 13$ #+60-#$ 1"/1$ 1"#6#$ O34#+$
/+,$1"#$&3+1-3)$3S$6#R0/)(1:$(+$1"#$7#&3+,$23-),$2/-G$
?\$8+$-#693+6#$13$1"(6$S#/-$/+,$.-3O(+.$-#9-#66(3+$/+,$&3+1-3)$3S$9-361(101(3+G$1"#$*7E$O3-Q#,$13$&-#/1#$/+$(4/.#$3S$
:#1$ 1"#$ 3-./+(_/1(3+$ 61())$ /6Q#,$ 1"#4$ 13$ 4/(+1/(+$ /$ 60N1)#$14 S)$."&'-)G_I%;;+',:0;;0%'H0;;02'"7'7?%'RVA+<'X%/$#"$*'Z+'JKWP='III=2"7#$5"*%6%`&0&1Q)27=G).='V%%'F)6%$'Q"1%= !%"V%%'!%1?"&':0&G?%;;+'9&&1$94*0:E$4;2)+',RVA'0&'Q%"G%'"&5'I"$+<'D4A#$>.?.@4+#+'ZP#"!("(%1"$7*+'P="
14
$ 8+$ /,,(1(3+$ 13$ /$ 61-(&1$ 6#)#&1(3+$ 9-3BG$ 1"#$ *7E$&3+1-3))#,$ /99-39-(/1#$ +31(3+6$ 3S$ S#4/)#$ 6#R0/)(1:$ 1"-30."$
;$#8() <--%)=#4$((43+$ ?U$F)1"30."$
?X$!"#$ 6&#+#$,#43+61-/1#6$ 1"#$9/-/,3R(&/)$4#66/.#$ /N301$ 1"#$
.3(+.$ 13$ 6/:$ :#6$ /+,$ +3$ 13$ 1"/1$ 7301"#-+$ I3:$ /1$ 1"#$ 6/4#$1(4#cM?Y$ ;0+(3-$"361#66#6$O#-#$#R9#&1#,$13$6/:$+3$O(1"$1"#(-$
,3#6+51$,-#66$09$(+$1"(6$9-#6#+1$O3-QG$6"#$(6$60-#):$)#11(+.$1"#$=>$2"()#$ 1"#6#$O34#+$O#-#$6##+$/6$,-#66(+.$ 13$
9)#/6#$4#+G$1"#:$O#-#$/)63$#R9#&1#,$13$,3$63$(+$/$]-#69#&1/N)#$
17 V7"1%']))$'F"&7%%&=']0$%G7%5'/*'X$"&_'C)$a"1%'EJKWOb'D)2'4&1%;%2'F";09)$&0"+'V);'D%22%$'@$)5#G70)&2M= 18'6,.?#$F&&*$G.+,##+19 6,.?#$F&&*$G.+,##+20 :0&G?%;;+'9&&1$94*0:8'[N.
15
=?$!"#$#R(61(+.$-0)#6$,#43+61-/1#$ /$ &3+6&(306$ /11#491$ N:$ 1"#$ *7E$ )#/,#-6"(9$13$ &3+1-3)$ S#4/)#$ 6#R0/)(1:G$ 1"30."$ (1$ (6$ 0+&)#/-$ O"#1"#-$
==$F6$%#."/+$2(+&"#))$61/1#6$L1"#$*7E$&30),$-#9-3,0&#$/+,$,(61-(N01#$1"#$O(++#-56$(4/.#$O(1"301$-#.-#1$
=Z$ 2"()#$ 1"#$ *7E$ &3+61-0&1#,$
$ I0(),(+.$3+$1"(6$9/-/,3R$O/6$1"#$9390)/-$(4/.#-:$3S$&'()*+,()
7#8#9+4(4/--(#,$&309)#6$1"/1$4#1$/1$1"#$*7E$O(1"$1"#$"#/,)(+#$LI3:$
=[$!"#$*7E$ 1"06$#4N3,(#,$/+$(+"#-#+1$&3+1-/,(&1(3+$3S$1"#$(,#/)$S#4/)#$O"#-#$
3S1#+$ 6/O$ 1"#$*7E$,/+$ /6$ /+$ 3993-10+(1:$ 13$4##1$ 1"#(-$
/&1#,$ /6$ /$ 9)/&#$ S3-$ 931#+1(/)$ 4/--(/.#$ .-30+,6G$ O34#+56$
$ !"#$ &3+61-0&1(3+$ 3S$ /99-39-(/1#$ 6#R0/)(1:G$ -/&#$ /+,$)/N30-$(+$1"#$*7E$(,#/)$3S$O34/+"33,$-#9-#6#+16$/+$/)1#-+/1#$
3+$1"#(-$-#69#&1/N()(1:$/+,$&3+S3-4(1:$13$#R(61(+.$.#+,#-$/+,$
21'D)6%;"G%+'J[L= 22 :0&G?%;;+'9&&1$94*0:8'JJO= 23 :0&G?%;;+'9&&1$94*0:8$JJO`W= 24 ,RVA'0&'Q%"G%'"&5'I"$<'D4A#$>.?.@4+#+'ZN=
16
/11#491$ 13$ &3+1-3)$ S#4(+(+(1:$ /+,$ O34/+"33,$ ,0-(+.$ /$
9/-/,3R(&/)$+/10-#$3S$ 1"#$*7E$"361#66$"#)96$ 6"#,6$ )(."1$3+$
17
23-Q6$J(1#,
5#%$+.()5-.(4D)/(E)%->(/6),#.+>F)%(>#$+-4/6)) #4G)$'()/$#$H/)-,)I-.(4)GH%+48)5-%>G)5#%)JJK))
L+:$-%F)?+%>/6)M'#N+25#:N+(/6)#4G)) O#$%+-$H$(/D)&'()0(8H>#$+-4)-,)3(.#>();(EH#>+$F)GH%+48)) 5-%>G)5#%)JJK)
&'()1-.(23%-4$)) 5#%D)5-%>G)5#%)JJ)#4G)!.(%+:#4);-:+($F6)#,(1#,$
$ &'()O(44/F>"#4+#)7#8#9+4()-,)1+/$-%F)#4G)P+-8%#Q'FG$
!.(%+:#4)1+/$-%+:#>)0("+(I)
!.(%+:#4)5-.(4)+4)#)5-%>G)) #$)5#%6)
$ E-(.(+/)):$90N)(6"#,$(+$!,%#.(%+:#4)5-.(4R/)S-H%4#>$
&'()1-.(23%-4$)5#%D)5-%>G)5#%)JJ)) #4G)!.(%+:#4);-:+($F6)
$ F4#-(&/+$73)(,#-GM$!44#>/)-,)$'()!.(%+:#4)!:#G(.F)-,)) O->+$+:#>)#4G);-:+#>);:+(4:(
;#$H%G#F)) T"(4+48)O-/$6)
18
P('+4G)$'()*+4(/D)) ?(4G(%)#4G)$'()&I-)5-%>G)5#%/6)#,(1#,$N:$%/-./-#1$C$
;$#8()<--%)=#4$((4K) ?Y[Zd$@36$
*+,()) 7#8#9+4(
$ 3%-4$+(%/D)!)S-H%4#>)-,)5-.(4);$HG+(/
?--G)?+%>/6)?--G)3--G6)?--G)3H4K)J"/9#)$"
19
:-&(.$&;<$&"=&(.$&>$."?/$%0&>$*2(<@&A*+-&*-/&(.$&B*?$&C*D$
B--:)$!/../-12"#+$/$O34/+$O/Q#6$09$(+$1"#$43-+(+.G$6"#$4(."1$
31"#-6G$ 13$ /$ 40)1(10,#$ 3S$ N#/01:P#+"/+&(+.$ 9-/&1($ 3+$ /$,/():$N/6(6G$O"(&"$/-#$(+1#+,#,$13$4/Q#$1"#4$43-#$,#6(-/N)#$
S#4/)#$ N3,:$43-#$,#6(-/N)#$ N#&/06#$ 1"#:$ S3-&#$ 1"#$O34/+$
96:&"3/+/):1(&$4#&"/+(64$N#"(+,$,#6(-#$(+$/-1G$/6$(1$/99)(#6$
(+$ )33Q(+.?
=Z
1'D"#$"'!#;6%*+',c02#";'@;%"2#$%'"&5'S"$$"706%'F0&%."+<'0&'!"#$)#'4+4:'$.+1$H4:;.0$G;0,;*#$I#.1#*$J+1$K14,4&+8'%5='4.%;0"'\)&%2='ES%I'd)$_3'-)#7;%51%+'PTJTM+'LK=''8/05+'LK=$'4&)7?%$'.%"&2'/*'I?0G?'60%I0&1'Q;%"2#$%'G"&'/%'%&1%&5%$%5'02'&"$G02202.='S"$G02202.'
20
9/-1$3S$ 1"#$N-/(+G$060/)):$ -#9-#66#,$N:$ 1"#$609#-#.3G$O"(&"$[
"(6$+/Q#,$431"#-56$N3,:G$/+,$"#-$9"/))(&$ )/&QG$/6$/$ 10-+(+.$`
S-34$"(4G$N01$ 1"/1$6"#$"/6$/1$634#$93(+1$ (+$"#-$4/10-/1(3+$
&34#6$ 13$ -#9-#6#+1$ 1"#$ (44(+#+1$ 1"-#/1$ 3S$ &/61-/1(3+$ (+$ 1"#$\
S#1(6"(_/1(3+$3S$ 1"#$ S#4/)#$N3,:$ 13$4/Q#$9/-16$3S$"#-$N3,:G$U
X
4#/+6$ 3S$ &-#/1(+.$ 9)#/60-#$ (6$ 3S$ 43-#$ (493-1/+&#$ 13$ 1"(6$
Y
!"(6$ /66#-16$ 1"#$4/)#$ &"/-/&1#-56$ ,34(+/+&#$ /+,$ -#(+S3-$
Q%$9%G7'6%$20)&')9'7?%.=4'8/05+'LK=5'8/05+'[P=('8/05+'[P=)'8/05+'[P=*'8/05+'[P=+'8/05+'[P=
21
?>
1"(6$9/9#-$O())$ 6"3O&/6#$ /-#$ 1"#$9":6(&/)$ #R#-1(3+$ 3S$ N/))#1$
>$*2(<&>"%-$&E<&>*??$(
63&(/)):$/&[/N)#$4#/+6$S3-$4#+$/+,$O34#+$13$130&"$#/&"$
S/+1/6(#6$ 3+13$ 1"#$ S#4/)#$ N3,(#6$ 3S$ 1"#$,/+&#-6??/0,(#+&#$ 4#4N#-6$ &30),$ +/-&(66(61(&/)):$ (,#+1(S:$ O(1"$ 1"#$4/)#$,/+&#-6G$130&"(+.$1"#$O34/+56$"/+,6G$/-46G$)#.6G$O/(61G$/+,$N0113&Q6$(+$/+$#-31(&$9#-S3-4/+&#$1"/1$,(6.0(6#,$(16#)S$/6$
O"(&"$ -#9#/1#,):$ -#S#--#,$ 13$ S#4/)#$ ,/+&#-6$ /6$ 9366#66(+.$L1"#$ )#.6$3S$ /$./_#))#GM$3-$31"#-$N3,:$9/-16$ /6$N#)3+.(+.$ 13$/+(4/)6G$#1"+(&$.-3096G$3-$609#-+/10-/)$N#(+.6?=,/+&#-6$O#-#$S0-1"#-$6#.-#./1#,$S-34$1"#$"04/+$O"(1#$4/)#$
2"()#$ 1"#$ #R1#-(3-$ 3S$ /$ 93(+1#$ 6"3#$ (6$ 4/,#$ S-34$ 64331"$9(+Q$ 6/1(+G$ 1"#$ (+1#-(3-$ (6$ /$ &3+61-0&1(3+$ 3S$ )#/1"#-G$ N0-)/9G$
/-#$/)63$1"#$63)#$60993-1$S3-$1"#$S#4/)#$,/+&#-$O"3$N/)/+$
!&'8/05+'[P=!!'V#2"&'D%01?'X)27%$+',Y?%'C";;%$0&"B2'@?";;0G'@)0&7%+<'0&'!"#$)#'4+4:'$.+1$H4:;.0$G;0,;*#$I#.1#*$J+1$#14,4&+$8'^5='4.%;0"'\)&%2='ES%I'd)$_3'-)#7;%51%+'PTJTM'OPK=!''8/05+'OOP=
22
2"()#$1"#$#R9#-(#+&#$3S$O#/-(+.$/$93(+1#$6"3#$(6$1-0):$9/(+S0)G$
O/1&"#6$"#-$61-#1&"$"#-$N3,:$9/61$1"#$93(+1$3S$9/(+$13$1"/1$3S$
"#-$&/61-/1(3+$#R9#-(#+&#G$(6$"#),$/&&30+1/N)#$S3-$(1G$/+,$(6$+3$
?Z
&3-96$,#$N/))#16$(+13$"#1#-36#R0/)$9/-1+#-6"(96$3-$)/-.#-$/))P
/+$0+P3993-10+(1:$
!$'Y)'60%I'7?02'"$7I)$_+'Q;%"2%'1)'7)'?77Q3ee60.%)=G).eJLJLNTW[=
%/-(#$J"30(+/-,G$A/1(3+/)$I/))#1$3S$J/+/,/G$%3+1-#/)G$
23
J"30(+/-,$ /)63$ ,(6-#./-,6$ 1"#$ 1-/,(1(3+/)$ S#4/)#$ /+,$4/)#$
,/+&#G1"#$4/)#$9#-S3-4#-56$-3)#$(6$13$)(S1G$N/)/+&#G$/+,$&/--:G$O"()#$1"#$S#4/)#56$(6$13$61-#1&"G$69(+G$/+,$1"-3O$"#-6#)S$093+$
13$-0+$)/1#-/)):$/O/:$S-34$1"#$4/)#$O"()#$"#$90))6$"#-$N/&QG$
1"#$S##1$O(1"$1"#$31"#-$6#R0/)(_#,$N3,:$9/-16$6##46$/$N)/1/+1$
1"#6#$N/+,6$J"30(+/-,$9-#6#+16$S#4/)#$,/+&#-6$0+S#11#-#,$N:$
$ F+31"#-$3S$J"30(+/-,56$9(#$-#1/(+6$1"#$06#$3S$93(+1#$
.E@KIBC'$
%/-(#$J"30(+/-,G$J349/.+(#$%/-(#$
J"30(+/-,G$%3+1-#/)G$=>>`.
24
?[
6(49):$O#/-$1O3$93(+1#$6"3#6$3+$1"#(-$S##1G$N01$4(."1$O#/-$
!"#$ 93(+1#$ 6"3#6$ /&1$ /6$ (+61-04#+16G$ Q+3&Q(+.$ 13.#1"#-$ 13$&-#/1#$ /$ N(-,P)(Q#$ 9#&Q(+.$ 630+,G$ /+,$ /6$ &36104#$ 9(#$
6"3#6$ N#/-$ 1"#$ #+1(-#$O#(."1$ 3S$ 1"#$ ,/+&#-$ (+$ /$O/:$O"(&"$
N:$ "/-+#66#6G$ &/+#6G$ /+,$ "3-(_3+1/)$ N/--#6G$ O"(&"$ 1/Q#$ 3+$
1"#:$ /-#$ /+$ /(,$ 13$ 1"#$ ,/+&#-$O"3$"/6$ )361$ 1"#$ S0+&1(3+(+.$
06#,$ 6(40)1/+#306):G$ /)63$ S0+&1(3+$ /6$ /(,6G$ (+$ 1"(6$ &/6#$ 13$
$ F$ 6#&3+,$ N#/01:P#+"/+#+1$ 9-/&1(6#$ /)63$ "/6$ (16$
90N)(&(1:$3S$1"#$"#/)1"$-(6Q6$/663&(/1#,$O(1"$O#/-(+.$&3-6#1614'Y)'60%I'7?02'"$7I)$_+'Q;%"2%'60207'?77Q3eeIII=*)#7#/%=G).eI"7G?f6g```5:ad(`9!=
25
?`
1"#$%/Q(+.$ 3S$ 1"#$ <(&13-(/+$234/+GM$ &3))#&16$ 90N)(&/1(3+6$/+,$&3--#693+,#+&#$O"(&"$,#6&-(N#$ 1"#$9-/&1(6#$3S$O#/-(+.$
&3--#693+,#+&#$ N#1O##+$4/)#$ S-(#+,6$ &3+6(61#+1):$ ,#6&-(N#$
9-/&1($O"(&"$60N6&-(N#,$13$1"#$"#.#43+:$3S$1"#$4/)#$./_#$
,3&04#+16$/)63$-#S#-$13$1"#$O#/-(+.$3S$&3-6#16$/6$L1-/(+(+.$1"#$
?\$!"#$9/(+$1"/1$1"#$O34/+$N#/-6$O"()#$O#/-(+.$ 1"#$ &3-6#1$ (6$ /$ &"-3+(&$ -#P#+/&14#+1$3S$
S-34$9-(4/-:$630-$ 1"/1$ 1"#$O34#+$O"3$#+./.#,$ (+$ 1"(6$?U$
$ C#+##$J3R$(6$/+$/-1(61$O"3G$(+$"#-$93-1-/(16$'-/+,431"#-$
"#-$N3,:$09$S3-$6&3939"()(&$9)#/60-#G$/+,$&3+S-3+16$1"#$4/)#$
93-1-/(1$O"(&"$#R936#6$1"#$1(."1P)/&#,$N/&Q$3S$/$N)/&Q$)#/1"#-$
J3R56$O#/-(+.$ 3S$ 1"#$ &3-6#1$ ,3#6$ +31$ /99#/-$ 13$ N#$9-30,):$
15'(%;%&%'^='-)/%$72+',Y?%'^hi#0207%'V;"6%3'7?%'-);%')9'F;)7?%2'0&'7?%'!"_0&1')9'7?%'c0G7)$0"&':)."&+<'64?+:8'c);='P+'S)='O'EVQ$0&1'JKKZM+'"GG%22%5'S)6%./%$'JO+'PTJJ+'L[P=!('8/05+'L[W=17'8/05+'L[W=
26
@#/1"#-$ @/&#P*9$ ,3#6$ +31$ #+./.#$ (+$ 1"#6#$ 9/(+S0)$ N#/01:P9-/&1($ O())(+.):$ /+,$ 4061$ 1"#-#S3-#$ N#$ /O/-#$ 3S$ "#-$
S/&#$T$6"#$(6$N31"$/O/-#$3S$1"#$4/)#$./_#$/+,$"(,(+.$S-34$
C#+##$J3RG$I)/&Q$@#/1"#-$@/&#P*9G$=>>?G$9"313.-/9"G$I-33Q):+V$
?%#4G.-$'(%)#4G)@4:>(
27
6#R0/)(_#,$93-1-/(16$3S$"#-6#)SG$6#9/-/1#,$N:$/$93-1-/(1$3S$"#-$
?X
>$*2(<&!2(&+-&!"5,$(+9&32%F$%<
&364#1(&$ 60-.#-:$ (6$ 6(4()/-$ 13$ 1"/1$ 3S$O#/-(+.$ 93(+1#$ 6"3#6$3-$ /$ &3-6#1V$ 1"#$ 9/(+$ /663&(/1#,$O(1"$ 1"#$ 9-3B$ S3-$ 1"#$
"#-$ 1"-#/1$ 13$ 1"#$ 4/)#56$ 96:&"#$ /+,$ /))3O(+.$ "(4$ 13$ 1/Q#$
4#,(&/)(_/1(3+$ 3S$ 1"#(-$ N3,(#6$ N#./+$O(1"$ 1"#$ #R"(N(1(3+$ 3S$?Y$%#+$ /+,$O34#+$ S-34$
=>$!"#6#$9#-S3-4/+$O#-#$1"#$3+):$)(+Q$ N#1O##+$ 1"#$ )/-.#):$ ())(1#-/1#$ B0-39#/+$ 9390)/&#$ /+,$1"#$ #R9/+,(+.$ N30+,/-(#6$ 3S$ 1"#(-$ O3-),$ /+,$ O#-#$ 1"06$
=?
18'Y"."$'Y%./%G_+',X%.0&027'!%7?)5);)10%2<'E;%G7#$%+'!GH0;;'R&06%$207*+'!)&7$%";+'j#%/%G+'V%Q7%./%$'PO+'PTJJM=19'F)G)'X#2G)+',Y?%'A7?%$'(027)$*')9'8&7%$G#;7#$";'@%$9)$."&G%+<'0&'!"#$)#'4+4:'$.+1$H4:;.0$G;0,;*#$I#.1#*8'%5='4.%;0"'\)&%2='ES%I'd)$_3'-)#7;%51%+'PTJTM+'PPN=20'8/05+'PPN`PPK=21'8/05+'PPK=
28
3S$ 1"#(-$ /6604#,$ (+S#-(3-(1:==
=Z$;061$63G$
=[$
13$(+1#-+/)(_#$1"#4$/6$+/10-/)G$O"()#$N3,():$9-3B#6$60&"$/6$/.#(+.$/+,$S3-4/1(3+$3S$&#))0)(1#$/-#$1"30."1$3S$/6$0+P+/10-/)G$
=`$ J364#1(&$ 60-.#-:$ (6$90-60#,$/6$/$4#/+6$3S$4/(+1#+/+&#G$ -#.0)/-):$&"#&Q(+.$1"#$
W#-$/99/-#+1$&3+S3-4(1:$13$1"#$4/+,/1#6$3S$1"#$4/)#$./_#$(6G$
'''8/05+'PPN='$'8/05+'POP=',']$='X"/0%&&%']"$;0&1`:);9+',X$).'40$/$#2?0&1'7)'D0Q)2#G70)&3'7?%'7%G?&);)10G";'$%G)&27$#G70)&')9'7?%'9%.";%'/)5*+<'0&'LC#+$B&;+1.*4#:/$3$G.+.14.+$-&'#+M:$6,;14#:$I#.1#*$N*1$K14,4&++'%5='C"$/"$"'4='F$)I'"&5'D02%'H)7%;;='EY)$)&7)3'@%"$2)&'F"&"5"'8&G=+'PTTKM'PLP='%'8/05+'PLP=
29
936#6$ (6$ +31$ /$ -#9-3,0&1(3+$ 3S$ 4/(+61-#/4$ &0)10-#$ N01$ /$
6&0)910-#6$-#6#4N)#$6&/-6$/+,$N)/1/+1):$#R936#$1"#$9)#/60-#$
$ F+31"#-$ /-1(61$ O"3$ #R/4(+#,$ 1"#$ -3)#$ 3S$ &364#1(&$
&"3&3)/1#G$ O"(&"$ 6"#$ &/61$ S-34$ "#-$ S/&#G$ /+,$ 1"#+$ S0-1"#-$
;/+(+#$F+13+(G$@(&Q$/+,$@/1"#-G$?YYZP?YY[G$6&0)910-#$(+$63/9$/+,$&"3&3)/1#G$A#O$D3-QV$
30
=\$F+$(4/.#$3S$1"(6$
6&0)91$"#-$S/&#$(6$,#+(#,=U
1"#$&"(),=X
!"-30."$1"#$9-3B$3S$9-3,0&1(3+G$ 1"#$N0616$N#&34#$S#1(6"$
$ !"#$90-936#$3S$1"(6$9/9#-$O/6$1O3PS3),V$13$())04(+/1#$
J"30(+/-,G$ C#+##$ J3RG$ W/++/"$ 2()Q#G$ /+,$ ;/+(+#$ F+13+($
9-/&1($ 3S$ N/))#1$ ,/+&(+.G$ O#/-(+.$ &3-6#16G$ /+,$ &364#1(&$
9"()3639"(&/)$ S-/4#O3-Q$6#1$301$N:$1"(6$9/9#-G$ (1$ (6$#+1(-#):$9366(N)#$ 1"/1$ 1"#:$ O#-#$ +31$ &-#/1#,$ O(1"$ 1"#$ (+1#+1(3+$ 3S$
9/9#-$ (6$ )#.(1(4/1#G$ /6$ 1"#:$O#-#$ &-#/1#,$N:$ S#4(+(61$ /-1(616$
26 D"#$"'Y$0QQ0+',R&707;%5'4$70272B'@$)k%G72'/*'\"&0&%'4&7)&0+'C%&'>0&.)#&7+'-0$_$07'Y%$"6"&0k"+<'0&'K.,4+?$G;0,;*#8'%5='-)&'VG"QQ'"&5'C$0"&'V%07a='E4;/"&*3'V7"7%'R&06%$207*')9'S%I'd)$_'@$%22+'JKKNM+'JLT=27'8/05+'JLT=28'!"$*'>%;;*+',]%20$0&1'8."1%2e8."10&1']%20$%+<'0&'!"#$)#'4+4:'$.+1$H4:;.0$G;0,;*#$I#.1#*$J+1$K14,4&+8O$%5='4.%;0"'\)&%2='ES%I'd)$_3'-)#7;%51%+'PTJTM+'NZ=
31
I(N)(3.-/9":
UC)O%(>HG(/
$*+:N)#4G)*#$'(%G$6&0)910-#$(+$63/9$
VA<W)%T7JXY8A*<PT0?)"!0J!&JAZ;%3+1-#/)V$J349/.+(#$%/-(#$
P>#:N)*(#$'(%)*#:(2@Q
?%#4G.-$'(%)#4G)@4:>(6)$
$ @(9360&1(3+V$1"#$1#&"+3)3.(&/)$-#&3+61-0&1(3+$3S$AQ(4)P-H4G#%+(/D)!)=#4#G+#4)
) 5-.(4R/);$HG+(/)0(#G(%)[%G)TG+$+-4G$#,(1#,$N:$I/-N/-/$
&'()3(.+4+/.)#4G)L+/H#>)=H>$H%()) 0(#G(%6
&'()) 3(.+4+/.)#4G)L+/H#>)=H>$H%()0(#G(%)U4G)TG+$+-46)#,(1#,$
$ &'()3(.+4+/.)#4G)L+/H#>)=H>$H%()0(#G(%)U4G)(G+$+-46$
$ &'()3(.+4+/.)#4G)L+/H#>)=H>$H%()0(#G(%)U4G)TG+$+-46$
32
;+84/6
T#$+48)=H>$H%(6$
33
"=&(.$&7(.$%&+-&1*,$5&!*,$%"-G5&'#*(*%
B44/$%&I-(,#$ 8+$ K#N#-$ =>>YG$ !(1/+(&$ ,(-#&13-$ ;/4#6$ J/4#-3+$
#4/+&(9/1(3+$ 3S$ /$ 9)/+#156$ (+,(.#+306G$ &3)3-#,$ LE1"#-6M$ (6$0)1(4/1#):$/$61#-#31:9(&/)G$-/&(61G$/+,$"/-4S0)$-#9-#6#+1/1(3+$
32,,*%<&*-/&'-*?<5+556$9-31/.3+(61$(6$/$:30+.G$4(,,)#P&)/66$O"(1#$4/+$
1#&"+3)3.:$ (+$ O"(&"$ "(6$ &3+6&(306+#66$ (6$ (49)/+1#,$ (+13$ /$
34
399-#66#,G$4/-.(+/)(_#,G$/+,$Q())#,$N:$B0-39#/+$(44(.-/+16$
O3-6"(9$ S#4/)#$ +/10-#$ .3,6G$ 06#$O/-$ 9/(+1$ /+,$ N3O6$ /+,$
0+,#-61/+,(+.$ 3S$ L43,#-+M$ 1#&"+3)3.:G$ /+,$ 693-1$%//6/(P
/+,$.-##,:$"04/+$&"/-/&1#-6$O"3$J/4#-3+$&/616$/6$O"(1#G$
35
F4#-(&/$/6$ 1"#$ -(&"$/+,$N#/01(S0)$ )/+,$F4#-(&/$&30),$N#$ (S$
$ !"#6#$ 61#-#31:9#6$ &3/)#6&#$ (+13$ /$ -/&(/)$ S/+1/6:$ 1"/1$
-#/)(_/1(3+$3&&0-6$O"#+$1"#$O"(1#$9-31/.3+(61$(6$/66(4()/1#,$
13$"(6$"04/+$N3,:G$/+,$3+&#$"#$+3$)3+.#-$&/+G$"#$"/6$N#&34#$
O"(1#6$S/+1/6(_#$/N301$N#&34(+.$31"#-$-/G$(156$3+):$S0+$(S$1"#:$&/+$N)(1"#):$(.+3-#$1"#$S0+,/4#+1/)$#R9#-(#+&#$3S$N#(+.$
/+,$ 1"#$ S/&1$ 1"/1$ "#$ (6$ 361-/&(_#,$ S-34$ 1"#$ LN/,M$ "04/+$
6#&1(3+$06#6$1"#$O3-Q$3S$S#4(+(61$1"#3-(61$N#))$"33Q6$13$#R/4(+#$
$ !"#$-/&(/)$S/+1/6:$3S$O"(1#$.0()1$/+,$-#,#491(3+$(6$+31$
36
N#))$"33Q6$O-(1#6V
$ &0)10-#$(6$1"#$&3+1#493-/-:$)3&/1(3+$1"/1$N31"$90N)(&):$$ ,#&)/-#6$/+,$9#-9#10/1#6$1"#$(,#/$1"/1$1"#-#$(6$9)#/60-#$
$ ,#)(."1G$43-#$(+1#+6#G$43-#$6/1(6S:(+.$1"/+$+3-4/)$
1"#$#R&(1(+.$/+,$,/+.#-306$/+1(1"#6(6$13$43,#-+$63&(#1:$1"/1G$
(+$ "33Q65$ /-1(&)#G$ /+,$ "#-$ /+/):6(6$ &/+$ N#$ /99)(#,$ 13$ 1"#$
E1"#-$ -#9-#6#+16$ #R9)3-/1(3+$ 1"/1$ (6$ +31$ 6##+$ /6$ -/&(61G$ N01$-/1"#-$/6$/$6#/-&"$S3-$43-#$(+1#+6#$9)#/60-#$1"/+$1"/1$1"/1$&/+$
$ a2"(1#$4/)#6b$&)/(4$1"#$N3,:$3S$1"#$&3)3-#,$E1"#-$(+61-04#+1/)):G$/6$0+#R9)3-#,$1#--/(+G$/$6:4N3)(&$S-3+1(#-$1"/1$O())$N#$S#-1()#$.-30+,$S3-$1"#(-$-#&3+61-0&1(3+$3S$1"#$4/6&0)(+#$+3-4G$S3-$/66#-1(+.$
37
&/))$093+$1"#$E1"#-$13$N#$N31"$O(1+#66$/+,$9/-1(&(9/+1$
!"(6$ &3+[$ S3&06#6$ 63)#):$ 3+$ 1"#$ #R9#-(#+&#$ 3S$ 1"#$O"(1#$
#493O#-(+.$ "(46#)S$ 1"-30."$ 6#R0/)$ &3+1/&1$ O(1"$ /$
06#,$13$S0-1"#-$1"#$9-31/.3+(6156$9#-63+/)$#493O#-4#+1$/+,$
/6V$L+361/).(/G$3S1#+$S30+,$0+,#-$(49#-(/)(64G$O"#-#$9#39)#$
3-$/6$L/$9-3B$3S$:#/-+(+.$S3-$O"/1$3+#$"/6$,#61-3:#,$1"/1$
/66(4()/1(3+$ (+13$ (+,(.#+306$ &0)10-#6$ -#9-#6#+1$ 1"(6$ )3+.(+.$
3S$,/-Q$E1"#-6$O"36#$&0)10-#6G$1-/,(1(3+6G$/+,$)(S#61:)#6$4/:$
&3++#&1#,$13$/$69(-(10/)$-#/)(1:$O(1"$O"(&"$O"(1#$&0)10-#$"/6$
1"/1$L,0-(+.$1"#$)/61$,#&/,#$3S$1"#$+(+#1##+1"$&#+10-:G$/6$1"#$
38
O(),#-+#66G$+/10-/)$9)#+1:G$6#+60/)(1:G$1"#$N3,:G$/+,$"/-43+:$
"33Q65$ /+,$C36/),356$ (49#-(/)(61$ +361/).(/$9#-S#&1):G$ 6#))(+.$
"33Q6$#R9)/(+6$(+$"#-$/-1(&)#V
$ (49#-(/)(64G$0+#49)3:4#+1G$)/&Q$3S$#&3+34(&$
$ (,#+1(1:G$&/+$N#$4/+(90)/1#,$N:$&0)10-/)$61-/1#.(#6$
$ (,#+1(1:$(+$1"#$O#61G$#69#&(/)):$/6$#R9#-(#+&#,$N:$O"(1#$
39
O/:G$"/6$ 1"#$93O#-$ 13$ -#613-#$ 3+#56$ &3++#&1(3+$ 13$+/10-#$ (S$
$ 2"(1#$ 9#39)#56$ )3+.(+.$ S3-$ 6#R0/)$ &3+1/&1$ O(1"$ 1"#$
)(S#61:)#$ 1"/1$ O"(1#$ (49#-(/)(64$ 1"-#/1#+6G$ /-#$ N31"$ &)#/-):$
/+,$ (4/.(+#$ 1"#$ #4/+&(9/1(3+$ /+,$ S-##,34$ 1"/1$ &30),$
H).$-&)+??&).+($&A$"I?$&3("I&B*J+-F&B"#+$5&?+J$&'#*(*%KL$ 81$(6$+31$/)O/:6$/6604#,$1"/1$4#,(/$/N301$O"(1#$.0()1G$
1"/1$ B0-39#/+$ &0)10-#$ )/&Q6$ &3++#&1(3+6$ O(1"$ +/10-#G$ O(1"$69(-(10/)(1:G$ 3-$ O(1"$ #49/1":$ (6$ +31$ +#B/-():$ /$ "/-4S0)$
40
"#$O-(1#6G$L13$N#$O"(1#G$3-$61-/(."1G$3-$4/)#G$3-$4(,,)#$&)/66$(6$
O"(1#$ 4/)#$ )#/,#-6"(9$ (6$ /+$ /6604#,$ -(."1$ O"(&"$ ,#&/,#6$
9-31/.3+(61$(6$1"#$)#/,#-$N#&/06#$(1$6##46$+/10-/)$S3-$"(4$13$
/-#$ -#/)(1(#6G$ O"(&"$ 0)1(4/1#):$ (6$ 1"#$ -#/63+$O"(1#$ 9#39)#56$
/+1(P&3)3+(/)(61$/+,$/+1(P-/&(61G$N01$1"#$936(1(3+6$3S$)#/,#-6"(9$
41
S3-$&3+1/&1$O(1"$1"#$E1"#-$(6$0)1(4/1#):$/$-30+,P/PN301$O/:$3S$
$ (6$ +31$ /N301$ 1"#$ 399-#66(3+$ /+,$
42
:#1$4/66$4#,(/$&/++31$6##4$13$ )#1$.3$3S$ 1"(6$613-:$3S$O"(1#$
#66#+1(/)$13$-#&3.+(_#$1"/1$613-(#6$S#/10-(+.$&3)3-#,$9#39)#$/-#$+31$ +#B/-():$ 613-(#6$ /N301$ 1"36#$ 9#39)#G$ 9#-"/96$ ,#69(1#$
1"#$ 93O#-$ 13$ &"/))#+.#$ ,##9P-331#,$ -/&(/)$ /660491(3+6$ 3+$
43
23-Q6$J(1#,
44
7()):$6()):$4(6.0(,#,$)/,:G
@#156$.-3O$30-$"/(-G
D30^$D30$O/+1$(+6(61$3+$0+O/R#,$099#-@(96G$,(-1:$N-3O+$4/+P6"3#6G$61-/(1;/&Q#16$/+,$6()Q$1(#6$O(1"$O34N6!"/1$&/+51$&)/(4
D30$
$ $
AM%31"#-$#/-1"$4061$N#
234#+$O#/-$1"#$9/+16$/+,$O#))G
K3O+$1"#$10N#$3S$"(613-:!"#$4:61#-:$3S$S#4(+(64$N#
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$O(),#-6
$$$$$$$$$$!"#:$O/+1$$ $ $$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$609#-(3-(1:
$$
A/10-/)):$3-,/(+#,$93O#-$
9#-6(61G$
O3-,V
F+,$1"#+$85))$1#))$1"#4
45
7()):$6()):$4(6.0(,#,$)/,:G
@#156$.-3O$30-$"/(-G
D30^$D30$O/+1$(+6(61$3+$0+O/R#,$099#-@(96G$,(-1:$N-3O+$4/+P6"3#6G$61-/(1;/&Q#16$/+,$6()Q$1(#6$O(1"$O34N6!"/1$&/+51$&)/(4
D30$
$ $
P$'-/&#$;3"+
46
>?*9J&N$5E+*-50&'&O$9+I$&="%&*-&7II%$55+#$&N*<$%&!*J$
A(&"3)/6$%0,-(&Q
:-(%"/29(+"-$ @#6N(/+$ O34#+$ 3S$ &3)3-$ /-#$ #+1/+.)#,$ O(1"(+$ /$
J/0&/6(/+$&30+1#-9/-16G$)#6N(/+6$3S$&3)3-$"/-N3-$1"#$/,,(1(3+/)$
#1"+(&$4(+3-(1:56$&3440+(1:G$1"#(-$6#R0/)$(,#+1(1:$4/:$N#$/))$
6#R(64G$ /+,$ "#1#-36#R(64$ 3S$ N31"$ ,34(+/+1$ /+,$ 4(+3-(1:$
1"#$"(613-:$3S$1"#$*+(1#,$71/1#6G$63&(#1:$"/6$N##+$&3+S-3+1(+.$
%/-1(+#_$/-.0#6$/$ -/+.#$3S$ S/&13-6$ 6"30),$N#$&3+6(,#-#,$ (+$,#1#-4(+(+.$ 1"#$ (49/&1$ 3S$ #1"+(&$ (,#+1(1:G$ .#+,#-G$ 6#R0/)$3-(#+1/1(3+G$ /+,$ 1"#(-$ 3+.3(+.$ /+,$ ,:+/4(&$ (+1#-/&1(3+$
O(1"$'-##+#G$ 1"#6#$#)#4#+16$ (+&)0,#$1"#$,34(+/+1$&0)10-#56$1-/,(1(3+/)$.#+,#-P-3)#$61#-#31:9#6G$ 1"#$-3)#$/+,$(493-1/+&#$3S$ S/4():$ /+,$ &3440+(1:G$ /+,$ 1"#$ -3)#$ 3S$ -#)(.(3+$ /+,$
-3)#$3S$-/&(/)$/+,$#1"+(&$61#-#31:9#6G$1"#$(+&(,#+&#$3S$-/&(64$/+,$ 6#R(64$O(1"(+$ 1"#$4(+3-(1:$ &0)10-#G$ /+,$ 1"#$ ,34(+/+1$&0)10-#56$(4936(1(3+$3S$1"#$L#1"+36#R0/)$4:1"3)3.:M$3+$1"#6#$
47
)#6N(/+6$3S$&3)3-$&/++31$/0134/1(&/)):$#R9#&1$1"#$/&[/+&#$
$ C#6#/-&"$3+$)#6N(/+6$3S$&3)3-$(6$ )(4(1#,$(+$/+/):6(6$3S$
9#39)#6$"/6$N##+$"(+,#-#,$N:$6/49)(+.$/+,$4#1"3,3)3.(&/)$#--3-6G$ S0+,(+.$ )(4(1/1(3+6G$ /+,$ 93)(&(#6$ /&1(+.$ 13$ 1"#$
@'I!$ 9#39)#$ "/6$ "/,$ /$ 9-#,34(+/+1):$ J/0&/6(/+$ S3&06G$
-#6#/-&"$ /)63$ S/()6$ 13$ /&&30+1$ S3-$ 1"#$ 9-/&1(&/)$ 63&(/)$ /+,$96:&"3)3.(&/)$1/6Q6$/+,$61-#663-6$1"/1$/-#$&3493+#+16$13$1"#$
.-3096$ 3S$ 6#R0/)G$ -/&(/)G$ /+,$ S#4/)#$4(+3-(1(#6$ -#6#/-&"$ 3+$
$ !"#$90-936#$3S$1"(6$9/9#-$(6$13$&3+63)(,/1#$O"/1$)(11)#$
&0)10-/)$&3+1#R1$(+$O"(&"$(660#6$3S$"#1#-36#R(64G$"3439"3N(/G$
48
1"#$ &34(+.$ 301$ 9-3B$ /+,$ 1"#$ (+1#.-/1(3+$ 3S$ (,#+1(1:$ /+,$96:&"3)3.(&/)$(660#6$/+,$O())$&3+&)0,#$O(1"$/+$#R/4(+/1(3+$3+$1"#6#$(660#6$/+,$1"#(-$(49)(&/1(3+6$S3-$96:&"31"#-/9#01(&$
N+($%*(2%$&O$#+$P!)=H>$H%#>)P#:N8%-H4G
N31"$1"#$9-3S#66(3+/)$/+,$.#+#-/)$&3440+(1:$13$60&&04N$13$
9-3431#,$ N:$ 1"#$ ,34(+/+1$ &0)10-#G$ 1"#:$ /-#$ /)63$ -#1/(+#,$
,3$+31$ &3+S3-4$ 13$ 1-/,(1(3+/)$ .#+,#-P-3)#$ 61#-#31:9#6$4061$
$ F+$ (493-1/+1$ &3493+#+1$ 13$ /$,(6&066(3+$ &3+&#-+(+.$)#6N(/+6$ 3S$ &3)3-$ (6$ /+$ #R9)/+/1(3+$ 3S$ 63&(/)$ /+,$ "(613-(&/)$#)#4#+16$ /+,$ 1"#(-$ &3+1-(N01(3+6$ 13$ 1"#$ &-#/1(3+$ 3S$ /+$
1"#$6#R0/)):$9-34(6&0306G$43-/)):$ )336#G$4/6&0)(+(_#,G$/+,$
1"/1V$ 71#-#31:9#6$1"/1$,#9(&1$)#6N(/+6$/6$4/6&0)(+(_#,$$ O34#+$93(.+/+1):$(+1#-6#&1$O(1"$61#-#31:9#6$3S$$ FS-(&/+$F4#-(&/+$/+,$FS-(&/+$J/-(NN#/+$O34#+$(+$
!"#$9#-[(3+$3S$1"#$#R31(&$FS-(&/+$O34/+$"/6$&3+1-(N01#,$
49
$ !"#$61-#+.1"$3S$S/4():$1(#6$-#9-#6#+1#,$(+$1"#$FS-(&/+$
(+13)#-/+&#$/+,$39936(1(3+$13$1"#(-$6#R0/)$3-(#+1/1(3+$9#-6(616$
9#-[(3+G$1"#$S/4():$4/:$&"336#$13$4/(+1/(+$/$-#)/1(3+6"(9$
)#6N(/+6$3S$FS-(&/+$,#6&#+1$"/6$N##+$.-3O(+.$/+,$9-3,0&(+.$/$6#1$3S$+#O$&0)10-#6$/+,$+#O$(,#+1(1(#6$O(1"(+$1"#6#$4(+3-(1:$
=-.+48)AH$$ B49(-(&/)$ )(1#-/10-#$ 60--30+,(+.$ N)/&Q$ )#6N(/+G$ ./:$/+,$N(6#R0/)G$3-$@'I!$:301"$/+,$1"#(-$9-3B#6$3S$&34(+.$301$ (6$ O-30."1$ O(1"$ &3+1-/,(&1(3+6$ /+,$ #R9#&1/1(3+/)$
60..#61$ 1"/1$ 1"#$ &0)10-/)$ S/&13-6$ 3S$ S/4()(/)$ (493-1/+&#G$
50
/+,$ O(,#69-#/,$ "3439"3N(/$ /+,$ -/&(64$ 4/:$ )#/,$ 13$ 1"#$
&3+6(616$ 3S$ 1"#$ 9366(N()(1:$ 1"/1$ 61-3+.#-$ &0)10-/)$ 9-#660-#6$
O(1"(+$1"#$9-#,34(+/+1):$2"(1#$/+,$@'I!$&3440+(1:$1"/1$
$ C#6#/-&"$3+$1"#6#$":931"#6#6$"/6$:(#),#,$&3+1-/,(&13-:$
)3+.(10,(+/)$ -#93-1$ 3S$ ?[`$ @'I!$ :301"6$ 13$ #R/4(+#$ #1"+(&$
40)1(9)#$4(+3-(1:$61/106#6$/+,$4#+1/)$"#/)1"$(+$/,3)#6&#+16$
$ C#6#/-&"$ (+13$ 1"#$ &/06/)(1:$ N#"(+,$ 1"#$ )(4(1#,$96:&"3)3.(&/)$,(61-#66$6"3O+$N:$N)/&Q$)#6N(/+$/,3)#6&#+16$"/6$"(613-(&/)):$(+,(&/1#,$1"/1$N:$/,3)#6&#+&#G$4361$N)/&Q$:301"6$
N3361$ 6#)SP#61##4$/+,$ 13$ S/&()(1/1#$ /+$ #R&"/+.#$3S$ -#630-$
51
(,#+1(1(#6$ 4/:$ N#$ &/06#,$ N:$ &3+S30+,6$ 3S$ /&[/+&#$ /+,$
JG(4$+$F
+3-46$ /+,$ #R9#&1/1(3+6G$ O"()#$ 6(40)1/+#306):$ /&[(+.$ /$
9#-63+6$ /-#$ 9)/&#,$ (+$ /$ &349)(&/1#,$936(1(3+$ /6$ /$4(+3-(1:$.-309$S3-$1"#$-#/63+$1"/1$1"#(-$9/-#+16$/+,$S/4()(#6$.#+#-/)):$
/&1$13$)(4(1$1"#$(+1#-+/)(_/1(3+$/+,$/&[/+&#$3S$/+$(+1#.-/1#,$
F))$1"(6$(6$&34930+,#,$O(1"$1"#$S/&1$1"/1$(,#+1(1:$S3-4/1(3+$
1"#$&"/))#+.#6$1"/1$&3+1#493-/-:$1"#3-#1(&/)$ )(1#-/10-#$S/$O"#+$/11#491(+.$13$&-#/1#$/+,$(+1#.-/1#$/$60&BS0)$43,#)$
$ %361$1"#3-#1(&/)$-#6#/-&"$60--30+,(+.$6#R0/)$(,#+1(1:$
O(1"$ 6/4#P6#R$ /11-/&1(3+G$ 1"#+$ #R9)3-/1(3+G$ /+,$ #+,(+.$ (+$9#-63+/)$/&[/+&#$/+,$90N)(&$-#&3.+(1(3+$S3-$1"#$+#OS30+,$
52
N(6#R0/)6$/+,$1-/+6$9#39)#6$O(1"$./:$4#+$/+,$)#6N(/+6$/+,$
$ C#&#+1$43,#)6$3S$(,#+1(1:$S3-4/1(3+$3+$1"#$&34(+.$301$
13O/-,6$ N31"$ .-3096$ /+,$ 1"#(-$ Q+3O)#,.#$ 3S$ 1"#$ &0)10-/)$
1"#$#61/N)(6"4#+1$3S$4/+:$N/6#6$3S$63&(/)$60993-1$13$4#,(/1#$
!"30."$/$)/&Q$3S$#49(-(&/)$,/1/$#R(616$13$60993-1$1"(6$(,#3)3.:G$
&3493+#+16$&3+1-(N01(+.$13$/$60&BS0)$#R(61#+&#$O(1"(+$1"#$
53
)#6N(/+6$3S$FS-(&/+$,#6&#+1G$1"#:$"(.")(."1#,$1"#$(493-1/+&#$
1"/1$9/-1(&(9/+16$O"3$#4N-/&#,$/+,$&#)#N-/1#,$1"#(-$)#6N(/+$
7(4$#>)1(#>$')J//H(/$ B1"+(&$4(+3-(1:$./:6$/+,$)#6N(/+6$/-#$6(10/1#,$O(1"(+$
3S$ 399-#66(3+$ /+,$ ,(6&-(4(+/1(3+$ 1"/1$ /&&349/+(#6$ 60&"$
1"#$S/&1$1"/1$6099-#66(3+$3S$/$,#)#1#-(306$#R9#-(#+&#$)(4(16$/+$
3S$,(6&-(4(+/1(3+$N01$-#S06#,$13$,(6&066$1"#(-$#R9#-(#+$"/,$
54
/+,$O34#+$-#693+,#+16$O"3$/&[#,$1"#$,(6&-(4(+/1(3+$N01$
/,,-#66(+.$(660#6$S/&#,$N:$)#6N(/+6$3S$FS-(&/+$,#6&#+1$/6$1"#:$/-#$&3+S-3+1#,$N:$40)1(9)#$399-#66(3+6$N/6#,$3+$1"#(-$4/+:$
$ 8+$/&&3-,/+&#$O(1"$-#6#/-&"$(49)(&/1(+.$1"#$(493-1/+&#$
3+$1"#$4#+1/)$"#/)1"$3S$I)/&Q$)#6N(/+6G$7_:4/+6Q($/+,$'091/$
O(1"$ 6#)SP#61##4$ /+,$ 4/:$ N#$ 1"#$ 4361$ 96:&"3)3.(&/)):$
"#1#-36#R(64$/+,$(+1#-+/)(_#,$-/&(64G$60993-1(+.$/$40)1(9)#$
55
)/&Q$ 3S$ 60993-1$ S-34$ 1"#(-$ (44#,(/1#$ &3440+(1:$ /+,$ /$
:,I?+9*(+"-5&="%&A%*9(+9$$ !"30."$4361$ #49(-(&/)$ -#6#/-&"$ #R9)(&/1(+.$ &3+1#R16$(+$O"(&"$)#6N(/+6$3S$&3)3-$4061$S/&#$(6$61())$(+$(16$(+S/+&:G$(1$(6$
C(."1$ +3OG$ 1"#-#$ #R(616$ 1"#$ +##,$ 13$ #R/4(+#$ 1"#$ 6(10/1(3+/)$
(.+3-#$-/&(61$)/N#)6G$/+,$&34N/1$61/1#4#+16$0+,#-4(+(+.$1"#(-$
/-.0#6$S3-$1"#$1"#-/9(61$13$0+,#-.3$9#-63+/)$#R/4(+/1(3+$3S$
N/&Q.-30+,$/+,$1"#$.-#/1#-$(660#6$S/&(+.$1"#$6#R0/)$4(+3-(1:$
&3+,0&1$ "#-$ 3O+$ #R/4(+/1(3+$ 3S$ "#-$ 9#-63+/)$ S##)(+.6$ /+,$-#693+6#6$13$"#-$-/&(/)$/+,$6#R0/)$4(+3-(1:$&)(#+16G$(+&)0,(+.$
56
3S$1"#$61#-#31:9#6$/+,$(+/&&0-/1#$39(+(3+6$/N301$6#R0/)$/+,$
/)63$/&&3443,/1#$1"#$&)(#+1$13$60&"$/+$#R1#+1$1"/1$1"#-#$)/&Q6$
4061$ N#$ 60-#$ 1"/1$ 1"#$ (660#6$ 3S$ "#1#-36#R(64G$ "3439"3N(/G$
&34#6$13$S-0(1(3+$3&&0-6$,0-(+.$/$-(6Q$9#-(3,G$/6$1"#$9-3N)#46$
S/4():G$ 433,$ ,(63-,#-6G$ 9-#.+/+&:G$ /+$ (+&-#/6#,$ -(6Q$ S3-$6#R0/)):$ 1-/+64(11#,$ (+S#&1(3+6G$ 60N61/+&#$ /N06#G$ (+1#+6#$
(+&)0,#$/-#$&0)10-/)):$&3+1#R10/)G$60&"$/6$1"#$O(,#69-#/,$N#)(#S6$(+$1"#$FS-(&/+$F4#-(&/+$&3440+(1:$/6$1"#$9-39/./1(3+$3S$1"#$
#R/4(+#$1"#$(+1#-/&1(3+$N#1O##+$1"#$,34(+/+1$/+,$4(+3-(1:$
/+,$/66(4()/1(3+$3S$1"#$&)(#+1$O(1"(+$1"#6#$&3440+(1(#6$/+,$/+$
1"#$1"#-/9(61$,3#6$+31$9-#604#$/+:1"(+.$/N301$1"#(-$&)(#+165$#R9#-(#+$ /6$ #/&"$ O34/+$ /11#+,6$ 13$ /+,$ ,#/)6$ O(1"$
57
J30+6#)3-6$/-#$#+&30-/.#,$13$9-3431#$/+$/O/-#+#66$3S$ 1"#$
J3+&3-,/+1):G$'-##+#$/-.0#6$1"/1$1"#$&)(#+1$6"30),$N#$4/,#$
4/+/.#4#+1$ 61-/1#.(#6$ /43+.$ )#6N(/+6$ 3S$FS-(&/+$ /+=-:G$
"/-4S0)$ N#)(#S6$ /+,$ 13$ "#)9$ 9-3431#$ /+$ /&[(+.$ /+,$
!"-9?25+"-
1"#$ 61(.4/$ /11/&"#,$ 13$ 1"#(-$ 6#R0/)$ 3-(#+1/1(3+$ N01$ /)63$
58
B49(-(&/)$)(1#-/10-#$60--30+,(+.$1"#$&34(+.$301$9-3BG$1"#$&-#/1(3+$/+,$4/(+1#+/+&#$3S$/$I)/&Q$)#6N(/+$(,#+1(1:G$/+,$1"#(-$
/-#$9-34(6(+.G$(+$+3$O/:$/-#$1"#:$.#+#-/)(_/N)#$3-$3-./+(_#,$(+$ 60&"$/$4/++#-$ /6$ 13$,-/O$,(-#&1$ &3+&)06(3+6G$O"(&"$ &/+$
-#6#/-&"$60--30+,(+.$1"#6#$(660#6$(6$"39#S0)$N01$(6$(+$+##,$3S$
59
C#S#-#+$
$ B1"+(&(1:G$/+,$C34/+1(&$F11-/&1(3+6V$%0)1(9)#$
$ =H>$H%#>)<+"(%/+$F)#4G)T$'4+:)7+4-%+$F)O/F:'->-8F)B\
$ S-H%4#>)-,)?#F)])*(/V+#4)7(4$#>)1(#>$'6)B^
$ 8,#+1(1:G$/+,$7#R0/)$8,#+1(1:$3S$@#6N(/+6$/+,$'/:$S-H%4#>)-,)?#F)])*(/V+#4);-:+#>);(%"+:(/6)UU
$ 8,#+1(1:$%/+/.#4#+1$71-/1#.(#6$F43+.$@#6N(/+6$3S$S-H%4#>)-,)*?P&&)J//H(/)+4)
) =-H4/(>+486)B
S-H%4#>)-,)) =-4/H>$+48)#4G)=>+4+:#>)O/F:'->-8F6)_U
S-H%4#>)-,)*(/V+#4)) ;$HG+(/6)B
=H>$H%#>)) <+"(%/+$F)#4G)T$'4+:)7+4-%+$F)O/F:'->-8F6)B\
!.(%+:#4)) S-H%4#>)-,)A%$'-Q/F:'+#$%F6)`a
O/F:'->-8+:#>)PH>>($+46)BBC
S-H%4#>)-,)1-.-/(EH#>+$F6)C^
60
$ @#6N(/+$8,#+1(1:$/+,$(16$849)(&/1(3+6$S3-$J30+6#)(+.$&'()=-H4/(>+48)O/F:'->-8+/$6)UC
$ !.(%+:#4)S-H%4#>)-,)OHV>+:)1(#>$'6)B\\
&'()=-H4/(>+48)O/F:'->-8+/$6)) [b
$ B1"+(&(1:$/+,$7#R0/)$E-(#+1/1(3+V$8+1#-6#&1(+.$=H>$H%#>)<+"(%/+$F)#4G)T$'4+:)7+4-%+$F)
) O/F:'->-8F6)B\
$ @#6N(/+G$'/:G$/+,$I(6#R0/)$D301"6V$F$J349/-(63+$3S$=H>$H%#>)
) <+"(%/+$F)#4G)T$'4+:)7+4-%+$F)O/F:'->-8F6)B\
!)Z(I)*--N)#$)1-.-Q'-V+#)#4G)1($(%-/(E+/.)+4)) =#4#G#
$ 5-.(4)])&'(%#QF6)U`
S-H%4#>)-,)*(/V+#4);$HG+(/6)) U
S-H%4#>)) -,)*?P&&)J//H(/)+4)=-H4/(>+486)UU
61
$ C#)/1(3+6"(9$I#1O##+$%0)1(9)#$8+1#-+/)(_#,$$ E99-#66(3+6$/+,$FS-(&/+$F4#-(&/+$@#6N(/+G$'/:G$
S-H%4#>)-,)=-H4/(>+48)) O/F:'->-8F6)^_
S-H%4#>)) -,)1-.-/(EH#>+$F6)B`
62
@C3>#+$D-#$4(6#$C/1#-A9?
;"/-+/$E#?
63
8+$-#&#+1$,#&/,#6G$/+$(+&-#/6(+.$+04N#-$3S$O34#+$(+$
3S$.:+#&3)3.(&/)$60-.#-(#6$06#,$13$&0-#$0-(+/-:$(+&3+1(+#+&#$
/+/134:M$O"(&"$9-(4/-():$/(4$13$/)1#-$/#61"#1(&6$-/1"#-$1"/+$
/+,$ /$ -#60)1$ 3S$ 1"#$ N(+/-:$ .#+,#-$ 6:61#4$ 1"/1$ &3+1(+0#6$ 13$
&0)10-#6$ 1"#$ &)(13-(6$ (6$ 6##+$/6$ (+"#-#+1):$4/)#$ /+,$4061$N#$
H'&A.*-(",&B*?$&>"/<L0&Q$,*?$&C$-+(*?&!"5,$(+9&32%F$%<&R&C$-/$%&8+,"%I.+5,
64
6#RM$O"(&"$4061$N#$#)(4(+/1#,$(+$3-,#-$S3-$/$L9-39#-M$6#R0/)$
N:$ #R&(6(3+G$ 1"#$ S#4/)#$ N3,:$ (6$ &3+6(,#-#,$ ]133$4/6&0)(+#5$
.#+(1/)$ &011(+.$O"(&"$ (6$ &3+&#-+#,$O(1"$ 1"#$9-39#-$ 6)311(+.$
S#4/)#$&(-&04&(6(3+$(+$/+&(#+1$B.:91$/+,$'-##&#$/+,$/&&30+16$3S$ &)(13-(,#&134(#6$ S3-$O34#+$O(1"$ L4/6&0)(+#$ ,#6(-#6M$ (+$
O34#+$,##4#,$6069#&1$N:$1"#(-$-/&#$3-$1"#(-$6#R0/)(1:G$60&"$/6$
9-361(101#6$ O"#-#N:$ L(+/99-39-(/1#$ S#4(+(+#$ #4N3,(4#+1$
1"#$/+/134:$3S$/$9"/+134$4/)#$N3,:$(+"/N(1(+.$1"#$)#6N(/+56$
4/99#,$3+13$1"#$N3,(#6$3S$O34#+$O(1"$(49-39#-$6#R0/)(1(#6G$
-#&344#+,#,$ &)(13-(,#&134(#6$ S3-$ )#6N(/+(64$ 6(+&#$ 1"#$6#&3+,$&#+10-:G$S3-$4/610-N/1(3+$6(+&#$1"#$1#+1"$&#+10-:G$/+,$S3-$ +:49"34/+(/$ /+,$ 1"#$ ":9#-1-39":$ 3S$ S#4/)#$ .#+(1/)(/$
65
?Y`>6G$9":6(&(/+6$(+$B+.)/+,$/+,$1"#$*+(1#,$71/1#6$-301(+#):$
F69#&16$ 3S$ S#4/)#$ .#+(1/)(/$O"(&"$ /-#$ &3443+):$ &3--#&1#,$
/6$ 9/1"3)3.(&/)$ N#&/06#$ 1"#:$ N)0-$ 1"#$ N30+,/-(#6$ N#1O##+$
/-#$ -#./-,#,$ /6$ +31$ 3+):$ 0+6(."1):$ N01$ 9-3N)#4/1(&$ /+,$ (+$
$ !"(6$ -#)/1#6$,(-#&1):$ 13$/$ 1"(-,$ S3-4$3S$ S#4/)#$.#+(1/)$&011(+.G$O"(&"$(16#)S$(6$3+#$9-/&1(&#$O(1"(+$/$N-3/,#-$/--/:$3S$
N(-1"6$ /-#$ &3+6(,#-#,$ #4#-.#+&(#6$ ,#4/+,(+.$ (44#,(/1#$
J"/6#$/-.0#6$1"/1$(+1#-6#R0/)(1:$(6$4/+/.#,$(+$1"(6$O/:$+31$
4/Q(+.$4/)#$/+,$S#4/)#$.#+(1/)(/$(+13$,(6&-#1#$39936(1#6G$1"#$4/+/.#4#+1$ 3S$ (+1#-6#R$ N3,(#6$ /)(.+6$O(1"$ &0)10-/)$ N#)(#S6$/N301$1"#$,(&"3134306$+/10-#$3S$6#R$/6$(1$/11#4916$13$-#+,#-$
&)(13-39)/61:$ /-#$ 9#-S3-4#,$ 3+$ (+1#-6#R$ (+S/+16$ (+$ 3-,#-$ 13$
66
31"#-(+.M$3S$&)(13-(,#&134:$(+$1"#$!"(-,$23-),$&3+1#R1$O"(&"$
60-.#-:$S3-$(+1#-6#R$].(-)65$O/6$39#+):$Q+3O+$/6$&)(13-#&134:$
+#B(1/1(+.$ &364#1(&$ 60-.#-:$ S3-$O34#+$ /-#$ )#66$ 0+(S3-4$
/-#/$N#1O##+$1"#$/&[/N)#$6(_#$3S$/$&)(13-(6$/+,$1"#$/&[/N)#$
3S$.#+,#-$,(43-9"(64$(6$06#,$13$,#1#-4(+#$O"#+$/$O34/+56$.#+(1/)6$ /-#$ 9/1"3)3.(&/)T$ O"#+$ 1"#:$ /-#$ 133$ ]4/6&0)(+#5$
/,-#+/)$ ":9#-9)/6(/$ /99#/-$ )#66$ )(Q#$ N3:6$ N:$ /4901/1(+.$
63&(/)$6:61#4$6#1$09$/)3+.$6#R$/+,$.#+,#-$)(+#6$&3+1(+0#6$13$
+31$9#-S3-4#,$S3-$S0+&1(3+/)$-#/63+6$N01$63)#):$S3-$/#61"#1(&$
13$4/Q#$/$43-#$ S#4(+(+#P)33Q(+.$.#+(1/)$/-#/M$ (6$4#,(&/)):$
67
O(1"(+$ 1"#$ 1O3P6#RP.#+,#-$ 6:61#4G$ /,"#-(+.$ 13$ 61-(&1$ -0)#6$
&364#1(&$60-.#-:$(6$L9-#,(&/1#,$3+$1"#$/660491(3+$1"/1$634#$N3,(#6$ /-#$ (+$ +##,$ 3S$ 60-.(&/)$ &3--#&1(3+$ (+$ 3-,#-$ 13$ 4##1$
&/06#,$ 60-.#-:$ 13$ N#$ 6##+$ /6$ 1"#$ 3+):$ 63)01(3+G$ 9-#&)0,(+.$96:&"3)3.(&/)G$/+,$9#-"/96$4361$(493-1/+1):G$63&(3P93)(1(&/)$
O"#-#$aO34#+b$&3+1(+0/)):$/+,$-301(+#):$1/Q#$613&Q$3S$1"#(-$
/(4$3S$1"(6$9/9#-$(6$+31$13$,#+:$O34#+56$/.#+&:$(+$4/Q(+.$,#&(6(3+6$/N301$1"#(-$N3,(#6G$N01$13$1/Q#$(+13$&3+6(,#-/1(3+$1"#$
734#$60-.#3+6$/+,$6&"3)/-6$93(+1$13$6"(S16$(+$&0)10-/)$+3-46$
68
N:$ L931#+1(/)):$ &-#/1(+.$ /$ 6#)SP-#S#-#+1(/)$ &:&)#$ (+$ O"(&"$
(+1#--091(+.$(+$ 1#-46$ 3S$ O34#+56$ 9":6(&/)$ N3,(#6$ /+,$ /)63$ (+$ 1#-46$ 3S$
1"#$+/10-/)+#66$3S$1"#$N(+/-:$.#+,#-$43,#)$(6$/$06#S0)$61/-1(+.$
4#,(&/)$ #61/N)(6"4#+1$ "/6$ /))3O#,$ 06$ 13$ (+6(61$ 1"/1$ 9#39)#$/-#$#(1"#-$+/10-/)):$4/)#$3-$ S#4/)#$N:$/11#491(+.$ 13$-#+,#-$
&0--#+1$61/+,/-,6$3S$&0)10-/)$(+1#))(.(N()(1:$(+$1"#$4/+/.#4#+1$
8+$N31"$&/6#6G$0++#B/-:$60-.#-(#6$O(1"$931#+1(/)$(/1-3.#+(&$
60-.#-:$L4(."1$"#)9$:30$Q##9$:30-$4/+$S-34$-0++(+.$/S1#-$
9":6(&/)$ &349)(&/1(3+6G$ 60&"$ /6$ 9/(+S0)$ (+1#-&30-6#$ 3-$
69
N#(+.$3S$O34#+$N#S3-#$1"#$]/99-39-(/1#+#665$3S$1"#(-$.#+(1/)6$
/663&(/1(3+6$13$&3))#&1$,/1/$3+$1"#6#$9-3&#,0-#6G$/+,$&#+60-#$
O())$9-3,0&#$+#O$/&&30+16$3S$+/10-#$/+,$4/Q#$(1$9366(N)#$S3-$
I3-+61#(+G$.#+,#-$(6$90-#):$/$63&(/)$&3+61-0&1G$09"#),$N:$30-$
/-.0#6$ 1"/1$ 1"#$ 1-/+6.#+,#-#,$ 1"(-,$ 6"30),$ #4N-/&#$ 1"#(-$
N(+/-:$6:61#4$1"/1$9/1"3)3.(_#6$1"#6#$O34#+G$O"(&"$4(."1$
70
63&(#1:$ S-##$ S-34$1"#$&3+61-/(+16$3S$+3+P&3+6#+60/)$.#+,#-M$
O#-#$ +3$ )3+.#-$ "#),$ 13$ 1"#$ 61-(&1$ -0)#6$ 3S$ (+1#))(.(N()(1:$ /+,$
/+:3+#$O"3$&/-#6$13$/,4(1$1"#(-$3O+$.#+,#-$/4N(.0(1(#6G$/$N/++#-$1"/1$(+&)0,#6$/))$6#R0/)(1(#6G$-/$/+,$#1"+(&(1(#6G$/.#6G$
K#69(1#$ 1"#$ )(N#-/1(+.$ 9366(N()(1(#6$ 3S$ ,#&3+61-0&1(+.$
/./(+61$1"#$+31(3+$3S$/N/+,3+(+.$1"#$.#+,#-$N(+/-:G$93(+1(+.$301$1"/1$6#RP$3-$.#+,#-PN/6#,$,(6&-(4(+/1(3+$4/:$+31$#+,$O(1"$
O30),$(16#)S$N#$/$S3-4$3S$399-#66(3+G$/Q(+$13$&34N/1(+.$-/&(64$N:$/N3)(6"(+.$-/&(/)$3-$#1"+(&$&/1#.3-(#6T$43-/)):$4/+,/1(+.$
71
/&Q+3O)#,.#$1"#$9":6(&/)$S/&16$093+$O"(&"$.#+,#-$(6$N/6#,M$
/-.0#6$1"/1$6##(+.$.#+,#-$/6$(+"#-#+1):$N/,$(.+3-#6$1"#$O/:$
O34#+$/-#$&349)(&(1$(+$/+,$9#-9#10/1#$1"#(-$3O+$399-#66(3+$
O34#+$O"3$#+./.#$(+$&364#1(&$60-.#-:$4/:$,3$63$13$&349):$O(1"$&0)10-/)$&3+61-/(+16$3S$S#4(+(+(1:$O"()#$6(40)1/+#306):$
63&(/)$6#R$-3)#6$(+$/$O/:$1"/1$O())$-#63+/1#$O(1"$9#39)#$O"3$,3$+31$&3+6&(306):$#R9#-(#+&#$.#+,#-$,:69"3-(/G$/$1/6Q$1"/1$
/-.0#6$/./(+61$1"#$,(663)01(3+$3S$1"#$.#+,#-$N(+/-:G$6"#$,3#6$
N#$S-##$13$"3),$3+$13$1"#(-$N(3)3.(&/)$6#R$/+,$/66(.+#,$.#+,#-G$
936(16$ 1"/1$ O#$ 6"30),$ N#.(+$ -/(6(+.$ &3+6&(306+#66$ /N301$
#R9#-(#+G$N-(+.(+.$L.#+,#-$1:-/++:M$13$)(."1$N:$#R/4(+(+.$
72
&/1#.3-(#6$3S$4/)#$/+,$S#4/)#$61())$#R(61G$.#+,#-$4/:$N#$)#66$(493-1/+1$1"/+$31"#-$/69#&16$3S$(,#+1(1:G$O"#-#$(1$(6$9366(N)#$
-/1"#-$ 1"/+$4/+,/13-:$ /+,$ /))3O(+.$ -3)#6$ S3-$ 9#39)#$ O"3$
.#+(1/)$(,#/)$(+$3-,#-$13$&349):$O(1"$&0)10-/)$-0)#6$4/+,/1(+.$
#4#-.#+&:$60-.#-(#6$S3-$(+1#-6#R$&"(),-#+G$/+,$S#4/)#$.#+(1/)$
/+,$ -#)/1(3+6"(96G$ N01$ (6$ 0)1(4/1#):$ 9#-S3-4#,$ 13$ &3--#&1$.#+(1/)6$1"/1$60..#61$/$]4/6&0)(+(1:5$0+/&[/N)#$/&&3-,(+.$
,#&3+61-0&1(3+$3S$1"#$N(+/-:$(16#)SV$N3,(#6$O30),$&#/6#$13$N#$
73
63&(#1/)$&3+61-/(+16$O(1"(+$O"(&"$1"#:$4/Q#$,#&(6(3+6$/N301$
23-Q6$J(1#,
$ /+,$1"#$9/1"3)3.(6/1(3+$3S$S#4/)#$
$ /+,$FN06#$3S$1"#$%3,#-+$
6,S
74
HS*,*5($<&!*-*/*LT.$&:,I*9(&"=&!2?(2%*?&S*(+"-*?+5,&"-&:-/+*-&)",$-&+-&(.$&8+*5I"%*
$
c;-.($+.(/)I(),((>)$'#$)I()/$%#GG>()$I-):H>$H%(/d)#$)-$'(%)$+.(/6)$'#$)I(),#>>)V($I((4)$I-)/$-->/KeB
)))
S/4():$ 1"-30."301$ 4:$ /,3)#6&#+&#$ &3+1-(N01#,$ 13$ 4:$
4:$ +3+P8+,(/+$ S-(#+,6$O#-#$ +31$ /N)#$ 13$ 0+,#-61/+,$O":$ 8$&30),$+31$1/Q#$1"#$N06$/)3+#$/1$+(."1G$/11#+,$&#-1/(+$&3+&#-16$
#+30."G$4:$8+,3PJ/+/,(/+$S-(#+,6G$O"3$1"#3-#1(&/)):$6"30),$
N#$8+,(/+$63$(1$O30),$+31$4/11#-G$-(."1^$FS1#-$/N301$/$43+1"$/)3+#$(+$K#)"($8$S30+,$4:6#)S$/0134/1(&/)):$(,#+1(S:(+.$O(1"$1'V";."&'-#2?50%+'8."10&"$*'().%;"&52+'E@%&1#0&'H$)#Q+'JKKPM+'JZ=
75
$ !"(6$ 40)1(9)(&(1:$ 3S$ (,#+1(1(#6$ (6$ /$ &3443+$ 1-/(1$ (+$
%#4N#-6$ 3S$ &0)10-/)$ ,(/693-/6$ S##)$ 9-#660-#$ 13$ (+1#.-/1#$9-39#-):$ (+13$ 1"#$ 63&(#1:$ 3S$ 1"#(-$ &30+1-:$ 3S$ -#6(,#+&#G$
-/+.(+.$S-34$.3,,#66#6$13$%31"#-$8+,(/=
&0)10-/)$+/1(3+/)(64$3S$,(/693-/$&3440+(1(#6$/+,$(16$(49/&1$
N:$#R/4(+(+.$1"#$1"#3-#1(&/)$S-/4#O3-Q$1"/1$&3+61(101#6$1"#$
(+$1"#$,(/693-/$/-#$+31$/$-#60)1$3S$/$]&)/6"$3S$&0)10-#65$N01$-/1"#-$
O())$ 1"#+$ &-(1(&/)):$ #+./.#$ 1"(6$ 1"#3-#1(&/)$ S-/4#O3-Q$ N:$#R/4(+(+.$ 1"#$ -3)#$ 3S$ 9390)/-$ 4#,(/G$ 1"-30."$ 1"#$ &/6#$
-#(+S3-&(+.$1"#$1-/,(1(3+/)G$9/1-(/-&"/)G$&0)10-/)$-#9-#6#+1/1(3+$
T.$"%$(+9*?&Q%*,$P"%J$ 8,#+1(1:$ S3-4/1(3+$ (+$ 1"#$ ,(/693-/$ &3+6(616$ 3S$ /+$/11/&"4#+1$ 13$3+#56$ &30+1-:$3S$3-(.(+$O"()#$ 6(40)1/+#306):$
L6&/11#-#,$&3440+(1(#6$)33Q(+.$S3-$/$)361$+/1(3+/)$"34#)/+,G$2' '
76
O"#1"#-$ -#/)$ 3-$ (4/.(+/-:MZ(+1#-9-#1/1(3+$ #49"/6(_#6$ 1"#$ 3-./+(_/1(3+/)$ &/9/&(1:$ 3S$,(/693-/$&3440+(1(#6$/+,$1"#(-$-331#,+#66$(+$1"#(-$&30+1-(#6$
O(1"301$ /&&30+1/N()(1:5G$ 1"(6$ +#O$ /99-3/&"$ /6&-(N#6$ /.#+&:$
1"#$ 3-./+(_/1(3+/)$ &/9/&(1:$ 3S$ ,(/693-(&$ &3440+(1(#6$ /6$
"(."):$93)(1(&(_#,$ S3-4/1(3+6$ 1"/1$L&"/))#+.#$ 1"#$"#.#43+:$/+,$N30+,#,+#66$3S$1"#$+/1(3+P61/1#$/+,G$(+,##,G$3S$/+:$90-#$(4/.(+/-(#6$3S$+/1(3+"33,M[
O(1"$60&"$/+.)#6M`9390)/1(3+6G$ /+,$ &344#+,$ 1"#(-$ 3-./+(_/1(3+/)$ &/9/&(1:$
$ !"-30."$ 1"(6$ &3+[G$ 1"#$ 61-3+.$ 3-./+(_/1(3+/)$&/9/&(1:$ /+,$ &3440+(1:$ 1(#6$ 3S$ ,(/693-(&$ 9390)/1(3+6G$
4#+1(3+$3S$ /+$ ]())(&(15$ -#)/1(3+6"(9$O(1"(+$4:$3O+$ S/4():$ (6$/&&349/+(#,$ N:$ /$ ,-/4/1(&$ -#P1#))(+.$ 3S$ O"/1$ "/99#+#,$13$4:$431"#-56$4/1#-+/)$ &306(+G$%(-/\$'@&0&"':%$/&%$+',Y?%'@;"G%'I?0G?'02']0"2Q)$"3'F070a%&2?0Q+'-%;010)&'"&5'H%&5%$'0&'7?%'!"_0&1')9'F?")$50G=,':%$/&%$+'JPT=5'-#2?50%+'JL=('4;;'&".%2'?"6%'/%%&'G?"&1%5=
77
O(1"$1"#$63&(#1/)$9-#660-#$/./(+61$1"#(-$0+(3+$9-39#))#,$1"#4$
N/N:$ ,/0."1#-G$ /+,$ /11#4916$ 13$ -#&3+&()#$ O(1"$ "#-$ S/4():G$
/O/:$ 6"3-1):$ /S1#-O/-,6G$ /+,$ "(6$ ,:(+.$O(6"$O/6$ 1"/1$ 6"#$
3-./+(_#,$,(66#4(+/1(3+$3S$60&"$613-(#6$1"-30."301$,(/693-(&$
3S$&0)10-/)$9-/&1($3S1#+$,-/O6$&-(1(&(64$S-34$9361P&3)3+(/)$
/+,$ ]1-/,(1(3+/)5$ (+$ -#)/1(3+$ 13$ 43,#-+(1:$ -#9-#6#+1#,$ N:$2#61#-+$ &0)10-/)$ +3-46$ ,#)#.(1(4(_#6$ /+,$ "343.#+(_#6$]+3+PB0-39#/+5$ &0)10-#6U9#-6(61#+1):$,#6&-(N#,$/6$)(4(1#,$/+,$-#9-#66#,$(+$/,,(1(3+$13$N#(+.$/N06#,$N:$1"#(-$4/)#$&30+1#-9/-16G$/-#$3S1#+$&349/-#,$13$ ])(N#-/1#,5$2#61#-+$O34#+G$O"(&"$ &-#/1#6$ /$ 9-3N)#4/1(&$
(+S#-6$ 1"/1$B/61#-+$ /+,$2#61#-+$ &0)10-#6$ /-#$ S0+,/4#+1/)):$
B0-3&#+1-(&$ +3-46$ /6$ 1"#$ :/-,61(&Q$ N:$ O"(&"$ 13$ 4#/60-#$X$
Y
!"(6$ $/-.04#+1$/11#4916$ 13$,#6&-(N#$/$-/&(/)(_#,$/&&30+1$3S$1"#$ 6:61#4(&$ &"/))#+.#6$ ,(/693-(&$ 9390)/1(3+6$ S/&#$ O"()#$
7'S0$.";'@#I"$+'"&5'@"$6"70'-"1?#$".+'V)#7?'420"&':).%&'0&'7?%']0"2Q)$"+'EAh9)$53'C%$1+'PTTOM+'PPN=8'8/05='PPK=9'@#I"$+'PPK=
78
$ 2"()#$9-3431(+.$/.#+&:$/43+.61$7301"$F6(/+$O34#+$
&/6#G$ 4:$ .-/+,431"#-56$ .#+#-/1(3+$ #4N3,(#6$ 1"#$ &0)10-/)$
N:$ ,(/693-(&$ &3440+(1(#6G$ O"(&"$ /-#$ 43-#$ )(Q#):$ 13$ /99):$
$ 2"()#$ 1"(6$ 39(+(3+$ 4/:$ N#$ ,#N/1#,$ /+,$ &3+1#61#,$
61-0&10-#6$ 13$ I-(1(6"$ 8+,(/G$ O"#-#$ /+1(P&3)3+(/)$ ,(6&30-6#$
8+,(/G$O"#-#$ &0)10-#$O/6$ &3+61-0#,$ (+$ /$I-/"4/+(&$W(+,0G$9/1-(/-&"/)G$/+,$&/61#(61$&3+1#R1?>&3+61-0&1(3+$ 3S$ +/1(3+/)(61$ -"#13-(&$O/6$ +31$ (+&)0,#,$ "#+&#$1"#$ &3+61-0&1$ 3S$ 1"#$ 1-/,(1(3+/)$ S#4(+(+#$ (,#/)$ 3-(.(+/1#,$S-34$ /$ W(+,0$ I-/"4/+(&/)$ /+,$ 099#-P&)/66$ 9/1-(/-&":$ (+$
C3N(+/$%3"/44/,$&3+&0-6V$L234#+56$N3,(#6$/-#$&-0&(/)$13$
10'(0."&0'C"&&%$k0+'@*1.";0)&'S"70)&3'Y)I"$52'"'F$070i#%')9'V#/";7%$&'V7#50%2'"&5'7?%',-%2);#70)&')9'7?%':).%&B2'j#%270)&<+'EY)$)&7)3'R&06%$207*')9'Y)$)&7)'@$%22+'PTTJM+'OZ=
79
/+,$1-/,(1(3+M??
S-34$ 61-0&10-/)$ -#)/1(3+6$ 3S$ 9-39#-1:$ /+,$ &)/66M?=
6099-#66(3+$O/6$4#-#):$ /$ &3)3+(/)$ S/N-(&/1(3+$ 13$ )#.(1(4(_#$
!%+(+9*?&;-F*F$,$-(&"=&T.$"%$(+9*?&Q%*,$P"%J$ 8,#/)(61(&/)):G$8$/(4$13$&"/))#+.#$1"#$&3+[$3S$L8+,(/+M$
,#&(6(3+6$60--30+,(+.$9-/&1($8$O(6"$13$/&[$/+,$/,"#-#$
@$ (1$(6$ (+,(-#&1):$ 60993-1#,$ N:$ 1"#$ ,#43.-/9"(&$ (1$ &3+1(+0#6$ 13$-#9-#66G$/+,$ (+,(-#&1$ S3-46$3S$&0)10-/)$+/1(3+/)(64$&3+1(+0#$13$(49/&1$1"#$S3-4/1(3+$3S$O34#+56$
(+$,(/693-(&$9390)/1(3+6G$ -/+.(+.$ S-34$ 6#-(306$ (+&(,#+16$ 3S$11'-)/0&"'!)?".."5+',@?0$'/?0'50;'?"0'(0&5#27"&0'Ed%7'7?%'?%"$7'$%."0&2'8&50"&M3'C);;*I))5+'7?%'U?).%;"&5B'&"70)&`27"7%+'"&5'7?%'50"2Q)$"+<'^&60$)&.%&7'"&5'@;"&&0&1']3'V)G0%7*'"&5'VQ"G%+'PL+'&)='['EPTT[M3'OWT=12'C"&&%$k0+'OK=
80
,34#61(&$/N06#G$13$6##4(+.):$"/-4)#66$-#)0&1/+$3S$S/4()(#6$
S3-40)/1#,$O(1"(+$/$O(,#-$&3+1#R1$3S$&0)10-/)$(+1#-9-#1/1(3+$
S3-4$3S$ 60993-1$ .-3096$ /+,$3-./+(_/1(3+6$ 1/-.#1#,$ /1$ 1"#(-$F6(/+$234#+56$J3440+(1:$J#+1#-$
60&"$/6$,34#61(&$/N06#$(+$7301"$F6(/+$(44(.-/+1$"34#6$N:$
3016(,#G$ 4/Q#$ a8+,(/+$O34#+b$ #/6:$ 1/-.#16$ S3-$ /N06#G$ /+,$O"(&"$O#$/(4$13$
?Z
1/Q#+$-#./-,(+.399-#66(3+G$1"#$#R(61#+&#$3S$(+61(101(3+/)$&"/++#)6$3S$60993-1$
$13$ ,#6&-(N#$ 1"#$ 1-/+6&#+,#+1$ &0)10-/)$ (49/&1$ I3)):O33,$"/6G$ -#S#--(+.$ 13$ (1$ /6$ L/$ 1/&(1$ 3S$ (,#+1(1:$ (+$ /$ ,(/693-(&$&3+1#R1M?[
.-3096G$ O"3$ &)(+.$ 13$ /+$ #R/&#-N/1#,$ 4#,(/$ -#9-#6#+1/1(3+$
S/$ 3S$ &0)10-/)$ +/1(3+/)(64G$ 1"#-#S3-#$ 1"#$ -#9-#6#+1/1(3+$
)366$ 3S$ &0)10-#$ #R9#-(#+&#,$N:$AC86$ (6$ /$ &3443+$ 1"#4#$ (+$
1"#$ &(+#4/13.-/9"(&$ &3+1-(N01(3+6$ 13$ 8+,(/+$ ,(/693-(&$
3+.3(+.$ 9-#3&&09/1(3+$ O(1"$ -331#,+#66$ (+$ 1-/,(1(3+$ /+,$&0)10-#G$ O"#-#$ 8+,(/+P+#66$ (6$ S3-#$ .-30+,#,$ /6$ /$ 93-1/N)#$
13'4Q"$&"'C"2#+'@%$2Q%G706%2')&':).%&3'F"&"5"'"&5'8&50"+'E4?.%5"/"53'4;;0%5'@#/;02?%$2+'JKKLM+'NK=14'4&"&5".'>"6))$0+'"&5'F?$0270&"'\)2%Q?+',C);;*G#;7#$%3'^7?&)1$"Q?*')9'85%&707*+'!%50"'"&5'@%$9)$."&G%<'H;)/";'!%50"'"&5'F)..#&0G"70)&+'Z+'&)='JZ'EPTJJM=
81
?`
$
/+$ E&&(,#+1/)(64$ 1"/1$ &-#/1#6$ 1"#$2#61$ /6$ /+$ #66#+1(/)(_#,$LE1"#-M?\
!*5$&3(2/<0&S*,*5($<&N"-/"-&UVWWXY" !"#$.)3N/)(_#,$+/10-#$3S$8+,(/+$&(+#4/$-#60)16$(+$1"#$
,(/693-/$9390)/1(3+6G$3S1#+$06(+.$ 1"#$ S#4/)#$9-31/.3+(61$ 13$
];/__5$%/)"31-/G$/$:30+.$.(-)$N3-+$ (+$@3+,3+$O"3G$ 1"-30."$,-(+Q(+.G$9/-1:(+.G$/+,$63&(/)(_(+.$O(1"$4#+G$O"3)#"#/-1#,):$
?U
W#-$O3--(#,$S/1"#-$/--/+.#6$/$1-(9$13$8+,(/$13$"#)9$"#-$-#P
"#-$4/--(/.#$13$N3:$+/4#,$
&"/-/&1#-$ (6$ 93-1-/:#,$ /6$6(49)#G$ O"3)#634#G$ /+,$
13$ #R1#+,$ "(6$ 0+#+,(+.$9/1-(31(64$ 13$ ;/64##1G$ /+,$
4/--(/.#G$ "#$ &/+$ "#)9$ "#-$
15'F?$0270"&%'C$)20#2+'"&5'S0G);"2'd"a10+',<82'Y?%$%'S)'@;"G%'D0_%'().%f<3'F)&7%27`0&1'F0&%."7)1$"Q?0G'F)&27$#G70)&2')9'8&50"&']02"Q)$0G'^hQ%$0%&G%2+<'F)&7$0/#70)&2'7)'8&50"&'V)G0);)1*'+'WJ+'&)='OLL'EPTTZM+'[=16'8/05='JT'!)'S"."27%*'D)&5)&=']c]=']0$%G7%5'/*'c0Q#;'4.$#7;";'V?"?='PTTZ
82
(+1-3,0&1(3+$ 3S$ ;/64##156$(+1-3,0&#,$3+$/+$/--/+.#,$,/1#$O(1"$931#+1(/)$8+,(/+$60(13-G$
]6/)O/-$ Q/4##_5$ /+,$ (44#,(/1#):$ 3-,#-6$40)1(9)#$ 6"316$ 3S$
65$,#6(-#$S3-$"#-$13$4/--:$
/+,$.#16$(+13$/$1/R(G$O"#-#$6"#$,(6&/-,6$"#-$8+,(/+$./-N$/+,$
W/--(6$ 71-##1M?X
-#9)(#6V
$ &/+$8$N#$8+,(/+^$ F6$ ;/64##1$ N#.(+6$ 13$ ,#6&-(N#$ "#-$ (,#/)$ 4/1#G$ /$ -#,$693-16$&/-$90))6$09G$,- N:$1"#(-$N366G$/$"/+,634#G$N)3+,#$I-(1(6 $;/64##1$ 13$-0+6$13$"(6$&/-G$ "#-$ S-(#+,$O/-+6$"#-$ /N301$ "(6$ +313-(306$ 9-34(6&0(1:$/+,$ S3+,+#66$ 3S$ 3 &#$/ / $ ;/64##1$ (.+3-#6$ "#-$ S-(#+,56$ /, (&#$ /+,$ .#16$ (+13$"(6$ &/-$ (+$ /+$ /&1$ 3S$ ,# /+&# $ !"#$43,#61):$ ,-#66#,$ 8+,(/+$S-(#+,$ -#9-#6#+16$ /$ -/1(3+/)$ S3()$ 13$ ;/64##156$ )336#$ 43-/)6$/+,$-#N#))(306$&"/-/&1#- $ ;/64##156$&/-##-P3-(#+1#,$4#+1/)(1:$(6$ &"/-/&1#-(_#,$ /6$ #-N#/-(+.$ /+,$ 6# "G$ /+,$ "#-$ +/4#$&"/+.#$(6$/ #-1$/66(4()/1(3+$(+13$B+.)(6"$&0)10-# $W# -P#R/..#-/1#,$,(64(66/)$ 3S$ "#-$ -3316$ (6$ 9#-&#( #,$ /6$ 6"/4(+.$"#-$ 9/-#+16G$ O"3$"/ #$ +3$ 31"#-$ 391(3+$ N01$ 13$ /--/+.#$ "#-$18'S"."27%*'D)&5)&=
83
4/--(/.#$ O(1"$ F- + $ !"#$ ,#9(&1(3+$ 3S$ "#-$ /+,$ F $B+.)/+,$(6$/$&3+61/ R1/936(1(3+$N#1O##+$/+$(,#/)(_#,$S3-4$3S$8+,(/+$&0)10-#$1"/1$-#9-#6#+16$"3+#61:$/+,$43,#61:$ #-606$/$+#3P&3)3+(/)$B+.)(6"$301)33Q$ 1"/1$#49"/6(_#6$4/1#-(/)(64$/+,$ &0)10-/)$ ,34(+/+&# $ W#-$ &0)10-/)$ (+1-369#&1(3+$ /+,$# #+10/)$-#9/1-(/1(3+$13$"#-$3O+$"#-(1/.#$ Q#,$1"-30."$"#-$-34/+&#$O(1"$F $ $&"/-/&1#-$/&16$/6$/$ ]6/ $O"3$ -#,##46$ ;/64##1G$ -#,0&(+.$ "#-$ 2#61#-+$ N#"/(.+3-/+&#$9#-9#10/1#,$N:$"#-$&3--091$I-(1(6"$60--30+,(+.6 $!"#$ (#$#+,6$O(1"$;/64##1$/+,$F /99():$O#,G$-(,(+.$1"-30 #),6$3+$"(6$4313-&:&)#$(+$
/6$)(."1P"#/-1#,$#+1#-1/(+4#+1$/6$39936#,$13$(+P,#91"$63&(/)$
(49/&1$ 3+$ 1"#$ S3-4/1(3+$ 3S$O34#+56$ (,#+1(1(#6$ (+$ ,(/693-/$
3S$9390)/-$4#,(/G$ &309)#,$O(1"$ 1"#(-$ 61/106$/6$ 1"#$ 6(+.0)/-$
9#-9#10/1#,$ N:$ 63&(/)):$ /&[#,$ 4#,(/$ -#9-#6#+1/1(3+6$/+,$ #+S3-&#,$ N:$ 1"#$ 3-./+(_/1(3+/)$ &/9/&(1:$ 3S$ ,(/693-(&$
3S$1"#$1##+/.#$8+,(/+$.(-)6$8$.-#O$09$/-30+,$O#-#$(+,(-#&1):$
9#-63+/)$ /99-#&(/1(3+$ 3S$ 4:$ "#-(1/.#$ &/+$ N#$ &"/++#)#,$ (+$
/+,$L2#61#-+M$O())$0)1(4/1#):$ )#/,$13$ 1"#$,#&3+61-0&1(3+$3S$1"#$9-3N)#4/1(&$,(&"3134:$1"/1$8+,(/+$O34#+$(+$1"#$,(/693-/$
84
23-Q6$J(1#,
70N/)1#-+$710,(#6$/+,$1"#$LC#63)01(3+$3S$1"#$234#+56$
J(+#4/13.-/9"(&$J3+61-0&1(3+6$3S$8+,(/+$K(6/93-(&$
B1"+3.-/9":$3S$(,#+1(1:G$4#,(/$/+,$
C#)(.(3+$/+,$'#+,#-$(+$1"#$%/Q(+.$3S$J"/3-,(&$
85
Z+9(+,.""/&*-/&Z"+9$0
;#++(S#-$@/"+"
!#--(13-(#6G$4:$431"#-$O/6$ 13),$N:$ 1"#$ 8+0(1$O34#+$ (+$"#-$
N#&/06#$8$O/6$/$)/-.#$N/N:G$8$&/+51$N#$60-#G$N01$1"#$O34#+$O#-#$0+S/)1#-(+.$(+$1"#(-$/660-/+$1"/1$:#6G$4:$431"#-$O/6$.3(+.$
$$ 8$ "/1#$ 13$ 1"(+Q$ 1"/1$ 6"#$ O/6$ ,(6/993(+1#,$ O"#+$ 8$
60..#61(3+$ 1"/1$ /6$ /+$ (+S/+1$ 8$ Q+#O$ 1"/1$ 8$O/6$O#/-(+.$ 1"#$
60N)(4(+/)):G$1"-30."$1"#$1"(+$O/))6$3S$1"#$O34NG$/+,$(+$1"#$#/-):$,/:6$/+,$43+1"6$3S$)(S#G$O"3$-#/)):$Q+3O6$O"/1$N/N(#6$
8$&/4#$(+13$1"(6$O3-),$3+):$13$,#S:$1"#$6#R$/+,$.#+,#-$1"/1$
86
"
[R[$ 9(&Q09$ 1-0&QG$ O(1"$ 1O3$ 1O3P9#-63+$ 1#+16$ S3-$ 6)##9(+.$
3S$ 1"#$"361#)$O/))6$/+,$6)#91$ (+$30-$ 1#+16$ (+61#/,$3S$ -#+1(+.$
3+#$ -#/)):$ .#1$ 1"#$ &"/+&#$ 13$ 6)##9$ 3+$ 1"#$ -33S$ 3S$ /$ 9(&Q09^$$ F$&309)#$3S$+(."16$(+13$30-$61/:G$4:$S-(#+,6$/+,$8$O#+1$
3S$43+#:$/+,G$S3-$1"#$,0-/1(3+$3S$1"#$1"-##P"30-$&-0(6#G$"/,$
:30$&/+$(4/.(+#G$1"#6#$&-0(6#6$/-#$9/-1(&0)/-):$9390)/-$O(1"$
4/+:$,-(+Q6$,0-(+.$1"#$&-0(6#G$O#$-#10-+#,$13$1"#$"361#)$/+,$&3+1(+0#,$13$63&(/)(_#$O(1"$S#))3O$130-(616$O"34$O#$4#1$3+$1"#$ &-0(6#G$ /6$O#))$ /6$ /$ S#O$ )3&/)6$ 1"/1$ 1"#$"361#)$4/+/.#-6$Q+#O$/+,$O"3$-#.0)/-):$"0+.$301$/1$1"#$"361#)$-#61/0-/+1$/+,$
$
4:6#)S$/+,G$/6$#/&"$3S$1"#$4#4N#-6$3S$4:$.-309$-#1(-#,$S3-$
/+,$ ,-(+QG$ 8$ &)046():$ 4/,#$ 4:$ O/:$ 09$ 1"#$ )/,,#-$ 13$ 4:$$
$ 8$O3Q#$09$(+$1"#$#/-):$43-+(+.$"30-6$13$+31(&#$1"/1$8$
8$6/O$E6&/-?G$3+#$3S$1"#$)3&/)$4#+$S-34$1"#$"361#)$N/-G$1"#-#G$
1Names have been changed for the purpose of this article.
87
$
$$ F6$1"#$"31$O/1#-$930-#,$301$3S$1"#$6"3O#-$"#/,$(+$1"#$
I01$8$,(,+51$+##,$13$-#4#4N#-$13$Q+3OG$9":6(&/)):G$O"/1$"/,$
/+,$,(6.0(6#$1"#$O/1#-$S-34$4:$#:#6G$&/-#S0)$+31$13$)#1$4:$63N6$$
$ FS1#-$ 1"#$ 6"3O#-$ 8$ S-/+1(&/)):$ 6#/-&"#,$4:$ 1#+1$ "(."$
"/,+51$&3+6(,#-#,$1#))(+.$/+:3+#$/N301$O"/1$"/,$"/99#+#,G$
$$ FS1#-$ 9/(+S0)):$ ,(6&066(+.$O"/1$ "/,$ "/99#+#,$O(1"$4:$S-(#+,6G$8$)#/-+#,$1"/1$E6&/-$"/,$/11#491#,$13$#+1#-$30-$
88
$ 8+$"#/-(+.$O"/1$"/,$"/99#+#,G$I#+$O/6$/99/))#,$/+,$,##9):$/93)3.#1(&$ 1"/1$"#$"/,+51$ 1"30."1$3S$4#G$6)##9(+.$(+$
3SPS/&1):G$ /+,$ 1"#$ "#/,$ 3S$ 6#&0-(1:$ /1$ 1"#$ "361#)$ 133Q$ 4:$$
:30$,3+51$Q+3O$E6&/-56$)/61$+/4#G$/+,$/-#$0+60-#$3S$4/+:$
$
$$ F1$ 1"#$ "369(1/)$ 8$O/(1#,$ S3-$O"/1$ 6##4#,$ )(Q#$ "30-6$
89
O#$Q+3&Q#,$3+$1"#$,33-G$)33Q#,$(+$1"#$O(+,3O6G$&(-&)#,$1"#$
$
S#)1$)(Q#$1"#$)/61$N(1$3S$4:$61-#+.1"$/+,$#R9)/(+#,$4:$6(10/1(3+$
O(1"$1"/1$,/:G$/+,$8$&30),+51$1#))$(S$1"/1$4/,#$4#$S##)$N#11#-$3-$
1"/1$8$+##,#,$13$O/(1$/$4(+(404$3S$[>$,/:6$13$N#$1#61#,$S3-$W8<$
3S$ &3+,34$06#G$N01$09$0+1()$ 1"(6$434#+1$ 1"#$9366(N()(1:$3S$$
$$ @33Q(+.$ N/&Q$ 3+$ 1"(6$ ,/:G$ 634#1(4#6$ (156$ "/-,$
O(1"$ /))$ "#-$ 6"/4#$ /+,$ "04()(/1(3+G$ 10&Q#,$ /O/:$ ,##9$
$
1"(6$,/:G$1"30."16$3S$6#)SPN)/4#$6O(4$(+$/+,$301$3S$1"#$S3-#S-3+1$
$
90
13$ 4/Q#$ 4#$ &3O#-$ /+,$ "(,#$ 4:$ #R9#-(#+&#$ O(1"$ 6"/4#^$$
$
4/+:$ /660491(3+6G$ 133$40&"$ N/../.#G$ 13$ S##)$ &34S3-1/N)#$
$
91
61-3+.$/+,$(+,#9#+,#+1$O34/+$/+,$:#1$8$&3O#-$O(1"$S#/-$/1$$
$ 8$$$,3+51$O/+1$13$&3O#-$/+:43-#d$8$S##)$1"/1$(+$3-,#-$13$#R9)3-#$
13$O/+1$31"#-6$13$6"/-#$1"#(-$613-(#6G$O"()#$Q##9(+.$4:$9/61$$
1"#$)/&Q$3S$4#43-:$4/Q#6$(1$O3-6#G$/))3O(+.$4:$(4/.(+/1(3+$
O/))6$3S$4:$4(+,$ (6$4:$3O+$4/63&"(61(&$ (4/.(+/1(3+G$ /+,$
(493-1/+1$/.#+&:$(6G$/+,$"3O$3+#$30."1$13$N#$/N)#$13$&)/(4$
3S$ 90N)(&):$ N-(+.(+.$ /O/-#+#66$ 13$ 1"#$ 9-3N)#4/1(&$ /+,$
$
N#$43-#$39#++#66G$43-#$O())(+.+#66$13$O-(1#G$69#/Q$/+,$6"/-#$3+#56$#R9#-(#+$O(1"301$6"/4#$(S$O#$/-#$13$6"(S1$1"#$93O#-$/O/:$S-34$1"#$399-#663-6$/+,$N/&Q$13$1"#$399-#66#,G$O"#-#$(1$
92
N##+$61-(99#,$S-34$06G$/+,$O#$N#&34#$&)36#-$13$6"#,,(+.$1"#$
$
8$S##)$1"/1$(1$+##,6$13$N#$6/(,$1"/1$(+$O-(1(+.$1"(6$/-1(&)#$8$/4$
3-$"#-$#R9#-(#+$ (6$+31"(+.$ (S$+31$#R1-#4#):$9#-63+/)$/+,$
O"#1"#-$O#$/-#$"3),(+.$3+13$30-$613-(#6$3-$6&-#/4(+.$1"#4$301$)30,G$8$/4$(+6(61(+.$1"/1$O#$+##,$+31$N#$/6"/4#,$3S$30-$
93