HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

24
1. HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT Applicant ...................................................................... Provident Partners 129, LLC Request ........................................................................ Rezone from Agricultural Residential-IV (AR- IV) to Light-Industrial (I-I) Proposed Use .............................................................. Distribution warehouse Size ............................................................................... 66.85± acres Zoning .......................................................................... AR-IV Location ....................................................................... On the south side of Athens Highway at its intersection with Roy Parks Road; a.k.a. 3104 Athens Highway; Tax Parcel 15024 000227 Commission District ................................................... Three County Commission Date .......................................... August 2, 2021 Staff Recommendation ............................................... Denial This request was tabled at the July 19, 2021 Planning Commission meeting. Applicant Proposal The applicant is requesting to rezone the subject property from Agricultural-Residential-IV (AR-IV) to Planned Industrial Development (PID) for warehouse and distribution facilities. The proposed facility will include three (3) buildings of various sizes totaling to 380,000 square feet in area. The warehouses will facilitate the distribution of dry goods and possibly food-grade and general commodities, but not refrigerated or frozen goods. The proposed design of the buildings include tilt-wall concrete and cross docks with truck courts, as well as reveals and clerestory windows to enhance the building’s aesthetic. As the property falls within the Gateway Corridors Overlay District (GCOD), the applicant requests certain variances from this section of the code: §17.420.050.C.1.c. Transitional Buffers Transitional buffers are required along and inside the property line at the perimeter of a planned development district that abuts single-family residential zoning or uses, in accordance with the requirements of this subsection, but no transitional buffers are required between dissimilar uses within the planned development district. o There is a 50-foot buffer depicted along the southern and eastern property on the submitted site plan. The applicant states that as the rear property line is heavily wooded and will not be disturbed during construction, it is requested that no additional planting be required in this area. §17.420.050.D.5 Visual blending of slopes Cuts and fills shall be terraced to blend into the natural terrain. Cut or fill slopes more than ten feet in height shall be landscaped with evergreen shrubbery planted at the rate of ten shrubs per 100 lineal feet.

Transcript of HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

Page 1: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

1.

HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

Applicant ...................................................................... Provident Partners 129, LLC Request ........................................................................ Rezone from Agricultural Residential-IV (AR-

IV) to Light-Industrial (I-I) Proposed Use .............................................................. Distribution warehouse Size ............................................................................... 66.85± acres Zoning .......................................................................... AR-IV Location ....................................................................... On the south side of Athens Highway at its

intersection with Roy Parks Road; a.k.a. 3104 Athens Highway; Tax Parcel 15024 000227

Commission District ................................................... Three County Commission Date .......................................... August 2, 2021 Staff Recommendation ............................................... Denial

This request was tabled at the July 19, 2021 Planning Commission meeting.

Applicant Proposal

The applicant is requesting to rezone the subject property from Agricultural-Residential-IV (AR-IV) to

Planned Industrial Development (PID) for warehouse and distribution facilities. The proposed facility

will include three (3) buildings of various sizes totaling to 380,000 square feet in area. The warehouses

will facilitate the distribution of dry goods and possibly food-grade and general commodities, but not

refrigerated or frozen goods. The proposed design of the buildings include tilt-wall concrete and cross

docks with truck courts, as well as reveals and clerestory windows to enhance the building’s aesthetic.

As the property falls within the Gateway Corridors Overlay District (GCOD), the applicant requests

certain variances from this section of the code:

§17.420.050.C.1.c. Transitional Buffers –Transitional buffers are required along and inside the

property line at the perimeter of a planned development district that abuts single-family

residential zoning or uses, in accordance with the requirements of this subsection, but no

transitional buffers are required between dissimilar uses within the planned development

district.

o There is a 50-foot buffer depicted along the southern and eastern property on the

submitted site plan.

The applicant states that as the rear property line is heavily wooded and will

not be disturbed during construction, it is requested that no additional planting

be required in this area.

§17.420.050.D.5 Visual blending of slopes – Cuts and fills shall be terraced to blend into the

natural terrain. Cut or fill slopes more than ten feet in height shall be landscaped with evergreen

shrubbery planted at the rate of ten shrubs per 100 lineal feet.

Page 2: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

2.

o The applicant states that as this is a light industrial development, it is requested that

this screening requirement be waived along Athens Highway (US Hwy. 129), Roy

Parks Road, and the rear property line.

§17.420.050.F.2.b Outdoor Lighting – Parking lot, sidewalk, and building illumination – Only

incandescent, florescent, metal halide, low-pressure sodium, or color corrected, high-pressure

sodium may be used. The same type of lighting must be used for the same or similar types of

lighting on any one site.

o The applicant states that as technology has improved since the adoption of the code,

it is requested that more energy-efficient LED lighting be installed and utilized.

§17.420.050.G.2.b Interparcel Access – A design speed of 15 mph and a two-way travel aisle

with a minimum paved width of 22 feet (back of curb to back of curb). Paving, base and curb

specifications shall meet Hall County's standards for public streets.

o The applicant states that the private access drive design will be designed to

accommodate anticipated truck traffic for the site and this requirement be waived

because this will not be a public road.

§17.420.050.G.2.d Interparcel Access – Driveway aprons, stub-outs and other design features

to indicate that abutting properties may be connected to provide cross access via a service

drive.

o The applicant states that while the private access road will provide vehicular access

between buildings, there will be no pedestrian connection between buildings. The

applicant asks that this requirement be waived.

§17.420.050.H.1.b Architectural Standards for Non-Residential Buildings - Building height Any

non-residential building located within 250 feet of a residential or agricultural use street shall

be limited to no more than three stories in height.

o The applicant states that while the buildings will be only 1 story in height, the exterior

walls will measure approximately 38 feet in height. The applicant asks that this

requirement be waived.

§17.420.050.H.2.c Architectural Standards for Non-Residential Buildings - Building materials

– Building materials used for all four sides of new or reconstructed buildings are restricted to

the following: Brick and/or Stone. Natural stone such as, but not limited to, granite, limestone,

and marble are allowed building materials. Terra cotta and/or cast stone, which simulate

natural stone, are also acceptable. Painted stone is prohibited. Split-face block/concrete

masonry unit (CMU) is restricted to 50 percent of the surface area of each side of a principal

building. Stucco is restricted to 50 percent of the surface area of each side of a building. Glass

and glass block. Exposed concrete block, painted concrete block, metal, tilt/up and pre-cast

concrete are prohibited materials for any exterior wall.

o The applicant states that while the buildings will be for light industrial use, i.e.

warehousing, and proposed construction will be 100% concrete tilt-wall construction

for the buildings. The applicant asks that this requirement be waived.

§17.420.050.H.3 Architectural Standards for Non-Residential Buildings - Roof materials –

Materials for pitched roofs shall be limited to architectural grade composition shingles, natural

slate, natural terra cotta, natural wood shake, or factory finished metal with standing seams.

o The applicant states that the industry standard roof for construction of this type is a

60mil white TPO membrance roof. The applicant asks that this requirement be waived.

Page 3: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

3.

Proposed Development Standards:

Standard Proposed Official Code of Hall County

Min Lot Area: 15,000 sq. ft. 15,000 sq. ft. (§17.240.010)

Max Impervious Area: 80% 80% of lot area (§17.240.110)

Max Building 300,000 sq. ft. 80% of lot area (§17.240.110)

Max Building Height 35 ft. ≤ three stories (§17.420.050.H.1.B)

Min Lot Frontage: 100 ft. 150 feet (§16.50.040)

Front Building Setback (US129): 100 feet from c/l or

75 feet from property

line, whichever is

greater

100 feet from centerline of arterial

road (§17.240.040)

Exterior Buffer: No additional planting

at rear boundary

buffer

50 feet (§17.420.050.C.2.C)

Visual blending of slopes: Waive screening

requirement along

Athens Hwy, Roy

Parks Rd, and rear

boundary

Cut or fill slopes more than 10 feet to be landscaped with ten shrubs every 100 feet (§17.420.050.D.5)

Outdoor Lighting: LED lighting Only incandescent, florescent, metal

halide, low-pressure sodium, or color

corrected, high-pressure sodium may

be used. (§17.420.050.F.2.b)

Interparcel Access: Private access drive

designed to

accommodate

anticipated truck

traffic for the site.

A design speed of 15 mph and a two-

way travel aisle with a minimum

paved width of 22 feet (back of curb

to back of curb). Paving, base and

curb specifications shall meet Hall

County's standards for public streets.

(§17.420.050.G.2.b)

Interparcel Access: Private access road

will provide vehicular

access between

buildings; there will

be no pedestrian

connection between

buildings.

Access Driveway aprons, stub-outs

and other design features to indicate

that abutting properties may be

connected to provide cross access via

a service drive. (§17.420.050.G.2.d)

Architectural Standards: Industry standard

roof for construction

of this type is a 60mil

white TPO

membrance roof.

Materials for pitched roofs shall be

limited to architectural grade

composition shingles, natural slate,

natural terra cotta, natural wood

shake, or factory finished metal with

standing seams. (§17.420.050.H.3)

Page 4: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

4.

History and Existing Land Uses

The subject property consists of 66.85± acres and is zoned Agricultural-Residential-IV (AR-IV). The

property is undeveloped and a mix of open and wooded areas. A stream is located near the western

boundary, and an overhead power line easement runs north and south through the middle. The

property has frontage on both Athens Highway (US Hwy. 129) and Roy Parks Road.

Adjacent properties to the west and across Athens Highway are also zoned AR-IV, and developed

with single-family residences or agricultural uses. The Bluffton Subdivision is located to the east, zoned

Residential-I (R-I) and is partially developed. Across Athens Highway are two cold warehouse facilities,

which are both zoned Light-Industrial (I-I). Across Roy Parks Road is a property zoned Planned

Commercial Development (PCD) for a gas station.

The subject property also falls within the Gateway Corridors Overlay District (GCOD), which is

supplemental to the underlying zoning district classification. The GCOD governs non-residential

property development standards.

Comprehensive Plan Land Use Designation

The subject property is located within a Mixed-Use/Revitalization corridor according to the Future Land

Use Designation. The primary future land uses within this type of corridor are for retail, office, higher

density residential (including multi-family), civic uses, and open/park spaces. Developments within this

corridor should be low-impact industrial or higher-density residential only where the same is found on

adjacent properties. The proposed use is inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan as the adjacent

parcels are zoned Residential-I and Agricultural-Residential-IV. The parcel is separated from the non-

residential zoned properties by existing right-of-ways.

The corridor is primarily developed with large agricultural tract the subject parcel; however, the

immediate area across Athens Highway is also zoned I-I and there is a commercial development

across Roy Parks Road. Additionally, there has been recent non-residential and non-agricultural

development along this corridor to the north and south, though no rezoning requests have been

approved on adjacent parcels.

Development Support and Constraints

Public Facilities

The subject property is located approximately 2.5 miles from Hall County Fire Station #1, located at

2460 Athens Highway. There are multiple fire hydrants along Athens Highway and Roy Parks Road in

front of the subject property.

Hall County Environmental Health

In an email dated July 7, 2021 Emily McGahee stated that the development “Must meet all

Environmental Health commercial septic system permitting requirements. Further determination will

be made during the civil plan review process. A detailed business plan must be submitted to Hall

County Environmental Health for review. Additional items, including, but not limited to: recorded plat,

soil evaluation, and septic system installation may be required after review of business plan.”

Hall County Public Works and Utilities

In a memorandum from Public Works and Utilities on July 8, 2021, Director Srikanth Yamala stated

the following:

Page 5: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

5.

Engineering

No comment

Traffic

1. Improve Roy Parks Road from Athens Highway (SR11/US129) to site access to Hall

County industrial/commercial standards.

2. Provide a left turn lane on Roy Parks Road for site access.

3. Development construction and business commercial traffic only be permitted to use Roy

Parks Road from site access to Athens Highway (SR11/US129) and the remainder of Roy

Parks Road will be restricted. Developer must provide and maintain the appropriate traffic

signage to ensure compliance.

4. Improvements to Roy Parks Road must be constructed concurrently with site development.

5. It will be the developer’s responsibility to coordinate Roy Parks Road improvements with

the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT) and acquire any necessary permits.

6. All costs associated with improvements will be the developer’s responsibility.

7. Site access along Athens Highway (SR11/US129) must be approved and permitted

through the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

Utilities

No sewer available

Hall County Tax Assessors

No comments provide.

Water Service

Per Hall County GIS, there is access to public water along Athens Highway.

Georgia Department of Transportation

In an email dated July 9, 2021, Parker Niebauer, a Traffic Operations Supervisor with GDOT, stated

that this project will require GDOT coordination.

Zoning Analysis

The proposed use for light manufacturing and warehouse/distribution facilities is inconsistent with

the Comprehensive Plan designation of a mixed use/revitalization corridor as the proposed

development is adjacent to single-family residential zoned parcels.

o The current corridor is primarily developed with large agricultural tracts in close proximity

to the subject parcel although there is nearby I-I zoned property.

It is anticipated that future development along Athens Highway may trend towards

more intensive non-residential and non-agricultural uses and would be classified

differently in an updated version of the Comprehensive Plan.

Per §17.180.090.B.2 of the Official Code of Hall County “The development controls for the district

shall be detailed (lot coverage, setbacks, building heights, lot sizes, etc.). If standards are not

specifically proposed, then the applicable standards in the light industrial (I-I) district, together with

the screening and buffer requirements, shall apply.”

Page 6: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

6.

The GCOD provides guidelines for non-residential property development. The guidelines apply to

both permitted uses and development standards.

o Within the GCOD, the following uses are prohibited: adult entertainment, junk yards, and

billboard signs.

o Uses subject to the approval of the Hall County Board of Commissioners include: self-

storage warehouses, vehicle sales lots (new or used), automobile repair and maintenance,

commercial outdoor recreation, car wash, and outdoor storage.

Per §17.420.050.D.2.a, a ten-foot wide landscape strip is required along each street frontage,

continuous along the frontage except for perpendicular crossings for driveways and utilities.

o This is not depicted on the applicant’s submitted site plan; this condition is not met.

Per §17.420.050.D.4.d, all outdoor storage shall be screened from view from public streets and

adjacent property by a permanent opaque enclosure consisting of a minimum eight-foot high solid

fence or wall.

o No outdoor storage is proposed; this does meet the GCOD standard.

Per §17.420.050.C.2.C, the transitional buffers where an industrial zoning district abuts property

zoned for residential or agricultural use shall be no less than 50 feet and shall be placed along the

inside property line of the non-residential property.

o The applicant is requesting a buffer variance for the rear boundary where existing

vegetation shall not be supplemented with planting; this does not meet the GCOD

standard.

Per §17.420.050.D.3, if a loading or service area is located within 50 feet of a side or rear lot line

abutting residentially zoned property, then the loading or service area shall be surrounded by either

a six foot height masonry screening wall, or a six foot height solid wooden fence placed on the

inside of the required landscaped buffer.

o According to the site plan, this condition is met.

Per §17.420.050.E.4.A, each parking area over 50 spaces shall include landscaped islands within

the parking area equivalent to not less than five to ten percent with planning director discretion of

the total paved area of the parking lot.

o The narrative and/or site plan does not show landscape islands within the parking area,

this does not meet the GCOD standard.

Building materials for all four sides of a new building are restricted to the following: brick, stone,

and glass or glass block. Up to 50% of the surface area of each side may be stucco, and up to

50% of the surface area of each side of a principal building may be split-face block/concrete

masonry unit. Concrete block, painted concrete block, tilt-up and pre-cast concrete are not

allowed.

o The applicant is requesting a variance to allow exterior walls of the building to be tilt-

up or pre-stress concrete wall panels.

o This condition is not met.

Per §17.420.050.H.3, roof materials for pitched roofs shall be limited to architectural grade

composition shingles, natural slate, natural terra cotta, natural wood shake, or factory finished

metal with standing seams.

o The applicant is requesting a variance to allow an industry standard roof for construction

of this type to be a 60mil white TPO membrane roof.

o This condition is not met.

Per §17.420.050.F.1 outdoor lighting shall be provided on all public streets and parking lots.

o The applicant is proposing LED exterior lighting; this condition is not met.

Page 7: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

7.

§17.250.020A of the Official Code of Hall County lists the following minimum parking standards

for the development:

o Office, office building or studio: 3.5 spaces for each 1,000 square feet of gross floor area

(§17.250.20A)

o Warehousing: 1 space for each 2 employees (§17.250.20A)

o Industrial uses: 1.6 spaces for each 1,000 square feet of gross floor area (§17.250.20A)

The applicant shows proposed parking for each building on the site plan; this

condition has been met.

The following recommendations have been provided by Hall County Traffic Engineering:

o Improve Roy Parks Road from Athens Highway (SR11/US129) to site access to Hall

County industrial/commercial standards.

o Provide a left turn lane on Roy Parks Road for site access.

o Development construction and business commercial traffic only be permitted to use Roy

Parks Road from site access to Athens Highway (SR11/US129) and the remainder of Roy

Parks Road will be restricted. Developer must provide and maintain the appropriate traffic

signage to ensure compliance.

o Improvements to Roy Parks Road must be constructed concurrently with site development.

o It will be the developer’s responsibility to coordinate Roy Parks Road improvements with

the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT) and acquire any necessary permits.

o All costs associated with improvements will be the developer’s responsibility.

o Site access along Athens Highway (SR11/US129) must be approved and permitted

through the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

Staff Recommendation

Staff recommends denial of the applicant’s request However, if the board sees fit to approve, staff

recommends that the following conditions shall apply:

1. The development shall conform substantially with the proposed narrative, modified as

necessary for compliance with current development standards at time of application.

2. All future development shall be subject to all standards set forth by the Gateway Corridor

Overlay District; no variances to these standards shall be approved.

3. The developer shall improve Roy Parks Road from Athens Highway (SR11/US129) to site

access to Hall County industrial/commercial standards.

4. The developer shall provide a left turn lane on Roy Parks Road for site access.

5. Development construction and business commercial traffic only be permitted to use Roy

Parks Road from site access to Athens Highway (SR11/US129) and the remainder of Roy

Parks Road will be restricted. Developer must provide and maintain the appropriate traffic

signage to ensure compliance.

6. Improvements to Roy Parks Road must be constructed concurrently with site development.

7. It will be the developer’s responsibility to coordinate Roy Parks Road improvements with the

Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT) and acquire any necessary permits.

8. All costs associated with improvements will be the developer’s responsibility.

9. Site access along Athens Highway (SR11/US129) must be approved and permitted through

the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

10. All conditions of zoning shall become a part of any plat recorded for this property.

/EGG

Page 8: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 9: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 10: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 11: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 12: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 13: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 14: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 15: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

BLUFFTONDR

IVE

ROYPARKS

ROAD

SOUTHCHASEDRIVE

BARRETT ROADSUGAR

HI LL

WAY

FAIRHILL DRIVE

J FARMER ROAD

PRIEST CIRCLE

REEC

ECIR

CLE

ATHENS

HIGHWAY

PENNINGTON

T RAIL

BAKERROAD

BOB BRYANT ROAD

DORSEYP EEK

ROAD

UVPCD

UVPCFD

UVR-I

UVPRD

UVR-I-L

UVH-B

UVS-S

UVPID

UVAR-IVUVI-I

0 600 1,200300Feet

Subject Area

±Zoning BoundaryCity LimitsSubject AreaStructure

Applicant: PROVIDENT PARTNERS 129, LLC Tax Parcel #: 15024 000227 Location: 3104 ATHENS HIGHWAY, GAINESVILLE, GA 30507 Commission District 3 PC Mtg. Date: 07/19/2021

Page 16: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

ROY

PARK

SRO

AD

SOUTH MEADOW COURT

BLUF

FTON

DRIVE

FAIR

HILLDRIVE

ATHENSHIGHWAY

J FARMER ROAD

UVR-I

UVAR-IV

UVPCD

UVH-BUVI-I

0 200 400100Feet

±Zoning BoundaryCity LimitsSubject AreaStructure

Subject Area

Applicant: PROVIDENT PARTNERS 129, LLC Tax Parcel #: 15024 000227 Location: 3104 ATHENS HIGHWAY, GAINESVILLE, GA 30507 Commission District 3 PC Mtg. Date: 07/19/2021

Page 17: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

ROY

PARK

S RO

AD

SOUTH MEADOW COURT

BLUF

FTON

DRIVE

FAIR

HILLDRIVE

ATHENSHIGHWAY

J FARMER ROAD

UVR-I

UVI-I

UVR-I

UVAR-IV

UVPCD

UVH-B

UVAR-IV

UVI-I

0 200 400100Feet

±Zoning BoundaryCity LimitsSubject Area

Applicant: PROVIDENT PARTNERS 129, LLC Tax Parcel #: 15024 000227 Location: 3104 ATHENS HIGHWAY, GAINESVILLE, GA 30507 Commission District 3 PC Mtg. Date: 07/19/2021

Page 18: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT
Page 19: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

1

Laura Ogletree (Planning)

From: Emily McGahee (Environmental Health)Sent: Wednesday, July 7, 2021 3:54 PMTo: Laura Ogletree (Planning); Sarah McQuade (Planning)Cc: Chad Harper (Environmental Health); Kelly Hairston (Environmental Health)Subject: HCPC Tentative Agenda for 7.19.21

Please find Environmental Health comments below: Items 1 and 2, 0/4258 Cagle Road, Cagle Road LLC: No comment. Public Sewer. Item 3, 1400/1515 River Place: No comment. Public sewer. Item 4, 4157 Arthur Miller Road, Gay: Must meet all Environmental Health residential septic system permitting requirements. Level 3 Soil Evaluation and to-scale site plan required at time of permit application. Item 5, 1507 Browns Bridge Ave, Calvo: Existing septic system approved for a total of 2 bedrooms only. Floor plan will be required prior to any approval for new construction. Item 6, 3623 Dorsey Circle, Conde Properties: In 2001, Environmental Health issued septic permit 01-00681 to allow construction of a new home with the condition that the existing mobile home be removed from the property. This property does not meet the area requirements to support 2 residential structures as required by the Hall County Board of Health Lot Size Resolution; therefore, Environmental Health cannot approve any building permits for upgrades/renovations to the mobile home. Item 7, 3104 Athens Hwy, Provident Partners: Must meet all Environmental Health commercial septic system permitting requirements. Further determination will be made during the civil plan review process. A detailed business plan must be submitted to Hall County Environmental Health for review. Additional items, including, but not limited to: recorded plat, soil evaluation, and septic system installation may be required after review of business plan. Item 8, 4240 Winder Hwy, Aoun: No comment. Public Sewer. Item 9, 3835/3875 Cornelia Hwy, GA Lula Cornelia Hwy, LLC: No comment. Public Sewer. Item 10, 5697 Green Road, Jackson: All proposed lots must meet Hall County Board of Health Lot Size Resolution requirements. Item 11, 3818 Falcon Pkwy, Lam: Must meet all Environmental Health commercial septic system permitting requirements. Further determination will be made during the civil plan review process. A detailed business plan must be submitted to Hall County Environmental Health for review. An existing system evaluation and/or septic system installation/modification may be required. Items 12 and 13, 4152 Browns Bridge Road, Lanier Luxe: Must meet all Environmental Health commercial septic system permitting requirements. Further determination will be made during the civil plan review process. A detailed business plan must be submitted to Hall County Environmental Health for review. An existing system evaluation and/or septic system installation/modification may be required. Item 14, 5092/5118 Hog Mountain, McGee: Must meet all Environmental Health commercial septic system permitting requirements. Further determination will be made during the civil plan review process. A detailed business plan must be

Page 20: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

2

submitted to Hall County Environmental Health for review. Additional items, including, but not limited to: recorded plat, soil evaluation, and septic system installation may be required after review of business plan. Item 15, 5301 L. J. Martin Road, Skelton: A variation of this subdivision plat (2 lots) was approved by our office on June 9, 2021. Any further subdivision of the property must meet all Hall County Board of Health Lot Size Resolution Requirements. Emily McGahee Hall County Environmental Health Hall County Government Center – 3rd Floor 2875 Browns Bridge Road Mailing: PO Box 5901 Gainesville, GA 30504 (770) 531-3973 (770) 531-6767 (fax)  http://dph.georgia.gov/environmental‐health (State Website) http://www.phdistrict2.org/HallCounty.htm (District Website) http://www.hallcounty.org/devserv/environmental.asp (County Website & Forms) 

 

Page 21: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

Hall County Government PUBLIC WORKS AND UTILITIES

POST OFFICE DRAWER 1435 GAINESVILLE, GA 30503

t: 770.531.6800 | f: 770.531.3945

SRIKANTH YAMALA Director

BILL NASH, P.E.

Assistant Director

M E M O R A N D U M

To: Sarah McQuade, Director of Planning and Development

From: Srikanth Yamala, Director of Public Works and Utilities

Date: July 8, 2021

Subject: July 19, 2021 Hall County Planning Commission Agenda

Please be advised that our office has reviewed the Hall County Planning

Commission agenda for the June 23, 2021 meeting. Upon review, we

provide the following comments:

1. Previously tabled application of Cagle Rd, LLC for a Use Subject to County Commission approval on 31.50± acres located on the south side of Cagle Road across from its intersection with Oak Lake Drive; a.k.a. 0, 0, and 4258 Cagle Road, Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcels 09098 000007, 000008, and 000002. Proposed Use: sawmill, lumberyard, wood boiler, and biofuel plant. ** Commission District 3.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: Previous Comments Apply

c) Utilities: No Comment 2. Previously tabled application of Cagle Rd, LLC to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III (AR-III) to Heavy Industrial (I-II) on 31.50± acres located on the south side of Cagle Road across from its intersection with Oak Lake Drive; a.k.a. 0, 0, and 4258 Cagle Road, Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcels 09098 000007, 000008, and 000002. Proposed Use: sawmill, lumberyard, wood boiler, and biofuel plant. ** Commission District 3.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: Previous Comments Apply

c) Utilities: No Comment 3. Previously tabled application of Northeast Georgia Health System, Inc. (NGHS) to rezone from Planned Commercial Development (PCD) and Planned Office Development (POD) to Planned Office Development (POD) and to amend conditions of a Planned Office Development (POD) on a 119.16± acre tract located on the north side of Friendship Road approximately 1680 feet from its intersection with Old Winder Highway; a.k.a. 1400 & 1515 River Place; Zoned POD & PCD; Tax Parcels 15039 000465 & 000592. Proposed Use: amend parking requirements. ** Commission District 1.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: No Traffic Comments

c) Utilities: No Comment

Page 22: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

4. Application of Ronald Gay for a rear yard setback variance from 25 feet to 15 feet on a 0.68± acre tract located on the east side of Arthur Miller Road 900± feet from its intersection with Old Cornelia Highway; a.k.a. 4157 Arthur Miller Road; Zoned AR-IV; Tax Parcel 15018 000181. Proposed Use: construct a single-family residence. * Commission District 3.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: No Traffic Comments

c) Utilities: No Comment

5. Application of Emiliano Arroyo Calvo a Use Subject to Planning Commission approval on a 0.36± acre tract located on the west side of Browns Bridge Avenue approximately 320 feet from its intersection with Carter Street; a.k.a. 1507 Browns Bridge Road; Zoned O-I; Tax Parcel 00123 007020A. Proposed Use: expansion of a non-conforming use – enclose existing carport for residential purposes. * Commission District 4.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: No Traffic Comments

c) Utilities: No Comment

6. Application of Sergio Felix/Conde Properties, LLC a Use Subject to Planning Commission approval on a 0. 47± acre tract located on the east side of Dorsey Circle approximately 445 feet from its intersection with Dorsey Drive; a.k.a. 3623 Dorsey Circle; Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcel 08034 002014. Proposed Use: expansion of a non-conforming use –two residences on one parcel. * Commission District 2.

a) Engineering:

b) Traffic: No traffic comments

c) Utilities:

7. Application of Provident Partners 129, LLC to rezone from Agricultural Residential-IV (AR-IV) to Light Industrial (I-I) on a 66.85± acre tract located on the south side of Athens Highway at its intersection with Roy Parks Road; a.k.a. 3104 Athens Highway; Zoned AR-IV; Tax Parcel 15024 000227. Proposed Use: distribution warehouse. ** Commission District 3.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: We recommend the following: 1. Improve Roy Parks Road from Athens Highway (SR11/US129)

to site access to Hall County industrial/commercial standards. 2. Provide a left turn lane on Roy Parks Road for site access. 3. Development construction and business commercial traffic

only be permitted to use Roy Parks Road from site access to Athens Highway (SR11/US129) and the remainder of Roy Parks Road will be restricted. Developer must provide and maintain the appropriate traffic signage to ensure compliance.

4. Improvements to Roy parks Road must be constructed concurrently with site development.

Page 23: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

5. It will be the developer’s responsibility to coordinate Roy Parks

Road improvements with the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT) and acquire any necessary permits.

6. All costs associated with improvements will be the developer’s responsibility.

7. Site access along Athens Highway (SR11/US129) must be approved and permitted through the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

c) Utilities: No Sewer Available

8. Application of Maroum Aoun to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III (AR-III) to Planned Office Development (POD) on a 7.51± acre tract located on the west side of Winder Highway approximately 880 feet from its intersection with Martin Road; a.k.a. 4240 Winder Highway, Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcel 15044B000009. Proposed Use: daycare center. ** Commission District 1.

a) Engineering: Green Drive ROW Extends Through Property

b) Traffic: No traffic comments

c) Utilities: Oakwood Sewer

9. Application of GA Lula Cornelia Hwy, LLC to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III (AR-III) to Planned Industrial Development (PID) on 79.70± acres located on the north side of Cornelia Highway approximately 4,700 feet from its intersection with Cagle Road, a.k.a. 3835 and 3875 Cornelia Highway, Zoned AR-III and I-I; Tax Parcels 15007 000095A and 000276. Proposed Use: office and warehouse. ** Commission District 3.

a) Engineering: Stormwater Must Meet Hall County Regulations

b) Traffic: Access must be approved and permitted through the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

c) Utilities: Sewer Design Shall Be Part Of Development Plan

10. Application of Jason Jackson to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III (AR-III) to Planned Residential Development (PRD) on a 3.804± acre tract located on the east side of Green Road approximately 265 feet from its intersection with Holiday Road; a.k.a. 5697 Green Road; Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcel 07329 004016. Proposed Use: 5-lot subdivision. ** Commission District 1.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: No Traffic Comments

c) Utilities: No Comment

11. Application of Hung Lam to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III (AR-II) to Highway Business (H-B) on a 3.86± acre tract located on the west side of Falcon Parkway approximately 155 feet from its intersection with Chris Avenue; a.k.a. 3818 Falcon Parkway; Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcel 08050 001005. Proposed Use: outdoor storage – boat and RV storage. ** Commission District 2.

a) Engineering: Stormwater Shall Meet Hall County Standards

b) Traffic: Access must be approved and permitted through the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

c) Utilities: No Comment

Page 24: HALL COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

12. Application of Lanier Luxe Self Storage to rezone from Residential-I and

Agricultural Residential-III (AR-III) to Highway Business (H-B) on a 9.862± acre tract located on the north side of Browns Bridge Road at its intersection with Cherokee Trail; a.k.a. 4152 Browns Bridge Road; Zoned R-I & AR-III; Tax Parcel 08050 003002. Proposed Use: self-storage warehouse. ** Commission District 2.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: We recommend site access be on Browns Bridge Road (SR 369). If access on Cherokee Trail is considered, we recommend the following:

1. Improve Cherokee Trail from Browns Bridge Road (SR 369) to site access to Hall County commercial standards including, but not limited to, roadway width, pavement section, turning radii at Browns Bridge Road (SR 369) and markings.

2. The gated access must be appropriately designed to allow vehicles to stage without protruding into Cherokee Trail.

3. It will be the developer’s responsibility to acquire any necessary permits from the Georgia Department of Transportation (GDOT).

4. Required improvements will be constructed concurrently with site development.

5. All costs associated with improvements will be the developer’s responsibility.

c) Utilities: No Comment

13. Application of Lanier Luxe Self Storage for a Use Subject to Planning Commission approval on a 9.862± acre tract located on the north side of Browns Bridge Road at its intersection with Cherokee Trail; a.k.a. 4152 Browns Bridge Road; Zoned R-I & AR-III; Tax Parcel 08050 003002. Proposed Use: caretaker or employee residence. * Commission District 2.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: No traffic comments regarding caretaker residence request. Development comments above.

c) Utilities: No Comment

14. Application of C. Sam McGee to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III to Planned Commercial Development (PCD) on a combined 6.41± acres located on the west side of Hog Mountain Road approximately 1,760 feet from its intersection with Holland Dam Road; a.k.a. 5092 and 5118 Hog Mountain Road; Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcels 08116 000002 and 000007. Proposed Use: self-storage warehouse. ** Commission District 1.

a) Engineering: Submit Combination Plat

b) Traffic: No traffic comments

c) Utilities: No Comment

15. Application of Mark Skelton to rezone from Agricultural Residential-III to Residential-I (R-I) on a 6.41± acre tract located on the north side of L J Martin Road approximately 1,235 feet from its intersection with Strickland Road; a.k.a. 5301 Strickland Road; Zoned AR-III; Tax Parcel 15037 000031. Proposed Use: 3-lot subdivision. ** Commission District 1.

a) Engineering: No Comment

b) Traffic: No Traffic Comments

c) Utilities: No Comment