Economic Impacts of Lead Exposure and Remediation in Michigan

8/12/2019 Economic Impacts of Lead Exposure and Remediation in Michigan

1/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7

"#$%$&'# (&)*#+,!" $%&' ()*+,-.% &/' 0%1%'2&32+/

2/ 425627&/

-.%/0 1234 8 .%*+.3 *.%*&.%' 9: 36% ;/2


2/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8

85=/+AB%'7%1%/3,

-.#/+ +01 -/+0#2

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, #- ./*0 !1)#,23/ *$0 4/%/0&*+$ &$ 5&"6&7*$ 9&+ 9-122%. :; 3=4> /%+%&-45 =*%41&?1+2 &2 25% @.1A%-+12; !" 314516&. =45!!? !" B,:?14 C%&?25 /1+D=41%.4% E%.2%-F 3+F =91.:,-. 5&+ &. 3=4 1. (4!.!014 G%A%?!*0%.2 "-!0 25% $!.'!. =45!!? !"

(4!.!014+F

31)#2+ 314&1512,

=*%41&? 25&.D+ 2! !,- -%A1%9%-+ "!- 25%1- 4!.2-1:,21!.+ 2! 25% -%*!-2

3BC> (4!?!6; E%.2%-B&,? C&&.> C%&?25; C!0%+ E!&?121!. !" H%+2 314516&.B-!"F I.'-%9 3&;.&-'> @.1A%-+12; !" 314516&.B&0%?& JF 3&)+!.> B5FGF> @.1A%-+12; !" 314516&.G-F B5;??1+ GF 3%&'!9+> @.1A%-+12; !" 314516&./%:%44& 3%,.1.4D> 314516&. K%29!-D "!- E51?'-%.L+ (.A1-!.0%.2&? C%&?25B-!"F /145&-' K%12M%?> @.1A%-+12; !" 314516&. @.1A%-+12; !" 314516&.


3/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. O

>*+/,+.2/7 !.7&/2E&32+/,

-.#/+ +01 6)#$,#2&$7 827*$&9*+$,


4/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. V

F&9B% +" ?+/3%/3,"5/#.+'6/ 7.&&*89 :

;.

>-11&.:G&5=7.+-/'8/&B:,2,>-11&.: ?+,3, +" $%&' 89&3%1%/3H2,5-,,2+/

"%?%$+/, 1:

=/@/8/%#/, 1A


5/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. W

"#$%$&'# (&)*#+,+" $%&' ()*+,-.% &/' 0%1%'2&32+/2/ 425627&/

()%5-32-11&.:

84124&15 &+ 9%??F

:*";72#/$< 95145%)&01.%' 25% &..,&? %4!.!014 4!+2 !" ?%&'*!1+!.1.6> &+250&> 4&.4%-> &.''%A%?!*0%.2&? '1+&:1?121%+F 25%-% &-%!.6!1.6 %)*!+,-%+ 2! 51+2!-14 +!,-4%+ !"


6/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. ^

4!.2&01.&21!.> .&0%?; ?%&'P:&+%' *&1.2 1.!?'%- 5!0%+F

=#,+, #> ?1*< !@)#,/21

@+1.6 %+2&:?1+5%' 0%25!'+ &.' 0%2-14+> 251+

&++%++0%.2 &**?1%+ "!,- 9%??P'!4,0%.2%'4!+2+ !" 451?'-%.L+ ?%&' %)*!+,-% 1.314516&.S 1.4-%&+%' 5%&?25 4&-%> 1.4-%&+%'4-10%> 1.4-%&+%' +*%41&? %',4&21!.> &.''%4?1.% 1. ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+F 2!2&?%' !A%-\7b 01??1!. &..,&??;F H% :%?1%A% 25%+%%+210&2%+ &-% 4!.+%-A&21A% :%4&,+% 25%;"!4,+ !. c,+2 29! 0%2-14+ ]100%'1&2%2-%&20%.2 &.' IGCG 2-%&20%.2X 951?%16.!-1.6 !25%- 5%&?25 &.' '%A%?!*0%.2&?10*&42+ 25&2 0&; -%Q,1-% -%6,?&- &.'4!.21.,1.6 5%&?254&-% 4!+2+F I''121!.&??;>25% 91'%- 10*&42+ !. *-!',421A12; &.'+2-%++ !. "&01?; 0%0:%-+ &.' 4&-%2&D%-+9%-% .!2 4!.+1'%-%'F

=3&%/

I. %+210&2%' 7[d !" c,A%.1?% 4-10%+ 1.314516&. 9%-% &++!41&2%' 9125 ?%&'%)*!+,-%> 4!+21.6 &. %+210&2%' \O8 01??1!.&..,&??; 1. 1.4&-4%-&21!. &?!.% "!- ?%&'P&++!41&2%' c,A%.1?% 4-10%F R,-25%-0!-%>&',?2 4-10%+ 4&. :% ?1.D%' 2! 451?'5!!' ?%&'%)*!+,-%> &.' &**?;1.6 %+2&:?1+5%'+2&.'&-'+ 2! &',?2 4-10%+ 1. 314516&.> &.%+210&2%' \eO 01??1!. &..,&??; 4&. :%&22-1:,2%' 2! ?%&'P&++!41&2%' 4-10%+F 1.4&-4%-&21!.> &.' ?!+2 %&-.1.6+ 2! :!25 25%

4-101.&? &.' A14210F 4!+2+ &++!41&2%' 9125 *5;+14&? &.'0%.2&? 5%&?254&-%> &.' ?!+2 Q,&?12; !" ?1"%F_.4?,+1!. !" 25%+% 4!+2+ 9!,?' +,:+2&.21&??;1.4-%&+% 25% 2!2&? 4!+2+F

>)/"&*: !02"*+$

Y%4&,+% !" ?%&'P&++!41&2%' -%',421!. 1.4!6.121A% &:1?12;> &. %+210&2%' 8[d !"451?'-%. 9125 :?!!' ?%&' ?%A%?+ 0%&+,-%' &2!- &:!A% 8W a6T'$ &2 &6% 8 -%4%1A% +*%41&?%',4&21!.> "!- &. &A%-&6% !" f ;%&-+F ?1"%210%4!+2 "!- 25% 4!5!-2 !" 8P;%&-P!?'+ 1. 8[7[F &.'25% 4!+2+ &++!41&2%' 9125 451?'-%. 95!+%Y$$ *%&D+ ?&2%- 25&. 8 ;%&-+ !" &6%FI''121!.&??;> 251+ 4!.+%-A&21A% %+210&2% !.?;4!.+1'%-+ +*%41&? %',4&21!. 4!+2+ "!-451?'-%. 9125 Y$$+ !" 8Wh i6T'?> 95%.-%+%&-45 1.'14&2%+ 25&2 10*&42+ &2 ?!9%-?%A%?+ 0&; &?+! -%Q,1-% +*%41&? %',4&21!.&?+,**!-2F

?/"3/*,/0 .&-/+&%/ !*3$&$7,

(?%A&2%' :?!!' ?%&' ?%A%?+ &-% 4!--%?&2%'9125 1--%A%-+1:?% '%4?1.%+ 1. _`> 951454!--%+*!.' ]!. &A%-&6%X 2! -%',421!.+ 1.?1"%210% %&-.1.6+F @+1.6 %+2&:?1+5%'+2&.'&-'+> ?!++ !" ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+ 1.314516&. 9%-% %+210&2%' &2 !A%- \8[^01??1!. "!- 25% 8[7[ 4!5!-2 !" 8P;%&-P!?'+F


7/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. e

I''121!.&??;> :?!!' ?%&' ?%A%?+ ,.'%- Wa6T'$ 9%-% .!2 4!.+1'%-%' '%+*12%%A1'%.4% +,66%+21.6 10*&42+ !. _` &2 :?!!'?%&' ?%A%?+ :%29%%. 8PW a6T'$F

25% 4!+2+ !" ?%&' %)*!+,-% 2!2&?%' !A%-\OO[ 01??1!. &..,&??;> 1.4?,'1.6 \7VW01??1!. :!-. :; 2&)*&;%-+F

6/%%*2A #> "#,+, *,,#"&*+1< 5&+0 B1*< 1@)#,/21C DEFDC &$ GEEE,

=#,+, #> ?1*< -.*+1%1$+

_. ?1.% 9125 *,:?1+5%' -%+%&-45> 9%4!.+%-A&21A%?; &++,0% 25&2 e[d !" ?%&'%)*!+,-% 1+ &++!41&2%' 9125 ?%&' *&1.2 1.5!0%+F H% 1??,+2-&2% & +4%.&-1! 95%-%7[[>[[[ 0!+2 &2 -1+D 5!0%+ 1. 314516&. &-%?%&' &:&2%'> -%',41.6 25% ?%&' %)*!+,-%&.' &++!41&2%' 4!+2+ :; e[d ]95145 4-%&2%+4!+2 +&A1.6+ !" \8O[ 01??1!. &..,&??;XF H125&. &A%-&6% 4!+2 !" &:&2%0%.2 &2 \^>[[[ *%-,.12> 251+ &:&2%0%.2 +4%.&-1! 4!+2+ &.%+210&2%' \^[[ 01??1!.F

H&,"/,,$

-%+*%421A%?;F

_. & ?%&' *&1.2 &:&2%0%.2 +4%.&-1!> &.1.A%+20%.2 !" \^[[ 01??1!. &44-,%+ :%.%"12+!" \8O[ 01??1!. &..,&??;> *&;1.6 "!- 12+%?"&"2%- 25-%% ;%&-+ &.' 25%. &44-,1.6 4!+2+&A1.6+ "!- ;%&-+ 2! 4!0%F I"2%- O[ ;%&-+25% &A%-&6% .%2 -%2,-. *%- '!??&- +*%.2 !.&:&2%0%.2 1+ \7[FW[F


8/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. b

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

Q,&.21"1%'> &.' 9!,?' ?1D%?; &''+16.1"14&.2?; 2! 25% 4!+2+ %+210&2%' 5%-%F0!-% 1."!-0&21!. !. ,.2%+2%' 451?'-%.X>25% 4&?4,?&21!.+ 5%-% 4!,?' :% ,*'&2%' &.'10*-!A%'F


9/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. f

"#$%$&'# (&)*#+,+" $%&' ()*+,-.% &/' 0%1%'2&32+/

2/ 425627&/I-BB 0%*+.3

6/%%*2A

251+&.&?;+1+ +,66%+2+ 25&2 ?%&' &:&2%0%.2 *&;+"!- 12+%?" 1. OP^ ;%&-+ &.' *-!A1'%+ 0&.;",-25%- ;%&-+ !" *!+121A% -%2,-.+F I"2%- O[;%&-+ 25% &A%-&6% .%2 -%2,-. !. \7 1.A%+2%'1. &:&2%0%.2 1+ %+210&2%' &2 \7[FW[F 9125 4!.+1'%-&:?%*,:?14 5%&?25 :%.%"12+> &+ 9%??F


10/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7[

:*";72#/$ &.

%4!.!014 %+210&2% !" %.A1-!.0%.2&??;&22-1:,2&:?% 4!+2+ !" "!,- *%'1&2-144!.'121!.+ Z ?%&' *!1+!.1.6> &+250&>4&.4%-> &.' '%A%?!*0%.2&? '1+&:1?121%+F +,45 &+ 5&.' 2! 0!,25 &421A12;

&.' 4-&9?1.6 &.' *?&;1.6 !. 25% "?!!->451?'-%. 0&; 4!.+,0% *&1.2 451*+ !- 1.6%+2?%&' ',+2 ]*-!',4%' "-!0 '%2%-1!-&21.6+,-"&4%+ !- -%.!A&21!.+X 25-!,65 %A%-;'&;&421A121%+> +,45 &+ !*%.1.6 91.'!9+ 9125?%&'P*&1.2%' "-&0%+ ]$%A1./+ *: 8[[bXF

I',?2+ &-% 0,45 :%22%- &2 %)*%??1.6 ?%&']25-!,65 ,-1.% &.' "%4%+X 25&. 451?'-%.>95!+% :!'1%+ &:+!-: & ?&-6% *-!*!-21!. !"25% ?%&' 1.6%+2%'> +2!-1.6 12 1. 25%1- :!.%+Fl.4% +2!-%'> ?%&' 10*&42+ & 451?'L+ -&*1'?;'%A%?!*1.6 4%.2-&? .%-A!,+ +;+2%0F $%&'%)*!+,-% 1+ &++!41&2%' 9125 -%',4%'4!6.121A% ",.421!.> ?%&'1.6 2! -%',4%'&4&'%014 &451%A%0%.2 &.' ?!9%- _`F $%&'%)*!+,-% 1+ &?+! &++!41&2%' 9125 :%5&A1!-&?*-!:?%0+ &.' &66-%++1A% :%5&A1!-+>1.4?,'1.6 &22%.21!.P'%"1412T5;*%-&421A12;'1+!-'%- &.' '%?1.Q,%.2> 4-101.&?> !-&.21+!41&? :%5&A1!- ](BI 8[7O> k!,?' 8[[f>$&.*5%&- 8[[WXF -&25%- 25&. 25%

&A%-&6% ?%A%?> &?25!,65 25%-% 1+ &?+!%A1'%.4% 25&2 &A%-&6% ?%A%?+ 0&; :% &5%?*",? *-%'142!- "!- !?'%- 451?'-%.]$&.*5%&- 8[[WXX> &.' 25% 10*&42+ !" ?%&'!. 4!6.121A% '%A%?!*0%.2 &-% 1--%A%-+1:?%&.' *%-+1+2%.2 ](BI 8[7OXF I -%4%.2 +2,';1.'14&2%+ &. m1--%A%-+1:?% *&22%-. !".%,-!.&? ';+",.421!.n "!,.' 1. &',?2+ 25&29%-% %)*!+%' 2! ?%&' &+ 451?'-%. ]E%41? &2 &?8[77> *F V[OXF

I:&21.6 ?%&' 1. 4!.2&01.&2%' 5!0%+ ]!"2%.:; -%*&1-1.6 !- -%*?&41.6 91.'!9 &.' '!!-"-&0%+ !- %.4&*+,?&21.6T%.4?!+1.6 &-%&+ !"451**%' *&1.2X 6-%&2?; -%',4%+ 451?'-%.L+%)*!+,-% 2! ?%&' &.' 25% .%6&21A% 5%&?2510*&42+ &++!41&2%' 9125 ?%&' *!1+!.1.6 ]B 2&-6%21.6 25% -1652 5!0%+"!- &:&2%0%.2 1+ 45&??%.61.6 &.' 4&. &'' 2!25% !A%-&?? 4!+2 !" +,44%++",? &:&2%0%.2*-!6-&0+F

-$*BA,&,


11/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 77

+2&.'&-'+ &.' &**?; 25%0 1. & 314516&.P+*%41"14 &++%++0%.2> *-!',41.6 & !.%P;%&-]8[78X +.&*+5!2 1??,+2-&21!. !" 25%%+210&2%' 4!+2+ !" ?%&' %)*!+,-% &.' 25%4!0*&-&21A% 4!+2+ !" 01216&21.6 25&2%)*!+,-% 25-!,65 ?%&' &:&2%0%.2F

4!.+%-A&21A%&++,0*21!.+ &-% 0&'% 95%-%A%- *!++1:?%FR!- 1.+2&.4%> 9% &++,0%' 25&2 25%'%2-10%.2&? 10*&42+ !" ?%&' %)*!+,-% &-%!. 25% ?!9 +1'% !" 95&2 -%+%&-45 1.'14&2%+&.' 25&2 4!+2+ !" &:&2%0%.2 &-% !. 25% 5165+1'% !" '%0!.+2-&2%' 4!+2+F

_. 25% "!??!91.6 +%421!.> 9% %+210&2% ?%&'%)*!+,-% &0!.6 314516&. 451?'-%.> &+

0%&+,-%' :; :?!!' ?%&' ?%A%? ]Y$$X 2%+21.6F

H% 25%. 1'%.21"; "!,- 9%??P'!4,0%.2%'10*&42+ &.' 4!+2+ !" ?%&' %)*!+,-%S 7X1.4-%&+%' 5%&?25 4&-%> 8X 1.4-%&+%' 4-10%> OX1.4-%&+%' .%%' "!- +*%41&? %',4&21!.> &.' VX'%4?1.% 1. ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+F H% &**?; 25%+%

0%2-14+ 2! 25% &++,0%' ?%&' %)*!+,-% ?%A%?&0!.6 314516&. 451?'-%.> %+210&21.6 25%4!+2+ &++!41&2%' 9125 ?%&' %)*!+,-% 1. !.%;%&-F _. 25% "1.&? +%421!.> 9% 4!0*&-% 25%+%4!+2+ 2! 25% 4!+2 !" ?%&' &:&2%0%.2 &.''1+4,++ 25% %4!.!014 &.' *,:?14 5%&?2510*?14&21!.+ !" 25% -%+,?2+F

E51?'-%. ()*!+%' 2! $%&' 1. 314516&.


12/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 78

H% 45!+% 2! "!4,+ !. 25% 4!5!-2 !" 7 &.' 8P;%&- !?'+ "!- +%A%-&? -%&+!.+F (?%A&2%' Y$$+2%.' 2! *%&D &2 &-!,.' &6% 8 ]?1D%?; :%4&,+%!" 4-&9?1.6 &.' 5&.'P2!P0!,25 :%5&A1!-+2;*14&? &2 25&2 &6%X ]@=B= &.' *%&D?%A%?+ 2%.' 2! '-1A% 25% &++!41&2%' 5%&?2510*&42+ 25&2 91?? :% 4!.+1'%-%' 1. 251+&++%++0%.2F +%*&-&2%':; m95! +5!,?' :% 2%+2%'n &.' m!25%-n &-%*-!A1'%' 1. W a6T'$ 1+ 25%EGE m&421!. ?%A%?n "!- ?%&' %)*!+,-% 1.451?'-%. ](BI 8[7OXF R16,-% 7 1??,+2-&2%+ 25%:-%&D'!9. !" &?? 314516&. 7 &.' 8P;%&-!?'+> :; 2%+21.6 +2&2,+ &.' 95%25%-*-1!-121M%' &+ & 451?' m95! +5!,?' :% 2%+2%'n!- .!2F

I*.B1 FJ K&"0&7*$ :B##< ?1*< ?141B I1,+&$7 >#2 F *$< DLA1*2L#B"0&B)#)/B*+$

F *$< DLA1*2L#B8^W VFed VVW [F^Wd

8+012 F *$< DLA1*2L#Bb[b 7f>O8e 7eF[d O88 7F^d 8V [F78d

-BB F *$< DLA1*2L#B


13/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7O

25%

+&0*?% 0&; 4!.2&1. :#@/3 Y$$+25&. 1+ -%*-%+%.2&21A%XF

951?% !.?; 7F^d !" .!22&-6%2%' 451?'-%. 2%+2 &2 251+%?%A&2%' ?%A%?F 0&.;451?'-%. 0&; 5&A% 5&' !- 91?? 5&A%& 5165%- ?%A%? &2 +!0% *!1.2F 9% %+210&2%'-&2%+ !" %?%A&2%' Y$$+ "!- &??314516&. 7 &.' 8P;%&-P!?' 451?'-%.>0&D1.6 +%A%-&? 4!.+%-A&21A%&++,0*21!.+F

I0!.6 7 &.' 8P;%&-P!?'+> Wed !" 2&-6%2%'451?'-%. ]25!+% 25!,652 2! :% &2 5165 -1+D !"?%&' %)*!+,-%X 9%-% 2%+2%'> &.' 9% &++,0%25&2 25% -%0&1.1.6 VOd !" 2&-6%2%' 451?'-%.9!,?' 5&A% & +101?&- '1+2-1:,21!. !" 2%+2-%+,?2+F k1A%. 25&2 +! "%9 !" 25% m!25%-n 7&.' 8P;%&-P!?'+ 9%-% 2%+2%' ]7edX 9%&++,0% 4!.+%-A&21A%?; 25&2 !.?; 25!+%+&0*?%' 5&' %?%A&2%' Y$$+ &.' .!.% !" 25%-%0&1.1.6 bOd !" m!25%-n 451?'-%. 5&' &.%?%A&2%' Y$$F


14/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7V

H% &?+! '%-1A%' 25% 0!-% +*%41"14 Y$$ -&.6%%+210&2%+ 1. &+ 25%+% 91?? :%.%%'%' "!- 25% 10*&42 %+210&21!.+ 1."!??!91.6 +%421!.+F Y&+%' !. 25% *-!c%421!.+

1. 9% %+210&2%' 25&2 25% 2%+2%'%?%A&2%' Y$$+ -%*-%+%.2 Wfd !" 25% 2!2&?*!*,?&21!. !" %?%A&2%' Y$$+ "!- %&454&2%6!-; 1.


15/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7W

R!- 4&?4,?&21!.+ !" 8P;%&-P!?'+ !.?;> 9%&++,0% 25&2 25% %?%A&2%' Y$$+ 1. &.' !-&? &.'1.2-&A%.!,+ 45%?&21!. 1. %)2-%0% 4&+%+F &+ 25!+% ,.2%+2%' 9!,?',."!-2,.&2%?; .!2 :% -%4%1A1.6-%4!00%.'%' 2-%&20%.2F I?+!> 25%+%%+210&2%+ &-% &**?1%' 2! &?? 451?'-%. ,.'%-25% &6% !" ^ 2! -%"?%42 25% &42,&? 5%&?25 4&-%4!+2+ &++!41&2%' 9125 ?%&' %)*!+,-% &0!.6314516&. 451?'-%. 1. 8[78F Y%4&,+% .!%)2-&*!?&21!. 1+ 0&'% 2! ,.2%+2%' 451?'-%.>25% +&0*?% !" 451?'-%. ,.'%- ]-&25%- 25&.7 &.' 8 ;%&- !?'+ !.?;X 1+ ,+%'F

I*.B1 YJ d1*B+0"*21 "#,+, >#2 "0&B


16/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7^

I*.B1 PJ d1*B+0"*21 "#,+, #> B1*ef[ 7O8>WOV 8e>f^W \^VbFWV\7b>7O^>8Wf

A?


17/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7e

I*.B1 [J =#,+ #> -1$,1,21)#2+1 "2&%1,B&$;1< +#"0&B^fW 8Ffd e>[^7 V>^[7 \ O8>Vbe>[WV

/!::%-1%+ 7[>Oef [FVd V[ 8^>8V8 \ 7>[We>b^b

I66-&A&2%' I++&,?2+ 8b>VOe WF7d 7>VV8 8O>O^W \ OO>e[7>[bV

/&*% V>VOf OFed 7^V O8>^[V \ W>OW[>8bO

3,-'%- ^b7 8Ffd 8[ OW>^f^ \ ^fe>[Vb

I8I-? 8be>^O7 \ [XCDQXCXX[

_. &''121!. 2! c,A%.1?% '%?1.Q,%.4;> ?%&'%)*!+,-% &+ & 451?' 1+ ?1.D%' 2! 4-10% &+ &.&',?2F I**?;1.6 +2&.'&-'+ %+2&:?1+5%' :;k!,?' ]8[[fX> '-&91.6 "-!0 K%A1. ]8[[^X> '-&91.6 "-!0 =459&-2M]7ffVX %+210&2%+ 25&2 8[d !" 451?'-%. 9125:?!!' ?%&' ?%A%?+ !" 8W a6T'$ !- &:!A%-%Q,1-% +*%41&? %',4&21!. "!- &. &A%-&6% !"O ;%&-+F =&-:&,65P1. & G%2-!12P+*%41"14 &++%++0%.2> %+210&2%25&2 451?'-%. -%4%1A1.6 +*%41&? %',4&21!.:%4&,+% !" ?%&'P -%?&2%' -%',421!. 1.


18/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7b

I*.B1 ZJ =#,+, #> ,)1"&*B 1

ee 7b>87f \8>WOO>W8V

4!6.121A% &:1?12; -%4%1A% +*%41&? %',4&21!."!- :%29%%. f &.' 8[ ;%&-+> '%*%.'1.6 !.25% ?%A%? !" 4!6.121A% 10*&1-0%.2+F H%&++,0% f ;%&-+ !" +*%41&? %',4&21!. "!- 8[d!" 451?'-%. 0%&+,-%' &2 8W a6T'$ !- &:!A%&2 &6% 8> 95145 2!2&?+ &. %+210&2%' \8FW01??1!. 1. +*%41&? %',4&21!. 4!+2+F 1.4?,'1.6 ?!++ !" *&-%.2&? *-!',421A12; 1.4&-1.6 "!- & 451?' 9125 +*%41&? .%%'+ &.' 25%5%&?25 &.' +2-%++ 10*&42+ !. "&01?;

0%0:%-+F R,-25%-0!-%> 251+ &++,0%+ &*%&D Y$$ &2 &6% 8> &.' .! 4!+2+ &-% &++,0%'"!- 451?'-%. 95!+% Y$$ *%&D+ &2 & ?&2%- &6%F

?/"3/*,/0 .&-/+&%/ !*3$&$7,

$%&' 1+ &?+! &++!41&2%' 9125 -%',421!.+ 1. _`

&.' -%+,?21.6 -%',421!.+ 1. ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+]E&."1%?' %2 &? 8[[O> $&.*5%&- 8[[W> E&-?1+?%%2 &? 8[[fXS %?%A&2%' Y$$+ &-% 4!--%?&2%'9125 1--%A%-+1:?% '%4?1.%+ 1. _`> &.' -%',4%'_` ]!. &A%-&6%X ?%&'+ 2! -%',421!.+ 1.?1"%210% %&-.1.6+F


19/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 7f

VV7 1. .%2 *-%+%.2A&?,% ]KBgX !" ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+F

_. 2!2&?> 9% %+210&2% 25&2 0!-% 25&. \8[^01??1!. 1. KBg ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+ &-% ?!+2&0!.6 314516&. 8P;%&-P!?'+ 9125 %?%A&2%'Y$$+ 1. 8[78F H% 4!.+1'%- !.?; 8P;%&-P!?'+5%-% &+ &. &..,&? &++%++0%.2F E&-?1+?% %2 &? 8[[fX> &.' 251+ 4!,?' 10*&420&.; 0!-% 451?'-%.F

6/%%*2A

7O^>8Wf 7^>O88>^OO%+210&2%' f[d !" 451?'-%. 9125 %?%A&2%' Y$$ &-%!. 314516&. 0%'14&1' *-!6-&0+

($"21*,1, &$ ,)1"&*B 1


20/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8[

^&7/21 DJ 6/%%*2A #> "#,+, *,,#"&*+1< 5&+0 B1*< 1@)#,/21C DEFDC &$ GEEE,

=#,+, #> ?1*< -.*+1%1$+

Y; 4!0*&-1+!. 2! 25% 4!+2+ !" ?%&'%)*!+,-%> 9% %+210&2% 25% 4!+2+ !"%?101.&21.6 %)*!+,-%+ 2! ?%&' :; &:&21.6?%&' 1. 5!0%+F H% ,+% ?%&' &:&2%0%.25%-% 2! '%+4-1:% 95&2%A%- 2-%&20%.2+ &-%.%%'%' 1. & 5!0% 2! -%',4% !- %?101.&2%?%&' %)*!+,-%+F +,45 &+ %.4&*+,?&21!. !- %.4?!+,-% !" 25%*&1.2 1. &-%&+ 95%-% 12 1+ 451**1.6 !-*%%?1.6F

H% &++,0% 25&2 e[d !" %?%A&2%' Y$$+ &-%

&22-1:,2&:?% 2! ?%&' *&1.2 %)*!+,-% 1.5!0%+> 4!.+1+2%.2 9125 "1.'1.6+ 1. $%A1. %2&? ]8[[bXF &.' 95%-% ?%&' 1+%?101.&2%'> %A%. 6%.%-&21!.+ !" &A!1'%'

?%&' %)*!+,-%+ "!- 451?'-%.F

k!,?' ]8[[fX 4!0*&-%+ 25% :%.%"12+ !" ?%&'&:&2%0%.2 9125 25% 4!+2+ !" &:&21.6 5!0%+?1D%?; 2! :% &2 +16.1"14&.2 -1+D !" 5&A1.6 ?%&'*&1.2 5&M&-'+> &+ 1'%.21"1%' :; 25%B-%+1'%.2L+ &.' 9% &**?;

8b7 7b>7O^8>WOV

8[^>8OW

O7>f^f

eO>8fOC%&?25 4&-% P _00%'1&2% :?!!'?%&' 2-%&20%.2

C%&?25 E&-% P KBg

E-10% P J,A%.1?% 1.4&-4%-&j!.-%?&2%' 2! 451?'5!!' ?%&'

E-10% P I',?2 4-10%+ -%?&2%' 2!451?'5!!' ?%&'


21/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 87

& +101?&- 0%2-14 2! 314516&.F '%"1.%' &+*-%P7f [+ 5!0%+ 95!+% !44,*&.2+ ?1A%:%?!9 25% *!A%-2; ?%A%? ]=4!-%4&-' 8[7OXFl,- !9. 4&?4,?&21!.+ 1.'14&2% 7[[>[[[5!0%+ 1+ & -%&+!.&:?% *-!*!-21!. !" 25% 8FO01??1!. &2P-1+D 5!,+1.6 ,.12+ .&21!.&??;FI44!-'1.6 2! 25% 8[78 @= E%.+,+ I0%-14&.

E!00,.12; =,-A%;> 8fFWd !" 25% @=5!,+1.6 +2!4D> !- OV 01??1!. ,.12+> 9%-% :,1?2:%"!-% 7f^[> 951?% OeFVd !" 25% 314516&.5!,+1.6 +2!4D> !- 7FV 01??1!. ,.12+> 9%-%:,1?2 :%"!-% 7f^[ ]IE= 8[78XF [[[ 5165 ?%&' -1+D 5!0%+ 1. 314516&. 1+& +101?&- *-!*!-21!. ]VFOdX !" 25% .&21!.L+8FO 01??1!. 5165 ?%&' -1+D 5!0%+> +! 9%4!.+1'%- 7[[>[[[ 5!0%+ &+ 2&-6%2%' 1. !,-

+4%.&-1!F H% +%?%42%' *-%P7f^[+ 5!0%+ &+25% 4!0*&-&21A% 1.'14&2!- 5%-% :%4&,+%25%+% 5!0%+ &-% 25!+% 25!,652 2! :% 0!+2

&2 -1+D "!- ?%&' 5&M&-'> &?25!,65 ?%&' *&1.29&+ &A&1?&:?% ,.21? 25% 7fe[+ ]B-%+1'%.2L+

2&-6%21.6 7[[>[[[ 5!0%+ 1. 314516&. +%2+ &-%?&21A%?; 91'% 0&-61. 4!0*&-%' 2! 25%%+210&2%' e>[[[ 7 &.' 8P;%&-P!?'+ 9125%?%A&2%' Y$$+ ]


22/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 88

I++,01.6 25% &A%-&6% 4!+2 !" ?%&'&:&2%0%.2 1+ \^>[[[ *%- ,.12> 25% 4!+2 2!&:&2% &?? 7[[>[[[ 5165P-1+D 5!0%+ 1.314516&. 1+ &. %+210&2%' \^[[ 01??1!.F H%:%?1%A% &. &A%-&6% !" \^>[[[ *%- 5!0%&:&2%' 9!,?' :% & 5165 %+210&2%F Y;4!0*&-1+!.> 25% 7V[P7W[ 5!0%+ &:&2%' 251+;%&- 1. 314516&. :; 25% G%*&-20%.2 !"E!00,.12; C%&?25 &-% %)*%42%' 2! :%&:&2%' &2 &. &A%-&6% 4!+2 !" \b>V[[ %&45FH% %)*%42 25%+% 9!,?' :% &0!.6 25% 7W[0!+2P1.P.%%' 5!0%+> &+ 4!0*&-%' 2! &0,45 91'%- .%2 1. 251+ +4%.&-1! !" 25%7[[>[[[ 0!+2P1.P.%%' 5!0%+F 8^

_. 25% 1??,+2-&21A% +4%.&-1!> 25% ?%&'

&:&2%0%.2 !" 7[[>[[[ 5!0%+ -%',4%+ ?%&'%)*!+,-% :; e[d> -%',41.6 25% &..,&? 4!+2+!" ?%&' %)*!+,-% "-!0 !A%- \O[[ 01??1!. 2!\e[ 01??1!. ]& 4!+2 +&A1.6+ !" \8O[ 01??1!.&..,&??;XF %&45 '!??&- 1.A%+2%' 1.&:&2%0%.2 9!,?' -%2,-. &:!,2 \8Fb[ 1. .%24!+2 +&A1.6+ !A%- 2%. ;%&-+> \^F^[ &"2%- 8[;%&-+> &.' \7[FW[ &"2%- O[ ;%&-+F &+ 9%?? &+ 25% 2&-6%21.6 &.' 25%.,0:%- !" 451?'-%. 25&2 &A!1' ?%&'%)*!+,-%F

R-!0 & +2-142?; 2&)*&;%- *%-+*%421A%> 25%:-%&DP%A%. *!1.2 9!,?' 2&D% ?!.6%-> &+ 25%2&)*&;%- *-!*!-21!. !" ?%&'P&++!41&2%'4!+2+ 1+ c,+2 ,.'%- 5&?" !" 25% 2!2&?> \7VW01??1!. &..,&??;F I6&1.> 9% &++,0% 1. 25%7[[>[[[ 5!0% ?%&' &:&2%0%.2 +4%.&-1!25&2 e[d !" %)*!+,-%+> &.' e[d !" 25% \7VW01??1!. &..,&? 4!+2+ &-% %?101.&2%'> 95145%Q,&?+ 2&)*&;%- +&A1.6+ !" c,+2 !A%- \7[[01??1!. &..,&??;F I"2%- ^ ;%&-+> \^[[ 01??1!.1. &:&2%0%.2 4!+2+ 9!,?' *&; "!-25%0+%?A%+> &.' 2&)*&;%- +&A1.6+ 9!,?'25%. &44-,% !. 25% !-'%- !" \7[[ 01??1!.&..,&??;F R-!0 25% 2&)*&;%- *%-+*%421A%>%&45 '!??&- 1.A%+2%' 1. &:&2%0%.2 9!,?'-%2,-. & .%2 :%.%"12 !" \[F^e &"2%- 2%. ;%&-+>

\8FO[ &"2%- 8[ ;%&-+> &.' \V &"2%- O[ ;%&-+F

&+ 25% &42,&?2101.6 !" &:&2%0%.2 9!,?' 1."?,%.4% 95%.4!+2+ +&A1.6+ 9!,?' &44-,%F C!9%A%-> 9125Q,12% 4!.+%-A&21A% &++,0*21!.+> 25% !.%P;%&- +.&*+5!2 1??,+2-&21!. +,66%+2+ 25&2&:&2%0%.2 1+ & 9!-25951?% 1.A%+20%.2%4!.!014&??;> 1. &''121!. 2! 25% *,:?145%&?25 :%.%"12+ "!- "&01?1%+ 95!+% ?%&'%)*!+,-% 1+ *-%A%.2%'F


23/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8O

H&,"/,,$

4-10% &.' ?!+2 %&-.1.6+&++!41&2%' 9125 ?%&' %)*!+,-%> 9% -%?1%' !.%+2&:?1+5%'> *,:?1+5%' 0%2-14+ ]?&-6%?; "-!0.&21!.&? +2,'1%+X &.' &**?1%' 25%0 2!314516&.F I .,0:%- !" &++,0*21!.+ 9%-%

0&'% &:!,2 %)*!+,-% ?%A%?+ 1. 314516&.>4!+2+ !" 5%&?254&-% &.' %',4&21!.> &.' ?%&'&:&2%0%.2 4!+2+ &.' 2&-6%21.6F

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

-%+*%421A%?;F(A%. 9125 4!.+%-A&21A% &++,0*21!.+ 251+&++%++0%.2 1.'14&2%+ 25&2 ?%&' &:&2%0%.29!,?' :% & 9!-25951?% %4!.!014

1.A%+20%.2F H% %+210&2%' 25&2 &?? 7[[>[[[!" 314516&.L+ 0!+2 &2P-1+D 5!0%+ 4!,?' :%&:&2%' "!- \^[[ 01??1!.> &. 1.A%+20%.2 25&29!,?' *&; "!- 12+%?" &"2%- O ;%&-+ &.' 25%.&44-,% :%.%"12+ !" \8O[ 01??1!. &..,&??;FR-!0 & +2-142?; 2&)*&;%- *%-+*%421A%> & \^[[01??1!. 1.A%+20%.2 1. &:&2%0%.2 9!,?' *&;"!- 12+%?" 1. ^ ;%&-+ &.' 25%. &44-,%2&)*&;%- +&A1.6+ !" \7[[ 01??1!. &..,&??;>"!- 0&.; ;%&-+ 2! 4!0%F

I \^[[ 01??1!. 1.A%+20%.2 1. &:&2%0%.2 &2!.% 210% 1+ %)2-%0%?; ,.?1D%?;F Y,2 9%:%?1%A% 251+ 1+ & 5%?*",? 1??,+2-&21A% +4%.&-1!>+5!91.6 25% -%2,-. !. 1.A%+20%.2 "-!0

?%&' &:&2%0%.2> &.' &?+! &??!91.6 &.%+210&2% !" &A%-&6% -%2,-. !. 1.A%+20%.2*%- '!??&- !" &:&2%0%.2F I"2%- O[ ;%&-+> 25%.%2 -%2,-. !. \7 !" &:&2%0%.2 9!,?' :% &.&A%-&6% !" \7[FW[F I.' 25% :%.%"12+ 4!,?'&44-,% "!- ?!.6%-F I?+!> 1" & .%2 -%2,-. !"\7[FW[ 9!,?' :% 25% &A%-&6% -%2,-. &4-!++&?? 7[[>[[[ 5!0%+ &:&2%'> 9125 Q,&?12;2&-6%21.6 !" ?%&' &:&2%0%.2> 12 +%%0+ ?1D%?;25&2 & "1-+2 6-!,*1.6 !" ?%&' &:&2%' 5!0%+01652 :% &0!.6 25!+% 0!+2 1. .%%'>

'%?1A%-1.6 & '1+*-!*!-21!.&2%?; *!+121A%:%.%"12F _2 +%%0+ -%&+!.&:?% 25&2 1.A%+21.61. ?%&' &:&2%0%.2 1. &-%&+ 9125 25% 5165%+2?%A%?+ !" ?%&' *!1+!.1.6 ]5165%+2 Y$$+ :; M1*4!'% &-% 1'%.21"1%' :; 3GEC ]8[7OXX 9!,?';1%?' :%.%"12+ %A%. 6-%&2%- 25&. 25% &A%-&6%\7[FW[ *%- '!??&- %+210&2%'F


24/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8V


25/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8W

(/'/+3%,

7F G%&-:!-.> G%2-!12> R?1.2> k-&.' /&*1'+>C&02-&04D> C165?&.' B&-D> J&4D+!.> o&?&0&M!!> $&.+1.6> 3,+D%6!.T3,+D%6!. C%1652+> B!.21&4 &.'=&61.&9F8F G&2& "-!0 3GEC ]8[7OXFOF G&2& "-!0 3GEC ]8[7OXFVF =!,-4%S k!,?' ]8[[fX> '%-1A%' "-!0 EGE -%4!00%.'&21!.+ &.' o%0*%- %2 &? ]7ffbXFWF =!,-4%S k!,?' ]8[[fX> 1."?&2%' 5%-% 2! 8[78 @=GF^F Y%4&,+% 25% 3GEC '&2& 4&2%6!-; 1+ VW a6T'$ !- 6-%&2%-> 9% 4!.+%-A&21A%?; %+210&2% 25&2 &?? 314516&.451?'-%. 1. 251+ 4&2%6!-; "&?? 91251. 25% VWPe[ -&.6%> &.' .! 451?'-%. &-% 91251. 25% eWh -&.6%FeF G&2& "-!0 3G 1."?&2%' 2! 8[78 A&?,%+F8[F R!- 25% WP7[ a6T'$ 4&2%6!-; &.' 25% O[h a6T'$ 4&2%6!-;> 9% 0&D% 25% 4!.+%-A&21A% &++,0*21!.+ 25&2451?'-%. 5&A% 25% "?!!- ?%A%?+ !" 0%&+,-%' :?!!' ?%&' ]W a6T'$ &.' O[ a6T'$> -%+*%421A%?;XF R!- 25% 7[P8[&.' 8[PO[ 4&2%6!-1%+> 451?'-%. &-% &++,0%' 2! 5&A% &. %A%. '1+2-1:,21!. !" :?!!' ?%&' ?%A%?+ &4-!++ 25%4&2%6!-;F87F =%% %.'.!2% b &:!A%F88F 9125 25% 4!.+%-A&21A% &++,0*21!. 25&2 &?? 451?'-%. 1. 25% WP7[ a6T'$6-!,* 2%+2%' &2 W a6T'$F8OF $1"%210% %&-.1.6+ ?!++ *%- 451?' 1+ 4&?4,?&2%' &+ 25% %+210&2%' '%4?1.% 1. _` *!1.2+ 210%+ 25% &++,0%'\8[>VV7 ?!++ 1. ?1"%210% %&-.1.6+ *%- _` *!1.2 ?!++ 1. .%2 *-%+%.2 A&?,% ]KBgX> '%-1A%' "-!0 k!,?' ]8[[fXF8VF


26/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8^

0%"%.%/5%,

I0%-14&. E!00,.12; =,-A%; ]IE=X ]8[78XF @F=F E%.+,+ Y,-%&,F B5;+14&? C!,+1.6 E5&-&42%-1+214+ "!-l44,*1%' C!,+1.6 @.12+F E!5%. /I> R-%%0&. kF ]8[7[XF =,00&-; 5%&?25 +2&21+214+ "!- @F=F 451?'-%.S K&21!.&? C%&?25_.2%-A1%9 =,-A%;F K&21!.&? E%.2%- "!- C%&?25 =2&21+214+F g12&? C%&?25 =2&2 7[]8W[X ]8[77XF IA&1?&:?% &2522*STT999F4'4F6!AT.45+T'&2&T+%-1%+T+-t7[T+-7[t8W[F*'" F I44%++%' !. O[ l42 8[7OF

Y-&,. J3> o&5. /=> R-%!5?14D I,1.6%- B> $&.*5%&- YB ]8[[^XF ()*!+,-%+ 2! (.A1-!.0%.2&? C%.'%-+!. E/ J-> E!-;P=?%452& GI>/+ *: ]8[[OXF _.2%??%42,&? 10*&1-0%.2 1. 451?'-%. 9125 :?!!'?%&' 4!.4%.2-&21!.+ :%?!9 7[ 014-!6 *%- '%41?12%-FB/@ !$7:*$0 C#23$*: #- 5/0&"&$/D OVb]7^XS7W7eP8^F

E&-?1+?% JE> G!9?1.6 oE> =1%6%? G3> I?%)%%"" kg ]8[[fXF I :?!!' ?%&' :%.450&-D "!- &++%++1.6 -1+D+ "-!0451?'5!!' ?%&' %)*!+,-%F C#23$*: #- !$E&3#$%/$+*: >"&/$"/ *$0 G1%2-145 oK> I?2&;% 3> %2 &? ]8[77XF B-!2!. 3&6.%214 /%+!.&.4% =*%42-!+4!*; 1. I',?2+ 9125E51?'5!!' $%&' ()*!+,-%F (.A1-!.0%.2&? C%&?25 B%-+*%421A%+F 77f]OXSV[OPV[bF

E%.2%-+ "!- G1+%&+% E!.2-!? ]EGEX ]8[[eXF _.2%-*-%21.6 &.' 3&.&61.6 Y?!!' $%&' $%A%?+ u7[ ,6T'$ 1.E51?'-%. &.' /%',41.6 E51?'5!!' ()*!+,-%+ 2! $%&'F /%4!00%.'&21!. !" EGEL+ I'A1+!-; E!00122%% !.E51?'5!!' $%&' B!1+!.1.6 B-%A%.21!.F IA&1?&:?% &2S522*STT999F4'4F6!AT009-T*-%A1%9T009-520?T--W^[b&7F520 F I44%++%' !.S J&. b> 8[7VF

k!,?' ( ]8[[fX mE51?'5!!' $%&' B!1+!.1.6S E!.+%-A&21A% (+210&2%+ !" 25% $%&' C&M&-' E!.2-!?FnB&-2.%-+51* "!- I0%-14&L+ (4!.!014 =,44%++F _++,% B&*%- v77F

o%0*%- I/> Y!-'?%; HE> &.' G!9.+ =3 ]7ffbXF mE!+2P(""%421A%.%++ I.&?;+1+ !" $%&' B!1+!.1.6 =4-%%.1.6=2-&2%61%+ R!??!91.6 25% 7ffe k,1'%?1.%+ !" 25% E%.2%- "!- G1+%&+% E!.2-!? &.' B-%A%.21!.Fn A3"6&E/, #-9/0&*+3&" A0#/,"/$+ 5/0&"&$/F 7W8S78[8P[bF

J&4!:+ G(> E?14D.%- /B> N5!, Jw %2 &? ]8[[8XF m


27/28

!"#$#%&" (%)*"+, !" $%&' ()*!+,-% &.' /%0%'1&21!. 1. 314516&. 8e

$&.'-16&. BJ> =45%452%- EY> $1*2!. J3> R&5+ 3E> =459&-2M J ]8[[8XF (.A1-!.0%.2&? B!??,2&.2+ &.' G1+%&+%1. I0%-14&. E51?'-%.S (+210&2%+ !" 3!-:1'12;> 3!-2&?12;> &.' E!+2+ "!- $%&' B!1+!.1.6> I+250&> E&.4%->&.' G%A%?!*0%.2&? G1+&:1?121%+F!$E&3#$ =45!4D 3/> B&'1??& I> =1.D+ < ]8[[bXFm$%&' ()*!+,-% 1. @= E51?'-%.> 8[[bS _0*?14&21!.+ "!- B-%A%.21!.Fn!$E&3#$%/$+*: V^78>eP7O8P8fV8tVf77tVf7OPPP>[[F520?F I44%++%' !. W K!A 8[7OF

314516&. G%*&-20%.2 !" E!00,.12; C%&?25 ]3GECX> C%&?25; C!0%+ &.' $%&' B!1+!.1.6 B-%A%.21!.B-!6-&0 ]8[78XF 8[77 G&2& /%*!-2 !. Y?!!' $%&' &.' @.9%'B-%6.&.4;Fn!$E&3#$%/$+*: 4/,/*3"6 bOS7P88F

B145%-; EF> Y%??&.6%- 3F> N01-!,PK&A1%- GF> k?!-%..%4 BF> C&-2%0&.. BF> k-&.'c%&. BF ]8[77XF E51?'5!!'?%&' %)*!+,-% 1. R-&.4%S :%.%"12 %+210&21!. &.' *&-21&? 4!+2P:%.%"12 &.&?;+1+ !" ?%&' 5&M&-' 4!.2-!?F!$E&3#$%/$+*: J,.% 8[[bF

=459&-2M ]7ffVX m=!41%2&? Y%.%"12+ !" /%',41.6 $%&' ()*!+,-%Fn!$E&3#$%/$+*: 4/,/*3"6 ^^S7[WP78VF


28/28

=14D0,.'> 3F> =?&'D;> o&.6> HF> &.' B,MM&.45%-&> EF ]8[7OX m(&+; I44%++ 2! 25% E%.+,+ !" J,A%.1?%+ 1./%+1'%.21&? B?&4%0%.2Fn l.?1.%F IA&1?&:?% &2S 522*STT999F!cc'*F6!AT!c+2&2::T%M&4c-*T

=4!-%4&-' Z 8[7[Fn g12&? &.' C%&?25 =2&21+214+ 7[S8W[> G%4 8[77F IA&1?&:?% &2S522*STT999F4'4F6!AT.45+T'&2&T+%-1%+T+-t7[T+-7[t8W[F*'" F I44%++%' !. K!AF 7> 8[78

@F=F (.A1-!.0%.2&? B-!2%421!. I6%.4; ](BIX ]8[7OXF mI0%-14&L+ E51?'-%. &.' 25% (.A1-!.0%.2> 8[7VF

N5&.6> KF> Y&D%- CF> 8[[bP8[7[F

/%*!-2 G%+16. :;S

Economic Impacts of Lead Exposure and Remediation in Michigan

Documents

Transcript of Economic Impacts of Lead Exposure and Remediation in Michigan