Health Insurance: What it Actually Does -...
Transcript of Health Insurance: What it Actually Does -...
Health Insurance: What it Actually Does
Andrew FriedsonAssistant Professor of EconomicsUniversity of Colorado Denver
DABE LuncheonNovember 15, 2017
Health Insurance
Health Insurance is a big deal in the United States at the moment
2
80
82
84
86
88
90
92
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Percent of U.S. Population with Any Health Insurance (U.S. Census Bureau ‐ ACS)
We have just gone through a period of historic change in the U.S. health insurance market
The goal of this talk is to orient you to the big concepts needed to understand where we are going and why
A Brief History of Health Insurance in the U.S.
Around 1900 there was no such thing as health insurance – hospitals were places you went to die if you were poor
Soon after hospital care began to change and become much more effective – but care was incredibly expensive
Late 1920’s/Start of the Great Depression Baylor University Hospital and Blue Cross was the first true health insurance
3
A Brief History of Health Insurance
World War 2 was the perfect storm that set off the craze in employer provided health insurance
1. Wage freeze (1942 Emergency Stabilization Act)2. National War Labor Board (1942)3. Employer provided health insurance gains
preferred tax status (1943, and again in 1954)
The end result is growth in private insurance from 9 percent of the population in 1940 to 63 percent of the population in 1953. Around 70 percent is covered by the 1960s. 4
A Brief History of Health Insurance in the U.S.
A Brief History of Health Insurance
By the end of the war, the U.S. had a well developed private health insurance sector
Contrast this with the British Experience: wages were not capped, but the cost of living was kept in check by rationing and price controls on food.
At the end of the war, health insurance was almost completely absent from the U.K., and in 1946 the National Health Service was started with little private pushback.
5
A Brief History of Health Insurance in the U.S.
A Brief History of Health Insurance
The U.S. is very much an anomaly in world health insurance systems. Most countries rolled out a public health insurance system into a world with little private market
The U.S. had a private health insurance market develop early, and has to‐date provided government coverage for only select subpopulations: i.e. the elderly, disabled, poor, or the military
6
A Brief History of Health Insurance in the U.S.
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
The biggest misconception about health insurance is that it is insurance for your health
To make my point – let us consider CAR insurance
7
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the damage to the car• The current value of the car
9
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and restores you to “whole”
10
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and restores you to “whole”
11
Health Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and restores you to “whole”
12
Health Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you • The cost of obtaining treatment
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and restores you to “whole”
13
Health Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you • The cost of obtaining treatment
3. Also pays for routine maintenance and upgrades
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and restores you to “whole”
14
Health Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you • The cost of obtaining treatment
3. Also pays for routine maintenance and upgrades
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and other things, does not guarantee restoring you to “whole”
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and restores you to “whole”
15
Health Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you • The cost of obtaining treatment
3. Also pays for routine maintenance and upgrades
Insurance covers the risk of loss, and other things, does not guarantee restoring you to “whole”
This does not seem like good insurance for your health
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Maybe health insurance isn’t protection for your health at all. Maybe it’s protection for your WEALTH.
For life‐saving (and many other types of) care, people are not very price sensitive. They are willing to spend almost anything to obtain care.
If a health shock is essentially a wealth shock then the insurance policy makes more sense
16
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, restores you to “whole”
17
Health Wealth Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you • The cost of fully repairing the
financial damage
Insurance covers the risk of loss, restores you to “whole”
What does Health Insurance Really Cover?
Car Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you the lesser of• The cost of fully repairing the
damage to the car• The current value of the car
Insurance covers the risk of loss, restores you to “whole”
18
Health Wealth Insurance
1. Pay a premium for an insurance policy
2. In the case of an adverse event insurance pays you • The cost of fully repairing the
financial damage
Insurance covers the risk of loss, restores you to “whole”
Now this looks like an insurance policy!
Health Insurance as Wealth Insurance
This concept is central to health insurance, and is often overlooked in current policy discussions. This was not always the case:
“No longer will illness crush and destroy the savings that theyhave so carefully put away over a lifetime so that they mightenjoy dignity in their later years. No longer will young families seetheir own incomes, and their own hopes, eaten away simplybecause they are carrying out their deep moral obligations totheir parents, and to their uncles, and their aunts.”
‐President Lyndon B. Johnson, remarks when signing Medicareinto law, July 30, 1965
19
Health Insurance as Wealth Insurance
For the bulk of the population health insurance is not life or death, but it’s close. We are avoiding a state of the world where you have two choices:
1. Live the rest of your life in crushing debt or poverty
Or
2. You or a loved one live in horrible agony, die, or possibly both
20
Health Insurance as Wealth Insurance
For the bulk of the population health insurance is not life or death, but it’s close.
HOWEVER, for a subset of the population, health insurance is life or death. These are the very poor, who have no resources and often no access (beyond the ER). For them insurance can be equivalent to access.
21
Evidence
These claims are not controversial within Health Economics, as they have been tested and re‐tested. The most important study was the RAND Health Insurance Experiment
• The largest Randomized Control Trial in social science history ($136 million in 1984)
• Randomly assigned health insurance plans to households
• Little to no impact on health outcomes from insurance (UNLESS you’re low income)
• Big impacts on the amount of care you use, and out of pocket spending 22
Insurance Distorts the Price Signal
The next important thing to understand about health insurance is how it impacts patients decisions with regards to health care
If we believe that medical care is a well functioning market in the absence of health insurance, then adding insurance will scramble the price signal, undermining a market’s ability to operate efficiently
The price a patient feels becomes unhooked from the cost of care, incentivizing patients to overconsume
23
Insurance Distorts the Price Signal
The price a patient feels becomes unhooked from the cost of care, incentivizing patients to overconsume
• Insurers understand this and may try to steer patients to “effective” care and away from waste
• But, as long as coverage lowers the price patients feel, there will be overconsumption
24
Insurance Distorts the Price Signal
The law of demand: lower price, people buy more
Types of ways to pay for care when you have insurance• Flat copay• Co‐insurance• Deductibles• Health Savings Account
Prices via insurance are different than prices without insurance
25
Insurance Companies
Insurers are paid premiums, and pay out claims throughout the year. So to figure out how much an insurer needs to take in:
Some patients have more expenses, some have less, but on average this is what needs to be paid in
Premiums are paid in before the coverage starts, and paid out over time, so make a profit by investing in the interim
26
Insurance Companies
This works because insurers are able to cover a large number of people and pool the risk. This is the same idea as portfolio diversification, or a central limit theorem. The more people with uncorrelated risk, the lower the variance in total payouts and money in will equal money out.
27
Risk Pools
BUT a problem arises when the population as a whole has different groups with different levels of risk. i.e. some groups that on average need a lot of payouts and and some groups that need very little.
Presumably the high risk group is willing to pay more for coverage than the low risk group
28
Risk Pools
29
are low are medium are high
One thing we can do is EXPERIENCE RATING and charge people based on their risk. This is what we do with car insurance.
Risk Pools
30
are EXTREMELY high
One thing we can do is EXPERIENCE RATING and charge people based on their risk. This is what we do with car insurance.
But, for a subset of the population this would be impossibly unaffordable. AND for many of these people, their conditions are no fault of their own.
For a long time we did this in the U.S. – we either denied people coverage due to “pre‐existing conditions” or made their insurance incredibly expensive. There was a class of “uninsurable” people
Risk Pools
31
are EXTREMELY high
One thing we can do is EXPERIENCE RATING and charge people based on their risk. This is what we do with car insurance.
Also, as prices have grown ‐ in part due to better and more expensive treatments covering a wider variety of diseases – the group of “uninsurable” has expanded
are still pretty darn high
Risk Pools
32
are low are medium are high
Another solution is to charge everyone the same premium, based on the average for the population.
Risk Pools
33
are low are medium are high
Another solution is to charge everyone the same premium, based on the average for the population.
Here the premium will be low for the sick (relative to what it would be), and high for the healthy (relative to what it would be).
Risk Pools
34
are low are medium are high
If for some patients (the healthiest) premium > willingness to pay then those patients will choose to go without insurance
Risk Pools
35
are low are medium are high
If for some patients (the healthiest) premium > willingness to pay then those patients will choose to go without insurance
Risk Pools
36
are low are medium are high
If for some patients (the healthiest) premium > willingness to pay then those patients will choose to go without insurance
This changes the composition of who is insured, raising the group average and the group premium
Risk Pools
37
are low are medium are high
At the new premium, a new group of people will find that premium > willingness to pay and choose to go without insurance
This changes the composition of who is insured, raising the group average and the group premium
Risk Pools
38
are low are medium are high
At the new premium, a new group of people will find that premium > willingness to pay and choose to go without insurance
This changes the composition of who is insured, raising the group average and the group premium
Risk Pools
41
are low are medium are high
And so on, and so on…until only the riskiest people are left in the market. And they face the same incredibly high premiums as under experience rating!
This is referred to as an “adverse selection problem” or a “death spiral”
Stopping the Death Spiral
How to avoid this unpleasant outcome?
1. Go back to experience rating. Feel sorry for sick people
2. Break off the sick people into their own market and subsidize. Very Expensive market, still paid for by the healthy. May get mini‐death‐spirals
3. Convince healthy people to stay in the market
42
Stopping the Death Spiral
3. Convince healthy people to stay in the market
This is the approach most countries have taken
a) “Single Payer” ‐ everyone is on government insurance by law, then premiums (i.e. taxes) can’t spiral
b) “Market Based Solutions” – ACA
• AHCA, Various Senate Bills – split the difference between this and experience rating
43
Premise of the Current Plan
The ACA, or Jon Gruber’s 3‐legged stool
1. No more experience rating (touch off death‐spiral)
2. Mandate health insurance or pay penalty (throw the poor and self‐employed under the bus)
3. Expand insurance for the poor, roll out exchanges
Needs all 3 legs to stand
44
Expanding Insurance: The Good
45
Insurance as a “Merit Good”
Better financial stability• The early ACA‐Medicaid expansion cut payday loan usage
in California by over 1/3 among the young and working‐aged
• Better credit scores, less likely to go into collections, or into bankruptcy
Increased use of primary care, decreased use of ER with the Massachusetts Expansion
Job‐lock and Marriage‐lock
Expanding Insurance: The Bad
46
Taxes and regulatory frictions on business? Unemployment? Not much evidence of this happening
Moral Hazard
• Take worse care of yourself when you’re insured –for example more likely to get flu shot after losing Medicaid
• Care overuse – flat of the curve, and congestion
Expanding Insurance: The Bad
47
‐20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
2013Q1
2013Q2
2013Q3
2013Q4
2014Q1
2014Q2
2014Q3
2014Q4
2015Q1
2015Q2
2015Q3
2015Q4
2016Q1
2016Q2
Percen
t Growth Relative to 201
3 Q4
Non‐Minor Injury Minor Injury
Ambulance Call Volume in NYC
The average U.S. county saw a slowdown in ambulance response times of 1.8 minutes
Expanding Insurance: The Uncertain
48
Insurers and Bargaining Power
The insurance, drug, and care markets are all highly consolidated. A large influence on the prevailing prices is the relative size and bargaining power of an entity
Expanding insurance changes these power dynamics, but it can be hard to parse out who wins.• A bigger insurer will bargain better with a hospital and
lower payouts• At the same time they will bargain better with employers
and raise premiums
These markets continue to consolidate (CVS‐Aetna), it is unclear who this helps