DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR...

25
DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap de Gruijter, Budiman Minasny 7 th Global DSM Workshop Århus June 27 – July 1 2016

Transcript of DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR...

Page 1: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS

Alex McBratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap de Gruijter, Budiman Minasny

7th Global DSM Workshop Århus June 27 – July 1 2016

Page 2: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

DSM & Soil Monitoring

• Digital soil maps of soil attributes and associated uncertainties have been produced at global, continental, country and regional extents.

• There are many applications of these products.

• One use may be to establish strata for soil

monitoring.

Page 3: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

HOW?

Page 4: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Map of prediction of target variable

Page 5: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

How to stratify?

compact geographical stratification K-means, minimise the mean of the shortest distance

Map of prediction of target variable

Page 6: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

How to stratify?

compact geographical stratification K-means, minimise the mean of the shortest distance

Minimise sampling variance Cum √f method (Dalenius and Hodges, 1959)

Map of prediction of target variable

Page 7: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

The two extremes

1. No prior information at all? (Brus et al. 2003)

2. No spatial context, assume implicitly that the predictions have only negligible errors,

Page 8: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Optimal stratification (Ospats)

compact geographical stratification Minimise sampling variance

Map of prediction of target variable & uncertainty

OSPATS

Page 9: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Optimal stratification (OSPATS) de Gruijter et al. 2015

Predictor

Page 10: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Designed for small extents

Recall earlier talk by Hedley et al. for an example from New Zealand

Page 11: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Applying it to a very large extent

• Computationally expensive/challenging

Page 12: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

NSW, Australia 809,000 km2

Page 13: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

OSPATS 50 strata

kmeans

Cum_sqrt_f

OSPATS

Page 14: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Example sampling locations

Page 15: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

France Calibration data: Legacy soil data

Validation data: Soil Monitoring Network

550,000 km2

Page 16: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Map of topsoil (0-30 cm) C content Prediction mean (using Quantile Random Forest) Prediction variance

Independent Validation R2 = 0.32 RMSE = 17.52 g/kg

Page 17: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Stratifications

• 5km grid • 10 strata

Needs annealing schedule

Sologne

Jura

Massif Central

Page 18: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Standard error of the mean of C content in g/kg

Page 19: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Percentage RVp

• Calculated using the SMN observations

Page 20: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

the ‘equivalent sample size’, which would yield the same precision if Simple Random

Sampling were used

Page 21: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Conclusions

• Using the OSPATS algorithm Use of national or global DSM (e.g., GlobalSoilMap) products can be used for designing regional or national soil monitoring schemes to detect regional or national mean change.

• Conversely these monitoring schemes can be used to remove bias and/or update national or global DSM products (e.g., GlobalSoilMap).

Page 22: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

Further Work

• For computational efficiency work needed on allocation method

• Putting it into practice – collaborators welcome

Page 23: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

We are renewing the GlobalSoilMap Consortium All institutions, including universities, welcome More information from Dominique Arrouays

Page 24: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap
Page 25: DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS … · DESIGNING SOIL MONITORING SCHEMES FOR LARGE AREAS BASED ON DIGITAL SOIL MAPPING PRODUCTS Alex M c Bratney, Nicolas Saby, Jaap

TAK FOR AT LYTTE

AN AUSTRALO-FRANCO-DUTCH CO-PRODUCTION