Dunn, Michael Discovery_R

8/13/2019 Dunn, Michael Discovery_R

1/156

(as Number 20406772

a sction casingsRun 31-Jan1 .85117 nsd

1511 nsd758 nsd

C5F1PO nsd35138 nsdTH1 nsd

135317 nsd153 nsd51338 nsd1533 nsd

WA nsdPOX nsd185 nsdAME nsd

5818 nsdFGA nsd

Sal

Run

85117151758C5F1PO

3138

TH113531713513381533

A

Dte: 02/11/1


2/156

·

\I nil:F# -

FDLE Cae # o \d o l T - �

J a


3/156

1

3

a

o of fo

oo o

SAP PPAATION OST

Iitials

.;;7

DNA IQ™ SIS F TOD NNDFNTIA Date nayst: rea: leane K

Vol.Sample D I Description ase # I oents (L)

lsw22467Ex lsw22467RBQlsw22468_Exlsw22468_Exlsw22468Exlsw2468_Ex6lsw2468_Ex7lsw468_Ex8lsw2468_RBQ

Place the sape cutting into a sterile etraction tbe

A 100 DA IQ™ ysis ufer ith Dto the sample tbe.

orte an biey centrifuge to force the cutting into the bufer

FTA Crds

Saple I D I Decription ase # I oents

ls0100604 1

ls0100604 RQ

lsw44779Ex lsw2 44779_Ex2lsw2 44779_RBQ

™ Lysis Bufer with OTT ot: ·;

Temperaur

Sta Tim

/ Incubate in a y heat block at 9° for approiately 30 inutes. Stop Tim4b ; (

General Temperatur

.. St Tim Incubate in a y heat block at 70° for approiately 30 inutes to overnight Stop TmAllo the saple to reach roo temperature an briefly entrifuge to reove any conensation fro the cap

6 Optional: Transfer the substrate ino a spn basket. Centfuge at maxiu speed for Reove he base fro he exract ube and rean he substrate \Optonal Concenraon Wash

Date nayst rea eaeicrco Lot A IQ™ Lysis uer it O Lt:

Iommets

, · : r

\


4/156

- · -

- · - -

Sa I scrn

ls2204067 3

2 lsw2020406772_RB

lsw2012040680114 lsw201204068012

5 sw20120406801_

6 �w20120406801 6

7 lsw201204068017

8 lsw20120406801 8

9 lsw20120406801 RB

lsw2020005 Ex1

lsw20120005 RBQ

2 sw20110404779_91

3 lsw2011 040477992

4 ls20110404779 RB

5 lsw2009040138423

lsw20090401384_RBK37 lsw20120406646

1 lsw2012040664_RBK9 lsw20120406801_32

2

22

23

2

25

26

27

28

29

3

3

lsw20120406801_RBK-A

lsw20120406801 4lsw20120406801_RBK

. ·lsw201204005

lsw20120005 BK. ·W2012040677111

lsw20120406771RBKlsw20120404249lsw20120404249 RBK

sw2012040678_1

lsw2012040678 _RBK

lsw212008 1

-

Florida Depment of Lw EnforceentBology Secto

xc a: 30Jan13 Pla m

se # ens KQ

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

K

K

K

KK

K

K

K

K

K

K

K

K

K

K

K

Sal srton

1 edmh 20120407111 3

2 edmh_20120407111 4

3 edmh_20120407111

5

5

5

5

5

5

5

5

55

64

65

RBQ edmh201204071131

5 edmh_20120407113_2

edmh_20120407113RBQ

7 edmh20120402713_4

8 edmh_20120402713RBQ2

9 edmh_20130400029 1

edmh20130400029_2

edmh 20130400029 3

2 edmh201304000294

3 edmh20130400029 RBQ

edmh20120407111 A

5 edmh20120407111_RBQTA

edmh_20120407111 6

7 edmh20120407111RBK

8 edmh201204071133 edmh20120407113_4

0 edmh_20120407113

1 edmh 20120407113 RBK

sw20130400493 23 lsw20130400493 RBQ

empy1

jtm20120404427 2 mn2

jtm20120404427 RBQ mn2

7

68

70

71

se # ens

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

Q

K

K

K

K

KK

KKQ

Q

ple only Q

ple only Q


5/156

r rtnt nrnt tnI® Smple Run Workshefor DNA IQ ™ Pexo ®

DNA ™ Lot#:

End Coumn

00000648

Buer OTT o# W Bu t#:

Exp Date Elution Vo 60

-158

158

B3K Pate Nae J

Sample Pat was cenfuged prior o mov o seang im

DNA Date Run J me un

A

B

c

D

E

F O«4779_Ex6 RQ

Ex Ex2.

H xB RK-

peraor- DNA obo# 00

edmh 201 J407111

5l Rk 1 5m Rk 2Comens 89le ly, be e by epty

.m Rk 3

exo ® o 000004 Exp ate: 0//0E o#

oeon o deck eied by:

perator uan

nstrumen#

0010 11 12

5 Rk 4

N Stdrd Lo# 0000044oa Exraced Sampe 6

66 .5l Tubes for Trsfer Mehod Verifed by

1


6/156

CLE oi p o L oioog oBiomek® Amplfcaton Worshetlx ® suls

Auosomal ( M )

yeSlop

s- {3 3 to 0 Y ·.0 o �.6)yes 232 Y-lntecp Y-2426) sye sye Cvaue d 10ng ys

ye 20 t 21 2 o 22} yes ae d 1 (00g) sye - (28 o 29} Y 29 0 esyes IP Veried

yes OerPC C Gouedflr 7981°C V Y 81-BC:yes PC M uM (79 1°

*PG ou /,. ·-

ra

Me T ou of / . raQuat P Name HY AR30an 13 7500A RFQa evao EDH

Commts d G 11 d

. ..... . �Rurc W : . 1..

1

1E1.. F1 1H122

02, A5 bk fglx Y suls

Quaniam Na/ a

(/J)

lsw20100672 Ex3 sw201006772 RBQ 6lsw201006801 E1 17800

lsw201006801 Ex0.000

lsw201006801 Ex 00053lsw201006801 Ex6 00170sw201006801 Ex? 0.0055lsw201006801 Ex8 00259lsw201006801 BQ lsw20 100605 Ex1 00966sw20100605 BQ 0.0039

Y Quan(/�

.1050000390460.0820033

[Au]/M

1.70

1030750

15.013801902001.20

#o

2356789

101

+ K Lo #Exp ae:

hera Cyce

97 #Cabrao dae

E" ac #

j ls edmh

Da 30Jan13K Pa Nm 30 n3

109050

04 Oct 2013

115 1

51 Nber o apes o be ped 65


7/156

. 0 -

4C444F4G4H4

A5B5C5

5 · · 5 F5 G5

: . .

. . .

H5A66C666

F6G6H6A7B7C777F7

G7

H7 ACDFGHA9

9C999F9

G9H9

A10

x Y sus

ls01006771 R ls202004249 x5 53300ls0100449 R l0100657 x 75000ls01006578 R ls012006998 x 101000ls01006998 R ls01007000 x1 95000ls01007000 RB ls202006771 x1sp 60300

ls200406771 124000ls01006771 ls201006771 edmh 012007111 00385edmh 01040711 0.0660edmh 2012040711 3 0.0108edmh 0040711 4 00846edmh 0120407111 RBQ edmh 2012040713 1 0.0135edmh 00407113 2 00043

edmh 01040713 RBQ' edmh 202040713 4 03300edmh 01040273 RBQ2 edmh 2030400029 1 28900edmh 0130400029 2 0.4370edmh 13040009 3 0.007edmh 13040009 4 05830edmh 13040009 RBQ edmh 12040711 5 FTA 0160edmh 01047111 RQ FTA 00073

edmh 210407111 6 9700edmh 1040711 RB edmh 40713 3 3100edmh 21040713 4 05540edmh 1040713 5 46300edmh 2120407113 RB ls201340093 x 5ls2013400493 RQ

N/A2 mn 00170

RQ mn

1.9500464006.0900

0104000051001100055005035

0.603.09000485000095076600024100078

21500#N/A

00124

70160100

199075057000170

4810850

1300900900080480090

140

N/140

6272829

3031

32

33

3435

33738

39

40

4

4

43

4445

46 47

48

4950

515253

54

55

565758

56061626364

65

6667686970

71

7273

C4 ls004449 x5 533004 ls01040449 R ls00406578 x1 75000F4 ls00406578 R G4 ls00406998 x1 101000H4 ls0120406998 RB 5 ls0120407000 RB C5 ls0040677 603005 ls01040677 40005 ls010406771

F5 ls0040677 G5 edmh 012040711 1 0.0385H5 edmh 01040711 2 006606 edmh 01040711 3 0.0108B6 edmh 20120407111 4 00846C6 edmh 0040711 RQ 6 edmh 201204073 1 001356 edmh 0120407113 00043F6 edmh 2010407113 RBQ G6 edmh 20104073 03300

H6 edmh 01040713 RQ A7 edmh 203040009 1 8900B7 edmh 013040009 04370C7 edmh 03040009 3 00077 edmh 2013040009 4 058307 edmh 013040009 RQ F7 edmh 2010407111 5 FA 01160G7 h 010407111 00073H7 edmh 0120407111 6 9700A edmh 010407111 R

B edmh 0120407113 3 300C edmh 010407113 4 05540D edmh 2010407113 5 4.6300 edmh 2010407113 R F ls0130400493 5G ls0130400493 RQ

12 APC R30Jan3 0.510B12 NC R30Jan13

A9 2 mn2 00170

9 RQ mn2


8/156

- -

10l lnut + Master Mix= 25 ms(ID+- f o p NA) ttg l ttal n

m m m 65malzatn End Clun 9

0 is used if volume s between2.0I and 19I00 s use f volume s over 110I

Vrfy tht TE vu d nt d 11QI 3JI

Anyt) ls edmh Dt: 30-Jan13

83K Plt R30Jan13

TE 0

0

4

0

00

0

0

0

0

1.0

0

0

00

0

6.4

10

7

0

5.5

0

88

0

89

0


9/156

- - - -- -

·

X

1.0

010

0

0

0

0

0

10

10

39

0

0

0

0

1.0

0

40

0

3.1

0

62

0

0

00

0

0

0


10/156

Ext Pit

1P1P1

11111111

11111111P1

111P11111

111P11111P1

11P111P1

Source

Wel

A11C1

1E1F1G1H12C2

2F2G2H2A3

3C3

33

F3G3HA 4

4C44E 4

F 4 G4H 4

5C555F5

G5

H5A66C66E6

- ·

-

Sample Nae

lsw201 20406772x3lsw201 2040672_RBQlsw201 20406801 _Ex1

lsw201 20406801 _Elsw201 20406801 _x5lsw201 20406801 Ex6lsw201 20406801 _x7lsw201 20406801 Ex8lsw201 20406801 RQsw201 20406045Ex1lsw201 20406045_RQ

lsw201 1 0404779Ex92lsw201 1 0404779RQsw20090401 38 4_23I sw20090401 384RBK-3lsw201 0406645_x6lsw201 20406645RBKlsw201 20406801 _x3lsw201 20406801 _RBKFAlsw201 20406801 Ex4

lsw201 20406801 RKlsw201 20406045 Ex2sw201 20406045RKlsw201 20406771 x1 1lsw201 20406771 RKlsw201 20404249x5lsw201 20404249_RKlsw201 20406578_x1

lsw201 20406578RKlsw201 20406998 x1lsw201 20406998RKlsw201 20407000RKlsw201 20406771 _Ex1 .2splsw201 20406771 _x1 2epilsw201 20406771 RQsplsw201 20406771 RQepedmh_201 204071 1 1 _1

edmh_201 2040711 1 2edmh_201 20071 1 1 3edmh_201 204071 1 1 _ 4edmh201 204071 1 1 _RQedmh_201 204071 1 31edmh_201 204071 1 32

·

-

Nor it

P3P3

P3P3P3P3P3P3P3P3

P3 P3P3P33P3P3P3P3

P3P3P33P3P3P3

P3P3P3P3P3P3

P33P3P3P3P3

· ·

New Wel

A11C1

1E1F1G1H1A

2C2

2E2F2G2H2A33C33

E3F3

G33A 4

4C44

4F 4

G4 4

A5

5C555

F5G55

66C6

v (u)

0000

0

38000.00000000.000

0000 200.0

2000

2.000

20

0.0 2000

2000

2.000

20

00 200.000

20 20000000000.0000.00.000

-

TE _oResroir

00 200 200 2

00 200 200 20.0 200 200 2 4.5 200 2

8.0 20.0 200 200 200 200 20.0 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 20.0 2

00 200 200 200 200 200 200 P200 200 200 200 2

23 200 P200 200 2

Twe

A1A11

11A1A1A11A1A1

A1A1A1A1A1A1A1A1A1A11A11A1A1A1A1

1A1A1A1A1A1A1A1A1A1A11A1A1A1

.


11/156

- - · - -

xt PitS

am N Nr it N WTmt

TEvT

TW v (u) Rvr

P1 8 edmh201 20401 1 33 P3 H7 20 00 P2 1P1 C edmh201 20401 1 3 4 P3 2 00 P2 1P1 D edmh201 20401 1 35 P3 8 20 00 P2 11 8 edmh201 204071 1 3RBK C 00 00 P2 1 F8 sw201 300093 3 00 00 P2 A11 G w201 30400493RBQ 3 8 00 00 P2 1

P1 1 2 PC30Jn 1 3 P3 8 60 00 P2 1P1 12 C 30J n 1 3 P3 G 00 00 P2 11 emt P3 H8 00 0.0 P2 11 9 jtm201 20404427 2mn2 P 9 00 00 P2 1P1 9 jtm201 20404427 RBQmn2 3 9 00 00 P2 1


12/156

�

PitP1

P1

P1P1P1P1

P1

P1

P1P1

P1

P1P1

P1

P1

- P1

P1

P1

P1

P1P1P1P1P1P1P1P1P1

P1

P1

P1

P1, P1

P1P1

P1

P1 P1

P1

P1P1P1

P1

- Soree

A11

C11E1

F1

G1H12C

EF2GG2H 2

A3A33

C33E3F33G3H3A 4

A 4

8 4

C4EE4F4G

GH 5C5C555

. Sampe ame

sw201 204062_Ex3sw01 04062_RQsw201 040680 1 _Ex1lsw01 006801 _sw201 20406801 _Ex5lsw201 0406801 _Ex6 lsw201 20406801 _Exsw201 0406801 _x8sw201 0406801 _RQsw201 006045 _E1sw201 200605 _RQ

lsw01 1 0407799.lsw201 1 0409_RQlsw20090401 38 _x.3lsw20090401 384_Ex3lsw0090401 38 _RK-3lsw01 006645_Ex6lsw201 0406645_Ex6lsw201 040665 _RBKsw01 0406801 _Ex3lsw201 006801 _RKFTAsw201 0406801 _Ex4sw201 0406801 _RBKlsw201 006045_Exsw201 040605 Esw201 046045 RBKsw01 0406771 _Ex1.1sw01 040671 _Ex1.1

sw01 0406771 RBKsw201 0404249_Ex5sw201 0049 _Ex5s 01 04049 _RBKlsw201 00658_Ex1sw201 0406578_Ex1sw201 0406578 _RBKlsw201 0406998_Ex1

sw201 006998_x1sw201 0406998 _RBKsw201 0407000RBKsw201 040671 _Ex1 spsw201 0061 Ex1 2spsw201 0061 _Ex1 episw201 04061 Ex1 ep

-

orm P

P3P3P3

P3P3P3P3P3PPP3

P3P3P

PP3P3P3P3PP3P3P3P3P3P3P3P

P3PP3P3P3PP3P3P3PPP3P3

P3P

· e e

A11C1

1E1F1G112C

E2FF2G222A33

C33E3

F3

F3G333

A444C 4

4E 4

FF4G44AS

AS

55

· empe-

o

00

0000

00 200

200

20.0

200

20.01 5.5

200

1 0 200

0.000

200

0.000

200

0.0

200

00 00

0000

200

0000

200 0.00.0

2000000

2000000

200

00

000.00000

E _v

0000

5.5

1 6.300000000000.00.0

00009899890.0

630 63.0

0.0524

001 09

00872820.0

88 488.4

0070.1 701

0099099000

1 0001 000

0.000

94 79. 4

81 7

81 7

TE -

Reeror

PP

P

PPP

P

P2

PP

P2

P2

PPPPP

PPP

PPP

PP

P

PP

PPPPPP

PP

P

PP

P

PP

P

E we

A1

A1A1

A1A1A1

A1

A1

A1A1A1A1A1

1A1

A1

A1A1A1

A1

A1 A1A1

A1

A1

A1A1 1

A1

A1

A1

A1

A1A1

A1A1

A1

A1 1A1A1A1

A1


13/156

· - ·

- ·

Suc Smple me m Pt ew Wel Templte _o eWell l {u ese

1 edmh201 304021 P3 G6 00 51 P2 11 edmh21 30402 P3 H6 0 1 6.6 P2 1

1 edmh201 340023 P3 A 7 200 0 P2 11 edh201 30404 P3 0 1 4 P2 11 edmh201 3040RQ P3 C7 2 0 P 11 edmh201 241 1 1 5 P3 0 7 1 2 00 P2 11 G 7 dh20120407111_RBQFTA P3 20 0 11 edmh201 2041 1 1 6 P3 00 2 P2 11 S edmh201 2401 1 1 RBK P3 G 20 00 P2 11 8 edh201 20401 1 33 P3 00 5.6 P2 11 8 edmh201 2041 1 3 4 P3 S 00 1 3 P2 11 8 edmh01 20401 1 35 P3 8 0 608 P2 11 8 edmh201 20401 1 35 P3 8 00 60.8 P2 11 8 edmh201 2041 1 3R P3 8 20 00 P 11 F8 lw20 1 340043 2 P3 8 200 .0 P2 11 G8 w201 3040043 RB P3 200 00 P2 11 1 2 P R30Jan1 3 P3 8 00 1 40 P2 11 12 NR30Jan1 3 P3 G 20.0 00 P2 11 epty P3 H8 0 0 P2 1

1 jtm201 2040442 2mn2 P3 ·0 00 P2 11 t201 204044 RBmn2 P3 0 00 P 2 1

y(


14/156

(LEItuent I

Caay Aray ot

Ara Cou o DatePOP4 otBfer ot

lod epen L nfoemen

Bolog" Seton

c · Biomek 2000 Opeato: Aalyst(s) dmh

Dte 3-an3

Pae Record Nae AR 3an13Boek 2000 Method 15

313x D+ Ladde Lo 5413A4 Ye adde Lot

Fomami Lot 111 600 Lot 44 eatue T3@ 5

AACCFGGH

HA3A3C3C33

F3FG3GH3H5

10+0+0+10+0+10+10+0+0+10+0+0+0+0+0+

10+10+0+10+0+10+10+0+0+0+10+

10+10+10+0+0+10+0+10+

10+ Lesw4 x3 Rsw14 Ex1sw141 Exsw14 Ex5sw4 Exsw141 Exsw41 Exsw141 RQsw445 E1sw445 RQsw 44 Ex sw144 RQsw4 134 Ex3

sw4134 R310+ Laesw1445 xsw1445 Rsw14 Ex3sw141 RFTAsw141 x4sw14 Rsw1445 Exsw1445 Rsw4 Ex11

sw14 Rsw444 ExSsW1444 Rsw145 Ex1sw45 Rsw4 x10+ aesw4 R


15/156

A7 ID D LadderAS D dmh 0040 RBQ87 ID dmh 0040009 8 ID+ dmh 0040009 C7 ID dmh 0040009

CB IDdmh 0040009 4

07 ID dmh 0040009 RBQDB D dmh 0040 AE7 D dmh 0040 RBQ AEB ID dmh 0040 6F D dmh 0040 RBKFB 10 dmh 0040 G7 0 dmh 0040 4GB D dmh 0040 H7 10 dmh 0040 RBKHB 0 lw0040049 E

A9 0 10 LadderA1 ID lw0040049 RBQ89 0 APC AR0a

81 D ANC AR0aC9 10

C1 0 m pler09 10 RBQ m pler

01 0 E9 10 mle

E1 10 ampleF9 0

F1 10 ampleG9 10 ampleG1 10 ampleH9 10 ample

H1 0 ampleA11 IDA2 10811 10812 0C11 0C12 D011 10012 0E11 0E12 10F11 1012 IDG11 DG12 10


16/156

o o o

o

Analyst Run Folder . f S !r. Lc at in: ! � SCs Number() S S

pent nd coe ly lald All ldd hav t lll ll

Alele e esold/belw

m pk ig tn

Al nrol v el Pove/gve/Blnk)

mm

� 0 \ bL 6 O S \ �


17/156

ppBy

GenMappr v3.21

31308 30Jan13sw

e Ne PA lsw4677 Ex3 fsa Ex3 Pus Panel v

9

9

6

15

A ·ooz sw . 4677 Ex3 o fsa

9 15

90

6

21 27 9

Ex3 Plu Panel v

21

. 27 9

A lsw4677 Ex3 fsa lw477 Ex3 denfler Pus Panel v

9 15

9

6

o lsw4677 Ex3 fsa

9 15

21 27 9

sw477 Ex3 denfler Plu Panel v

21 27 3 3 0 9

8 3 lw4677 RBQ a RBQ Plus Pane v


18/156

pd1y

GenMar v32131308 30Jan13 ls

Nm P81 lsw1677 R 1sa lsw177 R ldenle Pls Panels 1

6

5 2 27

81 lsw677 R · 1a lsw177 R ldenfle Pls Panels 1

5 2 27

6

81 lw1677 R 1a lsw177 R ldenfle Pls Panels 1

5 2 27

6


19/156


20/156

FDEFoda Depamet ofLw Eforcemet

Jacksonve Regiol Oratons Cente 921 N Dvs See, Bug E

Jacsovlle Fora 32209-683 81802266481

Rck Sco GveorPm Bod� Atoe el

Je aer Chef Fica Ocerrald M. BaeyCoissioner

A Pua Cosso of Agcre

TO

ww.fles aels

LBORTORY PORT Febray12,2013

Sheriff Jon H. utherfordJacksonve Sheis Ofce

51 East Bay StreetJacksonie F 32202-2975

LE NUMB SUBMISSION

AGENCY NUMBE R

2120467721 and2

1208393

A M A Msser61139SUBPOENAS PRTG TO TS CASSHOULD FE TO TH FDL UER

VICTIM (S): Jordan Rsel avis

SUBJE CT(S) Michael David n

FFENSES) Death nvestigato Duval ot11/23/212

SkHan Warf Crme Laborator Aalyst Boogy Sectio

E FE ENCE

Ts repo references idece subed to the Forida Department of aw Eorcement o December06,2012 nd

Deceber18, 2012 by arce Lawrence

repor may cotan coclso opnions an/ or

teetatos made by the author

E VIDENCE

FLE Item#

38

910

Agency E xhibi

1962

636

E SLTS

Desrption

NA swab from se casngs at sceeA swabs from she casings recoered from spect vece

DNA swab from top of magazne recoered om spect ehce DA swab from ie rou recoered from sspect ecle

STR A aass was perfoed o a sampe om Exib 3 utg the AmpF STR Idetr Pl PCRAmplicato


21/156

FDLE NUMB: 2012040677 Susson: 1 nd 2

RMAS

· · · · · · submed edee · i vable-Jor eev oette erles op; edece · ncdes DA eacts I recomended t DNA exrcts be stored f rozn

Abrevto tht my pper t repo re CO DIS CombinedDNA Ind Syste; DNAdeoxyribonucleic acid; PRolymere Chain eaction Sshort tandem repeat Y-ST R mle speccsort tande repeat; FBIFede ral Bureau ofInvestigaton; n d FS Journal ofForensic Sciences.

Questio egrdng repo r shoud e ddressed to jroc ioogy@fde stte.u.


22/156


23/156

PlexorH quantitation traing FDLEY fler training, FDLEIdentiler lus training, FDLE

Courtroom Experience: List the discipline/category(ies) of testing i which you have qualied to testi a an exper witness

and indicate over what period of time and approximately how many times you have testied i each.

Serology (ince 2005):25DNA sinc 2005)35

Professional Aiations: List any professioal organizatios of which you are or have bee a memer Indicate any oces orother positios held ad the date(s) of these activities

mpoymen History: List all scietic or technical positios held paricularly those related to forensic sciece List curretpos ition rst Be sure to indicate employer ad give a rief summary of prncipal duties and tenure each postio

Job Tit Crime Tenure 2/2005 - FDLE

Provide a rief of duties:

eidece STRDNA of evidece d courroom

ob Tite Crime Tenure rime

FDLEProvide a rief of dutiesIn to learn STRDNA of evidece and courtroom

Job Tite Forensic Tenure 8/2002 - 5/2004FDLE

Provide a rief of dutiesGeeral la sppor, instrumet maiteance and operation, alys suppor sweep cases for trace evidece geeral seroogyevidece

Job Tite Volunteer Tenure 3/2002 8/2002FDLE

Provide a rief descriptio of duties

Evidece and ofce

Job ite enure

Provide a rief of duties

Other Quaictions: List elow ny scietic pulication and/or presetation you have authored or coauthored research iwhich you are or have een ivolved academic or other teaching positios you have held and any other iformatio which youconsider relevant to your qualication as a forensic scientist


24/156

Ful Membr om

IF Associate Meber, Name ofFu ember Sponsor

Badge ame ·

1 4 Drivers Licene ) <Newseter by E? Yes J Nomai Address :

c ebeip ber

Sgn m up fo he

I e y nbe

Initiati Fee

6Year ues Fee �

Tota ?

.Vice Presiden

Treasurer

Executve Ofcer

I certi that of good repute; that I a not a meber of any orgization or group hing its purpose the oerrow orisrption by foce or violence the Goerment of the United States o f America or any of the poi ical sud iisions that haeneer been concted of a crime of vioence; that if admited to membership, I will the obigations of good sportsmanship andgood citienshi hereby atest the above statements are true and any falseh ood wil derive me of emb ership. I understdthat I must rem an NRA meber for the duration of my cub members hip I aso uderstad that b sig ning this appic ation Iam consenting t a possible ackground check

Applicant Signature


25/156

RELEE HL HRMLE REEME

I considetion fo picipting in cub ctivit sponsoed o ogized b the Po Mb ie nd Piso ub, In. theudesigned Pticipt HEEBY AGEES TO WAIVE, ELEASE, DISCHAGE, AND HOLD HAMLESS the Potb Rie d Pisto Cub, Ic fom n d cims fo dges fo deth, peso inju, o pope dge which the

hve o whic the m heee ccue s esut of piciptio i Po b Rie d Pisto Cub, Ic pogm oeted ctivi nd events incudig, but not imited to unogized pctice, ogized pctice, tiig nd instuction ndogized shooting events

sigig this Reese d Hod Hmess Ageement, the undesigned ecogizes tht the spot of ie, pisto, dshotgun shooting eted ctivities peset ceti inheent dnges tht cot be eiminted eve b the execise of eonbece As such , the udesigned Pticipnt heeb expess ssumes the isk tht is inheent to the spo of ie, pisto, d shotgushootig

As equisite codition to the Pticipt being owed to ted d pticipte in n Po b Rie nd Pisto Cub,

Ic sponsoed eent o tip, the undesiged Pticipt heeb ckowedges tht e Stte of Foid hs the most signictetionship with the pies to this Ageement the then the destintion stte o pov idence As such, the pies heeto expessgee to Foid the Choice of w nd Choice of Foum to cim, suit o cotoves tht m ise by nd beeen theies o of eted fites, nd he gee tht n ctio, suit, o cim mde by the Pticipt us be bought in theStte of Foi d s the pope Venue hving excusi ve subject me jui sdiction to - such cim, demnd, o suit o effectutethis expessed Chi ce of w, Ch oice of Foum nd V enue povision, the udesigned heeb gees tht the ste o povidecewhee the injuy o cuse of ctio ose sh hve eihe subject me juisdiction o s juisdictio ove the piesheeto

y signig this Reese d Hod Hmess Ageemet, the udesiged icipnt asses he is inheent to ie,

pisto, nd shotgun shooting, d theeb cosents to the Picipnt's pticiption Po Mb Rie nd Pisto Cub, Icpogms nd eted ctivities, d he cknowedge tht he/she undestnds tht isks, whethe known o unkow, eexpess ssumed b the undesigned, nd tht cims, hethe known o unown, e expess ived i dvnce

I ddition to the foegoig, the undesigned ticipnt heeby expess gees d ecog nizes tht the ot b Riend Pisto Cub, nc, though its idividu tch iectos, Mtch Chie, Rge Oces, judges nd efeees, ofces,diectos, gents, individus o entities pefom vu svs d s such, sid entities nd/o idividus e immue fomibiit s vountee edes, ssistts, d ognizes

Abiaion:In the considetio fo being owed to pticipte in ctivities sponsoe b the Pot b Rie d istoCub, Ic the unesiged Picipt ecogizes d gees tht this coct invoves intestte commece which is ecessicotoed b the Fedea Abiion A (9 USC § ) nd theefoe, pusut to the Fede "biion A (F) s we sthe Foid Abiion A ( § ) heeb gee to submit to bidig bittio d cims, demds,suits, o othe disutes tht m ise out of this contct, o tht m be peseted b o o

beh f of the icipt fo esoution

unde the Co meci Rues of the Ameic Abittion Ass ocitio with the iiti ig fees theeof to b e pid by the pt igthe emnd fo bittion subject to the schedue of fees then in eect t the time of the ing of emd with the AmeicnAbittion Assocition

I HVE RE E FOGOING ERS AN CONIONS AN AGE O E OUN Y A OF HECONIIO S S FORH AOVE


26/156


27/156


28/156


29/156

Detectve T A Sta #7725


30/156

Detectve M A Msse #6 39 (Lead Detectve)Detectve E M Caenne #6060Detectve T D Olive #7779

WITNESSES INTERVIEWED B DETECTIVE CAENNE

DETAILS OF INVETIGATION

Fda/ 23-2/2000 hos Detectve Caenn e eceved a hone call fom Segeant al advsng o team wasbeng called to 825 Sohside Bolevad Gate Gas Staton n efeence to a shooting in the akng lotSeea nt a l advsed that when we ae done wth o othe cme scene we co ld eet at the Gae Gas Staton

Note Let t be noted that Detectves Stapp a nd Cayen ne was ha nd ln anothe death n vestiaton and neveade t to the ci e scene

F ida/ -23- 2/23 0 hos Detectve Caenne soke wth Segeant a and adv sed h m that Detectves

Caen ne and Sta wee done wth o death nvestigation whee dd he need s to espond Seeant a ladvised Detectve Cayenne to espond to th e Hom cde Oce

Fday/ -23-2/230 hos Detectve Cayenn e aved at the Ho mic de Oce

Tesda/ -27- 2/ 805 hos Detectves Caen ne and Sa esponded to he stp mall located at 822Sothside Bolevad to condct a canvass of the bsnesses

Detective Cayenne spoke wth ownes o employees of the follown bsnesses

U n t 3- Kalb's Dance Clb advsed the had vdeo sel lancei nsd e the b sn ess and otsde on the b ack sde. Thee was no vdeo otside the font of the bsness

U n t 5 The Loo Restaant advsed the bsness hass ve lla nce nsde a nd vews otsde the ea of the bs ness Thee was no vdeo otsde the font of thebsness


31/156

Case Ceared CLEAED BY AEST (D ETECTIVE)


32/156

CRME ANAL YSSAgaaed Assaut/Murder AGUMENType o Weapon HANDGUN DISC HAGED)Forced Ent NOT APLICABLE Structure Occupan Code: NOT APLICABLENuber oPreses Entered

Locaton e Gas/Srvic Statiobsiess that srvics vehics)Icidet Occ rred Otside th is Locatio Incdent Occurred In he Parkng Lot at hs Locaon YesNuber o Vehces Recoered Nuber oArrested Schoo Nae Schoo Nuber

MSCELEOUS:Is Oense Reaed o Doesc Voence No yes, ere Chdren under 18 Present No No s t Doestc Reated NOIs hre aona noraon ncuded on a connuaon report No Are there other Pertnent Reports YsIn your opnon s there sncant reason o beee hat the cre can be soed by a parooo-up nestgaton? NoNeghborhood Canass Conducted Yes Case Inoraton Card Le Wth: NA Oher (ae Address)

Address Apt/Lot # SubSector

C State Zp

Crossseet

Hoe Phone # Bus. Phone # Ext.

Ce Phone # Ce Phone Proder Ea

Is Vagrant? NO

Investigative Tm:#1 0 Hours 0 Mnues 0 Cos Aount $48240

Deecte Caed o the SceneMAMUSSE #6 39Edence echncan Caed o the Scene #0Reportng Ocers EMCAYENNE

Approng Suersor A AULDson: DETECTIVE Unt HOMCIDE

NA ( NA [

D #60601D #0ID #6097

Noted [ X Assned By HQ: [ X

8//203 3:0


33/156


34/156

at the Burer Ki ocated ear the itersectio of Beach Bouevard ad St Johs Buf


35/156

This reo docuets a id ividu a i nvestigative eos i this case that were cod ucted by Detective OiverRefer to Detective Musser's repo for ore detai s of the ivestiatio

learance Status: CL EARED BY ARREST learance oe ADULT Date case was cleare 24202 Nuber ofases leare ase leare CLEARED BY ARREST (DETECTVE)

CRME YSSgavated ssault/Murer ARGUMENTType of Weapon HANDGUN DSCHARGED)Forced En NOT APLCABLE Sructure Occupan oe: NOT ALCABLENuber oPremises Entere

Location Tye: GasService Statio bus iess that se rvices vehices)ncidet Occurred Outside this Locatio Incient Occurre In te Parng Lot at tis Location YesNuber o Veicles ecovered: Number ofrrested School Nae Scool Number

MSCELEOUS:Is Oense Related to Doesic Violence No Jyes were ildren uner 18 Present: No No is it Doestic elate NOIs there aitional inoration inclue on a continuation report No re tere oter Pertinent Reports YesIn your opinion is there sincant reason to believe that te crie can be solved by a parolollowup investigation NoNeighboroo anvass onducted Yes ase Inforation ard Le With NAIOther ae ress)

ress pt/Lot # Sub-Sector

i State Zip:

Taz: rossstreet

Home Pone # Bus Pone # Ex

ell Pone # ell Pone Provier Eail

Is Vaant NO

Investigative Time#11 ours 0 Minutes 0 ost mount:

Detective alled To te SceeMAMUSSER #639Evience Tecnician alled to te Scene #0eporting Ocers T DLVERpproving SuervisorM A AULDivision: DETECTVE Unit HOMCDE

N: [ N: [

ID #7779ID #0ID #6097

Noted [ X ssigne By Q [ X

89203 423


36/156

f


37/156


38/156


39/156


40/156


41/156

' .


42/156

· - � , - · '" ·-� . · • " -

· Q • " . _ r � · - �-

' f I _ .:. t

._,J . -· . " �

•. _ -- -t · .

- · , ._ . · -. -·

j_ - . ·

. - �

. -�· · .-� · . -

.

�

� '"• . " '

� . "

· ! i

-i� �:

. • ' 6 o . - . -


43/156


44/156


45/156


46/156

l


47/156


48/156


49/156


50/156


51/156


52/156


53/156

:


54/156


55/156


56/156


57/156


58/156


59/156


60/156


61/156


62/156


63/156


64/156


65/156


66/156


67/156


68/156


69/156


70/156


71/156


72/156


73/156


74/156


75/156


76/156


77/156


78/156


79/156


80/156


81/156


82/156


83/156


84/156


85/156


86/156


87/156

7 -3 :


88/156


89/156


90/156


91/156


92/156


93/156


94/156


95/156


96/156


97/156


98/156


99/156


100/156


101/156


102/156


103/156


104/156

� � .Q

· G '_

: - . Ms

·

.•£

· - J - _ • & �-Af' - . . . _ . _ . . _ kl u-� /_' rS . � - ±L

_ _ G br __W �


105/156


106/156


107/156


108/156


109/156


110/156


111/156


112/156


113/156


114/156


115/156


116/156


117/156


118/156


119/156


120/156

k J ough on to e rl n oght of ou y l of s d d Mke by eall enjoy d t b oe WatchingYouAct, proposd byDemocMsahe Rep. Michl Capuo d

Rep lc No Cla Re. Wa Jons, ll k cootions om g W e (DVR) olt d s o peon ion

Ke Pn repo T bll wo eqi n roe o cot befoe


121/156

Ke Pn repo. T bll wo eqi n roe o cot befoefo ato s cllect, d opeaor o e l hav to ode access o how e s colct, sd ess eee n e Ho's wbt.

r d c nsle n

DVs ould be used to collect he sc

fo o If t n cose ' ion t b e woud e forc� ooer or opton t does not lm he oes bt at is oerwise dencal spct" a c ser does llow he oao to be cecte a ht d a t eds W G U" us b hd o t all t wh rodg

T ouses pess relese explin e tci• ompe nteest s tcl: Essntaly, het to bete d ore quky e ot wh l yo- a o "tgt Capo saf s eone s tc a favt prgr e c

g e itchen for produs at wll ke

pl ces shie ay show up Ifa couple is t o whee to din v weeke o njoyng c chy sck hile atcng he S u l, tvon y sere up food sugesos atet alcon ev es so f to at f a couple s tng d sso ted h relatosp oug ght lcte for the, t sd

Je Capuo o od quoes th s ase. l ht of e goee's "ufortute histo o secetly collectin piae zs oao

o we must ens sgs plae t potect Aeis' ghts,oe dp o sess ed t hough s a so eosteo it s "neithe joke o exggeto,"d ged cosuers o coside th impact s sot o nfoao shg wl hav on her pesol

about ha ou do in h pivacy of o o home n he about how·ou would feelg tha infaion you cable compn e avesers yo

ess ree conclude e essge s i e o awnss, a choce u nsumers sld av e o ag no to ng watche.

II h o I reped o .

"Mr o a or cm wl m oroe Er u nab �t si ack e , r u n' u r f g I sl do't h d f a fral aw

f t t t see t b Xx S Ntd coe ot wt acoptie od a no o k "My


122/156

I to is l I ked at my ab box. at cops eied sl W'vy Ild n wha abl ops you an us. Withut ny verg v t , thcabl �mp cud wrk tgr and pu ht t Mt l w d wtut a gmgc wud actuy ay no ab?

Sof rping Yu :u ai oug, e pcpe is x no at ow m yo w od/1 My Ry bck

o a fra h t t tfrc w

ytng, hs s t cs. T gv jb rectg gt t

ay It on f th fw gs gv is spps t d o pro w t gvt g corprtos nt unh u w n aw th o sy I u

a gu py o n1T on ha no dy o o yor it prc i y naos rt ctzs/ts u hav r rt t bx wtut cer t a

gt to vgtb wut geicy mi ogs No do yo v gt o abA wa yu dd? Te e gi ccsi w fe peprcdt w u ave riht t rc (b he Stt, gur) duer to kaccr t u wh? do't ke beg spi , s I wo't uy he rduc t wr aas

My r ck

do n t i te u crrt t p on e iizn Ca cpe es ily prvae s. Thy h subszd by bg vet y wry prive es ay spyg w po p s aj e sd


123/156

"It ee ·s at ee h en upck n nulcio om o e e d gh," d a pressor Urty o Cforia Los Ags o z csti law.

Yet e cl - e upreay ase (o e US Coson) y p e lws re sre ove con se l, evn on oe eradded

ov sate ones hsn't stoped sme aes m e e - mee ccs


124/156

20 es no hae medi j a peoe o use o o ea conc pin doe men despite eder la a s crimlz mja son e.Cedn ud to e saes, Presiden Back Obm's a h made t ederapose trs at n' t wor eir me o te ose eopl

auies hve epeae delae mplementaton o e 5 Rea ID At, ierisa s et gen eqreens f poo dec cs be ue d coercal igsr edera uldings Te a bn tye, in p, cuse at te ae eaeae psed is impemeatio, acg e Na Ceee Se egs laes .Aou 0 s ate hve eate mese cengng Obm's 01 0 ea ce as, my wispe

llrejet e proisin dating mo e ae ea nsce o ce

e

t

eg in 04A Mona passd 29 a dcg at ee res regulions on a o gs aded pt tat sate eg oer aes ave enc l a.

T upreme Cou red in 197 a ll police cud nt be cmeled o ary o vin of af ono a B sm staes e nw emptg ke septer by aseing cr n edera aws c even e enorced b eer uoies.

A e K aw e it eon for a feera gen aep ece lw n s de in Ks A sil Wing made it a mi eeor Te M d dee a mseer cre u u ap re ay t l eer as deg atis - p, pre en fue- ha "ige on e people's righ to keep d be s."

U. S Genral Eic Holder sent a leer i late Apl to he Ks oveorwing at the l oveent is wilg o o to cou over the ne '. "Kas may ot pev federa

e ees d ocls o cig ot heir ocia reponiies, Holer ote.

So wou� hapen if a ocl oscutor ac he a eder gent f o is o er job?

"T y're g o ve prbem ifey d it- ere's o dub abu i,"sdMichael Boldexe e directr o e Teth Aee Cenr Lo Angele se en promte state'

Sign g he mee "wll hw or hw to ess e y dra beaucats w wto ro you of your rght o e-en, oe mesage sg b Aena Sowas w

g hp tov, Mo.·

e?ag ! Peoe ee reaze at e fera gveet oes o ae ou bes teret If we c't e o co bak ecos b w c s bak i lcai


125/156


126/156


127/156


128/156


129/156


130/156


131/156


132/156


133/156


134/156


135/156


136/156


137/156


138/156


139/156


140/156


141/156


142/156


143/156


144/156


145/156


146/156


147/156


148/156


149/156


150/156


151/156


152/156


153/156


154/156


155/156


156/156

Dunn, Michael Discovery_R

Documents

Transcript of Dunn, Michael Discovery_R