Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner...

40
Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980, Fall 2011

Transcript of Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner...

Page 1: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical

Energy

Aaron Wagner

Mike Knoop

University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980, Fall 2011

Page 2: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

HvZ Image

Page 3: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Defining the Problem

Page 4: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Consumers modify blastersto increase power

Page 5: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Increasing power decreases performance

Page 6: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Goal of this capstone group

1. Verify if adding rotation to darts improves flight characteristics

2. Develop and optimize a design to maximize performance

Page 7: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Defining Performance

a) Distance

b) Shot Grouping

c) Consistency of (a) and (b)

Page 8: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Cost of

Manufacture

RPM of Soft

Projectile

Distance

Traveled

Shot Grouping

Weight of soft projectil

e

Non Custom

Parts

Mass of

System

Muzzle

Velocity

Current

Competitor

s

Custome

r Importance

Improve

ment Ratio

Increased Effective Range 9 9 9 9 3 5 1.7Safety 9 6 4 4 1Cost 9 9 4 4 1Weight 1 9 3 3 1Durability of System 1 3 3 3 1Absolute Importance 39 45 45 45 39 45 27 69 354Relative Importance 11 13 13 13 11 13 8 19Current Competitors 5 1 2 2 5 5 4 2Technical Difficulty 5 3 3 4 5 5 5 4Target Value a 7.7* b 40Units $ RPM m cm m/s

Notesa Less than $200b 22.6±12.3*

This value is expected to change once adjustments are made to account for improvements resulting from the copper breach.

Quality Function Deployment

Page 9: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Design Strategy: Iteration

Page 10: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Designing the Initial Prototype

Page 11: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Design inspiration

Page 12: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Design Strategy: Mock Launcher

Page 13: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Initial Prototype Concept

Directionof Motion

Page 14: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Selecting a Flywheel Rotational Velocity

Page 15: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Measuring muzzle velocity of existing soft-projectile launcher

Page 16: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Calculating a necessary rotational velocity

= 30 m/s = 3.81 cm.

= 7500 RPM

Page 17: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Construction and Development

Page 18: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

 "A successful FMEA activity helps a team to identify potential failure modes based on past

experience "

Failure Mode Effects Analysis

Page 19: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Initial Prototype Build

Directionof Motion

Page 20: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Second Prototype BuildDirectionof Motion

Page 21: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Highspeed of Jamming

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_Mi0BmmiFc&list=PL0FF1657C0B08FAB8

Page 22: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Third Prototype Build

Directionof Motion

Page 23: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Highspeed of Fishtailing

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BSyDEoXlY4c&list=PL0FF1657C0B08FAB8

Page 24: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Highspeed of Single-Prong Barrel Close-up

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=87Y0A6IMJM8&list=PL0FF1657C0B08FAB8

Page 25: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Barrel Iteration

Page 26: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Highspeed of Double-Prong Barrel Close-up

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1uctE_u4qk&list=PL0FF1657C0B08FAB8

Page 27: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Final Prototype Build

Directionof Motion

Page 28: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Testing and Optimization

Page 29: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Parameters to Optimize

Flywheel rotation angle

Flywheel gap distance

Page 30: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Foam darts with high rotational velocities are less-able to self-correct!

1250 RPMHigh tip-offActually self-corrects

5000 RPMLittle apparent tip-offActually fishtails

Page 31: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

1250 RPM Barrel Close-up

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cDyEDYOw7E&list=PL0FF1657C0B08FAB8

Page 32: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

5000 RPM Barrel Close-up

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBa-ZM7owLc&list=PL0FF1657C0B08FAB8

Page 33: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Selecting a Flywheel Rotational Velocity

Page 34: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Selecting a Flywheel Gap Distance

0.50 0.46 0.42 0.38 0.33 0.290.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

Distance Between Wheels (in)

Dis

tanc

e T

rave

led

(ft)

Page 35: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Does Rotational Velocity Help?

Page 36: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Yes

25 30 35 40 45 50

0123456

Neutral Angled

Distance (ft)

Num

ber

of O

ccur

ence

s Distance +4.6 ft. (14%)

Standard Deviation

-2.3 ft. (40%)

Page 37: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Future Work

• Precision machining

• Foam dart wear

• Integrating into an existing SPL

Page 38: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Final Thoughts

• Iteration is very important

• Pick a project which motivates you

• Relevance, Market Size

Page 39: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Acknowledgments

Humans vs. Zombies Mizzou for project funding

Brian Graybill for teaching us SolidWorks

Dr. El Giz-awy for Capstone guidance

Richard Oberto for fixing the highspeed camera!

Page 40: Development and Optimization of a Soft-Projectile Launcher Utilizing Mechanical Energy Aaron Wagner Mike Knoop University of Missouri, MAE Capstone 4980,

Questions and Feedback

(or should we just test fire of our final design?)