Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

52
FINAL REVIEW Elaine Mau // Professional Supply Chain Intern

Transcript of Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Page 1: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

FINAL REVIEW

Elaine Mau // Professional Supply Chain Intern

Page 2: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Overview

� Projects

� Progress at Midpoint

� Since Midterm

� Follow-up

� Success Criteria and Milestones

� Questions

� Acknowledgement

Page 3: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Priority 1

FI on Line 12 Un-scrambler

Page 4: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Progress at Midpoint

Page 5: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 3: Analyze Causes

� Bowl Exit Chute� Where: Top and bend of chute outside the bowl

� Phenomenon: Bottles getting jammed between rail or sticking to rail

� Why 1: Worn electrical brushes on preorienter motor cause erratic stops and goes, resulting in uneven flow of bottles and therefore produced jams

� Why 2: The coating on railings caused too much friction and constricted the area in which the bottle can pass through.

� Why 3: Dimensions of the chute did not direct bottles as designed.

Page 6: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 4 & 5: Plan and implement improvement

� TBM (PM 1656) for electrical brushes

� Use spare chute

Page 7: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 6: Check Results

Results for Brushes Replaced

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Bowl Exit

Chut e

Turn

Table

Flipped

Bot t les

Paddle

Wheel

Bowl

Phot oeye

Slot

Ot her Overf ill Bad

Bot t les

No

Bot t les

Baseline Brushes replaced

Page 8: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 6: Check Results

Results for Replacing Existing Chute with Line 10 Chute

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Bowl Exit

Chute

Turn

Table

Flipped

Bottles

Paddle

Wheel

Bowl

Photoeye

Slot

Other Overfill Bad

Bottles

No

Bottles

Av

era

ge

Nu

mb

er

of

Sto

ps

Pe

r S

hif

t

Baseline Replaced Chute

Page 9: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 3: Analyze Causes

� Fallen Bottles� Where: On the conveyor as bottles exits the unscrambler

� Phenomenon: Bottles get stuck in the space when it falls.

� Why: Bottles have room to get stuck.

Page 10: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 4 & 5: Plan and implement improvement

� Lowered rails and centerlined

Page 11: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 3: Analyze Causes

� Turn Table� Where: As bottles flip up onto the conveyor

� Phenomenon: Bottles jams between rails and conveyor

� Why: Buckets and rails are not in correct centerlines (unmarked)

Page 12: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 4 & 5: Plan and implement improvement

� Rails moved and centerlined

Page 13: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 3: Analyze Causes

� Paddlewheel� Where: Paddle wheel

� Phenomenon: Bottles jams between rails and paddle wheel

� Why: Gap allows bottles to get stuck

Page 14: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 4 & 5: Plan and implement improvement

� Paddlewheel moved closer and centerlined

Page 15: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 6: Check Results

Final Results for FI Unscrambler Project

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Bowl Exit

Chute

Turn

Table

Flipped

Bottles

Paddle

Wheel

Bowl

Photoeye

Slo t

Other Overfill Bad

Bottles

No

Bottles

Av

era

ge

Nu

mb

er

of

Sto

ps

Pe

r S

hif

t

Baseline Present

85% reduction

100%91%

Page 16: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 7: Consolidate Gains

� Replaced rail with spare chute

� Pin the paddlewheel at new position

� Pin conveyor rail to prevent fallen bottles

� Centerline turntable rails

� Unscrambler speed centerlined and added in documentation

� Centerline audit added to CIL

� Reapplication unscrambler improvements Ln 10, Ln 5

Page 17: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Success Criteria and Milestones

� Success Criteria

� Reduce minor stops due unscrambler from 8.33% PR (40 minutes) to 3.23% PR (15 minutes) per shift

� Milestones

� Achieved 3.03% PR (14.5 minutes) minor loss

� Significantly reduced bowl exit chute jams

� Eliminated fallen bottle and paddlewheel problems

Page 18: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Priority 1

Line 12 Speed Optimization Analysis

Page 19: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Progress at Midpoint

Page 20: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Results

Minor Stops

Loss

PR

Page 21: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Optimal Speed and Observations

� Constraint Factors

� Unscrambler

� Labeller Slugs

� Ratio of speed between each unit op.

Un-scramblerDye-

Filler/CapperLabeller Cartoner

210 207 210 216

3-4 bottles

faster

3 bottles

slower

Belt Speed:

1.00 ft/sec

Constraint

Machine

Page 22: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Additional Work

� Uneven bottle piles in chute� Where: Between long and short conveyor belt

� Phenomenon: Synchronization of long and short belt and eyes

� Why: Bottle material causes sticking between bottles as well as belt set-up create alternating large and small piles of bottles

Page 23: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Plan and implement improvement

� Electrical- Maxi-Beam Sensor Head

� Mechanical- Add-on

� Speed adjustment to make up any losses

Page 24: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Additional Work

� Falling bottles� Where: Between unscrambler and dye-filler/capper

� Phenomenon: Bottles fall on conveyor belt

� Why: Balance of forces from hitting against each other and from belt friction

F

F

F

FFFriction

N

Page 25: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Plan and implement improvement

� Cleaned to baseline condition

� Work order for missing zerk fitting and hose

� Optimal Speed: 1.00 ft/sec, posted

Page 26: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Actions to sustain the gain

� Centerlines posted on each equipment, belt, unscrambler

� OPL on speed analysis results

� Work order for zerk fitting tubing

Page 27: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Follow-up

� Unscrambler

� Ability to run faster

� Additional mechanical adjustment and replacements

� Labeller Slug Issue

� Thermal Imaging Unit

Page 28: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Success Criteria and Milestones

� Success Criteria

� Familiarized with line personnel

� Validated lines speeds posted on each unit op.

� Minor stops PR reduction by 2%

� Milestones

� Familiarized with line personnel

� Validated line speed posted on each unit op.

� Minor stops PR reduction by 7%

Page 29: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Priority 2

Line 10 Rapid Changeover

Page 30: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Progress at Midpoint

Page 31: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 1: Understand the Situation

Purging Bottle

Chute

Page 32: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 2 & 3: Identify improvement Ideas and plan the improvements

Page 33: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 2 & 3: Identify improvement Ideas and plan the improvements

� Separate Internal from External

� Streamline the internal

Page 34: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 2 & 3: Identify improvement Ideas and plan the improvements

� Streamline Internal

� Perform Parallel Operations

Page 35: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Task Sheets

� Training material to implement changes

Page 36: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 4: Implement Improvements

Page 37: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 4: Implement Improvements

� Major Loss: Bottle Dumping (up to 1½ hrs!)

�Meetings

�OPLs

� Visual Control

PLANNER LTBOTTLE DUMPER COORDINATOR

Product Labels Shippers

Bottles and

Caps

Changes in scheduleScrap material

Over/under usage

Page 38: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

OPLs for Bottle Dumping

Page 39: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Visual Controls

Page 40: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 5: Check Results

Saves 31.3

Minutes!

Page 41: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Step 6: Consolidate Gains

� Drip pan installed

� Chutes have visual controls for bottles and caps

� OPLs for bottle dumping procedure for normal production and brand to brand change over

� Task Sheets for B/C -> Jazzing

� Reapplication- any line that requires many changeovers

Page 42: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Follow-up

� Continued work with bottle dumpers and line technician, Lena Dushku

� This week:

� Final Training Session (sign), planned for Tuesday, August 12th, 2008 both shifts

Page 43: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Success Criteria and Milestones

� Success Criteria

� Reduce c/o time from 100 minutes to 80 minutes

� Milestones

� Reduce c/o time from 100 minutes to 60-70 minutes

� Eliminated bottle excess during changeover

Page 44: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Priority 3

Y-Y Analysis on Line 15 Kalish Filler

Page 45: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Erratic fill weight for gallon bottles

� Where: Filler nozzle

� Phenomenon: Pumps do not fill bottles with consistent weights

� Why 1: Because of hot water washouts, aculyn build up causes different torques on each motor

� Why 2: Pumps gears are worn out

� Why 3: Leaking nozzles had wrong O-rings

Page 46: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Actions Implemented to Sustain the Gain

� Adjusted SOP to use cold DI water vs hot DI water

� Nick Dushku and Joseph Iorfino will continue validation work

� Reapply approach from line 33 developer filler to manage idle time

� This week:

� Change to new pumps

� Continue with cold water washout

Page 47: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Priority 3

Y-Y Analysis on Line 1 Conditioner Filler

Page 48: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Heating Cone Contamination on Line 1 Conditioner Filler

� Where: Heating cone

� Phenomenon: Leaking nozzles leads to contamination of heater cones

� Why 1: Leaking nozzles due to worn nozzle stems.

� Why 2: Leaking nozzles due to unsynchronized nozzle closing.

Page 49: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Results

� Day 1 Baseline � Week 1 Present� Day 1 Present

Page 50: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Actions Implemented to Sustain the Gain

� TBM from 1 year to 8 months

� Centerline

Page 51: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Thank you!

Travis Gombos, Karnik Patel, Joseph Deleo, Kevin Shaw, RanjithMathew

Miguel Paz, Charlie Popp, Peter Bybel, David Velez, Rocco Catalano, Jerry Talis, Geraldine Miller, Douglas, Age I., Eduardo, Tony, Marizol, Paul, Emmillianne, Lena Dushku, Mary Thompson

Bob Fitts, Eddie Lopez, Bob Flitner, Ernie, Tony, Lee Copolla, Luis, Alexis, Nestor Mendez

Page 52: Final Review Elaine Mau Procter and Gamble

Any Questions?