Decision_dated_04.07.2013_-_Lt._Col._Retd._R._Bansal_Vs._Army_Welfare_Housing_Organisation_AWHO_Full_Bench.pdf...

8/14/2019 Decision_dated_04.07.2013_-_Lt._Col._Retd._R._Bansal_Vs._Army_Welfare_Housing_Organisation_AWHO_Full_Bench…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/decisiondated04072013-ltcolretdrbansalvsarmywelfarehousingorganisationawhofullbenchpdf 1/18

CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSIONRoom No. 308, B-Wing, August Kr nti B! " n, B!i# $i C m %& '(, N(" )(&!i- **00++

File No.CIC/LS/A/2013/000543

A (&& nt Lt. Co&. R(t ./ R. B ns &R(s on (nt Arm W(&1 r( 2ousing Org nis tion AW2O/.) t(s o1 !( ring * t! M r'!, *4 t! A ri&, 4n M 5 46 t! M ,

40*3) t( o1 ('ision 7 t! u& , 40*3

Facts :-

T!( 1 'ts, in 9ri(1, r( t! t Lt. Co&. R(t ./ R. B ns & n !is "i1( Smt. K.B ns & "(r( r(gist(r( s 'o- &i' nts 1or t!( &&otm(nt o1 1& t in t!(AW2O:s S'!(m( t ;(& ! n# . T!(r( " s inor in t( (& in t!( &&otm(nt o1t!( 1& t. B(si (s, t!(r( " s &so 'ost (s' & tion. In t!is 'onn('tion, 9 RTI

&i' tion o1 4<.*.40*3, t!( (&& nt ! soug!t t!( 1o&&o"ing in1orm tion1rom t!( AW2O =-

> / ?n (r "! t && !( s@ su9!( s@1 'tors@su9 1 'tors-our (tition toCOAS, s (r ou, " s ( min( in (t i&:.

9/ W!o && ( min( , 5 "! t " s@"(r(, ( '! ( min(r:s, (t i&(

'omm(nts- &( s( 1or" r CTC 'o o1 ( '! "it! t(rms o1 R(1(r(n'(gi (n to t!( ( min(rs/ o1 t!(ir 'omm(nts, t!(r( to.

'/ W!i'! && (rsons@ ointm(nts@o11i'(rs@o11i'(s "(r( 5 no"@st nin'&u ( , un (r t(rm m(ntion( in &(tt(r t( *+ n *4/ D > &&'on'(rn( . R( u(st &( s( s(n t!(ir (t i&( &ist, "it! (sign tion s/,o11i'i & r(ss(s 5 'ont 't num9(rs- & n &in( 5 mo9i&(.

/ %&( s( r(1(r r **, o1 our &(tt(r t( 0 No 40**, to M $ G(nK M $um r, A)G C5W, AG Br n'!, Arm 2( u rt(rs, un (r "!i'!"( s(nt (n'&osur(s 5 (n i'(s to !im, in t! t "( ! r( u(st( D no ortunit to us, 1or r(s ons( to@on AW2O su9mitt(

o'um(nts@in1orm tion &( s(. %&( s( s(n CTC 'o ( '! o1 t!(r(s ons( s/@in1orm tion@ o'um(nts, AW2O must ! ( s(nt, in r(s ons(to our (tition@s(nt 1our (n i'(s, "it!@un (r our &(tt(r t( 0 No40**.

*

(/ %&( s( r(1(r, A (n i C: s(nt to M $. G(n. K. M $um r,(n'&os( un (r our &(tt(r t( 0 No 40**, "( ! m ( '(rt inr( u(sts, s o tion B: t!(r(in. %&( s( ( ('ut( t!( o tion B:.

1/ R( u(sts, 9 us, i1 r( uir( 1or ition & in1orm tion, "i&& 1o&&o",

1t(r r('(i t o1 in1orm tion@ o'um(nts, r( u(st( in 9o ( r s 5 su9r s.

4. Co&. Bino Kum r, )ir('tor, RTI %IO/, t!roug! !is 'o (ring &(tt(r t(*8. .40*4 ! 1or" r ( '(rt in in1orm tion r('(i ( 9 !im 1rom t!( o11i'( o1t!( AW2O, N(" )(&!i. T!is &(tt(r r( s s 1o&&o"s =-

“Lt. Col. Rakesh Ba sal!Ret".#$42$ Sa%as&ati 'iha%$ Rai()% Roa"$*eh%a") $ +tta%a ,ha "-24 001.

A R C : BAN AL R !6 LA AN,A AR 7A8#

1. Re9e%e ce o)% lette% No. RB-,B/A / e%s/0 "ate" 2; a12 a""%esse" to <a=. e ,. <a=)>"a% A* C? .

2. It >a @e a((%eciate" that o)% co ce% s a@o)t the "ela i the(%o=ect as &ell as

i c%ease i the costs o9 the *&elli + its !*+s# ha e also @ee

co ce% s 9o% this% a isatio .

3. he "ela i co>>e ce>e t o9 the (%o=ect &as @%o) ht to theotice o9 the * *C? . A"=)ta t e e%al !Chai%>a # as &ell as

the Chie9 o9 the A%> Sta99 a " it &as a((%eciate" @ the> that the"ela &as @e o " the co t%ol o9 this % a isatio i s(ite o9 all thee99o%ts &hich &e%e >a"e to e (e"ite the a((%o al o9 the (la s @e9o%eco>>e ce>e t o9 the &o%k. is celle c the o e% o% o9,a% ataka a " the co ce% e" atte%.

4. he%e has @ee a co sta t i c%ease i the cost o9 theco st%)ctio >ate%ials e e% si ce the (%o=ect &as co cei e". he%easo s 9o% the i c%ease ha e al%ea" @ee co>>) icate" to allco ce% e" a " it is o ce a ai %eite%ate" that the%e &as i c%ease ithe S)(e% A%eas o9 the *+s 9%o> those &hich &e%e i itialla o) ce". he%e &as co si"e%a@le i c%ease i the cost o9

4



co st%)ctio >ate%ials a(a%t 9%o> le o9 Se% ice a a " La@o)%Cess. he%e &as also co si"e%a@le i>(%o e>e t i the S(eci9icatio sa " the 9i ishes as co>(a%e" to &hat &as (la e" at the i itial sta e.It is a &ell k o& 9act$ &hich has @ee &i"el ()@liciDe" i the

e&s(a(e%s a " othe% >e"ia$ that the%e ha" @ee ) (%ece"e te"

i c%ease i the cost o9 co st%)ctio @et&ee the (e%io" 200E 200 .he%ea9te%$ also the%e has @ee a co sta t i c%ease i the cost o9

co st%)ctio >ate%ials &hich has lea" to the i c%ease i the costs o9the *+s.

5. he a@o e as(ects &e%e @%o) ht to the otice o9 * * C?a " A @e9o%e a o) ci the Costs o9 the *+s a " co>>e ce>e to9 the &o%k. he Costi o9 the *+s has @ee sc%)ti iDe" i "etail atthe le el o9 * *C? a " has also @ee (e%)se" @ A a " C AS.

E. 6o)% %e(%ese tatio to the C AS has also @ee co si"e%e" i"etail at a((%o(%iate le el. A* C? lette% o.B/4G55E/ et/A /C Coo%" "ate" 1E a . 12 >a (lease @e%e9e%%e".H

3. )iss tis1i( "it! t!( r(s ons( o1 t!( C%IO, t!( (&& nt ! 1i&( 1irst( & "!i'! " s is os( o1 9 FAA t!roug! or (r t( 43.6.40*4

m(ntioning t!(r(in t! t !( " s s tis1i( t! t t!( ( u t( i& 9&( in1orm tion! 9((n ro ision( 9 t!( C%IO i ( &(tt(r t( *8. .40*4.

7. Aggri( ( "it! t!( 9o ( or (rs, t!( (&& nt ! s 1i&( t!( r(s(nt( &.

. T!( m tt(r " s initi && !( r 9 t!( B(n'! o1 S!ri M.L. S! rm , IC, on* .3.40*3. T!( (&& nt " s r(s(nt &ong "it! !is "i1( Smt. K. B ns &. T!(AW2O " s r( r(s(nt( 9 A o' t( A.K. Ti" ri. It " s ( & in( to t!(

(&& nt t! t s (r s( (r & ('isions o1 t!is B(n'!, t!( AW2O " s not !(&to 9( %u9&i' Aut!orit un (r s('tion 4 !/ o1 t!( RTI A't. T!( (&& nt,!o"( (r, su9mitt( t! t t!( issu( r is( 9 !im " s ( tr(m(& 'om &( nr is( n im ort nt issu( o1 & " 'on'(rning t!( 'onstitution n 1un'tioning o1t!( AW2O n r( u(st( 1or t!( 'onstitution o1 Fu&& B(n'! to ('i ( t!ism tt(r. In i(" o1 t!is, t!( C!i(1 In1orm tion Commission(r " s &( s( to'onstitut( t!( Fu&& B(n'! 'onsisting o1 t!( 1o&&o"ing =-

• S!ri S t n n Mis!r , CICH• S!ri M.L. S! rm , ICH n• S!ri i$ S! rm , IC.

3



+. T!( B(n'! !( r t!is m tt(r on *4.7.40*3. T!( (&& nt " s r(s(nt&ong "it! !is "i1( Smt. K. B ns &. T!( AW2O " s r( r(s(nt( 9 t!(

1o&&o"ing =-

• A o' t( A.K. Ti" riH• Co&. Bino Kum r, )ir('tor, RTI, Arm 2( u rt(rsH• Co&. R(t ./ R.K. S 9! r" &, )ir('tor-A)M AW2O/H n• M $. R.K. % n!otr .

6. T!( (&& nt ! s 1i&( (t i&( r( r(s(nt tion "!i'! is t #(n on r('or .It is !is 'ont(ntion t! t t!( AW2O is %u9&i' Aut!orit un (r s('tion 4 !/ o1 t!(RTI A't. 2is 1irst n 1or(most su9mission is t! t 9 t!( Arm :s o"n

mission, t!( AW2O is its 9io&ogi' & '!i& . It is n ins( r 9&( rt o1 t!(

Arm . T!( '! rt su9mitt( 9 !im ( i'ting t!( Arm :s 9ro stru'tur("!(r(in t!( AW2O 1igur(s in t!( A $ut nt G(n(r &:s Br n'! is ( tr 't(9(&o"=-

7

8. It is &so t!( (&& nt:s 'ont(ntion t! t &ong "it! rious ot!(rBr n'!(s o1 t!( Arm , t!( A $ut nt G(n(r &:s Br n'! 1un'tions ir('t& un (rt!( C!i(1 o1 Arm St 11 COAS/. T!( AG ! s & rg( num9(r o1org niJ tions@Br n'!(s "or#ing un (r !im n t!( AW2O is on( o1 su'!

org niJ tions@Br n'!(s. T!us, t!( AW2O is r(s onsi9&( to t!( COAS t!roug!t!( AG. Bot! t!( COAS 5 AG ! ( 'om &(t( 'ontro& o (r t!( 11 irs o1 t!(AW2O. It is !is 'ont(ntion t! t "!(n Arm is %u9&i' Aut!orit (r s(, t!(AW2O, 9(ing n ins( r 9&( rt o1 t!( Arm , ' n not '& im t! t it is not

u9&i' ut!orit un (r t!( RTI A't.

<. T!( (&& nt ! s &so r(&i( on &(tt(r No. B@030* @AW2O@NOC@OAt( 4*.*0.40*0 o1 t!( AW2O un (r t!( tit&( To "!om it m 'on'(rn:

"!i'! '&( r& st t(s t! t t!( AW2O is 'ontro&&( 9 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt!( ( 9 A $ut nt G(n(r & s ( -o11i'io C! irm n. T!( s i &(tt(r is ( tr 't(9(&o" =-

“1. I co ectio &ith *+ L SIN L +NI N 300 SJ "allotte" to No. IC 1;0 3< Ra k Lt.Col !R# Na>e Rakesh Ba sal ato)% Ba alo%e$ - 6elaha ka (%o=ect i"e A >e>@e%shi( No.

F/*S3/G 301/AR/B 6/2004 it is ce%ti9ie" that Sale *ee"/Lease*ee" @et&ee the A a " %i ate a%t has @ee 9i aliDe".Co e a ce *ee" &he e ec)te" &ith the allottee &ithi the %)leslai" "o& $ A &ill ha e o o@=ectio 9o% the allottee to >o%t a e

that a@o e 9lat/(%o(e%t to +N AB NA I NAL BAN,$ R AILASS BRANC $ * RA*+N.

2. It is ce%ti9ie" that A is co t%olle" @ the Boa%" o9<a a e>e t hea"e" @ A"=)ta t e e%al as e -o99icio Chai%>a .All othe% >e>@e%s o9 the @oa%" a%e se% i se io% o99ice%s o9 theA%> $ the <a a i *i%ecto% o9 A a " ci ilia o99ice%s o9@e%e" at (%ese ta " i 9)t)%e o actio &ill @e take @ !A # &hich &ill >ake ite c)>@e%e".

4. It is 9)%the% >e tio e" that the A%> el9a%e o)si% a isatio is %e iste%e" as a societ ) "e% the Societies

Re ist%atio Act I o9 1 E0 ) "e% ce%ti9icate iss)e" @ theRe ist%a% o9 Societies$ *elhi &ith ce%ti9icate No. S/G142 "ate" 20<a%$ 1G; .H

*0. To 9uttr(ss t!is oint 1urt!(r, t!( (&& nt ! s r(&i( on t!( Minut(s o1t!( m((ting o1 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O !(& on *+.4.40*4. As

(r t!is o'um(nt, t!( m((ting " s !(& in E-in-C:s Br n'!, K s!mir 2ous(,R $ $i M rg, N(" )(&!i, "!i'! " s tt(n ( 9 Lt. G(n&. i %r # s! M(!r ,

AG, n (&( (n ot!(r o11i'(rs. T!is o'um(nt, "!i'! " s u& sign( 9 t!(tt(n ((s, is r( ro u'( 9(&o" =-

“AR<6 LFAR +SIN R ANISA I N

B AR* F <ANA < N < IN : 1E F B 2012

he 9ollo&i o99ice%s atte "e" the Boa%" o9 <a a e>e t <eeti o9A%> el9a%e o)si % a isatio !A # hel" at 1000 h%s. o 1E Fe@2012 at <ai Co 9e%e ce hall$ -i -C8s B%a ch$ ,ash>i% o)se$ Ra=a=i<a% $ Ne& *elhi-110011 :-

Se%No.

Ra k ? Na>e A((oi t>e t *esi atio o B <Si -at)%e

1. Lt. e . ai %akash Neh%a$A'S<

A"=)ta t e e%alA 8s B%a ch$A%> K

Chai%>a! -o99icio#

S"/-

2. Lt. e . <) ish Si@al$A'S<

K)a%te% <aste%e e%al K< 8s

B%a ch$A%> K

'ice Chai%>a! -o99icio#

S"/-

3. Lt. e . 'i=ai Sha%>a$A'S@e%! -o99icio#

S"/-

4. <a= e S Na%asi>ha $'S<

<a a i *i%ecto%A

<e>@e% S"/-

5. <a= e 6C ha%aka $'S<< -IC-A"> KSo)the% Co>>a "

<e>@e%! -o99icio#

S"/-

E. <a= e A>a% ,%ish a < -IC-A"> Kaste% Co>>a "

<e>@e%! -o99icio#

S"/-

;. <a= e Nee%a= Bali$ S< < -IC-A">. Keste% Co>>a "

<e>@e%! -o99icio#

S"/-

. <a=. e S Na%a < -IC-A"> KCe t%al Co>>a "

<e>@e%! - 99icio#

S"/-

G. <a= e ' <e o $'S<

< -IC-A"> KNo%the% Co>>a "

<e>@e%! -o99icio#

S"/-

10. <a= e S, ha$ S<$'S< < -IC-A"> KSo)th estCo>>a "

<e>@e%! -o99icio#

S"/-

11. B%i Bik%a> Si h B%i . A">. KA%> % Co>>a "

<e>@e%! - 99icio#

S"/-

+

12. Col RS Si%ohi Sec%eta% A Sec%eta% S"/-IN A N*ANC

13. B%i A.,. Sa%ka% * <* S"/-14. Col. , R Si h!Ret"# *i%!F?A# S"/-15. <%. Ra i "e% Bhatia Cha%te%e" Acco) -

ta t$ AS"/-

H

**. It is, t!us, t!( (&& nt:s 'ont(ntion t! t t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt o1 t!(AW2O (ntir(& 'om ris(s o1 Arm o11i'(rs iJ. t!r(( Li(ut(n nt G(n(r &s,s( (n M $or G(n(r &s n num9(r o1 Brig i(rs n Co&on(&s. A''or ing to!im, t!( AW2O is not!ing 9ut ur( n sim &( Arm org nis tion.

*4. Furt!(r-mor(, t!( (&& nt ! s r(&i( on t!is Commission:s ('isiont( *8.04.400< in ).M. G ut m D s- In i n R i&" s W(&1 r(

Org nis tion IRWO/ Fi&( Nos. CIC@OK@C@4008@00 60,CIC@OK@C@4008@00 6+, CIC@OK@C@4008@00 < /. T!( 1 'ts in t!(s( ' s(s "(r(t! t t!( IRWO ! r('(i ( t!( &o n o1 Rs. *0 'ror( 1rom t!( Ministr o1R i&" s "!i'! ! 9((n r(- i . T!( IRWO ! &so t #(n &o n o1 Rs. +'ror( 1rom rious R i&" %S?s "!i'! " s &so r(- i 9 t!( IRWO, minus

n mount o1 Rs. *.40 'ror(. T!( M(m9(r St 11/, R i&" Bo r , " s t!( ( -o11i'io, C! irm n o1 t!( IRWO. A r( r(s(nt ti ( o1 t!( Ministr o1 R i&" s" s &so on t!( M n g(m(nt Bo r . IRWO " s o''u ing 9out 3000 s . 1t.o1 Go (rnm(nt s '( 1or its 2( u rt(rs o11i'( in S! n# r M r#(t, Conn ug!t

%& '(, N(" )(&!i, t nomin & &( s(@&i'(n'( 1(( o1 $ust Rs. *4,700@- 1or 4*( rs. In t!( 9o ( 1 'ts n 'ir'umst n'(s, t!( Commission ' m( to t!(

1o&&o"ing 'on'&usion =-

“G. A9te% i i tho) ht9)l co si"e%atio to the s)@>issio s a "s)((o%ti e "oc)>e ts (%o i"e" @ @oth o9 the (a%ties a " kee(i i

ie& the 9acts a " ci%c)>sta ces o9 the Case$ the Co>>issioacce(ts the s)@>issio s o9 the Co>(lai a t/Co>(lai a ts. heCo>>issio 9i "s that IR is i "i%ectl o& e"$ co t%olle" a "s)@sta tiall 9i a ce" @ the Rail&a Boa%"$ <i ist% o9 Rail&a s.I 9act$ the i itiatio o9 the %e ist%atio o9 the Societ &as itsel9 take@ the <i ist% o9 Rail&a s a " the @asic i 9%ast%)ct)%e i cl)"ila " &as also (%o i"e" @ the Rail&a Boa%" a " <i ist% o9Rail&a s a " the @asic i 9%ast%)ct)%e i cl)"i la " &as also(%o i"e" @ the Rail&a Boa%" a " e i to e iste ce. he hel( @ &a o9loa co stit)tes i "i%ect 9i a ci o9 a o% a iDatio /Societ . he

6

la " has also @ee (%o i"e" to the IR at a e% o>i al %ate i*elhi$ &hich is also co stit)tes i "i%ect 9i a ci 9%o> the

o e% >e t. he R I Act c%eates a %e i>e o9 t%a s(a%e c a "acco) ta@ilit i a % a iDatio . he Co>>issio is ) a@le to) "e%sta " &h the o99icials o9 IR a%e so hesita t i c%eati a

%e i>e o9 t%a s(a%e c i thei% % a iDatio $ &hich is i the i te%esto9 the % a iDatio itsel9. IR &o%ks 9o% the &el9a%e o9 Rail&a

>(lo ees a " i9 a %e i>e o9 t%a s(a%e c is c%eate" i the% a iDatio $ the 9aith o9 the Rail&a >(lo ees &o)l" @e

st%e the e" i it.

10. e ce$ kee(i i ie& the 9acts a " ci%c)>sta ces o9 the(%ese t case a " i the i te%est o9 t%a s(a%e c a " acco) ta@ilit $the Co>>issio "ecla%es the IR a )@lic A)tho%it ) "e% theRi ht to I 9o%>atio Act 2005. Sh%i S. .S. ai $ the <a a i*i%ecto%$ I "ia el9a%e % a iDatio $ Ne& *elhi$ is "i%ecte" toa((oi t the Ce t%al )@lic I 9o%>atio 99ice% a " Assista tCe t%al )@lic I 9o%>atio a " the Fi%st A((ellate A)tho%it i theo% a iDatio &ithi 15 "a s o9 the %ecei i the %"e% o9 theCo>>issio a " co>(l &ith the othe% (%o isio s o9 the R I Act2005$ &ithi 120 "a s o9 the %ecei i o9 the %"e% o9 theCo>>issio . he Res(o "e t is$ 9)%the%$ "i%ecte" to (%o i"e the"esi%e" i 9o%>atio to the Co>(lai a ts &ithi 15 "a s o9 %ecei ithe %"e% o9 the Co>>issio .H

*3. It is t!( (&& nt:s 'ont(ntion t! t t!( AW2O is 1un'tioning on t!( s m(&in(s s t!( IRWO n , t!(r(1or(, t!( r tio o1 t!( 1or(s i ('ision &i(s int!( r(s(nt ' s(, mor( so "!(n t!( ('ision o1 t!( CIC in t!( IRWO ' s( ! s9((n u !(& 9 t!( )(&!i 2ig! Court in or (r t( 3. .40*0 in IRWO D s-).M. G ut m 5 Anr. Writ %(tition C/ No. 84*<@400</.

*7. It is t!( 1urt!(r 'ont(ntion o1 t!( (&& nt t! t Arm O11i'(rs r( 9(ing( ut( to t!( AW2O on r(gu& r 9 sis on t(rms 5 'on itions r(s'ri9( 9

Mo). As (r Mo) &(tt(r No. 334+4@[email protected] @*608-II@) % @S(r i'(s/t( M **, *<84, t!( (rio o1 ( ut tion o1 n Arm O11i'(r to t!( AW2O

is to 9( tr( t( s A%> se% ice 9o% ()%(oses s)ch as se io%it $ i c%e>e t o9(a $ (e sio a% a&a%"s a " lea e etc. i the A%> . B(si (s, n o11i'(r is(ntit&( to r(t in t!( 'ting r n# !(& 9 !im t t!( tim( o1 ( ut tion. Furt!(r-mor(, t!( o11i'(rs 'ontinu( to 9( (&igi9&( 1or && Arm 1 'i&iti(s, su'! s

ur'! s( t Arm s!o s, ' nt((ns (t'. T!( 'ir'u& r 1urt!(r s s t! t t!( Armo11i'(rs "i&& 9( (ntit&( to r " n &&o" n'(s s (r t!( r t(s &i' 9&(to t!( r(gu& r Arm o11i'(rs. Mor( im ort nt& , t!( o11i'(rs ost( to t!(

8

AW2O "i&& 9( un (r t!( ministr ti ( 'ontro& o1 t!( r(s ('ti ( &o' &Form tions, ( (n t!oug! t!( 1un'tion & 'ontro& "i&& (st "it! t!( )G, AW2O.T!( 'ir'u& r 1urt!(r sti u& t(s t! t t!( s(&('tion o1 o11i'(rs to 9( s(nt on

( ut tion to t!( AW2O "i&& 9( ' rri( out 9 t!( S(r i'( 2( u rt(rs nro ( 9 t!( Ministr o1 )(1(n'(. L ing gr( t (m ! sis on t!is 'ir'u& r,

t!( (&& nt "ou& &( t! t t!( AW2O is not!ing 9ut n ( t(ntion o1 t!(Arm 1or && r 'ti' & ur os(s.

* . T!( (&& nt ! s &so r(&i( on t!( Mo):s &(tt(r No. B.04*80-83-87@AG Bu g(t/*6+6@)O.II@) o1 +.<.*<83 i ( "!i'! s n'tion o1 t!( %r(si (nto1 In i r(g r ing t!( gr nt o1 &o n o1 Rs. 'ror(s to t!( AW2O " s 'on ( ( .T!( s i &(tt(r is r( ro u'( 9(&o" =-

“No. B.021 0- 3- 4/A !B)" et#1;E;/* .II/*!Res#o e% >e t o9 I "ia$

@e%$ 1G 3

S)@=ect : RAN F L AN AR<6 LFAR+SIN R ANISA I N N * L I.

Si%$

I a> "i%ecte" to co e the sa ctio o9 the %esi"e t to the

%a t o9 a loa o9 Rs. 5.00 c%o%e!R)(ees 9i e c%o%e# o l to the A%>el9a%e o)si % a isatio 9o% the ()%chase o9 la " s)@=ect to the

9ollo&i co "itio s :-

!a# A >atchi loa o9 Rs. 5.00 c%o%e!R)(ees 9i e c%o%eso l # &ill also @e (%o i"e" @ the A%> %o)(I s)%a ce Sche>e.

!@# he loa &ill @e sec)%e" @ o@tai i >o%t a e o9 la "i 9a o)% o9 the o e% >e t.

!c# I te%>s o9 R)le 15; o9 .F.R. 1GE3 a loa a %ee>e t&ill @e e ec)te" @e9o%e the loa is "%a& .

!"# A &ill 9)% ish )tiliDatio ce%ti9icate &ithi o e ea%o9 "%a&al o9 loa i acco%"a ce &ith the (%o isio o9 the

FR that the loa has @ee )tiliDe" 9o% the ()%(ose 9o%&hich it ha" @ee sa ctio e".

<

!e# he + "e% Sec%eta% *! st.2#$ o) t &ill @e "is@)%se" to the

Chai%>a $ A%> el9a%e o)si % a isatio $ A%>ea"J)a%te%s$ Roo> No ..So)th )t>e ts ,ash>i%o)se$ Ne& *elhi-11.

!9# Necessa% 9) "s ha e @ee (%o i"e" i the @)" et 9o%1G 3- 4 %a t No. 1 $ o) ta)tho%iDe" is "e@ita@le to the ea" i "icate" i theA e )%e e close".

! # he loa &ill @e %e(a a@le o e% a (e%io" o9 15 ea%s.he esse tial "etails o9 the loa a " %ate o9 i te%est to @e

cha% e" a%e i e i the attache" a e )%e.

!h# he ..o9 loa @ A &ill @e c%e"ite" to the. i e i the A e )%e a " %eco e% o9 the i te%est

to ea" 704G8 I te%est Recei(t: -*- the% I te%estRecei(ts-I te%ests o loa a " a" a ce @ the Ce t%al

o e% >e t I te%est o loa to A .

2. his iss)es &ith the co c)%%e ce o9 the I te %ate" Fi a ce*i isio i"e thei% +. . No. 1E32/< / 3 o9 1G 3.

6o)%s 9aith9)ll $S"/-

S.,. Sa a%*esk 99ice%.H

*+. T!( (&& nt ! s ro u'( (t not!(r &(tt(r t( *8.3.*<8 o1 t!(Mo) 'on ( ing t!( s n'tion o1 t!( %r(si (nt o1 In i r(g r ing t!( gr nt o11urt!(r &o n o1 Rs. 'ror(s to t!( AW2O. Anot!(r &(tt(r t( 3*.3.*<8+ &so'on ( s t!( s n'tion o1 t!( %r(si (nt o1 In i in r(g r to t!( gr nt o1 1urt!(r&o n o1 Rs. 04 'ror(s to t!( AW2O. It is, t!us, t!( (&& nt:s 'ont(ntion t! tt!( AW2O is not on& 'ontro&&( 9 t!( Arm 9ut is &so in ir('t& 1in n'( 9t!( C(ntr & Go (rnm(nt.

*0

*6. Mor( im ort nt& , t!( (&& nt "ou& su9mit t! t t!( AW2O is g(ttingIn'om( T ( (m tion un (r s('tion *0 43AA/ o1 t!( I.T. A't n is, t!us,in ir('t& , 1in n'( 9 t!( C(ntr & Go (rnm(nt.

*8. As t!( !( ring r(m in( in'on'&usi (, t!( m tt(r " s $ourn( to 4 n

M , 40*3.

*<. T!( m tt(r is ' &&( 1or !( ring on 4 n M , 40*3. T!( (&& nt is notr(s(nt. T!( AW2O is r( r(s(nt( 9 =-

• A . A.K. Ti" riH• Brig. Bino Kum rH• Co& = %.R.S. Siro!iH• Smt. In u&(#! 2 & rH n• M $. %. N gr $.

40. A . Ti" ri r(1ut(s t!( (&& nt:s 'ont(ntions in !is 9ri(1 r(ss to t!(Commission n !( s((#s s!ort $ournm(nt to r(ss t!( Commission t&(ngt! n 1i&( (t i&( r( r(s(nt tion on 9(! &1 o1 AW2O. 2(n'(, t!( m tt(ris $ourn( to 46 t! M , 40*3.

4*. As s'!( u&( , t!( m tt(r is 1urt!(r !( r on 46. .40*3. T!( (&& nt isnot r(s(nt. T!( AW2O is r( r(s(nt( 9 =-

• S!ri A.K. Ti" ri, A o' t(• Brig. Bino Kum r• Co&. %.R.S.Siro!i• Co&. A. R $i• Mrs. In u&(#! 2 & r,AOG AG Coor /.

44. A . T(" ri ! s r(ss( t!( Commission t &(ngt!. 2( rgu(s t! t t!(AW2O is So'i(t r(gist(r( "it! t!( R(gistr r o1 So'i(ti(s, )(&!i, un (r t!(So'i(ti(s R(gistr tion A't, *<80. It is ri t( 9o n is not m(n 9&( to t!(

ro isions o1 RTI A't. T!( o9$('ti ( o1 t!( AW2O is to ro i ( "(&&ing unitsto s(r ing n r(tir( Arm (rsonn(& n t!(ir "i o"s on no ro1it no &oss:9 sis. In 1 't, it is n Org nis tion m( nt 1or t!( "(&1 r( o1 t!( r(tir( ns(r ing Arm (rsonn(&. As to t!( 'ontro& o1 t!( Arm on t!( AW2O, A .T(" ri "ou& su9mit t! t it is, no ou9t, tru( t! t num9(r o1 s(nior s(r ingArm o11i'(rs r( r( r(s(nt( on t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O 9utt!( r( t!(r( in t!(ir ( -o11i'io ' 'it . T!( AW2O o(s not gi ( t!(m nr(mun(r tion 1or t!( s(r i'(s r(n (r( . T!(ir ro&( is isor in n tur(.

**



)('isions in t!( AW2O r( t #(n 9 its )ir('tor G(n(r &. As r(g r s t!(u(stion o1 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O 9(ing !( ( 9 t!(

A $ut nt G(n(r &, A . T(" ri "ou& su9mit t! t AG is t!(r( in !is ( -o11i'io' 'it n o(s not (ri ( n 9(n(1it 1rom t!is osition. A . T(" ri "ou&1urt!(r su9mit t! t ( ut tion o1 num9(r o1 Arm o11i'(rs to t!( AW2O is

r(gu& t( 9 t!( gui (&in(s issu( 9 t!( Mo) to t!( Arm 2( u rt(rs. It is routin( ministr ti ( 'ti it n not!ing mu'! s!ou& 9( r( into it. 2(

"ou& &so su9mit t! t t!( ( ut tionist o11i'(rs r " t!(ir s & r n ot!(r&&o" n'(s 1rom t!( 1un s o1 t!( AW2O n not 1rom t!( r(gu& r Arm n

m(r( ( ut tion o1 Arm o11i'(rs to t!( AW2O o(s not r(n (r t!( AW2O %u9&i' Aut!orit . In sum n su9st n'(, it is A . T(" ri:s 'ont(ntion t! t

(s it( o (r"!(&ming r(s(n'( o1 s(nior Arm o11i'(rs in t!( Bo r o1M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O, it is not 'ontro&&( (it!(r 9 t!( Arm2( u rt(rs or 9 t!( Mo).

43. As to t!( u(stion o1 t!( AW2O 9(ing in ir('t& 1in n'( 9 t!(Go (rnm(nt, A . T(" ri "ou& su9mit t! t gr nt o1 '(rt in &o ns to t!(AW2O 9 Mo) o(s not mount to 1in n'ing. T!( 1 't o1 t!( m tt(r is t! tt!( AW2O ! s t #(n &o ns 1rom n tion &iJ( B n#s n ot!(r institutions n( (n 1rom t!( Mo) 1rom tim( to tim( s (r its r( uir(m(nt. T!(s( &o ns r(9(ing r( i on t!( t(rms n 'on itions s s(tt&( 9(t"((n t!( rti(s. It is 'omm(r'i & tr ns 'tion n ' nnot 9( s i to 9( in ir('t 1in n'ing o1 t!(AW2O.

47. As to t!( u(stion o1 In'om( T ( (m tion 9(ing i&( 9 t!(AW2O, !( "ou& su9mit t! t t!is ( (m tion is not ('u&i r to t!( AW2O.T!(r( r( t!ous n s o1 C! rit 9&(@W(&1 r( Org nis tions in t!( 'ountr "!i'!

r( i&ing t!is t ( (m tion 9ut t!( ' nnot 9( !(& to 9( u9&i' ut!orit ont!is 'ount &on(.

4 . In (ss(n'(, it is A . T(" ri:s su9mission t! t t!( AW2O is not'ontro&&( 9 t!( A2 , nor is it 1in n'( , &(t &on( su9st nti && 1in n'( 9 t!(Mo). 2(, t!(r(1or(, m #(s ssion t( &( 1or ismiss & o1 t!( ( &.

4+. Co&. %.R.S. Siro!i ! s 1i&( (t i&( r( r(s(nt tion t( 4 .7.40*3 on9(! &1 o1 t!( AW2O "!i'! is t #(n on r('or . It "ou& 9( (rtin(nt to!ig!&ig!t t!( s &i(nt oints m ( in t!is r( r(s(nt tion =-

i/ T!( AW2O is So'i(t r(gist(r( "it! R(gistr r o1 So'i(ti(s, )(&!i,un (r t!( So'i(ti(s R(gistr tion A't, *8+0, "it! its !( u rt(rs t Sout!2utm(nts, K s!mir 2ous(, R $ $i M rg, N(" )(&!iH

*4

ii/ T!( '!i(1 o9$('ti ( o1 t!( AW2O is to ro i ( "(&&ing units tos(r ing n r(tir( Arm (rsonn(& n t!(ir "i o"s on no ro1it no &oss:9 sisH

iii/ T!( AW2O o(s not g(t n gr nt or n'( 1rom AG@A2 H

i / T!( AW2O t #(s &o n 1rom B n#s@2)FC@N tion & 2ousing B n#, s(r its r( uir(m(nt 1rom tim( to tim(H

/ A Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt minist(rs t!( 1un s o1 t!( AW2OH

i/ T!( E ('uti ( Committ(( o1 t!( AW2O:s Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt' rri(s out to m n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O n ssists t!( Bo r o1M n g(m(nt. T!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt is !( ( 9 t!( C! irm n "!o isA $ut nt G(n(r & o1 t!( Arm n 1un'tions s su'! in ( -O11i'io ' 'it H

ii/ T!( issu( r(& ting to t!( st tus o1 t!( AW2O " s r is( in t!(% r&i m(nt in *<80, n t!( MoS in t!( Ministr o1 )(1(n'( ! t #(n t!( st nt! t t!( t!( Mo) " s not 'on'(rn( "it! t!( 11 irs o1 t!( AW2OH

iii/ No M(m9(r o1 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt is nomin t( 9 t!( C(ntr &Go (rnm(nt, nor ' n !( 9( r(mo ( 9 it. Furt!(r, n(it!(r t!( C(ntr &Go (rnm(nt nor t!( A2 ' n issu( n s ('i & or g(n(r & ir('tions to t!(AW2OH

i / It is n(it!(r Br n'! o1 t!( o11i'( o1 AG or Arm 2( u rt(rsH noris it n instrum(nt &it o1 t!( C(ntr & Go (rnm(ntH

/ T!( "(9sit( o1 In i n Arm s!o"s t!( AW2O s rt o1 )G:sBr n'! 9ut t!is "(9sit( ! s not 9((n 'r( t( 9 t!( AW2O. R(g r &(ss o1 t!(

9o (, t!( 1 't r(m ins t! t t!( AW2O is not rt o1 t!( AG:s Br n'!. T!isn mo& ! s to 9( ( & in( 9 t!( Arm 2( u rt(rs n not 9 t!( AW2OH

i/ T!( &o ns n'( to t!( AW2O 9 t!( Mo) o not r(1&('t t!(Go (rnm(nt:S 'ontro& o (r AW2O or on its 1un'tioningH

ii/ 2o& ing o1 Annu & Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt m((tings in t!( r(mis(s o1E-in-C:s Br n'! or in t!( AG:s o11i'( o(s not r(1&('t Arm :s 'ontro& o (r t!(AW2OH

*3

iii/ )( ut tion o1 r(gu& r Arm O11i'(rs to t!( AW2O is r(gu& t( 9 t!(ir('tions issu( 9 Mo) to t!( Arm 2( u rt(rs n not to t!( AW2O.

T!is o'um(nt &so o(s not r(1&('t 'ontro& o1 t!( Mo)@A2 o (r t!( AW2OH

i / T!( AW2O is o (r ting on no ro1it no &oss: 9 sis n o(s not

r('(i ( n gr nts 1rom t!( Mo)@A2 . T!( s & ri(s o1 t!( ( ut tionist Armo11i'(rs n (rsonn(& r( 9(ing i 9 t!( AW2O 1rom its o"n 1un sH

/ A num9(r o1 s(nior Arm o11i'(rs r( r( r(s(nt( on t!( Bo r o1M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O in t!(ir ( -o11i'io ' 'it 1rom && t!( 'omm n so1 t!( Arm 9ut t!is o(s not n('(ss ri& (st 9&is! 'ontro& o1 Arm o (r t!(

11 irs o1 t!( AW2OH

i/ T ( (m tion gr nt( to t!( AW2O un (r t!( In'om( T A't isnot uni u( to t!( AW2O. Su'! ( (m tion is 9(ing gr nt( to t!ous n s o1ot!(r W(&1 r( Asso'i tions, C! rit 9&( Trusts n E u' tion & Foun tions (t'.M(r( gr nt o1 In'om( T ( (m tion ' nnot r(n (r t!( AW2O u9&i'

ut!orit

46. Ms. In u&(#! 2 & r, )( ut )ir('tor G(n(r &, AG:s Br n'!, ! s &so1i&( 9ri(1 r( r(s(nt tion t( 4. .40*3 in "!i'! s!( ! s rgu( t! t t!(1un s o1 t!( AW2O r( 'r( t( 9 its "(&1 r( 'ti iti(s n s!ort t(rm9orro"ings 1rom rious 1in n'( g(n'i(s n t! t t!( Arm 2( u rt(rs or

t!( Mo) o(s not gi ( n 1in n'i & i @ ssist n'( to t!( AW2O. S!( ! s &so'ont(n ( t! t t!( Mo) or AG:s Br n'! o(s not ( (r'is( n 'ontro& o (r t!(AW2O. T!( C! irm n n ot!(r M(m9(rs o1 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt nE ('uti ( Committ(( "!o r( s(nior s(r ing Arm o11i'(rs (r1orm t!(ir1un'tions ur(& in n ( -o11i'io ' 'it . % r 04 o1 !(r r( r(s(nt tion is( tr 't( 9(&o" =-

“2. he stat)s o9 A is as 9ollo&s :-

!a# A is a Societ %e iste%e" &ith the Re ist%a% o9 Societies$*elhi ) "e% the Societies Re ist%atio Act I o9 1 E0 a " its a99ai%sa%e co t%olle"$ a">i iste%e" a " >a a e" @ its Boa%" o9>a a e>e t a " ec)ti e Co>>ittee &hose >e>@e%s a%ea((oi te" i “ 99icioH ca(acit .

!@# he 9) "s o9 A a%e c%eate" @ its &el9a%e acti it a "sho%t te%> @o%%o&i s 9%o> a%io)s 9i a cial a e cies. A%>

ea"J)a%te%s o% the <i ist% o9 *e9e ce "oes ot i e a 9i a cial*7

ai"/assista ce to A . he latte% &o%ks o a o (%o9it o loss@asis a " )tiliDes 3M cost o9 co st%)ctio to&a%" esta@lish>e te (e "it)%e &hich i cl)"es sala%ies o9 sta99 a " %e tal o9 o99iceacco>>o"atio . he sta99 also i cl)"es se% i 99ice%s$ C s a "

R &hose sala%ies i cl)"i all >o eta% @e e9its a%e @ei 9) "e"

@ A . sta@lish>e t cost o9 A a " sala%ies to sta99>e>@e%s a%e (ai" @ A 9%o> the %e e )es e e%ate" 9%o> its&el9a%e acti ities &hich a%e 9) "e" @ the allottees.

!c# + io o9 I "ia o% the A"=)ta t e e%al B%a ch o9 A%>ea"J)a%te%s "oes ot e e%cise a co t%ol o e% A . he

"ischa% e o9 ")ties @ Chai%>a a " othe% >e>@e%s o9 the Boa%" o9<a a e>e t a " ec)ti e Co>>ittee &ho a%e all se io% se% iA%> 99ice%s is ()%el i a “ 99icioH ca(acit .H

* CISI N N IC AN* R AS NS

48. T!( u(stion 9(1or( t!( Commission is "!(t!(r t!( AW2O is u9&i'ut!orit un (r s('tion 4 !/ o1 t!( RTI A't.

4<. S('tion 4 !/ o1 t!( RTI A't (1in(s u9&i' ut!orit : s 1o&&o"s =-

!h# “()@lic a)tho%it H >ea s a a)tho%it o% @o" o% i stit)tioo9 sel9- o e% >e t esta@lishe" o% co stit)te"$ --

!a# @ o% ) "e% the Co stit)tio!@# @ a othe% la& >a"e @ a%lia>e t!c# @ a othe% la& >a"e @ State Le islat)%e

!"# @ oti9icatio iss)e" o% >a"e @ the a((%o(%iateo e% >e t$ a " i cl)"es a

!i# @o" o& e"$ co t%olle" o% s)@sta tiall 9i a ce"!ii# o - o e% >e t % a isatio s)@sta tiall9i a ce"$ "i%ectl o% i "i%ectl @ 9) "s (%o i"e" @ thea((%o(%iate o e%% >e t H

30. It is uit( '&( r to us t! t t!( AW2O o(s not 1 && in su9 '& us(s /, 9/5 '/ o1 '& us( !/ ( tr 't( 9o (. No", t!( u(stions t! t r(m in to 9('onsi (r( is =-

i/ "!(t!(r t!( AW2O is 'ontro&&( 9 A2 H 5@orii/ "!(t!(r t!( AW2O is su9st nti && 1in n'( 9 Mo).

*



3*. W( "i&& t #( u issu( num9(r i/ 1irst. As not( !(r(in 9o (, t!(AW2O ! s 9((n s!o"n s on( o1 t!( Br n'!(s@O11i'(s o1 t!( AG:s o11i'( int!( Arm :s "(9sit(. E (n i1 t!( 'ont(ntion m ( on 9(! &1 o1 t!( AW2O t! tt!( "(9sit( is t!( 'r( tion o1 t!( Arm n not t! t o1 t!( AW2O is ''( t( ,

t!( 1 't r(m ins t! t uring && t!(s( ( rs, t!( AW2O ! s 9((n tr( t( s "ing o1 AG:s o11i'( 1or && r 'ti' & ur os(s. T!( 'onstitution o1 t!( Bo r o1M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O, ! s 9((n ( i't( in r *0 9o (. Out o1 *

tt(n ((s o1 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt m((ting !(& on *+.4.40*4, t!r(( "(r(Li(ut(n nt G(n(r &s n s( (n M $or G(n(r &s. T!( r(st o1 t!( tt(n ((s "(r(

&so s(r ing Arm o11i'(rs. In our o inion, t!( 'om osition o1 t!( Bo r o1M n g(m(nt o1 t!( AW2O r(1&('ts its tru( '! r 't(r. It is not!ing 9ut n( t(ntion o1 t!( A2 . As not( 9o (, t!( A $ut nt G(n(r & ! s &" s 9((nt!( ( -o11i'io C! irm n o1 t!( AW2O ( (r sin'( its in'( tion. rious'omm n s o1 t!( Arm r( r( r(s(nt( on t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt t (rs(nior &( (&s. A&& m $or ('isions r(g r ing t!( 1un'tioning o1 t!( AW2O r(t #(n 9 t!( Bo r o1 M n g(m(nt "!i'! is un (r t!( (r si ( 'ontro& o1 t!(s(r ing Arm o11i'(rs, "it! t!( AG s its 2( . In i(" o1 t!is, "( ! ( no!(sit tion to 'om( to t!( 'on'&usion t! t A2 'ontro&s t!( 11 irs o1 t!(AW2O t!roug! t!( A $ut nt G(n(r & 1or && int(nts n ur os(s. E ('ution o1t!( o&i' 9 t!( (m &o ((s o1 t!( AW2O, 'om rising o1 Arm (rsonn(& n'i i&i ns, in our o inion, o(s not &t(r t!( (ss(nti & '! r 't(r o1 t!( AW2O s

n Arm org nis tion. Furt!(r-mor(, r(gu& r ( ut tion o1 Arm o11i'(rs to t!(AW2O on t!( t(rms n 'on itions (t(rmin( 9 t!( Mo), &so r(in1or'(s t!(

im r(ssion t! t in uint-(ss(n'( t!( AW2O is not!ing 9ut n ArmOrg nis tion. As t!( Arm is u9&i' ut!orit u@s 4 !/, "( !o& t! t t!(AW2O, 9 irtu( o1 its 9(ing un (r t!( (r si ( n (11('ti ( 'ontro& o1 t!(Arm , is &so u9&i' ut!orit 9 rit o1 r( soning.

34. No" "( 'om( to t!( u(stion o1 "!(t!(r t!( AW2O ' n 9( s iin ir('t& 1in n'( 9 t!( C(ntr & Go (rnm(nt. T!r(( inst n'(s o1 gr nt o1 &o n9 t!( Mo) to t!( AW2O ! ( 'om( on r('or . In our o inion, &o ns ' nnot9( 'onstru( s gr nts s &o ns r( r( 9&( 9 t!( 9orro"(r. T!(s( &o nssim & r(1&('t t!( Mo):s s m t!(ti' n !(& 1u& ttitu ( to" r s t!( AW2O.2o"( (r, t!( in'om( t ( (m tion gr nt( to t!( AW2O un (r t!( In'om(T A't st n s on i11(r(nt 1ooting. No 1irm 1igur(s ! ( 9((n ro1(rr(9(1or( us r(g r ing t!( ( (m tion i&( o1 9 t!( AW2O o (r t!( ( rs 9utt!is 1 't ! s not 9((n (ni( 9 t!( 'ouns(& o1 t!( AW2O (it!(r in or & or"ritt(n su9missions. E (m tion 1rom In'om( T , sur(& , 9(sto"s 1in n'i &9(n(1its on t!( AW2O.

*+

33. To sum u , "( !o& t! t t!( AW2O, t!oug! on (r s( r t( (ntit , isnot!ing 9ut n ( t(ntion o1 t!( Arm 9 irtu( o1 9(ing un (r t!( && (r si ('ontro& o1 t!( s(nior s(r ing Arm o11i'(rs, in'&u ing t!( AG. W(, t!(r(1or(,!o& t! t t!( AW2O is u9&i' ut!orit u@s 4 !/ o1 t!( RTI A't. 2(n'(, "(

ir('t t!( )ir('tor G(n(r &, AW2O, to (sign t( C%IO n 1irst A (&& t(

Aut!orit un (r t!( RTI A't "it! in 04 &eeks o1 t!( r('(i t o1 t!is or (r.A1t(r ssum tion o1 o11i'(, t!( C%IO "ou& r(s on to t!( RTI &i' tion in

u(stion s (r & " in 30 s tim(. T!( (&& nt r(s(r (s t!( rig!t to ( &g inst t!( or (r o1 t!( C%IO un (r t!( ro isions o1 s('tion *< o1 t!( RTI A't.

Or (r r(s(r ( n ronoun'( on 7 t! u& , 40*3.

i$ S! rm / M.L. S! rm /

In1orm tion Commission(r In1orm tion Commission(r

S t n n Mis!r / C!i(1 In1orm tion Commission(r

*6



Aut!(nti' t( tru( 'o . A ition & 'o i(s o1 or (rs s! && 9( su &i( g inst&i' tion n m(nt o1 t!( '! rg(s, r(s'ri9( un (r t!( A't, to t!( C%IO o1 t!is

Commission.

K.L. ) s /)( ut R(gistr r

A r(ss o1 rti(s =-

*. T!( Lt. Co&. 5 C%IO, RTI C(&&, A)G AE, G-+, )-Wing,S(n B! " n, G t( No. 7, I2 o1 Mo) Arm /,N(" )(&!i-**00**.

4. Lt. Co&. R. B ns & R(t ./,74 S r s" ti i! r, R i ur Ro ,)(!r un-47800*.

*8

Decision_dated_04.07.2013_-_Lt._Col._Retd._R._Bansal_Vs._Army_Welfare_Housing_Organisation_AWHO_Full_Bench.pdf...

Documents

Transcript of Decision_dated_04.07.2013_-_Lt._Col._Retd._R._Bansal_Vs._Army_Welfare_Housing_Organisation_AWHO_Full_Bench.pdf...