FINAL REVIEW REPORT FOR THE MURRAY-DARLING BASIN AUTHORITY ... · 19 of 27 Sept MDBA report....
Transcript of FINAL REVIEW REPORT FOR THE MURRAY-DARLING BASIN AUTHORITY ... · 19 of 27 Sept MDBA report....
FINAL REVIEW REPORT
FOR THE MURRAY-DARLING BASIN AUTHORITY (MDBA)
AN INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC
MODELLING INPUTS TO THE NORTHERN BASIN REVIEW
RFQ Nos: MD3480 & MD003604
12 October 2016
Prepared by Dr Boyd Blackwell1, Mr Jim McFarlane1, & Mr Richard Stayner2
1. UNE Business School, University of New England
2. Institute for Rural Futures, University of New England
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
2
©2016Blackwell,McFarlaneandStaynerUniversityofNewEngland,ArmidaleNSW2350Sourcesoffiguresfrontpage:Fromtoprightclockwisewww.mdba.gov.au/basin-plan-roll-out/northern-basinMDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,FinalReport,27Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA.MDBA.(2015).FishandFlowsintheNorthernBasin:ResponsesofFishtoChangesinFlowintheNorthernMurray-DarlingBasin.Canberra:MDBA.Retrievedfromhttp://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/2555%20-%20Fish%20and%20Flows%20in%20the%20Northern%20Basin%20Stage%203%20Final%20Report%20August%202015%20-%20Executive%20Summary.pdfBettles,Colin.(2015,29September).CountingBasinPlan'sSocialCosts.TheLand.Retrievedfromhttp://www.theland.com.au/story/3388655/counting-basin-plans-social-costs/?cs=4963Asuitablereferenceforthisreportis:Blackwell,Boyd,McFarlane,JimandStayner,Richard(2016).FinalReviewReportFortheMurray-DarlingBasinAuthority(MDBA):AnIndependentReviewoftheSocialandEconomicModellingInputstotheNorthernBasinReview,12October2016.Armidale:UniversityofNewEngland.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
3
TableofContents1. ExecutiveSummary..........................................................................................................4
Overallviewofmodelling...........................................................................................................4Socialandeconomicmodelling..................................................................................................4CommunityConsultationReport................................................................................................6LowerBalonnefloodplaingraziersmodellingreport.................................................................9
2. Introduction...................................................................................................................11Backgroundandcontext...........................................................................................................11Materialsprovidedandimplicationsforreview.......................................................................12Generalapproachtoundertakingmodellingreview................................................................13Outlineofreport.......................................................................................................................16
3. LiteratureReview...........................................................................................................17Globalassessmentofriverbasinwaterproductivity................................................................17Critiqueoftraditionalwaterefficiency.....................................................................................17WaterproductivityintheAustraliancottoncontext................................................................17WorkundertakenbyMDBA......................................................................................................18Regionaleconomicresilience,commuting,andtechnologicalshifts.......................................22Australianwaterpolicyspecificstudies....................................................................................23Internationaleconomicassessmentofwaterreductions.........................................................24Summaryandconclusiononliteraturereview.........................................................................25
4. CommentsonGeneralApproachtoModelling...............................................................28Introduction..............................................................................................................................28Generalapproachandfactorsofproduction...........................................................................28
5. CommentsonSpecificAspectsofModelling...................................................................31Broaderconsiderationofsectorsforregionalandlocaleconomies........................................31UseofABSemploymentdata...................................................................................................31ThelinearrelationshipusedinMDBAwater(ML)toland-usemodelling................................33Relationshipbetweenhectaresandjobs..................................................................................34Longerperiodfordata..............................................................................................................34Referencingofdatasourcesandassumptions.........................................................................34Clearandexplicitpresentationoftheeconometricresults......................................................35Correctionforomittedvariablebias.........................................................................................35Otherreviewercomments........................................................................................................36
6. CommunityConsultationOverModelling.......................................................................37Introduction..............................................................................................................................37Briefreview...............................................................................................................................37
7. LowerBalonneFloodplainGrazierModelling..................................................................40Introduction..............................................................................................................................40ReviewItems.............................................................................................................................42
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
4
1. ExecutiveSummaryOverallviewofmodellingTheMDBAisreviewingthewaterrecoverytargetsfortheNorthernBasinandtoinformtheirdecision-making,inourindependentview,theyhaveundertakenanextensiveseriesofworksonmodellingthesocialandeconomicimpactsofwaterrecoveryfromthecommunitiesoftheNorthernBasin.Theybringthistogetherinaninterimsummaryreport1thatallowsthereaderthentoseetheextentofworkandthekeyassumptionsandresults,whileatthesametimeifrequired,beingabletodrilldeeperintothedetailoftheaccompanyingreports.2Undertakingthismodellingworkisnoeasytask,givendatalimitationsandmethodologicalhurdles,howeverweareconfidentthatthroughourreviewprocess,theMDBAhaveshownawillingnesstorefineandenhancetheirmodellingbytakingonboardthemajorityofourimprovementrecommendations,ifnotintheshorttermduetotimeconstraints,thenaspartoftheirmediumtolongertermplannedworkprogram.WearealsoinagreementwiththeMDBAsoverallapproachtotheuseofthemodellingwork,andrefertoFeldstein’squotethat“ausefulmodelisnotonethatis‘true’or‘realistic’butonethatisparsimonious,plausibleandinformative”.3Becauseofthisinherentlimitationinallmodels,theMDBAhasabroadrangeofsupportingsocial,economic,contextualandlocalinformationthatispresentedandshouldbedulyconsideredalongwiththemodellingoutputsinreachinganygivendecision.Similarly,noruralcommunityexistsina‘stablestate’ofperfectpredictability,butisadynamicallycomplexsystemthatisinacontinualstateofadjustmenttosomesocio-economicchangeoranother.Havingahealthyappreciationofthiscomplexity,suchasbyunderstandingthateachcommunityhasadifferentadaptivecapacitytochange,showsthattheMDBA’smodellingandsupportinginformationaretogethercriticaltomakingdecisionsoverwaterwithdrawals.SocialandeconomicmodellingTheMDBAhaveprogressedtheirsocialandeconomicmodellingworkfortheNorthernBasincommunitiesbyusingthekeyindicatorforsocialandeconomicwellbeingforcommunities:employment.Aspartourindependentreviewwehavemade14recommendations(notedinthemaintextofthisreportasRecommendation#andinyellowhighlights)whereinouropiniontheMDBAwasabletoimproveitsmodellingwork.Theserecommendationsshouldbetemperedbyourthreecaveatsorfindings(alsonotedinthemainbodytextasFinding/Caveat#inbluehighlights).Table1summarisesourrecommendationsanddocumentshowtheMDBA,inconjunctionwithKPMG,havefolloweduponthemajorityoftheserecommendationsasnotedinthefinaltwocolumnsinredorsubsequentlyingreen.Table1:Summaryofrecommendationsandfindingsorcaveats,andresponseperiod(Sourceandnotes:seeRecommendation#orFinding/Caveat#intext;*meansimportantmatterstoaddress)Recommendation#• Finding/Caveat#
Detail ShorttermMDBAresponseandsubsequentresponse,subsequentresponse
MediumtolongtermMDBAresponseandsubsequentresponse,subsequentresponse
R1 Considerationofwaterwithdrawalimpactsonotherfactorsofproduction
✔ Atleasttobediscussed✔
4 ✔ andaddressedonpp.8-9,
19of27SeptMDBAreport.
✔ Ongoingworkprogramcouldincorporatethetechnicalinclusionoffactor
1MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewoftheSocioeconomcAnalysis,DraftInterimReport,27Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA.2Forexample,KPMG.(2016).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,16August2016DraftReport.Sydney:KPMG.3Feldstein,Martin.(1982).Inflation,TaxRulesandInvestment:SomeEconometricEvidence,The1980Fisher-SchultzLectureoftheEconometricSociety,Econometrica50(4),825-862,p.829.http://www.jstor.org/stable/19127664KPMG.(2016).pp.18-19.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
5
Recommendation#• Finding/Caveat#
Detail ShorttermMDBAresponseandsubsequentresponse,subsequentresponse
MediumtolongtermMDBAresponseandsubsequentresponse,subsequentresponse
tolabour,likelandandcapital
impactsandsubstitutability.✔ Responsivewagedatamayhelpcapturesubstitutioneffects5
R2 Theneedtoattachmonetaryvaluesviaimpactsonreturnstofactorsofproductionortheassetvaluesofthesefactors
✔ Atleasttobediscussed✔ asabove–assetvaluesnotexplicitlyaddressedthoughmentionede.g.p.17KPMGreport✔ andaddressedonpp.8-9,19of27SeptMDBAreport.
✔ Ongoingworkprogramcouldincorporatetheinclusionofmonetaryvaluesforfactorimpacts✔ asabove–assetvaluesnotexplicitlyassessedthoughmentionede.g.p.17KPMGreport,
• F/C1 Exogenousfactorsmayhaveagreaterinfluenceonfactorimpacts,substitutability,returnsandassetsvalues
✖ Ifsuchacasecanbeproven,Nil;MDBAhavecapturedthenuboftheissueceterisparibus✔ AddressedinMDBAreporte.g.p.2,27Sep2016version
?Influencescouldbetemporallycontrolledforandmonitored
• F/C2 Jobsonlycapturespartofthesocialandeconomicimpactpicture
SeeR1&2above SeeR1&2above
R3 Incorporationofrelativeemploymentmeasuresintothemodelling
✖ (Currentlyas%oftotalemploymentsufficient)✔
✔ Areviewtoidentifymostdesirablerelativeemploymentmeasurese.g.employmentconcentration,utilizationcombinedwithStenekesetal.6✔ notedonp.33ofKPMGreport
• F/C3 Joblosseslikelytobeoverestimated7duetoimpactsoftechnology(e.g.GMcotton)andsubstitutionoflabourwithcapital
✔ Canbenotedassuch✖notexplicitlyaddressed:substitutiondiscussedp.19ofKPMGreport,thoughdiscussedasdriverofchangeonp.20ofMDBAreport.8✔–counterreasonsforunderestimationnowincludedin27SeptMDBAreport,pp.18-19
✔ Couldbeexplicitlyaddressedinongoingmonitoringandevaluation✖(NeedasectionlikeinKPMGreportaboutfuturework)✔–futureworksectionnowincluded
R4 Greaterexplicitbreakdownofemploymentimpactsby720industrialsubsectorsforeachcommunity
✔ Willbetterinformagreementmakingbyhelpingstakeholderswithfocusingadaptationresponses✔ notedresultsbasedon720;MDBA,p.15and✖ MDBAbreakdowncouldbeprovidedwhererequestedbycommunity.
R5 Mappingofspatialimpacts ?Thoughveryusefulinhelpingreachagreement,timeframeslikelytobetooshort
✔ ✖recommendationstillstandstobeaddressed.Couldbeincludedinpossiblefuturework
R6 Identifyspatialemploymentimpactsthroughvarioustypesofemployment(local,inbound,andoutbound,microsubsectorsources)
?SeeR7whereinsufficienttimetodothis,thoughdoingsocouldeasedecision/agreement-making
✔ ✖recommendationstillstandstobeaddressed.Couldbeincludedinpossiblefuturework
R7 SourceofABSemploymentdataandhowitwas
✔ importanttoprovideanearlyindicationofspatialconsequencesofjoblosses,orto
5KPMG.(2016).p.33.6Stenekes,N,Kancans,R,Randall,L,Lawson,K,Reeve,I,&Stayner,R.(2012).RevisedIndicatorsofCommunityVulnerabilityandAdaptiveCapacityAcrosstheMurray-DarlingBasin:AFocusonIrrigationinAgriculture.Canberra:ABARES.http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/1715-Revised-indicators-of-community-vulnerability.pdf7Seepreviousfootnoteaboutcaseswherejobsmayalsobeoverestimated.8MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
6
Recommendation#• Finding/Caveat#
Detail ShorttermMDBAresponseandsubsequentresponse,subsequentresponse
MediumtolongtermMDBAresponseandsubsequentresponse,subsequentresponse
extractedneedstobediscussed
providecaveatsondegreeofoverorunderestimation ✖notyetdiscussedinMDBAorKPMGreports.✔–nowidentifiedasPlaceofUsualResidencee.g.p.19of27SeptMDBAreport
R8 Relationshipbetweenwateruseandyield
✔ Asperbelow✔ nowexplainedthoughourviewisthattheunderlyingseriesistimedependent
R9 Relationshipbetweenhectaresandjobsneedsasuitabletransformationandalagofdependentvariableasexplanatoryvariable
✔ Standardstatisticalpracticeswithtimeseries(orpanel)data✔ nowexplainedinMDBAreportthoughourviewisthattheunderlyingseriesistimedependent
R10 Obtainalongerperiodforthedata,i.e.largernumberofobservations
✔ (toimprovethestatisticalpowerofthemodelling)✔ nowexplainedinKPMGreportp.5thatlimitedbyverysmallnumberofobservations
R11 Referencingofdatasourcesandassumptionsinmodellingspreadsheetsand‘groundtruthing’datawithstakeholderse.g.industry
✔ ✔ nowdetailedandhaveundertakencommunityconsultation(MDBA,p.8)–itisnotwithinthereview’sscopetoverifytheveracityofthisconsultation
R12 Clearandexplicitpresentationofstatisticalresultsofmodellingincludingstandarddiagnostictesting
✔ ✔ nowdetailedinreporting,includingautocorrelationasatimeseriesdiagnosticaltestwithexplanationgiven9
R13 Inclusionorresultsofpotentialomittedexplanatoryvariablesinregressions
✔ Otherwiseresultscouldbemisinformingorinsufficientlydocumented.✔ reportingnowexplainsprocessundertakentocheckforomittedvariables
R14 Otherreviewercomments ✔ Havenotcheckedforthese;thesearelefttoMDBAtoaddress.Thesearenotwithinthescopeofourtermsofreference
Asshowninthetable,anumberofopportunitiesexistfortheMDBAtobetterpresentresultstotheaffectedcommunitiesaspartoftheirongoingworkprogram,includingaspartoftheirmonitoringandevaluationframework,particularlythroughtheadditionofasectionintheirsummaryreportofplannedfuturework(F/C3)asKPMGhaveintheirdraftreport.Thisfutureworkcouldincludespatialmappingofimpactsandbetteraccountingforleakageintheemploymentimpactanalysis.Thereportshavebeenimmediatelyimprovedbyprovidingabriefdescriptionofthetypeofsourceofemploymentdataprimarilyused,thatis,placeofusualresidenceisusedratherthanplaceofworkorplaceofenumeration(R7).WhilewewouldliketoseeamoredetailedbreakdownofimpactedindustrialsectorstohelpwithcommunityadaptationandeconomicplanningwearesatisfiedwithhowtheMDBAorKPMGhaveaddressedourpriorconcerns.CommunityConsultationReportInadditionwereviewedtheMDBAconsultationreportandsummarisetheoutstandingissuesinTable2.Thefullreviewcanbereadinsection6ofthisreport.Ofnote,realestatevaluechanges,accountingorplanningforlagtimesfornewindustriestostart-up,costsbeinggreaterthanbenefits,significanceofimpactsontownsandbusinessesfrombuybacks,andthefactthatlocalirrigatorsdonotwanttoselltheirwaterneedtoallbeaddressedintheMDBA’s(orKPMG)modellingreporting.9MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewoftheSocioeconomcAnalysis,DraftInterimReport,10Oct2016.Canberra:MDBA,pp.14-15.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
7
Table2:IssuesraisedthroughCommunityConsultationPhase210IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse Ourresponse(subsequent)
DataandInformation
CCI1 Datapaucity MDBAaskedhowhandingdatagapspost2011.
ConstrainedbyABScensusyears–2011mostrecent(2016inprogress,availablemid2017&willbeincludedinfuturereports)yetsupplementedthrough(i)annualABSagand(ii)ABARESfarmsurveysand(iii)AustralianCollaborativeLandUseandManagementProgramMay2016updateaswellasTownsend(iv)talkingwithlocalfarmers,businessesandpeopleinthecommunity.
✔MDBAresponsevalid,except(iv)whileprovidingcontextcannot,aspresented,bevalidatedasrepresentative✖
CCI2 Jobnumbers Preferenceforactualjobnumbersratherthanpercentagechange
Incorporatedintoanalysis ✔
CCI3 Full-timeequivalents(FTEs)versusemploymentlevels
EmploymenthaslowcorrelationwithFTEs:PeaksandtroughsnotcapturedbyFTEs.
Variabilitytakenintoaccountinanalysis
✔
CCI4 Realestatevaluechanges
Whynotincludedintheanalysis?
(Noresponseprovided) ✖ ShouldbeaddressedbyMDBA,similartoourcommentinregardstoaccountingforsubstitutionbetweenfactorsofproduction:Land,LabourandCapital.✔ nowaddressedonp.19of27SeptMDBAreport.
Impactlagtime
CCI5 Impactsfrompreviousbuybacksstillflowingthroughcommunities
Dirranbandiusedasaanexample
Seebelow Seebelow
CCI6 Lagtimefornewindustriestostart-up
Temporalnatureofimpactsandconsequencesforclosuresandstart-upsneedsgreaterconsideration
Lagtimelikelytobe2-5yearsforadaptationoradjustmenttowaterrecoveryshock.Wheretownsarelookingtonewindustriesandinnovation,theyshoulddiscussbroadrangeofissuesincluding:credit,supply,andfarm-townconnections.
✖ Theanalysisshouldincorporateatleastsomediscussionoftemporalimpacts–atleastshorttermandintermediatetolongerterm.
ManagementofBusinessandCommunityDiversityandConnectivity
CCI7 Communityboundaries
WhydidtheyusethosedifferenttoABS?
BecauseboundarieswereestablishedbasedontakingaccountofthediverseeconomyandcommunitycontextforeachBrokenlinesindicateconnectivitybetween
✔ butnotedifficultlyforthirdpartytoreproduceresultswithoutconversionofstandarddatatonewboundaries
10ThistableprovidesasummaryofMDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReviewPhase2EngagementProgram:CommunityMeetings,July2016.Canberra:MDBA.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
8
IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse Ourresponse(subsequent)
communitiesandmorebroadly–demarcationalwaysdifficult.
CCI8 Noagandagbusinessrelationship
Arenotallindustriesconnectedanddependentonaginsmallagtowns?
Nonagincludes:hairdressers,retailandaccommodation.Appreciatethesearen’tunrelatedtoagesp.insmalltowns.KPMGmodellingdesignedtoaccountfortheserelationships.
✔ again,sometimesdemarcationdifficultbuthastobedone.
CCI9 StructuralchangesinStGeorge
Resultedinislessdiversityofbusinesses
(Noresponseprovided)
Buybacksversusadditionalinfrastructureinvestment
CCI10(i)
Buybacks–v-infrastructurehavedifferentimpacts
TheseneedtobeunderstoodbyMDBA
(Noresponsenecessary–seebelow.)
NA
(ii) Coststocommunitiesgreaterthanwhatpresented
Whynotafullcost-benefitanalysis?
(Nodirectresponseprovided) ✖ Needstobeexplicitlyaddressed.✔ Nowaddressedonp.7ofMDBA27Sepreport:limitedinformationtodoso,wouldrequirevaluejudgments,andmonetizationmayobscuresocialandeconomicrelationshipoutcomes.
(iii) Significantimpactsontownsandbusinessesfrombuybacks
HowisMDBArespondingtothis?
(Nodirectresponseprovided) ✖ Needstobeexplicitlyaddressed
(iv) Localirrigatorsdonotwanttoselltheirwater
ReasonwhyAustralianGovernmentisprioritizinginfrastructurespendingoverbuybacks11
ImplicitreferencetoAustralianGovernmentWaterRecoveryStrategy?
✔ WhilestrategysetsoutGovernment’sstrategydoesthisaddresscommunityconcernsandideologicaldividebetweensavingwaterfortheenvironmentthroughbuy-backsandcreatingmorewaterforgrowersthroughinfrastructureinvestment?Thereisacaponwaterbuy-backsandplanforinvestment.✖
Climatevariabilityandchange
CCI11 Impactofdrought
Discussed Modellingthroughscenariostakesalong-termviewtotakeaccountofarangeofpressures,incl.drought,whichcommunitiesneedtomanage.MDBApresentedshiftsindeclineincasuallabour,changeinagestructure,impactsonbusinessresultingfromdroughtovertime
✔
CCI12 Climatechangeimpactsoncommunity
Havethesebeenincluded?
Hydrologicalmodellingdoesnotincorporateclimatechangescenariosratherincorporatesarangeofhistoricalclimateconditions12thatmorethanadequatelycapturesaverageclimate
✔
11DepartmentofEnvironment.(2014).WaterRecoveryStrategyfortheMurray-DarlingBasin,June2014.Canberra:CommonwealthofAustralia.Retrievedfromhttp://www.environment.gov.au/system/files/resources/4ccb1c76-655b-4380-8e94-419185d5c777/files/water-recovery-strategy-mdb2.pdf12MDBA.(2012).HydrologicalModellingtoInformtheProposedBasinPlan,February2012.Canberra:MDBA.Retrievedfromhttp://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/pubs/Hydrologic_Modelling_Report.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
9
IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse Ourresponse(subsequent)
changeimpactsonwateravailability.ReferredtoMDBAsapproachtoclimatechange13
Movingforward
CCI13 QldMurray-DarlingCommittee
ComplimentaryaboutworktodateandneedtoworkwithUniversitiesonimpactsforfishandbirds
(Noresponserequired) NA
LowerBalonnefloodplaingraziersmodellingreportFinally,wereviewedthemodellingofimpactsforthefloodplaingraziersintheLowerBalonne.Overallthemodellingappearsthoroughbeingcontextualizedbyconsultationanddiscussionwithgrazierstobetterinterprettheresults;themodellinghasbeenpreparedinasufficientlycomplexwayyetgroundedbyin-builtrulesthatmirrorpracticalgrazierdecision-making.OurconcernswiththemodellingcentreonthatdoneforgrazierearningsassummarizedinTable3butwebelievethesehavebeenrespondedtobytheMDBAasnotedinthetable.Ifnecessary,furtherMDBAmodellingworkinthelonger-termcouldincludethesesuggestions.Table3:SummaryofreviewitemsIssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse(whererelevant,oursuggestion)
GI1 Earningsmodelling–inclusionoffullcosts
Overheadorfixedcostscouldbeincludedintheearningestimatestoprovidenetearnings(toensuregrazierstakeaccountoflandtaxes,capitalassets,managerincome–notedonp.15–andforgoneincometothemselves),however,onlyconsideringthemarginalcostsisaneconomicallyvalidapproachandfixedcostandwealtheffectsareexplicitlynotedasnotincludedinthemodellinginAppendixB,p.43andasalimitation.
✔Floodplainmodelledasasingleunitratherthanforindividualbusiness–toogreatavariation(10-20timessizedifference,smallesttolargest)tomodelatypicalbusinessplusmodellingcomplexities(changesinbusinessstructure/processes)fromwaterchanges)outsidescopeofproject.14
GI2 Earningsmodelling–inclusionofrelevantmarginalcosts
Establishingwhetherfloodplaingrazingisviableshouldincludeconsiderationofallrelevantmarginalcosts(asnotedabove)butalsoforgoneincometograziersthemselves–toensuretheyearnenoughtopaythemselvesfortheirefforts),otherwisetheseco-benefitsofenvironmentalflowsshouldbeseenasco-costs/non-benefitsofwaterfortheenvironment.
✔Labourcosts(variable)explicitlyincludedinmodelling,thoughnot‘forsell-offs’or‘agistmentwhichmostlyinvolveloadingandunloading’stock.15
GI3 Yearlyearningsestimates–incorporationoftimevalueofmoney
Asnotedbyauthoronp.32,theseneedtobesummedovertimebecausetheyaretypicallyearnedatpointsintime.Hastheauthorconsideredtimevalueofmoneyintheirearningsmodelsandifnot,itmaybebettertoconvertannualbenefitstonetpresentvaluestoaccountforthemismatchofcostsandbenefitflowsovertime.
✔Yeswasconsideredthoughresultstobeinterpretedaswhatisexpectednextyearunderthedifferentscenarios,NPVmayconfoundsomeofimportantmessagesaboutsequenceofflowsbecausevolumesnotrandomlydistributedthroughtime,itdoesnotincludecostsandbenefitsforcottonreducedupstreamandisonlyapartialanalysis,andresultsrelatetowholefloodplainandnotindividual
13Neave,I,McLeod,A,Raisin,G,&Swirepik,J.(2015).ManagingwaterintheMurray-DarlingBasinunderavariableandchangingclimate.Water,42(2),102-107.Retrievedfromwww.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/pubs/Managing%20water%20in%20the%20murray-darling%20basin%20under%20variable%20and%20changing%20climate.pdr14Wakerman-Powell(2016)Pers.Comms(Email),16Sep2016,MDBA,Camberra.15Ibid.Wakerman-Powellprovidedspreadsheetmodelthatincludes‘workingcosts’assheepandpricingvariables.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
10
IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse(whererelevant,oursuggestion)
businesses.(Recommendtheinclusionofthesecomplexitiesinfuturemodelling)
GI4 Modeldrivenbywaterinputratherthancommodityprices
Otherfactorsmaydrivegrazierdecisionsmorethanenvironmentalflows,suchascommoditypricesandexchangerates.Wakerman-Powellspecificallynotesthisonp.43ofAppendix,particularlywhereafterdroughtrestockingisassignificanttodecisionmakingasreturnofwater.
Notnecessary
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
11
2. IntroductionBackgroundandcontextThisreportprovidesanindependentreviewofthesocio-economicmodellingundertakenbytheMurray-DarlingBasinAuthority(MDBA)forarangeofwaterscenariosforthe21communitiesoftheNorthernBasinasshowninFigures1and2.Figure1:LocationofNorthernBasincommunities,Qld&NSW,Australia(Source:MDBA201616)
ThisreportfollowsthatwhichwehavepreparedfortheMDBA’ssocio-economicmodellingundertakenfortheStGeorgeandDirranbandi(Hebel)communities.17Bybuildingonthispreviousreport,thecurrentreportincludessomenecessaryduplicationincludingtheliteraturereviewandsomegeneralreviewcommentsfromthepreviousreportwhichremainrelevanttomodellingthe19othercommunities.
16UpdatefromBradley,J.(2016)Pers.Comms(Email),12Oct,Canberra:MDBAofMDBA.(2016).Socialandeconomicchange–Bourke,10Aug2016.PowerPointPresentation.Canberra:MDBA.17Blackwell,Boyd,McFarlane,Jim,&Stayner,Richard.(2016).IndependentReviewofMDBADirranbandi(&Hebel)andStGeorgeSocio-EconomicModellingfortheNorthernBasin:FinalReport23June2016.Armidale:UniversityofNewEngland.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
12
Figure2:MapofNorthernBasinandTributaries(Source:www.agforceqld.org.au)
CopiesofthetermsofreferenceinpreparingthisreportareprovidedinFigure3.MaterialsprovidedandimplicationsforreviewWehavebeenpresentedwithinitialandfinaldraftsanddescriptionsrespectivelyof:
1. the21communityprofilesanddescriptionsaswellas2. thecommunity‘narratives’preparedbyAmandaBarwick3. KPMGmodellingreport184. MDBA’s‘Documentationforthehydrology-landusemodelingreport’andtwosupporting
18VariousdraftsincludingKPMG.(2016a).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,16August2016DraftReport.Sydney:KPMG;andKPMG.(2016b).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,September2016DraftReport.Sydney:KPMG.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
13
modellingsheetsentitled‘NBRhydro-landusemodel’and‘NthBasinrainallocnag’195. MDBA’sPresentation,‘TripleBottomLineAssessmentofSDLsfortheNorthernBasin’206. MDBA’scommunityconsultationreport217. MDBA’sLowerBalonnefloodplaingraziersreport228. MDBAtechnicalsummaryreport239. UniversityofCanberrareport24
thefinalversionsofwhichwehavenotyetseenbutwebelieve1and2provideessentialcontextandadditionstothemainmodelingworkdonethrough3and4fromqualitativeaswellasquantitativeperspectives.ThemarryingofqualitativeandotherquantitativecontextualinformationtothemodellingmeansthattheMDBAisnotrelyingonthemodellingsolely,thoughthishasthepotentialtoaddtoevidenceinsupportingtheirdecisions.Forexample,theMDBAisapplyingtheTripleBottomLine(TBL-5)approachtoitsdecision-making,asdepictedinFigure4.Thecommunityconsultationthathasbeenundertaken(6)iscriticaltohelpaddresscommunityconcernsoverwaterwithdrawals.Waterwithdrawalswouldrarelybeacceptabletoregional,ruralandremotecommunities.However,agreatdealofangstandstresscanbereducedifafairapproachusedtodeterminetheallocationofwithdrawalsamongstcommunities(thoughthisiscomplicatedbythehydrologicalandphysicalconstraintswithinthebasinaswellasenvironmentalflowrequirements)–thatisifproceduraljustice25isfollowed–distributionaljusticeiswhatcommunitiesmaybemostconcernedaboutbutwehavenotbeencommissionedtocommentonthisdirectly–ratherwehavebeenaskedtocommentonthesocialandeconomicmodelling,howitcanbeimprovedandwhethertheMDBAapproachisreasonable.TheMDBAtechnicalsummaryreportisakeytocommunicatingtothepeopleofthe21communitiesthemodellingapproachusedbyMDBAandsynthesisingthefindingsfromthevariousreportsandelementstotheirmodellingapproachfortheNorthernBasin.GeneralapproachtoundertakingmodellingreviewOurgeneralapproachtoassessingthemodellingispresentedinFigure5andentailsassessingthereliabilityandvalidityofthekeylinksordriversbetweenvariouswaterscenarios,allocationstoenvironmentalassetsandproduction,andhowthesewaterinputsarethenusedinproduction(suchasthroughthelandusemodelforDirranbandiandStGeorge),andtheresultingbenefitsthatresultlikeemployment,profitandsocialbenefitsorcosts.Employmentoffersanidealinitialmeasureofthesocialandeconomicconsequencesofwaterallocationsandthisisthekeyindicatorofsocio-economicimpactthattheMDBAhasfocusedoninitsmodelling.Aspartofthisfinalreportwefocuson:
1. whethertheapproachandtheresultsobtainedcanbeusedbytheMDBAtohelpreachadecisionabouttheeffectsofchangesinwateravailabilitybyinterpretingthemodeloutputs(i.e.hectaresusedinproductionandemploymentimpacts)
2. limitationsinthisregardand3. considerationsforfuturework.
19ReceivedfromTownsend,Phil(2016).Pers.Comms(Email),Canberra:MDBA,26August2016.20MDBA.(2016).TripleBottomLineAssessmentofSDLsfortheNorthernBasin,1August2016.Canberra:MDBA.21MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:Phase2EngagementProgram,CommunityMeetings,July2016.Canberra:MDBA.22Wakerman-Powell,Kai.(2016).LowerBalonneFloodplainGrazingModelReport-Draft,September2016.Canberra:MDBA.23MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA.24Tanton,Robert,Vidyattama,YogiandPeel,Domonic.(2016).MDBACommunityProfilesdataextraction.May,Canberra:NATSEM,UniversityofCanberra.25Lukasiewicz,Anna,&Baldwin,Claudia.(2014).Voice,power,andhistory:ensuringsocialjusticeforallstakeholdersinwaterdecision-making.LocalEnvironment,1-22.Retrievedfromhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13549839.2014.942261
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
14
Figure3:TermsofReference(Source:MDBAExecutedContractMD3480,pp.26-27)
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
15
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
16
Figure4:ApproachtopreparingPlanamendment(Source:MDBA2016a26)
Figure5:BuildingBlockApproachtoAssessingModelling(Source:Blackwell2016)
OutlineofreportAsanoutlineoftheremainderofthereport,inregardstoitems2and3weidentifyelementsofthemodellingwhichwebelievemightbeconsideredbytheMDBAasareaswhereimprovementscanbemadeingeneralinSections4throughtoSection7.Insections4and5,wedistinguishbetweenthosepiecesofworkthatcanbedonerelativelyquicklyandeasilyintheshort-termandthosethatmightbecomepartoftheMDBA’songoingworkprograminthemediumtolongterm.PriortodoingthiswepresentarapidreviewoftherelevantliteratureinSection3tohelpidentifywhatmodelinghasbeendonepreviouslyandlessonslearnedforimprovements.
26MDBA.(2016a).‘TripleBottomLineassessmentofSDLsfortheNorthernBasin’.PowerPointpresentation.MDBACanberra:providedbyPhilTownsendviaemail1August2016.
Waterscenarios
Production/ecosystemhealthbeneiits
Economicandsocialconsequences(jobs,proiit,socialbeneiits/costs)
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
17
3. LiteratureReviewGlobalassessmentofriverbasinwaterproductivityCai et al. undertook a water productivity assessment in 10 river basins across Asia, Africa and SouthAmerica, reflecting a rangeof socio-economic and agro-climatic conditions.27They found that intensivefarmingintheAsianbasinsgivesmuchgreateragriculturaloutputandhigherwaterproductivitythanthelargely subsistence agriculture in Africa. Theymodelledwater productivity as the output derived fromwaterusedividedby thewater inputwith cropyieldsmeasuredas tonnesperha.Theyusedkg/m3or$/m3asmeasuresofwaterproductivityforrice.Thesefindingsmeanthatwaterproductivityisimportantforincreasedfoodsecurityandfarmers’livelihoods,thoughconsiderationsofthecostofimprovingwaterproductivity, including environmental trade-offs, need to be considered within context and analysedcarefully. Importantly, the authors note that current large-scale assessment of whole basins ‘reliesoverwhelminglyonstatisticaldata,whicharevariableinquality,thespatialscaleisoftenpooranddoesnot correspond to hydrological boundaries’.28These are similar limiting factors for the socio-economicmodellingworkdoneby theMDBA.However,Caietal.dopoint to remotesensing forestimatingcropproduction and water consumption combined with basin-scale hydrological modelling to understandwater cycling, to examine existing interventions and better understand processes on the ground(Literature insight 1, LI1). This reinforces the approach taken by the MDBA in its current social andeconomicmodellingwork.CritiqueoftraditionalwaterefficiencyGleick, Christian-Smith, and Cooley (2011) critique traditional approaches to water efficiency such asthroughawholeofbasinefficiencyapproach29which,thoughhelpingclarifyissuesaroundthescaleandscopeofwaterefficiency,isflawedby:30
• excludingordiscountingunproductiveconsumptiveuse,called‘wet’water,amajorcomponentofinefficientwateruse
• onlyvaluing‘new’waterandnotusingabroadmeasureofwaterproductivityand• failing toaccount formanyco-benefitsofefficiency suchas improvedwaterquality, increased
production, greater reliability, decreased energy demands (i.e. impacts on other factors ofproduction),andreducedordelayedinfrastructureinvestments.
WhatthismeansfortheMDBAisthatassessingwaterproductivity,howmanygoodsandservicescanbeproduced bywater use, rather than efficiency, or howmuchwater is used relative to total amount ofwater available, is important to account for in the modelling (LI2). For example, crop yield, GDP orhouseholdsservedperunitofwaterratherthansimplytheproportionoftotalwaterused.Measuringthemarginal changes in jobs (through land area under cropping via changes inwater availability), in part,takesaccountofthesedevelopmentsinmeasuringwaterproductivityvis-à-visefficiency.31WaterproductivityintheAustraliancottoncontextWateriscriticaltothecottonindustryintheMDBtomaximisecropyieldsandfibrequality.Roth,Harris,Gillies, Montgomery, and Wigginton (2013) found that 80% of Australian cotton-growing area usedsurface-irrigation systems with 6-7ML/ha applied to cotton crops (dependent on the amount of rain
27Cai,Xueliang,Molden,David,Mainuddin,Mohammed,Sharma,Bharat,Ahmad,Mobin-ud-Din,&Karimi,Poolad.(2011).Producingmorefoodwithlesswaterinachangingworld:assessmentofwaterproductivityin10majorriverbasins.WaterInternational,36(1),42-62.doi:10.1080/02508060.2011.542403.28Caietal.2011,p.59-60.29Thisapproachinvolvesmeasuringhowmuchofthewaterthatentersabasinisrecoveredandused.30Gleick,PeterH.,Christian-Smith,Juliet,&Cooley,Heather.(2011).Water-useefficiencyandproductivity:rethinkingthebasinapproach.WaterInternational,36(7),784-798.doi:10.1080/02508060.2011.631873.31Seeourcommentsinthenextsectionaboutadditionalmeasuresofsocialandeconomicchangeresultingfromwaterwithdrawals.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
18
received) and 729mm of seasonal evapotranspiration over 23 years, and in the decade ending 2013,water-use productivity increased 40% for Australian cotton growers (due to whole farm irrigationefficiencygainsof57-70%andacropwateruse indexof>3kg/mm.ha(highby internationalstandards))(Rothetal.2013,p.1033).32TheyalsofoundthatinmanyAustraliancotton-growingregions,cropwaterdemandexceedstherainfallsupplysowater-useperformanceishighlyvariablebetweencottongrowingregions. These findings reinforce the necessity of site-specific measurement or studies, as beingundertaken by the MDBA with the modelling of 21 communities beginning with St George andDirranbandi(Hebel)tocapturetherelationshipbetweenwateruses,hectaresirrigatedandthesocialandeconomicconsequences(LI3).WorkundertakenbyMDBASince2009,theMDBAhasundertakenanextensiveprogramofresearch, includingthoseintothesocialandeconomicimplicationsofthedraftBasinPlan(LI4).TheextentofanalysisissosignificantthatMDBAhasalsoundertakentosynthesisethework-to-dateatcertainpoints in time,e.g., see itssynthesis thataccompaniesthePlan.33Thefollowingprovidesaselectionoftheirresearchprogram.34• Irrigated Agriculture in the Murray-Darling Basin: An Economic Survey of Irrigators, 2012-13 to 2014-15
(ABARES)presentskey farmperformancemeasures for irrigatedhorticulture,dairy,cotton (‘mostly located inthe Northern Basin’ p. 19) and rice farms in the Basin, including data on water trading, use of irrigationtechnologies and with an emphasis on results from 2012-13 to 2014-15.35Because of the severe drought,incomesof horticulture, dairy, rice and cotton farmswere relatively low for the first three survey years from2006-07to2008-09withrecordlowriverinflowsandirrigationwaterallocations.Incomesimprovedin2010-11following improved conditions and water allocations. However from 2012-13 to 2014-15 average farm cashincomeofcottongrowersdeclined(stillsignificantlyhigherthanotherindustriesataround2014-15$0.5m(p.9),whilehorticulture and rice growers’ remainedevenanddairy farmersearned recordhigh levels in real termssince2006-07.Averagereturnstocapitalsince2006-07washighestforcottongrowersat4.9%(3.5%-8%,p.16)(horticulture1.8%,diary2.2%,rice1.5%,p.1),reflectinggreatervariabilityincottonpricesorriskofreturnthanthose for other irrigated industries (p. 5). During the drought, water trading provided irrigators with animportant tool for managing low water allocations, with horticulture being the largest net buyer of waterallocations, irrigated broad acre and dairy being largest net sellers. As conditions improved, trading declined.Cottonfarmshadthesmallestproportionsoffarmssellingpermanentwaterentitlements.90%ofdairy,riceandcottongrowersused floodor furrow irrigationsystemsand19%ofcotton farmsand28%ofdairy farmsusedtravelling irrigators (p.1).Averagewateruseper farm for cotton remainshigh ranging from1250-2750MLperyear, thoughforall industrieswateruse increasedsignificantly from2010-11(p.21).Cottonwaterapplicationratesataround4.5-7ML/ha(LI5,p.24)wereaveragecomparedwithvegetables,citrus,stonefruit,promefruit,rice(significantlyhigherat10.5-15ML/ha),dairypastureandwinegrapes.
• Condamine-BalonneSustainableYieldRegionalProfile (MDBA)providesinformationontheregionasdefinedby CSIRO’s Sustainable Yields, and includes data on population, employment, agriculture, and communitycharacteristics.Theprofilewasproducedtoallowmeaningfulcomparisonsbetweenregionalcharacteristicsandpopulationsandbetweenthosepopulationsover.36
• Lower Balonne Community Profile: Irrigation Region (MDBA) provides a brief socioeconomic profile of theLowerBalonneirrigationregionintheMurray-DarlingBasin.Itincludesresponsesfromregionalstakeholdersto
32Roth,Guy,Harris,Graham,Gillies,Malcolm,Montgomery,Janelle,&Wigginton,David.(2013).Water-useefficiencyandproductivitytrendsinAustralianirrigatedcotton:areview.CropandPastureScience,64(12),1033-1048.doi:10.1071/CP13315,p.1033.33MDBA.(2012a).SocioeconomicAnalysisandtheDraftBasinPlanPartA-OverviewandAnalysis.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/archives/proposed/social_economic_analysis_part_b.pdfMDBA.(2012b).SocioeconomicAnalysisandtheDraftBasinPlanPartB-CommissionedandNon-CommissionedReportsWhichInformedTheMDBA'sSocioeconomicAnalysis.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/2129-social_economic_analysis_part_b.pdf34Thefulllistofsocialandeconomicanalysiscanbefoundhere:www.mdba.gov.au/publications/archived-information/basin-plan-archives/socio-economic-analysis(asat16June2016).35ABARES.(2015).IrrigatedAgricultureintheMurray-DarlingBasin:AnEconomicSurveyofIrrigators,2012-13to2014-15.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://data.daff.gov.au/data/warehouse/9aas/2015/IrrigatedAgMDB/IrrigatedAgMDBEconSrvy_v1.0.0.pdf36MDBA.(2009).Condamine-BalonneSustainableYieldRegionRegionalProfile.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/1366-ABS-Revised-Regional-Profile-Condamine-Balonne.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
19
a series of water availability scenarios, including the impacts they believe those scenarios will have onagriculture,theagriculturalvaluechain,andlocalbusinessesandservices.37
• Integration of SocioeconomicAssessments of theMurray-Darling Basin (Nous) seeks todistil andsynthesizekey findings and conclusions arising from the following two studies commissioned by the MDBA: 1 -"EnvironmentallySustainableDiversionLimitsintheMurray-DarlingBasin:SocioeconomicAnalysis”(ABARE);2-“Delivering the Basin Plan: Economic and Social Profile and Impact Assessments in theMurray-Darling Basin”(MarsdenJacobAssociates-ledconsortium).38
• ReporttotheMurrayDarlingBasinAuthorityontheLiaisonbetweentheMDBAandtheBankingSectorontheDraftBasinPlan(MDBA).Thiswasa2012reportcommissionedbytheMDBAandpreparedbyTheHon.DeanBrownAO.ItreportsonaseriesofconsultativemeetingsandbriefingsarrangedbytheMDBAfortheBankingSectoronthedraftMurray-DarlingBasinPlanatwhichthemodellingoftheeconomicandsocialimpactsofthedraftBasinPlanwaspresented.39
• ReviewingTheScientificBasisofEnvironmentalWaterRequirementsintheCondamine-BalonneandBarwon–Darling: Summary Report. The MDBA engaged a panel of independent scientists to consider the scienceunderpinningtheenvironmentalwaterrequirementsfortheCondamine-BalonneandBarwon-Darlingsystems,asastartingpointformoreworkonsurfacewatersustainablediversionlimits(SDLs).40
• People and Place in Australia: The 2014 Regional Wellbeing Survey (University of Canberra). This reportcomparestheexperiencesofpeoplelivingindifferentregions,andofpeopleofdifferentages,gender,andwhoareandaren’tengagedinfarming.Intotal,12,125peopletookpartinthe2014RegionalWellbeingSurvey,anincreaseofalmost3,000comparedtothe9,135whotookpartinthe2013.41
• Review of the MDBA's Socio-Economic Impact Modelling (KPMG). The MDBA commissioned a report todetermineanassessmentof the (CGE) socio-economic impactmodellingundertaken for theBasinPlanwhichincludedtheworkofWittwer,ABARESBRSandUQRSMG.42KPMGfoundthatthethreegroupsofindependentresearchers produced a set of informative studies that serve to ‘(a) provide important insights into particularcomponentsoftheproblemand(b)highlighttheneedforalargerscale,moreintegratedapproachtothesocio-economicmodelling……(througha)morecoordinatedandcooperativeapproach……thatincludesagreementonscenarioanalysisandtheappropriatefoundationofmodelbaselines’.43
• AssessingtheSocio-EconomicImpactsofSustainableDiversionLimitsandWaterfortheFutureInvestments:An Assessment of the Short-Term Impacts at the Local Scale – Final Report.ArcheConsulting andGillespieEconomics were engaged by the Department of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population andCommunities (DSEWPaC) and theMDBA to undertake input-output analysis of the short-run impact of policychanges in theMDB at the local community scale using 12 representative Local Government Areas (LGAs).44MoreePlains(NSWBorderRiversSDLregion)andBalonne(Condamine-BalonneSDLregion–i.e.StGeorgeandDirranbandi,Hebel)LGAswereincluded,eachencompassingmultiplecommunitiesrelyingondifferenttypesofwater.Theanalysisprovidedcompressedresults for the7years to2018-19 inasingleyearwhichallowedforwatertrading,Commonwealthbuybackstodate,WaterFortheFutureinfrastructureupgrades,andcommodityprices from 2005-06.With a 19.6% and 8.6%withdrawal ofwater for irrigation respectively for Balonne andMoreePlainsShires,impactsonirrigatedproduction(-49,-37jobs),potentialoffsettingincreasesinthevalueofdryland or cereal production (+3, +6 jobs), net impacts on farm employment (-46, -31 jobs), and flow-onemployment impacts for the local community (-59, -41 indirect jobs, with -4.9%, -1.3% of total jobs) were
37MDBA.(2010).LowerBalonnecommunityprofile:irrigationregion.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/1296-Community-Profile-Lower-Balonne-Irrigation-Region-May-2010.pdf38Nous.(2010).IntegrationofSocioeconomicAssessmentsoftheMurray-DarlingBasinRetrievedfromCanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/1280-Integration-of-Socioeconomic-assessment-report.pdf39MDBA.(2012c).ReporttotheMurrayDarlingBasinAuthorityontheLiaisonbetweentheMDBAandtheBankingSectorontheDraftBasinPlan.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/2499_Report_to_MDBA_Banking_Sector_on_the_Draft_Basin_Plan.pdf40MDBA.(2014).ReviewingtheScientificBasisofEnvironmentalWaterRequirementsintheCondamine-BalonneandBarwon-Darling.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/pubs/NBSR-Synthesis-accessible-summary-report.pdf41CentreforResearchandActioninPublicHealth,HealthResearchInstitute.(2015).PeopleandPlaceinAustralia:The2014RegionalWellbeingSurvey.RetrievedfromUniversityofCanberra,Canberra:https://www.canberra.edu.au/research/faculty-research-centres/ceraph/regional-wellbeing/survey-results/2014-survey-results/2014-Regional-Wellbeing-Survey.pdf42KPMG.(2011).ReviewoftheMDBA'sSocio-EconomicImpactModelling.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/1719-ReviewOfTheMDBAsSocioEconomicImpactModelling.pdf43KPMG.(2011),pp.9-10.44ArcheConsulting,&GillespieEconomics.(2012).AssessingtheSocio-EconomicImpactsofSustainableDiversionLimitsandWaterfortheFutureInvestments:AnAssessmentoftheShort-TermImpactsattheLocalScale–FinalReport.RetrievedfromSydney:http://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/archived/proposed/Arche-Basin-Case-Studies-final-report.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
20
assessed (forBalonneandMoreePlainsLGAs respectively). Losses incottonandcerealproductionamount to$48.89m,$37m(19.9%,9.9%) inGVIAPandlocalvalueaddedof$27.9m,$19.4m(11.4%,3%)forBalonneandMoreePlainsShiresrespectively(pp.20,23,24,27).
• Commenton“AssessingtheSocio-EconomicImpactsofSustainableDiversionLimitsandWaterfortheFutureInvestments”.KPMGreviewed theworkofArcheandGillespie45asencompassinga reasonableapproachbutthat their methodology would overestimate the impact of the Basin Plan (and underestimate impacts ofinfrastructureupgrades)(LI6)asArcheandGillespienotedthemselves.Thisisbecauseoftheinherentlimitationsinavailabledataandthemethodology itself,andthemodellingcouldbe improvedby including likely inherentadjustmentprocesses(includingemploymentforfallingpopulationsandagriculturalsector,automated(ratherthanmanual)adjustedland-usebasedonmarginalvalueofwater,andadjustablelabourandcapitalratios,likelylagininfrastructurespendandproductivitygains)overtheperiodandincorporatingregionalvariationinwateruseintensity(pp.1-2).
• Revised Indicators Of Community Vulnerability And Adaptive Capacity Across TheMurray-Darling Basin: AFocusOn Irrigation InAgriculture.Stenekesetal.werecommissionedtomeasurethevulnerability, resilienceandadaptivecapacityofBasincommunitiestochangesinwateravailability-duetoarangeoffactors-inorderto informMDBAplanninganddecision-making.46Inparticular, ‘(t)he indicescould……beusedasabaselineofinformation to measure future socioeconomic changes and as part of a potential framework for measuringeffectsoftheBasinPlanoncommunities’,thatis,thesocialandeconomicmonitoringandevaluationframeworkof the Plan (see Figure 6). Of note are a series of comprehensive maps in Appendix B (pp. 31-41) that aregeospatiallyexplicitfortheLowerBalonneincludinglocationofStGeorgeandDirranbandi.Resultsinclude:
o StGeorgeandDirranbandirelativevulnerabilitytochangesinwateravailabilitypriortotheBasinPlanreadasmedium(~0.5)andhighlevel(~0.75)respectively(1.0isthehighestrankedindex)
o subindexofrelativesensitivitytowateravailability,similarresultso higheraverageadaptivecapacityresults(~0.75forbothlocations),o lower(~0.5)forrelativecommunityvulnerabilityfor2800GLwaterrecoveryscenario,o around12.5%waterreduction(relativetomaximumof25%)forexposurerequiredtomeet2800
GLSDLaftermodeledwatertradeandusing2005-06commodityprices,o similarresultsforaverage2006-07and2010-11commodityprices,o arelativeimpactsubindexrankingofapproximately0.5forbothlocations(max1.0)using2005-06
commodityprices(higherthanmostsurroundinglocationsbutnotcomparedwiththeareawestoftheseabuttingtheborder),
o similarresults forvariationwith2400to3200GLSDLscenarios,andforcommunityvulnerabilitywiththesescenariosandlattercommodityprices.
o moststrikingisforSLAirrigationintensity(MLapplied/no.ofirrigatedfarmestablishments)withStGeorgeandDirranbandifallingintothehighestcategory(5242-6551ML)inthebasin.
o employment in agriculture as apercentageof total employment varieswidely for the SLAs andbecauseStGeorgeandDirranbandiabutvariousSLAs,thepercentagerangeisfrom30%-75%butagain,theregiontothewestandontheborderhasthehighestcategoryat90%.
Theresultspointtotheneedfornuancedandspecific(ratherthangeneralized)localinformationonthesocialand economic consequences of waterwithdrawals and provide a useful starting point for comparison acrossSLAsandcontributetoabaselineforongoingmonitoringandevaluationofthePlan’simplementation(LI7).
• EffectsofChange inWaterAvailabilityon IndigenousPeopleof theMurray-DarlingBasin:A ScopingStudy.ThisreportconsiderstheimpactsoftheBasinPlanonAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeopledrawingonareviewofthe literature,casestudyanalysisfromtheMurrumbidgee,Barwon-DarlingorMurrayRiverRegions,descriptivecharacterizationofimpactsbasedoncasestudiesandliterature,andrecommendationstoenhanceormitigatethe impacts fromtheplan includingfutureresearch.Someofthekeyfindingsarethat impacts forAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandersareleastwellknownofthesocialandeconomicimpactsandthisisbecauseof a paucity of information, limited water reforms and institutions to strategically capture these people’saspirations,andtheneedforanMDBAongoingworkprogramtoaddressthispaucity.47
45KPMG.(2012).Commenton“AssessingtheSocio-EconomicImpactsofSustainableDiversionLimitsandWaterfortheFutureInvestments”.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/2015-KPMG-Review-of-Arche-Method-FinalReport.pdf46Stenekes,N,Kancans,R,Randall,L,Lawson,K,Reeve,I,&Stayner,R.(2012).RevisedIndicatorsofCommunityVulnerabilityandAdaptiveCapacityAcrosstheMurray-DarlingBasin:AFocusonIrrigationinAgriculture.Canberra:ABARES.47Jackson,S,Moggridge,B,&Robinson,CJ.(2010).EffectsofChangeinWaterAvailabilityonIndigenousPeopleoftheMurray-DarlingBasin:AScopingStudy.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/publications/archived-information/basin-plan-archives/socio-economic-analysis
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
21
Figure6:SocialandeconomicmonitoringandevaluationframeworkforBasinPlan48
Of the work undertaken on social and economic impacts of the Basin Plan, Wittwer (2011) used theTERM-H2OCGE(computablegeneralequilibrium)modeltoassessthelong-termimpactsofanSDLtargetentailingpurchasesof2800GLofwaterfromfarmersbetween2008and2029onGDPandemploymentwithin the MBD.49There is little change in overall economic activity (LI8). At a basin scale and givenlimiting long term view assumptions of CGE, GDP is expected to fall by about 0.3 per cent andemployment falls by 0.1 percent or 600 jobs because ‘given that the process of environmental waterpurchasesinvolveswillingsellerswhoarepaidamarketprice,thisisnotsurprising’(Wittwer,2011,p.1).Wittwer (2011) also regressed irrigation water prices in the southern basin against water availability,droughtandoutputpricesandfoundthatpriceismoreresponsivetodroughtthanchangesinirrigationwateravailability(LI9)anditissensitivetothefarmproducerpriceindex.Furthermoreandrelatedtothenextsubsectionheading,MDBAengagedEBCetal.(2011)toassessthecommunity(andregionalincludingQueenslandandCondamineBalonne)impactsoftheguidetotheplanandone interesting finding is thehighrisk levels forwaterwithdrawal identified forDirranbandiandStGeorge, given both have relatively small populations and are dependent (35-40% and 25-30%respectively)onemploymentinagriculture,processing,transportandstorage(seeFigure1.1RiskFactorsforSocialCatchments (bytown)onp.13ofVolume3:Community Impacts).Priortothismoredetailedlocal analysis, in their Synthesis Report,Marsden Jacob Associates et al. (2010, p. 11) found that as a
48MDBA.(2016b).‘Oursocialandeconomicevaluationmethodology’.MDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/socio-economic-profile-murray-darling-basin49Wittwer,Glyn.(2011).BasinPlanCGEModellingUsingTERM-H20.ReporttotheMDBA.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/archived/basinplan/1718-BasinPlanCGEModellingUsingTermH20.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
22
whole(i.e.Balonne)thesecommunitieshadthesmallestgrossvalueofirrigatedagricultureof12regions,yetthehighestmeasuresofsocio-economiccondition,andwithirrigationproductaccountingfor50%oftotalgrossagriculturalproduct.Again, theseexamplesofdifferingspatial scalesofeconomicandsocialanalysespointtotheimportanceoflocalconditionsdifferingfromregionalandtheneedforthelocalizedanalyses(LI10).Regionaleconomicresilience,commuting,andtechnologicalshiftsMeasuring socioeconomic conditions is away of gauging a region’s economic resilience. The economicstructure of labourmarket areas has long been a staple of regional and urban analysis. For example,recentlyHanandGoetzmodelledandmappedtheeconomicresilienceofallcountiesintheUnitedStatesduringtheglobal financialcrisisusingemploymentasameasureofeconomicactivitybycomparingthedrop in economic activity and subsequent rebound that follows.50For the MDBA and their social andeconomic modelling, we note that Han and Goetz used employment data as a starting point butrecommended in their discussion (p. 146) that future studies should include consideration of personalincomewhich providemore nuanced qualitative changes of changes in job types rather than numbersaloneandmakeforusefulcomparisonwithemployment(LI11).WeareinformedthattheMDBAhasusedwageincometoconvertpart-timeworktofulltimeequivalent(FTE).Commutinginandoutofregionsforworkhasexpandedovertime,andtherehasbeenarecentshiftforAustralianregionsfromanagriculturaltominingbase.51Studiesshowthatnetworkdegreeandentropymeasures explain variations in county per capita income growth patterns.52Also higher in and out-commutingentropiesareassociatedwithlowerpercapitaincomegrowth,buttheirinteractionenhanceseconomic growth in places simultaneously open to both in and out-commuters. 53 Accounting forcommuting and work-migration will be important in modelling the impacts on jobs from waterwithdrawalsintheMDB(LI12).Globalisationhaschangedtheoutlookofeconomicactivityinregionsacrosstheglobe.54Alsotechnologyhas changed production techniques in many industries55, such as in the case of genetically modifiedcotton requiring less sprayingandassociated labour. Studies around theworld reflect favorablyon the
50Han,Yicheol,&Goetz,StephanJ.(2015).TheEconomicResilienceofUSCountiesDuringtheGreatRecession.45(2),131-149.http://journal.srsa.org/ojs/index.php/RRS/article/view/45.2.251McFarlane,JimA,Blackwell,BoydD,Mounter,StuartW,&Grant,BlighJ.(2016).Fromagriculturetomining:Thechangingeconomicbaseofaruraleconomyandimplicationsfordevelopment.EconomicAnalysisandPolicy,49,56-65.doi:10.1016/j.eap.2015.11.01252Hussain,R,Maple,M,Hunter,SV,Mapedzahama,V,Reddy,P,&Hunter,Sally.(2015).TheFly-inFly-outandDrive-inDrive-outmodelofhealthcareserviceprovisionforruralandremoteAustralia:benefitsanddisadvantages.Ruralandremotehealth,15(3068),1-7.http://www.rrh.org.au/articles/subviewnew.asp?ArticleID=3068Storey,Keith.(2010).Fly-in/fly-out:implicationsforcommunitysustainability.Sustainability,2(5),1161-1181.doi:10.3390/su205116153Goetz,StephanJ,Han,Yicheol,Findeis,JillL,&Brasier,KathrynJ.(2010).UScommutingnetworksandeconomicgrowth:Measurementandimplicationsforspatialpolicy.GrowthandChange,41(2),276-302.www.blackwell-synergy.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1468-2257.2010.00527.x54McCann,Philip,&Acs,ZoltanJ.(2015).Globalisation:Countries,citiesandmultinationals.GlobalEntrepreneurship,InstitutionsandIncentives:TheMasonYears,45,371.doi:10.1080/00343404.2010.50591555Feldmann,Horst.(2013).Technologicalunemploymentinindustrialcountries.JournalofEvolutionaryEconomics,23(5),1099-1126.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs00191-013-0308-6#page-2Loi,Michele.(2015).Technologicalunemploymentandhumandisenhancement.EthicsandInformationTechnology,17(3),201-210.http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10676-015-9375-8
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
23
industry nonetheless56and the broader community can expect a deskilling in labour in those regionalareasandanassociatedlesseningoflabourdemand.57
Whenmeasuring the social andeconomic impactsof irrigated cotton in theMDA, resilience,migrationand commuting, globalisation and technological advancements and associated falls in labour demand,shouldbeconsidered.AllthesefacetshavebeenconsideredintheMDBAsocialandeconomicmodellingandanalysistodateexceptforcommutingandthisisdiscussedinthemoredetailinthenextsectionofthisreport(LI13)AustralianwaterpolicyspecificstudiesTherehavebeenmanystudiescoveringawiderangeofaspectsinAustralianwaterpolicyanddecision-makingwithaselectiondemonstratingtherangeofissuesconsidered:
• modellingtheeconomiceffectsoftheplanonthesouthernbasin58• a reviewof relevant environmental economics applied to developing an eclectic policy reform
framework including taxingpolluters, creationofnew formsof communalproperty rights, andregulationtoachieveenvironmentalsustainability59
• modellingofwateruseefficiencyuptakeintheNamoicatchment,amountingtoaround100GL,resulting in more water for irrigation and income, bringing into question the necessity ofgovernmentsupport60
• modellingofirrigatordecisionmakingoverwateruseusingmindmapping61and• areviewofhistoricalandfuturehydrologicalchangesintheMDB.62
Dixon,RimmerandWittwerused their TERMH2OdynamicmultiregionalCGEmodel to find thatwaterbuybacks increasedwater asset values and had little effect on aggregate farm output in the southernbasin as farms reallocated resources between activities (LI14).63Because the effects of the basin planplay-outwithtime,thesetypesofforecastscanbetested.BanjereeusedTERMH20tomodeltheeconomicimpactsofinvestmentinirrigationinfrastructureusingacasestudyof theMurrumbidgeesubcatchment (SouthernBasin).64Thispublic investment results inan
56Bennett,Richard,Kambhampati,Uma,Morse,Stephen,&Ismael,Yousouf.(2006).Farm-leveleconomicperformanceofgeneticallymodifiedcottoninMaharashtra,India.AppliedEconomicPerspectivesandPolicy,28(1),59-71.doi:10.1111/j.1467-9353.2006.00273.xQaim,Matin,&Zilberman,David.(2003).Yieldeffectsofgeneticallymodifiedcropsindevelopingcountries.Science,299(5608),900-902.http://science.sciencemag.org/content/299/5608/90057Bennett,Richard,Morse,Stephen,&Ismael,Yousouf.(2006).TheeconomicimpactofgeneticallymodifiedcottononSouthAfricansmallholders:yield,profitandhealtheffects.TheJournalofDevelopmentStudies,42(4),662-677.http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00220380600682215Stone,GlennDavis.(2007).AgriculturaldeskillingandthespreadofgeneticallymodifiedcottoninWarangal.CurrentAnthropology,48(1),67-103.doi:10.1086/50868958Dixon,P,Rimmer,M,&Wittwer,G.(2011).SavingtheSouthernMurray-DarlingBasin:TheEconomicEffectsofaBuybackofIrrigationWater.EconomicRecord,87(276),153-168.doi:10.1111/j.1475-4932.2010.00691.x59Quiggin,John.(2001).EnvironmentaleconomicsandtheMurray–Darlingriversystem.AustralianJournalofAgriculturalandResourceEconomics,45(1),67-94.doi:10.1111/1467-8489.0013460Ticehurst,JeniferL.,&Curtis,AllanL.(2015).Canexistingpracticesexpectedtoleadtoimprovedon-farmwateruseefficiencyenableirrigatorstoeffectivelyrespondtoreducedwaterentitlementsintheMurray–DarlingBasin?JournalofHydrology,528,613-620.doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2015.06.05561Douglas,EllenM,Wheeler,SarahAnn,Smith,DavidJ,Overton,IanC,Gray,StevenA,Doody,TanyaM,&Crossman,NevilleD.(2016).Usingmental-modellingtoexplorehowirrigatorsintheMurray–DarlingBasinmakewater-usedecisions.JournalofHydrology:RegionalStudies,6,1-12.doi:10.1016/j.ejrh.2016.01.03562Leblanc,Marc,Tweed,Sarah,VanDijk,Albert,&Timbal,Bertrand.(2012).AreviewofhistoricandfuturehydrologicalchangesintheMurray-DarlingBasin.Globalandplanetarychange,80,226-246.doi:10.1016/j.gloplacha.2011.10.01263Dixon,P,Rimmer,M,&Wittwer,G.(2011).SavingtheSouthernMurray-DarlingBasin:TheEconomicEffectsofaBuybackofIrrigationWater.EconomicRecord,87(276),153-168.doi:10.1111/j.1475-4932.2010.00691.x64Banerjee,Onil.(2015).InvestinginrecoveringwaterfortheenvironmentinAustralia'sMurray-DarlingBasin.InternationalJournalofWaterResourcesDevelopment,31(4),701-717.doi:10.1080/07900627.2014.979398
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
24
increase in regional output, incomeandemployment,whilenationally there is a small negative impact(LI15)resultingfromthetransferofresourcestothebasinandacrowdingoutofprivateinvestment.Theyalso note that ‘(w)hen water-balance modelling for a catchment does not account for return flows(reduced return flow fromwater saving infrastructure upgrades), thewater savingsmaybe overstated’andwheretheinfrastructureresultsinwater-useefficiency,returnflowsarereduced,withthepossibilityof ‘norealeffectonwatersavings’(p.72)(LI16).However,thehighergeographicalscaleofthiswork isdifferenttothelocalgeographicalscaleofsocialandeconomicimpactbeingconsideredforStGeorgeandDirranbandi(Hebel).Wheeler,ZuoandBjornlundfoundaweaktonoimpactforCommonwealthwatersalesonlaggednetfarmincomefromsellingwaterentitlementsinthesouthernMDB(LI17)acrosstheperiod2008to2012.65Thiswasusedasevidencetosuggestthatirrigatorsusedtheproceedsfromthesesalestoreducetheirdebtandinterestpayments,restructureandinvestonfarm.Interestingly,onfarmconsequencesfromthesalesincludedgreaterexistingusefromentitlements,implyingthatirrigatorssimplysoldtheirsurplusorbufferwater.Theseauthorsadvisesellingirrigatorstoundertakefurtherincrementaladaptation,watermanagementoron-farmchanges,tonotriskregularwatershortagesgiventheadventofclimatechange.Theauthorspointoutalsothattheirstudyfocusedonfarmrelatedimpacts,ratherthanthoseoncommunitieswhichmightalsobenegativeandpositive,thoughthetimeperiodandlocationofsalesisdifferenttothatofthecurrentwork.(LI18)WittwerandDixon,usingTERMH2O,foundthatpublicspendingonhealth,educationandotherservicesin thebasinweresuperior regionaleconomicmanagementoptions to infrastructureupgrades, creatingbetweenthreeandfourjobsrelativetotheonecreatedfromupgrades.66Theauthorsthereforeseejobs,and the relative impact on jobs, as important social and economic measures of wellbeing in regionaldevelopmentanalysis(LI19).Loch,WheelerandAdamsonhighlighttheimportanceofpeopleandplaceinriver-basedmanagementoftheMDBinAustralia.Historicallytherehasbeenafocusonpeople(socialandeconomicobjectives)butmore recentlyanemphasisonplace (throughenvironmentalobjectives).While jobsalone insufficientlyrepresentanappropriateassessmentof‘peopleandplace’intheNorthernBasin,theMDBAareawareofthislimitationandhaveundertakenasurveyofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderstoidentifythesocialand cultural values for thebasinaswell as a regionalwell-being survey,bothnotedaboveandpartoftheirongoingmonitoringandevaluationframework(LI20).67InternationaleconomicassessmentofwaterreductionsBekchanov and Lamer assessed the economic effects of upstream infrastructure developments andreducedriverrun-offondownstreamcountriesincentralAsiausingaCGEmodel.68Theyfoundthata10-20%watersupplyreductioncausedtheirrigatedareasinUzbekistantobereducedby241,000to374,000ha,withemployment lossesof712,000to868,000, resulting inanational income lossof3.6 to4.3percent(p.1).
65Wheeler,SarahAnn,Zuo,Alec,&Bjornlund,Henning.(2014).Investigatingthedelayedon-farmconsequencesofsellingwaterentitlementsintheMurray-DarlingBasin.AgriculturalWaterManagement,145,72-82.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agwat.2013.10.01566Wittwer,Glyn,&Dixon,Janine.(2013).EffectiveuseofpublicfundingintheMurray-DarlingBasin:acomparisonofbuybacksandinfrastructureupgrades.AustralianJournalofAgriculturalandResourceEconomics,57(3),399-421.doi:10.1111/1467-8489.1200167Jackson,S,Moggridge,B,&Robinson,CJ.(2010).EffectsofChangeinWaterAvailabilityonIndigenousPeopleoftheMurray-DarlingBasin:AScopingStudy.RetrievedfromMDBACanberra:http://www.mdba.gov.au/publications/archived-information/basin-plan-archives/socio-economic-analysis;CentreforResearchandActioninPublicHealth,HealthResearchInstitute.(2015).PeopleandPlaceinAustralia:The2014RegionalWellbeingSurvey.RetrievedfromUniversityofCanberra,Canberra:https://www.canberra.edu.au/research/faculty-research-centres/ceraph/regional-wellbeing/survey-results/2014-survey-results/2014-Regional-Wellbeing-Survey.pdf68Bekchanov,Maksud,&Lamers,JohnP.A.(2016).EconomiccostsofreducedirrigationwateravailabilityinUzbekistan(CentralAsia).RegionalEnvironmentalChange,1-19.doi:10.1007/s10113-016-0961-z
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
25
Liu,HertelandTaheripourreviewedtheincorporationofwaterintoCGEmodellingattheglobalscale.ImportantlyfortheMDBA,theyfoundthatignoringsub-nationalhydrologicalboundariesinglobaleconomicanalysisofwaterscarcitymaybesufficientwhenconsideringnational-scaletrade,productionandwelfarechanges,butforassessingthe’distributionofinputsandoutputswithinaregion,preservingtheriverbasinandsectorialdetailinthemodelbringsconsiderableaddedvaluetotheanalysis’.69(LI21)Zhongetal.assessedtheeconomiceffectsofthe2000droughtinChinausingaCGEmodelwhichaccountedforthedichotomybetweenirrigation(including16provincialirrigationwatersuppliesandtheirsubsidies)andpipedwaterandparallelpricingarrangements.70SimilartotheanalysisundertakenbyWittweroftheBasinPlaninAustralia71,theeffectsofthedroughtontheChinesemacroeconomywerefoundtobenegligible(notingthatCGEmodelstheeffectsinthelong-run)(LI22).However,theyfoundsignificanteffectsonagriculturalproductionmainlyundertakeninthenorthernareasofChinawheremorecapitalandlabourwereusedtoamelioratetheeffectsofthedrought(LI23).Labourmovedfromnon-farmingagriculturalproductionsectorsintofarming.Urbanandruralhouseholdssufferedseverelossesinfoodconsumptionandwelfare,despitereceivingadditionalincome(LI24).Ruralhouseholdsinthenorthernandsouthernregionssufferedtheworstlosses.SummaryandconclusiononliteraturereviewTheMDBAhasalreadyundertakenanextensiverangeofsocialandeconomicmodellingtoinformthedevelopmentandimplementationofthePlan.Wehaveidentified24insightsfromthedomesticandinternationalliteraturewhichrequiredconsiderationinundertakingthesocialandeconomicmodellingofimpactsforwithdrawalsintheNorthernBasin.AsummaryoftheseisprovidedinTable4whichshowsthatmostofthesearealreadyincorporatedinthemodellingorprovideimpetustothecurrentmodelling,notingthatmostofourcommentshavebeenaddressed,atleastthroughexplanation,inthelatestdraftreportsasnotedintheTable’sfinalcolumninred.OnlyoneinsighthasbeenoverlookedandcouldbedoneaspartoftheMDBAsongoingworkprogramratherthanimmediately.Togainfurtherdetailsforeachinsightsimplygotothecoding(LI#)andyellowhighlightintheabovetext.Overall,these24insightsreinforceourrecommendationsinregardstothemodellingwhichareprovidedinthefollowingsection.Table4:Summaryofliteratureinsights(LI),relevance,andincorporation(Source:seeLI#intext)LI# Insight RelevancetoMDBAmodelling Whetherincorporated(✔ OR✖)byMDBA
modelling/processes(suggestedinclusiontimeframe)SubsequentincorporationbyMDBA(✔ OR✖)
1 Remotesensingcanbecombinedwithbasin-scalehydrologicalmodellingtobetterunderstandwatercyclingandlocalprocesses
Notdirectlyrelevantbutreinforcescurrentlocallynuancedapproachtaken
NA
2 Waterproductivityshouldbemeasuredthroughimpactongoodsandservicesratherthanfocusedonamountofwaterused
Assessingimpactsonjobsgoessomewaytodoingthis.
✔ Previousmodellingincorporatesimpactsforlocalcommunitiesonjobs,valueaddedandregionaloutput(ArcheandGillespie).But,morenuancedimpactscouldbeassessedforcommunitiesbybuildingsmallerlocaleconomymodels
3 Siteorlocalespecificstudiesnecessaryforestablishing
ReinforcesMDBAcurrentapproach ✔
69Liu,Jing,Hertel,Thomas,&Taheripour,Farzad.(2016).AnalyzingFutureWaterScarcityinComputableGeneralEquilibriumModels.WaterEconomicsandPolicy,2(2),1650006:1650001-1650030.doi:doi:10.1142/S2382624X16500065,p.1650006-1.70Zhong,Shuai,Shen,Lei,Sha,Jinghua,Okiyama,Mitsuru,Tokunaga,Suminori,Liu,Litao,&Yan,Jingjing.(2015).AssessingtheWaterParallelPricingSystemagainstDroughtinChina:AStudyBasedonaCGEModelwithMulti-ProvincialIrrigationWater.Water,7(7),3431.71Wittwer,Glyn.(2011).BasinPlanCGEModellingUsingTERM-H20.ReporttotheMDBA.RetrievedfromMelbourne:http://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/archived/basinplan/1718-BasinPlanCGEModellingUsingTermH20.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
26
LI# Insight RelevancetoMDBAmodelling Whetherincorporated(✔ OR✖)byMDBAmodelling/processes(suggestedinclusiontimeframe)SubsequentincorporationbyMDBA(✔ OR✖)
relationshipbetweenwateruse,hectaresirrigatedandthesocialandeconomicconsequences
4 SignificantbodyofworkalreadyundertakenbyMDBAinitssocialandeconomicanalysisofthePlan
LargebodyofbackgroundworkthathasguidedtheMDBAandreinforcesneedandapproachforcurrentmodellingwork
✔
5 Cottonwaterapplicationrateof4.5-7ML/ha
Consistentwithcurrentmodelling ✔
6 KPMGfoundArcheGillespieI-Oapproachreasonablebuttemporalandtransitionalprocessesneedtobeincorporated
Reasonforcurrentmodelling NA
7 CommunityvulnerabilityandadaptabilityindicesprovideanimportantbaselineforongoingmonitoringandevaluationframeworkofsocialandeconomicconsequencesofPlan
MDBAhassuchaframework ✔
8 CGETERMH2Omodellingshowsemploymentimpactsacrossentirebasinrelativelysmallduetotradabilityofwater
Whilethecaseatmacro-level,isnotthecaseatlocallevelandhenceneedforcurrentwork
✔
9 Waterpricemoresensitivetodroughtandproducercoststhanwateravailability
ThisresultmaybemoreafunctionoftheCGEmodellingapproachthanreflectinglocalconditions,reinforcingneedforsuchlocalmodelling
Suchmodellingatthemicro-scalecouldbeundertakentoassesssuchsensitivitybutwouldbeconstrainedbydataavailability
10 StGeorgeandDirranbandi(Hebel)identifiedashighriskareas(proportionofirrigatedag,socio-economiccondition)inimplementationofthePlan
Reinforcesneedforcurrentworknuancedtomeetlocalconditions
✔
11 Incomemeasurescouldbeincorporatedandprovidecomparisonwithemploymentnumberanalysis
WeareinformedthatMDBAusedincomemeasurestoconvertpart-timeemployeestofulltimeequivalent.
✖ MeasuringlocalizedemploymentincomeimpactscouldbepartoftheMDBA’songoingsocialandeconomicmonitoringandevaluationframework(mediumtolong-term)✔notedinchapter5ofKPMGcommunitymodelreport72
12 Commutingandworkmigrationwillbeimportanttomodellingthespatial(i.e.local)consequencesforjoblosses
Webelievethisishighlyrelevantgivenrecentlyemergingliteratureofitssignificancenotjustforminingbutforallsectors
✖ (mediumtolong-term)✔notedasalimitationinKPMGcommunitymodelreport73
13 Resilience,migrationandcommuting,globalisationandtechnologicaladvancementsandassociatedfallsinlabourdemandneedtobeincorporatedintoanymodelling
Allthesehavebeenincorporatedexceptforcommutingandworkmigration
Seeliteratureinsight12formoredetail.
72KPMG.(2016).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,16August2016DraftReport.Sydney:KPMG,p.33.73KPMG.(2016).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,16August2016DraftReport,p.16.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
27
LI# Insight RelevancetoMDBAmodelling Whetherincorporated(✔ OR✖)byMDBAmodelling/processes(suggestedinclusiontimeframe)SubsequentincorporationbyMDBA(✔ OR✖)
14 TERMH2OCGEpredictedwaterbuybacksincreasedwaterassetvaluesandhadlittleeffectonaggregatefarmoutputintheSB
Thispredictioncouldbetestedwithtimeforboththesouthernandnorthernbasins,thoughitwasdoneatamacro-scaleandnotlocal/microscale.
✖ (mediumtolong-term)✖
15&16 InvestmentininfrastructureupgradesinSBincreasedregionaloutputandjobsbutcouldhavelittleeffectonwatersavings
UsedTERMH2OCGEandreinforcesneedforlocalizedunderstandingofeffectsofinfrastructureinvestment
✔ InfrastructurejobsstimuluswasincorporatedintoworkofArcheandGillespieasoffsettinggainsinjobsthoughnotedasunderestimatedbyKPMG✖ Returnflowsnegatingwatersavings(shortterm)✔discussed Collarenebri,DirranbandiflowonforMoree,StGeorge74
andsomeinfrastructurewatersavingsretainedforproductiveuses,nettedforcurrentwaterrecoveryinrelevantcommunities,75andaccountedas30%returnofwatersavingsinWeeWaa.76
17&18
CommonwealthwaterbuybacksinSB(2008-2012)hadlittleimpactonfarmnetincome
Proceedsfromsalewereusedtopay-offdebt/interestorinveston-farmandresultedingreateruseofexistingentitlements(andthislatterresponsenotsustainable).Communityimpactsnotassessedandcouldbepositiveandnegative
✖ Substitutionbetweenfactorsofproductionneedstobeincorporatedintojobsimpactwork(temporalinclusionnotyetknown))✔discussedinKPMGreport.77
19 Impactonjobsconsideredanimportantmeasureofsocialandeconomicconsequence
Foundationforcurrentwork.(Infrastructureinvestmenthasemploymentmultipliers1/3to¼ofthoseforpublichealthandeducation)
✔
20 Importanceofincorporating‘peopleandplace’thinkingintosocialandeconomicmonitoringandevaluationframework
MDBAconsciousoftheseconcernsandhaveundertakenanidentificationofculturalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslandervaluesandhasanongoingprogramofmonitoringcommunitywellbeing
✔ Wherecommunitiesbelievethisisnotthecase,thiscouldbecomepartoftheMDBA’songoingworkprogram(i.e.mediumtolong-term)
21-24 NegligibleeffectsofdroughtonChinesemacroeconomythoughurbanandruralhouseholdsexperiencedseverelossesinfoodandwelfareduetowaterwithdrawals,especiallyinnorthernandsouthernbasins
Farmerssubstitutedcapitalandlabour(movedfromnon-agtoag)forwater.Distinctionbetweennegligiblemacroandsignificantregionalandcommunityimpactsreinforcesneedforcurrentmodellingwork.AbilitytosubstitutelabourforwaterhinderedbyhigherwagesinAustralia,andalreadyincreasedcapitalizationfromdrought.
Seeinsight17and18above.
74MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,p1.75MDBA(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA,p26.76MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA,p33.77KPMG.(2016).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,16August2016DraftReport.Sydney:KPMG,pp.18-19.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
28
4. CommentsonGeneralApproachtoModellingIntroductionTheMDBAapproachtomodellinglocalizedsocialandeconomiccommunityimpactissummarizedintheirfinalreportwiththefollowingfigure.Figure7:Overviewoflocalsocialandeconomicimpactmodelling78
Figure7isconsistentwithourgeneralviewofmodellingtheimpactsofchangesinwaterrecoveryanditsimpactonlanduseandemployment(seeFigure5intheIntroductiontothisreport).Keyfactorsaretakenintoaccountincludingtheeffectofwaterrecoveryscenariosonextractionsbyirrigatorstakingintoaccounttheirlanduse,anduseofgroundwaterandseasonalrainfall.Theresultingchangeinareairrigatedthendeterminesthechangeinemploymentinagricultureandnon-agriculturesectors.GeneralapproachandfactorsofproductionWebelievetheMDBAhasfocusedonthekeyindicatoroftheimpactonsocialandeconomicwellbeingfromchangesindiversionsoncommunities,thatis,jobsoremployment.Jobsarefundamentaltothewellbeingofcommunities,providepeoplewithasenseofplaceandcontribution,andprovidemuchneededincometospendonothergoodsandservicesinthecommunity,providingfurtherstimulustothelocaleconomyandjobsandwellbeingtoothermembers.Havingsaidthat,jobsareonlyoneofthethreemainfactorsofproduction79:
• land(andnowwithwaterreform,waterhasbeenseparatedasanasset)• labourand
78UpdatefromBradley,J.(2016)Pers.Comms(Email),12Oct,Canberra:MDBAofthatprovidedinMDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA,p.8.79BlackwellBandBDollery(2013)IncomefactorsharesfrommininginremoteAustralia:AnanalysisoftheRangeruraniummineandtheTanamigoldmineintheNorthernTerritory,AustralasianJournalofRegionalStudies19(3),pp.369-395.Accessed19Aug2014from:http://www.anzrsai.org/assets/Uploads/PublicationChapter/546-BlackwellandDollery.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
29
• capital.Itisthecombinationofthesefactorsthatresultsinproductionandsupplyofgoodsandservices.Incomparisonwithjobs,thereareotherreturnstootherownersoffactorsofproduction,notablyownersoflandandwaterandcapital,thatwillalsobeimpactedthroughthediversionofwatertomeetenvironmentalorotherobjectives.(Recommendation1)Somediscussionofthesefactorsandtheirlikelyimpactsinadditiontotheimpactonlabourorjobsisthereforerecommendedandwesuggestsomereasoningastowhythesewerenotincluded.ThishasnowbeenaddressedintheKPMGcommunitymodellingreportandMDBAreport.80Forexample,aswateriswithdrawn,theimpactonjobswillbecomplicated(offsetorcompounded)throughsubstitutionbetweenallfactorsofagriculturalproduction.Relatedtothesefactorsofproductionare‘factorshares’orreturnstothesefactorsemployedintheproductionprocess.Fromaneconomicviewpoint,economicmeasuresareusuallydescribedindollarsandsomequantificationinmonetarytermsoftheimpactsonjobs(andotherfactorsofproduction)wouldbeanimportantaddition(thoughexplainedtousthatlocalwageandsalaryestimatesarecomplexanddataisnotreadilyandreliablyavailable).InhisWealthofNations,AdamSmithobservedthat“Wages,profit,andrent,arethethreeoriginalsourcesofallrevenue”andthatthedisbursementofagriculturalrevenuetothefactorsofproduction,“eitherasthewagesof[‘inhabitant’s’]labour,profitsoftheirstock(ormachinery,geneticmaterialetc.),ortherentoftheirland”isakeyconsiderationineconomicandpoliticalanalyses.81Whileitismoredifficulttoattachwageandsalaryestimatestojobs,webelievethereissufficientdatatodosoatbelowtheshirescale,atleastbytransferringvaluesformlocalgovernmentareasorappropriatestatisticalareasaswehavepreviouslydoneforTheNorthernTerritory.82Similarly,lossesinrentsassociatedwithwaterandland,andprofitsfromtheapplicationofcrops,machineryandotherequipmenttoagriculturallandwillbeimpacted.(Recommendation2)Themonetaryvalueoftheseimpactshavenotbeenassessedintheanalysisandtheextenttowhichthesewillimpacttheselocaleconomiesandcommunitiesshouldataminimumbediscussed(shortterm)asshouldareasoningfortheirnon-inclusion(shortterm).Inthelongerterm,itwouldbepreferablethatlocalmeasuresofwageandsalaryincomebeattachedtothejoblosses.Thesearenowidentifiedonp.33oftheKPMGcommunitymodellingreportasanareaforfutureworkanddiscussedintheMDBAreport.83However,agoodpointraisedbytheMDBAinourdiscussionson31May2016,istheextenttowhichthesechangestothereturnstofactorsofproductionareimpactedbywaterwithdrawalsratherseparatefromotherexogenousfactors(likechangesincommodityprices,reductionintradebarriersetc.),orwillbeimpactedbyotherexogenousfactorsastheseplayoutthroughtime.(Finding/Caveat1)WethereforebelievetheMDBAhascapturedthenuboftherequiredanalysishereusingceterisparibus,allotherthingsheldthesameoraccountedfor.Becausethefactorsoflandandwater,labourandcapitalarecombined,theirrespectivereturnswillbeimpactedbyachangeinthevolumeofanygivenfactor(herewaterappliedtocropsetc.)asaresultofthewaterwithdrawals.Thereforeconsideringtheimpactsonjobsalonedoesnotforetelltheimpactsonlandandcapital(equipment)whicharecombinedwithwaterinproducingagriculturaloutputandincome,andsubsequentconsumptionandproductionimpactsthroughoutthelocalandregional
80MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftInterimReport,27Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA,pp.8-9,19.81Smith,A.(1904).AnInquiryIntotheNatureandCausesoftheWealthofNations,firstpublished1776,MethuenandCo.Ltd,London.Onlineversionaccess18Oct2012:www.econlib.org/library/smith/smWN2.html82SeeBlackwellB,McFarlaneJandSBlake(2014)LocalEmploymentofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderPeoplesbyLocalGovernmentAreaintheNorthernTerritory:RedDirtEmploymentandIncome,JournalofAustralianIndigenousIssues,vol.17,no.4,pp.72-90.83MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftInterimReport,27Sep2016,pp.8-9,19.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
30
economies.(Finding/Caveat2)Onlypartofthesocialandeconomicimpactpicturewillberepresentedthroughjobs.Aremeasuresofjobs,ratherthanrelativemeasuresofjoblosses,enough?Suchananalyticalextensionwouldproviderelativemeasuresofimpact,particularlywhereemploymentisconcentratedinindustrialsubsectors(asinthecaseofcommunitieswithirrigatedcotton–importantinconsideringtheresilienceofcommunitiesandtheireconomiestobouncebackfromshockssuchasfromwaterwithdrawals.Forexample,seeourworkonlabourconcentrations(relativemeasure)inFigure884.(Recommendation3)WeacknowledgethatKPMGhaveincorporatedthepercentagechangeinjobsrelativetothebasecase,butinthelongertermwebelieveareviewofrelativeemploymentmeasureswouldbeworthwhilee.g.locationquotientswhichprovidemeasuresofemploymentconcentration,employmenttoworkingagepopulationratioswhichprovideanindicationofutilizationofcommunitypopulationsintheworkforceetc.toidentifythoseofmostbenefittotheongoingmonitoringandevaluationframework.IntegratingthisworkwiththatofStenekesetal.85maypresentthegreatestsynergyfortheMDBA.Thisadditionisnownotedonp.33oftheKPMGCommunityModellingreport.(Finding/Caveat3)Overalljoblossesmaybeoverestimatedduetoanumberoftechnologicaladvances(e.g.GMcottonandtheneedforlesssprayingandemployment)andthegeneralsubstitutionoflabourforcapitalinAustralia86.Theformerwasdiscussedonp.19oftheKPMGreport,thoughdiscussedasdriverofchangeonp.20ofMDBAreport.87Thesearecounteredbydiscussionofvalidreasonsforunderestimatesonpp.18-19intheSept27draftoftheMDBAreport.
84Calculationoflocationquotientsisastandardtechniqueineconomicgeographicanalysis,thoughourparticular4waygeospatialvisualizationisunique.OtherstudiesusingLQtypeanalysesinclude:TontsM.,DaviesA.andHaslam-MckenzieF.(2008)RegionalWorkforceFutures:AnAnalysisoftheGreatSouthern,SouthWestandWheatbeltRegions.UniversityofWesternAustralia,Perth;LawrieM.,TontsM.andPlummerP.(2011)Boomtowns,ResourceDependenceandSocio-economicWell-being,AustralianGeographer42,139-64.TontsM.,PlummerP.andLawrieM.(2012)Socio-economicwellbeinginAustralianminingtowns:Acomparativeanalysis,JournalofRuralStudies28,288-301.LehtonenO.andTykkyläinenM.(2012)EstimatingRegionalInputCoefficientsandMultipliers:IstheChoiceofaNon-SurveyTechniqueaGamble?,RegionalStudies48,382-99.85Stenekes,N,Kancans,R,Randall,L,Lawson,K,Reeve,I,&Stayner,R.(2012).RevisedIndicatorsofCommunityVulnerabilityandAdaptiveCapacityAcrosstheMurray-DarlingBasin:AFocusonIrrigationinAgriculture.Canberra:ABARES.http://www.mdba.gov.au/kid/files/1715-Revised-indicators-of-community-vulnerability.pdf86SeeBlackwellBandBDollery(2014)TheimpactofminingexpenditureonremotecommunitiesinAustralia:TheRangeruraniummineandtheTanamigoldmineintheNorthernTerritory,AustralasianJournalofRegionalStudies20(1):68-97.'Accessed19Aug2014from:http://www.anzrsai.org/assets/Uploads/PublicationChapter/Blackwell-and-Dollery-final.pdf87MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
31
5. CommentsonSpecificAspectsofModellingBroaderconsiderationofsectorsforregionalandlocaleconomiesWeappreciatethatthemodellinghasconsideredthejobimpactsforwaterwithdrawalsandaggregatedimpactedsectorsinspecificgroupings(4intotal:farmandfarmsupplies,agriculturalprocessing,non-agriculturalprivate,governmentservices),whichisbasedon720subsectorjobcategoriesaggregatedto11industrialcategorieshoweverwebelieveinclusionofthismirco-levelanalysisofjobimpactswillrevealimpactsmorespecificallyforcommunitiesandthereforefocustheirattentiononadaptiveorresponsivestrategies(Recommendation4,shortterm).Thisrecommendationstillstandstobeaddressed.Wherecommunitiesrequest,the720industrysubsectordatacouldbeprovided.Forexample,inourtrackingandmappingofmineexpenditureinremoteAustralia–weusethe720+industrialsubsectorslikeMDBAandaggregatetheseto111subsectorsoftheeconomyandpresentaverageemploymentconcentrationgraphsforeachLGA(seeFigure8AforWesternAustraliaandFigure8Basanexampleofgeospatialjobsconcentrationimpacts).Furthermoreandalongwiththeregionalprofilinganddescriptions,mappingthegeospatialimpactsmighthelpcommunities,governments,andindustryvisualizethelikelyimpacts(Recommendation5).Thisrecommendationstillstandstobeaddressedandcouldbeincludedinthefutureworkprogram.Thismappingwouldformanidealnegotiatinginstrumentintheshort-termforvariousjurisdictionsbutthetimeframesfordecision-makingmaybesufficientlyshorttomeanthesemapsarepreparedinthemediumtolongerterm.UseofABSemploymentdataWehaveclarifiedindiscussionswiththeMDBAthatthesourceofemploymentdatafromtheABSisplaceofusualresidence(PUR).Ifthismeansthatallworkers,regardlessoftheirplaceofworkbutwhomlivelocallyareincludedintheanalysisthenthisdataaccountsforlocalresidentswhoworklocallybutalsolocalresidentswhoworkoutsidethelocalareaandreturnhomeandspendtheir‘outside’wageandsalaryincomelocally.Inthiscase,theimpactonjobsmaybeoverestimatedbecausepeoplewhoworkoutsideagivencommunity’sareaarenotlikelytobeimpactedbywaterwithdrawalsdirectlyandwillnodoubtcontinuetheiremploymentafterthesewithdrawalsareimplemented.Incontrast,ifplaceofwork(POW)datawasusedthiswouldaccountforlocalresidentsemployedlocallyaswellasresidentscommutinginforworkbutleavingtoanoutsidecommunitytospendtheirmoney.Inthislattercase,thetotalemploymenteffectsofwaterwithdrawalswillnotbeoverestimatedbecauseitisthelocallyorientedwithdrawalsthatarelikelytoimpactlocaljobs,butthelocationofemploymentimpactswillbemis-specifiedbecausesomeofthisemploymentlivesoutsidethelocalcommunity.Toprovideageneralindicationofpossiblemis-estimationofimpacts,ABSTablebuilder88indicatesthatofthe2296peoplewhoareemployedanywhere89andliveinBalonne,1886(82%)worklocally,271(12%)workelsewhereinQueensland[ofthis62(3%)identifiedaparticularLGA,91(4%)wereinQueenslandwith‘nofixedaddress’,and118(5%)werecategorizedasinQueensland‘undefined’],and139(6%)elsewhereinAustralia(ofthese56(2%)fromNSW,3(0.1%)fromWA,81(4%)‘notstated’).Inotherwords,82%ofjobsarelocallyplaced,18%areplacedoutsideBalonnebringingadditionalincometothelocalcommunitythatdoesnotrelyonlocaljobsandtheimpactsforjoblosseswilltendtobeoverestimatedforthiscomponent,thoughtheMDBAdomodelforseasonalworkers.Incorollary,ofthe2096peoplewhoworkinBalonne,1884(90%)livelocally,155(7%)liveelsewhereinQueensland,and57(3%)liveelsewhereinAustralia.Inthiscase10%ofemploymentincomefromBalonneislosttooutsideareasorstates,lesseningtheimpactlocally,butspreadingtheimpacttooutsideareas.
88ABS.(2016).TableBuilder,accessed20June2016from:http://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/censushome.nsf/home/tablebuilder?opendocument&navpos=24089TheonlineandspreadsheetABSnotesreferto‘POWgeographicalarea-PlaceofWorkrelatestowherethepersonworkedintheweekpriortoCensusNight.Applicabletoemployedpersonsaged15yearsandover.’
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
32
Figure8:A.Employmentconcentrations(LQs)inWesternAustralia;B.PredictedspatialimpactsforpossiblefutureRangeruraniummineclosure(SourceandNotes:Blackwell,FischerandMcFarlane2016;AG=agriculture;MI=mining;MA=manufacturing;UT=utilities;BS=businessservices;PS=publicandpersonalservices;LQ=employmentlocationquotient.)A
B
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
33
Thereforeanimprovementinuseofthedataandpresentationoftheimpactswouldbetoidentifythespatialimpactsbybreakingdowntheemploymentdataintoitsvarioustypes(Recommendation690):
1. Localemployment(PURcrosstabulatedwithPOWforlocalcommunity)2. Localsemployedoutside(PURcrosstabulatedwithPOWoutsidelocalcommunity)3. Outsidersemployedlocally(localcommunityPOWwithPURoutsidelocalcommunity)and4. Industrialsubsector(e.g.2or4digitlevel)toprovidecluesastothespecificindustrialsourcesof
employmentincomeleakageorgain.Whileitwouldbepreferredtobetterinformnegotiationbetweenvariousjurisdictionsandcommunitiesthatthisworkisdonequicklyintheshortterm,theshort-timeframesmaymeanthisbecomespartofthemediumtolonger-termworkprogram.Thisrefinementwouldthencapturetheextenttowhichlocaljobswillbeimpacted(Item1)andoutsidejobs(item2)thatwillnotbeimpactedbythewithdrawals,andemploymentimpactsoutsidethelocalareathatwillbeimpactedbythewithdrawals(item3).Figure8BaboveprovidesanexampleofasimilartypeofspatialanalysisforlossofjobsfromapotentialclosureoftheRangermineintheNorthernTerritory.WhiletheNorthernTerritoryisrenownedforitsiterantworkforce,thereisgrowingevidenceintheliteratureoftheneedtoaccountforlabourmigrationandcommutinginbetterunderstandingthechangingeconomicgeographyoflocalandregionalcommunities.91ThereforenotingthesourceofdataandhowitwasextractedfromtheABSisimportanttoidentifythedegreetowhichcommutingandemploymentmigrationareaccountedforandthespatialeffectsthattheneventuate(Recommendation7).Recommendations6and7havenotyetbeenaddressedintheMDBAorKPMGreportsandcouldformpartoftheMDBA’sfutureworkprogram.ThelinearrelationshipusedinMDBAwater(ML)toland-usemodellingThismodelissimplisticanddoesnotaccountfortimeseriesnatureofthedata–thereforewerecommendtheinclusionoflagsandtransformations,unlesssomeotherexceptioncanbediscussed(Recommendation8).WenowacceptthatthereportinghasattemptedtoaddressourconcernsherewithadiscussionastowhythoroughtimeseriesdiagnostictestsarenotemployedandwithanadditionofanFtesttoprovideatestoftheoverallperformanceofthemodel(seeI4inTable2below).Furtherdiscussionisprovidedinthe27SeptMDBAreportwhichoutlinesthetestingdonetoaddresstheseissues.Inaddition,weprovidedabriefandrapidresponsetotheMDBA92onthisworkasoutlinedinTable5.TheMDBAalsoco-respondedasnotedinthetable.Table5:Summaryissues(Sourceandnotes:Blackwell,201693)IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse94
I1 Difficulttomodelreality–thoughoverall
Approachcommendablebecausethereisamodelforeachcommunitytohelp
NA
90Afurtherrecommendationaroundaccountingforlabourmigrationmaybetoincorporatelagstoaccountforwhenpeopleleaveandarrive,againthiswouldbeamediumtolongtermworkprogramrecommendation.91Seeforexample,Nicholas,C,&Welters,R(2016)ExploringdeterminantsoftheextentoflongdistancecommutinginAustralia:accountingforspace.AustralianGeographer,47(1),pp.103-120.doi:10.1080/00049182.2015.1090300;andBlackwellB,FischerA,McFarlaneJandDolleryB(2015).'MiningandotherindustrycontributionstoemploymentleakageinAustralia'sNorthernTerritory',JournalofDevelopingAreas,SpecialIssue,49(6):pp.263-278.Accessed30Sep2015from:http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/journal_of_developing_areas/summary/v049/49.6.blackwell.html92Blackwell,Boyd.(2016).RE:Updateofmodellingfiles.EmailsenttoPhilTownsend22August2016.Armidale:UniversityofNewEngland.93Blackwell,Boyd.(2016).RE:Updateofmodellingfiles.EmailsenttoPhilTownsend22August2016.Armidale:UniversityofNewEngland.94Townsend,Phil,(2016).Emailreceived22August2016inresponsetoBlackwell(2016).Canberra:MDBA.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
34
IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse94
approachcommendable captureappropriatecontextandnuanceI2 Approach,assumptions
andresultsforeachcommunitydetailed
Willhelpcommunitiesseehowtheirparticularcommunitymodelled
NA
I3 Approachofmodellingrealityandthenadjustingsoperformanceofmodelbettermatchesactuality
Forexample,somedummyvariableaddedtogainabetterfitwithactualwatertolanduserelationship
NA
I4 PresentationofResultsshouldincludeFstatistic
Fstatisticneededinadditiontotandadj.R2totestoverallsignificanceofmodelinexplainingwateruse
✔ Addedtomodels(thoughdoesnotappearincurrentversionofdraftsingreycolouredresultsboxes✖)
I5 Somecommunities’pastwaterusenotpredictedbymodelsaswellasothers
Whilethisisthecase,webelieveitsimportantforMDBAtoexplainwhythemodelsarebetteratpredictingfuturewateruseratherthanpasttoprovidecommunitiesgreaterconfidence.
✔ StGeorgenotedasanexample:hydrology-modellingoutputsforwatercourseproblematic.Tobedocumentedandclarified.
I6 Needforinclusionoftimeseriesdiagnostictesting
ThoughexplicitlyexplainedinKPMGreport,timeseriesnatureofdatarequiresstandarddiagnostictestingtoshowtheseinherentbiasesareaccountedforbecausecrosssectionalresultssuggestgreaterperformancethanwouldotherwisebethecase
✔ WillexplainatfrontofDocumentwhydatanottechnicallytimeseriesbutcross-sectionalandthatcottonpricesnotstatisticallyrelatedtoareaofproduction.Usershaveadevelopmentareafrom2000setbywaterpolicy,developmentcosts,andwaterreliabilityrisk.RefertoChp.4andAppendix4ofKPMGdraftreport.
I7 Greatertimespentonmodellingonecommunityoveranother
ExplanationofreasonswhymayprovidecommunitieswithgreaterconfidenceinMDBAapproach
✔ WillbeexplainedinDocument.
I8 Whilemodellingmaypredictspastwaterusewell,thisdoesnotequatetopredictingfuturewell
IssueneedsdiscussionintermsofmodellingapproachasperI5andI3above.
✔ Modelsnotintendedtobeusedtopredictfuturebecauseofchangingproductionsystemsandefficiencies.
RelationshipbetweenhectaresandjobsWhiletakingaccountoftimedependency(throughtheTvariabletakingonavalueof1foreachsuccessiveyearofthemodel)thisrelationshipneedstobeexplainedexplicitlyintheKPMGreport.Similartothelinearwaterandland-usemodel,thehectarestojobsrelationshipusingtimeseriesdatarequiresasuitabletransformationsuchasafirstdifferenceofthedependentvariable,againunlesssomeotherreasoningcanbeprovidedandregardlessofthepreferredapproachshouldbeexplainedinthetextofthereport.(Recommendation9a).Italsorequiresalagvariableofthedependentvariableasanexplanatoryvariable(Recommendation9b).Theseissueshavenowbeenexplainedinthereporting.LongerperiodfordataCurrentlyasweunderstand,thenumberofobservationsusedintheregressionforlabourisrelativelysmallcomparedwithtypicaltimesseries(orpaneldata)analysis.(Recommendation10)Thisisthemostimportantextensionofthecurrentmodellingfromaneconometricperspectivebecausethiswilladdconsiderablestatisticalpowertothemodellingandallowfortheincorporationofotherpossibleexplanatoryvariables.WenotethedatalimitationsnowdocumentedintheKPMGreportonp.5.ReferencingofdatasourcesandassumptionsFormodellingspreadsheetstheseshouldbeexplicitlystatedinthespreadsheetssoitiscleartotheviewerwherethedatahasbeenderived(Recommendation11).Whilethevarioussourceswereverballyexplainedtous,tothelayreader,heorshewillbeleftwonderingwhatthesourceswere.SuchdocumentationwillalsohelpwithinterpretationbyotherMDBAstaffnewtotheprojectorspreadsheetsandbystakeholdersreviewingthemodel.Onthislatterpointwealsorecommendthatstakeholders,particularlyindustry,verifythedatainputsinthemodel.Referencingofdatasources,assumptionsand
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
35
limitationsnowdetailedinthereportsandtheMDBAhasundertakencommunityconsultation(MDBA,p.8)thoughitisnotwithinthescopeofourtermsofreferencetoverifytheveracityofthisconsultationotherthanwhatwehaveprovidedinSection6ofourreport.ClearandexplicitpresentationoftheeconometricresultsThismustbeprovided(Recommendation12):
• Providingtherequiredstandarddiagnostictestresultsforrunningtimeseriesorpaneldatamodels,e.g.,totestforautocorrelation,endogeneityandomittedvariablebiasetc.95
• AdjustedR2insteadofsimplyR2toaccountforthenumberofexplanatoryvariablesinthemodels;thiswillbeimportantwherethenumberofobservationsarerelativelysmall.
• IsanappropriatetimeseriesmodifiedR2usedasperWooldridge96,page366-367,becauseR2fortimeseriesdataareinherentlyhighregardlessofthemodel’sunderlyingexplanatorypower?
• Allteststatisticsshouldbeexplicitlynamedcorrectlyinthespreadsheetstoeaseinterpretation.Wearesatisfiedthatthesearenowaddressedthroughbothreports,forexample,seepp.14-16oftheMDBAinterimsummaryreportandthedetailedresultsintheappendicesoftheKPMGReport.97However,ourviewisthattheunderlyingdataistimesseriesinnature.CorrectionforomittedvariablebiasCurrently,withonlyonemainvariableincludedinthemodelling,thereislikelytobeomittedvariablebiasintheresults.Thisoccurswhereonevariablecapturesthevariationofothersvariablesnotincludedinthemodel.Thisresultsinthecoefficientfortheexplanatoryvariable(haoragriculturallabouremployment)beinglargerthanitotherwiseshouldbeandforanygivenreductioninwater,andthusreductioninhaoragriculturallabouremployment,thepredictedlossinemploymentwillbeoverestimated.98(Recommendation13)Wethereforebelieveanumberofotherexplanatoryvariablesshouldbeincludedandreportedintheresultstoconfirmwhetheromittedvariablebiasisoccurring.Forexample,anon-exhaustivelistofvariablesthatmayimpactemploymentapriori(signsinbrackets)are:
• Priceoflabour(i.e.wagesrates,-)• Levelofinvestment99(+)asaproxyforcapital(seepreviouspointsaboutLabour,Capital,Land
andWatersubstitution)• Volumeofoutput(+)whichshouldbereadilyknowninanagriculturalenterprise(elseitcanbe
approximatedbythelevelofvalueaddedcalculatedbysubtractingfrombusinessvolumethevalueofintermediateoutput
• Priceofoutput(i.e.Cottonprice,+)ortoovercomemulticollinearitybetweenvolumeandpriceofoutput–thevalueofoutput
95ThecurrentlyveryhighR2forthemodelssuggestsomeunderlyingproblemsthatcanbeidentifiedandcorrectedthroughdiagnostictesting.96Wooldridge,JM(2009)IntroductoryEconometrics:AModernApproach,4e,CengageLearning,Sydney.97KPMG.(2016).NorthernBasinCommunityModelling:EconomicAssessmentofWaterRecoveryScenarios,16August2016DraftReport.Sydney:KPMG;MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftInterimReport,10Oct2016.Canberra:MDBA.98Whileomittedvariablebiasislikelytoresultinanoverestimateofimpactsoflabour,thereisalsothepotentialforunder-estimationthroughthemodellingbecausenoteveryMLofwaterrecoveryhasthesameeffectonthelocaleconomy/community.Asmoreandmorewaterisrecovered,themarginalimpactmayvary.Furthermore,thewaywaterisrecoveredmayhaveasignificantimpactonemployment,e.g.buyingwateronadayfromthebiggestoroneofthebiggestirrigatorsinacommunity.99Forexample,seeinclusionofinvestmentintheempiricallabourmarketmodellingundertakenbyLichter,A,Piechl,A,&Siegloch,A.(2012).Micro-levellabourdemandestimationforGermanyNEUJOBSWorkingPapers,April4(WorkingPaperD10.3),1-49.http://www.neujobs.eu/sites/default/files/publication/2012/04/NEUJOBS_Working%20PaperD.10.3.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
36
WearesatisfiedthatTheMDBAhasgonethroughaseriesofprocessesthattestforomittedvariablebiasasnotedintheirreportonpp.11-12.100OtherreviewercommentsWhilewehavereadthecommentsfromotherreviewersoftheLowerBalonnesocialandeconomicmodellingbytheMDBA,wehaveundertakenourreviewindependentlyoftheirconcernsinthefirstinstance,thatis,wehavereadtheseotherreviewconcernsafterdrawingourownopinions.Firstly,wehavereviewedthecommentsbyMrJimBinneyfortheQueenslandGovernmentprovidedbyPhilTownsendonFriday3June2016inmarked-upchangesonvariousearlierworkundertakenbyKPMG101andMDBAandhavenecessarilynodisagreementwithhisgeneralcomments–thoughsomeoftheseseemirrelevanttotheStGeorgeDirranbandi(Hebel)workgiventhegeneralapproachtakenbyKPMGsincethisreview(nofaultofMrBinney’s)appearstohavebeentosimplifythemodellingwithafocusonjobs.OnepointwedisagreewithisaroundtheassumedimmobilityofAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderpeoples.CRCREPresearchsuggestsotherwiseandindeedrecentevidencesuggeststheyarerecognizedas‘highlymobile’–e.g.seeDockery102page4.Secondly,wehavereadthecommentsraisedbyDNRMoftheQueenslandGovernmentprovidedbyMsSophieRollsviaemailonFriday3June2016.Againwedonotnecessarilydisagreewiththematterstheyraise.Insteadwehavefocusedourreviewonthoseissuesthatinouropinionsareimportant.Thishowever,isnottosaythatDNRM’sconcernsareanylessimportantthanours,andshouldnotalsobegivendueconsideration.Inthisway,ourrecommendationscanbeseenascorroboratinginsomeinstances,whileoriginalandadditionalinotherinstances.WethereforebelievethattheconcernsofanyotherreviewersofthemodellingworkshouldbeaddressedbyMDBAinclearlyarticulatedterms.Theincorporationorotherwiseexplanationastowhyincorporationwouldnotbeappropriateorisimpracticalshouldbeprovidedtothesereviewersortheagenciesforwhichtheyact(Recommendation14-shortterm).Wehavenotcheckedforthisbecausethisisoutsidethescopeofourtermsofreference,butrequestthatMDBAaddresstheseconcernsseparately.
100MDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReview:TechnicalOverviewofSocioeconomicAnalysis,DraftReport,2Sep2016.Canberra:MDBA.101KPMG(2016b)DevelopmentofcapabilitytoassesseffectsofwaterrecoveryfortheenvironmentatthecommunitylevelintheNorthernBasin:Modellingspecificationbrief,March,KPMG,Melbourne;KPMG(2016c)DevelopmentofcapabilitytoassesseffectsofwaterrecoveryfortheenvironmentatthecommunitylevelintheNorthernBasin:Modellingbrief,February,KPMG,Melbourne;Townsend,P(n.d.)‘ModellingirrigatedagricultureproductionintheLowerBalonne’,(LowerBalonneareayieldmodelling)Unpublished,MDBA,Canberra;Mainstream(2016)ReviewofdocumentsoutliningmodelstoassessimpactsofchangestoSustainableDiversionLimits,Mainstream,Brisbane.102Dockery, AM (2014) Reconceptualising mobility for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians, CRC-REP Working Paper CW015, Ninti One Limited, Alice Springs. Accessed 8 June 2016: http://www.crc-rep.com.au/resource/CW015_ReconceptualisingMobility.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
37
6. CommunityConsultationOverModellingIntroductionAsnotedintheintroduction,wereceivedareportoncommunityconsultationassummarizedinTable6.ThefullprocessforthisconsultationhasbeenoutlinedintheMDBAtechnicalsummaryreportforwhichwearenotcommenting–suchwouldbeoutsidethescopeofourreview–insteadwefocusonanycommunityconcernsoverthemodellingelements.BriefreviewOfthe13identified,fiveneedtobemoreexplicitlyaddressedbytheMDBAtohelpallaycommunityconcernsincluding:realestatevaluechanges,accountingorplanningforlagtimesfornewindustriestostart-up,costsbeinggreaterthanbenefits,significanceofimpactsontownsandbusinessesfrombuybacks,andthefactthatlocalirrigatorsdonotwanttoselltheirwater.Table6:IssuesraisedthroughCommunityConsultationPhase2103IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse Ourresponse
DataandInformation
CCI1 Datapaucity MDBAaskedhowhandlingdatagapspost2011.
ConstrainedbyABScensusyears–2011mostrecent(2016inprogress,availablemid2017&willbeincludedinfuturereports)yetsupplementedthrough(i)annualABSagand(ii)ABARESfarmsurveysand(iii)AustralianCollaborativeLandUseandManagementProgramMay2016updateaswellasTownsend(iv)talkingwithlocalfarmers,businessesandpeopleinthecommunity.
✔MDBAresponsevalid,except(iv)whileprovidingcontextcannot,aspresented,bevalidatedasrepresentative✖
CCI2 Jobnumbers Preferenceforactualjobnumbersratherthanpercentagechange
Incorporatedintoanalysis ✔
CCI3 Full-timeequivalents(FTEs)versusemploymentlevels
EmploymenthaslowcorrelationwithFTEs:PeaksandtroughsnotcapturedbyFTEs.
Variabilitytakenintoaccountinanalysis
✔
CCI4 Realestatevaluechanges
Whynotincludedintheanalysis?
(Noresponseprovided) ✖ ShouldbeaddressedbyMDBA,similartoourcommentinregardstoaccountingforsubstitutionbetweenfactorsofproduction:Land,LabourandCapital.
Impactlagtime
CCI5 Impactsfrompreviousbuybacksstillflowingthroughcommunities
Dirranbandiusedasanexample
Seebelow Seebelow
CCI6 Lagtimefor Temporal Lagtimelikelytobe2-5years ✖ Theanalysisshouldincorporateatleastsome
103ThistableprovidesasummaryofMDBA.(2016).NorthernBasinReviewPhase2EngagementProgram:CommunityMeetings,July2016.Canberra:MDBA.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
38
IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse Ourresponse
newindustriestostart-up
natureofimpactsandconsequencesforclosuresandstart-upsneedsgreaterconsideration
foradaptationoradjustmenttowaterrecoveryshock.Wheretownsarelookingtonewindustriesandinnovation,theyshoulddiscussbroadrangeofissuesincluding:credit,supply,andfarm-townconnections.
discussionoftemporalimpacts–atleastshorttermandintermediatetolongerterm.
ManagementofBusinessandCommunityDiversityandConnectivity
CCI7 Communityboundaries
WhydidtheyusethosedifferenttoABS?
BecauseboundarieswereestablishedbasedontakingaccountofthediverseeconomyandcommunitycontextforeachBrokenlinesindicateconnectivitybetweencommunitiesandmorebroadly–demarcationalwaysdifficult.
✔ butnotedifficultlyforthirdpartytoreproduceresultswithoutconversionofstandarddatatonewboundaries
CCI8 Noagandagbusinessrelationship
Arenotallindustriesconnectedanddependentonaginsmallagtowns?
Nonagincludes:hairdressers,retailandaccommodation.Appreciatethesearen’tunrelatedtoagesp.insmalltowns.KPMGmodellingdesignedtoaccountfortheserelationships.
✔ again,sometimesdemarcationdifficultbuthastobedone.
CCI9 StructuralchangesinStGeorge
Resultedinislessdiversityofbusinesses
(Noresponseprovided)
Buybacksversusadditionalinfrastructureinvestment
CCI10(i)
Buybacks–v-infrastructurehavedifferentimpacts
TheseneedtobeunderstoodbyMDBA
(Noresponsenecessary–seebelow.)
NA
(ii) Coststocommunitiesgreaterthanwhatpresented
Whynotafullcost-benefitanalysis?
(Nodirectresponseprovided) ✖ Needstobeexplicitlyaddressed
(iii) Significantimpactsontownsandbusinessesfrombuybacks
HowisMDBArespondingtothis?
(Nodirectresponseprovided) ✖ Needstobeexplicitlyaddressed
(iv) Localirrigatorsdonotwanttoselltheirwater
ReasonwhyAustralianGovernmentisprioritizinginfrastructurespendingoverbuybacks104
ImplicitreferencetoAustralianGovernmentWaterRecoveryStrategy?
✔ WhilestrategysetsoutGovernment’sapproachdoesthisaddresscommunityconcernsandideologicaldividebetweensavingwaterfortheenvironmentthroughbuy-backsandcreatingmorewaterforgrowersthroughinfrastructureinvestment?Thereisacaponwaterbuy-backsandplanforinvestment.✖
Climatevariabilityandchange
CCI11 Impactofdrought
Discussed Modellingthroughscenariostakesalong-termviewtotakeaccountofarangeofpressures,incl.drought,whichcommunitiesneedtomanage.MDBApresentedshiftsin
✔
104DepartmentofEnvironment.(2014).WaterRecoveryStrategyfortheMurray-DarlingBasin,June2014.Canberra:CommonwealthofAustralia.Retrievedfromhttp://www.environment.gov.au/system/files/resources/4ccb1c76-655b-4380-8e94-419185d5c777/files/water-recovery-strategy-mdb2.pdf
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
39
IssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse Ourresponse
declineincasuallabour,changeinagestructure,impactsonbusinessresultingfromdroughtovertime
CCI12 Climatechangeimpactsoncommunity
Havethesebeenincluded?
Hydrologicalmodellingdoesnotincorporateclimatechangescenariosratherincorporatesarangeofhistoricalclimateconditions105thatmorethanadequatelycapturesaverageclimatechangeimpactsonwateravailability.ReferredtoMDBAsapproachtoclimatechange106
✔
Movingforward
CCI13 QldMurray-DarlingCommittee
ComplimentaryaboutworktodateandneedtoworkwithUniversitiesonimpactsforfishandbirds
(Noresponserequired) NA
105MDBA.(2012).HydrologicalModellingtoInformtheProposedBasinPlan,February2012.Canberra:MDBA.Retrievedfromhttp://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/pubs/Hydrologic_Modelling_Report.pdf106Neave,I,McLeod,A,Raisin,G,&Swirepik,J.(2015).ManagingwaterintheMurray-DarlingBasinunderavariableandchangingclimate.Water,42(2),102-107.Retrievedfromwww.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/pubs/Managing%20water%20in%20the%20murray-darling%20basin%20under%20variable%20and%20changing%20climate.pdr
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
40
7. LowerBalonneFloodplainGrazierModellingIntroductionWhilewehavealreadyprovidedourindependentreviewreporttotheMDBAonthemodellingdonefortheStGeorgeandDirranbandi(includingHebel)communities107thisdidnotconsiderthemodellingwork(throughsimulation)donebytheMDBAontheimpactsfromincreasedenvironmentalflowsforthefloodplaingraziersoftheLowerBalonne(seeFigure9)asreportedbyWakerman-Powell108.Inthissectionofourreportweaddressthisasperourtermsofreference(seesection2Introduction).Figure9:LowerBalonneRiverFloodplain(Source:Wakerman-Powell109,p.3)
Figure10depictsaprofileofirrigationsystemsatplayintheBalonneRiverincludingtheLowerBalonneRiverFloodplain(greenshading).TheFigurekeyalsodenotesthatthisfloodplainiskeyenvironmentalassetsiteoftheBasin.UpstreamagriculturaldevelopmentontheCondamine-BalonneRivershasreducedthe‘sizeandscopeoflargeoverbankflows’and‘smallerflowswhichallowforin-channelenvironmental
107Blackwell,Boyd,McFarlane,Jim,&Stayner,Richard.(2016).IndependentReviewofMDBADirranbandi(&Hebel)andStGeorgeSocio-EconomicModellingfortheNorthernBasin:FinalReport23June2016.Armidale:UniversityofNewEngland108Wakerman-Powell,Kai.(2016).LowerBalonneFloodplainGrazingModelReport-Draft,September2016.Canberra:MDBA.109Wakerman-Powell,Kai.(2016).p.3.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
41
benefitsandstockanddomesticwater’.110ThesereducedflowshavethussignificantlyimpactedLowerBalonnegraziersandtheenvironmentoverthelast20years–somegraziershavelostasmuchasaquarterofstockandearningsfromlowerflows.111Thereforereturningflowstothefloodplainisexpectedtodeliverenvironmentalbenefitsandimprovedyieldstograziers,contributingtothebusinessesandeconomiesofGoodooga,Brewarrina(seeFigure9)andWeilmoringle.TheMDBAfloodplainreportinthisregardthereforeattemptstosimulatetheextentofbenefitsthataretransferredtograziersasaresultofthewaterscenariosforincreasedenvironmentalflowstotheLowerBalonneFloodplain,andthiswillhelprecommendarecoverytarget‘alongsideotherdetailedstudiesofenvironmental,socialandeconomicimpacts’.112Figure10:LongitudinalProfileofLowerBalonneRiverFloodplain(Source:http://www.mdba.gov.au/sites/default/files/pubs/Balonne_LP.pdf)
Thesimulationmodel,usingcomputationalandstatisticalestimationandconsultationwithgraziers,takesintoaccount‘overbankflows,rainfallandpropertyconditionstoestimategrazingproductivityonaseasonalbasis’asnotedinFigure11.113However,opportunitycroppingbenefits,orgeographicalimpactdistributionacrossthefloodplainisnottakenintoaccountandmore‘workisrequiredtotracetheimpactofspecificflowsonthefloodplain’.114Between25%and33%ofloststockproductivityandearningscanbereturnedacrossthefloodplainscenariosconsideredasmirroredbywithdrawalsofbetween278GLand390GLintheNorthernBasin.115Interestingly,greatervolumesofwaterrecoveryacrossthesescenariosmaynotnecessarilyhaveincreasingimpactsforgraziers,becauseofthevaryingdistributionofwaterrecoveryacrossvalleysandenvironmentalwaterholderuse;thereisanon-linearbenefitresponsefromincreasedenvironmentalflows.116Themodellingusesa100-yearbaselineuptoJune2009priortotheBasinPlanaswellastakingaccountofupstreamdevelopment.
110Wakerman-Powell,Kai.(2016).p.1.111Ibid.112Ibid.113Ibid.114Ibid.115Ibid.116Wakerman-Powell,Kai(2016),p.
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
42
Figure11:LowerBalonneFloodplainGrazierModelStructure117Thestockinanyoneperiodisafunctionofthecurrentseason(4seasonsincluded),thestockinthepreviousperiod,andtheoverbankflowsandrainfallovertheprevioustwoyears,asderivedfromgrazierconsultations,whereoverbankflowsonthefloodplainhavelargelaggedeffectsandaresequencedependent.
ReviewItemsOverallthemodellingforfloodplainglazierimpactsappearsthoroughbeingcontextualizedbyconsultationanddiscussionwithgrazierstobetterinterprettheresults(e.g.Seegraziercommentp.8aboutevensmallflowsindryyearsfollowinganoverbankflowyearpresentsanidealsequence).Wealsobelievethemodellinghasbeenpreparedinasufficientlycomplexway(usingexcelsheets,simulations,MonteCarloresultsestimation,computationallyoptimizedmodelvariables,seasonality,conditionsasrulesbased,separateestimationofcarryingcapacityandearningswiththelatterestimatedseasonally)yetgroundedbyin-builtrulesthatmirrorgrazierpracticaldecisionmaking.ThefullsetofmodellingassumptionsandlimitationsareoutlinedintheAppendixB:ModelDesignofWakerman-Powell(2016).Forthisreason,wehavenomajorconcernswiththeLowerBalonneFloodplainGrazingModeloritsreportotherthanthoseoutlinedinTable4,andonlyoneofthesemaybeusefultoconsiderinfuturemodellingwork(seeGI3inTable4)undertakenbytheMDBA.
117UpateviaWakerman-Powell,K.(2016)Pers.Comms(Email),13Oct2016,Canberra:MDBAofWakerman-Powell(2016,p.25).
FINALNORTHERNMURRAYDARLINGBASINSOCIO-ECONOMICMODELLINGREVIEW12OCTOBER2016
43
Table7:SummaryofreviewitemsIssueNo.
Issue Detail MDBAresponse
GI1 Earningsmodelling–inclusionoffullcosts
Overheadorfixedcostscouldbeincludedintheearningestimatestoprovidenetearnings(toensuregrazierstakeaccountoflandtaxes,capitalassets,managerincome–notedonp.15–andforgoneincometothemselves),however,onlyconsideringthemarginalcostsisaneconomicallyvalidapproachandfixedcostandwealtheffectsareexplicitlynotedasnotincludedinthemodellinginAppendixB,p.43andasalimitation.
✔Floodplainmodelledasasingleunitratherthanforindividualbusiness–toogreatavariation(10-20timessizedifference,smallesttolargest)tomodelatypicalbusinessplusmodellingcomplexities(changesinbusinessstructure/processesfromwaterchanges)outsideproject’sscope.118
GI2 Earningsmodelling–inclusionofrelevantmarginalcosts
Establishingwhetherfloodplaingrazingisviableshouldincludeconsiderationofallrelevantmarginalcosts(asnotedabove)butalsoforgoneincometograziersthemselves–toensuretheyearnenoughtopaythemselvesfortheirefforts),otherwisetheseco-benefitsofenvironmentalflowsshouldbeseenasco-costs/non-benefitsofwaterfortheenvironment.
✔Labourcosts(variable)explicitlyincludedinmodelling,thoughnot‘forsell-offs’or‘agistmentwhichmostlyinvolveloadingandunloading’stock.119
GI3 Yearlyearningsestimates–incorporationoftimevalueofmoney
Asnotedbyauthoronp.32,theseneedtobesummedovertimebecausetheyaretypicallyearnedatpointsintime.Hastheauthorconsideredtimevalueofmoneyintheirearningsmodelsandifnot,itmaybebettertoconvertannualbenefitstonetpresentvaluestoaccountforthemismatchofcostsandbenefitflowsovertime.
✔Yeswasconsideredthoughresultstobeinterpretedaswhatisexpectednextyearunderthedifferentscenarios,NPVmayconfoundsomeoftheimportantmessagesaboutsequenceofflowsbecausevolumesnotrandomlydistributedthroughtime,itdoesnotincludecostsandbenefitsforcottonreducedupstreamandisonlyapartialanalysis,andresultsrelatetowholefloodplainandnotindividualbusinesses.Recommendtheinclusionofthesecomplexitiesinfuturemodelling.
GI4 Modeldrivenbywaterinputratherthancommodityprices
Otherfactorsmaydrivegrazierdecisionsmorethanenvironmentalflows,suchascommoditypricesandexchangerates.Wakerman-Powellspecificallynotesthisonp.43ofAppendix,particularlywhereafterdroughtrestockingisassignificanttodecisionmakingasreturnofwater.
Notnecessary
118Wakerman-Powell(2016)Pers.Comms(Email),16Sep2016,MDBA,Camberra.119Ibid.Wakerman-Powellprovidedspreadsheetmodelthatincludes‘workingcosts’assheepandpricingvariables.