Evidence Fulltext Batch 2

8/12/2019 Evidence Fulltext Batch 2

1/23

1| P a g e

EVIDENCE FULLTEXT BATCH 2ROLEX SUPLICO, Petitioner,

versus

NATIONAL ECONOMIC ANDDEVELOPMENT

AUTHORITY, represented by NEDA SECRETARYROMULO L. NERI, and te NEDA!INVESTMENTCOORDINATION COMMITTEE, DEPARTMENT O"TRANSPORTATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONS #DOTC$,represented by DOTC SECRETARY LEANDRO

MENDO%A, &n'()d&n* te COMMISSION ONIN"ORMATIONAND COMMUNICATIONS

TECHNOLO+Y, eaded by &ts Ca&ran, RAMON P.SALES, THE TELECOMMUNICATIONS

O""ICE, -IDS AND AARDS "ORIN"ORMATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONS

TECHNOLO+Y #ICT$, eaded by DOTC ASSISTANTSECRETARY ELMER A. SONE/A as Ca&ran, and te

TECHNICAL OR0IN+ +ROUP "OR ICT, AND DOTCASSISTANT SECRETARY LOREN%O"ORMOSO, AND ALLOTHER OPERATIN+ UNITS O"THE DOTC "OR

IN"ORMATIONAND COMMUNICATIONSTECHNOLO+Y, and %TE CORPORATION, AMSTERDAMHOLDIN+S, INC., AND ALLPERSONS ACTIN+ INTHEIR -EHAL", Respondents.

+.R. N1. 234456

Present:PUN, C.J.,!UI"U#BIN$,%NARE"&"ANTIA$,

CARPI,AU"TRIAARTINE',CRNA,CARPI #RALE",A'CUNA,TIN$A,CHIC&NA'ARI,(

VELA"C, )R.,NACHURA,RE%E",LENARD&DE CA"TR, *nd

BRIN,JJ.

Pro+-*ted:

/)(y 27, 8664

/&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& /

AMSTERDAM HOLDIN+S, INC., and NATHANIEL SAU%, Petitioners,

versus

DEPARTMENT O"TRANSPORTATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONS, SECRETARYLEANDRO MENDO%A, COMMISSION ONIN"ORMATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONS TECHNOLO+Y, andASSISTANT SECRETARY LOREN%O "ORMOSO III, Respondents.

+.R. N1. 239523

/&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& /

+ALELEO P. AN+ELES, VICENTE C.AN+ELES, /O- "LORANTE L. CASTILLO, TRINI ANNE +.NIEVA, ROY ALLAN T. ARELLANO, CARLO MA+NO M.REONAL, ETHEL -. RE+ADIO, RAENAN -.

MALI+, ANDVINALYN M. POTOT, TO+ETHER ITHLAYERS AND ADVOCATES "OR ACCOUNTA-ILITY,TRANSPARENCY, INTE+RITY AND+OOD +OVERNANCE#LATI+O$,

Petitioners,

versus

DEPARTMENT O"

TRANSPORTATION ANDCOMMUNICATIONS #DOTC$,represented by DOTC SECRETARY LEANDRO MENDO%A,and %HON+XIN+ E:UIPMENT#%TE$ COMPANY,LTD., AND ANY AND ALL PERSONS ACTIN+

ON THEIR -EHAL", Respondents.

+.R. N1. 239;25

/&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& /

R E S O L U T I O N

REYES, R.T.,J.er6*--= reested !st"ndorse#ent is notsi0ient 6*sis or t1e 0on0-sion t1*t t1e 'TE&DTC NBN de*- 1*s 6eenper+*nent-= s0r*pped.

79. "i0e to s t*te, s*id !st"ndorse#ent is

-*rin-= se(=!ser>&n*, espe0i*--= *nt sin0e e to r*nt t1e +otion.

"&rst(y, t1e Cort notes t1e trip-e petitions to 6e or certiorari, pro1i6ition *nd+*nd*+s, id*- pr*=ers in e*01 o t1e t1ree ; 0onso-id*ted petitions*re:

+.R. N1. 234456
http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn4http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn5http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn6http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn6http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn7http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn7http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn8http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn9http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn9http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn10http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn11http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn4http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn5http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn6http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn7http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn8http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn9http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn10http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn11


3/23

3| P a g e

HEREFRE, it is respe0t--= pr*=ed o t1is Honor*6-e Cort:

4. Upon t1e i-in o t1is Petition, prs*nt to

t1e se0ond p*r*r*p1 o R-e , "e0tion o t1e R-eso Cort, isseforthwith *n e' parte te+por*r=restr*inin order enB1&n&n* resp1ndents, t1eirs6ordin*tes, *ents, represent*ti>es *nd *n= *nd *--persons *0tin on t1eir 6e1*- =r1 p)rs)&n*, enter&n*

&nt1 &ndebtedness, d&sb)rs&n* =)nds, and&p(eent&n* te %TE!DOTC -r1adband Dea(J

2. C1pe( resp1ndents, pon rit o

#*nd*+s, t1 forthwithpr1d)'e and =)rn&spet&t&1ner 1r &s )nders&*ned '1)nse( a 'ert&=&edtr)e '1py 1= te '1ntra't 1r a*reeent '1>er&n* te

N-N pr1Be't as a*reed )p1n &t %TE C1rp1rat&1nJ. "01ed-e r*- Ar+ents in t1e present 0*se

prs*nt to R-e ?G in re-*tion to "e0tion 2, R-e 7 ot1e re>ised R-es o CortJ *nd,

?. Ann)( and set as&de te aard 1=

te %TE!DOTC -r1adband Dea(, *nd 0o+pe-p6-i0 respondents toforthwith0o+p-= isions o -*< re*rdin pro0re+ent o o>ern+ent

ICT 0ontr*0ts *nd p6-i0 6iddin or t1e NBN 0ontr*0t.3445 E+p1*sis spp-ied;

+.R. N1. 239523

HEREFRE, petitioners A+sterd*+ Ho-dins, In0., *nd N*t1*nie-"* respe0t--= pr*= *s o--o&ty &n '1nne't&1n &t te Nat&1na(-r1adband Net1r Pr1Be'tJ

B. t1e inst*nt Petition or #*nd*+s 6e i>ende 0orseJ *nd,C. *ter de 0onsider*tion o *-- re-e>*ntisses, d+ent 6e rendered dire0tin respondents to*--o< 1erein petitioners *00ess to *-- *ree+ents entered

into ern+ent o C1in*, t1e 'TE Corpor*tion,*ndKor ot1er entities, o>ern+ent instr+ent*-ities,*ndKor indi>id*-s ised R-es o CortJ

. Ann)( and set as&de te aard 1= te

'1ntra't =1r te nat&1na( br1adband net1r t1resp1ndent %TE C1rp1rat&1n, pon t1e rond t1*ts*id 0ontr*0t, *s &s&1ns 1=(a re*ard&n* pr1')reent 1= *1>ernent&n=rastr)'t)re pr1Be'ts, in0-din p6-i0 6iddin ors*id 0ontr*0t to ndert*e t1e 0onstr0tion o t1en*tion*- 6ro*d6*nd net


4/23

4| P a g e

HEREA", t1e "pre+e Cort, on 44 "epte+6er 2889, *dopted *reso-tion in t1e *6o>e&entit-ed 0*se, to ei++edi*te-= *nd 0ontinin nti-rt1er orders ro+ t1is Cort,enoinin t1e i; N*tion*-E0ono+i0 *nd De>e-op+ent At1orit=,ii; NEDA&In>est+ent Coordin*tionCo++ittee, iii; Dep*rt+ent oTr*nsport*tion *nd Co++ni0*tions,Co++ission on Inor+*tion *ndCo++ni0*tions Te01no-o=, i>;Te-e0o++ni0*tions i0e, Bids *ndA; Te01ni0*- orin $rop orICT, *nd *-- ot1er per*tin Units o t1eDTC or Inor+*tion *nd

Co++ni0*tions Te01no-o=, >i; 'TECorpor*tionJ >ii; A+sterd*+ Ho-dins,In0., *nd >iii; ARE"C#, In0., *nd *n=*nd *-- persons *0tin on t1eir 6e1*-ro+ Oprsin, enterin into

inde6tedness, dis6rsin nds, *ndi+p-e+entin t1e 'TE&DTC Bro*d6*ndDe*- *nd Proe0t@ *s pr*=ed or.M

N THEREFRE, ee0ti>e i++edi*te-= *nd 0ontinin nti-

rt1er orders ro+ t1is Cort, %o, Respondents i; N*tion*- E0ono+i0 *ndDe>e-op+ent At1orit=, ii; NEDA&In>est+ent Coordin*tion Co++ittee, iii;Dep*rt+ent o Tr*nsport*tion *nd Co++ni0*tions, Co++ission onInor+*tion *nd Co++ni0*tions Te01no-o=, i>;

Te-e0o++ni0*tions i0e, Bids *nd A; Te01ni0*- orin $ropor ICT, *nd *-- ot1er per*tin Units o t1e DTC or Inor+*tion *ndCo++ni0*tions Te01no-o=, >i; 'TE Corpor*tionJ >ii; A+sterd*+Ho-dins, In0., *nd >iii; ARE"C#, In0., *nd *n= *nd *-- persons *0tin ont1eir 6e1*- *re 1ere6= EN/OINED=r1 ?p)rs)&n*, enter&n* &nt1&ndebtedness, d&sb)rs&n* =)nds, and &p(eent&n* te %TE!DOTC

-r1adband Dea( and Pr1Be't as prayed =1r .345E+p1*sis spp-ied.;

Petitioners in $.R. Nos. 498 *nd 49G74 pr*= t1*t t1e= 6e rnis1ed 0ertiied tre0opies o t1e 0ontr*0t or *ree+ent 0o>erin t1e NBN proe0t *s *reed pon e 6r*n01 on t1e P1i-ippine $o>ern+ent@s de0ision not to 0ontine&den'e, o t1e e/isten0e*nd territori*- e/tent o st*tes, t1eir po-iti0*- 1istor=, or+s o o>ern+ent*nd s=+6o-s o n*tion*-it=, t1e -*< o n*tions, t1e *d+ir*-t= *nd +*riti+e0orts o t1e e, e@e')t&>e *nddi0i*-departents 1= te P&(&pp&nes, t1e -*isions. E+p1*sis spp-ied;Under t1e r-es, it is andat1ry*nd t1e Cort 1*s no *-tern*ti>e 6t to t*e

di0i*- noti0e o t1e oi0i*- *0ts o t1e President o t1e P1i-ippines, e
http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn16http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn16http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn17http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn18http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn18http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn16http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn17http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/jurisprudence/2008/july2008/178830.htm#_ftn18


5/23

5| P a g e

6r*n01 o or o>ern+ent. It is rt1er pro>ided in t1e *6o>e&oted r-e t1*t t1e 0orts1*-- t*e di0i*- noti0e o t1e oreoin *0ts &t1)t &ntr1d)'t&1n 1= e>&den'e. "in0ee departent, t1e Cort +st t*e di0i*- noti0e o s01oi0i*- *0t iden0e.

In )avid v. Macapagal-Arroyo,345e too di0i*- noti0e o t1e *nnon0e+ent 6=t1e i0e o t1e President 6*nnin *-- r*--ies *nd 0*n0e-in *-- per+its or p6-i0 *sse+6-ies

o--oin t1e*0t*- inredient o t1e petition.

#oreo>er, nder "e0tion 2, p*r*r*p1 +; o R-e 44 o t1e R-es o Cort,t1e 1==&'&a( d)ty o t1e e/e0ti>e oi0i*-s3285o inor+in t1is Cort o t1e o>ern+ent@sde0ision not to 0ontine


6/23

6| P a g e

to or+-*te idin *nd 0ontro--in 0onstittion*- prin0ip-es, pre0epts,do0trines or r-es or tre id*n0e o 6ot1 6en01 *nd 6*r.

In t1e 0*se *t 6*r, t1e reso-tion o ed in t1is 0ontro>ers=. E/0ept ort1e deter+in*tion o &den'e. T1ere is not *n iot* o do6t t1*t t&say n1t be d1ne by t&s C1)rt &n te =&rst &nstan'e be'a)se, *s 1*s 6een st*ted oteneno1, t&s C1)rt &s n1t a tr&er 1= =a'ts.

Ang pagpapasiya sa tatlong petisyon ay nangangailangan ng paglilitis na

hindi gawain ng Hukumang ito.

Respondent 'TE, in its Co++ent in $.R. No. 498,3250orre0t-= pointed ot t1*tsin0e petitioner "p-i0o i-ed 1is petition dire0t-= ene or t1is *0t*- +*tter to 6e t1res1ed ot.

T&rd(y, petitioner "p-i0o in $.R. No. 498 pr*=ed t1*t t1is Cort order p6-i0

respondents to forthwith0o+p-= isions o -*< re*rdin pro0re+ent oo>ern+ent ICT 0ontr*0ts *nd p6-i0 6iddin or t1e NBN 0ontr*0t.M325 It 1)(d be t11pres)pt)1)s 1n te part 1= te C1)rt t1 s)ar&(y '1pe( p)b(&' resp1ndentsto0o+p-= isions o -*< re*rdin pro0re+ent o o>ern+ent inr*str0treproe0ts &t1)t any =a't)a( bas&sor prior deter+in*tion o >er= p*rti0-*r >io-*tions0o++itted 6= spe0ii0 o>ern+ent oi0i*-s o t1e e/e0ti>e 6r*n01. For t1e Cort to do soern+ent. A per0ei>ed error 0*nnot 6e 0orre0ted 6= 0o++ittin *not1er error. it1otproper e>iden0e, t1e Cort 0*nnot st pres+e t1*t t1e e/e0ti>e did not 0o+p-= esti*tion in *id o -eis-*tion 0*nnot 6e t1e 6*sis

o r de0ision


7/23

7| P a g e

)sti0e Antonio T. C*rpio t*es t1e >ie< t1*t t1e N*tion*- Bro*d6*nd Netoid. T1e oreoin t1reeo-d re*sons iden0ee; i-ed 6= t1e ndersined0o+p-*in*nt prose0tors +e+6ers o t1e D) P*ne- o Prose0tors; **inst t1e *00sed#rs. I+e-d* Ro+*-de #*r0os, or Vio-*tion o Centr*- B*n Forein E/01*ne Restri0tions,*s 0onso-id*ted in CB Cir0-*r No. G78, in re-*tion to t1e pen*- pro>isions o "e0. ? o R.A.27, *s *+ended, . . .J

2. T1*t respondent )de issed 1is rder so-e-= on t1e 6*sis o neern+ent o *-- orein e/01*ne restri0tions *nd t1e *rri>*- *t s01 de0ision 6= t1e#onet*r= Bo*rd *s per st*te+ent o Centr*- B*n $o>ernor )ose Cisi*J

. T1*t 0-*i+in t1*t t1e reported *nnon0e+ent o t1e E/e0ti>e Dep*rt+ent on t1e -itino orein e/01*ne restri0tions 6= tin t1e $o>ern+ent o its ri1t to 6e 1e*rd, *nd 0-e*r-=e/posin 1is 6i*s *nd p*rti*-it=J *nd. T1*t, in *0t, t1e +oti>e o respondent )de in dis+issin t1e 0*se en en p-*0ed 1is dis+iss*- rdersspe0t.Prs*nt to * reso-tion o t1is Cort d*ted "epte+6er , 4GG2, respondent de i-ed 1is

0o++ent, 70ontendin, inter alia, t1*t t1ere


8/23


9/23

9| P a g e

inn0tion s1o-d isse. E>ent*--=, on Apri- 2G, 4GG, t1e Cort o Appe*-s rendered *de0ision 9settin *side t1e order o Ast 4, 4GG2, *nd reinst*tin Cri+in*- C*ses Nos.G2&484GG to G2&484G7G.In indin t1*t respondent de *0ted in e/0ess o risdi0tion *nd e *6se odis0retion in issin t1e order o dis+iss*-, t1e *ppe--*te 0ort 1e-d t1*t:T1e order isions in C1*pter X o CBCir0-*r No. 44 inso*r *s t1e= *re not in0onsistent isions o

t1is Cir0-*r, s1*-- re+*in in -- or0e *nd ee0t: Provided, however, t1*t *n= re-*tion onnon&tr*de orein e/01*ne tr*ns*0tions io-*tions o esti*tions, s1*-- not6e 0onsidered repe*-ed inso*r *s s01 pendin *0tions or in>esti*tions *re 0on0erned, it6ein nderstood t1*t *s to s01 pendin *0tions or in>esti*tions, t1e re-*tions e/istin*t t1e ti+e t1e 0*se o *0tion *00red s1*-- o>ern.Respondent de 0ontends t1*t t1e s*>in 0-*se reers on-= to t1e pro>isions o Cir0-*rNo. 44, en 0ri+in*- 0*ses 1e dis+issed in>o->e * >io-*tion o CB Cir0-*rNo. G78. Hen0e, 1e insists, Cir0-*r No. G78 is dee+ed repe*-ed 6= t1e ne< 0ir0-*r *ndsin0e t1e or+er is not 0o>ered 6= t1e s*>in 0-*se in t1e -*tter, t1ere is no +ore 6*sis ort1e 01*res in>o->ed in t1e 0ri+in*- 0*ses ides t1*tQany re-*tion on non&tr*de orein tr*ns*0tions esti*tions *re 0on0erned, it 6ein nderstood t1*t *s to s01 pendin *0tions or

in>esti*tions, t1eregulations e'isting at the ti#e the cause of action accrued shall govern.QT1e ter+s o t1e 0ir0-*r *re 0-e*r *nd n*+6ios *nd -e*>e no roo+ or interpret*tion. Int1e 0*se *t 6*r, t1e *00sed in t1e e-e>en 0*ses 1*d *-re*d= 6een *rr*ined, 1*d p-e*ded noti-t= to t1e 01*res o >io-*tions o Cir0-*r No. G78, *nd s*id 0*ses 1*d *-re*d= 6een setor tri*-


10/23

10| P a g e

spposed to pro0eed ides:"e0. 444. %epealing clause. & A-- e/istin pro>isions o Cir0-*rs 7, G78 *nd 482, in0-din*+end+ents t1ereto, e detri+ent*- 0onseen0es6e=ond t1e i++edi*te 0ontro>ers=. He s1o-d *d+inister 1is oi0e iden0e ot1e i-t o t1e *00sed. To repe*t, 1e t1ere6= ee0ti>e-= depri>ed t1e prose0tion o its

ri1t to de pro0ess.83

#ore i+port*nt-=, notiden0e e>en i 1e t1inst1*t t1e oppositors proos +i1t not 6e *de*te to o>ert1ro< t1e 0*se or t1e ot1er p*rt=.A disp-*= o pet-*n0e *nd i+p*tien0e in t1e 0ond0t o t1e tri*- is * nor+ o 0ond0t e serios-= *nds6st*nti*--= *e0ted t1e ri1ts o t1e prose0tion 1*d t1e *00sed in>oed t1e deense o

do6-e eop*rd=, 0onsiderin t1*t t1e dis+iss*-


11/23

11| P a g e

in. To stress t1is point, *nd *s *caveat to tri*- 0orts **inst *--in into t1e s*+e di0i*-error, e its 0*se, itsri1t to de pro0ess is t1ere6= >io-*ted.T1e 0*rdin*- pre0ept is t1*t io-*tion o 6*si0 0onstittion*- ri1ts, 0orts*re osted o t1eir risdi0tion. T1s, t1e >io-*tion o t1e "t*tes ri1t to de pro0ess r*ises *

serios risdi0tion*- isse . . . er or disre*rded *t oid or -*0 o risdi0tion . . . . 56

It is *-so sinii0*nt t1*t *00sed #*r0os, despite de noti0e, ne>er s6+itted eit1er 1er0o++ent on or *n *nses to rt1er nders0ore t1e *0tt1*t t1e order o dis+iss*- io-*tion o t1e -e*- pre0ept.52

In t1e present 0*se, * 0rsor= pers*- o t1e 0o++ent i-ed 6= respondent de re>e*-s t1*tno s6st*nti*- *r+ent 1*s 6een *d>*n0ed in p-*si6-e stii0*tion o 1is *0t. He tter-=*i-ed to s1o< *n= -e*-, *0t*-, or e>en eit*6-e stii0*tion or t1e dis+iss*- o t1e e-e>en0ri+in*- 0*ses. T1e e/p-*n*tion i>en is no e/p-*n*tion *t *--. T1e str*ined *nd *--*0ioss6+issions t1erein do not spe* ern+ent Q1*s LIFTED *-- orein e/01*ne 0ontro-s,Q*nd in t1e ot1er nee, t1*t QT1e o>ern+ent =esterd*= -ited t1e -*stre+*inin restri0tions on orein e/01*ne tr*ns*0tionsQ. T1e -itin o t1e -*st re+*inine/01*ne re-*tions ee0ti>e-= 0*n0e--ed or repe*-ed Cir0-*r No. G78.T1e President, e, p6-i0-= *nnon0ed t1e -itin o *-- oreine/01*ne re-*tions. T1e President 1*s ised 6= t1e Centr*- B*n$o>ernor )ose Cisi* *nd )sti0e "e0ret*r= Fr*n-in Dri-on t1*t t1e #onet*r= Bo*rdRe-*tion e/0-ded ro+ its 0o>er*e *-- 0ri+in*- 0*ses pendin in 0ort *nd s01 * positions1*-- st*nd -e*- s0rtin=, #rs. A6*=*, s*id.QI


12/23

12| P a g e

t1e C1ie E/e0ti>e ro+ e+6*rr*ss+ent 6= *ss+in responsi6i-it= or errors in t1e -*tters*nnon0e+ent, t1ese *d>isers 1*>e 01osen to toss t1e 6-*+e or t1e 0onseen0e o t1eir*i-in to +e, e 0*se, *n RT) de e ponre0eipt o t1is de0ision." RDERED.

+.R. N1. 2F;6F8 Mar' 3, 8663SOCIAL /USTICE SOCIETY #S/S$, VLADIMIR ALARI:UE T. CA-I+AO, and-ONI"ACIO S. TUM-O0ON,Petitioners,

>s.HON. /OSE L. ATIEN%A, /R., &n &s 'apa'&ty as May1r 1= te C&ty 1=Man&(a,Respondent.D E C I " I NCORONA,J.:

In t1is oriin*- petition or #anda#us,4petitioners "o0i*- )sti0e "o0iet= ")";, V-*di+irA-*rie T. C*6i*o *nd Boni*0io ". T+6oon see to 0o+pe- respondent Hon. )ose L.Atien*, )r., +*=or o t1e Cit= o #*ni-*, to enor0e rdin*n0e No. 829.T1e *nte0edents *re *s o--oe+6er 28, 2884, t1e (angguniang Panlungsodo #*ni-* en*0ted rdin*n0e No.829.2Respondent +*=or *ppro>ed t1e ordin*n0e on No>e+6er 2, 2884.It 6e0*+eee0ti>e on De0e+6er 2, 2884, *ter its p6-i0*tion.?

rdin*n0e No. 829


13/23

13| P a g e

Se't&1n 2.& Consistent es st*ted *6o>e, t1e IL C#PANIE" s1*--, ponsinin o t1is #U, ndert*e * pror*+ to s0*-e doe-op+ent *nd +*inten*n0e o t1e s*et= *nd reen 6er ones+entioned t1erein,


14/23

14| P a g e

SO ORDERED.

THE DIRECTOR O" LANDS,petitioner, vs. COURT O" APPEALS and TEODOROA-ISTADO, s)bst&t)ted by MAR+ARITA, MARISSA, MARI-EL, ARNOLD and MARYANN, a(( s)rnaed A-ISTADO, respondents.D E C I S I O NPAN+ANI-AN,J.&den'e 'ann1t &n any anner be treated as e>&den'e. Ne&ter 'an s)')nre'1*n&ed pr11= be ass&*ned any e>&dent&ary e&*t and >a()e. It +st 6estressed t1*t t1ere is * sinii0*nt distin0tion 6etiden0e

*nd its or+*- oer. T1e or+er is done in t1e 0orse o t1e pre&tri*-, *nd tri*- is*00o+p*nied 6= t1e +*rin o t1e e>iden0e *s *n e/1i6itJ


20/23

20| P a g e

iden0e. It +st 6e e+p1*sied t1*t *n= e>iden0e


21/23

21| P a g e

#oreo>er, *ppe--*nt@s *d+ission drin t1e pre&tri*- t1*t AAAM iden0e **inst t1e *00sed n-ess red0ed

to ie< on certiorarinder R-e ? o t1e R-es o Cort sees to re>erse t1eDe0ision o t1e Cort o Appe*-s, d*ted 0to6er 2G, 4GG, in C.A. $.R. No. CV ??97, *s ie


22/23

22| P a g e

pi-ots in0-din p-*inti o t1e sit*tion *nd *d>ised t1e+ to t*e *d>*n0e -e*>es. E/1. Q4Q,p. ?77, Re0.;.

Re*-iin t1*t t1e re0ession ieiee on-= t. 42, 4G9. p. 2;.Arie>ed, p-*inti on )ne 2G, 4G, institted * 0*se or i--e*- dis+iss*- 6eore t1e L*6or

Ar6iter. Deend*nt +o>ed to dis+iss on risdi0tion*- ronds. Beore s*id +otion ed, t1e 0o+p-*int e no risdi0tion o>er t1e inst*nt 0*se. Deend*nt 0ontends t1*t t1e 0o+p-*int isor i--e*- dis+iss*- toet1er *-ent in P1i-ippine 0rren0= *t t1e 0rrent r*te o e/01*ne *t

t1e ti+e o p*=+ent, *s *nd or ne*rned 0o+pens*tion e +otions or re0onsider*tion


23/23

23| P a g e

QArticle 87!. #one= 0-*i+s. & A-- +one= 0-*i+s *risin ro+ e+p-o=ee&e+p-o=er re-*tions*00rin drin t1e ee0ti>it= o t1is Code s1*-- 6e i-ed e period i/ed in Arti0-e

44?? o t1e Ci>i- Code ay n1t 6e in>oed 6= petitioners, or t1e Ci>i- Code is * -*< oener*- *pp-i0*tion, e period i/ed in Arti0-e 2G2 o t1e L*6or Code 3no

Evidence Fulltext Batch 2

Documents

Transcript of Evidence Fulltext Batch 2