IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award...

21
IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING

Transcript of IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award...

Page 1: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

I M P E R I A L A W A R D R E F L E C T I O N & R E F L E C T I V E W R I T I N G

Page 2: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Graham Gibbs

“It is not sufficient simply to have an experience in order to learn. Without reflecting upon this experience it may quickly be forgotten, or its learning potential lost.It is from the feelings and thoughts emerging from this reflection that generalisations or concepts can be generated. And it is generalisations that allow new situations to be tackled effectively.”

Page 3: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

The key to the Imperial Award is self-reflection on experiences to find their impact on your personal development.

This guide provides tools, techniques, explanations and examples that will help you complete the Programme. It will show you that the key to the Imperial Award is self-reflection.

Each stream requires you to write a short reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria.

To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand their impact on you, and convert them into evidence about each attribute. You’ll need to use structured reflective writing to present your evidence as you argue your claim, to fulfil Award criteria.

▴ In addition to this guide, imperial.ac.uk/imperial-award has details of the Reflective Writing workshop, video guides and more.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

1

Page 4: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Reflection

REFLECTIONReflection is the personal learning activity of looking at your own experiences to see your own development.

Reflecting requires you to understand not only what you do well, but also to be critical of yourself. It is an analytical cycle enabling your personal development, and helping you become aware of it.

DescriptionWhat happened? In what context?

EvaluationWhat worked well? What did not work

well? What were the impacts?

ConclusionsLooking back, what could you have

done differently?

Future action planHow will you think and act differently

in the future, and why?

FeelingsWhat were you thinking and feeling –

before and afterwards?

Reflection also helps you to recognise, and gain confidence from, your own development. It helps you discover more about your potential.

PRACTICAL REFLECTIONUse the online Portfolio to record your reflection on experiences, assisted by the diagram of the Gibbs Reflective Cycle below.

Use the self-interview questions (on p4–5) to convert that reflection into evidence for the Award ▴

AnalysisLooking back, why did these aspects

work well or not work well?

Adap

ted

from

Gib

bs’ R

efle

ctiv

e Cy

cle

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

2

Page 5: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Transformation

W e all change and develop during our lives, including during our time at Imperial. Our mindsets

and perspectives shift as we learn from experiences. This also changes what we do.

During your time at Imperial, as undergraduate or postgraduate, full-time or part-time, you will acquire specialist expertise in your field but you’ll also develop your existing or new values, assumptions, opinions and frames of reference. They will affect you, your interactions with others and how you do things. The Imperial Award encourages you to identify not only the changes in you but also their cause(s).

USING TRANSFORMATION IN YOUR STATEMENTThe Award asks you to discuss the link between your experience, its transformative impact and the attribute.

You can fulfil the criteria by reflecting on:

▴ The definition of the attribute

▴ Whether the attribute matches your current ways of thinking/behaving and how your understanding of it changed

▴ The experiences which evidence your development of the attribute

▴ The reasons why your experience(s) caused you to develop Imperial Award attributes. ▴

Unpredicted one-off experience, that changes you or your understanding (you are never the same again)

Predicted one-off experience, good or requiring you to get it ‘right first time’ (you can prepare for it, but will not avoid it)

A combination of varied experiences independently contributing to your development (as you react, cope, adapt, fix)

Cumulative experiences sought from varied activities (purposeful, ongoing and strategic)

Cumulative experiences within one activity (progressing to greater responsibility/challenges)

▸ Adapting and extending Mezirow’s concepts of epochal and cumulative experiences (Ahearn 2018)

TYPES OF TRANSFORMATIVE EXPERIENCE

Adap

ted

from

Gib

bs’ R

efle

ctiv

e Cy

cle

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

3

Page 6: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Reflection tools

T hese self-interview questions will help you to start linking your experiences to Imperial Award

attributes. Use your online portfolio to record these links and your reflections.

If you’re not sure you possess an attribute start by asking yourself questions about your experiences (this page). If you think you already possess an attribute you can do the reverse (p5). ▴

Ahea

rn (2

017)

PRIMARY QUESTION KEY ASPECTS

Which of your past activities would you handle differently, in future?

Reflect on activities that feel significant for you: what was the situation and context?

What specific experience caused you to re-think your assumptions, choices and actions?

Why did you need to change your thinking/actions? Did you seek advice/training? How difficult or easy was it to modify your thinking/actions? What helped/hindered you?

Does this experience show thinking/actions that match any of the attribute definitions?

Reading the definitions of streams and attributes, what matches the thinking/actions evidenced by your experiences?

Why did the specific experience(s) helped you develop that attribute?

Why was that specific experience so transformational for you? How do you know?

What impact do you expect to have in future, using the attribute?

What has been your impact on others, or on new situations, since you developed the attribute?

SELF-INTERVIEW QUESTIONS, STARTING FROM YOUR EXPERIENCES

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

4

Page 7: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

SELF-INTERVIEW QUESTIONS, STARTING WITH THE ATTRIBUTES

Ahea

rn (2

017)

PRIMARY QUESTION FURTHER REFLECTIVE QUESTIONS

Which attributes do you think you can evidence most strongly when thinking about your experience

From the definitions of the attribute and the stream, which words and ideas describe you?

Can you discuss the differences between this attribute and the other three in the stream?

Think of one concrete example for each of your chosen attributes.

Does your example show your independence of thinking and action in the activity?

What did you do (background and context)?

What was the context of the experience?

How did you do it? Did you use any training, advice, trial-and-error, group discussions, personal reflection or research as part of your experience of handling the situation?

Why? Give a rationale for the change in you, before and after your experience.

What was your thinking/practice before you developed the attribute? What specifically changed your thinking/practice? What is your thinking/practice now?

What was the impact of your actions/choice/approach on others and on yourself?

What is the evidence of this transformative impact on you or others?

Use feedback from others, from observers, from your own reflections, anecdotal evidence or your own observations to back up your argument.

Would you do anything differently to improve the outcome? What? Why?

Will you use the attribute to handle future situations/challenges/opportunities?

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

5

Page 8: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Your online portfolio

WHY USE THE AWARD PORTFOLIO?The online Portfolio lets you use your reflection as evidence. You can use the Portfolio as a diary or journal to list activities, analyse experiences, map the links to attributes and produce an automated Overview or summary.

It is accessed on the Award web page, using your College log-in. It is simple enough to use as a daily diary to capture fresh experiences and track your own development. It is intuitive to use.

The Portfolio Activities and Experiences pages are entirely private but, helpfully, the Overview can be seen by your personal tutor or mentor, to aid discussions.

ACTIVITY RECORDINGActivities can include anything you engage in, including but not limited to:

▴ Summer internships or any work

▴ Volunteering, any type

▴ Business, enterprise or hackspace projects

▴ Life experiences e.g. Parenting or care-giving

▴ UROP or postgraduate research

▴ Conferences, presentations, outreach

▴ Mentoring, tutoring, training

MAPPINGMapping means selecting, and labelling, your experiences as evidence of an attribute. When you add a new experience to an activity, the new page will list the 12 attributes at the bottom of the page. After reflecting on the experience, you can click-to-match the experience to relevant attributes (see opposite).

The three streams of attributes are:

THE MATRIX OVERVIEWWhen you click-to-match attributes to an experience, it populates a matrix which gives you an overview of the strengths of your evidence for each attribute. You can fill gaps with new experiences. A complete set of evidenced attributes in a stream would indicate that you are ready to write a statement for the assessors ▴

Independent, open-minded thought

Effective teamwork

Self-awareness and active self-management

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

6

Page 9: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

ACTIVITY RECORDING

EXPERIENCES

THE MATRIX OVERVIEW

MAPPING ATTRIBUTES

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

7

Page 10: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

PROCESS USING THESE TOOLS AND SUPPORT

1 Recall and record your activities and experiences in your private online Portfolio

▴ Use your memory, CV, calendar/diary to recall activities

▴ Use your online Portfolio as a journal, diary or notepad

2 Read and reflect on the definitions of attributes and the Award Criteria used by the assessors

▴ See Student Guidance or this resource (p. 19) for attribute definitions and Award criteria;

▴ Use workshops, videos, talk to your peers to discuss them

3 Reflect on your experiences, identifying transformative experiences and map them to your attributes

▴ Use the tools in this guide and on the website;

▴ Use workshops; videos; peers/tutor chats

▴ Use your online portfolio

4 Review your evidence per attribute; seek new experiences or re-use steps 1—3

▴ Read your own portfolio, use the matrix

▴ Continue to self-reflect

5 Produce your written statement, self-checking that it fulfils the Assessor’s criteria

▴ Use the writing tools and examples in this Guide

▴ Read the Award criteria in the Student Guidance document

▴ Attend the workshop on Reflective Writing

6 Submit your statement online. Reflect on the assessor’s written feedback. Re-use any prior steps

▴ Use the Award online system to submit a statement of 4,000 characters; reflect on and follow your assessor’s feedback; assessment dates available throughout the year; resubmissions permitted

Using reflection to gain the Award

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

8

Page 11: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

A TOOL FOR REFLECTIVE WRITINGThe SCART model provides a simple approach to structuring your reflective statement (Step five in the Award Processes). You must write clearly and concisely, fulfilling the Award criteria. Remember that the Imperial Award is not about the volume or success of your activities; it is about recognising your personal development of attributes.

SITUATION/CONTEXTBriefly set the scene, explain how and why the situation arose, what needed to be achieved, and the context of your claim that you have developed the attributes.

▴ This scene-setting must be specific and not generalised

▴ Keep your explanation of the situation/task/context to an absolute minimum

ACTIONA brief explanation of what you did and how you achieved (or missed) your goal or handled the situation.

▴ Explain what you did or what you experienced

▴ Highlight the aspects relevant to the attribute(s) by using key-nouns, key-verbs and key-ideas from the attribute

REFLECTIONEvidence that you have thought about what you have experienced, why it

matters and that you understand what you did well, what you could improve and how it has affected your priorities, assumptions or viewpoint.

▴ Show understanding of the impact of your actions on yourself and, where appropriate, others

▴ Use the reflection tools (Gibbs Reflective Cycle; the Self-interviews) to generate evidence about your experiences and select small examples directly relevant to the attributes you are claiming

TRANSFORMATIONYou must evidence (argue persuasively) that, as a result of your reflection, you understand the transformative impact of your experiences in helping you to develop the attributes, enabling you to perform differently in the future.

▴ Address attributes explicitly

▴ Explain how you know, personally, that your experiences have changed you

▴ Look carefully at the Award criteria to see what does / does not work as evidence ▴

The SCART model

INCLUDE THESE IN YOUR STATEMENT

Situation | Context | Action Reflection | Transformation

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

9

Page 12: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

DESCRIPTIVE WRITING A description of what has happened. It may tell a story but from only one perspective. Generally only one point is made at a time.

+ ELEMENTS OF REFLECTION As above, with little addition of ideas from outside the event and no references to alternative viewpoints or the attitudes of others. There is recognition of the worth of further exploration, but it does not go very far.

REFLECTIVE WRITING There is description but certain aspects are emphasised for reflective comment. There may be a sense that the role of self is being thought about. The account shows some analysis and there is recognition of the worth of exploring the motives and reasons for behaviour.

DEEPER REFLECTIVE WRITING Description now only serves the process of reflection, covering the issues for reflection and noting their context. There is clear evidence of standing back from an event and conducting a deep, thoughtful internal dialogue. The account shows deep reflection, and it incorporates recognition that the frame of reference (the ‘lens’ through which an event is viewed) can change.

Reflective writing

Your short reflective statement requires reflective writing; you must go beyond mere description.

T his framework, adapted from work by Jenny Moon, describes the transition from descriptive to reflective writing.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

10

Page 13: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Your reflective statement

WRITING YOUR REFLECTIVE STATEMENTTo achieve each Imperial Award stream you need to produce a written reflective statement of no more than 4,000 characters per stream, demonstrating how you meet the Imperial Award criteria in relation to each of the four attributes within that stream.

Before you write your statement, you should have already started reflecting upon your experiences in relation to the attributes in that stream. The portfolio, overview matrix, Gibbs Reflective Cycle and the Self-interview questions, are designed to help you reflect and make use of your reflection. The SCART model is designed to help you to structure your writing so that you present an argument rather than simple description. Express yourself reflectively by using the reflective sentence and verb generators (p15 & p16).

This table lists Reflective Statement Do/Don’t rules, based on the Assessor’s Criteria (set out in the Imperial Award Student Guidance). ▴

THE DO RULES TABLE

DO DON’T

▴ Do use all of the analytical reflective tools to reflect deeply, before you start writing-up

▴ Do not write your statement without reflecting on the impact of your experiences.

▴ Do use your matrix tool to select your best evidence for each attribute

▴ Do not try to squeeze in a mention of every activity and experience. Be selective.

▴ Do write using “I”, “me”, “my”, “mine”, keeping your focus on impacts of your experiences

▴ Do not use assertions in lieu of argument. If in doubt attend an Award writing workshop or discuss with peers.

▴ Do explicitly address each attribute in the stream, arguing in support of your claim, with experiences as evidence

▴ Do not list achievements (successful results) instead of experiences.

▴ Do weave a coherent statement for the whole stream.

▴ Do not stretch thin evidence to cover all attributes. Better to seek further, deeper experiences, if time permits.

▴ Do focus on the why, or the reasons behind your feelings and actions.

▴ Do not focus on a factual description of your experience.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

11

Page 14: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

FICTIONAL STREAM: EFFECTIVE PRESENTATIONSImperial graduates will take impressive technical qualifications into the workforce, to have impact on society, knowledge and the future. To operate at a level befitting the quality of their qualifications, graduates need to be able to communicate with impact, achieving more than the mere transmission of data but communicating at a deeper level to shape the response to the communication. Great responsibility comes with the ability to persuade others, and this stream recognises attributes which enable proficient communication (what and how) and societal responsibility (what and why).

FICTIONAL ATTRIBUTES:1. Awareness of audience needs: Effective presenters

are audience-focused instead of information-centric, and consider the audience’s context including why the audience is present, the range of audience wants/needs/priorities, and their range of likely responses. Critically, effective presenters know what impact they wish to have on the audience beyond the presentation.

2. Uses effective presentation tools: effective presenters do not merely display information but explain it, using strategies tailored to their audience. Strategies and tools can include rhetoric, argument/counterargument, evidence and also visual, verbal, aural, digital or other modes of delivery. An effective tool helps the presenter have their intended impact on the audience.

3. Ethically responsible: a presenter makes choices about what to present and what to omit, and how to present and how not to present. In these choices, the presenter must be careful to ensure the honesty and integrity of communication, whether controversial or not in its content.

4. Persuader mindset: an effective presenter seeks to have an impact (an effect) on the audience. A persuader mindset is required for a presenter to be able to identify what the effect should be and how to achieve it, and how to follow-up on an effective presentation.

EXAMPLE REFLECTIVE STATEMENT

To help you understand what reflective writing looks like we have created a fictional Imperial Award stream called Effective Presentation, and invented an example statement by an imaginary student called ‘Sam’, with comments from an assessor.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

12

Page 15: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

FICTIONAL SHORT REFLECTIVE STATEMENT: SAM’S STATEMENTMy experience on the ICU Toilets-for-Us Project (T4Us: a sanitation project for rural India), made me rethink my approach to presentations and changed my practice. My claim to have the attributes of an Effective Presenter is evidenced by 3 key experiences which transformed my presentations strategy, impacting different audiences and me.

Looking back, despite often presenting coursework, my three most transformative experiences as a presenter have been (1) as media officer for the T4Us project, (2) getting T4Us communications coaching and (3) talking to my personal tutor about this Award stream. As media officer, I needed my presentations to start changing people’s minds; the training gave me know-how; but my reflective discussion with my PT truly helped me to shift my student focus from ‘information’ towards ‘presentation’, changing my strategy.

With my tutor, I debated the differences between teaching, presenting, proving, and information-dumping when we discussed “Persuader mindset” (attribute (d)). I realised that I’d never needed a “persuader mindset” when presenting coursework to teachers who already knew the topic. I’d merely collected relevant information, and won marks for information-gathering. The teachers were changing me with feedback, not me persuading them.

In contrast, I definitely need a persuader mindset when I explain the Toilets-for-Us project to other people, to convert students into volunteers, potential funders into sponsors; and the public into supporters who realise that people are dying from cholera and suffering social harm in places without sanitation systems. My training increased my audience awareness (attribute (a)) and so now each audience gets a tailored presentation, instead of one fact-filled standard presentation. I believe that audiences talking to me after a presentation is evidence that I met their needs and persuaded them about our project’s potential. We now have an existing sponsor who increased their funding and we doubled our volunteer force from 5 to 11, a good impact from my shift from talker to persuader and my discussions with audiences are deeper now.

ASSESSOR’S NOTES: WHAT MAKES THIS REFLECTIVE

Sam helpfully sets the Situation/context (Following the SCART model)

Sam focuses on claiming to possess the attributes and how Sam’s experience is evidence. Keywords include: rethink, claim, attributes, transformed, impacts and change.

Sam has prioritised reflective (analytical) thinking over description of details. (Reflection from the SCART model)

Sam explicitly addresses the attribute and shows reflection upon the dilemma of whether Sam’s experiences as a presenter have always involved the attributes. Sam argues using a counter-example and then highlights positive examples. Sam shows a shift in their own basic assumptions, which cannot happen without reflection. Sam uses descriptive detail of action mostly to illustrate the transformation and avoids too much detail about the T4Us story.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

13

Page 16: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

My transformation into someone who “uses effective presentation tools” for attribute (b), occurred during T4Us communications training. Tough feedback from the trainer changed me from someone who loved powerpoint and pictures, into someone who now relies more on ‘conversation’ with my audience. I use rhetorical questions as hooks, I build up arguments using data instead of just showing data for the audience to interpret. I have pushed background knowledge to the background and brought forward my main points. I acknowledge, instead of hiding, any problems (the counter-arguments against our project) to show my audience that I anticipate their concerns. This impresses funders in particular, as it shows transparency on issues such as ‘westerners imposing solutions on India’ or our tiny project scale, which are the biggest counter-arguments we face and were issues I needed to address.

In my discussion with my Personal Tutor, we really debated what the Imperial Award attribute of being “ethically responsible” would truly mean for my T4Us project. I thought it meant “do not plagiarise” but he thought it was wider. When I showed him my new presentation of T4Us, his reaction to those counter-arguments was that it hit the ethical issues head-on. Do we cause harm when 10 homes access get deep-pit toilets but we do not reach the neighbours 2km down the road? Are our claims grounded on facts, opinions or hopes? Do we make it clear to the audience? This is an aspect that I had not truly considered before looking at Imperial Award, so I am still developing my understanding but I am now consciously aware of trying to be ethically responsible as a presenter and not a ‘glib salesman’. I now make clarity about our tough issues the key to my ethical presenting.

The communications training and the process of reflecting on what I do as a presenter has shifted my entire approach and I am now more ambitious for my presentation’s impact. I no longer give the entire history of the project, I shifted my focus to the audience, my priority to the impacts of the presentation and I use more varied tools because my presentations are about persuading people to act. Although it would be nice to earn the Imperial Award, the real impact of my transformation into an effective presenter will be when I revisit the Indian village this summer, to see the impact of having persuaded more people to give more help, money and support to challenge this real-life problem and see the solution happen ▴

Character count: 3,895 (no spaces)

Sam highlights transformation, using a before and after technique, with phrases like ‘from someone who loved…into someone who now…’.

This is rich in details, but they are always reflecting on Sam’s progress into someone with the IA attributes.

Sam makes explicit the approach taken to reflection: Sam illustrates how debate and discussion with another person (Tutor) introduced Sam to new ways of looking at their own practice as a T4Us communicator and gives a specific example of change resulting from that new insight.

Sam finishes by pulling together the stream’s themes (persuasion; audience; effective tools) and reminds us of Sam’s know-why, know-what and know-how. Transformative impact of Sam’s experiences remains the dominant focus of Sam’s claim to possess the attributes.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

14

Page 17: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

If you wish to SHOW JUDGEMENTimportant event happened when…

For me, the (most) meaningful idea arose from…

relevant learning began after…

If you wish to CLAIM DEVELOPMENTdeveloped understanding of...

I have improved my skills in…

enriched ability to…

If you wish to SHOW CHANGE OVER TIMEPreviously, thought…

Initially, I felt…

At the time, noticed…

If you wish to SHOW SHIFT IN THINKING/ACTION

Having

read…

I now

think…

explored… realise…

analysed… know…

learned… feel…

Reflective sentence generatorUse this sentence-generator to adopt reflective–contemplative writing.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

15

Page 18: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Verb generator

Achievement

Communication

Taking initiative

Research

Organising and planning

Interpersonal

achieved, completed, improved, enhanced, prevented, produced, implemented, delivered, closed-out, finalised.

advised, wrote, instructed, presented, edited, chaired meeting, persuaded , pitched, reviewed, listened, learned, adjudicated, claimed, justified, negotiated, reported, professed, acclaimed, counter-argued.

created, designed, established, introduced, developed, set up, initiated, instigated, re-started, re-designed, convened, proposed, pitched, re-examined, re-evaluated.

investigated, determined, searched, surveyed, examined, catalogued, classified , reviewed, published, wrote-up, analysed, compared, presented, queried, hypothesised.

recognised, arranged, budgeted, verified, scheduled, planned, produced , checked, recast, replenished, delegated, devolved, involved, re-organised, accounted, reported, recruited.

advised, facilitated, collaborated, proposed, trusted, evaluated, consulted, mediated, handled , negotiated, welcomed, hosted, consoled, cheered, commiserated, celebrated, diversified, recognised, acknowledged, introduced.

Look at the themes and the verbs we’ve suggested. These are merely a starting point and may help you reflect on your experiences.

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

16

Page 19: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Advice and clarifications

An activity gives you the opportunity to gain experience. The activity of being an academic representative could give experiences of committee work communication, actively listening to individual students’ concerns and with being strategic to create rule changes.

An experience is gained during an activity, having an impact on you, shaping your subsequent thoughts and actions.

Evidence (to support your claim to the Award) is composed of personal experiences analysed to discover why they converted you from your old set of assumptions and behaviours towards your newer behaviours, ideas and actions.

Definitions of streams and attributes (in the blue Student Guide) have specific wording which you need to understand before reflecting on your experiences to find evidence for a persuasive claim that you have those attributes.

Statements are 4,000 characters long. You must write a coherent argument covering all four attributes in a stream. Your selected evidence must be from your own independent personal engagement in activities that gave you experiences.

The Assessor’s Criteria can be found in the Student Guidance. Write and review your statement with these criteria in mind.

Private Feedback from the Assessor panel is given online on every statement, helping you decide what to do next.

There are multiple Assessment Cycles per year (two per term plus some summer vacation assessment may be offered). Different assessors may contribute on different cycles. Students are free to submit and resubmit amended statements at multiple cycles, if wished.

Your online Portfolio can also be used daily/weekly as a diary or journal for capturing your thoughts/reactions to experiences as you have them.

The Portfolio has a Mapping tool, for matching attributes to your experiences.

An automatic Matrix Overview is generated when you use the Mapping tool in the Portfolio. It shows your strongest evidence.

Self-interview tools, the SCART Model and the Reflective Sentence Generator are optional tools to use and re-use when doing reflection and again when structuring and writing your statement.

Within a stream, your re-written or amended statements are considered as revisions of your first statement, and thus there is no concern over self-plagiarism. (You can re-use earlier writing, in a given stream) ▴

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

17

Page 20: IMPERIAL AWARD REFLECTION & REFLECTIVE WRITING...reflective statement that fulfils the Award criteria. To write those statements, you’ll need to reflect on your experiences, understand

Stream one Independent, open-minded thought

Thinking for yourself and taking open-minded approaches to situations or tasks means that you draw on, but are not confined by, what you already know from your studies and from your life experiences. The four attributes can be discussed in relation to a single activity or may have been gained/demonstrated across several activities. Situations requiring independent thinking may have involved risks with no guarantee of success, and yet these situations can be highly transformative for you and others. The emphasis in this stream is on the student’s ability to distinguish the different aspects of each attribute and relate them to their own thinking.

Innovative approachApplying your scientific or research knowledge, or skills, to improve an existing thing, or to develop, identify or establish something new.

CreativityGenerating ideas and applying them to develop an initiative, solve a problem, instigate a course of action, or bring value to an individual, situation, or process.

Practical, intelligent problem-solvingIdentifying a solution and justifying it with intelligent reasoning.

Enterprising mind-setIdentifying opportunities and taking risks to develop outcomes relevant in society or that have an impact within an existing organisation.

Stream two Effective teamwork

Imperial students have a strong tradition of group activities, however progressing beyond mere groupwork to effective teamwork requires an effort to understand teams, develop teamwork skills and apply them to enhance the team’s activities. Students will use this stream to evidence their transformation into an effective contributor to a team, reflecting upon their impact on a team’s operation and their contribution to team achievements.

Communication and active listeningManaging communication processes and the flow of information to ensure that teams work effectively and that there is a shared understanding.

MotivationUnderstanding how you or others are motivated, using this understanding to help achieve a collective goal or aim.

Awareness of group dynamics and collaboration

Observing and understanding how others behave and interact; using individuals’ different approaches and perspectives to benefit the team; and working with others to achieve a collective goal or aim.

Strategic mind-setContributing to effective leadership, enabling a team to achieve its collective goals or aims.

Stream three Self-awareness and active self-management

Imperial students enjoy the reputation of people who can handle intense academic challenges. Many also enjoy a reputation for working to benefit society and for being achievers who can identify opportunities and have an impact, aware of the world beyond their own context. In this stream, students are required to demonstrate their emotional intelligence, to recall and reflect upon their own internal drivers and to consider their impact on others. Students will reflect upon instances and events which demonstrate attributes going to the core of their identity and their ability to manage transformation.

Critical self-analysis/self-evaluationConsidering personal strengths and opportunities for self-improvement, presenting a case or argument to justify behaviour or personal development.

Social conscienceBeing conscious of how your values or ethos impacts the application of your expert skills, knowledge and experience and how your behaviour can affect others.

Recognising opportunitiesSeizing and exploiting opportunities to further develop yourself.

Global mind-set

Appreciating broad social, cultural or international contexts and adapting behaviours and approaches in a range of diverse situations, showing self-awareness and empathy.

19THE IMPERIAL AWARD FRAMEWORK THE IMPERIAL AWARD ATTRIBUTES

Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing Imperial Award Scheme | Reflective writing

1918