FACILITATED )INDUSTRIAL)SYMBIOSIS) Thecirculareconomyinacon) · 2018. 9. 13. · • G7 Alliance...

© Copyright Interna0onal Synergies Limited -‐ 2016

FACILITATED INDUSTRIAL SYMBIOSIS The circular economy in ac>on

Peter Laybourn Chief Execu>ve

Interna>onal Synergies Limited

The circular economy package: what’s in it for the regions? 5th February 2016, Brussels


Interna>onal Synergies Limited – Our Vision

"Striving to lead the world in innova>ve industrial ecology solu>ons for a low

carbon, sustainable economy"


Sri Lanka

Hungary

Turkey

South Korea

Romania

Mexico

Chile

Poland

Belgium

Brazil

Italy

Netherlands Slovakia

United Kingdom

Finland

South Africa

Kenya Uganda

China

USA

Australia

Canada

Denmark France

Ghana Burkina Faso

Germany

Spain

Interna>onal Synergies’ Global Experience 2015 Expressions of Interest

Cambodia

Egypt

Namibia

Mozambique

Portugal

Tanzania

Peru

Senegal

Mauritius

Vietnam


Industrial symbiosis delivers for regions:

•  Resource efficiency •  Demand-‐led innova0on •  SME engagement •  Landfill diversion •  Water savings •  Carbon emissions reduc0on •  Virgin material savings •  Jobs •  Cascading of best prac0ce •  Increased sales, reduced costs, profits leading to tax revenues


Driving factors for Business, for Europe

Risk

Cost

Profit

Growth

Jobs

Compe>>veness

For Business For Europe


Added Value in Policy Terms for Big Agendas and suppor>ve evidence base

Eco- Innovation

Circular Economy

Green Growth

Sustainable Development Goals

Resource Efficiency

Climate Change Mitigation

•  UNEP •  WWF •  OECD •  ETAP •  DG INNO •  Worldwatch Institute

•  European Commission CE package •  UNIDO •  Accenture •  The Circulars •  Globescan 2015 •  FP7 POLFREE & DYNAMIX

•  Global Green Growth Forum •  Global Green Business

Summit •  GLOBE •  DG Regions •  DG Grow •  Technopolis report

•  United Nations SDGs 8, 9, 12, 13, 17

•  G7 Alliance for Resource Efficiency •  EREP •  Manufacturing Commission 2015 •  Roadmap to a Resource Efficient

Europe •  COWI report

•  UK FCO •  Financial Times •  Nature Climate •  Renewable Energy

Focus

Facilitated Industrial Symbiosis


Circular Economy Business Models

Circular supplies Resource recovery Product life extension Sharing platforms Product as service

Accenture, 2014, Circular Advantage


•  Accenture 2014 Circular Advantage •  Globescan 2015 www.govsgocircular.com Top 30 circular economy best prac0ce examples for governments (two are industrial symbiosis examples)

Report co-‐authored by Accenture, De Groene Zaak, EY, IMSA and Royal Haskoning DHV

•  FP7 POLFREE & DYNAMIX 2015 (Top 10) •  Manufacturing Commission 2015 Industrial Evolu0on

Circular economy recommenda>ons for industrial symbiosis:


Input savings Lower embedded energy in processing recycled materials than virgin raw materials

Process savings Savings in gas, electricity or other fuel use by one of the synergy partners principally through innovation

Fuel substitution Replacing fossil fuels with other non fossil fuel sources in industrial processes

Transport savings Reduction in transport directly associated with synergies

Disposal savings Reduction in biodegradable material sent to landfill

Energy Savings Production of energy through, for example, anaerobic digestion and utilisation of waste heat

Industrial symbiosis addresses climate change mi>ga>on (COP21)


OECD Iden>fies Industrial Symbiosis as Cri>cal to Green Growth Agenda

OECD declared industrial symbiosis ‘a la NISP’ to be “an excellent example of systemic innova>on vital for future green growth”

Pollu>on Control

Cleaner Produc>on

Eco-‐efficiency Lifecycle Management Closed-‐loop Produc>on

Industrial Symbiosis

Green products

Eco-‐design

New business models

New modes of provision

Mass applica>on Product & Service

Produc>on Process

Organisa>onal Boundary

Incremental Innova>on Systemic Innova>on


Facilitated Industrial Symbiosis a la NISP®: Circular Economy in Ac>on

(Lombardi and Laybourn, 2012. J. Industrial Ecology)

Success factors: •  Practitioners with

industrial experience •  Engagement model (all sectors, all sizes) •  Holistic approach:

resources, materials, energy, capacity, expertise, logistics

•  Data + ICT Synergie®

Impacts: •  Eco-Innovation •  Jobs, green growth •  Improved business processes •  Best practice sharing and

cascading

•  Regional economic development


•  Regional Development Agencies (Local Enterprise Partnerships)

•  Environment Agency/Regulator •  Universi0es as innova0ve solu0on providers •  Knowledge Transfer Networks (Catapults) •  Public sector investment for facilita0on

Partnerships are key to maximise opportuni>es


•  Poor implementa0on (we know the reasons) •  Dogma “if industry benefits they should pay” •  Short term investment •  Percep0on “all about waste” •  To date H2020 not really helpful •  Not enough champions

Some challenges …


Engagement is at the Heart of NISP: Connec>ng Industry -‐ Crea>ng Opportunity


Opportunity Mapping


Thousands of Case Studies (Synergies)


NISP® (England) Delivered Outcomes April 2005 -‐ March 2013

€43.4 million investment since 2005 *All outputs independently verified Rate of return for Govt. 9:1 Exchange rate £1 = €1.18

METRICS In Year Benefits* Life>me Impact (Max 5 year)

Landfill diversion 9.4 million tonnes 47 million tonnes CO2 reduc>on 8.4 million tonnes 42 million tonnes Virgin material savings 12 million tonnes 60 million tonnes Hazardous waste eliminated 0.4 million tonnes 2.1 million tonnes Water savings 15 million tonnes 72 million tonnes

Cost savings €243 million €1.21 billion Addi>onal sales €234 million €1.17 billion Jobs 10,000+ Private investment €374 million


NISP Economic Valuation Report, by Manchester Economics 2009

We’ve achieved: NISP® (England) Economic Impact Assessment

Total investment over 5 years

£27 million

Total Economic Value Added

£1.5 -‐ £2.5 billion

Direct receipts to Government

£148 -‐ £247 million

Benefit Cost Ra0o 32:1 to 53 :1


February 2nd 2016 Rhône-‐Alpes Workshop


– 

Implementa>on: Regions Having IS Specific Ac>vi>es/Strategies

None!Regions having IS specific activities/strategies!


•  Planning/regenera0on •  Inward investment •  Construc0on and u0li0es (MIROG) •  Involvement of public sector (par0cipa0on) •  Knowledge transfer •  Post-‐disaster/post-‐conflict situa0ons •  ASPIRATION Government direct involvement e.g. defence, health, transport etc.

Steady stream of innova>ve applica>ons


Pro-‐ac>ve Planning for Economic Development & Regenera>on (Birmingham)

Industrial plas0cs

ASR/ash for metal recovery Site 4

Site 1

Site 3 Site 2

Site 5

MSW Non-‐recyclable

Clean plas0cs

RDF

Acids

WEEE

Non-‐recyclable plas0cs

ASR

Paper sludge

Food waste

Bokom ash for metal recovery

Medical waste

Recovered metals

plas0cs

Char Repaired equipm

ent

Recovered acids Bin bags

Fuel cells

Plas0cs manufacturer

ERF


Paper Sludge & Ash

Paper Co Water

Rejected Loads

Incinera>on

2 partners 1 partner

Vermiculture

Aggregate Produc>on

Construc>on

4 partners

Waste Paper

4 partners

Screening Materials

12 partners

Power

Soil Condi>oning

Organics Plas>cs

5 partners

1 partner

5 partners

2 partners

4 partners

7 partners

Industrial Symbiosis Opportuni>es: Aurac>ng Inward Investment


Concluding Remarks Industrial symbiosis is…

•  An excellent model to help deliver circular economy •  A flexible tool to contribu0ng to global agendas •  Ideally delivered at the regional level though na0onal coordina0on gives added value

•  Available today -‐ new implementers can learn from our experience and proven tools

•  Providing an excellent return on investment “Scaling up what works is the best strategy for green growth.”

Global Green Growth Forum (3GF)


Peter Laybourn Chief Execu0ve

Interna>onal Synergies Limited

t: +44 (0) 121 433 2660 www.interna0onal-‐synergies.com

@IntlSynergies @NISPnetwork

Thank you for listening...


Business Opportunity Workshop, South Africa


•  European Waste Framework Direc0ve -‐ Best Prac0ce (2009)* •  Roadmap to a Resource Efficient Europe – exemplar (2011)* •  DG Regions: Connec0ng Smart and Sustainable Growth through

Smart Specialisa0on – exemplar (2012)*

•  DG Enterprise: Communique on Green Entrepreneurship (2013) •  European Resource Efficiency Plarorm key recommenda0on

(2014)

•  DG Innova0on and Research: Short guide to assessing environmental impacts of research and innova0on policy (2014) *

•  Circular Economy Package (forthcoming 2015) + Turkey, South Africa and others

European Commission promotes industrial symbiosis for eco-‐innova>on & green growth

* Ci0ng NISP ®


Heinz Leuenberger -‐ 2014 Former Director of Environmental Branch UNIDO

“The concept of industrial symbiosis is indispensable to the long-‐term development of global industry in all countries of the world. Developing economies around the world can achieve a more sustainable industrial development trajectory and move their economies towards a circular model more rapidly by taking advantage of the opportuni0es inherent in this approach.”

FACILITATED )INDUSTRIAL)SYMBIOSIS) Thecirculareconomyinacon) · 2018. 9. 13. · • G7 Alliance...

Documents

Transcript of FACILITATED )INDUSTRIAL)SYMBIOSIS) Thecirculareconomyinacon) · 2018. 9. 13. · • G7 Alliance...