Hazardous Area Classification and Control of Ignition Sources

17
Hazardous Area Classification and Control of Ignition Sources This Technical Measures Document refers to the classification of plant into hazardous areas, and the systematic identification and control of ignition sources The relevant Level 2 Criteria are 5.2.1.3(29)c [1] , 5.2.1.11(63)f [2] , 5.2.1.13 [3] and 5.2.4.2(93)a [4] . Design of plant, pipework and general plant layout is considered in Technical Measures Documents on Plant Layout [5] , Design Codes Plant [6] , Design Codes Pipework [7] , Plant Modification / Change Procedures [8] , Maintenance Procedures [9] . The Dangerous Substances and Explosive Atmospheres Regulations 2002 (DSEAR) provide for the first time a specific legal requirement to carry out a hazardous area study, and document the conclusions, in the form of zones. General Principles Hazardous Area Classification for Flammable Gases and Vapours Area classification may be carried out by direct analogy with typical installations described in established codes, or by more quantitative methods that require a more detailed knowledge of the plant. The starting point is to identify sources of release of flammable gas or vapour. These may arise from constant activities; from time to time in normal operation; or as the result of some unplanned event. In addition, inside process equipment may be a hazardous area, if both gas/vapour and air are present, though there is no actual release. Catastrophic failures, such as vessel or line rupture are not considered by an area classification study. A hazard identification process such as a Preliminary Hazard Analysis (PHA) or a Hazard and Operability Study (HAZOP) should consider these abnormal events. The most commonly used standard in the UK for determining area extent and classification is BS EN 60079 part 10 1 , which has broad applicability. The current version makes clear the direct link between the amounts of flammable vapour that may be released, the ventilation at that location,

description

Hazardous Areas Classification and Control of Ignition Sources by HSE

Transcript of Hazardous Area Classification and Control of Ignition Sources

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 1/17

    HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSourcesThisTechnicalMeasuresDocumentreferstotheclassificationofplantintohazardousareas,andthesystematicidentificationandcontrolofignitionsources

    TherelevantLevel2Criteriaare5.2.1.3(29)c [1],5.2.1.11(63)f [2],5.2.1.13 [3]and5.2.4.2(93)a [4].

    Designofplant,pipeworkandgeneralplantlayoutisconsideredinTechnicalMeasures

    DocumentsonPlantLayout [5],DesignCodesPlant [6],DesignCodesPipework [7],Plant

    Modification/ChangeProcedures [8],MaintenanceProcedures [9].

    TheDangerousSubstancesandExplosiveAtmospheresRegulations2002(DSEAR)provideforthefirsttimeaspecificlegalrequirementtocarryoutahazardousareastudy,anddocumenttheconclusions,intheformofzones.

    GeneralPrinciplesHazardousAreaClassificationforFlammableGasesandVapours

    Areaclassificationmaybecarriedoutbydirectanalogywithtypicalinstallationsdescribedinestablishedcodes,orbymorequantitativemethodsthatrequireamoredetailedknowledgeoftheplant.Thestartingpointistoidentifysourcesofreleaseofflammablegasorvapour.Thesemayarisefromconstantactivitiesfromtimetotimeinnormaloperationorastheresultofsomeunplannedevent.Inaddition,insideprocessequipmentmaybeahazardousarea,ifbothgas/vapourandairarepresent,thoughthereisnoactualrelease.

    Catastrophicfailures,suchasvesselorlinerupturearenotconsideredbyanareaclassificationstudy.AhazardidentificationprocesssuchasaPreliminaryHazardAnalysis(PHA)oraHazardandOperabilityStudy(HAZOP)shouldconsidertheseabnormalevents.

    ThemostcommonlyusedstandardintheUKfordeterminingareaextentandclassificationisBS

    EN60079part101,whichhasbroadapplicability.Thecurrentversionmakesclearthedirectlinkbetweentheamountsofflammablevapourthatmaybereleased,theventilationatthatlocation,

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 2/17

    andthezonenumber.Itcontainsasimplisticcalculationrelatingthesizeofzonetoarateofreleaseofgasorvapour,butitisnothelpfulforliquidreleases,wheretherateofvaporisationcontrolsthesizeofthehazardousarea.

    Othersourcesofadvice,whichdescribemoresophisticatedapproaches,aretheInstituteofPetroleumModelCodeofPractice(AreaClassificationCodeforPetroleumInstallations,2002),andtheInstitutionofGasEngineersSafetyRecommendationsSR25,(2001).TheIPcodeisforusebyrefineryandpetrochemicaltypeoperations.TheIGEcodeaddressesspecificallytransmission,distributionandstoragefacilitiesfornaturalgas,ratherthangasutilisationplant,butsomeoftheinformationwillberelevanttolargerscaleusers.

    Zoning

    HazardousareasaredefinedinDSEARas"anyplaceinwhichanexplosiveatmospheremayoccurinquantitiessuchastorequirespecialprecautionstoprotectthesafetyofworkers".Inthiscontext,'specialprecautions'isbesttakenasrelatingtotheconstruction,installationanduseof

    apparatus,asgiveninBSEN60079101.

    Areaclassificationisamethodofanalysingandclassifyingtheenvironmentwhereexplosivegasatmospheresmayoccur.Themainpurposeistofacilitatetheproperselectionandinstallationofapparatustobeusedsafelyinthatenvironment,takingintoaccountthepropertiesoftheflammablematerialsthatwillbepresent.DSEARspecificallyextendstheoriginalscopeofthisanalysis,totakeintoaccountnonelectricalsourcesofignition,andmobileequipmentthatcreatesanignitionrisk.

    Hazardousareasareclassifiedintozonesbasedonanassessmentofthefrequencyoftheoccurrenceanddurationofanexplosivegasatmosphere,asfollows:

    Zone0:Anareainwhichanexplosivegasatmosphereispresentcontinuouslyorforlongperiods

    Zone1:Anareainwhichanexplosivegasatmosphereislikelytooccurinnormaloperation

    Zone2:Anareainwhichanexplosivegasatmosphereisnotlikelytooccurinnormaloperationand,ifitoccurs,willonlyexistforashorttime.

    Varioussourceshavetriedtoplacetimelimitsontothesezones,butnonehavebeenofficiallyadopted.Themostcommonvaluesusedare:

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 3/17

    Zone0:Explosiveatmosphereformorethan1000h/yr

    Zone1:Explosiveatmosphereformorethan10,butlessthan1000h/yr

    Zone2:Explosiveatmosphereforlessthan10h/yr,butstillsufficientlylikelyastorequirecontrolsoverignitionsources.

    Wherepeoplewishtoquantifythezonedefinitions,thesevaluesarethemostappropriate,butforthemajorityofsituationsapurelyqualitativeapproachisadequate.

    Whenthehazardousareasofaplanthavebeenclassified,theremainderwillbedefinedasnonhazardous,sometimesreferredtoas'safeareas'.

    Thezonedefinitionstakenoaccountoftheconsequencesofarelease.Ifthisaspectisimportant,itmaybeaddressedbyupgradingthespecificationofequipmentorcontrolsoveractivitiesallowedwithinthezone.Thealternativeofspecifyingtheextentofzonesmoreconservativelyisnotgenerallyrecommended,asitleadstomoredifficultieswithequipmentselection,andillogicalitiesinrespectofcontroloverhealtheffectsfromvapoursassumedtobepresent.WhereoccupierschoosetodefineextensiveareasasZone1,thepracticalconsequencescouldusefullybediscussedduringsiteinspection.

    Asanexample:

    AproposalwasmadetozoneanaircrafthangerasZone1,althoughtheuseoffuelshandledabovetheirflashpointwouldbearareevent.ItproveddifficulttoobtainafloorcleaningmachinecertifiedforZone1areas,thoughthefloorneededsweepingregularly.TheoptionofwritingoutanexceptiontonormalinstructionstoallowanonExprotectedmachinetobeusedregularlyisnotrecommended.Instead,amorerealisticassessmentofthezonesisneeded,andspecialinstructionsissuedfortherareeventofusingmorevolatilefuels.

    Ahazardousareaextentandclassificationstudyinvolvesdueconsiderationanddocumentationofthefollowing:

    Theflammablematerialsthatmaybepresent

    Thephysicalpropertiesandcharacteristicsofeachoftheflammablematerials

    Thesourceofpotentialreleasesandhowtheycanformexplosiveatmospheres

    Prevailingoperatingtemperaturesandpressures

    Presence,degreeandavailabilityofventilation(forcedandnatural)

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 4/17

    Dispersionofreleasedvapourstobelowflammablelimits

    Theprobabilityofeachreleasescenario.

    Thesefactorsenableappropriateselectionofzonetypeandzoneextent,andalsoofequipment.TheIPcodegivesamethodologyforestimatingreleaseratesfromsmalldiameterholeswithpressurisedsources,andshowshowboththebuoyancyandmomentumofthereleaseinfluencetheextentofazone.IttabulatesvaluesforanLPGmixture,gasoline,naturalgas,andrefineryhydrogenforpressuresupto100barg.SimilarlytheIGEcodegivesamethodologyfornaturalgas,relatingtheleakratetotheholesizeandtheoperatingpressure.Thetablesofdispersiondistancestothezoneboundaryaddressinthemainquitelargediameterdeliberatevents.Thereisinpracticelittleoverlapbetweenthecodes.

    TheresultsofthisworkshouldbedocumentedinHazardousAreaClassificationdatasheets,supportedbyappropriatereferencedrawingsshowingtheextentofthezonesaround(includingaboveandbelowwhereappropriate)theplantitem.

    SelectionofEquipment

    DSEARsetsoutthelinkbetweenzones,andtheequipmentthatmaybeinstalledinthatzone.Thisappliestonewornewlymodifiedinstallations.TheequipmentcategoriesaredefinedbytheATEXequipmentdirective,setoutinUKlawastheEquipmentandProtectiveSystemsforUseinPotentiallyExplosiveAtmospheresRegulations1996.Standardssetoutdifferentprotectionconcepts,withfurthersubdivisionsforsometypesofequipmentaccordingtogasgroupandtemperatureclassification.Mostoftheelectricalstandardshavebeendevelopedovermanyyearsandarenowsetatinternationallevel,whilestandardsfornonelectricalequipmentareonlyjustbecomingavailablefromCEN.

    TheDSEARACOPdescribestheprovisionsconcerningexistingequipment.

    Therearedifferenttechnicalmeans(protectionconcepts)ofbuildingequipmenttothedifferentcategories.These,thestandardcurrentinmid2003,andthelettergivingthetypeofprotectionarelistedbelow.

    Zone0 Zone1 Zone2

    Category1 Category2 Category3

    'ia'intrinsicallysafeEN50020,2002

    'd'Flameproofenclosure

    ElectricalType'n'EN50021

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 5/17

    EN500182000 1999NonelectricalEN134631,2001

    ExsSpecialprotectionifspecificallycertifiedforZone0

    'p'PressurisedEN500162002

    'q'PowderfillingEN50017,1998

    'o'OilimmersionEN50015,1998

    'e'IncreasedsafetyEN50019,2000

    'ib'IntrinsicsafetyEN50020,2002

    'm'EncapsulationEN50028,1987

    's'Specialprotection

    Correctselectionofelectricalequipmentforhazardousareasrequiresthefollowinginformation:

    Classificationofthehazardousarea(asinzonesshowninthetableabove)

    Temperatureclassorignitiontemperatureofthegasorvapourinvolvedaccordingtothetablebelow:

    TemperatureClassification

    MaximumSurfaceTemperature,C

    IgnitionTemperatureofgasorvapour,C

    T1 450 >450

    T2 300 >300

    T3 200 >200

    T4 135 >135

    T5 100 >100

    T6 85 >85

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 6/17

    Ifseveraldifferentflammablematerialsmaybepresentwithinaparticulararea,thematerialthatgivesthehighestclassificationdictatestheoverallareaclassification.TheIPcodeconsidersspecificallytheissueofhydrogencontainingprocessstreamsascommonlyfoundonrefineryplants.Considerationshouldbeshownforflammablematerialthatmaybegeneratedduetointeractionbetweenchemicalspecies.

    IgnitionSourcesIdentificationandControl

    Ignitionsourcesmaybe:

    Flames

    Directfiredspaceandprocessheating

    Useofcigarettes/matchesetc

    Cuttingandweldingflames

    Hotsurfaces

    Heatedprocessvesselssuchasdryersandfurnaces

    Hotprocessvessels

    Spaceheatingequipment

    Mechanicalmachinery

    Electricalequipmentandlights

    Spontaneousheating

    Frictionheatingorsparks

    Impactsparks

    Sparksfromelectricalequipment

    Straycurrentsfromelectricalequipment

    Electrostaticdischargesparks:

    Lightningstrikes.

    Electromagneticradiationofdifferentwavelengths

    Vehicles,unlessspeciallydesignedormodifiedarelikelytocontainarangeofpotentialignitionsources

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 7/17

    Sourcesofignitionshouldbeeffectivelycontrolledinallhazardousareasbyacombinationofdesignmeasures,andsystemsofwork:

    Usingelectricalequipmentandinstrumentationclassifiedforthezoneinwhichitislocated.Newmechanicalequipmentwillneedtobeselectedinthesameway.(Seeabove)

    Earthingofallplant/equipment(seeTechnicalMeasuresDocumentonEarthing [10])

    Eliminationofsurfacesaboveautoignitiontemperaturesofflammablematerialsbeinghandled/stored(seeabove)

    Provisionoflightningprotection

    Correctselectionofvehicles/internalcombustionenginesthathavetoworkinthezoned

    areas(seeTechnicalMeasuresDocumentonPermittoWorkSystems [11])

    Correctselectionofequipmenttoavoidhighintensityelectromagneticradiationsources,e.g.limitationsonthepowerinputtofibreopticsystems,avoidanceofhighintensitylasersorsourcesofinfraredradiation

    Prohibitionofsmoking/useofmatches/lighters

    Controlsovertheuseofnormalvehicles

    Controlsoveractivitiesthatcreateintermittenthazardousareas,e.g.tankerloading/unloading

    Controlofmaintenanceactivitiesthatmaycausesparks/hotsurfaces/nakedflamesthroughaPermittoWorkSystem

    Precautionstocontroltheriskfrompyrophoricscale,usuallyassociatedwithformationofferroussulphideinsideprocessequipment

    DirectFiredHeaters,HotOilSystemsandProcessesOperatingAboveAutoIgnitionTemperaturesArangeofpetrochemicalandrefineryprocessesusedirectfiredheaters,e.g.steamcrackersforethyleneproduction.Clearly,ifthefuelsupplytotheheaterorthepipeworkcarryingtheprocessfluidleaksclosetothefurnace,anyleakmustbeexpectedtofindasourceofignition,eitherdirectlyattheflames,orbyasurfaceheatedbyaflame.Inthesecircumstances,hazardousareaclassification,andappropriateselectionofATEXequipmentisnotsuitableasabasisofsafetyfor

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 8/17

    preventingfireandexplosionrisks.

    Instead,safetyshouldbeachievedbyacombinationofahighstandardofintegrityoffuelandprocesspipelines,togetherwithameansofrapiddetectionandisolationofanypipesthatdofail.TheconsequencesofthefailureofapipecarryingprocessmaterialswithinthefurnaceshouldbeconsideredinanyHAZOPstudy.

    Otherprocesses(suchashotoilheatingcircuits)mayhandleproductsabovetheirautoignitiontemperature.Anysuchprocessesshouldbespecificallyidentifiedinasafetycase.Again,areaclassificationisnotasuitablemeansofcontrollingtheignitionrisks,andthesameconsiderationsapply,aswithfiredheaters.

    LightningProtectionProtectionagainstlightninginvolvesinstallationofasurgeprotectiondevicebetweeneachnonearthbondedcoreofthecableandthelocalstructure.FurtherguidancecanbefoundinBS

    6651:19991(Codeofpracticeforprotectionofstructuresagainstlightning).Ignitionscausedbylightningcannotbeeliminatedentirely,particularlywithfloatingrooftanks,wherevapourisusuallypresentaroundtherimseal.Inthesecircumstances,measurestomitigatetheconsequencesofafireshouldbeprovided.

    VehiclesMostnormalvehiclescontainawiderangeofignitionsources.Thesewillincludeelectricalcircuitstheinletandexhaustofanyinternalcombustionengineelectrostaticbuildupoverheatingbrakes,andothermovingparts.Siterulesshouldbeclearwherenormalroadvehiclesmaybetaken,andareaswheretheymustbeexcluded.

    StandardEN17551setsouttherequirementsfordieselpowderedATEXcategory2or3lifttrucks.Electricpoweredvehiclescanalsobebuiltusingacombinationofthisstandardandthenormalelectricalstandards.Nospecificationisavailableforvehicleswithsparkignitionengines,anditisunlikelythatsuchanenginecouldbebuilteconomically.VehiclescertifiedtoATEXrequirementsarehoweverexpensive,andformanyapplicationsanunprotectedtypehastobeextensivelyrebuilt.Consequently,manyemployersarelikelytotryandjustifynotzoningstoragecompounds,wherelifttruckshandleflammableliquidsorgasesincontainers.Insomestores,perhapswithlimiteduseofavehicle,thismaybeacceptable.DiscussionshavebeenheldwiththeBritishChemicalDistributorsandTradersAssociation,withtheobjectiveofclarifyingwhen

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 9/17

    storageareasshouldbeclassifiedaszone2.Theconclusionsfromthisexercisewillbemadeavailableinduecourse.Discussionsarealsoongoing,aboutvehicleswithgasdetectionsystems,designedtoshuttheengineandisolateothersourcesofignitionintheeventofagasrelease.AtpresentthesearesoldwithoutanyclaimforATEXcompliance,butwiththesuggestiontheymaybeusefulincasesofremoterisk.

    ForthepurposesofCOMAH,anassessmentisneededoftheriskthatanignitionwithinastoragecompoundwillproduceamajoraccident,eitherdirectlyorbecauseafireorexplosionspreadstoinvolveothermaterials.Ifthisispossible,itismoreappropriatetoprovidecontrolstopreventthespread,ratherthansimplyapplymoreconservativezoning,andmorerestrictiverulesontheequipmentusedinthestore.

    Wherespecialistvehicles(e.g.cranes)areneededduringmaintenanceoperations,propercontrolsandplantisolationmayallowthenormalzonestobesuspended.Typicallythesewillinvolvewritteninstructions,asspecifiedinDSEARschedule1,oraformalpermittoworksystem.

    Manysiteswillhaveoperationsoffillingandemptyingroadtankerswithflammablematerials.Controlswillbeneededtopreventorminimisethereleaseofgasorvapourbutcontrolsoverignitionsourcesarealsoneeded.Hazardousareasmaybeconsideredtoexistduringthetransferoperation,butshouldnotbepresentoncethetransferiscomplete.Safesystemsofworkareneededtoensuresafetywheresuch'transient'zonesexist.

    FactorsforAssessorofaSafetyCasetoConsiderIsafullsetofplansidentifyinghazardousareasavailable?Foralargesitetheyneednotallbeprovidedinthereport,butthoseexamplesrelevanttotherepresentativesetofmajoraccidentsuponwhichtheALARPdemonstrationisbasedmustbeincluded.

    Haveallflammablesubstancespresenthavebeenconsideredduringareaclassification,includingrawmaterials,intermediatesandbyproducts,finalproductandeffluents?Commonlythesewillbegroupedforthepurposesofanyareaclassificationstudy.

    Locationswherealargereleaseispossibleandtheextentofhazardousareashasbeenminimisedbytheuseofmechanicalventilationshouldbeidentified,e.g.gasturbinepowergenerationunits,compressorhouses.Somereferencetodesigncodes,andcommissioningcheckstoensuretheventilationachievesthedesignaim,shouldbeprovided.Theconsequencesofalossofpowertothesystemshouldbeincludedinanysectionlookingatotherconsequencesofpowerloss.

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 10/17

    Haveappropriatestandardsbeenusedforselectionofequipmentinhazardousareas?ExistingplantwillnotmeettheformulainDSEAR,butolderstandardsdistinguishedbetweenelectricalequipmentsuitableforzones0,1and2.Doesthereportidentifyoldelectricalequipmentstillinserviceinahazardousarea,andwhatassessmenthasbeenmadetoensureitremainssafeforuse?

    Isthereareferencetotheimpactuponextentandclassificationofhazardousareasinthesectiondescribingplantmodification(seeTechnicalMeasuresDocumentonPlant

    Modification/ChangeProcedures [12])passiveitemslikenewwallsandbuildingscaninfluencethisiftheyobstructnaturalventilationofadjacentplant

    Haveallignitionsourcesbeenconsidered?AchecklistisprovidedintheDSEARACOP

    oncontrolandmitigationmeasures,andBSEN1127part11(Explosiveatmospheres.Explosionpreventionandprotection.Basicconceptsandmethodology).

    FactorsthatcouldbeconsideredduringanonsiteinspectionIfthereareanylargeareasofzone1onthedrawings,isthereevidencethatbydesignandoperationcontrols,thesourcesofreleaseandconsequentlythelocationandextentofhazardousareashavebeenminimised?

    Doanyzone2areasextendtoplaceswheretheoccupierhasinadequatecontroloveractivitiesthatcouldcreateanignitionsource,oristhereanysuggestionthatthezoneboundarieshavebeenarbitrarilyadjustedtoavoidthis?

    Hasignitionprotectedelectricalequipmentbeeninstalledandmaintainedbysuitablytrainedstaff.

    Aretherisksfromstaticdischargescontrolledproperly?Earthingofplant,drumsandtankersisthemostbasicrequirementotherprecautionsaredescribedinthereferences

    Whatcontrolmeasuresoverignitionsourcesareadoptedinhazardousareasduringmaintenancewhereignitionsourcesmustbeintroduced,typicalprecautionsincludetheuseofsupplementaryventilation,portablegasdetectors,andinertingofsectionsof

    plant.AlocalprojectonElectricalEquipmentinFlammableAtmospheres [13]wasundertakenandareportoftheproject'sconclusionscompleted.

    DustExplosionsTheCOMAHRegulationsdonotapplytoanymaterialiftheonlyriskcreatedisthatofadust

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 11/17

    explosion.However,manytoxicmaterialsarehandledinfinepowderform,andaseriousdustexplosioncouldcauseamajoraccident.Adustexplosioninvolvinganontoxicdustlikepolyethylenewouldnotresultinamajoraccidentasdefinedintheregulations,unlessitalsoledtolossofcontainmentofaCOMAHsubstance.Adustexplosioncouldthenbeaninitiatorofamajoraccident.Measurestopreventmajoraccidentsshouldaddressallpotentialinitiators.

    DSEARrequiresthathazardousareaclassificationforflammabledustsshouldbeundertakeninthesamemannerasthatforflammablegasesandvapours.Zoningasdescribedabovemaybeapplied,replacing'gasatmosphere'with'dust/airmixtures'.Thezonenumbersusedare20,21and22,correspondingto0,1and2usedforgases/vapours

    TheonlyrelevantstandardtohelppeoplezonetheirplantisBSEN50281part3,20021,whichisanadaptationoftheIECequivalent.

    Wheretoxicdustsareprocessed,releasesintothegeneralatmosphereshouldbeprevented,andtheextentofanyzone21or22outsidethecontainmentsystemshouldbeminimalornonexistent.Theinsideofdifferentpartsoftheplantmayneedtobezonedas20,21or22,dependingontheconditionsatparticularlocations.

    Classificationofdustsrelatingtoautoignitionandminimumignitioncurrentisundertakensimilarlytogases/vapours,butinvolvesadditionalcomplications.

    Theexplosibilityofdustsisdependentuponanumberoffactors:

    chemicalcomposition

    particlesize

    oxygenconcentration

    Wheretoxicdustsarehandled,inmostcasesoccupierswillneedtocarryouttestingoftheproductforitsexplosionproperties.CompaniesabletoundertakensuchtestingarelistedintheIChemE'sbookonthepreventionofdustexplosions.Thereisnolegallydefinedtestforanexplosibledust.However,formanyyearswehaveusedasmallscalescreeningtest,thevertical

    tubetest,describedinHSG1032.Theissuesaboutrepresentativesamplesofdust,andotherfactorsthatmightcausetheresultstovaryarealsodiscussedinthisguidance.Ingeneral,dustswithaparticlesizegreaterthan500mareunlikelytocauseanexplosion.Formostchemicalproductsitispreferabletotestdusttakenfromtheprocess,butiftheparticlesizedistribution

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 12/17

    varies,itiscommontotestmaterialthatpassesa63micronsieve,andtakethisastheworstcase.

    Ignitionduetoahotsurfaceispossible,butthetemperatureneededtoigniteadustlayerdependsonlayerthicknessandcontacttime.ForCOMAHsiteswithtoxicdusts,themostlikelyhazardwouldariseindryingprocesses,ifsubstantialquantitieswereheldforextendedperiodshotenoughtostartselfheatingorsmoulderingcombustion.

    StatusofGuidanceExistingcodesofpracticeprovideinformationwithrespecttogoodpracticeforhazardousareaclassification.Thestandardsdetailingselectionofappropriateelectricalapparatushavebeenupdatedtotakeintoconsiderationventilationeffects.

    Europeanequipmentstandardsmaybecome'harmonised'whenareferencetothemispublishedintheOfficialJournaloftheEuropeanCommunity.AlistofATEXharmonisedstandardscanbe

    checkedontheEUwebsite [14]:

    Equipmentbuilttosuchaharmonisedstandardmayassumeautomaticconformitywiththoseessentialsafetyrequirementsofrelevantdirectivesthatarecoveredbythestandard.TheEPSregulationsdescribetheconformityassessmentproceduresthatapplytodifferenttypesofequipment.

    ReferenceDocumentsHS(G)512Storageofflammableliquidsincontainers,HSE,1998.Appendix3describestherequirementsforhazardousareaclassification.TheuseofBS

    EN6007910:20031,andtheInstituteofPetroleumCode'AreaClassificationCodeforPetroleumInstallations:ModelCodeofpracticeinthePetroleumIndustry'Part15arerecommended.Itsuggestsalldrumstoresshouldbezone2,toaheight1mabovethestack.ThesameadviceappearsinHSG166andHSG113onignitionprotectedlifttrucks.Discussionswithindustryontherelaxationofthisinparticularcircumstancesareongoing.

    HS(G)712Chemicalwarehousing:thestorageofpackageddangeroussubstances,HSE,1998.Thiscontainsverylimitedinformationonhazardousareaclassificationorcontrolof

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 13/17

    ignitionsources

    HS(G)1032Safehandlingofcombustibledusts:precautionsagainstexplosions,HSE,2ndEdition,2003

    HS(G)1132Lifttrucksinpotentiallyflammableatmospheres.ThecontentsofthishavebeenovertakentosomedegreebyDSEAR,andtheEPSregulations.

    HS(G)1402Safeuseandhandlingofflammableliquids,HSE,1996.Appendix3describestherequirementsforhazardousareaclassification.TheuseofBS

    EN60079141andtheInstituteofPetroleumCode'AreaClassificationCodeforPetroleumInstallations:ModelCodeofpracticeinthePetroleumIndustry'Part15arerecommended.Thisisaimedmainlyatsmallscalehandling,withcontainersof200litresorless.

    HS(G)1662Formulaforhealthandsafety:guidanceforsmallandmediumsizedfirmsinthechemicalindustry,HSE,1997.Theguidancedescribestherequirementsforhazardousareaclassification,andgivessometypicalexamples.Theseshouldnowbeseenasratherconservative.Theuseof

    BSEN6007914,BSEN50281andBSEN605291arerecommended.Thisisbasiclevelguidance,andCOMAHreportsshouldnormallyreferencemorespecificpublications,suchastheotherHSGseriesbookslisted,andotheritemsinthislist.

    HS(G)1762Thestorageofflammableliquidsintanks,HSE,1998.Paragraphs35to39describetherequirementsforhazardousareaclassification.This

    crossreferencesBSEN6007910:20031,andtheInstituteofPetroleumCode'AreaClassificationCodeforPetroleumInstallations:InstituteofPetroleumModelCodeofSafePractice,part15,areaclassificationforinstallationshandlingflammablefluids,2ndedition2002.

    HS(G)1862Thebulktransferofdangerousliquidsandgasesbetweenshipandshore,HSE,1999.Appendix2describestherequirementsforhazardousareaclassification.TheuseofBS

    EN60079101andtheInstituteofPetroleumCode'AreaClassificationCodeforPetroleumInstallations:ModelCodeofpracticeinthePetroleumIndustry'Part15arerecommended.Containsusefulinformationaboutelectrostatichazardsduringunloading.

    LPGACOP1BulkLPGstorageatfixedinstallations.Part1:Design,installationand

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 14/17

    operationofvesselslocatedaboveground,LPGasAssociation,1998.

    LPGAcodeshavenotpreviouslydrawnacleardistinctionbetweenhazardousareas,andseparationdistancesrequiredforotherreasons.Thesearecurrentlyunderrevision,andwillspecifyhazardousareas,thatinmostcaseswillbesmallerthantheseparation

    distance.CurrentcodesarelistedontheUKLPGwebsite [15].

    ModelCodeofpracticeinthePetroleumIndustry'Part15isrecommended.Theguidancealsorecommendsthatzonesberecordedinaplantopreventsourcesofignitionbeingbroughtin.

    ElectricalEquipment

    StandardsproducedbyEuropeintheBSEN50014rangearegraduallybeing

    supersededbyinternationalstandardsproducedintherangeBSIEC600791.Equipmentbuilttoolderstandards,includingpurelynationalstandardsmayremaininservice,provideditisproperlymaintained.TheIECrangeofstandardsalsoincludesdocumentsonselection,installationandmaintenanceofequipmentforuseinexplosiveatmospheres.

    Nonelectricalequipment

    ThefirststandardforexplosionprotectednonelectricalequipmentisBSEN13463part

    11.Itdescribesrequirementsfor"Category3"equipment.Furtherpartsofthisstandardarewelladvancedandwillappearduring2004.

    BSEN11271:19981ExplosiveatmospheresExplosionpreventionandprotectionPart1:Basicconceptsandmethodology,BritishStandardsInstitution.ThisgivesadditionalgeneraladviceonthemanyoftheissuescoveredinthisTMD.

    Electrostaticignitionrisks

    ThemostrecentgeneralsourceofadvicewasdraftedbyaEuropeanstandardsworkinggroup,butwaspublishedintheUKasBSPDR044001andnotasafullstandard.Itcontainsmuchusefuladviceaboutlimitingpumpingspeeds,electrostaticrisksfromclothing,andmanydetailed

    operations.ThetwopartsoftheolderBS5958:19911CodeofPracticeforthecontrolofundesirablestaticelectricityremaincurrent,becausetheycontainsomeusefulinformationnotduplicatedbythePD.Thetwopartsare:

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 15/17

    Part1:1991Generalconsiderations

    Part2:1991Recommendationsforparticularindustrialsituations

    BSEN502811.Thedifferentpartsofthisstandardsetoutrequirementsforconstructionofequipmentforuseinatmospherescontainingexplosivedustsinformationaboutselectionandmaintenanceand

    BSEN502813:20021coverstheclassificationofareaswherecombustibledustsareormaybepresent.

    BS6651:19991.Codeofpracticeforprotectionofstructuresagainstlightning,BritishStandardsInstitution.Section9providesguidanceonlightningprotectionofstructureswithinherentexplosiverisks.

    BS7430:19981Codeofpracticeforearthing,BritishStandardsInstitution.Lightningprotection.Section23providesguidanceonlightningprotection.

    FurtherReadingMaterialCox,A.W.,Lees,F.P.andAng,M.L.,'ClassificationofHazardousLocations',1993.

    Thiswasastudyledbyaconsortiumofthechemical,electricalandmechanicalengineeringinstitutes,andshowedhowthesubjectspannedthetraditionaldivides.Itwasimportantinthedevelopmentofideas,butprovidesnonewmethodologyforusers.

    AGuidetoSafetyinAerosolManufacture,BAMA,ThirdEdition,1999.

    DustExplosionPreventionandProtection:APracticalGuide,IChemE,ISBN0852954107

    Apractitioner'shandbookElectricalinstallationandmaintenanceinpotentiallyexplosive

    atmospheres [16],PublicationNo.186,TheEngineeringEquipmentandMaterialsUsersAssociation.

    References1. ForfurtherinformationontherelevantBritishStandards,pleaseaccesstheBritish

    Standardswebsite [17]andusethesearchfacility.

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 16/17

    Pagelastupdated:22ndSeptember2004

    LinkURLsinthispage

    1. 5.2.1.3(29)chttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sram/index.htm

    2. 5.2.1.11(63)fhttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sram/index.htm

    3. 5.2.1.13http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sram/index.htm

    4. 5.2.4.2(93)ahttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sram/index.htm

    5. PlantLayouthttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasplantlay.htm

    6. DesignCodesPlanthttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasplant.htm

    7. DesignCodesPipeworkhttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeaspipework.htm

    8. PlantModification/ChangeProcedureshttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasplantmod.htm

    9. MaintenanceProcedureshttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasmaintena.htm

    10. Earthinghttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasearthing.htm

    11. PermittoWorkSystemshttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeaspermit.htm

    12. PlantModification/ChangeProcedureshttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasplantmod.htm

    13. ElectricalEquipmentinFlammableAtmosphereshttp://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/images/flamatmosphere.pdf

    14. EUwebsitehttp://europa.eu/index_en.htm

    15. UKLPGwebsite

  • 5/24/2015 HazardousAreaClassificationandControlofIgnitionSources

    http://www.hse.gov.uk/comah/sragtech/techmeasareaclas.htm 17/17

    http://www.uklpg.org/

    16. Electricalinstallationandmaintenanceinpotentiallyexplosiveatmosphereshttp://www.eemua.org/Products/Publications/Print/EEMUAPublication186.aspx

    17. BritishStandardswebsitehttp://www.bsiglobal.com/index.xalter