INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy...

31
INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology- Economics, for the case of Mexico Federico Puente Espel 26-29 August 2014 IAEA, Vienna, Austria

Transcript of INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy...

Page 1: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology-

Economics, for the case of Mexico

Federico Puente Espel

26-29 August 2014

IAEA, Vienna, Austria

Page 2: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Outline

• Nuclear Energy in Mexico

• Mexico current situation o Power Mix, population, energy, economic, and social indicators

o Energy Outlook 2013-2027

o National Energy Strategy 2013-2027

• Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology

2 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 3: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Nuclear Energy in

Mexico

3 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 4: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

4 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico: Nuclear Power

One NPP: Laguna Verde Two GE BWR-5 reactors 4% installed capacity

1600 MWe (after the uprate)

Page 5: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

5 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico: Nuclear Sector

Nuclear Research Institute

Regulatory Body

Operator / Utility

Page 6: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Electricity Sector

Outlook 2013-2027

6 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 7: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

7 June 2014

Ref. http://www.inegi.org.mx/,

http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/

INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico’s current situation

Page 8: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

8 Ref. Electricity Information 2013. International Energy Agency

Installed Electric Energy Capacity, OECD members 2010 (GW)

Page 9: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

9 August 2014 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico’s electricity prices

Ref. Electricity Information 2013. International Energy Agency

17th place (OECD) with the

highest electricity prices

for industry

Lowest electricity prices for

households

5.87 US$ above OECD average (108.86

US$/MWh)

Page 10: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

10 August 2014 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico’s current situation

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico 2013-2027

& CFE

Page 11: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

11 August 2014 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico’s current situation

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico 2013-2027

& CFE

Page 12: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

12 August 2014 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Mexico’s current situation

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico 2013-2027

& CFE

Page 13: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

13

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico

2013-2027

INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Statistical regionalization

Page 14: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

14 Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico

2013-2027

INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Fuel Prices

Uranium

National coal

Pacific & Golf coal

Gas

National Fuel Oil

Imported Fuel Oil

Page 15: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

National Energy Strategy

2013-2027

15 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 16: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

16

Ref. ENE 2013-2027, SENER

2013

INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 17: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

National Energy Strategy 2013-2027

• Ley para el Aprovechamiento de las Energías Renovables y el

Financiamiento de la Transición Energética (LAERFTE)

• Law on the Use of Renewable Energies and Financing of

Energy Transition (LAERFTE)

17 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 18: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Electricity Sector Outlook 2013-2027

18 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico 2013-2027

Page 19: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Electricity Sector Outlook 2013-2027

• Estimated total electric energy to be satisfied 465.1 TWh

• Self supply & Non-technical losses 62.5 TWh

• Electric Power Savings 39.2 TWh

• Estimated federal electric energy to be satisfied 363.4 TWh

19 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 20: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Estimated additional required capacity

20 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

47,503 MW

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico 2013-2027

Page 21: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Electricity Sector Outlook Planning vs. Alternative

21 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Ref: Prospectiva del Sector Eléctrico 2013-2027

Page 22: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO

Methodology for NES

22 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 23: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

• Evaluation of a national nuclear energy system

based on its long term sustainability.

• Evaluation of the financial figures of merit:

attractiveness of investing in nuclear power.

• Assessment whether nuclear power is competitive

with alternatives considering economic conditions

in the country.

23 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 24: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

• INPRO Methodology (these will be analyzed for the

case of Mexico and described)

o One basic principle (BP).

o Four user requirements (UR).

o Eight criteria (CR).

24 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 25: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

• Situation considered for Mexico (four situations

considered in the INPRO Methodology):

o Deployment of additional units of the same basic type of NPP.

• Case of Mexico: nuclear power will be compared with

fossil fuelled plants and hydro.

• It is not a deregulated market: centralized decision-

making process.

• The values of CN and CA and financial figures of merit.

o Comparison of the LUEC for CN with those for alternatives, CA

25 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 26: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

26 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Ref: COPAR 2012. Generación. Sub

Programación. CFE

Page 27: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

27 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Ref: COPAR 2012. Generación. Sub

Programación. CFE

Page 28: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

28 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Ref: COPAR 2012. Generación. Sub

Programación. CFE

Page 29: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Proposal to apply the INPRO Methodology for NES

29 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Ref: COPAR 2012. Generación. Sub

Programación. CFE

Page 30: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Next step is to apply the INPRO Methodology for

NES

30 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8

Page 31: INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 Proposal to apply the INPRO ... · INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 2 . Nuclear Energy in Mexico INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 3 . INPRO Dialogue Forum 8 4 Mexico: Nuclear Power

Thank you!

31 INPRO Dialogue Forum 8