Insider Business Services Global M&A October...
-
Upload
nguyennhan -
Category
Documents
-
view
213 -
download
0
Transcript of Insider Business Services Global M&A October...
Global M&A is one of the world’s leading independent M&A advisory firms. Specialized in the middle market, we provide support and opportunities locally and internationally for clients buying or selling companies as well as financings, corporate restructurings and other corporate finance transactions.
In the last 10 years, we have closed more than 1,500 transactions with an aggregate deal value of more than €30 billion. The Global M&A team has accumulated extensive experience in cross border deals. The main success factors are: local expert knowledge of international markets, discrete and efficient execution and longstanding track record.
The Business Services team understands the challenges of service delivery, typical client demands and the market dynamics in the sector, and has a clear appreciation of how these factors can drive value and the interest of purchasers and investors inyour business. The team is well positioned to advise you on the best ways of creating or unlocking maximum value, and on the best industrial and cultural fit.
Areas of Expertise:• Consultancy Services• Business Process Outsourcing• Catering• Facilities Management• Mechanical & Electrical Maintenance• Security• Recruitment, Contract Staffing & Other HR Services• Waste Management & Recycling
Please visit the Business Services sector area of the Global M&A website atwww.globalma.com for more information.
THE GLOBAL BUSINESS SERVICES INDUSTRY
Introducing Global M&A
Global Sector Expertise
Global M&A has created a growing number of specialised sector teams. These groups meet regularly and exchange intelligence and deal ideas constantly.
Most importantly, they co-operate to create seamless cross-border teams on joint projects.
This well established system enables us to deliver a unique level of advice and support to our clients.
Some of this system’s advantages include:
Multinational teams for seamless cross-border co-operation on specific M&A projects. Centralised industry-relevant knowledge on:
Public and privileged information on company valuationsBuyers‘ and sellers‘ strategies.
Access to decision makers at groups and investment houses around the world.
The Global M&A Business Services Team
Our Sector Teams
Business Services 14%
Construction & Real Estate 10%
Consumer Products 10%
Financial Services & Insurance 8%
Healthcare & Pharmaceuticals 6%
Industrials 13%
Leisure & Retai l6%
Marketing & Media 5%
Packaging 6%
Technology/IT 10%
Other 13%
% of GMA
Deals Done in
2009
OCTOBER 2010
Table of Contents
Section I: Executive Summary
Section II: BPO Companies
Section III: Facilities Management Companies
Section IV: Security Services Companies
Section V: Contract Catering Companies
Section VI: Human Resources Services Companies
Section VII: Waste Management Services Companies
Section VIII: Consulting Services Companies (Excludi ng IT)
APPENDIX: Global M&A deal highlight
Groupe Dynavision/Grande Armée ConseilDelba Maritima Navegaçao/BourbonCargolux
Sampling of Business Services Deals
The Global M&A Business Services Team
Nicolas AmbrosioniFinancial Analyst
Veronique Zeid-MaurelPartner
Global M&A Business Services team leader
Section I: Executive SummaryOverview
In this report, the Global M&A Knowledge Centre together with the Global M&A Business Services Industry team reviews valuations and recent valuation trends for various sub-sectors of the global business services industry. The seven sub-sectors that we have analyzed for this report include: business process outsourcing (BPO), facilities management, security services, waste management, human resources services, consulting and contract catering companies. For the purpose of this paper we have either excluded smaller or larger sub-segments of the industry, where the data samples are either not as statistically significant or are too numerous to manageably analyze. Our analysis uses the seven aforementioned sub-segments merely as a means to categorize the industry in an easily understandable manner. In the report, we examine valuation statistics derived fromthe most common valuation techniques used in the Investment Banking and Private Equity industries, namely comparable public company analysis and comparable transactions analysis. In our comparable company analysis we study the valuation of the industry and its sub-sectors based on operating and financial measurements (e.g., EV/EBITDA or EV/EBIT) of groups of public companies that have similar characteristics (for example, a peer or sub-sector group). Our comparable transaction valuation analysis derives an approximation of value from prices at which entire companies (or significant interests in companies) have been sold by comparing the valuation parameters of the M&A transactions.
The results of our analyses are the following:
• BPO Companies : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public BPO companies are 11.3x and 7.6x, respectively. The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 10.1x.
• Facilities Management Companies : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public facilities management companies are 9.9x and 7.2x, respectively. The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 7.9x.
• Security Services Companies : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public security services companies are 9.5x and 6.5x, respectively The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 9.8x.
• Contract Catering Companies : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public contract catering companies are 12.4x and 6.9x, respectively. The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 7.1x.
• Human Resources Services Companies : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public human resources services companies are 14.8x and 10.9x, respectively. The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 8.6x.
• Waste Management Companies : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public waste management companies are 14.6x and 6.2x, respectively. The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 7.9x.
• Consulting Services Companies – excluding IT : At the end of October 2010, the median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for comparable public consulting services companies are 9.7x and 7.8x, respectively. The median EV/EBITDA of comparable M&A transactions is 7.6x.
Section II: BPO CompaniesComparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s BPO comparable public company analysis involves 12 publicly traded BPO companies (IT and IT-enabled BPO not included) providing several different outsourcedservice offerings (Exhibits 1 and 2).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins are 7.0% and 12.3%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA are 11.3x and 7.6 x, respectively.
Exhibit 1
BPO Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Comparable Public Company Valuations (Con’t)
Exhibit 2
BPO Public Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Apac Customer Services Inc 1,0x 0,2x 0,4x 0,9x 0,4x 6,3x 2,9x 15,9x 38,3x 95,3x 8,4x 7,7x nm nm nm 5,4x 17,2x 11,3x nm nm
Capita Group 2,0x 2,3x 2,3x 2,4x 2,1x 14,3x 14,8x 15,0x 15,5x 13,8x 18,9x 18,3x 18,3x 19,1x 17,0x 24,8x 27,7x 25,6x 26,9x 25,7x
CCA International 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 9,0x 7,5x 5,6x 17,8x 16,2x 10,7x 8,6x nm 27,8x 22,8x 10,7x nm
Convergys Corp. 0,5x 0,4x 0,8x 1,2x 0,9x 8,5x 4,7x 5,8x 8,2x 6,1x nm 9,5x 8,6x 12,5x 10,5x 630,2x nm 12,4x 19,5x 18,1x
Datamatics Global Services Ltd. 0,7x 0,3x 0,8x 1,4x 7,4x 2,7x 11,2x 14,7x 11,4x 3,6x 25,4x 24,1x 8,2x 3,1x 12,6x 16,4x
Fiserv Inc 2,6x 2,0x 3,6x 2,1x 2,0x 8,4x 7,6x 15,5x 10,1x 9,0x 11,3x 11,0x 19,5x 12,8x 11,1x 15,6x 10,0x 20,9x 19,9x 15,2x
Scicom Msc Bhd 1,0x 0,4x 0,8x 7,8x 4,0x 6,9x 14,1x 7,4x 14,4x 15,4x 7,3x 16,6x
Spanco Ltd 0,1x 0,1x 1,2x 1,1x 0,8x 0,7x 8,1x 7,3x 0,8x 0,9x 9,2x 8,4x 2,5x 2,9x 8,6x 12,6x
Startek 0,3x 0,2x 0,4x 0,7x 1,0x 4,2x 4,8x 6,3x 17,0x 6,6x nm nm nm 29,6x 10,6x 23,9x nm nm 40,0x 20,5x
Sykes Enterprises 0,9x 0,7x 0,8x 1,0x 0,8x 7,7x 5,4x 7,1x 9,6x 7,7x 11,0x 7,4x 11,2x 12,3x 14,7x 24,5x 13,0x 18,6x 16,9x 22,5x
Teleperformance SA 0,7x 0,6x 0,8x 0,9x 0,9x 6,1x 4,4x 6,2x 6,8x 6,7x 9,8x 6,1x 9,0x 9,7x 10,1x 14,6x 9,2x 15,0x 19,6x 15,0x
WNS Holdings Ltd. 1,0x 0,7x 1,2x 3,1x 5,1x 5,1x 12,8x 25,3x 22,2x 13,3x 84,9x 40,7x 126,5x 27,4x 68,9x 45,9x
Mean 0,9x 0,7x 1,1x 1,4x 1,1x 7,1x 5,2x 9,8x 14,4x 20,4x 12,4x 8,5x 21,1x 17,8x 12,3x 76,6x 13,1x 21,2x 22,8x 19,5xMedian 0,8x 0,4x 0,8x 1,1x 0,9x 7,6x 4,7x 7,8x 10,1x 8,3x 11,3x 7,6x 12,8x 12,7x 10,9x 19,8x 10,0x 16,6x 19,6x 19,3x
nm = "not meaningful"
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Apac Customer Services Inc 204 32 24 222 207 15,9% 7,8% 2,3% 2,4% 0,4% 11,8% 3,0% -4,0% -3,2% -8,0%
Capita Group 2 986 425 322 5 385 6 275 14,2% 15,2% 15,4% 15,5% 15,3% 10,8% 12,3% 12,6% 12,6% 12,4%
CCA International 97 4 2 19 28 4,0% 2,8% 5,6% 6,9% 2,4% 2,2% 1,1% 3,9% 4,5% -1,5%
Convergys Corp. 1 973 120 -62 1 021 1 120 6,1% 9,3% 13,7% 14,6% 15,7% -3,1% 4,6% 9,3% 9,6% 9,1%
Datamatics Global Services Ltd. 42 4 3 31 29 9,2% 11,9% 6,8% 9,2% 15,1% 6,0% 9,0% 3,0% 5,6% 12,2%
Fiserv Inc 2 844 892 660 5 979 8 325 31,4% 26,4% 23,5% 20,8% 22,8% 23,2% 18,3% 18,6% 16,4% 18,4%
Scicom Msc Bhd 31 4 2 29 27 12,7% 10,0% 11,1% 16,2% 19,6% 7,0% 5,4% 5,3% 10,1% 14,0%
Spanco Ltd 195 34 32 83 83 17,5% 11,6% 14,4% 15,6% 19,7% 16,2% 9,9% 12,7% 13,6% 13,5%
Startek 202 15 0 54 39 7,6% 4,2% 7,1% 4,4% 15,5% -0,2% -5,7% -1,7% 2,5% 9,7%
Sykes Enterprises 590 70 49 509 305 11,9% 12,8% 10,8% 10,1% 10,5% 8,3% 9,4% 6,8% 7,9% 5,5%
Teleperformance SA 1 848 207 130 1 302 1 288 11,2% 14,0% 13,6% 13,5% 13,3% 7,0% 10,1% 9,4% 9,5% 8,9%
WNS Holdings Ltd. 433 83 19 307 381 19,2% 14,1% 9,4% 12,4% 15,6% 4,4% 5,4% 1,4% 7,7% 10,0%
Mean 13,4% 11,7% 11,1% 11,8% 13,8% 7,8% 6,9% 6,5% 8,1% 8,7%Median 12,3% 11,8% 11,0% 12,9% 15,4% 7,0% 7,2% 6,1% 8,7% 9,9%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Section II: BPO Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable BPO M&A transactions are 10.4x and 10.1x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 9xEBITDA)
Exhibit 3
BPO Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Sep-10 FirstAssist Services Holdings
Limited
UK based company engaged in providing risk managed
solutions, employee assistance services and
occupational health services
The Capita Group Plc United Kingdom 20 14 0,7x 30,6x
Sep-10 Pipal Research Corporation US based provider of financial and business research,
corporate intelligence, and quantitative analytics services
CRISIL Limited India 6 10 1,6x
Sep-10 Kale Consultants Ltd. (58.6%
Stake)
Indian provider of technology and business solutions Accelya Spain 21 22 1,9x 7,1x 2,9x
Aug-10 Zenith Provecta (60% Stake) UK based provider of bespoke fleet management
services, concentrating on the provision of innovative
management solutions, and vehicle outsourcing
businesses
Morgan Stanley Private
Equity
USA 118 103 1,5x 28,0x
Aug-10 Tela Sourcing Inc US and India bassed provider of business process
outsourcing (BPO) services to the health care industry
TriZetto Group Inc USA 23
Aug-10 BeCogent Limited Scottland based customer interaction centres and
providers of outsourced services.
Teleperformance SA France 47 42
Jun-10 Telegate AG (Livorno and Turin
Call Centers)
Italy based call centers owned by Telegate AG Contacta SpA Italy 25
Jun-10 AT&T Japan (domestic network
outsourcing services business)
Japan based domestic network outsourcing services
business of AT&T Japan LLC
Internet Initiative Japan Inc Japan 82
May-10 Dataforce Interact Lmited UK based outsourcing service provider of integrated data-
driven CRM solutions of Twenty PLC
HOV Global Services
Holdings Limited
UK 12
May-10 Adventity Global Services US based full service KPO/BPO firm for the Banking &
Financial Services and the Airlines & Travel industry
Sutherland Global Services USA 39 44 1,1x
Apr-10 Ryla Inc US based provider of value-added customer contact
services
Alorica Inc USA 76 53 0,7x
Apr-10 WuXi PharmaTech China based pharmaceutical and biotechnology research
and development outsourcing company
Charles River Laboratories
Inc
USA 188 1112 5,9x 30,7x 21,0x
Apr-10 Fortify Infrastructure Services Inc US based remote IT operations management company MphasiS BFL Ltd India 15 12 0,8x
Mar-10 Convergys Corporation (human
resources management business)
US based human resources management business of
Convergys Corporation
NorthgateArinso Nederland
BV
Netherlands 74
Feb-10 Integreon Inc (30.00% stake) US based company engaged in business, legal and
knowledge process outsourcing services with businesses
in China India Philippines South Africa and the UK
Actis Capital LLP UK 36
Feb-10 Affiliated Computer Services Inc US based provider of business process outsourcing
(BPO) and information technology outsourcing (ITO)
solutions to commercial and government clients
Xerox Corporation USA 4 613 5 029 1,1x 10,4x 6,4x
Feb-10 ICT Group, Inc US based outsourcing company Sykes Enterprises
Incorporated
USA 306 139 0,5x
Jan-10 CPA Global Limited Channel Islands based legal outsourcing company
providing legal support and intellectual property
management services to corporations and law firms
Intermediate Capital Group
(ICG)
UK 173 508 2,9x 9,8x
Jan-10 Xafinity Group Limited UK based company that provides specialist outsourcing
and consultancy services regarding pensions, employee
benefits, and payments expertise
Advent International
Corporation
USA 144 317 2,2x 46,2x 13,7x
Jan-10 Intelenet UK Services Ltd UK based company which handles the ticketing and
other functions of FirstGroup's UK rail operations
Intelenet Global Services
Limited
India 49
Dec-09 Bellsystem24 Inc Japan based call center management company providing
CRM, e-CRM and marketing solutions, e-Commerce and
e-Support services
Bain Capital LLC USA 825 748 0,9x 10,4x
Nov-09 McCamish Systems LLC US based providing business process outsourcing
solutions, and software and services to life insurance and
financial services industries
Infosys BPO Ltd India 27 26 0,9x
Nov-09 American Express (back-office unit
in India)
India based back-office operations of American Express
Business Travel
ExlService Holdings Inc USA 20
Enterprise Value /
Section II: BPO Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 3
BPO Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $) Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Oct-09 eTelecare Global Solutions Inc Philippines based provider of business process
outsourcing service
Stream Global Services Inc USA 214 100 0,5x 10,4x
Sep-09 Alitalia SpA (three branches of
payroll business)
Italy based payroll business Byte Software House SpA Italy 15
Sep-09 Laguna Medical Systems Inc US based business process outsourcing service provider SPi Global Solutions Philippines USA 6
Sep-09 Omnia Group Service srl;
Vox2Web SpA
Italy based company providing sale, marketing, facility
management and administrative skills to Omnia
Network's clients; Italy based system integrator and
value added reseller for CRM platforms
Voicity (formerly Omnia
Service Center S.p.A.)
Italy 9
Sep-09 Voicity (formerly Omnia Service
Center S.p.A.)
Italy based company providing outsourcing services Alba Rental Srl Italy 20
Aug-09 IP BPO Holdings Pte Ltd Philippine based provider of business process
outsourcing services formerly owned by IPVG group
PCCW Teleservices (Hong
Kong) Limited
Hong Kong 15
Jul-09 Resolve Business Outsourcing
Income Fund
Canada based provider of customized business process
outsourcing solutions (BPO)
Davis + Henderson Income
Fund
Canada 217 100 0,5x
Jul-09 Resolve Corporation (Supply Chain
Management division)
Canada based supply chaing management operations of
Resolve Corporation
Archway Marketing Services,
Inc.
USA 14
Jul-09 eRx Network LLC US based provider of electronic claims management
services to the retail pharmacy industry
Emdeon Inc USA 19 54 2,7x
May-09 Cockleshell Limited UK based investment holding company having interest in
business process outsourcing, facilities services,
property services and consumer sectors
BCB Holdings Limited Belize 62
Apr-09 Ordina BPO B.V. Netherlands based business process outsourcing
provider
Centric Holding B.V. Netherlands 43 24 0,6x
Mar-09 e-Services Group International Inc Jamaica based company providing business process
outsourcing (BPO) services
Affiliated Computer Services
Inc
USA 51 63 1,2x
Mar-09 Kurtzman Carson Consultants LLC US based claims and noticing agent that provides
administrative-support services and technology solutions
to companies undergoing a corporate restructuring
Computershare Limited Australia 75
Mar-09 The Phone House (Proprietary)
Limited
South Africa based call centre of Talk Talk Telecom
Group
eTelecare Global Solutions
Singapore Pte Ltd
Singapore 4
Dec-08 Citigroup Global Services Limited
(96.26% stake)
India based provider of BPO services. It offers
transaction processing solutions, customer care solutions
and technology services solutions to the financial
services industry
Tata Consultancy Services
Limited
India 375
Dec-08 US Healthcare Holdings Llc US based company engaged in providing outsourcing,
management and consulting services
Prodigy Health Group Inc USA 19
Dec-08 eTelecare Global Solutions Inc Philippines based provider of business process
outsourcing service
EGS Acquisition Co LLC USA 178 161 0,9x 10,4x 6,2x
Average 1,5x 21,6x 11,2x
Median 0,9x 10,4x 10,1x
Enterprise Value /
Section III: Facilities Management CompaniesComparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s facilities management comparable public company analysis involves 20 publicly traded facilities management companies (Exhibits 4 and 5).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins are 4.7% and 6.3%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA are 9.9x and 7.2x, respectively.
Exhibit 4
Facilities Management Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Abm Industries 2 352 85 61 842 942 3,6% 3,5% 3,5% 6,4% 3,3% 2,6% 2,7% 2,8% 5,7% 2,5%
AWC Facility Solutions Bhd 20 2 1 16 16 10,0% -0,5% 15,4% 16,1% 6,7% -9,6% 11,3% 12,2%
Balfour Beatty 9 950 372 244 2 099 1 757 3,7% 3,3% 3,2% 4,1% 4,8% 2,5% 2,2% 2,3% 2,8% 3,8%
Compass Group 14 669 1 206 953 11 191 12 342 8,2% 7,4% 6,8% 6,9% 7,6% 6,5% 5,6% 5,2% 4,8% 2,4%
Connaught 750 51 37 6,8% 5,3% 5,5% 5,1% 4,3% 4,9% 4,9% 4,4% 4,7% 3,3%
Derichebourg 2 432 105 -3 606 1 544 4,3% 6,8% 5,2% 2,4% 3,1% -0,1% 4,3% 2,8% 0,6% 0,6%
Emcor Group 3 871 215 183 1 264 890 5,6% 5,2% 4,0% 2,8% 2,2% 4,7% 4,5% 3,4% 2,4% 1,7%
FirstService Corp. 1 188 81 28 536 910 6,8% 12,8% 7,3% 8,5% 8,4% 2,3% 9,0% 4,8% 6,0% 6,2%
IMPEL SA 259 22 16 104 108 8,3% 10,0% 5,5% 6,0% 8,0% 6,3% 7,8% 3,3% 3,7% 5,6%
Interserve Plc 2 119 93 75 287 332 4,4% 6,4% 7,3% 7,2% 5,3% 3,6% 4,8% 5,8% 2,9% 4,0%
Mears group 522 30 22 286 279 5,8% 5,5% 6,2% 5,8% 5,5% 4,2% 4,1% 5,1% 5,1% 4,8%
Mitie Group 1 927 115 91 820 927 6,0% 6,3% 6,0% 5,8% 6,1% 4,7% 5,2% 5,0% 4,7% 5,1%
Nippon Kanzai 582 34 28 260 206 5,9% 5,4% 6,8% 7,7% 7,6% 4,8% 4,6% 6,3% 7,1% 6,0%
Parkwood 131 5 0 11 14 3,9% 6,1% 7,6% 5,8% 5,5% -0,3% 1,6% 3,4% 2,6% 2,6%
Prodef SA 133 7 4 5,6% 4,9% 4,3% 6,3% 5,7% 3,0% 2,5% 2,4% 3,1% 2,0%
Renaissance Services S.A.O.G. 450 112 74 470 809 24,9% 23,4% 21,6% 15,7% 16,3% 16,4% 15,9% 13,9% 15,6% 15,3%
Rentokil Initial 2 812 445 133 2 063 3 321 15,8% 14,2% 18,8% 20,5% 19,8% 4,7% 3,4% 9,8% 11,8% 12,2%
Sodexo SA 14 681 963 746 7 367 10 356 6,6% 6,6% 6,1% 6,2% 6,1% 5,1% 5,2% 4,8% 4,7% 3,7%
Synergis Holdings Limited 49 3 3 26 18 6,8% 7,4% 7,1% 6,5% 9,5% 5,9% 6,6% 6,5% 5,6% 8,6%
UGL Ltd. 2 938 197 155 1 772 1 936 6,7% 17,9% 21,0% 20,0% 20,0% 5,3% 16,8% 19,7% 18,7% 18,7%
Mean 7,5% 7,9% 8,5% 8,3% 7,9% 4,7% 5,1% 6,1% 6,2% 5,7%Median 6,3% 6,3% 6,5% 6,3% 6,1% 4,7% 4,7% 4,9% 4,8% 4,0%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Section III: Facilities Management Companies
Comparable Public Company Valuations
Exhibit 5
Facilities Management Public Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Abm Industries 0,3x 0,3x 0,4x 0,3x 0,4x 7,8x 8,3x 10,5x 4,6x 10,8x 10,8x 10,7x 13,0x 5,3x 14,0x 15,4x 18,3x 22,4x 10,4x 16,7x
AWC Facility Solutions Bhd 0,7x 0,2x 0,3x 7,1x nm 1,7x 10,6x nm 2,3x 20,5x nm 4,0x
Balfour Beatty 0,2x 0,2x 0,3x 0,4x 0,3x 4,4x 4,8x 9,1x 8,8x 7,2x 6,7x 7,0x 12,5x 12,9x 9,3x 8,3x 8,0x 14,3x 20,9x 14,3x
Compass Group 0,6x 0,6x 0,6x 0,6x 0,5x 7,3x 8,7x 9,3x 9,0x 7,1x 9,3x 11,5x 12,3x 13,0x 22,7x 12,1x 14,3x 11,1x 19,8x 4 452,1x
Connaught 0,9x 1,0x 0,9x 0,7x 0,6x 12,9x 19,0x 15,3x 13,6x 13,9x 17,8x 20,9x 19,5x 14,7x 18,2x 28,1x 32,3x 29,0x 22,5x 32,4x
Derichebourg 0,7x 0,3x 0,5x 0,5x 0,6x 15,1x 4,4x 8,9x 22,6x 19,8x nm 6,9x 16,8x 94,9x 98,2x nm 6,8x 13,5x nm nm
Emcor Group 0,2x 0,2x 0,3x 0,3x 0,2x 4,1x 3,6x 6,4x 11,6x 9,0x 4,8x 4,2x 7,6x 13,9x 11,7x 11,1x 8,1x 12,1x 22,1x 17,5x
FirstService Corp. 0,6x 0,6x 0,7x 0,7x 0,8x 9,5x 4,3x 9,6x 8,7x 9,3x 27,5x 6,2x 14,5x 12,4x 12,6x nm 7,1x 22,6x 23,6x 10,6x
IMPEL SA 0,3x 0,1x 0,3x 0,4x 3,9x 1,4x 6,0x 6,2x 5,1x 1,7x 9,9x 10,1x 9,9x 2,8x 41,3x 20,2x
Interserve Plc 0,1x 0,2x 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 3,4x 3,4x 5,5x 6,0x 6,6x 4,2x 4,6x 7,0x 14,8x 8,8x 3,5x 5,2x 12,8x nm 13,8x
Mears group 0,4x 0,4x 0,5x 0,9x 0,8x 7,4x 8,2x 8,3x 15,2x 14,6x 10,2x 10,8x 10,0x 17,3x 16,8x 14,9x 15,3x 15,6x 22,0x 23,7x
Mitie Group 0,5x 0,4x 0,6x 0,6x 0,7x 8,8x 6,3x 9,4x 10,3x 10,8x 11,1x 7,7x 11,3x 12,7x 13,0x 14,1x 11,4x 17,0x 19,4x 19,5x
Nippon Kanzai 0,3x 0,3x 0,6x 0,7x 1,2x 5,4x 6,4x 9,4x 9,4x 15,7x 6,5x 7,5x 10,2x 10,2x 20,0x 16,6x 28,1x 25,1x 20,3x 25,2x
Parkwood 0,1x 0,5x 0,4x 0,2x 1,9x 7,2x 7,2x 3,5x nm 15,8x 16,0x 7,5x 3,1x 13,5x 13,1x 8,9x
Prodef SA 0,1x 0,1x 0,2x 1,2x 1,5x 3,6x 2,2x 2,9x 10,3x 7,9x 9,4x 18,8x
Renaissance Services S.A.O.G. 1,6x 1,3x 2,0x 1,2x 6,3x 5,5x 9,3x 7,9x 9,6x 8,1x 14,5x 7,9x 8,2x 6,3x 19,0x 7,0x
Rentokil Initial 1,3x 0,9x 1,4x 2,0x 1,7x 8,0x 6,3x 7,6x 9,6x 8,6x 26,8x 26,1x 14,6x 16,7x 13,9x 43,9x 42,3x 3,3x 12,2x 9,2x
Sodexo SA 0,6x 0,7x 0,7x 0,6x 0,4x 9,6x 10,9x 11,0x 10,2x 7,1x 12,4x 14,0x 14,0x 13,3x 11,7x 15,9x 19,4x 21,7x 20,1x 28,2x
Synergis Holdings Limited 0,4x 0,3x 0,3x 0,3x 0,4x 5,4x 4,1x 4,8x 5,4x 4,3x 6,2x 4,7x 5,3x 6,2x 4,7x 11,0x 8,6x 10,7x 12,7x 9,5x
UGL Ltd. 0,6x 0,4x 0,7x 1,0x 0,9x 8,8x 2,4x 3,1x 5,0x 4,7x 11,1x 2,6x 3,3x 5,4x 5,0x 15,4x 12,0x 15,3x 24,7x 24,7x
Mean 0,5x 0,5x 0,6x 0,7x 0,6x 6,9x 6,1x 8,0x 9,5x 9,2x 10,7x 8,8x 11,3x 16,5x 17,6x 14,4x 14,2x 17,1x 18,2x 295,3xMedian 0,5x 0,3x 0,5x 0,6x 0,5x 7,2x 5,1x 8,9x 8,9x 8,6x 9,9x 7,3x 12,3x 12,9x 12,6x 13,1x 10,4x 15,3x 20,1x 18,1x
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Section III: Facilities Management Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable Facilities Management M&A transactions are 11.2x and 7.9x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 10,4xEBITDA)
Exhibit 6
Facilities Management Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $) Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Oct-10 IDA Service AS Denmark based providers of service solutions for facility
management, cleaning and canteen
Compass Group Plc UK 20
Oct-10 Jackson Lloyd Ltd UK based company engaged in building
maintenance and providing services
Mears Group Plc UK 6
Sep-10 POWER SUPPORT Spanish company engaged in the operation and maintenance
of industrial facilities and power generation plants
Fenice Spa Italy 14
Sep-10 Skelleftea Energi Underhall
formerly owned by Vattenfall
Sweden based company engaged in providing maintenance
services to wind, water and heat industry
Skelleftea kraft AB Sweden
Sep-10 DTE Rail Services, Inc. US based provider of railcar maintenance, fleet management,
railroad operations and technology services
FreightCar America, Inc. USA 20 18 0,9x
Aug-10 Antimite Termite and Pest Control US based pest control company The Terminix International Company
L.P.
USA 23
Aug-10 Swisher International, Inc US based provider of hygiene products and services CoolBrands International Inc Canada 77
Jul-10 Rimex GmbH (70% Stake) Germany based facility management company engaged in
cleaning and maintenance of green spaces and outdoor
facilities
STRABAG Property and Facility
Services GmbH
Germany 27
Jul-10 Mid Western Lifts Services Ltd. Ireland based company engaged in installation, repair,
refurbishment and maintenance of lifts and escalators
Grupo Orona Spain 25 20 0,8x
Jul-10 Faceo FM SA France based integrated solutions provider for service sector
maintenance, with activities in engineering, systems
integration and multi-service and multi-technical maintenance
Vinci SA France 450
Jun-10 Caverion GmbH Germany based company that offers services in facility
engineering and facility systems. It provides consulting and
planning, construction and operation of complex air-
conditioning and ventilation systems, heating and refrigeration
YIT Corporation Finland 440 73 0,2x
Jun-10 Diversco Inc US based company providing cleaning and maintenance
specialized contract services and security services
ABM Janitorial Services USA 58
Jun-10 Powerminster Gleeson Services
Ltd
UK based company engaged in providing commercial and
residential property maintenance services
Morgan Sindall Group plc UK 8
Jun-10 SAS Ground Services UK Ltd UK based dvision of SAS Ground Services, the service
supplier of airline ground handling inNordic countries
BBA Aviation Plc UK 25
Jun-10 Clockwork Home Services Inc US based company having franchises for the home services
contractor market
Direct Energy LP USA 153
Jun-10 Audeca SL Spain based infrastructure, road maintenance and
environmental services company
Elecnor SA Spain 39 23 0,6x
Jun-10 Knightsbridge Guarding Limited;
Perception UK LLP
UK based provider of security and receptionist services for the
corporate sector
Rentokil Initial Plc UK 8
Jun-10 Castle Support Services Plc UK based investment holding company with interests in
electro-mechanical inspection, maintenance and repair
services
Sulzer (UK) Holdings Ltd UK 146 157 1,1x 7,8x 6,9x
Jun-10 DFM Providers Limited; Dalkia
Energy & Facilities Ltd
Ireland based provider of facilities management services;
Ireland based provider of facilities management services
Mitie Group Plc UK 29 13 0,4x
Jun-10 Southeast Service Corporation US based provider of facilities management services Crothall Services Group Inc Canada,USA 107 54 0,5x
May-10 Utilicom Group Limited UK based provider of services in building maintenance and
energy management and conservation
GDF Suez SA France 36
Enterprise Value /
Section III: Facilities Management Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 6
Facilities Management Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Apr-10 National Grid Energy Services
(service contract business)
US based provider of heating, cooling, and water heater repair
services
Homeserve Plc UK 22
Mar-10 D&S (Engineering Facilities)
Limited
UK based provider of facilities management services to blue-
chip UK client list
T. Clarke Plc UK 18 8 0,5x 21,5x 16,8x
Mar-10 Euro Environmental Group Limited UK based provider of drain and sewer cleaning, inspection
and repair services
Sovereign Capital Partners LLP UK 22
Feb-10 Hurley Corporation Canada based provider of cleaning and facility management
services
Compass Group Canada Ltd Canada 34
Dec-09 Sistema-Hals ZAO (40.62% stake) Russia based company engaged in development, asset
management and facilities management
VTB Bank JSC Russia 79
Dec-09 RSM Rail Service Management
GmbH
Germany-based train maintenance company EuroMaint AB Sweden 94 18 0,2x
Nov-09 Juan Galindo, SL Spain based company which provides electrical installation
and maintenance services.
Grupo Ortiz Spain 5
Nov-09 Champions of the West Inc US based facility management company providing services to
the US Government
G4S Plc UK 88 40 0,5x
Oct-09 Quala Systems Inc US based company providing tank cleaning and repair
services
QualaWash Holdings LLC USA 9
Oct-09 Veris Plc (Property Management
and Facilities Management
Business)
Ireland based property management and facilities
management Business of Veris Plc, the listed Ireland based
provider of integrated property services
Aramark Investment Limited Aramark
Ireland Limited
UK Ireland 74 46 0,6x 3,9x
Sep-09 Veolia Proprete Nettoyage et
Multiservices SA
France based company specalised in industrial cleaning Groupe TFN France 350 120 0,3x
Aug-09 Eurogem SAS France based provider of real estate facilities management
services formerly owned by Icade
Groupe TFN France 63 18 0,3x
Aug-09 Dalkia Technical Facilities
Management
UK based provider of outsourced Technical Facilities
Management and Energy Services
Mitie Group Plc UK 280 151 0,5x 11,3x
May-09 Mosdachtrest OJSC (58.00%
stake)
Russian based real estate asset management company AFK Sistema Russia 12 11 1,6x
Apr-09 Godrej Hicare Ltd Indian company providing pest control services ISS Facilities Services India India 15
Apr-09 Radhakrishna Hospitality Services
Pvt Ltd
India based food service & hospitality solutions, integrated
facilities management and vending solutions
Sodexo SA France 70 99 1,4x
Mar-09 Temple Security Limited UK based provider of contract cleaning, security and
maintenance services
LPM Group Ltd UK 21 13 0,6x
Jan-09 Centre Europeen de Domotique et
d'Energie (33.00% stake)
France based company engaged in installation, and
maintenance of thermodynamic heating equipment.
Turenne Capital Partenaires France 5
Dec-08 Zehnacker Holding GmbH (90.00%
stake)
German company providing building and facility management
services.
Sodexo SA France 250 172 0,8x
Oct-08 Padana Everest srl (75.00% stake) Italy based provider of health sector services Servizi Italia Spa Italy 21 18 1,1x 11,2x 4,0x
Sep-08 Jan-Pro Franchising International
Inc
US based franchisor of commercial cleaning services Gemini Partners Inc ; Webster
Capital Fund II
USA 47
Enterprise Value /
Section III: Facilities Management Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 6
Facilities Management Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Source: MergerMarket
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Sep-08 Taylor Woodrow Construction Ltd UK based company engages in construction, facilities
management, and engineering businesses
Vinci Plc UK 871 86 0,1x
Sep-08 Radhakrishna Hospitality Services
Pvt Ltd (50.00% stake); SHRM
Food and Allied Services Private
Ltd (50.00% stake) from Compass
India based food service & hospitality solutions, integrated
facilities management and vending solutions
Radhakrishna Group India 17
Sep-08 Eastlake Group Ltd UK based provider of workplace interiors and property
services.
Work Inc Group Limited UK 40 17 0,4x 18,5x 11,6x
Aug-08 Noonan Services Group Ireland based company providing facilities management and
cleaning services
Alchemy Partners LLP UK 90
Aug-08 InStar Services Group, LP US based provider of commercial disaster response and
reconstruction services formerly onwed by ServiceMaster
BlackEagle Partners LLC USA 16
Jul-08 Equipo Blanco Argentina based company engaged in facility services ISS Holdings AS Denmark 7
Jul-08 Diversco Inc US based company providing cleaning and maintenance
specialized contract services and security services
Temco Service Industries Inc USA 54 20 0,4x
Jun-08 Synergis Holdings Ltd Hong Kong based investment holding company interested in
property management and facility management services,
security services, cleaning services, laundry services, repair
and maintenance works, trading of related products and
membership programmes
Hsin Chong Construction Group Ltd Bermuda
British Virgin
Islands Hong
Kong
35 32 0,9x 14,8x 5,3x
Apr-08 HRI Inc US based provider of critical maintenance services in high
temperature and confined space environments to the heavy
industry
Timec Company Inc USA 3
Mar-08 The Lord Group Limited UK based building and maintenance services provider. Kinetics Group UK 14 6 0,4x 8,4x 7,9x
Average 0,6x 12,3x 9,1x
Median 0,5x 11,2x 7,9x
Enterprise Value /
Section IV: Security Services CompaniesComparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s security services comparable public company analysis involves 16 publicly traded security services companies (Exhibits 7 and 8).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins are 5.9% and 8.8%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA are 9.5x and 6.5x, respectively.
Exhibit 7
Security Services Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Exhibit 8
Security Services Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Brink's Co (The) 2 187 229 145 801 882 10,5% 11,2% 14,4% 12,9% 10,4% 6,6% 7,6% 8,6% 7,1% 4,5%
Central Security Patrols Co Ltd 321 22 10 103 50 6,9% 8,2% 8,2% 8,0% 7,3% 3,1% 4,7% 4,1% 3,9% 3,3%
China Security & Surveillance Technology Inc.405 55 53 225 221 13,5% 15,7% 19,9% 24,7% 23,7% 13,0% 13,4% 17,8% 23,7% 22,9%
Command Security Corp. 108 3 3 17 24 3,2% 2,9% 2,6% 1,5% 0,4% 2,5% 2,3% 2,5% 1,2% 0,0%
G4S plc 7 789 717 465 4 295 6 035 9,2% 9,6% 9,0% 8,6% 8,3% 6,0% 5,9% 6,0% 5,6% 4,8%
Garda World Security Corp 730 80 27 193 578 11,0% 6,2% 8,7% 8,4% 10,4% 3,7% -5,4% 5,5% 6,6% 8,7%
GlobalOptions Group Inc. 71 -1 -3 23 21 -0,9% -3,1% -20,1% -3,5% -36,7% -4,2% -7,3% -31,5% -28,5% -39,0%
IMPEL SA 259 22 16 104 108 8,3% 10,0% 5,5% 6,0% 8,0% 6,3% 7,8% 3,3% 3,7% 5,6%
Loomis AB 1 165 155 80 655 865 13,3% 12,6% 8,2% 11,8% 13,6% 6,8% 6,5% -3,8% -5,2% 7,2%
Mitie Group 1 927 115 91 820 927 6,0% 6,3% 6,0% 5,8% 6,1% 4,7% 5,2% 5,0% 4,7% 5,1%
Niscayah Group AB 741 69 48 449 568 9,3% 5,9% 11,5% 11,8% 11,1% 6,5% -2,9% 9,1% 9,4% 10,8%
Prosegur 2 187 310 234 2 614 2 933 14,2% 12,9% 11,4% 9,1% 11,0% 10,7% 10,0% 8,8% 6,4% 8,2%
Secom 5 251 1 108 737 7 758 7 215 21,1% 17,8% 23,3% 24,6% 23,3% 14,0% 11,0% 14,2% 13,9% 13,0%
Securitas AB 6 090 455 351 2 965 3 896 7,5% 7,1% 6,2% 5,0% 9,4% 5,8% 5,5% 3,1% 2,9% 6,3%
Sohgo Security Services Co 2 234 176 68 754 391 7,9% 7,7% 8,8% 9,5% 8,8% 3,0% 3,1% 4,6% 5,0% 3,7%
Turvatiimi Oyj 27 0 -1 23 26 -0,8% -6,2% -1,2% -6,4% -3,2% -4,0% -12,1% -5,0% -11,0% -6,6%
Mean 8,8% 7,8% 7,6% 8,6% 7,0% 5,3% 3,5% 3,3% 3,1% 3,7%Median 8,8% 7,9% 8,5% 8,5% 9,1% 5,9% 5,3% 4,8% 4,9% 5,4%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Brink's Co (The) 0,4x 0,4x 0,9x 1,1x 1,2x 3,9x 3,5x 6,2x 8,6x 11,4x 6,1x 5,3x 10,4x 15,6x 26,2x 5,8x 6,7x 21,1x 5,3x 19,7x
Central Security Patrols Co Ltd 0,2x 0,2x 0,2x 0,4x 0,3x 2,5x 2,1x 3,0x 4,5x 4,1x 5,4x 3,6x 6,1x 9,2x 8,9x 17,0x 11,6x 14,3x 18,5x 17,9x
China Security & Surveillance Technology Inc.0,7x 0,8x 4,1x 4,9x 5,0x 20,5x 5,2x 5,8x 22,9x 7,0x 6,7x 26,3x
Command Security Corp. 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 12,2x 29,3x 107,6x 15,1x 36,2x 1 199,8x 27,2x 26,2x nm
G4S plc 0,7x 0,7x 0,9x 0,7x 0,7x 8,1x 7,7x 9,9x 8,3x 7,9x 12,5x 12,6x 14,8x 12,8x 13,8x 18,2x 19,1x 21,3x 24,9x 25,3x
Garda World Security Corp 0,8x 0,6x 0,9x 1,2x 2,0x 7,3x 9,8x 10,4x 13,9x 18,8x 21,8x nm 16,6x 17,7x 22,6x nm nm 29,4x 29,2x 29,0x
GlobalOptions Group Inc. 0,2x 0,2x 0,5x nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm
IMPEL SA 0,3x 0,1x 0,3x 0,4x 3,9x 1,4x 6,0x 6,2x 5,1x 1,7x 9,9x 10,1x 9,9x 2,8x 41,3x 20,2x
Loomis AB 0,6x 0,5x 4,8x 4,2x 9,3x 8,2x 11,4x 8,4x
Mitie Group 0,5x 0,4x 0,6x 0,6x 0,7x 8,8x 6,3x 9,4x 10,3x 10,8x 11,1x 7,7x 11,3x 12,7x 13,0x 14,1x 11,4x 17,0x 19,4x 19,5x
Niscayah Group AB 0,9x 0,5x 1,4x 1,8x 9,2x 9,0x 12,2x 15,3x 13,3x nm 15,4x 19,1x 17,0x nm 19,9x 30,2x
Prosegur 1,1x 0,8x 1,0x 1,1x 1,1x 7,8x 6,3x 8,5x 12,0x 9,6x 10,4x 8,1x 11,1x 16,9x 12,8x 14,1x 11,4x 15,3x 26,5x 18,3x
Secom 1,4x 1,2x 1,5x 1,9x 2,1x 6,5x 6,9x 6,6x 7,5x 9,2x 9,7x 11,1x 10,8x 13,3x 16,4x 20,0x 39,4x 18,3x 22,0x 27,9x
Securitas AB 0,5x 0,6x 0,7x 0,8x 0,9x 7,3x 7,9x 11,5x 16,6x 9,7x 9,5x 10,4x 22,6x 28,2x 14,4x 12,1x 9,6x 62,7x 45,6x 16,9x
Sohgo Security Services Co 0,2x 0,3x 0,5x 0,7x 0,7x 3,2x 3,8x 6,1x 7,8x 8,3x 8,2x 9,3x 11,8x 14,8x 19,5x 24,2x 20,1x 18,5x 29,1x 34,4x
Turvatiimi Oyj 1,2x 0,8x 0,8x 1,0x 1,4x nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm nm
Mean 0,7x 0,5x 1,0x 0,9x 1,0x 6,0x 6,1x 9,2x 11,7x 19,7x 9,8x 8,2x 13,6x 17,2x 134,7x 14,2x 14,5x 25,4x 24,8x 23,2xMedian 0,6x 0,5x 0,8x 0,8x 0,9x 6,5x 6,3x 9,0x 9,4x 9,6x 9,5x 8,2x 11,6x 15,2x 15,4x 14,1x 11,4x 20,5x 25,5x 19,7x
nm = "not meaningful"
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Section IV: Security Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable Security Services M&A transactions are 22x and 9.8x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 9.5xEBITDA)
Exhibit 9
Security Services Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
sept.-10 Reliance Security Group (UK security
services operations)
UK based security services operations Securitas AB Sweden 232 50 0,2x
sept.-10 QinetiQ North America Security and
Intelligence Solutions (S&IS)
US based security and intelligence solutions company
operating across a range of government sites in the
United States
ManTech International
Corporation
USA 41 44 1,1x
sept.-10 SpecTal, LLC; Advanced Concepts,
Inc.; McClendon, LLC
US based companies providing technical and
professional services to the US intelligence and military
communities
BAE Systems, Inc. USA 232
août-10 VSG Group Limited UK based security and support services company Compass Group Plc UK 136 99 0,7x 26,9x 17,9x
juil.-10 Zener Electronics Services Unites Arab Emirates based electronics company
engaged in the design, supply, installation and providing
maintenance services for electronic products
Sicli Holding SAS France 19
juil.-10 Legend Group Holding International
Pte Ltd
Singapore based provider of security services Securitas AB Sweden 7 6 0,9x
juin-10 Kroll Inc US based risk consulting company engaged in
background screening, drug testing, and surveillance
services, fraud investigations, security services and
technology services
Altegrity Inc USA 944
juin-10 Knightsbridge Guarding Limited;
Perception UK LLP
UK based providerS of security services for the
corporate sector
Rentokil Initial Plc UK 8
Aug-10 Legion Group plc UK based provider of total security solutions OCS Group UK Limited UK 15
juin-10 Paragon Paragon is specialized in providing high level, armed
security officer services to various government agencies
and facilities under the oversight of the U.S. Federal
Protective Service and the U.S. Government
Department of Defense.
Securitas AB Sweden 107 26,8 0,3x
juin-10 Instalarme Instalarme is a Brazilian electronic software and
hardware integration company, the market leader in the
country’s banking sector and counts all of Brazil’s largest
banks among its clients.
The business, founded in 1975 and acquired by the
G4S Plc UK 19 20,6 1,1x
juin-10 Bren security The Shri Lanka based company operates in guarding
services, mainly for embassies, international non
governmental organizations (NGOs), commercial sites
and residential customers in the Colombo city area.
Securitas AB Sweden 2 3,8 2,5x
mai-10 Brink's Home Security Holdings Inc US based manufacturer of security alarms Tyco International Ltd Switzerland 417 1277 3,1x 17,1x 9,0x
avr.-10 Protection One Inc US company providing security alarm monitoring
services to residential and commercial subscribers
GTCR Golder Rauner LLC USA 256 617 2,4x 22,0x 9,8x
avr.-10 DynCorp International Inc. US based provider of support to military and civilian
government institutions, including aviation support,
infrastructure development, security, and logistics
Cerberus Capital Management
LP
USA 2 970 1238 0,4x 6,3x
avr.-10 Dan Kontrol Dan Kontrol, with 25 employees, is the largest
independent monitoring company in Denmark.
Securitas AB Sweden 2,6
mars-10 Civil Biztonsagi Szolgalat Zrt Hungary based security services company Prostasia Zrt Hungary 30
mars-10 SDB Cisco (India) Ltd (60.00% stake) India based security services company ISS A/S Denmark 31 24 1,3x
mars-10 Zicom Electronic Security Systems Ltd
(electronic security systems integration
business)
India based electronic security systems integration
business
Schneider Electric India Pvt
Ltd
India 30 36 1,2x
Enterprise Value /
Section IV: Security Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 9
Security Services Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
mars-10 GE Security Inc US based supplier of security and life safety
technologies
United Technologies
Corporation
USA 1 486 1502 1,0x
mars-10 Secredo Seccredo is a leading Swedish consulting firm in the
field of highly qualified risk, crises and security
investigations and services
Securitas AB Sweden 3 1,2 0,5x
mars-10 Claw Protection Services, South Africa The South African company is specialized in guarding,
mainly in the areas of Johannesburg and Pretoria
Securitas AB Sweden 4 1,2 0,3x
janv.-10 Adesta LLC and Adesta LP (formerly
McCarthy Group)
Adesta is US-based and provides systems integration
and project management services for integrated security
systems and communication systems. The business has
three areas of focus related to secure solutions for
critical infrastructure – seaports, other critical
G4S Plc UK 75 54 0,7x
déc.-09 Nuclear Security Services Corporation US based risk consulting and security solutions firm G4S International Holdings Ltd UK 15 15 1,0x
déc.-09 Tecniserv, SA Spain based alarm monitoring company operating in
three areas: service of own connections portfolio,
installation of new alarm systems and monitoring of third
party connections.
Securitas AB Sweden 5 3,9 0,8x 33,3x 21,2x
déc.-09 Long Hai Security The Vietnam based company is the market leader in the
Vietnamese security services market, provides mainly
guarding services and operates throughout Vietnam,
with its largest branches being in Ho Chi Minh City and
Securitas AB Sweden 6 1 0,2x
déc.-09 Gordon Serbian private security company with 1 100 employees,
a majority of Gordon’s sales is in guarding services.
Securitas AB Sweden 5 3,4 0,6x
déc.-09 Grupo Argos Mexican private security company, a majority of the
operations are guarding services.
Securitas AB Sweden 5 1,9 0,4x
déc.-09 Dora Security a.s. Czech Republic based security services company Securitas AB Sweden 14 8,7 0,6x
nov.-09 Hill & Associates Hill & Associates, Asia’s leading provider of specialist
risk mitigation consulting services with 20 m$ revenues
and operations in 14 countries
G4S Plc UK 16 6,5
nov.-09 GMCE Gardiennage Moroccan private security company Securitas AB Sweden 0 1,3 13,0x
nov.-09 Ferssa Group French based security services company Securitas AB Sweden 17 3,6 0,2x
oct.-09 Socovig Columbia based provider of security services, mainly
operating in guarding, also has mobile and monitoring
operations. Socovig has approximately 1,100 employees
Securitas AB Sweden 7 4,1 0,6x
sept.-09 Guardforce Ltd Hong Kong based security services company, provides
security personnel and cash transport services (formerly
owned by UTC)
Securitas AB Sweden 11 1,9 0,2x
sept.-09 GE Security Inc (Homeland Protection
Business) (81.00% stake)
US based Homeland Protection business of GE Security
Inc. It develops tomography based detection systems for
hazardous or illicit substances in baggage
Safran SA France 196 438 2,8x
sept.-09 Vigilan The Argentina based company is mainly operating in
guarding services and alarm monitoring in the south of
Argentina. A majority of the customers are in the
petroleum, energy, retail, industry and bank segments.
Securitas AB Sweden 10 4,4 0,4x
août-09 GST Holdings Limited (70.97% stake) China based fire alarm system and solution services
provider
United Technologies Far East
Limited
Hong Kong 119 133 1,7x 10,2x 9,2x
juil.-09 Mega Italia SpA Italy based provider of installation and maintenance of
alarm systems
Sicurglobal SpA Italy 34
juil.-09 U.K. Fire International Limited UK based fire service company providing services
including fire safety compliance inspection, testing and
reporting, fire extinguisher and fire alarm system
servicing
Connaught Plc UK 12 14 1,2x
Enterprise Value /
Section IV: Security Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 9
Security Services Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
juil.-09 Federal Security Group Ireland based security solutions company formerly
owned by Newcourt Group Plc
Noonan Services Group Ireland
(Republic)
100 15 0,2x
juil.-09 Groupe Martec France based provider of electronic security and critical
embedded systems to the Defence, Aeronautical, Naval,
Environmental, Industrial and Transport sectors formerly
woned by Eryma SAS
Eolane Group France 22
juil.-09 Grupo Interlabora Spanish security and other support services provider Securitas AB Sweden 8 7,36 0,9x
juil.-09 Cyveillance US based provider of online risk management and
monitoring services
QinetiQ Group Plc UK 7 60 8,1x
juil.-09 Konsalnet SA (80.00% stake) Poland based security services firm SGAM Private Equity Eastern
Europe
France 66 22 0,4x
juil.-09 Norsergel Vigilancia e Transporte de
Valores Ltda
Brazilian group focused on the secUrity and
transportation of valuable material and money formerly
owned by Grupo Nordeste and Macedo Participacoes
Prosegur Compania de
Sequridad SA
Spain 85 61 0,7x
juin-09 SAS Ground Services Finland Finland based provider of airline ground services
formerly owned by SAS AB
ISS Palvelut Oy Finland 20
juin-09 Worldwide Security S.A. Chilean provider of security and alarm monitoring
services
Securitas AB Sweden 11 8,37 0,7x
juin-09 Infratek Vakt AS Norway based company providing security products and
guard services formerly owned by Infratek ASA
Vakt Service AS Norway 9
juin-09 Grupo Orus Peru based provider of security and private surveillance
services
Prosegur Compania de
Sequridad SA
Spain 35 19 0,5x
juin-09 Garda World Security (US and Mexico
Guarding operations)
US and Mexico based guarding operations of Garda
World Security, Canadian provider of security and cash
handling services
Andrews International USA 90 31 0,3x 9,8x
mai-09 Control Holding Group Inc.(Cleaning & US based Janitorial and Engineering Services assets of ABM Industries Inc USAmars-09 Temple Security Limited UK based provider of contract cleaning, security and
maintenance services
LPM Group Ltd UK 21 13 0,6x
mars-09 Setha Industria Eletronica Ltda Brazilian developer and manufacturer of electronic
security systems and industrial communication
equipment
Prosegur Compania de
Sequridad SA
Spain 10 7 0,8x
févr.-09 G4S Holdings SAS France based security solutions firm formerly owned by
G4S.
Neo Securite SAS France 250
févr.-09 General Industries Argentina SA
(GIASA)
Argentina based provider of electronic security services Prosegur Compania de
Sequridad SA
Spain
févr.-09 Moore Security US based security company Securitas AB Sweden 15 4 0,3x
févr.-09 V Valtis France based company manufacturing safety and
security equipments
Prosegur Compania de
Sequridad SA
Spain 16
févr.-09 Alarm.com US based Internet security service provider ABS Capital Partners; Egis
Capital Partners
USA 22
févr.-09 China Security systems Limited Hong Kong based provider of security and alarm
services incorporated in British Vergin Island
Bay Peak 4 Acquisition Corp China
janv.-09 Sebival-Seguranca Bancaria Industrial
e de Valores Ltda; Setal Servicos
Especializados, Tecnicos e Auxiliares
Ltda
Brazilian providers of cash-in-transit (CIT) and payment
processing services
Brink’s-Seguranca e
Transporte de Valores Ltda
Brazil 44 36 0,8x
janv.-09 Detection Logic Fire Protection Inc US based fire, life safety, and security contractor and
related services provider
UTC Fire & Security USA
Average 1,3x 21,9x 11,9x
Median 0,7x 22,0x 9,8x
Enterprise Value /
Section V: Contract Catering Companies
Comparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s contract catering comparable public company analysis involves 5 publicly traded contract catering companies (Exhibits 10 and 11).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins are 5.1% and 8.2%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA are 12.4x and 6.9x, respectively.
Exhibit 10
Contract Catering Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Exhibit 11
Contract Catering Public Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Autogrill Finanziaria 5 817 606 251 2 390 4 304 10,4% 10,2% 10,6% 12,3% 4,3% 5,6% 6,9% 7,6%
Catering International serv 160 17 13 115 93 10,4% 11,7% 14,1% 13,7% 5,9% 8,1% 9,3% 11,9% 11,8% 5,2%
Compass Group 14 669 1 206 953 11 191 12 342 8,2% 7,4% 6,8% 6,9% 7,6% 6,5% 5,6% 5,2% 4,8% 2,4%
Fuji Foods Inc 483 28 7 69 151 5,7% 5,3% 5,8% 5,9% 2,5% 1,5% 1,9% 2,5% 2,8% -1,4%
Sodexo SA 14 681 963 746 7 367 10 356 6,6% 6,6% 6,1% 6,2% 6,1% 5,1% 5,2% 4,8% 4,7% 3,7%
Mean 8,3% 8,2% 8,7% 9,0% 5,5% 5,1% 5,5% 6,2% 6,3% 2,5%Median 8,2% 7,4% 6,8% 6,9% 6,0% 5,1% 5,6% 5,2% 4,8% 3,0%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Autogrill Finanziaria 0,7x 0,6x 0,8x 1,0x 6,9x 6,0x 8,0x 7,9x 16,6x 10,8x 12,3x 12,8x 60,6x 11,1x 18,7x 23,2x
Catering International serv 0,6x 0,5x 0,7x 0,6x 0,6x 5,3x 4,1x 5,2x 4,1x 10,3x 6,8x 5,1x 6,1x 4,8x 11,7x 16,1x 11,1x 13,6x 9,2x 17,6x
Compass Group 0,6x 0,6x 0,6x 0,6x 0,5x 7,3x 8,7x 9,3x 9,0x 7,1x 9,3x 11,5x 12,3x 13,0x 22,7x 12,1x 14,3x 11,1x 19,8x 4 452,1x
Fuji Foods Inc 0,3x 0,2x 0,2x 0,3x 0,2x 4,4x 3,3x 3,0x 4,4x 9,8x 17,2x 9,2x 6,9x 9,2x nm 15,6x 12,2x 7,8x 8,8x nm
Sodexo SA 0,6x 0,7x 0,7x 0,6x 0,4x 9,6x 10,9x 11,0x 10,2x 7,1x 12,4x 14,0x 14,0x 13,3x 11,7x 15,9x 19,4x 21,7x 20,1x 28,2x
Mean 0,5x 0,5x 0,6x 0,6x 0,5x 6,7x 6,6x 7,3x 7,1x 8,6x 12,4x 10,1x 10,3x 10,6x 15,4x 24,0x 13,6x 14,6x 16,2x 1 499,3xMedian 0,6x 0,6x 0,7x 0,6x 0,5x 6,9x 6,0x 8,0x 7,9x 8,5x 12,4x 10,8x 12,3x 12,8x 11,7x 15,9x 12,2x 13,6x 19,8x 28,2x
nm = "not meaningful"
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Section V: Contract Catering Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable contract catering M&A transactions are 12.0x and 7.1x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 9,5xEBITDA)
Exhibit 12
Contract Catering Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Dec-09 Mediterranea de Catering SL Spain based catering company Alia Private Equity SCR SA
Inversiones Ibersuizas SA
Spain 74 70 0,9x 11,7x 9,5x
Apr-09 Radhakrishna Hospitality
Services Pvt Ltd
India based food service & hospitality solutions,
integrated facilities management and vending
solutions
Sodexo SA France 70 99 1,4x
Oct-09 Vanyera3 SL Spanish catering company Union Castellana de Alimentacion
SA
Spain 5
Dec-08 G2M (50.00% stake) Turkish catering company Actera Group Turkey 96 24 0,5x
Oct-08 Horkram Schulz Food Service AS Denmark based catering company Citti Handelsges mbH & Co. KG Germany 80
Oct-08 ITP services, s.r.o. Czech Republic based company engaged in
managing food and beverage activities at Prague
Airport
Airest Slovakia Gastronomy and
Retail sro Airest Terminal &
Catering Business Holding GmbH
Slovakia Austria 8
Oct-08 Arjan van Dijk Groep (75.00%
stake)
Netherland based event management services
provider.
Jaarbeurs Catering Services Netherlands 30
Sep-08 Centerplate, Inc. US based provider of food and related services,
including concessions, catering and merchandise
services in sports facilities, convention centers and
other entertainment facilities
Kohlberg & Company LLC USA 503 150 0,3x 9,5x 4,1x
Sep-08 Fast Food Servis Czech Republic based provider of operator
activities in Food & Beverage at the airport in
Prague Czech Republic
Airest Terminal & Catering
Business Holding GmbH
Austria 6 15 2,6x 19,6x
Aug-08 CAFE Group Capitol Vending US based food service provider; US based local
vending operation servicing central Indiana
Treat America Food Services Inc USA
Aug-08 7 Yedi Endustriyel Yemek Turkey based catering company Yemekci Turkey
Jul-08 Qua.ser s.r.l.; Zilch Ristorazione
s.r.l.
Italy based company engaged in catering services.;
Italy based provider of canteen and refectory
outsourcing services.
Gruppo Gemeaz Cusin Srl Italy
Jul-08 CLS Catering Services Limited
(30.00% stake)
Canada based provider of catering services in
airlines
LSG Lufthansa Service Europa
Afrika GmbH
Germany 4
Jul-08 Olympic Catering SA (55.70%
stake)
Greece based inflight catering company Alkmini Catering Greece 24
Jul-08 Lufthansa Airport Service-
Gesellschaft
Germany based catering company which has its
core competencies in food processing, logistics and
service profitably on the ground
SSP Deutschland GmbH Germany 27
Jun-08 Sardunya AS Turkey based catering group ISS Turkey Turkey
Jun-08 Cerfal Lecocq SA SDM France based companies providing food catering
and event organisation related services.
Holding SDPL Finorpa France
Enterprise Value /
Section V: Contract Catering Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 12
Contract Catering Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Jun-08 Grupo Servicoin S.A. de C.V Mexico based catering company ISS A/S Denmark
Jun-08 Yedi Turkey based company engaged in catering
business.
Bulutoglu Gida ve Lojistik
Hizmetleri AS
Turkey 13
Jun-08 SCK DUS GmbH& Co KG
Duesseldorf
Germany based joint venture, created by Air Berlin
and SCK Sky Catering Kitchen GmbH
Bordverpflegung & Co Service KG Ulm
Gate Gourmet Switzerland GmbH Switzerland
USA
May-08 Topic Caterers Australian based resources catering company ISS A/S Denmark 20
Apr-08 Polrest SA (formerly Gastropol
Group Sp. z.o.o.)
Poland based catering company and restaurant
operator.
ISS A/S Denmark 10
Apr-08 Aeromeal (majority stake) Russia based provider of airline catering services LSG Lufthansa Service Europa
Afrika GmbH
Germany
Mar-08 Cremonini s.p.a. Italian company operating in the food sector. The
business interests include distribution, production
and catering.
Luigi Cremonini Italy 2 482 138 0,4x 11,1x 7,0x
Mar-08 Catering Partnership Holdings
Limited
UK based food services operator Mitie Facilities Services Limited UK 18 9 0,5x
Mar-08 Accor (GR Brasil Servicos de
Alimentacao) (50.00% stake)
Brasil based provider of catering services Compass Group Plc UK 383 119 0,6x
Feb-08 The Oggenfuss Catering by
Wilfinger services GmbH
(Majority Stake)
Switzerland based restaurant operator and catering
service provider
Kofler & Kompanie AG Germany
Jan-08 Redcoral Catering Limited
(Insomnia) (51.00% stake)
Ireland based coffee shops chain and catering
company
Penninn H F Iceland 16
Jan-08 Patman Services Indian provider of facilities management,
housekeeping, business dining, catering and other
services
Aramark Corporation USA
Dec-07 Aviapartner Group (catering
activities)
Belgium based catering business of Aviapartner
Group
Gate Gourmet, Inc. Switzerland
Dec-07 Air Czech Catering Czech Republic based catering arm of Czech
Airlines
Alpha Overseas Holdings Limited Italy 26
Dec-07 Lsg Sky Chefs Espana SA Spain based provider of catering facilities. Newrest Inflight Espana SA Spain
Dec-07 Holroyd Howe Limited UK based catering company BaxterStorey Limited UK 48
Dec-07 Grupo Rocha Spanish services restaurant and catering service
provider.
ISS A/S Denmark
Nov-07 Bongrain Gastronomie French providers of catering services and
organisation of banquets and receptions
21 Centrale Partners France 94
Nov-07 Emin Catering (51.00% stake) Turkey based food and catering company. Klueh Service Management Germany 9
Enterprise Value /
Section V: Contract Catering Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 12
Contract Catering Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Source: MergerMarket
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (m€) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Oct-07 Airo Catering Services Sweden
AB (46.00% stake)
Sweden based inflight catering company LSG Lufthansa Service Holding AG Germany 16
Sep-07 Alpha Flight Services Pty Ltd
(49.00% stake)
Australia based provider of of in-flight catering
services
Emirates Airline United Arab
Emirates
Aug-07 Gemeaz Cusin Ristorazione Srl;
Scapa Italia Srl
Italy based catering and food distribution company
(formerly owned by Accor)
Barclays Private Equity Limited UK 312 135 0,4x
Jul-07 Nordic Airlink holding AB Sweden based company engaged in airline
business formerly owned by Finnair Oyj
Norwegian Air Shuttle ASA Norway 94 6 0,1x
Jun-07 Groupe Vivae France based contract catering company (formerly
owned by French PE Quartus)
Groupe Elior France 92
Jun-07 Brahim's-LSG Sky Chefs
Holdings Sdn Bhd (51.00% stake)
Malaysia based investment holding company
involved in the provision of in-flight catering.
Tamadam Bonded Warehouse Bhd Malaysia
Jun-07 Searcy Tansley & Co Ltd UK based catering group. Alternative Hotel Group UK 57 43 0,8x 5,1x
Jun-07 Mars Restaurants Private Limited;
SkyGourmet Catering Pvt Ltd
Indian airline catering company.; Indian hotel and
restaurant company.
India Hospitality Corp Cayman Islands 83
Jun-07 Alpha Airports Group Plc (57.30%
stake)
UK based company providing catering and retailing
services for airlines and airports
Autogrill SpA Italy 848 227 0,4x 12,3x 7,1x
May-07 Selecta Management AG Swiss food and beverage vending services operator
formerly owned by Compass Group
Allianz Capital Partners GmbH Germany 705 1129 1,6x
May-07 Chester Boyd Ltd Uk based catering services provider. Charlton House Catering Services
Ltd.
UK 15
May-07 Caterhouse Ltd UK based company providing catering services to
schools.
ISS Mediclean Ltd UK
Apr-07 Impact Exhibition Management
(42.22% stake)
Thailand based company provides exhibition,
convention space and related services as well as
food, beverage and catering services in connection
with the exhibition and convention facilities.
Juutland Ltd Cayman Islands 159
Mar-07 Saudia Catering (49.00% stake) Saudi Arabia based catering service Al Hokair And Sons Group Ltd
Newrest Inflight
Saudi Arabia
France
168
Feb-07 Waterfall Services Ltd UK based contract caterers. YFM Group Limited UK 18 6 0,4x
Jan-07 ARAMARK Corp Facilities services and catering buyer group USA $8032 0,7x 13,1x 8,5x
Jan-07 Carestel (95.95% stake) Belgium based catering and hospitality group with a
focus on food services (formerly owned by PE
Gimv)
Autogrill SpA Italy 79 45 0,6x 31,3x 8,9x
Jan-07 USAS Ucak Servisi AS (Catering Service Operations)
Turkey based catering service operations. THY Do & Co Catering Service AS
Turkey 36
Average 0,8x 15,9x 6,9x
Median 0,5x 12,0x 7,1x
Enterprise Value /
Section VI: Human Resources Services Companies
Comparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s Human Resources comparable public company analysis involves 20publicly traded Human Resources Services companies (Exhibits 13 and 14).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins are 1.2% and 2.0%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA are 14.8x and 10.9x, respectively.
Exhibit 13
Human Resources Services Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Adecco Sa 14 797 379 64 7 328 7 440 2,6% 5,2% 5,7% 4,6% 7,5% 0,4% 3,8% 5,0% 4,0% 3,6%
Ambition Group Ltd. 54 0 -4 17 15 0,7% 0,9% 8,1% 9,8% 7,7% -8,3% -18,7% 7,3% 9,1% 6,8%
CPL Resources 190 5 4 80 38 2,6% 0,5% 8,0% 9,6% 7,2% 2,1% 0,1% 7,7% 9,5% 7,0%
D.L.S.I. 117 2 1 18 26 1,7% 4,0% 4,6% 3,1% 2,6% 1,2% 3,8% 4,3% 3,3% 2,5%
Demos 96 7 4 61 71 7,2% 12,0% 11,1% 10,4% 7,2% 3,7% 8,8% 9,4% 8,8% 4,1%
Groupe CRIT SA 1 128 20 14 205 186 1,8% 3,5% 4,9% 3,8% 4,1% 1,2% 3,1% 4,4% 3,4% 3,6%
Harvey Nash Group 434 4 2 43 38 0,8% 2,7% 2,9% 3,0% 2,9% 0,4% 2,5% 2,7% 2,7% 2,5%
Hays PLC 3 322 69 48 1 753 1 840 2,1% 6,9% 11,3% 10,6% 10,9% 1,5% 6,5% 10,6% 10,2% 10,6%
Hydrogen Group Plc 82 0 -6 36 33 0,5% 3,6% 8,9% 8,8% 9,8% -7,2% 2,2% 7,1% 7,0% 7,7%
InterQuest Group PLC 108 3 2 19 22 3,2% 5,2% 5,3% 5,4% 6,5% 2,0% 4,1% 4,2% 4,2% 5,3%
Matchtech Group Plc 315 14 14 58 60 4,6% 5,6% 5,5% 5,6% 5,1% 4,3% 5,3% 5,3% 5,3% 4,8%
Michael Page Intl 796 36 23 1 659 1 505 4,5% 15,1% 18,9% 16,0% 13,8% 2,8% 14,0% 17,9% 15,0% 12,7%
OPD Group Plc 55 -1 -2 -2,5% 7,1% 10,8% 11,8% 7,5% -3,7% 0,7% 8,5% 10,8% 6,5%
Parity 132 2 1 4 15 1,4% 2,4% 2,6% 0,8% -0,5% 1,0% 2,1% 2,3% 0,5% -4,7%
Poolia AB 127 4 3 53 46 3,3% 7,8% 5,8% 6,5% 2,0% 2,2% 7,3% 5,2% 6,1% -3,2%
Prime People 16 1 1 8 5 4,6% 4,6% 11,0% 10,9% 1,7% 3,2% 3,5% 10,4% 10,3% -1,9%
Robert Walters 334 6 2 265 246 1,8% 6,4% 8,8% 7,7% 6,2% 0,5% 5,5% 8,2% 7,1% 5,5%
SThree Plc 572 16 7 420 374 2,7% 9,2% 10,5% 5,4% 5,0% 1,3% 8,3% 9,8% 4,9% 4,4%
Synergie SA 948 19 16 280 246 2,0% 3,8% 4,0% 3,7% 4,2% 1,7% 3,6% 5,4% 3,4% 3,8%
Work Group Plc 25 -1 -1 4 1 -2,6% 2,6% 9,1% 8,3% 5,0% -3,6% 1,7% 7,5% 5,9% 3,6%
Mean 2,1% 5,5% 7,9% 7,3% 5,8% 0,3% 3,4% 7,2% 6,6% 4,3%Median 2,0% 4,9% 8,0% 7,1% 5,7% 1,2% 3,7% 7,2% 6,0% 4,3%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Section VI: Human Resources Services Companies
Comparable Public Company Valuations
Exhibit 14
Human Resources Services Public Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Adecco Sa 0,5x 0,2x 0,4x 0,5x 0,4x 17,9x 4,6x 6,4x 10,9x 5,6x 106,1x 6,4x 7,2x 12,4x 11,7x 834,6x 8,5x 9,2x 15,7x 16,0x
Ambition Group Ltd. 0,2x nm 0,5x 0,5x 0,4x 28,0x nm 6,7x 4,8x 4,6x nm 0,0x 7,5x 5,2x 5,2x nm nm 11,4x 9,2x 10,2x
CPL Resources 0,2x 0,0x 0,1x 1,2x 0,8x 6,5x 7,7x 1,7x 12,6x 11,7x 8,3x 53,0x 1,8x 12,9x 12,0x 16,8x 78,0x 4,0x 16,0x 15,6x
D.L.S.I. 0,2x 0,2x 0,3x 0,3x 12,1x 3,8x 6,8x 10,6x 17,4x 4,1x 7,3x 10,1x 24,8x 4,0x 8,7x 13,1x
Demos 0,7x 0,7x 1,5x 9,8x 5,8x 13,6x 19,1x 7,8x 16,1x 99,8x 15,4x 35,1x
Groupe CRIT SA 0,2x 0,1x 0,3x 0,4x 0,4x 9,2x 2,7x 5,6x 9,5x 9,0x 13,4x 3,1x 6,2x 10,8x 10,2x 27,3x 4,1x 8,6x 14,3x 13,5x
Harvey Nash Group 0,1x 0,0x 0,1x 0,2x 0,2x 6,3x 1,6x 3,1x 7,0x 6,0x 12,1x 1,8x 3,3x 7,9x 6,9x 30,7x 3,4x 6,1x 12,4x 8,2x
Hays PLC 0,5x 0,5x 0,5x 1,2x 1,2x 24,2x 7,0x 4,6x 11,4x 11,0x 34,4x 7,5x 4,9x 11,8x 11,3x 136,5x 11,2x 6,6x 14,9x 11,4x
Hydrogen Group Plc 0,2x 0,1x 0,6x 43,7x 3,9x 6,3x nm 6,3x 7,8x nm 12,9x 12,7x
InterQuest Group PLC 0,2x 0,2x 0,4x 5,6x 3,1x 7,7x 9,0x 4,0x 9,6x 10,9x 4,2x 10,8x
Matchtech Group Plc 0,1x 0,2x 0,6x 2,5x 4,4x 10,0x 2,6x 4,6x 10,4x 3,7x 6,7x 14,4x
Michael Page Intl 1,5x 0,6x 1,1x 2,3x 1,7x 34,0x 4,1x 5,9x 14,5x 12,2x 53,5x 4,4x 6,3x 15,5x 13,3x 98,6x 7,1x 9,3x 23,0x 18,0x
OPD Group Plc 0,4x 0,0x 0,3x nm 0,6x 2,5x nm 6,1x 3,2x nm nm 6,9x
Parity 0,1x 0,1x 0,2x 0,2x 0,3x 8,3x 2,1x 6,6x 26,6x nm 11,7x 2,4x 7,5x 47,1x nm nm nm 51,6x 34,9x nm
Poolia AB 0,3x 0,1x 0,3x 0,7x 0,5x 9,7x 1,4x 5,1x 11,0x 25,8x 14,7x 1,5x 5,6x 11,7x nm 26,1x 3,3x 7,7x 17,6x nm
Prime People 0,2x nm 0,3x 0,8x 2,0x 3,5x nm 3,0x 7,1x 117,9x 4,9x nm 3,2x 7,5x nm 13,7x 3,2x 4,8x 10,9x nm
Robert Walters 0,5x 0,2x 0,3x 1,0x 0,5x 27,5x 2,6x 3,6x 12,8x 8,0x 92,6x 3,0x 3,9x 13,9x 8,9x 680,5x 6,4x 6,7x 19,7x 15,4x
SThree Plc 0,5x 0,2x 0,5x 1,3x 0,9x 18,5x 2,3x 4,8x 24,6x 18,1x 39,7x 2,6x 5,1x 27,4x 20,2x 63,4x 4,3x 8,0x 44,1x 40,0x
Synergie SA 0,3x 0,1x 0,3x 0,3x 0,4x 12,8x 2,9x 8,5x 9,1x 8,7x 15,0x 3,1x 6,3x 9,9x 9,7x 31,8x 6,1x 10,1x 15,5x 16,0x
Work Group Plc 0,0x 0,0x 0,4x 0,6x nm 1,4x 4,9x 6,9x nm 2,1x 5,9x 9,7x nm 6,9x 9,1x 13,2x
Mean 0,3x 0,2x 0,5x 0,8x 0,7x 15,6x 3,4x 5,9x 12,0x 19,9x 28,4x 6,5x 6,5x 14,3x 10,9x 140,0x 10,9x 12,1x 18,3x 16,4xMedian 0,2x 0,1x 0,3x 0,6x 0,5x 10,9x 3,0x 5,8x 10,9x 10,0x 14,8x 4,0x 6,2x 11,7x 10,8x 30,7x 6,4x 8,9x 15,5x 15,5x
nm = "not meaningful"
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Section VI: Human Resources Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable Human Resources Services M&A transactions are 11.3x and 8.6x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 9.6xEBITDA)
Exhibit 15
Human Resources Services Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $) Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Sep-10 INPUT, Inc. US based provider of market intelligence, analysis, consulting, and
events and training services
Deltek, Inc. USA 19 44 2,3x
Sep-10 Wridgways Australia Limited Australia based company providing removal, packaging, storage, and
relocation solutions
Santa Fe Holdings Ltd Hong Kong 78 59 0,7x 9,9x 8,6x
Sep-10 Learn.com, Inc. US based provider of SaaS learning management solutions Taleo Corporation USA 99
Sep-10 Insurance Overload Services, Inc. US based company that offers temporary and permanent
employment staffing services
Corporate Resource Services Inc USA 5
Aug-10 FujiStaff Holdings Inc (79.5% Stake) Japan based provider of personnel placement and planned
recruitment services
Randstad Holding NV Netherlands 473 162 0,4x 13,3x 11,1x
Aug-10 Rigzone.com, Inc. U.S. based online company specializing in career services for
professionals in the oil and gas industry, as well as in content, data,
and advertising related to the oil and gas industry
Dice Holdings, Inc. USA 7 43 6,5x 9,8x
Aug-10 Online Career Center Mexico Inc (40%
Stake)
Mexico based operator of online employment services SEEK Limited Australia 31
Jul-10 Medfinders Inc US based provider of nurse staffing services to hospitals and other
healthcare facilities
AMN Healthcare Services Inc USA 169
Jul-10 Integrity Interactive Corporation US based compliance and business ethics consultant and training
services provider
SAI Global Limited Australia 132
Jul-10 Sharpstream Life Sciences Limited UK based provider of search services for executive to middle
managers in the life sciences industry
On Assignment, Inc. USA 3 4 1,1x
Jul-10 Vaughan Systems (55% Stake) Spain based on-site and multimedia English language training
company
AC Capital Premier II Spain 20 14 1,3x
Jul-10 Optimark SA (56.46% Stake) Optimark is one of the leading French operators in the field of
commercial presentations, external sales forces, and training.
OC Financial Inc USA 20 9 0,8x 11,7x
Jul-10 Medical Staffing Network Inc US based healthcare staffing company and provider of per diem
nurse staffing services
MSN AcquisitionCo, LLC USA 237 67 0,3x 6,0x
Jun-10 Intelligence Ltd Japan based recruitment and consulting company Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co USA 452 288 0,6x 27,9x
Jun-10 Independent Clinical Services Limited UK based provider of temporary nursing staff on a short term, last
minute and emergency basis
Blackstone Group Holdings LLC USA 132
Jun-10 Wynnwith Group Ltd UK based technical engineering personnel and project design
solutions provider
Morson Wynnwith Limited United
Kingdom
79 9 0,1x
Jun-10 Ross Education LLC (58% Stake) US based provider of vocational school job training and related
services
JLL Partners USA 195
May-10 Melorio Plc UK based company providing vocational training, apprenticeships
and TtG Plus programs to the information and communications
technology industries
Pearson Plc UK 66 121 1,8x 7,9x 6,5x
May-10 WorldwideWorker.com Netherlands based company that provides energy jobs for engineers
and professionals in the energy sector
Dice Holdings Inc USA 7
Apr-10 The Cambridge Group Ltd US based provider of recruiting, consulting and staffing services for
physician, pharmaceutical and IT jobs
On Assignment Inc USA 8 4 0,5x
Apr-10 COMSYS IT Partners Inc US based company specialized IT staffing and project
implementation services, including Website development and
integration, application programming and development, client/server
development, systems software architecture and design, systems
engineering and systems integration
Manpower Inc USA 450 296 0,7x 29,8x 16,2x
Mar-10 Trustaff Inc US based national health care staffing company Medical Connections Holdings
Inc
USA 20
Enterprise Value /
Section VI: Human Resources Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 15
Human Resources Services Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Feb-10 Brainhunter Inc (formerly TrekLogic
Technologies Inc)
Canada based recruiting and staffing firm. It manages post-hire
activities, including contract management, billing, internal and
external payment processing, payroll administration and financial
reporting
Zylog Systems Limited India 35 34 1,0x
Feb-10 OneClickHR Plc UK based company engaged in the design, production, marketing,
and sale of human resources software. The company also provides
consulting services, online HR services, and HR outsourcing and
training services
ADP Network Services Ltd UK 6 16 2,6x 52,0x 21,2x
Feb-10 Hotjobs.com Inc US based online recruitment solutions and software company of
Yahoo! Inc
Monster Worldwide Inc USA 162
Feb-10 Tatum LLC US based recruiting and staffing company SFN Group (formerly Spherion
Corporation)
USA 84 33 0,4x
Jan-10 MPS Group Incorporated US provider of staffing and consulting services, as well as solutions
in the areas of information technology, finance, accounting, law,
engineering and healthcare.
Adecco SA Switzerland 1 591 772 0,5x 9,3x 7,9x
Jan-10 HighCare Detachering BV (Significant
Stake)
Netherland based staffing agency of medical professionals High Care Holding BV Netherlands 5
Jan-10 Towers Perrin Forster & Crosby Inc US based provider of human resource and administration consulting
services, reinsurance intermediary, and actuarial and management
consulting
Watson Wyatt Worldwide, Inc USA 1245
Jan-10 Fagro Consultancy BV MBO of Netherlands based interim and financial consultancy firm of
Altran Technologies SA
Fagro Consultancy BV (MBO
Vehicle)
Netherlands 19 12 0,6x 3,0x 3,0x
Dec-09 International Resources Group Limited
(50.50% stake)
UK based executive search and selection services firm formerly
onwed by OPD Group Plc
Odgers (MBO Vehicle) UK 79 13 0,2x 2,6x 2,3x
Dec-09 Koosharem Corporation US based company that provides temporary staffing services Atlas Acquisition Holdings Corp USA 988 577 0,6x 11,8x
Dec-09 CAE (A320 Training Center) (51.00%
stake)
Russia based airline pilots training center OAO Aeroflot Russia 12
Dec-09 HSBC Actuaries and Consultants Limited UK based provider of actuarial, pension scheme administration,
employee benefit and investment consultancy services
Jardine Lloyd Thompson Group
Plc
UK 40 5 0,1x 3,0x 2,8x
Nov-09 New Dynamic Institute (undisclosed stake) China based company providing educational training Matrix Partners China; WI Harper
Group Inc
China USA 7
Oct-09 Spring Group Plc UK based company engaged in the provision of recruitment, staffing
and related services formerly onwed by ET Training LLC
Adecco SA Switzerland 540 62 0,1x 9,2x 6,5x
Sep-09 StepStone ASA (67.03% stake) Norway based online recruitment company Axel Springer AG Germany 124 82 1,1x 12,5x 8,3x
Aug-09 Alljobs Ltd (75.00% stake) Israel based online jobseeker company formerly onwed by
Headhunter.ru
Yediot Ahronot Israel 6
Aug-09 Air Energi Group Limited UK based recruitment agency for the oil and gas sector Zeus Private Equity LLP UK 35
Jul-09 BPP Holdings Plc UK based provider of professional education Apollo Global Inc USA 173 387 2,2x 17,2x 13,4x
Jul-09 Phoenix Associates Co Ltd Japan based company providing business communication skills
training and human resources development programs to
multinational corporations
Berlitz International Inc USA 8 7 1,0x
Enterprise Value /
Section VI: Human Resources Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 15
Human Resources Services Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Country Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Jul-09 FIITJEE Limited (Undisclosed Stake) India based provider of training for IIT-JEE, AIEEE and other
engineering entrance exams
Matrix Partners India India 22 15
Jun-09 Educomp Solutions Limited (vocational
training business) (50.00% stake)
India based vocational training business Pearson Plc UK 13
Jun-09 Gissings Consultancy Services Limited UK based pension consultants, providing actuarial, advisory,
investment and administration services for UK pension plans
Capita Hartshead UK 11
Apr-09 Wall Street English China based provider of English language training to university
students and professionals in China, through 39 company-owned
training centers in seven cities including Beijing, Shanghai,
Guangzhou and Shenzhen
Pearson Plc UK 110
Mar-09 Westaff Inc (49.50% stake) US based recruitment company formerly owned by Delstaff LLC Koosharem Corporation USA 255 8 0,1x
Feb-09 CHKS Limited UK based provider of healthcare intelligence and quality
improvement services formerly onwed by Healthcare Knowledge
Systems International Ltd
The Capita Group Plc UK 9 13 1,5x
Feb-09 Arena Personal AB Sweden based staffing and recruitment company SMTW Personal Holding AB Norway 19 16 0,8x 10,9x 10,6x
Feb-09 Integrata AG (91.04% stake) Germany based provider of training solutions in the fields of
information technology, personnel and organization development,
and systems, applications and products (SAP) trends and processes
formerly owned by Logica Plc
Cornerstone Equity Investors USA 36 15 0,4x 18,1x 9,6x
Average 1,0x 14,9x 9,1x
Median 0,7x 11,3x 8,6x
Enterprise Value /
Section VII: Waste Management Services CompaniesComparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s Waste Management comparable public company analysis involves 23 publicly traded Waste Management & Recycling companies (Exhibits 16 and & 17).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins for the Waste Management industry are 11.1% and 23.0%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the Waste Management industry are 14.6x and 8.2x, respectively.
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins for the Recycling industry are 2.3% and 4.3%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the Recycling industry are 17.2x and 11.3x, respectively.
Exhibit 16
Waste Management & Recycling Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Waste Management
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Augean plc 35 6 -59 29 36 18,2% 26,4% 31,6% 32,5% 33,2% -169,1% 12,9% -86,8% -24,3% -24,5%
Casella Waste Systems 395 91 34 93 500 23,0% 19,9% 20,4% 20,5% 21,8% 8,6% -3,2% 6,8% 2,5% 9,5%
Clean Harbors Inc 749 103 54 1 307 1 354 13,7% 14,8% 13,0% 13,2% 11,3% 7,2% 9,9% 9,0% 7,9% 7,3%
Covanta Holding Corp. 1 082 278 120 1 749 3 085 25,7% 30,6% 34,7% 38,8% 35,9% 11,1% 18,6% 18,7% 23,4% 22,5%
Fomento Const y Contr(Fcc 12 700 1 461 738 2 305 10 870 11,5% 12,3% 14,6% 14,3% 13,8% 5,8% 6,8% 9,3% 9,2% 9,2%
GPE Groupe Pizzorno Environnement168 27 13 68 123 16,3% 15,0% 16,8% 19,0% 20,2% 7,8% 3,9% 7,0% 9,5% 9,3%
IESI-BFC Ltd. 704 199 89 1 849 2 479 28,3% 27,5% 30,0% 30,6% 30,4% 12,7% 11,5% 11,6% 11,4% 8,5%
Perma Fix Environmental Services 70 10 7 69 77 14,1% 8,9% 10,6% 12,6% 10,7% 9,4% 2,9% 3,1% 7,0% 5,8%
Republic Services Inc 5 720 1 623 1 018 8 419 13 370 28,4% 19,8% 26,9% 26,7% 26,5% 17,8% 7,7% 17,3% 17,1% 16,7%
Seche Environnement 366 95 63 477 724 26,1% 26,7% 27,1% 26,0% 25,2% 17,3% 16,8% 14,2% 16,2% 14,3%
Shanks Group 766 101 40 510 892 13,2% 16,3% 16,8% 15,4% 15,8% 5,2% 9,2% 9,8% 9,2% 8,2%
Stericycle 822 248 218 4 409 5 113 30,2% 28,2% 27,4% 29,0% 31,3% 26,5% 25,0% 24,3% 25,3% 20,5%
Suez Environnement SA 12 296 1 706 783 6 932 13 685 13,9% 14,4% 15,2% 15,8% 15,1% 6,4% 8,0% 8,4% 8,8% 6,9%
US Ecology Inc. 92 22 16 213 189 24,3% 25,9% 24,8% 28,4% 31,9% 17,6% 19,8% 18,7% 21,4% 31,1%
Veolia Environnement SA 34 551 3 409 1 837 10 294 28 059 9,9% 9,4% 11,6% 11,6% 11,9% 5,3% 5,3% 7,3% 7,3% 7,3%
Waste Connections Inc 831 252 156 2 241 2 868 30,3% 29,6% 30,6% 30,0% 32,3% 18,7% 20,2% 21,6% 20,3% 23,3%
Waste Management Inc 8 226 2 130 1 317 12 572 18 326 25,9% 25,9% 26,1% 24,9% 23,4% 16,0% 16,7% 16,7% 14,9% 12,8%
Waste Services Inc 303 69 37 22,7% 18,4% 21,0% 15,4% 14,1% 12,4% 8,8% 9,1% 4,6% 2,8%
WCA Waste Corp. 135 35 15 70 225 26,0% 25,7% 27,4% 28,6% 28,2% 11,3% -11,0% 12,2% 14,0% 14,1%
Mean 21,1% 20,8% 22,5% 22,8% 22,8% 2,5% 10,0% 7,3% 10,8% 10,8%Median 23,0% 19,9% 24,8% 24,9% 23,4% 11,1% 9,2% 9,8% 9,5% 9,3%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Recycling
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Commercial Metals 4 748 184 76 1 172 1 754 3,9% 5,1% 8,2% 8,9% 8,4% 1,6% 3,8% 6,9% 7,7% 7,2%
Metalico, Inc. 204 19 14 157 237 9,5% 4,0% 10,3% 11,6% 10,5% 6,8% -4,6% 8,9% 9,6% 8,0%
Sims Metal Management Ltd. 5 230 256 155 2 284 2 274 4,9% 3,0% 10,2% 8,4% 9,2% 3,0% -1,2% 9,0% 7,3% 8,1%
Derichebourg 2 432 105 -3 606 1 544 4,3% 6,8% 5,2% 2,4% 3,1% -0,1% 4,3% 2,8% 0,6% 0,6%
Mean 5,7% 4,7% 8,5% 7,8% 7,8% 2,8% 0,6% 6,9% 6,3% 6,0%Median 4,6% 4,5% 9,2% 8,6% 8,8% 2,3% 1,3% 7,9% 7,5% 7,6%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Section VII: Waste Management Services CompaniesComparable Public Company Valuations
Exhibit 17
Waste Management Public Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Waste Management
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Augean plc 1,4x 1,6x 3,3x 3,8x 4,0x 7,7x 6,2x 10,3x 11,5x 12,1x nm 12,8x nm nm nm nm 13,5x nm nm nm
Casella Waste Systems 1,3x 1,1x 1,4x 1,3x 1,6x 5,8x 5,4x 7,0x 6,3x 7,3x 15,7x nm 21,2x 51,2x 16,8x nm nm nm nm 51,0x
Clean Harbors Inc 1,5x 1,3x 1,1x 1,2x 0,8x 11,1x 8,6x 8,7x 9,2x 7,3x 21,0x 12,9x 12,6x 15,4x 11,3x 42,6x 26,2x 23,9x 20,6x 22,0x
Covanta Holding Corp. 3,0x 3,1x 4,4x 11,7x 10,1x 12,6x 27,2x 16,6x 23,4x 27,6x 24,3x 32,6x
Fomento Const y Contr(Fcc 0,9x 0,8x 1,2x 1,8x 1,0x 8,2x 6,5x 8,3x 12,3x 7,4x 16,3x 11,8x 13,0x 19,0x 11,1x 11,3x 8,8x 9,1x 18,8x 14,8x
GPE Groupe Pizzorno
Environnement0,7x 0,7x 0,9x 1,5x 1,5x 4,5x 4,5x 5,1x 8,1x 7,5x 9,3x 17,5x 12,3x 16,2x 16,3x 15,6x 35,1x 21,5x 29,8x 34,4x
IESI-BFC Ltd. 2,2x 1,7x 2,8x 2,9x 3,3x 7,7x 6,2x 9,4x 9,6x 10,8x 17,2x 14,7x 24,2x 25,7x 38,8x 24,7x 12,9x 48,5x 44,0x 139,7x
Perma Fix Environmental
Services1,4x 1,1x 2,8x 1,4x 1,0x 9,8x 12,6x 26,3x 11,4x 9,0x 14,7x 39,4x 88,4x 20,8x 16,6x 13,2x 36,1x nm 25,6x 20,9x
Republic Services Inc 2,2x 4,6x 2,3x 2,2x 2,3x 7,6x 23,4x 8,6x 8,3x 8,6x 12,1x 59,9x 13,4x 13,0x 13,7x 21,8x 127,1x 20,0x 18,9x 20,5x
Seche Environnement 2,1x 1,7x 3,8x 3,2x 2,5x 8,0x 6,4x 13,9x 12,2x 10,0x 12,0x 10,1x 26,5x 19,6x 17,6x 20,7x 12,0x 48,5x 31,8x 22,2x
Shanks Group 1,1x 0,8x 1,7x 1,8x 1,4x 8,2x 4,9x 9,9x 11,4x 8,7x 20,6x 8,7x 17,1x 19,0x 16,7x 10,7x 20,7x 21,8x 20,3x 13,7x
Stericycle 4,8x 4,8x 6,2x 4,8x 4,8x 15,9x 17,1x 22,7x 16,5x 15,5x 18,1x 19,3x 25,6x 19,0x 23,6x 26,6x 29,9x 43,9x 31,7x 38,7x
Suez Environnement SA 1,2x 1,0x 8,6x 6,9x 18,7x 12,5x 19,6x 11,0x
US Ecology Inc. 2,1x 2,0x 2,5x 2,8x 3,0x 8,6x 7,7x 10,1x 9,9x 9,3x 11,8x 10,0x 13,3x 13,0x 9,6x 22,1x 17,1x 22,1x 21,2x 16,6x
Veolia Environnement SA 0,8x 0,8x 1,4x 1,4x 1,2x 8,6x 8,7x 12,3x 12,1x 10,2x 15,9x 15,5x 19,4x 19,3x 16,7x 19,5x 25,9x 31,8x 31,8x 25,0x
Waste Connections Inc 2,9x 2,9x 3,0x 3,1x 3,1x 9,7x 10,0x 9,7x 10,3x 9,5x 15,7x 14,6x 13,7x 15,2x 13,1x 23,9x 23,9x 20,9x 24,6x 18,9x
Waste Management Inc 2,1x 1,8x 1,9x 2,1x 1,9x 8,0x 7,0x 7,1x 8,3x 8,2x 13,0x 10,9x 11,1x 13,8x 15,0x 16,5x 15,0x 14,0x 17,1x 14,2x
Waste Services Inc 1,9x 1,4x 1,6x 2,1x 1,5x 8,3x 7,5x 7,8x 13,6x 11,0x 15,3x 15,7x 17,9x 45,5x 54,6x 30,0x 30,3x nm nm nm
WCA Waste Corp. 1,6x 1,2x 1,7x 1,7x 2,7x 6,1x 4,5x 6,3x 6,1x 9,5x 14,0x nm 14,1x 12,4x 19,0x nm nm nm 99,8x 37,7x
Mean 1,9x 1,8x 2,4x 2,3x 2,2x 8,6x 8,6x 10,9x 10,4x 9,5x 16,0x 17,8x 21,6x 21,1x 19,4x 21,6x 27,6x 27,6x 31,2x 32,7x
Median 1,6x 1,4x 2,1x 2,1x 1,9x 8,2x 7,0x 9,5x 10,3x 9,3x 15,7x 14,6x 17,1x 19,0x 16,7x 21,2x 23,9x 22,1x 25,1x 22,0x
PEEV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Recycling
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Commercial Metals 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 0,3x 10,3x 7,7x 5,4x 4,3x 3,7x 25,0x 10,4x 6,4x 4,9x 4,4x 91,6x 12,8x 9,6x 7,1x 6,1x
Metalico, Inc. 1,2x 0,2x 1,3x 0,6x 0,6x 12,2x 5,5x 12,8x 4,8x 5,3x 17,2x nm 14,8x 5,8x 6,9x nm nm 23,3x 5,7x 4,3x
Sims Metal Management Ltd. 0,5x 0,6x 1,0x 0,7x 0,7x 9,5x 19,1x 10,1x 7,8x 8,1x 15,7x nm 11,4x 8,9x 9,2x 27,5x nm 17,4x 13,1x 12,7x
Derichebourg 0,7x 0,3x 0,5x 0,5x 0,6x 15,1x 4,4x 8,9x 22,6x 19,8x nm 6,9x 16,8x 94,9x 98,2x nm 6,8x 13,5x nm nm
Mean 0,7x 0,4x 0,8x 0,5x 0,6x 11,8x 9,2x 9,3x 9,9x 9,2x 19,3x 8,6x 12,4x 28,6x 29,7x 59,6x 9,8x 15,9x 8,7x 7,7xMedian 0,6x 0,3x 0,7x 0,6x 0,6x 11,3x 6,6x 9,5x 6,3x 6,7x 17,2x 8,6x 13,1x 7,3x 8,1x 59,6x 9,8x 15,4x 7,1x 6,1x
nm = "not meaningful"
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Section VII: Waste Management Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable Waste Management M&A transactions are 13.3x and 7.9x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 8.1xEBITDA)
Exhibit 18
Waste Management Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Bidder
Country
Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Sep-10 Donarbon Limited UK based waste management company AmeyCespa Limited UK 22 58 2,6x 22,2x 16,3x
Sep-10 Healthcare Waste Solutions Inc US based provider of waste management services to the
healthcare industry
Stericycle Inc USA 180
Sep-10 Cooper Island Investments, L.L.C.
(51% Stake)
Turkey based company having interest in steel dust recycling
plant in Iskenderun
Befesa Medio Ambiente, SA Spain 7
Sep-10 Resta AB Sweden based compnay engaged in collection, transportation,
sorting, and treatment of waste for municipalities and industrial
customers
RenoNorden AS Norway 10
Sep-10 Stablex Canada Inc. Canada based industrial waste treatment and disposal
company
US Ecology Inc USA 29 61 2,1x
Aug-10 Cork County Council (Waste
collection business)
Ireland based Waste collection business of Cork County
Council
Country Clean Recycling Ltd Ireland 10
Jul-10 Controlled Recovery Inc; U.S. Liquids
of Louisiana LP; Calpet / R&G Group
of Companies
US based companies engaged in the treatment, recovery and
disposal of oil and gas wastes, liquid waste management
services
R360 Environmental Solutions USA 193
Jul-10 Alchema Limited; Future Industrial
Services Ltd
UK based company engaged in supply and recycling of
chemical etchant solutions ; UK based provider of waste
management and specialised industrial waste management
services
One51 plc Ireland 18
Jul-10 Global Renewables Australia Pty Ltd
(51% Stake)
Australia based company providing waste management
solutions
SSP Resources Gloucester Holdings
B.V.
USA 32
Jul-10 Hoefler Consulting Group US based company that provides pollution prevention services SLR Holdings Limited UK 8 6 0,8x
Jun-10 Reconomy Recycling Solutions
Limited
UK based materials recycling company Viridor Waste Management Ltd UK 29
Jun-10 Greenstar Environmental Limited UK based waste management company Biffa Limited UK 163 164 1,0x 17,8x
Jun-10 Simpro Limited UK based waste management company TEG Group Plc UK 4 6 1,6x 9,5x 5,8x
May-10 SWEEEP Limited (50.00% stake) UK based company specialising in recycling electronics Kuusakoski Oy Finland 6 8 2,6x 13,1x 10,6x
May-10 Geo Vision Solucoes Ambientais e
Energia SA (50.00% stake)
Brazil based waste management firm operating in Sao Paulo
state
SUMA Group Portugal 45 22 1,0x
Apr-10 Veolia Environnement SA (5.00%
stake)
France based environmental services company, which is
involved in water holding, waste management, energy and
transport operations
Qatari Diar Real Estate Investment
Company
Qatar 34 551 647 0,8x 14,1x 7,5x
Apr-10 Umwelt-und Entsorgungstechnik AG
(certain operations)
Austria based recycling operations of Umwelt-und
Entsorgungstechnik AG
Asamer Holding AG Austria 15
Mar-10 Ecocentro Soluzioni Ambientali Srl;
Esposito Servizi Ecologici Srl
Italian waste management companies Actelios SpA Italy 13
Mar-10 Waterchem Limited UK based company providing water hygiene and water
treatment services to facilities management companies,
hospitals, universities and local authorities
Green Compliance UK 9 11 1,2x
Mar-10 Eco Services Korea Co Ltd South Korea based waste management company Corporation KG Ltd South Korea 30
Mar-10 Euro Environmental Group Limited UK based provider of drain and sewer cleaning, inspection and
repair services
Sovereign Capital Partners LLP UK 22
Mar-10 Hudson Valley Waste Holding Inc
(Majority Stake)
US based company engaged in collection, processing, and
recycling of nonhazardous solid waste materials
Clairvest Equity Partners III Limited ;
Clairvest Group Inc
Canada 26
Feb-10 Western Rubber Group Canada based company recycling scrap rubber tires in raw
materials
Laurel Mountain Partners LLC USA 14
Enterprise Value /
Section VII: Waste Management Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 18
Waste Management Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Bidder
Country
Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Jan-10 AbitibiBowater Inc (Recycling
Division's material recycling facilities)
US based three material recycling facilities at Arlington,
Houston, and San Antonio
Waste Management Recycle
America
USA 8
Dec-09 Valdi France based company specialised
in the processing and recycling of non-ferrous metals
Eramet S.A. France 25 20 0,8x
Dec-09 Champion City Recovery Transfer
Station LLC; Sunny Farms Landfill
LLC
US based companies engaged in waste disposal and recycling
of non hazardous, solid wastes
WCA Waste Corporation USA 23
Dec-09 The International Metals Reclamation
Company Inc
US based recycler of metal bearing wastes Horsehead Holding Corp USA 41 23 0,6x 2,7x
Dec-09 General Environmental Management,
Inc. (DE)
US based full-service hazardous waste management and
environmental services firm.
PSC Environmental Services LLC USA 11
Dec-09 GreenSafe Demanufacturing Inc
(60.00% stake)
Canada based company engaged in dismantles old appliances,
such as fridges and stoves, and recycle the materials, including
plastic, aluminum, copper and steel
Bergamo Acquisition Corp USA 33
Nov-09 Waste Services Inc Canada based integrated solid waste services company
providing collection, transfer, landfill disposal and recycling
services for commercial, industrial and residential customers
IESI-BFC Ltd. (formerly BFI Canada
Ltd.)
Canada 339 487 1,4x 16,3x 7,8x
Oct-09 Veolia Environmental Services Ltd
(commercial waste and recycling
operations)
Ireland based commercial waste and recycling business of
Veolia Environmental Services Ltd
Greenstar Environmental Ltd UK 50
Oct-09 Kommunekemi a/s Denmark based waste treatment company EQT Infrastructure Fund Sweden 43 35 0,8x 7,9x 4,3x
Oct-09 Republic Services, Inc. (operations
and related assets located in Miami-
Dade)
US based solid waste collection, recycling and disposal
services business
Waste Services Inc Canada 22
Oct-09 DisposAll Waste Services, LLC
(Miami-Dade operations)
US based recycling and disposal services business Waste Services Inc Canada 11
Sep-09 Manutencoop Servizi Ambientali SpA Italy based company offering environmental services like waste
management and waste disposal
Aimeri Ambiente Srl Italy 108 48 0,4x 13,3x 4,2x
Sep-09 WastePro USA Inc (Undisclosed
Stake)
US based company providing solid waste collection, disposal
and recycling services
Roark Capital Group USA 69
Sep-09 Santa Clara Waste Water US based privately owned wastewater treatment business General Environmental Management
Inc
USA 5 6 1,2x
Sep-09 UKAEA Limited UK based company providing nuclear clean-up, waste
management and environmental restoration services. It offers
programme management, decommissioning, waste
Babcock International Group Plc UK 35 42 1,2x
Sep-09 EcoSecurities Group Plc Ireland based provider of emission reduction and consulting
services, incorporated in Ireland
JPMorgan Chase & Co USA 69 91 1,3x
Aug-09 City Waste Inc US based company engaged in providing waste management
services that includes waste transfer, landfills, disposal and
recycling services
Waste Management Inc USA 12
Aug-09 Miljotransport AS Norway based waste management company Franzefoss Bruk AS Norway 12
Aug-09 Transpacific Industries Group Ltd
(20.35% stake)
Australian company providing integrated industrial cleaning and
total waste management, with particular focus on the liquid,
solid and hazardous waste management markets
Warburg Pincus LLC USA 1 259 181 1,6x 14,3x 9,1x
Aug-09 Shanghai Environment Group Co Ltd
(40.00% stake)
Chinese waste management company Wheelabrator China Holdings Ltd Hong Kong 99
Jul-09 Intercontinental Recycling Limited UK based plastics recycling company Viridor Waste Management Ltd UK 9
Jul-09 Chonbuk Envitech (39.00% stake) South korea based wastewater treatment company Environmental Facilities
Management Corporation
South Korea 11 6 3,7x 31,6x 17,7x
Jul-09 Pyros Environmental Limited UK based hazardous waste processing company Tradebe Group Spain 19 12 0,6x
Jul-09 Serhat Atik AS (70.00% stake) Turkey based waste management company engaged in
hazardous waste disposal activities
Cimentas Izmir Cimento Fabrikasi
Turk AS
Turkey 11
Jul-09 Sanipac Inc US based solid waste services company providing waste
collection, transfer, disposal, inter modal logistics and recycling
services
Waste Connections Inc USA 31
Enterprise Value /
Section VII: Waste Management Services Companies
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 18
Waste Management Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Source: MergerMarket
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Bidder Company Bidder
Country
Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Mar-09 Auburndale Recycling Center Inc US based recycler of tires Ridge Recyclers Inc USA 4
Feb-09 CMA Corporation Limited (32.14%
stake)
Australia based scrap metal group with operations in the
sourcing, supply, processing and exporting of scrap metal
Scholz Invest GmbH Germany 303 25 0,5x 12,0x 7,9x
Feb-09 Promotora Ambiental del Sureste SA
DE CV (75.00% stake)
Mexico based company that provides waste management and
recycling services
Double V Holding SA de CV Mexico 8
Feb-09 Lawrence Recycling and Waste
Management (50.00% stake)
UK based provider of waste disposal and recycling services Maven Capital Partners UK LLP;
Orbis Partners LLP
UK;UK 11
Feb-09 Republic Services Inc (Certain
Assets)
US based six municipal solid waste landfills, six collection
operations and three transfer stations across seven markets of
Republic Services Inc
Waste Connections Inc USA 85 195 2,3x
Feb-09 Advanced Manufacturing Control
Systems Limited (34.39% stake)
Ireland based company which provides tech solutions to the
waste and recycling industry
Ulster Bank Diageo Venture Fund;
WHEB Venture
Ireland
(Republic);U
K
5
Feb-09 CMA Corporation Limited (32.14%
stake)
Australia based scrap metal group with operations in the
sourcing, supply, processing and exporting of scrap metal
Scholz Invest GmbH Germany 303 25 0,5x 12,0x 7,9x
Jan-09 Ecolevante SpA; Waste Recycling
SpA
Italy based companies engaged in waste management and
recycling services.
Corvette Srl Italy 82
Average 1,2x 14,3x 8,1x
Median 1,1x 13,3x 7,9x
Enterprise Value /
Section VIII: Consulting Services – Excluding IT
Comparable Public Company Valuations
The Knowledge Centre’s Consulting Services comparable public company analysis involves 28 publicly traded Consulting Services companies (Exhibits 19 and 20).
The median EBIT and EBITDA margins are 6.2% and 8.2%, respectively. The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA are 9.7x and 7.6x, respectively.
Exhibit 19
Consulting Services Comparable Company Profit Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company NameSales
(Last)
EBITDA
(Last)
EBIT
(Last)
Market
cap.
(Current)
Enterprise
Value
(Current)
2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Accenture Plc 16 194 2 371 1 848 23 063 20 228 14,6% 13,9% 13,8% 11,6% 13,5% 11,4% 11,9% 11,6% 10,1% 12,4%
Aea Technology 127 15 12 56 86 11,7% 11,8% 15,0% 34,2% 37,7% 9,4% 10,0% 12,1% 31,8% 0,4%
Akka Technologies SA 333 24 17 151 161 7,1% 9,7% 9,6% 10,8% 10,2% 5,2% 7,8% 8,0% 9,0% 8,6%
Alten SA 857 74 58 762 767 8,6% 13,0% 12,8% 14,9% 16,4% 6,7% 11,7% 11,0% 14,2% 15,3%
Altran Technologies SA 1 404 -17 -72 442 628 -1,2% 8,8% 7,6% 7,6% 7,6% -5,1% 4,9% 4,6% 3,1% 2,0%
Amec 2 822 226 205 3 910 3 076 8,0% 7,7% 5,9% 1,3% 3,1% 7,3% 10,8% 5,7% -3,1% 1,0%
Assystem 613 21 8 261 263 3,4% 8,6% 8,1% 6,5% 8,9% 1,3% 7,0% 5,6% 5,2% 8,3%
Atkins Ws 1 555 175 126 887 570 11,2% 10,1% 9,2% 4,9% 10,3% 8,1% 7,0% 6,7% -3,3% 7,5%
Bureau Veritas 2 648 478 406 5 650 6 331 18,1% 16,9% 14,9% 15,7% 15,3% 14,5% 12,8% 13,9%
Cap Gemini SA 8 371 508 333 5 846 4 578 6,1% 9,4% 7,9% 6,6% 3,6% 4,0% 6,7% 5,7% 4,3% 0,7%
Diamond Management & Technology Consultants Inc.156 13 12 245 202 8,3% -6,7% 8,5% 6,2% 8,2% 7,5% -7,9% 7,7% 5,2% 6,3%
Ginger SA 269 22 16 8,2% 7,2% 7,1% 6,4% 4,6% 6,0% 5,3% 5,1% 4,3% 2,3%
Hyder Consulting 346 27 17 156 152 7,9% 4,0% 7,5% 9,8% 7,3% 4,9% 1,5% 5,3% 7,1% 5,4%
Jelf Group PLC 77 4 -11 58 64 4,7% 14,9% 17,9% 13,6% 12,3% -13,8% 8,0% 8,1% 8,3% 8,4%
Management Consulting Group 307 17 11 121 215 5,7% 4,9% 11,8% 11,4% 11,2% 3,7% -4,3% 10,1% 9,5% 10,4%
Mattioli Woods plc 16 6 5 47 41 34,7% 32,6% 34,0% 35,3% 30,9% 30,9% 28,7% 30,5% 32,8% 28,7%
Ricardo Group 201 27 16 173 182 13,3% 13,3% 12,5% 12,8% 14,3% 7,7% 8,4% 8,0% 7,7% 9,1%
RPS Group 493 69 57 525 562 14,0% 14,4% 15,6% 14,0% 14,1% 11,6% 12,5% 13,2% 12,6% 12,3%
RSM Tenon Group PLC 235 18 9 216 240 7,5% 14,1% 12,1% 10,5% 9,9% 3,8% 9,1% 8,7% 6,2% 5,0%
RWS Holdings Ltd 60 15 14 137 110 24,9% 23,8% 23,0% 21,7% 20,5% 23,3% 22,5% 20,9% 19,4% 17,9%
Sapient 465 43 28 1 239 1 087 9,3% 12,5% 3,0% 2,5% 11,1% 6,1% 9,6% 3,4% -0,3% 6,5%
Scott Wilson Group Plc 375 35 25 9,3% 12,0% 13,5% 12,4% 17,3% 6,6% 7,6% 10,4% 10,3% 15,7%
Sigma Ab 110 6 5 50 52 5,2% 5,8% 6,3% 8,8% 9,0% 4,1% 4,9% 1,8% 7,9% 8,0%
Sms Management 174 27 26 325 303 15,4% 14,5% 14,8% 14,9% 12,9% 15,2% 14,3% 14,6% 14,6% 12,6%
Solving Efeso International S.A. 50 3 2 20 38 6,0% 9,8% 1,5% 6,0% 9,4% 4,3% 9,1% -1,8% 5,1% 7,0%
Vantis 100 -1 -3 -1,5% 13,6% 14,1% 13,2% -3,0% 12,4% 11,2% 9,2%
White Young Green 308 -42 -145 9 106 -13,7% 11,1% 11,0% 10,6% -47,2% 7,6% 7,7% 7,9%
WSP Group 804 69 51 272 345 8,6% 11,5% 10,1% 9,5% 8,9% 6,3% 9,7% 8,1% 7,6% 6,9%
Mean 9,1% 11,5% 11,7% 11,9% 12,5% 5,1% 9,0% 9,2% 9,3% 8,7%Median 8,2% 11,7% 11,4% 10,7% 10,3% 6,2% 8,8% 8,0% 7,9% 8,0%
EBITDA / Sales EBIT / Sales
Section VIII: Consulting Services – Excluding IT
Comparable Public Company Valuations
Exhibit 20
Consulting Services Public Company Valuation Trends(€ in millions)
Source: Infinancials (25/10/2010)
Company Name 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005
Accenture Plc 0,8x 1,1x 1,3x 1,2x 1,2x 5,8x 8,0x 9,6x 10,4x 8,6x 7,4x 9,4x 11,4x 11,9x 9,4x 14,8x 18,5x 25,1x 25,2x 23,1x
Aea Technology 0,7x 0,6x 1,3x 1,9x 1,1x 5,7x 5,1x 8,8x 5,7x 2,9x 7,1x 6,0x 10,8x 6,1x 265,7x 14,9x 4,2x 10,2x 5,1x nm
Akka Technologies SA 0,4x 0,3x 0,7x 0,8x 0,9x 5,5x 2,9x 7,4x 7,3x 9,3x 7,5x 3,6x 8,9x 8,7x 11,1x 9,8x 5,9x 13,3x 16,1x 20,3x
Alten SA 0,7x 0,6x 1,2x 1,5x 1,7x 8,3x 4,6x 9,2x 10,0x 10,3x 10,6x 5,1x 10,6x 10,5x 11,0x 33,1x 8,8x 19,2x 19,1x 20,4x
Altran Technologies SA 0,5x 0,1x 0,5x 0,8x 1,0x nm 1,6x 7,1x 10,6x 13,4x nm 2,8x 11,7x 26,1x 50,7x nm 34,0x 22,7x 214,1x 4 696,6x
Amec 0,7x 0,3x 0,9x 0,3x 0,3x 9,3x 4,5x 15,0x 25,2x 9,1x 10,3x 3,2x 15,7x nm 29,8x 15,3x 8,3x 8,2x 6,4x 285,8x
Assystem 0,3x 0,2x 0,4x 0,6x 0,8x 7,5x 2,3x 4,5x 9,4x 9,0x 19,8x 2,8x 6,6x 11,8x 9,6x nm 4,3x 11,8x 56,4x 14,6x
Atkins Ws 0,2x 0,2x 0,7x 0,6x 0,7x 2,2x 2,0x 7,8x 13,3x 6,4x 3,0x 2,8x 10,6x nm 8,8x 6,1x 6,1x 11,0x nm 15,0x
Bureau Veritas 1,8x 1,6x 2,4x 9,7x 9,2x 16,3x 11,5x 10,8x 18,9x 15,7x 14,2x 27,4x
Cap Gemini SA 0,4x 0,4x 0,6x 0,7x 0,5x 7,1x 3,9x 7,8x 10,3x 14,2x 10,8x 5,4x 10,8x 15,6x 74,1x 27,3x 8,9x 14,2x 23,4x 31,6x
Diamond Management & Technology Consultants Inc.0,7x 0,1x 0,6x 1,5x 8,9x nm 7,0x 24,4x 9,8x nm 7,6x 29,0x 17,3x nm 8,3x 11,8x
Ginger SA 0,2x 0,2x 0,4x 0,4x 0,4x 2,8x 3,4x 6,0x 6,3x 7,9x 3,8x 4,6x 8,4x 9,3x 15,4x 5,3x 5,6x 13,3x 13,3x 48,8x
Hyder Consulting 0,3x 0,1x 0,7x 0,8x 0,5x 3,9x 2,7x 9,5x 8,0x 6,4x 6,2x 7,3x 13,5x 11,0x 8,7x 8,8x 8,2x 13,8x 14,9x 12,4x
Jelf Group PLC 0,5x 1,3x 1,8x 10,9x 8,7x 10,0x nm 16,1x 22,2x nm 33,0x 58,3x
Management Consulting Group 0,5x 0,4x 0,8x 1,0x 0,6x 9,1x 8,0x 6,8x 8,4x 5,3x 13,9x nm 7,9x 10,1x 5,8x 9,5x nm 8,5x 12,9x 10,1x
Mattioli Woods plc 2,3x 2,6x 4,2x 4,8x 4,6x 6,7x 8,0x 12,5x 13,7x 15,0x 7,5x 9,1x 13,9x 14,7x 16,2x 12,5x 14,6x 19,9x 22,0x 23,4x
Ricardo Group 0,9x 0,6x 0,8x 1,1x 0,8x 6,8x 4,7x 6,6x 8,3x 5,8x 11,6x 7,3x 10,3x 13,9x 9,1x 18,3x 11,9x 13,3x 11,7x 11,4x
RPS Group 1,1x 0,7x 1,9x 2,0x 1,6x 8,0x 4,8x 12,5x 14,0x 11,1x 9,7x 5,6x 14,7x 15,6x 12,7x 13,9x 7,9x 21,8x 23,0x 17,7x
RSM Tenon Group PLC 0,6x 0,7x 0,8x 0,4x 4,5x 5,7x 7,9x 3,9x 6,9x 7,9x 13,4x 7,7x 9,1x 11,6x 23,1x 25,3x
RWS Holdings Ltd 1,9x 2,2x 2,3x 2,3x 2,1x 7,7x 9,4x 10,2x 10,6x 10,3x 8,2x 9,9x 11,2x 11,9x 11,8x 9,0x 14,9x 16,5x 18,7x 19,2x
Sapient 1,3x 0,6x 1,8x 1,3x 1,7x 14,3x 4,5x 59,7x 52,7x 15,4x 21,8x 5,9x 52,6x nm 26,2x 12,5x 9,0x 76,3x 227,0x 27,4x
Scott Wilson Group Plc 0,2x 0,2x 0,5x 1,0x 0,6x 2,6x 1,6x 4,1x 8,4x 3,7x 3,7x 2,5x 5,3x 10,2x 4,0x 5,9x 6,1x 12,2x 24,7x 11,6x
Sigma Ab 0,4x 0,3x 0,5x 1,0x 1,0x 7,9x 4,4x 7,5x 11,1x 11,7x 9,9x 5,2x 26,5x 12,3x 13,1x 13,1x 7,1x nm 19,7x 19,1x
Sms Management 1,5x 1,0x 0,9x 2,0x 1,4x 9,6x 6,9x 6,4x 13,6x 10,7x 9,7x 7,0x 6,5x 13,9x 11,0x 14,3x 10,6x 9,7x 20,8x 16,8x
Solving Efeso International S.A. 0,7x 0,6x 0,8x 1,1x 1,1x 11,2x 5,8x 50,2x 18,2x 11,1x 15,7x 6,3x nm 21,6x 15,1x nm 13,8x nm nm 88,3x
Vantis 0,9x 0,9x 1,7x 2,0x nm 6,3x 11,9x 15,3x nm 7,0x 14,9x 21,8x nm 8,0x 19,0x 37,5x
White Young Green 0,4x 0,8x 1,2x 1,2x nm 7,6x 10,8x 10,8x nm 11,2x 15,4x 14,6x nm 11,8x 21,9x 20,9x
WSP Group 0,3x 0,2x 0,8x 0,9x 0,7x 3,9x 2,2x 7,8x 9,9x 8,3x 5,2x 2,5x 9,7x 12,4x 10,6x 13,5x 3,5x 13,5x 18,5x 16,3x
Mean 0,8x 0,7x 1,2x 1,3x 1,1x 7,3x 5,1x 12,1x 13,2x 9,1x 9,8x 6,4x 13,5x 14,2x 27,7x 13,8x 11,1x 19,3x 36,9x 248,0xMedian 0,7x 0,6x 0,8x 1,1x 0,9x 7,6x 4,6x 8,3x 10,5x 9,1x 9,7x 6,0x 10,8x 12,4x 11,1x 13,5x 8,9x 13,7x 20,2x 19,8x
nm = "not meaningful"
PEREV/EBITEV/EBITDAEV/Net Sales
Section VIII: Consulting Services – Excluding IT
Comparable M&A Transactions
The median EV/EBIT and EV/EBITDA for the comparable Consulting Services M&A transactions are 9.8x and 7.6x, respectively. (NB 5 past years average multiple of 10.4xEBITDA)
Exhibit 21
Consulting Services Comparable M&A Transactions(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Country Bidder Company Country Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Sep-10 Scott Wilson Group Plc UK based company engaged in providing
consultancy services in the field of engineering,
management, planning and environment
UK URS Corporation USA 393 273 0,7x 11,0x 7,6x
Sep-10 Axco Insurance Information
Services Limited
UK based insurance information and consultancy
service provider
UK Wilmington Group Plc UK 6 24 3,8x 17,2x
Sep-10 TheMarkets.com LLC US based company that provides web based
research and estimate services
USA Capital IQ USA 230
Sep-10 Technical Systems
Integrators LLC ; Keenan
and Keenan Group
US based consultation and installation company;
US based education consulting company
USA Core Projects & Technologies
Limited
India 19 15 0,8x
Sep-10 Chapman Kelly Inc US based company which provides health care
cost-containment services
USA HMS Holdings Corp USA 10
Sep-10 Intrepid Consultants Inc UK based social media analytics and market
research consultancy
UK Alterian Plc UK 9
Sep-10 Boyd Exploration
Consultants Ltd.
Canada based oil and gas exploration advisory
services provider
Canada RPS Group Plc UK 9 9 1,0x
Aug-10 inVentiv Health Inc US based commercialisation services provider to
the global pharmaceutical and life sciences
industries
USA Thomas H Lee Partners LP USA 746 889 1,2x 12,7x 9,5x
Aug-10 InforMed Direct Limited UK based provider of healthcare communications
and consultancy services in the pharmaceutical
and biotechnology industries
UK United Drug plc Ireland
(Republic)
8 12 1,4x 8,0x 7,4x
Aug-10 FS Asia Advisory Limited Hong Kong provider of consulting services in the
areas of corporate finance, turnaround, corporate
advisory and corporate recovery services
Hong Kong FTI Consulting, Inc. USA 28 63 2,3x
Aug-10 Akimeka, LLC. US based health service information technology
consulting company
USA VSE Corporation USA 30 26 0,9x
Aug-10 Cypoint Group AB Sweden based company offering functional
commitments, consulting services, sourcing and
systems management services
Sweden Sigma AB Sweden 10 13 1,4x 6,4x
Aug-10 Hughes Trueman Pty Ltd Australia based consultancy firm providing
planning, engineering and management services
Australia Mott MacDonald Group
Limited
UK 12
Aug-10 The Route Development
Group Limited
UK based air service development firm UK UBM Aviation UK 8 10 1,3x
Aug-10 Wellsco, Inc. US based telecom engineering service provider USA Infotech Enterprises America
Inc
USA 9 11 1,3x
Jul-10 James Lee Witt Associates
LLC
US based company engaged in providing crisis
and emergency management consulting services
USA Witt Group Holdings LLC USA 27 18 0,6x 7,0x 6,3x
Jul-10 Mediterranean Smart Cards
Company
Egypt based smart card payment processing
services to banks
Egypt Actis Emerging Markets 3
fund
UK 23
Jul-10 GlobalOptions Group Inc
(Fraud and Special
Investigations Unit)
US based Fraud and Special Investigations unit of
GlobalOptions Group Inc
USA GlobalOptions Services Inc USA 7
Jul-10 Seeds Group France based financial consultancy firm France Morningstar France Holding
SAS
France 5
Jun-10 Inspectorate International Ltd UK based commodity inspection and testing
company
UK Bureau Veritas SA France 277 543 2,0x
Jun-10 Kroll Inc US based risk consulting company engaged in
background screening, drug testing, and
surveillance services, fraud investigations,
security services and technology services
USA Altegrity Inc USA 944
Enterprise Value /
Section VIII: Consulting Services – Excluding IT
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 21
Consulting Services Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Country Bidder Company Country Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Jun-10 Vantis Plc UK based provider of accountancy advice,
support to owner-managed businesses and
private individuals
UK RSM Tenon UK 111 7 0,1x
Jun-10 Encore International Limited UK based energy risk consultancy firm UK,Hungary,
Netherlands
Lyceum Capital Partners LLP UK 8
Jun-10 Sia Conseil SAS France based management consultancy firm France Sia Holding France 34
Jun-10 Selantic AS Norway-based company offering consultation
services on marine operations and synthetic fibre
engineering
Norway Actuant Corporation USA 8 14 1,7x
Jun-10 YMedia (30% Stake) Spain based advertising consultancy firm Spain Ymedia (MBO Vehicle) Spain 6 12 6,6x
Jun-10 Nightingale Associates
Limited
UK based architects practice specialising in health
and education
UK IBI Holdco Limited UK 20 12 0,6x 8,4x
Jun-10 Clear View Retirement
Solutions; MBF Life
Australia based financial services company
providing financial advice, products and services
to people nearing their retirment; Australia based
life insurance company
Australia MMC Contrarian Limited Australia 131
May-10 Daylight Forensic & Advisory
LLP
US based fraud risk management firm conducting
forensic investigations and advising on regulatory
compliance to corporations
USA Navigant Consulting Inc USA 32
May-10 Norca Ingenieria de Calidad
SL
Spain based company specialized in providing
infrastructure risk assessment services for the
energy industry in Spain.
Spain Intertek Group Plc UK 4
May-10 LPA Group Inc US based transportation consulting firm USA Michael Baker Corporation USA 65 45 0,7x
Apr-10 Ryla Inc US based provider of value-added customer
contact services
USA Alorica Inc USA 76 53 0,7x
Apr-10 Old Broad Street Research
Limited
UK based provider of fund research, ratings and
investment consulting services
UK Morningstar UK Ltd UK 14
Mar-10 CSM Worldwide Inc US based company providing automotive market
forecasting services and strategic advisory
solutions to the automotive manufacturers,
suppliers and financial organizations
USA IHS Inc USA 20
Feb-10 Heggies Pty Limited Australia based acoustics and vibration
consultancy firm
Australia SLR Management Limited UK 11 12 1,1x
Feb-10 Emerging Energy Research
LLC
US based advisory and consulting firm tracking
emerging technologies in global energy markets
USA IHS Inc USA 13
Jan-10 Currie & Brown (Australia)
Pty Ltd
Australia based cost and management
consultancy firm
Australia Amec Plc UK 23
Jan-10 Xafinity Group Limited UK based company that provides specialist
outsourcing and consultancy services regarding
pensions, employee benefits, and payments
expertise
UK Advent International
Corporation
USA 144 317 2,2x 46,2x 13,7x
Jan-10 COM S.A (75.00% stake) Peru based provider of consultancy, outsourcing,
and project management services to Information
Technology industry
Peru Indra Sistemas SA Spain 7
Jan-10 McKinnon & Clarke Limited UK based company providing consultancy in the
energy, utility and telecoms markets
UK Lyceum Capital Partners LLP UK 25 25 1,0x
Jan-10 Towers Perrin Forster &
Crosby Inc
US based provider of human resource and
administration consulting services, reinsurance
intermediary, and actuarial and management
USA Watson Wyatt Worldwide, Inc USA 1245
Dec-09 HSBC Actuaries and
Consultants Limited
UK based provider of actuarial, pension scheme
administration, employee benefit and investment
consultancy services
UK Jardine Lloyd Thompson
Group Plc
UK 40 5 0,1x 3,0x 2,8x
Enterprise Value /
Section VIII: Consulting Services – Excluding IT
Comparable M&A Transactions
Exhibit 21
Consulting Services Comparable M&A Transactions (Con’t)(€ in millions except where mentioned in $)
Deal value
Date Target Company Target Description Country Bidder Company Country Revenue (€m) Sales EBIT EBITDA
Nov-09 Hill & Associates Consultants
Limited
Hong Kong based corporate risk management
services provider
Hong Kong G4S Plc UK 14 5 0,4x
Nov-09 First Advantage Corporation
(26.00% stake)
US based provider of risk mitigation and business
process solutions
USA The First American
Corporation
USA 521 136 1,4x 11,1x 7,7x
Nov-09 Archstone Consulting LLC US based strategy, operations and CFO advisory
consultancy
USA The Hackett Group Inc USA 12
Nov-09 DiscoverReady, LLC
(85.00% stake)
US based provider of outsourced discovery
management and fixed-fee document review
services
USA Dolan Media Company USA 21
Nov-09 Fitch Group (20.00% stake) US based global rating agency comprised of Fitch
Ratings, Fitch Solutions and Algorithmics
USA The Hearst Corporation USA 629 300 2,4x 8,6x
Nov-09 Rapid Reporting Verification
Company LP
US based national provider of IRS tax transcript
information and social security number
authentication services
USA Equifax Inc USA 49
Oct-09 Fountains Plc UK based environmental consultant UK Connaught Plc UK 53 15 0,3x 260,6x 8,9x
Oct-09 Enviros Group Ltd UK group of consulting companies operating in
the environmental, products, software and
technology sectors
UK Sinclair Knight Merz Australia 29
Oct-09 Baker Energy, Inc. US based provider of operations engineering
consulting services for the oil and gas industry
USA John Wood Group Plc UK 174 26 0,1x
Sep-09 IntegriGuard LLC US based company engaged in the prevention
and detection of fraud, waste, and abuse in the
healthcare system
USA HMS Holdings Corp USA 4
Sep-09 Tristone Capital Inc Canada based corporate advisory firm providing
investmnet banking, acquisition and divestitures
and global equity capital market services firm in
Canada Macquarie Group Limited Australia 74
Jul-09 InforSense Limited UK based analytics company providing business
intelligence and reporting software
UK ID Business Solutiions Ltd UK 6
Jul-09 Page Kirkland Group Australia based provider of property consultancy
services
Australia Altus Group Income Fund Canada 19
Jul-09 Conics Limited Australia based planning, surveying and
environmental consultancy company
Australia RPS Group Plc UK 37
Jul-09 Property & Portfolio
Research Inc
US based company providing real estate research
and portfolio strategy services to the institutional
real estate community
USA CoStar Group Inc USA 13 15 1,2x
Jul-09 Malcolm Pirnie Inc US based provider of engineering, science, and
consulting services with exclusive focus in
environmental issues
USA Arcadis NV Netherlands 281 159 0,6x
Jul-09 Sira Certification Service;
Sira Consulting Limited; Sira
Environmental Limited; Sira
UK based certification body which provides quality
and environmental management system, product
and personnel certification ; UK based certification
UK CSA International Canada 4 10 2,3x 11,1x
Jun-09 FASE Estudos e Projectos
SA
Portugal based company providing consultancy,
design, project management, engineering and
architecture services
Portugal GED Iberian Private Equity Spain 18 17 1,0x 6,9x
Average 1,3x 33,4x 8,2x
Median 1,0x 9,8x 7,6x
Enterprise Value /
Groupe Dynavision Inc
Appendix. Global M&A Deal Highlight
On 14 April 2010, Global M&A Canada announced that GroupeDynavision inc, a leading Canadian technology consulting firm, completed the sale of 51% interest in the share capital to French group Grande Armée Conseil.
The DynaVision Group is a consulting firm specialized in claiming Scientific Research and Experimental Development (SR&ED) income tax credits. The combined knowledge of the team of experienced research and technical consultants covers a broad spectrum of technologies. Its service a territory extending fromBritish Columbia to Nova Scotia, in both official languages.
Grande Armée Conseil is a leading advisory firm specializing in social and fiscal costs optimization and R&D tax credits with over 200 consultants in France, Spain, Portugal and Canada.
Global M&A Canada advised the sellers on the sale.
On 17 March, 2010 – Global M&A announced that BOURBON has acquired the 50% of the shares it did not already own in its Brazilian subsidiary Delba Marítima Navegação.
This acquisition was made at the request of BOURBON’s historic partner in the joint-venture, who wished to withdraw from Delba MaritimaNavegação. BOURBON is taking this opportunity to consolidate its medium and long-term position in Brazil.In a spirit of continuity, the operational management and organization of the subsidiary remain unchanged.
About Bourbon
BOURBON offers a broad range of offshore oil and gas marine services. Under its Horizon 2012 strategic plan BOURBON intends to become the leader in modern offshore oil and gas marine services by offering the most demanding clients worldwide, a full line of innovative, high performance and new-generation vessels and a modular offer of Inspection, Maintenance and Repair services, with the launch of its new "Subsea Services" Activity. BOURBON also specializes in bulk transport and protects the French coastline for the French Navy. Classified by ICB (Industry Classification Benchmark) in the "Oil Services" sector, BOURBON is listed for trading on Euronext Paris, Compartment A, and is included in the Deferred Settlement Service SRD and in the SBF 120 and Dow Jones Stoxx 600 indices. www.bourbon-online.com
Global M&A Brazil advised Bourbon on the transaction.
Delba Maritima Navegaçao S.A
CARGOLUX
Global M&A Deal Highlight
21 April 2010
Cargolux Release Annual Report As Air Freight Shipping Struggles
After what they are calling the most difficult year in the history of air freight, Cargolux, based in the Grand Duchy and the biggest all cargo fleet air carriers on the continent, have issued a concise report as to their recent performance. With shipping in the sector declining by around 20% last year causing a glut of over capacity the company saw a reduction in fleet utilization and load factors, but, most importantly, a reduction in yields. In 2009, Cargoluxtonnage declined by close to 11%, but yields were down by over 26%. The daily average aircraft utilization dropped 6.7% to 14.34 hours. Total block hours for 2009 decreased by 9.3% to 83,102 and tonnage fell by 10.8% to less than 630,000 tonnes. Freight tonne kilometres where down by 11.3% to 4,800 million while available tonne kilometres reached 6,954 million, a reduction of 9.3%. Load factors declined by 1.6 points to 69%. (All figures include data for Cargolux Airlines International S.A. and Cargolux Italia SpA who lease one aircraft from their parent) the resultant reduction in tonnes sold and the decline in yields resulted in a drop in revenue of 34% to US$ 1.3 billion meaning Cargolux recorded an overall loss of US$153 million. The group retained its existing fleet of 16 B747-400Fs but lower utilisationequated to the equivalent of having two aircraft on the ground during the months of June and July. In September and October, two aircraft were delivered to UPS in a deal that had been concluded before the crisis hit and was intended to facilitate the planned delivery of new B747-8 freighters in 2009. However, by the time those two aircraft left the fleet, the company actually found a need for more capacity, as the markets began to rebound and they found it necessary to lease in up to three extra craft for the last three months of the year. Production delays for the B747-8F have pushed the first delivery to Cargolux from 2009 to late 2010 which they view with mixed emotions. On one hand, the delay helped to preserve much needed cash although the company could have well used the added efficiency, lower fuel consumption, higher range and payload to reduce its operating costs. As a result of the losses incurred and to ensure the survival of the company, a re-capitalization of Cargolux became necessary.
In November 2009, the company implemented a restructuring of its capital structure in a two step transaction. First, shareholder SAirlines (part of the defunct Swissair Group) sold its 33.7% stake to Luxair, BCEE, SNCI (all current shareholders of Cargolux) and, as a new shareholder, the Luxembourg State. Cargolux’ shareholders approved the creation of an authorized capital of US$200 million, giving power to the board to issue new shares. A capital injection of US$100 million took place before year-end.
ZETRA International, Global M&A Switzerland, assisted SAirLines as exclusive M&A advisor in this transaction.
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services TeamBusiness Services Team Leader
Business Services Team Members
Verónica Klammer joined the Buenos Aires based company in March 2006. Previously, Ms. Klammer was a banker at Citigroup/Citibank N.A., where she worked for five years, participating in transactions in the areas of debt restructurings, M&A advisory, private and multilateral debt structuring, syndicated loans and acquisition finance such as the purchase of Hylsamex by Grupo Techint. Prior to joining Citibank, Ms. Klammer worked at Accenture for two years as a financial analyst in the Business Consulting Unit
Education:Certified Public Accountant, Universidad Católica Argentina; Bachelor Degree in Business Administration, Universidad Católica Argentina (Valedictorian 1998); Postgraduate Degree in Marketing, Universidad de San Andrés (2004).
Email: [email protected]
ARGENTINAVerónica Klammer EN
Vice President
Quintin Althann is an Associate at the Wien based company. He has significant experience in balance sheet and market analysis as well as in research and consulting activities. He has also assisted numerous acquisitions and other transactions.
Quintin is an active member of the Global M&A Business Services and CEE Teams. Prior to joiningthe company, Quintin worked for Civitas International Management Consultants and the Swiss Private Bank Ehinger & Armand von Ernst.
Education:Bachelor of Business Administration, Webster University, Vienna
Email: [email protected]
AUSTRIAQuintin Althann
Associate
Bill Beerworth is an Investment Banker with a background in Corporate Law. He held a number of senior positions before establishing the Sydney based company 20 years ago, including Executive Director of HSBC Bank Australia and Managing Director of HSBC Bank Australia Corporate Finance and Senior Partner of Mallesons Stephen Jaques, one of Australia’s leading law firms, where he specialised in corporate law, particularly in Mergers & Acquisitions and Equity Capital Markets. Bill has been Chairman or a Director of a number of successful listed companies. He is currently Chairman of Contango Capital Partners Limited, a listed funds management holding company.
Education:BA LLB (Sydney), LLM SJD (Virginia), MCOM (NSW), MBA (Macquarie)
Email: [email protected]
AUSTRALIABill Beerworth
Managing Director
FRANCEVéronique Zeid-Maurel
Senior Partner
Véronique Zeid-Maurel is Global M&A Business Services team leader with18 years experience as M&A deal maker specializing incross border transactions. Selection of cross border deals closed: Acquisition by MBO team of POLYMARK (France/UK, sale & installation of laundry equipment); sale of French subsidiary HONEYWELL Sécurité & Télésurveillance to CERBERUS SIEMENS; sale of TEAMWORKS (IT Services, Austria) to ALTRAN; sale of KNIGHTS SERVICES (cleaning services, Ireland) to PENAUILLE POLYSERVICES; sale of ORION ENGINEERING (high added value engineering advisory services, Netherlands) to ALTEN.
Education:Sorbonne Paris IV, Foreign Languages Applied to Economics
Email: [email protected]
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Benoit Roose has over 20 years of experience advising on international acquisitions and divestitures. Previous experience in Belgium, Germany, France and North Africa in reorganizing commercial and industrial groups, and in launching new ventures.He is a founder of the Brussels based company
Education:Master of Economics, University of Bonn and Cologne, Germany; Post-Graduate in Business Administration, Solvay Brussels School of Economics and Management, Belgium
Email: [email protected] Roose
Managing Partner
Antonio Baptista founded the Porto Alegre based company in 1994.
Prior to that, he was Vice President of one of the leading Brazilian leather and shoe groups for 18 years. He was also a corporate finance and strategic planning consultant for seven years. Antonio has experience in acquisitions, IPO and corporate finance.
Education:Business Administration, Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul
Email: [email protected] Baptista
Principal
Roman Osipov has six years experience in investment consulting. Roman joined the Minsk based company in 2002 as an analyst. He became head of the Financial Advisory department by the end of 2005. He worked closely on the financial advisory of leading private Belarusian companies, advised EBRD and HeidelbergCement AG. In 2006-2007 Roman was a member of the team responsible for M&A advisory of Delta-Bank (Ukraine), GetIn Holding (Poland), and individual investors in their acquisitions of stakes in Belarusian banks and insurance companies.
Education:Master’s degree in International Business, Belarusian State Economic University; CFA candidate
Email: [email protected]
BELARUSRoman Osipov
Director of Investment and Financial Advisory
Márcio Fiuza is one of the founding partners of the São Paulo based firm. From 1997 through 2001, Mr. Fiuza worked for Bear, Stearns & Co. Inc., one of the leading Wall Street investment banks in NewYork where he was a Vice President at the Global Communications group.
Business Services segment experience include the purchase by Bourbon of the 50% it did not already own in Delba MarítimaNavegação,maritime services to the offshore oil sector in Brazil, valuation of Brazilian contact center company ASK!, buy-side target identification in the collection agencies segment as well as sell-side experience in payroll processing BPO segment.
Education:M.Sc. Engineering; MBA Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania
Email: [email protected]
BRAZIL Márcio Fiuza
Partner
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Carlos Taborga Ibargüen has 20 years of experience in top executive positions and 10 years experience in restructuring and turnarounds. He joined the Santiago based firm in January 2007.Previously, he was CEO of Matreq (Caterpillar Dealership) in Bolivia, General Manager of Ferrocarriles Andinos in Bolivia, General Manager of Morgan Impresores in Chile, and former Undersecretary of Finance in Bolivia. He is a Board member of Empresa Electrica Valle Hermoso.
Education:BS and MBA, Babson College, USA
Email: [email protected]
CHILECarlos TaborgaIbargüen
Luis David joined Guatemala based company in 1998. He has several years of experience in the banking and financial sectors in the Central American region. He is currently on the Board of Directors of GE-BAC (Banco de America Central) and Credomatic. He has been responsible for closing several deals in the CentralAmerican Region, Mexico, USA and Europe including leverage buyouts, management buyouts, mergers, acquisitions, debt restructuring, strategic alliances and private equity placements.
Education:Masters Degree in Banking and Finance, Giordano Dell’amoreInstitute in Milan, Italy; B.S. in Business Administration, Universidad Francisco Marroquín, Guatemala
Email: [email protected]
Mr. Lariviere’s work experience includes several years for RBC Royal Bank as corporate credit advisor, as well as institutionalasset management with UBS Global asset management and Landsbankinn Island.
Prior to joining the Montreal based company, Mr. Lariviere founded AJP financial a boutique financing advisory firm which focused on non traditional banking credit solutions for the Canadian mid-market. Mr. Lariviere has been involved in equity & debt financing as well as M&A transactions for his clients.
Education:Bachelor degree, finance major, University of Mount-Allison
Email: [email protected]
CANADAJean-Patrick Larivière
Partner
Before founding the Bogota based firm in 2001, Mr. Vargas was a managing director with ING Barings responsible for the corporateand investment bank in Colombia. Mr. Vargas joined Baring Securities in 1994 as Head of the Andean Pact Region and was subsequently appointed as President and CEO for the merged operations of Barings and ING Colombia on January 1997. Before joining ING Barings, Mr. Vargas acted as founding CEO of Proexport Colombia and previously he was Head of the External Financing and Foreign Reserves Department at the Colombian Central Bank (Banco de la República).
Education:MBA, Columbia University; Economics BA and MS candidate, Universidad de Los Andes, Bogotá, Colombia
Email: [email protected]
COLUMBIABernardo Vargas
Partner
CENTRAL AMERICALuis David
Managing Director
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Prior to joining the Denmark based company, Peter Søgaard was a Director at Booz.Allen & Hamilton Corporate Finance, Director at PricewaterhouseCoopers Financial Advisory Services, Area Manager for Industrialisation Fund for Developing Countries and Vice President of BG Bank Investment Bank.
Education:Master of International Economics and Management, Copenhagen Business School; Bachelor of Law, University of Aarhus
Email: [email protected] Søgaard
Managing Partner
Karla Polli is a founding partner of the Tallin based firm. Immediately prior to establishing the company he was member of Danske Bank’s Corporate Finance team and prior to that member of KPMG Estonia Corporate Finance team. With 11 years of experience in corporatefinance, Karla has advised several M&A and capital raising transactions including some of the biggest private deals ever closed in Estonia.
Education: B.A., Corporate Finance and Economics, Tartu University
Email: [email protected] Polli
Partner
Adam Blecha has been working in the field of M&A since 1994. Before founding his own M&A company, he worked for Corporate Value Associates, an English-French strategic consulting company as well as for Credit Lyonnais (now CALyon), in the internal M&A department in Paris.
Education:Adam Blecha graduated from HEC (Hautes Etudes Commerciales) in Paris
Email: [email protected]
CZECH REPUBLICAdam Blecha
Managing Partner
Antti Kemppainen is a Partner at the Helsinki based company. Previously, he worked at Mandatum & Co since 1998, most recently working as an Associate Director from 2000-2003. He has eleven years of experience in investment banking.
Education:M.Sc. Economics; MBA
Email: [email protected]
FINLAND Antti Kemppainen
Partner
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Faisal set up the Middle East based company in 1994 having spentseveral years with Andersen & Co. as the Middle East managing partner for corporate finance. With an extensive network of contacts in the region, Faisal has successfully closed many medium- to large-size transactions for clients in various industry segments, and has particular expertise in the arena of private placements and public offerings.
Education:M.B.A. University of Vermont; M.S., Accounting, University of New Haven; Certifications: CVA, CMEA, CM&AA, ASA, CFC, CPES
Email: [email protected] COUNTRIES & YEMENFaisal Al Sayrafi
CEO & Managing Director
Prior to joining the Budapest based firm in 2003, Oliver Martin spent seven years at ABN AMRO Corporate Finance Budapest, assuming various positions including acting head of the Budapest operation. He has been Director of Raba Automotive Group, a stock exchange listed automotive manufacturing company, since April 2003. Mr. Martin has an extensive track record of executing corporate finance advisory mandates, mainly in the field of cross-border M&A, financial restructuring and capital raising transactions.
Education:Masters Degree in Finance, Technische Universitaet Berlin, Germany
Email: [email protected]
HUNGARYOliver Martin
Director
GERMANYChristian Kollmann
Partner
Christian joined the Düsseldorf based firm in 1995. He led domestic and cross border transactions in various industries, in particular business services, automotive, mechanical engineering and food &beverages. Since 2006 he is head of Global M&A‘s sector team Industrials and an active member of Global M&A’s business services team. Selection of transactions: Acquisition of Skyworks (design and rental of professional access equipment (scaffolds, ladders), acquisition of Edutec (eLearning solutions) by Tertia Group. Sale of internet service provider Topnet to Mobilcom.
Education:University of Erlangen-Nuremberg (MBA)
Email: [email protected]
Brynhildur Bergthorsdottir is a partner at the Reykjavik based company. Brynhildur worked in the advertising industry and as a marketing manager for a number of years. After completing her MBA in 1996, she worked for Innovation Center Iceland as a consultant to SME’s and entrepreneurs. She was GM of the Icelandic Quality Association from 2000-2005. Brynhildur has served as board member of various funds, committees and organizations.
Education:BA, Fine Art and Design, Loretto Heights College, USA; MBA, Bradford Management Center, UK; Licensed Stockbroker and Real estate agent
Email: [email protected]
ICELANDBrynhildurBergthorsdottir
Partner
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Saiyam has 5 years of experience in the areas of corporate finance and consulting. At the Indian based company, he reviews sectorssuch as Business Services and Education. He has worked with Crisil Ltd. and has lead assignments in the areas of valuations, financial feasibility, entry strategies and market studies.
Education:Graduate in Commerce, Mumbai University; Masters in Management Studies NMIMS, Mumbai
Email: [email protected] Shah
Senior Associate
Patrick joined the Dublin based firm in 2008. Previously, he was a manager with KPMG’s Manufacturing, Retail and Distribution division and has significant knowledge of firms operating withindifferent sectors. Patrick is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants.
Education:Masters of Business Studies, University College Dublin
Email: [email protected]
IRELANDPatrick Sheehan
Manager
The Tel Aviv based firm is led by Yair Ephrati. Mr. Ephrati has been involved in numerous Israeli related transactions in the past years including a Leveraged Buyout of an electronic equipment (rugged computers) importer and manufacturer, acquisition of semiconductor trading company, financing of medical device companies, acquisition search for services company in Asia and strategic partnership for a software company in Bulgaria. Previously, Mr. Ephrati was with McKinsey & Co. in London and New York for three years. At McKinsey, he led teams advising Fortune 100 companies on new market development, acquisitions and strategy.
Education:B.A., Economics and Business, Tel Aviv University; M.B.A., University of Michigan
Email: [email protected]
ISRAELYair Ephrati
Managing Director
Ugo has been with the Milan based firm since 1999. He has advised transactions and executed project management in a wide range of sectors, specialising in project management within Business Services and ICT. He has assisted Italian and foreign companies on domestic and international transactions and has previous experience in a financial advisory boutique.
Education:Master SME, SDA Bocconi, Milan; Degree in Political Science, Turin University
Email: [email protected] Zampieri
Partner
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Tamotsu Majima, Director, Advisory Group at the Tokyo and Osaka based group, has been engaged in cross border transactions for more than ten years. Before joining the group in 1998, he worked as securities analyst of Japanese corporations and was also involved in international corporate finance business for ten years at Yamaichi Securities. He is a Chartered Member of the SecuritiesAnalysts Association.
Education:B.A., Tokyo University of Foreign Studies; M.B.A., INSEAD, France
Email: [email protected] Majima
DirectorAdvisory Group
Andrey Golubchikov joined the Riga based firm in 2005 in an Analyst position. Prior to that he worked as an intern in the Latvian state-owned telecommunication operator Lattelekom (2004). At Prudentia, Mr. Golubchikov specializes in M&A, buyout and business restructuring transactions, covering such industries asmanufacturing, wholesale and retail trade, business services, pharmaceuticals and logistics. He was involved in the acquisition of additional share issue of RĪGAS BANKETU SERVISS (contract catering services) by a venture capital fund ZGI FONDS.
Education:B.Sc. degree in Economics and Business Administration, StockholmSchool of Economics in Riga; CFA Level III Candidate, CFA Institute
Email: [email protected]
LATVIAAndrey Golubchikov
Associate
Prior to joining the Mexico based firm in 2002, Mr. Plettner worked for 3 years as manager of Publix, S.A., a graphic design studio, and Star Technologies, S.A., a company active in the design of information systems, businesses he founded in 1996 and 1997, respectively. Previously, Mr. Plettner worked as a trainee in brand management at Procter & Gamble Mexico. During the summer of 2001, Mr. Plettner worked as a consultant at The Boston Consulting Group, where he worked on the merger of two multi-national food companies, and evaluated additional acquisition projects.
Education:BS in Industrial and Systems Engineering, Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey (ITESM); MBA, Stanford Graduate School of Business
Email: [email protected]
MEXICOMartin PlettnerRutishauser
Partner
Douwe Tijsma has been a partner at the Rotterdam based firm since 1999. Before joining the company, he was CFO of European Packaging Holding with operations in Holland, Germany, France and Poland. He was engaged in an MBO in 1994. Within EPH, he was responsible for acquisition, divestments, turnaround and financial engineering. The company was successfully sold. Since 1999, he has been involved in a large number of buy outs, sale- and buy processes in the Netherlands and internationally as leading partner and transaction manager.
Email: [email protected] Tijsma
Partner
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Mr. Hellum has extensive experience as an advisor within bankingand corporate finance. Previous positions include Vice President in DnB, Head of Bergen Bank Securities, Vice President of Bergen Bank, Executive Vice President of Nord og Syd Kredittforsikring, founder/partner in Nordic Merger and Principal in Booz Allen Hamilton.
Education:Law degree, University of Oslo
Email: [email protected] Hellum
Partner
Mr. Salazar has professional expertise in investment banking, capital markets and finance, with 20 years of experience. Mr. Salazar has been involved in numerous deals with a total value in excess of US$ 2 billion. Mr. Salazar also participated in studies on the development of the Peruvian capital market for the Ministry of Economy and Finance and CONASEV. His previous experience includes the position of General Manager of SudamericanoBrokerage House, Member of Banco Sudamericano’s Assetsand Liabilities Committee, Investment Manager of Macrovalores andInvestment Advisor to MAPFRE Compañía de Seguros.
Education:Economist graduate,Universidad Católica del Perú; Post Graduate Studies in Finance from ESAN
Email: [email protected]
PERUManuel Salazar
Partner
At the Warsau based company, Rafal Nowakowski specializes in deal origination, transaction structuring, corporate finance andinvestment advisory services. Prior to becoming a co-founder and partner of HCA, Rafal was a managing director and partner at Innova Capital, a leading Central European private equity firm. In the Business Services sector, Rafal was involved in several transactions including investments, sell and buy sides of companies dealing with IT outsourcing, IT consulting, facility management,electro-nic data storage, cleaning, security and mass print and mail outsourcing.
Education:MSc in Economics from Poznań Academy of Economics; certificate in Corporate Finance & European Law (ERASMUS); INSEAD alumnus; Securities Representative (SFA) and certified accountant.
Email: [email protected]
POLANDRafal Nowakowski
Managing Partner
Marina Evans joined the Moscow based company in 2006 as the head of the legal department. Later on she became a partner and managed the consulting branch of the company, supporting relations with a large number of Russian and international clients from various industries. Prior to joining Meridian, Mrs. Evans gained extensive legal experience providing services to a number of international and Russian companies in the areas of M&A transaction support, corporate and securities laws.
Education:J.D., Tomsk State University; S.J.D., Moscow Foreign Relations Institute; LL.M., with honors, Northwestern University School of Law
Email: [email protected]
RUSSIAMarina Evans
Partner
APPENDIX: The Global M&A Business Services Team
Bosco Salaverri is a Founding Partner of the Madrid based firm. Previously, he was a Founding Partner of Proyectos Panikkar, S.L. and worked in the Corporate Finance Department of Benito & Monjardín.
At the firm, Bosco is responsible for business origination and is the lead advisor to several Spanish companies.
Education:Graduate in Economics and Business Administration, Universidad Comercial de Deusto (Bilbao)
Email: [email protected]
SPAINBosco Salaverri
Founding Partner
Prior to joining the Stockholm based firm, Anders Jonsson held several positions both in the IT industry and as a consultant toPrivate Equity funds. Anders was the owner and CEO of Oscar Dellert AB, a distributor of IT products, Executive Director Strategic Marketing at ISA International, and CEO of Lap Power Holding. Anders has also been a board member of Information Highway, and is the current Chairman of Academic Work (Recruitment).
Email: [email protected]
SWEDENAnders Jonsson
Partner
Gerhard Willi has 10 years of experience in M&A, succession planning, banking, corporate finance transactions as well as complex restructuring cases. In 2007 his team completed the sale of JobOne, one of the leading Swiss staffing companies, to Randstad, the sale of Jobs.ch the leading Swiss job portal, the sale of ULD management services of Swissport "Unit Pool Ltd" and the sale of Special Security Services operations to Cargologic. Prior business services experience includes the sale of Serimo (FM company) to Bilfinger Berger, the sale of a leading call center to Cyberline AG, and various due diligence support, valuation, turnaround and business plan support for companies in the business services industry.
Education:CFA, BA in International Business
Email: [email protected]
SWITZERLANDGerhard Willi
Partner
In 1995, Esin began her career in equity research and worked forvarious brokerage houses including Finans Yatırım and Caspian Securities. Since 1999, after joining Raymond James Securities as a Director, Esin has concentrated on corporate finance. At the Istanbul based firm she is responsible for business development,origination and execution of corporate finance deals.
Education:Industrial Engineering degree, Middle East Technical University,Ankara; M.B.A. IAL Consortium of International Business Studies,Italy and Clemson University, U.S.A.
Email: [email protected]
TURKEYEsin Özçelik Ünsal
Director
APPENDIX: The Business Services Team
After graduating in PPE from Oxford University, John qualified as a barrister in 1984. He joined Hill Samuel Merchant Bank and became Head of Corporate Finance and a member of the Bank Executive Committee. The team moved to Close Brothers and John became Chief Executive of the enlarged corporate finance group and founded its international business. He was also an Executive Director of Close Brothers Group. He joined the Londonbased firm in 2002 and since 2003 has led the development of Noble into a growth market investment bank.
Education:PPE from Oxford University
Email: [email protected]
UKJohn Llewellyn-Lloyd
CEO Investment Banking
Randall Miles joined the Seattle based firm as a Managing Director in 2009. Randall has over twenty-five years of extensive M&A and executive level experience working with both investment banks and financial technology companies. Prior to joining the firm, Randall was a managing partner with SCM Capital Group, a private M&A advisory and strategic consulting group focused on financial services, software and technology companies. Most recently, Randall served as CEO of Syngence Corporation and acting CEO of Officespace.com. Prior to that, Randall served as chairman and CEO of LionMTS, a publicly traded financial software and services company where he directed the strategic expansion of the company.
Education:BBA in Finance, University of Washington
Email: [email protected]
USARandall Miles
Managing Director
Effram Kaplan focuses on mergers and acquisitions, private placements and financial restructuring with primary industry experience in metals and mining as well as experience in diversified manufacturing and distribution. Before joining the Cleveland andChicago based firm, Effram was a summer associate at McDonald Investments’ Investment Banking group and, prior to, a Manager in Arthur Andersen’s management consulting practice<<;EducationB.S., Miami University; M.B.A, The University of Chicago Graduate School of Business
Email: [email protected] E. Kaplan
Director & Principal
Mr. Klymenko has over 10 years experience in investment businessand consulting. He has worked in private equity funds (Balkan Accession Fund and Euroventures Ukraine) and has been responsible for full investment cycle from origination of deals to exit. He has been involved in valuation, negotiations, structuring andexecution of investment deals, as well as management of portfolio investments in various industry sectors.He managed consulting firm providing services to leading Ukrainian companies and institutional investors.
Email: [email protected] Klymenko
Investment Banking Director