Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
-
Upload
digital-library-numis-dln -
Category
Documents
-
view
213 -
download
0
Transcript of Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
1/100
/';-=09 )(8*
=-0/']
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:07:56 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
2/100
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
3/100
NUMISMATIC NOTES AND MONOGRAPHS
Number 115
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:07:56 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
4/100
NUMISMATIC NOTES AND MONOGRAPHS
is
devoted
o
essays
nd treatises n
subjects
elat-
ing
to
coins,
aper money,
medalsand
decorations.
PUBLICATION COMMITTEE
Herbert E.
Ives,
Chairman
Alfred
R. Bellinger
Agnes
Baldwin
Brett
Thomas
O.
Mabbott
Sawyer McA.
Mosser,
Editor
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:07:56 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
5/100
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
6/100
COPYRIGHT,
949,
Y
THEAMERICANUMISMATICOCIETY
RUDISILL
COMPANY,NC.,
ANCASTER,A.,
.S.A.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:07:56 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
7/100
Hacienda Tokens
of
Mexico
BY
O. P.
EKLUND
AND
SYDNEY
P.
NOE
THE
AMERICAN NUMISMATIC
SOCIETY
BROADWAYT
15ÓTH
TREET
NEW
YORK
1949
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
8/100
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
9/100
HACIENDA TOKENS
OF MEXICO
This
monograph
s
chiefly
due
to
the
initiativeof Mr.
O.
P.
Eklund,
whose
specializing
n
Minor
Coinages
is well
known,
nd
who
early
realized the
importance
of the tokens
issued
by
the
haciendas of
Mexico. The careful
catalogue
which
comprises
he
major
part
of this
publication
s his
work,
ave for
ome
slight
ddi-
tions
ormodifications. volumeofrubbings f all thepieceswhich
had
come to his
notice,
ncluding
he
collection
ormed
y
him and
later
acquired
by
Mr.
Howard
D.
Gibbs,
supplemented
is manu-
script.
his was later
amplified
y
the
pieces acquired
by
The
Ameri-
can
Numismatic
Society.
The
pieces
illustrated n the
plates
are
part
of the cabinet
of The
American Numismatic
Society.
Reference
o the
catalogue
is
made
by
number.
Pieces
bearing
monograms
re
designated
by
letters n
the
plates,
as
they
are not included
in the
alphabetical
catalogue.
Those described n themonograph, os Tlacos Coloniales (Mexico,
1935),
by
Señor
Manuel Romero
de Terreros are so
designated,
and the ones he
illustrates
re asterisked.
The
complicated
coinage
of Mexico
has
intrigued
many
numis-
matists nd collectors.
The
War
of
Independence
(1811-21),
the
era
of
Maximilian,
and
the Revolution of
1913-16,
have all left
indelible
marks
upon
the
country's oinage,
and
previous
mono-
graphs published
by
The American Numismatic
Society
have con-
sidered some of
the
problems
connected
with this
coinage.
Our
present oncern s with hegroupof Mexico's coins,generally nown
as
Hacienda
Tokens,
which,
because of
the extended
chronologi-
cal
period
over
which
their ssues
extend,
hares
n
the
complexity.
It
provides
n admirable
illustration f the
importance
f a
minor
coinage
in
reflecting
he
life of a
people.
Inasmuch as definition
s
the best
corrective
or
complexity,
t will be
well for us
to
digress
long
enough
to obtain
a
comprehension
f
what the
word ha-
cienda
involves.
An
excursus
nto the
geography
and
agrarian
economy
of Mexico
may
be found
not
without value for other
phases of that country'smonetaryhistory.
In
1923,
The
American
Geographical
Society
published
n
its
Research
Series
(No.
12)
a
volume
entitled
The Land
Systems
f
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
10/100
2 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
Mexico
by
George
McCutchen
McBride,
in which the
important
part
played
by
these
units of
the
agricultural
ife of
the
country
s
given
the
prominence
t
deserves.
We are under
obligation
o
Dr.
McBride for
illuminating
uotations
which will afford
he reader
a better
understanding
f the situation
han
may
be
had
by
other
than direct
recourse
to his
book,
which is
now
out
of
print.
We
make
grateful
cknowledgment
or
permission
o
quote.
One
important
tatement
must be made as a
preliminary.
he
hacienda
system
which Dr. McBride has described o
helpfully
s
gone.
It
has
passed just
as the
cowboy
and the
life of the
range
which
figured
o
controllingly
n
the
development
f the
West
n
our
own
country
no
longer
exist. The
political
changes
which
have
brought
his
about are not
part
of our
study,
ut it
is
interesting
o
note that
the
transitions still
going
on and its course s
providing
profitable
ield f observation
o economists.
In
reading
what Dr. McBride has
written,
e
must
keep
in
mind
that
where he uses
the
present
we
must
supply
the
past
tense
even
though
his book was written
nly
twenty-fiveears
go.
The
haciendas of Mexico are the most
conspicuous
feature f
the land
system
f the
country.They give
to
agricultural
Mexico
its
distinctive
ast,
and,
by
their
great
size,
create the
impression
that the entire and is divided
nto vast rural
estates.These
prop-
erties,
ndeed,
are
the
only
type
of
agricultural
olding mmediately
visible o thetraveler n
many
parts
f
Mexico,
ust
as the
haciendado
is the
only
type
of
agriculturist
hose
interests each
beyond
the
immediate
neighborhood
f
his
home.
Many
of
the haciendas are
of
very
great
extent;
t
is
estimated
that
300 of
them
contain at least
25,000
acres
each;
116
have not
less than
62,500 acres;
51 have
approximately
5,000
acres;
while
11
are believed to
have
250,000
acres
apiece.*
The
Mexican ha-
cienda
seldom
contains
ess than
25,000
acres
whether
ituated
n
the
arid
plans
of
the
north,
where and is worth ittle
r
nothing,
r
in
the
densely
ettled reas
of
the
Mesa
Central,
where
the
price
of
land is
high
even
in
comparison
with
that of
agricultural
ands
in
other
countries.
*
J.
R.
SouthworthEl directorioficial e
las
minas haciendas e
Mexico
(
title
lso n
English:
he
Official
irectory
fMines nd
Haciendas)Mexico,
1910.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
11/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 3
The
great
size
of these
holdings
s
due,
in
part,
to
the fact that
the
typical
hacienda
aspires
o
be
self-sustaining,
nd
the
variety
f
a
countryside
s
taxed to
render t
independent.
Hence,
for the
many
different
roducts
required,
different
inds of land must
be in-
cluded within
ts
limits.
n the first
lace,
a
large
acreage
of
valley
land is
needed for the
production
of
grain.
These hundreds
of
thousands of
acres
of
arable land formthe nucleus
of the estate.
An haciendado would
not, however,
e satisfied o hold
valley
ands
alone; for,
n his
economy,
the
products
of the hills are
only
ess
important
han those of the lowlands.
Thus,
the
farm
requires
supply
of
water,
for
rrigation
s
well
as for the live
stock;
the ha-
cienda
must,therefore,
nclude some
stream,
which
should be con-
trolled
up
to
its
headwaters n order to
insure
he
undisputed
use
of
the
supply.
Again, grazing
land
is
needed
for the herds of
cattle,
horses,
heep,
and
goats;
this s
found
upon
the
parklike
mountain
sides
and the
alpine
meadows.
Timber, also,
is
a
prime
necessity
and is
derived
either
from
he deciduous treesthat
grow along
the
lower mountain
slopes
or from he
pine
forests
hat
clothe
the
tops
of the
higherridges.
The
products
ven of the waste and are
like-
wise
essential,
ince from his are obtained stoneand lime for
build-
ing
purposes,
clay
for adobe
huts,
coarse
grass
for thatched
roofs,
salt,
and the
wild
fruits nd
herbs
which are
gathered
orhousehold
use. The administration
f such
extensive
properties
necessarily
presents
reat
difficulties.
The haciendas are
settlements
omplete
n
themselves.
ndeed,
few of theseestateshave less than a hundred,whilemanyofthem
have as
many
as a
thousand,
nhabitants. n Michoacán there are
two
haciendas,
Huaracha
and
Buenavista,
ach
of
which maintains
over two thousand
persons;
while
in
Morelos, Mexico,
Puebla,
Durango,
Veracruz,
Queretaro,
and
Chihuahua
there
re others
n
which the number
s not much smaller.
Furthermore,
he
haciendas
are all
named;
they
appear
on
the
maps,
and
they
are
important
units of
public
administration,
ften
being
incorporated
s
munici-
pios. They
include
all the
customary
ccessories f an
independent
community,uchas a church, store, postoffice, burying round
and sometimes
school
or
a
hospital. Workshops
re
maintained,
not
only
for
the
repair
but even for
the
manufacture f
machinery
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
12/100
4 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
and
of the
numerous
mplements equiredupon
the estate.
Over
this
aggregation
he owner
presides
n a
more
or
less
patriarchal
manner,
the
degree
of
paternal
care
or
of
tyranny arying
with
he
character
of
the
ndividual
and withthat of his
superior
mployees.
In
an earlier
chapter
of
his
book,
Dr. McBride
explains
that the
tillable
oil
is
chiefly
o
be
found n the tableland
section
of
Mexico,
known as the
Mesa
Centrale and
that,
with
relatively nimportant
exceptions,
the
exigencies
of rainfall
and
soil
impose
conditions
which make
haciendas
impossible
lsewhere.
n
more
modern imes
irrigation
as
somewhat
ffected
hese
onditions.
he
Mesa
Centrale
is the most
thickly
populated
section
of Mexico.
It surrounds
he
capital city,
and
we
are told that its climatic conditions
re
ad-
mirable,
ince
altitude counteracts atitude
with such
nicety
that
the mean
temperature
ver the entire
plateau
is
nearly
uniform.
Most of
the haciendas
are to
be
found
in this
section,
and
they
provide
the
agricultural
upplies
not
only
forthemselves
ut for
the
remainder
of the country,whereclimatic conditions
re less favor-
able.
From
the
quotations
already
cited,
something
of
the
inde-
pendent
nature
of
these
huge
land
holdings
will have
been
shown,
and it
will
be
apparent
that
conditions avorable
o the
untroubled
operation
of such
large
units
encouraged
conservatism
n
the
part
of
the owners.The
employment
f native aborers nd the
faultsof
the
peonage
system
ed to
occasional
insurrectionsnd
explain
some
of the
happenings
n
Mexico's
history.
It
is
not
surprising
o
find,
nder uch
conditions,
hat the
owners
ofthehaciendas found tnecessary o have a circulatingmediumof
low
denomination,
nd that this medium should
vary
widely
in
form
and
reflect ome of the
independence
that marks the life of
the
hacienda.
It is this
very diversity
which has
attracted he at-
tentionof
numismatists o these tokens.
There
are,
and
always
have
been,
wide differencesn the
ha-
ciendas
a
condition
nevitable because of their
varying adapta-
bility
o
the
raising
f
agricultural
roducts
f a
wide
range,
as
well
as
to
problems
of labor
and
water
supply.
The
employment
f
Indians and thegrowth f thepeonagesystem layeda considerable
part
in
their
development.
ome
of the
haciendas
found their
and
suitablefor
attle-raising,
nd thoseforwhich this
became
the
prin-
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
13/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 5
cipal objective
are called rancheros
We
shall see that
there
s
much
plausibility
or
he dentificationlaimed for ome of
the
monograms
which
appear
on the
tokens s marksused for
branding
cattle.
An-
other
modification,
ue
to the
employment
f
native
workers,
inds
its
cause
dating
back before the
Spanish
conquest,
when
tribal
holdings
of
property
were vested
n
the chief. Some
of the
Indian
pueblos
resisted
ncroachment,
nd survived
n
the
formof collec-
tive
holdings.
Some
of
the
tokens,
s
we
shall
see,
are
issues
of
such
municipalidades although not all such are to be consideredof
Indian
origin.
In
view of all these
conditions,
nd
of
others
not
considered,
we
shall look in vain for
uniformity
n
the
tokens.
n
fact,
part
of
their
attractiveness
s
their resistance o classification.
here were some
hacienda tokens
n the
famous FonrobertCollection
sold
in Berlin
in
1878,
and that
catalogue
was for a
long
period practically
he
only
source
for numismatists
eeking
nformation
egarding
hem.
Under date of
1932,
a short
article,
Mexikanische Hacienda-
Marken, 1
by
FriedrichFreiherr on Schrötter, ecorded
pecimens
in the Berlin
Museum
with
a
fairly
representative
election l-
lustrated
n
a
single,
xcellent
plate.
The
difficulties
n the
way
of
identifying
hese
pieces
are illus-
trated
by
the author's
describing
s different
his
Nos.
28
and
31)
two
pieces
with the same
monogram
compare
withour illustration
Plate
IX).
Although
not from
the identical
die,
and
differing
n
their flan outlines
(one
is
heart-shaped
nd the other
oval),
the
monogram
s
unquestionably
he
same,
and
the differencen
shape
probably
ndicates ssues
eparated
by
a short ntervaln
output.
Had
the author
been in
possession
f a
largerbody
of
material
on
which
to base
his
conclusions,
he would
probably
have modified ome of
them.
In
1935,
a
privately
rinted
Ensayo
Numismatico
by
Manuel
Romero
de
Terreros,
ntitled os
Tlacos
Coloniales,
appeared
the
first
ndication,
so
far as
we
know,
that the
importance
of these
tokens
had
been
appreciated
by
Mexican scholars.This
is
limited o
pieces believedto have been struckbefore1821. The authorgives
a valuable
summary
f
the
legislation egarding
oinage
in
copper
1
Zeitschriftür
umismatik,
LII
(1935),pp. 128-135, l.
I.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
14/100
6 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
and
a
description
f over two hundred
varieties f
these
tokens,
s
well as
illustrations f
fifty-eight.nfortunately,
ome of
his selec-
tions for
llustration o not lend themselves
o
half-tone
eproduc-
tion.
This
study,
however,
s
the first erious effort o treat
the
hacienda
tokens. The information t
supplies
concerning
hem
is
truly
mpressive
nd of
great
value,
and
certainly
eserves
wider
distribution nd
appreciation
than it has
received.
With
the
kind
permission
f the
author,
many
of the
pieces
have
been included
here.
A
second
publication
by
the same
author
s entitled Las Mone-
das
de Necesidad del Estado de
Michoacán. 2
The concern
here
is
not with
hacienda tokens as
such,
but with the
issues of
a
single
state
of
Mexico,
most of which are octavos and
quartos
put
out
by
municipalities
nd
haciendas between
1825
that
is,
shortly
fter
the close of the
War
of
Independence
and
1871,
just
beforethe
death of
Juarez.
The effort eems to
have
been to
provide
for
the
need
of small
change
which
was
being nsufficientlyuppliedby
the
governmental
trikings.
his
study
gives helpful
nformation e-
garding
the
issuing
authorities,
careful
description
f more than
one hundred
and
fifty
arieties,
nd
four
plates
illustrating
orty
pieces.
In
addition,
there
s
an
illuminating
map
showing
he oca-
tion of
many
of the
places
named.
It is
to
be
hoped
that
a
similar
treatment
f the
ssues
f other tates
will
follow.
The
collectionof hacienda tokens
t the Museum of The
Ameri-
can
Numismatic
Society
owes a
great
deal to the initiative nd
interest f the late Howland Wood, the far-seeing uratorof its
collections rom
1913 to
1938,
who did
much to
stimulate nterest
in this
series. He
transmitted
is
appreciation
of
their
mportance
to his
successor,
nd to others. After
his death
in
1938,
an
op-
portunity
ame to the Museum
to
acquire
the considerable ollection
of hacienda
pieces
formed ver a
long
period
of
yearsby
Mr. H. L.
Hill of
San
Francisco,
under
especially
favorable circumstances.
These
represented,
n
most
cases,
pieces
in
fine
condition,
and
comprised
sizable
proportion
f
dated issues. The
acquisition
was
made possible throughsubscriptions rom Messrs. E. T. Newell,
2
Anales
del Instituto e
Investigaciones
stéticas,
niversidad
acional
Autónoma
e
México, (1940),pp.
17-39, pls.,map.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
15/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 7
F.
C. C.
Boyd,
H. E.
Gillingham,
Elliot Smith
and Moritz
Worm-
ser,
which
supplemented
balance
in the
Avery
Fund.
The acces-
sion
raised
the
Society's
holdings
o a
much
higher
evel;
and
since
that
time a fewfurther
dditionshave
increased
ts
mportance.
he
giftby
Mr.
Alexander Orlowski of tokens
acquired
during
a
visit
to
Mexico was one
outstanding
ddition,
and
a
small
lot
acquired
in the
market dded
severaldesirable
varieties.
he
Society
has
now
a
thoroughly epresentativeollection, lthough
t can never
hopeto secureone thatcan claim
anything
ike
completeness.
A
glance
at the
plates
will show that hacienda
tokenshave
great
variety
s to
form;
that
they
provide
an
impressive
mass of
mate-
rial for
study
of their
historical
bearing
should
also
be
obvious.
Wear,
probably
due to
circulation,
mperfect
triking,
ountermark-
ing
and
other
vicissitudes
educe their ttractiveness
o a
minimum,
but the
strong
ndividuality
which marks
many
of these
pieces
is
ample compensation
ortheir ack of aesthetic
ppeal.
Circulation
of the tokenswas forbidden
n
1917,
and a
provision
that
all
salary
payments
must be made
in
legal
tender
was written
into the Constitution
f
1924.3
We
are told that
these
tokens are
rarely
o
be
found
n Mexico
now,
and there
seems
strong
proba-
bility
that
most of
them
have
been melted down or have
disap-
peared
for other
reasons.
The
many
and
great
changes
n
Mexico
during
the
period
in which
they
circulated
are reflected n these
substitutes or coin.
After
1871,
the
growth
n
commercial
pros-
perity
brought
about
the introduction f
modern business
tokens,
which it is difficulto separate fromthe pieces issuedby the ha-
ciendas. While
their
egends
are more
explicit,
he later ssues
have
none of
the attractiveness
f the
pre-revolutionaryieces.
It
is
to
the
period
between
1821
and 1847
that most
of the
selection of
municipal
issues
on
Plates
XXI and XXII
belong,
a selection
which
upplements
ather
han
repeats
he one
made
by
M.
Romero
de
Terrerosfor
Michoacán.
One circumstance
f
prime
mportance
emphasized
by
Romero de Terreros
will bear
repetition
ere.
The
Spanish
colonial
government
did
not
begin
the
coinage
of
low
denominationsn copper until 1814. There seemsto have been an
aversion o the
use
of
copper
on
the
part
of
the
natives,
nd earlier
3
Zeitschrift
ür
Numismatik
XLII
(
1935),
p.
130.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
16/100
8 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
efforts o
introduce a minor
coinage
in this metal had resulted n
failure.
These issues are
found
sometimes
uring
the
reign
of
Fer-
dinand
VII,
used
a
second time
through
the
application
of
a
counterstamped
monogram
or incised
nitials,
nd
serve
to
date
the
second use
as
later
than
we
might
therwisehave
thought.
The
foregoing
will
enable
the reader to
realize
that
the most
n-
teresting
eriod
for thesehacienda tokens
s the
colonial,
that
s,
up
to
1821.
Any
classification ased on
the names
that
appear
on
the
tokensmeets
complications
because of the
large
number of
pieces
bearing monograms,
ome of
which are
so
involved
hat
unanimity
in
reading
them,
nd
therefore ase
in
their
dentification,
s
out of
the
question.
Furthermore,
he
monogram
f the
same hacienda
will
change
in
form on successive
ssues to an
extent
which
makes
a
conclusion
that
they
represent
he same
holding
an
assumption
rather han a
conviction.
Then, too,
some
family
names are
fairly
common
in
Mexico,
as
elsewhere,
nd
the
given
names
of the
haciendas are likely o
be
repeated (e.g.,
Buena
Vista). Distinguish-
ing
between what
is
municipalidad
and
what
is
hacienda
is all
but
impossible
or one
who
does not have a
thorough
nowledge
f
Mexican
geography
and
history.
ortunately
or our
purposes,
a
number
of the tokens
re
dated or
are
datable,
and
it has been
de-
cided
to
arrange
the
plates
so
thatthe
chronological
onsideration
s
the one
emphasized.
This
permits
grouping
which
essens r seems
to
lessen the
confusion
nd enables a
break-down nto
sub-groups,
and
makes
further
tudy
easier.
It
must be
made
clear
through
repetitionhatthis isting s notcompleteor comprehensive.t will
have to
be
modified
s
further vidence
is
brought
forwardand
closer
dating
becomes
possible.
For
that
reason,
he
steps
eading
to
the
conclusions
expressed
are
frankly
aid before
the
reader,
and
any rigidity
f
statement
r
of contention
s
avoided
where doubt
exists.
Bringing
rder
out of
the
complexities
f this seriescan be
effected
nly by
the
further
ooperation
f
nterested ollectors.
Because
of
the variations
n the
practices
f the haciendados
and
other
ssuersof
these
tokens,
t
is
almost
mpossible
o be consistent
in makingan arrangementfthem. Since some ofthe tokens how
an earlier
design
which
has not
been
entirely
bliterated,
ndicating
a second
using
of
the
piece,
and
because
countermarking
ccurs,
o
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
17/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 9
that a
name
may
be
superimposed
n a
monogram
or
a
monogram
over the
name,
the wide variance
n
the
unregulated
rocedure
must
be
taken into
consideration
n
using
the
plates.
These
have
been
arranged
to
show what
homogeneity
here
s
so
far as
the dates are
concerned,
o
far as the
shapes
are
concerned,
nd so
far as
the
monograms
re concerned.
There are also
plates
showing
he tokens
put
forth fter
1821
by
the
municipalidades
nd
pueblos
as
well as
ones
bearing
he
word
puente bridge)
When
a
given
piece permits
he
reading
of
a
name,
ts ocation
n
the
alphabetical
list
and thence the reference o
its
place
on
the
plates
of
this
monograph
s
simple.
The
pieces
bearing
monograms
only
are less
susceptible
o
arrangement
nd
consequently
re not
included in the
alphabetical
ist.
With a few
exceptions,
he earlier
ones have
been
segregated
n Plates II to
IV. Some
which
seem
to be later ssues will
be found on
Plate
XIX.
Many
of them
will
be
easily
decipherable
to our Mexican confrères ven
though they
maybe puzzling ous. In some casesconjectural dentificationsave
been
given
which
may
require
ater
correction.
his
may
also be true
of
statements
egarding
ocations
of the
ssuing gencies.
It is
comparatively
asy
to
identify
nd
separate
the
store cards
and
business okensmade
after1870 on the basis of
workmanship
r
material. Hard
rubber, elluloid,
wood and thin brass with
a
con-
sistent
tyle
of
lettering
re
used
for
pieces
which are
usually
dis-
tinguishable
rom
pre-revolutionary
ssues
by
anyone
who has
even
a
nodding
acquaintance
with hacienda tokens.The
great
number
of thesepiecesis sufficienteasonforour not including hemhere,
even
though
here
re
some
which
bear the
name
hacienda. Some
of the
wooden
pieces
may
be
older than
we consider
them
here.
The
likelihood
of their
having
been
preserved
s
even
slighter
han
that of theirmetal
counterparts,
ut
those that are
dated indicate
the
general period
of theircirculation s between
1870-1880.
Because
of
the
many
uncertaintieswhich invest the
earlier
ha-
cienda
tokens,
t
has
been
deemed desirable to
begin
our
com-
mentary
n the
pieces
with
those of
comparatively
ate dates
(il-
lustrated n Plate XX) and itmightbe well tostatewhythis s so.
In
1814,
Calleja,
the
Spanish
Viceroy,
ordered
he
coining
of
two,
one
and
one-half
uartos
of
copper
(i.e.,
one-half, ne-quarter
nd
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
18/100
10 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
one-eighth eales),
and in the
following
ecember
their
cceptance
was
assured
by
the
passage
of a law
regulating
heir irculation
nd
limiting
he
amount
acceptable
as
legal
tender.
Quartillos
of
silver
had
been
struckfrom
1794 to
1816;
these for some
reason
seem
not
to
have met the needs
supplied
by
the
copper
pieces.
With
the
outbreakof the
War of
Independence,
we find hat
the
difficulty
f
moving
bullion from he mines
to the
mint
of Mexico
City
became
too
great
a
risk,
nd
branchmintswereestablished
n six ocalities
Chihuahua,
Durango,
Guadalajara,
Guanajunto,
Sombrerete nd
Zacatecas.
Provisional
oinages
were
also struck
t Nueva
Viscaya,
Oaxaca,
Real
del
Catorce and Valladolid. For
the
insurgent
orces,
almost the entire
coinage
of Morelos
in
Oaxaca
was in
copper,
although
t
involved a
promise
of
Morelos
of
redemption
n
gold
and
silver
upon
the
resumption
f
the mines.
Although
there
are
octavos
dating
within he
period
of the
War
of
Independence,
hey
appear
to
have
been destined o meet ocal
needs,
and
their
carcity
seems
a
dependable
indicationthat their
quantity
was small.
The
inability
f Morelos to
redeemhis
promises
may
have contributedo
the
disfavor n which
copper
seems
o
have been
held.
It is not
easy
to
gauge
the extent o which the
coinage
of
hacienda
tokens
was
affected
y
the
changed
condition.
Certainly
here
are
few
pieces
dated
between 1814 and
1821,
whereas the
municipal
issues eem to have
been
widely
truck.
As an
outcome
of the War
of
Independence,
municipal
tokens
developed
a considerable
degree
of
uniformity. any
bear
numer-
als indicatingtheirvalue as one-eighth eal,
and
occasionally
we
find
he
word tlaco
appearing
on
them.
Their
workmanship
r
die-
cutting
will
not
serve
as a
dependable
dating
criterion,
or ome
of
the
earlierones are
much
better han
those
dating years
ater. t
is
instructive
o
study
groups
such as
that for
Colima,
called
a
Villa
on one
issue
(Plate
XX)
or that
of
Ameca,
a
pueblo
(Plate
XX).
For each of
these
groups,
he
progression
f
dates
and
the attendant
changes give
a
clear
indicationof
the troubled
tate of
the
country,
even after
peace
had returned.
t is
because
of
this
that Romero
de
Terreroshas justly alled certainpieces truckn the tateof Michoa-
cán coins
of
necessity,
lthough
he
is
careful
o
explain
that
this
does not
imply
anything
n the nature
of a
siege
piece
such
as
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
19/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 11
frequently
as the
case
with
this classification
n
Europe.
The
first
iece
of the
group
bearing
the
name of Colima
(Plate
XX,
No.
106)
is
dated
1813,
is
uniface,
and otherwise
iffers
ut
slightly
rom he hacienda
tokens
which
preceded
t.
It was
during
this
year
that
Morelos was
active;
on December
22,
he
suffered
seriousreverse
t Valladolid. Haste
may
therefore
xplain
the
form
of the
square
piece
dated 1814
(Plate
XX,
No.
107). By
1816,
there
was a
return o the earlier
form, xcept
that
it is no
longer
uniface,
but bears on the reverse
monogram
to be read as Co-
lima,
and
this form eems to have
persisted
ntil
1824,
for
which
year
we
have
three
differing
ssues.
The
other
series illustratedon
Plate XX consists
of
uniface
coins
of
Ameca,
a
pueblo
that
is,
an
Indian controlled
holding,
situated n the district f
Jalisco,
with a
population
given
as
1500.
Here,
there
is a
sharp
contrast
between
the
workmanship
f
the
earliest
piece,
dated
1814,
(No.
25)
and those
which follow.
The
inscriptions noteworthy P.D. AMECA QUITILLA
D 1814.
In
the
field,
here
s
a
façade
of a
building
urmounted
y
a cross
and
flanked
by
two conventionalized
rees
?),
with 3 on
the left nd
8
on
the
right.
The
piece
is uniface.
The coin dated 1833
(No.
31)
has
coarse
lettering,
while one dated
1853
(No. 30)
is
even
cruder
nd
the
inscription
eads
from he
rim.
There are two
issues
dated 1855
with
ettering
hat
s
stillcrude.
An undated
ssue
(No.
26),
whose
workmanship
would
seem
to
place
it
as
later,
bears the
designation
TLACO
DE AMECA.
The historicalvalue of some of these tokens is illustratedby
No.
197
(Plate
XXII),
a coin of
Hermosillo n
the Province
of
Sonora at the
north.4
A
concession
to
coin silver
quartillos
n this
town
was
obtained
n
1828.
The earliest
dated
specimens
of
this silver
coinage
are
from
1832,
and
pieces
are
known for
the
following
ix
years.
The
L.
S.
on the obverse
s read
as
an abbreviation
for
Leonardo San-
toyo,
the
concessionaire,
who
was
connected
with the
mining
interests f the
district. t
is
noteworthy
hat
the
coinage
in
copper
did not startuntil 1851. It is not improbablethat equally impor-
4
Cf.A.
F. Pradeau.
he MexicanMints
f
Alamos
nd
Hermosillo,
.Y.,
1934
(Num.
Notes
Monographs
o.
63).
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
20/100
12 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
tant
historical
data
may
be
recorded
by
othersof
these
tlacos,
but
without
detailed
knowledge
of their local
significance,
we
must
await
their
onsideration
y
Mexican
numismatists.
Two of the
Ameca
pieces
(Plate
XX,
Nos.
30 and
31)
bear
initials
which
are read as for
personal
names.
The
implication
s
that these
re in the
nature
of
store
ards.
Breaking
up
the
tokens
which come
before
1821
into
smaller
groups
would be
extremely
ifficult
without the
help
which
we
get
from he dated
pieces,
although
groupings
ccording
to charac-
teristics f flan
or of execution of their
lettering
become
fairly
obvious
and,
within
imits,
reasonably
dependable
once
we have
the
dated
pieces
for
a
key.
In the
arrangement
f the
plates
we
have tried
to
bring
this
out.
It
would
greatly
implify
ur
study
f
we could
say
that the
pieces
having
naturalistic r
irregular hapes,
such as
leaves,
flowers,
hearts,
and other
simple
but
distinctive
forms,
many
of which are
undated,
are
preceded
by
those
bear-
ing monograms only,
and
that,
in
general,
the
monogramspre-
cede those
bearing
the names
in
full,
but
there are
too
many
ex-
ceptions
to make such a
generalization.
Fortunately,
we have a
few dated
pieces
which tend to confirm
his,
but there
seems to
have been too much
overlapping
to
make
any
such classification
certain.
Many
of
these
exceptions
are
probably
due to
scanty
mechanical facilities or
making
the tokens
n the
widely
eparated
centers
n which
they
originated.
For
example,
in
the
period
be-
tween
1800
and
1806,
there s
a certain
homogeneity
n
the
pieces
whichare shown on Plate X and, although
we
are without lear
indication of their
ocale,
these haciendas
probably
will be found
to have lain
within an area which was served
by
a
single
die-
cutter. Such
a one
may
have received
his
training
from some
jeweller,
or even
through
n
apprenticeship
n the
mint of
Mexico
City.
A second
group
within his
period
(Plate XII)
is of a
much
clumsier fabric and heavier
workmanship,
nd
here we have
an
indication
that two of the
pieces
came
from
Celaya (No.
470)
and
Queretaro
(No.
362),
respectively,
wo cities not
widely
sep-
arated. It would not be surprisingo find that the twohaciendas
whose
tokens
follow
(Nos.
72
and
297)
were located
in the same
neighborhood.
t will be seen
that
trying
o date
pieces
on the
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
21/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 13
basis of
workmanship
s
far from
certain
except
within broad
limits.
Inasmuch as the
tokens of a
typical
hacienda
must
have
been in
use
over a
considerable
number
of
years,
we
can
expect
definitenesss
to time
of
issue from
the
dated
pieces
only.
With this
in
mind,
let us
look
at
the
plates
in some
detail,
be-
ginning
with the
one
(Plate
I)
which bears
the earliest
dated
pieces
which we have been able to
find.
Before
tarting,
owever,
one
peculiarity
f
dating
should be noted. One
piece
illustrated
n
this
plate
(No. 381)
is
doubly
unusual.
First,
both obverse and
reverse ear
inscriptions,
lthough
the
reverse oes
not enable
us to
localize the
token's
place
of
origin.
The obverse
reads,
n addition
to the name
of
the
issuing
owner,
ANO
84.
Comparison
with
other
pieces
will
remove
any
necessity
f
laboring
the
point
that
this
must be
1784 and that
it cannot be 1884. We
are enabled
likewise
to read the date which
appears
on
the
first oken on
Plate
III
(A)
as
1750.
A
contrast
o this
contraction
f the
date
is
to
be
found on
Plate I
(B)
where the date
is
given
n Roman
numerals mdcclxxui. The
monogram
t the centerhas not been
identified.The
irregularity
n
the
shape
of the flan
supports
he
traditional
ssignment
f
the
shaped pieces
as
early.
Turning
to
the first
iece
on
Plate III
(A),
dated
1750,
we
find
ourselves
n
possession
of another
very
valuable
piece
of
in-
formation
or on the reverse f this
piece
we
read
8 R. We also
note
that there
re
two smaller
pieces
bearing
this ame
monogram
(one
without
date),
and
that instead of
that
date,
they
bear on
their
obverses
4
(B)
and
2
(C), respectively,
nd
that,
in
addition,
they
are
graduated
in
size,
making
a series.
These
numerals
cannot
be
fractions
f
the real as were
the
municipal
tokens
previously
mentioned
(page
10),
for
the
8 R
piece
is
much
larger
than that of
2
R.
If the intentionwere to
indi-
cate a
fractional
one-eighth
of a
real,
the most valuable
piece
would
have been the half-real
which should
have been the
larger.
Not
only
do we
have
a
parallel
to
Nos.
391-395
described
by
Romero
de
Terreros
Cf.
Note
to
No.
391),
but we have a date
whichgoes far towardestablishingheperiod n whichthepractice
common to the
two
series was in use. In
other
words,
we
have a
clear
indicationthat
these
tokenshad a valuation
n
reals,
and
this
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
22/100
14 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
permits
the
identification f
similar numerals
on
other
pieces,
many
of
which are
also
identical
n fabric.
The PERES
piece
(No.
376)
to
which we have
had occasion to
referbecause of
its date
802,
has
a
4
above
the
name,
and
gives
us indication
that
this
valuation in
reals continued
to that
date.
We
may
even
go
further,
or the
piece
shown
(Plate
XII,
A)
is
one
which
has a
format
closely
similar
to
the
group
on Plate X
and has
the
figure
8
counterstamped
within he
large
O
above the
mono-
gram.
This confirms he evidence of the PERES
token,
forthis
piece,
too,
should
be dated between 1800
and
1806,
or
not much
before
or
after
hose
years.
Similarly,
he
inscription
n the
token
LARA
on Plate III
(No.
218)
becomes
significant,
or
we can
point
to
analogies
which
enable us to read
the
letter
after
the
figure
4
as a lower-case
r rather
han
x which t more
nearly
resembles.
his, then,
ndicates four
reals,
and
we
have
the
proba-
bility
that there
were
larger
and
smaller
denominations
or
this
hacienda.
Likewise,
the oval token
with a trefoil
with
a
2
be-
neath
it
(Plate
III,
E)
falls nto
this
group.
Of
the other
tokens,
one
with
2
Rs
(D)
bears no other
ndicationof
its
origin,
while
the
last,
with a cursive
r
(G)
within
chain border
has an
8
on
its
reverse,
lthough
smaller than
any
of
the
2
R tokens
on this
plate.
The date
following
he earliest ne
we have
found
s
1767
(Plate
I,
A).
This is
engraved
or
incised on
the
reverse,
while the
obverse
bears four letters
whose
significance
we are
unable to
recognize.
Can the four pelletson the obversebe an indicationthat it
was
valued at four
reals?
In addition to
the
date,
the reverse
ears the
name or
syllable
Sol
as
well as
the
letter
N
preceding
the
date.
The tilde
over
the N dictates
ts
reading
as an abbreviation
for
Anno,
or Año.
The
Sol
is
to
be
taken as an abbrevia-
tion for a
name
such as
Solis
(Plate
IV,
431)
or some
other
name
whose
first
yllable
is identical.
Although
this is
not the
best
representative
f
the
cast tokens
(others
are
illustrated n
Plate
II),
there
s
a
considerable
number
of tokens
which show
the same large and crude letters nd which afford ther evidence
of their
having
been cast.
Almost
without
exception,
they
are
uniface.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
23/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 15
The
next coin
dii Plate
I,
(No. 133)
bears the date 1770.
Compared
with
the token
we have
just
been
considering,
ts
workmanship
s refined
nd
finished.
t, too,
is
representative
f
a
fairly arge
class;
it is
surprising
o find
workmanship
f this
order at such an
early
date,
as
well
as
the
use of
punch
dies. Pieces
of
this class
frequently
ave
small units of
a decorative nature
which are
repeated
to form a
pattern
or
border,
and
examina-
tion discloses that
some of their
inscriptions
re made
by usingindividual letter
punches
(some
of the
repeated
letters
display
identical flaws or other
peculiarities
which are
unmistakable).
No evidence has
been
observed of
a
graduated
series
or
of two or
more denominations
n this class. The reverse
nscription
n
Plate
I,
381
{Para
la
Plaza)
is
probably
ndicative hat it circulated
n
the market
place
of some
city
or
town,
as the
catalogue
notes.
Filling
out
Plate I
are
contrasting
okens
dated
1791,
the first
with
a
monogram (C),
the second
with CATALANES
and what
looks ike a cask
(No. 90)
-
both
struck romdies. The
piece
with
VAQUEDANO (No.
467)
bears a
target-like
enterand
the
date
1796.
The last
(D)
dated
1799,
has a
monogram
n an
octagonal
impression.
All
three
are die-struck.
With
possible exceptions
n the
top
row,
Plate II consists f
tokenswhich have
been
cast,
bearing monograms
or
single
etters
as the sole indication of
their
origin.
The resistance o wear
on
the
monogram
is
a
consequence
of the boldness of the
lettering.
f
the first ive
pieces
do not
belong
to the same
hacienda,
their
close
similarity emonstrates he difficultyf distinguishinghem.
It would be rash to venture
dating
forthese cast
pieces.
Their
boldness or occasional
cruditymay
be
nothing
more than a result
of
having
been made
in rural
districts emoved from
the
conven-
ience
of cities.
Casting
thesetokens
would
be
a
simple process,
nce
the
technique
had been
mastered,
whereasthe
preparation
f a
die
such as
is
obvious
on most
of the
pieces
on Plates
III
and
IV
is
far more
complicated
an
operation.
One
would
think
that
the
tokensfor which
dies were used
(Plates
III
and
IV)
were later
than these cast pieces on Plate II. If thisbe so, some of the cast
tokens
may
be earlier than
1750,
the
date for the first
iece
on
Plate
III.
Nor
may
we
lose
sight
of
the tokens
n Plate
V
which
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
24/100
16 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
bear neither
name
nor
monogram merely
the
type.
Some
of
these
may
have
used the
punning
principle
common
to
other
coinages,
so
that No. C
may
have
indicated the same
hacienda
as
did
No.
227
(Plate XVI).
There
seems to be no convention
r
rule
which
may
be
applied
to
the
reading
of
the
monograms,
ut
this
is
a condition that
might
have been
expected
in marks
for
branding
cattle,
which is what some of these are
believed
to have
been.
Similar combinations r variations
n the letters
ccur
on
the
much later
branding
ronsofthewestern anchesofour
country.
Plate
V
is
given
to tokens
bearingtypes
but without
he owners'
names
they
re
indicatedon the
plate
by
letters.No.
A
clearly
de-
picts
a
hunter
holding
a
jack-rabbit.
t seems that the
intention
f
obliterating
he
monogram
on
the
reversewas
unsuccessful.
n
the
reverse f No.
F
there
s a
counterstamp
which seems
to
consist f
the letters P and
Q
with
a tilde
over
them.
The
object
on
No.
E is a formalized
branding-iron.Why
the
mere
date
1802
should
have been
used
for No.
H is
something
or which we should
ike to
have an
explanation.
Romero
de
Terreros lso illustrates o.
D.
He
describes
he
design
as
two Indians
dancing.
There are two
figures
facing
medial
axis,
a
plant
with two
long
branches
continuing
n
an
arch over each
of the
figures
nd
extending
nearly
to
the base
line.
The die
outline
s
notchedwhile
the flan
s
irregularly
ctag-
onal. The
tiny
piece
(No.
G)
with
an
eagle
on
the
nopal plant
may
not be a hacienda
token.
On
Plate
VI seven
tokens re
grouped
which bear
some
form
of the wordpuente,which means a bridge.We cannottell whether
these were
used
for
tolls or
whether
hey
were ssued
by
haciendas
situated
near
bridges
from
which
they
took
their
names.
Some
bear
rude
representations
f
bridges.
n
the
catalogue,
these have been
placed
under the letter
P. This
procedure
s
followed
also
for
the
tokens
put
out
under the
designation
f
Esquina
-
or
Esquila.
On Plates
VII to
IX,
tokens
with
variously
haped
flans are
grouped;
most of these are other than circular.The
group,
which
is
arranged
lphabetically
or
convenience,
s
representative,
ut
not
exhaustive.Heart-shapedtokensseem the most favored (one on
Plate V
may
be
added to the
seven
here).
Leaves and
fruits
re
distinguishable,
ven
a ram
or
goat (
Chiuato .
The
flans
of most
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
25/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 17
of
these,
whether
riginally
ast
or
punched
out
of sheetsof
metal,
have in
a second
operation
had
a die
applied
to them.The
lettering
is
usually
bold
rather han
crude,
and
some
ingenuity
s shown n
its
spacing.
A
dated
piece
is
helpful
occasionally,
uch as the cres-
cent-formed
dken
No.
300
(Plate
VIII)
which reads
1804,
while
on
Plate
I
we
have noted the
date
1773
in Roman
numerals.Two
pieces
at the
bottom
of
Plate
VII have
incised
etters
Nos.
117
and
120).
Some
of
the dies
have
scalloped edges,
while
the flans
t
the
top
of Plate VII have
pie-crust
ims
which
must have been
acquired
by
casting.
One
exception
o the
statement
hat
these
odd-
shaped
tokens
re
usually
uniface s
to be found n
No. 413
(Plate
IX),
where
the
design
admirably
its ts
oval and both
obverseand
reversedies
are
well
executed. The
reverse f
No.
53
(Plate VII)
bears an
incised
letterT.
No. 63
(Plate
VII) may
be a
bridge
token,
or
perhaps
the
structure s
intended
to
represent
church.
The
given
name of
an
individual
occasionally
accompanies
the
more
usual
familyname, and thiswill be found trueon succeeding
plates.
Odd
shapes
were
selected for
these
tokensbecause
of their
distinctiveness
they
ccomplished
heir
urpose.
The
tokens
n
Plate X
to XII
form
fairly
omogeneous
roup.
With one
or
two
exceptions,
hey
re
similar
n
size,
tyle
nd
fabric,
although
as to
fabric there
s
a
light
and
heavy
form. The
dated
pieces range
between
1801 and
1806.
Many
are
uniface. The thin-
flanned
ones
are
marked
by
a
daintiness
of
lettering
nd
design,
while
the
heavier
pieces
have
a
boldness
quite
in
keeping
with
their
greaterthickness.On the thinner-flannedokens,branches with
flowers
r berries
ie with
animal
figures Plate
XI,
198
and
275
.
On
the
Olbera
issue
(Plate
X,
286)
we
note a
pennon
or
spear
used
with
a
cannon.
On
the
Molina
piece
(Plate
X,
264)
there
is
a
monogram
s well
as this
name
and the
date
1801.
On
Plates XI
and
XII
we
find
a
contrast.The
Aguilar
token
(Plate
XI,
10)
is
broad,
thick
and
heavy,
and
the
lettering
s
bold.
This
piece
and
several
others
have
inscriptions
n
both
sides.
The
given
name
is on
the
obverse
and
the
family
name
on
the
reverse n more than one instance,withthe name of the place of
issue
added
on
two
coins,
Queretaro
(No.
362)
and
Celaya
(No.
470).
The
Butron
oken
No.
71
on
Plate
XI
seems
to
have
had
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
26/100
18 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
this
name
applied
to some other
token of
the fabric
we have
been
considering.
Unfortunately,
he
earlier
design
s not
distinguishable.
Monogrammed
pieces
of both
forms re
placed
at
the bottom of
Plate XII.
Note that the Munos
(No.
275)
and
Munoz
(No.
277)
pieces
on
Plate XI seem to
have
nothing
n common.
Plates XIII
and
XIV
may
be
considered
ogether. hey
offer
further
ontrasts o
Plates X to XII.
Most have smaller
flans
which bear
dates with a
slightly
more extended
range,
1800-1814.
With the
exception
of Nos. 103 and
A,
they
are
uniformly
ie-
struck nd
many
have bordersof
repeated
units,
ome
of which
are
very
effective s
well as
ingenious.
The
majority
re
uniface;
some
are
counterstamped
with
dates or
numerals,
he
latter a
possible
indication of
value. The
Cocula
token
(No. 103)
is
dated 1808
and bears
two
counterstamps,
ne of which s
a crown.The second
is
applied symmetrically
nd
adds
the
name
Vandino which can
hardly
e a
Spanish
name.
The three
plates (XV-XVII)
devoted
to
the
tokensbearing
names
in full
(or
nearly
so),
like
those
devoted to the
irregular-
shaped pieces,
offer
some
significant
henomena. They
are ar-
ranged
alphabetically,
espite
he
necessary
eviations n
the nterest
of
plate symmetry.
t
will
be noted
that there
re
a few
pieces
not
circular n
shape.
Attention
might
be
called
to
similaritiesn
treat-
ment,
s,
for
xample
a. C
AREDES,
CVRIL
and
LOZO
(Plate
XV,
79,
129
and
241)
share with
DE
PRIETO
(Plate
XVI,
344),
a
technique
which seemsto indicatethat either hetoken orthedie withwhich
it
was struck
ad been
cast.
b. Pieces
on whichdies
show
similar
workmanship
1.
Square-
V. DE
S.
FRANCISCO
and
TLACOMULCO
(Plate
XVII,
483
and
451)
.
2.
Dies
showing
linear
frame
AGUILERA
and
SANCHES
(
Plate
XV,
11
and Plate
XVII,
408 .
3.
Dies with
ornate frame
ALDANA,
GUERRA,
OCANPO,
PANZACOLA
(Plate
XV,
21,
191
and
Plate
XVI,
283,
302)
4. Dies havinga notched or toothed dge QUEMADA, RIO,
VAREDO,
ZARATO
(Plate
XVI,
361
and
Plate
XVII,
380, 54,
491).
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
27/100
Hacienda Tokens of Mexico 19
5.
Pieces
with
uatrefoil
ie-outlines,
ENA
and
ROME
(Plate
XVI,
256
and Plate
XVII,
388)
6.
Pieces
having
border r
frame
f
pellets
r
periods
ADAME,
LUNA
(Plate
XV,
6 and
243)
It
would
be
too much to claim that these
similarities
ndicate
a
relation n
time
or
place,
but there s
at least
the
possibility.
c.
Single
tokens
often
raise
questions
for which answer is not
always
obtainable.
1. On the
piece
inscribedOXORO
(Plate
XVI,
298),
is the
X
to be
read
as
a
lower-case r as
it
certainly
s
on
Plate
XVII,
458,
which
Romero de
Terreros
eads
as
Torrescano ?
2.
The
AGUILERA
(Plate
XV,
11)
and ADAME
(Plate
XV,
6)
tokens oth
bear
a
counterstamped
onogram
whichcom-
bines
he
etters
A
and P
-
does
this
onnote
combination
of
two
haciendas with
the final
ownership
ndicated
by
the
monogram?
Compare,
lso,
Plate
III,
A
to
E)
.
3.
Are
the
added
scrolls
n
the
LEDO
piece
(Plate XV,
226)
purelydecorative?
4.
The
MAGIAS
piece
(Plate XVI,
246)
bears
a
triangle
with
an
incised
monogram ?)
or
brandmark.
Why
was it
ncised n-
stead
of
having
been
made
a
part
of
the
original
design?
5.
The
MED
piece (Plate
XVI,
254)
has a
counterstamped
ate
of
1820.
Is
this
an
abbreviation or
half
or for
a
proper
name?
Why
was
not
the date
made a
part
of
the
name-die?
Was
it
possibly
later
ddition?
On
No. 451
(Plate
XVII),
there is
a
very
nteresting
rans-
literation.
On
the token
we read
CAVEZERA. Dr.
A. F.
Pradeau
kindly
nforms
y
letter hat this s a substitute
or
cabecera,
a word
meaning
county
seat ;
and
that
TLAJOMULCO
(Cf.
Plate
XVII,
45
1
,
with
about
four
thousand
nhabitants,
s
a
station n
the
State of
Jalisco
on
the
railroad
between
Mexico and
Guadala-
jara.
Plate
XVIII
is
intended
to
demonstrate
imilarity
f
names
or
monograms.
eñor
Romero
de
Terreros
llustrates
nd
identifies
a
piece
with
a
large
and
crude
G
and
a small
a
as
GARCIA.
Here (Nos. 177 and 178) we have two roughlycircularpieces
with
a
toothed-die
mpress
nd
the
inscription
AR/SIA. Between
them
is
a
diamond-shaped
token
(No.
179),
with
smaller
and
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
28/100
20 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
better formed etters
reading
GARSIA/TAGLE.
In the bottom
row of this
plate
we
have
(No. 232)
a
piece
reading
R. DEL.
CHICO.
ANO.
D.
1808,
and
within
the circle at
the
center,
he
name
LOPEZ
with
ornaments bove
and
below.
The token
(No.
G)
shows
a
monogram
which
can
hardly
be read
other than
as
LOPEZ,
and
the
preceding piece
(No. F)
with its
neighbor
to
guide
one,
should be
probably
read
similarly.
On
the same
line,
we
have an
octagonal
token with
the name
ERA/RA.
Counter-
stamped
beneath,
in smaller
etters,
s the name LOPEZ. As this
is
unquestionably
common name in
Mexico,
there
may
or
may
not
have been a
connection etween
hesefour
pieces.
The
monogrammed
okens on
the second line on this
plate
will
bear
study
because of their
imilarities.
o.
324
which has
a
heart-
shaped
die-imprint
s
apparently
unrelated to
any
of the
heart-
shaped
tokens
n
Plate IX.
Plates XXI
and XXII
provide
an
amplification
f
what
ap-
pears
on Plate
XX
(cf. pp.
10
to
12).
Most
of theseare octavos;
Nos. 136
(Plate
XXII)
and
412
(Plate
XXI)
are
quartillos.
Many
are without
ndication
of value.
No. 364
(Plate XXI)
is
counterstamped.
ome are
without
dates;
those
bearing
dates
vary
from
1813
(Plate
XXI,
14
and
489)
to 1853
(Plate
XXII,
452).
The
workmanship
on both
coins
and dies
varies
widely
well-
preserved
pecimens
re
uncommon.
Several other
designs
re
am-
bitious
beyond
the
power
of the
die-cutter,
or
example,
No. 309.
Apparently,
hese
are all issues
of
Municipalities
with
littleor no
directconnection with the Hacienda token. They are illustrated,
herein,
o make this
distinction lear.
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
29/100
CATALOGUE
1.
Abar te
uy.
ABA
ļ
RATE
ļ
GVY within raised
notched
order.
Uniface.
Cast.
21
mm.MRdeT.*
Plate
VII.
2.
Abascal. ABAS
ļ
CAL;
a
rosette
etween
ellets
bove and
below.
Ornamental
order.
Uniface.
Octagonal
planchet.
4
mm.
3.
Abila. ABI
|
LA*
in a
circle
of dashes.
Triangular
die.
Uniface.
30 mm.
MRdeT.
4. Acirre.A [ CIRRE, withornament elow; thewhole n border
of
repeated
rnaments. ie
20
mm.;
flan
26
mm.
Uniface.
Plate
XIII.
5.
Adad.
A
|
DAD within
raised and notchedborder
on
octagon
with
urved
ides.Uniface.
Plate VII.
6.
Adame.
ADAME
between ines of
dots above and
below,
in
rectangular epression.
n
round
die-imprint
elow,
AP in mono-
gram.
Uniface.
3
mm.Plate
XV.
Admitido.
ee
No.
253.
7.
Africano.
AFRI
ļ
CANO,
a
sheathed sword
dividing
the two
lines,
n
arrow
pointing
o
right
bove,
and another
n
opposite
direction
elow;
the
wholewithin
crudecircle.Uniface. 8mm.8.
Agebedo.
AGE
|
BEDO in
square
depression.
n
shape
of a
four-leaved
osette. niface.
Plate
VII.
9.
Agire.
AGI
ļ
RE in
crude
cript.
niface.
Cast.
22
mm.
10.
Aguilar.
LORENZO
within circle
of
large
beads.
Rev. AGUI
LAR
with imilar
order.
MRdeT.
32
mm.Plate XI.
11.
Aguilera.
AGUI
ļ
LERA
within
inear
frame n
square depres-
sion;
a
monogram,
P,
in
separate
round
mpression
elow.
Uni-
face.
21
mm.
Plate
XV.
12.
Aguirre.
A
|
GUIRRE,
rude
flowers
elow,
within circle
of
dots and
dashes.
Uniface.
26
mm.
Two varieties
llustrated;
wo
other
variants n
A.N.S. Plate
X.
(Two specimens.)Aho.See No. 13.
13.
Ahualulco.
AHO in
crude
script,
/s
real)
below.
Milled
border.
Uniface. 18
mm.
14.
Ahualulco.On
raiseddisc
at
center,
/s.
egend:
AHUALULCO.
1813.
Uniface.
21
mm.
Plate
XXI.
15.
Alarcon.
ALARCON
only.
Uniface.
23
mm.
MRdeT.
16.
Alba.
AL.BA,
an
arrow
point
below;
raised
ndented
order.
Uni-
face.
25
mm.
Very
rude
ast.
MRdeT.*
*
The
abbreviation
RdeT
used
herein
efers
o
the
monograph
os
Tlacos
Coloniales
y
Manuel
Romero
e
Terreros
ublished
n
Mexico
n
1935
cf.
p.
5.
Tokens
llustrated
n
thiswork
re
asterisked.
second
ublication
y
thesame uthor as Monedas e Necesidad elEstadodeMichoacáns re-ferredo asMRdeT. Michoacán).
21
This content downloaded from 83.85.149.119 on Fri, 26 Feb 2016 11:08:02 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-
8/20/2019 Hacienda tokens of Mexico / by O.P. Eklund and Sydney P. Noe
30/100
22 Hacienda Tokens of Mexico
17.
Albares.
ALBA
ļ
RES in crude
script
within
borderof
large
pellets,
heR like
n X. Uniface.Cast.
22
mm.
18.
Alb res.Similar o astbut the
S
retrograde.
19.
Alb res
(Alvares).
ALBA
|
RES within aised
notchedborder.
Uniface.
Flan
cast,
he
name added with die.
23
mm. MRdeT.
Plate VII.
20.
Albares.
ALBA
ļ
R.S 806 above
a
star
nd coiled
ariat,
hewhole
in
a
wreath. oothedborder.
4
mm.
Plate XIII.
AlcantArilla.
See No. 38.
21. Aldana.
ALDA
|
NA
withfour osettes
n
ornate
rame.
Uniface.
Rectangular. 8x 24mm.MRdeT. Plate XV.
22.
Aliala
(Ayala).
ALLA
ļ
L