GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public...

121

Transcript of GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public...

Page 1: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR co Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

It is hereby informed that as per Ministry of Environment and Forests Government of India New Delhi vide its Notification No 501533 dated September 14 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Gandhinagar District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b)

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 06062015 at 1100 hrs Open Ground opp Gram Panchayat Office Village Nadri Ta Kalol Dist Gandhinagar is as under

(iHct ltil~lNl qi ltgtt-1 F[qlltl gtigtllcH icil [Sttl1il 6l~Nltlhti~ gtitltiltgttl 91JJ ctl 9 6~ lOO_

ltgtlA ctil 1l91il ~~lllhti~ ~ltiltgttlJOs0(8) ctl09 HWO~ il ltgttjlti~l-1 12)lll- ~ tt ltgttlqll

C1qli1C-1 gti il0lt2l ~-s -1lIC-1 )llti ~hn~li R-1gt-fi2s rlll 16llct ll6-1 il ltgttillttSt6l )lt~1i)ll ltgtt-1

ltgtttt-lqlS 61C--1l tt ltgttlcc-1 ~i8~C-11fl ~ cc-11~ ltflltgtllltgttt~iltgtli - 10909 ltilltgttlltgtll~i~i

- 10905 ltil ltgttlltgttl~i~i -WO~ il H [)l ltgtt18C-1il ~qlltgttlil ~C-11)l ltill~lt tl2fi

1ll-ll6il(lltt6-~2) 12)lltl ltgt1 ltgtlct)lct )lt~li)llt o6lC--1L tl2 C-1tr ~ilqlt(l ltlmiddotNltt ltgttlk-1

~Iltct lltl6r2 tl2 C-11r ~ilqlt(l j ltgttl-ll6i ctL 05 0s W 1 il 1106 ql~ 9 9 00 sC-1L1 1C--1l islitl

lt ill-lct s~lt1 li )llt ilSltl ctl rlC-11C-1 61 )lt~li)ll llct ltllqltt ltgttlQC-1 0

Sr No

isli Name and Designation

-tll lt1lt ttt OrganizationNillage

~~l lt1lt ~lll Sign

~41

q lshy

Mmiddot K - lt tr--e-~ c e lpound

ONG( --S E pound1 d~ ~

) (

elvlt V 1 )1shy JQJv-bLtpoundLo ~(GLlt) dot

tgtp ~ - -~ (I

3 rz-tI a a1Sr V-cl G IVshy

L~dI ~ rf c- -shy -b ~1~A-shy y Jeo-4vv- YI IU ltJ ~

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovn

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage

lslt t ~ ~ illl ~ ~IGI lti~l~t Ollll

122-1 oampti q t D-tl ~ ampJ 4 11 ltgtiL

_S Qgt1~--I ~~ltQ~ cZ~~~~~JJ gt

~ ~ ~~

l~~~ ~~Sciv-shy l~

L ~~ ~~5

2-4 -0 ~~

( z) ~~ J) ~~- -0 011171 (n9-c

~() M1vrYt~ lW-o- t1A

I1 t ~lJiL Clmiddotk~fY11~- shy61 Campl~

ltcc Q11lt7 L ~~M) ~ 11 t~J u

(t~ C-t l~ d-J 1(prLGIC ~ ~l~-

Ct~L

lf ~1152--~ t(4lt11 =t C (1 -0H ~I Zf ~ (-11( n ~ Of (f -I

11L

~ 1 J-J t I 6-1 L l-~r 1 1 -It -(I ~ n l) )( IZ

tJ ( bullbull I 1-7 J-I 41 pound lY c(

ltr) 1 l lt7s (I -0 llf

tL ~ ~ () b- OJ i~ 3T)1 Z -(f (~(1 67 H~

t (-(t I lt I 2shy 2 I (I ~~gt 1

0-1 r -ltl

0(0 ~ r-l shy ltcv (1J at ) cJ ~ -lll-t-t )-( ()r( I U

laquoL (p - - J (I p I J Y7 1 r7 bull

Sign

ltlJl h 1-1IP

~ -J

~Slw-v~

=(

=

ja~~

J[ (J_~~JJ

~ I

NWcwgtk-shy

rKshy~7ur- (-fl ~t c -I

[filt-i ~ ~~-f1 en ~

=t-~ I) _~ 11 0 [gt(1

Sl-~J) ~ CU J I Z

J)shy 5-ll (-gt1shy~L-

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHI NAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No OrganizationNillage Sign Name and Designation

~~l ltgti-1 ~ll1-tllPgti-1 ~ltil ~JlIs+

(~ [~J-0-(1 PI(1 rh- CA tr VI1 YV) ~ Pnn t

~3 (Pit IJltAr en u ~( ~ I fI1 IIJ 1 M-f 17[1

~-( I I ((711f hICmiddot J~ o-nJ3 ~I~lo (

o(t 1 GI2tJ~[~ i f 12- Sttl 1-ltv1 -9l(llt

~5 - ~a= (-1 AL( )11 lt( ~) shI J

(5 ) I1 2-~1gt - Q1 ~

~

lt--( ~

Gl - ~ --- -tsr I ( U7 CJ I ~ 702L aP - _J ~- shyCCL I l~_ C1I 1 gJ)~

clt amp

~Ll middot(~~ 1 middot 1 tr~- v lts yen6~- L~l3 0

C-t I c (J I11hJn) vi V IhJ)fw ))ff73t ~ 7 lt Ot ~~ OYl1 [Cr1 c3 ~ (1(--( ~ rl0W~ -

JItH I-n O ( Itt l rt J(tId or l1 ( (If) i1f( F((d~2

( c11 ~I C) c1-IJ~J~O1Lr~L

3 Y ~ (y Y H - GIl-tl ( T tl P ~~ l~lWc- gt

)-o 1 gt(0 1middot V ~

0-1 Ia Cf( l)t 2--4 l 1 1raquo7 Jfb[fYLt -

13 J LL ~

~cPtJ1 tf rvu ~12J37Ufi)iJ i73_) (f6~

~ - c--~ LV ~l Lezt I - 3 L shy V~ riA)

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN iliage

hlt Ill ltIt-1 ~l~l ~~l ltIt-1 ~lll

2 Eshy - C (-I n2 lt J01 (81 () 10U l( ( sect vI

YO In~L) q(ltlJ (1 10 gt 1(1 1 b n 12 -- j J

t ~cn 1 1) v 01 J C~l 1 2 pound J gtgt-I V 1

~

~ 1 tllaquo ~o4l2-r ~ tJ (J t Urre( I

C C D( J--1t71 1V

13 12- L flo 1 r v cln 6)~d-)shyc laquo r V

00 ]~ Iw ~ N~

DL lt2t l 1q 1 $ t1 ~W) ~ crl ) L I)

0 1 ~ f (-tJ 1 3 J C iJvyr(1 uJ

OJ ~Gvcl j D 1lt (Ll-z fVl 0 G to f)

gt-t -cq c t ltgt (2 IfJ t ~ 2h 1

YJ 611~ shy Go ~ (Tj 0( lt1 (q d () ~ac shy~ -L 01 ~ shy

YL ~0~ cl~ n~ c- q lt 1 J Y I i) O~~l

ycshy O lld ~ t- Pgt4J-z I t-1--lCrc a t IltLlt CZd 1- IL U)-- ~ I -2~ CVL-to ltcr (U~ Y)t-f 0 fk(2 ~~

~t 01 ZOfA rlt 0shy lv -2V o N v C

l ltG rVJ 1 q Yl~0 I0 Cgt ~J M 0- 1)

kA~( ~o-~~ ~~ LlfL( 3 -1~

~

ui tXI ~II ~J [1 c1J~ ~il t gti pound)C1 01 f l lt~

-L 7 1 lt - If (11V dlot) C-i 51 t7l 1

Sign

~41

t ( [ Cl [ L q (r

q Ch I Z(l

1~vT)

~

~ f

~- fLCV

~ ~~

~~~ VI2~ J-)

cSM lk~

sl a-y_)1f~ tshy~ -r

r= JiM ~

V rJ RM -1 ~~ Y I M v

-- [ 1gt c rv

j(r I 1shy ~j C-ret

( Otlyl

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN il lage

lsll ll+ ltgtit l~l ~~l ltgtit Oll+

--L~ lAq~- J4lt ~~ ltr L-ltl

~VJ r gt i4f1 h1u z r VI I J ~WlC1 l lj ltJ1 I Eq

~ u

l(rr ~-tL 51(Q11 (ttl -)~~ I -shy

t t-lq ( ~ rV -V 1 gI~H vlli~ (3 1-1

( ) l J

SO blt J _N V 0 I ~~

1 ~ ~~ CU

il 0~~ ~~L ~ ~ ut d s L )-------~ =6 ~ lI-) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

53 ~ ~ f3 v I OZ ~of ) J - fj 55- _9Z1 ~y Jaltltov ~~GW ~ I t [n middotn i ~ 1

~ uf II)

f Cl -~

(miaNv1 i~w1trVIIIeAAA~i fQel

i~ v-~o-f r11 Z 7 ~q amp1 i7~~ lJshyltl --)1 11

f 5 Gf - JL 0 l (1 bull fl~ n ~0 c NQ L ~~

f L ~ ~ ~ ~o -tampLshy t1l) f1t (O (r~t ~ II i lti JI ~

Sign

~Jl

8 --alfltshyui ( r~-I

~efr UJ71tgtVl shy

J ~L-l1~J

6k~shy --shy

Ik 11

CP -kmiddot Offe)(~

~st

~ ~ ~~ ~L~ ~ ~9

V

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL tsUAKU REGIONAL OFFICE PALANPUR

Room No 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla Seva Sadan - 2 Joravar Palace Palanpur District - Banaskantha

Ph (02742) 251300 251301

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14 2006 and its amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) Government Of India New Delhi Public hearing is conducted for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Executive Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make it available for inspection to the public during normal office hours till the Public Hearing is over

1 The District Collector Office Palanpur 2 District Development Office Palanpur 3 District Industry Centre Palanpur 4 Taluka Development Office Tal Vav Tharad Deodar amp Bhabhar Dist Banaskantha 5 The Chief Conservator of Forests IViinistry of Environment amp Forests Government of India Regional

Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan E-5 Area colony Link Road-3 Ravishankar Colony Bhopal 462016

6 Regional Office Gujarat Pollution Control Board Room no 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla 5eva Sadan -2 Joravar Palace Palanpur

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities

The public hearing was held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram Panchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village - Kotarvada Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha

An advertisement in English was published in Indian Express and in Gujarati in Sandesh dated 15052015

Sh N D Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha as representative of District Magistrate and District Collector Banaskantha supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A

A statement showing salient pOints highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English language is enclosed as Annexure B and in Gujarati Languages is enclosed herewith as Annexure B1

A copy of response received in writing from other persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects is enclosed herewith as Annexure C1 and the reply by the applicant to the same is enclosed herewith as Annexure D1

amp~Place-Gram Panchayat I B Ch udhari N D Mistry Office Regional Officer Palanpur and Additional District Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Member Banaskantha

Talshy Deodar Secretary GPCB as representative of District Distshy Banaskantha Collector and District Date- 1762015 Magistrate Banaskantha

Enel 1 Annexure A B 81 C1 amp D1 as above 2 Video CD of Public Hearing

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 2: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovn

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage

lslt t ~ ~ illl ~ ~IGI lti~l~t Ollll

122-1 oampti q t D-tl ~ ampJ 4 11 ltgtiL

_S Qgt1~--I ~~ltQ~ cZ~~~~~JJ gt

~ ~ ~~

l~~~ ~~Sciv-shy l~

L ~~ ~~5

2-4 -0 ~~

( z) ~~ J) ~~- -0 011171 (n9-c

~() M1vrYt~ lW-o- t1A

I1 t ~lJiL Clmiddotk~fY11~- shy61 Campl~

ltcc Q11lt7 L ~~M) ~ 11 t~J u

(t~ C-t l~ d-J 1(prLGIC ~ ~l~-

Ct~L

lf ~1152--~ t(4lt11 =t C (1 -0H ~I Zf ~ (-11( n ~ Of (f -I

11L

~ 1 J-J t I 6-1 L l-~r 1 1 -It -(I ~ n l) )( IZ

tJ ( bullbull I 1-7 J-I 41 pound lY c(

ltr) 1 l lt7s (I -0 llf

tL ~ ~ () b- OJ i~ 3T)1 Z -(f (~(1 67 H~

t (-(t I lt I 2shy 2 I (I ~~gt 1

0-1 r -ltl

0(0 ~ r-l shy ltcv (1J at ) cJ ~ -lll-t-t )-( ()r( I U

laquoL (p - - J (I p I J Y7 1 r7 bull

Sign

ltlJl h 1-1IP

~ -J

~Slw-v~

=(

=

ja~~

J[ (J_~~JJ

~ I

NWcwgtk-shy

rKshy~7ur- (-fl ~t c -I

[filt-i ~ ~~-f1 en ~

=t-~ I) _~ 11 0 [gt(1

Sl-~J) ~ CU J I Z

J)shy 5-ll (-gt1shy~L-

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHI NAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No OrganizationNillage Sign Name and Designation

~~l ltgti-1 ~ll1-tllPgti-1 ~ltil ~JlIs+

(~ [~J-0-(1 PI(1 rh- CA tr VI1 YV) ~ Pnn t

~3 (Pit IJltAr en u ~( ~ I fI1 IIJ 1 M-f 17[1

~-( I I ((711f hICmiddot J~ o-nJ3 ~I~lo (

o(t 1 GI2tJ~[~ i f 12- Sttl 1-ltv1 -9l(llt

~5 - ~a= (-1 AL( )11 lt( ~) shI J

(5 ) I1 2-~1gt - Q1 ~

~

lt--( ~

Gl - ~ --- -tsr I ( U7 CJ I ~ 702L aP - _J ~- shyCCL I l~_ C1I 1 gJ)~

clt amp

~Ll middot(~~ 1 middot 1 tr~- v lts yen6~- L~l3 0

C-t I c (J I11hJn) vi V IhJ)fw ))ff73t ~ 7 lt Ot ~~ OYl1 [Cr1 c3 ~ (1(--( ~ rl0W~ -

JItH I-n O ( Itt l rt J(tId or l1 ( (If) i1f( F((d~2

( c11 ~I C) c1-IJ~J~O1Lr~L

3 Y ~ (y Y H - GIl-tl ( T tl P ~~ l~lWc- gt

)-o 1 gt(0 1middot V ~

0-1 Ia Cf( l)t 2--4 l 1 1raquo7 Jfb[fYLt -

13 J LL ~

~cPtJ1 tf rvu ~12J37Ufi)iJ i73_) (f6~

~ - c--~ LV ~l Lezt I - 3 L shy V~ riA)

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN iliage

hlt Ill ltIt-1 ~l~l ~~l ltIt-1 ~lll

2 Eshy - C (-I n2 lt J01 (81 () 10U l( ( sect vI

YO In~L) q(ltlJ (1 10 gt 1(1 1 b n 12 -- j J

t ~cn 1 1) v 01 J C~l 1 2 pound J gtgt-I V 1

~

~ 1 tllaquo ~o4l2-r ~ tJ (J t Urre( I

C C D( J--1t71 1V

13 12- L flo 1 r v cln 6)~d-)shyc laquo r V

00 ]~ Iw ~ N~

DL lt2t l 1q 1 $ t1 ~W) ~ crl ) L I)

0 1 ~ f (-tJ 1 3 J C iJvyr(1 uJ

OJ ~Gvcl j D 1lt (Ll-z fVl 0 G to f)

gt-t -cq c t ltgt (2 IfJ t ~ 2h 1

YJ 611~ shy Go ~ (Tj 0( lt1 (q d () ~ac shy~ -L 01 ~ shy

YL ~0~ cl~ n~ c- q lt 1 J Y I i) O~~l

ycshy O lld ~ t- Pgt4J-z I t-1--lCrc a t IltLlt CZd 1- IL U)-- ~ I -2~ CVL-to ltcr (U~ Y)t-f 0 fk(2 ~~

~t 01 ZOfA rlt 0shy lv -2V o N v C

l ltG rVJ 1 q Yl~0 I0 Cgt ~J M 0- 1)

kA~( ~o-~~ ~~ LlfL( 3 -1~

~

ui tXI ~II ~J [1 c1J~ ~il t gti pound)C1 01 f l lt~

-L 7 1 lt - If (11V dlot) C-i 51 t7l 1

Sign

~41

t ( [ Cl [ L q (r

q Ch I Z(l

1~vT)

~

~ f

~- fLCV

~ ~~

~~~ VI2~ J-)

cSM lk~

sl a-y_)1f~ tshy~ -r

r= JiM ~

V rJ RM -1 ~~ Y I M v

-- [ 1gt c rv

j(r I 1shy ~j C-ret

( Otlyl

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN il lage

lsll ll+ ltgtit l~l ~~l ltgtit Oll+

--L~ lAq~- J4lt ~~ ltr L-ltl

~VJ r gt i4f1 h1u z r VI I J ~WlC1 l lj ltJ1 I Eq

~ u

l(rr ~-tL 51(Q11 (ttl -)~~ I -shy

t t-lq ( ~ rV -V 1 gI~H vlli~ (3 1-1

( ) l J

SO blt J _N V 0 I ~~

1 ~ ~~ CU

il 0~~ ~~L ~ ~ ut d s L )-------~ =6 ~ lI-) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

53 ~ ~ f3 v I OZ ~of ) J - fj 55- _9Z1 ~y Jaltltov ~~GW ~ I t [n middotn i ~ 1

~ uf II)

f Cl -~

(miaNv1 i~w1trVIIIeAAA~i fQel

i~ v-~o-f r11 Z 7 ~q amp1 i7~~ lJshyltl --)1 11

f 5 Gf - JL 0 l (1 bull fl~ n ~0 c NQ L ~~

f L ~ ~ ~ ~o -tampLshy t1l) f1t (O (r~t ~ II i lti JI ~

Sign

~Jl

8 --alfltshyui ( r~-I

~efr UJ71tgtVl shy

J ~L-l1~J

6k~shy --shy

Ik 11

CP -kmiddot Offe)(~

~st

~ ~ ~~ ~L~ ~ ~9

V

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL tsUAKU REGIONAL OFFICE PALANPUR

Room No 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla Seva Sadan - 2 Joravar Palace Palanpur District - Banaskantha

Ph (02742) 251300 251301

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14 2006 and its amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) Government Of India New Delhi Public hearing is conducted for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Executive Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make it available for inspection to the public during normal office hours till the Public Hearing is over

1 The District Collector Office Palanpur 2 District Development Office Palanpur 3 District Industry Centre Palanpur 4 Taluka Development Office Tal Vav Tharad Deodar amp Bhabhar Dist Banaskantha 5 The Chief Conservator of Forests IViinistry of Environment amp Forests Government of India Regional

Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan E-5 Area colony Link Road-3 Ravishankar Colony Bhopal 462016

6 Regional Office Gujarat Pollution Control Board Room no 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla 5eva Sadan -2 Joravar Palace Palanpur

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities

The public hearing was held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram Panchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village - Kotarvada Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha

An advertisement in English was published in Indian Express and in Gujarati in Sandesh dated 15052015

Sh N D Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha as representative of District Magistrate and District Collector Banaskantha supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A

A statement showing salient pOints highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English language is enclosed as Annexure B and in Gujarati Languages is enclosed herewith as Annexure B1

A copy of response received in writing from other persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects is enclosed herewith as Annexure C1 and the reply by the applicant to the same is enclosed herewith as Annexure D1

amp~Place-Gram Panchayat I B Ch udhari N D Mistry Office Regional Officer Palanpur and Additional District Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Member Banaskantha

Talshy Deodar Secretary GPCB as representative of District Distshy Banaskantha Collector and District Date- 1762015 Magistrate Banaskantha

Enel 1 Annexure A B 81 C1 amp D1 as above 2 Video CD of Public Hearing

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 3: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHI NAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No OrganizationNillage Sign Name and Designation

~~l ltgti-1 ~ll1-tllPgti-1 ~ltil ~JlIs+

(~ [~J-0-(1 PI(1 rh- CA tr VI1 YV) ~ Pnn t

~3 (Pit IJltAr en u ~( ~ I fI1 IIJ 1 M-f 17[1

~-( I I ((711f hICmiddot J~ o-nJ3 ~I~lo (

o(t 1 GI2tJ~[~ i f 12- Sttl 1-ltv1 -9l(llt

~5 - ~a= (-1 AL( )11 lt( ~) shI J

(5 ) I1 2-~1gt - Q1 ~

~

lt--( ~

Gl - ~ --- -tsr I ( U7 CJ I ~ 702L aP - _J ~- shyCCL I l~_ C1I 1 gJ)~

clt amp

~Ll middot(~~ 1 middot 1 tr~- v lts yen6~- L~l3 0

C-t I c (J I11hJn) vi V IhJ)fw ))ff73t ~ 7 lt Ot ~~ OYl1 [Cr1 c3 ~ (1(--( ~ rl0W~ -

JItH I-n O ( Itt l rt J(tId or l1 ( (If) i1f( F((d~2

( c11 ~I C) c1-IJ~J~O1Lr~L

3 Y ~ (y Y H - GIl-tl ( T tl P ~~ l~lWc- gt

)-o 1 gt(0 1middot V ~

0-1 Ia Cf( l)t 2--4 l 1 1raquo7 Jfb[fYLt -

13 J LL ~

~cPtJ1 tf rvu ~12J37Ufi)iJ i73_) (f6~

~ - c--~ LV ~l Lezt I - 3 L shy V~ riA)

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN iliage

hlt Ill ltIt-1 ~l~l ~~l ltIt-1 ~lll

2 Eshy - C (-I n2 lt J01 (81 () 10U l( ( sect vI

YO In~L) q(ltlJ (1 10 gt 1(1 1 b n 12 -- j J

t ~cn 1 1) v 01 J C~l 1 2 pound J gtgt-I V 1

~

~ 1 tllaquo ~o4l2-r ~ tJ (J t Urre( I

C C D( J--1t71 1V

13 12- L flo 1 r v cln 6)~d-)shyc laquo r V

00 ]~ Iw ~ N~

DL lt2t l 1q 1 $ t1 ~W) ~ crl ) L I)

0 1 ~ f (-tJ 1 3 J C iJvyr(1 uJ

OJ ~Gvcl j D 1lt (Ll-z fVl 0 G to f)

gt-t -cq c t ltgt (2 IfJ t ~ 2h 1

YJ 611~ shy Go ~ (Tj 0( lt1 (q d () ~ac shy~ -L 01 ~ shy

YL ~0~ cl~ n~ c- q lt 1 J Y I i) O~~l

ycshy O lld ~ t- Pgt4J-z I t-1--lCrc a t IltLlt CZd 1- IL U)-- ~ I -2~ CVL-to ltcr (U~ Y)t-f 0 fk(2 ~~

~t 01 ZOfA rlt 0shy lv -2V o N v C

l ltG rVJ 1 q Yl~0 I0 Cgt ~J M 0- 1)

kA~( ~o-~~ ~~ LlfL( 3 -1~

~

ui tXI ~II ~J [1 c1J~ ~il t gti pound)C1 01 f l lt~

-L 7 1 lt - If (11V dlot) C-i 51 t7l 1

Sign

~41

t ( [ Cl [ L q (r

q Ch I Z(l

1~vT)

~

~ f

~- fLCV

~ ~~

~~~ VI2~ J-)

cSM lk~

sl a-y_)1f~ tshy~ -r

r= JiM ~

V rJ RM -1 ~~ Y I M v

-- [ 1gt c rv

j(r I 1shy ~j C-ret

( Otlyl

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN il lage

lsll ll+ ltgtit l~l ~~l ltgtit Oll+

--L~ lAq~- J4lt ~~ ltr L-ltl

~VJ r gt i4f1 h1u z r VI I J ~WlC1 l lj ltJ1 I Eq

~ u

l(rr ~-tL 51(Q11 (ttl -)~~ I -shy

t t-lq ( ~ rV -V 1 gI~H vlli~ (3 1-1

( ) l J

SO blt J _N V 0 I ~~

1 ~ ~~ CU

il 0~~ ~~L ~ ~ ut d s L )-------~ =6 ~ lI-) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

53 ~ ~ f3 v I OZ ~of ) J - fj 55- _9Z1 ~y Jaltltov ~~GW ~ I t [n middotn i ~ 1

~ uf II)

f Cl -~

(miaNv1 i~w1trVIIIeAAA~i fQel

i~ v-~o-f r11 Z 7 ~q amp1 i7~~ lJshyltl --)1 11

f 5 Gf - JL 0 l (1 bull fl~ n ~0 c NQ L ~~

f L ~ ~ ~ ~o -tampLshy t1l) f1t (O (r~t ~ II i lti JI ~

Sign

~Jl

8 --alfltshyui ( r~-I

~efr UJ71tgtVl shy

J ~L-l1~J

6k~shy --shy

Ik 11

CP -kmiddot Offe)(~

~st

~ ~ ~~ ~L~ ~ ~9

V

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL tsUAKU REGIONAL OFFICE PALANPUR

Room No 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla Seva Sadan - 2 Joravar Palace Palanpur District - Banaskantha

Ph (02742) 251300 251301

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14 2006 and its amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) Government Of India New Delhi Public hearing is conducted for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Executive Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make it available for inspection to the public during normal office hours till the Public Hearing is over

1 The District Collector Office Palanpur 2 District Development Office Palanpur 3 District Industry Centre Palanpur 4 Taluka Development Office Tal Vav Tharad Deodar amp Bhabhar Dist Banaskantha 5 The Chief Conservator of Forests IViinistry of Environment amp Forests Government of India Regional

Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan E-5 Area colony Link Road-3 Ravishankar Colony Bhopal 462016

6 Regional Office Gujarat Pollution Control Board Room no 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla 5eva Sadan -2 Joravar Palace Palanpur

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities

The public hearing was held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram Panchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village - Kotarvada Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha

An advertisement in English was published in Indian Express and in Gujarati in Sandesh dated 15052015

Sh N D Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha as representative of District Magistrate and District Collector Banaskantha supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A

A statement showing salient pOints highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English language is enclosed as Annexure B and in Gujarati Languages is enclosed herewith as Annexure B1

A copy of response received in writing from other persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects is enclosed herewith as Annexure C1 and the reply by the applicant to the same is enclosed herewith as Annexure D1

amp~Place-Gram Panchayat I B Ch udhari N D Mistry Office Regional Officer Palanpur and Additional District Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Member Banaskantha

Talshy Deodar Secretary GPCB as representative of District Distshy Banaskantha Collector and District Date- 1762015 Magistrate Banaskantha

Enel 1 Annexure A B 81 C1 amp D1 as above 2 Video CD of Public Hearing

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 4: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN iliage

hlt Ill ltIt-1 ~l~l ~~l ltIt-1 ~lll

2 Eshy - C (-I n2 lt J01 (81 () 10U l( ( sect vI

YO In~L) q(ltlJ (1 10 gt 1(1 1 b n 12 -- j J

t ~cn 1 1) v 01 J C~l 1 2 pound J gtgt-I V 1

~

~ 1 tllaquo ~o4l2-r ~ tJ (J t Urre( I

C C D( J--1t71 1V

13 12- L flo 1 r v cln 6)~d-)shyc laquo r V

00 ]~ Iw ~ N~

DL lt2t l 1q 1 $ t1 ~W) ~ crl ) L I)

0 1 ~ f (-tJ 1 3 J C iJvyr(1 uJ

OJ ~Gvcl j D 1lt (Ll-z fVl 0 G to f)

gt-t -cq c t ltgt (2 IfJ t ~ 2h 1

YJ 611~ shy Go ~ (Tj 0( lt1 (q d () ~ac shy~ -L 01 ~ shy

YL ~0~ cl~ n~ c- q lt 1 J Y I i) O~~l

ycshy O lld ~ t- Pgt4J-z I t-1--lCrc a t IltLlt CZd 1- IL U)-- ~ I -2~ CVL-to ltcr (U~ Y)t-f 0 fk(2 ~~

~t 01 ZOfA rlt 0shy lv -2V o N v C

l ltG rVJ 1 q Yl~0 I0 Cgt ~J M 0- 1)

kA~( ~o-~~ ~~ LlfL( 3 -1~

~

ui tXI ~II ~J [1 c1J~ ~il t gti pound)C1 01 f l lt~

-L 7 1 lt - If (11V dlot) C-i 51 t7l 1

Sign

~41

t ( [ Cl [ L q (r

q Ch I Z(l

1~vT)

~

~ f

~- fLCV

~ ~~

~~~ VI2~ J-)

cSM lk~

sl a-y_)1f~ tshy~ -r

r= JiM ~

V rJ RM -1 ~~ Y I M v

-- [ 1gt c rv

j(r I 1shy ~j C-ret

( Otlyl

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN il lage

lsll ll+ ltgtit l~l ~~l ltgtit Oll+

--L~ lAq~- J4lt ~~ ltr L-ltl

~VJ r gt i4f1 h1u z r VI I J ~WlC1 l lj ltJ1 I Eq

~ u

l(rr ~-tL 51(Q11 (ttl -)~~ I -shy

t t-lq ( ~ rV -V 1 gI~H vlli~ (3 1-1

( ) l J

SO blt J _N V 0 I ~~

1 ~ ~~ CU

il 0~~ ~~L ~ ~ ut d s L )-------~ =6 ~ lI-) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

53 ~ ~ f3 v I OZ ~of ) J - fj 55- _9Z1 ~y Jaltltov ~~GW ~ I t [n middotn i ~ 1

~ uf II)

f Cl -~

(miaNv1 i~w1trVIIIeAAA~i fQel

i~ v-~o-f r11 Z 7 ~q amp1 i7~~ lJshyltl --)1 11

f 5 Gf - JL 0 l (1 bull fl~ n ~0 c NQ L ~~

f L ~ ~ ~ ~o -tampLshy t1l) f1t (O (r~t ~ II i lti JI ~

Sign

~Jl

8 --alfltshyui ( r~-I

~efr UJ71tgtVl shy

J ~L-l1~J

6k~shy --shy

Ik 11

CP -kmiddot Offe)(~

~st

~ ~ ~~ ~L~ ~ ~9

V

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL tsUAKU REGIONAL OFFICE PALANPUR

Room No 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla Seva Sadan - 2 Joravar Palace Palanpur District - Banaskantha

Ph (02742) 251300 251301

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14 2006 and its amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) Government Of India New Delhi Public hearing is conducted for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Executive Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make it available for inspection to the public during normal office hours till the Public Hearing is over

1 The District Collector Office Palanpur 2 District Development Office Palanpur 3 District Industry Centre Palanpur 4 Taluka Development Office Tal Vav Tharad Deodar amp Bhabhar Dist Banaskantha 5 The Chief Conservator of Forests IViinistry of Environment amp Forests Government of India Regional

Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan E-5 Area colony Link Road-3 Ravishankar Colony Bhopal 462016

6 Regional Office Gujarat Pollution Control Board Room no 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla 5eva Sadan -2 Joravar Palace Palanpur

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities

The public hearing was held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram Panchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village - Kotarvada Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha

An advertisement in English was published in Indian Express and in Gujarati in Sandesh dated 15052015

Sh N D Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha as representative of District Magistrate and District Collector Banaskantha supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A

A statement showing salient pOints highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English language is enclosed as Annexure B and in Gujarati Languages is enclosed herewith as Annexure B1

A copy of response received in writing from other persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects is enclosed herewith as Annexure C1 and the reply by the applicant to the same is enclosed herewith as Annexure D1

amp~Place-Gram Panchayat I B Ch udhari N D Mistry Office Regional Officer Palanpur and Additional District Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Member Banaskantha

Talshy Deodar Secretary GPCB as representative of District Distshy Banaskantha Collector and District Date- 1762015 Magistrate Banaskantha

Enel 1 Annexure A B 81 C1 amp D1 as above 2 Video CD of Public Hearing

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 5: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE GANDHINAGAR CIO Paryavaran Bhavan Sector 10 A Gandhinagar - 382 010 Website wwwgpcbgovin

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationN il lage

lsll ll+ ltgtit l~l ~~l ltgtit Oll+

--L~ lAq~- J4lt ~~ ltr L-ltl

~VJ r gt i4f1 h1u z r VI I J ~WlC1 l lj ltJ1 I Eq

~ u

l(rr ~-tL 51(Q11 (ttl -)~~ I -shy

t t-lq ( ~ rV -V 1 gI~H vlli~ (3 1-1

( ) l J

SO blt J _N V 0 I ~~

1 ~ ~~ CU

il 0~~ ~~L ~ ~ ut d s L )-------~ =6 ~ lI-) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

53 ~ ~ f3 v I OZ ~of ) J - fj 55- _9Z1 ~y Jaltltov ~~GW ~ I t [n middotn i ~ 1

~ uf II)

f Cl -~

(miaNv1 i~w1trVIIIeAAA~i fQel

i~ v-~o-f r11 Z 7 ~q amp1 i7~~ lJshyltl --)1 11

f 5 Gf - JL 0 l (1 bull fl~ n ~0 c NQ L ~~

f L ~ ~ ~ ~o -tampLshy t1l) f1t (O (r~t ~ II i lti JI ~

Sign

~Jl

8 --alfltshyui ( r~-I

~efr UJ71tgtVl shy

J ~L-l1~J

6k~shy --shy

Ik 11

CP -kmiddot Offe)(~

~st

~ ~ ~~ ~L~ ~ ~9

V

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL tsUAKU REGIONAL OFFICE PALANPUR

Room No 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla Seva Sadan - 2 Joravar Palace Palanpur District - Banaskantha

Ph (02742) 251300 251301

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14 2006 and its amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) Government Of India New Delhi Public hearing is conducted for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Executive Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make it available for inspection to the public during normal office hours till the Public Hearing is over

1 The District Collector Office Palanpur 2 District Development Office Palanpur 3 District Industry Centre Palanpur 4 Taluka Development Office Tal Vav Tharad Deodar amp Bhabhar Dist Banaskantha 5 The Chief Conservator of Forests IViinistry of Environment amp Forests Government of India Regional

Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan E-5 Area colony Link Road-3 Ravishankar Colony Bhopal 462016

6 Regional Office Gujarat Pollution Control Board Room no 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla 5eva Sadan -2 Joravar Palace Palanpur

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities

The public hearing was held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram Panchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village - Kotarvada Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha

An advertisement in English was published in Indian Express and in Gujarati in Sandesh dated 15052015

Sh N D Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha as representative of District Magistrate and District Collector Banaskantha supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A

A statement showing salient pOints highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English language is enclosed as Annexure B and in Gujarati Languages is enclosed herewith as Annexure B1

A copy of response received in writing from other persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects is enclosed herewith as Annexure C1 and the reply by the applicant to the same is enclosed herewith as Annexure D1

amp~Place-Gram Panchayat I B Ch udhari N D Mistry Office Regional Officer Palanpur and Additional District Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Member Banaskantha

Talshy Deodar Secretary GPCB as representative of District Distshy Banaskantha Collector and District Date- 1762015 Magistrate Banaskantha

Enel 1 Annexure A B 81 C1 amp D1 as above 2 Video CD of Public Hearing

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 6: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL tsUAKU REGIONAL OFFICE PALANPUR

Room No 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla Seva Sadan - 2 Joravar Palace Palanpur District - Banaskantha

Ph (02742) 251300 251301

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14 2006 and its amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009 Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) Government Of India New Delhi Public hearing is conducted for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment report and the Executive Summary of Environment Impact Assessment Report were sent to the following authorities or offices to make it available for inspection to the public during normal office hours till the Public Hearing is over

1 The District Collector Office Palanpur 2 District Development Office Palanpur 3 District Industry Centre Palanpur 4 Taluka Development Office Tal Vav Tharad Deodar amp Bhabhar Dist Banaskantha 5 The Chief Conservator of Forests IViinistry of Environment amp Forests Government of India Regional

Office (West Zone) Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan E-5 Area colony Link Road-3 Ravishankar Colony Bhopal 462016

6 Regional Office Gujarat Pollution Control Board Room no 20 to 24 3rd Floor Jilla 5eva Sadan -2 Joravar Palace Palanpur

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in the environment aspects were requested to send their response in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities

The public hearing was held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram Panchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village - Kotarvada Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha

An advertisement in English was published in Indian Express and in Gujarati in Sandesh dated 15052015

Sh N D Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha as representative of District Magistrate and District Collector Banaskantha supervised and presided over the entire public hearing proceedings

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A

A statement showing salient pOints highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing in English language is enclosed as Annexure B and in Gujarati Languages is enclosed herewith as Annexure B1

A copy of response received in writing from other persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects is enclosed herewith as Annexure C1 and the reply by the applicant to the same is enclosed herewith as Annexure D1

amp~Place-Gram Panchayat I B Ch udhari N D Mistry Office Regional Officer Palanpur and Additional District Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Member Banaskantha

Talshy Deodar Secretary GPCB as representative of District Distshy Banaskantha Collector and District Date- 1762015 Magistrate Banaskantha

Enel 1 Annexure A B 81 C1 amp D1 as above 2 Video CD of Public Hearing

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 7: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

ANNEXURE-A

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 8: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Annexure - A

A Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing

As per the Ministry of Environment[ Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)[ Government of India[ New Delhi vide its Notification No 50 1533 dated September 14[ 2006 and subsequent amendment 503067 (E) dated 1st December 2009[ Public hearing was fixed for Ms Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in NELP-IX blocks CB-ONN-20101[ CBshyONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category A of the schedule l(b) as mentioned in their request application

The Statement showing participants present during the Public Hearing held on 17062015 at 1200 hrs Gram P3nchayat Office Kotarvada Deodar Road Village Kotarvada[ Ta Deodar Dist Banaskantha is as under

(1l ~ d ~n~L~ iL qi ott t~Lq ~ ttlltLltttt iq11l~~1il ltr6l~ ~ iliUsiLis ~~otl 9 t~~ dL 9 6~~oos ott ctiL tt91iL ~4L~L htLis ~~otL~0S0(8) dL099~~oo~ iL ot1~4lt 120l~1- 01 iL ouq~1 0qLi( lt otlD( ~s t=ltt~( Ol~ ~Lt1hLi Rt12S ~L~l ~ltr6~ld ~Lltr6tt il Uiim~Lbl Oli41iOl~ ott

otiSLqLS ltrJl~(L iL otLq( ~i8~(ltD ~ 6(l~ ~1Ui1otl~ioi - ~0909 ~1Ui1otl~i~i

-~O90 s ~1 Ui1 oil ~i ~i -~090~ iL ~ ~ --i OL otL8(iL l$qlotLiL ~(Lol ~L ~~Li iL2i1

t~1tthfiL(JtLltr6~2) 120L~1 ~ ~ctOld UiiL~~ibL 001(-(L il2 (Lis ~iLql~a ~L1gtqLiL otLqltt

~Rtct JtL06 ~2 iL2 (lis ~iLq~a j otLttlOOi dl ~00s=~0~ l il ~l~ ~ctl~ ~ ~ 00 Elllr 9Ult li~Wd

~lI~~ ld~ctlSl ~llf~ ~IS 0lllt ld~ctLSl dl~lIS~ otl(ElI ~iL~l6l1gtlct ~LutqLiL otLq(

t9

Sr No

h+t

laquo )

I i

iJI- ( ISshy

L-t ~NIL I-~A-fl-- t 4 lS) I~v Il~ ~ I

i

~ SA- ~~_h~M(6

010 t--) ~ rt6 oN ~tj Ct () r rl A gtVii bull -

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 9: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

is+

ill ati ~l~l ~~l att ~lll

i-1amp~C~cel5l

~41 r--sfNoT Name and Designation Organizationvillage I Sign

Lf ( Z 4 ~ ) ~Y11 J-7

cJ-l ~ rOlJV

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 10: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign ~

amp+t il+ ~i ~lGl tl~l ~i ou+

~ ~ )7 ~ middotft+-IHILtf

I1 rlW If I

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 11: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Sr No Name and Designation

il+l ~i ~lGlJs+t Sign

~41

I JL

1 I

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 12: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationlVillage Sign

Is~ I ottl raquotot tlampt

(i~l ~ Ott+

ti ql5r

(iJl

i Bilr( triO i

d~

t~O1C11 ~~(j ~~ZV11 ~~~~--------------~~----

~~frt cQ CCtl i (ltillel

jo

~

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 13: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

~fV-~~ 1()1 t015j

i GY1c1~J llFz gt1 -~o ) (r1~cJ J-5 r

I~Yj~ Ilaquo) - IYJY) i -1 12 (~

l) l (f--vshy

~

Of ~ 1 ~ dvt~ ~ t 511ffY ~Yr 17J

bullG2(J-t 1euroJ I

r J ~

rt C -L~ toc

~ ~0~~ ttj~~~

~

lt5 gt 6 Cgt-l1 01 ) $ IL~lU1

U (

(u~~~ qlmiddot (A~~f I

(]~ltc l~~ 11

1(f Vj ltR-rvI ~(~ V I [s ~laquo1Lc 2l i C(r

([-) ~~1laquo)

teL J1 CC ~Cl--1J

I ~

c=L c5Lipoundttf- hl6)~3JrMO ~-~~ middot~l ntct LJ -shy

tc-) t1shy ~lo1 ~ irl q I-lt

G-~ 40L-- ~

Sign Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage ~~t (t1 Ottl is+ i 1tl (t1 ~l~t ~Jt

)C ~ I ~02-157 (61)

I

61 oo~ OJ ~ 2-)g i1 -0 -j-J~() ~ C l) ~ poundrcflf-J

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 14: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

I Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNiliageII I m Sign

I ~ -ttl Olt tltampl ltilt2lt Olt ttl lti41

~01 b21~ Iamp1J q-4j~ J~ 0)gt IIsect I J(1z_LI_S_J_---+-_~_~_middot_d-_~)_~_IiP1__-I

(---s ~ i --j 0

(I ~) 141 ~~ItLI-c(bJJL~~~J4U-_J~~l

tL--(T-----~=--~~~~u~c---l-i amp-J(dLJ-=--~---~S2_J__1)-J41----IcLgt~it-L----O~-I~

II IC-V ~~poundll)

~

~lti

~ -shy L~ p- a (1

~

i (il(1)Jr I 8Jci~L(lc51 ~ t~~lrV ltI $JC~-t( S ~~ II~() 04 ~g S~

ct0L ~ ~J~ y t~~ ~~ll ~q)reg i

amp i qc+gt=~-I-~~I____ I 0

55 t-~t ~ ~~ tAU 0Ji~ I sletlu ~ I sectG-lL c1fl t--~~J~p r---===----l-~~~ S~t f1 4 t ~~

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 15: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Sr No Name and Designation OrganizationNillage Sign

is+ illt ~1 ~l~l ~~l ~i Jlllt ~Jl

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 16: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

ANNEXURE-B

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 17: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

ANNEXURE - B (English)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses by the

representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing

As per the provision of Notification No 50 1533 dated 14th September 2006 and its 1stamendment 50 3067 (E) dated December 2009 issued by Ministry of

Environment Forest and Climate Change Government of India New Delhi Public Hearing is conducted for Mis Oil amp Natural Gas Corporation Limited for exploratory drilling of 22 nos wells in IIELP-IX Blocks CB-ONN-20101 CB-ONN-20106 CB-ONN-20109 at Districts Banaskantha Gandhinagar and Ahmedabad for part of Banaskantha District which is covered under category - A of the schedule l(b) of above referred Notification under the Chairman ship of Shri N 0 Mistry Additional District Magistrate Banaskantha and Chairman of Public Hearing Committee

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of the GPCB - a paneled member of Public hearing committee welcomed all present in the Public Hearing He outlined the various provisions of the Notification and briefed the procedural details for conducting this public hearing including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of this public hearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local daily newspapers He announced that as per the provision of Notification only locally affected persons will be allowed to make their verbalwritten representation during the Public Hearing while others having plausible stake holders may submit their representations in writing which would be included in the proceedings He also made it clear to the gathering that the Committee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing and submit it to the Central Government The final decision regarding the Clearance of the proposed project will be taken by the Expert Appraisal committee of the MoEFCC New Delhi

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from Additional District Magistrate He invited the project proponent to give their introduction and to make the presentation of their project

Mr Azhar Kazi Kadam Environment Consultant Environment consultant of Ms ONGC welcomed the gathering Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introduction of the company salient features of the project technical details of proposed project Environmental Management System its impact on environment along with proposed mitigation measures was presented

After the presentation by the project proponent Regional Officer Palanpur and the representative of GPCB with the due permission of the Additional District Magistrate requested gathering for representations suggestionsobjections from the locally

affected people

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 18: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

i

The statement showing issues suggestions objections opinions raised by the participants during Public Hearing and also responses by the representative of the applicant during the Public Hearing are as under

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No

1

and Point Represented

Shri Shivaji Maganji Thakor Village - Kotarwada

bull How many total survey nos and in which villages are these proposed wells located

bull What shall be the benefits to villages

Proponent

bull Survey no shall be known only after Scientific study of the area

bull The locations at which this well shall come this land shall be taken on lease from the farmer as per Government rules and regulations and crop compensation shall be paid based on decision ta ken by ONGC committee

r----r--------~--------~----- ------~------------------~ 2 Shri Mukesh Shivaji

Thakor village - Kotarwada

bull How shall ONGC make Land agreement with farm owners and how shall youth of the villages shall be employed

bull For how much time ONGC shall take the

bull Presently survey nos are not finalized whenever it shall be finalized land shall be taken on lease for temporary period based on Government rules and regulations Once drilling is completed and if Oil is discovered then

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 19: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Sr Name and Address Replies from Project No and Point Proponent

Represented land on lease land shall be taken and what rent on permanent basis shall be paid and if there is no

discovery then land shall be restored to its original condition and handed over to farmers and land and crop compensation shall also be paid based on Government rules and regulations Based on the educations qualifications local youths shall be employed OIJGCs mehsana asset has formed land losers committee and 30 vehicles are taken from them

bull What shall be bull ONGC is having CSR benefit to village funds Application by under CSR need full villages policy shall be given to

ONGC in designated Form which shall be placed in front of ONGC CSR committee and further benefits shall be given to need full villages based on ONGC CSRs policy and till date ONGC has distributed amount of Rs 419490 for basic

Remarks

I

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 20: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Name and Address Replies from Project Remarks No Sr

and Point Proponent Represented I

requirements among I

Schools Panchayat office in affected villages of Banaskantha District

3 Shri Punjabhai Amrabhai Patel Sarpanch Village Rampur

bull Add District taken by OIJGC

bull If land to be bull Based on Government rules Magistrate

is Panchayat and regulations

informed that graze land or Panchayat land based on Government graze land or Government waste land Government waste Order Ilon what shall be Agriculture shall the benefits to on lease from District be given to ONGC Villages wise Land acquisition based on

Officer

land shall be taken

Government rules and regulations and after knowing what steps shall be taken for village development

bull Around 130 m x 130 expoI rato y r

bull After m of land shall be

drilling during blasting what shall be impacts on land and agriculture field

L

taken on lease for exploratory drilling activity and during drilling there shall be no vibration hence no impacts on nearby land and agriculture field shall

-_________----___b_e_e_n_v_is_a-g-e_d____-l-_________

Shri I B Chaudhari Regional officer GPCB Palanpur and representative of GPCB informed that written representation were received from (1) Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad prior to conduct of the Public Hearing which would be included in the proceedings along with the reply of project proponent The same is

-l

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 21: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

enclosed as Annexure - C1 along with the reply submitted by project proponent Annexure - 01

Regional Officer GPCB had repeatedly requested the gathering for any other representation however no additional representationquery were raised

Regional officer GPCB summarized the gist of the entire Public Hearing proceeding to the participants

The Additional District Magistrate informed the villagers who were present that this is an open platform in which any person can express his opinion and thought He also stated that the said public hearing has been arranged so that the ONGC can carry out their drilling Operation in the future and the Ministry of Environment and Forests as well as the Pollution Control Board will allow them to do so However if any of the persons who are present have any objection to the same they may represent their thoughts orally or even in writing The Additional District Magistrate further informed that ONGC shall discuss the matter with Village leaders Talati shall obtain the CSR form from ONGC and shall help for the development of villages After completion of drilling If ONGC shall not pay the land compensation or not fulfill the promises then it shall be put up to District Collector which shall be further taken up in district level Coshyordination (Sankalan) meeting scheduled monthly

The Chairman then thanked the gathering and announced the conclusion of the meeting

ky Place-Gram I B Cha hari N D Mistry ~~

Panchayat Regiona Officer Additional District Office Palanpur and Magistrate Kotarwada representative of the Banas kantha

Talshy Deodar Member Secretary GPCB as representative of Distshy Banaskantha District Collector and Date- 1762015 District Magistrate

Banaskantha

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 22: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

blM 1l-tlbt lcT) 1~lS )~ynntc h-Btc llD1J1-)~ lPlD 12)1k1t lClcb112h

1gtM lDb 121Cl~ lfl-n1M u-o~ftC l2Jl-t~ 1o1l-oPo~lfh f)t~fR hlM If)lSl[t 1gtcllScR O~

lflS cl1212 hllgt 121lS 1gt~) lfblM 1gt1PM1M If)~l6 lJigt~ l-oll2lc3 TIClbll-oR l2J~R TIClbll-oR lS1)

f)~1t ~ lflS If)amphc tc~1 lS16 lflS 1l-tf)t9t f)lM~c 10~1 f)SU1V 1oc19M 1oc l~eJ

~recRM 1l6f) blM ll-tlbclS )tlR ll-thllgt 191b1t21lS 1gtamp lS16 lflS f)l~c f)t9tlSt9Ut

ll-tTIClbllDR lS1[) Po 1J1[) ~rccRM lS~lm f)lS~ clRfoM mb1e~ 1olD16~WZJu-o c3R ~

lflS f)lc~19o tc~1 ll-trb 1)llM lP~ll-t lClh ~ftC f)lC~19o HelM ll-tlbclS 1gt1)l1M cMl-nc~19o

ll-t~hlDll-tpb lS~~ lS~lm ~ftC lJn~n un~M 1oTIClb1l-oR lS1) 1M 1cll ~10 1poundll-t~ 1)llM

lP~ll-t 1l-t1-gtl)~ f)M1M TIClbll-oR lS1) 1gtM ~~lble~ heJeJ f)lef)ftC l-ol-o16~WZJ11gt tc~lM~

tc~~ 1121lSblM 1gtUt f)~h~ ll-tTIClbll-oR lS1) tc 12J~l2Jn ll-o~10 lClk2~ lClh~n

f)lcPofe lJampb~R rwR 1l6f) chl-o)lh 1J0W1)l~ lfllS12JM lS~~1n lfhltC1J0BlM lJamp

)e1M

ll-tlbl-nlc lJ)9~ If)~lc1M 1o191lSRllDM 2~~t lY)~ lS12JM 1c~lrlDtc lJamp ~ll-n 19WRll-oM

1Y)~ c3~~JW llt)lbcf) l-tllc lt)~ c3~~ lltlbcf) R~~ f)12l1cr l-tlTc ~1)lS

OOTb ~lbR Po~ llD hbOc506blf) l-oPo~lM ~TIClbllDR lS1) ~1l-t lent) )elM ll-tlY)~

1911SRllDM f)1cf)ftC (2lSampl[t)llDPo~lfh f)~1t 1o~1l-t l-t1lSclR leu-)~ llD~lb~ llD)~~

lcto cc llD ~ObOc-lDtc~1J0W 1gtM 50bOc-lDtc~lYgtW bObOc-lDtc~1J0W

lS1I) ~ 1)l)tc~lDtc )elM ll-tlY)~ 31b13l-tM 1gtM clClD1Pllc 191lSRllDM ll-ot2Polc

f)lcPofe lcll lt~1)-t~ lD16reg R~ ltotc )~~t )~lbt lfblM 1l-t tc-lflc~~ 1gtlh~foM

llD ~OOccbbOmiddotlf) (~)650E ~Rtc lS1l-t~ lclhR llD1sect1h llD1 1gtM 500c~ORbmiddot1f)

E Eh b ~Rtc lS1l-t~ ll-tllDc~19o llD1J1-)~ TIllD t2)1k1t lCl c b 1t2 h 1gtM lDb llDc 1lS cR f) c ltv

lQ1PPo HelM Tlt1PhlM 1cl t~J~l~n

1lDc1390cM ~M ~l9tt )t21M 1l-t1PclS ]c 1c1 1) l)~c c901g lD1t21c3 uapi~ lS1[)

(lP1cJofc) 1 -lr c~1lC

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 23: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

ljvt amp~L 1lL5oj ClUlct~

~bto1~ill ol 5[la

~L~L 01581 amp2L vtL C I

ULl Clll-lL ULCl ~

~ ampllj1~L mClL~ 6l~l~

l Lll-l 81 ct~ ClL S L

bull ~bto1~ill 1Act~o1l bull ampLC- sectClL~o1l ~q oivt~

l-ll5 ~l~ 5~l~ 5t) 01581 o1W 2l~ 01581

itct 5~~ ctampL dCllotl~ amp~ (Cll~ ~~5l~amplo1l olrU

~llLit 5t) itct [2l-l ljvt 1Act~o1l

ULl~ l-lL5 1lL~W ampllll-[t

bull l-[t01 1C- l ~l-l2 l-lLe l1 ~~ gt2l ltA Clll-ll ulCl ~

QmiddotIlS ltA~ u~ 1cj Qlsect u~ ~lL~5ll-l vtLc Vvt~

lt5Cl~ 1lS~ 1 Ul gt2ll-ll ctC- 19 ct l-lol l-[t01 5 L 2 l-[t l1 ~~

ltAClL l-ll ULCl~ o1~ct~

l-[to1 l-lL5~ ctol gt2l

ljUl ~(ctl-lL 1llt9l UL1lClL l-ll Ul Cl~ u~

ol l2loj Ql~ ctampl 1ll5oj

ClUl ct~ ~~5lit (l2 l-l

ljvt UL1lClL l-lL uLCl ~

u~ ~8~5 C-l25lctatl

ULcu~ Wl[5 dCllotl~

~lll it l-lUl~ ctampL

~ btat~ ill l-l~~llSlL

bt~ ifl~l ~1lllct amp~C-

l-[tat atl l-lL (( 81ol bt5

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 24: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

l1Ptt lD~ M90h

b1c9 lf1~crc

~ )t2112l90

lc13 11~~(1 1)-)( ~Q)rrc

1c 13 Ifl~Q)rrc bull lD31hrc lDlJt90 1lD1)-)(

1 ~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lfl~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

middotlD1ft90 lP 121hr bull

)~~ lD13forrc

bull fo Ogt~gtb n~ )~

~161rrc Z1l-t lJCm12)R

12lJ1llttlJ) 1l-t 1fgtIf~~

P121h r lJC11f)116

1fgtlt11C wfccrcrrc

llDl)-)( 191~rc1lDM

1c13 W(lDtcllR

1l-tWR c1lc-lrrc ~rrc

~h1rrc 1t)1) ~lt11C

3l-t P l12 t)e90 M90h

lt12~ 1lD1 1fCJ~ tlS8

~rrc ~b1rrc 1l-t1bc~

9c 1l-t1fCJ~ tlS8 1

1J51bh lrrc 1c15 lt11 c 311

P 112 t)e90 If1t) 1t~ )~~

P12~ ~ 12~ ~~

tlS8 ~lh W(lDtc1C bull

e1rrc 1l-tlb~ 1J5~11t)

1lqlb 1)~~ 0pound 1lDl-t1

1l-t~ )ellDM 1fCJ~

I I ~ 12~ l12c90 1fgt1M1clltt

lf1~crc ~ lDlJt90 chUc

lDlJt90 1fgtP121hr

lDlJt90 1Pb 1trc 1l-tlb~

1c15 U-=C (lDtclJC bull cnl-t1c l-t11c middotn~hrcrc

)Zh m1t)lcl-trrc Bl1t)l9oFt 11 I pound

~hl)Q 1t)1) f6

f6 1l-tl-tl1C PlcPM tlS8 bull

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 25: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

1R 1o1b181l1c Ifol-tl1c middotW~fotcQC ~ el1~ tc ~QC12 1l-trb W6 1f8 Pl~c ~n~l1c

1l-t8tgUt ~ 1l-tPtg1gt 1tP 1P lclsectgt 101b tto c181 lClhGW lo 1gtW1[) hll1c jJ~h ~bll1c 1l-tlbhll1c

lClh 1f~ft 1gtl-t12 lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 116P lc)llCft lClcb1lch 1gtl1c ~c8 l-t18cl16 pQClbsect

1l-tml2JlV Wmiddot~fotcQC ~ ~ 1Pl1c 1l-tlb~ltC ~1l-t 1)2tc 89t 1l1c ~~16 1f8 Pll1c~c PtJRgt

lClhGW 1l-tamp ~ left 1[)-)fn 1l1c ~ )ell~ 1gt1o~l-tlrc Phg) tc~2~~t 1)-)~ 8~l1c

)el1c 1l-tlbbll~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Phg)

161c1R tto19b1lc18 rcl-trc UOUClblfoR 81[) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fc 1f8~l1c 8~~11

1PSgt ]0 H~l-t Pl~c GW rb rcol1c jJ~h Hel1c 1l-tlbbll~ clb~lb ~ll-t lbc~ 12 1P lclsectgt Pl~c

GW rcol1c 1gt~rccrcl1c ~~l~ Plhg) lcl~ ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c 8~~11

~ )~~ lCll~~ ~1fP 6-1) ct21gttc t~fol1c

1gt cl-lFegt1 l]o]o1t1 2~amplEt 1gtl1c 6 -W ch 1gttc t ~fol1c 1gtamp ~ H~l-t 1J6~c P 3lb13l-tl1c

lCt9 lClcb1lch lR~1t GllV16~l-t ~ (6) Pl~c Ptgl UOQCP~Rgt lPblch P~ lCOl1c g)l1cl1c

UClbl]oR ~1[) ~ )ellCl~ 1gtlc13Ftrcfo~ Plhg) ~Q0 lCllC1C~ lClR~1 Plc~fe 1f~~l1c ~~~11

~b1l1c 1l-tlbh1l1c

31M llc16 15~]o

~hll1c 1lDl~

f6 ~ll-t rc 1~l2J

1]0l-t e 116P

1l-tlbh1l1c e l1c

1gt GC ~]0tcQC

M~Ft 1tlc~

1f~crc 1gt]0lJt~

19]0

~16 ]0116 ~fo 1gt]ol)Vo

CP~ Ifo~IM~ll1c ~

116P ]o1612Glb

]o1121c3 lC1r)~

1J6amp ~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt

u-o lJtO t6 x lJtO t6

]olJt~ ~1l-t ]oh1l6fC bull

~bll1c 1l-tlb1gt M~Ft

t~16

fol16~fo f6 1gt]0 lJt~

1gtl1c 1gtc12~ 1J61fo12

~bll1c 1l-tlb c~ lel~1HI)

ll-t]oU~ 31M ]orIQ6fC bull

1tlc~ l]o~cl~crc I ~ ~16 tlclg 16 1gtl-tlle

12

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 26: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

cUctltflct B~~ ctcuil3U ~ijai~w ~l~l WijttUl~ $ll- lUlci1 Jlll-lail (ampct l-ll~ (ClBlttail

Bll-ll-lL l-lpoundpound B~~ ~ijai~W I1-l~l ~cu~ai ~ll~Bll-l B~cUl-lL UlQ u~ ttrn Ul -yl-ll~

qUlct~ ct~l qlt-laioj -lLC-ai ai B~ ct1 ~(-(-l BltABc~ m~ tttl ~~Ulct B~ ~lBl~ gt~ pound~ l-lL~

ltAqLamp ~C-(-L ltAqC-aU ~B(-ai tt(l(ctaU (l4ltJll-lL tttL ttLl(- B~cUl-lL Ulq~

~at 8tct~qLSL J)Ll-l

Lilt-lL-lct B~~

ctlclBl (lcUpound ~

~cltl 0-laiLttBl6L

ctl~ut (h9OS~09tt

~ UltSca ltfi~fl

-yLS~B UBl~ ~41WvD

-lL(-ai ~ u~ tt~ ttRtq3U

Jj~~lct -y~1ttL rotciltl uUSaiL

-y(ctrot

L~otSl~ UB ~C-(-L l~~c3U

0-laiLttBL6l

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 27: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

ANNEXURE - C amp 0

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 28: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

ANNEXURE - C amp D

A statement showing response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons having plausible stake in the environmental aspects (Annexure - Cl) amp replied (Annexure- Dl) by the project proponent Mis Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd

I Sr No

Response amp comments received in writing from other concern persons

Response given by Project proponent

Remarks

1 Shri Mahesh Pandya Letter No PM MP258420 15 dated 09062015

Vide letter dated 170612015

I Annexure C 1

I Annexure Dl

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 29: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

PARYAVARAN MITRA (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax ~ (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email paryavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

Ref PMIMP1258412015 Date 09062015

To

Shri Hardik shah

Member Secretary

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Gandhinagar

Sub EPH of MIs Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha

Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district on June 17 2015

Sir

Ve have studied the draft ErA report of the above-mentioned project Following are our

observationcommentsquestions regarding project and draft ErA report

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of each samples of ambient air water noise and

soil monitoring rather than mentioning study period as post monsoon 2014

2 ErA report mention baseline environmental scenario for the area It is our strong demand

that post project monitoring of air water and soil sample must be carried out so that

actual damage can be assessed

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge contaminated soil and drilling mud in each well

4 Vhat measures vill be taken to ensure that the air emissions and noise from vehicular

movement generators does not disturb the local flora and fauna

5 What will be the effect on groundwater and how will it be remediated if it IS

contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that - Chemicals used in drilling fluid makeup

a Provide name of these chemicals and possibility of toxicity and heavy metals

in it

b How will these chemical affect the local communities and the environment

7 Please give name ofTSDF site where Hazardous waste I oil sludge will be disposed

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to whom spent oil will be sent

0

sil(~j ~

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 30: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

PARYAVARAN MlIt(A (JANVIKAS)

502 Raj Avenue Bhaikaka Nagar Road Nr Thaltej Cross Road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380 059 Telefax - (079) 26851321 bull Phone (079) 26851801

Email parvavaranmitrayahoocom Website httpparyavaranmitraorgin

9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon would be found in any well for how long temporary acquisition of land will continue

10 Whether any temporary relocation of surrounding population has been involved if commercial level hydrocarbon found out

11 How many local people will get employment through this proposed project

12 What types of the socio-economic development activities industry will take up as a part of CSR activity

Yourstrul~

Mahesh Pandya

CC I Collector Banaskantha Palanpur

2 Regional officer GPCB Palanpur

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 31: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN~ VADODARA GUJARATonoc

To

Shri Mahesh Pandya Paryavaran Mitra 502 Raj Avenue Bhaikakanagar road Thaltej Ahmedabad - 380059 Telefax - 079-26851321

Sub EPH of Ms Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited At Districts Banaskatha Gandhinagar amp Ahmedabad- Gujarat for part of Banaskantha district to be held on June 17 2015

Ref Your letter vide Reference PMMP25842015 dated Ogth June 2015

Sir

Point wise reply to your observationcommentsquestions are as belowshy

rSr I Query I ONGCs Response N0

1 Please give exact dates of monitoring of The dates of air monitoring are given in each samples of ambient air water noise Annexure 3 of EIA report and for water noise and soil monitoring rather than mentioning and soil monitoring dates are given in Chapter 4 study period as post monsoon 2014 in Table 424 amp 428 Table 414 Table 418

I resQectively 2 EIA report mention baseline environmental Apart from baseline assessment of various

scenario for the area It is our strong parameters related with land water and air demand that post project monitoring of air environment stack monitoring ambient air water and soil sample must be carried out quality monitoring noise and vibration monitoring so that actual damage can be assessed etc are carried out on half yearly basis at drill

sites through competent third party and six monthly returns are filled to MoEF Bhopal in comQliance to EC stipulations

3 How to dispose wastewater sludge Waste water shall be collected in HOPE lined pit contaminated soil and drilling mud in each for solar evaporation drill cutting shall be well disposed in accordance to MoEF GSR 546 (E) 30th

August 2005 guideline and waste drill mud will be recycled to the extent possible

4 What measures will be taken to ensure that Adequate stack height and acoustic enclosure the air emissions and noise from vehicular shall be provided to DG and all vehicles will be movement generators does not disturb the properly maintained

Ilocal flora and fauna 5 What will be the effect on groundwater and ONGC adopt two three casing policy due to

how will it be remediated if it is which ground water do not get disturbed contaminated

6 Section 172 indicates that Chemicals Water based mud will be used I used in drilling fluid makeuQ _____-- __________________

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 32: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED WESTERN ONSHORE BASIN

VADODARA GUJARAT

IA Provide name of these chemicals and I None I

B possibility of toxiclty and heavy metals in it How will these chemical affect the 10caTI o~nl-y-re-q-u-ir-e--d-q-u-an-t-it--ie-s-s--ha-I-I-be-m-a-d-e-a-va-i-la-bl-e----1

communities and the environment at site and all chemicals are inert and nonshy

7 ihazardous Please give name of TSDF site where Hazardous waste oil sludge generated at site Hazardous waste oil sludge will be shall be disposed as per Hazardous Waste Rules d d d d h is pose 2008 amen e till date

8 Please give name of authorized recyclers to Spent oil will be sent to authorized recyclers as I i whom spent oil will be sent per Hazardous Waste Rules 2008 amended till

date 9 If commercial level oil or other hydrocarbon Minimum most land necessary to maintain well

would be found in any well for how long operations at drill sites is retained by ONGC once temporary acquisition of land will continue drilling activities are over and if found producing

land will be acquired permanently 10 Whether any temporary relocation of No relocation of local population happens as

surrounding population has been involved if petroleum and gas produced through well are commercial level hydrocarbon found out transported to nearby processing installation

I either through underground pipeline or road tankers

11 How many local people will get employment Total 30-40 people shall be employed at site through this ~roposed project I among them few will be from local

I J

12 What types of the socio-economic Various component covered under CSR are development activities industry will take up education including vocational training as a part of CSR activity healthcare entrepreneurship infrastructure

support environmental protection women1s employment promotional of sports and water management I

Hope the above things are as per your requirements

ForONGC Yours truly

M KGarg CE (P) ONGe WOB

Page 33: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REGIONAL OFFICE, GANDHINAGAR c/o, "Paryavaran Bhavan"

Sustainability andBiodiversity - Paryavaran Mitra

Sustainability andBiodiversity - Paryavaran Mitra

Gujarat Pollution Control Board · 6. Regional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Gandhinagar, C/o. “Paryavaran Bhavan”, Sector-10A, Gandhinagar -382 010. Other concerned

Gujarat Pollution Control Board · 6. Regional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Gandhinagar, C/o. “Paryavaran Bhavan”, Sector-10A, Gandhinagar -382 010. Other concerned

 · 2018-04-03 · -torrent- trc / hse / gpcb / 2017 / 25 09th june 2017 to, bmw gujarat pollution control board paryavaran bhavan", sector — 1 oa, - 382 010. sub.: annual report

 · 2018-04-03 · -torrent- trc / hse / gpcb / 2017 / 25 09th june 2017 to, bmw gujarat pollution control board paryavaran bhavan", sector — 1 oa, - 382 010. sub.: annual report

· PDF fileParyavaran Parisar, E-5. Arera Colony Bhopal-4620 16 ... Control Board, Paryavaran Parisar, E-5. Arera ... Pollution Control Board, Paryavaran Parisar,

· PDF fileParyavaran Parisar, E-5. Arera Colony Bhopal-4620 16 ... Control Board, Paryavaran Parisar, E-5. Arera ... Pollution Control Board, Paryavaran Parisar,

PDF - Gujarat Pollution Control Boardgpcb.gov.in/pdf/green-gujarat.pdfthe in the paradigm by Gujarat governance. "Gujarat Control aims at all round capabilities to protect the environment

PDF - Gujarat Pollution Control Boardgpcb.gov.in/pdf/green-gujarat.pdfthe in the paradigm by Gujarat governance. "Gujarat Control aims at all round capabilities to protect the environment

Full page photo - Gujarat Pollution Control Board · 2018-07-26 · West Zone). Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan. E-5, Arera Colony, link Road-3- Nagar. Bhopal -462016 Office. GPCB Mehsana,

Full page photo - Gujarat Pollution Control Board · 2018-07-26 · West Zone). Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan. E-5, Arera Colony, link Road-3- Nagar. Bhopal -462016 Office. GPCB Mehsana,

Gujarat Pollution Control Board - indiaenvironmentportal · Gujarat Pollution Control Board . Paryavaran Bhavan, Sector-10A, Gandhinagar . INDEX . FOREWORD. 2 . Chapter – 1 . 3-17

Gujarat Pollution Control Board - indiaenvironmentportal · Gujarat Pollution Control Board . Paryavaran Bhavan, Sector-10A, Gandhinagar . INDEX . FOREWORD. 2 . Chapter – 1 . 3-17

Biomedical Waste Management Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Biomedical Waste Management Gujarat Pollution Control Board

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTHOL BOARD - Ami Lifescience

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTHOL BOARD - Ami Lifescience

Full page photo - HPCL Clearance.pdf · Paryavaran Parisar, E-5. Arera Colony Bhopal-4620 16 ... Wing Madhya Pradesh Pollution Control Board. Paryavaran Parisar, ... Planning, Bhopal,

Full page photo - HPCL Clearance.pdf · Paryavaran Parisar, E-5. Arera Colony Bhopal-4620 16 ... Wing Madhya Pradesh Pollution Control Board. Paryavaran Parisar, ... Planning, Bhopal,

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD-~ REGIONAL OFFICE 203-205, BBlock,Sardar Patel Bhavan,

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD - …environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/Public Hearing...GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD-~ REGIONAL OFFICE 203-205, BBlock,Sardar Patel Bhavan,

Aapala Paryavaran March 2016

Aapala Paryavaran March 2016

chandigarhenvis.gov.inchandigarhenvis.gov.in/beta/departments/cpcc/New Categ0001.pdf · CHANDIGARH POLLUTION CONTROL COMMITTEE PARYAVARAN BHAWAN, MADHYA MARG, SECTOR 19-B, CHANDIGARH.

chandigarhenvis.gov.inchandigarhenvis.gov.in/beta/departments/cpcc/New Categ0001.pdf · CHANDIGARH POLLUTION CONTROL COMMITTEE PARYAVARAN BHAWAN, MADHYA MARG, SECTOR 19-B, CHANDIGARH.

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDgpcb.gov.in/pdf/Gujarat_Helogen_Petro_Co_PH_MIN_PRO.pdf · REGIONAL OFFICE, NADIAD GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD 201-203, "B" Block, Sardar Patel

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDgpcb.gov.in/pdf/Gujarat_Helogen_Petro_Co_PH_MIN_PRO.pdf · REGIONAL OFFICE, NADIAD GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD 201-203, "B" Block, Sardar Patel

Gujarat Pollution Control Board · 2016-05-03 · l Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office Sardar Patel Commercial Complex, namesnwemaqer, Bedi Bander Road, Jamnagar-361008.

Gujarat Pollution Control Board · 2016-05-03 · l Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office Sardar Patel Commercial Complex, namesnwemaqer, Bedi Bander Road, Jamnagar-361008.

Gujarat Technological University DSTU... · 2015-10-21 · Gujarat Technological University Minutes of meeting on fifth DSTU meeting held on 18th May, 2013 at Paryavaran Mandir, Ahmedabad

Gujarat Technological University DSTU... · 2015-10-21 · Gujarat Technological University Minutes of meeting on fifth DSTU meeting held on 18th May, 2013 at Paryavaran Mandir, Ahmedabad

Gujarat Pollution Control Board...Gujarat Pollution Control Board :Regional Offi ce-Bharuch As per the provision of Notification No. S.O. I533, dated 1410912006 and its subsequent

Gujarat Pollution Control Board...Gujarat Pollution Control Board :Regional Offi ce-Bharuch As per the provision of Notification No. S.O. I533, dated 1410912006 and its subsequent

MINUTES OF THE 217th MEETING OF THE STATE LEVEL … Minutes of the 217th.pdf · GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD, GANDHINAGAR ... December, 2014 at Committee Room, Gujarat Pollution

MINUTES OF THE 217th MEETING OF THE STATE LEVEL … Minutes of the 217th.pdf · GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD, GANDHINAGAR ... December, 2014 at Committee Room, Gujarat Pollution

M.P Pollution Control Board ,Bhopal 12-12-2018.pdfMADHYA PRADESH POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Paryavaran Parisar" E-5 Arera Colony, Bhopal- 462616 Phone : (0755)2464428, 2466191 Fax : 0755

M.P Pollution Control Board ,Bhopal 12-12-2018.pdfMADHYA PRADESH POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Paryavaran Parisar" E-5 Arera Colony, Bhopal- 462616 Phone : (0755)2464428, 2466191 Fax : 0755

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDgpcb.gov.in/pdf/Solaris_Chemtech_Limited_PH_MIN_PRO.pdfRegional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, GERI Compound, Race Course, Vadodara - 390007

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDgpcb.gov.in/pdf/Solaris_Chemtech_Limited_PH_MIN_PRO.pdfRegional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, GERI Compound, Race Course, Vadodara - 390007