EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean...

36
EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF PARTIAL CONSENT DECREE MDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC) EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 1 of 36

Transcript of EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean...

Page 1: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

 

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREE MDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

EXHIBIT 3

Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 1 of 36

Page 2: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016Advanced Environmental Group LLC

VW-2LCMT0000001 VW-2LCMT0000002 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016 Air Alliance Houston VW-2LCMT0000003 VW-2LCMT0000004 Exhibit 4A

8/1/2016Alabama Department of Environmental Management

VW-2LCMT0000005 VW-2LCMT0000005 Exhibit 4A

8/3/2016American Association of Port Authorities

VW-2LCMT0000006 VW-2LCMT0000008 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016 American Bus Association VW-2LCMT0000009 VW-2LCMT0000011 Exhibit 4A8/4/2016 American Idle Reduction VW-2LCMT0000012 VW-2LCMT0000012 Exhibit 4A8/4/2016 American Lung Association VW-2LCMT0000013 VW-2LCMT0000019 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000020 VW-2LCMT0000021 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016Association of Truck Stop Electrification Providers

VW-2LCMT0000022 VW-2LCMT0000054 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016

Attorneys General: GA; HI; IA; ID; MD; ME; NH; NJ; NY; TN; UT; VA; VT; WA; WI; WY

VW-2LCMT0000055 VW-2LCMT0000074 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016Berkshire Hathaway Energy Company

VW-2LCMT0000075 VW-2LCMT0000078 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016 Blue Bird Corporation VW-2LCMT0000079 VW-2LCMT0000081 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016Blue Bird Corporation - Attachment 1

VW-2LCMT0000082 VW-2LCMT0000084 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016 Boyden Gray & Associates VW-2LCMT0000085 VW-2LCMT0000109 Exhibit 4A7/26/2016 Brian Kurtz Trucking Ltd. VW-2LCMT0000110 VW-2LCMT0000110 Exhibit 4A7/26/2016 Brilliant Light Power VW-2LCMT0000111 VW-2LCMT0000112 Exhibit 4A8/5/2016 BYD America VW-2LCMT0000113 VW-2LCMT0000116 Exhibit 4A8/4/2016 California Assemblymen VW-2LCMT0000117 VW-2LCMT0000119 Exhibit 4A8/5/2016 California Greenworks VW-2LCMT0000120 VW-2LCMT0000121 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016California Greenworks - Attachment 1

VW-2LCMT0000122 VW-2LCMT0000124 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016California Greenworks - Attachment 2

VW-2LCMT0000125 VW-2LCMT0000127 Exhibit 4A

8/5/2016Center for American Progress

VW-2LCMT0000128 VW-2LCMT0000129 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Center for American Progress - Attachment 1

VW-2LCMT0000130 VW-2LCMT0000155 Exhibit 4B

N/A Chargepoint VW-2LCMT0000156 VW-2LCMT0000157 Exhibit 4B

Page 1 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 2 of 36

Page 3: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016 ChargePoint, Inc. VW-2LCMT0000158 VW-2LCMT0000171 Exhibit 4B8/5/2016 Cherokee Nation VW-2LCMT0000172 VW-2LCMT0000189 Exhibit 4B8/3/2016 Chirping Frogs Farm VW-2LCMT0000190 VW-2LCMT0000191 Exhibit 4B8/5/2016 City of Philadelphia VW-2LCMT0000192 VW-2LCMT0000196 Exhibit 4B

8/4/2016City of Phoenix/Valley of the Sun Clean Cities Coalition

VW-2LCMT0000197 VW-2LCMT0000198 Exhibit 4B

8/4/2016 City of Somerville, Mass. VW-2LCMT0000199 VW-2LCMT0000200 Exhibit 4B8/3/2016 Clean Air Minnesota VW-2LCMT0000201 VW-2LCMT0000202 Exhibit 4B8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Michigan VW-2LCMT0000203 VW-2LCMT0000204 Exhibit 4B8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210 VW-2LCMT0000216 Exhibit 4B7/31/2016 CleanFuture, Inc. VW-2LCMT0000217 VW-2LCMT0000218 Exhibit 4B8/4/2016 Clinton Global Initiative VW-2LCMT0000219 VW-2LCMT0000221 Exhibit 4B

8/4/2016Clinton Global Initiative - Attachment 1

VW-2LCMT0000222 VW-2LCMT0000224 Exhibit 4B

7/29/2016 CNG Cylinders International VW-2LCMT0000225 VW-2LCMT0000225 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment

VW-2LCMT0000226 VW-2LCMT0000227 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Columbia-Willamette Clean Cities Coalition

VW-2LCMT0000228 VW-2LCMT0000229 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Colville Tribal Federal Corporation

VW-2LCMT0000230 VW-2LCMT0000230 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Competitive Enterprise Institute

VW-2LCMT0000231 VW-2LCMT0000245 Exhibit 4B

8/4/2016Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection

VW-2LCMT0000246 VW-2LCMT0000247 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Consolidated Comments of Alternative Fuel Providers

VW-2LCMT0000248 VW-2LCMT0000253 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Consolidated Edison Company of New York

VW-2LCMT0000254 VW-2LCMT0000255 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016Consumers Union / Consumer Reports

VW-2LCMT0000256 VW-2LCMT0000268 Exhibit 4B

8/5/2016 CSX VW-2LCMT0000269 VW-2LCMT0000272 Exhibit 4B

Page 2 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 3 of 36

Page 4: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016Diesel Emissions Reduction Act Coalition

VW-2LCMT0000273 VW-2LCMT0000278 Exhibit 4B

8/4/2016 Diesel Technology Forum VW-2LCMT0000279 VW-2LCMT0000287 Exhibit 4B8/5/2016 Diesel Technology Forum VW-2LCMT0000288 VW-2LCMT0000296 Exhibit 4C8/5/2016 Drive Electric Florida VW-2LCMT0000297 VW-2LCMT0000297 Exhibit 4C8/4/2016 Drive Electric Minnesota VW-2LCMT0000298 VW-2LCMT0000301 Exhibit 4C8/4/2016 Duke Energy VW-2LCMT0000302 VW-2LCMT0000303 Exhibit 4C

7/27/2016Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians

VW-2LCMT0000304 VW-2LCMT0000306 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians

VW-2LCMT0000307 VW-2LCMT0000333 Exhibit 4C

7/15/2016 Edison Electric Institute VW-2LCMT0000334 VW-2LCMT0000339 Exhibit 4C8/5/2016 Edison Electric Institute VW-2LCMT0000340 VW-2LCMT0000340 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016 Environmental Defense Fund VW-2LCMT0000341 VW-2LCMT0000346 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016 Envision Solar International VW-2LCMT0000347 VW-2LCMT0000350 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Envision Solar International - Attachment 1

VW-2LCMT0000351 VW-2LCMT0000354 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016 ESW Group VW-2LCMT0000355 VW-2LCMT0000356 Exhibit 4C8/5/2016 EVgo Services LLC VW-2LCMT0000357 VW-2LCMT0000359 Exhibit 4C8/5/2016 Feinman, James B. VW-2LCMT0000360 VW-2LCMT0000364 Exhibit 4C7/26/2016 First Priority Green Fleet VW-2LCMT0000365 VW-2LCMT0000366 Exhibit 4C7/28/2016 First Priority Green Fleet VW-2LCMT0000367 VW-2LCMT0000370 Exhibit 4C

7/22/2016Foundation for California Community Colleges

VW-2LCMT0000371 VW-2LCMT0000372 Exhibit 4C

7/29/2016 Georgia Ports Authority VW-2LCMT0000373 VW-2LCMT0000374 Exhibit 4C8/5/2016 Governor of Oregon VW-2LCMT0000375 VW-2LCMT0000379 Exhibit 4C

8/3/2016Greater Washington Region Clean Cities Coalition

VW-2LCMT0000380 VW-2LCMT0000380 Exhibit 4C

7/21/2016 Green Commuter VW-2LCMT0000381 VW-2LCMT0000381 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Harvard University, Boston University Professors

VW-2LCMT0000382 VW-2LCMT0000383 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Harvard University, Boston University Professors - Attachment 1

VW-2LCMT0000384 VW-2LCMT0000396 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Idaho Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000397 VW-2LCMT0000397 Exhibit 4C

Page 3 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 4 of 36

Page 5: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016IdleAir / Convoy Sollutions, LLC

VW-2LCMT0000398 VW-2LCMT0000431 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016 Illinois Attorney General VW-2LCMT0000432 VW-2LCMT0000436 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Johns Hopkins School of Public Health

VW-2LCMT0000437 VW-2LCMT0000440 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016 Kansas Attorney General VW-2LCMT0000441 VW-2LCMT0000443 Exhibit 4C

8/2/2016Kentucky Energy and Environment Cabinet

VW-2LCMT0000444 VW-2LCMT0000446 Exhibit 4C

8/3/2016 Maersk Agency USA VW-2LCMT0000447 VW-2LCMT0000448 Exhibit 4C

8/5/2016Manufacturers of Emission Controls Association

VW-2LCMT0000449 VW-2LCMT0000452 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016Maryland Department of Environment

VW-2LCMT0000453 VW-2LCMT0000454 Exhibit 4D

8/3/2016Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority

VW-2LCMT0000455 VW-2LCMT0000458 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection

VW-2LCMT0000459 VW-2LCMT0000461 Exhibit 4D

8/3/2016 Members of U.S. Senate VW-2LCMT0000462 VW-2LCMT0000463 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016Michigan Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000464 VW-2LCMT0000489 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

VW-2LCMT0000490 VW-2LCMT0000495 Exhibit 4D

8/4/2016Missouri Department of Natural Resources

VW-2LCMT0000496 VW-2LCMT0000498 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016Montana Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000499 VW-2LCMT0000500 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016 Moving Forward Network VW-2LCMT0000501 VW-2LCMT0000503 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016NAFA Fleet Management Association

VW-2LCMT0000504 VW-2LCMT0000506 Exhibit 4D

8/2/2016National Association of Clean Air Agencies

VW-2LCMT0000507 VW-2LCMT0000514 Exhibit 4D

8/2/2016National Association of Clean Air Agencies

VW-2LCMT0000515 VW-2LCMT0000530 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016National Association of State Energy Officials

VW-2LCMT0000531 VW-2LCMT0000538 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016 National BioDiesel Board VW-2LCMT0000539 VW-2LCMT0000545 Exhibit 4D

Page 4 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 5 of 36

Page 6: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016National Tribal Air Association/Tribal Air Monitoring Support Center

VW-2LCMT0000546 VW-2LCMT0000552 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016Natural Resources Defense Council

VW-2LCMT0000553 VW-2LCMT0000560 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services

VW-2LCMT0000561 VW-2LCMT0000566 Exhibit 4D

8/5/2016New Jersey Attorney General

VW-2LCMT0000567 VW-2LCMT0000568 Exhibit 4D

8/3/2016New York State Department of Environmental Conservation

VW-2LCMT0000569 VW-2LCMT0000571 Exhibit 4D

7/27/2016 NextEV VW-2LCMT0000572 VW-2LCMT0000573 Exhibit 4D7/26/2016 North American Repower VW-2LCMT0000574 VW-2LCMT0000578 Exhibit 4E8/4/2016 North American Repower VW-2LCMT0000579 VW-2LCMT0000598 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016North Central Texas Council of Governments

VW-2LCMT0000599 VW-2LCMT0000603 Exhibit 4E

8/4/2016North Florida Clean Fuels Coalition

VW-2LCMT0000604 VW-2LCMT0000604 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016Northeast States for Coordinated Air Use Management

VW-2LCMT0000605 VW-2LCMT0000606 Exhibit 4E

8/1/2016Northwest Environmental Defense Center

VW-2LCMT0000607 VW-2LCMT0000611 Exhibit 4E

7/26/2016 Nuvera Fuel Cells, LLC VW-2LCMT0000612 VW-2LCMT0000612 Exhibit 4E

8/3/2016Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

VW-2LCMT0000613 VW-2LCMT0000616 Exhibit 4E

8/3/2016Ohio Environmental Protection Agency - Attachment

VW-2LCMT0000617 VW-2LCMT0000672 Exhibit 4E

7/29/2016 Paper Transport Inc. VW-2LCMT0000673 VW-2LCMT0000673 Exhibit 4E

7/29/2016Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection

VW-2LCMT0000674 VW-2LCMT0000683 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016 Plug In America VW-2LCMT0000684 VW-2LCMT0000687 Exhibit 4E

8/4/2016Pollution Prevention Resource Center

VW-2LCMT0000688 VW-2LCMT0000689 Exhibit 4E

Page 5 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 6 of 36

Page 7: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/4/2016 Port Authority of NY & NJ VW-2LCMT0000690 VW-2LCMT0000691 Exhibit 4E8/3/2016 Port of Houston Authority VW-2LCMT0000692 VW-2LCMT0000693 Exhibit 4E8/1/2016 Port of Long Beach VW-2LCMT0000694 VW-2LCMT0000696 Exhibit 4E8/3/2016 Port of Los Angeles VW-2LCMT0000697 VW-2LCMT0000700 Exhibit 4E8/5/2016 Port of New Orleans VW-2LCMT0000701 VW-2LCMT0000702 Exhibit 4E7/29/2016 Port of Portland VW-2LCMT0000703 VW-2LCMT0000703 Exhibit 4E8/2/2016 Port of Seattle VW-2LCMT0000704 VW-2LCMT0000706 Exhibit 4E8/4/2016 Proterra VW-2LCMT0000707 VW-2LCMT0000710 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016Puget Sound Clean Air Agency

VW-2LCMT0000711 VW-2LCMT0000714 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016 ReachNow VW-2LCMT0000715 VW-2LCMT0000716 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016Renewable Hydrogen Fuel Cell Coalition, OSU

VW-2LCMT0000717 VW-2LCMT0000718 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016 Ruan Transport Corporation VW-2LCMT0000719 VW-2LCMT0000720 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016Securing America's Future Energy

VW-2LCMT0000721 VW-2LCMT0000724 Exhibit 4E

8/5/2016 SemaConnect VW-2LCMT0000725 VW-2LCMT0000726 Exhibit 4E8/5/2016 Shorepower Technologies VW-2LCMT0000727 VW-2LCMT0000728 Exhibit 4F8/5/2016 Shorepower Technologies VW-2LCMT0000729 VW-2LCMT0000730 Exhibit 4F8/5/2016 Sierra Club VW-2LCMT0000731 VW-2LCMT0000733 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control

VW-2LCMT0000734 VW-2LCMT0000742 Exhibit 4F

8/4/2016South Coast Air Quality Management District

VW-2LCMT0000743 VW-2LCMT0000748 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Southwest Energy Efficiency Project / Utah Clean Energy

VW-2LCMT0000749 VW-2LCMT0000751 Exhibit 4F

8/4/2016 State of Vermont VW-2LCMT0000752 VW-2LCMT0000758 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation

VW-2LCMT0000759 VW-2LCMT0000773 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Texas Commission on Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000774 VW-2LCMT0000776 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection

VW-2LCMT0000777 VW-2LCMT0000785 Exhibit 4F

Page 6 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 7 of 36

Page 8: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016 Time Mark Enterprises VW-2LCMT0000786 VW-2LCMT0000787 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Transportation Energy Partners

VW-2LCMT0000788 VW-2LCMT0000796 Exhibit 4F

7/28/2016 Tulsa Area Clean Cities VW-2LCMT0000797 VW-2LCMT0000797 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016University of North Carolina Asheville

VW-2LCMT0000798 VW-2LCMT0000799 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016 US PIRG Education Fund VW-2LCMT0000800 VW-2LCMT0000801 Exhibit 4F8/5/2016 Utah Clean Cities Coalition VW-2LCMT0000802 VW-2LCMT0000803 Exhibit 4F

8/3/2016Utah Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000804 VW-2LCMT0000806 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Vermont Energy Investment Corporation

VW-2LCMT0000807 VW-2LCMT0000811 Exhibit 4F

8/2/2016 Virginia Clean Cities VW-2LCMT0000812 VW-2LCMT0000812 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Virginia Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000813 VW-2LCMT0000816 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016 Vollan Oil VW-2LCMT0000817 VW-2LCMT0000818 Exhibit 4F

8/4/2016 Wasatch Clean Air Coalition VW-2LCMT0000819 VW-2LCMT0000819 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016Western States Air Resources Council

VW-2LCMT0000820 VW-2LCMT0000822 Exhibit 4F

8/1/2016Wyoming Department of Environmental Quality

VW-2LCMT0000823 VW-2LCMT0000824 Exhibit 4F

8/4/2016Yellowstone-Teton Clean Cities

VW-2LCMT0000825 VW-2LCMT0000825 Exhibit 4F

8/5/2016ZEV Comments - Various Nonprofits

VW-2LCMT0000826 VW-2LCMT0000829 Exhibit 4F

7/25/2016 Beard, Chaan W. VW-2LCMT0000830 VW-2LCMT0000831 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bleything, Abby VW-2LCMT0000832 VW-2LCMT0000832 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Christie, Michael VW-2LCMT0000833 VW-2LCMT0000833 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Dimmick, Ross A. VW-2LCMT0000834 VW-2LCMT0000837 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Finis, Thomas VW-2LCMT0000838 VW-2LCMT0000839 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Flaherty, Dennis VW-2LCMT0000840 VW-2LCMT0000840 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Haver, Lance VW-2LCMT0000841 VW-2LCMT0000842 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Jennings, Andrew VW-2LCMT0000843 VW-2LCMT0000843 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Jerominek, Amy VW-2LCMT0000844 VW-2LCMT0000844 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Jura, Graham C. VW-2LCMT0000845 VW-2LCMT0000845 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Kalina, Brian VW-2LCMT0000846 VW-2LCMT0000847 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Marz, Loren Carl VW-2LCMT0000848 VW-2LCMT0000852 Exhibit 4G

Page 7 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 8 of 36

Page 9: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/28/2016 Patch, Keith D. VW-2LCMT0000853 VW-2LCMT0000853 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Phelan, Matt VW-2LCMT0000854 VW-2LCMT0000855 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Phelan, Matt VW-2LCMT0000856 VW-2LCMT0000857 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Raver, James M. VW-2LCMT0000858 VW-2LCMT0000858 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Reed, John VW-2LCMT0000859 VW-2LCMT0000860 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Rees, Matt VW-2LCMT0000861 VW-2LCMT0000861 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Renick, Joseph D. VW-2LCMT0000862 VW-2LCMT0000863 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Rice-Herdt, Jasper J. VW-2LCMT0000864 VW-2LCMT0000864 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Rymer, Bill VW-2LCMT0000865 VW-2LCMT0000866 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Schalet, Philip B. VW-2LCMT0000867 VW-2LCMT0000867 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Schlectic, Gary VW-2LCMT0000868 VW-2LCMT0000868 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Skarha, Julie VW-2LCMT0000869 VW-2LCMT0000869 Exhibit 4G6/28/2016 Smith, Timothy P. VW-2LCMT0000870 VW-2LCMT0000871 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Taylor, Kim VW-2LCMT0000872 VW-2LCMT0000872 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Venner, Marie VW-2LCMT0000873 VW-2LCMT0000873 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Zamore, Wig VW-2LCMT0000874 VW-2LCMT0000876 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Saxton, Mike VW-2LCMT0000877 VW-2LCMT0000878 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 A., Noah VW-2LCMT0000879 VW-2LCMT0000879 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 A., Noah VW-2LCMT0000880 VW-2LCMT0000880 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 A., Noah VW-2LCMT0000881 VW-2LCMT0000881 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Achey, Steven VW-2LCMT0000882 VW-2LCMT0000882 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Adams, C. Berkeley VW-2LCMT0000883 VW-2LCMT0000883 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 Adams, William VW-2LCMT0000884 VW-2LCMT0000884 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Adelantado, Carlos VW-2LCMT0000885 VW-2LCMT0000885 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Aldrich, John VW-2LCMT0000886 VW-2LCMT0000886 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Alliston, Jason VW-2LCMT0000887 VW-2LCMT0000887 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Aman, Wendy VW-2LCMT0000888 VW-2LCMT0000888 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Amoroso, Joe VW-2LCMT0000889 VW-2LCMT0000889 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Anthony VW-2LCMT0000890 VW-2LCMT0000891 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Aresco, Mark VW-2LCMT0000892 VW-2LCMT0000892 Exhibit 4G

8/2/2016Augustson, Kenneth; Augustson, Nancy

VW-2LCMT0000893 VW-2LCMT0000893 Exhibit 4G

8/3/2016 B., Jennifer VW-2LCMT0000894 VW-2LCMT0000894 Exhibit 4G7/24/2016 B., Mike VW-2LCMT0000895 VW-2LCMT0000895 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Bailey, Caren VW-2LCMT0000896 VW-2LCMT0000896 Exhibit 4G

7/26/2016 Bailey, Caren - Attachment 1 VW-2LCMT0000897 VW-2LCMT0000897 Exhibit 4G

7/13/2016 Baird, Edward VW-2LCMT0000898 VW-2LCMT0000898 Exhibit 4G

Page 8 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 9 of 36

Page 10: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/27/2016 Balle, Hank VW-2LCMT0000899 VW-2LCMT0000899 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Bancroft, David VW-2LCMT0000900 VW-2LCMT0000900 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Banks, Sean VW-2LCMT0000901 VW-2LCMT0000901 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Barker, Troy VW-2LCMT0000902 VW-2LCMT0000902 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Barnett, Brian VW-2LCMT0000903 VW-2LCMT0000903 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Bartlett, Jeff VW-2LCMT0000904 VW-2LCMT0000904 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Beard, Chaan W. VW-2LCMT0000905 VW-2LCMT0000906 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Beatty, Michael VW-2LCMT0000907 VW-2LCMT0000907 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Beedell, Val VW-2LCMT0000908 VW-2LCMT0000908 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Beltz, Justin VW-2LCMT0000909 VW-2LCMT0000911 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Beltz, Justin - Attachment 1 VW-2LCMT0000912 VW-2LCMT0000915 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Beltz, Justin - Attachment 2 VW-2LCMT0000916 VW-2LCMT0000921 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Bennett, Joan VW-2LCMT0000922 VW-2LCMT0000922 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Bianco, Peter T. VW-2LCMT0000923 VW-2LCMT0000923 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Bias, David VW-2LCMT0000924 VW-2LCMT0000924 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Blake, Josh VW-2LCMT0000925 VW-2LCMT0000925 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Blondin, Jason VW-2LCMT0000926 VW-2LCMT0000926 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Bloom, Joshua VW-2LCMT0000927 VW-2LCMT0000927 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Bodkin, Patrick VW-2LCMT0000928 VW-2LCMT0000928 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Bonebrake, Greg VW-2LCMT0000929 VW-2LCMT0000929 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Bonebrake, Michelle VW-2LCMT0000930 VW-2LCMT0000930 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Borja, Dale VW-2LCMT0000931 VW-2LCMT0000931 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Botson, Jonathan VW-2LCMT0000932 VW-2LCMT0000932 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Bowdem, Dustin D. VW-2LCMT0000933 VW-2LCMT0000933 Exhibit 4G

7/13/2016Bowden, Valerie DeGiovanni

VW-2LCMT0000934 VW-2LCMT0000934 Exhibit 4G

7/14/2016 Bowling, Darrell R. VW-2LCMT0000935 VW-2LCMT0000935 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Bridgham, Brett VW-2LCMT0000936 VW-2LCMT0000936 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Brill, Bob VW-2LCMT0000937 VW-2LCMT0000937 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Brodie, Lonnie VW-2LCMT0000938 VW-2LCMT0000938 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Brown, Ainslie VW-2LCMT0000939 VW-2LCMT0000939 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Brown, J. C. VW-2LCMT0000940 VW-2LCMT0000941 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Brown, Kimberly VW-2LCMT0000942 VW-2LCMT0000944 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Brown, Mark VW-2LCMT0000945 VW-2LCMT0000945 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Brown,Gene VW-2LCMT0000946 VW-2LCMT0000946 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Bryant, James VW-2LCMT0000947 VW-2LCMT0000947 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Buck, Dennis VW-2LCMT0000948 VW-2LCMT0000948 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Burton, Chet VW-2LCMT0000949 VW-2LCMT0000949 Exhibit 4G

Page 9 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 10 of 36

Page 11: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/8/2016 Burton, Ken VW-2LCMT0000950 VW-2LCMT0000950 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Bush, Thomas VW-2LCMT0000951 VW-2LCMT0000951 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 Byrd, Scott VW-2LCMT0000952 VW-2LCMT0000952 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Cain, Matthew VW-2LCMT0000953 VW-2LCMT0000953 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Carparelli, Adam VW-2LCMT0000954 VW-2LCMT0000954 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Carroll, Hobson D. VW-2LCMT0000955 VW-2LCMT0000955 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Carter-Pokras, Olivia VW-2LCMT0000956 VW-2LCMT0000956 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Carter-Pokras, Olivia VW-2LCMT0000957 VW-2LCMT0000957 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Case, Laurie VW-2LCMT0000958 VW-2LCMT0000959 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Chapin, Carin VW-2LCMT0000960 VW-2LCMT0000960 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Charuk, Ken VW-2LCMT0000961 VW-2LCMT0000961 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Clendaniel, Ian VW-2LCMT0000962 VW-2LCMT0000962 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Clow, Kent VW-2LCMT0000963 VW-2LCMT0000963 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Codori, Greg VW-2LCMT0000964 VW-2LCMT0000964 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Cohen, Mark VW-2LCMT0000965 VW-2LCMT0000965 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Cole, Michael VW-2LCMT0000966 VW-2LCMT0000966 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Cole, Michael VW-2LCMT0000967 VW-2LCMT0000969 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Coll, Benjamin VW-2LCMT0000970 VW-2LCMT0000970 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Collins, Bryant VW-2LCMT0000971 VW-2LCMT0000971 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Conrad, Douglas VW-2LCMT0000972 VW-2LCMT0000972 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Conrad, Peter VW-2LCMT0000973 VW-2LCMT0000973 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Coon, Matthew VW-2LCMT0000974 VW-2LCMT0000974 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Cooper, Josh VW-2LCMT0000975 VW-2LCMT0000975 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Coppin, John VW-2LCMT0000976 VW-2LCMT0000976 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Costill, Rod VW-2LCMT0000977 VW-2LCMT0000977 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Crafton, Tom VW-2LCMT0000978 VW-2LCMT0000978 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Cummings, Nicholas VW-2LCMT0000979 VW-2LCMT0000979 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Czeto, Alexanader VW-2LCMT0000980 VW-2LCMT0000980 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Daly, Moira VW-2LCMT0000981 VW-2LCMT0000982 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Daniel, Trae VW-2LCMT0000983 VW-2LCMT0000983 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Dans, Roy E. VW-2LCMT0000984 VW-2LCMT0000984 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Darby, Timothy VW-2LCMT0000985 VW-2LCMT0000986 Exhibit 4G

7/27/2016Daubney, James W.; Daubney, Lisa A.

VW-2LCMT0000987 VW-2LCMT0000987 Exhibit 4G

8/5/2016 Daugherty, Amber VW-2LCMT0000988 VW-2LCMT0000988 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 David VW-2LCMT0000989 VW-2LCMT0000989 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 DeCaneo, Phil VW-2LCMT0000990 VW-2LCMT0000990 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 DeFilipps, Kenneth F. VW-2LCMT0000991 VW-2LCMT0000992 Exhibit 4G

Page 10 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 11 of 36

Page 12: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/7/2016 Dempsey, Bruce VW-2LCMT0000993 VW-2LCMT0000994 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 DeSpain, Tyler VW-2LCMT0000995 VW-2LCMT0000995 Exhibit 4G7/5/2016 Dinkel, Robert VW-2LCMT0000996 VW-2LCMT0000996 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Dintino, Daniel VW-2LCMT0000997 VW-2LCMT0000997 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 DiPasquale, Nick VW-2LCMT0000998 VW-2LCMT0000998 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Dolina, Emily VW-2LCMT0000999 VW-2LCMT0001000 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Doran, Rick VW-2LCMT0001001 VW-2LCMT0001001 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Dorrer, Douglas R. VW-2LCMT0001002 VW-2LCMT0001002 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Downes, Perry VW-2LCMT0001003 VW-2LCMT0001004 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Downes, Perry VW-2LCMT0001005 VW-2LCMT0001005 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Doyle, Benjamin VW-2LCMT0001006 VW-2LCMT0001007 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Driver, William D. VW-2LCMT0001008 VW-2LCMT0001008 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Drolet, Philippe VW-2LCMT0001009 VW-2LCMT0001010 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Druckemiller, Chris VW-2LCMT0001011 VW-2LCMT0001011 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Duvall, Dustin VW-2LCMT0001012 VW-2LCMT0001012 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Ehlers, Richard E. VW-2LCMT0001013 VW-2LCMT0001013 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Ehrat, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001014 VW-2LCMT0001014 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Elliott, Tiffany VW-2LCMT0001015 VW-2LCMT0001015 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Eric VW-2LCMT0001016 VW-2LCMT0001016 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Eric VW-2LCMT0001017 VW-2LCMT0001017 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Erickson, Bart VW-2LCMT0001018 VW-2LCMT0001018 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Erickson, Bart VW-2LCMT0001019 VW-2LCMT0001019 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Ernst, David VW-2LCMT0001020 VW-2LCMT0001020 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Erstling, Mark VW-2LCMT0001021 VW-2LCMT0001021 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Eulenstein, Stefan VW-2LCMT0001022 VW-2LCMT0001022 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 F, Kenny VW-2LCMT0001023 VW-2LCMT0001023 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Farris, Connie VW-2LCMT0001024 VW-2LCMT0001025 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Fedorczyk, Melissa R. VW-2LCMT0001026 VW-2LCMT0001026 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Feeley, Kelley VW-2LCMT0001027 VW-2LCMT0001027 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Finis, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001028 VW-2LCMT0001029 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Fiorello, Joseph Jr. VW-2LCMT0001030 VW-2LCMT0001030 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Flores, Lisa VW-2LCMT0001031 VW-2LCMT0001031 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Ford, Elizabeth VW-2LCMT0001032 VW-2LCMT0001033 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Ford, Elizabeth VW-2LCMT0001034 VW-2LCMT0001036 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Fox, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001037 VW-2LCMT0001037 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Frenchu, Kathleen VW-2LCMT0001038 VW-2LCMT0001038 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Garlikov, Andrew VW-2LCMT0001039 VW-2LCMT0001039 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Gemeiner, Terry VW-2LCMT0001040 VW-2LCMT0001041 Exhibit 4G

Page 11 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 12 of 36

Page 13: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/7/2016 Gilman, Andrew VW-2LCMT0001042 VW-2LCMT0001042 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Gilman, Andrew VW-2LCMT0001043 VW-2LCMT0001043 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Gingrich, Kyle VW-2LCMT0001044 VW-2LCMT0001044 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Girzon, Gary VW-2LCMT0001045 VW-2LCMT0001045 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Gomez, Nicholas VW-2LCMT0001046 VW-2LCMT0001047 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Graham, John VW-2LCMT0001048 VW-2LCMT0001048 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Gratchner, John VW-2LCMT0001049 VW-2LCMT0001050 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Greenberg, Melissa VW-2LCMT0001051 VW-2LCMT0001051 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Greenblatt, Alan VW-2LCMT0001052 VW-2LCMT0001052 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Gregory, Tyler VW-2LCMT0001053 VW-2LCMT0001053 Exhibit 4G

7/22/2016 Griffith, Alan; Griffith, Keith VW-2LCMT0001054 VW-2LCMT0001054 Exhibit 4G

7/17/2016 Grochowsky, Jason VW-2LCMT0001055 VW-2LCMT0001056 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Groover, Bruce E. VW-2LCMT0001057 VW-2LCMT0001057 Exhibit 4G

7/24/2016Grossman, Jonathan; Portnow, Jana

VW-2LCMT0001058 VW-2LCMT0001059 Exhibit 4G

7/10/2016 Guild, Bruce VW-2LCMT0001060 VW-2LCMT0001060 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Guttman, Michael VW-2LCMT0001061 VW-2LCMT0001061 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 H., Ken VW-2LCMT0001062 VW-2LCMT0001062 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Hagen, Alexander T. VW-2LCMT0001063 VW-2LCMT0001063 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Hammond, Herbert VW-2LCMT0001064 VW-2LCMT0001065 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Hardy, Lewis VW-2LCMT0001066 VW-2LCMT0001066 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Harkin, Don VW-2LCMT0001067 VW-2LCMT0001067 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Harris, Bob VW-2LCMT0001068 VW-2LCMT0001068 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Harris, James D. VW-2LCMT0001069 VW-2LCMT0001069 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Harris, Mark VW-2LCMT0001070 VW-2LCMT0001070 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Harris, Mark VW-2LCMT0001071 VW-2LCMT0001071 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Hart, Robert VW-2LCMT0001072 VW-2LCMT0001072 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Hart, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001073 VW-2LCMT0001073 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Hart, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001074 VW-2LCMT0001074 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Harvey, Gabriel VW-2LCMT0001075 VW-2LCMT0001075 Exhibit 4G

8/5/2016Hattan, William; Hattan, Susan

VW-2LCMT0001076 VW-2LCMT0001077 Exhibit 4G

7/21/2016 Heidorn, Samuel VW-2LCMT0001078 VW-2LCMT0001079 Exhibit 4G

7/28/2016Helmick, Blaine; Helmick, Tammie

VW-2LCMT0001080 VW-2LCMT0001080 Exhibit 4G

7/17/2016 Hendricks, Duane VW-2LCMT0001081 VW-2LCMT0001081 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Henin, Peter VW-2LCMT0001082 VW-2LCMT0001082 Exhibit 4G

Page 12 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 13 of 36

Page 14: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/8/2016 Henry, Brian VW-2LCMT0001083 VW-2LCMT0001083 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Hernandez, David VW-2LCMT0001084 VW-2LCMT0001084 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Herriott, Michael Shawn VW-2LCMT0001085 VW-2LCMT0001085 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Hiatt, Russell VW-2LCMT0001086 VW-2LCMT0001086 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Hilleman, Brent VW-2LCMT0001087 VW-2LCMT0001087 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Hodgins, James VW-2LCMT0001088 VW-2LCMT0001088 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Hoffa, Dan VW-2LCMT0001089 VW-2LCMT0001089 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Hollstein, Paul VW-2LCMT0001090 VW-2LCMT0001090 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Hoon, Twila A. VW-2LCMT0001091 VW-2LCMT0001091 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Hu, Wilson VW-2LCMT0001092 VW-2LCMT0001092 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Huang, James VW-2LCMT0001093 VW-2LCMT0001093 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Hubbell, Rawson VW-2LCMT0001094 VW-2LCMT0001094 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Huffstutter, Allen VW-2LCMT0001095 VW-2LCMT0001095 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Hughes, Jennifer VW-2LCMT0001096 VW-2LCMT0001096 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Hughes, Ray VW-2LCMT0001097 VW-2LCMT0001097 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Ingram, Traci VW-2LCMT0001098 VW-2LCMT0001098 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Jackson, Chris VW-2LCMT0001099 VW-2LCMT0001099 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Jacobs, Donna S. VW-2LCMT0001100 VW-2LCMT0001100 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Jacobs, Robert VW-2LCMT0001101 VW-2LCMT0001101 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Jake VW-2LCMT0001102 VW-2LCMT0001102 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 James, Debbe VW-2LCMT0001103 VW-2LCMT0001103 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Jassem, Harvey VW-2LCMT0001104 VW-2LCMT0001104 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Jassem, Harvey VW-2LCMT0001105 VW-2LCMT0001105 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Jed, Leo VW-2LCMT0001106 VW-2LCMT0001106 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Jinkens, Michael VW-2LCMT0001107 VW-2LCMT0001107 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Joglekar, Sarang VW-2LCMT0001108 VW-2LCMT0001108 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Johnson, Everett A. VW-2LCMT0001109 VW-2LCMT0001109 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Johnson, J. Paul VW-2LCMT0001110 VW-2LCMT0001111 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Johnson, Jeff VW-2LCMT0001112 VW-2LCMT0001112 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Jones, Phillip Michael VW-2LCMT0001113 VW-2LCMT0001113 Exhibit 4G7/16/2016 Kassman, April VW-2LCMT0001114 VW-2LCMT0001116 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Kazorian, Danny VW-2LCMT0001117 VW-2LCMT0001117 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Keating, Gregory VW-2LCMT0001118 VW-2LCMT0001119 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Keating, Gregory VW-2LCMT0001120 VW-2LCMT0001121 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Kelley, Jack VW-2LCMT0001122 VW-2LCMT0001122 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Kelly, Maureen VW-2LCMT0001123 VW-2LCMT0001123 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Keppers, Justin VW-2LCMT0001124 VW-2LCMT0001124 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Kilroy, Denis B. VW-2LCMT0001125 VW-2LCMT0001125 Exhibit 4G

Page 13 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 14 of 36

Page 15: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/18/2016 Komaniak, Todd VW-2LCMT0001126 VW-2LCMT0001126 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Kowtica, Christopher VW-2LCMT0001127 VW-2LCMT0001127 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Krause, Tim VW-2LCMT0001128 VW-2LCMT0001128 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Kuhlman, Roger L. VW-2LCMT0001129 VW-2LCMT0001129 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Kurtz, Edward Jr. VW-2LCMT0001130 VW-2LCMT0001130 Exhibit 4G6/30/2016 Kwan, Jasmine VW-2LCMT0001131 VW-2LCMT0001131 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Land, Bruce VW-2LCMT0001132 VW-2LCMT0001133 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Lantrip, Julie VW-2LCMT0001134 VW-2LCMT0001134 Exhibit 4G8/7/2016 LaRoche, Roy VW-2LCMT0001135 VW-2LCMT0001135 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Lawrence, Alex VW-2LCMT0001136 VW-2LCMT0001136 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Lazar, Andy VW-2LCMT0001137 VW-2LCMT0001137 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Leach, Sammy Jr. VW-2LCMT0001138 VW-2LCMT0001138 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Lee, Alan VW-2LCMT0001139 VW-2LCMT0001139 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Leigh, Chad VW-2LCMT0001140 VW-2LCMT0001141 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Lesch, Karl R. VW-2LCMT0001142 VW-2LCMT0001143 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Lewis, Susan P. VW-2LCMT0001144 VW-2LCMT0001144 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Lipe, Preston VW-2LCMT0001145 VW-2LCMT0001145 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Livingston, Robert VW-2LCMT0001146 VW-2LCMT0001146 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Livingstone, Ryan VW-2LCMT0001147 VW-2LCMT0001147 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Locke, John VW-2LCMT0001148 VW-2LCMT0001148 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Logman, Tim VW-2LCMT0001149 VW-2LCMT0001149 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Lopez, Enrique VW-2LCMT0001150 VW-2LCMT0001151 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Low, Doug VW-2LCMT0001152 VW-2LCMT0001152 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Lum, Rodney VW-2LCMT0001153 VW-2LCMT0001153 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Lynch, Patrick G. VW-2LCMT0001154 VW-2LCMT0001154 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 Lynch, Paul M. VW-2LCMT0001155 VW-2LCMT0001155 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Lyons, Michael VW-2LCMT0001156 VW-2LCMT0001157 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 MacNeil, Rod VW-2LCMT0001158 VW-2LCMT0001158 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Magdzinski, Julia VW-2LCMT0001159 VW-2LCMT0001160 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Manning, Jim VW-2LCMT0001161 VW-2LCMT0001162 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Marc VW-2LCMT0001163 VW-2LCMT0001163 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Marchetti, Karin VW-2LCMT0001164 VW-2LCMT0001164 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Marincic, Tomislav VW-2LCMT0001165 VW-2LCMT0001166 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Marks, Joshua VW-2LCMT0001167 VW-2LCMT0001167 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Marks, Mary Jo VW-2LCMT0001168 VW-2LCMT0001168 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Marks, Mary Jo VW-2LCMT0001169 VW-2LCMT0001169 Exhibit 4G8/7/2016 Marsiglia, Brian J. VW-2LCMT0001170 VW-2LCMT0001170 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Marten VW-2LCMT0001171 VW-2LCMT0001171 Exhibit 4G

Page 14 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 15 of 36

Page 16: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016 Martin, Jeremy VW-2LCMT0001172 VW-2LCMT0001172 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Martin, Robert VW-2LCMT0001173 VW-2LCMT0001173 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Martin, Tracy VW-2LCMT0001174 VW-2LCMT0001174 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Marzetta, Frank VW-2LCMT0001175 VW-2LCMT0001175 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Matelli, Joan Charlotte VW-2LCMT0001176 VW-2LCMT0001176 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Mathis, Aaron VW-2LCMT0001177 VW-2LCMT0001178 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 May, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001179 VW-2LCMT0001179 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 May, Wes VW-2LCMT0001180 VW-2LCMT0001180 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Mayes, Meredith VW-2LCMT0001181 VW-2LCMT0001181 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 McCall, Laura VW-2LCMT0001182 VW-2LCMT0001182 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 McCann, Timothy VW-2LCMT0001183 VW-2LCMT0001183 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 McCarver, Mike VW-2LCMT0001184 VW-2LCMT0001185 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 McClure, Jeff VW-2LCMT0001186 VW-2LCMT0001186 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 McCrann, Sean VW-2LCMT0001187 VW-2LCMT0001188 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 McDonnell, Miles D. VW-2LCMT0001189 VW-2LCMT0001189 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 McEachron, Luke VW-2LCMT0001190 VW-2LCMT0001190 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 McFarland, Rob VW-2LCMT0001191 VW-2LCMT0001191 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 McKelvey, John VW-2LCMT0001192 VW-2LCMT0001192 Exhibit 4G7/16/2016 McKissick, Renee VW-2LCMT0001193 VW-2LCMT0001193 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 McManus, Chris VW-2LCMT0001194 VW-2LCMT0001194 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 McMillan, Natasha VW-2LCMT0001195 VW-2LCMT0001195 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 McNeill, Megan VW-2LCMT0001196 VW-2LCMT0001196 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 McWilliams, Clifton VW-2LCMT0001197 VW-2LCMT0001197 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Meinze, William VW-2LCMT0001198 VW-2LCMT0001198 Exhibit 4G7/24/2016 Merola, A.C. VW-2LCMT0001199 VW-2LCMT0001199 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Meskill, Brian VW-2LCMT0001200 VW-2LCMT0001200 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Mihale, Linda VW-2LCMT0001201 VW-2LCMT0001201 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Milberger, William VW-2LCMT0001202 VW-2LCMT0001202 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Miller, Andrew H. VW-2LCMT0001203 VW-2LCMT0001210 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Miller, James L. VW-2LCMT0001211 VW-2LCMT0001211 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Minnie, Frank VW-2LCMT0001212 VW-2LCMT0001212 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Minton, Leon VW-2LCMT0001213 VW-2LCMT0001213 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Mittelstaedt, Brian VW-2LCMT0001214 VW-2LCMT0001214 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Mitts, Jon VW-2LCMT0001215 VW-2LCMT0001215 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Moore, Steve VW-2LCMT0001216 VW-2LCMT0001216 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Morrison, Eric Ryan VW-2LCMT0001217 VW-2LCMT0001217 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Muller, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001218 VW-2LCMT0001218 Exhibit 4G7/16/2016 Murawski, Deena VW-2LCMT0001219 VW-2LCMT0001219 Exhibit 4G

Page 15 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 16 of 36

Page 17: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/14/2016 Murray, Scott VW-2LCMT0001220 VW-2LCMT0001220 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Mutton, Jim VW-2LCMT0001221 VW-2LCMT0001221 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Natale, Leigh VW-2LCMT0001222 VW-2LCMT0001222 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Naughton, Ken VW-2LCMT0001223 VW-2LCMT0001223 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Nayar, V Timothy VW-2LCMT0001224 VW-2LCMT0001224 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Neault, David VW-2LCMT0001225 VW-2LCMT0001226 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Neilson, Jim VW-2LCMT0001227 VW-2LCMT0001228 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Nicol, Sara VW-2LCMT0001229 VW-2LCMT0001229 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Niederhaus, Charles VW-2LCMT0001230 VW-2LCMT0001231 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Nielsen, Matt VW-2LCMT0001232 VW-2LCMT0001232 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Nollette, Neal P. VW-2LCMT0001233 VW-2LCMT0001235 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Nollette, Neal P. VW-2LCMT0001236 VW-2LCMT0001238 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Novotne, Becky VW-2LCMT0001239 VW-2LCMT0001239 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Olsen, Jim VW-2LCMT0001240 VW-2LCMT0001240 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Olsvik, Julie VW-2LCMT0001241 VW-2LCMT0001241 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 O'Neill, Maureen VW-2LCMT0001242 VW-2LCMT0001242 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Onofrey, Kimberly VW-2LCMT0001243 VW-2LCMT0001243 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 O'Steen, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001244 VW-2LCMT0001244 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 O'Steen, Mary VW-2LCMT0001245 VW-2LCMT0001245 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Osteen, Sissy R. VW-2LCMT0001246 VW-2LCMT0001246 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Ostrowski, Michal VW-2LCMT0001247 VW-2LCMT0001247 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Parker, Russ VW-2LCMT0001248 VW-2LCMT0001248 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Paul, Jenny VW-2LCMT0001249 VW-2LCMT0001249 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Penticuff, Mark VW-2LCMT0001250 VW-2LCMT0001250 Exhibit 4G8/7/2016 Perez, Jorge VW-2LCMT0001251 VW-2LCMT0001251 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Perieteanu, Anca VW-2LCMT0001252 VW-2LCMT0001252 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Pervanger, Dorothy VW-2LCMT0001253 VW-2LCMT0001255 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Pervanger, Dorothy VW-2LCMT0001256 VW-2LCMT0001258 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Pervanger, Dorothy VW-2LCMT0001259 VW-2LCMT0001261 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Peters, Raechel VW-2LCMT0001262 VW-2LCMT0001262 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Phelan, Teresa VW-2LCMT0001263 VW-2LCMT0001263 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Pichowsky, David VW-2LCMT0001264 VW-2LCMT0001264 Exhibit 4G8/7/2016 Pierce, Matt VW-2LCMT0001265 VW-2LCMT0001265 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Pilewski, Thaddeus VW-2LCMT0001266 VW-2LCMT0001266 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Pilla, Mike VW-2LCMT0001267 VW-2LCMT0001267 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Pimentel, Julie VW-2LCMT0001268 VW-2LCMT0001268 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Plasters, Gregory VW-2LCMT0001269 VW-2LCMT0001269 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Pleva, Megan VW-2LCMT0001270 VW-2LCMT0001270 Exhibit 4G

Page 16 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 17 of 36

Page 18: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/13/2016 Poindexter, Miles VW-2LCMT0001271 VW-2LCMT0001271 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Pooch, Scott VW-2LCMT0001272 VW-2LCMT0001272 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Porter, Thomas A. VW-2LCMT0001273 VW-2LCMT0001273 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Powell, Liam VW-2LCMT0001274 VW-2LCMT0001274 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Preis, Jeff VW-2LCMT0001275 VW-2LCMT0001275 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Price, Eric VW-2LCMT0001276 VW-2LCMT0001276 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Pritchard, Jean VW-2LCMT0001277 VW-2LCMT0001277 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Pudjayana, Ed VW-2LCMT0001278 VW-2LCMT0001278 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Puentes, Yangers VW-2LCMT0001279 VW-2LCMT0001279 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Quinn, Robert VW-2LCMT0001280 VW-2LCMT0001280 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Quinn, Walt VW-2LCMT0001281 VW-2LCMT0001281 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Quirk, Bill VW-2LCMT0001282 VW-2LCMT0001282 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Raffa, Diane VW-2LCMT0001283 VW-2LCMT0001283 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Ray, Catherine VW-2LCMT0001284 VW-2LCMT0001284 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Reimann, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001285 VW-2LCMT0001285 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Rice-Herdt, Jasper J. VW-2LCMT0001286 VW-2LCMT0001286 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Rice-Herdt, Jasper J. VW-2LCMT0001287 VW-2LCMT0001287 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Richardson, Tim VW-2LCMT0001288 VW-2LCMT0001288 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Robertson, Greg VW-2LCMT0001289 VW-2LCMT0001289 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Ronald, Roger VW-2LCMT0001290 VW-2LCMT0001290 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Rossen, Robert VW-2LCMT0001291 VW-2LCMT0001291 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Rowland, Gordon VW-2LCMT0001292 VW-2LCMT0001292 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Ruddy, William VW-2LCMT0001293 VW-2LCMT0001293 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Rule, Jefffrey A. VW-2LCMT0001294 VW-2LCMT0001294 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Rule, Jeffrey A. VW-2LCMT0001295 VW-2LCMT0001295 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Rush, Frederick VW-2LCMT0001296 VW-2LCMT0001296 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Sachek, Christian VW-2LCMT0001297 VW-2LCMT0001297 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Sahbegovic, Dino VW-2LCMT0001298 VW-2LCMT0001298 Exhibit 4G7/16/2016 Salazar, Ryan and Eva VW-2LCMT0001299 VW-2LCMT0001299 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Sanabia, Melissa VW-2LCMT0001300 VW-2LCMT0001300 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Sandstrom, David VW-2LCMT0001301 VW-2LCMT0001301 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Sassin, Michael VW-2LCMT0001302 VW-2LCMT0001302 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Scharein, Arthur VW-2LCMT0001303 VW-2LCMT0001305 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Scheer, Jason VW-2LCMT0001306 VW-2LCMT0001306 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Schiltz, Christopher VW-2LCMT0001307 VW-2LCMT0001307 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Schiltz, Christopher A. VW-2LCMT0001308 VW-2LCMT0001314 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Schorr, Jennifer VW-2LCMT0001315 VW-2LCMT0001315 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Schrecengost, Randy VW-2LCMT0001316 VW-2LCMT0001316 Exhibit 4G

Page 17 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 18 of 36

Page 19: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/11/2016 Schuler, Doug VW-2LCMT0001317 VW-2LCMT0001317 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Schult, Sheila VW-2LCMT0001318 VW-2LCMT0001318 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Schwanholt, Amanda VW-2LCMT0001319 VW-2LCMT0001319 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Schwanholt, Amanda VW-2LCMT0001320 VW-2LCMT0001320 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Schwartz, Laura VW-2LCMT0001321 VW-2LCMT0001321 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Schwartzhoff, Margaret M. VW-2LCMT0001322 VW-2LCMT0001322 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Scott, John VW-2LCMT0001323 VW-2LCMT0001323 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Scurlock, Brian A. VW-2LCMT0001324 VW-2LCMT0001324 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Self, Christopher R. VW-2LCMT0001325 VW-2LCMT0001325 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Shahry, Saied Naaseh VW-2LCMT0001326 VW-2LCMT0001326 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Shannon, Michael VW-2LCMT0001327 VW-2LCMT0001327 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Shea, John VW-2LCMT0001328 VW-2LCMT0001328 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Sherman, Gery VW-2LCMT0001329 VW-2LCMT0001329 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Name Withheld by Request VW-2LCMT0001330 VW-2LCMT0001330 Exhibit 4G7/8/2016 Shock, Blair VW-2LCMT0001331 VW-2LCMT0001331 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Sholes, Jeremiah VW-2LCMT0001332 VW-2LCMT0001332 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Shorett, Jean VW-2LCMT0001333 VW-2LCMT0001333 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Silverberg, Bruce A. VW-2LCMT0001334 VW-2LCMT0001335 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Silverberg, Bruce A. VW-2LCMT0001336 VW-2LCMT0001336 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Sinclair, Angie VW-2LCMT0001337 VW-2LCMT0001337 Exhibit 4G7/16/2016 Siperek, Trevor VW-2LCMT0001338 VW-2LCMT0001339 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Sipula, Ian VW-2LCMT0001340 VW-2LCMT0001340 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Slattery, Kevin VW-2LCMT0001341 VW-2LCMT0001341 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Slovinsky, Peter VW-2LCMT0001342 VW-2LCMT0001342 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Small, Julie VW-2LCMT0001343 VW-2LCMT0001343 Exhibit 4G7/15/2016 Smith, Brandon VW-2LCMT0001344 VW-2LCMT0001344 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Smith, Charles T. VW-2LCMT0001345 VW-2LCMT0001345 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Smith, Kathryn VW-2LCMT0001346 VW-2LCMT0001346 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Smith, Roderick W. VW-2LCMT0001347 VW-2LCMT0001349 Exhibit 4G7/16/2016 Somer, Nora VW-2LCMT0001350 VW-2LCMT0001350 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Sorensen, Chris VW-2LCMT0001351 VW-2LCMT0001351 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Spiegelhoff, Sarah F. VW-2LCMT0001352 VW-2LCMT0001354 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Spradlin, Damian VW-2LCMT0001355 VW-2LCMT0001355 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Spruill, Paula VW-2LCMT0001356 VW-2LCMT0001356 Exhibit 4G7/24/2016 Staats, Shane VW-2LCMT0001357 VW-2LCMT0001357 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Stacy, Jim VW-2LCMT0001358 VW-2LCMT0001358 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Stacy, Jim VW-2LCMT0001359 VW-2LCMT0001359 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Stahr, Ed VW-2LCMT0001360 VW-2LCMT0001360 Exhibit 4G

Page 18 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 19 of 36

Page 20: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/8/2016 Stanley, Jodi VW-2LCMT0001361 VW-2LCMT0001361 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Staudt, John VW-2LCMT0001362 VW-2LCMT0001362 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Steger, Dustin VW-2LCMT0001363 VW-2LCMT0001364 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Stein, Hailey VW-2LCMT0001365 VW-2LCMT0001366 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Stockton, Doug VW-2LCMT0001367 VW-2LCMT0001367 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Stout, Amber, Stout, Jeremy VW-2LCMT0001368 VW-2LCMT0001368 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Suchorsky, Michael VW-2LCMT0001369 VW-2LCMT0001369 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Sullivan, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001370 VW-2LCMT0001370 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Surette, Pete VW-2LCMT0001371 VW-2LCMT0001371 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Swartz, Andy VW-2LCMT0001372 VW-2LCMT0001372 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Switzer, Adam D. VW-2LCMT0001373 VW-2LCMT0001374 Exhibit 4G7/10/2016 Taggart, Edward VW-2LCMT0001375 VW-2LCMT0001375 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Taylor, Travis VW-2LCMT0001376 VW-2LCMT0001376 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Taylor, Travis VW-2LCMT0001377 VW-2LCMT0001378 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Thomas, Brian VW-2LCMT0001379 VW-2LCMT0001379 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Thompson, Bryan VW-2LCMT0001380 VW-2LCMT0001380 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Thompson, James VW-2LCMT0001381 VW-2LCMT0001381 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Tom, David; Tom, Rebecca VW-2LCMT0001382 VW-2LCMT0001382 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Tran, Anh VW-2LCMT0001383 VW-2LCMT0001383 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Trapnell, Donny VW-2LCMT0001384 VW-2LCMT0001384 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Trapp, Samuel VW-2LCMT0001385 VW-2LCMT0001386 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Trela, Andrew VW-2LCMT0001387 VW-2LCMT0001387 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 True, Claus VW-2LCMT0001388 VW-2LCMT0001388 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Tsiolis, Kostas VW-2LCMT0001389 VW-2LCMT0001389 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Tumbev, Ivan VW-2LCMT0001390 VW-2LCMT0001391 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Turner, Todd VW-2LCMT0001392 VW-2LCMT0001393 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Ugarte, Michael VW-2LCMT0001394 VW-2LCMT0001394 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Urso, Wayne R. VW-2LCMT0001395 VW-2LCMT0001395 Exhibit 4G7/13/2016 Utech, William VW-2LCMT0001396 VW-2LCMT0001397 Exhibit 4G

7/16/2016 Vertz, Laura; Frendreis, John VW-2LCMT0001398 VW-2LCMT0001398 Exhibit 4G

7/10/2016 Villalovos, Edward VW-2LCMT0001399 VW-2LCMT0001399 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Volkov, Vitaly VW-2LCMT0001400 VW-2LCMT0001400 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Von Oehsen, Gary VW-2LCMT0001401 VW-2LCMT0001401 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Voss. Curt VW-2LCMT0001402 VW-2LCMT0001402 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Walsh, Brian VW-2LCMT0001403 VW-2LCMT0001403 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Walters, James VW-2LCMT0001404 VW-2LCMT0001404 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Wasdyke, Matthew VW-2LCMT0001405 VW-2LCMT0001405 Exhibit 4G

Page 19 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 20 of 36

Page 21: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/5/2016 Watson, Austin G. VW-2LCMT0001406 VW-2LCMT0001406 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Watson, Brian Lyndon VW-2LCMT0001407 VW-2LCMT0001408 Exhibit 4G7/17/2016 Wavernek, Brian VW-2LCMT0001409 VW-2LCMT0001409 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Weiss, Thomas G. VW-2LCMT0001410 VW-2LCMT0001410 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Whelan, Sean VW-2LCMT0001411 VW-2LCMT0001411 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Whelan, Sean VW-2LCMT0001412 VW-2LCMT0001412 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Wieczorek, Alfred VW-2LCMT0001413 VW-2LCMT0001415 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Williams, Charles E. VW-2LCMT0001416 VW-2LCMT0001418 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Williams, James C. VW-2LCMT0001419 VW-2LCMT0001419 Exhibit 4G7/9/2016 Wimmer, Kent L. VW-2LCMT0001420 VW-2LCMT0001421 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Wimmer, Kent L. VW-2LCMT0001422 VW-2LCMT0001422 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 Winfrey, Santino VW-2LCMT0001423 VW-2LCMT0001423 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Winnig, Marc Lee VW-2LCMT0001424 VW-2LCMT0001425 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Winnig, Marc Lee VW-2LCMT0001426 VW-2LCMT0001427 Exhibit 4G7/12/2016 Wolf, Kenneth VW-2LCMT0001428 VW-2LCMT0001428 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Wood, Craig VW-2LCMT0001429 VW-2LCMT0001429 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Woodard, Dane VW-2LCMT0001430 VW-2LCMT0001430 Exhibit 4G7/19/2016 Woods, Blair VW-2LCMT0001431 VW-2LCMT0001431 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Woodward, Chris VW-2LCMT0001432 VW-2LCMT0001437 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Woodward, Chris VW-2LCMT0001438 VW-2LCMT0001439 Exhibit 4G7/11/2016 Worth, John VW-2LCMT0001440 VW-2LCMT0001440 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Wotherspoon, James VW-2LCMT0001441 VW-2LCMT0001441 Exhibit 4G8/6/2016 Yager, Eric VW-2LCMT0001442 VW-2LCMT0001442 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Yost, Walter VW-2LCMT0001443 VW-2LCMT0001443 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Ziegler, Stephanie VW-2LCMT0001444 VW-2LCMT0001444 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Ashcraft, Ray VW-2LCMT0001445 VW-2LCMT0001445 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Bodkin, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001446 VW-2LCMT0001447 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Corrigan, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001448 VW-2LCMT0001448 Exhibit 4G7/7/2016 Csank, Adam VW-2LCMT0001449 VW-2LCMT0001449 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Grainger, Jerry VW-2LCMT0001450 VW-2LCMT0001450 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Johnson, Larry VW-2LCMT0001451 VW-2LCMT0001451 Exhibit 4G7/18/2016 Luce, Michael VW-2LCMT0001452 VW-2LCMT0001452 Exhibit 4G7/14/2016 Parsons, Bill VW-2LCMT0001453 VW-2LCMT0001453 Exhibit 4G7/6/2016 Polston, Penny VW-2LCMT0001454 VW-2LCMT0001454 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Acker, Antonio VW-2LCMT0001455 VW-2LCMT0001455 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Adair, Kenneth VW-2LCMT0001456 VW-2LCMT0001456 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Adelman, Louis VW-2LCMT0001457 VW-2LCMT0001457 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Aguilar, Sergio VW-2LCMT0001458 VW-2LCMT0001458 Exhibit 4G

Page 20 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 21 of 36

Page 22: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/25/2016 Ahara, Emoito VW-2LCMT0001459 VW-2LCMT0001459 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Ali, Garad F. VW-2LCMT0001460 VW-2LCMT0001461 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Allen, Jeff VW-2LCMT0001462 VW-2LCMT0001463 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Alty, Gary VW-2LCMT0001464 VW-2LCMT0001464 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Alty, Gary VW-2LCMT0001465 VW-2LCMT0001465 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Alvarado, Mauricio A. VW-2LCMT0001466 VW-2LCMT0001466 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Anariba, Oscar VW-2LCMT0001467 VW-2LCMT0001467 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Anderson, Terry VW-2LCMT0001468 VW-2LCMT0001468 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Anderson, Tunsghen VW-2LCMT0001469 VW-2LCMT0001469 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Archer, James D. VW-2LCMT0001470 VW-2LCMT0001470 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Argento, Charles VW-2LCMT0001471 VW-2LCMT0001471 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Arnold, Jim VW-2LCMT0001472 VW-2LCMT0001472 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Ashley, John VW-2LCMT0001473 VW-2LCMT0001473 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Ashley, John VW-2LCMT0001474 VW-2LCMT0001474 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Avera, Tony VW-2LCMT0001475 VW-2LCMT0001475 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Baez, Fsoto VW-2LCMT0001476 VW-2LCMT0001476 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bag, C. VW-2LCMT0001477 VW-2LCMT0001477 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Bailey, Charles VW-2LCMT0001478 VW-2LCMT0001478 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bailey, James VW-2LCMT0001479 VW-2LCMT0001479 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bailey, James VW-2LCMT0001480 VW-2LCMT0001480 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Baldwin, L. VW-2LCMT0001481 VW-2LCMT0001481 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Balk, John VW-2LCMT0001482 VW-2LCMT0001482 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Ballard, Chris VW-2LCMT0001483 VW-2LCMT0001483 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Basra, Parwinder S. VW-2LCMT0001484 VW-2LCMT0001484 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Bassig, Rodney VW-2LCMT0001485 VW-2LCMT0001485 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Batcke, Pete VW-2LCMT0001486 VW-2LCMT0001486 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Batcke, Pete VW-2LCMT0001487 VW-2LCMT0001487 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Beasley, George VW-2LCMT0001488 VW-2LCMT0001488 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bell, Luke VW-2LCMT0001489 VW-2LCMT0001489 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Bellinger, Ray VW-2LCMT0001490 VW-2LCMT0001490 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Benline, Eugene L. VW-2LCMT0001491 VW-2LCMT0001491 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Bianowski, Stan VW-2LCMT0001492 VW-2LCMT0001492 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bice, James VW-2LCMT0001493 VW-2LCMT0001493 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Biggs, Mary VW-2LCMT0001494 VW-2LCMT0001494 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bissig, Gregory VW-2LCMT0001495 VW-2LCMT0001495 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Bisson, Alelbert VW-2LCMT0001496 VW-2LCMT0001496 Exhibit 4G8/7/2016 Blackman, Jim VW-2LCMT0001497 VW-2LCMT0001497 Exhibit 4G7/30/2016 Blackmon, Kenneth VW-2LCMT0001498 VW-2LCMT0001498 Exhibit 4G

Page 21 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 22 of 36

Page 23: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/2/2016 Blanco, Yosbel VW-2LCMT0001499 VW-2LCMT0001499 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Bodenhamer, Teresa VW-2LCMT0001500 VW-2LCMT0001500 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Boisvert, L. VW-2LCMT0001501 VW-2LCMT0001501 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Bolen, William VW-2LCMT0001502 VW-2LCMT0001502 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Bollenbach, Dennis VW-2LCMT0001503 VW-2LCMT0001503 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Bond, James VW-2LCMT0001504 VW-2LCMT0001504 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Bond, Walter VW-2LCMT0001505 VW-2LCMT0001505 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Bonilla, Marianne VW-2LCMT0001506 VW-2LCMT0001506 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Bonner, Robert VW-2LCMT0001507 VW-2LCMT0001507 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Bonnett, Douglas VW-2LCMT0001508 VW-2LCMT0001508 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Borges, Alex VW-2LCMT0001509 VW-2LCMT0001509 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Borneo, Stephen VW-2LCMT0001510 VW-2LCMT0001510 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Bouwens, Randal VW-2LCMT0001511 VW-2LCMT0001511 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Boves, Hernan VW-2LCMT0001512 VW-2LCMT0001512 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Bowes, Pete VW-2LCMT0001513 VW-2LCMT0001513 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Bowkley, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001514 VW-2LCMT0001514 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Brady, Waine VW-2LCMT0001515 VW-2LCMT0001515 Exhibit 4G8/5/2016 Branton, Kevin VW-2LCMT0001516 VW-2LCMT0001516 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Braun, Joseph VW-2LCMT0001517 VW-2LCMT0001517 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Braun, Travis VW-2LCMT0001518 VW-2LCMT0001518 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Brehm, Rick VW-2LCMT0001519 VW-2LCMT0001519 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Brodes, Eddie VW-2LCMT0001520 VW-2LCMT0001520 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Brooks, Dale VW-2LCMT0001521 VW-2LCMT0001521 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Brooks, Dizon VW-2LCMT0001522 VW-2LCMT0001522 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Browder, Jay VW-2LCMT0001523 VW-2LCMT0001523 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Browder, Jay VW-2LCMT0001524 VW-2LCMT0001524 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Brown, Daniel H. VW-2LCMT0001525 VW-2LCMT0001525 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Brown, Erick VW-2LCMT0001526 VW-2LCMT0001526 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Brown, Jason VW-2LCMT0001527 VW-2LCMT0001527 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Brown, Jessie L. VW-2LCMT0001528 VW-2LCMT0001528 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Brown, Michael VW-2LCMT0001529 VW-2LCMT0001529 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Brunswick, Nathan VW-2LCMT0001530 VW-2LCMT0001530 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bryant, Bruce VW-2LCMT0001531 VW-2LCMT0001531 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Bunn, Paul VW-2LCMT0001532 VW-2LCMT0001532 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Burgener, Joseph VW-2LCMT0001533 VW-2LCMT0001533 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Burke, Stephen VW-2LCMT0001534 VW-2LCMT0001534 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Burnett, Benjamin VW-2LCMT0001535 VW-2LCMT0001535 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Burnett, Kelley VW-2LCMT0001536 VW-2LCMT0001536 Exhibit 4G

Page 22 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 23 of 36

Page 24: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/21/2016 Burnham, Jay VW-2LCMT0001537 VW-2LCMT0001537 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Buse, Lee VW-2LCMT0001538 VW-2LCMT0001538 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Bush, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001539 VW-2LCMT0001539 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Caldera, Alfredo VW-2LCMT0001540 VW-2LCMT0001540 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Callender, Richard VW-2LCMT0001541 VW-2LCMT0001541 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Campbell, Mike VW-2LCMT0001542 VW-2LCMT0001542 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Cardona, Larry VW-2LCMT0001543 VW-2LCMT0001543 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Carlisle, Denard VW-2LCMT0001544 VW-2LCMT0001544 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Carlson, Carl VW-2LCMT0001545 VW-2LCMT0001545 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Carpenter, Albert VW-2LCMT0001546 VW-2LCMT0001546 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Carr, David VW-2LCMT0001547 VW-2LCMT0001547 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Carter, John VW-2LCMT0001548 VW-2LCMT0001548 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Castillo, Edgar VW-2LCMT0001549 VW-2LCMT0001549 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Castro, Stephen VW-2LCMT0001550 VW-2LCMT0001550 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Caughlin, Anthony VW-2LCMT0001551 VW-2LCMT0001551 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Chambers, Stephen VW-2LCMT0001552 VW-2LCMT0001552 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Chandler, James VW-2LCMT0001553 VW-2LCMT0001553 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Cheney, Colin VW-2LCMT0001554 VW-2LCMT0001554 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Childers, Levi VW-2LCMT0001555 VW-2LCMT0001555 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Cledonor, Genet VW-2LCMT0001556 VW-2LCMT0001556 Exhibit 4G7/20/2016 Clendaniel, Charles VW-2LCMT0001557 VW-2LCMT0001557 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Clevenger, Billy VW-2LCMT0001558 VW-2LCMT0001558 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Climo, Michael VW-2LCMT0001559 VW-2LCMT0001559 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Clowdus, Brandy VW-2LCMT0001560 VW-2LCMT0001560 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Coci, Al VW-2LCMT0001561 VW-2LCMT0001561 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Collins, Michael J. VW-2LCMT0001562 VW-2LCMT0001562 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Conrad, James VW-2LCMT0001563 VW-2LCMT0001563 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Contreras, David VW-2LCMT0001564 VW-2LCMT0001564 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Cook, Descanon VW-2LCMT0001565 VW-2LCMT0001565 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Costa, Bill VW-2LCMT0001566 VW-2LCMT0001566 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Craig, Ron VW-2LCMT0001567 VW-2LCMT0001567 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Crouse, Mille VW-2LCMT0001568 VW-2LCMT0001568 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Crowder, Bennie VW-2LCMT0001569 VW-2LCMT0001569 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Cullen, Brian VW-2LCMT0001570 VW-2LCMT0001570 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Dahmem, Frank VW-2LCMT0001571 VW-2LCMT0001571 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Daniels, Stephon VW-2LCMT0001572 VW-2LCMT0001572 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Davenport, Jim VW-2LCMT0001573 VW-2LCMT0001573 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Davis, Helen VW-2LCMT0001574 VW-2LCMT0001574 Exhibit 4G

Page 23 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 24 of 36

Page 25: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/28/2016 Davis, Jimmie VW-2LCMT0001575 VW-2LCMT0001575 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Davis, Richard VW-2LCMT0001576 VW-2LCMT0001576 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 De los reyes, Ricardo VW-2LCMT0001577 VW-2LCMT0001577 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 De los reyes, Ricardo VW-2LCMT0001578 VW-2LCMT0001578 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Dealva, Debra VW-2LCMT0001579 VW-2LCMT0001579 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 DeGroff, Bill VW-2LCMT0001580 VW-2LCMT0001580 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 DeLeon, Anthony VW-2LCMT0001581 VW-2LCMT0001581 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 Dembow, Larry VW-2LCMT0001582 VW-2LCMT0001582 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Demko, Don VW-2LCMT0001583 VW-2LCMT0001584 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Denney, Linda VW-2LCMT0001585 VW-2LCMT0001585 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Detvongsa, Outsa VW-2LCMT0001586 VW-2LCMT0001586 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Devaughn, Dana VW-2LCMT0001587 VW-2LCMT0001587 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Devine, James VW-2LCMT0001588 VW-2LCMT0001588 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Dhamrait, Ripudaman VW-2LCMT0001589 VW-2LCMT0001589 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Dille, Mark Jr. VW-2LCMT0001590 VW-2LCMT0001590 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Dodge, Tim VW-2LCMT0001591 VW-2LCMT0001591 Exhibit 4G7/25/2016 Doggett, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001592 VW-2LCMT0001592 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Donovan, James VW-2LCMT0001593 VW-2LCMT0001593 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Doyle, Ken VW-2LCMT0001594 VW-2LCMT0001594 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Drake, Eric VW-2LCMT0001595 VW-2LCMT0001595 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Dubois, Danny VW-2LCMT0001596 VW-2LCMT0001596 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Dunnam, Ricky VW-2LCMT0001597 VW-2LCMT0001597 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Duran, John VW-2LCMT0001598 VW-2LCMT0001598 Exhibit 4G7/24/2016 Duran, Ramon VW-2LCMT0001599 VW-2LCMT0001599 Exhibit 4G7/24/2016 Duryea, William VW-2LCMT0001600 VW-2LCMT0001600 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Earnhardt, Stacy VW-2LCMT0001601 VW-2LCMT0001601 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Edwards, Curtis VW-2LCMT0001602 VW-2LCMT0001602 Exhibit 4G7/24/2016 Edwards, Shane VW-2LCMT0001603 VW-2LCMT0001603 Exhibit 4G7/31/2016 Ehlen, Kenneth R. VW-2LCMT0001604 VW-2LCMT0001604 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Elliott, David VW-2LCMT0001605 VW-2LCMT0001605 Exhibit 4G7/29/2016 Ellis, Robert H. VW-2LCMT0001606 VW-2LCMT0001606 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Elliss, John VW-2LCMT0001607 VW-2LCMT0001607 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Enns, Grace VW-2LCMT0001608 VW-2LCMT0001608 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Ernst, John VW-2LCMT0001609 VW-2LCMT0001609 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Errar, Cornelius VW-2LCMT0001610 VW-2LCMT0001610 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Esquivel, Jason VW-2LCMT0001611 VW-2LCMT0001611 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Fairbanks, Jerold VW-2LCMT0001612 VW-2LCMT0001612 Exhibit 4G8/4/2016 Farnham, Jim VW-2LCMT0001613 VW-2LCMT0001613 Exhibit 4G

Page 24 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 25 of 36

Page 26: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/28/2016 Felton, Michael VW-2LCMT0001614 VW-2LCMT0001614 Exhibit 4G7/23/2016 Fenivon, Sally VW-2LCMT0001615 VW-2LCMT0001615 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Ferrell, Gregory VW-2LCMT0001616 VW-2LCMT0001616 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Ferrer, Alfredo VW-2LCMT0001617 VW-2LCMT0001617 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Ferri, Richard VW-2LCMT0001618 VW-2LCMT0001618 Exhibit 4G8/2/2016 Ferris, Troy VW-2LCMT0001619 VW-2LCMT0001619 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Finley, William III VW-2LCMT0001620 VW-2LCMT0001620 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Fleischman, Don VW-2LCMT0001621 VW-2LCMT0001621 Exhibit 4G7/27/2016 Fletcher, Scot VW-2LCMT0001622 VW-2LCMT0001622 Exhibit 4G7/21/2016 Flores, Ted VW-2LCMT0001623 VW-2LCMT0001623 Exhibit 4G7/26/2016 Forvoux, Robert VW-2LCMT0001624 VW-2LCMT0001624 Exhibit 4G7/22/2016 Franklin, Julius VW-2LCMT0001625 VW-2LCMT0001625 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Frazier, Joseph VW-2LCMT0001626 VW-2LCMT0001626 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 French, Pat VW-2LCMT0001627 VW-2LCMT0001627 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 French, Pat VW-2LCMT0001628 VW-2LCMT0001628 Exhibit 4G7/28/2016 Fretty, Kevin VW-2LCMT0001629 VW-2LCMT0001629 Exhibit 4G8/3/2016 Friesen, Klas VW-2LCMT0001630 VW-2LCMT0001630 Exhibit 4G8/1/2016 Gabrielli, Michael VW-2LCMT0001631 VW-2LCMT0001631 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Gadd, William VW-2LCMT0001632 VW-2LCMT0001632 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Galang, John VW-2LCMT0001633 VW-2LCMT0001633 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Gall, Jerel VW-2LCMT0001634 VW-2LCMT0001634 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Gamble, Arielle VW-2LCMT0001635 VW-2LCMT0001635 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Ganzer, Ronald VW-2LCMT0001636 VW-2LCMT0001636 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Gao, Peng VW-2LCMT0001637 VW-2LCMT0001637 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Garcia, Mariano VW-2LCMT0001638 VW-2LCMT0001638 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Garcia, Peter VW-2LCMT0001639 VW-2LCMT0001639 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Garcia, Richard VW-2LCMT0001640 VW-2LCMT0001640 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Gardner, John VW-2LCMT0001641 VW-2LCMT0001641 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Gaskins, William VW-2LCMT0001642 VW-2LCMT0001642 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 George, Ronnie Sr. VW-2LCMT0001643 VW-2LCMT0001643 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Gibson, Andrew VW-2LCMT0001644 VW-2LCMT0001644 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Giddings, Bruce VW-2LCMT0001645 VW-2LCMT0001645 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Gilbert, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001646 VW-2LCMT0001646 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Gilbert, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001647 VW-2LCMT0001647 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Gilliam, Damian VW-2LCMT0001648 VW-2LCMT0001648 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Glibert, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001649 VW-2LCMT0001649 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Gochenaur, Donna VW-2LCMT0001650 VW-2LCMT0001650 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Godwin, Gene VW-2LCMT0001651 VW-2LCMT0001651 Exhibit 4H

Page 25 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 26 of 36

Page 27: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/21/2016 Goetz, Mike VW-2LCMT0001652 VW-2LCMT0001652 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Gonzalez, Alejandro VW-2LCMT0001653 VW-2LCMT0001653 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Gordon, Johnny VW-2LCMT0001654 VW-2LCMT0001654 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Gore, Mark VW-2LCMT0001655 VW-2LCMT0001655 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Grant, Scott VW-2LCMT0001656 VW-2LCMT0001656 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Graves, George VW-2LCMT0001657 VW-2LCMT0001657 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Graves, George VW-2LCMT0001658 VW-2LCMT0001658 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Grawe, Doug VW-2LCMT0001659 VW-2LCMT0001659 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Green, Derrick VW-2LCMT0001660 VW-2LCMT0001660 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Green, Gary VW-2LCMT0001661 VW-2LCMT0001662 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Greenlee, Jack VW-2LCMT0001663 VW-2LCMT0001663 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Gregory, Mark VW-2LCMT0001664 VW-2LCMT0001664 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Grim, Melissa VW-2LCMT0001665 VW-2LCMT0001665 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Grooms, Randall VW-2LCMT0001666 VW-2LCMT0001666 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Guerra, Juan VW-2LCMT0001667 VW-2LCMT0001667 Exhibit 4H7/31/2016 Gulad, Hasan VW-2LCMT0001668 VW-2LCMT0001668 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Hamilton, David VW-2LCMT0001669 VW-2LCMT0001669 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Hamilton, Steve VW-2LCMT0001670 VW-2LCMT0001670 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Hamm, Jerry VW-2LCMT0001671 VW-2LCMT0001671 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Hance, Earl VW-2LCMT0001672 VW-2LCMT0001672 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Hancock, Roger VW-2LCMT0001673 VW-2LCMT0001673 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Harris, George VW-2LCMT0001674 VW-2LCMT0001674 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Heglmeier, Steve VW-2LCMT0001675 VW-2LCMT0001675 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Heid, Robert VW-2LCMT0001676 VW-2LCMT0001676 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Helsley, Christina VW-2LCMT0001677 VW-2LCMT0001677 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Hendrix, Deborah VW-2LCMT0001678 VW-2LCMT0001678 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Henry, Barb VW-2LCMT0001679 VW-2LCMT0001679 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Henson, Justin VW-2LCMT0001680 VW-2LCMT0001680 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Herlein, Phil VW-2LCMT0001681 VW-2LCMT0001681 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Herman, Richard VW-2LCMT0001682 VW-2LCMT0001682 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Herring, Jay VW-2LCMT0001683 VW-2LCMT0001683 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Herron, Brad VW-2LCMT0001684 VW-2LCMT0001684 Exhibit 4H8/6/2016 Herron, Chip VW-2LCMT0001685 VW-2LCMT0001686 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Higgins, Larry VW-2LCMT0001687 VW-2LCMT0001687 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Hillen, Scott VW-2LCMT0001688 VW-2LCMT0001688 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Hillen, Scott VW-2LCMT0001689 VW-2LCMT0001689 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Himelright, Philip VW-2LCMT0001690 VW-2LCMT0001690 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Hipp, Peter VW-2LCMT0001691 VW-2LCMT0001691 Exhibit 4H

Page 26 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 27 of 36

Page 28: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/21/2016 Hodge, Carolyn VW-2LCMT0001692 VW-2LCMT0001692 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Hoffman, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001693 VW-2LCMT0001693 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Hoffman, Don VW-2LCMT0001694 VW-2LCMT0001694 Exhibit 4H7/30/2016 Hogard, Stephanie VW-2LCMT0001695 VW-2LCMT0001695 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Holliday, Wayne VW-2LCMT0001696 VW-2LCMT0001696 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Homburg, Carlos VW-2LCMT0001697 VW-2LCMT0001697 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Home, Chad VW-2LCMT0001698 VW-2LCMT0001698 Exhibit 4H8/6/2016 Hopkins, Ray VW-2LCMT0001699 VW-2LCMT0001699 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Horne, Nathaniel VW-2LCMT0001700 VW-2LCMT0001700 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Hugger, Anthony VW-2LCMT0001701 VW-2LCMT0001701 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Hughes, Arthur VW-2LCMT0001702 VW-2LCMT0001702 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Hunke, Charles VW-2LCMT0001703 VW-2LCMT0001703 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Hunt, Michael VW-2LCMT0001704 VW-2LCMT0001704 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Hurlow, Joseph VW-2LCMT0001705 VW-2LCMT0001705 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Hyde, Paula VW-2LCMT0001706 VW-2LCMT0001706 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Ingersoll, Jim VW-2LCMT0001707 VW-2LCMT0001707 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Jackson, Brandon VW-2LCMT0001708 VW-2LCMT0001708 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Jackson, Chico VW-2LCMT0001709 VW-2LCMT0001709 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Jackson, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001710 VW-2LCMT0001710 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Jackson, Harry VW-2LCMT0001711 VW-2LCMT0001711 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Jackson, Sammy VW-2LCMT0001712 VW-2LCMT0001712 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Jackson, Xavier A. VW-2LCMT0001713 VW-2LCMT0001713 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 James, Eric VW-2LCMT0001714 VW-2LCMT0001714 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Jamison, Michelle VW-2LCMT0001715 VW-2LCMT0001715 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Jandrew, Ann VW-2LCMT0001716 VW-2LCMT0001716 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Jantzi, Bruce VW-2LCMT0001717 VW-2LCMT0001717 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Johnson, Herman VW-2LCMT0001718 VW-2LCMT0001718 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Johnson, Herman VW-2LCMT0001719 VW-2LCMT0001719 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Johnson, Karl VW-2LCMT0001720 VW-2LCMT0001720 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Johnson, Kenneth VW-2LCMT0001721 VW-2LCMT0001721 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Johnson, Ross VW-2LCMT0001722 VW-2LCMT0001722 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Johnson, Ross VW-2LCMT0001723 VW-2LCMT0001723 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Johnson, Ross VW-2LCMT0001724 VW-2LCMT0001724 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Johnson, Scott VW-2LCMT0001725 VW-2LCMT0001725 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Jones, Anthony VW-2LCMT0001726 VW-2LCMT0001726 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Jones, Elizabeth VW-2LCMT0001727 VW-2LCMT0001727 Exhibit 4H9/2/2016 Jones, Kenneth VW-2LCMT0001728 VW-2LCMT0001728 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Judy, Raford VW-2LCMT0001729 VW-2LCMT0001729 Exhibit 4H

Page 27 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 28 of 36

Page 29: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/1/2016 Karja, Carl VW-2LCMT0001730 VW-2LCMT0001730 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Kerry, Dan VW-2LCMT0001731 VW-2LCMT0001731 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Kidd, Lonnie VW-2LCMT0001732 VW-2LCMT0001732 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Kim, Jeff VW-2LCMT0001733 VW-2LCMT0001734 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 King, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001735 VW-2LCMT0001735 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Kinnunen, Alan VW-2LCMT0001736 VW-2LCMT0001736 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Kizner, John VW-2LCMT0001737 VW-2LCMT0001737 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Knapp, Kevin VW-2LCMT0001738 VW-2LCMT0001738 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Kolody, Richard VW-2LCMT0001739 VW-2LCMT0001739 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Krawczynski, Charles VW-2LCMT0001740 VW-2LCMT0001740 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Krumma, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001741 VW-2LCMT0001741 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Kubli, Randy VW-2LCMT0001742 VW-2LCMT0001742 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Kyle, Michael VW-2LCMT0001743 VW-2LCMT0001743 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Ladd, James VW-2LCMT0001744 VW-2LCMT0001744 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Lagace, Ruichard VW-2LCMT0001745 VW-2LCMT0001745 Exhibit 4H7/31/2016 Landry, Bryant VW-2LCMT0001746 VW-2LCMT0001746 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Lane, Richard VW-2LCMT0001747 VW-2LCMT0001747 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Laney, Douglas VW-2LCMT0001748 VW-2LCMT0001748 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Langley, Earl VW-2LCMT0001749 VW-2LCMT0001749 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Lapp, George VW-2LCMT0001750 VW-2LCMT0001750 Exhibit 4H7/30/2016 Lara, Jose VW-2LCMT0001751 VW-2LCMT0001751 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Larkin, Walter VW-2LCMT0001752 VW-2LCMT0001752 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Lasorsa, Frank VW-2LCMT0001753 VW-2LCMT0001753 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Laster, John VW-2LCMT0001754 VW-2LCMT0001754 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Latimer, Andy VW-2LCMT0001755 VW-2LCMT0001755 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Lawrence, Randy VW-2LCMT0001756 VW-2LCMT0001756 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Lecomte, Angela VW-2LCMT0001757 VW-2LCMT0001757 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Ledahl, Auden VW-2LCMT0001758 VW-2LCMT0001758 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Lehsten, William VW-2LCMT0001759 VW-2LCMT0001759 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 LeRoy, James VW-2LCMT0001760 VW-2LCMT0001760 Exhibit 4H7/31/2016 Leslie, Christopher VW-2LCMT0001761 VW-2LCMT0001761 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Lewallen, John VW-2LCMT0001762 VW-2LCMT0001762 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Lewis, Alvin VW-2LCMT0001763 VW-2LCMT0001763 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Lewis, Alvin VW-2LCMT0001764 VW-2LCMT0001764 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Lewis, Jimmy VW-2LCMT0001765 VW-2LCMT0001765 Exhibit 4H7/13/2016 Lisek, Ryan VW-2LCMT0001766 VW-2LCMT0001766 Exhibit 4H7/13/2016 Lisek, Ryan VW-2LCMT0001767 VW-2LCMT0001767 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Littrell, Curtis VW-2LCMT0001768 VW-2LCMT0001768 Exhibit 4H

Page 28 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 29 of 36

Page 30: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/4/2016 Lizotte, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001769 VW-2LCMT0001770 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Lockhart, Brian VW-2LCMT0001771 VW-2LCMT0001772 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Lojewski, Paul VW-2LCMT0001773 VW-2LCMT0001773 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Lotz, Donald VW-2LCMT0001774 VW-2LCMT0001775 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Lucas, Corey VW-2LCMT0001776 VW-2LCMT0001776 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Luce, Brad VW-2LCMT0001777 VW-2LCMT0001777 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Ludeke, Mike VW-2LCMT0001778 VW-2LCMT0001778 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Lux, Andrea VW-2LCMT0001779 VW-2LCMT0001779 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 M, Fabio VW-2LCMT0001780 VW-2LCMT0001780 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Madsen, Bernadette VW-2LCMT0001781 VW-2LCMT0001781 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Maguire, Amber VW-2LCMT0001782 VW-2LCMT0001782 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Mann, Chris VW-2LCMT0001783 VW-2LCMT0001783 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Manning, Marcellin VW-2LCMT0001784 VW-2LCMT0001784 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Mansbridge, William VW-2LCMT0001785 VW-2LCMT0001785 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Markley, Paula VW-2LCMT0001786 VW-2LCMT0001786 Exhibit 4H7/24/2016 Markovich, Mike VW-2LCMT0001787 VW-2LCMT0001787 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Marshall, Robert VW-2LCMT0001788 VW-2LCMT0001788 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Martin, Judy VW-2LCMT0001789 VW-2LCMT0001789 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Martinez, Arsenio VW-2LCMT0001790 VW-2LCMT0001790 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Mason, Steve VW-2LCMT0001791 VW-2LCMT0001791 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Matter, Desiree VW-2LCMT0001792 VW-2LCMT0001793 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Matthews, Tony VW-2LCMT0001794 VW-2LCMT0001797 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Mayes, Mike VW-2LCMT0001798 VW-2LCMT0001798 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 McCall, James VW-2LCMT0001799 VW-2LCMT0001799 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 McCall, Ronald VW-2LCMT0001800 VW-2LCMT0001800 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 McCarthy, Patrick VW-2LCMT0001801 VW-2LCMT0001802 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 McDavid, Deborah VW-2LCMT0001803 VW-2LCMT0001803 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 McElyea, Bobby VW-2LCMT0001804 VW-2LCMT0001804 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 McKee, Thomas VW-2LCMT0001805 VW-2LCMT0001805 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 McKeigue, Dale VW-2LCMT0001806 VW-2LCMT0001806 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 McMillan, Peter VW-2LCMT0001807 VW-2LCMT0001807 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 McNeill, John VW-2LCMT0001808 VW-2LCMT0001808 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Medeiras, Chester VW-2LCMT0001809 VW-2LCMT0001809 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Merithew, Chester VW-2LCMT0001810 VW-2LCMT0001810 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Messenbrink, Gina VW-2LCMT0001811 VW-2LCMT0001811 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Mikulski, Chris VW-2LCMT0001812 VW-2LCMT0001812 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Miles, Melissa VW-2LCMT0001813 VW-2LCMT0001813 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Miller, Jeffrey VW-2LCMT0001814 VW-2LCMT0001814 Exhibit 4H

Page 29 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 30 of 36

Page 31: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/1/2016 Miller, Nicole VW-2LCMT0001815 VW-2LCMT0001815 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Miller, Richard VW-2LCMT0001816 VW-2LCMT0001816 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Miller, Terry VW-2LCMT0001817 VW-2LCMT0001817 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Mills, Robin VW-2LCMT0001818 VW-2LCMT0001818 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Mitchell, McKinley VW-2LCMT0001819 VW-2LCMT0001819 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Molloy, Aidan VW-2LCMT0001820 VW-2LCMT0001820 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Monroe, Linda VW-2LCMT0001821 VW-2LCMT0001821 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Morgan, Eric VW-2LCMT0001822 VW-2LCMT0001822 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Morgan, Juliette VW-2LCMT0001823 VW-2LCMT0001823 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Morgan, Morris VW-2LCMT0001824 VW-2LCMT0001824 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Mote, Nathanial VW-2LCMT0001825 VW-2LCMT0001825 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Mujahid, Basil VW-2LCMT0001826 VW-2LCMT0001826 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Murray, Raymon VW-2LCMT0001827 VW-2LCMT0001827 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Murray, Richard VW-2LCMT0001828 VW-2LCMT0001828 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Myres, Cory VW-2LCMT0001829 VW-2LCMT0001829 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Nelson, Edward VW-2LCMT0001830 VW-2LCMT0001830 Exhibit 4H7/30/2016 Neumann, Daniel VW-2LCMT0001831 VW-2LCMT0001831 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Neumayer, Angela VW-2LCMT0001832 VW-2LCMT0001832 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Newgent, John VW-2LCMT0001833 VW-2LCMT0001833 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Newson, Albert VW-2LCMT0001834 VW-2LCMT0001834 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Nichols, Richard VW-2LCMT0001835 VW-2LCMT0001835 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Niederer, Terrel VW-2LCMT0001836 VW-2LCMT0001836 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Niederer, Terrel VW-2LCMT0001837 VW-2LCMT0001837 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Njoroge, Frank VW-2LCMT0001838 VW-2LCMT0001838 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Noble, Simon VW-2LCMT0001839 VW-2LCMT0001840 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Noe, Todd V. VW-2LCMT0001841 VW-2LCMT0001841 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Nofziger, Devon VW-2LCMT0001842 VW-2LCMT0001842 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Nogard, Marc VW-2LCMT0001843 VW-2LCMT0001843 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Nolte, Scott VW-2LCMT0001844 VW-2LCMT0001844 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Oertell, Marvin VW-2LCMT0001845 VW-2LCMT0001845 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Oquendo, Cesar VW-2LCMT0001846 VW-2LCMT0001846 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Oreri, Brian VW-2LCMT0001847 VW-2LCMT0001847 Exhibit 4H7/30/2016 Ortega, Juan VW-2LCMT0001848 VW-2LCMT0001848 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Page, John VW-2LCMT0001849 VW-2LCMT0001849 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Palazuelos, Carlos VW-2LCMT0001850 VW-2LCMT0001850 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Panch, Michael VW-2LCMT0001851 VW-2LCMT0001852 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Parker, Harold VW-2LCMT0001853 VW-2LCMT0001853 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Paskiewicz, Harry VW-2LCMT0001854 VW-2LCMT0001854 Exhibit 4H

Page 30 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 31 of 36

Page 32: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/21/2016 Pazo, Eliberto VW-2LCMT0001855 VW-2LCMT0001855 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Peacock, Dan VW-2LCMT0001856 VW-2LCMT0001856 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Pederson, Jill VW-2LCMT0001857 VW-2LCMT0001857 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Perlaker, Timothy VW-2LCMT0001858 VW-2LCMT0001858 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Phister, Steve VW-2LCMT0001859 VW-2LCMT0001859 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Pierce, Bill VW-2LCMT0001860 VW-2LCMT0001860 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Pilone, Steve VW-2LCMT0001861 VW-2LCMT0001861 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Pilone, Steve VW-2LCMT0001862 VW-2LCMT0001862 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Pinion, Laura VW-2LCMT0001863 VW-2LCMT0001863 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Pintiliuc, Vasile VW-2LCMT0001864 VW-2LCMT0001864 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Pitchford, Christopher VW-2LCMT0001865 VW-2LCMT0001865 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Pocino, Richard VW-2LCMT0001866 VW-2LCMT0001866 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Podgwaite, Frank VW-2LCMT0001867 VW-2LCMT0001867 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Polt, Victor VW-2LCMT0001868 VW-2LCMT0001868 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Pomps, Robert VW-2LCMT0001869 VW-2LCMT0001869 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Poole, Ricky VW-2LCMT0001870 VW-2LCMT0001870 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Pooler, Robert VW-2LCMT0001871 VW-2LCMT0001871 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Potter, Travis VW-2LCMT0001872 VW-2LCMT0001872 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Price, Charles A. Jr. VW-2LCMT0001873 VW-2LCMT0001873 Exhibit 4H7/20/2016 Pritchard, Vincent VW-2LCMT0001874 VW-2LCMT0001874 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Pritchard, Vincent VW-2LCMT0001875 VW-2LCMT0001875 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Proctor, George VW-2LCMT0001876 VW-2LCMT0001876 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Pyles, Ben VW-2LCMT0001877 VW-2LCMT0001877 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Raether, Randon VW-2LCMT0001878 VW-2LCMT0001878 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Rafael VW-2LCMT0001879 VW-2LCMT0001879 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Raff, Tom VW-2LCMT0001880 VW-2LCMT0001880 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Rainey, Larry VW-2LCMT0001881 VW-2LCMT0001881 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Rainey, Mark VW-2LCMT0001882 VW-2LCMT0001882 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Ramirez, Rolando VW-2LCMT0001883 VW-2LCMT0001883 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Ramos, Charles VW-2LCMT0001884 VW-2LCMT0001885 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Ramos, Ramiro VW-2LCMT0001886 VW-2LCMT0001886 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Randolph, Chad VW-2LCMT0001887 VW-2LCMT0001887 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Ransom, William VW-2LCMT0001888 VW-2LCMT0001888 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Rasmussen, Brian VW-2LCMT0001889 VW-2LCMT0001889 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Raven, Karen VW-2LCMT0001890 VW-2LCMT0001890 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Reid, Tony VW-2LCMT0001891 VW-2LCMT0001891 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Rensler, Matthew VW-2LCMT0001892 VW-2LCMT0001892 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Renteria, Juan VW-2LCMT0001893 VW-2LCMT0001893 Exhibit 4H

Page 31 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 32 of 36

Page 33: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/29/2016 Reuse, Elmer VW-2LCMT0001894 VW-2LCMT0001894 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Reynolds, Rusty VW-2LCMT0001895 VW-2LCMT0001895 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Rhyne, Albert VW-2LCMT0001896 VW-2LCMT0001896 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Riegsecker, Corwin VW-2LCMT0001897 VW-2LCMT0001897 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Robinson, Steven VW-2LCMT0001898 VW-2LCMT0001898 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Rocha, Darlene VW-2LCMT0001899 VW-2LCMT0001899 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Rodriguez, Jose VW-2LCMT0001900 VW-2LCMT0001900 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Rogers, Jeff VW-2LCMT0001901 VW-2LCMT0001901 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Romaine, Justin VW-2LCMT0001902 VW-2LCMT0001902 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Rorick, Harry VW-2LCMT0001903 VW-2LCMT0001903 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Rowe, William VW-2LCMT0001904 VW-2LCMT0001904 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Ruiz, Marc VW-2LCMT0001905 VW-2LCMT0001905 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Salazar, Jesus VW-2LCMT0001906 VW-2LCMT0001906 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Salinas, Victoria VW-2LCMT0001907 VW-2LCMT0001907 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Sams, Eugene VW-2LCMT0001908 VW-2LCMT0001908 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Sanchez, Javier VW-2LCMT0001909 VW-2LCMT0001909 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Sanchez, Marco VW-2LCMT0001910 VW-2LCMT0001910 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Sanders, Joel VW-2LCMT0001911 VW-2LCMT0001911 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Sapyta, Terry VW-2LCMT0001912 VW-2LCMT0001912 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Scarparo, David VW-2LCMT0001913 VW-2LCMT0001913 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Schneider, Rusty VW-2LCMT0001914 VW-2LCMT0001914 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Scott, Cliff VW-2LCMT0001915 VW-2LCMT0001915 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Sealey, Ernest P. VW-2LCMT0001916 VW-2LCMT0001916 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Self, Robert VW-2LCMT0001917 VW-2LCMT0001917 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Selhorst, John VW-2LCMT0001918 VW-2LCMT0001918 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Severson, Terry VW-2LCMT0001919 VW-2LCMT0001919 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Seymour, Clyde VW-2LCMT0001920 VW-2LCMT0001920 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Shamblin, Yes VW-2LCMT0001921 VW-2LCMT0001921 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Shampang, Brian VW-2LCMT0001922 VW-2LCMT0001922 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Sheaffer, Doug VW-2LCMT0001923 VW-2LCMT0001923 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Shear, Morris VW-2LCMT0001924 VW-2LCMT0001924 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Sherman, Terry VW-2LCMT0001925 VW-2LCMT0001925 Exhibit 4H7/31/2016 Silva, Juan VW-2LCMT0001926 VW-2LCMT0001926 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Simer, Jeffrey VW-2LCMT0001927 VW-2LCMT0001927 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Simon, David VW-2LCMT0001928 VW-2LCMT0001928 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Sines, Todd VW-2LCMT0001929 VW-2LCMT0001929 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Singh, Kuldip VW-2LCMT0001930 VW-2LCMT0001930 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Singh, Ranjit VW-2LCMT0001931 VW-2LCMT0001931 Exhibit 4H

Page 32 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 33 of 36

Page 34: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/2/2016 Slavin, George VW-2LCMT0001932 VW-2LCMT0001932 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Smith, Bradley VW-2LCMT0001933 VW-2LCMT0001933 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Smith, Ed VW-2LCMT0001934 VW-2LCMT0001934 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Smith, Jeffrey VW-2LCMT0001935 VW-2LCMT0001935 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Smith, Larry VW-2LCMT0001936 VW-2LCMT0001936 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Smith, Manuel VW-2LCMT0001937 VW-2LCMT0001937 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Smith, Mark VW-2LCMT0001938 VW-2LCMT0001938 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Smith, Stuart Buchanan VW-2LCMT0001939 VW-2LCMT0001939 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Smith, Vern VW-2LCMT0001940 VW-2LCMT0001940 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Snyder, Charles VW-2LCMT0001941 VW-2LCMT0001941 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Soro, Isidor VW-2LCMT0001942 VW-2LCMT0001942 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Southers, Kim VW-2LCMT0001943 VW-2LCMT0001943 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Spadafore, Joe VW-2LCMT0001944 VW-2LCMT0001944 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Spradlin, Tim VW-2LCMT0001945 VW-2LCMT0001945 Exhibit 4H7/14/2016 Stancati, Joe VW-2LCMT0001946 VW-2LCMT0001946 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Stanoyevic, Carl VW-2LCMT0001947 VW-2LCMT0001947 Exhibit 4H7/30/2016 Starr, Barry VW-2LCMT0001948 VW-2LCMT0001948 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Stephens, Dwight VW-2LCMT0001949 VW-2LCMT0001949 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Stiles, Candance VW-2LCMT0001950 VW-2LCMT0001950 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Strong, Cody VW-2LCMT0001951 VW-2LCMT0001951 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Sturgess, Steve VW-2LCMT0001952 VW-2LCMT0001953 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Sundstrom, Troy VW-2LCMT0001954 VW-2LCMT0001954 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Suozzo, Frank VW-2LCMT0001955 VW-2LCMT0001955 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Swafford, Kevin VW-2LCMT0001956 VW-2LCMT0001956 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Swearingen, Jason VW-2LCMT0001957 VW-2LCMT0001957 Exhibit 4H7/31/2016 Swift, Jon'Nathan VW-2LCMT0001958 VW-2LCMT0001958 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Tazewell, Anne VW-2LCMT0001959 VW-2LCMT0001959 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Tazewell, Anne VW-2LCMT0001960 VW-2LCMT0001960 Exhibit 4H7/25/2016 Thind, Amandeep S. VW-2LCMT0001961 VW-2LCMT0001961 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Thomas, Edward VW-2LCMT0001962 VW-2LCMT0001962 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Thompson, Tito VW-2LCMT0001963 VW-2LCMT0001963 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Tillit, Richard P. VW-2LCMT0001964 VW-2LCMT0001964 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Tobitt, Terry VW-2LCMT0001965 VW-2LCMT0001965 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Trapp, Robert VW-2LCMT0001966 VW-2LCMT0001966 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Trautman, Dan VW-2LCMT0001967 VW-2LCMT0001967 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Tubman, Robert VW-2LCMT0001968 VW-2LCMT0001968 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Tuck, Jeffrey VW-2LCMT0001969 VW-2LCMT0001969 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Vadasz, Gabor VW-2LCMT0001970 VW-2LCMT0001970 Exhibit 4H

Page 33 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 34 of 36

Page 35: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

8/1/2016 Vadasz, Gabor VW-2LCMT0001971 VW-2LCMT0001971 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Valentine, Juan R. VW-2LCMT0001972 VW-2LCMT0001972 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Valvo, Doc VW-2LCMT0001973 VW-2LCMT0001973 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Van Wagoner, Mike VW-2LCMT0001974 VW-2LCMT0001974 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Varvel, Mark VW-2LCMT0001975 VW-2LCMT0001975 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Vaughn, Ronald VW-2LCMT0001976 VW-2LCMT0001976 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Velez, Ruben VW-2LCMT0001977 VW-2LCMT0001977 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Villegas, Edward VW-2LCMT0001978 VW-2LCMT0001978 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Wadsworth, Rane VW-2LCMT0001979 VW-2LCMT0001979 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Ward, Eva VW-2LCMT0001980 VW-2LCMT0001980 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Ward, Wendell VW-2LCMT0001981 VW-2LCMT0001981 Exhibit 4H7/26/2016 Wasikowski, Shawn VW-2LCMT0001982 VW-2LCMT0001982 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Watson, Jeffrey VW-2LCMT0001983 VW-2LCMT0001983 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Watson, Robert VW-2LCMT0001984 VW-2LCMT0001984 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Watson, Tim VW-2LCMT0001985 VW-2LCMT0001985 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Watson, Victoria VW-2LCMT0001986 VW-2LCMT0001987 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Watts, James VW-2LCMT0001988 VW-2LCMT0001988 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Weaver, John VW-2LCMT0001989 VW-2LCMT0001989 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 West, Edward VW-2LCMT0001990 VW-2LCMT0001990 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 West, Nick VW-2LCMT0001991 VW-2LCMT0001992 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Whatley, Kelvin VW-2LCMT0001993 VW-2LCMT0001993 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 White, David VW-2LCMT0001994 VW-2LCMT0001994 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 White, Kelly VW-2LCMT0001995 VW-2LCMT0001995 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Whitehead, John VW-2LCMT0001996 VW-2LCMT0001996 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Whitney, Jim VW-2LCMT0001997 VW-2LCMT0001997 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Whitson, John David VW-2LCMT0001998 VW-2LCMT0001998 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Whyte, Harold VW-2LCMT0001999 VW-2LCMT0001999 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Wideman, Stewart VW-2LCMT0002000 VW-2LCMT0002000 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 Willett, Rob VW-2LCMT0002001 VW-2LCMT0002001 Exhibit 4H7/27/2016 William, Bill VW-2LCMT0002002 VW-2LCMT0002002 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Williams, Burley VW-2LCMT0002003 VW-2LCMT0002003 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Williams, David VW-2LCMT0002004 VW-2LCMT0002004 Exhibit 4H8/4/2016 Williams, Jim VW-2LCMT0002005 VW-2LCMT0002005 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Williams, Richard VW-2LCMT0002006 VW-2LCMT0002006 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Wingate, James VW-2LCMT0002007 VW-2LCMT0002007 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Woloszyn, Mark VW-2LCMT0002008 VW-2LCMT0002008 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Wood, Kim VW-2LCMT0002009 VW-2LCMT0002009 Exhibit 4H7/28/2016 Worley, Pamela VW-2LCMT0002010 VW-2LCMT0002010 Exhibit 4H

Page 34 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 35 of 36

Page 36: EXHIBIT 3 Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice · 2019-10-04 · 8/5/2016 Clean Fuels Ohio VW-2LCMT0000205 VW-2LCMT0000209 Exhibit 4B 8/5/2016 CleanFuture VW-2LCMT0000210

United States of America v. Volkswagen AG, et al., Case No. 3:16-cv-00295Index of Comments Received by Department of Justice

Date Rec’d

Commenter Bates Begin Bates End Exhibit

7/30/2016 Wu, Tony VW-2LCMT0002011 VW-2LCMT0002012 Exhibit 4H7/29/2016 Wu, Vivian VW-2LCMT0002013 VW-2LCMT0002014 Exhibit 4H7/30/2016 Wu, Vivian VW-2LCMT0002015 VW-2LCMT0002016 Exhibit 4H8/2/2016 Wyman, Donald VW-2LCMT0002017 VW-2LCMT0002017 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Xander, Robert VW-2LCMT0002018 VW-2LCMT0002018 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Yates, Aaron VW-2LCMT0002019 VW-2LCMT0002019 Exhibit 4H8/3/2016 Young, Kelvin VW-2LCMT0002020 VW-2LCMT0002020 Exhibit 4H8/5/2016 Young, Ryan VW-2LCMT0002021 VW-2LCMT0002021 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Young, Thomas VW-2LCMT0002022 VW-2LCMT0002022 Exhibit 4H8/1/2016 Yusuf, Harsi VW-2LCMT0002023 VW-2LCMT0002023 Exhibit 4H7/23/2016 Zarate, E. Jesse VW-2LCMT0002024 VW-2LCMT0002024 Exhibit 4H7/21/2016 Zechman, Scott VW-2LCMT0002025 VW-2LCMT0002025 Exhibit 4H7/22/2016 Zurek, Ron VW-2LCMT0002026 VW-2LCMT0002026 Exhibit 4H

Page 35 of 35

EXHIBIT 3 TO UNITED STATES MOTION FOR ENTRY OF

PARTIAL CONSENT DECREEMDL No. 2672 CRB (JSC)

Case 3:15-md-02672-CRB Document 1973-3 Filed 09/30/16 Page 36 of 36