Devizes Town Council: DeliveringDemocracy to Devizes 01380 ...
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF ... · Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2...
Transcript of IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF ... · Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2...
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF PUERTO RICO
WILLIAM ANTHONY COLON, * CASE NO. 07-1380 (JAG)(JA) *
Plaintiff, * Hon. Magistrate Justo Arenas *
v. * * RUBEN BLADES, ROBERTO *MORGALO, MARTINEZ, MORGALO *AND ASSOCIATES *
* Defendants. ** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *RUBEN BLADES, *
*Cross-plaintiff, *
*v. *
*ROBERT MORGALO, ETC., *et als., *
*Cross-defendants. *
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
ROBERT J. MORGALO, * Consolidated with *
Plaintiff, * CASE NO. 07-1380 (JA) *
v. * *
RUBEN BLADES, *RUBEN BLADES PRODUCTIONS, *
*Defendants. *
** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Deposition of:
RUBEN BLADES-VELLIDO DE LUNA
taken on April 22, 2009, at the Juan Saavedra Law offices,
Banco Popular Building, 7th floor, 206 Tetuán Street, Old San
Juan, Puerto Rico.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 1 of 327
2
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
APPEARANCES:
On behalf of plaintiff and cross-defendant:
JUAN SAAVEDRA LAW OFFICE
Banco Popular Building, 7th floor
206 Tetuán Street
Old San Juan, Puerto Rico 00901
By: JUAN SAAVEDRA-CASTRO, ESQ.
JOSE A. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL, ESQ.
On behalf of defendants and cross-plaintiffs:
BUFETE ROBERTO CORRETJER PIQUER
625 Ponce de León Avenue
San Juan, Puerto Rico 00917-4819
By: PAMELA D. GONZALEZ, ATTORNEY-AT-LAW
ROBERTO J. MORGALO, pro se
Notary-public:
MANUEL SAN JUAN
Also present:
Mr. William Anthony Colón
****************
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 2 of 327
3
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
STIPULATIONS
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Your name, please?
THE REPORTER: Rosiris Miranda Cuadrado.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Do you solemnly swear to
transcribe everything that's asked---
MS. GONZALEZ: Oh, I'm sorry, counsel. I thought your
co-counsel was going to administer the oath. I would certainly
object to your taking the oath
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Excuse me, I'll be---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---of the deponent.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---right back.
You're taking the oath?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'll get someone.
MS. GONZALEZ: Please.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: He's asking the questions. I'm
not going to be asking the questions.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "No, pero" I'll get someone,
I'll get someone.
MS. GONZALEZ: Oh, no, but certainly, you're attorney
of record for Mr. Colón. It's highly improper.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "'Pérate, 'pérate, 'pérate. Tú
me dijiste que... José... Tú no tienes problema que José tome
el juramento."
MS. GONZALEZ: "Sí, si él no iba a hacer las
preguntas."
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 3 of 327
4
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: "O sea, yo pensé que tú ibas a hacer
la... el examen..."
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "No, no, yo no iba a hacer las
pregun..."
MS. GONZALEZ: "...del testigo."
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "No, yo no."
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE NOTARY: On the record, Manuel San Juan, I've been
asked to serve as notary-public for the purposes of swearing in
the witness and the court reporter in this deposition, and I
understand that there will be a stipulation that, once I do so,
I will be discharged from any further---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Attendance in this---
THE NOTARY: ---participation in this deposition.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: That is correct.
MS. GONZALEZ: So stipulated.
THE NOTARY: OK. Very well. So, madame court reporter,
if you will, please, state your full name, raise your right
hand.
THE REPORTER: Rosiris Miranda Cuadrado.
(Whereupon, the notary took the oath of the
reporter.)
THE NOTARY: And the witness, sir, could you, please,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 4 of 327
5
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
raise your right hand and state your full name?
THE DEPONENT: Rubén Blades Vellido de Luna.
(Whereupon, the notary took the oath of the
deponent.)
(Whereupon, the notary was excused.)
Whereupon,
RUBEN BLADES-VELLIDO DE LUNA
having been duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY JOSE A. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL, ESQ.:
Q I know you just stated your name, but just to have a
clean record, could you, please, restate your full name?
A Rubén Blades Vellido de Luna.
Q Mr. Blades, have you ever attended a deposition
before?
A Yes, I have.
Q I said attended, but I meant have you been to a depo-
--? Has someone taken your deposition before?
A Yes, sir.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: So, you know the process. I
will ask some questions, you will provide the answers to the
best of your knowledge.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I would ask you not to guess,
not to speculate. If you don't remember something, you just
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 5 of 327
6
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
don't remember it.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: This is not a test, it's just
an exercise in obtaining facts regarding an incident that we
all know about.
If my questions aren't clear, you can ask me to
clarify them, to restate them, as you wish. If you wish to take
a break for any reason, just let me know, and we'll do it
immediately.
THE DEPONENT: Thank you.
(Pause.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Well, Mr. Blades, do you know a person by the name of
Morgalo?
A Yes.
Q When did you meet Mr. Morgalo?
A I don't quite remember the exact date, but I met him
when he was working with David Maldonado Management.
Q And who is David Maldonado?
A David Maldonado Management is a--- ah--- booking
agency that worked in New York, and that I worked with many
years.
Q Could you estimate the date when you met Mr. Morgalo
for the first time? Let's say, give or take a decade.
A Ninety eighty something.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 6 of 327
7
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. And did you have business dealings with Mr.
Maldonado at---
A Yes---
Q ---that time?
A ---sir.
Q So, Mr. Morgalo---? Did Mr. Morgalo do some work on
your behalf, as an employee of Martínez?
A I believe he did.
Q In the '80s?
A I don't quite remember when it was. But whenever it
was that he worked with David Maldonado, where I met him, he
worked with David, and as a worker within the Maldonado
Management, he worked--- ah--- projects that I was involved
with. I don't quite remember the date.
Q What type of projects were you involved---
A Music projects.
Q ---with back then?
A Music projects, specifically concerts, shows. Music
shows.
Q So, Mr. Maldonado's company would be in charge of
booking concerts for you?
A They would book shows and concerts, yes.
Q OK. The difference between a show and a concert is
the size?
A Ah--- yes, I would say.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 7 of 327
8
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK.
A It's semantics. Music--- music engagements.
Q That's wide enough a term. And---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Argumentative or---?
MS. GONZALEZ: It's not a question. Characterization.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Fine.
Q At that time, were you a--- did you have your own
band?
A It depends, because my--- I can't--- I cannot--- if--
- if---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, no.
THE DEPONENT: David began to work with us--- David---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, no, let's stop. I don't
know, if you appreciate--- Let's go off the record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q You want me to repeat the question, or---?
A The question was whether--- when did he work with my
band, did he manage my band.
Q Did you have a band back then?
A I don't remem--- I--- My band began in 1983-84. If
Mr. Morgalo was not working with David by then, I don't know if
he would have worked with me in that concert. But with
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 8 of 327
9
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Maldonado himself, he also did bookings with--- when I was with
Willy--- ah--- I think he also booked some shows.
Q Maldonado?
A Yes.
Q And when you say when you were with Willy, what was
the nature of that relationship?
A I was working with Willy Colón. We were together in
a band. Willy Colón and Rubén Blades.
Q And it is your testimony that Mr. Maldonado did some
bookings for you and Willy Colón---
A It is my---
Q ---when you were---?
A ---it is my belief that he did, at some point. We
were working with different promoters.
Q So, Mr. Maldonado was not like your regular promoter?
A I never sign a contract of exclusivity with anybody.
Q Now, did it come a time when Mr. Morgalo started his
own company?
A Yes.
Q Do you recall the approximate date when that
occurred?
A It must have been after '84.
Q And did you engage the services of mister---
A Absolutely?
Q ---Morgalo? When you say absolutely---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 9 of 327
10
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A I did.
Q ---were they your main booking agents?
A No. I wasn't sign--- I never signed a contract with
them either.
Q OK. You said that it must have been after 1983, but
you cannot be more precise.
A No, because at the time--- I don't remember when he
did--- ah--- his agency. I--- I would assume that it was after
'84.
Q Do you recall the name of that company?
A Of which company, sir?
Q Of Mr. Morgalo's company.
A Martínez Morgalo.
Q OK. And who is Mr. Martínez?
A Arturo Martínez was his partner.
Q Did Mr. Martínez also work for Maldonado?
A Yes, at one point.
Q And did you meet Mr. Martínez at about the same time
you met Mr. Morgalo?
A Yes.
Q And you also worked with Mr. Martínez through the
Maldonado company?
A Probably.
Q But you don't have any specific recollection?
A Not really, because there were different people. Juan
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 10 of 327
11
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Toro was there--- ah--- they had different secretaries, and I
don't know exactly who was assigned to what.
Q Do you recall the name of a company that---
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. Their company was called Martínez and Morgalo---?
A Martínez Morgalo.
Q Martínez Morgalo. And what did that company do?
A Basically, I think that they did shows. They did---
Actually, they promoted, which was the--- the part that I was
interested in. I don't know what else they did. They probably
did shows, produced shows.
Q When you say they promoted, what does that entail?
A Promoter is known, and perhaps is not the right term,
but it's known as the person who represents the artist in
shows.
Q Would it be accurate to say that the work they would
do is to find people in the different places where you could do
a concert, to have them contract with you, to do a show or a
concert?
A Some do that.
Q What about Mr. Martínez and Morgalo?
A I imagine they also did that. Some wait for the phone
call to come in. That's the advantage of having an office, that
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 11 of 327
12
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
people call there.
Q Because they--- people know that they have access to
the artist?
A That is correct. Or they have had somebody tell them
that they should call there and ask.
Q And you used to use the services of the Martínez---
I mean, the Maldonado company---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and you testified that you also used the services
of Martínez and Morgalo, correct?
A In different times.
Q OK. Did you stop using Maldonado's services and
switched to Martínez and Morgalo?
A More than switch, I think Maldonado sort of took off
a different direction. I'm not sure--- I can't remember if he
was sick then, or if he left, and left Juan, but--- ah--- I
wanted to help Martínez Morgalo more, 'cause they were young.
Q And were they friends of yours, or---?
A Absolutely.
Q And did it come a time where Martínez and Morgalo
would be--if we're going to use the word promoter--your main
promoters?
A Absolutely.
Q Did at any time---? Were they exclusive?
A No.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 12 of 327
13
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q In fact, not--- maybe not---
A No.
Q ---not legally, but---
A No.
Q No?
A No.
Q OK. But you do say that, at some point, they were
your main promoter.
A I did most of my work with them.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to show you a
document dated May 9th, 2000. I want you to look at it---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---and once you're ready, I'll
ask you some questions.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Do you recognize this document?
A Yes, I do.
Q OK. It has your signature?
A "Ese garabato es mío", yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Did you catch that?
THE REPORTER: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
Q And it's on the M&M Associates letterhead, correct?
A Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 13 of 327
14
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q And what is this?
I have to ask you--- You're going to have to answer
in words---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---not in "uh-huhs", because
she can't---
THE DEPONENT: Oh, I'm sorry.
THE REPORTER: You have to verbalize.
THE DEPONENT: Yes, sir.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q What is this document about?
A From what I read, apparently, there was a database
that had someone, which happened frequently, present---
representing themselves as my managers, or something, and
periodically, I would get--- ah--- this type of enquiry, and---
ah--- I guess this is the answer, saying that the only people
that had the authority to represent me are these two.
Q And who is Pollstar Magazine?
A I have no idea.
Q You've no idea. And who is Rubén Blades Productions,
Inc.?
A That is my company.
Q And it has--- it says management. What is the
difference between booking and management?
A The booking, like I said before--you know--managers
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 14 of 327
15
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
determine what you're going to do. That's why I never had a
manager in my life. If I had a manager, I could have not done
all the things that I've done.
Booking means that you're going to be doing shows,
very specific shows. You're not obliged to give them fifteen
percent of everything you make; you're not obliged to consult
with them over film offers; you're not supposed to--- to--- to
have any specific obligation with booking. Booking books. They
call, or they propose to you a show, or somebody calls them.
It's a whole different thing.
Q So---
A The--- the--- Excuse me.
Q Go ahead.
A The word management here is management. But there's
no manage--- I never had a manager.
Q And is Rubén Blades Productions, Inc., a company
owned by you?
A Yes, sir.
Q Solely owned by you?
A As far as I can think of. Maybe my wife had something
to do with it.
Q OK. As of May 9th, 2000, where did you live?
A I'm sorry?
Q As of May 9th, 2000, where did you live?
A In Los Angeles.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 15 of 327
16
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q You've lived in Los Angeles since when?
A First--- ah--- '86.
Q OK. Now, I notice that this--- the first paragraph of
this letter says: "Please, be advised that the information in
the database concerning my representation is incorrect".
A Uh-huh.
Q "Martínez, Morgalo and Associates, Inc., and Rubén
Blades Productions, Inc., are the only companies that have
authority to represent me."
A Uh-huh.
Q You were stating here--were you not?--that Martínez,
Morgalo and Associates and Rubén Blades Productions were the
only companies authorized to represent you.
A What I was saying there is they can speak for me.
Q And whomever appear in their database was wrong?
A I don't know what appeared in their database.
Q OK. Now, I also notice that the address that appears
here for Martínez, Morgalo and Associates is 350 Broadway,
suite 1211---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---New York---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---correct?
A Uh-huh.
Q And it's---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 16 of 327
17
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE REPORTER: Yes?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes, the "uh-huhs" are---
We're going to have to deal with the "uh-huhs".
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You need to say yes.
THE REPORTER: You have to verbalize the answers.
THE DEPONENT: Oh, yes. I apologize.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I know, it happens to
everyone, so don't---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---worry about it.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q And it also appears to be the same address for Rubén
Blades Productions, Inc., correct?
A Yes, it's the same.
Q And is that--- was that a true statement back then?
A That they're both there, yes.
Q And they have the same phone number. Or had the same
phone number?
A Uh-huh.
Q Yes?
A Yes. I'm sorry.
Q And the same fax number.
A Yes.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 17 of 327
18
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. Would it be safe to say that the same person
would answer the phone, both for Rubén Blades Productions and
for Martínez and Morgalo?
A Yes, it would be safe to say.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let the record reflect counsel Saavedra
just passed counsel Hernández Mayoral a note.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: You'd like a copy of it?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Take the same.
MS. GONZALEZ: Counsel, I would like a copy of it.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Sure, but I'm not going to give
it to you.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: I know you would, but I'm not
going to give it to you.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Did Rubén Blades Productions, Inc., have any
employees at 350 Broadway, suite 11, as of May 9th, 2000?
A No.
Q So the people from Martínez and Morgalo would provide
that service to Rubén Blades---
A I think---
Q ---Productions, Inc.?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. What service?
THE DEPONENT: What service?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 18 of 327
19
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, answering the phone.
THE DEPONENT: If somebody called there, I think they
would tell me: "Rubén, somebody called for Rubén Blades
Productions".
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. You didn't have an office, personally.
A I'm surprised it's there, because my business manager
has always been Jerry Shustek. Business manager.
Q Yes, but you did sign this.
A Yes, I'm not discussing that I signed it or not.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "¿Tú lo marcaste o no lo quieres
marcar?"
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Sí." I'm going to mark this
as exhibit 1.
(Whereupon, exhibit 1 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to show you--- I'm
showing you what appears to be a photocopy of a July 22nd,
2000, Billboard Magazine cover---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---and I draw your attention
to the story that says "Innovative Route"--or "Route",
depending on what part of the country you come--for Latino
Tours".
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 19 of 327
20
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And it has the M&M Associates
logo, the same one that's in the letter.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And it says: "New York based
Martínez, Morgalo and Associates, founded by Robert Morgalo and
Arturo Martínez, in association with Rubén Blades---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---is on target to exceed
first year projections by more than one million."
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Do you recall reading this story back then?
A Not really.
Q Is this the first time you see this, or have you seen
it in relation to this case?
A In this case? No. First time I see it.
Q OK. Now, it says here that it was founded by Robert
Morgalo and Arturo Martínez, in association with Rubén Blades.
A Uh-huh.
Q Is that true?
A Depending on what you mean by that. It doesn't say
MM&B---
Q That is right.
A ---so---
Q But this story that appeared--- that apparently
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 20 of 327
21
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
appeared on Billboard Magazine---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---says "in association with Rubén Blades". Did you,
back then, when Martínez and Morgalo were going to start their
own company---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---did you promote the idea that they do that?
A I encouraged them.
Q Encourage. That's the word I was looking for.
A Absolutely.
Q And did they form the company relying on having your
business?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Speculative.
A I have no idea.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q But when you encouraged them to start---
A No.
Q ---to go on their own--- You said you encouraged them
to go---
A Yes, after they said: "We think we should do this".
Q When you encouraged them---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---what was the content of that encouragement?
A I think people who work by themselves do better.
Q Did part of the encouragement include offering them
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 21 of 327
22
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
your business?
A No.
Q But you did, in fact, give them---
A I encou--- I didn't offer them the business
exclusively.
Q That's right, but you--- but---
A "I'll work with you guys."
Q Do you have any idea of why the story would say that
they founded the company in association with you?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, speculative.
A I--- I don't.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q You don't.
A No. Like I said, it doesn't say MM&B.
Q Do you recall what bookings M&M did for you in the
year 2000? I know that's a little far away, but---
A Do I remember? Sir, I really don't.
Q How many concerts and shows would you do in a year,
around that date, around the year 2000?
A I don't know, because I had other things to do, like
films, so--- I didn't work all the time.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to have this marked
as exhibit 2.
(Whereupon, exhibit 2 was marked for the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 22 of 327
23
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q But would you do more than once concert a year?
A Yes.
Q And when I say--- I'm going to say musical
engagement, to use---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---the term that you used.
A I would hope so. More---
Q And would you---
A ---than one.
Q ---do more than five?
A Yes.
Q More than ten?
A Probably. It really depends on the price, on the
amount of the money earned--- earned in the business office---
ah--- film office.
Q Back then---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---say, year 2000, 2001, and 2002---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---what percentage of your bookings were carried out
through Morgalo and--- Martínez and Morgalo?
A I have no idea. Of--- of music business?
Q Yes.
A I don't know.
Q You don't know because you don't remember, or you
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 23 of 327
24
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
don't know because you've never known?
A I've never known. I mean, what percentage?
Q Yes. I mean, the--- They were, according to that
letter signed by you---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---they would do bookings for you.
A Right.
Q And my question is, during the three year period
between--I mean--2000, 2001, and 2002, out of the totality of
musical engagements you had, how many were booked by Martínez,
Morgalo and Associates?
A I don't know, I mean---
Q What percentage?
A I don't know. I don't know what percentage.
Q OK. Do you think it would have been more than fifty
percent?
A Probably.
Q More than seventy five percent?
A I have no idea, sir.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
(Pause.)
Q Did M&M provide any consulting services to you?
A Not that I can recall. Consulting?
Q Yes.
A Not to my recollection.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 24 of 327
25
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q And just to finish this thing about the May 9th
letter, did you pay M&M any fees for identifying your company
with their same address?
A Not that I remember.
Q Who's office was actually located at that address?
A I have no idea. I don't remember. What office? Must
have been them. I have--- I have---
Q M&M's?
A I don't know.
Q OK.
A I guess.
Q But you don't---? You wouldn't pay any fee---
A No.
Q ---any rent?
A No.
Q OK. Mr. Blades, did Martínez, Morgalo and Associates
obtain an engagement contract for a concert by you in Puerto
Rico for September of 2002?
I'm going to show you--- Now, let me show you---
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: I don't remember seeing this.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I am showing you a
document that has a Martínez, Morgalo and Associates name and
address at the top---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 25 of 327
26
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---it's titled "Engagement
contract", it has a 17th September, 2002, date, and it's
unsigned, it's two page document, and it---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: It was produced by---?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: By Martínez.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, I---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes, this means it was produced
by Rubén Blades.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. It was produced by your
attorney during discovery in this case---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---I believe, and it makes
reference to a concert on November 23rd, 2002, once concert
performance at the Coliseo Rubén Rodríguez.
Q Do you recall that?
A No.
Q You don't recall playing there that day?
A No.
Q You have no recollection about this event---
A No.
Q ---or the details surrounding it? Whether it got
canceled, whether it was held---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, compound.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 26 of 327
27
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Whether it was canceled?
A I said no. Do I remember this? No.
Q Remember receiving a payment for this concert?
A No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to mark it as
exhibit 3.
(Whereupon, exhibit 3 was marked for the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Now, Mr. Blades, have you ever had a canceled
concert, or a concert canceled?
A Sure.
Q Let's say, on account of the promoter canceling the
concert. Has that happened to you?
A Probably.
Q OK. What is your customary practice when that
happens, in terms of any deposit that might have been paid to
you?
A Depends what the scenarios are.
Q Have you ever returned money given to you when a
concert gets canceled?
A I don't recall. Probably. Or not. I don't know. I
don't---
Q You don't know?
A ---remember that. No.
Q When was the last time you had a concert canceled?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 27 of 327
28
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Over five years ago. That's for sure.
Q OK. And you don't recall whether you have had to
return money or not?
A I didn't really have many concerts canceled by me.
Q I don't mean by you. I mean by the other side.
A I have not--- What other side?
Q Well, the promoter; the person who's engaging you for
the concert.
A Not many. I don't remember having concerts canceled.
Q OK.
A Specifically.
Q Now, Mr. Blades, you know that we are here regarding
a concert that you did with Mr. Willy Colón, correct?
A Yes, sir.
Q Do you recall when that concert was held?
A With all this, it's--- ah--- It was in--- in 2003.
Q OK. To the best of recollection how did the idea of
doing that concert originate?
A They called me.
Q You mean Mr. Morgalo?
A Uh-huh.
Q You said they. Martínez and Morgalo?
A The agency.
Q They called you and said what?
A "There's a great concert, great idea for a concert,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 28 of 327
29
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
and we spoke to some promoters in Puerto Rico, and they're
offering a lot of money to do this concert with Willy Colón and
you." Siembra, or whatever.
Q OK. Did they say that it was their idea, or it was
the idea of some promoters in Puerto Rico?
A I don't recall them explaining who's idea was. They
just said: "There's a tremendous chance here, it's a lot of
money to do this concert".
Q That would have been like a significant date with
regards to Siembra, right?
A So they said.
Q Was like the 20th anniversary, or something like
that?
A I don't remember.
Q And so, they called you, and they said that, and what
did you tell them?
A No.
Q That you weren't interested?
A Right.
Q And what happened next?
A What happened next is that they called me again.
Q Mr. Morgalo and---? Martínez and Morgalo?
A I can't remember who, who it was
Q But it was---
A Or--- or---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 29 of 327
30
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---from the agency?
A ---or Willy called me. Huh?
Q It was from the---? OK., go ahead. You don't remember
who it was?
A First time, I said no.
Q Why did you say no?
A Why?
Q Yes.
A I didn't need the money, I was involved in like three
films, and working in another one, I had an album, Mundo, that
I was about to release, and I thought it was stupid to do that
concert with my album coming out. I had--- ah--- I really
didn't have any reason, because we had already done the '93
concert, and I felt like--you know--we're going to go back and
play the same things again---
Q OK. So then, you recall--- Again, you don't recall
who called you?
A No. I think maybe Willy called me. I think they
called him.
Q After speaking to you?
A Right.
Q And he might have thought it was a good idea?
A Yes.
Q And did it come a time when you said: "Yes, I'll do
the concert"?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 30 of 327
31
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A I spoke to him about it, and he gave me his reasons.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let the record reflect the witness is
pointing to Mr. Colón.
THE DEPONENT: Willy gave me his reasons, which I
calibrated, and then, I said OK.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q And when you said OK., what happened?
A No, the thing continued moving. The process continued
through the office, M&M.
Q OK. Who is Arturo?
A I'm sorry?
Q Arturo. Who is Arturo?
A Arturo Martínez?
Q Yes. I mean, if I said Arturo in the context of this
case, you would think it's Mr. Martínez?
A In the context of this meeting?
Q Of this concert, of the---
A Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I'm going to show you a
document.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It's a document in Spanish, it
has a handwritten date of January 21, 2003, to someone referred
to as Arturo, and it's unsigned, but it has two names at the
end, Ariel Rivas and César Sainz. Once you have a chance of
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 31 of 327
32
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
looking through it, I'll ask you some questions.
(Long pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q You've seen it?
A Yes.
Q Do you know who Ariel Rivas and César--- who Ariel
Rivas is?
A Absolutely
Q Who is he?
A He's a promoter.
Q And César Sainz?
A He's also a promoter.
Q A promoter based in Puerto Rico?
A I think so, yes. I don't know if they still are, but
I think they were then.
Q And Arturo, you would say is Arturo Martínez?
A Yes, sir. I would think so.
Q Based on the content of the document, it would seem
that it's addressed at Arturo Martínez, correct?
A Right.
Q And it says, in the first paragraph, that this is in
reference to a May 3rd concert, correct?
A Aha.
Q And the May 3rd--- That was the date of a concert
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 32 of 327
33
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
that you---
A Yes.
Q ---did with Mr. Colón, correct?
A Right. Yes.
Q So, even though the date here is handwritten, we at
least know, from the context, that this is a 2003 document,
because it says: "On May 3rd of this year".
A Where does it say that?
Q The same--- The first sentence.
A Aha. Yes.
Q And they're talking about starting the promotion on
February the 3rd, correct? The next paragraph.
A Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Now, I want you to look at
the bottom third of the document, where it says Arturo, and
then, it has some bullets.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: First, bullet says: "We've
been working on the possibility of presenting Rubén in Puerto
Rico since 2001---".
Q Are you aware of that?
A No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---where we made the first
approach to Rubén, personally, in Los Angeles".
Q You don't remember that? During the Grammies. A
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 33 of 327
34
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Grammy thing for Paul Simon.
A I remember the--- Paul Simon. I don't remember them
talking to me. People come and talk to you about all kinds of
things. I don't---
Q And that wouldn't be something that you would
particularly remember?
A No, why would I?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, the second bullet says:
"We have complied with the corresponding deposits---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---for the Rubén show---"
"puntualmente" meaning "on time", I guess---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---when you have requested it.
"Given the case that you already have the first sixty two
thousand five hundred dollars that we sent several months ago."
Q Do you recall that?
A No.
Q Is it your testimony that you have no recollection
that, let's say---
A Never.
Q ---assuming that this state is correct, that as of
January 21, 2003, César Sainz and Ariel Rivas were stating that
they had already---
A No.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 34 of 327
35
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---given a sixty two thousand five hundred dollar
deposit?
A Absolutely not.
Q And that they had been working for a year and a half
on this project?
A On the Siembra thing? I don't know what---
Q I can't---
A ---that means.
Q I don't know. It says: "on this project"; "to make
this project a reality".
A I have no idea---
Q OK.
A ---what he means by that.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Then, the last--- the last---
OK. The last bullet on that page says: "We're sure that we can
find a favorable solution for everybody".
Q Do you recall any conflicts regarding the contract---
the engagement---
A Not from---
Q ---on the early part of 2003?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
A No.
MS. GONZALEZ: The engagement.
THE DEPONENT: I think that they're talking about---
from what I see in this paper, about the Salsa, Día de la
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 35 of 327
36
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Salsa. That's what I think they're talking about. They seem to
be complaining that there's going to be--- that I'm going to do
Día de la Salsa, and that's going to clash with the date of
their concert. That's what I think they're talking about.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: I don't have any idea about what he
means, or what Arturo said, or--- You know, I don't know
what--- what it is.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Because on the second page, they're talking about how
to promote the concert, right? The Rubén and Willy concert. The
top two proposals.
A I'm--- I'm very sorry. I don't--- I didn't get that.
Q You're saying that you think they're talking about
the conflict between El Día Nacional de la Salsa and---
A Only responding to what you said. "Estamos seguros de
que podemos encontrar una solución favorable para todos." I
don't know what he means, other than maybe he's talking about
appear--- He says: "Es para nosotros de suma importancia
comenzar la promoción, por lo menos, tres meses anti...
anticipación..." eh... "y respetamos los lazos que unen a Rubén
con el Día Nacional de la Salsa y disfrutamos..." blah, blah,
blah, "sin embargo, la posibilidad de que Rubén se presente
nuevamente este año conflige con la promoción."
"Y me imagino que es eso."
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 36 of 327
37
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. So they talk---
A I have no idea.
Q OK.
A I'm just saying, from what this paper means, you're
asking me?
Q You were not told by Mr. Martínez or Mr. Morgalo, at
this point in time, January 21, 2003, that César Sainz and
Rivas had stated they already paid sixty two thousand five
hundred dollars?
A No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I'll have this marked as
the next exhibit.
(Whereupon, exhibit 4 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to show you another
document. It's stapled.
And my first question would be--- And they have
consecutive Bates numbers. "Eso es de ella, ¿verdad?"
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Bueno, nosotros se lo pusimos,
pero pones así."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I think they go together, but
if they don't--- if you don't think they go together---
THE DEPONENT: I have no--- no clue.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I would like to have you look
at it, and after you've gone over it, I'll ask you some
questions.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 37 of 327
38
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. The first page is a document on the M&M
Associates letterhead, dated January 22nd, 2003, addressed to
César Sainz and Ariel Rivas, it says: "Reference Rubén Blades
and Willy Colón", and it's signed by Arturo Martínez.
Q Do you recognize Mr. Martínez's signature?
A No.
Q 'Cause you've never seen it before, or---?
A Do I recognize it? No.
Q Yes. But you don't--- You wouldn't say that this is
not his signature? That's---
A I cannot say it is---
Q OK.
A ---either. I don't know.
Q OK. And it says: "Based on our conversations, I
confirm the date of May the 3rd, 2003, for the exclusive
presentation of Rubén Blades and Willy Colón at the Hiram
Bithorn Stadium in Puerto Rico". Correct?
A Uh-huh. I'm sorry, yes.
Q And that would be a correct statement, right? That
date was confirmed in that venue, for that venue.
A There was---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 38 of 327
39
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: Yes. The statement that I can confirm
to you is that the concert was realized, it happened on the 3rd
of May, with Willy Colón, in--- at the Bithorn---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: In---
THE DEPONENT: ---in Puerto Rico.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. In the usual course of the business of musical
engagements, would this be a document that is generated at some
point in time?
A I'm sorry, sir?
Q In the music business---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---when dealing with musical engagements---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is this the type of document that is generated at
some point in time? The confirmation of the booking.
A It's the first time I hear of somebody signing a
document confirming a date.
Q And are you saying that it is unusual, or are you
saying that you just don't know---
A I've---
Q ---whether this---
A ---never seen---
Q ---is the way---?
A ---it before it happened.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 39 of 327
40
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Yes, but the question is: do you think--- do you find
this unusual, or is it---?
A Yes, I do.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Let's take a look at the
second page.
THE DEPONENT: I did.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. It says "contract offer".
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q You know what this document is about?
A I imagine it is--- I can--- I can see that it has
the--- ah--- the points of the concert, except the name of the
artist, they inverted the usual. It should have read Willy
Colón and Rubén Blades.
Q Why would that be?
A Because that's the way it's always been.
Q Ah, it's a historical, traditional thing? Because
that's---
A It's a dif---
Q ---that's the way it started?
A It's a difference to Willy.
Q And--- But my question was: what is this document
about?
A I would imagine these are the points, the--- the
specific points about the show; when it was going to be held,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 40 of 327
41
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
how much money was going to be paid--- ah--- offered by these
people, the promoters, and--- ah--- they offered three fifty,
plus sound and lights.
Q And---
A All inclusive.
Q And is this an accurate statement of what you
considered the deal to be?
A Yes, sir. We had to pay for everything, except for
sound and lights.
Q And is this document a document that is typically
generated in this type of business?
A This? Yes. This type of thing, yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I will have it marked as
the next exhibit.
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 5.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Exhibit 5.
(Whereupon, exhibit 5 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'll show you another
document.
Let's look at it, and when you're done looking at it,
I'll ask you some questions.
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, this is---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 41 of 327
42
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: Ah, yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You've seen it. OK. This is a
two page document, it says Martínez, Morgalo and Associates at
the top, it has a title--- it's titled "Engagement contract",
has a date on the first paragraph, 22nd day of January, 2003,
and the second page has signature lines, although it doesn't
have a signature. Dissar, D-i-s-s-a-r, Production, Ariel Rivas,
with a Caguas address, and on the other side, it says Martínez,
Morgalo and Associates, FSO Rubén Blades and Willy Colón, and
on the bottom, it says Arturo Martínez, agent.
Q Have you seen this document before?
A Probably. I don't remember it, but probably I--- I
did. It doesn't surprise me.
Q Is this the typical format of an engagement contract
for a---
A Yes.
Q ---show? And again, it mentions the name of the
artist, Rubén Blades and Willy Colón, you said that was
inverted, was--- but it's in reference to the concert that was
held on May 3rd?
A Say that again, I'm sorry.
Q OK. It's says--- it identifies you and Mr. Colón as
the artist---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and it identifies the engagement date as May 3rd,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 42 of 327
43
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
2003, correct?
A Yes.
Q And the amount to be paid would be three hundred and
fifty thousand dollars.
A Right.
Q Now, I want you to look at number 7---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---where it says how the payments would be made by
the employer.
A Right.
Q First deposit in the amount of sixty two thousand
five hundred dollars, received April 2002. Do you know what
that is a reference to?
A You know what I think? I think they were two
different papers issued, and this one was done after.
Q After the first one?
A I would think, because if I had seen that, I would
have asked.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Let's mark that one--- I'm
going to show you the--- another document, but let's mark that,
let's put a number to it. It would be exhibit?
MS. GONZALEZ: 6.
THE REPORTER: 6.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Exhibit 6. I'll hand it back
to you.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 43 of 327
44
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
In the meantime, I'm going to show you this one.
(Whereupon, exhibit 6 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., exhibit 6. And I want you
to look a the other one---
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: Is this one 6a, 6b? 7?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, we're going to do it 7,
but after he has looked through it.
OK. Let me mark the other one, before I ask you
questions, so that we don't get confused; so we can make
reference to numbers.
(Whereupon, exhibit 7 was marked for the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK., Mr. Blades, you said--- Looking at exhibit 6---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---you stated that---
A This is exhibit 6? 6?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes. You thought--- "A la
izquierda. El que está abajo, a la izquierda..."
THE DEPONENT: "Oh, perdón."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "...es el de esta deposición."
Q That you thought that there was another one, and
that this was--- this one was done after?
A If I see--- I remember being surprised by the fact,
when we were arguing--and I'm going ahead--about the
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 44 of 327
45
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
deposits---
Q You're going ahead in time?
A Yes.
Q You're going to after the concert in time, or are you
going---?
A No, before, when we were---
Q Before the concert? OK.
A We're trying to determine if the guys had paid or
not.
Q OK.
A The fact that they were saying they had paid this
money, and I said that's not true, because I was told that they
had not paid. This is money that was owed.
Q OK.
A So the fact that this showed up at all, as an
advance, was something that I have in my--- in my brain,
because we never got that money.
Q OK. Let me backtrack a little bit, so I can---
A So---
Q ---sort this out---
A I'm sorry. So---
Q ---sort this out. I showed you what's been marked
exhibit 7---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---prompted by your reaction that there was another
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 45 of 327
46
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
document that didn't have that advance.
A It's very obvious to me that, if I see this---
Q You're looking at exhibit 6, yes.
A ---exhibit 6, saying: "first deposit in the amount of
sixty two thousand five hundred dollars, received April, 2002",
there's something wrong---
Q But you---
A ---right away.
Q OK. But did you see this document, exhibit 6, before
the concert?
A I'm sorry?
Q Did you see this document before the concert?
A Which one? The 6?
Q Yes, the 6.
A I don't recall that, seeing it before--- That
document itself, no. I don't remember seeing it before.
Q OK., but you did mention, a few minutes ago, that
before the concert, there was a controversy as to whether the--
- what they call here the employer---
A Monies had been paid.
Q Had been paid.
A Uh-huh.
Q And did at that point the issue of them claiming that
they had already paid sixty two thousand five hundred dollars
arise?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 46 of 327
47
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A That's correct.
Q And they were saying that they had paid that back in
2002?
A At some point. Remember that everything came in--- in
a matter--- hours, days; two, three days, all this information.
Personally, I thought they were not being truthful.
Q They meaning who?
A The promoter. I didn't think that they had paid.
Q You mean Rivas and Sainz?
A Right. I thought that they were--- You know, for
whatever reasons, promoters do that. They tell you they paid,
and they're--- they're holding back, or whatever. I didn't
think that there was going to be anything wrong, that "I feel
they're going to pay, they're just late", or something. But---
Because I kept asking the office: "What's going on? Is the
money coming?" When---?" "Well, they're taking long--you know--
but--- blah, blah---"
Q When you say the office, you're referring to what?
A Martínez Morgalo.
Q OK.
A So, all of a sudden, I get a call from the newspaper
here, a guy who--you know--writes for a newspaper here, and I
said to him: "I don't know if this is going to happen, because
we haven't gotten paid". Then, he printed something, and that
made the people over here react. And then, they started saying:
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 47 of 327
48
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
"No, they paid", and then, they talked to somebody that I know,
who called me, and said: "These people are good people".
And that's when we started, then, finding out what
had really happened. And including, in the conversations during
that period, came out this thing, which really was a stunner.
Q When you say---
A When they first said something about having paid
already sixty two thousand, because I said: "Where's the money?
You know, where's this money?" And they said: "No we paid that
a while ago, because we had a canceled show, and then, we
applied this money to this", and I said: "What canceled show?
What are you talking about?"
Q Going back to exhibit 3--I'm going to show it to you
again--you mentioned earlier that you didn't recall whether
that concert took place or didn't take place.
A Ecuador?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Ecuador?
MS. GONZALEZ: Uh-huh.
(Pause.)
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Which exhibit number do you
have?
THE DEPONENT: 3.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: 3?
THE DEPONENT: Now you're really confusing.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, well, let me see that.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 48 of 327
49
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Maybe I'm confusing myself. Where do you say Ecuador?
THE DEPONENT: "Allá abajo." The money has to be paid
before leaving.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Oh, you're talking about---
Because it's a concert for Rubén Rodríguez Coliseum, right?
THE DEPONENT: "Pero aquí abajo dice: `Artist must
receive payment in full thirty days prior to departure for the
Ecuador'."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm trying to find--- ah---
Oh, I see.
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry. It's point 7.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I see, I see.
Q Well, would you have had a concert in Ecuador before
the concert in Puerto Rico? Could that be a reference to that?
A I don't remember, sir.
Q OK. Do you have a file with your---
A Proba---
Q ---where you---
A Didn't we---?
Q ---have your musical engagements?
A Me, personally, a file? No. But---
Q I mean, if you had to reconstruct where you played,
when---
A I would have to ask my--- my business office, and we
could, maybe, check through---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 49 of 327
50
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Maybe his questions are better posed to
Mr. Morgalo, or his partner, Arturo Martínez. They can explain
the document.
THE DEPONENT: But maybe---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It could be, but--- but---
THE DEPONENT: ---tax returns---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---I--- I---
MR. MORGALO: Can I take a look at---? Can I have a
copy of that, sir, to take a look at it?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You do have a copy.
MR. MORGALO: Well, I don't.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes, but---
MR. MORGALO: Oh, number 3 you said? Oh, number 3.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes. But---
THE DEPONENT: November 23rd---
MR. MORGALO: This one?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: But now that we've come to the
point where you're stating that you were told---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry, sir?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm just trying to sort things
out.
THE DEPONENT: I know.
THE DEPONENT: So are we.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You know, we're trying to---
THE DEPONENT: Understand
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 50 of 327
51
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---to get all the facts---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: First, understand. Firstly,
understand.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q I think you just stated that, at some point before
the concert---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---a controversy arose as to whether Rivas and Sainz
had paid in full.
A "Así es."
Q And they were claiming that they had paid sixty two
thousand five hundred dollars---
A Let me--- Can I expand on that?
Q Yes, sure, sure.
A When the issue arose---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let's go off the record for a
second.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE DEPONENT: When the issue arose about whether
these people had made the--- these people meaning the
promoters, had made the payments or not, they began to submit--
- I think they did it very quickly, 'cause we were supposed to-
-- I was supposed to rehearse with Willy on the--- on the
Wednesday before leaving--on Thursday I think we were supposed
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 51 of 327
52
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
to leave--and then, we were supposed to have a press conference
on Friday, and then, we had to play on Saturday.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: I think that's the way it was. So, I
didn't go to the rehearsal, because I'm waiting from the papers
from these guys. They had to tell me--- you know, send me all
this stuff. And this all happened because of a woman here that
I trusted, her name is Tuti Bou, and she works for Sony. And
Tuti called me, and said: "Rubén, I read the paper, these guys
are good people, they're serious people, and they're saying---
they showed me stuff", and I said: "Well, show it to me. I want
to see that."
Within that explanation, within the scope of all
that, there was a mention of the sixty--- Because I started
adding up. And I said: "You know, we're missing, not just the
last payment", or whatever it was that they were supposed to
make, and didn't make, or--- or didn't show, but there was this
other figure, and I said: "What is---" you know, "What is this
about?" And then, the claim was: "No, no, that was given"--you
know--"in advance, a concert you were supposed to do, and
canceled, that money was applied to that show". And then, I
thought--- I remember I called my office to try to check and
see--you know--if they have any remember--- if--- remember this
thing. And it was like in, to this date, we don't know what
that was.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 52 of 327
53
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q But they did show that they had sent Martínez and
Morgalo six--- that money at---
A There was---
Q ---some point?
A ---something. I mean, I gave all those papers that I
received. I gave---
Q Yes.
A ---them all. So, proba--- most likely, it had to be
there, because they had their stuff very well documented, I
have to say. Those guys were very clean, I mean, everything was
there. So, I--- I can't--- ah--- confirm it, but I would think
that it wasn't just that they said they sent it--you know--
because they can talk whatever they want. I--- I'm pretty sure
I must have seen something that convinced me they had, in fact,
sent that money. Otherwise, you know---
Q Now, to the best of your recollection, did you ever
agree to perform on Coliseo Rubén Rodríguez on November of
2002?
A No, not that I remember at all. I don't remember
that--- that--- that date.
Q OK.
A What--- what concert was it?
Q Well, the one that--- on exhibit 3, the one that---
A No, but I mean---
Q ---says that you have---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 53 of 327
54
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A ---why---?
Q ---to be paid before you left for Ecuador.
A I--- I have to say I don't remember.
Q But it could have happened?
A I think it could be checked, if I ever played here.
I think that's something that should be on the record.
Q Well, I think what--- I think the fact is that you
didn't play here. What I'm---
A Oh.
Q What I'm trying to--- On that day. What I'm trying to
ask you is whether you recall---
A No, I don't.
Q ---doing this engagement, and then, getting a deposit
for it---
A No, no, no, no. No. Not at all.
Q Is it your best recollection that no such thing ever
happened?
A No. Yes.
Q OK. Now, going back to exhibit 6 and 7---
A But whether or not I played, it's something that
could be checked. I don't recall ever playing this show.
Q But you do recall Mr. Sainz and Mr. Rivas saying:
"Well, the thing is we had sent sixty two thousand five hundred
dollars---"
A Only---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 54 of 327
55
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q "---for a concert at---".
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Misquoting the witness.
THE DEPONENT: Yes. Only--- only in terms of the
explanation they did when they felt that we were going to
cancel because they hadn't paid.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, I agree. That's the basis
of my question.
THE DEPONENT: Basically---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: They were claiming that.
THE DEPONENT: But I--- I'm saying I con--- I think I
must have seen something, because when I was adding up this
stuff, there were sixty two whatever--- no--- They didn't come
up. So where is this? This is--- This was a question also that,
in the press conference, I talked about it.
In the press conference, I talked several times about
the fact that I had been surprised about the fact that there
were sixty two five hundred thousand dollars that these guys
were saying that they had sent to the office. I said: "Where
was that? Did we ever receive that money? No, we didn't receive
that money."
And again, I see this thing you have over here,
saying that the money was sent in April, 2002, and that was a
re--- a huge red flag, if I had seen that. To say: "Where---
where did that money come from, that sixty two?" They would
have to explain to me where did the money come---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 55 of 327
56
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
And fir--- And let me say something else for the
record. Would have been dishonest with him, because then, that
means that he would have gotten screwed out of sixty two
thousand dollars.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let the record reflect---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry, Willy.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---the deponent pointed to Mr. Colón.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let's go back to 6 and 7. On
exhibit 7, which is a copy of an engagement contract, in
similar format to exhibit 6, except for what we've been
discussing about number 7, which says--- On exhibit 7, it says
that the payments would be made in the following manner: first
deposit in the amount of sixty two thousand five hundred
dollars due immediately---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---and--you know--the second
deposit in the amount of eighty seven thousand five hundred
dollars---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---due March 22nd 2003---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---third deposit in the amount
of eighty seven thousand five hundred dollars, US dollars, due
April 1st, 2003, and the balance of a hundred and twelve
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 56 of 327
57
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
thousand five hundred dollars shall be paid no later than April
22nd, 2003.
Q Is that---? Does that reflect your understanding of
what the deal was?
A I have to say I don't remember specifically this, but
I--- it looks fine to me.
Q And when you compare that to--- Well, strike that. Do
you recall how the payments were actually received?
A No. But I remember, when I spoke to these guys about-
-- Because I'm very much a stickler--you know--I like to get my
money paid in advance, I want it paid in the--- in the times.
Promoters usually don't do that.
And then, you're faced with the problem if having
received some money, the guys are selling the tickets, and
then, they don't pay when they're supposed to pay, if you
cancel, you're going to hurt a lot of people on that, so you
figure always end up giving them a little more rope, you know?
Q And they know that?
A They probably do know that, but in this particular
issue, the promoter said that the terms had been changed by the
office.
Q Meaning Martínez and Morgalo?
A Correct. I thought--- That they were going to--- You
know, I don't know. It--- What was a new arrangement, because
I--- I was on top of the thing: "Where's the money? Where's the
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 57 of 327
58
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
money? Where's the money?", after we got all the information of
what had happened after the thing came out in the paper, after
they were like--- you know---
Q What was your agreement with Willy Colón with regards
to this concert?
A Half and half of whatever it was after expenses.
Q And what about the duties of each?
A I'm sorry?
Q The duties.
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, vague.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Well, what---?
A Base---
Q Besides playing---
A No, basically--- No.
Q Or what else---? Was there a distribution of tasks?
A He was going to--- he was going to be looking after
the music, and what not, and I'm going to be after the office,
telling them: "Where's the money? Did the money come in? How
you got---? What's going on? What's happening?" That sort of
thing.
Q And you were going to split the proceeds?
A After taking out all the expenses.
Q And what would the expenses be?
A I--- At the end, it was like---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 58 of 327
59
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q No, I'm not talking about the amounts. What---
A I'm sorry---
Q ---would be---
A Oh.
Q ---in terms of categories; what were the---?
A Hotels, band, the cost of the band "per diem", air
travel, food, rehearsal---
Q And who would pay for that initially?
A We would.
Q What? Who is we?
A Willy and I.
Q I mean, would you write checks, fifty fifty, or---?
A The company would write the checks.
Q What company would write the checks?
A I'm sorry. Martínez Morgalo would pay--you know--give
out the advance for the rehearsal, the studio, whatever was
needed.
Q Let me follow the money flow here.
A Uh-huh.
Q Pursuant to whichever contract is the one that
Martínez Morgalo and the promoters had, the money would be paid
to whom?
A Martínez Morgalo's office.
Q They would receive, presumably, the checks in---
according to the schedule that's in the contract?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 59 of 327
60
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Correct.
Q And they would pay the expenses before paying you
guys?
A Absolutely.
Q And where would that---? When would they---? When
were they supposed to pay you two?
A I think after the gig.
Q OK. And you---?
A After the show.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Aha. I think everybody got
that.
(Pause.)
Q And you would be informed by Mr. Martínez or Mr.
Morgalo as to whether money had come in?
A Right.
Q OK. So, before the concert---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---you're saying that, in the days, few days prior to
the concert, you thought the promoter had not paid in full?
A I thought several things. One thing I thought was the
money was there. I mean, I--- I--- I had no reason not to
believe the money wasn't there. First of all, I never had this
happen to me before. One.
Two, it was too big a concert.
Three, these guys--- You know, I didn't have any
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 60 of 327
61
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
reason to believe they weren't going to pay, being that it was
such a notorious type of--- of--- of show. It wasn't like some
show. It was like Willy Colón and myself, in Puerto Rico,
Siembra. "O sea", you know, they're going to pay. Of course
they're going to pay. So, that's one issue.
The other thing was I was told--you know--"They
haven't come, the money `todavía no llega', they're delaying,
`blah, blah, blah'---" You know, so I figured--- That has
happened before.
Q Who's saying that to you? Mr. Morgalo, or Mr.
Martínez?
A The office--- ah---
Q The office meaning M&M?
A Yes.
Q So, you were told by M&M, before the concert, that
they were--- some money hadn't come in?
A That is correct, 'cause I'm seeing the date
approaching, I got a--- You know, I got to--- we got to--- I
got to look after ours--- Then, I'm saying: "What---?" You
know, how's things happening, what's happening with the thing--
-
Q Do you know---
A ---with the money.
Q ---who--- And by that, I mean whether it's the
office, or the promoter in Puerto Rico---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 61 of 327
62
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q ---who drafts the documents that have being marked
exhibit 3, 6, and 7?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Speculative.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q No, do you know?
A No---
Q That's not---
A ---I don't.
Q ---speculative.
A No, I frankly don't.
Q You don't know if this is something that's referred
by M&M?
A This--- this, I would think it's M&M. It has the
thing upstairs. It says--- ah--- on the top, it says Martínez,
Morgalo and Associates.
Q OK. So, if you look at exhibit 6---
A Uh-huh.
Q No, strike--- Well, if you look at exhibit 6---
A It also says that.
Q This is not signed. Is it customary for these
documents not to be physically signed?
A It depends at times. I think it--- it--- it is
customary, because they're acting on our behalf, so, they sign
for--- for us.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 62 of 327
63
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q You don't sign the---?
A No. I don't remember ever signing a contract. So, for
that matter---
Q So, there is an element of trust involved?
A Absolutely.
Q Now---
A With then, every promoter. I mean, it used to be the
same thing with Mercado, God bless him, or whomever, you know.
I don't remember--- I don't remem--- I'm not saying it never
happened, but--- ah--- I don't remember sitting down--- Unless
there was a press thing.
Q OK., based on what you know now---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---did the promoters actually--- had actually paid
those sixty two thousand five hundred dollars?
A I still, to this day, don't know what happened there.
I trust that they did, but--- ah--- frankly--- I mean, I would
think they did. You know, remember that--- remember that
they're saying they paid this in advance. They paid this for a
concert that was canceled. And then, they applied the
cancellation money to the--- as an advance for this show. Since
I never saw the contract, and never received a penny from those
sixty two thousand five hundred, I don't know if that was true
or false. I would assume that it was true, that what they said
was real, given the context of what happened.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 63 of 327
64
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q To this date, you don't know if M&M contracted with
these promoters for a Rubén Blades concert in 2002 without you
knowing about it?
A Absolutely.
Q You have no---? You don't---?
A No. And as a matter of fact, and maybe I should
mention it also, in the internet, there were--- I'm not a real
internet person--- ah--- but there were rumors about other
shows, of people complaining that they had sent advances--you
know--so I don't--- I don't know--you know--I really don't
know. For shows that never happened.
Q OK.
A So, I really--- I'm not at liberty to say, but---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now---
(Pause.)
Q OK. Did you---? Do you recall booking--- having any
other concerts booked by Martínez and Morgalo in 2002 period?
A Frankly, no, because remember, I was doing movies,
so---
Q You don't recall ever receiving money from Martínez
and Morgalo on account of canceled concerts?
A No.
Q And your testimony was--I don't have it clear--as to
exhibit 6, the one that talks about a payment having been made-
-- received, actually, on April, 2002, you don't recall having
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 64 of 327
65
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
seen this before---
A No, sir.
Q ---the concert?
A Before which concert?
Q Before your concert with Willy.
A Oh, no. This, no.
Q No?
A No.
Q OK.
A Unless--excuse me--you mean in the days before the
concert?
Q Yes.
A I don't remember, but I--- like I said, they sent me
a lot of papers justifying that--- the fact that they had sent
this, and they had done that--you know--so, I don't know. I
may--- If I saw it two, three days before--- But had I seen it
before, no.
Q Did you---?
A Before that moment, no. It would have called my
attention to see something with a 2002 date.
Q But you do recall having been told by a reporter, or
by--- By a reporter?
A By a friend, by a friend. Tuti Bou.
Q No, I think---
A Oh, I'm sorry.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 65 of 327
66
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q I know where the confusion comes, and maybe it's my
confusion. By a reporter who showed you the payments.
A No.
Q That was Tuti Bou?
A No. Tuti Bou---
Q Tuti Bou told you they were serious people.
A Tuti Bou told me: "They are serious people, I had
seen the receipts".
Q Very well.
A And I said: "Tuti, I trust you, but I--- You know,
you--- I got--- I have to see it myself." And then, they sent
them to me. I don't remember if it was by fax, or by FedEx,
which is why I couldn't go to the rehearsal. I was waiting for
the papers to arrive, so I could look at them, and--- and---
and--- and then, be able to tell Willy something, because I
wasn't sure what the heck was going on.
So, we ended up--- ended up talking to Willy, if I'm
not wrong, that Wednesday night, or in the morning--- ah--- of
the--- of the Thursday, when we talked to the lawyer, you know?
Q Did at any point---? Prior to the concert, once this
incident about payments arises--- arose---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---did you ever contact Mr. Morgalo and Mr. Martínez
to enquire about this allegation regarding the sixty---
A Absolutely---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 66 of 327
67
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---two thousand---?
A ---tried. I called the office, and I could not get
Arturo anywhere. Or--- ah--- Robert wasn't there, so---
Q He was in Afghanistan, I think, or---
A It was not---
MR. MORGALO: Iraq.
THE DEPONENT: As far as I understood---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Iraq.
THE DEPONENT: ---he was not in there, in the office,
at that moment.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let the record reflect that attorney
Saavedra and plaintiff, Mr. Colón, have stepped outside of the
conference room.
THE DEPONENT: And--- ah---
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK., so you couldn't reach Mr. Martínez?
A I couldn't reach the o--- In the office, nobody
answered the phone. Let's put it that way. I called, and
called, and called, and called.
Q And was that unusual?
A Ah--- yes, it was. Very unusual.
Q All right. How many people worked there, if you know?
A I don't recall, but--- ah--- I think they had a
secretary. They had somebody else. A lot of the stuff--- I
think they started going through--- You know, maybe they had
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 67 of 327
68
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
some problems--- ah--- But I--- I think there was--- there
were--- The two of them worked there, physically involved, and-
-- ah--- and then, I think there was a secretary, I--- I think.
Q And you couldn't even reach the secretary?
A There was nobody. No one. I remember I called Juan
also, to ask what happened.
Q Juan?
A Juan Toro.
Q OK. Who is Juan Toro?
A Juan Toro used to work with David Maldonado, and---
and when they were working there, Juan assigned both Roberto
and Arturo to work with me, 'cause I--- you know, I--- I've
seen--- you know, I--- I was not--- ah--- Sometimes, I could be
hard, and--- ah---
MS. GONZALEZ: Let the record reflect that attorney
Saavedra and plaintiff have just returned---
THE DEPONENT: And---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---to the room.
THE DEPONENT: ---and--- ah--- they--- ah--- You know,
they felt I'd go. They know Rubén and they know his quirks and
his stuff, so--you know--they assigned them to me. That's how
I actually began to work with them.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to show you another
document.
(Pause.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 68 of 327
69
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Take a look at it. I believe
it's identical to exhibit 7, except for some handwritten notes,
and the fact that it bears a fax thing on the top. But in terms
of the content---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---I believe it's the same.
THE DEPONENT: Yes, it is.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. Do you recognize the handwriting?
A It's mine, I think.
Q And do you know what---? What does it---? What is it
about?
A From what it says, it's all inclusive; means that we
have to pay for everything, and that the promoters only
covering sound and light.
Q Do you know when---? Well, if you know why you wrote
that in there. It's all inclusive a---? A term of art in the
music business?
A No, maybe this is only something that I was writing
after the fact--- ah--- I don't know. To explain Willy--you
know--what it meant, or---
Q And is it accurate? Is that what all inclusive means?
A Well, that's what I understand it means, and that's
what the promoters understand. It said all inclusive, except
for sound and lights, it means we don't pay for anything,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 69 of 327
70
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
except for sound and light. We--- You take care of all the
rest.
Q OK. So--- But you don't recall---
A It wasn't a---
Q ---the context in which you wrote this?
A No.
Q Do you see that, at the top, it has a--- like a fax
date 4.10.2003, 8:27---
A Where?
Q ---p--- At the top---
A Aha.
Q ---at the very top.
A Uh-huh.
Q See that?
A Yes. This year. That's this year?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, 2003.
THE DEPONENT: Oh, I'm sorry. April. April 10.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Yes. That's like a week before the concert, or---?
A No.
Q I mean---
A "Un mes."
Q "Un mes." So would---? Is it you recollection that
you saw this before the performance?
A Saw what? This?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 70 of 327
71
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q This, the engagement contract. This one.
A Oh, the--- the original points? We knew about them.
Q Yes, but this, the document. I mean, when you did
this, when you---
A This, I don't recall.
Q When you wrote this note, do you think you wrote
that---? Is it your recollection that you wrote it before the
engagement?
A I don't remember. But like I said, if I did it, was
pro--- was most likely to explain--- ah--- to someone, whether
it was Willy, or the office, or I don't know what--- what it
meant. I knew what it meant.
Q OK.
A But certainly, I didn't write it for my benefit, you
know.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I'm going to mark it as 8.
(Whereupon, exhibit 8 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Going back to that--- the
days before the concert, there's this controversy as to whether
you've been paid, or you haven't been paid. You meaning both of
you.
Q Did it come a time when you thought it would be
better not to do the concert---
A Absolutely.
Q ---because of that?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 71 of 327
72
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Yes, I did.
Q When? When did you---
A I men---
Q ---think you shouldn't do the concert?
A It was so confusing. The whole scenario was so
confusing--- ah--- that I--- My recall--- recollection is that,
on the Thursday--- on the Wednesday night, when I--- I don't
know if Willy called me, or I called him. I don't remember. I
do remember his lawyer was there, and my feeling was "let's not
do this". That was my position. "Let's not do this, and let's
clear this up."
Q Are you already in Puerto Rico when this is
happening?
A No, I was---
Q No.
A ---in Los Angeles. Willy was in New York. And--- ah--
- the lawyer said: "I don't think it's a good idea to cancel
this", for several reasons. One was: "These guys paid in good
faith. You're going to get sued." And number two, Willy had a
problem with some guy here, Pepe Dueño, or somebody, that was
suing him, or threatened to sue him, because of--- he--- he
claimed that Willy had canceled a concert, or not shown up, or
something. So, it would--- it would've not been good.
But basically, the thing was: "These guys paid in
good faith, you're going to get sued", basically. His lawyer.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 72 of 327
73
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
And was good advise, so I figured: "OK., now, let's do the
gig".
Q OK. But your objection to playing was because you
thought you had not been paid in full?
A I--- To tell you the truth, at the time, as I try to
remember that unpleasantness, it was I was very upset I didn't
understand what happened. I like to have all the points clear,
you know? I like to be clear. And I was not clear. I was not
clear about a lot of stuff. I didn't understand what--- why it
happened, why did they do this--you know--I--- I wasn't sure
what the heck happened here. Not sure.
Q And---
A And my position--- Excuse me. And my position was:
"Let's--- let's step back, and really find out what happened.
Let's chase this 'till the end, and find out what happened."
And--- ah--- But the lawyer--- ah--- Das--- or Das--- I don't
know his name. He has--- ah--- he had a very good--- ah---
It--- it was good advise.
Q And the--- This is already in the papers?
A What is in the papers, sir?
Q The controversy about the concert, while you're
still---
A Yes, I think---
Q ---in L.A., and---?
A No, no, no. I think it is in the papers already. I
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 73 of 327
74
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
think it happened the week before. I can't remember exactly,
but it must have been like, at some point, the guy calls, on a
Thursday or a Friday, or something, and I call him and I tell
him: "Hey, you know? This may not happen, because we haven't
gotten paid", and the guy printed it in the paper. That's when-
-- that's when the thing began to create reactions from the
promoters. The promoters started, then, making noise. And
that's when Tuti Bou reaches me, and tells me: "Hey, this is
the--- these guys are OK." You know? 'Cause it's when the thing
hits the fan--- ah--- when the paper publishes that the
Siembra--- ah--- concert is--- ah--- maybe not--- will not
happen, or something, that's when everybody starts getting
panic.
Q Did at any point, before the concert, did you suspect
that the money had been paid to Martínez and Morgalo, and they
weren't telling you?
A No. I had no reason to believe that at all.
Q OK. Did you look at exhibit 7, the last payment,
according to that exhibit, the balance of one hundred and
twelve thousand five hundred dollars---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---had to be paid by April 22nd, 2003.
A Uh-huh.
Q That would have been eleven days---
A Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 74 of 327
75
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---before the concert.
A Uh-huh.
Q Does the issue about not being paid in full arise
after April 22nd, when you were---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---supposed to have received full payment?
A ---- (no audible answer).
Q "Tienes que hablar."
A Ah, sorry--- ah--- Yes.
Q And is it your testimony that you couldn't reach
Martínez and Morgalo at that point?
A No, the testimony wasn't exactly that. The testimony
is that, every time I asked him, before I had--- when I could
talk to him, the thing was the money---
Q Him meaning---
A Him---
Q ---Martínez?
A ---meaning Arturo, at the office, was--- ah--- "Well,
I can't reach the guy, the guy hasn't called me back---" ah---
"You know how these guys are, I'm sure the money will come,
`blah, blah, blah'." That was before. And like I said, before
these guys--- This is not un--- unheard of, that these kinds of
things happen.
Q Do you re---?
A So---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 75 of 327
76
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. Do you recall how much--- what was the amount you
thought remained unpaid at that time?
A No, I don't.
Q You don't know if it was the one hundred and twelve,
or---?
A I can't exactly remember, but it probably--- If--- if
I had asked how much money, it would probably mean the last---
the last payment, or--- You know, I don't know. I can't--- I
cannot confirm that, but there was money missing. Let's put it
that way. Money not--- not acknowledged, not paid.
Q OK. Prior to that April 22nd deadline for---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---the last payment, did you and Willy receive
payment from M&M---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---any money from M&M for that---?
A Yes, we did.
Q Is that based on--- because you do an estimate of
what the costs are going to be, and you can distribute the
difference?
A Ah--- probably. It was like an advance, I think. It
wasn't a lot of money. I don't think.
Q So, the reason---? So, you would know if money has
been coming in, because they are paying you those advances?
A Absolutely.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 76 of 327
77
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q And the remaining amount---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---would that be an amount that you and Willy would
distribute completely?
A Right.
Q I mean, that--- Expenses would have been taken care
of by then?
A Not necessarily, but most pro--- probably. There's
always something.
Q And what about the commissions? The M&M commission.
They take them from the--- from the first check?
A They shouldn't have, but they do.
Q From the first payment?
A They take it right away.
Q Now, did at any point, while you're discussing the
lack of payment issue with Mr. Colón, did Mr. Colón suggest
that you call the police?
A He probably did.
Q You don't recall?
A I don't recall. No, but he probably did.
Q And what do you think he probably did? What do you
think---?
A Because I'm sure he was pissed.
Q And he was---?
A I'm sorry. He was angry.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 77 of 327
78
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Aha. Well---
A I was angry too. I mean--you know---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Pissed is probably more
accurate; a more accurate reflection of what the feelings were.
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q So, based upon Mr. Das'--D-a-s--says---
MR. MORGALO: Das, Das.
THE DEPONENT: D--- I don't know, really---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: ---how you write it. Das.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q ---recommendation or suggestion---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---you decided to fly to Puerto Rico and do the
concert?
A That is correct.
Q What was Mr. Colón's position regarding doing or not
doing the concert at the time?
A I didn't hear any opposition to going. Otherwise, I
don't go.
Q So Das what Mr. Colón's attorney at the time?
A He was there, in the room. I mean, my feeling. I---
I talked to the guy. He was there--- ah--- I was in Los
Angeles, and Willy was in New York.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 78 of 327
79
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Oh, so he was with Mr. Colón---
A That is correct.
Q ---in the same room---
A That is correct.
Q ---when it was decided that the concert had to go
forward, otherwise, you might get sued?
A That is correct.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes.
(Pause.)
Q OK. So you do the concert, you don't--- you haven't
heard from Mr. Martínez regarding that last payment.
A No, but before we did the concert, they told us the
guy tried to kill himself.
Q Who told you?
A I think it was Juan Toro, or somebody, but it think
it probably was Juan.
Q That Martínez tried to kill himself?
A Yes.
Q For any stated reason?
A I don't know. I don't know why. That's what we heard
at the time, but--- We didn't know what to believe. And then,
we started talking to his wife, and I--- You know, we didn't
know what was going on. We--- Like I said before, there was a
lot of confusion. I mean--- you know---
Q And when you got to Puerto Rico---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 79 of 327
80
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q ---did you meet Mr. Sainz and Mr. Ríos?
A I think Willy and I spoke with the people for a long
time. We sat down, and we spoke a long, long time with those
people. I--- I'm not sure, probably--- might have been the---
the day before the concert--- ah--- in the night. I don't---
I--- We arrived on a Thursday---
Or maybe we talked before the press conference then.
If we arrived on a Thursday, we--- we talked with those people
on--- all the night--you know--late. We talked late, because
we--- you know, it was---
Q And what were they saying?
A The guys would--- I--- As I recall, they were upset,
they thought that the concert was going to suffer, because of
the bad publicity, that people weren't going to show up, they
were concerned about their reputation--you know--they wanted to
make sure that we made--- and specially me, made clear that
they had been on the up and up, which is what I did in the
press conference several times, just to clear the--- it--- it--
- you know, it's the thing with--- with that type of situation,
you throw it in, and it--- it spreads, and--- ah--- so, that---
that's what I think we were talking, and also the fact that we
were going to perform here.
They were just upset. Those guys were very upset
also.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 80 of 327
81
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Their position, at all times, was: "We have paid"?
A The position--- their position was, and they had all
the--- the papers--you know--"This is what we paid".
Q Good. Payments are usually done by wire transfer in
this business?
A Legal payments, yes. Unless--- Some people show up
with a brown bag, which is not the kind of thing you want, but-
-- ah---
Q With cash?
A Well, we've seen everything. In the old days, they
paid you with dollar bills. In back office.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm--- Let's go off the
record. I'm going to take a five minute recess---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---before going to---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Would like some coffee or---?
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Mr. Blades, before--- prior to the concert, once you
were in Puerto Rico, did Mr. Colón ever meet with you, together
with a relative or friend of his, called Pablo Rodríguez?
A "No, yo no recuerdo eso."
MS. GONZALEZ: In English.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Ah, en inglés."
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 81 of 327
82
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: Oh, I'm sorry. No, I don't remember
ever doing that.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q You don't recall if someone who came with Willy Colón
and gave you a book, a biography of Ramón Emeterio Betances?
A I don't remember that.
Q Do you recall ever telling Mr. Colón, prior to the
concert, that if Mr. Martínez and M&M had actually received
payment, that you would take care of Mr. Colón's part?
A No.
Q When you say no--- My question was whether you
remember--- you distinctly remember not having said that, or
you just don't remember---?
A I didn't say that.
Q Did you say anything close to that?
A Before the concert?
Q Yes.
A No.
Q Or after the concert?
A After the concert, I remember feeling terrible still,
because of the conversation I had with him before, when we
accepted, at the time when we said--- Remember I said "I don't
want to do this"?
Q Yes.
A And then, explained me his reasons?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 82 of 327
83
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Yes.
A OK. After the concert, the idea arose that more
concerts would be made, and then, I--- I told him: "When we do
the next concert, from the monies that we may get, that we got
stolen from, I'll give you some of your money that you lost".
Q And what exactly did you mean by that?
A I meant that, if we did the Shea Stadium concert, for
instance, and they--- you know, I don't know, what would have
happened, let's say we get a hundred thousand each, then--you
know--I think we were having like--- The money that was
appropriated, which I included now the--- the--- the money that
was collected by the agency as a fee, I think, I felt that they
didn't deserve that, which was thirty five thousand, or
something, and whatever was left was, maybe, like seventy five,
or--- or something, that if you split that in two, it's thirty
two thousand dollars--you know--and then, that "whatever my fee
was, you can take those thirty two".
Q OK. Let me see if I understand. If you were going to-
-- Each were going to get a hundred thousand dollars on the
Shea Stadium---
A Just as a--- as an example, yes.
Q ---you would take thirty two thousand from your
hundred, and give it to Willy?
A That's correct.
Q Because you felt terrible?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 83 of 327
84
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A I felt awful.
Q Did you feel awful because---?
A I felt awful be--- You want---? You know, I'm trying
not to say it, I'll say it. You know why I felt awful? Because
I think he needed the money.
Q OK. But did you---
A That's why.
Q ---feel that---? Did you feel awful also in part
because Martínez and Morgalo were your booking agents?
A That was a personal awful.
Q OK. Did you feel---? But did you feel in any way---
A Uh-huh. The obligation?
MS. GONZALEZ: Let him finish the question.
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Did you feel in any way that this had happened---?
Strike that. Did you feel in any way that this was caused by
the booking agents that did work for you?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. They did work for both.
THE DEPONENT: They worked for both of us, and they
stole from both of us. I felt worse, because I knew these guys,
and I was very happy when they made the--- the--- the agency,
I mean. And I just couldn't believe that they did this.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, that is actually what I
mean.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 84 of 327
85
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
(Pause.)
Q Were you upset because the people who might have done
this, or let's say, did this---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---were a group that used to represent you---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and that, in terms of this deal, they were working
on your end of the bargain, which was the collection of the
money and---
A I felt---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Compound. There are two
questions being---
THE DEPONENT: I felt, at the time, and I think it---
it so reflects a note that I wrote, that was--- ah--- "un
borrador", a draft of a letter--- ah--- in--- in the sense of
I felt terrible about what had happened, and--- but I had no
obligation whatsoever to do anything related to paying him
anything. I had no obligation to do it. Just felt terrible. But
more terrible, because I knew he needed the money at the time.
That's my--- That was my recollection of this.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q And you did tell Mr. Colón that, if--- that from a
future concert, and you were thinking about the Shea Stadium
deal at the time, you would take a part of the money you were
going to receive personally, and give it to him?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 85 of 327
86
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A After the concerts. After the--- after the Puerto
Rico concert?
Q Yes, after the concert.
A OK. There were several--- there were several offers
made to do shows, which I--- you know, again, I was doing film,
I was doing other things, but I thought--- He said, if I don't-
-- He mentioned something in New York, which I thought would
have been nice--- ah--- In Shea Stadium, I think, or something.
And I thought that would be nice. And I figured: "You know,
well, since that's going to be probably the last gig", you
know?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I show you a letter, or
what looks like a letter. I ask you to look at it, and once
you've done so, I'll ask you questions.
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q It's a document that has the William Anthony Colón
Román---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---letterhead, dated May 8th, 2003, addressed to
Rubén Blades, in L.A., and it says at the end: "Un abrazo,
Willy".
A Uh-huh.
Q Do you recall seeing this letter?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 86 of 327
87
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Yes.
Q Do you recall seeing this letter at about the date
that's stated there?
A I guess.
Q Let me put it in context. The concert was on May 3rd,
2003, this has a May 8, 2003, date.
A Uh-huh.
Q Do you recall that you had discussions, and I don't
mean that in an adversary way, discussions with Mr. Colón,
after the concert, regarding the amount owed?
A No, I don't.
Q What is this document about?
A This is what Willy sent me, stating that this is the
amount of money that he felt I--- I--- he was owed.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And--- Let me run by the
different figures here, so that I can understand what they are
referring to, if you know. I mean, you're not the author of the
letter, but you received it, and I understand you commented on
it.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q First of all, do you recognize the handwriting in
that document?
A Yes, that's mine. Mine--- my--- my handwriting.
Q Yes.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 87 of 327
88
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q Now, it says--- There's a table there---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---where it says: "Contract total", and Mr. Colón
wrote a hundred and seventy five thousand dollars.
A Uh-huh. Which is wrong.
Q Why is it wrong?
A Because one seventy five doesn't include any
expenses.
Q OK. One seventy five---
A One seventy five times--- times two is three fifty.
Q Which was the contracted amount?
A Yes.
Q Yes.
A He just split it and said--you know--one seventy
five.
Q OK. And you wrote something on that row there,
something like plus fourteen thousand nine hundred and seventy
nine sixty two.
A Uh-huh.
Q You know what that is in reference to?
A No, sir. I don't remember.
Q OK. Then, it says: "Less advance from Arturo---"
A Uh-huh.
Q "---thirty one thousand two hundred and fifty
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 88 of 327
89
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
dollars, on March 7", and another one from Arturo on March
31st, for the same amount. Correct?
A Yes, sir.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, if you look at exhibit 7,
exhibit 7 says, on the--- Do you have it near you? OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes, look at it, right here.
THE DEPONENT: Aha.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Item 7, number 7, says that a
deposit of sixty two thousand two hundred and fifty--- I mean,
sixty two thousand five hundred dollars would be due
immediately, and eighty seven thousand five hundred dollar
payment would be due in March 22nd. And then, another one on
April 1st, and the final one, on April 22.
Now, I see that Mr. Colón is saying that an advance
was received from Arturo on March 7---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---and another one, on March
31st.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Is it your---? Do you recall whether there were other
advances?
A Paid to whom?
Q To either of you.
A I have no idea.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 89 of 327
90
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q To you.
A No.
Q No meaning you don't recall, or you don't---?
A No, I must have received the same amount--- ah---
Whatever it was that was being sent to Willy. I never received
extras different than what he got. That was not the deal. The
deal was we get the same amount.
Q At the same time?
A Not nece--- I don't know at the same time, what
they're going to do--- If they going to send us both the same--
- You know, I--- I don't know. That part, I don't know. But
the--- the deal always was--- And I know this, because that's
the way I deal. He gets what I get. I get what he gets.
Q But you don't know how M&M would send out the
payments---
A No.
Q ---but is it your understanding---
A If he got sixty two, I'm must have gotten sixty two.
Q And you have no reason to believe that you would have
received it at a different point in time?
A Received what?
Q The same payments that he was receiving, or---
A No, I---
Q ---vice versa.
A We got a check, is--- They should take--- ah---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 90 of 327
91
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Let me ask in a different way, because I am being
confused.
A Tax forms--- ah---
Q I'm being--- I'm the one being confused. You have no-
--
A Uh-huh.
Q In your deal with Mr. Colón---
A Aha.
Q ---you would share the profits.
A Yes. After expenses.
Q After expense.
A Aha. Equally.
Q Equally, and there was no provision as to one
receiving the money first or the other one---
A No.
Q ---receiving---? So, as far as you know, it should
have occurred at the same time?
A Yes, should have.
Q OK.
A And--you know--yes.
Q You had no special provision for collecting first---
A No, no.
Q OK. So---
A And let just add this. If it had to be something like
that, I'd rather that he gets paid first, given the context of
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 91 of 327
92
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
the situation.
Q OK. Now, he is stating here, on this May 8th letter,
that---
"¿Qué pasó?"
THE DEPONENT: "No, dale, dale. El hielo..." I'm
sorry.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: All right.
THE DEPONENT: The ice was weird.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q ---that--- that as of that date, May 8th, he had only
received sixty two thousand five hundred dollars.
A Aha.
Q And he's deducting thirty two thousand five hundred
dollars in expenses.
A Uh-huh.
Q And you wrote--- you added a little over twenty six
hundred dollars next to it, right?
A I don't know.
Q Are you---? I'm sorry.
A This? A little added where?
A You added to the expenses row, which is the third row
in the table---
A Oh.
Q ---Mr. Colón said---
A Oh, aha.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 92 of 327
93
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---thirty two thousand five hundred dollars, and
apparently--- OK., well, apparently, and you wrote---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---next to it plus two thousand six hundred fifty
three and seventy seven.
A Right.
Q And then, like a total, you totaled it next to it,
thirty five thousand a hundred and fifty three seventy seven.
A Uh-huh. Uh-huh?
Q Is that because you had specific data regarding the
expenses?
A At the time, with the numbers that I--- As I recall,
the numbers that I had taken, it was around seventy--- between
seventy, but then, I think some more--- couple of more things
came up, and it went up to like seventy three, or something
like that, seventy five--- I don't recall, but it was--- I just
remember that this is something that I was sort of doing, and
responsive--- When I received this, I started checking, and
adding--you know--putting numbers there, but I wasn't--- ah---
done. And I think that actually came out to--- ah--- It
actually came--- came up a little higher than that. Because
there were some things that we hadn't put in, I think they had
to do with New York.
Q And based on your calculations---
A Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 93 of 327
94
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---done in handwriting, on this document---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---it was your understanding that Mr. Colón was owed
sixty two thousand three hundred and sixty six---
A At the---
Q ---dollars?
A ---time, that's what I thought, yes, sir.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. This document was produced
by your attorney---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MS. GONZALEZ: And also by Mr. Colón.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Just for housekeeping
matter, I would beg all the parties to try to find a better
copy, because this one is--- it has some--- some numbers cut
off on the side---
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: It's your hand, your plain
handwriting.
THE DEPONENT: Huh?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I mean, he might have an
original, so---
THE DEPONENT: No, I gave everything I had.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., but---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 94 of 327
95
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: Oh, I see.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---you gave everything to her,
and we produced a copy, she produced a copy. I'm just trying to
find out if we can find a copy that's not--- that doesn't have
the numbers cut off.
THE DEPONENT: OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: We should mar this as exhibit
8.
THE REPORTER: 9.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 9.
(Whereupon, exhibit 9 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Mr. Blades, you made reference
to a draft of a letter that you wrote.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to show you a
document, I'd like you to examine it, and---
THE DEPONENT: Yes, this is it.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
This is--- appears to be in memo format, addressed to
Willy Colón, from---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---you---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---date, May 10th, 2003---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 95 of 327
96
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---regarding the Martínez
Morgalo mess---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---Puerto Rico concert, May
3rd, and it's a typewritten document, with a lot of--- Well,
I'm not going to say a lot. A bunch of handwritten---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---corrections, or editing in
it.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Correct?
THE DEPONENT: It's a draft.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q You never sent this to Mr. Colón?
A No.
Q And what were you doing here? What's this document?
A Basically, I was very upset, because--- ah--- I
didn't--- When I got the other note--- ah--- the expenses he
felt were fifty one, and that he would take sixty five--you
know--I--- I--- I--- ah--- and he had eighty coming--you know--
it was all of a sudden as if like--- my feeling at the time was
like he thinks I got to pay him this. That was my--- my
reaction was: "He thinks I have to pay him this?"
And I felt--you know--"We both got robbed, I don't
have to pay you anything". I mean, this whole scenario happened
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 96 of 327
97
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
because of what these guys did to us.
Q These guys meaning M&M?
A The--- the M&M office. And basically, as you can tell
by the May 10th--- ah--- issue, it was after the concert, and
my feeling, when I talked to him, was: "If we do another show,
because--like I said--go back to what I said before, because I-
-- I---" And I don't like to talk about it, but I'm going to
have to mention it, that because I felt that there was a need
at the time for Willy to get his money--you know--I said: "You
know, I'll give you whatever it is that--- whatever part of---
of the money you didn't get, you can take it out of mine, of my
portion, when we do the second concert, or the next concert".
And that's what I mean when I say pay you.
And then, I read the draft, and I thought I was too
angry--you know--and I said: "I'm not---" You know. And them,
I--- I sent another--- another letter, which I don't know where
it is or what it was.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It might be here.
THE DEPONENT: I don't know. But it was a draft. But
that's the origin of that.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. By May 10th, you already thought Martínez and
Morgalo had robbed you?
A On May 10th? Oh, yes.
Q Do you recall whether you already had that thought
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 97 of 327
98
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
when the concert was actually held?
A No, I wasn't sure what happened. I was not sure. I
remember, in the press conference, people kept trying to get me
to say that--- And I--- and I kept saying: "I don't know what
happened. I don't know what happened, and I don't want to say
something, and then, I'm going to have to regret it", so--you
know--the whole--- Yes, I don't recall when I met Arturo,
because I did meet with Arturo, I just don't remember the date,
'cause I kept trying to get him, and get him, and get him. I
don't think it was on the--- by the 10th. I'm not sure.
So, by then, it was clear that something really
terrible had--- had happened. And when I met him finally, which
was---
THE REPORTER: Stop. Off the record.
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE DEPONENT: And when I met Arturo--- ah--- Arturo,
because I asked Juan to produce him. I kept after Juan: "Juan,
you know? I've got to know what happened. I've got to know what
happened." When I met Arturo, then, he told me how everything--
- what--- everything that had happened.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q So, all you knew before the concert was that Arturo
supposedly had tried to kill himself---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 98 of 327
99
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Yes.
Q ---and you weren't told why?
A No, I wasn't sure why.
Q Did you---?
A I didn't even know if it--- if it was true, I mean---
Q Did you, at any time before the Puerto Rico concert,
come to believe that M&M had--- were in financial trouble?
A No.
Q No? You had no reason to suspect that?
A No.
Q Do you know what point--- when, between May the 3rd,
and May the 10th---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---did you come to realize, or to believe that M&M
had taken the money?
A I think by the fact that this guy never showed up.
There was--- there were no explanations--- ah--- You know, we
tried to find him--you know--get--- get the real sense of what
had happened. Nothing. I said: "You know, the monies---" I knew
now the money had been paid. I knew I didn't have it.
Q Now you mean by May 10th?
A Absolutely. The monies--- Even before that. I have to
say even before that. I wasn't going to say that in a press
conference at the time, 'cause didn't really have all the
information. But after we did the concert, and everything was
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 99 of 327
100
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
clear, the guys had paid. We saw the--- all the bills, we saw
the--- the statements, and we know. I don't have the money. He
doesn't have the money. Then, the money was taken by the
office. Who else would have the money?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now---
THE DEPONENT: So---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---now, looking at paragraph
1 of your draft letter, exhibit--- Well, we haven't marked it,
but it's going to be exhibit 10.
"Esta."
MS. GONZALEZ: "Ajá, es ésta."
THE DEPONENT: "Dale."
(Whereupon, exhibit 10 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: In the--- towards the middle
of that paragraph---
MS. GONZALEZ: What paragraph, counsel?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 1.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Third, I told you I'd pay
you, because I feel morally obliged to do so."
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Why did you feel morally obliged to do so?
A Because the whole point of the concert, of me
agreeing to the concert, was to help him, 'cause he was having-
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 100 of 327
101
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
-you know--difficulties. Money difficulty. And the bottom line
is instead of getting the money, the money is stolen.
Q OK. But let me try and understand this. Your choice
of words here---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is---
A In the draft.
Q In the draft, yes.
A Aha.
Q Is that you felt morally obliged to do so.
A Yes.
Q OK. What was the moral component of that feeling.
A I love him, and--- and---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Fair enough. Now, I have
another--- "¿Cogemos un `break'?" OK.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE DEPONENT: No, let me finish.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Go ahead, yes.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let me show another document.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, no---
MS. GONZALEZ: Proceed.
THE DEPONENT: No, let me just finish. So basically,
that's the issue. I felt terrible.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Let me show you another
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 101 of 327
102
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
document. Here.
It's rather long, so just look at it, and when you're
done, I'll ask the questions.
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Aha.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Have you seen this document before?
A Yes, because I see my handwriting over here.
Q Where?
A Over here.
Q On the page that has the Bates number 146 at the
bottom?
A "No, el 6." Number 6.
Q 6 on top, yes. OK. This is a document that has a May
10th, 2003, date.
A Uh-huh.
Q That it says: "Estimado Rubén", I would gather that
Rubén is you.
A Yes.
Q Do you know who wrote this?
A Do I know who wrote it? I think this is Ariel Rivas.
Q OK. You recall receiving this?
A I--- Yes, I--- I--- I remember writing--- I mean, I
don't remember receiving it, but I know I did receive it.
Q And it's like a long narration of events---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 102 of 327
103
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and it incorporates emails---
A Uh-huh.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Counsel was pointing out to
me, Mr. Saavedra, that the fax line, that's how that thing is
called, at the top, has an April 11, 2003, date on top. That
just doesn't make any sense. I mean, there's no reason---
This was obviously written after the concert.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes. So some fax are---
Q What is this document about, in general terms?
A I think that it was the--- "resumen" by the promoter
Ariel Rivas of--- of his memory of the whole scenario of
negotiations that led to Siembra, to the concert of the--- of
May 3rd.
Q And it--- OK. And the first page, at the bottom,
there appears to be like--- It appears to be including an email
that has your name at the center. Page 1, the bottom. Rubén
Blades 1, 2, 3.
A No, but that wasn't me.
Q You don't know who that is?
A That's probably the--- The office had that---
Q Email?
A Aha.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 103 of 327
104
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Oh, so this text is not from you? What's---
A This text? No. "Rubén Blades 1, 2, 3, AOL"? "Si yo ni
usaba computadora en este tiempo." "Digo", I didn't have a---
I don't think I was that good in the--- I don't know if I had
a--- I don't remember if I had already an email address, but if
I did, it wasn't that one.
Q This has a 2001--- I mean, that apparent email that's
included, that--- that--- You said Rivas is the on who sent
this?
A No--- ah---
Q No, the letter.
A I'm sorry? O, Rivas?
Q The letter.
A I think it was him who sent this letter.
Q OK. And he is making reference to an email---
A Right.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: The letter. No, he was saying
the cut and paste here---
THE DEPONENT: "Ajá. Eso..."
MS. GONZALEZ: ---from Rubén Blades to Ariel.
THE DEPONENT: "Eso yo creo que lo recibió..." I'm
sorry. I think that that was received by Ariel Rivas, and was
sent by---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The office?
THE DEPONENT: ---the off--- Martínez Morgalo's
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 104 of 327
105
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
office.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. Well, according to that email, or what Ariel
Rivas is representing as an email---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---Arturo is saying that the spoke to you, and you
were very interested in doing something in Santo Domingo.
A Uh-huh.
Q Is that true? Do you recall having spoken to Arturo,
and saying: "I'm interested in doing something in Santo
Domingo"?
A I usually didn't start the--- the conversation--- ah-
-- I didn't start the--- the wheel moving to go some place.
Usually, I was told by someone: "`Oye, oye', there's a chance
to go X", and I'll say: "Oh, yes, I'd like to go there because
of something". So, I don't know how they--- ah--- represent
that to be, but I--- I know I did play in Santo Domingo at one
point. I hadn't been there in a long time. I think it was Altos
de Chavón. I'm not sure. Never played there. That's maybe what
it means. It maybe--- If it was like Altos de Chavón, I said:
"Oh, that's a nice place".
That was with my group. It wasn't with--- with Willy.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes. And on page 5, there's a
reference to a concert in Altos de Chavón with Danny Rivera.
THE DEPONENT: It says there?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 105 of 327
106
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Page 5.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Page 5?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Sí, aquí, mira."
THE DEPONENT: "Tiene Rubén Blades regresar a
trabajar..."
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "En mis manos."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No.
THE DEPONENT: "Ah, aquí. Sí, perdón." Uh-huh.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Aha. Altos de Chavón.
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And apparently, they're
narrating that there was some incident that left Rivas outside
of that concert, and it was given to Luis Medrano by Morgalo---
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And then, we get to page 6,
which is where you have your handwritten note.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Now, here, he's saying, and the stuff that you
underline--- I think it was you, right?
A Yes, sir.
Q All right. "Afterwards, Roberto---" I think we have
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 106 of 327
107
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
agreed that means Morgalo, right? Roberto?
A Yes.
Q Robert?
A I would think so.
Q "---talks to me about the possibility of doing
Siembra in Puerto Rico. We were very interested, and we
negotiated the May 3rd date for three hundred and fifty
thousand. At that moment, it was agreed, then, that the sixty
two thousand five hundred dollars, originally deposited for the
show with Cheo Feliciano---"
A Uh-huh.
Q "---would be credited to the new date for Siembra on
May 3rd."
A Uh-huh.
Q Do you recall having agreed to do a concert with Cheo
Feliciano?
A It was spoken for--- We'd spoken about that. I
remember ta--- The--- the talk--- As I remember, I remember
the--- the talk, the conversations that the show might happen,
or that it was a good idea to do that, or something to that
effect.
Q And it was canceled because Richie Ray and Bobby Cruz
were doing a concert on the same day.
A There was some kind of problem at the time, yes, and
I think there was a time--- a conflict--- I--- I--- I don't
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 107 of 327
108
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
have it very clear, because I remember that they mentioned, at
one point, talking about--- They talked about Cheo on one day,
and then, another time, they talked about Richie Ray and Bobby
Cruz, I don't remember--you know--really, at this time, not
clear about which of the two was the one that--- that we were
going to have the conflict that prevented the show from being
done. I don't remember which of the two, but there were like
two different dates. They were not the same day.
In other words, it wasn't like Cheo, Richie and me.
It was first with Cheo, I think, and then, there was with Ri---
with Richie, and then, there was--- This was canceled, and
then, there was a thing with Bobby, and then, it was the same
day, and--- You know, the thing is that nothing happened.
Q And this? If we look at that paragraph, it says--- It
suggests that the Bobby Cruz--- the Richie Ray, Bobby Cruz
concert---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---was going to be on the same day---
A Right.
Q ---or on the week of February the 16.
A I don't remember. I think that that's why probably---
The--- the concert was moved. The--- the--- they were talking
about dates. I--- I think it was like the 14 of February, or
something, and then, they couldn't get the--- the--- I don't---
the---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 108 of 327
109
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "El Coliseo."
THE DEPONENT: ---the Coliseo or some problem.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Era la noche de apertura."
THE DEPONENT: And the--- and the thing dropped. And
it was dropped. It was like an idea. It wasn't like---
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q But it was an idea for which they deposited sixty two
thousand.
A That's what it says there. I didn't get that money,
if that's what you're asking me.
Q I'm not asking--- I'm just---
A OK. But so---
Q I'm not asking.
A ---so everybody knows.
Q I'm trying to figure out---
A Right.
Q ---a chronology here.
A Uh-huh.
Now, may I ask something? Can I ask questions? No?
OK. Because is this the 2002 advance they're talking about?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: That's what I'm trying to
figure out.
THE DEPONENT: But this is in 2003.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And the exhibit says--exhibit
6--has a reference to a deposit in the amount of sixty two
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 109 of 327
110
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
thousand five hundred US dollars, received April, 2002. And
this must be--- I mean, it seems to me that February 16 is the
reference to 2003.
THE DEPONENT: I don't know, because 2003, I don't
think they would have done that, and then--- You know, I--- I--
-
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Then, a May Siembra concert.
THE DEPONENT: No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: But Rivas is saying that he
paid that for the Cheo Feliciano, Rubén Blades concert.
THE DEPONENT: Maybe this is something that refers to
the 2002 date, not 2003. I--- I don't see how that could have
happened.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Do you---?
THE DEPONENT: As a matter of--- Well, go ahead.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK. You--- But your testimony is that you never
received any money---
A That is my testimony, sir.
Q ---regarding the sixty two thousand five hundred
dollars---
A No.
Q ---of the Cheo Blades concert?
A Right.
Q Now, who is Editus?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 110 of 327
111
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Editus is a Costa Rican group that backs me up. At
the time, I was working with them.
Q OK. And in your handwritten note, you're saying---
You put an asterisk next to the Richie Ray Bobby Cruz sentence-
--
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and you say: "Cheo couldn't".
A Uh-huh. Remember that I'm reacting to what I'm
reading, and I'm trying to--- write down what I'm thinking as
I read this. And I recall--- Again, I don't--- I'm not--- I
don't understand the dates, but I do remember there was a
concert that they had suggested was a good idea to do, with
Cheo, on February 14.
Q OK.
A I don't know--- I--- I don't know. That year? I
don't--- I don't think so. I'd have to check and see what---
what movies I was doing, or what I was at--- doing at the time.
So, I think this was before. This must have been like before.
And I remember. I put in down "Cheo couldn't do it"
that time, because that's what I recall when they said that
that the--- mentioned--- ah--- this--- this point.
And then, it was another scenario, which had to do
with Richie, or maybe it's that--- Again, we're talking about
2002, I think, and then, they couldn't do--- When they moved
the concert, they couldn't do it, because Richie Ray had a
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 111 of 327
112
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
concert that same day.
Q You also wrote, at the bottom of the page---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---the phrase "with Morgalo". Do you know what that
means, what that meant?
A Well, at the time--- I'm--- I'm trying to determine
who did he talk to---
Q OK.
A ---because I remember that Morga--- Robert had left
for Iraq at one point. But before that--you know--he was in the
office. So, who did he talk to. That's why it leads me also to
believe it's 2002, because he couldn't have spoken with him in
2003, since the--- he wasn't there. So that means the sixty two
five had to do with the year before, when he was there.
Q OK. Let's---
A That's what I--- I mean, again, I'm just writing
little things in--- refresh my mind, well, what the heck
happened at the time, you know? Try to find a chronology,
because I was also confused.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let's look at page 7. The
second paragraph says: "Everything went well, until two days
before the show".
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Arturo sent me the writers."
Q What's a writer?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 112 of 327
113
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A It's--- ah--- the information regarding the band's
requirements.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "We verified it, and---" "Les
enviamos los contra writers." "We sent counter writers." That
would be like---
THE DEPONENT: Corrections.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Told us that Memo---"
Q Who's Memo?
A The sound man.
Q The sound man for---?
A For me. For Editus.
Q For Editus?
A Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Had said that everything was
perfect, he gave us the phone", and then, it says they talked
about the sound, et cetera, et cetera, that everything was
going well. Then, it says: "During this period, we agreed with
Arturo---" "Dice: `Cuadramos con Arturo'", "to make a
presentation---" "en sociedad contigo", that could be "in a
joint venture with you", or something else, "and Danny, in the
United Palace of New York".
Q Do you recall that?
A Uhm-uhm.
Q No?
A Uhm-uhm.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 113 of 327
114
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q You have to say no.
A I'm sorry. No, no, I don't. I'm sorry.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, page 8. That's where he
talks about the deposits.
The first full paragraph, the letter says: "We always
sent the deposits to Arturo---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---in the manner that money
was flowing in. Since he was conscious about how slow the
ticket sales were going, because of the situation regarding the
Pepe Dueño lawsuit, Willy--- lawsuit against Willy---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---and I must always say---
I must say always that the word that we made the deposits in
the way Arturo authorized. So he never pressured us to make the
deposits in the stipulated manner."
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh. Remember, at one point I said
that--- This is when, I guess, I--- I realize that they claim
that they had been told to--- to do it some different way---
You asked me, at one point, why the--- the payments had not
been made in the specified dates, and I said I recall that---
promoters saying that he had been authorized to do them
differently. This is, I guess, where I read that.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, he says: "There's some---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 114 of 327
115
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
there's a key person here called Christian.
Q Do you know who Christian is?
A No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Supposedly Arturo's brother."
THE DEPONENT: Excuse me. If I met him, I mean, do I
know--- If--- if you put his face right in front of me, would
I know, like I can recognize Robert, would I recognize him, if
I saw him right now, no.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Then, he says something that
coincides with your testimony. It says that he would call---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---apparently, Christian to
the Martínez and Morgalo office to inform that a transfer had
been sent, but that it was--- became strange to him that, in
the final weeks, he would call the office, and no one would
answer. And that, then, he found out that they had closed the
office, and that Arturo was working for his house.
Q You see that on page 8?
A Yes.
Q Were you ever told by Arturo that he had--- that they
had closed the Broadway office, and---
A No.
Q ---that he was working out of his house?
A No.
Q When you were trying to reach him, and you said you
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 115 of 327
116
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
couldn't reach him, were you calling the---
A I was calling the office.
Q ---the 212 number?
A I guess. The office number. I don't think I had his
home number.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Let's mark this as
exhibit---
THE REPORTER: 11.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---11.
THE DEPONENT: 11.
(Whereupon, exhibit 11 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "¿Cuándo quieren `break for
lunch'?"
THE DEPONENT: "Yo... yo, no importa si yo no como. Yo
estoy..." You know, I'm fine.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Estamos fuera de récord."
THE REPORTER: "No, estamos en récord."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Pues, vamos fuera del
récord."
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I handed over a document to
you, and please, review it, and let me know when you're done.
THE DEPONENT: Yes, go ahead. I remember this.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 116 of 327
117
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. This is a one page
document that says "confidential" on the top. It says page 1 of
two, but this is all I have. And it's addressed to you---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---date May 13, 2003, subject,
"Gilbertito bails Blades and Colón out", and it's sent by
Willy, which we gather should be Willy Colón.
Q Do you recall seeing this document?
A Yes, I---
Q Do you recall seeing it on that date, or on or about
that date?
A When he sent it, I think. Near--- near that date, I'm
not sure.
Q What is the document about?
A Ah--- apparently, a paper here wrote that--- ah--- I
don't know which paper, probably a big headline saying that---
ah--- Gilberto had--- ah--- had helped us, or not helped us,
but perhaps--- ah--- saved us, or something, I don't know. It
says "bails out"--you know--like he saved us, or something to
that effect, because--- ah--- when--- when all this--- When all
of this happened, Gilberto did help us, his office. There was
a need for cash. There was a need to receive money--you know--
to pay everybody at the time, because like I said, they had
made the advances, advances, and then, we found out that all
this--- all that happened, I paid some of the stuff with my
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 117 of 327
118
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Visa--you know--we had to pay the musicians, and we--- now,
we're needing money. So I--- They came forward, and helped us.
Q But do you remember in what amount of money?
A I don't quite remember, but I remember there was---
We found out that the last--- The last payment that these guys
sent, which they sent like perhaps days before the--- the
Siembra concert, these guys meaning the promoters, went to
Arturo's own--- I don't know if it was the Martínez Morgalo
account. And his wife, somehow, had access to the money, to the
funds---
Q Which wife was what?
A Arturo's wife. And I knew this, because of--- ah---
Juan. Juan Toro, who's--- Juan was the only guy that made the
contact--- ah--- with--- with Arturo's wife. I didn't know
where she was, and I guess they called him when he tried to
kill himself. I'm not certain about that part. I sure that
Juan, later on, when he goes to trial, he'll be able to you in
detail how did that--- all that thing happened.
But there was an amount that was never cashed, and
that amount was sent back to--- ah--- Gilberto Santa Rosa's---
his wife Meli--- Mélida--- Nélida, and--- and that money was
the money that we used to pay--you know--back the money that he
lent us. He lent us--- I think it was about ten or twelve
thousand dollars.
So, we returned him that money, and then, there was--
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 118 of 327
119
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
- There was another amount, like thirty nine thousand dollars,
or something, that was left, and it was paid--- you know, paid
everything, and out of that, then, I sent him, Willy, ten
thousand and something dollars. As I recall.
Q And Willy sort of feels embarrassed by that
situation?
A I guess he did. I guess he didn't like the idea that
people would think that--- ah--- you know--- that we were
helpless.
My feeling was different, but---
Q You want to say something? Ah, she's--- OK.
A No, my feeling was different. I think he helped us,
and that's why I said to people--you know--"Thank you,
Gilberto, and than to everybody", and then, the paper went in
to get that way, and gave it that spin--you know--as they
usually do.
Q And Willy Colón says, at the end: "I'm still very
proud of the work we did through the years, and the job we did
on the night of May 3rd".
A Uh-huh.
Q "I hope we get a chance to another date to make it
up."
A Uh-huh.
Q By that date, were you already discussing the Shea
Stadium---?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 119 of 327
120
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A I think we had spoken about it, yes. Because he was
working with the Blumberg people, and it--- We--- we had sort
of talked about--- about--- Yes, about that--- Specifically,
that--- that time. That day---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., let's mark---
THE DEPONENT: ---ah--- Shea Stadium.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let's mark this as exhibit 12.
THE REPORTER: 12.
(Whereupon, exhibit 12 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to show you another
document.
I'm going to ask you to review it, and when you're
ready, you let me know.
(Long pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Uh-huh means you're ready?
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry--- ah---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Ah, ¿una reacción a un pedazo
de...? ¿Algo que leyó? OK."
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: This document is dated May
14th, 2003---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---to WAC.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 120 of 327
121
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q It's safe to say that that is William Anthony Colón,
right?
A Yes, sir.
Q And RB is you?
A Yes, sir.
Q And says it's about the problem general.
A Uh-huh.
Q Now this---
A Ah, yes, sir.
Q Yes. What is this document about?
A Basically this is the letter stating--- I--- I---
ah--- I had drafted--- This is the letter. It's pretty much
explaining the situation, and what my concerns were.
Q You are--- The first thing you're telling Mr. Colón
is that you spoke to Arturo---
A No. Arturo called---
Q Oh.
A ---and left me a message.
Q That's right. So he would have called on May 13.
A That is correct.
Q And that you--- On item number 2, you told Juan Toro
to talk to Arturo, and you're making enquiries about the sixty
two thousand five hundred dollars---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---"the alleged payment made last year---"
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 121 of 327
122
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q "---for a different show, and applied to the May 3rd
engagement."
A Uh-huh.
Q So, at this point, you're telling Willy that you've
become aware of this.
A In the---
Q Yes?
A ---in the May 10th letter from---
Q From Rivas.
A Aha---
Q It makes---
A It's very clear. He--- he makes his own explanation.
Q Would that be the first time you become aware of that
situation?
A When? In May 10?
Q Yes. Of the allegation that that money had been paid
for a previous show?
A He might have mentioned it before. We talked to these
guys on May--- Before the concert, we sat down and spoke with
them, so that must have come out there as well.
Q Now, you say, after you make a reference to that
money: "I also want Arturo to clarify the extent of Roberto
Morgalo's involvement in this situation".
A Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 122 of 327
123
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q What do you mean by that?
A Well--- there is no doubt that Roberto Morgalo was
not there from a very specific time. I don't recall if it was
January or February. Don't recall after May. But given the
sixty two thousand five hundred dollar scenario, that allegedly
took place a year before, when he was there, my concern was
when did this whole thing started. When did the problem start.
My problem was they were taking money when. To us?
They--- Taking the money from this concert, from Willy and I,
or were they already taking money out from me? 'Cause I never
saw those sixty two. And when did this happen? And who was
involved in this?
Q You spoke to Arturo after this, correct?
A At some point, I did. Finally, Juan brought him.
Q And did you discuss the issue of the sixty two
thousand five hundred?
A Yes, I did.
Q And what did you tell him, and what did he tell you?
A It was a really tough--- ah--- It was a tough--- I
was very angry--- ah--- I try not to be. I thought it was
really stupid of them to not have come forward and said: "You
know, we're having problems", and basically, what I got from
him, as I recall, and again, this could be checked with---
ah--- Juan, who was there as well, was that they were doing
shows of their own, and their shows were not working, and they
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 123 of 327
124
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
had to ask for money on the street, and they were not paying---
the shows were not happening.
So, they would take money from an advance, and use it
for the show, or to pay--- and thinking they were going to make
money, and then, pay off, and then, the thing wouldn't work,
which led them to continue to try to book things, and get the
money to pay--you know--it's like a front seat backwards.
And--- and that's---
And then, at some point, it got--- the water just
drowned them, and--you know--he went away, and Mr. Morgalo went
away, and then, he was left alone to hold the--- the fort. And-
-- and that's when--- There was nothing--- there was nowhere
else to drag to draw money from, and that's when the whole
thing was exposed.
Q Now trying to put the pieces together---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---if the sixty two thousand five hundred dollars
were from a show that got canceled in 2002---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and if, from reading Rivas' memo, that was in
reference to a Cheo Feliciano concert that might have occurred
in February of 2002---
A That's my--- my memory of--- of when it was mentioned
that there would have been a concert, 2002. February.
Q This went on for over a year.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 124 of 327
125
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A People come and say they want to do a concert with
Frank Sinatra, they come in and tell you: "We got a call from
so and so, we're going to do this, we're going to do that".
Some things happen, some things don't happen. I mean, I don't
really hold my breath. I had other things to do. I was doing
movies. I did like three movies back to back. I wasn't paying
attention.
Q And you were worried, in this document, about
Hacienda thinking that you had made more money that you had?
A Yes. And they were really upset with Willy, because
he didn't show up at the meeting, and I told the guys, I said
he couldn't come, because he has a gig, and I think it was in
Florida. And they were really upset--- ah--- And I--- I wanted
him to understand--you know--'cause you don't want to mess with
IRS or Hacienda--- Well, we shouldn't mess with anybody from
government, but I'm saying, specially taxes. And--- ah--- and
I knew it wasn't going to go away.
Q They were thinking that you had made more money than
the---?
A Well, the thing is, again, this is--- I always like
to have things clear. I like to have things clear, 'cause I
like to argue with things clear, and I think what happens,
usually, is the promoters lie about the gigs. They don't tell
them--you know--exactly how much are the--- the gigs are for,
so they don't--- so they pay less--- ah--- or declare less. I
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 125 of 327
126
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
don't know. And I wanted them to be very clear it was three
fifty, then, they had to take away all the expenses, and all
the stuff, and then, whatever was left, that's what we're going
to pay taxes on. It's rumors.
Q What was Hacienda's final position on the matter?
A They believed us, because--I mean--I always pay my
taxes with them. And I asked for the meeting. I asked for the
meeting. You know, I said: "We're going to--- Yes, we're going
to meet---" I--- I--- I didn't remember, or didn't know that
Willy had a gig. He had to leave. Willy had to leave. And they
got pissed like I can't tell you. And I--- and I said: "No, he
had a show--you know--we didn't know that this was going to
happen, and anyway, I'm here. What's the problem? You know,
tell me." 'Cause they felt disrespected.
Q So, there's no issue outstanding there, with Hacienda
now?
A No. No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm going to mark it as the
next exhibit.
THE REPORTER: 13.
(Whereupon, exhibit 13 was marked for the record.)
THE DEPONENT: I think--- I'm sorry, can I add
something else? I think also the promoters were in hot water
with Hacienda, because the--- I think the--- the--- it's
required that they leave an amount as backup, withholding---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 126 of 327
127
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
you know, and they were supposed to have left like thirty
something thousand dollars, and they didn't. And then--- ah---
that didn't sit well with them. I don't know how--- how--- I
don't know how the promoters resolved that issue.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Have you been able to track those sixty two thousand
five hundred dollars---?
A No.
Q So---
A I asked--- The only thing I thought that could have,
in any way, from my perspective, bring any kind of clarity to
that was to ask my accountant, who's Jerry Shustek, is really
careful, it's not like--- ah--- you know, he's very, very
careful. I said: "Look into your records, and check and see if
we received any money during this period of time that we can
ascribe as to whether that money come from; any check, and it
wasn't there.
Q And--- But did you see anything from the promoters
that would---?
A I don't---
Q Or did the promoters---
A No, I don't---
Q ---demonstrate that they had---?
A I don't remember seeing anything of that, other than
what they said, but I--- I--- I stress again; Willy and I
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 127 of 327
128
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
stayed until like the wee hours of the morning talking to those
guys, and I am sure that they mentioned--- they must have
mentioned that. Why wouldn't they mention the sixty two five?
Why would they mention everything, except that? And I'm sure
that I said: "Where is the money? Where?" You know--- So---
Q But we're talking about more than sixty two five
right now, right? I mean---
A Well, we got the sixty two five, plus. I don't think
that the company deserves to get any fees, plus whatever it is
that was left. There was some money left. I think it was like
seventy thousand, or something, at the end of the day, that we
didn't get paid. I was six---
MS. GONZALEZ: Hundred and twenty five.
THE DEPONENT: Huh?
MS. GONZALEZ: Hundred and twenty five.
THE DEPONENT: The total?
MS. GONZALEZ: Unaccounted for. Yes.
THE DEPONENT: OK., so sixty two plus whatever---
MS. GONZALEZ: No, that's--- Yes. That would be.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., let me show you another
document.
THE DEPONENT: There was a moment there, when they
didn't come up with the money.
Huh?
MS. GONZALEZ: Amount--- amount unaccounted for.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 128 of 327
129
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: Oh, there you go. See, I put in "amount
stolen in 2002---"
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Wait, wait. Let's---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It gets messy.
THE DEPONENT: Oh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It's hard to recall afterwards
what you're looking at.
THE DEPONENT: OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I just showed--- I just handed
to you a document---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry, aha.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---that has as the title
"Report on the expenses for the May 3rd show".
Q Have you seen that document before?
A This?
Q Yes.
A I think I made this.
Q You made it? And it says as of May 16th?
A Yes, sir.
Q OK. Well, go ahead. What is this document about?
A Ah--- these are the numbers, as I had them at the
time--- ah--- and I was typing them. Trying to put them in
order, to understand--excuse me--what was what. But I see here,
for instance, Martínez Morgalo forty four, which means fifteen
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 129 of 327
130
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
percent---
MS. GONZALEZ: No, it's ten percent plus other
expenses they take.
THE DEPONENT: Oh, it includes their ten percent
commission.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., but let's--- Let me go
line by line. It says---
THE DEPONENT: OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---at the beginning: "A,
received by Willy Colón and Rubén Blades---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---a hundred and eighty
thousand four hundred and sixty dollars---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---the wire transfers to
Willy Colón, sixty two thousand five hundred dollars---"
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "---were transferred to Rubén
Blades, sixty eight thousand one twenty five".
Q Why is there a---
A I have---
Q ---six thousand one hundred and twenty five dollar
difference?
A I don't know. I--- I can't explain it.
Q Wire transfer of M&M balance left. What is that? A.C.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 130 of 327
131
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Oh, this is the monies that were---
Q Received?
A No, but these are the monies--- Remember I mentioned
that, at the end, there was--- ah--- an amount that had not
been cashed by Martínez--- by the office, that's the amount
that the wife of Arturo Martínez, through the offices of Juan
Toro, recouped and sent us here, to the office of Mélida, the
wife of--- ah--- of Gilberto Santa Rosa. That's the forty nine-
-- That was, I think, the last payment that the promoters from
here did---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., let me---
THE DEPONENT: ---that had not been cashed. It--- it
wasn't taken.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let me--- I give you--- show
you a photocopy of a check, with some handwritten notes. Let's
mark the first document, as exhibit?
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
THE REPORTER: 14.
MS. GONZALEZ: 14.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 14, which would be---
"Vamos a usar la copia de él, porque yo te estoy
dando las mías y, entonces, él se puede confundir allá."
Exhibit 14.
(Whereupon, exhibit 14 was marked for the record.)
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh. There it is.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 131 of 327
132
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., the document you're
looking at now, which is the piece of paper with a photocopy of
a check---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---for thirty thousand eight
hundred and twenty dollars, by Víctor Manuelle Ruiz, and some
handwritten notes, that's going to be marked as exhibit 15.
(Whereupon, exhibit 15 was marked for the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q What's that about?
A This was a copy of a--- of a part of the forty nine
thousand eight hundred and thirty five dollars that were
deposited in the Martínez Morgalo account, that were sent by
the promoter. That, I think, corresponds to the last payment---
ah--- And it was sent--- I had contacted Juan Toro, and I---
and he--- ah--- con--- This was a surprise. I thought the money
was all gone, and then, he said: "No--you know--the--- the last
advance that the promoters--- The promoters had told us there
was this money that had gone over", and said--- you know,
'cause they sent it almost too late. They didn't send it on the
right times. So the money was not spent. And--- and we found
this out, and then, I asked Juan: "You know, can you send it
over here? Because--you know--we got all these bills that we
need to pay, the expenses that they hadn't paid".
And then, I asked to--- ah--- Gilberto Santa Rosa, I
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 132 of 327
133
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
think Víctor Manuelle is his partner, or something, and--- and
his wife, and I said: "You know, we're going to need some cash
to pay the musicians, and--- and then, we're going to need to
pay the hotel, and--- and I---" I was paying things also with
my Visa, and what not, "and we're going to need the
reimbursements".
So, they sent the money--- I didn't have an account
here, so--- Neither did Willy, so they sent this amount, minus
whatever they took for the wire, to this--- ah--- to these
people here at the Banco Popular de Puerto Rico, at his
account, and then, from this account, we started drawing money
to pay for all the stuff that needed to be paid.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Exhi---
THE DEPONENT: "Aquí también falta un pedazo."
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "¿Falta algo?"
THE DEPONENT: "No, es que..."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "No, es que no se ve."
THE DEPONENT: It's cut.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Whoever has a better copy---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Exhibit 14, which is your May
16th breakdown, or reconciliation of accounts. I don't know
what the term is.
MR. MORGALO: That was 13.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: 13?
MR. MORGALO: That's 14?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 133 of 327
134
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, no. 13 "es esto".
MR. MORGALO: "Ah, verdad que sí."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 14 "es esto."
Says on AC, wire transfer of M&M balance left forty
nine thousand eight hundred and thirty five.
Q That's what you state that Morgalo's--- I mean,
Martínez's wife transferred from the M&M account---
A Yes.
Q ---to Mr. Víctor Manuelle?
A Uh-huh. I think he sent it to them, yes. The whole
thing I think it was.
Q OK. And Victor Manuelle---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---gave you ten thousand dollars in cash---
A Yes.
Q ---from that account?
A Yes.
Q That you used to pay expenses?
A The whole band and all that.
Q And he kept nine thousand as a reimbursement for a
loan of the same amount---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---given on Friday May the 2nd to pay musicians?
MS. GONZALEZ: "Per diem."
A Uh-huh. The per diem.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 134 of 327
135
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: "Per diem" and stuff.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q But is that the Gilberto Santa Rosa money---
A Yes.
Q ---or is that---?
A The amounts--- I--- You know, I really don't remember
what it was, but I did make the whole reconciliation of this
things. There were different bills to be paid. Some had to do
with the concert, the performances themselves, others had to do
with the "per diems", others had to do with hotels--- ah---
others had to do with even air transportation--- ah--- You
know, so I--- I can't, right now, remember--- I remember that
most of the cash went directly to musicians, who didn't want to
get paid in--- in checks, 'cause they needed--you know--the
money. They want their money right away. They don't want
checks--- ah---
So, I am sorry, I can't remember exactly--- ah---
Q Who the money went to? OK.
A It's--- it's reconciliating, though, I do--- I do,
and my lawyer has everything, right?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: All the--- the--- how the money was
spent; what was given to whom.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 135 of 327
136
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. Then, going back to 14---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---exhibit 14, B, expenses, Martínez and Morgalo,
forty four thousand six dollars and eighty cents---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---including the ten percent commission---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---which you are stating that they shouldn't get
that. I mean---
A After what happened?
A Yes. And then, there's the twenty nine thousand
dollars and seventy five cent expenses paid by Colón Blades,
bringing the total of expenses to seventy three thousand seven
dollars and fifty five cents.
A Right.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Take out the thirty five.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "¿Cómo que ̀ the thirty five'?"
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "El `thirty five' del `ten
percent commission'."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Ah.
THE DEPONENT: I mean, the out of pocket.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Sí."
And you reached the conclusion that there's a sixty
two thousand five hundred dollars--you write here--stolen in
2002, that refers to that deposit that is still unclear as to
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 136 of 327
137
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
where it actually came from, and sixty three thousand, thirty
three, and twenty, which is the amount they didn't--- M&M
didn't turn over to you two in 2003.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q That does not include the thirty five thousand dollar
commission that---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "No lo incluye."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Is that inclu---?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q This does not include the thirty five thousand dollar
commission that M&M collected, right?
A ---- (no audible answer).
Q The--- the two numbers that you state at the end, as
stolen, sixty two thousand five hundred, and sixty three
thousand thirty three and twenty, that does not include the
amounts you say that they should return, because they are not
entitled to a commission?
A Well, at the time, I mean, they did collect it.
Q Yes.
A I probably didn't put it in here.
Q No, no. I'm just trying to clear up the numbers---
A There were monies that were not paid---
Q Yes.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 137 of 327
138
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A ---and there were monies that I don't think that
they--- they deserve, so---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Got it.
THE DEPONENT: You know---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: And there, I put in the promoters
claim, and accepted the credit--- to credit the sixty two
thousand five a payment, and--- ah--- and this was never
mentioned to us. And it didn't appear in the contract that we
saw.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let me show you this document.
When you had a chance to--- seeing it, and you're ready to be
questioned at it, let me know.
(Long pause.)
THE DEPONENT: Oh, boy. Forgotten about this thing.
That they paid it in disbursements, the sixty two?
MS. GONZALEZ: To you?
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh. I didn't remember that.
Uh-huh.
THE DEPONENT: "¿Estas son las dos únicas..." These
are the only two pages on this thing?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, I don't know, because---
THE DEPONENT: Well, it seems like it didn't--- wasn't
finished.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, and it doesn't have
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 138 of 327
139
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
consecutive Bates numbers, or I--- I'm---
THE DEPONENT: No, it does. It has a 2 on the top.
"Pero..."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. We'll try to figure this
out, and---
THE DEPONENT: OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---we'll come back to it after
lunch---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---because I notice that it
goes from page 83 to 101.
THE DEPONENT: From--- Aha. "Ah, yo no sé esto qué
es." "Estas `pages'..." Who put these pages?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: I put the numbers on it from the
photocopies that she gave us.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes. So there--- I mean,
there's like twenty pages in between that.
MR. MORGALO: No, but if you notice, on the--- the
documents, a, b, c, d, and it continues to e, f, g, h, i.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: So it does continue. There's a
continuance, but the question is, at the bottom of that page,
it says 1, and then, it just stops there. Doesn't go beyond
that.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Actually, it was marked by
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 139 of 327
140
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
counsel--- by your counsel at the Martínez's deposition. She
introduced it as an exhibit.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Like this?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes. Exhibit number 8.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK., but during the lunch
break, we'll try to figure out this. Because it's unfair, based
on this confusion, to---
THE DEPONENT: But I have to--- Also, what it says,
what Morgalo--- Mr. Morgalo says is true in that--- in that it
does follow from d to e.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It seems to be a complete
document, yes.
THE DEPONENT: Aha. I don't--- I just see that there's
only "mis argumentos", 1, and then, there's nothing else.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: That document was produced by
your---
THE DEPONENT: I know, I know.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: ---attorney. I just don't know--
-
THE DEPONENT: But I'm just trying to figure out if
this is--- ah--- this was something that I was working on.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Do you recall seeing this document?
A Yes, I think I--- I--- I typed this.
Q OK. When you say typed, you mean on a typewriter?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 140 of 327
141
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Yes, sir. Or, like I said before, I came in late to
this computer age.
Q Aha.
A I typed everything.
Q And would you---? Would this have been done in 2003?
A Yes.
Q OK. Do you---? Even though there's this confusion as
to the Bates number, do you feel comfortable that this is a
document that you typed? Because it appears to be---
A That is my---
Q Page 1 and 2 of---
A Yes.
Q OK.
A Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: So, let me ask a few questions
on it, and then, we'll break for lunch.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q What is this document about? What does it do?
A As I continue to try to understand what happened, I--
- I think--- ah--- this is more based on the reception from the
promoters of all the documents that proved that they had made
the payments. Remember, at one point, I said to Tuti Bou--- not
Bone, Tuti Bou--- ah--- She showed--- ah--- She said: "These
guys are serious", and I think those are the things--- the
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 141 of 327
142
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
documents I saw on that Wednesday, that I received that
Wednesday, and I started to type a relation of all the
documents that I had received, that proved that they had sent
the money.
Q OK. Section A of the--- of this document simply makes
a reference to the amount---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---of the contract---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---right? And section B of the document, capital
letter B---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---states the way the payments should have been made,
in accordance to the engagement contract.
A Yes, sir, and corresponds to what the contract---
Q Correct.
A ---was that we saw.
Q Right. And then, subsection C, capital letter C, says
that you don't have to perform if you haven't received the
money.
A Uh-huh.
Q Correct?
A Uh-huh. Yes, sir.
Q OK. Then, there's a different heading that says about
the present situation. It starts, right, saying that the
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 142 of 327
143
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
promoter of the event alleges that he made payments of two
hundred and eighty seven thousand five hundred dollars between
February 27 and April 30, to the office of Martínez Morgalo in
New York, as proof of the allegation, the alleged payments, the
promoter presented--- or presents the following documents from
Banco Popular de Puerto Rico, "as I am told by Jaime Torres"
Torres, El Nuevo Día reporter?
A Uh-huh.
Q Does this mean---?
A And--- and Tuti Bou.
Q And Tuti Bou. Does this mean that they are telling
you that they saw that, or did they actually show you that?
A No, what--- what--- The word--- ah--- "presenta",
I'm--- I'm--- it sounds like it's in present, but it's really--
- I'm saying---
Q Showed.
A ---he--- he showed, and presented these documents to
these people--- ah--- which, then, were sent to me. You follow?
Q Yes.
A I--- I received word of this via Jaime Torres Torres,
and Tuti Bou. They said: "I--- we saw the documents, the
payments were made, these guys are real", and I said: "Well,
send them to me". And then, they send them. And that's when I
see them, and I start putting them all together in this line.
Q And these are money orders?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 143 of 327
144
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Ah--- yes. "Giros."
Q OK.
A I think they're tran---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, wire transfers.
THE DEPONENT: Wire transfers.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: Not money orders.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And--you know--specific
amount, specific date---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---from Banco Popular, in a
total of two hundred eighty seven thousand five hundred
dollars.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Then---
THE DEPONENT: And actually, look at this here.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---section 3, these are---
alleges that the amount owe--- I mean, the remaining amount---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---sixty two thousand five
hundred dollars were already paid in the year before.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And again, they--- Well, I'm
not going to say again.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 144 of 327
145
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And they list four payments---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---with specific dates.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: But there's no reference here
to wire transfers or money orders.
Q Do you recall seeing that?
A No.
Q This is just a list they gave in this same way?
A I'm sure that they must have had--- Like I said
before, those guys are very thorough, so they probably had---
Maybe we should look and--- at our record--- ah--- and find---
Because they--- I don't think that they could have remembered
it without a--- a--- a backup document, the date that they sent
them.
MS. GONZALEZ: They're right here.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Ah, ¿tú los tienes?"
THE DEPONENT: They're over here.
MS. GONZALEZ: Here.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Now---
MS. GONZALEZ: "Hay más documentos en esta... Pero..."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Now, Mr. Blades---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---let's go back to exhibit 3.
THE DEPONENT: Exhibit 3?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 145 of 327
146
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "A ver si está acá."
THE DEPONENT: "Ya, aquí está".
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. This is the Ecuador
document.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I understand you don't
remember ever agreeing to this concert, you don't remember
anything about it, the document reflects a date for the concert
of November the 23rd.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Correct?
A Yes.
Q And it says--- talks about some monies to be paid on
certain dates. And this is for November 23rd, 2002, and we have
payments that we're looking at, on this last document we're
examining---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---where they claim that they had sent sixty two
thousand five hundred dollars in 2002, and the payments appear
to end on October 28, 2002.
A Uh-huh.
Q Isn't that---? That's correct, right?
A That's what it says, yes.
Q And earlier, we saw the whole thing about the Richie
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 146 of 327
147
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Ray, Bobby Cruz, Cheo Feliciano concert being somewhere around
February. Again, just trying to put the pieces together. Could
these payments be in reference to the exhibit 3 engagement that
you stated that you knew nothing about?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, speculative.
A I really don't know, because like I said, there were-
-- First of all, I must confess. Even though I wrote this, I
didn't remember that the payments had been made in segments. I
always, for some reason, thought that they had been made in
bulk--you know--the whole sixty two five--- ah--- I really
don't know, because we're talking about a concert that I didn't
know about, and I can't--- in--- I can't right now figure if
this is something that was supposed to happen in November---
ah--- or if this is something that, then, didn't happen.
Remember also we're talking about--- If that--- in
this bill, we're talking about a hundred and twenty thousand.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: So, that would have meant that--- And
the date here is November 23rd, and the last payment down here
was October. Which mean--- which means they would have had to
come up with another sixty in three weeks, or something, to
cover the total. So, if at some point, it was canceled, then---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well---
THE DEPONENT: ---then--- If this happened
effectively, then, it was canceled somewhere around this---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 147 of 327
148
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
before this time---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Uh-huh.
THE DEPONENT: ---and forgotten about, and then,
another deal started, what--- "Why don't you---? Instead of
doing this show, why don't we do this other show? It's more
money, it's better", and then--- "And what about my money?"
"Oh, no, we'll apply this money to the other show."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And it---
THE DEPONENT: That's the only thing I can think of,
that that's how they--- this is how they did it. I--- I have no
idea.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And in this document that you
typed up, it does say that--- the promoter indicated that this
was for a concert that was canceled on two occasions, December
and February---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry, which document? Which of the
two---? Oh, this one? OK. Sorry. Aha?
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Indica---
A "Sí." Yes.
Q The pro--- That this was in relation to a concert
that was going to be done on December of 2002---
A OK.
Q ---and then, on February---
A Right.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 148 of 327
149
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---of 2003.
A That means---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, no, that was canceled. That-
--
THE DEPONENT: Canceled.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: ---was canceled in December---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: On both occasions.
THE DEPONENT: Right. It probably was canceled on both
occasions, with two different artists, meaning probably was
with Cheo, and probably was with Richie, or--- I don't know.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: You and---
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q And then, when you say---
THE DEPONENT: Yes, the--- both of us.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q OK., then, when you say "mis argumentos,..."
A Uh-huh.
Q "...sólo he recibido veintiocho mil..." "I've only
received twenty eight thousand from Martínez Morgalo, related
to this concert---"
A Uh-huh. I think we're talking about the Siembra
concert, or---
Q The Siembra concert.
A Yes.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 149 of 327
150
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Would that allow us to put a date on this document?
I mean, you're saying that you had only received twenty eight
thousand dollars.
A What date was this?
Q It's undated.
A Uh-huh. I really don't remember exactly what it was--
- ah--- and what date would this be? What date do you--- we
think this is?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well---
MS. GONZALEZ: It's undated.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: If you look at exhibit 14---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let's mark this one. This
would be marked as exhibit---?
THE REPORTER: 16.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 16. "Vamos a coger la de él,
para marcarla `16'."
(Whereupon, exhibit 16 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Look at 14, exhibit 14.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Es una hoja de un... Este. Este
es `14'".
THE DEPONENT: Aha.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Y el 16..."
THE DEPONENT: Aha.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: On 14, you're stating that, as
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 150 of 327
151
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
of May 16th, you had received wire transfers to Rubén Blades,
sixty eight thousand a hundred and twenty five, and on this
undated document---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---which is 16, your statement
at the end is you've only received twenty eight thousand
dollars related to this concert.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Is there an explanation as to the difference?
A Ah--- what I don't know, if it--- what--- what the
twenty eight was related to at this--- in this--- ah---
Q Could it be related to the sixty two thousand five
hundred dollars---?
A No. No.
Q You're sure of that?
A Absolutely.
Q OK.
A Absolutely.
Q But you have no other way to explaining why---?
A I think I didn't finish the thought.
Q OK.
A I didn't finish the thought. That's why I'm saying,
why was that there? I mean what--- what--- where was I going
with that?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 151 of 327
152
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Fair enough. So, let's take a-
-- You said thirty minutes?
MS. GONZALEZ: Forty five minutes, to lunch?
THE DEPONENT: I'm fine--you know--I---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: I'm a diabetic. I have to eat
something.
THE DEPONENT: No, please, do. I mean---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: So, let's do it--- Let's take
a forty minute---
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Forty minute break.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Mr. Blades, just to get back
on track after the break, I want you to look at exhibit 14
again. It's the one that looks like this.
THE DEPONENT: "Ajá, sí, aquí está."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I know we've already
discussed this, but just to refresh my memory.
Q When this was made, it says as of May 16---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---they declare--- or the accounted for expenses were
seventy three thousand zero zero seven and fifty five cents,
correct?
A Uh-huh. That's what I wrote.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 152 of 327
153
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. Of which twenty nine thousand and seventy five
cents were expenses paid by Colón and yourself, in whatever
proportion that was, and forty four thousand six dollars and
eighty cents were expenses called by Martínez and Morgalo,
including their commission, right?
A That's what it says.
Q And their commission would be thirty five thousand.
A ---- (no audible answer).
Q Ten percent, right?
A Yes, sir.
Q OK.
A There was an extra nine thousand something that I
can't remember what it was for.
Q These figures here, do they include the amount owed
to Gilberto Santa Rosa?
A I would think that they were part of what it says
expenses. I'm not sure.
Q OK.
A But if this is the number, I think it was seventy
three. I think it would have included it.
Q Uh-huh.
A So it should have been included in the twenty nine.
Q So--- OK., it should have been included in the twenty
nine.
A I would think so.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 153 of 327
154
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. So, when you got---
And this one is what? 16?
THE REPORTER: 15.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 15?
Q When you got exhibit 15, I mean, the check---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and the amount left in the account---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---which was close to fifty thousand dollars---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---you received ten thousand dollars in cash, which
you used to pay expenses?
A No, I think that--- I--- I'm--- I don't quite
remember. I think that, from the forty nine eight three five,
which was the wire---
Q Yes.
A ---transfer of--- reflecting in the balance. This is
what we received from--- from Arturo's wife. It was sent to---
It was sent by wire, which means I think it was received by
Víctor Manuelle's office, and then, from that, I think we asked
for a portion of it to be given in cash, so we could pay the
musicians--- ah--- and what--- whomever needed to be paid in
cash. And then, the rest was this--- ah--- this check that
appears there.
Q Plus nine thousand dollars that he kept as a
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 154 of 327
155
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
reimbursement.
A That--- Those were nine thousand dollars that were---
that were--- a re--- a reimbursement, correct.
Q And what was done with the thirty thousand dollars?
A The thirty thousand--- the--- ah--- there was twenty
thousand, I think, that--- Ten thousand I think were sent to
Willy, ten thousand something.
Q OK.
A And the rest, to pay for stuff that--- you know, I
don't know. Air fare, hotel--- ah--- reimbursement for me, for
my--- use of my Visa card--- ah--- what--- what not. It must be
all--- Everything has--- should me in the--- ah---
reconciliation--- ah--- all the--- the receipts.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Let me show you this
document.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 17. It will be 17.
(Whereupon, exhibit 17 was marked for the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Have you had a chance---
A Yes.
Q ---to look over the document? Do you recognize this
document?
A No.
Q You've never seen it before?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 155 of 327
156
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A I don't remember it.
Q So you don't know who prepared it?
A It wasn't me.
Q Do you know what Montana Studios is?
A Yes.
Q What is that?
A It's a recording studio.
Q And where is it located?
A New York.
Q And you know what--- who was Waldo Meléndez's air
fares is? Or is Waldo Meléndez? Is that a musician?
A No. I--- I--- Osvaldo? Yes.
Q Yes.
A He was, I think, with Willy.
Q José Dávila?
A I think they're all musicians.
Q All the ones that are listed here, all the way down
to---
A That says air fares?
Q Yes.
A Yes.
Q Do you know who Walter Flores is?
A Yes. Piano player. He worked--- ah--- with me. I
think he was--- ah--- was--- ah--- working in the band.
Q Did the---? Did you---? And by you, I mean you, and
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 156 of 327
157
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Willy, and M&M---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---incur in hotel expenses in New York---
A Yes.
Q ---in relation to this---
A Yes.
Q ---concert?
A Yes, because there were some guys who traveled from--
- ah--- tra--- guys who traveled from--- ah--- Costa Rica.
Q OK.
A There were several musicians, and the sound guys, who
came from Costa Rica.
Q What, if anything, would Montana Studios have to do
with this concert?
A That's where Willy rehearsed the band.
Q That's where he rehearsed the band. OK. So, this
looks like expenses incurred in relation to the concert?
A Yes. Except that I see here money sent to Rubén
Blades--- Aha, is that me? A hundred and seventeen thousand---
That I---
Q Do you have any idea where that number comes from?
A Not--- No, I mean, unless they added the--- I
received sixty eight, it said, in one--- in one thing, sixty
eight, one twenty five, and you take one seventeen, nine six 0,
and you have--- forty nine eight three five, which is the check
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 157 of 327
158
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
that we received from the moth--- his--- her--- ah--- Arturo's
wife.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Oh, so---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, OK.
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q So this---
A Arturo's balance---
Q ---they've added this to that?
A I'm sorry?
Q So they've added this---?
A Somebody did, yes.
MR. MORGALO: Hold on a second. I don't think those
numbers are--- I don't think those numbers are correctly
reflected, because if--- if--- if Arturo Martínez's wife
received those--- those funds into the company account, which
I don't know if she had access to it, or not, those monies are
sent from the promoter. It's not in addition to; it's part of
the wires that were originally sent.
THE DEPONENT: The monies were sent back from her
possession to Víctor Manuelle Ruiz's, or whomever---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: OK.
MR. MORGALO: Then, they should be deduced from---
THE DEPONENT: ---and then---
MR. MORGALO: ---the amount---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection to Mr. Morgalo---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 158 of 327
159
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: The monies---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---testifying.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---the monies--- Whoever--- whomever
did this---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Uh-huh.
THE DEPONENT: ---added the sixty eight thousand
dollars that I allegedly received, plus the forty nine eight
thirty five that correspond to the monies that Arturo's wife
returned by the exercise of Juan Toro. And that's how you get
the one seventeen nine sixty.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: OK.
THE DEPONENT: And--- Because it's--- if you--- if you
subtract it, that's exactly the number.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: So, the reason I'm asking is
that I believe that we got this---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---as part of the documents---
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes. This a document generated by Mr.
Colón.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: From Mr. Colón?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes. It's his font.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: His font?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The Colón font?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: It's your lower case number---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 159 of 327
160
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes. But it's a Willy Colón document.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: It's not---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I just wanted to figure out
what---
THE DEPONENT: Yes---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---what it meant.
THE DEPONENT: ---me too. Thank you. Because I've---
Now, I--- you know, I went--- I saw one seventeen, and I say:
"Where the heck is that coming from?"
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I--- Well, I had a chance
to examine--- If you take a look at the exhibit--- "¿Cuál es
éste?" 16.
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 16, the one you have right in
front of you.
THE DEPONENT: Aha.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Page 2, the list of payments
made for the--- in 2002---
THE DEPONENT: Aha.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---and your counsel, I
believe, provided some copies of the wire transfer originating
documents---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: We'll make copies, but I only
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 160 of 327
161
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
have one right now.
(Pause.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I'm showing them to you.
I draw your attention to the middle of those pages.
In the first--- In the one that says page number 1,
handwritten---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---it makes a reference to---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: There's a number of the lower
right hand side.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, no, the lower--- up---
up---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Sí, pero abajo, en el nombre."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "No, pero..." I'm referring to
the upper left---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, the handwritten number.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: That one. That page.
Q It makes a reference to a concert with Cheo
Feliciano, correct?
A "Ahí dice concierto Rubén Blades Puerto Rico 2002,
con Cheo Feliciano."
Q And it's set by Rompeolas--- That's a César Sainz
company, right?
A I don't know.
Q You don't know.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 161 of 327
162
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uhm-uhm.
Q To M&M.
A Uh-huh.
Q OK. And then, on the other pages, it simply says that
a 2002 concert.
A The--- "Segundo depósito", I guess it's eg--- dep---
Concierto Rubén Blades Puerto Rico 2002, "¿eso?"
Q Yes.
A Uh-huh, uh-huh.
Q And the dates, I believe, coincide with the ones that
are in the document that---
A Aha.
Q ---that you showed, that's exhibit 16.
A Uh-huh. I guess.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
(Pause.)
Q Now, the first one, which is dated--- It says here---
A "El primer pago o el primer documento en la lista."
Uh-huh.
Q Well---
A "Es que el primer pago fue el 27 de junio y está de
cuarto."
Q Yes.
A I'm sorry.
Q Yes. It says six--- I think it says six--- It might
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 162 of 327
163
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
say six twenty seven, or it might say six twenty one there.
A 27 of June of 2002.
Q Yes.
A It's twenty thousand dollars.
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry. That would be the 27. The
other one is twelve thousand five hundred, from 21st of June.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: This is the twelve thousand
five hundred. Yes.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The one that says twelve
thousand five hundred---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---says it's for---
THE DEPONENT: 21st of June.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Deposit for ten percent,
second deposit, third deposit--- Oh, I see. It's because the
dates here are not in---
THE DEPONENT: They're not in sequence.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes, they're not in sequence.
That's fine.
Q Now, after seeing this, you still don't recall the
thing about this concert?
A No.
Q Any issues regarding this concert?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 163 of 327
164
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A No. What I remember is that it was talked about, and
scratched, because conflicts of some kind. Was talked about.
Q OK. And I see that, in the concert with Willy
Colón---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---Martínez and Morgalo made some advance payments to
Willy and yourself, during the course of those months. I mean,
the--- each one of you received, at least, sixty two thousand
five hundred dollars---
A Yes.
Q ---from Martínez and Morgalo in two payments.
A Ah--- yes, I think it was two payments.
Q And you mentioned that--- I think you mentioned---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---but I'll ask again, isn't it customary to be
receiving advances as the booking agent is receiving the money?
A It depends. Sometimes--- ah--- Yes, sometimes you
figure you're going to be--- They were supposed to be paying
expenses, as they came along, so there was some money, I mean,
you expect to receive a bunk--- a bunch--- you know, twenty
something here, or twenty seven over here, and then, the--- the
lump sum.
Sometimes you get money in the middle, you call and
you say--you know--"Can you send me something?" Or where they
decide they're going to send you something, and--- it--- I
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 164 of 327
165
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
don't recall how--- how it was originated, but it's not---
ah--- it's not unheard of to have an--- an advance in the
middle of the---
Q And---
A ---of the--- of the--- ah--- period.
Q And you don't recall if, at any time between June of
2002, and October of 2002---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---as M&M is receiving money from Rompeolas, or César
Sainz, d/b/a---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---Rompeolas, M&M was advancing money to you?
A No.
Q You say no, you don't recall, or you---
A No, I don't---
Q ---say that---?
A ---have any information regarding that. And like I
said before, my accountant is very, very good at keeping
records, so if it's not in there, it didn't happen.
Q And as it stands today---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---it is your understanding that Rivas and Sainz---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---did disburse the full three hundred and fifty
thousand?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 165 of 327
166
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Yes, because I'm looking at the--- at the--- "¿cómo
se llama?", wire transfers. I don't think they made that--- for
what--- You know--- I don't think it's a bogus---
Q Yes. And---
A ---wire transfer.
Q ---and that--- those three hundred and fifty thousand
dollars include the sixty two thousand five hundred dollars
that they paid sometime during the course of 2002.
A That's what they said. Yes. That's what they said.
(Whereupon, exhibit 18 was marked for the record.)
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q Now, Mr. Blades, of those--- As of today, all
expenses have been paid?
A I--- I'm pretty sure, 'cause I never had--- I'm
not--- anyone called me for money.
Q If you were able to track the sixty two thousand five
hundred dollars---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---how much of this money belongs to Willy Colón?
A Half.
Q Half?
A Absolutely.
Q OK. "Ah, bueno", and if the M&M commission were---
A Half.
Q And any outstanding amount---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 166 of 327
167
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Half. Willy--- Willy--- Look, Willy gets half of
everything, you know? That's the deal. That's what we talked.
And that's the deal.
Q Is it your understanding that M&M is not entitled to
any commissions on this concert?
A My feeling in this thing, with all due respect to
everyone, and they can say: "Well, we worked, and--you know--we
deserve money", but my feeling is that we were all--- ah---
done a very huge disservice, so my feeling is you--- they
shouldn't get anything. But that's my feeling. They should not
get anything. You know? That's my feeling.
And I'm sorry, because you can argue: "OK., we
worked, and--you know--part of it, yes, we worked", but I mean,
I--- I don't think he--- I don't think either of us is
satisfied with what happened. So, under those conditions, they
should relinquish whatever amount they think they should have
earned, because this is a horrible scenario.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let the record reflect that Mr. Morgalo
is agreeing---
MR. MORGALO: Oh, I agree---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---nodding with his head.
MR. MORGALO: ---I--- I do agree a hundred percent. I
mean, I don't know if I'm allowed, but I--- I agree a hundred
percent with that statement.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. I'm going to mark--- I
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 167 of 327
168
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
don't have any more questions. I'm going to mark those last---
I'm going to get a copy of the last---
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---set of documents that I
showed you, and have it marked as an exhibit.
I need to ask the other parties if they have any
questions for Mr. Blades.
MR. MORGALO: I do. I have a series of questions. Can
I get five minutes to get my thing together?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Absolutely.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: And we should let the record
know that, after this deposition, sister counsel and I will be
reviewing some documents that Mr. Morgalo has brought, that we
intend to review, photocopy, and any questions arise from there
for Mr. Colón, you're welcome to make any such questions later,
after you review them.
MR. MORGALO: And I would like to add, I would like to
invite both, Willy and Rubén to examine---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: And I'm going to ask you to
sit here---
MR. MORGALO: While I do the---?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: To establish some---
MR. MORGALO: Some space?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Some space.
THE DEPONENT: Can I say something off the record.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 168 of 327
169
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Sure.
MS. GONZALEZ: Go off the record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. MORGALO: OK., this is Robert Morgalo, "pro se",
with my questioning of defendant and cross-plaintiff, Rubén
Blades.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
BY ROBERTO MORGALO:
A Mr. Blades, do you believe that I stole money from
you and Willy Colón?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. MORGALO: I'm asking---
MS. GONZALEZ: That's not within the scope of the
examination---
MR. MORGALO: It is, because---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---that counsel made.
MR. MORGALO: ---it pertains--- it pertains to
everything that we're asking questions off here.
MS. GONZALEZ: No. It pertains to your lawsuit against
him for defamation.
MR. MORGALO: Which is consolidated---
MS. GONZALEZ: And for that, you need---
MR. MORGALO: ---which is consolidated---
MS. GONZALEZ: But you need to depose him for that,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 169 of 327
170
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
because that's not the scope of this examination.
MR. MORGALO: Well, the--- the objection---
MS. GONZALEZ: If you want to ask questions about
that---
MR. MORGALO: ---is noted, correct?
MS. GONZALEZ: The ob--- If you want to ask questions
about that, you need to schedule a deposition for the purposes
of your lawsuit.
MR. MORGALO: I ask him a question. The objection is
noted. I just want to know if he can answer the question, if he
believes that I stole money from him.
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes, but you're not going to
instruct your client not to answer. I mean---
MR. MORGALO: It's noted.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: ---'cause I'll call the judge.
MR. MORGALO: It's noted.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes, the objection is noted.
MR. MORGALO: The objection is noted.
MS. GONZALEZ: I don't believe you use this deposition
to depose him on the substance of your claim---
MR. MORGALO: Well, I'm going---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---against Mr. Blades.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Counsel, your objection is
noted.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 170 of 327
171
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: It's noted.
MS. GONZALEZ: He does not need to answer that.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: You want to call---?
MS. GONZALEZ: It's not relevant. It is not relevant
to this.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: OK. The objection noted.
MS. GONZALEZ: You can ask a question about the scope
of his examination.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Quite frankly, I don't know
the answer to this, whether--- I mean, to be honest, because he
is a what? A cross? There's a cross-claim here?
MS. GONZALEZ: Correct.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes, and it's consolidated. It's
all consolidated.
MS. GONZALEZ: It's a claim that he initiated in the
Southern District of New York, it's a separate, different
claim---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Oh, it's a separate case.
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes, it is.
MR. MORGALO: No, it's consolidated to this case.
MS. GONZALEZ: It's a--- But it's a separate case.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Pamela---
MS. GONZALEZ: It's a--- The cases are separate---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Pamela---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---for the purposes of trial. Counsel,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 171 of 327
172
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
let me finish.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, I thought you had finished.
MS. GONZALEZ: Your case against my client is a
separate and distinct matter, that is not going to be tried
together with this case.
MR. MORGALO: Well---
MS. GONZALEZ: It will not.
MR. MORGALO: ---just so you understand, the numbers
and the figures that Rubén Blades is addressing here--all
right?--are the same numbers and figures, and he said, in this
particular case, in this statement, and--- and as of my
rebuttal, he said that we stole from him.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: He said it in this--- Hold a second. He
said it in this particular deposition. Forget about the other--
-
MS. GONZALEZ: No, he did not.
MR. MORGALO: Yes, he did. And we can---
MS. GONZALEZ: Not in---
MR. MORGALO: ---go back to the record.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---this deposition.
MR. MORGALO: In this deposition, he said it several
times.
MS. GONZALEZ: Secondly, it's immaterial.
MR. MORGALO: And it's in--- it's in---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 172 of 327
173
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: What he believes---
MR. MORGALO: It's in the record.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---after--- Excuse me. What he believes
about what you did, or what your partner did, or the
corporation did is immaterial to the---
MR. MORGALO: It's---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---to this case.
MR. MORGALO: It's immaterial, but in all the---
MS. GONZALEZ: Because---
MR. MORGALO: ---exhibits--- I heard you.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---the defenses--- the defenses---
MR. MORGALO: Hold on a second. In the---
MS. GONZALEZ: ---are stated.
MR. MORGALO: ---exhibits that are presented here as
evidence--all right?--it sates on---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Let's call the judge.
MS. GONZALEZ: What he believes is immaterial.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Sí, pero es que me molesta el
abuso."
MR. MORGALO: I appreciate that.
Look, exhibit 13, which is part of this---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: That might be the solution.
MR. MORGALO: Exhibit 13, which is part of the record
here, of this deposition, it says: "I also want Arturo to
clarify the extent of Robert Morgalo's involvement in this
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 173 of 327
174
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
situation, and because so far, Arturo is the one we all have
focused on, but it seems to me, it's obvious, Morgalo had a
hand as well in the embezzlement, and it's in Arturo's personal
interest to explain what the role the latter played in this".
This was not just entered into evidence, but it was stated
verbally---
MS. GONZALEZ: That's fine. You may ask a question
about that exhibit.
MR. MORGALO: Well, I just did. I just---
MS. GONZALEZ: Ask the question.
MR. MORGALO: The question that I have for your client
is:
Q Mr. Blades, I want to repeat it one more time. Do you
believe---?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. You may refer to the
exhibit, and ask him about the exhibit.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Thank you very much.
Q Mr. Blades, in exhibit 13---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---on paragraph 1, towards the middle, where it
starts saying: "I also want to clarify the extent of Robert
Morgalo's involvement in the situation".
A Uh-huh.
Q As you continue to read the end of that paragraph, do
you believe that Robert Morgalo stole money, and embezzled
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 174 of 327
175
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
money from you and Willy Colón?
A Yes.
Q OK. Thank you very much. Based on this statement
right here, from the same evidence, do you believe that if it
is proven that Robert Morgalo stole money, and embezzled money
from both you and Colón, that Robert Morgalo should be held
accountable for it?
A I think Morgalo and Martínez should be held
accountable for it.
Q OK. But you do believe Morgalo---
A I believe---
Q ---should be---
A ---Morgalo---
Q ---if found---
A ---Morgalo and Martínez office should be accountable,
held accountable for the monies that were not paid to Willy
Colón and myself.
Q If it is proven---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---that there was embezzlement going on, or that we
stole money, correct?
A That the office of Martínez and Morgalo stole, or---
Q Well, I'm ask---
A ---did not report the amounts--- Yes.
Q OK. I'm asking specifically about Robert Morgalo.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 175 of 327
176
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A I am answering you the office--- To me, Robert
Morgalo is one of the two people that were involved in this
issue. We're talking about the office of Martínez and Morgalo.
I'm not making this personal.
Q OK.
A As a member of that office, you are either solidary,
or you have a rep--- a responsibility in what happened.
Q OK.
A That's my--- that's my position.
Q OK. In the same token, if it's proven that Robert
Morgalo had no embezzlement, and Robert Morgalo did not steal
money, should Robert Morgalo, in the same token that he could
be held responsible and accountable---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---can Robert Morgalo be exonerated?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. It's a legal question.
A I have no idea, 'cause that would be up to a judge---
MR. MORGALO: OK.
THE DEPONENT: ---I mean, not to me.
MR. MORGALO: All right. Now, I'd like to present into
evidence--- Now, these are the only copies I have.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'll make copies.
MR. MORGALO: Thank you very much.
Counsel for Colón submitted into evidence a wire
transfer, or documents of wire transfer regarding monies that
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 176 of 327
177
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
were sent to Rubén Blades and to Willy Colón. I'd like to
present that as exhibits, all of them. And just to--- for the
record, there's two wire transfers from Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates to El Malo, Inc., and two wire transfers to Rubén
Blades Productions.
THE REPORTER: Exhibits 19 and 20.
MR. MORGALO: How you--- You know--- No, I don't know
how the process---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: You can put them together in one
document.
MR. MORGALO: Yes.
(Whereupon, exhibit 19 was marked for the record.)
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: What is the date of the second payment
of the forty? Can I see it? "Gracias."
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: I'm OK.
MR. MORGALO: You're good?
THE DEPONENT: "Sí."
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. There are two wire transfers there for Rubén
Blades Productions.
A Uh-huh.
Q Do you acknowledge that you did receive that wire?
A No. Oh, I'm sorry.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 177 of 327
178
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Yes.
A I would think so.
Q OK.
A Yes.
Q And your--- and your document, that's been entered
into---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It's been marked.
MR. MORGALO: Exhibit marked 14.
Q You put in there received by Willy Colón or Rubén
Blades, and it's a wire transfer to Willy Colón and a wire
transfer to Rubén Blades.
A Uh-huh.
Q Total, sixty eight thousand one twenty five---
A Right.
Q ---to Rubén, and sixty two thousand five hundred---
A Right.
Q ---to Colón. Does that add up to the amounts listed
in this---
A Yes, I would think that's the--- that--- Yes.
Q OK.
A I think those two are the---
MR. MORGALO: Thank you. Now, counsel for Colón also
entered into evidence two of wire transfers submission from the
promoters of Siembra to Martínez, Morgalo and Associates. I'd
like to present into evidence proof of wire transfers received,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 178 of 327
179
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
which--- on our end, that--- the--- the same dates and monies
that were sent--- that are listed on this document.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: This document being---?
MR. MORGALO: I'm sorry. Number 16.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 16.
MR. MORGALO: Which, on that document, it shows the
dates of the wire transfers, from Puerto Rico. This is the
acknowledgment of the receipt of those wire transfers on this
end.
Now, I don't have copies, but I need this stuff to
them--- so perhaps, later on, we can make copies---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: We'll make copies for
everybody.
MR. MORGALO: So if we can just annotate what--- what
we started with, which--- ah---
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 5.
MR. MORGALO: With which one we started? 17?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: The court reporter will know it.
MR. MORGALO: OK., OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 15.
MR. MORGALO: The one prior to that was--- was what?
THE REPORTER: 19.
MR. MORGALO: 19, OK.
(Whereupon, exhibit 20 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: If you want me to make copies
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 179 of 327
180
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
first, so that he can have a copy, while---
MR. MORGALO: No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---you ask him---
MR. MORGALO: I just want--- I just want to make sure
that we're all clear on the--- on the amounts, of who got what,
who got when, and just to make sure that--- that it's all in
there.
THE DEPONENT: I'm OK., uh-huh.
(Pause.)
MS. GONZALEZ: Excuse me.
(Long pause.)
MS. GONZALEZ: For the most part, they're underlined
for certain subjects, so we would like a copy, just so that we
know---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---what he underlined.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Counsel for Colón presented into evidence exhibit 11.
On page--- I guess it's page 147, bottom, right hand corner, or
page 8, top, right hand corner.
A Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. The first part of that paragraph, if
you could read--- I mean, you can read the whole paragraph. I'm
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 180 of 327
181
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
interested mainly in the first half of the paragraph, and in
the last sentence of that paragraph. Now, should I---? Can I
paraphrase it in English, to the best of---? Or should I have
the--- the---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: You can paraphrase.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You can paraphrase, and
counsel for Mr. Blades---
MR. MORGALO: I mean, Mr. Blades, can---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I mean, he knows if it's
accurate or not. Yes.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Can you tell me, in your own words, what the first
part of that paragraph states?
A Here?
Q I'm sorry, the top, page 8, or the---
A Top of page 8--- ah---
MR. MORGALO: Where it says: "Para el día 16".
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Page 7. No, "número" 7.
THE DEPONENT: All right, 7.
MR. MORGALO: Oh, OK. "Porque ahí dice... Ah, perdón,
OK., perdón. Disculpa, porque yo vi `page 8' allá arriba."
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Where it says: "Para el día 16 de
enero".
THE DEPONENT: Right.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 181 of 327
182
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: If you could read that, and let me
know---
THE DEPONENT: In English?
MR. MORGALO: Well, you could, if you want. I mean,
however you feel most comfortable.
THE DEPONENT: No, what is--- What should I do? It's
in Spanish.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, you should---
THE DEPONENT: Should I translate it?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You should say in English what
it says.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK., can you tell me in English what---?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It doesn't have to be---
MR. MORGALO: It doesn't have to be word per word.
Q Can you tell me what it means to you?
A In Eng--- It says: "By the 16 of January, I received
a call from Robert, where it indicates that he's going to the
Army, and that Arturo, from now on, is going to be in charge of
all negotiations. I called Arturo sad, because I had
established a professional relationship with Roberto, and we
had a little more--- developed more trust. Arturo says on
Saturday 18 January they would be making a farewell for Roberto
in his house, and I immediately told him I would like to go to
New York, and say good bye to Roberto, and thank him about all
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 182 of 327
183
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
the other"--- ah--- "past months of conversations, and wish him
good luck, and so it was, traveled to New York with my wife
18th January, and I remember, if not badly, that Arturo comment
that you were around, in that same day you went to Los
Angeles", meaning", I guess me.
"We handle about---" No, "we drove about two and a
half hours to give Robert a surprise that I had gone to Puerto
Rico to say good bye, and from that moment on, all the
conversations following that were with Arturo Martínez."
Q OK. So, for the purpose of establishing the timeline-
--
A Uh-huh.
Q ---regarding to the questions of the monies that came
in for the Siembra show, and the alleged monies that came in
for the 2002 shows, can we---? I mean, would you say---? You
OK.?
THE DEPONENT: Go ahead. No, no, it's OK.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Would you say that that day---? Would you ask
earlier, if you knew at what time, or you had commented
earlier, on the record, that you were not clear as to at what
point, whether it was January or February, that was no longer
operating the company.
A No.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 183 of 327
184
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: I should answer?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: No. What I meant was it was obvious to
me--- My concern right now, and I think this is the main issue,
I think, for all of us, is what happened with the sixty two
thousand five hundred dollars.
MR. MORGALO: Correct.
THE DEPONENT: And that, when I said that, I wasn't
sure what had happened, including yourself, has to do with fact
that those monies were paid, and those monies were used as a
backup, as an advance for a concert that we were having, that
had nothing to do with that gig. And the fact that I'm sure
Colón thought I had received the money, and I had pocketed it.
And that money was never given to me, and that money was
received by you guys, at the time when you were there, and
then, the question is why wasn't I told about this money, and
howcome that money, then, later on, shows up as an advance
against a concert that has nothing to do with Willy Colón or
myself.
And then, I went: "Where's the money? What happened
here?" And Arturo--you know--his position was, by then, they
were already having trouble, and the money was being used to--
you know--pay for stuff that didn't work, and that--- So, I
thought: "OK., we have to clear this part. This is the part
that I wanted to cle---" And that's when I--- when I mention
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 184 of 327
185
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
you---
MR. MORGALO: OK., well---
THE DEPONENT: ---because I was very careful, always,
with this thing, until I started getting information, and then,
I started making harder questions.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Now, can we go back to that same
page? I just want to---
Q The question that I have specifically---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is this: based on this conversation with--- or
this statement from Ariel Rivas, as of the 16th of January---
A Yes.
Q ---he was informed that all negotiations, from that
point on---
A Yes.
MR. MORGALO: That's the same one that we're not
supposed to be writing on.
THE DEPONENT: Oh. Yes, take it away.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Your attorney---
MR. MORGALO: There you go.
MS. GONZALEZ: ---has a copy.
THE DEPONENT: It's OK., it's OK. Sorry, sorry.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Basically, what I want to get at is that, based on
this letter from Ariel Rivas, we can determine that, as of---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 185 of 327
186
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
You can determine--- It can be determined that---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. MORGALO: What?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Let him finish the question.
MR. MORGALO: Yes, I'm not--- I'm not finished.
Q Based on this letter that's in evidence, from Ariel
Rivas to you, can it be established that, as of the 16th of
January, Ariel Rivas was clear that all negotiations for this
particular show, Siembra, was to be done through Arturo
Martínez?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Argumentative.
A Well, that's exactly what it says.
MR. MORGALO: Thank you very much. That's what I
wanted to know, OK.?
Q So, from the 16th of January forward, all
negotiations for Siembra is in the hands of Arturo Martínez,
correct?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
A I don't know that, because you could have been
addressing it through phone.
MR. MORGALO: OK., all right, that's fair--- that's a
fair answer. OK.
You have made allegations, and it's in here, in the
statement, and I hope I could find it, expeditiously.
In exhibit 14--OK.?--exhibit 14, in the bottom of the
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 186 of 327
187
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
page, it says here: "The amounts the promoters claim they paid
in 2002 for a show I was to do, and that was canceled twice by
them, due to conflicting schedules---" Now, you typed this up,
and used the word promoters claim. OK., and this was dated May
16th. All right?
Q As of May 16th, were you still not sure that the
claim was a fact, or just a claim?
A No, that's what they--- they stated. That's what I
meant. I didn't--- When I said--- when I wrote claim, it
doesn't mean that I doubted what they were saying. We had
already seen the--- I think by that date, I had already seen
the--- the wire transfers.
Q So, let me ask you a question. At the--- Your
determination that those funds---
A Which funds?
Q The sixty two thousand five hundred. That's what I'm
going to get to right now.
A OK.
Q The sixty two thousand five hundred dollars that is
being claimed was authorized to be applied towards that Siembra
show--all right?--where--- what gives you the impression that
those sixty two thousand five hundred dollars were to be
applied towards the Siembra show? Where do you get that from?
A I get it from the promoter.
Q From the promoters. So basically, your entire
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 187 of 327
188
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
knowledge of that sixty two thousand five hundred dollars being
applied towards that show comes from the promoter?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Argumentative.
A And your partner.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q And who's partner?
A Yours.
Q OK.
A Arturo Martínez.
MR. MORGALO: Arturo Martínez? OK.
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: I want to enter into evidence. This is
the only copy that I have.
(Whereupon, exhibit 21 was marked for the record.)
THE DEPONENT: And may I add something also? You
received--- you just showed--if I'm not wrong--receipts for
the--- for all the amounts received.
MR. MORGALO: No.
THE DEPONENT: Not those?
MR. MORGALO: No. The ones that I showed were the ones
that were listed out here. We're going to get to all of it.
"Luego..." By the time this is all over---
THE DEPONENT: All right, all right.
MR. MORGALO: ---there's going to be clarity here.
(Pause.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 188 of 327
189
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: I think we should make--- Let
me---
MS. GONZALEZ: Can you, please, make few copies?
We go off the record for a second.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Mr. Blades, I just handed out exhibit number 21. Can
you, please, tell me what this looks like to you?
(Pause.)
A It's a contract.
Q Contract for who?
A Rubén Blades, featuring Editus Ensemble.
Q OK. To perform where?
A At the Coliseo Roberto Clemente.
Q On what date?
A December 7, 2 0 2 (sic.)
Q What's the date of this contract?
A The date of the contract?
Q Of the contract. Top--- top right hand corner on the
document.
A 30th May 2002.
Q OK. So, it's a contract for the 30th of May, 2002---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---for a show---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 189 of 327
190
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A That's what it says.
Q ---for a show--- Yes. For a show in Puerto Rico,
September--- December 7, 2002.
A Right.
Q Correct?
A Uh-huh.
Q It says: "Deposit in the amount of six---" Can you
tell me what the deposit breakdown is?
A Sixty two thousand five hundred dollars---
Q Uh-huh.
A ---due no later than June 7th, 2002.
Q Uh-huh. OK. The second page of that---
A Yes.
Q ---what is the company for this presentation?
A Martínez, Morgalo and Associates, and then, it says:
"FSO Rubén Blades".
Q OK. Who's the promoter?
A César Sainz.
MR. MORGALO: OK. For the services of.
THE DEPONENT: FSO---
MR. MORGALO: FSO is for the services of.
THE DEPONENT: All right. OK.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Have you ever seen this contract?
A No.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 190 of 327
191
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. Are you aware what this contract is for?
A It's for a show in December, with an advance in June-
-- in May.
MR. MORGALO: In May. Correct.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: In June.
THE DEPONENT: The advance was in June?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Well, the deposit.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The contract there is 30th of
May, the first payment should be---
THE DEPONENT: OK. Sorry. The contract was allegedly
made on the 30th of May, 2002, and the deposit was supposed to
be paid no later than June 7, 2002.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Now, back to---
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: Back to exhibit 16, please.
On exhibit 16, a paragraph 3, page 2, can you read---
or translate in English, clarify paragraph 3 to us?
THE DEPONENT: Basically, it says that "Promoter
Dissar Productions alleges that the sixty two thousand five
hundred dollars that were missing from the three hundred and
fifty thousand dollar contract were paid the year before"--
meaning 2002--"this way, and I have ten thousand, on 28 of
October, two thousand into twenty thousand 3rd of October,
2002, twelve thousand five hundred, 21st of June, 2002, and
twenty thousand dollars on 27 of June of 2002.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 191 of 327
192
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: OK. Now---
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: OK. I want to submit to evidence the
only copies that I have of the wire transfers that came in to
Martínez, Morgalo and Associates, from that list that you just
listed, on exhibit---
MS. GONZALEZ: On the four--- those four?
MR. MORGALO: Yes, this is money that--- received by
Martínez, Morgalo and Associates, from---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let me make copies.
MR. MORGALO: OK., thanks.
Is an objection there, counsel?
MS. GONZALEZ: No.
(Off the record.)
(Whereupon, exhibit 22 was marked off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE DEPONENT: Twenty, ten and twenty. So there's a
twelve five, that's the one that is not--- Is this yours? Is
this the---?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: OK., so that's the one that is not---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'm just saying for the record
that Mr. Morgalo has presented, as exhibit 22 to this
deposition, three documents that appear to be the receipts of
some wire transfers--- October 3, 2002, for twenty thousand
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 192 of 327
193
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
dollars; October 29, 2002, for ten thousand dollars; and June
27, 2002, for twenty thousand dollars.
THE DEPONENT: I also want to say something, state
something for the record. I never heard of--- ah--- And my
memory doesn't help me, but I never--- I don't remember ever
seeing a contract in June for a gig in December. I don't--- I
don't ever remember anyone making contracts that far ahead in
advance.
(Pause.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Have you ever instructed Robert Morgalo, or Arturo
Martínez, or Martínez, Morgalo and Associates to hold funds
sent on your behalf?
A Have I ever authorized you to hold funds sent on my
behalf?
Q Instructed us to hold funds on your behalf.
A Not--- not--- not in so many words.
Q Have you ever specifically told us not to send money
to Jerry Shustek?
A No. Not that I can remember. On the contrary. I would
say that you would have to do that.
Q OK. Have you ever---? You were asked earlier today if
you have ever paid us consulting fees, and you said no, right?
A Consulting fees--- consult about what?
Q And you've also been asked have you ever paid rent---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 193 of 327
194
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Right.
Q ---at---
A At your office.
Q At our office.
A And---
Q And you said no.
A No.
Q OK.
A They also asked me if I had paid for an employee, and
I said no.
Q OK. Now, do you have any medical condition that--- or
history of---? Yes, I say this respectfully.
A No, it's OK.
Q I don't mean to--- Of absent mindedness, or
forgetfulness? Or forgetfulness?
A No.
Q Do you have a history of forgetting things?
A No, I don't.
Q OK.
A Well, I--- I forget things, but to have a medical
condition, no.
Q OK. All right. But you acknowledge that you are
forgetful in some things.
A I could be---
Q OK.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 194 of 327
195
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A ---and I have been told so.
MR. MORGALO: OK. I want to present as evidence--OK.?-
-to rebut the statements made---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, no, no, no.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You don't have to say what it
is for.
MR. MORGALO: Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. My apology.
OK.? I'm going to enter into evidence whatever you want to call
this. These--- well, let me---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Let me make copies of it.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
(Off the record.)
(Whereupon, exhibit 23 was marked off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. MORGALO: Mr. Blades, I just have admitted into
evidence exhibit--- exhibit 23?
THE REPORTER: 23.
MR. MORGALO: 23.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. Can you, please, tell me what exhibit 23 is?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: The--- "Ese es el que tiene que
mostrarle."
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: But he should have a copy.
A These are papers that say consulting fee for January,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 195 of 327
196
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
for eleven hundred dollars, sent to--- It says here Jerry
Shustek, and the're several amounts, invoices, from M&M to
Jerry Shustek, Rubén Blades Productions, care of Jerry
Shustek---
Q Can you list the---?
A ---for different amounts.
Q Can you list the dates of each one of those, please?
A Ah--- 8.23.2000, 9.26.2000, 11.21.2000, 8.11.2000---
And there's a band payroll, and ground transportation, and
reimbursement or tickets---
Q Uh-huh.
A ---I don't know what that is--- Sixty--- sixty two
hundred.
Q Uh-huh.
A There's another invoice for consulting fee for June,
2000---
Q Uh-huh.
A ---for eleven hundred dollars, there's something
tour, for two thousand, but--- The consulting fee of April of
2000.
Q OK. Do you know what that is---
A No.
Q ---what's that for? Do you recall---?
A No.
Q Do you recall that when--- ah--- Martínez, Morgalo
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 196 of 327
197
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
and Associates and Rubén Blades Productions opened up the
office---?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, you're testifying.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Counsel, let him finish.
MR. MORGALO: I'm asking a question.
Q I'm asking if you recall something, to clarify what
this is.
A Uh-huh.
Q Do you recall that Martínez, Morgalo and Associates,
and Rubén Blades Productions, when they opened their office,
that we shared, based on that document that was already
admitted into evidence, with the authorization of Martínez,
Morgalo and Associates, and Rubén Blades Production had the
same address, and same fax number, and same phone number,
right? Do you recall that, when we went looking for---? Do you
remember that we went looking for office space together?
A No, I don't.
Q You don't. Do you recall that you paid--- agreed to
pay rent at 350 Broadway?
A No, I don't.
Q OK. Do you recall that Jerry Shustek advised you
that, instead of calling it rent, we should call it consulting
fees?
A No, I don't.
Q So, why are we getting consulting fees every months
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 197 of 327
198
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
for eleven hundred dollars?
A I think that you're getting the eleven hundred
dollars for some reason, that's for sure, and I'm going to ask
Jerry what it is.
Q OK. Is it possible to reconcile that with some
payments from Rubén Blades Productions for that same timeframe?
A I have no idea. I would have to ask Jerry.
Q OK. Would you be able to produce those later on, if
needed?
A If he has them, I'll make sure he gives them.
Q OK. You also stated that you never told--- instructed
me, or anyone at Martínez Morgalo not to send money to Jerry
Shustek?
A No, I didn't say that. That I instructed you never to
send money to Jerry?
Q To not send money to Jerry.
A I never said that. And if you check the record,
that's not what I said. I--- I said that I would think that you
would send the money to Jerry.
MR. MORGALO: Well, let's go back---
THE DEPONENT: If you received money that was supposed
to go to me, those monies should be reported to my accountant
office.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q The question I asked you earlier---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 198 of 327
199
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q ---if you ever instructed Robert Morgalo---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---Arturo Martínez, or anyone at Martínez, Morgalo
and Associates---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---to hold your money, and specifically, not send
money to Jerry Shustek?
A I don't ever remember saying that.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 24.
(Whereupon, exhibit 24 was marked for the record.)
THE DEPONENT: To not send any monies to Jerry
Shustek's office, without my permission or approval. It's time
I check a first answer approach in matters concerning my
finances.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q What's the date on that?
A April 12, 2 0 2 (sic.)
MR. MORGALO: OK. Can we make copies of that, please?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Sure.
THE DEPONENT: That's different than saying that I
told you never to send money to Shustek.
(Pause.)
(Off the record.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 199 of 327
200
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Mr. Blades, do you recall writing that letter?
A I'm sure it was me.
Q OK. You had mentioned earlier that Arturo Martínez---
excuse me, Martínez, Morgalo and Associates only represented
you in matters of music and bookings. Did Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates do anything beyond the scope of booking for your
career?
A It might have happened that, at some specific
scenario, I would have said: "Could you help me with this?"
Q OK. Fair enough. Now, based on exhibit 24, regarding
your statement, or letter, and exhibit 23---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---your invoices to---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and other statements that you have made throughout
the course of this deposition, where you do not recall, or do
not remember, specifically statements when you said you do not
recall, and you don not remember---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---this particular show for sixty two thousand five
hundred dollars---
A Right.
Q Is it possible---?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 200 of 327
201
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, what show for sixty two
thou---?
MR. MORGALO: I'm sorry. The deposit for sixty two
thousand, five hundred--- The show with just you, with Ariel
Rivas---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---or the Dissar productions for the
December 7 show---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---that was going to be just you---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---OK.? You have mentioned---
THE DEPONENT: Talking about the one in May?
MS. GONZALEZ: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: I'm speaking right now specifically
about the one in 2002.
THE DEPONENT: The contract made that began that
deposit from June to--- when I---
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Right. Do you agree---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---that there's a huge question regarding the sixty
two thousand five hundred dollars?
A Yes.
Q OK. That's where I'm trying to get at right now.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 201 of 327
202
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q I'm trying to clarify this right now---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---OK.? You had stated earlier that you were not
aware of this particular show.
A That's correct.
Q OK. Is it possible---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---just as you have forgotten all these other things-
--
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is it possible Rubén---
A Uh-huh.
Q I'm sorry, Mr. Blades.
A Uh-huh.
Q I'm sorry about that.
A OK.
Q Is it possible---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---that you---? Is it possible that you may have
forgotten this?
A No.
Q OK. Why?
A Because when I--- Remember that I--- my--- I don't
make my own tax declaration. I send all of this to Shustek.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 202 of 327
203
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Uh-huh.
A So when I ask him to check, he checks everything.
Q Uh-huh.
A He doesn't just check his--- ah--- records for monies
that go to him. He would have checked my records, and seen my
bank account, and see if---
Q OK.
A ---I, all of a sudden, got a twelve thousand dollar--
- ah--- statement, or whatever it is that those amounts were.
Q OK.
A So--- And I never got any word on them--- on that,
and I, personally, don't remember ever receiving those monies.
Q OK. But you don't remember.
A No, I--- I--- See, I'm telling you. I mean, I---
other than to say no, no, I have not received---
Q OK.
A ---those amounts.
Q Oh. I'm not asking you about the amounts.
A Uh-huh.
Q I'm asking specifically about the date itself, OK.?
A The dates?
Q The show itself.
A No.
Q This particular show.
A No.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 203 of 327
204
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK.? All right. There is a contract---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---for--- that is presented into evidence here, for
Rubén Blades, at El Coliseo, for December 7th, correct?
A That's what it says there.
Q OK. You do not recall my speaking to you about this
particular show?
A No, I don't.
Q You don't recall my speaking to you about the
cancellation of this particular show?
A No.
Q Is it possible that you're forgetting that we had a
conversation about these shows?
A Is it possible?
Q Rubén---
A No.
Q Yes, is it possible?
A No. I don't think so.
Q So, when you're saying it's not possible that you
could be forgetting this, but it is possible that you could
forget all the other stuff that you have forgotten?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Argumentative.
THE DEPONENT: You're asking me very, very com--- you
know, very specifically do I remember this, and my question to
you is no. Do--- could have we talked about this thing, I'm
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 204 of 327
205
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
telling you--- Well, you're asking me could have we talked?
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Did we talk about this, Rubén Blades?
A No, I don't remember this concert at all.
Q OK. So, "I do not remember", does that constitute it
did not happen?
MS. GONZALEZ: What did not happen? The concert?
THE DEPONENT: The con--- the conversation.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q The question I'm asking--- You just said--- Your
answer, Mr. Colón--- Mr. Blades is this, that you do not recall
that we spoke about this.
A Yes, I'm telling you, I don't.
Q OK. So the question I have in follow up to that---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is you not recalling, does that mean that it
didn't happen? Your not having memory of it---
A It--- I can tell you it doesn't mean that it happen.
Q I--- I agree.
A So, there you have your answer.
Q But does it mean that it didn't?
A It means that---
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, asked and answered.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Thank you very much. OK.
Q What is the date of this--- of exhibit 21?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 205 of 327
206
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Date--- The date of--- Which date, Mr. Morgalo?
Q The---
A The contract described below, May--- this 30th day of
May---
Q Right.
A ---2002.
Q What is the date of the show?
A The date of the show is Saturday, December 7th.
Q December 7---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---correct?
A Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: All right.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Now, based on this contract, what is the fee there?
A A hundred and twenty five thousand dollars.
Q And what is the commission to Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates, based on that fee?
A What is it?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, what would be?
THE DEPONENT: I don't know.
MS. GONZALEZ: If there was a show for---?
THE DEPONENT: Ten percent, fifteen percent.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 206 of 327
207
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q What do you know if they--- ah---?
A I don't remember. It used to change. It was ten,
fifteen, I don't know. I don't remember what was it.
Q OK.
A Sometimes it was a certain amount, it would be more,
sometimes a less amount is less--you know--I don't remember
what the fee was.
Q You don't remember what the commission was to
Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
A I just told you. Sometimes it changed. Sometimes it
was fifteen, sometimes it was ten. No?
Q Do you---? I'm asking the questions.
A And I'm answering you.
Q Do you recall of any time that Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates charged you fifteen percent?
A Absolutely. I think that when you guys started,
that's what you used to charge.
MR. MORGALO: All right. I'd like to submit this into
evidence.
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 25.
(Whereupon, exhibit 25 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 25?
MS. GONZALEZ: 25.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK. Then, I have a mixup here.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 207 of 327
208
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Oh, I have two--- OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I have two copies---
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Mr. Blades, I just handed out exhibit 25---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---could you, please, tell me what that is?
A It says "we debit your account for payment for twenty
five thousand dollars".
Q "We debit" who's account?
A I'm sorry? Me, Rubén Blades Productions. Bank of
America.
Q Can you clarify that?
A What do you mean?
Q This is a wire transfer, correct?
A Yes.
Q OK. Who is the---
A It says---
Q ---beneficiary---?
A ---it says: "we debit your account", so I---
Q OK.
A ---guess that's it.
Q OK. Who's the beneficiary on the account?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 208 of 327
209
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Rubén Blades Productions Incorporated.
Q Who sent you the money?
A Martínez, Morgalo and Associates.
Q What's the date of that---?
A February---
MS. GONZALEZ: 2000, 2002---
MR. MORGALO: No, no, no. 12, December, 10---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: It's a---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: 2002.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, just for the record, it
says 02/12/10.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: The year in front, then, the
year, and then, the day.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Is that February or---?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, it's the year---
MR. MORGALO: No, if we look at the wire trans--- at
the exhibits that are presented prior to, the other wire
transfers, and you can see the dates on those, you'll be able
to clarify what the dates are on this one. We have sent--- we
have given some other exhibits earlier with dates on them.
MS. GONZALEZ: Is exhibit 25, which consists of two
pages, the same page reproduced twice?
MR. MORGALO: No, you look at the top corner of the
page, it's going to have some transaction on the top, left
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 209 of 327
210
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
hand. It's going to have a zero---
MS. GONZALEZ: 070000344FO, and---
MR. MORGALO: You have those. These are the originals.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: IMAD; I-M-A-D.
MR. MORGALO: Right here, up here. 08---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Y aquí, mira."
MR. MORGALO: Yes, well, here you have 08267 and
07268.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: And the IMAD here.
MS. GONZALEZ: OK.
MR. MORGALO: Oh, an IMAD? I've never--- I don't know
about that. So, what is that--- that number---? OK., OK.
OK. You see that?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Sure, yes.
MR. MORGALO: Now, if we can---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Fifty thousand dollars.
MR. MORGALO: And if you could see in--- Whe're the
other---? Where's the other exhibit that presented earlier with
the wire transfers?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The wire transfers? This one?
MR. MORGALO: The other ones. No, the ones that--- ah-
-- that were sent to El Malo, Inc., and to Rubén Blades
Productions.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Oh.
(Pause.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 210 of 327
211
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: OK. I just want to do it, so we could
cross-reference the dates, so we could be clear. We already
established, on the other ones, the dates were---
THE REPORTER: 19.
MR. MORGALO: ---the dates were---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: 19?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Ay, yo no tengo copia de
`19'." 19 hasn't been--- "Sácale cuatro copias ahí."
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: It's definitely the year.
MR. MORGALO: It's the year, so the first--- Can we
give that to Rubén Blades, so he can let us know---?
THE DEPONENT: So, what is the date here?
MR. MORGALO: All right.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes. The first number 02, means
the year.
THE DEPONENT: OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: And then---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Then, the month, and then, the
day. If you compare it to the prior wire transfer---
THE DEPONENT: So, December 10, I got---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: ---twenty five thousand dollars?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes, sir.
THE DEPONENT: On December 10?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: You're not asking the
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 211 of 327
212
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
questions.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q On 2002, you recei--- Those are two wire transfers,
for twenty five thousand dollars each, totaling---
A The same day.
Q ---totaling fifty thousand dollars, that's correct?
A The same day.
Q The same day, yes. OK.?
A OK.
Q Now, the---
A Make notes of that.
Q ---the---
MS. GONZALEZ: December 10---
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Based on the commission---
THE DEPONENT: December what?
MS. GONZALEZ: December 10th, 2002.
THE DEPONENT: OK.
MR. MORGALO: 2002.
Q Now, the contract--- the engagement contract number
21, exhib---
The engagement contract, exhibit number 21, says
there would be a deposit in the amount of sixty two thousand
five hundred dollars, correct?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Exhibit 21?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 212 of 327
213
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: Exhibit 21.
THE DEPONENT: Where is that?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Is the contract.
THE DEPONENT: OK.
What--- what is the question?
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q The deposit amount on that contract.
A Two--- sixty two thousand five hundred, due no later
than June 7, 2002.
Q OK., OK. Sixty two thousand five hundred dollars is
the deposit amount on that contract, correct?
A No later than June 7, 2002.
Q I got that. The question that I'm asking is this: the
amount is sixty two thousand---
A Sixty two thousand five hundred.
Q ---five hundred.
A Yes.
Q Which is fifty percent of the hundred and twenty five
thousand dollars, correct?
A Yes.
Q OK. Now, assuming, for the moment, because you're not
clear on what we charged--- Martínez, Morgalo and Associates
charges ten percent---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---or whether they charge fifteen percent.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 213 of 327
214
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q So, assuming, for the sake of this particular
question---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---if the commission is ten percent---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---of the hundred and twenty five thousand dollars,
how much is that?
A It would be twelve thousand five hundred.
Q If you subtracted twelve thousand five hundred from
the sixty two thousand five hundred, what does that leave you
with?
A Fifty thousand.
Q How much were the amounts of that wire transfer?
A Fifty two thousand five hundred.
Q The wire transfers sent to Rubén Blades Productions.
A Were twenty five thousand each.
Q For a total of?
A What alleged. Fifty thousand.
Q OK. All right, now, what are the dates of---? This
canceled show was December 7th, correct?
A Yes, that's---
Q December 7 was the date---?
A The contract says Saturday December 7th, yes.
Q OK. And you received the funds December 10th.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 214 of 327
215
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q There's a wire transfer there, there's two of them.
A Right
Q Wire transfer was sent---
A The wire transfers---
Q ---to Rubén Blades Productions.
A Those wire transfers that we're going to check state
December 10th---
MS. GONZALEZ: Exhibit 25. You're referring to exhibit
25?
MR. MORGALO: Yes, exhibit 25.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Was dated when? December 10th?
MS. GONZALEZ: Or October 12.
A No, what--- whatever. December--- Let us, for the
sake---
MS. GONZALEZ: December 10.
THE DEPONENT: ---sake of argument, yes.
MR. MORGALO: All right. I just want to get to the
bottom of this---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 215 of 327
216
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: ---just like you do---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---Rubén, OK.? So, we need to be clear.
Now, if we can--- Give me a moment--- We can stay on
the record, we can go off the record, while I look for what I'm
looking for.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Let's take a break.
MR. MORGALO: Yes.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. MORGALO: OK. Can you ask that question again?
MS. GONZALEZ: No, no, no, no, off the record--- It's
not supposed to be the other way around.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. Did you---?
MS. GONZALEZ: Off the record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK., Mr. Blades---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---on exhibit---
MS. GONZALEZ: That is not an exhibit.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "No, no, la carta."
MR. MORGALO: "La carta `itself, yes'."
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 216 of 327
217
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: That's WAC. The letter from "maestro"
Blades to "maestro..." "Esto, el 12."
MR. MORGALO: "El 12." OK. Exhibit 12.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "¿Este? No, mentira. Mala mía,
mala mía, mala mía. Ya lo confundí to'."
MS. GONZALEZ: 13.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "¿13? Gracias. La carta de
maestro Blades a... Ese es el 13. ¿13? ¿Willy Colón?"
MR. MORGALO: Yes, "ése mismo es, ése mismo es."
OK. All right. In exhibit--- Are we on the record?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Yes.
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Exhibit 13, first paragraph, where
it says: "I also want to clarify to the extent of Robert Mo---"
Can you read that out loud, please?
THE DEPONENT: Which?
MR. MORGALO: Where it says: "I also want to clarify
the extent of Robert Morgalo's involvement", from the--- from
that point---
THE DEPONENT: "I also want Arturo to clarify the
extent of Robert Morgalo's involvement in this situation."
MR. MORGALO: Keep going until the end of---
THE DEPONENT: "So far, Arturo is the one we all have
focussed on, but it seems to me, it's obvious, Morgalo had a
hand as well in the embezzlement, and it is in Arturo's
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 217 of 327
218
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
personal interest to explain what role the latter played in
this."
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q When you say it's obvious---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---Morgalo had a hand as well---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---what makes it obvious?
A It makes, to me, the fact that you're responsible,
solidary with the company. The fact that you never said
anything. I don't care you were in Iraq, or you could have been
at the end of the world. It's your name, it's your company, th
is whole thing was very public, the scandal was wide, and---
and never heard anything from you that said: "I had nothing to
do with this, this is not me---" ah--- "how dare you connect
me, I denounce Arturo for--- How could he do this to us, ̀ blah,
blah, blah'." So--you know--that's one issue.
The other issue is all of these things that we're
talking about now, about monies that were sent, the sixty two
thousand five hundred dollars, and nobody knew what--- where
they went, and we still don't know. So, all of those things,
But most--- mostly, the fact that my observation of you, and
how you ran the company, you were the one who really was making
decisions and doing things--- Arturo was more of the guy who
went out with the band, or the guy--- You were the guy who were
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 218 of 327
219
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
negotiating it, the deals, and that is very obvious also in the
testimony of Ariel Rivas.
Q Uh-huh.
A So, the fact that you--- That Arturo conned you, and
you had no idea of what was going on---
Q Let me ask a question, Mr. Blades, let me ask---
A ---that's hard for me to believe, Mr. Morgalo.
Q OK., Mr. Blades, you're a very accomplished man,
correct?
A Yes, sir.
Q OK. Were you conned by Arturo Martínez?
A We were all deceived, yes.
Q Well, the--- You find it hard to believe that I could
be conned---
A No.
Q ---but it's OK. for you to be conned?
A No, no, no. Not--- I think that there's a big
difference between conned--- my--- are being conned, and you
being conned. You were---
Q How so?
A You were in the responsibility area, sir. Your
company was the one who was providing us with a service.
Q Uh-huh.
A OK.? And your argument is you never knew of anything,
you didn't notice--- It's very interesting that I was asked
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 219 of 327
220
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
before whether or not I knew that the company was in financial
trouble. Obviously, you had a problem inside. And my
information coming from Arturo is that you were both in
trouble.
MS. GONZALEZ: Oh, really?
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. I'd like to present into evidence---
Hold a second. Can you just--- off the record, while I find
this evidence?
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q What knowledge do you have, Mr. Blades, of the
financial statements, or the financial positions of Martínez,
Morgalo and Associates?
A None.
Q None. Your basing that Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates had problems, based on who, or what?
A Based on several issues. One, most importantly, the
testimony of Arturo Martínez.
Q OK. Now, Arturo Martínez was communicating with both
you and Willy Colón, and Ariel Rivas---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---based on testimony that's already on the record,
up until a few days prior to the Siembra show.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 220 of 327
221
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Yes.
Q And up until a few days prior to the Siembra show---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---OK.?--no one knew, according to testimony, that
there was a problem, correct?
A That's what I believe, yes.
Q So, up until that moment---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---Arturo Martínez had been lying to everyone
involved, correct?
A Yes.
Q OK. So this same person, who has lied to everyone---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---who has admitted to spending the money, based on
evidence already presented---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---OK.?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection to the tone, counsel.
THE DEPONENT: Yes, but it's OK., I don't care.
Go ahead.
MR. MORGALO: I apologize for the tone. Well--you
know--I do.
THE DEPONENT: Well, good.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q The same Arturo Martínez, who has lied to everybody--
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 221 of 327
222
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
-
A Uh-huh.
Q ---apparently, and who has admitted, on the record,
to have spent the money---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---while I wasn't here, while I was in Iraq, and I
know you don't care about that, OK.? That same person, that
same person is the one that you're ta--- You're taking his
testimony on the financial situations of the company?
A The fact that a person has lied, or the fact that a
person is lying doesn't mean that the testimony that they
present is not truthful. That's going to be determined by the
tribunal, not by me. And one of the biggest cases in the mafia
are made with people who are hitmen, people who are cheats,
people who are killers, and they come up with testimony, and
it's all a matter of how strong the testimony may sound to the
jury, and the jury's going to make a decision. Not me.
Q OK.
A I have to go by what I--- you know---
Q All right.
A ---what I'm hearing directly from your partner.
Q OK.
A And excuse me, and word from the street, comments.
Q Words from the street. Do people in the street know
the financial--- internal finances---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 222 of 327
223
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A No.
Q ---of Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
A No.
Q OK.
A Not in detail, I wouldn't think.
MR. MORGALO: OK. I'd like to enter into evidence---
Let's start with--- Let's start with this one.
Are we on the record yet?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: No, it's just that my daughter
stepped into the---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, OK. You want to stop a
second? You want to---?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: She was asking for a key, but
I would---
MR. MORGALO: Oh, OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let's go off the record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. MORGALO: OK. I want to enter this as evidence.
This is the only copy I have. We're going to have--- Oh, is
that the case?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: We'll make copies.
MR. MORGALO: Make copies of all of this, if you don't
mind.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Déjame hacerlo rápido."
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 223 of 327
224
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: Let me put it in order first, so you can
make copies.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. MORGALO: OK. I'm going to be presenting into
evidence exhibit 26.
(Whereupon, exhibit 26 was marked for the record.)
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: You got the original, and three
copies.
MR. MORGALO: I have the original, and I passed out---
How many copies?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Three copies.
MR. MORGALO: Three copies.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Quédate con una y dale otra..."
MR. MORGALO: OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: Thank you.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Allí."
THE REPORTER: "¿Es una página nada más?"
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: "Sí, una página."
MR. MORGALO: Yes, one page only.
(Pause.)
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: OK., and that's exhibit what?
MR. MORGALO: This is exhibit--- what? 26?
Rubén--- or Mr. Colón--- I mean, sir, Mr. Blades---
THE DEPONENT: It's OK. Hey--- Aha, go ahead.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 224 of 327
225
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK., Mr. Blades, what is this that I just passed out?
A It's a hundred thousand dollars, advise of credit.
Q OK. Do you know what this is?
A No.
Q Are you aware that this is a grant from the
government to Martínez, Morgalo and Associates? It's a hundred
thousand dollar grant.
A OK.
Q OK.? How much is the amount on that?
A A hundred thousand.
Q OK. What's the date on that?
A Again, what? December 18th?
Q Yes. What year?
A 2002.
Q OK. So, there's a hundred thousand dollars into the
company, on December 18th, 2002, correct?
A Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. I want to pass out this one now.
(Pause.)
THE DEPONENT: "¿Y esto es otra cosa?"
MR. MORGALO: Yes, "eso es otra cosa."
THE DEPONENT: OK.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q What is that?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 225 of 327
226
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Ah--- I don't know.
Q Is that a wire transfer?
A Advise of credit.
Q Is it a wire transfer?
A I don't know. It's--- ah---
Q Does it---?
A ---advance of credit---
Q Does it look like the other wire transfers we've been
looking at all day?
A Not really. I would imagine it is. Is it? Yes, I
guess.
Q OK. It's a wire transfer. What is the amount of that
wire transfer?
A What is the what?
Q The amount of that wire transfer.
A One hundred and forty nine thousand dollars, and nine
hundred and seventy dollars. One hundred and forty nine
thousand nine hundred and seventy dollars.
Q That's correct.
A OK.
Q And the date of that wire transfer?
A It's--- ah--- January 12--- I'm sorry, December 12,
2002.
Q OK. And who received these funds?
A This was received by Martínez Morgalo.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 226 of 327
227
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q OK. So, on December 12, 2002---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---at Martínez Morgalo received a hundred and forty
nine thousand nine hundred seventy dollars.
A Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Hold on a second. Now, I'm looking
for---
THE DEPONENT: And these other---?
MS. GONZALEZ: What is Prestige Capital?
MR. MORGALO: No, I ask the questions here.
I'm sorry.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Getting the hang of it, huh?
MR. MORGALO: OK., but I'm going to go ahead and do
it. I just had to do that, 'cause I'm getting--- I am getting
the hang of--- I'm sorry about it.
MS. GONZALEZ: I'm glad you find this amusing.
MR. MORGALO: Well, the thing is I don't mean this---
But when I mess up, they tell me right away. And I don't have
the training.
(Long pause.)
THE DEPONENT: You're waiting for me?
MR. MORGALO: Did they pass that one out yet?
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. What does that look like to you?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 227 of 327
228
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A It looks like a slip, a bank slip, deposit, checking.
Q Oh, you can't see the back of this, can you? 'Cause
it's a copy.
A For fifty thousand dollars.
MR. MORGALO: Yes. We're going to make copies of the
second page, but that's what it says there.
THE DEPONENT: This is---
MR. MORGALO: 'Cause I made a copy of---
THE DEPONENT: OK. And it's a deposit, two deposits,
or one deposit for fifty thousand dollars.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q From?
A From Pernod Ricard.
Q OK. All right. What date is that?
A November 8.
Q November 8, so---
A I think. I don't--- Is that what it is?
MR. MORGALO: Yes, that was November 8. So, on
November 8, Martínez, Morgalo and Associates deposited fifty
thousand dollars into the account, correct? So, so far, between
November 8th, and December 12---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---there's three hundred thousand
dollars that went into the account. OK.? Let me take this one
now.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 228 of 327
229
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: So just so far, in the last quarter of
2002, we have three hundred thousand dollars going into the
bank account.
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 29.
MR. MORGALO: OK.?
(Whereupon, exhibit 29 was marked for the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Yes. You made a reference to
November 8?
MR. MORGALO: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I think the document says
November 14.
MR. MORGALO: Yes, but behind it--- Because you can't
see it on that side, and it's because of the way the copy was
made, all right? Behind it, and you made a copy---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Oh, sorry.
MR. MORGALO: It's OK. We can---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: I'll make another copy.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Just of the second page, that would
be good.
THE DEPONENT: So, what date is it? It was---?
MR. MORGALO: No, you were right on the date.
THE DEPONENT: The 8th, or 14th?
MR. MORGALO: The 8th.
(Pause.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 229 of 327
230
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: And like you said, getting close to it,
to--- The more arguments we have, the clearer it is.
This is yet another one?
MS. GONZALEZ: That's another exhibit, yes. The next
one.
MR. MORGALO: Are we still on the record, or---?
THE REPORTER: We are on the record.
MR. MORGALO: OK. We are on the record.
THE DEPONENT: We are? So this is another one for---?
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q For how much?
A A hundred and twenty five thousand dollars.
Q Uh-huh.
A And it's dated--- ah--- January, February, March---
March 13, 2002.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Esto es página 2 del exhibit,
aquel que..."
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q And who is it from?
A It's--- Who's it from? From--- from--- Wing Latino
Group.
Q Yes. OK. And it was for how much, again?
A A hundred and twenty five thousand.
Q A hundred and twenty five thousand dollars. And that
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 230 of 327
231
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
was dated---
A March 7, 2002--- Oh, March 13---
Q Yes.
A ---2002.
MR. MORGALO: And this is the next one, right here.
(Pause.)
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 30.
MR. MORGALO: OK., this is number 30?
THE REPORTER: Number 30.
(Whereupon, exhibit 30 was marked for the record.)
THE DEPONENT: Are we on the record?
THE REPORTER: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: This is another one, for two hundred
thousand dollars--- ah--- January, February, March, April---
April 3rd, 2002, from Pernod Ricard, check for Latin Nights,
2002 sponsorship.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. For how much? Two hundred thousand?
A Two hundred thousand.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: OK. I've got actually more, that I would
like to submit, but I don't even know if I need to. I guess
what I'm trying to show--- I mean, I could, if you want, 'cause
you're going to turn them all in, if you want. It's up to you.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 231 of 327
232
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: We have asked for all of the financial
record of Martínez, Morgalo and Associates.
MR. MORGALO: OK. And I have them all, OK.? All right?
I do have them all. As a matter of fact, give me the rest of
them, I'll just go ahead--- I'm going to submit the rest of
them as just one exhibit, instead of going back and forth with
all--- Is that OK.?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Sure.
MR. MORGALO: OK. So just for the save of time.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Sure. I think sister counsel and
I want to see the rest of the documents that you have--- I hope
you're not going to introduce the rest of the---
MR. MORGALO: No, no, no, no.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: ---pack. You just want to---
MR. MORGALO: No, no. This is---
MS. GONZALEZ: We also want your answers under oath to
the interrogatories that went with the document production
request.
MR. MORGALO: You'll have that tomorrow. You'll have
that tomorrow. Here you go. OK.
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 31st.
(Whereupon, exhibit 31 was marked for the record.)
THE REPORTER: Exhibit 31st.
MS. GONZALEZ: 31?
THE REPORTER: Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 232 of 327
233
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Two pages?
THE REPORTER: Yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Que no necesariamente `are
related', pero se lo están preguntando..."
THE DEPONENT: "¿Este no fue el que ya vimos? Oh, éste
es otro?" Two thousand--- two hundred thousand, and forty five
thousand?
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Sí, el primero, aparece el
`deposit slip' del cheque..."
THE DEPONENT: "De Pernod?"
MR. MORGALO: "The Pernod." Yes.
THE DEPONENT: "¿Del que ya vimos?"
MR. MORGALO: "Sí, yo creo que eso..."
THE DEPONENT: Supplemental business W--- World Trade
Center Business Recovery Grant?
MR. MORGALO: Yes.
THE DEPONENT: You applied for that?
MR. MORGALO: Yes. I got--- I got a bunch of grants.
THE DEPONENT: All right. Good.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q So based on the information I've just presented---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---OK.?--it adds up to roughly somewhere be---
Because I haven't added it all up here---
A Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 233 of 327
234
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---but I just want to make sure we have it all or not
have it all---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---it's roughly eight hundred thousand dollars.
A OK.
Q OK.? That the company, in 2002, aside from bookings,
aside from Rubén Blades, or anybody--- any other artist in
booking, just in grants, and sponsorship, and--- ah---
factoring, received almost eight hundred thousand dollars in
operational money---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---OK.? The--- Does--- And almost four hundred
thousand of which came in in the month of December---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---OK.? Does that sound to you like a company that's
having financial problems?
A I would have to know what the money was done for. I
mean, you can have four hundred thousand dollars and spend
eight hundred thousand dollars.
Q Correct.
A So I don't---
Q But the point I'm getting is this: you don't know for
sure that the company was in any kind of trouble.
A I have to look at your books. I mean, it's not about
the money that comes in. It's what--- what's the money that
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 234 of 327
235
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
comes out.
Q OK.
A You can get all the money in the world, and---
Q Well---
A ---and spend it all in gambling, or spend it all in--
- in bad shows, and be broke the next day. I mean, I don't
know.
Q But you're basing the--- the statement that the
company was in trouble, based on what you heard.
A Why did the company go down? Because you left.
MR. MORGALO: I think--- Well, you're asking
questions.
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
MR. MORGALO: Yes, I know, I know.
THE DEPONENT: It's a rethorical question.
MR. MORGALO: I know, and that's---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
MR. MORGALO: And that's--- I'm---
THE DEPONENT: I'm not asking for an answer.
MR. MORGALO: OK. Now, let's go back to---
THE DEPONENT: And it's just making a comment on the
fact that you say that the health--- the company was healthy,
and all of a sudden, it's not. It doesn't work that way.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Well, let me ask you a question. Do you find it
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 235 of 327
236
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
strange that, up until the time that I was in the company,
there was no problems with the company, but the moment I left
the company, there was big problems?
A I don't know if the company had no problems when you
were there.
Q Well, do you find it strange---
MS. GONZALEZ: I also--- Objection.
MR. MORGALO: Hold a second.
MS. GONZALEZ: Assumes facts not in evidence.
MR. MORGALO: OK.
MS. GONZALEZ: We don't know when you left the
company.
THE DEPONENT: In--- in---
MS. GONZALEZ: That hasn't been established.
THE DEPONENT: In all due--- with all due respect,
like I said before, it--- and that is, again, something that
needs to be--I guess--cleared at some point--you know--you can-
-- you can be--- You don't have to be inside of the office to
be a part of the office. And I know this.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. Let me ask you a question. Do you---? Is it your
belief that, although I was deployed to Iraq---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---that I had the ability---?
A I don't know.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 236 of 327
237
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q But are you making that assumption?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. They are---
A I don't know. I don't know, Robert Morgalo. I have no
idea what you did or did not do. I don't know.
MR. MORGALO: OK. So we're going to go back to the
statement that you made just a little while ago---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---to clarify, OK.? Where it says: "But
it seems to me, it's obvious---"
THE DEPONENT: Right.
MR. MORGALO: "---Morgalo had a hand as well in the
embezzlement, and it's in Arturo's personal interest to explain
what the role the latter played in it."
THE DEPONENT: And I go back to what I said to you
before. The problem did not begin in January 16th. The problem
began before that.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. So now, what you're saying is that the problem
here---
A Yes.
Q ---for the entire mess that we're sitting here right
now started prior to the 16th of January?
A The problem, as far as I'm concerned, had to do, in
part, with the inability to answer to some of these arguments
that this man Rivas also made in his statement.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 237 of 327
238
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q Which is?
A When he said that you negotiated the Siembra deal,
that you were in front of the--- that you were the guy in
charge, that you were the guy that did all the stuff, whereas
you say that you had nothing to do with the deal.
MR. MORGALO: I didn't say I had nothing to do with
the deal.
Q Mr. Blades, did I present a contract to you, to look
at, that states that, as a show, a concert for December 7th,
for Rubén Blades in Puerto Rico. Did I present that as
evidence?
A There was a contract there, yes, that I didn't
recognize.
Q I understand.
A Uh-huh.
Q Now, that contract that I'm submitting in evidence---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is it your impression I submitted it into evidence
to deny that there's such a concert?
A Which concert?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Unintelligible.
THE DEPONENT: Which concert?
MR. MORGALO: OK., OK.
Q I presented to you a contract---
A Uh-huh.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 238 of 327
239
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
Q ---which states December 7th Show for Rubén Blades in
Puerto Rico---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---with Rompeolas.
A Uh-huh.
Q I presented it as evidence.
A Yes.
Q You deny any knowledge of that contract.
A Yes, I'm saying---
Q OK.
A ---that I'm not---
Q Do you---?
A ---I don't recognize that---
Q Do you believe that I introduced that contract into
evidence---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---to deny the existence of that contract?
A I don't know why you presented it.
Q OK. Is it possible that I presented that contract
into evidence to show that there was, in fact, a contract for
that date?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Speculative.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Is Ariel Rivas claiming that there was a contract for
a date December 7th?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 239 of 327
240
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Ariel Rivas is not here.
MR. MORGALO: It's in the record.
THE DEPONENT: What is on the record.
MR. MORGALO: OK. We're going to go back to here.
February---
(Pause.)
MR. MORGALO: Exhibit 14. And that, on the pa--- it
says: "The amount the promoters claim they paid, claim they
paid in 2002 for a show I was to do, and what--- was the---
canceled--- and what was canceled twice".
Q What promoters are claiming that? Ariel Rivas?
A I don't--- I--- Let me--- let me find the--- the
paper, so I can look at it, please. 14?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: It's exhibit 14.
MS. GONZALEZ: Do you have exhibit 14 there? It's not
over here.
(Pause.)
THE REPORTER: This is 14.
MR. MORGALO: No, I'm sorry. This 14.
THE REPORTER: 13, then.
MR. MORGALO: I'm sorry.
Oh, yes, yes, that was the 14, yes. It's that form,
on the bottom.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Es el mismo 14 que tú
tenías."
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 240 of 327
241
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: "Sí, sí."
THE DEPONENT: "No, pero entonces..." Where is that?
MS. GONZALEZ: Oh, this?
MR. MORGALO: Yes.
MS. GONZALEZ: Oh. OK.
MR. MORGALO: Down at the bottom, where it says "The
promoters". "The amount the promoters claim they paid in 2002
for a show I was--- I was to do, and that was canceled twice by
them, due to conflicting schedules."
THE DEPONENT: Yes. What's the question?
MR. MORGALO: OK. And then, on number 6, exhibit 16,
in the bottom, exhibit 16---
THE DEPONENT: I don't have that. Yes.
MR. MORGALO: All right? In the bottom of page 2---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---this is from you---
THE DEPONENT: Uh-huh.
MR. MORGALO: ---where it says: "Indica el promotor".
Q Can you paraphrase that in English with---?
A "Promoters state that--- that such amounts"--that's
the sixty two thousand five hundred--"corresponds to the
concert--- of a concert to be realized in Puerto Rico that was
canceled in two different occasions; December, 2002, and
February, 2003.
Q So, Ariel Rivas is claiming---
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 241 of 327
242
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Uh-huh.
Q ---and had claimed, and has brought into question
sixty two thousand five hundred dollars that they sent, that
was received by Martínez, Morgalo and Associates for the
purposes of a show in December, correct?
A Yes, that's what it says here, December---
Q OK.
A ---and February.
Q OK. Now, that contract that I presented to you for
December, with Rompeolas--all right?---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---was for December 7th. It was of Rompeolas. Is
there anything in writing that represents an agreement to
transfer the funds from that show to the Siembra show?
A Not that I--- I've never seen that.
Q So that it doesn't exist?
A I don't know.
Q OK. All right. So, now we're getting some place. Do
you belie---? To your knowledge, did Robert Morgalo agree to
transfer those sixty two thousand five hundred dollars---?
A That's what Ariel says.
Q OK., so Ariel--- Ariel can say that your--- I don't
want to get disrespectful. Ariel could say anything. Because
Ariel say so, it's a fact.
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 242 of 327
243
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q I'm asking you a question. Is an allegation by Ariel
Rivas, that that money was supposed to be applied to this show,
a fact?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection, Mr. Morgalo. That's an issue
for trial.
A That's what the promoter is saying.
They presented every single amount of evidence
needed, except for the sixty two at one point, and then, they
gave me--- they gave us those slips.
MR. MORGALO: Correct.
THE DEPONENT: And then, your partner stated that they
received the monies.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q What slips? OK., let's go to the slips.
A The--- the four---
MR. MORGALO: OK. Let's go--- Now--- OK., now--- now
we're getting some place. We're going to go back to the wire
transfers---
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: ---for the Siembra show, which are in
evidence---
THE DEPONENT: You're talking about exhibit 16?
MR. MORGALO: Yes. Now, let me stay on a second---
(Pause.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 243 of 327
244
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The wire transfers for the
Siembra show, I think it was---
MR. MORGALO: Yes. We--- I presented them---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Ah, they're there. OK.
MR. MORGALO: Yes. I did present the--- all the wire
transfers that corroborate these dates, that Rubén Blades---
And you guys have presented it was well, the wire transfers
from Ariel Rivas.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: 22. No---
MR. MORGALO: Number 16, in the bottom of 16 is a
whole bunch of dates.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: I don't think there's any
question, if I may say, the--- I don't think there's any
question in this table that monies who per--- Sixty two
thousand five hundred dollars---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, no, he means---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: ---were---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, he doesn't mean that. He
means the ones sent afterwards for the Rubén--- Rubén Blades,
Willy Colón---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, I see.
MR. MORGALO: OK. I want to go back to the wire
transfers that you have here. Look at the dates--- On number
16, look at the dates on the bottom of 16.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 244 of 327
245
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: Look at all those dates.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: The contract for Siembra, according to
the record, is January 22nd is when that contract was--- was
written. According what evidence is on the record. January
22nd, 2003, exhibit 8, exhibit 7, exhibit 6--- January 22nd is
when the Siembra concert took place.
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. MORGALO: I'm sorry. That's when the contract is
written.
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
MR. MORGALO: What?
MS. GONZALEZ: That hasn't been established.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. The date on the contract is January 22nd,
correct?
A I don't know. Where is it?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. What contract?
MR. MORGALO: The engagement contract for Siembra.
MS. GONZALEZ: Well, we've seen a few versions of it.
MR. MORGALO: All three versions have the same date.
MS. GONZALEZ: Are they here?
MR. MORGALO: Yes, they're in evidence.
MS. GONZALEZ: But what's the exhibit number?
MR. MORGALO: 8, 7, and 6.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 245 of 327
246
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MS. GONZALEZ: Exhibit 8.
(Pause.)
MS. GONZALEZ: 7 and 8---
THE REPORTER: Off record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE DEPONENT: "The engagement described below, made
this 22nd day of January, 2003, between the undersigned,
purchaser of music, herein called employer, and now, it is name
of artist, Rubén Blades and Willy Colón.
MR. MORGALO: OK., that's fine.
Q So, the document states that the document was made on
the 22nd of January, correct?
A That's what the document says.
Q All right. So, for the record, the 22nd of January is
the date of the Siembra show---
A OK.
Q ---OK.? Of the contract, of the engagement contract.
A Uh-huh.
Q OK.? Based on that contract, and your statements here
of the money, and the wire transfers that have already been
presented into evidence, the wire transfers from the promoters,
and the receipt of those wire transfers, that I've presented as
evidence as well, to confirm the receipt of those wire
transfers, all corroborate with these dates.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 246 of 327
247
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A OK.
Q Correct?
A Yes, I guess.
Q OK. Now, when you look and add up all of dates, all
of the monies from those wire transfers, what does it add up
to?
A I don't know. What do they add up to?
Q How much the contracted amount for the show?
MS. GONZALEZ: For what show?
MR. MORGALO: For the Siembra show.
A Three fifty.
MR. MORGALO: Three hundred and fifty thousand
dollars.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q And those wire transfers for the Siembra show---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---is the three hundred and fifty thousand dollars
received, based on those wire transfers?
A I didn't add them up, but I--- you know, I guess we
can do that right now. Why don't we do it?
MR. MORGALO: Let's do it.
MS. GONZALEZ: Off the record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 247 of 327
248
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Mr. Blades, on the deposits paid for the Siembra
show, based on your calculations of exhibit 16, what is the
total that you came up with?
A Two eighty seven--- Two hundred and eighty seven
thousand five hundred dollars.
Q So, based on the wire transfers that we presented in
evidence, that---?
A No, based on the wire transfers that I received from
the promoters. It's two hundred eighty seven thousand five
hundred dollars.
Q Did you receive the deposits from the promoters
directly to you, or through Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
A No, they went to Martínez and Morgalo.
Q OK. So, these two hundred and eighty seven thousand
five hundred, does that constitute the deposits paid by the
promoters of the Siembra show, for the Siembra show?
A This is what the promoters inform me.
Q OK.
A This is what this paper says.
Q OK.
A I don't know what---
Q All right.
A ---you--- your--- your wire transfers say.
Q And what does that amount add up to, again?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 248 of 327
249
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A Two hundred and eighty seven thousand five hundred
dollars.
Q How much was the contracted amount for the show?
A Three fifty. Three hundred and fifty thousand.
Q So, what is the difference between the three hundred-
--?
A Sixty two thousand five hundred dollars missing.
Q OK., so the sixty two thousand five hundred dollars
missing?
A From the total of the three fifty.
Q That what? That the promoter was supposed to send?
A That the contract amounted to.
Q Well, the question I have. You have proof of two
hundred and eighty seven thousand five hundred dollars that the
promoter sent for that show, correct?
A That is correct.
Q Do you have proof for the other sixty two thousand
five hundred dollars that the promoter was supposed to send for
that show?
A No.
Q OK. So there's no proof of that---
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes, there is.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q ---of that sixty two thousand---
THE DEPONENT: Other than--- There is?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 249 of 327
250
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q ---five hundred dollars?
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
MR. MORGALO: OK., I'd like to see that.
THE DEPONENT: Take myself--- Oh, these are the four--
- I'm sorry, these are the four wires.
MR. MORGALO: Hold on a second.
Q What are the dates of those wires? Are these those
four wires that you have over here, that have listed here?
A I don't know.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Listed where.
MS. GONZALEZ: These are the---
MR. MORGALO: I'm sorry. Listed in number 16.
MS. GONZALEZ: Yes, they are---
THE DEPONENT: This is it?
MS. GONZALEZ: ---this one.
THE DEPONENT: Yes.
MR. MORGALO: OK. I want you to read, on number 16,
page 2, paragraph 3, number 3.
THE DEPONENT: "Promotor Dissar Productions alega
que... eh... claims had the amount that was missing to cover
the total contracted sixty two thousand five hundred dollars
were already paid last--- the year before, last year---"
MR. MORGALO: OK.
THE DEPONENT: ---meaning, I guess, 2002.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 250 of 327
251
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. MORGALO: So---
THE DEPONENT: "The promoter alleges that Martínez
Morgalo received such amounts the following: ten thousand
dollars, on 28th of October, 2002; twenty thousand dollars,
October 3, 2002; twelve thousand five hundred dollars, 21st o
June, 2002; twenty thousand dollars, 27th of June, 2002."
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q For a total of?
A Sixty two thousand five hundred.
Q OK. Now, those deposits---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---were made prior to the contract for Siembra ever
being established?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection. Ambiguous.
MR. MORGALO: Is that ambiguous? The dates speak for
themselves. You just write off a date---
THE DEPONENT: I don't know--- Excuse me. I'm no sure
when that contract of Siembra was finally discussed for the
first time. I don't know when was the first time this was
discussed.
This is what I know. These amounts were amounts that
were paid for a different type of show---
MR. MORGALO: Exactly, so---
THE DEPONENT: ---allegedly---
MR. MORGALO: Thank you very much.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 251 of 327
252
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: And then, those amounts were applied as
an advance against the Siembra concert. Is that correct?
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q OK. OK. You just stated that those funds were not for
the--- originally, were not for the Siembra show.
A Not that I stated. I stated what the promoter says.
Q OK. And then, you stated that those funds are
allegedly applied towards the Siembra show.
A The promoter states that that--- those amounts were
applied to the three fifty.
Q So, because the promoter says that, that's what it is
then, right?
MS. GONZALEZ: Objection.
BY MR. MORGALO:
Q Is there any evidence in wire transfers specifically
to---
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, wait a second.
THE DEPONENT: Are we going back to this?
MR. MORGALO: Yes, we are going back to this, because-
--
THE DEPONENT: But I--- No, I'm just saying---
MR. MORGALO: ---because---
THE DEPONENT: ---isn't this--- isn't this--- isn't
this a wire--- Am I nuts---
MS. GONZALEZ: No.
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 252 of 327
253
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
THE DEPONENT: ---or---?
MS. GONZALEZ: Off the record.
MR. MORGALO: Yes, go ahead, go ahead.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Mr. Morgalo, are you done with
your questions?
MR. MORGALO: Yes, yes, I am. Thank you very--- Mr.
Blades, thank you very much.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No, but you can stay.
MR. MORGALO: No, I'm just putting my pen away.
MS. GONZALEZ: On the record?
THE REPORTER: Yes, on the record.
BY PAMELA D. GONZALEZ, ATTORNEY-AT-LAW:
Q Mr. Blades, why did you not file a criminal or a
civil case against Robert Morgalo?
A Because I--- I got to say that, because I know Robert
has a--- a daughter, and--- that has a heart condition, and---
ah--- and I--- I wasn't going to punish his family.
Q Why did you not file a criminal or civil case against
Arturo Martínez?
A Because he was going to have a baby. And he has no
money.
Q Why did you not file a criminal or civil case against
Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 253 of 327
254
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
A They have no money. I'm not going to punish the
families. That's basically what I thought. The only way I
thought these guys would come--- you know, if they would have
come forward--- The only thing I thought was--- and I don't
know if I ever mentioned it to you, other than today, if I ever
said--you know--the only way these guys can come up forward is
to---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Let the record show that, when
he said you, he's referring---
THE DEPONENT: I'm sorry.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: ---to Willy Colón.
THE DEPONENT: Is to--- to make them work for us for
free, until they pay us, you know? The fifteen percent of---
and until they pay us, and then--- You know? Because I didn't
see any other way. I swear to God. I know Willy got upset about
that, but so was I, but I'm thinking: "These guys, they don't
have any money--you know--we're going to grab them, the--- the
family's going to be broken---" ah--- "you know, and it's what
for?" You know, it's--- ah--- you know---
BY MS. GONZALEZ:
Q Did you ever instruct Mr. Willy Colón not to press
charges, criminally or otherwise, against Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates, or its partners?
A No. I don't think I did. Or maybe.
Did I, Willy?
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 254 of 327
255
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
MR. COLON: Can I talk?
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Off the record.
MS. GONZALEZ: Let's go off the record.
(Off the record.)
(Back on the record.)
THE DEPONENT: You know, and I correct myself. If says
that, that's it. That's--- that's what happened. I mean, I---
I don't---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, it's the same. It's the
same.
THE DEPONENT: Huh? No, he didn't do it.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: OK.
THE DEPONENT: The thing is he didn't do it. But my---
my--- my feeling was the only way we can make these guys pay
for what they did is to hire them--- And I know it doesn't make
sense, perhaps--you know--after what they did, but I--- I'd
say--you know--"so, make them work, and then, they--- they
don't collect their fifteen percent--you know--until they pay
us our--- ah--- whatever they took--you know--and then---
That's what I thought.
And then, I just let it go, 'cause I didn't think
that it was--- I thought that was going to punish the family.
And then, I thought: "We're going to be doing---" You know,
there were some gigs, you said, that we're going to do this
thing, and I figured: "You know, I'll give him the money out of
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 255 of 327
256
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
there, and then, that will be OK." And--- and that will be the
end of that, you know?
And these guys, once they--- you know, once they get
their--- their--- their--- their--- ah--- their punishment--you
know--then, you cut them off, you know? You let them go. That's
what I thought.
Q Mr. Blades, do you own any shares---
A No, I don't.
Q ---in Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
A No, I don't.
Q Do you have any participation in the business entity
known as Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
A No, I don't.
Q Have you ever been a partner of Robert Morgalo?
A In the sense of the financial sense? No.
Q Correct. From the partnership or other business
association.
A No.
Q Have you ever been a partner of Arturo Martínez in
any business---
A No.
Q ---association? Do you have any financial interest in
or of Martínez, Morgalo and Associates?
A As a firm, no. And--- and--- and again, in this---
Also for the record, I didn't collect, out of the--- whatever
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 256 of 327
257
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
it is, the forty thousand or whatever, whatever it was that the
amount of the---
Q The forty nine thousand?
A No, no, no.
MR. MORGALO: The sixty two thousand five hundred?
THE DEPONENT: No, no, no, no, no. The---
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: The forty nine thousand?
THE DEPONENT: The--- No, no, no, the--- "el..." The
fee, the commission.
MS. GONZALEZ: It's thirty five hundred.
MR. SAAVEDRA-CASTRO: Oh, thirty five thousand
dollars.
THE DEPONENT: Whatever. Yes. I don't get commissions
from--- you know, I don't collect from the commission. So--you
know--it's not my deal.
BY MS. GONZALEZ:
Q When was the decision to travel to Puerto Rico, and
perform the Siembra concert made?
A Ah--- I think that--- that--- that night, the
Thursday--- When I--- we're talking with Das, with the--- with
Willy and the lawyer.
Q When you were in Los Angeles, and Mr. Colón was in
New York?
A Right.
Q Would you have agreed to travel to Puerto Rico, and
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 257 of 327
258
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
to perform the Siembra concert in the absence of that
conversation with Willy and his attorney?
A I would--- I--- I--- My position at the time, as I
remember, was to say no, and not go. I mean, I was--- I--- I
felt terrible, I thought we had like three more days to tell
people--you know--"I'm sorry, but we got to clear this up".
But the argument--- Like I said, I'm not an idiot,
and I heard the argument, and the argument--- With the--- the--
- It was also very--- You have to understand the moment. The
moment was he was being threatened by some guy over there---
ah--- which I don't know if I knew that at that time, or I knew
how--- you know--- I made--- gauged its importance--- ah--- But
it was right there, in the moment, I don't know if the man did
it just in spite of it, I don't know what it was, but the whole
point that he was claiming that Willy hadn't--- ah--- you know-
-- he hadn't shown up for a gig or what not.
But the other thing was that, in lieu of the fact
that these guys had made the payments, the--- Das thought--and
he was right--that we were going to get sued. "You're going to
get sued, and he's going to get sued twice", basically. Because
the other guy's going to jump right away, and say: "See what I
told you? This guy doesn't show up on the gigs, and `blah,
blah, blah'."
Q Did you ever instruct or authorize Martínez, Morgalo
and Associates, or its partners to apply sixty two thousand
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 258 of 327
259
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
five hundred dollars, that was paid to Martínez, Morgalo and
Associates, for a different show towards the Siembra concert
funds?
A Never.
Q To your knowledge, did Mr. Colón ever instruct or
authorize application of that sixty two thousand five hundred
dollars towards the Siembra show?
A Absolutely not. We would have known. We would have
talked to him.
Q Have everything you testified to here this afternoon,
this--- today been the truth?
A Absolutely.
MS. GONZALEZ: No further questions.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: One quick question.
RE-DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q When you were saying that M&M should work---
A Uh-huh.
Q ---without a commission for a while---
A Uh-huh. For both of us.
Q ---"for both of us" performing together? Is that---
A Yes.
Q ---what---?
A I thought--- Yes. I don't think Willy was going to
use them individually. Although, again, in--- in the business,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 259 of 327
260
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
we work with different people. Here Maisonar (phonetic) comes
over, perhaps Mercado--God bless him--comes over, these guys
come over, David Maldonado--you know--nobody was signed to
anybody that I--- I don't--- I don't--- I never sign with
anybody.
So, but these guys, I'm thinking, well--you know--
we're talking about doing other gigs, I figured, you know---
MS. GONZALEZ: Based on your question, counsel, I have
one more question.
RE-CROSSEXAMINATION
BY MS. GONZALEZ:
Q Why didn't the Shea Stadium offer that had been
proposed after the Siembra concert didn't go through?
A I don't know. I don't know. I think--- ah--- I--- I
thought it could be done. I--- I--- I thought it was a good
idea, actually.
RE-DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL:
Q But right now, the Shea Stadium does not exist.
A Yes, that'd be something.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: Well, I have no further
questions. Does anybody have any?
MS. GONZALEZ: No.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: No one has any questions.
Well, thank you very much. Thank you for coming here,
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 260 of 327
261
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
everyone.
THE DEPONENT: This has been painful as hell, but
I've--- But good.
MR. COLON: You should have been here yesterday.
THE DEPONENT: Why?
MR. COLON: 'Cause it was painful too.
THE DEPONENT: Oh.
THE REPORTER: Off the record?
MR. COLON: Yes, of course. Oh, yes.
MR. HERNANDEZ-MAYORAL: "Sí." Let's go off the record.
(Whereupon, the deposition was concluded.)
****************
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 261 of 327
262
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
CERTIFICATE OF DEPONENT
I, Rubén Blades Vellido de Luna, the deponent herein,
do hereby certify that this is an accurate and complete
transcription of the testimony given by me at the time and
place of my deposition.
Dated this ____ day of _____________, ____, in
________________________, Puerto Rico.
____________________________
RUBEN BLADES-VELLIDO DE LUNA
DEPONENT
****************
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 262 of 327
263
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
I, Rosiris Miranda, E.R. Reporter, member of FASYO
Reporters, do hereby CERTIFY:
That the foregoing is a true and accurate transcript
of the recording of proceedings held at the time and place
hereinabove set forth; and;
That I am not related by blood or marriage to any of
the parties in the above-captioned matter, nor am I in any way
interested in the outcome of the same.
In San Juan, Puerto Rico, this 26th. day of May 2009.
_____________________
ROSIRIS MIRANDA
E.R. REPORTER
****************
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 263 of 327
264
FASYO REPORTERS - English and Spanish510 Octavio Marcano Street Urb. RooseveltSan Juan, PR 00918 (787)767-5593 447-8858
CERTIFICATE OF NOTARY
I, Manuel San Juan, Attorney-at-Law and Notary
Public, duly commissioned and qualified in and for the
Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, do hereby CERTIFY:
That the foregoing deposition was taken on the date
and time heretofore mentioned;
That the reporter and the deponent were sworn by me
before the commencement of the taking of the deponent's
testimony;
In witness whereof, I sign these presents and affix
my notarial seal in San Juan, Puerto Rico, this ____ day of
________________________, ____.
____________________________
MANUEL SAN JUAN
NOTARY PUBLIC
****************
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 264 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 265 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 266 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 267 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 268 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 269 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 270 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 271 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 272 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 273 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 274 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 275 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 276 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 277 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 278 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JAG-JA Document 87-2 Filed 01/08/2009 Page 6 of 9Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 279 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 280 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 281 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 282 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 283 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 284 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 285 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 286 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 287 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 288 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 289 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 290 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 291 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 292 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 293 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 294 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 295 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 296 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 297 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 298 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 299 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 300 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 301 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 302 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 303 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 304 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 305 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 306 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 307 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 308 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 309 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 310 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 311 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 312 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 313 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 314 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 315 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 316 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 317 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 318 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 319 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 320 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 321 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 322 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 323 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 324 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 325 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 326 of 327
Case 3:07-cv-01380-JA Document 233-2 Filed 07/13/10 Page 327 of 327