Innovative Ideas in Currency Management October 2005.
-
Upload
morgan-crawford -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
4
Transcript of Innovative Ideas in Currency Management October 2005.
Innovative Ideas in Currency Management
October 2005
2
Evolution of Currency Management
• Currency mandates
– Hedging (late 1980s; mid 1990s); Pure alpha (late 1990s; current)
– Absolute return (early 2000s)
– Cash play – use innovative FX programs to fill cash flow gap
• Currency managers
– Single style using only forwards in EAFE markets (to late 1990s)
– Multi-style using forwards, options, developed and emerging
• Currency clients
– Passive benchmark to managing their own strategic currency risk
3
Philosophy: An Untapped Alpha Opportunity!
Corporate TreasurersCorporate Treasurers(Insure foreign profits)(Insure foreign profits)
Central BanksCentral Banks(Increase employment, (Increase employment,
lower inflation)lower inflation)
International Bond and Equity International Bond and Equity ManagersManagers
(Need to buy currency to buy (Need to buy currency to buy foreign assets)foreign assets)
Currency Currency MarketMarket
Many participants have non-profit motives Many participants have non-profit motives
IndividualsIndividuals(Tourism)(Tourism)
4
Impact of Diversification – Opportunities and MarketsDeveloped Developed
MarketsMarkets
AddAdd
Options Options (Developed)(Developed)
AddAdd
Emerging Emerging MarketsMarkets
All ThreeAll Three
Number of Number of TransactionsTransactions
Maximum 10
Additional 20Additional 20 Currencies
Average 40
Net ReturnNet Return
(for 12% (for 12% volatility)volatility)
7% 10% 17% 17%
Return/Risk Return/Risk RatioRatio
0.5 – 0.8 0.8 – 1.0 1.0 – 1.5 1.5
Cannot use overlay models/approach in this absolute return paradigm Cannot use overlay models/approach in this absolute return paradigm
5
Market Inefficiency = Simple Rules Make Money
• Three simple rules make money in currencies.
1. Currency markets trend.
Buy the currency that went up last month.
2. Currencies with high interest rates will appreciate
vs. currencies with low interest rates. Buy high interest rate currencies.
3. Options tend to be overpriced. Sell options.
6
Performance of JPY Rules/Strategies
• Rules Evaluated: (a) yield curve; (b) carry; (c) moving average
• USD/JPY Strategy = 40% Yield curve and Carry, 20% MA
• Diversification improves information ratio, skill, & drawdown
Strategy/ Rules
Annualized Return
Annualized Std Deviation
Information Ratio
Cumulative Return
Confidence in Skill
Success Ratio
Ratio Good /Bad Risk
Max Drawdown
USD/JPY Strategy 4.59% 8.56% 0.5365 57.45% 94.17% 52.86% 0.9103 -20.45% USD/JPY Yield Curve 4.54% 11.59% 0.3919 56.68% 85.59% 53.43% 0.8564 -26.21% USD/JPY Carry 4.33% 11.59% 0.3741 53.57% 84.26% 52.37% 0.8613 -26.21% USD/JPY MA 20-65 3.62% 11.59% 0.3121 43.22% 79.05% 51.12% 1.06 -20.51%
Source: AlphaEngineTM, Mcube Investment Technologies, LLC
www.mcubeit.com (purely hypothetical example for educational purpose only)
7
Performance of EUR Rules/Strategies
• Rules Evaluated: (a) yield curve; (b) carry; (c) moving average
• USD/EUR Strategy = 40% Yield curve and Carry, 20% MA
• Trend model losses are meaningful; but moderate lower drawdown and worst single performance of the strategy
Strategy/ Rules
Annualized Return
Annualized Std Deviation
Information Ratio
Cumulative Return
Confidence in Skill
Success Ratio
Ratio Good /Bad Risk
Max Drawdown
USD/EUR Strategy 3.79% 5.09% 0.7444 45.69% 98.89% 55.21% 0.9793 -7.78% USD/EUR Yield Curve 5.20% 6.26% 0.8301 40.10% 98.42% 82.95% 0.8599 -8.08% USD/EUR Carry 8.48% 9.71% 0.8729 127.66% 99.56% 55.21% 0.8997 -13.07% USD/EUR MA 20-65 -5.22% 9.72% -0.5372 -41.86% 3.13% 46.68% 1.1392 -49.12%
Source: AlphaEngineTM, Mcube Investment Technologies, LLC
www.mcubeit.com (purely hypothetical example for educational purpose only)
8Return calculated versus a 0% hedged position
EUR HEDGE RATIO
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
120%
Date
% E
xp
osu
re H
ed
ge
d
96
98
100
102
104
106
108
Cu
m.
Re
turn
In
de
x
Do Nothing
Partially Hedge
Fully Hedge
% o
f Exp
osu
re H
ed
ged
Gro
wth
of a
dolla
r from
h
ed
ges
9
Innovative Approaches for Clients
• Can generate meaningful cash, without funding, and with a specific dollar loss limit (easiest constraint to monitor)
• Can be delivered through a managed account or even total return swap
• Clients can also manage their own strategic decisions – biggest impact on performance
• Trend to move away from traditional approaches and markets