Geography

May 2013 Page 1 of 26

Year 10

Student Portfolio Summary

WORK SAMPLE PORTFOLIOS

The 2013 portfolios are a resource to support teachers in the planning and implementation of the Foundation to Year

10 Australian Curriculum: Geography. Each portfolio comprises a collection of student work illustrating evidence of

student learning in relation to the achievement standard.

Each work sample in the portfolio varies in terms of how much time was available to complete the task and/or the

degree of scaffolding provided by the teacher.

There is no pre-determined number of samples required in a portfolio nor are the work samples sequenced in any

particular order. Together as a portfolio, the samples provide evidence of all aspects of the achievement standard

unless otherwise specified.

As the Australian Curriculum is progressively implemented in schools, the portfolios will continue to be reviewed and

enhanced in relation to their comprehensiveness in coverage of the achievement standard and their representation of

the diversity of student work that can be used to highlight evidence of student learning.

THIS PORTFOLIO – Year 10 Geography

This portfolio comprises a number of work samples drawn from a range of assessment tasks, namely:

Sample 1 Report – Environmental change and management

Sample 2 Data response – Indicators of human wellbeing

Sample 3 Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

Sample 4 Practical exercise – International organisations and human wellbeing

This portfolio of student work shows that the student can explain how the interaction between geographical

processes change the characteristics of river and marine environments (WS1). The student predicts changes in these

characteristics over time, across space and at different scales, and explains the predicted consequences of change

(WS1). The student identifies significant interconnections between human wellbeing in a place and foreign aid (WS4),

and between people and environments. The student analyses and explains these interconnections, the changes

that result from them and the consequences of change (WS1). The student identifies and describes significant

associations between distribution patterns (WS2). The student evaluates alternative views on and strategies to

address a geographical challenge using environmental, social and economic criteria and proposes and justifies a

response (WS1).

Geography

May 2013 Page 2 of 26

Year 10

The student’s work shows an ability to use initial research to develop and modify geographically significant questions

to frame an inquiry (WS1, WS3). The student collects and critically evaluates a range of primary (WS1) and secondary

sources and selects relevant geographical data and information to answer inquiry questions (WS1, WS3). The

student accurately represents multi-variable data in a range of appropriate graphic forms (WS1, WS4), including

special purpose maps that use a suitable scale and comply with cartographic conventions (WS3). The student

evaluates data to make generalisations and inferences (WS3), and propose explanations for significant relationships

(WS2), trends (WS3) and anomalies (WS2, WS3).The student synthesises data and information to draw reasoned

conclusions (WS3), taking into account alternative points of view (WS1). The student presents findings, arguments

and explanations using relevant geographical terminology and graphic representations in a range of appropriate

communication forms (WS1, WS3, WS4). The student evaluates their findings and proposes action in response to a

contemporary geographical challenge taking account of environmental, economic and social considerations (WS1).

The student explains the predicted outcomes and consequences of their proposal (WS3).

The annotated samples in this portfolio provide evidence of most (but not necessarily all) aspects of the achievement

standard. The following aspects of the standard are not evident in this portfolio:

• propose explanations for distributions, patterns and spatial variations over time, across space and at different

scales

• evaluate data to predict outcomes.

Student Portfolio Summary

Geography

May 2013 Page 3 of 26

Year 10

Work sample 1

Report – Environmental change and management

Relevant part of the achievement standard

By the end of Year 10, students explain how the interaction between geographical processes at different scales change the characteristics of places. They predict changes in the characteristics of places and environments over time, across space and at different scales and explain the predicted consequences of change. Students identify, analyse and explain significant interconnections between people, places and environments and explain changes that result from these interconnections and their consequences. They propose explanations for distributions, patterns and spatial variations over time, across space and at different scales, and identify and describe significant associations between distribution patterns. They evaluate alternative views on a geographical challenge and alternative strategies to address this challenge using environmental, social and economic criteria and propose and justify a response.

Students use initial research to develop and modify geographically significant questions to frame an inquiry. They collect and critically evaluate a range of primary and secondary sources and select relevant geographical data and information to answer inquiry questions. Students accurately represent multi-variable data in a range of appropriate graphic forms, including special purpose maps that use a suitable scale and comply with cartographic conventions. They evaluate data to make generalisations and inferences, propose explanations for significant patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies, and predict outcomes. They synthesise data and information to draw reasoned conclusions, taking into account alternative points of view. Students present findings, arguments and explanations using relevant geographical terminology and graphic representations in a range of appropriate communication forms. They evaluate their findings and propose action in response to a contemporary geographical challenge taking account of environmental, economic and social considerations. They explain the predicted outcomes and consequences of their proposal.

Summary of task

Students were required to investigate change to a local environment and recommend an appropriate way to manage

the changed environment. The geographical inquiry took place over five weeks and students were asked to present

their findings as a written report.

May 2013 Page 4 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Defines the geographical process of erosion and explains how erosion and the destruction of riparian zones interact to increase the rate of erosion.

Uses a map that conforms to cartographic conventions to show the location of the study site.

Report – Environmental change and management

May 2013 Page 5 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Identifies an appropriate methodology to investigate the environmental change.

Uses a variety of primary sources (field observations, survey, interview) and secondary sources (land use maps, aerial photography) to gather information required for the investigation.

Report – Environmental change and management

May 2013 Page 6 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Uses a primary source to illustrate the extent of erosion at the study site.

Identifies the natural causes of change to the study site over time.

Communicates findings of the river profile as a graphic representation in the form of a cross section.

Identifies interconnections between people, places and environments and explains the impact of these interconnections.

Report – Environmental change and management

May 2013 Page 7 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Identifies the impact of erosion on environmental characteristics.

Explains how interconnections between people and places affect environmental characteristics.

Explains the connections between geographical phenomena within the one place and between places (the effect of erosion on both the Ross River and the Great Barrier Reef).

Predicts changes to the marine environment and the consequences of this change over time, at different scales and across space.

Report – Environmental change and management

May 2013 Page 8 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Identifies and explains two strategies to manage environmental change at the study site.

Uses a diagram to illustrate the strategy of riprap revetment.

Report – Environmental change and management

May 2013 Page 9 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Evaluates each management strategy by considering their social, economic and environmental impacts.

Report – Environmental change and management

May 2013 Page 10 of 26

Work sample 1

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations (Overview)The student presents findings and explanations using appropriate geographical terminology and graphic representations in a range of appropriate communication forms. The student posed a significant geographical question, ‘How should erosion in the river at Bicentennial Park be managed?’ and synthesised information from a range of primary and secondary sources to draw reasoned conclusions about how to manage environmental change.

Annotations

Makes a justified decision regarding the most appropriate strategy to manage change in the local environment.

Predicts outcomes of the proposal.

Considers the views of different groups of people when making decisions about management strategies.

Report – Environmental change and management

Geography

May 2013 Page 11 of 26

Year 10

Data response – Indicators of human wellbeing

Relevant part of the achievement standard

By the end of Year 10, students explain how the interaction between geographical processes at different scales change the characteristics of places. They predict changes in the characteristics of places and environments over time, across space and at different scales and explain the predicted consequences of change. Students identify, analyse and explain significant interconnections between people, places and environments and explain changes that result from these interconnections and their consequences. They propose explanations for distributions, patterns and spatial variations over time, across space and at different scales, and identify and describe significant associations between distribution patterns. They evaluate alternative views on a geographical challenge and alternative strategies to address this challenge using environmental, social and economic criteria and propose and justify a response.

Students use initial research to develop and modify geographically significant questions to frame an inquiry. They collect and critically evaluate a range of primary and secondary sources and select relevant geographical data and information to answer inquiry questions. Students accurately represent multi-variable data in a range of appropriate graphic forms, including special purpose maps that use a suitable scale and comply with cartographic conventions. They evaluate data to make generalisations and inferences, propose explanations for significant patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies, and predict outcomes. They synthesise data and information to draw reasoned conclusions, taking into account alternative points of view. Students present findings, arguments and explanations using relevant geographical terminology and graphic representations in a range of appropriate communication forms. They evaluate their findings and propose action in response to a contemporary geographical challenge taking account of environmental, economic and social considerations. They explain the predicted outcomes and consequences of their proposal.

Summary of task

Students were provided with a representation on the relationships between GDP per capita and indicators of human

wellbeing and were asked to analyse this data in order to answer the following:

1. Explain why GDP/capita is thought a suitable measure for comparing human wellbeing across countries.

2. Evaluate the reliability and usefulness of using GDP per capita as the only measure of human wellbeing.

3. For two of the indicators of wellbeing, explain the relationship with GDP/capita.

This task was completed under exam conditions in one 55 minute lesson. Students were given access to a computer

to record their answers.

Work sample 2

May 2013 Page 12 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Work sample 2

Data response – Indicators of human wellbeing

May 2013 Page 13 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Analyses data to identify associations between GDP/capita and aspects of human wellbeing.

Provides reasons why human wellbeing does not improve in some countries.

Proposes explanations for anomalies between the wealth of a country and other measures of human wellbeing.

Evaluates the reliability and usefulness of GDP/capita data for making inferences about aspects of human wellbeing.

Work sample 2

Data response – Indicators of human wellbeing

May 2013 Page 14 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Explains the relationship between GDP/capita and other measures of human wellbeing.

Work sample 2

Data response – Indicators of human wellbeing

Geography

May 2013 Page 15 of 26

Year 10

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

Relevant part of the achievement standard

By the end of Year 10, students explain how the interaction between geographical processes at different scales change the characteristics of places. They predict changes in the characteristics of places and environments over time, across space and at different scales and explain the predicted consequences of change. Students identify, analyse and explain significant interconnections between people, places and environments and explain changes that result from these interconnections and their consequences. They propose explanations for distributions, patterns and spatial variations over time, across space and at different scales, and identify and describe significant associations between distribution patterns. They evaluate alternative views on a geographical challenge and alternative strategies to address this challenge using environmental, social and economic criteria and propose and justify a response.

Students use initial research to develop and modify geographically significant questions to frame an inquiry. They collect and critically evaluate a range of primary and secondary sources and select relevant geographical data and information to answer inquiry questions. Students accurately represent multi-variable data in a range of appropriate graphic forms, including special purpose maps that use a suitable scale and comply with cartographic conventions. They evaluate data to make generalisations and inferences, propose explanations for significant patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies, and predict outcomes. They synthesise data and information to draw reasoned conclusions, taking into account alternative points of view. Students present findings, arguments and explanations using relevant geographical terminology and graphic representations in a range of appropriate communication forms. They evaluate their findings and propose action in response to a contemporary geographical challenge taking account of environmental, economic and social considerations. They explain the predicted outcomes and consequences of their proposal.

Summary of task

Students were introduced to the idea that, although the UN Human Development Index assesses human wellbeing

using 3 indicators of wellbeing, composite indicators are thought to give a more reliable measure of human wellbeing

in a country. Given this background, students were asked to frame an inquiry to determine and justify a composite

well-being index. They were provided with the following instructions:

• select a range of 10 social and economic indicators that could be used to measure human wellbeing in a country.

You should not choose composite indicators in this task

• outline each indicator and explain how it is a measure of human wellbeing

• draw up a table and collect the data for 10 countries, including Australia and India. You may use any number of

references; however, you must cite the source of all of your statistics

• evaluate the importance of each indicator in determining human wellbeing and decide on the weighting that each

indicator will be given in calculating the index

Work sample 3

Geography

May 2013 Page 16 of 26

Year 10

Work sample 3

• construct a wellbeing index, using your indicators and rank the 10 countries

• comment on the strengths and weaknesses of your index, including the reliability and bias of the data sources

• comment on how you could improve the index

• create a map to creatively and imaginatively display your wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 17 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Frames the inquiry by determining indicators of wellbeing.

Explains how each indicator is a measure of human wellbeing.

Explains the relevance of indicators as measures of human wellbeing.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 18 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Explains the relationship between indicators of human wellbeing (for example the effect of education on economic growth and the effect of physical wellbeing on development).

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 19 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Explains the connections between different indicators of human wellbeing.

Evaluates the relative importance of different indicators.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 20 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Collects relevant geographical data from secondary sources to answer the inquiry question.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 21 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

AnnotationsApplies a weighting to rank selected countries for each indicator of human wellbeing.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 22 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Synthesises data to rank selected countries in terms of their human wellbeing.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 23 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Evaluates the effectiveness of the index as a measure of human wellbeing.

Evaluates the reliability and usefulness of the data collected.

Makes generalisations about the cause and effect relationship between different measures of human wellbeing.

Proposes an explanation for anomalies in the data.

Suggests how the composite indicator of human wellbeing could be improved.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

May 2013 Page 24 of 26

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Geography Year 10

Annotations

Creates a special purpose map that complies with cartographic conventions to represent the spatial distribution of different levels of human wellbeing.

Work sample 3

Inquiry – Human wellbeing index

Annotations (Overview)The student synthesises data to draw reasoned conclusions and presents findings, arguments and explanations using relevant geographical terminology in a range of forms including text, maps and tables.

Geography

May 2013 Page 25 of 26

Year 10

Work sample 4

Practical exercise – International organisations and human wellbeing

Relevant part of the achievement standard

By the end of Year 10, students explain how the interaction between geographical processes at different scales change the characteristics of places. They predict changes in the characteristics of places and environments over time, across space and at different scales and explain the predicted consequences of change. Students identify, analyse and explain significant interconnections between people, places and environments and explain changes that result from these interconnections and their consequences. They propose explanations for distributions, patterns and spatial variations over time, across space and at different scales, and identify and describe significant associations between distribution patterns. They evaluate alternative views on a geographical challenge and alternative strategies to address this challenge using environmental, social and economic criteria and propose and justify a response.

Students use initial research to develop and modify geographically significant questions to frame an inquiry. They collect and critically evaluate a range of primary and secondary sources and select relevant geographical data and information to answer inquiry questions. Students accurately represent multi-variable data in a range of appropriate graphic forms, including special purpose maps that use a suitable scale and comply with cartographic conventions. They evaluate data to make generalisations and inferences, propose explanations for significant patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies, and predict outcomes. They synthesise data and information to draw reasoned conclusions, taking into account alternative points of view. Students present findings, arguments and explanations using relevant geographical terminology and graphic representations in a range of appropriate communication forms. They evaluate their findings and propose action in response to a contemporary geographical challenge taking account of environmental, economic and social considerations. They explain the predicted outcomes and consequences of their proposal.

Summary of task

As part of a unit on human wellbeing, students were asked to identify an international organisation that has

implemented strategies to reduce differences in global wellbeing in a specific country and explain the impact of this

strategy on indicators of human wellbeing.

Geography

May 2013 Page 26 of 26

Annotations

AcknowledgementACARA acknowledges the contribution of Australian teachers and students for providing the tasks and work samples. The annotations are referenced to the Australian Curriculum achievement standards.

Year 10

Annotations (Overview)The student has located, interpreted and represented data to show the impact of international organisations on reducing global inequalities in human wellbeing.

Work sample 4

Practical exercise – International organisations and human wellbeing