GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. ·...
Transcript of GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. ·...
![Page 1: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Governing Non-‐Tradi/onal Security, Rescaling the State in
Southeast Asia
Dr Lee Jones
![Page 2: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
• w/ Shahar Hameiri (Murdoch); ARC/ ESRC
• Defini;on of NTS
Star;ng ‘puzzle’: • Mul;tude of apparently ‘securi;sed’ NTS threats, but their governance varies wildly... some;mes non-‐existent!
![Page 3: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
SEA & NTS: a dismal record?
“there is no longer any excuse... it is ;me to put more effort into implemen;ng
[policies]... conven;onal responses are no longer adequate” (p.290)
• So, contra Copenhagen School, no necessary link between discursive securi;sa;on and security governance. Func;onalism also doesn’t work. • Typically a]ributed to ASEAN’s resistance to encroachments on sovereignty. But is there more going on? We think so...
![Page 4: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
The State Transforma;on Approach (1)
• Crucial characteris;c of NTS threats: border-‐spanning; problema;se ‘na;onal’ governance; appropriate scale open-‐ended.
• Predominant mode of governance ≠ shic from states to suprana;onal organisa;ons, but state transforma0on. – Focus on apparatuses tasked w/ specific issue – Transform to impose interna;onal disciplines – Network into mul;level governance
![Page 5: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
The State Transforma;on Approach (2)
• An a]empt to empower technocrats and circumvent poli;cs... But not so simple! – State ins;tu;ons distribute power, resources à their transforma;on is contested
– Di]o different scalar arrangements – Contesta;on = socio-‐poli;cal coali;ons, rooted in poli;cal economy of issue area • Power and organisa;on of industry interests • Access to state crucial: states as ‘scale managers’
– May focus on degree of rescaling, or opera;on of rescaled state apparatuses
![Page 6: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
The State Transforma;on Approach (3)
• Thus, NTS governance reflects con;ngent outcome of social conflicts over state transforma;on and rescaling
• Cases – Environmental degrada;on: the haze – Pandemic disease: avian influenza – Transna;onal crime: money laundering and terrorist financing
![Page 7: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
![Page 8: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
![Page 9: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
• h]p://news.asiaone.com/A1MEDIA/news/01Jan13/images/20130114.095312_afp_haze.jpg
![Page 10: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Governing the Haze
• General view: despite securi;sa;on, ASEAN didn’t establish suprana;onal authority à failure
• Our argument: – ASEAN pursued ‘regulatory regionalism’, not suprana;onal authority
– This has led to substan;al state transforma;on – But rescaling of governance is contested • Resistance at na;onal and local levels, rooted in poli;cal economy of forestry/ planta;ons • Corrup;on/ deflec;on of rescaled apparatuses towards small-‐scale farmers
![Page 11: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
![Page 12: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
![Page 13: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
ASEAN’s Haze Governance
• Focus on local capacity building • Interes;ng interven;ons by Singaporean and Malaysian environment ministries
![Page 14: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Explaining Outcomes (1)
• The Indonesian Context – Poli;cal economy of forestry and planta;ons
• NB role of Singaporean and Malaysian firms; impact on govt-‐govt level
– Decentralisa;on • Impact on NTS governance – General lack of law enforcement – PO industry influence à na;onal-‐level resistance
![Page 15: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Explaining Outcomes (2)
– Impact of decentralisa;on • MoE loss of line authority • Local priori;sa;on of business over environment à underfunding of an;-‐haze apparatuses • Constraint of rescaled ASEAN ins;tu;ons by local and na;onal power rela;ons
– Net result: deflec;on onto the poor, weak à irra;onal and counterproduc;ve outcome
![Page 16: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Conclusion / Q&A
• As security is becoming non-‐tradi;onal, so are states! But despite a]empts to empower technocrats, power and conflict determine outcomes.
• Other cases: avian influenza; money laundering and terrorist financing.
• [email protected] / [email protected] / @DrLeeJones
![Page 17: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
FATF/ An; Money Laundering
![Page 18: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Avian Influenza (Before)
![Page 19: GoverningNonTradional) Security,)Rescaling)the)State)in) … · 2018. 5. 14. · Governing#the#Haze# • General#view:#despite#securi;saon,#ASEAN# didn’testablish#supranaonal#authority#](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051806/5ffcc072eab3fa0d685cfb76/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Avian Influenza (Acer)