INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... ·...

25
ORIGINATOR CLIENT AUTHORITY NAME 31 : Henk Myburgh NAME 33 : Tshipi Mine NAME 35 : SIGN: SIGN: SIGN: DATE 32 : 20.09.12 DATE 34 : DATE 36 : Page 1 of 25 INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOP

Transcript of INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... ·...

Page 1: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 1 of 25

INCIDENT REPORTING AND

INVESTIGATION SOP

Page 2: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 2 of 25

1. PURPOSE .............................................................................................................................................................. 3

2. DEFINITIONS ......................................................................................................................................................... 3

3. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES ............................................................................................................................... 9

3.1 PROJECT MANAGER ...................................................................................................................................................... 9 3.2 PROJECT CONSTRUCTION MANAGER ................................................................................................................................ 9 3.3 LINE MANAGERS .......................................................................................................................................................... 9 3.4 SUPERVISORS............................................................................................................................................................. 10 3.5 PROJECT SHE MANAGER ............................................................................................................................................. 10 3.6 ALL EMPLOYEES ......................................................................................................................................................... 10

4. PROCEDURES ...................................................................................................................................................... 10

4.1 GENERAL .................................................................................................................................................................. 10 4.2 STATISTICAL REPORTING .............................................................................................................................................. 11 4.3 ASSESSMENT OF INCIDENT POTENTIAL ............................................................................................................................ 11 4.4 TRAINING.................................................................................................................................................................. 12 4.5 GUIDE TO INVESTIGATION ............................................................................................................................................ 12

5. ANNEXURE 1 – SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT CATEGORY TABLE......................................................................... 24

6. ANNEXURE 2 – REPORTING REQUIREMENTS ....................................................................................................... 25

Page 3: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 3 of 25

1. PURPOSE The purpose of this document is:

To assess in a systematic way, the potential of incidents which could adversely affect our business;

To identify the immediate and underlying causes of those incidents so that appropriate action may be taken to prevent recurrence;

To satisfy legal and contractual obligations, and

To provide all levels of employees and contractors with a consistent approach to incident investigation in order to achieve a quality reporting, investigation, analysis and follow-up standards.

This procedure covers the requirements associated with the reporting and investigation of incidents associated with the Tshipi Project activities. In contracting situations, the relevant contractor must ensure that this procedure is followed. Contractors at the Tshipi Project have the same roles and responsibilities as employees to initiate incident reports and take part in investigations.

2. DEFINITIONS

Near Hit – Where a dangerous act / condition occurred and no one got injured and no damage to property, but the likelihood exists that as a result of the act / condition an injury could be caused or property could be damaged.

Health / Hygiene Incident (Occupational Illness / Disease) – an incident which affects the health or hygiene of an employee. An Occupational Illness or Disease is contracted or exacerbated as a result of the conditions or environment of employment. The basic difference between injury and illness is the single event concept. If the event resulted from something that happened in one instance, it is an injury. If it resulted from prolonged or multiple exposure to a hazardous substance or environment factor, it is an illness. Categories may include:

Noise Induced Hearing Loss

Musculoskeletal Injury (e.g. Repetitive strain injuries / occupational overuse syndrome).

Dust disease.

Occupational Exposure Disease / Disorder (e.g. Lead / chemical).

Dermal Condition (e.g. Dermatitis).

Vibration injury.

Occupational Cancer.

Allergic Reaction / Environmental Sensitivity.

Respiratory Diseases / Disorders (e.g. Asthma / rhinitis)

Caissons Disease (Decompression Illness).

Cardio Vascular diseases / Disorder.

Infections Disease.

Ingestion Injury.

Mental Illness / Condition (e.g. Work-related stress).

Page 4: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 4 of 25

Nervous System Disorder

Reproductive Disorders

Environmental Incident – an incident which results in an impact on the environment, and can classed as one of the following categories:

Category 1: Negligible (caused negligible, reversible environmental impact, requiring very minor or no remediation)

Examples (for guidance only):

A slow droplet oil leak from a compressor, engine or other equipment.

A hydraulic hose on a loader fails and the contents of the hose are lost.

A fuel oil spill-over or splash back whilst fueling a vehicle.

Employee or contractor not following an internal Environmental Procedure.

Visible fume from a building rooftop resulting from an uncontrolled process.

Process water overflow from closed process loop to plant roadway or surface water collection pond.

Category 2: Minor (caused minor, reversible environmental impact, requiring minor remediation)

Examples (for guidance only):

Incorrect storage of hazardous materials.

Engine failed causing approximately 20 litres of oil to spill onto a roadway.

Tailings dust carried off site.

Decommissioned mobile equipment left without drip trays and oil has contaminated two or more square metres of bare ground.

A forklift has punctured a 44 gallon drum containing waste oil.

A hose feeding a waste oil tank is dislodged and the oil that escapes enters a body of surface water.

A fully loaded concentrate transport truck is bogged on the side of Highway.

Mercury concentration in waste water exceeded maximum allowed concentration.

Category 3: Significant (caused moderate, reversible environmental impact with short-term effect, requiring moderate remediation)

Examples (for guidance only):

A complaint from the public was received via the local regulator regarding product that was discovered in a nearby water source.

A sewage treatment plant overflowed and sewage was discharged off site and into a creek.

A major storm event caused the discharge of contaminated water off site.

Any license limit that is exceeded for an extended period.

Any event resulting in numerous community complaints or media exposure.

Seepage is identified at the base of a concentrator runoff pond.

A truck rollover on a public road resulting in a moderate spillage of chemical, oil, fuel or product that is contained within a limited area and that does not impact sensitive habitat that is difficult to remediate.

Page 5: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 5 of 25

Category 4: Serious (caused serious environmental impact, with medium-term effect, requiring significant remediation.)

Examples (for guidance only):

NOTE: Category 4 or 5 Environmental Incidents must also be reported as Critical Incidents (CI). Incidents that could have resulted in Category 4 or 5 Environmental Incidents must be reported as High Potential Risk Incidents (HPRI) – refer to the CI and HPRI definitions in this document.

Significant Sulphur dioxide plume that affects the local community.

Category 5: Disastrous (caused disastrous environmental impact, with long-term effect, requiring major remediation.)

Examples (for guidance only):

NOTE: Category 4 or 5 Environmental Incidents must also be reported as Critical Incidents (CI). Incidents that could have resulted in Category 4 or 5 Environmental Incidents must be reported as High Potential Risk Incidents (HPRI) – refer to the CI and HPRI definitions in this document.

A train derailment that causes a significant spillage (large volume) of sulphuric acid to flow over a wide area.

Property Damage – an incident which results in the damage to company property.

First Aid Case (FAC) – A first aid case (FAC) is a minor work related injury which in normal circumstances can be treated by the victim himself/herself. This usually includes application of non-prescription medicines e.g. antiseptic ointment and small wound dressings. If the treatment given by a medical professional amounts only to that described in this definition the case will remain an FAC. First Aid Injuries Include:

Visits to a medical practitioner / physician solely for observation, counselling or first aid treatment.

Diagnostic procedures such as x-rays and blood tests, including the administra-tion of prescription medications used solely for diagnostic purposes, e.g. Eye drops to dilate pupils.

Using a non-prescription medication at non-prescription strength, i.e. Using medication that does not require a physician’s prescription.

Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza.

Cleaning, flushing or soaking wounds on the surface of the skin.

Using wound coverings such as bandages, band-aids, gauze pads, etc, or using butterfly bandages or steri-strips.

Using hot or cold therapy.

First degree burns.

A series of less than five preventative treatments by a physiotherapist or chiropractor, without medical restriction by a physician.

Using non-rigid means of support, such as elastic bandages, wraps, non-rigid back belts, etc.

Using temporary immobilisation devices while transporting an injured person, e.g. Splints, slings, neck brace, back boards, etc.

Drilling of a fingernail or toenail to relieve pressure, or draining fluid from a blister.

Page 6: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 6 of 25

Removing foreign bodies from the eye using only irrigation or a cotton swab.

Removing splinters or foreign material from areas other than the eye by irrigation, tweezers, cotton swabs or other simple means.

Using finger guards.

Using massages.

Drinking fluids for relief of heat stress.

One time administration of oxygen therapy.

Medical Treatment Case (MTC) – A medical treatment case (MTC) is a work related injury which has not been classified as an LTI or RWI, and which results in the injured receiving attention which under normal circumstances would only be received from a medical professional (e.g. doctor, nurse, paramedic, physiotherapist etc.) via medical treatment and/or prescription. The injured will be able to resume his/her regular duties on the day following that of the injury. The following notes apply:

An injury which first resulted in (for example) an LTI and where the injured after resuming work continues to receive medical treatment for that injury will remain reported as an LTI.

Precautionary examinations, such as the taking of X-rays, are not considered to be MTCs. The application of sutures (stitches), or the removal of a foreign body embedded in the eye, are examples of MTCs. The criterion is the treatment, not the examination.

Medical Treatment Injuries include:

Any work-related injury resulting in a loss of consciousness.

Use of prescription medication, i.e. Medication that can only be prescribed by a medical practitioner / physician. (Except for a single dose of prescription medication administered on the first visit to the physician).

Use of stitches / sutures or staples to close a wound.

Infection from a work-related injury requiring antibiotics.

Second and third degree burns – based on the treatment required and the risk of infection e.g. a burn from a small drop of molten metal to the wrist may only require first aid treatment, whereas if a broader area is affected then medical treatment may be required.

Removal of foreign bodies from the eye requiring more than irrigation or cotton swabs to remove them.

The use of casts, splints or other rigid stays to immobilise parts of the body. A positive x-ray diagnosis for fracture(s).

Surgical removal of foreign material or dead skin i.e. Surgical debridement.

Removal of a fingernail or toenail.

A series of five or more treatments by a physiotherapist or chiropractor.

Admission to hospital for observation for more than 12 hours.

A Lost Time Injury (LTI) – occurs when a person is injured in the execution of his/her duties and as a result of this injury is unable to perform his/her regular duties for one full shift or more on the day following the day on which the injury was incurred, whether a scheduled work day or not.

Page 7: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 7 of 25

A lost time injury is registered as a safety statistic when the injury is confirmed as a work-related compensable case by the jurisdictional worker’s compensation board. The injury must also be confirmed by a medical practitioner / physician, as deemed appropriate by the jurisdictional worker’s compensation board. A fatality is also recorded as an LTI. The following notes apply:

Days lost are calendar days regardless of whether the injured was due at work or not on any of those days and includes scheduled time off. Regular duties are those duties associated with the job description of the injured.

Normal daily travel to and from work is only considered as being work related if the transportation is owned, hired or contracted by the Company.

Restricted work (or light duties) which may follow on from lost time will be counted as lost time.

Lost Time Injury Days (LTID) – are the actual number of calendar days a person was unable to work due to an occupational injury, illness or disease, from but not including, the last day worked. Lost Days shall be accumulated on a monthly basis until the ill or injured person returns to work, or up to a maximum of twelve months for any individual occurrence. If employment is terminated a maximum of twelve months lost time shall be assigned. In the case of a fatality, 12 months lost time shall be assigned with an automatic 12 months lost time in the month in which the fatality occurred.

Disabling Injuries – Disabling Injuries are LTI‟s and RWI‟s.

Restricted Work Injury (RWI) – A restricted work Injury, illness or disease (RWI) is a work related injury, illness or disease which results in the injured being able to return to work on the following shift, but unable to carry out his/her regular duties (light duty or light work). The following notes apply:

Restricted work days are calendar days regardless of whether the injured was due at work or not on any of those days and includes scheduled time off.

RWI’s only occur if restricted work days are the only consequence of the injury, illness or disease (in other words, if no full days are lost).

Restricted work days may occur after a lost time injury and the resulting lost days. In this case the event will remain an LTI and not be reduced to, or double reported as an RWI.

Restricted Work Injury Days (RWID) – is the number of calendar days a person was assigned Restricted Work Duties due to an occupational injury, illness or disease from, but not including, the last day worked. Will be accumulated until the ill or injured person returns

Page 8: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 8 of 25

to work or up to a maximum of twelve months for any individual occurrence. If employment is terminated 12 months time lost shall be assigned.

Permanent Disabling Injury (PDI) – this is also know as a permanent damage injury, and is any occupational injury:

From which there has not been, or is not expected to be, full recovery. This must be confirmed by a medical practitioner / physician, as deemed appropriate by the jurisdictional workers’ compensation board.

Which has substantial negative consequences for the individual, egg, permanent damage to body and body and function, all part or full amputations, including loss of appendages.

A Permanent Disabling Injury shall be recorded in the month of the injury occurrence.

A Permanent Disabling Injury shall also be recorded as an LTI, RWI, MTI or Occupational Disease, as appropriate.

Minor Permanent Disability (Minor PD) – such as partial loss of a digit, hearing or sight impediment etc.

Major Permanent Disability (Major PD) – such a disability includes loss of an eye, loss of a limb, hearing loss, paralysis from the waist down or redeployment with loss of income. Note PD’s are not used as part of the LTIFR calculation.

Fatality – A death resulting from an occupational injury, illness or disease, identified within the reporting period. A fatality is also recorded as an LTI, with an automatic 180 calendar days lost time assigned to it in the month in which the fatality occurred. (e.g. Fatality occurs in September, record 180 LTI days lost in September).

Critical Incident (CI) – An incident which falls into one of the following three categories: 1. Injury or Damage to Assets or Loss of Operations

An event, which has caused:

single or multiple fatalities; or

life threatening injury to a person(s), i.e. injuries that require immediate, aggressive action by site, ambulance and medical staff, such as urgent or emergency surgery, admittance to an intensive care or high dependency facility

damage to assets or property, or loss of operations, to a value greater than US$0.5 million

2. Environment - Category 4 (Serious) or Category 5 (Disastrous) Environmental Incidents.

3. Media Attention - Public exposure of a serious, negative consequence.

High Potential Risk Incident (HPRI) - An event, or near miss, which could have:

killed, or permanently disabled, a person(s);

or caused life threatening injury to a person(s);

or caused damage to assets or loss of operations to the value of greater than US$10 million; or

caused a Category 4 or Category 5 environmental incident.

Page 9: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 9 of 25

Caused media attention / public exposure of a serious, negative consequence.

Project Incident Statistics - are the monthly returns of:

Fatalities;

Lost Time Injuries;

Medical Treatment Cases;

First Aid Cases

Near Hits Damages Environmental Incidents

Hygiene / Health Incidents (Occupational Illness / Disease)

Hours of Exposure – Is the total number of hours worked by all employees (permanent or temporary) and contractors in the reporting period.

Lost Time Injury Frequency Rate (LTIFR) – Is the rate of occurrence of LTI‟s per 200,000 hours worked:

LTIFR = Number of LTIs x 1 000,000 Hours per exposure

Reportable Injury Where an employee got seriously injured and the injury must be reported, according to

the Occupational Health and Safety Act and Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act, to the Department of Labour.

Total Recordable Injuries Total Recordable Injuries include

Lost Time Injuries, inclusive of fatalities (LTI’s).

Restricted Work Injuries (RWI’s).

Medical Treatment Injuries (MTI’s) Total Recordable Injuries = LTI’s + RWI’s + MTI’s.

3. ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES

3.1 PROJECT MANAGER

Define arrangements for project incident reporting;

Provide a progress report to the executive board.

3.2 PROJECT CONSTRUCTION MANAGER

Ensure that Line Managers are aware of their responsibilities, in regards to inci-dent reporting and investigation, where deemed necessary to ensure effective information flow and coordination of remedial actions;

Implement, monitor and verify the effectiveness of this procedure.

3.3 LINE MANAGERS

Ensure that employees are adequately trained for the implementation of this procedure;

Investigate external notification requirements and prepare (but not issue) external notifications;

Page 10: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 10 of 25

Conduct regular reviews of all incidents reported within their areas, ensure that necessary actions arising from these reviews are followed up;

Ensure timely completion of corrective/preventative actions and provide regular progress reports to the Project Construction Manager;

Authorise and close out all incident reports within their area.

3.4 SUPERVISORS

Ensure that all incidents within their respective area are identified, investigated and reported in accordance with this procedure.

3.5 PROJECT SHE MANAGER

Establish the training standards required by this procedure;

Coordinate delivery of appropriate training courses in incident investigation and reporting; (ICAM)

Confirm return to work progress has been followed:

Maintain files of original incident reports in accordance with prevailing company and legal requirements;

Provide assistance to Line Managers in setting up appropriate teams for investigation and follow-up of serious safety related incidents;

Review incident reports, initiate further investigations and/or recommend extra corrective action as considered necessary to reduce risk

3.6 ALL EMPLOYEES

Report incidents to their supervisors as soon as practicable within the shift that the incident occurs or as soon as the employee becomes aware of a hazard; Participate in subsequent investigations and implementation preventative action as required.

4. PROCEDURES

4.1 GENERAL

All incidents occurring on site/premises must be reported and investigated in accordance with this procedure;

This document should be read in conjunction with any related project procedures. If there are any variants that arise between project procedures and this procedure, the matter should be raised with the Project SHE Manager.

Contractors shall notify the Project Management Representative immediately of any non-conformance to procedures or of any other incident within the Contractor and his sub-contractors‟ areas of responsibility in writing.

The contractor shall investigate all incidents on the ICAM format provided by the Project SHE department.

ICAM investigations shall be completed for:

Medical Treatment Cases

Lost time Injuries

Fatalities

Any incident with the potential to cause serious harm or result in a fatal. (HPRI)

Page 11: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 11 of 25

Any Incident so defined by the Project SHE Manager

ICAM investigation shall be completed and submitted within 24 hours to the Project SHE Manager.

4.2 STATISTICAL REPORTING Each of the contractor SHE Officers is responsible for collecting, recording, calculating

and reporting the SHE statistics. SHE statistics are to be reported to the Project SHE Manager.

The Project SHE Manager is responsible for consolidating the SHE statistics from

each contract and reporting these to the Project Management Team Each week each Contractor is required to report (qualitative) all incidents which have

occurred during the week:

Incidents and incident trends for week and month to date.

Injuries (all new injuries during the week to be reported on the initial accident notification report), including FAC’s, MTC’s, LTIs, SIs, PDs and fatalities.

Proactive Safety initiatives for forthcoming week based on work programme

Report on medical condition of personnel previously injured while on duty Report on status of remedial actions (actions closed, in progress, not yet started).

4.3 ASSESSMENT OF INCIDENT POTENTIAL 4.3.1 Sustainable Development Category Table

The Sustainable Development Category Table (Refer to Annexure 1) will be used as a tool by the Supervisor or Line Manager to assign a Category for Incident Potential. The aim of the Sustainable Development Category Table is to: - Increase the awareness of SHE implications of any incident; - Assess the significance of an incident in terms of its potential for injury,

damage, environmental impact and its likelihood of reoccurrence, and - To provide guidance in determining the depth or extent of incident

investigations and its follow-up.

4.3.2 Basis for Potential Categorisation The assessment of incident potential provides focus on events that pose signifi-

cant threat to our business. We identify four categories of potential incidents and their subsequent reporting and investigation requirements. These are illustrated in Annexure 2 – Reporting Requirements.

Where an incident has potential consequences relating to two or more dimen-

sions, the highest potential level shall be assigned. When assigning a level of investigation and reporting the measure of exposure rather than the actual injury or damage must be taken into account to ensure that credible possible consequences are considered and hence, „potential‟ equates to „reasonably possible‟. Usually, an additional failed defence or coincidental event should be added to the actual event to identify the potential event and associated potential level of investigation.

Page 12: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 12 of 25

4.4 TRAINING Employees who are expected to lead the investigation shall have undergone training

in Incident Investigation techniques, specifically ICAM. Investigation team members are required to be familiar with the investigation process

and documentation used during the process.

4.5 GUIDE TO INVESTIGATION 4.5.1 The Investigation Process

The investigation process for incidents will involve some or all of the following steps, depending on assessment of the potential:

Internal and external notification of the incident;

Definition of terms of reference and appointment of investigators;

Detailed investigation including inspections, interviews, etc.;

Time Line of incident

Root cause analysis;

Recommendation for remedial action;

Investigation report;

Management review and endorsement of recommendations;

Implementation of action items;

Distribution of investigation findings; and

Follow-up and close out.

4.5.2 Immediate Response Any person involved in or witnessing an incident, or identifying a hazard, must

initiate appropriate action to ensure the safety and medical treatment of injured personnel and to prevent consequential injury or loss at the incident site. This must be followed up by notification of the circumstances to his or her immediate Supervisor.

All reported incidents must be investigated initially by the responsible supervisor.

In each case the supervisor must ensure that an incident report is raised and that the relevant Line Manager and the Project SHE Manager are copied.

Any incident must be reported immediately and the client must be notified

timeously within the same shift depending on the severity and classification status. E.g. all high potential and medical incidents must be reported immediately.

A preliminary Incident Report must be completed within the same shift The Project SHE Manager or the Construction Manager will decide if a full ICAM

must be conducted and this report must be available within 24 hours of the incident.

Page 13: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 13 of 25

4.5.3 Investigation Team In the event of a serious incident, an investigation team will be established. The

size and composition of the investigation team will depend upon: - The extent of injury, damage or loss; - The potential for injury, damage or loss; - The potential for negative impact on repetition; - Technical complexity/requirement for specialist knowledge; and - Statutory requirements.

The relevant Line Manager should initiate incident investigations, setting up a

team as required. At least one member of the team must be competent to lead the incident

investigation; The investigation team shall comprise of three or more people such as:

- The supervisor of the work area involved; - A person outside the department; - A person with appropriate skills/competence in the area being investigated; - A person who is competent in incident investigation and experienced in the

use of ICAM; - Person with the appropriate technical/system expertise.

All members must be willing and able to devote the time necessary to the

investigation. 4.5.4 Preliminary Investigation

Preliminary investigation requires the following: - Incident Report Form must be completed; - Agreed corrective actions and actionees should be determined; - Line management must review corrective actions and ensure that all

actions are completed; - On completion of all items the incident report form must be signed off, as

closed-out, by line management and when finalised, sent to the SHE Manager.

4.5.5 Detailed Investigation A detailed investigation requires the following:

- Incident report form to be completed; - Line management to appoint an investigation team and define terms of

reference appropriate to the incident severity.

Scope and Aims The scope of the investigation should be such as to achieve the following primary

aims:

To identify the root cause/s of the incident such that actions can be taken to prevent recurrence of future incidents;

To review the application of management practices and their impact on SHE;

Page 14: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 14 of 25

To establish the facts surrounding the incident for use in relation to potential insurance claims or litigation;

To meet relevant statutory requirements on incident reporting.

Timing

Investigations must take place as soon as possible after the incident has occurred. The quality of evidence can deteriorate rapidly and delayed enquiries are usually not as conclusive as those conducted immediately.

Where possible, the site should remain untouched until at least a preliminary investigation has taken place (within 1 hour). If this is not feasible because of residual hazards or other serious factors, photograph or sketch the area, then carry out remedial actions.

For serious incidents the scene should be cordoned off until the Project SHE Manager releases the area for normal activity.

The incident must be logged within the same shift.

ICAM (when required) must be completed within 24 hours.

Incident notification / Alert (Flash Report) to be forwarded to the Project SHE Manager for communication within 36 hours of the incident.

4.5.6 Investigation Report Format – ICAM

Summary of incident;

Investigation team

Terms of reference;

Description of incident/sequence of events;

Results of investigation and cause analysis including root causes;

Recommendations and action items;

Appendices as appropriate (include copies of notification faxes, fault tree analysis, photographs, sketches etc);

The investigation report must be sent to the Line Manager who will review the recommended actions and assign actionees to carry out improvements;

On completion of all items, the detailed investigation report must be closed out by the Line Manager and when finalised, sent to the Project SHE Manager

4.5.7 The Investigation Method – ICAM The Incident Cause Analysis Method (ICAM) is used to carry out incident investi-

gations. The objectives of incident investigations using this procedure are to:

Establish the facts.

Determine direct, underlying and contributing causes / factors and latent hazards. Review adequacy of existing controls and procedures.

Report the findings.

Developing corrective actions which can improve efficiency, reduce risk and prevent recurrence.

Detect developing trends that can be analyzed to identify specific or recurring problems. Identify any key learning’s for distribution within the organisation and externally as required.

Page 15: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 15 of 25

The method of conducting an investigation consists of the following activities:

Fact finding;

Inspecting the location;

Gathering and recording physical evidence;

Interviewing witnesses.

Review documents, procedures and records;

Resolving conflicts in evidence;

Identifying missing information;

Recording additional factors and possible underlying causes including human factors.

4.5.8 Data Collection During this phase of the investigation as many relevant facts as possible should

be collected to help in understanding the incident and the events leading up to it. The collection of data can be divided into five main areas:

People.

Environment.

Equipment.

Procedures.

Organisation.

Interviews should be conducted individually and should begin soon after an incident to obtain information about the immediate events associated with the incident, including how the activity that was involved in the incident was planned and conducted. Interviews could include the following individuals:

Individuals directly involved in the incident.

Supervisory personnel.

Personnel at the scene.

Management

Emergency Services personnel (if illness or injuries involved). Safety personnel.

Subject matter experts.

People being interviewed should not be denied the right to have an adviser present if they so wish. Keep the interview short, informal, simple and use language the person understands. Opinions are acceptable provided they are recognised as such.

Data

Collection

Who or What Collection Methods Example Questions

People ▪ Witnesses

▪ Associated people

▪ Interview

▪ Written statement

▪ Observation

▪ Explain in their own words what happened?

▪ What could have been done differently to prevent the outcome?

▪ Whether they knew of any previous incidents or near hits associated

with conducting the task?

Environment ▪ Weather

▪ Workplace

▪ Incident scene

▪ Observation/ Review

▪ Inspection/ Photography

▪ Event reconstruction

▪ What were the weather conditions?

▪ Were any housekeeping issues involved?

▪ What were the workplace conditions?

▪ What surrounding noises were present?

▪ What were the light conditions?

▪ Were toxic or hazardous gases, dusts or fumes present?

Page 16: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 16 of 25

Equipment ▪ Vehicles

▪ Plant

▪ Tools

▪ Infrastructure, etc.

▪ Inspection

▪ Testing

▪ Operation

▪ How did the equipment function?

▪ Were hazardous substances involved?

▪ What identification did they have?

▪ Were any alternative substances available?

▪ What Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) was being used?

Procedures ▪ Existing maps

▪ Charts

▪ Documents

▪ Reports

▪ Photographs, etc.

▪ Review

▪ Comparison

▪ What work procedure was used?

▪ Was a risk assessment conducted prior to the task?

▪ Had conditions changed that would have affected the way normal

procedure worked?

▪ What tools and materials were available?

▪ How did the safety devices work?

▪ What lockout or isolation procedures were used?

Organisation ▪ Review

▪ Comparison

▪ Review

▪ Comparison

▪ What applicable safety rules were communicated to employees? When?

▪ What written procedures were available?

▪ How were they enforced?

▪ What supervision was in place?

▪ What training was given in how to do the work? When? Is it still valid and

current?

▪ How were hazards identified?

▪ What procedures had been developed to overcome them?

▪ How were unsafe conditions corrected?

Additional data sources include:

Pre-incident photographs – If available, these photographs may be com-pared with post incident photographs to help explain the incident. Staged photographs of the incident may be taken at a later time if they will help clarify the final report.

Diagrams and sketches – These may be used as substitutes for photo-graphs and can be especially useful when it is necessary to illustrate move-ments (e.g. personnel location or vehicle movements before and during an incident). Record directions, distances, and other relevant factors.

Maps – These show the relative locations of buildings and events. Maps should be used for plotting the location of personnel who are injured or have become ill as a result of a hazardous material release. This empirical “time and place‟ information is also useful for planning adequate evacuation distances in future emergencies.

Documents – A review of documents may also uncover contributing factors and should include:

Applicable regulations.

Training, medical and work history records.

Applicable procedures, work instructions, equipment manuals and mainte-nance records.

Incident reports, audit reports.

Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS).

Organisational policies and procedures.

4.5.9 Data Organisation After the collection of data and analysis, it should be possible to organise the

data to provide the sequence of events leading up to the incident, the incident itself and events post incident until control was regained. The data collected during the investigation should be correlated in a logical and sequential way.

Page 17: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 17 of 25

Several data organising techniques such as Timelines, Event and Condition Charts (Timeline) Trees are available to assist in understanding the incident. The technique used for determining the sequence of events in the incident should meet the following requirements:

Provide a framework to organise the data collected.

Assist in ensuring the investigation follows a logical path.

Aid in the resolution of conflicting information and the identification of missing data.

Provide a diagrammatical display of the investigative process for management briefing.

Events and Condition Chart / Timeline

4.5.10 Data Analysis The analysis of incidental data can identify trends which highlight the com-

position of the organization’s risk exposure. It can also address the effectiveness of the SHE strategies and identify the incident caused factors that must be controlled to improve the organization’s SHE performance. In order to benefit from the collecting and analyzing SHE data, there must be a process to address negative trends that re identified. Action plan must be developed to address negative trends. When an incident analysis clearly shows that improvement trends have resulted from the implementation of health and safety programs, it is important to celebrate the success, recognise those responsible and share practices and programmes to achieve the success with other NE sites.

The data analysis includes the following activities:

Analyzing the Findings.

Identification of the Absent or Failed defenses.

Identification of the Individual and Team actions.

Identification of the Tasks and Environmental conditions.

Identification of the Organisational factors.

Page 18: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 18 of 25

Possible Absent or Failed Defenses Include:

Awareness Awareness is knowing the risks and how to manage them. To understand the

nature and severity of the hazardous conditions present at the worksite. Awareness

problems reflect continuous shortcomings in those involved on site or those

supervising and managing processes.

Examples include: Induction Training, Ongoing Training, Communication, Hazard/Aspect Register

Detection Detection is how to see the event coming and prevent it. To provide clear warning

of both the presence and the nature of a potentially hazardous situation

Examples include: Warning Lights, Traffic

Warning Signs, Gas Detectors, Speed

Sensors.

Control and

Recovery Control and interim recovery is getting out of trouble without injury or damage. To

restore people or equipment to a safe state with minimal injury or damage.

Examples include: Procedures, Residual

Current Device, Bypass Valves,

Emergency Shut Down Systems.

Protection and

Containment Protection and Containment is preventing escalation of the problem. To limit the

adverse consequences of any unplanned release of mass, energy or hazardous

material.

Examples include: PPE, Fire Extingui-

shers, Spill Response Kits, Bunded

Areas.

Escape and

Rescue Escape and Rescue is caring for the injured and making the site safe. To evacuate

all potential victims from the hazard location as quickly and as safely as possible.

Examples include: Safe Access/ Egress,

Emergency Planning, Emergency

Communication.

Possible Individual / Team actions include:

Slips – errors in which the right intention or plan is incorrectly carried out. These usually occur during well-practiced and familiar tasks in which actions are largely automatic.

Lapses – failures to carry out an action. Lapses typically involve failures of memory.

Mistakes – involve deficiencies or failures in the judgment process. These occur when rules are applied incorrectly or knowledge relevant to the situation is inadequate, and a flawed plan is developed. When carried out, the plan will not lead to the desired outcome.

Violations – deliberate deviations from safe operating practices, procedures, standards or rules. These can be further categorized as:

Routine (the breach of rules or corner cutting has become implicitly accepted, and a normal activity).

Exceptional (one-off violation enacted in unusual circumstances).

Acts of sabotage (deliberate action intended to cause damage). Possible Task / Environmental Conditions include:

Workplace Factors

Error Factors Common Factors Violation Factors • Change of routine

• Poor signal / noise ratio

• Poor man/system interface

• Designer/user mismatch

• Educational mismatch

• Hostile environment

• Domestic problems

• Poor communications

• Poor mix of “hands on” work and written

instruction (Reliance on undocumented

knowledge)

• Poor shift patterns and overtime

working.

• Time shortage

• Inadequate tools and equipment

• Poor procedures and instructions

• Poor tasking

• Inadequate training

• Hazards not identified.

• Under-resourcing

• Inadequate supervision

• Poor access to job Poor housekeeping

• Poor supervisor/worker ratio

• Poor working conditions

• Inadequate mix of experienced and

inexperienced workers

• Violations tolerated

• Compliance goes unrewarded

• Procedures protect the system not the

individual

• Little or no autonomy

• Perceived license to bend rules

• Adversarial industrial climate

• Low operator pay

• Low operator status

• Unfair management sanctions

• Blame culture

• Poor supervisory example

• Task allows for easy shortcuts

Human Factors

Error Factors Common Factors Violation Factors

Page 19: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 19 of 25

• Preoccupation

• Distraction

• Memory Failures

• Perceptual set (tendency to perceive

one thing and not another)

• False perceptions

• Confirmation bias

• Situational awareness

• Incomplete knowledge

• Inaccurate knowledge

• Interference and reasoning

• Stress and fatigue

• Disturbed sleep patterns

• Error proneness

• Insufficient ability

• Inadequate skill

• Skill overcomes danger

• Unfamiliarity with task

• Poor judgment

• Overconfidence Performance anxiety

• Time pressures Monotony and boredom

• Emotional status

• Age and gender

• High risk target

• Behavioural beliefs (gains > risks)

• Subjective norms condoning violations

• Personality

• Perceived bahavioural control

• Low morale

• Bad mood

• Job dissatisfaction

• Attitude to the system

• Misperception of hazards

• Low self esteem

• Learned helplessness

Possible Organisational Factors include: The following are the ICAM classified Organisational Factors:

Hardware (HW)

Training (TR)

Organisation (OR)

Communication (CO)

Incompatible Goals (IG)

Procedures (PR)

Risk Management (RM)

Management of Change (MC) Organisational Culture (OC) Regulatory Influence (RI) Maintenance Management (MM) Design (DE)

Contractor Management (CM)

Factor Causes End Results

Hardware (HW) • Poor stock or ordering system

• Poor quality due to the local availability

• Poor state of existing equipment

• Equipment not fit for purpose

• Lack of resources available to buy, maintain or improve

equipment

• Theft

• Inappropriate use of tools or equipment

• Absence or unavailability of tools or equipment

• Improvisation . i.e. Using tools unsuitable for the job

Factor Causes End Results

Training (TR) • Training not directed to all the job skill requirements

• Ineffective pre-employment selection process

• Poor training needs assessment

• No assessment of training effectiveness

• Differing standards of training

• Training the wrong people

• Making assumptions about a person’s knowledge or skills

• Employees unable to perform their jobs

• Excessive time spent in training

• Excessive supervision needed

• Increased numbers of people required for the job

• Jobs taking longer, or poor quality, wasting material

Factor Causes End Results

Organisation (OR) • Poorly defined departments or section

• Unclear accountability, responsibility or delegation

• Lack of definition of objectives

• No structure to co-ordinate different activities

• Poor planning

• Excessive bureaucracy

• Frequent re-organisations

• Multi-layer hierarchy, slow response to changes

• Wrong person, or nobody, takes responsibility

• Resources used for non-business needs

• Decisions delayed or deferred

• People are only held responsible not accountable for their

actions / decisions

• Poor control or management of events Rules and

procedures not enforced

Factor Causes End Results

Communication

(CO)

• Language problems and cultural barriers

• Lack of clear line of communication

• Poor feedback

• Misunderstanding or incorrect interpretation

• Doing the wrong thing, at the wrong time or place

• Missing information, people not informed, do not report

Page 20: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 20 of 25

• No standard communication format

• Missing or excessive information

• Inability to make contact with the correct person

• Unreceptive or hostile target

• People not knowing who to inform

• Not knowing where information is located

Factor Causes End Results

Procedures (PR) • Poor knowledge of the procedure writer

• Poor feedback on practicality

• Non-operational objectives

• Failure to have a revision control system

• Ambiguous, non-comprehensive, incorrect and outdated

documents

• Difficult access for the users

• No procedures for some specific tasks

• Too many, overlapping or conflicting procedures

• Failure to communicate existing or new procedures

Factor Causes End Results

Goals (G) • Conflict between safe work and production priorities

• Conflict between work and personal priorities

• Imbalance between safety requirements and budget

constraints

• Suppressing information about hazards or injuries

• Shortcutting a procedure

• Overruling or relaxing procedures

• Putting people under pressure

• Operating closer than normal to operating limits

Factor Causes End Results

Organisational

Culture (OC)

• Diverse and conflicting values and beliefs of the people

within an organisation

• Poor (or filtered) organisational level reporting and rela-

tionships

• Factions and politics

• Unaddressed employee fears and anxieties

• Low levels of trust and stress

• Getting away with unnecessary risk taking

• Inappropriate social interaction

• Poor leadership

• Inconsistency between organisation’s values and actions

• Lack of compliance, performance monitoring and review

• Poor communications between divisions

• Failure to complete tasks

• Non-adherence to rules

• Poor commitment to safety, environment and community

issues

• Reluctance for voluntary resolution of identified hazards

• Low occurrence reporting

• Lack of clear management structures/processes Low staff

morale and motivation

• Miscalculation of the level of acceptable risk Ambiguous

expectations of behaviour requirements

• Slow acceptance of change, restricting continual

improvement process

Factor Causes End Results

Regulatory

Influence (RI)

• Ambiguous regulations

• Duplicated safety practices

• Multiple requirements for documentary evidence

• Conflicting regulatory requirements

• Lack of knowledge regarding regulatory requirements

• Delays in meeting regulatory requirements

• Additional resources to meet regulatory requirements

• Prescriptive regulatory requirements

• Restrictive work practices

• Difficulties in interpreting regulations

• Non-reporting of hazards due to fear of enforcement

action/penalty

• Inability to demonstrate compliance or satisfy other legal

requirements

• Potential revocation of operating license or other

regulatory sanctions

Factor Causes End Results

Risk & Change

Management (RM)

• Inadequate or poorly conducted risk management process

• Goals, objectives, scope and boundaries of risk

management activity not clearly determined

• Hazard identification process not being systematic, or

covering all operations and equipment

• Risk assessment conducted without the appropriate

competencies and experience

• Inappropriate selection or poor Implementation of risk

control measure

• Inadequate monitoring of risk control effectiveness

• Risk levels above ALARP

• Uncontrolled hazards and consequences Unexpected

incident and accident rate Inappropriate risk ranking and

allocation of risk control resources

• Incomplete, inadequate or out of date

• Risk Register

• Breach of local regulatory requirements

Factor Causes End Results

Maintenance

Management (MM)

• Poor planning, controlling, execution and recording of main-

tenance

• State of equipment not communicated to relevant people

• Shortage of specialized maintenance personnel

• Absent/inadequate manuals and documents

• Incorrect maintenance strategy

• Defective or malfunctioning equipment

• Makeshift or unplanned maintenance

• Breakdown before life expectancy

• Unexpected rapid corrosion

• Equipment not operable in the way intended

Factor Causes End Results

Design (DE) • No standardization of equipment or usage • Extra effort to do the job

Page 21: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 21 of 25

• No adapting to human needs and limitations

• Poor designer – user communication

• Time or financial constraints

• No indication of system status provided by design (on/off)

• Inadequate design premise data

• Unexpected performance of tools and equipment

• Inability to operate equipment properly

• Inability / difficult in controlling processes

• Long or repeated training requirements

• Equipment is unused or improvised usage

Factor Causes End Results

Contractor

Management (CM)

• Inadequate or poorly conducted contract management

process

• Lack of consideration of risk associated with the contract

• Poorly defined selection criteria, i.e. cost over performance

• Lack of formal contractor evaluation procedure

• Lack of a clearly defined work scope

• Contract not clearly defining SHE obligations performance

and reporting requirements

• Unclear reporting relationships, lines of communication,

roles and responsibilities

• The failure to identify / plan bridging requirements between

the contractor and company standards

• Inadequate or poorly conducted SHE compliance and

performance monitoring and review

• Risk levels above ALARP

• Deterioration in production and safety performance

• Requirement for additional supervision

• Substandard competency and manning levels

• Differing, conflicting or poor interface of procedures and

systems of work

• Poor employee / contractor relations, industrial relation

issues, high personnel turnover Imbalance between

contract compliance, production and SHE goals

• Lack of reporting of hazards, near-hits and incidents

4.5.11 Investigation by Local Authorities In the event that local authorities decide to conduct and manage their own

investigation, the Construction manager will liaise with the authorities and to assist in assembling the information required. Notwithstanding the involvement of local authorities, NE Project Management shall carry out its own investigation in the incident.

See SAMRASS 1 to 9 as per Mine Health and Safety Act Regulation

4.5.12 Recommendations The ultimate objective of the investigation is to initiate any action which may

be required to prevent further incidents. This can best be achieved by addressing all absent or failed defences and organisational factors identi-fied by the ICAM analysis. Not all contributing factors can be completely eliminated, and some may be eliminated only at a prohibitive cost. The investigation team should work with line management in the development of corrective actions.

Recommendations should be:

Actionable: Action description must be sufficiently defined to enable unambiguous implementation. The party responsible for the action must be specified.

Achievable: Actions must be feasible, and appropriate deadlines set for implementation.

Appropriate: Actions must be proportional to the risk posed and must act on root causes

4.5.13 Requirements for Formal Reports

Page 22: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 22 of 25

Reports arising from detailed investigations will usually require more space than is available on a standard incident form. In such cases, the basic details should be filled out on the form and a copy included in the appendix of the formal report. Also, additional copies should be attached if more than one person is injured. All formal reports will be retained on file by the Project SHE Manager and shall contain the following: - Executive Summary; - Investigation Team and Terms of Reference; - Description of Incident; - Sequence of Events; - Results of Investigation and Cause Analysis; - Recommendations on Corrective and Preventative Actions; and - Appendices:

Incident Report Form

Witness(es) Statements (if necessary)

Photographs (if taken)

Other Relevant Documents

4.5.14 Implementation of Recommendations Review of both investigation report and implementation of recommended

actions must be formalised with an agreed time schedule to ensure effective follow-up. Appropriate resources must be made available for timely completion of action item.

Incident investigation must be seen as a continual improvement process.

Address the Organisational Factors in order to identify areas to improve error prevention. Address the absent or failed defences in order to identify areas for improvement of error trapping and error mitigation.

An effective incident investigation requires strong management commitment

and involvement. Management must support the investigation process and act on the results. It must make sure that the investigators are capable and have sufficient resources for an effective investigation. It is management’s responsibility to evaluate the quality and outcome of all incident investiga-tions.

4.5.15 Incident Reporting Formats All incidents shall be reported to the Project SHE Manager immediately via

phone. The appointed responsible manager for the company shall be held accountable to ensure compliance.

The following incident reporting formats shall be used and complied with as

follows:

Deviations – Deviation Report & Action Plan TSW/CON/051

All Incidents - Preliminary Incident Report TSW/CON/027 / Incident Flash Report

TSW/CON/076

Page 23: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 23 of 25

All FAC / MTC / LTI / HPI / Fatal during weekly period - Incident feedback report

TSW/CON/073

Near Hits – Near Hit Report TSW/CON/029

Health & Hygiene (Occ Injury / Illness) Incidents – Mini ICAM TSW/CON/071 /

ICAM report TSW/CON/070

Environmental Incidents – Mini ICAM TSW/CON/071 / ICAM report TSW/CON/070

Damage to plant and equipment - Damage report TSW/CON/026

First Aid Cases (FAC) – Mini ICAM TSW/CON/071

Medical treatment cases (MTC) – ICAM report TSW/CON/070

High Potential Incidents (HPRI) – ICAM report TSW/CON/070 / HPRI Notification

TSW/CON/072

Lost Time Injuries (LTI) – ICAM report TSW/CON/070

Fatal – ICAM report TSW/CON/070

4.5.16 Incident Feedback Sessions – Steering Committee The Committee will be responsible to ensure the evaluation of proper incident investigations and that sufficient and adequate preventative control measures are implemented to ensure no-repeats. The appointed responsible Contractor Manager, Supervisor and Safety Officer shall be required to attend this session when incidents were experienced the previous week. The appointed Contractor Manager shall be responsible for feedback and not the Line Management. Feedback shall be demonstrated and made available on the format supplied by the Project SHE Manager.

4.5.17 Reporting of CI’s and HPRI’s As per Xstrata Reporting requirements,

All Critical Incidents (CI‟s) shall be verbally reported through the chain of command to:

Commodity Business Executive Management Team

Commodity Business Corporate Affairs Manager

Commodity Business Safety and Environment Manager (s)

General Manager SHE

An Alert / Report shall be generated for all Critical Incidents (CI’s) and High Potential Risk Incidents (HPRI’s) and shall be forwarded to the appropriate people within 24 hours for all CI’s and within 72 hours for all HPRI’s. The Alert shall be generated by the Project SHE Manager and will be forwarded to the Project Manager and Project Leader, who will forward the Alert to:

Appropriate Senior Managers in the Commodity Business

Commodity Business Safety and Environment Manager(s)

Page 24: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 24 of 25

Commodity Business Chief Executive

General Manager SHE

A full investigation of all CI‟s and HPI’s shall be carried out, and a detailed report shall be shall be forwarded within 30 days to:

Appropriate Senior Managers in the Commodity Business

Commodity Business Safety and Environment Manager(s)

Commodity Business Chief Executive

General Manager SHE

5. ANNEXURE 1 – SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT CATEGORY TABLE

Category 1: Low Category 2: Minor Category 3: Moderate Category 4: Major Category 5: Critical

8.1.1 Injuries

▪ Low level short-term

inconvenience or

symptoms.

▪ No measurable

physical effects.

▪ First Aid Injuries

▪ Medical treatment

injuries (MTI)

requiring

hospitalization.

▪ Irreversible disability

(<30%) to one or more

persons.

▪ RWI/LTI less than 14

days.

▪ Single fatality and/or

severe disability (>30%) to

one or more persons.

▪ LTI >14 days/Extensive

injuries requiring full admis-

sion into hospital.

▪ Short or long term health

effects leading to

multiple fatalities.

▪ Irreversible human

health effects to >50

persons.

▪ Fatality.

8.1.2 Environmental Effects

▪ Technical non-com-

pliance with environ-

mental regulations or

incident resulting in

no environmental

harm.

▪ Minor incident that

causes negligible

impact on environ-

ment, are readily

controlled by esta-

blished procedures.

▪ Incident cause moderate

localized reversible

environmental impacts.

▪ Incidents which cause

serious environmental

impact that can be rectified

in the medium term (1 – 12

months).

▪ Incidents which cause

major environmental

consequences and long

term impact (greater

than 12 months).

8.1.3 Operational Impact (SD Incidents)

▪ Easily addressed or

rectified by imme-

diate corrective

actions.

▪ No loss of produc-

tion.

▪ No damage to equip-

ment.

▪ Minor or superficial

damage to equip-

ment and/or facility.

▪ No loss of produc-

tion.

▪ Moderate damage to

equipment and/or facility.

▪ Loss of production <one

week.

▪ Major damage to facility

requiring significant correc-

tive / preventive action.

▪ Loss of production <six

months.

▪ Future operations and

site seriously affected.

▪ Loss of production >six

months

8.1.4 Legal

▪ Low-level legal issue

which could result in

a fine but

prosecution is

unlikely.

▪ Minor legal issues,

non-compliances

and breaches of

regulation which

could result in minor

prosecution or

possible litigation.

▪ Serious breach of

regulation resulting in an

investigation or report to

the authority with

prosecution and/or

moderate fine.

▪ Major breach of regulation

with potential of major fine

and/or investigation and

prosecution by authority.

▪ Very serious litigation,

including class actions.

Page 25: INCIDENT REPORTING AND INVESTIGATION SOPnamaqua-eng.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/SOP... · Administration of immunisations, e.g. Tetanus, hepatitis, influenza. Cleaning, flushing

ORIGINATOR

CLIENT AUTHORITY

NAME 31: Henk Myburgh NAME

33: Tshipi Mine NAME

35:

SIGN: SIGN: SIGN:

DATE 32: 20.09.12 DATE

34: DATE

36:

Page 25 of 25

Category 1: Low Category 2: Minor Category 3: Moderate Category 4: Major Category 5: Critical

8.1.5 Public / Government / Media / Reputation / Community

▪ Public concern

restricted to local

complaints.

▪ Ongoing scrutiny /

attention from

regulator.

▪ Community enquiry.

▪ Minor, adverse local

public or media

attention and com-

plaints.

▪ Significant hardship

from regulator.

▪ Reputation is adver-

sely affected with a

small number of

people.

▪ Community com-

plaint or Community

MTI as a result of

NE Operations.

▪ Local newspaper atten-

tion.

▪ Community LTI/RWI less

than 14 days as a result

of NE Operations.

▪ Significant adverse media /

public NGO attention.

▪ May lose license to operate

or may not gain approval of

permits.

▪ Environment / management

credentials are damaged.

▪ Community LTI/RWI more

than 14 days as a result of

NE Operations.

▪ Serious public or media

outcry.

▪ Damaging NGO

campaign.

▪ License to operate

threatened.

▪ Share price may be

affected.

▪ Community fatality as a

result of NE.

6. ANNEXURE 2 – REPORTING REQUIREMENTS (Refer to Annexure 1 for Risk Matrix)

Requirements Low Risk – Category 1 Medium Risk – Category 2 Significant Risk – Category 3 High Risk – Category 4

VERBAL

NOTIFICATIONS

▪ Immediate to Area

Supervisor.

▪ Immediate to SHE

Manager

▪ Immediate to Area

Supervisor.

▪ Immediate to Line Manager.

▪ Immediate to SHE Manager

▪ Immediate to Area Supervisor.

▪ Immediate to SHE Manager

▪ Immediate to Construction

Manager

▪ Immediate to Project Manager.

▪ Immediate to Project General

Manager

▪ As per Category 3.

REPORTING TIME,

NOTIFICATION OF

INCIDENT

▪ Within the shift to

persons on the

distribution list below.

▪ Within the shift to persons on

the distribution list below.

▪ Immediate to persons on the

distribution list below.

▪ As per Category 3.

INVESTIGATION

TYPE

▪ Preliminary. ▪ Detailed ICAM. ▪ Detailed ICAM. ▪ As per Category 3.

PERSON

RESPONSIBLE FOR

INVESTIGATION

▪ Immediate Supervisor. ▪ Line Manager. ▪ Project Construction Manager.

▪ SHE Manager.

▪ As per Category 3.

PERSON

RESPONSIBLE FOR

SIGN-OFF

▪ Line Manager. ▪ Project Construction Mana-

ger.

▪ SHE Manager.

▪ Project Manager / Project General

Manager.

▪ As per Category 3.

DISTRIBUTION LIST ▪ Supervisor, Line Mana-

gers, SHE Manager,

Construction Manager.

▪ Supervisor, Line Managers,

SHE Manager, Construction

Manager.

▪ Supervisor, Line Managers, SHE

Manager, Construction Manager,

Project Manager.

▪ As per Category 3.