Hoffner v State of Minnesota Blue Earth County Order for Declaratory Judgment and Permanent...

8/13/2019 Hoffner v State of Minnesota Blue Earth County Order for Declaratory Judgment and Permanent Injunction MGDPA

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/hoffner-v-state-of-minnesota-blue-earth-county-order-for-declaratory-judgment 1/23

MAY�03-2013 FRI 02:37 PM BEC COURT AMIN

I

STE OF MINSOTA

CONY OF AR

Tdd Mod one B.H. nd MA..

lai,

vs

St o Mnsota ad Blue a Conty,

Dedants.

FAX NO. 5073044700 .

DSRC OUR

FH DIAL DISIC

e No: 07-V12468

ORDER FOR DECLARATORY

PERMANT

INJUNCON

Te aov"ented er c on b e udeine Jug o h abvend ut n Feby 8 20 hrn lait' mon f njctonnd Min. St. § 08 ubd. an Pentia ntven Te e e ton flid e teentin Pntis To Ho e . we ersened yCsoh W Mad and ei M. Ron ois_ Kaan Mll & Cei LL.,

Maolis ine. Dendan St o Meoa l we epsentd yMel A. Hn Assta Be Ea Cony Aey Mank MneoaPtena Ineno T e es was epsentd y M . nn Atoy Law Mnaoi Mieo. Te Co cevd fna ubi on Mr 15, 0d too e ae under aisment tha

U les leadns and ed hen ogeth wit h rments ooe and e t bg oese adsed;

S HEBY ORER at lain moion dcao udgnt and

pen inon b nd te same s GED A nvstgae dat ed rcead y ce nd Mi. Sat § 3 .8 sd n e atter M Td Cs j [0C36], nd o psend a dce in il poedng s assfd s pa da nd e Mesot oeen Dat Practs A Minn. Sa§ 18 sud nd 30, sd. 2



MAY-03-2013 FRI 02:37 PM BEC COURT ADMIN FAX NO. 5073044700 .

Tdd H S fM

File V66

Pti o Her is e a otba oa a esota Sae

Usty - Mao (M O Agus 1 01 resorcs pamt

a MU e pe t ep ha nest empo a isoee e vieos

of sue il oorap o Pa work-ss elur po n The Mko

Poe Deen d Be E Cuty efs encd a c

gio o e . Tt eso eeae Pt eoe e ee

vieos i is oe a at hle t vos wee Pltfs mor cr

Basd o t t poe ee sspe rouo

possesio l pogra. y aso ad ad oba eah w!a t

sec Panf's resce adiona evdce f oogrp Te sbsequ

exeuo of tat ser waan eslte h scover o o aiioa i

poorap vience gust 2 s cg Pl w oe cou o

se of a io o engae a sexua per o o M a § 6746,

bd. a oe u f osss o oc wk nvovn nos n olao

o t§ 6727 sud 4 a

Oobe 3 12, ea, Plan mve o ss all has

ack of poabe as usua M R . P 104. Te stae re t e




tee aegd oograph vdo s vdce, as wU polc eo scs o

cid oete ite wh Pt chn, d ch wan apaion o

establ obbl c fr he chg. O ovmb 0 20 h o ud a

Ode dsmsng a ag. Te o fnd tee wa ce vdce to

eabl robl c o bev ht te vdeos contted "oogaph woks o a

sxul pece der o law. he Cort addtionlly cocudd hat he

vdos cou oed peson as ae o w nd ht he oeco o

P vod g o e pee d pvac der e Fs ad Fouemdms o h d Staes Contio stat ece o to a h

isma wt e te rcrd y a S R rm. P. 20 bds 1 1

d 2 eablg a -da od wch e stae ay apea n ay

c o any ea od cdi obbl ue dsm oder bd on

qo o law

ollo dsal o chaes Pt ddd tu o h etv

e de . St § 29C. l l o the Bue Eah County toey' Oce ad he

Bue ah Coty Sh . Flng � a Dcemb 1 201 t not

ca her o no el oce as eted ay dnfco o et iao to

P sa o t dd. O Deb 0 1 , 0 12, oli/t Paul KS

V o Nw "Fx 9 Nws ruest und h d Freedo o

mato Ac (O dand ces to Pla nvgtve e o Bl

h fd an conlo e o' Novemb 0 202 de aeodm ed n Cour le o. 0R-6 ae cooaed e been




E Co. Id. at 1 Te Cou ned Ps aoey o the FO eqes

nd expaine a Pox 9 would o be grae accs o e tee el o vdeos

ca h vde o wee ed y e CoL i t1e ra roceeg u l e

orazaton woud b gi ace o h eo ce as evidnce d mae ul

in he ml ocd d. a r 16 Te ouy ae t t wa ucai a o

th casscao o te reag oce eiec cont e Jaw

ercem vesie l ad ed Ps aoey ta efe a Co

Oder srucn [i] wha to do w esec o eease o the aa n tha le. d at 7.

O Decbe 20 laif coed e w aco o o he

ouy to oy wt e Mesota ove et Dta Practies t (MGP)

u M. Sa § 3 .08 pcfcally af eks a eclory j �et

deing tat e data conai e law encme vsgav s pae

daa ude e MD injtmcv ei prohibg e Cou om eleag e

aa to e c. O ecer 0, 20 an t uy ered nto a

pulad orde f empor nco saig te e vestgave fe o ublic

view u ie a h Cor dine e casiaon o data nde e

PA fo wg a n rvew o e daa e o ne a ua ore

meoalizg t1e ie' agremen h m da O aua 4 20 h Fr

e a oo mted oe ineeo as a aer o r to e wi

pocg Te o d a earing on ls oto o compel om

Prs moo o itee eru2 0. Pant d 1 Fr P

resentd ora a wrte ns po o te rpecve oo o oh te

5




da casscon td prpos veo issues. h Coty suitd

vsiat ve y Cut e b ors oe no posto o

eir isue. Te o w cosir ec ss .

LAW I ANYSS

T rs queso ps is wer stgtve aa, co!Iec o crea a

ecem cy e cos of par a cs agas a pat sspecd o

usn s nor cn to a sxl pece i voto of Mn Stat. §

724 sb 2 s p aa de te MGDP vstiato becos

acve by oran o a s ss prss a ueso o so ntetion.

Te ojec o stauto teo i to ace ecta th it o t

sre. Mn Sa § 64. (010. Te ou's st o a ars o

saoy irpato s ag o l1 ste. Mid-nk-Tamarac Rves

atr d Di Sngrm, N.W 4 40 M 00. f h sttt s

call ngo, te ou oos no te l1 la g to temne

sttes ng Hcso Tch Ic. v C o Rvenu 68 N.2

Mi. 2005 "W ha eedy h tha w us gve c o th a an

sutoy tet wh t is c and abo") If lgae sscpti o ore

a on asoab erato nd gous te Co es cao o

cocin o ascea d ec th gislat net We o J. ,

.W. 5 0 (. 0 M. a.§ 6456

-6



MAY-03-2013 FRI 02:3 PM BEC COURT AMIN FAX NO. 5073044700 .

Th eleva pon e MGDPA Mn.Stt.§ 8 sbds.7 d sates n

pt:

ubd. Crmnal nvesigt data Ect dta dened subdsos 2, 3, d 6 vesiaiv dt clced o red by a awcme cy orde o pe a cs as a peso wethkown o uow cso f rme ote oen w h ency has py sgve snsbiy a codenao tced onpblc we e nesgon s actv atvenvestgaiv d ae pub nss h reease e data woud jepardizeo ngn vsiaon o woud rve e detty vd poced ud sbdvo 17. A nvesgan beoes ve o1 cuence y of llw vents

) dson by e acy o poprae proseutoa aiy o prse e s;b xpan of h br a chrge o le a cpan ndl pc ste f mains o 0 yeas cissoof oense wchve oes aes o(c xsn o or epon aU s of ppal by pesoncovd n te bass of vegv da

Any sve dat prsend vdnce n cout sha be ubc Daade1ed to b tve der ( ay bc acive e cr apopae proseo aoy decds t rew e vestgn

d cie chld au daa vstativ da a becoeinaciv d sbdvso 7 cuse ( o b) <d t e e lgedabs nec o a c by a prs resnsib e d' cae asded scn 62656 subdivsion r pvae data

i1 t § 13.82, subd d (02 s and tnt Inev

P see t aee a te invesan t f Stae f .lnnesa Todd

Chrian Ho [7CR-2-36] beca "nacv d M Sat.§ 38 sbd

a) wh sta elced no t purue n pa e out's Nveb 3 0

Od dssng cages ack of rbab c cody,



MAY�03-2013 FRI 02:39 PM BEC COURT ADMIN FAX NO. 5073044700 .

wot ecdig te nvestitn s inactive" d n. t 3.

bd. 7 ( n lg is pspn estve dt et cet by w

enfocen n e rimal ca puc" e cognized xcptn a pie s Se

I. a s bd. 7 (s ag t []ac egve daa ubc]). oe

a inctve chd abus daa" e xce pon de . St § 82 ubd. 9

go cases ene vegi e a pr ia d n Act

cont tt scn 82 ubd 9 i bus n sul t be

cosed i way tt peents ccess o eti nves b o to oe

poio n at dc{v et t e lg o f us elc" em pas aded)

Te MGDPA ree o e cto creon se mitennce,

sntn acs o o in gov enties. n. §

3.01 . 3 oe oft1e G is ecnce e ig ts o daa bje ct

ptc era io m inmne dcoe w t e pubc to

know wt te oeen s dog e A a emp o blce ese omptg

rgs wn a cnext o efc gov opo." Mnt o ry a & C. v.

C y. H pi, 4 N.W.d 29 307 . 990. e ct pm

g oement dt pb c nd ccel by puic spc d copyi e

ee is l lw a at sttute ey clsscn o daa l p ovd e

ce data t c." . Stt. 13.0 sbd 3 Govn daa s t

bc" 1 GPA te wl n vera asao

tbe by te Ac. v. Ramsey ut 806 W 85 789 .

-8



MAY-03-2013 FRI 02:3 PM BEC COURT AMIN FAX NO. 507304470 .

0 "Publc da i ovemen at s ccesle to e gen publ Min.

Sa. § 102 ubd 14 15 I i dit o "not bli da wh i oer

ovee Mi Sa § 02 sd. (no da a ay omt

a cd by tte de w, o tory casifcio s condentil, pae

no nuc o roectd opbc d e MGDA do o et pub cc o

not bc aa, § 3.0 bd. 1 te d on nddul d

"nopbc aa two ypes o o c da; bo re accb oy o te

ndd j o e dt if ay. Min. St .0 d 9 2.

e t a s n he i case S. 3 . sd. 9 es

ca oennent da pve. cc le win he d iion o "o

dt ud Min. S . § 02 u. 8a ccongy te ov a

led y section 138 ubd. 9 o pub d nd not ceibe by inv id a

wo ae o b bjc o e da i § 0 ud Mi. S 3 .0

u 8a. Te stat od:

give d a bco ve ude sdv ion 7 s () o() d e to e egd abe o negc o d a po

oe e cids c nd on 6256 ion2 rvae da.

Mn. St. § 82 s. 9 T ies dt e eng o e "e

ued n ut cotds a t oud n d aow

o oy da wc " ea ts to leg s o n of a c

o oble 1 cids c e d t nt o e

nd ge h e over dta colec ed o ed b w nmen n te

9



MAY00 FR 0:9 PM C COUR ADMN FAX NO 07044700

nstgaton of ed abs or eglct o chd by a person rsponsl r e ci Id's

ce

To demn er te ps at eate o he aegd use o neec o

cd by eso esonse cds cae s easonaby suscetbe o oe

oe ntettio, e Cou us oo o he stoy dento and coon uses of

compoet es Se Mn t § 64.08 c F1iy s. Gr w v Sch edl,

616 N.Wd 2 27 in. 000) The decpiv erm "son esose

clds ce i exrssly deed y stute: A peson sponsb r e chd ce s

n indu ncion nd avg sponsbites cr

of h chid uch as a prn, rda o oter pero a sir ce

rsponsbtes[] Mnn St. § 66 sbd 2 ( (epsis ddd). Pit Todd

Honer ts is dnio i rpect to h cden o py int t e

dos no T egisa dd o specia o cc n o e , e

so gudnce s opate sot o dcoy e Min t. 608 )

st at "od d phrases ae cosrued accordng to rles of gram d

ccon o ter coon ad pprovd sae T e s umbgus n gt o

coon usag R es o brin no ogic o n associato o to v

conecto eton o rfeene. Web' New oge Dona 957 ( ed

00)

Tee, a inaciv sat da ta s coecon ro o

eec o aegaton o ause o nec o a cd b aent s cassied as

pat nder M a § 38 sud 9. e te poce ivestao



MAY00 FR 0:40 PM C COUR ADMN FAX NO 07044700

whch oveen data ude conderan ws oetd or cead ad oeon,

eaon o rce" to gio hat antf used s cden to ene a

seul pefance n ln o Mi1 Sat § 6746 ubd 2 Und secon

626, s]xa abus .. cds an w inoes a mino w constes

oaton o ... [seton 67.46. i. Sa § 66.556 sud. (d) phass added)

Consequen e aeaon tat Pint used hs r o enage n a a

p!c is a agaio a lati sea usd is r. Bcaus al daa

coetd o cead by poe n he r ietigi of ant as oneton ao

o r e nce o t allegtion at latf seuay asd s cen l o 1

vesgatv data s cassi as "prv und Mn Sat. § 38 sbd. 9

Th Lesatues rce seton 3.8 sbd 9 o Mnesotas andatoy-

roig sat M. St. 6266 u t epeaon eton

626.56 deleates pma nvesat esposbty oer Heaons o al ab

alled ofend is e paent grdan slin o a indvidua ctiong wtn

e ly y as a pson esponse r the chids ae o loa wr

anc Mn ta 66.56 sbd 3 A po depatmt or cy sif a

ees a epot o seu ause o a hd an us edatel noty h oa

welae y o he rp0 o h h loca wel acy y coen the

esgato requied by Jaw. M t. § 66.56 sd. 3 he polc dep o

2 e ca aw nent gny esposi r coducin etgao o rornvolvig xa a o a d "by a pero who is ot a paent grdan blng, osn esposbe f the clds car[.] Mn. Sta 62656 d O ) (ephasaded

•




' .

1 ony she, o eceivng r e po , l imedtely ofy e ol f

ge o acy eosbe sess sgg te em , oy d

wg.". [T o law efe agey ad oa l gey [ut]

coate d exe o e espv vsgo ssesme

e to aod a dico o t-nd es d u le ee Mn Sa

§ 62656 subd. 10 4) AJ eods oe dds ted oa

we ay or ey r e o i e asesi o vsgg ot d

[ue secio 66.56 e ad a rve d0

dv ial" ad o ss

t b M S. 666 sd l (). In fy reco d s rve

he dory-eoer stte ee seo 1382 d pvds:

Repts ted y y ole dee or oty e ha e pv e daa o dds xe es s de v o vsgg peo n o posecg aory cd uya xae o o oone Se 8 Slbdvs 8 9a 14 a to ere da oe te eos.

Leav tory ees h he noa ega su a osy ae ded

d aed or rees sect 182 d. d seio 66.56 sd 1

( 198 M. Las ch. 7 § , . tha e esl ou

ded ad efnced a o he eete sos des s awe f b

setons ad a eto a bo io be d oge ahe an as cg.

Mae o Pto Fo et Couty D o l, NW.d 54 6

Mi A. 4) o cl d t e eded t two sues e red oghe

leave h o dd ts e aded e s m l ity




ety I a o 1e Co s ba to espond to aa equess n Je

tn

To prom pper comace with a data euests MDPA equesgot etes to dsate a "esposble auhy3 wse jb is to sabs

procs . to se th sts oveent daa e eced and coed w

i apppate d prpt a M. Sat § 10 subd 2 a eonsibe

authort als chae wh e du t "de:ie w tes ta maitaid b

e nti a cassed s p o codenia, accodig t he detos o osetes pst to Mnesoa Sats sco Mnn R 2050800 (B;

M. Sa. §107 (T cossn sa pae rues i acodce wl e

remakn pces Av Prcedue ct wh sha app

o entities mpemet encent a adistaio o ts chapt

he esonse authot s unsue to respod t a pc rquest he

gov ety y seek a advs oo fo the consse. . Stat. §

30 sub. 1 a). aco ke n co hat oon eass

veent ty fo aiy uder the MG

3 goemet et s designat rsposibe auty e MGP poves

tha the spsb oy s f cos te uty coorda or admsrato[o] le cot does ot e a oodao o admiistato, e esposibeautht is the co adtor. Mi. Sat§ 30 sd6 (b) .

4 Mn S § 07 sbd "T mis o r sal aran pcisseno o pns ssue ude ths sect ad sha ndce whe the pesstated i oo a not eded to pvde gdace all sa! id pesonso go s.. gvmn ni .. on ha a n n a wn pn ssnr su t gnn n rs or




In the Nober 3 9 adioy opnion nd ao, omson

w asked to co Min. St. § .82 bd. b 99) nd dtn wtr te

state oerated to lasy a ativ rn stive pt becae e

invs on od gto o d bus b cld's hr O Co'

An. 9-048 No. 4. T stt roded:

Inv a d at bo ati nd sbio laus ob) d tat elat o te ed abuse o gt of d y a son

eposl e clds r s dnd in so 6265 sd , va dat"

. Stat. § 32 sbd. Sb (89. Te oson od low ot l

abo stat nd qston ped

. Cou tate at t nvsigaton tat podcd hs ul lew an i o a pso eposb h ilds ca atb ncte bcs s o tatons th algd os xird d tr t av nvtat data cad asrvate y Scto 3.2, Sbdio b of Act

Secon 3. sbdso b w ded to c by lslte 8. ( sota Seo Ls 198 h 77 Secto ) het eted oc dssd by legs r abo ctt o t chld mltetnt g s Mnota StatesSio 62656 adats at o ossons ust rpot sctdatt d sould llow a we n do po rate.lJg t mpi ncases the obaby ta c in ed o ptecton w t potton t alo wn cold wi that

Seton 66.56 llow nyoe o repo d meam ad toee aost ota onentliy pcn, ncrae th possbilt tat

pn h n iabl pl d ·

ad any i i ias i und ci 8 or a pnlty d tio .09 or s, awd o tty fs, or thnaty udr pt 1" ss addd)

5



MAY-03-2013 FRI 02:41 PM BEC COURT ADMIN FAX NO. 5073044700

_

tere wil be or unsbiaed ad e se reo mde ot rson eposi b r he e of he.

Th aoton o h dmt at bc eto 3 ubvsio 5b

reets a eg jdge hat f indv i ua i etated aed abuse o glet o a cd d the aw encet ivst i a i n agecy ot abe to estabis that ee Lie eden o hage e didual, te the iu's acy an epuaio wil proed y c i ng c v invei data abot a divda as rvate. I� hwe, 1 nvda nstiga is card ad red e nae esgatv data coceg at idva bcome blc Ths aen l efc a lglve co to ke te aw enceeteme o ata ceng aeged eeraos of alteaten of[s] ce cial vestgti s osistt wt he teaent o

mia ata abou hose nus ld poteto a i s counteare demens (Se Meota Stats eto 6.556 d i on tat classis al ata coeg aegaton an assessme oaeatn of chlden e agecs a ivate aa)

The ounty stats e lea h s pa invstigaon w abo aegaon i a pson r e po s ib le a c h d ce a t becam actve because te tate o mtaton exe e udelying n aegd crnal ose. he ys deato tha the daa ts f e va s a oet detiaton

.

O. Com Ad. -0 No 3 194). We s opion ovde b h

omisone nove da beong cv a dee eason an e ent

as s dstinon wout ga dee a pois l ea inrtatio

direcon ta le invsiaton d b proerly e a rvate

c

Eve d sente to t soen obgato to gad ee a potet

ey ight grte o seue y h oto o e Uted Sate a t aws ad

suae teo whenev thse gh a inoed any o proceedng bre

[] R v C n ly, 1 US. 62 67 18) h o ocs tha e neres

6




,_ �

of jsc wa cosiro o t ac at c ssao o da

coane he inactive cia ivestitive wold hav M. Hoe'

ama ights o ad vacy.

As al nce govee action h chs cosittonay poteced

sec o expressio contves e s Am Rley Naion Fedet of

i o N r C n 47 U.S 9 (1988); s Bat B ks. Inc. v

Suivn 3 US. 8 67 193) (sag t h s nn s govm

ocas o s "a sanctons - e hrea of okg ea sacos nd o1eeas o coercon pruo nd intidaton . to acve he spressio of

oect sch) O he sse o cna poscut o n ivda engn n

oec actiy t1e Spe o hs cozed ta []he chlg ect uon te

ecs o Fs eet s my deive o the c of ca oseco

nacted by the oscs o i sccess or !e. w v Pfse, 80 .S

49 4 (96). Wi resct to oven iesigatos o nduas olca

epession, he Supee Cot s also waed:

Ther is no ou at esaos 1e 01 d o sate vee capae o crochg uon cosona iberis o ndiduas.I paicua or t ecse o pow .. be caecisbed whn t vstve ocss tes o ge o scghy sesive <eas as do of speec or ess, eeo o oc

assocao a do of conncaon o deas

Swez v. ew I-am1shr 3 U.S. 234 24 1). o ls eason ou as said

at bee a sae can cope an dvdua ouh is vesatoy pows to scose

nton w trspass uo s Andn edos a suon

-I7




·-

nees o Sate" ust b por, ad th intest ut b copelig.' NAP

. Albama, 357 US 4 (

In t cas, 1 Cou dteed ta tere wa nuct evence o

demos·a 1a M Hoe a chlen Coequt te tate lacked a

compeng nes to nte wt s F medme ts. Te vegao

law ecent esued n 1 colecto of rge aont o psoa 1ation

coceg M. o and ly. s udsputed ta a of e aton

colected o cated b poce in corse of teir nvtation dscened om oe

ouc - le el phon veo wic costute proteced exeson ue te it

edent. Nothstang s cocion 1 P ges at t s entted to

acce te nvestae e bcase:

w proceedi e ecet ho o Bu Ea Couty a aguabyeven i the entir sta have raed ore ublc conce an ueionsabout 1 optos o ou puc uon ta as e cae of ae Ho n, epecly v how 1 cas nd Ma of hes eons aconce t le unaswerd the ar now e oos avaby whc to obta answe ecept le eco coected by govemetocas dr le cose of the iestigatio ha occe.

Poposed evenos Mo at 6 (ac 1, 203). e Cou conizn a

a dcson addesi e pot sue of lic acces to oveent t o

private nval mut be 1sd upon tkng d! cat bance eeen copetn

cosonal au. Wthout puc ght o acces to oveen t daa mpont

aect o eedo o speec a 'o res cou b ecea.' Rcond

N wp rs . Vrnia 448 US. 80 (98 But e irst enen doe not

uae l e a cottona o pecal acces o iao ot aalabe o

8




e p b geeU " l3mzburg . Hay s, 08 U.S. 66 68-85 (97. o e te

upee ot has eogze lat te ght of pul acces mu a ie gve wa to

e a nees of d

T od r o ecto fe b e rst Aee a m someg n e ae o ay du y o exe rcse the tecegt r esons a ty wey acowege ut ot aays obd yeor an pbliser t s o askng too u o s gget ta oe woexerce F Aenent gts n newpaes o roaatng eeesect oe efr o rotect l rg of e[]

easka Pes s v. S a US 3 60 (976.

uc an occaso were te pe t eeise restn a e o

et o o ec e ig of a acce o e seec va. T et

eect o irst ee t y goveet ove ight a conttnal

nuson[. ai tu 408 US 6 () ( Dog J seng) ( itto

o) (tng h bo a well as obo a gai te eece of precous

Fi ndnt ght a ow ene to goveet. Whee te ol ais

ol aton aganst a paent te mcoepton o tat ae seec o actity

poecte y e Frt mme t cl to oce v o a oe chJig eec o

t o tiatio of that et Ft mem gt t

gov o o rv rea o te miy hoe ts agng rough

he eo eects an exo8ue a tat oved o te blc e

Te Cotuon oe not pet sch collate uens o potecte xreson

Griwold v Conecti , 8 U.S 9 8 (6) ( (Te Ft menent a

ea w rv tecte m gov el uo.

9



MAY-03-2013 FRI 02:43 PM BEC COURT ADMIN FAX NO. 5073044700 P.

"· ._ .

c dscs o th nvesigave dta s case would al advrsy mact

th H' alys rg o rvac. Te Supm Cou has cnd h

ouo ght o vacy oud th Fu Amdts c

a, p o oy idvua utom a ates ut lo th

diduas n on dv!e hly on ato Se We

v Ro , 29 U.S. 89 5600 (97); s Nxon . Ao of Ge. Ss,

U 45 4 9 (oweg ta "[] emn o pacy as en

catzd a ddua ntst o dose o o as)

A pat ad s cdn not s�jc o at-assstd ubc sctny oi at

h ae ositoy ed o o We nvego v o a to

a mb o th y nt, ht os on whn te vac of t y hom s t

t puc ositoa buess

Fo all o te ras e Cou cncuds a aw ncnt

v l Stt of Mint Tod Chria Ho pctd

oe nd e st ad e

D

he Cour azs at s dcisin ot s w w didus desi

bd accs o o . Fr P 1t b ; dses acss

5 Bcus d ouon a pobs sclsu h daa as ve MDPA S M. S § 30 b. "A oven data cllctedad cv nd r dssenated by a gvnt ty h b pucss lassd by . . e w nonbl o tctd nnpub , o w stt daa dvual s v o ondl mp added)) s M. . §05000 bp 7 (del law mans . . e w u deon of yo n e jc yse.)

·




to n1ato to hep bet derst te cts d custances led t te

cmna ges e aganst Td Hoe as well as e deio to dsiss tose

cages" Te ny reasuce t CoL an e s tt te atio Fr P

sees s plan sght Al o th vstgative a eseted t oibus n a

led a Min Td Crn Hn [0R 6] as the

ell phne vdeos selves e pub. Stat § 18, sub. 7 Ay

nvestgtv ata pesete as ede i u sha be publc ). The state ad a ll

and oputy to a elevt and reile vence up o its rm alas th onib ar . M R C P sub. 1 (b). t t state ad a

dt to establsh prbabe cause f t hages agnt M. ub ly i at

ped_g Wkr . G oga, 47 US. 3 6 I 8) (obseg at a pblic

petal heag ps to ensue th juge a posecut c out t utes

esposbl"); In e Oliv r 33 S 57 0 .5 48) (The equremt

publc tal s f te beft o e asd that he pblc a e he s y eat t

and ot !st conee, a tat h pesene teste spetators a kp hs

es ke ae to a se o t sposiblty a to the ne o t

tios. ' . T Co panstang ved a cosdere a evdece pesente at

t1 obs eang and ssd a wtten oe arel xplang ts fgs t

a sios aw he state a ote ght to hav th fcua ndg

ewe le e a te lea t1natns eewe d n bt t eectd t

t. Beause dsmssal o all chas s ow al, te eco e cna

d s o pub sor fr natn tat a sed gt o te atns

1




'

actos, ad deiso o a pbi o ivod a cudn o of

ds Tha cord speaks se

hid-Pat

T o wl! t onid Potetia Inteno he F mtio to

r a a ar o g nd M. R. . P 240 1 . ntrvntion a o gh

petted Mi. R. G. P 2. 0 wh a potna ntevo e e og

r tera:

) [A] t appcaton teenton; ( n ntr atg to teoety o ctio wh e bjet of t aco; 3) rctedmostrag ta he dspoto o acto ay s a pctJ mampa o pde 1e pary's aby o proct at et a own at py o aeqey psnted b e xst pas .

Mneap lis Star & bun o v Schumhr 39 NW.2d 97 07 (M 986)

(atos oe) see n R C P. 40. Bcas e doe o hav a

l ntst e nsgav l nd GDPA i cesa acs a ntes

eag to he pey ts ao a i ot entld to tenion a a ttr o

ght. ar b v. a wns Patnesip 659 NW.2 87 99 (M. pp.

00 (oldng that ecas mda opa s ace ert reatg to sead ta

podced gato bee sp ts oso ad possoa bebl

tea ed opas d not e a to e ad seek modcao o

· pociv or).




CONCUON

F a gn s Pafs' mn f pn \ju

clay m GRANE ' mot on o nven s

oespoy DENIE MEMORDU a l eo a

ER

*

KJ

Hoffner v State of Minnesota Blue Earth County Order for Declaratory Judgment and Permanent...

Documents

Transcript of Hoffner v State of Minnesota Blue Earth County Order for Declaratory Judgment and Permanent...