DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison,...

23
DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories Albuquerque, NM August 6, 2010 FNST/MASCO/PFC Meeting Sandia is a multiprogram laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company, for the United States Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration under contract DE-AC04-94AL85000.

Transcript of DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison,...

Page 1: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

1

Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons

Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim BullockSandia National Laboratories

Albuquerque, NM

August 6, 2010

FNST/MASCO/PFC Meeting

Sandia is a multiprogram laboratory operated by Sandia Corporation, a Lockheed Martin Company,for the United States Department of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration

under contract DE-AC04-94AL85000.

Page 2: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

2

Outline

• What are hypervapotrons?

• Why hypervapotrons?

• Geometry optimization

• Boiling heat transfer in hypervapotrons– Why CFD?

• Benchmarking with HHF test data

• CHF prediction

Page 3: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

3

• Star-CCM+ Version 5.04.006, User Guide, CD-adapco, Inc., New York, NY USA (2010).

• S. Lo and A. Splawski, “Star-CD Boiling Model Development”, CD-adapco, (2008).

• D.L. Youchison, M.A. Ulrickson, J.H. Bullock, “A Comparison of Two-Phase Computational Fluid Dynamics Codes Applied to the ITER First Wall Hypervapotron,” IEEE Trans. On Plasma. Science, 38 7, 1704-1708 (2010).

• Upcoming paper in the 2010 TOFE .

Background

Page 4: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

4

ITER First Wall 04

Page 5: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

5

Why hypervapotrons?

Advantages:

•High CHF with relatively lower pressure drop•Reduction in E&M loads due to thin copper faceplate•Lower Cu/Be interface temperature (no ss liners)•Less bowing of fingers due to thermal loads

Disadvantages:

•CuCrZr/SS316LN UHV joint exposed to water

Page 6: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

6

What are hypervapotrons?

Hypervapotron FW “finger”

Page 7: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

7

Two-phase CFD in water-cooled PFCs

Problem: conjugate heat transfer with boiling

• Focus on nucleate boiling regime below criticalheat flux• Use Eulerian multiphase model in FLUENT & Star-CCM+• RPI model (Bergles&Rohsenow)• Features heat and mass transfer between liquidand vapor, custom drag law, lift or buoyancy and influence of bubbles on turbulence• CCM+ transitions to a VOF model for the film when vapor fraction is high enough – need to know when to initiate VOF

Page 8: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

8

Velocity distributions

5 MW/m2

400 g/st=2.05s

Drag on bubbles, lift or buoyancy, changes in viscosity and geometry, all affect the velocity distribution under the heated zone.

2mm-deep teeth and 3-mm spacing optimized to produce a simple reverse eddy in the groove.

Page 9: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

9

Star-CCM+ 560 k polyhedra mesh

Switches from Eulerian multi-phase mixture to VOF for film boiling.

Page 10: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

10

CCM+ boiling models were benchmarkedagainst US and Russian test data for rectangularchannels and hypervapotrons to within 10oC.

capability to predict CHF from CFD

Star-CCM+ Results

Surface temperature distribution, t=6.3 s

Case analyzed is a hot “stripe” on a section of the ITER first wall.

Page 11: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

11

With no boiling, heat transfer is highest under the fins

With boiling, the vapor fraction in grooves is 4%-6% on average

t=6.3 s

Star-CCM+ Results

Case analyzed is a hot “stripe” on a section of the ITER first wall.

The details of the heat transfer change dramatically as boiling ensues. Iso-surface of 2% vapor volume fraction

Page 12: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

12

Star-CCM+ gives same h as Fluentfor nucleate boiling.

Heat transfer coefficients increase in grooves where boiling takes place ranging from 12,000 to 13,000 W/m2K.

Page 13: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

13

Systematic parameter study performed on rectangular channels – then applied to hypervapotrons.

Page 14: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

14

Te

mp

era

ture

(C

)

Thermocouple response 3.5 MW/m2 through 6 s

Russian data

Thermocouple response 4.0 MW/m2 through 6 s

Te

mp

era

ture

(C

)

ICHFTrip @ 400 C

Not ss yet!

Rectangular channelresults

Page 15: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

15

Russian HV CHF Mock-up

flow

Page 16: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

16

Total of 490k poly cells in mesh

Heated area is 100 mm x 48 mm

3 prism layers

Page 17: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

17

Surface temperature – 6.0 MW/m2, 1 m/s 115 C inlet, 2 MPa

Page 18: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

18

CCM+ solid/fluid interface temperatures for 6.0 MW/m2 @6s

Page 19: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

19

Vapor fraction – 6.0 MW/m2 @6s

Page 20: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

20

Thermocouple response through 6 s

Russian data

4 s for TCs to ss

Page 21: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

21

Outlet temperature close to steady state.

Page 22: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

22

a) sub-cooledb) nucleate to transition boilingc) film boilingd) sub-cooled

All flow regimes can exist simultaneously.

4.0 MW/m2

115 oC, 2 MPa water1.0 m/s

T:

h:

Page 23: DL Youchison 5931/31.02 1 Boiling Heat Transfer in ITER First Wall Hypervapotrons Dennis Youchison, Mike Ulrickson and Jim Bullock Sandia National Laboratories.

DL Youchison 5931/31.02

23

CHF Testing Testing of the HV mock-up

Water 2 m/sPabs 10 MW/m2

tpuls 300s

T/C (1.5 mm from CuCrZr surface)

Second pulse at 10 MW/m2)ICHF !