Internal Mix 04 Pan
Transcript of Internal Mix 04 Pan
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 1/12
C H A P T E R 4 :D I M E N S I O N 1:H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
THE MASTERY OF THE FIRST DIMENSION is much underrated.
"That's easy, it's just amatter of left-right distribution." How v Tong can you
be! If you do not do your homework in this area, you wiU soon encounter
problems on the way to a tidy mix, because a good plan for the panorama is the
basis ofa good mix.
Start the mix by drafting amixing strategy in which you set out the placem ent of
{ -Oi/ei^md
jicoodk-(^u^darI Uef^/)
A U-^i^OtA M ' ^OC^
^a^J^^ou. \)[/[AUA^
^ $fc
-^^eo - C^(^
I
->
f- Leoid- ^ r^^eo -tk^efk
UCL d- Iji
'0
'OX
ye9peme fi<^e
f gvW*? .-j r_ (
cr
C r e a t e a m i x s t r a t e g y s k e t c h a t t h e b e g i n n i n g o f t h e m i x i n g p r o c e s s .
CHAPTER 4 : D I M E N S I O N 1 : H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 2/12
individual instrum ents, almost like placing them on a stage. For the sake of sim-
plicity, we will assume that the instrumentation is consistent and continuo us, thus
allowing us a static panoram a distribution. Of course, in the distribution, you do
not simply choose randomly, but apply certain rules. The most imp ortan t aspect
in planning your panoram a outline is three-dimensional thinking! Dimension 1
- the pan oram a distribution - is the horizontal level on your stage plan, you have
to imagine dimension 2 - the frequency distribution - and dimension 3 - depth
- appears as the vertical axis in this two-dim ensional representation.
Start v ith those aspects that have been tried and tested a million times: bass
drums and snares are placed at the center. This is essential for the simple rea-
son that the surfaces of two loudspeaker m embranes are better at simultaneously
transmitting a deep sound transfer than a single loudspeaker with half the sur-
face area. That would be the case, for example, if you placed the bass dru m to the
left. The same applies to ail deep or ultra-deep sound events. Deep sou nd partsthat are placed at the outer extremes of the sound pano rama can easily lead to a
lack of mono-com patibihty and a bad energy d istribution within the overall ap-
pearance of the panorama. The goniometer or a good peak meter will alert you
to an uneven energy distribution w ithin the panoram a. Accordingly, the bass is
also placed at the center. The remaining drum s are now placed more or less natu-
rally across the panoram a, according to the style you wish to achieve. For natural
drums, I always pan from the position of the listener. I visualize the drums in
front of me like a live mixer would see them on stage, and I place the hi-hats a bit
to the right, the high tom a quarter to the right, the mid tom at the center, and the
floor tom further to the left. It is essential dur ing pan ning to check the overheads
to determ ine whether the righ t-hand side is also the hi-hat side. At this stage, al-
ways monitor your correlation meter to check that the entire range does not slip
into the red sector as a result of the total left-right spread of the stereo overhead
track.. This should apply to most procedures related to setting up the micropho ne
and is simply remedied by gently limiting the pan oram a to a 9 o'clock to 3 oclock
setting, if you visualize the pan knobs. Now you correlate - and the correlation
meter indicates witli a cheerful green light that the tracks harmonize better.
The lead vocals naturally take center stage at the front; now we look at the second
dimension in our mental visualization, because the center is aheady crowded
with SO many events; the bass exclusively occupies the lowest one-and-a-half oc-
taves in the center. This is not a place for any o ther instrument] Above that is the
bottom sector of the bass drum at about 80 to 100 Hz. The heads create localiza-
C H A P T E R 4 : D I M E N S I O N I : H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 3/12
tion with the clapping sound; depend ing on the bass drum sound, it has quite a
broadband presence in the upper mid-range to 6 kHz. Because this section of the
bass drum sound is characterized by transients and occurs in obstinate rhythmic
sequences, this range does not generally interfere with the upper mid-range of
the lead vocals. Above the bass drums are the toms, which we will ignore here
because of the panorama distribution and their sporadic occurrence. The next in-
strument in the center is the bottom sector of the snares at 120 to 260 Hz. Because
of their rhythmic transient character, the snares coexist peacefully with the lead
vocals v^dthout any spectral competition. The main body of the lead vocals sets in
the lower mid or "misery" range, responsible for the warmth of the sound, and
from there develops upwards into the higher regions. The range around 1 kHz is
responsible for the nasal sound, whereas speech comprehensibility for the male
voice begins at about 2.5 kHz, and at slightly above 3 kHz for female voices. S-
sounds and similar consonants are located between 6 and 8 kHz, above that the"shiny" upper notes. The snares broadly occupy the area from the upper mid-
range to the treble areas. The only range so far with a potential cause for concern
is the lower m id-range, because it is also occupied by the bass drum and the bass.
However, because this range is less important to bass drum and bass, it is possible
to counteract this slightly with parametric filters, resulting in a slight thinning of
the range between 180 and 250 Hz.
Keeping these thoughts in mind, you can now distribute the harmonic instru-
ments across the panorama, which provide warmth and the harmonic basis.
Here, it is always my aim to maintain a complimentary spectral left-right balance.
For example, if there are two harmonic instrum ents, like a Rhodes and a rhythm
guitar - both played in the lower ranges - in addition to two higher events such
as Strings and a synthesizer phrase - you have to distribute the four events in the
panoram a in such a way that they do not overlap spectrally - in other words, in
the second dimension. That's why we place the R hodes on the left and the guitar
on the right. We also distribute the other two events to the left an d to the right
in the panorama in order to achieve a complimentary frequency distribution.
You have to take a fairly radical approach to this in order to ensure that the lead
vocals remain unchallenged in their center position. It is a very easy beginner's
mistake at this stage to take fright at the existence of so many stereo tracks andto make very little use of panning as a design aid or to use it too hesitantly. The
fact that the Rhodes is a stereo track and that the stereo chorus sounds simply
great is no excuse for placing it in ftrll stereo width right bang at the center! The
left Rhodes track can also be set at the far left and the right track to 10 o' clock, if
C H A P T E R 4 : D I M E N S I O N I : H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 4/12
tha t is more suitable for the overall picture. This way, the re is sufficient space on
the right for the guitar and it now n o longer overlaps with the frequency domain
of the Rhodes.
Take the same approach to all other similar m atters. If the hi-hats are slightly tothe right in the panoram a, place the shaker as a counterweight slightly to the left.
Mixes without an overall panorama strategy frequently suffer from an imbal-
ance in the energy between one channel and the othe r Tlie distribution strategy
becomes more complicated, the more instrum ents and events there are to be dis-
tributed and the more inconsistent their appearance, hi this situation, I recom-
mend separate panorama outlines for the various parts; if necessary the guitar
switches sides in the subsequent part, if this is what is required by the instru-
men tation. In complex pop music, there is no detrimental effect associated with
instruments switching sides within the panorama. However, any unnecessary
pano rama switches should be avoided in m ore intimate music with a consistent
instrumentation.
To und erpin your panorama strategy, follow these rules:
The acoustic rule that deep sounds spread in circular form and can hardly be de-
tected below 100 Hz, whereas high frequencies spread directionally and are easy
to detect gives rise to the following panning ru le:
Choruses, orchestrations and general instruments in pop productions are gener-
ally placed in such a way that deeper sounding instruments are always placed
more towards the center; the higher the sound event, the further out they arelikely to be placed. W ithin a chorus group, you would thus place the high voices
further to the sides in the panoram a, and deep voices more towards the center.
The same applies to string ensembles, orchestrations and almost all many-voiced
(thick chorus) soun d events.
Of course there are exceptions to this rule, depending on your ovm preferences
and artistic freedom.
9^110 C H A P T E R 4: D I M E N S I O N 1: H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 5/12
The art of a skillful panorama distribution is to pay due attention to the second
dimension (the spectrum), which is not part of the outline - and that at least
three times as m uch! The spectral d istribution across the center is a slightly vari-
able standard, and, as far as left and right are concerned, it makes sense also to
be aware of the spectral distribution. Distribute the events in such a way that
the frequency distribution is also balanced in the outer sectors. If a mix is very
complex, you can approach this spectral distribution in a series of "sUces" such as
"outer left - 9:00 to 10:30 - center - 1:30 to 3:00 - outer right" in order to find a
place for each event. In this instance^ using a stereo expander can create an extra
dimension.
E X E R C IS E : W H A T I S P H A S E
C A N C E L L A T I O N ?
Please take a mono bass track and duplicate this at a 1:1 ratio on a different
track without moving in the timeline. The easiest way to do this is by using
the "Duplicate track" function. Now rotate the phase of the copied track by 180
degrees. Now pan one track on the far left and the other on the far right. Listen
to the result while switching the mono sw itch of your co ntrol room m atrix o r the
control room mixer on and off. Bingo! If your DAW does not have a mono switch in
the master section, you can use a plug-in that has one or you can put both channel
panning knobs in the center position. When the mono switch is not pressed, you
will he ar the acoustic phase interference in the room, which is not as strong due
to natural s patial de-correlation. Wh en the mon o switch is pressed, you'll hear th ephysical phase interference, when both channels are mixed together.
Repe at this exercise in WaveLab with stereo files and finished mixes by selecting
one channel and reversing the phase with the command Invert phase in the
Process m enu. Here, too, the difference between acoustic and physical phase
interference is very obvious, w ith the latter occurring w henever your stereo mix
is played on a mono device. Once you have become familiar with what phase
displacements sound like, the regular use of the mono switch is a simple, but
effective device to monitor for unintentional phase interferences.
You can visually check the phase with the correlation meter, which very clearly
shows that the signals with the same frequency on the right a nd left stereochannels add up in their am plitudes as long as the phase of both signals is within
the O-to-90 degrees sector - generally shown as green.
P l e a se r e f e r t o t h e s e c t io n "C o r r e l a t io n M e t e r . "
C H A P T E R 4 : D I M E N S I O N I: H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 6/12
Sound Example
U06 & W7
S U M M A R Y OF P A N N I N G R U L E S
• Before mixing, make a sketch of your panning strategy.
• Anything that is not bass, bass drum, snare or lead vocals should not be in the
center.
• Instrum ents present in the same or overlaying frequency sectors should be
placed at opposite ends - complimenting each other - within the panoram a.
• Once you have established the basic static panning, but still find parts v/ithin
the song th at are unsatisfactory in their transparency, it is always worth an at-
tempt to remedy this by using panning au tomation.
• Well planned and carefully autom ated panning often creates greater clarity
in the mix than the use of EQ and is much better than unnecessary EQing.
If an event is drowned in a sound mush , your first step to solve the problemshould involve the panoram a Imob before resorting to EQ.
• Used in a controlled fashion, widening the sound basis can create extra space
in the horizontal dimension and thus ensure a clearer sound. Check by using
the correlation meter and the mono switch on your monitoring board Please
refer to the Sound Examples #06 and #07 to illustrate this.
• Be courageous! Try extreme panorama settings, making the center free for
lead vocals.
P R E V E N T I N G P H A S E C A N C E L LA T IO NThe mono-switch in the master section is a way to control mono-compatibil-
ity that is much underused in the native world. Even today, there are still many
mono radios and TVs. If your goal is to get airplay for your production or to
publish the mix on vinyl, please activate the mono switch regularly for checking
for compatibility. If the m ix collapses as soon as the m ono switch is pressed, then
there are probably too many deep sounds distributed across the panorama or
there are simply too many phase interferences.
C H A P T E R 4: D IMENSION I : HORIZONTAL = PANORAMA
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 7/12
Phase Interference Mostly Occurs in theFollowing Cases:
• Bad stereophonic recordings: when you record a signal using two micro-
phones, you have to position them in such a way that no phase interference
occurs. For that reason, they are positioned either with the capsules at equal
distance and on the sam e axis to the source of the sound, o r at such a distance
that the distance of the second micro phone to the source is at least three times
that of thefirst. Here, too, during the recording you should monitor the phas-
ing with a correlation m eter in comb ination with a mono switch.
• Simultaneous multi-channel recordings with correlation errors (mostly in the
case of drum or live recordings). For example: a snare recorded w ith a top mi-
crophone and a snare strainer microphone generally has phase interference,
if the phase reversal switch on the snare strainer microphone channel is not
activated. Phase problems between the snare top microphone and overhead
microphones can also lead to interferences. Controlled repositioning of the
microphones and/or the use of the phase reversal switch on the console or
the microphone preamplifier can remedy this. If the recording along w ith its
errors is already "on tape," using the phase-shift switch in the individual chan-
nels can remedy the situation at the mixing stage. Thanks to HD systems with
sample-exact zoom functions you can also use extreme enlargement of an au-
dio file and move it by just a few samples - and maybe solve the problem that
way. This simulates the change in the distance between microphone and sound
source.
• Keyboard pads and layered sounds often contain phase effects that are not
mono-compatible. Thanks to the three different panning functions available
in Nuendo & Cubase (Stereo Dual Parmer, Stereo Combined Panner, Stereo
Balance Panner), you can replace the old panning slider in a stereo track with
separate panners and, use them to limit the stereo width from 9:00 to 3:00 - in
the same way aswith classic knobs. The resulting signal is generally still broad
enough, but mono-compatible. The same trick can be used for problematic
overhead tracks recorded with microphon es no t positioned on an axis. If your
DAW only has a panning slider in the stereo channels, I suggest using small
plug-ins. For example, the PSP Stereo Controller from the PSP Stereo Pack
lets you easily adjust stereo width. Logic has separate pan controls on each
individual L-R channel
C H A P T E R 4 : D I M E N S I O N I: H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 8/12
• Reverb returns; the same applies. The 9:00/3:00 setting - or the 80 left/80 right
setting, to talk in Nuendo readings - generally remedies the situation. But be
careful; limiting the width is not always necessary and can create undesirable
masking. (The masking effect will be explained later.)
• Excessive use of stereo spread; use a lower setting.
• Chorus and other phase effects; if you really want to use a chorus on a bass,
select onewhich only allows you to process frequencies above 250 Hz. If that is
not available, copy the track, apply a steep lowcut filter at 250 Hz to the copied
track and only use a chorus on this copy Ano ther possibility isTCs FX matrix
called "FX Machine," which has the option of splitting a single audio source
vrith a crossover, so that the higher frequency range is processed separately.
The FX Machine is discontinued.
• Unintentional shifting of tracks during editing. If phase interferences occur
consistently, it is worthwhile to check the offset between the two channels.
Conclusion:
Stereo width and mono-com patibility are contradictory.
The actual stereo width - depending on the target format (for example, CD, TV,
or radio) ~ is a matter for the engineer to consider. The correlation meter helps
in the decision making process, and the m ono switch provides a way of check-
ing to support the decision. Not every flicker into the red area of the correlation
meter necessarily requires corrective action. Such action should only be taken ifimportant information is lost as a result of switching to mono. The width setting
of the Stereo expander should only be adjusted while using the mono switch for
constant monitoring.
To conclude this topic of panorama control, I will describe a situation during a
mix; due to legal reasons, I cannot include this on the accompanying DVD:
The lead vocals were embedded in a chorus in the refrain. The chorus had a lead-
ing fiinction for the hook. For one bar, the lead vocals transgressed from the hook
line, causing an unpleasant interference. For this onebar, the mix sounded mushy
and fuzzy. Neither the chorus nor the lead vocal track was clear and easy to isolate.With the aid of a simple panning automation, which I used to place the chorus
into the entire left-right width for this one bar, I could solve the entire problem.
ff you find n such a situation that, the normal stereo width is insufficient in order
^ 1 1 4C H A P T E R 4 : D I M E N S I O N 1: H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 9/12
to create more space at certain points, insert a stereo basis widening effect into
the group in question, which remains in a neutral position throughout the song
and, using automation, can be targeted at these specific fuzzy locations to create
mo re space.
The Masking Effect
The masking effect describes the pheno menon where a high-amplitude frequency
masks a neighboring frequency of lower amplitude. This principle is also familiar
from audio data reduction, Uke the MP3 compression format. Being aware of this
effect helps with the mixing process. But first, we should describe the masking
effect more precisely.
The more congruence there is between the direction from where two different sig-
nals of similar frequency originate, the stronger the masking effect on the quietersignal, and vice versa. In nature, there would be no m asking whatsoever, as long
as these two signals of similar frequency originated from completely different di-
rections. This lets us conclude that th e masking effect is much more pronounced
when we have fewer possibilities to separate frequencies in th e form of discrete
audio channels. To put it simply, in a mono reproduction, all sound originates
from just one d irection and as a result, the mix suffers from the m asking effect,
whereas the masking effect has little impact in a surroun d sound reproduction, as
long as the mixing engineer has taken it into account in the general panoram a dis-
tribution . Accordingly, you can deduce the rule that mixes with a lower num ber
of reproduction channels contain less spatial information, whereas a surroundsound mix can han dle a lot of spatial information without becoming fuzzy.
The masking problem is already taken into consideration, assuming that you
have a clear pann ing plan which involves left-center-right frequency distribution,
as suggested in the earlier section on panorama strategies. Anyone professionally
involved with sound knows the effect in conjunction with the application of re-
verb. If you apply reverb to a lead vocal during a long-held no te, the reverb, which
consists of a very similar frequency structure, only becomes audible once this
note has become m uch quieter or has finished altogether. We can make direct use
of this insight for the application of reverb to stereo and su rround soun d mixes.
If the reverb response of a center signal tends to be m asked in the case of a ste-
reo mix, try a spatial separation of the reverb section from the cen ter by using a
Stereo expander. Use the mo no sv atch to check phasing and mono-compatibility.
C H A P T E R 4 : D I I U E N S I O N 1 : H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 10/12
in order to achieve a happy medium between transparency and mono -compat-
ibility.
Signals that are placed on the left hand side within the static panorama can be
used with reverb that is weighted to the right, and vice versa. In that way, the lis-tener is provided with the spatial information without watering down th e mix.
In surround sound mixes, you pan the stereo reverb return for signals that are
oriented towards the front to surround left and surround right, and the reverb
return for signals placed at SL and SR to left and right.
Don't worry - decoupling direct signals from reverb wont irritate the listener.
Imagine the following real-Ufe situation; you stand in the front third of a large
church, looking towards the altar, and you are addressed loudly from the altar
from a few meters away. In addition to the direct signal, the full reverb tail spreads
forward from the back of the chu rch to the front. W ould that make you think that
you were being addressed from the back?
Lets summ arize the salient points with respect to masking:
• Because of directional masking, mixes that are supposed to be mon o-com pat-
ible - for example for TV - can handle less reverb than m ixes that are pre-
dominantly intended for stereo or even surroun d sound p roductions. Mono
mixes thus tend to become "mushy" or over sattirated much earlier, because
the reverb increasingly dilutes the perception of the direct so un d
• The greater the num ber of available loudspeakers for the reprod uction of a
recording, the greater the amount of reverb that can be used. In order to put
into place a clear spatial structure without over saturating the mix with spatial
information, you should keep the reverb away from the direction that the dry
soun d originates from. This avoids masking.
• Masking also applies to different sounds that occupy similar frequency ranges.
That is why a transparent mix requires that instrum ents and events with over-
lapping frequencies be placed in com plimentary positions across the panora-
ma, according to the panoram a strategy made at the beginn ing of your m ixing
project.
C H A P T E R 4 : D I M E N S I O N I : H O R I Z O N T A L = P A N O R A M A
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 11/12
S T E R E O P A N M O D E
As far as 1 know, Nuendo» Cubase, and Cakewalk SONAR 6.0 are the only se-
quencers that have a stereo pan m ode with an adjustable panning behavior
In Sonar, there are six different panoram a characteristics available, whereas with
the Steinberg products, there are five modes available in the Project Setup dialog
"Stereo Pan Law" that prov ide automatic level adjustment for m ono tracks. This
is based on the observation that a mono signal which is reproduced simultane-
ously and at equal volume on the left and on the right, i.e. at the center, sounds
louder than it would if was only reproduced at the far right or at the far left. The
default setting for the automatic level adjuster is minus 3 dB and results in a level
reduction of about 3 dB in the center position. At this setting, a mono signal
always retains the same physical sound level regardless of its position within the
panoram a. The settings minus 6 dB and minus 4.5 dB reduce the m ono signal atthe center correspondingly.
At the 0 dB setting, there is no level compensation, and right-left channels brought
together in the center are twice as loud as they would be if they were positioned
fiilly left and right. These different so-called "panning laws" correspond to the
behavior of analog mixing desks.
This function is very useful for eliminating the need for level adjustments after
panning changes. Experiment to find the right settings for your needs. In my
experience, the settings between 3 and 6 dB are particularly useful w hen you mix
orchestral music for mono-com patible TV productions.
C H A P T E R 4 : D l lM E N S I O N I : H O R I Z O N T A L = PANOR AMA
8/6/2019 Internal Mix 04 Pan
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/internal-mix-04-pan 12/12