CHASER Civil Oocket Report for 197cv 11743 httpciviJsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

CHASER Pre Extracted Civil Docket as of April It 2002 947pm LEAD

us District Court US District Court - Massachusetts (Boston)

CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE 197cv11743shy

Elbery v Sklut et al Filed 080 197

Assigned to Judge Mark L Wolf Jury demand Both

Demand $6000000 Nature of Suit 440

Lead Docket 197cvll 047shy Jurisdiction Federal Question

Dkt in other court None

Cause 42 1983 Civil Rights Act

rmiddotmiddotm~w_middotmiddotmiddot~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotpart1esmiddotmiddot~~~~- r-middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot middotmiddot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot middot_middotmiddot middotmiddotmiddotmiddot-Attorneys-middot~middot_middotw _

middot~~----IMichael ElberyIMICHAEL ELBERY I Plaintiff rCOR LD NTC]

l68 Fairfield Street Needham MA 02492-9106 781-444-7324I

IDANIEL SKLUT middotmiddot~middot_---~ouglasI LouisonIDefendant I[COR LD NTC] I Bradford N LouisonI [COR LD NTC] I MeITick and Louison II 67 Batterymarch Street I Boston MA 021 10 I 617-439-0305 I i

r-~~ ~-_ II f~~~b~~ ~T~~ahey m__

Pierce Davis Fahey amp

IPerritano LLP Ten Winlhop Square

Boston MA 02110 i6J 7-350-0950

l~middot~middot~m m~middot_ ==--------IMichael J A7k-e-rs-o-n---=--=-==_cmiddot

I rCOR LD NTC] Edward P Reardon Pc 397 Grove Street Worcester MA 01605

1508-7547385 m middotmiddotmiddotmiddotIlidward r Reardon m_mmmm __ m _

I rCOR LD NTC] IReardon amp Reardon 1397 Grove Street

_ _ _- rWorcester M---A-O16-O-=S--middot

1508754-7285 r------ fCerai(Hltabiano

I[COR LD NTC] Ipierce Davis Fahey amp

IPerritano LLP Ten Wintrop SquareIBoston MA 02] 10

I of28 04122002 [252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

1617-350-0950

JAMES CARLIN IDefendant

[I Douglas l Louison [term 04l498]

I (See above)

[COR LD NTClIBradford N Louison liteIm 041498] I(See above)I[COR LD NTC]

----~---rElizabethM-O-F=a-=h-ey I(See above)

-~ - bullbull __~__bullbullbullbull__ c__ _ _ ---middot_middot-=-~-It~~~~~~~rson--~----I(See above) i rCOR LD NTC] I Edward pcR=e-a-rcd-onc~----c-cc----

(See above) HCOR LD NTC]

STEPHEN FAUCHER-- rDouglasTlOliison-middot~middotmiddot-----_middot--~

Defendant I[term 0411498] (See above) I [COR LD NTC] IBradford N Louison (See above)

I [COR LD NTC]

Elizabeth M Fahev [term 091 099] (See above) [COR LD NTC]

----------~--------- [Michaei1middotAkersmiddotonmiddot- middot---middotmiddotmiddot---middot-middot----middot-

II (See above) [COR LD NTC] r-----middot----- ------~middot-middot------middot-rEchVrni P Reardon

(See above) [COR LD NTC]

I~5-d~tNS6N-- --- ---- rr~~~~~~~LC-u-son---------middot---------middot---middot

I IBradford N LouisonI (See above) I I[COR LD NTCl --- middotmiddot-middotmiddot--~~~~a~be~~e~ Fahey

I[COR LD NTC] ~middot-middotmiddot-middot_-middot-middot-middot-middot------middot---IMichaclJ_Akerson--

I(See above) i [COR LD NTCl

-middotmiddotmiddot__middotmiddot_middotmiddot--__-__---_middotmiddot_middotmiddotmiddot_--_middot~middotI---_middot-------bull---- bull-_---shy Edward P Reardon

(See above)II COR LD NTC]

------- Ir[)-ou-gI-a-sLLou-is-on--middot----middot~ --middot-- rCHESTER JOHNSONIDefendant I[term 041498]

I(See above)I[COR LD NTC]i IBradford N Louison [term 04l498] 1(See above)

I 1[COR LD NTC] -~-[Elizabeth M Famiddot-h-e-y----middot-middot

I[tenn 091 099]

20f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

1617-350-0950

JAMES CARLIN IDefendant

[I Douglas l Louison [term 04l498]

I (See above)

[COR LD NTClIBradford N Louison liteIm 041498] I(See above)I[COR LD NTC]

----~---rElizabethM-O-F=a-=h-ey I(See above)

-~ - bullbull __~__bullbullbullbull__ c__ _ _ ---middot_middot-=-~-It~~~~~~~rson--~----I(See above) i rCOR LD NTC] I Edward pcR=e-a-rcd-onc~----c-cc----

(See above) HCOR LD NTC]

STEPHEN FAUCHER-- rDouglasTlOliison-middot~middotmiddot-----_middot--~

Defendant I[term 0411498] (See above) I [COR LD NTC] IBradford N Louison (See above)

I [COR LD NTC]

Elizabeth M Fahev [term 091 099] (See above) [COR LD NTC]

----------~--------- [Michaei1middotAkersmiddotonmiddot- middot---middotmiddotmiddot---middot-middot----middot-

II (See above) [COR LD NTC] r-----middot----- ------~middot-middot------middot-rEchVrni P Reardon

(See above) [COR LD NTC]

I~5-d~tNS6N-- --- ---- rr~~~~~~~LC-u-son---------middot---------middot---middot

I IBradford N LouisonI (See above) I I[COR LD NTCl --- middotmiddot-middotmiddot--~~~~a~be~~e~ Fahey

I[COR LD NTC] ~middot-middotmiddot-middot_-middot-middot-middot-middot------middot---IMichaclJ_Akerson--

I(See above) i [COR LD NTCl

-middotmiddotmiddot__middotmiddot_middotmiddot--__-__---_middotmiddot_middotmiddotmiddot_--_middot~middotI---_middot-------bull---- bull-_---shy Edward P Reardon

(See above)II COR LD NTC]

------- Ir[)-ou-gI-a-sLLou-is-on--middot----middot~ --middot-- rCHESTER JOHNSONIDefendant I[term 041498]

I(See above)I[COR LD NTC]i IBradford N Louison [term 04l498] 1(See above)

I 1[COR LD NTC] -~-[Elizabeth M Famiddot-h-e-y----middot-middot

I[tenn 091 099]

20f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=11997cv J 1743ampplain=0amplive=Fi

I(See above) [COR LD NTC] rmiddotmiddotmiddot-middotmiddotmiddot~-----middotmiddot-middot---~-middot--middot- MichaefjAkerson--middotmiddot-middot-middotmiddot--middotmiddotmiddotmiddot-middot-middot--- shy

(See above) lCOR LD NTC] ImiddotEd~ardmiddotpmiddotI~eamiddotrdoilmiddotmiddot-middot-middot-middot-middot--middotmiddotmiddot--middotmiddot-middot ---shyi (See above) [COR LD NTC]

---- fOouglas I Louison FlWAYNE SAMPSON Defendant I[term 04114981

(see above) [COR LD NTC1iBradford N Louison i[term 04114981 (See above)I[COR LD NTC]

r- __- _ - ---bull~_ -__- jfHzabethNI-Fahey-middotmiddot-----middot---middot-middot- --middot shy

[term 091 0991 (See above) [COR LD NTC]

rlVIichael J Akerson -- shy(See above) [CORLD NTC]

-- - - ----------- fE(hvardmiddotmiddot~Reardonmiddot --- shy(See above) I[COR LD NTC]

middot1middot middot ---___ ___ shyIROBERT MCGINLEY

~--

Douglas I Louison IDefendant [term 041498]t (See above)i I[COR LD NTC1

Bradford N_Louison [term 0411498]I(See above) IrCOR LD NTC]___v~u~_~ ~- m__~___~____ r E Iizabeth M Fahey[term 0910991

I(See above) I[COR LD NTC]_ _ - _ rmiddot middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot middotmiddotbullmiddotmiddot-c = - _ _ - _

IMichaelJ AkersonI(See above) I[COR LD NTC]

rEdward P e-a-r-=-do-n----- -- shyRe-

I(See above) I[COR LD NTC]

IsiI-R-ltWSBU-R-YTOW-N-6FTHE--middot--middot- middotmiddotmiddotmiddot-locluglasIL-o-liisonmiddot---middotmiddotmiddot-- middotmiddotmiddotmiddot-middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot_middotmiddot-_

IDefendant i lterm 041498] II (See above)

I

rCOR LD NTC] IBradford N Louison I[term 0414981 (See above)

I I rCOR LD NTC]fmiddotmiddot -middotmiddot - __ _ --_-- ---iEiizabeth IVLFiihev- - --- _ --- - shy

I 1[tenl1 091 099] (See above)

[COR LD NTC] 1

IROliERTSijifKETOFF Anthony M Doniger

iConsolidated Defendant I[COR LDNTC] - r--

ISugarman Rogers Barshak amp

041122002 1252 PM30f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv 1I 743ampplain=0amplive=F

Cohen 101 Merrimac Street 9th Floor Boston MA 02] 14-4737 617-227-3030

rKfMBERLYHOMAN-Att~~iY------middot---middot-~middotmiddot~middot

Consolidated Defendant rSHEKETOFFmiddotampIIOMANmiddotmiddot-middotmiddot_middot-middotmiddot-middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot__middot_middot_middot_-middot~middot

Consolidated Defendant 01 ~_---middot--~- middot-_middotDmiddotavidFHassett~--middot-middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotICHARLESmiddoti)NoiANampSO----middot------

Iinterested pal1y lCOR LD NTC]ISarah L Brown lCOR LlJ NTC] IHealy amp Rocheleau i484 Main Street ISuite 560 iWorcester MA 01608 i508-791-6287 I

DENNIS KLUG IRomiddotbe-rtR Pierce i [COR LD NTC] Interestd P1y Pierce amp Mandell I I Beacon Street

ISuite 800IBoston MA 02108I 1617-720-2444

--_- [keHyAN)cksonmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot-middotmiddot _ IrCOR LD NTC] IPierce amp Mandell PCIt 1 Beacon Street Suite 800 I Boston MA 02108-3002 1617-720-2444

r-bull--~-----------------rmiddot-middotmiddotmiddot---~-middot----_middotmiddot-- ---middot~middot -_-- shyiDAYS INN MOTEL Robert R Pierce1

linterested pmty (See above) I I[COR LD NTCl

(See above) [COR LDNTCl

~ m=m=

Docket Proceedings

Doc Date Docket Entry

080197

080197

Notice of case assigmnent Case reassigned from Judge Saris to Judge Mark L Wolf (scj) [197cvl 743]

081297 2

r-~---~~~ f-=~~- ~ _~~~~~_ __=~ ___~_~~~~~~v-------~~m_~~~--~_~_~~~_~_~_ bullm_~_~~~~~

Complaint filed Case assigned to Judge 0129 Receipt 3 Amount$ 15000 Fee Status Paid (bdb) [Entry date 080897] [1 97cv 11743]

Summons issued for Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv- I 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-J 1743 (bdb) [Entry date 080897] [197cv 11743]

4 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for l97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

092497

111397

J 11797

112697

120397

121097

121897

032598

040898

041098

)

6

4

5

9

8

7

12

13

14

Answer by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 to complaint jury demand filedcs (scj) [l97cvl1743]

Answer by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to complaint jury demand filed cis (sad) [Entry date 120397] [I 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file amended complaint filed cis (sad) [Entry date 112497] [1 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 120 days to make service filed (sad) [Entry date 120397] [I 97cvI1743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [5-1J motion to extend time to 120 days to make service filed (ktb) [Entry date 021098] [1 97cv I 1743]

Waiver of service returned executed as to Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 Mailed on 12497 (ktb) [Entry date 020698] [I 97cvI1743]

Notice of appearance of attorney for Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 by Edward P Reardon Michael J Akerson filed cis (scj) [Entry date 122997] [197cvl1743]

012998 10 Wolf OJ Order entered Parties to report by February 13 1998 re consent to proceed before MJ Marianne B Bowler Any failure to respond by the foregoing date will be deemed a consent cccl (ktb) [Entry date 021098] [I 97cv11743]

-__---~-___- __- -------_shy --__ __-__- _-----shy -------_____-------shy020598 II Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 dated 2498 to clerk

NON-CONSENTING to the reassignment to MJ Bowler FILED (ktb) [Entry date 02l198] [I 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Notice of Hearingconference set scheduling conference for 400 41598 cccl (ktb) [Entry date 032798] [197cv 11743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-1 J 743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to continue the initial scheduling conference presently set for 41598 FILED cis (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

Notice of appearance of attorney for Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 by Elizabeth

50f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

0411498 15

M Fahey filed (ktb) [Entry date 041398] [1 97cvI1743]

Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 attorney Douglas l Louison for Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv- J J743 attorney Bradford N Louison fOlWayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

04116198

050498 16

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [13-1] motion to continue the initial schedu ling conference presently set for 411598 Motion alJowed The conference is hereby rescheduled to May 6 1998 at 4 15 pm (ktb) [Entry date 041798] [197cvI1743J

Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cY-11 743 to consoJidate cases filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

050598 17 Proposed Discovery Plan by Daniel Sklut lames Carlin Stephen Faucher Carl Hanson Chester Johnson Wayne Sampson Robert McGinley and Town of Shrewsbury filed cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

050598 18 Rule 161 Certification filed by Ms Carolyn J Hamel cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvlI743]

050598 J9 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Michael Hale cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [1 97cv I 1743]

050598 20 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Chester Johnson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Wayne Sampson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvJ 17431

21050598

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by James Hurley cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [l97cvl] 743]

050598 22

Judge Mark L Wolf Scheduling Order entered setting Joining of parties amending of pleadings on 51598 Discovery cutoff 73099 case ready for trial on 11199 (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [197cvI1743]

050598 26

J~_1 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 lames Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I Y7-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- 11743 Robert McGinley in ] 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 for order on scheduling conference filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

050698

Joint Statement by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 050798] I 197cv 11743]

24050698

Scheduling conference held (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [I 97cvI1743]050698

Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes Court Reporter Coppola There are two other pending cases before Judge Saris Pltf states the essence of all three cases Pitt

050698

60f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv 11743 httpcivi1so1madcircldcndccaseno=1 1997cv11743ampp1ain=0amp1ive=F

opposes the consolidation Clerk Cronin and pltf shall talk to Barbara Billig Scheduling Order to be issued (ktb) [Entry date 0508981 [I 97cv 11743]

050698

050898

051198 27

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [23-1] motion for order on scheduling conference denying [16-1] motion to consolidate cases (bfc) [Entry date 0302199] [1 97cv 11743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [5-1] motion to extend time to 120 days to make service granting [4-11 motion for leave to file amended complaint (bfc) [l97cvI1743]

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [16-1] motion to consolidate cases filed cis (letb) ll97cv11743]

071598 Notice of change of address filed by Michael E1bery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

28

081298 29 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]898] [l97cvlI743]

0811398 30 Letter dated 8113l)amp to Judge Wolf re letter from Michael Elbery filed (sad) [Entry date 0811998] [197cv 11743]

0811598 31

091798 32

Copy of a Letter (non-motion) dated 81098 from Atty Liftman to Mr E1berty in receipt of a subpoena she received from him to permit inspection of ther deposition of John Nolan FILED (ktb) [Entry date 082798] [I 97cv I 1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Elizabeth M Fahey in 197-cv-11743 by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 092298] [I 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [I 97cv] 1743]

0911898 33

0911898 34 Motion by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-ll743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl 1-1 anson in I 97-cv-1 l743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l 97-cv-lI743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [1 97cv 117431

092498 35

1010598 3636

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (ktb)

Response by Daniel SkIu in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-ll743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-ev-11743 in opposition to [33-]] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1007981 [197cvI1743]

r------~ ---- ---

70f28 04122002 1252 PM

lHAgtt-ltK Civil Docket RepOli for 197evl1743 httpcivilsolmadeireldcndeeaseno=l 1997cvI1743ampplain=0amplive=F1

1010598 37 Response by DanieJ Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [33-1 J motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 100798] [l97cvI1743]

1010898 38 Response by Daniel SkIm in I97-cv-1 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in l97-cv-1 J 743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [35-1] motion to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (sad) [Entry date 101398] [I 97cvl1743]

102698 39 Motion by Daniel Sklu in I 97-cv-1 J 743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carll-lanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 62-RCL FILED cis filed (ktb) [Entry date 110498] [l97cv 11743]

1113198 40 Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to require Pitts to comply With Applicable Rules tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 111798] [l97cvI1743]

1113098 41 Response and Opposition by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to [39-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 I 62-RCL filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120398 J [197cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in l 97-cv-11743 Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-II 047 to suppress filed (bfc) [Entry date 120798] 1l97cv 11047 l97cv I 1743]

120498 42

4~120998 J Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- J ] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-ev-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-ev-11743 in opposition to [42-1 ] motion to suppress tiled cis (sad) IEntry date 121098] 1197cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting 139-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-lOI62-RCL (bfc) [197cvI1743]

0111499

011499

0311499 44

Consolidated Lead Case (ktb) IEntry date 062199] II 97cv I] 7431

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered granting [29- JJmotion for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery f shall in the future comply with Fed R Civ cal Rule 52 (b) AJI papers required to be served shall be served on every party and shall contain or be accompanied by proof of service in al legally permissalbe fonn indication the time and manner of service cclcl (ktb) [Entry date 032499] [1 97cv 11743]

Notice of change of address filed by Edward P Reardon in I97-cv-1174i FILED cis (ktb) IEntry date 050799]1197cv11743]

050399 45

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compeJ production of documents tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 0511 0199] [197cvI1743]

050399 46

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-1 J743 to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (ktb) IEntry date 0510199] 1l97cv 11743]

0503199 47

of28 04122002 1252

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv 1I 743ampplain=0amplive=F

Cohen 101 Merrimac Street 9th Floor Boston MA 02] 14-4737 617-227-3030

rKfMBERLYHOMAN-Att~~iY------middot---middot-~middotmiddot~middot

Consolidated Defendant rSHEKETOFFmiddotampIIOMANmiddotmiddot-middotmiddot_middot-middotmiddot-middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot__middot_middot_middot_-middot~middot

Consolidated Defendant 01 ~_---middot--~- middot-_middotDmiddotavidFHassett~--middot-middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotICHARLESmiddoti)NoiANampSO----middot------

Iinterested pal1y lCOR LD NTC]ISarah L Brown lCOR LlJ NTC] IHealy amp Rocheleau i484 Main Street ISuite 560 iWorcester MA 01608 i508-791-6287 I

DENNIS KLUG IRomiddotbe-rtR Pierce i [COR LD NTC] Interestd P1y Pierce amp Mandell I I Beacon Street

ISuite 800IBoston MA 02108I 1617-720-2444

--_- [keHyAN)cksonmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot-middotmiddot _ IrCOR LD NTC] IPierce amp Mandell PCIt 1 Beacon Street Suite 800 I Boston MA 02108-3002 1617-720-2444

r-bull--~-----------------rmiddot-middotmiddotmiddot---~-middot----_middotmiddot-- ---middot~middot -_-- shyiDAYS INN MOTEL Robert R Pierce1

linterested pmty (See above) I I[COR LD NTCl

(See above) [COR LDNTCl

~ m=m=

Docket Proceedings

Doc Date Docket Entry

080197

080197

Notice of case assigmnent Case reassigned from Judge Saris to Judge Mark L Wolf (scj) [197cvl 743]

081297 2

r-~---~~~ f-=~~- ~ _~~~~~_ __=~ ___~_~~~~~~v-------~~m_~~~--~_~_~~~_~_~_ bullm_~_~~~~~

Complaint filed Case assigned to Judge 0129 Receipt 3 Amount$ 15000 Fee Status Paid (bdb) [Entry date 080897] [1 97cv 11743]

Summons issued for Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv- I 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-J 1743 (bdb) [Entry date 080897] [197cv 11743]

4 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for l97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

092497

111397

J 11797

112697

120397

121097

121897

032598

040898

041098

)

6

4

5

9

8

7

12

13

14

Answer by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 to complaint jury demand filedcs (scj) [l97cvl1743]

Answer by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to complaint jury demand filed cis (sad) [Entry date 120397] [I 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file amended complaint filed cis (sad) [Entry date 112497] [1 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 120 days to make service filed (sad) [Entry date 120397] [I 97cvI1743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [5-1J motion to extend time to 120 days to make service filed (ktb) [Entry date 021098] [1 97cv I 1743]

Waiver of service returned executed as to Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 Mailed on 12497 (ktb) [Entry date 020698] [I 97cvI1743]

Notice of appearance of attorney for Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 by Edward P Reardon Michael J Akerson filed cis (scj) [Entry date 122997] [197cvl1743]

012998 10 Wolf OJ Order entered Parties to report by February 13 1998 re consent to proceed before MJ Marianne B Bowler Any failure to respond by the foregoing date will be deemed a consent cccl (ktb) [Entry date 021098] [I 97cv11743]

-__---~-___- __- -------_shy --__ __-__- _-----shy -------_____-------shy020598 II Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 dated 2498 to clerk

NON-CONSENTING to the reassignment to MJ Bowler FILED (ktb) [Entry date 02l198] [I 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Notice of Hearingconference set scheduling conference for 400 41598 cccl (ktb) [Entry date 032798] [197cv 11743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-1 J 743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to continue the initial scheduling conference presently set for 41598 FILED cis (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

Notice of appearance of attorney for Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 by Elizabeth

50f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

0411498 15

M Fahey filed (ktb) [Entry date 041398] [1 97cvI1743]

Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 attorney Douglas l Louison for Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv- J J743 attorney Bradford N Louison fOlWayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

04116198

050498 16

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [13-1] motion to continue the initial schedu ling conference presently set for 411598 Motion alJowed The conference is hereby rescheduled to May 6 1998 at 4 15 pm (ktb) [Entry date 041798] [197cvI1743J

Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cY-11 743 to consoJidate cases filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

050598 17 Proposed Discovery Plan by Daniel Sklut lames Carlin Stephen Faucher Carl Hanson Chester Johnson Wayne Sampson Robert McGinley and Town of Shrewsbury filed cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

050598 18 Rule 161 Certification filed by Ms Carolyn J Hamel cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvlI743]

050598 J9 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Michael Hale cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [1 97cv I 1743]

050598 20 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Chester Johnson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Wayne Sampson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvJ 17431

21050598

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by James Hurley cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [l97cvl] 743]

050598 22

Judge Mark L Wolf Scheduling Order entered setting Joining of parties amending of pleadings on 51598 Discovery cutoff 73099 case ready for trial on 11199 (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [197cvI1743]

050598 26

J~_1 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 lames Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I Y7-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- 11743 Robert McGinley in ] 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 for order on scheduling conference filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

050698

Joint Statement by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 050798] I 197cv 11743]

24050698

Scheduling conference held (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [I 97cvI1743]050698

Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes Court Reporter Coppola There are two other pending cases before Judge Saris Pltf states the essence of all three cases Pitt

050698

60f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv 11743 httpcivi1so1madcircldcndccaseno=1 1997cv11743ampp1ain=0amp1ive=F

opposes the consolidation Clerk Cronin and pltf shall talk to Barbara Billig Scheduling Order to be issued (ktb) [Entry date 0508981 [I 97cv 11743]

050698

050898

051198 27

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [23-1] motion for order on scheduling conference denying [16-1] motion to consolidate cases (bfc) [Entry date 0302199] [1 97cv 11743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [5-1] motion to extend time to 120 days to make service granting [4-11 motion for leave to file amended complaint (bfc) [l97cvI1743]

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [16-1] motion to consolidate cases filed cis (letb) ll97cv11743]

071598 Notice of change of address filed by Michael E1bery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

28

081298 29 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]898] [l97cvlI743]

0811398 30 Letter dated 8113l)amp to Judge Wolf re letter from Michael Elbery filed (sad) [Entry date 0811998] [197cv 11743]

0811598 31

091798 32

Copy of a Letter (non-motion) dated 81098 from Atty Liftman to Mr E1berty in receipt of a subpoena she received from him to permit inspection of ther deposition of John Nolan FILED (ktb) [Entry date 082798] [I 97cv I 1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Elizabeth M Fahey in 197-cv-11743 by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 092298] [I 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [I 97cv] 1743]

0911898 33

0911898 34 Motion by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-ll743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl 1-1 anson in I 97-cv-1 l743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l 97-cv-lI743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [1 97cv 117431

092498 35

1010598 3636

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (ktb)

Response by Daniel SkIu in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-ll743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-ev-11743 in opposition to [33-]] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1007981 [197cvI1743]

r------~ ---- ---

70f28 04122002 1252 PM

lHAgtt-ltK Civil Docket RepOli for 197evl1743 httpcivilsolmadeireldcndeeaseno=l 1997cvI1743ampplain=0amplive=F1

1010598 37 Response by DanieJ Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [33-1 J motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 100798] [l97cvI1743]

1010898 38 Response by Daniel SkIm in I97-cv-1 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in l97-cv-1 J 743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [35-1] motion to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (sad) [Entry date 101398] [I 97cvl1743]

102698 39 Motion by Daniel Sklu in I 97-cv-1 J 743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carll-lanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 62-RCL FILED cis filed (ktb) [Entry date 110498] [l97cv 11743]

1113198 40 Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to require Pitts to comply With Applicable Rules tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 111798] [l97cvI1743]

1113098 41 Response and Opposition by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to [39-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 I 62-RCL filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120398 J [197cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in l 97-cv-11743 Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-II 047 to suppress filed (bfc) [Entry date 120798] 1l97cv 11047 l97cv I 1743]

120498 42

4~120998 J Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- J ] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-ev-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-ev-11743 in opposition to [42-1 ] motion to suppress tiled cis (sad) IEntry date 121098] 1197cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting 139-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-lOI62-RCL (bfc) [197cvI1743]

0111499

011499

0311499 44

Consolidated Lead Case (ktb) IEntry date 062199] II 97cv I] 7431

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered granting [29- JJmotion for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery f shall in the future comply with Fed R Civ cal Rule 52 (b) AJI papers required to be served shall be served on every party and shall contain or be accompanied by proof of service in al legally permissalbe fonn indication the time and manner of service cclcl (ktb) [Entry date 032499] [1 97cv 11743]

Notice of change of address filed by Edward P Reardon in I97-cv-1174i FILED cis (ktb) IEntry date 050799]1197cv11743]

050399 45

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compeJ production of documents tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 0511 0199] [197cvI1743]

050399 46

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-1 J743 to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (ktb) IEntry date 0510199] 1l97cv 11743]

0503199 47

of28 04122002 1252

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for l97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

092497

111397

J 11797

112697

120397

121097

121897

032598

040898

041098

)

6

4

5

9

8

7

12

13

14

Answer by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 to complaint jury demand filedcs (scj) [l97cvl1743]

Answer by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to complaint jury demand filed cis (sad) [Entry date 120397] [I 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file amended complaint filed cis (sad) [Entry date 112497] [1 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 120 days to make service filed (sad) [Entry date 120397] [I 97cvI1743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [5-1J motion to extend time to 120 days to make service filed (ktb) [Entry date 021098] [1 97cv I 1743]

Waiver of service returned executed as to Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 Mailed on 12497 (ktb) [Entry date 020698] [I 97cvI1743]

Notice of appearance of attorney for Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 by Edward P Reardon Michael J Akerson filed cis (scj) [Entry date 122997] [197cvl1743]

012998 10 Wolf OJ Order entered Parties to report by February 13 1998 re consent to proceed before MJ Marianne B Bowler Any failure to respond by the foregoing date will be deemed a consent cccl (ktb) [Entry date 021098] [I 97cv11743]

-__---~-___- __- -------_shy --__ __-__- _-----shy -------_____-------shy020598 II Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 dated 2498 to clerk

NON-CONSENTING to the reassignment to MJ Bowler FILED (ktb) [Entry date 02l198] [I 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Notice of Hearingconference set scheduling conference for 400 41598 cccl (ktb) [Entry date 032798] [197cv 11743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-1 J 743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to continue the initial scheduling conference presently set for 41598 FILED cis (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

Notice of appearance of attorney for Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 by Elizabeth

50f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

0411498 15

M Fahey filed (ktb) [Entry date 041398] [1 97cvI1743]

Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 attorney Douglas l Louison for Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv- J J743 attorney Bradford N Louison fOlWayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

04116198

050498 16

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [13-1] motion to continue the initial schedu ling conference presently set for 411598 Motion alJowed The conference is hereby rescheduled to May 6 1998 at 4 15 pm (ktb) [Entry date 041798] [197cvI1743J

Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cY-11 743 to consoJidate cases filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

050598 17 Proposed Discovery Plan by Daniel Sklut lames Carlin Stephen Faucher Carl Hanson Chester Johnson Wayne Sampson Robert McGinley and Town of Shrewsbury filed cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

050598 18 Rule 161 Certification filed by Ms Carolyn J Hamel cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvlI743]

050598 J9 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Michael Hale cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [1 97cv I 1743]

050598 20 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Chester Johnson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Wayne Sampson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvJ 17431

21050598

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by James Hurley cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [l97cvl] 743]

050598 22

Judge Mark L Wolf Scheduling Order entered setting Joining of parties amending of pleadings on 51598 Discovery cutoff 73099 case ready for trial on 11199 (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [197cvI1743]

050598 26

J~_1 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 lames Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I Y7-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- 11743 Robert McGinley in ] 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 for order on scheduling conference filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

050698

Joint Statement by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 050798] I 197cv 11743]

24050698

Scheduling conference held (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [I 97cvI1743]050698

Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes Court Reporter Coppola There are two other pending cases before Judge Saris Pltf states the essence of all three cases Pitt

050698

60f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv 11743 httpcivi1so1madcircldcndccaseno=1 1997cv11743ampp1ain=0amp1ive=F

opposes the consolidation Clerk Cronin and pltf shall talk to Barbara Billig Scheduling Order to be issued (ktb) [Entry date 0508981 [I 97cv 11743]

050698

050898

051198 27

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [23-1] motion for order on scheduling conference denying [16-1] motion to consolidate cases (bfc) [Entry date 0302199] [1 97cv 11743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [5-1] motion to extend time to 120 days to make service granting [4-11 motion for leave to file amended complaint (bfc) [l97cvI1743]

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [16-1] motion to consolidate cases filed cis (letb) ll97cv11743]

071598 Notice of change of address filed by Michael E1bery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

28

081298 29 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]898] [l97cvlI743]

0811398 30 Letter dated 8113l)amp to Judge Wolf re letter from Michael Elbery filed (sad) [Entry date 0811998] [197cv 11743]

0811598 31

091798 32

Copy of a Letter (non-motion) dated 81098 from Atty Liftman to Mr E1berty in receipt of a subpoena she received from him to permit inspection of ther deposition of John Nolan FILED (ktb) [Entry date 082798] [I 97cv I 1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Elizabeth M Fahey in 197-cv-11743 by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 092298] [I 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [I 97cv] 1743]

0911898 33

0911898 34 Motion by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-ll743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl 1-1 anson in I 97-cv-1 l743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l 97-cv-lI743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [1 97cv 117431

092498 35

1010598 3636

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (ktb)

Response by Daniel SkIu in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-ll743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-ev-11743 in opposition to [33-]] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1007981 [197cvI1743]

r------~ ---- ---

70f28 04122002 1252 PM

lHAgtt-ltK Civil Docket RepOli for 197evl1743 httpcivilsolmadeireldcndeeaseno=l 1997cvI1743ampplain=0amplive=F1

1010598 37 Response by DanieJ Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [33-1 J motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 100798] [l97cvI1743]

1010898 38 Response by Daniel SkIm in I97-cv-1 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in l97-cv-1 J 743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [35-1] motion to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (sad) [Entry date 101398] [I 97cvl1743]

102698 39 Motion by Daniel Sklu in I 97-cv-1 J 743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carll-lanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 62-RCL FILED cis filed (ktb) [Entry date 110498] [l97cv 11743]

1113198 40 Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to require Pitts to comply With Applicable Rules tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 111798] [l97cvI1743]

1113098 41 Response and Opposition by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to [39-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 I 62-RCL filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120398 J [197cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in l 97-cv-11743 Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-II 047 to suppress filed (bfc) [Entry date 120798] 1l97cv 11047 l97cv I 1743]

120498 42

4~120998 J Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- J ] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-ev-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-ev-11743 in opposition to [42-1 ] motion to suppress tiled cis (sad) IEntry date 121098] 1197cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting 139-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-lOI62-RCL (bfc) [197cvI1743]

0111499

011499

0311499 44

Consolidated Lead Case (ktb) IEntry date 062199] II 97cv I] 7431

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered granting [29- JJmotion for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery f shall in the future comply with Fed R Civ cal Rule 52 (b) AJI papers required to be served shall be served on every party and shall contain or be accompanied by proof of service in al legally permissalbe fonn indication the time and manner of service cclcl (ktb) [Entry date 032499] [1 97cv 11743]

Notice of change of address filed by Edward P Reardon in I97-cv-1174i FILED cis (ktb) IEntry date 050799]1197cv11743]

050399 45

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compeJ production of documents tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 0511 0199] [197cvI1743]

050399 46

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-1 J743 to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (ktb) IEntry date 0510199] 1l97cv 11743]

0503199 47

of28 04122002 1252

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

0411498 15

M Fahey filed (ktb) [Entry date 041398] [1 97cvI1743]

Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attomey Douglas 1 Louison for Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 attorney Bradford N Louison for Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 attorney Douglas l Louison for Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv- J J743 attorney Bradford N Louison fOlWayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

04116198

050498 16

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [13-1] motion to continue the initial schedu ling conference presently set for 411598 Motion alJowed The conference is hereby rescheduled to May 6 1998 at 4 15 pm (ktb) [Entry date 041798] [197cvI1743J

Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cY-11 743 to consoJidate cases filed cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

050598 17 Proposed Discovery Plan by Daniel Sklut lames Carlin Stephen Faucher Carl Hanson Chester Johnson Wayne Sampson Robert McGinley and Town of Shrewsbury filed cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

050598 18 Rule 161 Certification filed by Ms Carolyn J Hamel cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvlI743]

050598 J9 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Michael Hale cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [1 97cv I 1743]

050598 20 Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Chester Johnson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [I 97cv 11743]

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by Wayne Sampson cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [197cvJ 17431

21050598

Local Rule 161 Certification filed by James Hurley cis (rca) [Entry date 050698] [l97cvl] 743]

050598 22

Judge Mark L Wolf Scheduling Order entered setting Joining of parties amending of pleadings on 51598 Discovery cutoff 73099 case ready for trial on 11199 (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [197cvI1743]

050598 26

J~_1 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 lames Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I Y7-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- 11743 Robert McGinley in ] 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 for order on scheduling conference filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

050698

Joint Statement by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 050798] I 197cv 11743]

24050698

Scheduling conference held (ktb) [Entry date 050898] [I 97cvI1743]050698

Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes Court Reporter Coppola There are two other pending cases before Judge Saris Pltf states the essence of all three cases Pitt

050698

60f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv 11743 httpcivi1so1madcircldcndccaseno=1 1997cv11743ampp1ain=0amp1ive=F

opposes the consolidation Clerk Cronin and pltf shall talk to Barbara Billig Scheduling Order to be issued (ktb) [Entry date 0508981 [I 97cv 11743]

050698

050898

051198 27

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [23-1] motion for order on scheduling conference denying [16-1] motion to consolidate cases (bfc) [Entry date 0302199] [1 97cv 11743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [5-1] motion to extend time to 120 days to make service granting [4-11 motion for leave to file amended complaint (bfc) [l97cvI1743]

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [16-1] motion to consolidate cases filed cis (letb) ll97cv11743]

071598 Notice of change of address filed by Michael E1bery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

28

081298 29 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]898] [l97cvlI743]

0811398 30 Letter dated 8113l)amp to Judge Wolf re letter from Michael Elbery filed (sad) [Entry date 0811998] [197cv 11743]

0811598 31

091798 32

Copy of a Letter (non-motion) dated 81098 from Atty Liftman to Mr E1berty in receipt of a subpoena she received from him to permit inspection of ther deposition of John Nolan FILED (ktb) [Entry date 082798] [I 97cv I 1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Elizabeth M Fahey in 197-cv-11743 by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 092298] [I 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [I 97cv] 1743]

0911898 33

0911898 34 Motion by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-ll743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl 1-1 anson in I 97-cv-1 l743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l 97-cv-lI743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [1 97cv 117431

092498 35

1010598 3636

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (ktb)

Response by Daniel SkIu in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-ll743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-ev-11743 in opposition to [33-]] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1007981 [197cvI1743]

r------~ ---- ---

70f28 04122002 1252 PM

lHAgtt-ltK Civil Docket RepOli for 197evl1743 httpcivilsolmadeireldcndeeaseno=l 1997cvI1743ampplain=0amplive=F1

1010598 37 Response by DanieJ Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [33-1 J motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 100798] [l97cvI1743]

1010898 38 Response by Daniel SkIm in I97-cv-1 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in l97-cv-1 J 743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [35-1] motion to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (sad) [Entry date 101398] [I 97cvl1743]

102698 39 Motion by Daniel Sklu in I 97-cv-1 J 743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carll-lanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 62-RCL FILED cis filed (ktb) [Entry date 110498] [l97cv 11743]

1113198 40 Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to require Pitts to comply With Applicable Rules tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 111798] [l97cvI1743]

1113098 41 Response and Opposition by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to [39-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 I 62-RCL filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120398 J [197cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in l 97-cv-11743 Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-II 047 to suppress filed (bfc) [Entry date 120798] 1l97cv 11047 l97cv I 1743]

120498 42

4~120998 J Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- J ] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-ev-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-ev-11743 in opposition to [42-1 ] motion to suppress tiled cis (sad) IEntry date 121098] 1197cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting 139-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-lOI62-RCL (bfc) [197cvI1743]

0111499

011499

0311499 44

Consolidated Lead Case (ktb) IEntry date 062199] II 97cv I] 7431

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered granting [29- JJmotion for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery f shall in the future comply with Fed R Civ cal Rule 52 (b) AJI papers required to be served shall be served on every party and shall contain or be accompanied by proof of service in al legally permissalbe fonn indication the time and manner of service cclcl (ktb) [Entry date 032499] [1 97cv 11743]

Notice of change of address filed by Edward P Reardon in I97-cv-1174i FILED cis (ktb) IEntry date 050799]1197cv11743]

050399 45

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compeJ production of documents tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 0511 0199] [197cvI1743]

050399 46

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-1 J743 to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (ktb) IEntry date 0510199] 1l97cv 11743]

0503199 47

of28 04122002 1252

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv 11743 httpcivi1so1madcircldcndccaseno=1 1997cv11743ampp1ain=0amp1ive=F

opposes the consolidation Clerk Cronin and pltf shall talk to Barbara Billig Scheduling Order to be issued (ktb) [Entry date 0508981 [I 97cv 11743]

050698

050898

051198 27

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [23-1] motion for order on scheduling conference denying [16-1] motion to consolidate cases (bfc) [Entry date 0302199] [1 97cv 11743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [5-1] motion to extend time to 120 days to make service granting [4-11 motion for leave to file amended complaint (bfc) [l97cvI1743]

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [16-1] motion to consolidate cases filed cis (letb) ll97cv11743]

071598 Notice of change of address filed by Michael E1bery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 (ktb) [l97cv 11743]

28

081298 29 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-1 1743 for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]898] [l97cvlI743]

0811398 30 Letter dated 8113l)amp to Judge Wolf re letter from Michael Elbery filed (sad) [Entry date 0811998] [197cv 11743]

0811598 31

091798 32

Copy of a Letter (non-motion) dated 81098 from Atty Liftman to Mr E1berty in receipt of a subpoena she received from him to permit inspection of ther deposition of John Nolan FILED (ktb) [Entry date 082798] [I 97cv I 1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Elizabeth M Fahey in 197-cv-11743 by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 092298] [I 97cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [I 97cv] 1743]

0911898 33

0911898 34 Motion by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-ll743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl 1-1 anson in I 97-cv-1 l743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l 97-cv-lI743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092398] [1 97cv 117431

092498 35

1010598 3636

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (ktb)

Response by Daniel SkIu in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-ll743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-ev-11743 in opposition to [33-]] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1007981 [197cvI1743]

r------~ ---- ---

70f28 04122002 1252 PM

lHAgtt-ltK Civil Docket RepOli for 197evl1743 httpcivilsolmadeireldcndeeaseno=l 1997cvI1743ampplain=0amplive=F1

1010598 37 Response by DanieJ Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [33-1 J motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 100798] [l97cvI1743]

1010898 38 Response by Daniel SkIm in I97-cv-1 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in l97-cv-1 J 743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [35-1] motion to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (sad) [Entry date 101398] [I 97cvl1743]

102698 39 Motion by Daniel Sklu in I 97-cv-1 J 743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carll-lanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 62-RCL FILED cis filed (ktb) [Entry date 110498] [l97cv 11743]

1113198 40 Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to require Pitts to comply With Applicable Rules tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 111798] [l97cvI1743]

1113098 41 Response and Opposition by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to [39-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 I 62-RCL filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120398 J [197cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in l 97-cv-11743 Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-II 047 to suppress filed (bfc) [Entry date 120798] 1l97cv 11047 l97cv I 1743]

120498 42

4~120998 J Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- J ] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-ev-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-ev-11743 in opposition to [42-1 ] motion to suppress tiled cis (sad) IEntry date 121098] 1197cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting 139-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-lOI62-RCL (bfc) [197cvI1743]

0111499

011499

0311499 44

Consolidated Lead Case (ktb) IEntry date 062199] II 97cv I] 7431

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered granting [29- JJmotion for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery f shall in the future comply with Fed R Civ cal Rule 52 (b) AJI papers required to be served shall be served on every party and shall contain or be accompanied by proof of service in al legally permissalbe fonn indication the time and manner of service cclcl (ktb) [Entry date 032499] [1 97cv 11743]

Notice of change of address filed by Edward P Reardon in I97-cv-1174i FILED cis (ktb) IEntry date 050799]1197cv11743]

050399 45

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compeJ production of documents tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 0511 0199] [197cvI1743]

050399 46

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-1 J743 to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (ktb) IEntry date 0510199] 1l97cv 11743]

0503199 47

of28 04122002 1252

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

lHAgtt-ltK Civil Docket RepOli for 197evl1743 httpcivilsolmadeireldcndeeaseno=l 1997cvI1743ampplain=0amplive=F1

1010598 37 Response by DanieJ Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-lI743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [33-1 J motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 100798] [l97cvI1743]

1010898 38 Response by Daniel SkIm in I97-cv-1 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in l97-cv-1 J 743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [35-1] motion to require court reporter to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript filed cis (sad) [Entry date 101398] [I 97cvl1743]

102698 39 Motion by Daniel Sklu in I 97-cv-1 J 743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carll-lanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 62-RCL FILED cis filed (ktb) [Entry date 110498] [l97cv 11743]

1113198 40 Motion by Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to require Pitts to comply With Applicable Rules tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 111798] [l97cvI1743]

1113098 41 Response and Opposition by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to [39-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-10 I 62-RCL filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120398 J [197cvI1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in l 97-cv-11743 Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-II 047 to suppress filed (bfc) [Entry date 120798] 1l97cv 11047 l97cv I 1743]

120498 42

4~120998 J Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- J ] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-ev-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-ev-11743 in opposition to [42-1 ] motion to suppress tiled cis (sad) IEntry date 121098] 1197cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting 139-1] motion to consolidate case with 98-CY-lOI62-RCL (bfc) [197cvI1743]

0111499

011499

0311499 44

Consolidated Lead Case (ktb) IEntry date 062199] II 97cv I] 7431

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered granting [29- JJmotion for order of court that pltf comply with the FRCP Concerning Discovery f shall in the future comply with Fed R Civ cal Rule 52 (b) AJI papers required to be served shall be served on every party and shall contain or be accompanied by proof of service in al legally permissalbe fonn indication the time and manner of service cclcl (ktb) [Entry date 032499] [1 97cv 11743]

Notice of change of address filed by Edward P Reardon in I97-cv-1174i FILED cis (ktb) IEntry date 050799]1197cv11743]

050399 45

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compeJ production of documents tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 0511 0199] [197cvI1743]

050399 46

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-1 J743 to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (ktb) IEntry date 0510199] 1l97cv 11743]

0503199 47

of28 04122002 1252

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno= I 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

051399 48 Response by Daniel SkJut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [46-1 ] motion to compel production of documents filed cis (bfc) [I 97cv 11743]

051399 49 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-l ]743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-1] motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months filed cis (bfc) [197cvI1743]

051399 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [50-1] motion for protective order Allowed The depositions shall be scheduled for May 20 June 492324 or 25 1999 Defts shall pay all reasonable expenses incurred by pltf due to cancellation of the Mmay 18 1999 deposition (faxed 51799 to Elizabeth Fahey abd Anthony Doniger Esq)) (ktb) [Entry date 0511799] [197cvI1743]

051499 Emergency Motion (Request) by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 for protective order filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [197cvl1743]

50

0511799 90 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses for enlargemen1 of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvl1743]

93051999 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [85- j I motion to compel [85-2J motion to compel [85-3] motion ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring 10 attend pltfs deposition of McGin ley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cs(received for docketing on 82799) dope (ktb) [Entry date 08319911-1 97cv 1743]

940511999 Response by Daniel Sklu1 in J 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-l1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-l1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts ray for future deposition and expenses filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0813199J [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel1he Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [I 97cv 11743]

OS2499 51

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS25991 [197cvI1743]

OS2499 52

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to amend [I-I] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date OS2599] [1 97cv 11743]

OS2499 53

Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-l l743 in opposition to [51-]] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts 10 Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis

060199

90f28 04l22002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cvl1743 htlplcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

(ktb) [EntlY date 0621199] [197cvI1743]

060199 55 Memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-I 1743 in opposition to [51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Dens Lo Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199]11 97cv 11743]

060899 56 Notice by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 of defts poor Conduct at Pltfs Deposition June 4 1999 FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0621199] [1 97cv I 1743]

060899 57 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-1 1743 to response to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry dale 062199] [I 97cvl1743]

060999 58 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- I J743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-I 1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-I] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [I 97cv 11743]

060999 59 Response by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chcster Johnson in 197-cv-l 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [51-1] motion to compel the Shrcwsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs interrogatories filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062199] [197cvI1743]

Response by James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chestcr Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [53-1 J motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062299] [I 97cv I 1743]

0611499 60

Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint filed (ktb) [Entry date 0622991 [1 97cv11743]

0611599 61

0611899 62

0612399 64

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-lI743 in support of [51-1] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories filed cis (ktb)

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-l 1743 to [56-I] remark filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 062499] [I 97cvI1743]

John Nolans Motion to quash deposition and for protective order filed cis Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

062499 63

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [63-1] motion to quash deposition granting [63-2] motion for protective order without prejudice Allowed with regard to the deposition scheduled for June 25 1999 without prejuduce to a decision by the Magistrate Judge regarding whether any deposition should occur later and the scope of documentation production This case is hereby REFERRED to the magistrate Judge for all permissabJe purposes prior to trial ccc1 [EOD Date 62499] (ktb) [Edit date 062499] [l97cvl 1743]

062499

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Joyce L Alexander062499

04122002 1252 PM100f28

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11 743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvI1743ampp1ain=0amplive=F

Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

062899 66 Notice regarding pltfs depositions in Sklut case by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I1743 by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

062899 67

0710299 68

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l 1743 for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena for order of COUlt that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged And Pltfs Opposition to John A Nolans Motion to Quash Subpoenaed FILED cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered This court hereby recuses itself from Elbery v Sklut and Elbery v Sheketoff pursuant to 28 USCA Sec 455(a) SO ORDERED [EOD Date 71299] (ktb) [Entry date 07l299] [J 97cv1 1743]

070999 69 Joh Nolans Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071299] [l97cvI1743]

071299 70 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [197cvl J743]

071299 Response in opposition to [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 071699] [I 97cv 11743]

71

Judge Mark L Wolf ORDER entered referral to Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Purpose Special Instructions For All pretrial purposes (ktb) [Entry date 07l699] [I 97cv 11743]

071599 72

Response in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [I 97cv 11743]

071699 74

Motion by John B Nolan amp Sons to quash Depsoition Subpoena Objection to Production inspection and Copying of Documents and Motion for Protective Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [Edit date 072199] [I 97cvI1743]

071699 75

c---~middotmiddotmiddotmiddot_~-~ t~--~~~~~ -m bull ----~ ~ ~__~u

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoenas and Motion to Enlarge Discovery Period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [1 97cv I 1743]

071999 76

~__ ~~_ _~ ~ __m _ __~~__~ laquo_____middot~_~middot_middotmiddotm~~~ __middot middot_m~_middotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot_laquo__ _~ ~ ___~_

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072199] [J 97cv 11743]

07] 999 77

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Status Conference set status conference for 1000 8399 before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler ccc (rca) [] 97cv1 [743]

072099 73

-__-___- ~~---_ _-- -----~---___---~ _----------~

11 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for [97cvl [743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

072199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [70-11 motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition denying [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deaulted by Dennis King as Subpoenaed denying [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period [EOD Date 72199] Denied without prejuduce This cOUIi will review all disocvery issues at the conference scheduled for August 3 1999 at 1000 aI11 (ktb) r I97cv 11743]

072299

1 middotmbull bull tmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot

072299 78

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [75-1] motion to quash Depsoition Subpoena granting [75-2] motion for Protective Order [EOD Date 72299] wed Allowed This court will review all discovery issues at the status conference (ktb) [J 97cvI1743]

_ _ - ~-

Letter by Douglas I Louison in 197-cv-11743 dated 72199 advising that he has withdrawn from the case as a result of the successor appearance by Atty Elizabeth Fahey and thus will not be at the 8399 status conference FILED (ktb) fl 97cv 11743]

072899 79 Response by Daniel SkJut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in ] 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-] 1743 Chester Johnson in [97-cv-1 1743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 072999] [I 97cv] 1743]

080399

080399 86

Status conference held (kd) [Entry date 081199] [1 97cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re status conference held COUli addresses counsel as to Procedure and Discovery issues Pro Se Plaintiff addresses cOUli as to discovery Counsel for defendant addresses court Discovery to be completed by 10l99 Counsel for Dennis Klug addresses the court Dispositive Motions due 111199 Responses by 121199 set Motion hearing for 100081699 Court Reporter tape 99-19 (kd) [Entry date 0811 [99] fl 97cv 11743]

Reply Briefby Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in support of various discovery issues at 8-3-99 hearing tiled (mlb) [l97cvlI743]

080599 80

Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 to compel to compel ro sanction Atty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pJtfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [l97cvI1743]

080599 85

080699 81 Response by Daniel Skim in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 J 743 Stephen Faucher inl 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-I1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in l97-cv-11743 in opposition to [47-IJ motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months and in opposition to motion to compel deft to pay costs of defaulted depofiJed (eaf) [197cv 11743]

Supplement to Pltfs Motion to Amended Complaint with James Coates and Objection to Judge Bowlers Preventing Oral Argument on Coates Amendment and Resultant Due Process of Law Violation FI LED cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvI1743]

82080699

Response by Daniel SkIm in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in l97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in l97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case filed

080699 83

120f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket RepOli for l97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=11997cv 1I743ampplain=Oamplive=Fi

i cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] [197cvJ 1743]

080699 84 Response by Daniel Sklut in ] 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in ] 97-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-] 1743 in opposition to [70-1] motion to compel Witness Dennis Kings Attendance at Deposition [70-2] motion to access costs of Deposition Deau Ited by Dennis King as Subpoenaed [70-3] motion to extend the discovery period filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 080999] P97cv11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for reconsideration of allowing pitts second set of document requests or to compel defts to respond to pItts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08] 1199] [197cvlI743]

081 099 87

0811 1199 88 Notice of Michael Elbery Status of 81399 Deposition in I 97-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08]299]ll97cvI1743]

08] 3199 89 Notice Regarding 813199 Pretrial Hearing by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 08il7199] I I97cv 11743]

08116199 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [67-1] motion for order of Court Order Compelling Documentation as per the pltfs 6-14-99 Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-2] motion for order of Court order Crediting Witness Fees paid to John Nolan to be Creditied to future E-Z Subpoena granting in part denying in part [67-3] motion for order of Court that subpoenaed documentation is not Privileged Allowed in part and Denied in Part to the extent set fOlih in open court on this date The June 14 1999 subpoena directed to John A Nolan as opposed to E-2 Mini Storage is not a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notice Nolan whi resdies in Minnesota is not requitred to appear or prodcue the requested documents See fedR Civ P45(b)(2) Nolans counsel shall produce the single report referred to in open cOUIi on this date A Rule 3O(b)(6) deposition of the person designated by E-Z Mini Storage as knowledgeable with rcpect to the 894 fIre shall take place on 9 199 at 200 pm as set forth in open court on 81699 The motions are otherwise DENEID as except as set forth in open court on this date [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743J

r~~----~~~~ ~ -~_ rm~~~-- wm~~~~~U~w__gt ~ _~__~__ wm~middot ~_ middot~m_~~__middotN _~~~_~~_~~_~~~

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [35-1 J motion to require court repoJier to allow this pltfto review transcript of deposition transcript [EOD Date 82099J Denied to the extent that pltf shall be allowed to rebiew the deposition transcripts in uaccordance with the time frame and the procedure set forth in FedR iv P 30(e) Defts indicate that pltfwas given the oppurtunity and did complete an errata sheet See Docket entry 43 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvI1743]

0811699

laquo n _gtn m __ _ _ __bullbull

0811699 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [77-1] motion to Ban Attorney Joe Coppola from the Depositions held on the case [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [197cvl1743]

~_~~~~~~ ~__~m~ ~~_ bull__~_ bullbull_bullbull~_~~_~~_~ bullbullbull__bullbullbullbull~_~~~=~=_~_~~~~~~_~__ __~~~

Magistrate Judge Mariane Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [90-1] motion to compel attendance at the pltfs deposition denying [90-2] motion pltfs motion to require defts pay for future deposition and expenses denying [90-3] Illotion for enlargement of time of discovery period due to defts continued delay tactics [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [1 97cv 11743]

0811699

08] 699 Mag Judge Marianne Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [47-1J motion to Extend the Discovery Period by 6 months [EOD Date 82099] Denied except as to the extent that discovery is extended until October I 1999 (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

~ --~~~- r-middot~--~ ~~~~-

13 of28 04122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

bullbullbull

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cvl1743 hrtplcivilsolmadcirc 1dcndccaseno=1 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

081699 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [85-1] motion to compel denying [85-2] motion to compel denying [85-3] motion ro sanction Arty Liz Fahey for ignoring to attend pltfs deposition of McGinley and to enlarge discovery period to allow for McGinleys Deposition [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] I 197cv I 1743]

081699

081699

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [34-1 J motion to compel the deft to produce clear and readable copies of discoverable documents [EOD Date 82099] Defts represent that they produced the best copies available of the documents and that the originals are available for inspection (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvI1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [4-1] motion for leave to file amended complaint [EO D Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [l97cvlI743]

081699 91 Amended complaint by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

081699

081699 92

Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cv II 743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes Motion Hearing held Counsel to Charles Nolan and Sons addrresses the Court Pltf addresses the court as to discovery issues Counsel to Town of Shrewsbury addresses the court Court establishes deposition schedule for 9199 Counsel to Robert Sheketoff addreses court as to discovery motions Conf set for 92999 at 1000 am (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [1 97cvI1743]

081799 Magistrate Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [53-1] motion to amend [1-1] complaint Denied The Motion is untimley in light of the May 5 1998 Scheduling Order requiring thatAmendment of the pleadingsshalJ be filed by May 15 1998 In addition defts represent that their initial discovery disclosure included a copy fa police paperwork indication Officer Coates in involvement Accordingly pltfs argument that this Shrewsbury Police Dept concelaed Officer Cotates identity is without merit and does not provide an adequate basisto allow the late filing Not withstanding pltfs failure to seek leave of court this court considered pltfs supplemental filings (Docket entry 61 and 82) I [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 082099] [Edit date 082099] [l 97cvl 1743]

08]799 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [33-1] motion to compel production of subpoenaed documentation Arty Liftman is not under a obligation to produce to pItf without costs acopy of the transcript of the deposition of John A Nolan [EOD Date 82099] (ktb) [Entry date 0820991 [Edit date 082099] [I 97cvI1743]

r bullbullbull-~_bullbullbull~~- ~~ m

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [42-1 J motion to suppress [EOD Date 92999] (ktb) [Entry date 092999] [I 97cvI1743]

081799

~~~~~~_~~_~ m bullbullbull ~~ ~~w_~bull~__~ bullbullbull bullbull~~ ~__ w~__~~_~~_middot~

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-] l743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Subpoenaed Documentation of Charles D Nolan amp Sons FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0831199] [l97cvI1743]

083099 95

Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 re [0-0] endorsed order Regarding Amendments of James Coates filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 083199] [1 97cv 11743]

083099 96

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

97083199

140f28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil ~ocket Report for I97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

083199 98 Motion by Dennis Klug for protective order re 9199 deposition tiled cis (ktb) [l97cvl1743]

083199 99 Memorandum in SUppolt of [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

083199 100 Dennis Klug named deft in 98-12468PBS Response in opposition to [97-[] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cvI1743]

083199 101 Motion by Dennis Klug named deft in Elbery v King CA 98-12468-PBS for protective order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 090199] [197cv11743]

090199 102 Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [98-1] motion for protective order re 9199 deposition filed cis (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

0910399 103 Emergency Motion by Roben Sheketoff in I 97-cv-II 743 for protective order filed cis (ktb) [ I97cv I 1743]

0910499 ludge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [103-1] motion for protective order [EOD Date 9799] (ktb) [Entry date 090799] [ I 97cv 11743]

090799 104 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [103- 11 motion for protective order tiled cis (ktb) [Entry date 090899] [I 97cvI1743]

090799 105 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- I J 743 to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition and Objection to Deposition of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0910899] [I 97cvl 1743]

0911 099 106 Notice of withdrawal of counsel by attomey Elizabeth M Fahey for Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 1743 attorney Elizabeth M Fahey for Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091399] [l97cvI1743]

10809114199

091499 J09

091599 107

Motion by Robert Sheketotf in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0911599] [l97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklu in I97-cv-11743 lames Carlin in 197-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv- I 1743 Chester Johnson in l97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robelt McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 Robelt Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-1 1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-l 1743 in support of[l08-1] motion for sanctions for pltfs failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 091599] [I 97cv I 1743]

r~ =~~_ _~~m~~middotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middot__~_~~_Y~_~-~~m___~ -__~_~~ __

Charles D Nolan amp Sons Incs Response in opposition to [105- I] motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 17431

04122002 1252 PM150f28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

092099 1] 0 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 092 I199] [197cvI1743]

r~~~-yen~--- _~----~-~~~

092799 II [ Objection by Michael Elbery in I97-cv- J 1743 to Magistrate Judges Handling of Discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 092899] fl 97cv11743]

092899 113 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cvl 1743]

092999 112

r---~

092999

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to PItfs Various Motions s to Entend Discovery FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cvI1743]

--- ------shy

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [10 I-I Jmotion for protective order [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvl1743]

092999 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [98-11 motion for protective order re 911 99 deposition [EOD Date 913099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cv 11743]

092999

092999

092999

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [97-1] motion to compel Dennis Klug to Deposition [EOD Date 930991Granted The pltf is directed to give reasonable notice (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [I 97cv I 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in pari [108-1] motion for sanctions for pitts failure to answer interrogatories or alternatively to compel answers As stated in open cpurt on this date the motion tocompel is allowed to the extent that pltf shall respond to interrogatories by 10399 The motion for sanctions is Denied without prejudice at th is time to be renewed at the conclusion of the case [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [197cv 11743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [40-1] motion to require Pltfs to comply With Applicable Rules [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI174j]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [46-1] motion to compel production of documents cccl [EOD Date 930991 (ktb) [Entry date 093099] [1 97cvI1743]

092999

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered denying [105-1 J motion to send knowledgeable witness for new deposition [EOD Date 93099] (ktb) [Entry date 0930 99] [ I 97cvI1743]

092999

Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 1743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv- I 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [87-2J motion to compel defts to respond to pitts document request filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 093099J [I 97cvl1743]

092999 114

160f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cvl1743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=I1997cv I I743ampplain=0ampJive=F

] J5092999 Objection by William T Bill Walls and Houston General Insuance Companys Objections to Subpoena FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date] 00199] [1 97cv 11743]

0929199 116 Affidavit of Willaim T Bill Walls FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 100199] [1 97cvI1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date 100499] [l97cv 11743]

r-v~~ m~ rm~~ ~m_~~~=~ _= ~~_~~ bullbull__~~_ u__~=_~ ~=w=__ __

092999 118 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler CJerks Notes re Status Conference Court Reporter TAPE (ktb) [Entry date 1010499] [197cv 11743]

100199 117 Response in opposition of Crum amp Forster Insurance and United States Fire Insurance Company to [113-1 J motion to compel filed cis (ktb) [1 97cv 11743]

101499 119 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulinglOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pitts 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested FILED cis filed (ktb) [197cv 11743]

101899 120 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [I 97cy 11743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Dept of Treasury shy101899 121 BATF to Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [I 97cvl 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed cis (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

101899 122

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cy-11743 to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1012199] [197cv I ] 743]

102099 123

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cy-11743 to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1021199]

l24102099

Response in opposition to [120-1 J motion to compel Bi II Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102199] [197cvI1743]

102099 125

126102299 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 200 1l1799 for [113-1] motion to compel set for 200 111799 for [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed set for 200 1l1799 for [12 I -I J motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF Produce Documents set for 200 I 111799 for [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 200 ] 1] 799 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled ccleI (rca) [l97cY] 1743]

Status conference held (ktb) [Entry date l02599] [ 97cY I 1743]102299

0411212002 1252 PM 17 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cvlI743ampplain=0amplive=F

102299 127

lO2299

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Status Con Court Reporter TAPE Court addresses parties as to status of pending discovery Pltf adresses court as to pending discovery motions Court to schedule hearings on motions Nos 113 and 120 Court allowes response period to run for motions [21123124 even though discovery cut off has passed Court sets hearing on pending discovery motions for 1111799 at 300 pm Re s I 13120121123 and 124 Court recesses Court resumes (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [Edit date 102599] [197cvl 1743]

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting in part denying in part [I 10-1 j motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Produce Second Document Requesti Motion allowed in part and denied in part in accrdance with rulings made in open comi [EO D Date 102599) (ktb) [Entry date 102599] t I 97cv11743]

102299 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered withdrawing r51-I] motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police Defts to Answer Pltfs Interrogatories Withdrawn in open court [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date lO2599] [197cvI1743]

102299

102599 128

110399 129

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered [52-I) motion to compel the Shrewsbury Police efts to produce Documentation as Requested Pltf states in open court that this docket entry ad duplicative of docket 46 [EOD Date 102599] (ktb) [Entry date 102599] [197cv I 1743)

~-~--~-~-~~~~~~-

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [I 19- J] Motion to Judge Wolf and Response to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested filed (ktb) [1 97cv I 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 for review of the IO2299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) [197cv J 1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv- I 1743 to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pltfs Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date II II 899] [I 97cv 11743]

IIIJ 599 130

Motion hearing re [121-1] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents Motion hearing held [l20-1 ] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed Motion hearing held [I J3-1] motion to compel Motion hearing held (ktb) [Entry date ] 11899] [197cvI1743]

111799

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [121- I] motion to compel the Dept of Treasury - BATF to Produce Documents denying [120-1] motion to compel Bill Walls and Houston General Insurance Cpo to Produce Documents as Subpoenaed denying [113-1] motion to compel Court Reporter Tape (ktb) [Entry date 111899) [197cv I1743]

l1l1799 J 31

Notice of appearance of attorneys Kelley A Niclkson and Robert Pierce for dennis KJug and Days Inn Motel FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1201991 [197cvI17431

132112999

I 12999 I ~ ~

JJ Response by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-1 1743 Days Inn Motel (parties in a related action in Elbery V Klug et als CA 98-12468-PBS in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation of this Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 120699] [197cvlI743]

i __~~_ ~- _ ~ ~_ _-__ _-_shy ~~~ ~---~------~-~=

180f28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

__

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv [ 1743 httpcivilso1madcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv11743ampplain=0amplive=F

120299 134 Motion and request for a Hearing by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 for review of Magistrates 11799 ruling re PItfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 120799] [197cvl 1743]

120899 135 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-ll743 to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of pltf filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 121399] [197cv I 1743]

122799 136 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment ofpltf filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv11743]

010600 137 Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 Daniel SkIut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 l743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv- I 1743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-l 1743 Raben Sheketoff in I97-cv- J 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 Sheketoffamp Homan in l97-cv-J 1743 in opposition to [136-1] motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pItf filed (ktb) [l 97cvI1743]

0111900 138 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 to extend time to to filed (ktb) [Entry date 0112400] [J97cv 11743]

r---~-~ bull-~~- ~~-~ - -~-- _~_

020300 Mag Judge Bowler Endorsed Order entered granting [138- J] motion to extend time to reply to Defts opposition to Motion to Freeze Action [EOD Date 2 1000] (ktb) [Entry date 021000] [Edit date 021000] [l97cvI1743]

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv- 11743 FILED CIS (ktb) [Entry date 022200] [I 97cv 11743]

021700 139

022900 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered denying [130-1] motion to reconsider Magistrates Violation ofthis Pitts Due Process Regarding Deposition Fee Due to Default of Dennis King S pltf has not shown either an abuse of discretion or error of Jaw by the Magistrate Judge this Motion is hereby Denied cccl [EOD Date 22900] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

]40022900

031500 141

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered It is ORDERED that the defts shan by 31500 file oppositions or other responsive pleadings 10 each of the following motions and objections of the pltf PItts objection to the Magistrates handling of subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan and Sons (Docket No 95 CA 97-11743-MLW) [EOD Date 31100] cccl (ktb) [Entry date 030100] [l 97cv 11743]

Reply by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv- 11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-l 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-1 J743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to response to Pitts Objection to magistrates Handling of Subpoenaed documents of Charles D Nolan amp Sons Inc FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvI1743]

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-1 [743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-l 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-ll743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to PItts Objection to Magistrats Ruling on Pltfs First Document Request FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [197cvll743]

142031500

_ __ (~~_ ~~ ~ ~mm~~~~ bullbull~~ _n~_middot~

19 of28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I 97cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Idcndccaseno= I 1997cv11743 ampplain=Oamplive=F

0311500 143 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-1 1743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to [134-IJ motion for review of Magistrates 111799 rul ing re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cvl 1743]

031500 144 Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv- J 1743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-11743 Chester Jolmson in 197-cv-1 J 743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town ofin 197-cv-11743 to [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins CoBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 031700] [I 97cv II 743]

0315100 145 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-l] 743 James Carlin in I97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-] 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-] 1743 to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [] 97cv 1743]

0311600 146

031600 147

Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-l 1743 James Carlin in 197-cv-] ] 743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [95-1 J miscellaneous filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700] [197cv 11743]

Response by Charles D Nolan amp So in I97-cv-I1743 in opposition to [122-1] motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition filed (ktb) [Entry date 0311700J [1 97cv11743J

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 32200 at 032000 1100 am (ktb) [Entry date 032100] [I 97cv 11743J

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 (ktb) [Entry date 0321100J [1 97cv I 1743J

032000 148

------- rmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddotmiddot_middotmiddot~- ------ ------------- _-__-_ -- shy149 Replyresponse by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743

Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester JoImson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 to [Ill-I] miscellaneous filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [197cv 11743J

032200

Response by Daniel SkIu in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-1 1743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv- 11743 in opposition to Pltfs Objection to Magistrates ruling on the amendment of James Coates FILED (ktb) [Entry date 032400] [1 97cvlI743]

ISO032200

Response by Daniel Skiut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in l97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-1 ]743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [129-l]

1510322100

motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents filed (ktb) lEntry date

200f28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

- - -- -

CHASER Civil uocket Report for l97cvI1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=R

032400J [l97cv 11743J

033 J 00 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [135-1] motion to suspend or freeze action due to i prosonment of p]tf [EOD Date 33L1001 (ktb) [197cvI17431

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [136-1J motion to suspend or freeze action fue to imprisonment of pltf [EOD Date 33100J (ktb) [1 97cvl1743]

033100

033100 152 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Memorandum and Order entered denying [87-11 motion for reconsideration of allowing pltfs second set of document requests denying [87-2J motion to compel clefts to respond to pltfs document request [EOD Date 331001 (ktb) [197cvll7431

040300 153 Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Notice of motion Hearing Motion hearing before Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler set for 103042400 for [123-1J motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents set for 103042400 for [124-11 motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled cclcl (rca) [1 97cv11743J

042000

_~~_~ r~m~_

042400

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents [EOD Date 4251001 Moot the answers having been provided to the staisfaction of this court having reviewed the documents produced in open court this date (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvll7431

m~~~~~__m~ _bullbullbull_bull__~~_~~_ ~~~~~~__middot~_m ~_middot bullbullbullbullbullbull _bullbullbullbullbull _~___ ~bullbullbullbull_______ w_

Motion hearing re [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents Motion hearing held [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled rvlotion hearing held (ktb) [1 97cv117431

042400 154 Magistrate Judge Bowler Clerks Notes re Motion Hearing mooting [123-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pklfs Subpoena and Produce Docwnents mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled Court informs the panies that with no other issues pending in the case it will be turned over to the District Judge Coun Reporter Tape (ktb) [Edit date 0425001 [197cvlI743]

CASF NO LONGER REFERRED TO Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler (ktb) [l97cvIJ047197cvlI743]

042400

Motion(s) no longer referred [l24-I] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled lI23-1] motion to compel the Massachusetts Dept of Public Safety to Respond to pktfs Subpoena and Produce Documents (ktb) [I 97cv117431

042400

042400

~__~~_~~ ___w

042400 155

Mag udge Marianne B Bowler Endorsed Order entered mooting [124-1] motion to compel the Commonwealth of mass Crime Lab to produce Documents as Compelled [EOD Date 425001 (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [1 97cv l 1743]

____~~____~ _~m~~~___~____ ____~__ _ _

Mag Judge Marianne B Bowler Order entered This case was referred to this court for pretrial purposes (Docket Entry 72) [EOD Date 42500] (ktb) [Entry date 042500] [I 97cvlI743]

r

21 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CiviJ Docket Report for 197cv J1743 httpcivilsolmadcirc Jdcndccaseno~ I 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

042800 156 PJtfs Notice Regarding the 42400 discovery hearing filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 050100] [197cvI17431

05105100 157 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for leave to file discovery late filed Referred to Judge Mark L Wolf(bfc) [1 97cvl17431

072500 158 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay case with notice of address change FILED (lctb) [Entry date 07 3UOOI 1197cvl 1743]

0811 000 159 Reply by Michael EJbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to fl58-1] motion to stay case filed cis (ktb) [I 97cv I 1743]

092800

092800

Tenninated document denying fl58-I] motion to stay case Requested by mlw to 92800 Memorandum and Order (ktb) [Entry date 092900] rI 97cvl 1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting rI 45-1] motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying r119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce docwnents as requested denying [122-1] Illation for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review ofthe 102299 Magistrates Ruling on PltPs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 1111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1] Objection Pretrial conference set for 12600 at 300 pm cccl [EOD Date 92900] (ktb) [Entry date 092900] [Edit date 092900] [197cvI1743]

092800 180 Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered granting [145-1 J motion to extend time to 32200 to file respondive pleadings or oppositions to Pltfs Motions and Objections denying [119-1] motion to Judge Wolf and Objection to Magistrates RulingOrder on Discovery Issue Regarding Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 1st set of documents and failure of deft SPD to produce documents as requested denying [122-1 J motion for review of Magistrate Judges ruling on Discovery Issue Re Failure of Charles D Nolan amp Sonss to prodcue Knowledgable Witness for Deposition denying [129-1] motion for review of the 102299 Magistrates Ruling on Pltfs 2nd Set of Documents and Failure of Deft SPD to Prodcue Documents denying [134-1] motion for review of Magistrates 111799 ruling re Pltfs Subpoena for Documents to Houston General Ins ColBill Walls Crumb and Foster - US Fire Inc Co denying [96-1 j [EOD Date 92900] Objection PTC set for 126200 ccc (ktb) [Entry date 09 29001 rl97cvI1743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered set pretrial conference for 300 12600 trial to be scheduled atht eh pretrial conference ccc [EOD Date 10300] (ktb) [Entry date 100300j [197cv117431

092800 181

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting f157-1] motion for leave to file discovery late [EOD Date 103000] (bfc) [Entry date 1030100] [I 97cv 11743]

092800

Motion by Dennis Klug in 197-cv-11743 for order of Dismissal filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 101900] [197evI1743]

182101 8100

Motion by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- I 1743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv- 11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l 97-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment and for a separate and final judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

183102700

220f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsolmadcirc1dcndccaseno=l 1997cv I I743ampplain=Oamplive=F

102700 184

185102700

102700 186

Affidavit of Robert Sheketoff in I97-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [1 97cv 11743J

Affidavit of Karen McNutt Esq FILED es (ktb) [Entry date 03000] [197cvI1743]

middotmiddotmiddotmiddotlaquolaquo~middotmiddotmiddot~w__umiddotmiddotmiddot bullbull_bullbull~_~middot~

Statement of Facts by Robert Shckctoffin l97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in l97-cv-1 1743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [197cvI1743]

102700 187 Affidavit of Anthony M Doniger in 197-cv-11743 re [183-1] motion for summary judgment filed (ktb) [Entry date 103000] [l97cvI1743]

102700 188 Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-lI743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 103100] [197cvI1743]

102700 189 Motion by Michael Elbery in l97-cv-11743 for clarification of 92800 Order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1013100] [I 97cv 11743]

1112900 190 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-I1743 Robert Sheketoffin I97-cv-1 ] 743 Kimberly Homan in I97-cv-11743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 Charles D Nolan amp So in I 97-cv-11743 Dennis Kug in I 97-cv-l 1743 Days Inn lote in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order filed (bfc) [I 97cvI1743]

Pretrial memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-J 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv- 11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I97-cv-l1743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-lI743 filed (bfc) [I 97cv I 1743]

191I 13000

1921201100

120400 J 93

Pretrial memorandum by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv- 11743 fIled cis (ktb) [Entry date 120400] [197cvl 743]

Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered The docket shall changed to reflect the pJtfs address as Michael Wlberty SECC 12 Administrative Road Bridgewater MA 02324The hearing shceduled for 121600 is RESCHEDULED for 22601 at 300cccl [EOD Date 12400] (ktb) [I97cvl 1743]

Motion by Dennis Klug in I 97-cv-11743 Days Inn Motel in I97-cv-l1743 for separate and fma judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 122600] [I 97cv 11743]

194122100

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to Defts Request toppose Pltfs Summary Judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [I 97cv 11743]

010210 I 202

Objection by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-I 1743 re [180-1] memorandum order re discovery FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [1 97cv 11743]

010501 195

Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-l 1743 for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 0110801] [197cvl 1743]

1960l050 I

23 0[28 041212002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv11743 httpcivilsoLmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=Oamplive=F

OliOSOJ 197 Exhibits (List of Attachments) by Michael Elbery in support of l97-cv-1 1743 [196-1] motion for summary judgment FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 0108011 [197cvI1743]

010501 198 Memorandum by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in SllppOit of[ 196-1) motion for summary judgment against the Shrewsbury Police Defts and the Town of Shrewsbury FILED cis (ktb) [Entry date 010801] [197c I 1743]

0105101 199 Schedule of Abbreviations to Pltts memorandum in Support of pitts motion for summary judgment FILED (ktb) [Entry date 0108101] [l97cv11743]

010501 200 Affidavits of Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc 196) FILED filed (ktb) [Entry date 011080 I] [I 97cv 11743]

01117101 201 Motion by Daniel SkIm in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-ll743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv- j 1743 to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [197cv11743]

012201 Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [20 I-I] motion to extend time to 112601 to file opposition to pItts motion for summary judgment cccl [EOD Date 1250 I J (ktb) [Entry date 01250 1J [197cv1 1743J

012410 J Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-II743 to disqualify Judge Mark Will filed (ktb) [Entry date 01250 I] [197cv I (743)

203

Judge Mark L Wolf Endorsed Order entered granting [201-1 J motion to extend time to 1260 I to file opposition to pitts motion for summary judgment ccc1 [EOD Date l290 I] (ktb) [Entry date 011290 I] [I 97cv 11743)

01240 I

Response by Daniel Sklut in l97-cv-11743 James Carlin in l97-cv-lI743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-I ]743 Carl Hanson in ] 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-l) motion for summary judgment filed (bfc) [Entry date 011290]] [197cvI1743]

012601 204

01260 I 205

~_~~~~w___

020110 I 206

Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-I 1743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-l 1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-l743 Carl Hanson in 197-cv-1 ]743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in ] 97-cv-11743 in support of [204-1] opposition response filed (bfc)

_~ ~ ~ ___~__~ __~_~~_~~~~ ~____m

Response by Robert Sheketoff in 197-cv-1 1743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [203-1] motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wolf filed cis (wattachments) (ktb) [I 97cvI1743]

Memorandum by Robel1 Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [196-1] motion for summary judgment and in further support ofthir motion for sj filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

02080 J 207

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [203-IJ motion to disqualify Judge Mark Wi1f[EOD Date 22001] cc(cl (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

20802200 I

r- ~m~m~middot_~middotmiddotm ~~~~ __middotmiddotmiddot m_middotmiddot~~m middotw_~ ~--~ ~-~_ bullbull ~~~~~--~----__- bull~

24 of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for I97cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l 1997cv I 1743ampplain=0amplive=F

02200 I Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michael Elbery on 22601 at 300 pm (ktb) [l97cvlI743]

030101 212 Part II Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cs (ktb) [Entry date 03220 I] [ I 97cv 11743]

030110 I 213 Reply by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to response to [196-1] motion for summary judgment filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032201 j [197cv] 1743]

030101 216 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 032301J [197cvI1743]

030110 I 217 Affidavit of Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 1743 in support of[216-1 Jmotion to stay trial filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 03230 I] [I 97cv I 1743]

0307101 209 Motion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 to stay trial filed (copy) (eaf) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvl1743]

2]0030701

030701 214

0311610 I 211

Memorandum by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in support of [209-1 J motion to stay trial filed (copy) (eat) [Entry date 031901] [l97cvI1743]

_--__----_--__-_---__-------__-----shyLetter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 requesting that a printout of docket entries from 71100 to 3701 be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 03220]J [197cvI1743]

_----___

Response by Robert Sheketoff in I 97-cv-11743 Kimberly Homan in I 97-cv-I1743 Sheketoff amp Homan in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed cis (m Ib) [Entry date 0311 910 1] [197cv I 1743]

Reply by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to response to [209-1] motion to stay trial filed (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

21503220 I

Judge Mark L Wolf Memorandum and Order entered denying [196-1] motion for summary judgment set pretrial conference for 300 1112901 set Jury trial for 121001 cccl [EOD Date 9260]] (ktb) [l97cvI1743]

09260 ] 218

Judge Mark L Wolf Procedural Order entered re PretrialTrial PTC set for 111910 1 at 300 pm Counsel shan be preparred to commence trial on or after 1211 1 cccl [EOD Date 92601 j (ktb) [I 97cv 11743]

09260 I 219

Tenninated document [209-11 motion to stay trial [216-1] motion to stay trial [194-11 motion for separate and final judgment [189-1] motion for clarification of 92800 Order [183-1] motion for summary judgment [183-2] motion and for a separate and final judgment [182-1] motion for order of Dismissal Requested by mlw (ktb) [197cvI1743]

092601

Letter by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-l [743 requesting that trial subpoenas be mailed to him FILED (ktb) [Entry date 10220 I] [I 97cvI1743]

10170 I 220

Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for reconsideration of [218-1] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 112901 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10230 I] [197cv 11743]

1011801 221

0411212002 1252 PM25 of28

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER Civil Docket Report for 197cv 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndcc aseno=l 1997cvl1743ampplain=0amplive=F

] 0250 I 222 Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 to have US Marshals serve pitts subpoenas filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvI1743]

102510 I 223 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for a copy of Pitts opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-1 043 8-MLW filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743J

10250 I 224 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-l 1743 to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 unti I disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 10290lJ [197cvI1743]

102510 I 225 Motion by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 102901] [197cvl1743]

103010 I 228 Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to extend time to 103010 I to oppose pitts otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of92601 filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1I050lJ [197cvI1743J

103010 I 242 Response by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-I 1743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-] 1743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [221-IJ motion for reconsideration of [21 8-11 memorandum order filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1112901] rI97cv 11743]

110101 226 Response by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in opposition to [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11050 I] [I 97cv 11743]

Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I 97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-l 1743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [225-1] motion to continue trial date filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110501] [I 97cvI1743]

1101101 227

Letter by Gerald Fabiano in 197-cv-11743 dated 1013 IO I to Deputy Clerk OLeary containing a list of citations with parallel citations to the West reports FILED (ktb) [Entry date 1110501] [197cvl1743]

I 110 110 I 229

11080 I 230 Motion by Daniel Sklut in 197-cv-11743 James Carlin in I 97-cv- J1743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I97-cv-11743 in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110901] [l97cvI1743]

Motion by Daniel Sklut in l 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I97-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 1109011 [197cvI1743]

1110810 I 231

260f28 04122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

CHASER CYil Jocket Report for 197cy 11743 httpcivilsolmadcircldcndccaseno=l I997cv I I743ampplain=0amplive=F

10801 232 Supplementation Memorandum to Defts Pretrial Memorandum by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv- 11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-11743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I 97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Robert McGinley in 197-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 filed (ktb) [Entry date 11109011 [1 97cv 11743]

110801 )---

---_--~

110901 234

Motion by Daniel Sklut in I97-cv-11743 James Carlin in 197-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in 197-cv-1 1743 Carl Hanson in I 97-cv-11743 Chester Johnson in I97-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in 197-cv-11743 Roben McGinley in 197-cv-l J743 Shrewsbury Town of in 197-cv-11743 to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 110910 I] [1 97cv I 1743]

__--~~- -----__--shyMotion by Michael Elbery in 197-cv-11743 in limine filed cis (ktb) [Entry date 11I1401J [197cvI17431 bull_

Pretrial memorandum by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

111150 I 235

11260 I

] 1260]

~~_==~=~

11260 I

Writ of Habeas Corpus issued for appearance of Michae] Elbery on 112901 at 300 pm (ktb) [197cvl1743]

_ ~~_ ~~middot_m_middot~m

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction filed cis (ktb) [197cv 11743]

236

~~ mm~ __m~~ -~ m~~yen _____=~~ ~~ __

Response by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 in opposition to [231-1 J motion in limine to preclude evidence relating only to previously adjudicated issues filed cis (ktb) [197cv 117431

237

Response by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 in opposition to [233-1] motion to bifurcate filed cis (ktb) [197cvlI743]

238I 12601

11260 I 239 Notice by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 that prison is holding pltfs legal mail FILED cis (ktb) [197cvI1743]

~_ _~_ u__ ~~~= __ _~~~~ ~~~ __~~~~~~ ~_~~ __~~__~ ~

I 12601 240 Response by Daniel Sklut in I 97-cv-11743 James Carlin in I97-cv-11743 Stephen Faucher in I 97-cv-l1743 Carl Hanson in I97-cv-l1743 Chester Johnson in 197-cv-11743 Wayne Sampson in I97-cv-11743 Robeli McGinley in I 97-cv-11743 Shrewsbury Town of in I 97-cv-11743 to [234-1] motion in limine filed cis (ktb) [197cvl1743]

Motion by Michael Elbery in I 97-cv-11743 for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act filed cis (ktb) [197cY 11743]

2411112701

243I 112910 I Judge Mark L Wolf Order entered denying [221-1 J motion for reconsideration of [218- I] memorandum order set pretrial conference for 300 I 12910 I denying [241-1J motion for the Court to Perform Ministerial Act mooting [224-1] motion to stay Judgment on Consolidated Cases 98-10163 and 98-10438 until disposition of the Sklut Case granting [228-1] motion to extend time to 1030101 to oppose pltfs otion to correct courts error of law on summary judgment decision of 9260 1 [EOD Date 1130101] (ktb) [Entry date 11130101] [l97cvI1743]

Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 11I3010lJ [1 97cvI1743]111290 I

04122002 1252 PM27 of28

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM

LHAt-K c- il uucket Report for 197cv 11743 httpeivilsolmadeireldendceaseno= I 1997cv 11743ampp1ain=Oamplive=F

112901 Pre-trial conference held (ktb) [Entry date 12030 IJ f197cv 11743]

112901 244 Judge Mark L Wolf Clerks Notes granting [223-1] motion for a copy of Pltfs opposition to sj motions filed in Elbery v Breen 98-cv-I0438-MLW granting [225-1] motion to continue trial date [233-1] motion to bifurcate taken under advisement [234-1 Jmotion in limine taken under advisement reserving [234-1] motion in limine for district judge granting [230-1] motion in limine to preclude memtion of claimed consequences of arrest for firearms on previous criminal conviction Defts motion in limine 231 deft ordered to specifyidentity the exact claimsevidence he seeks to preclude parties to file proposed voir dire jury instructions special verdict forms trial briefs and suppOlting motions in limine by 4II 902 responses to suu motions filed by 42602 Final Pretrial conference scheduled for 5202 at 300 pm parties to file any stipulations in writing exhibit lists identifying those in dispute and potential by 411902 i (ktb) [Entry date 120301] [197cvlI743]

12020 I 245

12060 I 246

1210701 247

Letter dated 1220 I to Michael Elbery from Barbara Morse Pro Se Attorney re copies of documents and subpoenas for witnesses Mr Elbery had requested PILED (ktb) [Entry date] 20501] [I 97cv 11743]

Applicationpetition by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-11743 for Writ of Mandamus filed (ktb) [1 97cvI1743]

Supplementto Petition for Writ of Mandamas [FLED (ktb) [Entry date 121401] [197cvI1743]

248122110 I Order of the US Court of Appeals re Writ of Mandamus Petitioner has failed to show either in his initial fI1ing or in his supplementary papers that an appeal will not suffice to protect his rights Mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that will not lie where an appeal is and available rcmcdypetitioner may move in the district court for voluntary dismissal of his claim ifhe chooses to do so The petition as supplemented is DENIED (if) [I 97cvI1743]

Docuement compliance with COUlts request FILED (letb) [I 97cv I 1743] 0104102

Notice of change of address filed by Michael Elbery in I97-cv-1 J 743 FILED (ktb) [Entry date 041 J02] [I 97cv 11743]

040402

[END OF DOCKET 197cvI1743]

of28 041122002 1252 PM