CSAE Working Paper WPS/201612 · 2019-06-17 · csae working paper wps/201612 ... mi ih@l...

#+164+!,24!6-+!&67*8!2,!",4.)(1!$)2120.+5

5GQCSUNGOU!PH!6EPOPNKET!"!@OKWGSTKUZ!PH!<YHPSF!"!9COPS!>PCF!3VKMFKOI!"!<YHPSF!<B)!+@=

[1!$,,!"(#)0.-!*/)(0,!"!M1!$,,!"(#)0.-!*0),,/!"!L1!ETCG&GORVKSKGT2GEPOPNKET&PY&CE&VL!"!^1!XXX&ETCG&PY&CE&VL

CSAE Working Paper WPS/201612

,7?67B"0B<7?D76 /3?9E397C 3?6 +7>3=7/34@EB +@B57 13BD<5<A3D<@?'

*F<67?57 8B@> 2E4"23;3B3? (8B<53 !

4D>C@FF@ 6<I !

%?6 -E?7! %#$& $

(4CDB35D' 9LDHB MC@ ?<M< AKIG MC@ -@GIBK<JCD> <H? 0@<FMC 7NKO@RL! MCDL

J<J@K @LMDG<M@L MC@ K@F<MDIHLCDJ =@MP@@H F<HBN<B@ <H? F<=INK AIK>@ J<KMD>"

DJ<MDIH IA PIG@H DH 7N="7<C<K<H +AKD><# 8C@ K@LNFML LNBB@LM MC<M PIG@H

PCI LJ@<E F<HBN<B@L PDMC LMKIHB@K ?DLMDH>MDIHL =@MP@@H G<L>NFDH@ <H? A@G"

DHDH@ <K@ F@LL FDE@FR MI J<KMD>DJ<M@ DH MC@ F<=INK AIK>@# 8CDL K@F<MDIHLCDJ

CIF?L =IMC <>KILL <H? PDMCDH >INHMKD@L! @O@H <AM@K >IHMKIFFDHB AIK DH?DOD?N<F

>C<K<>M@KDLMD>L! K@FDBDIH <H? JKIQD@L AIK B@H?@K LI>D<F HIKGL K@F<M@? MI IH@L

@MCHD>DMR! LN>C <L CDLMIKD><F NL@ IA MC@ JFINBC# 8C@ K@LNFML LNBB@LM MC<M F<H"

BN<B@ C<L < ?DK@>M @!@>M IH JK@A@K@H>@L K@B<K?DHB F<=INK G<KE@M ?@>DLDIHL!

<=IO@ <H? =@RIH? B@H?@K HIKGL <KDLDHB AKIG @MCHD>DMR <H? K@FDBDIH# 8C@L@

SH?DHBL >IHMKD=NM@ MI MC@ BKIPDHB FDM@K<MNK@ IH MC@ K@F<MDIHLCDJ =@MP@@H

LI>DI"JLR>CIFIBD><F A<>MIKL <H? B@H?@K ?D!@K@H>@L DH @>IHIGD> INM>IG@L#

-*/ )=3CC<I53D<@?' -$&! 2%(! 5&)! $''

.7HG@B6C' 3<HBN<B@* 1?@HMDMR* ,NFMNK@* /@H?@K LI>D<F HIKGL* .@G<F@

F<=INK AIK>@ J<KMD>DJ<MDIH * 7<JDK";CIKA CRJIMC@LDL

!, E;3@= 'A@@3 +3CC<D! -3?7D )7@D=7! 'AF9>3D *A>><@! 1E783@A &3C<3 3@6 .FEK /3CE7@

8AC E;7<C 5A??7@ED 3@6 DF997DE<A@D"!2@<G7CD<EJ A8 0I8AC6# ?<5;7>>7"C3A$9?3<>"5A?$% G7CD<A@ A8 E;<D B3B7C H3D DF4?<EE76 3D 3@ 7IE7@676 7DD3J 8AC E;7 /15 <@ (5A@A?<5D

8AC '7G7>AB?7@E 3E 0I8AC6

&/6./9!(93/6</. '+61=+1/; +6. %/5+4/ '+,7=9 %79-/

)+9<3-38+<376" $>3./6-/ 0975 *=,!*+2+9+6 #093-+

'% 8QVTRGWFVLRQ

=T]STa SX!TaT]RTb X] [PQ^da \PaZTc ^dcR^\Tb aT\PX] P bXV]XsRP]c WX]SaP]RT c^TR^]^\XR STeT[^_\T]c "9dt^ +)**#' HWTbT SX!TaT]RTb _TabXbc êTa [^]V _TaX^Sb ÛcX\T% TeT] STb_XcT X\_aêT\T]cb X] TR^]^\XR Va^fcW P]S TSdRPcX^]P[ PccPX]\T]c"7[Pd P]S @PW] +))/#' ?] Tg_[PX]X]V cWXb caT]S% aTRT]c bcdSXTb U^Rdb ^] cWT a^[TÛ VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b P]S Rd[cdaP[ QT[XTUb cWPc SXRcPcT QTWPeX^da Uâ \T] P]Sf^\T] X] cWT [PQ^da UâRT "<âcX] +)).4 <Ta]P]STi +))0#'

HWXb _P_Ta X]eTbcXVPcTb cWT a^[T Û VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b ^] [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_P&cX^] cWa^dVW P R^]bXSTaPcX^] Û [P]VdPVT' ?] _PacXRd[Pa% [P]VdPVTb PaT SX!TaT]c X]cWT STVaTT c^ fWXRW cWTh SXbcX]VdXbW QTcfTT] QX^[^VXRP[ bTg X] cWTXa ]^d] R[PbbTb'KWTaTPb [P]VdPVTb bdRW Pb <aT]RW WPeT cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb% \PbRd[X]T P]S UT\X&]X]T% ^cWTa [P]VdPVTb% bdRW Pb cW^bT Ua^\ cWT CXVTa&8^]V^ UP\X[h% PaT Z]^f] UâR^\_[Tg ]^d] R[PbbXsRPcX^] bhbcT\b fXcW *) â \âT ]^d] R[PbbTb "9Xg^] *21/#'

? cTbc cWT Wh_^cWTbXb cWPc f^\T] b_TPZX]V \âT VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb PaT[Tbb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] cWT [PQ^da UâRT' 6b PaVdTS Qh TR^]^\Xbcb bdRW PbCâcW "*22*#% [P]VdPVT UPRX[XcPcTb cWT caP]b\XbbX^] Û Rd[cdaT PRa^bb VT]TaPcX^]b'HWT fPh P [P]VdPVT \PaZb VT]STa o\Ph X]tdT]RT cWT bP[XT]RT Û VT]STa X] b_TPZ&Tabr \X]S "R^V]XcX^]# P]S(â \Ph aTtTRc cWT bP[XT]RT Û VT]STa SXbcX]RcX^]b X]cWT Rd[cdaT%p "7â^SXcbZh Tc P[' +)*, _'/.#' I]STabcP]SX]V cWT TgcT]c c^ fWXRW[P]VdPVT X]tdT]RTb cW^dVWc% P cTa\ [X]VdXbcXRb aTUTa c^ Pb [X]VdXbcXR aT[PcXeXch%Xb cWTaTUâT _^cT]cXP[[h X\_âcP]c Uâ ^da d]STabcP]SX]V Û VT]STa SX!TaT]RTb X][PQ^da \PaZTc ^dcR^\Tb'

IbX]V P aP]VT Û [X]VdXbcXRb b^daRTb% ? U^[[^f =Ph Tc P[' "+)*,# X] R^]bcadRcX]V PCd\QTa Û =T]STab ?]cT]bXch ?]STg "C=?? WT]RTUâcW# T`dP[ c^ * XU cWT [P]VdPVT^][h WPb cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb% P]S ) ^cWTafXbT' 8a^bb&[X]VdXbcXR bcdSXTb ^] 6UaXRP][P]VdPVTb bW^f cWPc [P]VdPVTb fXcW ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb cT]S c^ QT bTg&QPbTS%fWTaTPb [P]VdPVTb fXcW P [PaVTa ]d\QTa Û ]^d] R[PbbTb cT]S c^ QT d]aT[PcTS c^bTg SXbcX]RcX^]b "9X =PaQ^ +)*)#' HW^dVW cWTaT PaT TgRT_cX^]b c^ cWXb ad[T% C=??PRcb Pb P _a^gh X]SXRPcâ Uâ cWT X]cT]bXch Qh fWXRW cWT [P]VdPVT \PaZb VT]STa'

?] cWT sabc WP[U Û cWT _P_Ta% ? ad] cf^ bTcb Û aTVaTbbX^]b Û P] X]SXRPcâ Û UT&\P[T T\_[^h\T]c ^] C=?? dbX]V X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ SPcP ^] f^\T] X] GdQ&GPWPaP]6UaXRP Ua^\ cWT 9T\^VaP_WXR P]S >TP[cW GdaeThb' HWT RêPaXPcTb Uâ cWT sabc bTcÛ aTVaTbbX^]b PaT P aXRW bTc Û R^]ca^[b Uâ X]SXeXSdP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb P]S R^d]cahRWPaPRcTaXbcXRb aT[PcTS c^ VT^VaP_Wh% WXbcâh P]S R^]cT\_âPah TR^]^\XR T]eXa^]&\T]c' H^ T]bdaT \h aTbd[cb PaT ]^c SaXeT] Qh d]^QbTaeTS T!TRcb PRa^bb Va^d_b% ?ad] P bTc Û fXcWX]&Va^d_ aTVaTbbX^]b fXcW sgTS T!TRc Sd\\XTb Uâ R^d]cah% QXacWR^Wâc% \PaXcP[ bcPcdb P]S ]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT]' <X]P[[h% Pb ? RP]]^c Ud[[h ad[T ^dc^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb QXPb% ? U^[[^f 6[c^]YX% ;[STa P]S HPQTa "+)))# P]S DbcTa "+)*,#

"

#

X] `dP]cXUhX]V cWT _^cT]cXP[ QXPb Û cWT TbcX\PcTS caTPc\T]c T!TRc' Bh aTbd[cbR^]bXbcT]c[h bW^f cWPc f^\T] b_TPZX]V [P]VdPVTb fXcW ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb PaTP__a^gX\PcT[h . _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb [Tbb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] cWT [PQ^da UâRT'HWT \PV]XcdST Û cWXb aT[PcX^]bWX_ aT\PX]b R^]bXbcT]c P]S bcPcXbcXRP[[h bXV]XsRP]c%P]S Xb d]P!TRcTS Qh RWP]VTb X] Ud]RcX^]P[ Uâ\' <dacWTa\âT% Xc S^Tb ]^c bTT\c^ QT SaXeT] Qh bT[TRcX^] ^] d]^QbTaePQ[T RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb'

?] cWT bTR^]S WP[U Û cWT _P_Ta% ? X]eTbcXVPcT cWT _^cT]cXP[ \TRWP]Xb\b cWa^dVWfWXRW [P]VdPVT \Ph QT P!TRcX]V UT\P[T [PQ^da bd__[h' <Xabc[h% ? X]eTbcXVPcTfWTcWTa cWT aTbd[cb PaT SaXeT] Qh VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW cW^bT fW^b_TPZ VT]STa âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb% dbX]V _a^gh R^]ca^[b bdRW Pb aT[XVX^] P]S P]&RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb fWXRW WPeT QTT] bW^f] c^ WPeT T!TRcb ^] R^]cT\_âPahRd[cdaP[ QT[XTUb "6[TbX]P Tc P[' +)**4 <T]bZT% +)*.4 Cd]] P]S KP]cRWTZ^]% +))2#'GTR^]S[h% ? X]eTbcXVPcT cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S P f^\P]rb ]d\QTa ÛRWX[SaT]% TSdRPcX^]P[ PccPX]\T]c% P]S S^\TbcXR eX^[T]RT% Pb cWTbT \Ph QT Râ&aT[PcTS fXcW cWT ]Tc \PcTaXP[ QT]Tscb Û fâZX]V' FTbd[cb Ua^\ cWTbT bTcb ÛaTVaTbbX^]b _aêXST bdVVTbcXeT TeXST]RT cWPc cWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT Xb ]^c SaXeT]Qh SX!TaT]cXP[ \PcTaXP[ QT]Tscb c^ fâZ% â Ua^\ VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b PaXbX]V Ua^\aT[XVX^] â Ua^\ P]RTbcaP[ QT[XTUb'

7a^PS[h b_TPZX]V% \h aTbd[cb R^\_[T\T]c cWT TgXbcX]V T\_XaXRP[ TeXST]RT UâcWT X\_âcP]RT Û VT]STa XST]cXch X] [PQ^da \PaZTc ^dcR^\Tb'* Bh _P_Ta RP] QTbTT] Pb P] X]SXaTRc cTbc Û 6ZTa[Û P]S @aP]c^]rb \^ST[ Û XST]cXch "+)))% +))+%+)).#' HWa^dVW R^]bXSTaX]V cWT a^[T Û [P]VdPVT% ? _aêXST TeXST]RT X] bd__âc ÛcWT X\_âcP]RT Û R^V]XcXeT UaP\TfâZb P]S _bhRW^[^VXRP[ _Ph^!b X] Tg_[PX]X]Vf^\T]rb a^[Tb X] cWT [PQ^da \PaZTc'

Bh s]SX]Vb P[b^ R^\_[T\T]c aTRT]c bcdSXTb ^] [P]VdPVT P]S TR^]^\XR ^dc&R^\Tb' 8WT] "+)*,# s]Sb cWPc cWT fPh [P]VdPVTb VaP\\PcXRP[[h \PaZ cX\T Xb_aTSXRcXeT Û UdcdaT&âXT]cTS QTWPeX^da' B^bc R[^bT[h aT[PcTS c^ \h bcdSh Xb fâZQh =Ph Tc P[' "+)*,# fW^ s]S cWPc f^\T] b_TPZX]V [P]VdPVTb fXcW bca^]VTa VT]&STa SXbcX]RcX^]b PaT [Tbb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] cWT [PQ^da \PaZTc P]S _^[XcXRP[PRcXeXcXTb' ? SXbcX]VdXbW \h _P_Ta Ua^\ cWTbT fâZb X] cf^ fPhb'

<Xabc[h% Q^cW 8WT] "+)*,# P]S =Ph Tc 6[' "+)*,# aT[h WTPeX[h ^] cWT Kâ[S 6c[PbÛ AX]VdXbcXR GcadRcdaTb "K6AG#% P SPcPQPbT RêTaX]V *2+ bcadRcdaP[ _a^_TacXTbÛ fâ[S [P]VdPVTb Qh P cTP\ Û [X]VdXbcb' KWX[T cWXb SPcPbTc RêTab P fXST aP]VTÛ [P]VdPVTb X] R^d]caXTb fâ[SfXST% Xc [PRZb SPcP Uâ \P]h 6UaXRP] AP]VdPVTb'HWT aTbd[cb Û cWTbT _P_Tab cWTaTUâT WPeT [X\XcTS eP[dT Uâ d]STabcP]SX]V cWTaT[PcX^]bWX_ Û X]cTaTbc Uâ R^d]caXTb X] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP' ? PSSaTbb cWXb QhdbX]V P fXSTa aP]VT Û [P]VdPVT aTb^daRTb' ?] c^cP[% ? PSS P] PSSXcX^]P[ -0 6UaXRP][P]VdPVTb c^ \h P]P[hbXb cWPc PaT ]^c R^]bXSTaTS X] =Ph Tc P[' "+)),#'

GTR^]S[h% TbcX\PcX^] X] =Ph Tc P[' "+)*,# aT[XTb _aX\PaX[h ^] Ra^bb&R^d]cahePaXPcX^]' 7h X]cTVaPcX]V cWT 9T\^VaP_WXR P]S >TP[cW GdaeThb% ? WPeT P [PaVTaSPcPbTc fXcW \âT STcPX[TS SPcP ^] X]SXeXSdP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb' HWXb P[[^fb \T c^QTccTa PRR^d]c Uâ d]^QbTaePQ[T RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb PRa^bb Va^d_b% cWa^dVW XST]cXsRP&

!HRR 7R^`^NZQ "+)**# S[^ N SaXX ^RbVRc [S ÙR XV`R^Nà^R'

$

cX^] dbX]V ePaXPcX^] Uâ f^\T] fXcWX] cWT bP\T R^d]cah% cWT bP\T QXacW R^Wâc%P]S fXcW bX\X[Pa UP\X[h bcadRcdaTb'

HWa^dVW U^RdbX]V ^][h ^] R^d]caXTb fXcWX] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP% \h _P_Ta P[b^_aêXSTb P] X]cTaTbcX]V R^\_[T\T]c c^ =Ph Tc P['rb V[^QP[ bcdSh' GdQ&GPWPaP]6UaXRP Xb ^]T Û cWT \^bc [X]VdXbcXRP[[h SXeTabT aTVX^]b X] cWT fâ[S% W^bcX]V \âTcWP] ,)! Û cWT fâ[Srb [P]VdPVTb "EPd[ Tc P[' +))2#' 9Tb_XcT cWXb SXeTabXch%\P]h VêTa]\T]cb X] 6UaXRP] R^d]caXTb T]UâRT cWT dbT Û Ydbc ^]T 6UaXRP] âR^[^]XP[ [P]VdPVT Uâ \TSXd\ Û X]bcadRcX^] P]S fâZ' <â cWXb aTPb^]% [X]VdXbcXRXbbdTb X] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP PaT ePbc[h SX!TaT]c Ua^\ cW^bT X] cWT KTbcTa] Kâ[S'Bh U^Rdb ^] cWXb aTVX^] cWTaTUâT _aêXSTb P d]X`dT ^__âcd]Xch c^ d]STabcP]ScWT TgcT]c c^ fWXRW VT]STa a^[Tb X\_^bTS Qh [P]VdPVT bdaeXeT X]cTaPRcX^]b X][^]V bcP]SX]V \d[cX&[X]VdP[ T]eXa^]\T]cb' Bh aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc cWT T!TRc Û[P]VdPVT ^] [PQ^da \PaZTc ^dcR^\Tb Uâ f^\T] TgXbcb X] cWXb aTVX^]% Qdc WPb P]^cXRTPQ[h b\P[[Ta T!TRc cWP] cWPc U^d]S X] ^cWTa R^d]caXTb'

(% <RWQ 2ODUUL^FDVLRQ @[UVHPU DQG 6HQGHT

AP]VdPVTb SX!Ta X] cWT STVaTT c^ fWXRW cWTh \PZT SXbcX]RcX^]b QTcfTT] bTgTb X]cWTXa VaP\\Pa' D]T R^\\^] \PaZTa Û QX^[^VXRP[ bTg Xb U^d]S X] ]^d] R[PbbXsRP&cX^] bhbcT\b% oP] ^Q[XVPcâh VaP\\PcXRP[ bhbcT\% fWTaT TPRW ]^d] RW^^bTb Ua^\P b\P[[ ]d\QTa Û _^bbXQX[XcXTbp "9Xg^] *21/#' HWT TgXbcT]RT Û P R[PbbXsRPcX^]bhbcT\ Xb X]SXRPcTS Qh cWT _aTbT]RT Û _aTsgTb â ^Q[XVPcâh PacXR[Tb cWPc RWP]VTPRRâSX]V c^ P ]^d] R[Pbb'

CXVTa&8^]V^ [P]VdPVTb% ^]T Û cWT [PaVTbc UP\X[h Û [P]VdPVTb b_^ZT] X] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP% cT]S c^ WPeT \âT cWP] cT] ]^d] R[PbbTb aT[PcTS c^ P]X\PcT P]SX]P]X\PcT ^QYTRcb P]S S^ ]^c WPeT X]SXRPcâb Uâ QX^[^VXRP[ bTg' GfPWX[X Xb ^]T ÛcWTbT [P]VdPVTb% P]S WPb P c^cP[ Û *1 ]^d] R[PbbTb' Hf^ Û cWTbT ]^d] R[PbbTb%8[Pbb * P]S 8[Pbb -%+ PaT dbTS Uâ ]^d]b aTUTaaX]V c^ _T^_[T P]S ]P\Tb Û caTTb%aTb_TRcXeT[h' 6b bTT] X] cWT TgP\_[T QT[^f% cWT TgXbcT]RT Û P ]^d] R[Pbb bhbcT\Xb TeXST]RTS Qh P RâaTb_^]SX]V RWP]VT X] cWT _aTsgTb Û cWT ]^d] P]S eTaQ'

D" BfP]PUd]iX P]Pb^\P B]SX\d d[XP]VdZPGcdST]c aTPSb' 8A6GG *' GX]Vd[Pa AX\T caTT UT[[' 8A6GG -' GX]Vd[PaoHWT bcdST]c Xb aTPSX]Vp oHWT [X\T caTT UT[[p

!1GDSVHG ITRP =MLDPER (&'*"

7h R^]caPbc% cWT ]^d] R[PbbXsRPcX^] bhbcT\ X] G^\P[X% P] 6Ua^PbXPcXR [P]VdPVTb_^ZT] X] G^\P[XP% ;cWX^_XP% 9YXQ^dcX P]S @T]hP% WPb ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb m\PbRd[X]T P]S UT\X]X]T' HWTbT PaT P[b^ TeXST]RTS ^dcbXST Û cWT ]^d] XcbT[U% QdcQh P RâaTb_^]SX]V RWP]VT X] cWT bd"gTb Û cWT eTaQ P]S ]^d]'

"IUR_R N^R [ÙR^cV_R WZ[cZ N_ ÙR hC&cNi NZQ hC&YVi PXN__R_

%

E" QPPQdOda&ZXX fPPdd hX\XS ]jPPV&cXX fPPPh cX\XSHadRZ R^\T' B6G8' GX]Vd[Pa K^\P] R^\T' <;B' GX]Vd[PaoHWT cadRZ RP\Tp oHWT f^\P] RP\Tp

!@DHHG '///# S%+,"

<^[[^fX]V =Ph Tc 6['rb \TcW^S^[^Vh "+)*,#% ? cWTaTUâT R^]bcadRc P Cd\QTa Û=T]STab ?]cT]bXch ?]STg "C=??# T`dP[ c^ * XU cWT [P]VdPVT ^][h WPb cf^ ]^d]R[PbbTb% P]S iTa^ ^cWTafXbT' 6b TeXST]RTS Qh 9X =PaQ^rb "+)*,# Ra^bb&[X]VdXbcXRbcdSh% ]^d] R[PbbXsRPcX^] bhbcT\b RP] QT bT_PaPcTS X]c^ cf^ RPcTVâXTb3 [P]VdPVTbfXcW ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb fWXRW cT]S c^ QT bTg QPbTS P]S [P]VdPVTb fXcW P[PaVT ]d\QTa Û ]^d] R[PbbTb cWPc S^ ]^c SaPf SXbcX]RcX^]b QTcfTT] cWT bTgTb',

HWTaTUâT% cW^dVW X\_TaUTRc% C=?? PRcb P _a^gh Uâ cWT X]cT]bXch Qh fWXRW cWT[P]VdPVT SaPfb SXbcX]RcX^]b QTcfTT] QX^[^VXRP[ bTgTb'

)% 7[SRVKHULU DQG ;HFKDQLUPU

HWT \PX] Wh_^cWTbXb Û cWT _P_Ta Xb cWPc f^\T] b_TPZX]V \âT VT]STa&âXT]cTS[P]VdPVTb PaT [Tbb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] cWT [PQ^da UâRT' HWXb Wh_^cWTbXb bcT\bUa^\ cf^ _^cT]cXP[ T!TRcb Û [P]VdPVT ^] bP[XT]Rh P]S VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b' ?]cWXb bTRcX^]% ? X[[dbcaPcT cWTbT T!TRcb cWa^dVW QdX[SX]V P bX\_[T \^ST[ Û QX]PahfâZ RW^XRT'

8aXcXRP[[h% ? U^[[^f 6ZTa[Û P]S @aP]c^] "+)))% +))+% +)).# X] Pbbd\X]V cWPc Pf^\P] Tg_TaXT]RTb R^V]XcXeT SXbb^]P]RT XU cWTXa PRcX^]b STeXPcT Ua^\ cW^bT _aT&bRaXQTS Qh b^RXTcP[ VT]STa ]â\b' 6 f^\P]rb dcX[Xch cWTaTUâT R^\_aXbTb cf^_Pacb3 P \PcTaXP[ _Ph^!% ST_T]ST]c ^] R^]bd\_cX^] P]S [TXbdaT% P]S P _bhRW^&[^VXRP[ _Ph^!% cWPc P__[XTb c^ f^\T] fW^ fâZ' ? Pbbd\T Uâ bX\_[XRXch cWPc cWTVT]STa _aTbRaXQTS ]â\ Uâ P[[ f^\T] Xb c^ ]^c fâZ' HWTaTUâT% P _bhRW^[^VXRP[SXbdcX[Xch Xb UT[c Qh f^\P] 9 ^][h XU cWTh RW^^bT c^ fâZ'

ATccX]V cWT dcX[Xch Ud]RcX^] QT PSSXcXeT[h bT_PaPQ[T X] _bhRW^[^VXRP[ P]S \PcTaXP[_Ph^!b% P f^\P]rb dcX[Xch VXeT] cWTXa fâZ bcPcdb Xb3

,#

% 5 6"3#

% ! ;#% # ! . " 7"(!! !%"*# #

fWTaT K Xb P QX]Pah X]SXRPcâ Uâ fâZ bcPcdb' HWT \PcTaXP[ _Ph^! Ua^\ fâZX]VXb RP_cdaTS Qh 6"3#

%! ;#

%#% P Ud]RcX^] Û R^]bd\_cX^] 3#

%% P]S [TXbdaT ;#

%' HWT

\PV]XcdST Û cWT _bhRW^[^VXRP[ R^bc Û fâZX]V Xb aT_aTbT]cTS Qh 7"(!! !%#% fWTaT7"(!! !%# " )'

7"(!! !%# ePaXTb Qh X]SXeXSdP[ ST_T]SX]V ^] cf^ UPRcâb' ?c sabc[h ST_T]Sb ^](!% cWT \PV]XcdST Û cWT R^\\^] SXbdcX[Xch Ua^\ fâZX]V cWPc Xb bWPaTS fXcWX]P Rd[cdaP[ Va^d_ "fWTcWTa cWXb Xb Qh R^d]cah% TcW]XR Va^d_% â ^cWTafXbT#' 6b

#IUR^R N^R NX_[ VZ_`NZPR_ cUR^R XNZTaNTR_ UNbR N YVd [S _Rd&ON_RQ NZQ Z[Z _Rd&ON_RQ TRZQR^ N__VTZ&YRZ` _e_`RY_' ?Z UV_ _àQe [S 6S^VPNZ XNZTaNTR è\[X[Te% U[cRbR^% >RVZR "*21+# N^TaR_ ÙN` ÙR_R N^RbRê ^N^R'

&

(! Xb ]^c _TaUTRc[h ^QbTaePQ[T% cWT X]SXeXSdP[ b_TRXsR _bhRW^[^VXRP[ _Ph^! UdacWTaST_T]Sb ^] !%% P cTa\ cWPc aTtTRcb cWT STVaTT c^ fWXRW cWT f^\P] RâaTRc[h eP[dTb(!' HWXb RP]% Uâ TgP\_[T% QT X]cTa_aTcTS Pb cWT bP[XT]Rh Û VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b'? Pbbd\T cWT U^[[^fX]V3

7"(!! !%# 5 !%(!! !% # M)! *N $9! (! ""+# )

HWTaTUâT% P f^\P] fX[[ RW^^bT c^ fâZ XU3

6"3# 5*% ! ;#5*

% # ! 6"3#5)% ! ;#5)

% # " !%(!",#

HWPc Xb% XU cWT ]Tc \PcTaXP[ QT]Tsc Û fâZX]V Xb VaTPcTa cWP] cWT _bhRW^[^VXRP[R^bc c^ fâZX]V'

6bbd\X]V RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb Û ^]Trb [P]VdPVT S^ ]^c SX!TaT]cXP[[h P!TRc cWT ]Tc\PcTaXP[ QT]Tsc Û fâZX]V% cWT aTbd[cb Ua^\ cWXb \^ST[ VXeT cf^ \PX] \TRWP]Xb\bcWa^dVW fWXRW b_TPZX]V P [P]VdPVT fXcW bca^]VTa bTg&SXbcX]RcX^]b \Ph aTSdRT[PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] Uâ f^\T]'

;HFKDQLUP ' \ @DOLHQF[0 AP]VdPVTb cWPc \PZT bca^]VTa SXbcX]RcX^]b QT&cfTT] \PbRd[X]T P]S UT\X]X]T X]RaTPbT cWT bP[XT]Rh% !%% Û VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b'6b bTT] X] bTRcX^] cf^% TeXST]RT Uâ ]^d] R[PbbTb Xb U^d]S FKJIB=> Û cWT ]^d]XcbT[U' ?U cWT [P]VdPVT WPb P ]^d] R[PbbXsRPcX^] bhbcT\ fWXRW Xb bTg QPbTS cWXb X]&RaTPbTb cWT _bhRW^[^VXRP[ SXbdcX[Xch Û fâZX]V Pb X]SXeXSdP[b QTR^\T \âT PfPaTÛ (!' HWPc Xb% Qh \PaZX]V VT]STa X] [X]VdXbcXRb% ob^RXP[ VT]STa Xb qRP[[TS d_r M' ' ' N\PZMX]VN Xc SX"Rd[c Uâ P b_TPZTa c^ XV]âT VT]STap ";RZTa P]S BR8^]]T[[&=X]Tc%+)*,% _'1/#' HWTaTUâT f^\T] b_TPZX]V C=?? 5 * [P]VdPVTb PaT [Tbb [XZT[h c^fâZ'

;HFKDQLUP ( \ 6HQGHT @RFLDO <RTPU0 K^\T] fW^ b_TPZ [P]VdPVTb fXcWbca^]V bTg&SXbcX]RcX^]b cT]S c^ QT Ua^\ b^RXTcXTb fXcW bca^]VTa Pbb^RXPcTS VT]STab^RXP[ ]â\b% P]S WT]RT P WXVWTa (!' 6b cWT PbbXV]\T]c Û ]^d]b X]c^ ]^d] R[PbbTbXb ÛcT] a^^cTS X] bT\P]cXRb "6XZWT]eP[S +)),#% cWT R[PbbXsRPcX^] Û ]^d]b X]c^bTg&QPbTS RPcTVâXTb R^d[S aTtTRc cWT VT]STa ]â\b X]WTaT]c c^ P]RTbcâb Û cW^bTb_TPZX]V cWT [P]VdPVT' HWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT ^] RdaaT]c TR^]^\XR ^dcR^\Tbf^d[S cWTaTUâT QT TeXST]RT Û X]cTa&VT]TaPcX^]P[ caP]b\XbbX^] Û VT]STa ]â\bcWPc PaT STT_[h a^^cTS X] b^RXTcXTb cWPc b_TPZ bTg&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb'

*% 3DVD

&"$" ,>DF@H9GAB< 9E= 0>9CJA 6KHL>MI

? dbT cWT SPcP ^] f^\T] [XeX]V X] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP Ua^\ cWT 9T\^VaP_WXRP]S >TP[cW GdaeThb "9>G# Ea^VaP\% P bTc Û bdaeThb Û ]PcX^]P[[h aT_aTbT]cPcXeTf^\T] êTa cWT PVT Û *.' IbT Û cWT 9>G VXeTb \T P] PSeP]cPVT êTa _aTeX^dbbcdSXTb Û [P]VdPVT P]S TR^]^\XR ^dcR^\Tb Uâ cWT U^[[^fX]V aTPb^]b' <Xabc[h%Xc _aêXSTb \T fXcW R^\_aTWT]bXeT X]SXRPcâb Uâ [P]VdPVT% T\_[^h\T]c% P]S

'

UP\X[XP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb Pc cWT X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[' GTR^]S[h% cWT SPcPbTcb PaT eTah[PaVT% fWXRW P[[^fb \T c^ dbT \TcW^Sb cWPc PaT \âT bcPcXbcXRP[[h ST\P]SX]V^] cWT SPcP% bdRW Pb Sd\\XTb Uâ R^d]cah P]S QXacW R^Wâcb% fXcW^dc bPRaXsRX]V_aTRXbX^]'

? dbT cWT \^bc aTRT]c bdaeTh fPeT cWPc WPb SPcP ^] [P]VdPVT b_^ZT] P]S SPcP aT&[PcTS c^ P f^\T]rb bcPcdb P]S T\_^fTa\T]c% X]R[dSX]V X]SXRPcâb ^] T\_[^h\T]c%TSdRPcX^]% P]S \PaaXPVT' 6UcTa \TaVX]V cWT SPcP% ? WPeT P c^cP[ Û ,2*%0)* ^QbTa&ePcX^]b PRa^bb +. R^d]caXTb X] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP'- Gd\\Pah bcPcXbcXRb Uâ \PX]ePaXPQ[Tb P]S X]SXeXSdP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb Û cWT bdQbP\_[T PaT U^d]S X] ADEOH ''

HPQ[T *n3 ?]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb

#*$ #+$AL]O\`K^SYX] ?OKX

#D^N( 7\\Y\$

@9<< +/0&/.2 )(,/#)(-1$

7WZVYcON +/0&/.2 )(/)#)(-2$

DO\`SMO +/0&/.2 )()-/#)(+*$

3Q\SM_V^_\O +/0&/.2 )(+.#)(-,$

3QO +1.&*11 +1(0#2(0-$

IOK\] YP 7N_MK^SYX +1.&*,/ .(+.#-(12$

5RSVN\OX +1-&-/, +(1/#+(1.$

HOKV^R <XNOb +1.&*11 ,(*,#*(-,$

?K\S^KV D^K^_] +1.&*11 )(/,#)(-1$

F\LKX D^K^_] +1.&*11 )(,1#)(-2$

5R\S]^SKX +1.&*11 )(.2#)(-2$

?_]VSW +1.&*11 )(+0#)(-.$

;DLQ BDTLDEOHU0

>TLPDT[ ODQJWDJH USRNHQ% HWTaT PaT cWaTT X]SXRPcâb aT[PcTS c^ [P]VdPVTcWPc P__TPa X] cWT 9>G bdaeThb3 ]PcXeT [P]VdPVT% [P]VdPVT b_^ZT] Pc W^\T% P]S[P]VdPVT Û cWT X]cTaeXTf' KWT] cWT sabc cf^ X]SXRPcâb PaT PePX[PQ[T% ? dbT cWT\

$IUR _a^bRe ^[aZQ_ a_RQ VZPXaQR3 7</% 7@/% 89/% 8=.% 8?/% 8C/% ;I/% =>/% =D/% A;/% AC/%BH.% CB.% CK.% D=/% D?/% DC/% GK-% HB/% HD/% HM.% I=/% J=/% MC/% MK/

(

Pb cWT \PX] X]SXRPcâ Uâ [P]VdPVT' DcWTafXbT% ? dbT [P]VdPVT Û cWT X]cTaeXTfPb P _a^gh Uâ _aX\Pah [P]VdPVT b_^ZT]' KWT] Xc Xb aT_âcTS P] X]cTa_aTcTa fPb]TTSTS c^ R^]SdRc cWT X]cTaeXTf% ? TgR[dST cWT ^QbTaePcX^] Ua^\ \h bP\_[T' HWXb[TPeTb P c^cP[ Û 0, [P]VdPVTb'

CRPHQ]U UVDVWU DQG HPSRYHTPHQV% HWT 9>G R^]SdRcb P bTc Û bdaeThbfXcW `dTbcX^]b aT[PcTS c^ P f^\P]rb bcPcdb P]S T\_^fTa\T]c' 7PbTS ^] cWTbT`dTbcX^]b% ? STs]T P bTc Û Sd\\h ePaXPQ[Tb Û X]cTaTbc' o-DGCFM>=p% Xb P Sd\\hePaXPQ[T cWPc X]SXRPcTb fWTcWTa â ]^c cWT X]SXeXSdP[ R^]bXSTab WTabT[U Pb T\_[^hTSPc cWT cX\T cWT `dTbcX^]]PXaT fPb R^]SdRcTS' 7PbTS ^] cWT 9>G Va^d_X]V Û^RRd_PcX^]b% ? STs]T X]SXRPcâb Uâ cWT X]SXeXSdP[rb ^RRd_PcX^]% bdRW Pb o6>HLB<>pP]S o)@HB<KCJKH>p'

&"%" +C9IIBN<9JBFE F? 29E@K9@>I

H^ R[PbbXUh [P]VdPVTb X]c^ cWTXa aTb_TRcXeT C=?? RPcTVâXTb% ? dbT P aP]VT Û SPcPb^daRTb c^ s]S cWT ]d\QTa Û ]^d] R[PbbTb Û TPRW [P]VdPVT X] \h 9>G SPcPbTc'HWT \PX] SPcP b^daRT dbTS Uâ cWXb Xb cWT Kâ[S 6c[Pb Û AX]VdXbcXR GcadRcdaTbD][X]T "K6AG#% P SPcPQPbT RêTaX]V *2+ bcadRcdaP[ _a^_TacXTb Û fâ[S [P]VdPVTbQh P cTP\ Û [X]VdXbcb' KXcWX] cWXb SPcPQPbT% ? dbT cWT RWP_cTa ^] oCd\QTa Û=T]STabp Qh 8âQTcc "+)*,# fW^ RPcTVâXiTb TPRW [P]VdPVT X]c^ cWTXa aTb_TRcXeT]d\QTa Û ]^d] R[PbbTb' BPcRWX]V cWT K6AG [P]VdPVTb fXcW cWT 9>G VXeTb cWT]^d] R[Pbb bhbcT\b Uâ *- [P]VdPVTb X] cWT 9>G'

<â cWT aT\PX]X]V .2 [P]VdPVTb% ? dbT P ePaXTch Û b^daRTb c^ R[PbbXUh cWT [P]&VdPVTb' ? dbT 6Q^dcKâ[SAP]VdPVTb'R^\ P]S ;cW]^[^VdT% ^][X]T aTb^daRTb cWPc_aêXST X]Uâ\PcX^] ^] cWT WXbcâh P]S VaP\\Pa Û fâ[S [P]VdPVTb' HWTbTSPcPQPbTb P[[^f \T c^ \PcRW P] PSSXcX^]P[ *. [P]VdPVTb ^] cWT 9>G' HWT aTbcÛ cWT [P]VdPVTb PaT R[PbbXsTS \P]dP[[h dbX]V P aP]VT Û 6UaXRP] [P]VdPVT VaP\&\Pa Q^^Zb "bTT P__T]SXg Uâ RXcPcX^]b#' HWTbT \TcW^Sb P[[^fTS \T c^ R[PbbXUh Pc^cP[ Û /) [P]VdPVTb X] \h SPcPbTc% [TPeX]V P c^cP[ Û +/0%/.2 ^QbTaePcX^]b' 6R^\_[TcT [Xbc Û cWT [P]VdPVT ]P\T% [P]VdPVT UP\X[h% ]d\QTa Û ]^d] R[PbbTb P]SX]Uâ\PcX^] b^daRT RP] QT U^d]S X] cWT P__T]SXg'

+% =XHTXLHY RI 4PSLTLFDO @VTDVHJ[

HWT \PX] T\_XaXRP[ \^ST[ dbTS X] cWXb _P_Ta Xb cWT AX]TPa Ea^QPQX[Xch B^ST["AEB#% T`dXeP[T]c c^ âSX]Pah [TPbc b`dPaTb fXcW P QX]Pah ST_T]ST]c ePaXPQ[T'KWX[bc ^cWTa Ud]RcX^]P[ Uâ\b% bdRW Pb A^VXc P]S Ea^QXc% PaT ÛcT] dbTS Uâ QX&]Pah ST_T]ST]c ePaXPQ[Tb% ? dbT AEB SdT c^ TPbT Û X]cTa_aTcPcX^] Û \PaVX]P[T!TRcb P]S tTgXQX[Xch Û b_TRXsRPcX^] "6]VaXbc P]S EXbRWZT +))1#' ? bW^f cWPc \haTbd[cb PaT a^Qdbc c^ SX!TaT]c Ud]RcX^]P[ Uâ\ P]S SXbcaXQdcX^]P[ Pbbd\_cX^]b X]cWT a^Qdbc]Tbb RWTRZb'

IbX]V cWT AEB% cWT R^]SXcX^]P[ _a^QPQX[Xch Û P] X]SXeXSdP[ QTX]V T\_[^hTSVXeT] cWTXa RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb Xb Pbbd\TS c^ QT [X]TPa bdRW cWPc cWT Tg_TRcTS eP[dT Û

)

T\_[^h\T]c "R^]SXcX^]P[ ^] C=?? P]S RêPaXPcTb# Xb VXeT] Qh3

&"D%&$!)'((&! !"#!! "#!4 "! #! ! !! "!# 5 " $ #)'((& $ ! !!"#! $ "!"#! $ $%&$"-#

fWTaT D%&$ Xb P QX]Pah ePaXPQ[T% X]SXRPcX]V fWTcWTa X]SXeXSdP[ 9 fXcW [P]VdPVT ;

P]S [XeX]V X] R^d]cah 3 Xb T\_[^hTS' Dda \PX] ePaXPQ[T Û X]cTaTbc Xb )'((& P]X]SXRPcâ Uâ fWTcWTa cWT [P]VdPVT b_^ZT] Qh cWT X]SXeXSdP[ WPb ^][h cf^ ]^d]R[PbbTb' !"#! Xb P < g * R^[d\] eTRcâ Û X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb% P]S "#!

Xb P] = g * R^[d\] eTRcâ Û R^d]cah b_TRXsR R^]ca^[b'

HWT \PX] TR^]^\TcaXR \^ST[ RP] cWTaTUâT QT Tg_aTbbTS Pb U^[[^fb3

D%&$ 5 " $ #)'((& $ ! !!"#! $ "!"#! $ $%&$".#

HWT sccTS eP[dT Ua^\ cWT \^ST[ VXeTb cWT _aTSXRcTS _a^QPQX[Xch Û P] X]SXeXS&dP[ QTX]V T\_[^hTS VXeT] WTa RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb' GcP]SPaS Taaâb PaT R[dbcTaTS Qh[P]VdPVT' HWXb P[[^fb \T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ "*# cWT X]T"RXT]Rh cWPc PaXbTb Ua^\ WTc&Ta^bZTSPbcXR bcP]SPaS Taaâb X]WTaT]c X] AEB \^ST[b% P]S "+# P]h RâaT[PcX^] X][PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] ^dcR^\Tb fXcWX] [P]VdPVT Va^d_b' HWT [PccTa Xb _Pa&cXRd[Pa[h X\_âcP]c VXeT] ^da R^]cTgc3 Pb C=?? ^][h ePaXTb Pc cWT [TeT[ Û cWT[P]VdPVT% fT ]TTS c^ PRR^d]c Uâ X]caP&R[Pbb RâaT[PcX^] b^ Pb ]^c c^ êTaTbcX\PcT_aTRXbX^] "B^d[c^] *21/#'

8GHQVL^FDVLRQ >TREOHP0 GX\X[Pa c^ bcP]SPaS DAG% cWT AEB _a^SdRTb R^]&bXbcT]c P]S d]QXPbTS TbcX\PcTb Û cWT cadT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h&\T]c ^][h XU cWT iTa^ R^]SXcX^]P[ \TP] Pbbd\_cX^] W^[Sb3

&"$%&$!)'((&4 !"#!! "#!"/# # 5 )

8^\\^] cWaTPcb c^ cWXb PaT aTeTabT RPdbP[Xch P]S ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb QXPb' ?][X]VdXbcXRb% cWT VT]STa âXT]cPcX^] Û P [P]VdPVT Xb R^]bXSTaTS c^ QT ^]T Û cWT\^bc \PcdaT P]S bcPQ[T UTPcdaTb Û [P]VdPVT% Uâ\TS _aXâ c^ [^]V Te^[dcX^]PahRWPX]b "9PW[ +))-4 KXRW\P]] P]S >^[\^] +))2#' HWTaTUâT% ? Pbbd\T cWTaT Xb ]âTeTabT RPdbP[Xch% Pb cWT VT]STa âXT]cPcX^] Û P [P]VdPVT Xb [XZT[h c^ QT Tg^VT]^db'

? P\ W^fTeTa% R^]RTa]TS fXcW ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb QXPb% fWXRW PaXbTb Ua^\ ^\XccX]VRêPaXPcTb cWPc \Ph QT RâaT[PcTS fXcW C=?? P]S fXcW [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^]'<â TgP\_[T% P] X]SXeXSdP[rb PS^_cX^] Û [P]VdPVT \Ph WPeT R^[^]XP[ âXVX]b' HWXbXb _PacXRd[Pa[h aT[TeP]c Uâ 6UaXRP] R^d]caXTb% fXcW ^"RXP[ [P]VdPVTb P]S [P]VdPVTÛ TSdRPcX^]P[ X]bcadRcX^] ÛcT] QTX]V cWT Uâ\Ta R^[^]XP[ [P]VdPVT' 6c cWT bP\TcX\T% R^[^]XP[ âXVX]b PaT bW^f] c^ WPeT [^]V ad] T!TRcb ^] TR^]^\XR Va^fcW P]SSTeT[^_\T]c% fWTcWTa cWXb Xb cWa^dVW cWTXa T!TRc ^] X]bcXcdcX^]b â b^RX^TR^]^\XRbcadRcdaTb ";]VTa\P] P]S G^Z^[^! *220% +))+4 AP EâcP Tc P[' *2214 6RT\^V[dTc P[' +))*% +))+#' D\XbbX^] Û R^[^]XP[ âXVX]b X] cWT \PX] b_TRXsRPcX^] f^d[ScWTaTUâT QT [XZT[h c^ [TPS c^ P] X]R^]bXbcT]c TbcX\PcT Û cWT cadT aT[PcX^]bWX_QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h\T]c' KWX[bc ? P\ PQ[T c^ R^]ca^[ Uâ b^\T Û cWTbT

*

^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb ^cWTab PaT d]^QbTaeTS P]S RP]]^c QT P__a^_aXPcT[h PRR^d]cTSUâ'

HWT aT\PX]STa Û cWXb _P_Ta bTTZb c^ \X]X\XiT cWXb QXPb X] âSTa c^ VTc R[^bTa c^cWT SXaTRc RPdbP[ aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb P]S [PQ^da UâRT_PacXRX_PcX^]' ?] bTRcX^] ,%'% ? dbT P [X]TPa _a^QPQX[Xch \^ST[ sabc[h fXcW R^]&ca^[b% P]S bTR^]S[h fXcW sgTS&T!TRc Sd\\XTb% c^ PRR^d]c Uâ bT[TRcX^] ^] R^d]cahâ X]SXeXSdP[&[TeT[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb cWPc \Ph QT SaXeX]V cWT aTbd[cb' 6b ? RP]]^cad[T ^dc ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb QXPb% ? cWT] `dP]cXUh cWT _^cT]cXP[ QXPb SaXeT] Qh d]&^QbTaePQ[T WTcTa^VT]TXch X] bTRcX^] ,%(' ?] bTRcX^] -% ? R^]ca^[ Uâ R^]cT\_âPahaT[XVX^db QT[XTUb P]S P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb' HWTbT ePaXPQ[Tb PRc Pb _a^gXTb UâVT]STa QT[XTUb P]S eP[dTb% P[[^fX]V \T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ Rd[cdaP[ QT[XTUb cWPc \Ph QTPbb^RXPcTS fXcW cW^bT fW^ b_TPZ C=?? [P]VdPVTb' HWXb T]PQ[Tb \T c^ VTc R[^bTa c^SXbcX]VdXbWX]V QTcfTT] cWT \TRWP]Xb\b cWa^dVW fWXRW [P]VdPVT \Ph QT P!TRcX]VfâZ RW^XRT Uâ f^\T]'

,% ;DLQ ?HUWOVU

'"$" *9I>CBE> 5>IKCJI

8QGLXLGWDO DQG 2RWQVT[ OHXHO FRQVTROU0Bh sabc bTc Û aTVaTbbX^]b% Pb b_TRXsTS X] T`dPcX^] . X]R[dSTb P aXRW bTc Û X]SXeXS&dP[ [TeT[ P]S R^d]cah b_TRXsR R^]ca^[b% /%&$ P]S 0&$% cWPc \Ph QT RâaT[PcTS fXcWQ^cW cWT Taaâ cTa\ P]S C=??'

7LUVRT[ 2RQVTROU0 6b _aTeX^db[h Tg_[PX]TS% R^[^]XP[ âXVX]b PaT [XZT[h c^ QTRâaT[PcTS fXcW Q^cW T\_[^h\T]c P]S PS^_cX^] Û [P]VdPVT' 8^\\^] R^[^]XP[[P]VdPVTb bdRW Pb <aT]RW P]S EâcdVdTbT ^][h WPeT cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb' ?U WPeX]VP <aT]RW â EâcdVdTbT R^[^]XiTa P[b^ [TS c^ bca^]VTa X]bcXcdcX^]b P]S WXVWTa T\&_[^h\T]c% cWT] ^\XbbX^] Û cWTbT X]SXRPcâb f^d[S [TPS c^ P] êTaTbcX\PcT Û cWTcadT T!TRc Û C=??' H^fPaS cWXb T]S% ? X]R[dST Sd\\h ePaXPQ[Tb Uâ R^[^]XP[ âXVX]X] \h \PX] b_TRXsRPcX^]' ? P[b^ R^]ca^[ Uâ TcW]XR UaPRcX^]P[XiPcX^] P]S WXbcâXRP[R^d]cah&[TeT[ b[PeT Tg_âcb% fWXRW 6[TbX]P P]S AP <TaaPaP "+)).# P]S Cd]] P]SKP]cRWTZ^] "+))2#% aTb_TRcXeT[h bW^f c^ QT ]TVPcXeT[h RâaT[PcTS fXcW TR^]^\XRSTeT[^_\T]c c^SPh' HWTbT R^]ca^[b P[[^f \T c^ PSSXcX^]P[[h PRR^d]c Uâ PS^_cX^]Û [P]VdPVTb cWPc \Ph QT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW WXbcâXRP[ X]cTaPRcX^]b QTcfTT] SX!TaT]cRd[cdaTb'

6HRJTDSK[ FRQVTROU0 ? U^[[^f Cd]] "+))1# X] R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ PQb^[dcT [PcX&cdST% cWT [^VPaXcW\ Û R^Pbc[X]T SXeXSTS Qh cWT [P]S PaTP% P]S fTPcWTa X]SXRPcâb%X]R[dSX]V PeTaPVT \X]X\d\ \^]cW[h aPX]UP[[% \PgX\d\ Wd\XSXch% P]S cT\_TaP&cdaT' HWTbT P[[^f \T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ cWT T!TRc Û VT^VaP_Wh ^] [^]V ad] TR^]^\XRSTeT[^_\T]c cWPc WPb QTT] U^d]S X] cWT [XcTaPcdaT "7[^^\ Tc P[' *2214 GPRWb TcP[% +))*#m fWTcWTa cWXb Xb cWa^dVW _aTeP[T]RT Û X]UTRcX^db SXbTPbTb% PVaXRd[cdaP[_a^SdRcXeXch â ^cWTa RWP]]T[b'

2RQVHPSRTDT[ FRQVTROU0 ? U^[[^f AP EâcP Tc P[' "+))1# P]S 8WT] "+)*,# X]cWTXa Ra^bb&R^d]cah aTVaTbbX^] \TcW^S^[^Vh X] R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ [^V =9E _Ta RP_XcP%

"!

Va^fcW Û =9E _Ta RP_XcP P]S cWT d]T\_[^h\T]c aPcT' HWTbT bTaeT Pb X]SXRPcâbUâ cWT TR^]^\XR T]eXa^]\T]c Û cWT R^d]cah% fWXRW X] cda] P!TRcb TPbT Û Y^QbTPaRW' ? P[b^ R^]ca^[ Uâ caPST ^_T]]Tbb% fWXRW kDi[Ta P]S CX[dkUTa "*22.# WPeTbW^f] c^ QT RâaT[PcTS fXcW UT\P[T [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^]'

8QGLXLGWDO FRQVTROU0 6c cWT X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[% ? U^[[^f 6[TbX]P Tc P[' "+)*,#X] R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ TSdRPcX^]P[ PccPX]\T]c% \PaXcP[ bcPcdb% daQP] bcPcdb% PVT P]SPVT b`dPaTS' 8^]ca^[[X]V Uâ PVT b`dPaTS P[[^fb \T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ _^cT]cXP[ PVTT!TRcb cWPc f^d[S ^cWTafXbT QT ^\XccTS X] cWT b_TRXsRPcX^]' ? UdacWTa R^]ca^[Uâ fTP[cW bcPcdb. P]S ]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT] Pc W^\T Pb cWTbT \Ph P!TRc cWT ]Tc\PcTaXP[ QT]Tsc c^ fâZX]V'

;bcX\PcTb Û T`dPcX^] . PaT aT_âcTS X] R^[d\]b *&- Û HPQ[T +' FTVaTbbX^]b "*#P]S "+# dbT ^][h Tg^VT]^db R^]ca^[b Uâ XST]cXsRPcX^]' FTVaTbbX^] "*# aT_âcb cWTaT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h\T]c R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ PVT P]S PVT b`dPaTS'HWXb R^T"RXT]c TbcX\PcT bd\\PaXiTb cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S _PacXR&X_PcX^] X] cWT [PQ^da UâRT3 ^] PeTaPVT% f^\T] b_TPZX]V [P]VdPVTb fXcW ^][hcf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb PaT -'/, _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb [Tbb [XZT[h c^ fâZ% cW^dVW cWXb Xb ]^cbXV]XsRP]c Pc cWT *)! [TeT[' FTVaTbbX^] "+# PSSb X] R^]ca^[b Uâ WXbcâh P]S VT^VaP&_Wh c^ T]bdaT fT PaT ]^c PccaXQdcX]V cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S [P]VdPVTc^ Ra^bb&R^d]cah SX!TaT]RTb X] sgTS RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb _TacPX]X]V c^ P] X]SXeXSdP[rbR^d]cah Û aTbXST]RT' 6UcTa PRR^d]cX]V Uâ sgTS R^d]cah [TeT[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb% cWT_aTSXRcTS aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h\T]c X]RaTPbTb X] \PV]XcdST%P]S Xb bXV]XsRP]c Pc .!'

6b cWXb aTbd[c \Ph QT R^]U^d]STS Qh \PaZTc R^]SXcX^]b b_TRXsR c^ cWT R^d]cahâ c^ cWT X]SXeXSdP[% aTVaTbbX^] ",# PSSb cWT Ud[[ bTc Û R^]cT\_âPah R^]ca^[baT[PcTS c^ P R^d]cahrb TR^]^\XR R^]SXcX^]b' HWXb P[[^fb \T c^ _PacXP[ ^dc P]hRâaT[PcX^] QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h\T]c cWPc \Ph QT SaXeT] Qh [PQ^da \PaZTcR^]SXcX^]b P!TRcX]V cWT PePX[PQX[Xch P]S TPbT Û bTRdaX]V T\_[^h\T]c' 6SSXcX^]Û R^]cT\_âPah R^d]cah [TeT[ R^]ca^[b X]RaTPbTb cWT _aTSXRcTS ]TVPcXeT T!TRc ÛC=?? c^ .'0+ _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb'

FTVaTbbX^] "-# PSSb X] cWT T]cXaT bTc Û X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ R^]ca^[b cWPc \Ph P!TRccWT ]Tc \PcTaXP[ QT]Tsc Û fâZX]V3 cWTbT X]R[dST ePaXPQ[Tb bdRW Pb \PaaXPVT%]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT]% daQP] bcPcdb P]S fTP[cW' HWXb VXeTb db cWT \PX] aTbd[c Û cWT_P_Ta3 P f^\P] b_TPZX]V P [P]VdPVT fXcW ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb Xb .'*. _TaRT]cPVT_^X]cb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] cWT [PQ^da UâRT'

C^cT WTaT cWPc cWT Ud[[ bTc Û X]SXeXSdP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb P]S R^]cT\_âPah R^]&ca^[b PaT _^cT]cXP[[h ^dcR^\Tb Û VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb' HWTaTUâT% cWTh R^d[SQT bTT] Pb oQPS R^]ca^[bp fWXRW% P[cW^dVW R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb QXPb%f^d[S P[b^ X]ca^SdRT Xcb ^f] bT[TRcX^] QXPb "6]VaXbc +))1#' 6b cWT R^T"RXT]cb S^

%KRNXÙ H`Nà_ V_ N 9>H VZQVPN`[^ S[^ _`NZQN^Q [S XVbVZT% YRN_a^RQ Oe [cZR^_UV\ NZQ NPPR__ `[ N__R`_NZQ ON_VP SNPVXV`VR_' IUR VZQRd V_ [Z N _PNXR [S *&.% VZ N_PRZQVZT [^QR^ [S cRNXÙ' Ce _\RPVkPN`V[Z a_R_QaYYe bN^VNOXR_ S[^ RNPU PN`RT[ê% RdPXaQVZT ÙR k^_`'

""

HPQ

[T+n

3B

PX]

FTb

d[c

b

"*#

"+#

",#

"-#

".#

"/#

"0#

;Y

\X[

eRQ

;Y

\X[

eRQ

;Y

\X[

eRQ

;Y

\X[

eRQ

;Y

\X[

eRQ

;Y

\X[

eRQ

;Y

\X[

eRQ

D=

??&)

')-/,

&)')

./0$$

&)')

.0+$$

&)')

.*.$$

&)')

.1.$$

&)')

.1+$$

&)')

.1)$$

")')

+11#

")')

++)#

")')

+*1#

")')

+)1#

")')

+1.#

")')

+1-#

")')

+1-#

?ZQ

VbVQ

aNX

8[Z`^

[X_

6TR

NZ

Q6

TR

H]a

N^R

Q

6TR

NZ

Q6

TR

H]

aN^R

Q

6TR

NZ

Q6

TR

H]a

N^R

QL

;H

L;

HL

;H

L;

H

>V_

`[ê

8[Z

`^[X_

DE

L;

HL

;H

L;

HD

ED

ED

E=

R[T^N

\Ue

8[Z`^

[X_

DE

L;

HL

;H

L;

HD

ED

ED

E8

[Z

`RY

\[^N

ê8

[Z`^

[X_

DE

DE

L;

HL

;H

DE

DE

DE

8[a

Z`^

e<

;D

ED

ED

ED

EL

;H

L;

HL

;H

7V^

Ù8

[U

[^`

<;

DE

DE

DE

DE

DE

L;

HL

;H

CN^V

`NX

H`N

à_

d8

UVX

Q^R

Z<

;D

ED

ED

ED

ED

ED

EL

;H

EO

_R^b

N`V

[Z

_+/0%/

.2

+/0%/

.2

+/0%/

.2

+//%1

1.

+//%1

1.

+//%1

1.

+/0%.

2)

G&_

]a

N^R

Q)'*

*+

)'*

./

)'*

.0

)'*

/)

)'*

0,

)'*

0-

)'*

00

,./-

+H

`NZ

QN^Q

R^^[

^_PX

a_`

R^RQ

N`

XRbRX

[S

ÙR

XNZ

Ta

NTR

N^R

^R\

[^`

RQVZ

\N^R

ZÙ

R_R_

'$%

$$

NZ

Q$$$

VZQ

VPN`R

ÙR

_VTZ

VkPN

ZPR

[S

ÙR

\&b

NXa

R_N`

*)!

%.!

NZ

Q*!

'9

R_P^

V\`V

[Z

[S

ÙR

_R`

[S

P[Z`^

[X_

N^R

N_

S[XX

[c_3

?ZQ

VbVQ

aNX

P[Z`^

[X_

N^R

NTR%

NTR

_]a

N^R

Q%

RQa

PN`V

[Z

NX

N``

NVZ

YRZ

`%Za

YO

R^[S

PUVX

Q^R

ZNZ

QY

N^V

`NX%

aÔ

NZ

NZ

Qc

RNX`

U_`

Nà

_4>

V_`[

êP[

Z`^

[X_

VZPX

aQ

RR`

UZ

VPS^

NP`

V[Z

NXV

fN`V

[Z

"S^[

Y6

XR_V

ZN

NZ

QB

N<

R^^N

^N+)).#%

UV_

`[^V

PNX

P[a

Z`^

e&X

RbRX

_XNbR

Rd\

[^`

_"S

^[Y

Da

ZZ

NZ

QK

NZ`P

URW

[Z

+))2#

NZ

QQ

aY

Ye

bN^V

NO

XR_

S[^

P[X[

ZVN

X[^V

TVZ

"VZ

PXa

QVZ

TVZ

QVP

N`[

^_S[

^7

^V`N

VZ%

<^N

ZPR

%F

[^`

aTNX%

7RX

TVa

Y%

H\

NVZ

%J

DNZ

Q?`

NXe

#4=

R[T^N

\Ue

P[Z

`^[X_

N^R

S^[Y

Da

ZZ

"+))1#%

VZPX

aQ

VZT

NO

_[Xa

`RXN

`Và

QR%

X[TN^V

ÙY

[S

P[N_`

XVZ

RQ

VbVQ

RQOe

XNZ

QN^R

N%

NbR^

NTR

YVZ

VYa

YY

[ZÙ

Xe^N

VZSN

XX%

YNdVY

aY

[S

Y[ZÙ

XeNS`

R^Z

[[Z

Ua

YVQ

Vè

NZ

QY

VZVY

aY

[S

NbR^

NTR

Y[ZÙ

Xe`R

Y\

R^Nà

^R4

8[Z`R

Y\

[^N

êP[

Z`^

[X_

VZPX

aQ

RX[

T[S

=9

F\

R^PN

\V`

N%

T^[

cÙ

[S

=9

F\

R^PN

\V`

N%

ÙR

aZ

RY\

X[eY

RZ`

^N`R

NZ

Q`^

NQ

R[\

RZZ

R__'

"#

]^c RWP]VT [PaVT[h Qh PSSX]V cWTbT R^]ca^[b "R^\_PaXb^] Û aTVaTbbX^]b +&-#% fTRP] QT aT[PcXeT[h R^]sST]c cWPc cWXb Uâ\ Û bT[TRcX^] Xb ]^c SaXeX]V ^da aTbd[cb'

CLVKLQ$6TRWS ?HJTHUULRQU0

9Tb_XcT cWT aXRW bTc Û R^]ca^[b Pc cWT R^d]cah P]S X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[% cWT aTbd[cbUa^\ aTVaTbbX^]b "*#&"-# R^d[S bcX[[ QT SaXeT] Qh d]^QbTaeTS SX!TaT]RTb PRa^bbR^d]caXTb â X] ]â\b P]S eP[dTb PRa^bb VT]TaPcX^]b P]S UP\X[h bcadRcdaTb' H^fPaScWXb T]S% ? R^]SdRc P bTaXTb Û aTVaTbbX^]b fXcW X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ R^]ca^[b P]S sgTST!TRcb% Pc cWT [TeT[ Û cWT R^d]cah P]S QXacW R^Wâc' ? cWT] U^[[^f 8WT] "+)*,# X]X]R[dSX]V sgTS T!TRcb Uâ \PaXcP[ bcPcdb P]S ]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT]' HWXb P[[^fb \Tc^ TbcX\PcT cWT T!TRc Û C=?? b^[T[h QPbTS ^] ePaXPcX^] fXcWX] Va^d_b' ? cWTaTUâTad[T ^dc P]h XST]cXsRPcX^] cWPc \Ph QT SaXeT] Qh d]^QbTaePQ[T RWPaPRcTaXbcXRbPRa^bb R^d]caXTb% VT]TaPcX^]b P]S UP\X[h bcadRcdaTb'

? TbcX\PcT cWT U^[[^fX]V3

D%&$ 5 " $ #)'((& $ ! !!"#! $

!!

$5*

%$3>B=A?D$ $

"!

%5*

&%29?A83>8>?A%$

"!

%5*

'%<1?9A1;@A1AB@% " 389;4?5=% $ $%&$

"0#

fWTaT !"#! PVPX] X]R[dSTb cWT bTc Û X]SXeXSdP[ b_TRXsR RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb' I][Tbb^cWTafXbT bcPcTS Uâ aTPb^]b Û \d[cXR^[[X]TPaXch% cWT bTc Û R^]ca^[b X]R[dSTS PaTcWT bP\T bTc Û R^]ca^[b Pb cW^bT _aTeX^db[h STs]TS' >TaT% 3>B=A?D$ Xb P Sd\\hePaXPQ[T bTc c^ * XU cWT X]SXeXSdP[ [XeTb X] R^d]cah 3' 29?A83>8>?A% PaT X]SXRPcâbUâ cWT X]SXeXSdP[rb hTPa Û QXacW% STs]TS X] seT hTPa X]cTaeP[b' <1?9A1;@A1AB@%%PaT P bTc Û X]SXRPcâb Uâ cWT X]SXeXSdP[rb \PaXcP[ Va^d_% Pb STs]TS Qh cWT 9>G'/

APbc[h% 389;4?5=% X]SXRPcTb P] X]SXeXSdP[rb ]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT]% X] Va^d_b Û seT'? aTUTa c^ cWT X]cTaPRcTS sgTS T!TRcb Û \PaXcP[ bcPcdb P]S ]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT] PboUP\X[h bcadRcdaTp sgTS T!TRcb'

Hf^ _^cT]cXP[ _a^Q[T\b \Ph ^RRda fWT] dbX]V sgTS T!TRcb Û cWXb ZX]S' <Xabc[h%fWX[bc cWXb \TcW^S^[^Vh P[[^fb \T c^ R^]ca^[ Uâ P aXRWTa bTc Û ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb%Xc Xb P[b^ \âT ST\P]SX]V ^] cWT SPcP' ?] cWT \^bc ST\P]SX]V b_TRXsRPcX^]fXcW R^d]cah% QXacW R^Wâc P]S UP\X[h bcadRcdaT sgTS T!TRcb% XST]cXsRPcX^] aT[XTbWTPeX[h ^] ePaXPcX^] fXcWX] cWTbT bdQVa^d_b aPcWTa cWP] [PaVT ePaXPcX^]b PRa^bbVa^d_b' HWXb \TP]b cWPc fT \Ph [^bT _^fTa P]S _aTRXbX^]' GTR^]S[h% XU cWTaT XbR[PbbXRP[ \TPbdaT\T]c Taaâ X] ^da SPcP% sgTS T!TRcb RP] fâbT] PccT]dPcX^] QXPbPb cWT bXV]P[ c^ ]^XbT aPcX^ Xb [XZT[h c^ QT [^fTa Uâ fXcWX]&Va^d_ ePaXPcX^]'

FTbd[cb Uâ cWT fXcWX]&Va^d_ aTVaTbbX^]b PaT aT_âcTS X] R^[d\]b .&0' FTVaTb&

&IUR^R N^R . YN^V`NX T^[a\_ ^R\[^`RQ VZ ÙR 9>H _a^bRe3 ZRbR^ VZ aZV[Z4 YN^^VRQ4 XVbVZT cVÙ \N^`ZR^4cVQ[cRQ4 QVb[^PRQ4 NZQ Z[ X[ZTR^ `[TRÙR^(_R\N^N`RQ

"$

bX^] ".# R^]ca^[b ^][h Uâ R^d]cah sgTS T!TRcb% dbX]V ^][h fXcWX] R^d]cah ePaXPcX^]'FTVaTbbX^] "/# XST]cXsTb cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S [PQ^da UâRT _PacXR&X_PcX^] Qh R^\_PaX]V ^][h X]SXeXSdP[b fXcWX] cWT bP\T R^d]cah P]S Qâ] X] cWTbP\T seT&hTPa b_P]' HWXb TbcX\PcT P[[^fb cWT R^]SXcX^]P[ \TP] Û cWT SXbcaXQdcX^]c^ RWP]VT PRa^bb R^d]caXTb P]S PRa^bb QXacW R^Wâcb'

<X]P[[h% X] aTVaTbbX^] "0#% ? PSS sgTS T!TRcb Uâ \PaXcP[ bcPcdb P]S ]d\QTa ÛRWX[SaT]% X]cTaPRcTS' HWTbT P[[^f \T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ P f^\P]rb UP\X[h bcadRcdaT%fWXRW \Ph QT P!TRcX]V cWT \PcTaXP[ QT]Tscb Û fâZX]V' 6VPX]% cWT TbcX\PcTbUâ cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] S^ ]^c RWP]VT[PaVT[h X] \PV]XcdST PaT bcX[[ bXV]XsRP]c Pc cWT .! [TeT[' C^cT WTaT cWPc bX\X[Pa c^cWT Ud[[ bTc Û R^]ca^[b Uâ X]SXeXSdP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb% cWTbT UP\X[h bcadRcdaT sgTST!TRcb R^d[S QT X]cTa_aTcTS Pb ^dcR^\Tb Û [P]VdPVT' HWT TbcX\PcTS aT[PcX^]bWX_WTaT bW^fb cWPc% TeT] V^X]V PQêT P]S QTh^]S cWT _^cT]cXP[ T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT ^]^dcR^\Tb aT[PcTS c^ \PaaXPVT P]S RWX[SaT]% cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]ST\_[^h\T]c bcX[[ W^[Sb'

?\_âcP]c[h% TbcX\PcX^] X] aTVaTbbX^]b .&0 P[[^fb \T c^ R^]ca^[ Uâ P]h d]^Q&bTaePQ[T RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb PRa^bb QXacW R^Wâcb% R^d]caXTb â UP\X[h bcadRcdaTb cWPc\Ph WPeT QTT] SaXeX]V cWT aTbd[cb X] aTVaTbbX^]b *&-' 9Tb_XcT cWT bcP]SPaS TaaâbQTX]V b[XVWc[h [PaVTa% cWT aTbd[cb PaT bcX[[ bXV]XsRP]c Pc cWT .! [TeT[' HWT X]RaTPbTX] \PV]XcdST Û cWT R^T"RXT]cb bdVVTbcb \TPbdaT\T]c Taaâ Xb ]^c QXPbX]V cWTTbcX\PcTS aT[PcX^]bWX_'

9T_T]SX]V ^] cWT b_TRXsRPcX^]% cWT bXiT Û cWT R^T"RXT]c aP]VTb Ua^\ !)").*.c^ !)").1)' 6c cWT [^fTa Q^d]S% \h aTbd[cb X\_[h cWPc RWP]VX]V Ua^\ P C=??5 ) c^ P C=?? 5 * [P]VdPVT Xb Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW P UP[[ X] T\_[^h\T]c cWPc Xb T`dP[c^ 1'+0! Û cWT PeTaPVT P]S *)'.! Û ^]T bcP]SPaS STeXPcX^] Û cWT T\_[^h\T]caPcT' HWTaTUâT% cW^dVW ]^c [PaVT% fWT] _dc X] R^]cTgc cWT TbcX\PcTS T!TRc WPb P\TP]X]VUd[ T!TRc ^] T\_[^h\T]c'

'"%" 6>C><JBFE FE 7EF;I>HL9;C>I

HWTaT Xb bcX[[ cWT _^bbXQX[Xch cWPc cWT TbcX\PcTS T!TRc Xb SaXeT] Qh d]^QbTaeTS^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb% bdRW Pb X]bcXcdcX^]P[ `dP[Xch% cWPc PaT ]^c Ud[[h PRR^d]cTS UâQh cWT bTc Û R^]ca^[b' H^fPaS cWXb T]S% ? dbT cTbcb _a^_^bTS Qh 6[c^]YX% ;[STaP]S HPQTa "+)))# P]S DbcTa "+)*,# c^ PbbTbb cWT bTeTaXch Û cWT _^cT]cXP[ QXPb SdTc^ d]^QbTaePQ[T WTcTa^VT]TXch'

HWT QPbXb Û cWXb cTbc Xb cWT Pbbd\_cX^] Û _a^_âcX^]P[ bT[TRcX^] fWXRW% X] cWTR^]cTgc Û cWXb _P_Ta% RP] QT STs]TS Pb U^[[^fb3

%%>C"*2@5?C54! )'((#

- 1?"*2@5?C54#5

%>C",=>2@5?C54! )'((#

- 1?",=>2@5?C54#

fWTaT % Xb cWT R^T"RXT]c Û _a^_âcX^]P[Xch' HWPc Xb% cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT]cWT d]^QbTaeTS ePaXPQ[Tb P]S C=?? "cWT caTPc\T]c# Xb _a^_âcX^]PcT c^ cWT aT[P&cX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] cWT ^QbTaeTS R^]ca^[b P]S C=??' =XeT] P Z]^f] %% DbcTa "+)*,#cWT] bW^fb cWPc fT PaT PQ[T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ cWT bT[TRcX^] SdT c^ d]^QbTaePQ[Tb% P]S

"%

cWTaTUâT STaXeT P R^]bXbcT]c P]S d]QXPbTS TbcX\Pcâ Uâ cWT caTPc\T]c T!TRc' C^cTW^fTeTa% cWPc cWXb \TcW^S Xb d]PQ[T c^ PRR^d]c Uâ od]^QbTaeTS R^]ca^[b fWXRW=F EFJ bWPaT RêPaXP]RT _a^_TacXTb fXcW cWT ^QbTaeTS R^]ca^[bp "DbcTa +)*,% _'2#'

?] _aPRcXRT% fT RP]]^c RP[Rd[PcT %' >^fTeTa% fT RP] TbcX\PcT cWT d]QXPbTScaTPc\T]c T!TRc VXeT] SX!TaT]c [TeT[b Û %' ? U^[[^f 6[c^]YX% ;[STa P]S HPQTa"+)).# P]S DbcTa "+)*,# X] Pbbd\X]V % # M)! *N3 Pb cWT R^]ca^[b PaT RW^bT] _aTRXbT[hc^ _PacXP[ ^dc RâaT[PcX^] SaXeT] Qh d]^QbTaePQ[Tb% 6[c^]YX Tc P[' "+)).# PaVdTP] d__Ta Q^d]S Û * Xb bdXcPQ[T Uâ P__[XTS P]P[hbXb' IbX]V cWXb Pbbd\_cX^]%? RP[Rd[PcT cWT TbcX\PcTS d]QXPbTS caTPc\T]c T!TRc d]STa cWT Pbbd\_cX^] cWPc% 5 ) P]S % 5 *% fWTaT % 5 ) Xb cWT \^bc ^_cX\XbcXR Pbbd\_cX^] fWXRW Pbbd\TbcWTaT Xb ]^ bT[TRcX^] ^] d]^QbTaePQ[Tb "P]S WT]RT ]^ ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb QXPb#% P]S% 5 * _aêXSTb cWT \^bc R^]bTaePcXeT TbcX\Pcâ% fWXRW Pbbd\Tb

%>C"*2@5?C54! )'((#

- 1?"*2@5?C54#5

%>C",=>2@5?C54! )'((#

- 1?",=>2@5?C54#

HPQ[T ,n3 8^T"RXT]c 7^d]Sb

#*$ #+$ #,$7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON

@9<< ')().*.%% ')().1.%% ')().1)%%#)()+)1$ #)()+1.$ #)()+1-$

5YO!MSOX^ 4Y_XN] #')(.*.& ')()*+1$ #')(.1.& ')().0)$ #')(.1)& ')().-*$

5YX^\YV]5YWZVOÔ DO^ YP

5YX^\YV]

5Y_X^\c 8SbON7"OM^] " <XNS`SN_KV

5YX^\YV]

5Y_X^\c& 4S\^R5YRY\^ KXN 8KWSVcD^\_M^_\O 87& 3QOKXN 3QO D[_K\ON

AL]O\`K^SYX] +//&11. +//&11. +/0&.2)C'][_K\ON )(*/) )(*0, )(*00

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX [S ÙR XNZTaNTR N^R ^R\[^`RQ VZ \N^RZÙR_R_' $% $$ NZQ $$$VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_ N` *)!% .! NZQ *!' 8[R!PVRZ` O[aZQ_ N^R PNXPaXN`RQ a_VZTÙR FH686B8 P[YYNZQ TRZR^N`RQ Oe E_`R^ "+)*,#' h8[Y\XR`R _R` [S P[Z`^[X_i ^RSR^_ `[ ÙR SaXX _R` [SVZQVbVQaNX% UV_`[ê% TR[T^N\Ue NZQ P[Z`RY\[^Nê P[Z`^[X_ QR_P^VORQ VZ "#$&% !' h?ZQVbVQaNX 8[Z`^[X_iN^R NX_[ XV_`RQ VZ "#$&% !'

6b bTT] Qh cWT R^T"RXT]c Q^d]Sb X] ADEOH ) \h aTbd[cb S^ ]^c bTT\ c^ QTSaXeT] Qh bT[TRcX^] ^] d]^QbTaePQ[Tb cWPc PaT bhbcT\PcXRP[[h RâaT[PcTS fXcW cWT^QbTaePQ[T RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb' 7XPb SdT c^ bT[TRcX^] ^] d]^QbTaePQ[Tb Xb _PacXRd[Pa[hWXVW fXcW cWT Ud[[ bTc Û X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ P]S R^d]cah [TeT[ R^]ca^[b3 WTaT% cWTd__Ta Q^d]S ^] cWT TbcX\PcTS T!TRc Xb aTSdRTS c^ &)')*+1 cW^dVW Xc Xb ]^c T[X\X&

"&

]PcTS' 7h R^]caPbc% cWT R^T"RXT]c Q^d]Sb ^] aTVaTbbX^]b "+# P]S ",# bdVVTbc cWPcTeT] d]STa cWT \^bc R^]bTaePcXeT Pbbd\_cX^] Û % 5 *% cWT TbcX\PcTS d]QXPbTScaTPc\T]c T!TRc aT\PX]b bcPcXbcXRP[[h bXV]XsRP]c P]S bX\X[Pa X] \PV]XcdST' HWXbbdVVTbcb cWPc% P[cW^dVW cWT bXiT Û cWT TbcX\PcTS caTPc\T]c T!TRc Xb bX\X[Pa QT&cfTT] b_TRXsRPcX^]b "*#% "+# P]S ",#% aTVaTbbX^]b fXcW sgTS T!TRcb "Pb X] "+# P]S",## PaT PQ[T c^ QTccTa PRR^d]c Uâ ^\XccTS ePaXPQ[Tb'

-% 8QXHUVLJDVLQJ VKH ;HFKDQLUPU

HWT aTbd[cb cWdb UPa S^ ]^c P[[^f \T c^ SXbcX]VdXbW QTcfTT] cWT _^cT]cXP[ \TRW&P]Xb\b cWa^dVW fWXRW VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVT \Ph QT P!TRcX]V fâZ RW^XRT Uâf^\T]' ?] cWXb bTRcX^]% ? PSSaTbb cWXb Qh SXaTRc[h R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ R^]cT\_âPahP]S P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb cWPc PaT bW^f] c^ QT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW VT]STa ]â\bP]S QT[XTUb X] cWT [XcTaPcdaT'

("$" 5>CB@BFE

?] ADEOH * ? ad] P aTVaTbbX^] Û T\_[^h\T]c ^] C=?? fXcW PSSXcX^]P[ R^]ca^[bUâ aT[XVX^]' ? S^ cWXb Qh dbX]V X]SXRPcâb Uâ P] X]SXeXSdP[ QTX]V Bdb[X\ P]S UâQTX]V 8WaXbcXP]% cWT cf^ \^bc _a^\X]T]c aT[XVX^]b X] \h bP\_[T Û R^d]caXTb'

FTVaTbbX^]b "*# P]S "+# R^]ca^[ Uâ +AHBIJB9E P]S 3KICBD bT_PaPcT[h' HWT R^TU&sRXT]c TbcX\PcTb bW^f cWPc aT[XVX^] WPb P [PaVT P]S bcPcXbcXRP[[h bXV]XsRP]c T!TRc^] UT\P[T [PQ^da bd__[h' FTVaTbbX^] "+#% Uâ TgP\_[T% bW^fb cWPc f^\T] fW^PaT Bdb[X\ PaT /'), _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb [Tbb [XZT[h c^ fâZ' HWXb T!TRc Xb [PaVTacWP] cWT TbcX\PcTS X\_PRc Û C=??% Qdc ]^cPQ[h% cWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT Xb ]^cT[X\X]PcTS' 6UcTa X]R[dSX]V Q^cW X]SXRPcâb X] aTVaTbbX^] ",#% cWT T!TRc Û C=??aTSdRTb c^ &)')-1+' HWT R^T"RXT]c Xb ^][h bXV]XsRP]c Pc *)!% cW^dVW cWXb S^Tb]^c bTT\ c^ QT SaXeT] Qh P] X]RaTPbT X] ]^XbT'

FPcWTa% cWT aTSdRcX^] X] \PV]XcdST P]S bXV]XsRP]RT Xb aTtTRcXeT Û cf^ UPRcâb'<Xabc% R^]bXbcT]c fXcW cWT [XcTaPcdaT "ATWaTa *22.% +))-4 8P\_P]cT P]S 9a^cc+)*,#% VT]STa QT[XTUb PaXbX]V Ua^\ cWT ?b[P\ aT[XVX^] WPeT P ]TVPcXeT T!TRc ^]UT\P[T [PQ^da bd__[h' GTR^]S% QTX]V Bdb[X\ Xb [XZT[h c^ QT _^bXcXeT[h RâaT[PcTSfXcW b_TPZX]V P [P]VdPVT fXcW ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb' <â TgP\_[T% 6aPQXR Xb PCX[^&GPWPaP] [P]VdPVT fXcW ^][h cf^ ]^d] R[PbbTb% P]S Xb \^bc R^\\^][h b_^ZT]Qh Bdb[X\b fâ[SfXST' 6b 3KICBD Xb ]TVPcXeT[h RâaT[PcTS fXcW C=?? P]S -D!

GCFM>=% Xcb PSSXcX^] X]c^ cWT aTVaTbbX^] aTSdRTb cWT \PV]XcdST Û cWT TbcX\PcTSR^T"RXT]c'

9Tb_XcT cWXb% cWT R^T"RXT]c ^] C=?? Xb bcX[[ bXV]XsRP]c Pc *)!' HW^dVW cWTT!TRc Û C=?? ^] [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] Xb bcX[[ b\P[[Ta cWP] cWPc Û 3KICBD%cWT a^[T Û C=?? S^Tb ]^c V^ PfPh' 8^\_PaX]V cWXb c^ cWT bP\T aTVaTbbX^] fXcW^dcR^]ca^[b Uâ aT[XVX^] X] ADEOH ( "R^T"RXT]c3 &)').1.4 bcP]SPaS Taaâ3 )')+1.#%cWT aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc Ydbc d]STa +) _TaRT]c Û cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=??P]S T\_[^h\T]c RP] QT Tg_[PX]TS Qh QT[XTUb PaXbX]V Ua^\ aT[XVX^db QT[XTUb' HWXb

"'

ST\^]bcaPcTb cWPc cWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT ^] [PQ^da bd__[h Xb ]^c SaXeT] fW^[[h QhSX!TaT]cXP[ VT]STa QT[XTUb PaXbX]V Ua^\ aT[XVX^]'

HPQ[T -n3 8^]ca^[[X]V Uâ FT[XVX^]

#*$ #+$ #,$7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON

@9<< ')().*0% ')()-1*% ')()-1+%#)()+00$ #)()+00$ #)()+01$

5R\S]^SKX )()-0.%%% )())2//#)()*/,$ #)()*0)$

?_]VSW ')()/),%%% ')().*0%#)()+++$ #)()+01$

5Y_X^\c 8SbON7"OM^]

I7D I7D I7D

<XNS`SN_KV 5YX^\YV] I7D I7D I7D

AL]O\`K^SYX] +//&11. +//&11. +//&11.C'][_K\ON )(*0- )(*0- )(*0-

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX [S ÙR XNZTaNTR N^R ^R\[^`RQ VZ \N^RZÙR_R_' $% $$ NZQ $$$VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_ N` *)!% .! NZQ *!' IUR SaXX _R` [S VZQVbVQaNX P[Z`^[X_ N^RQR_P^VORQ aZQR^ "#$&% !'

("%" )E<>IJH9C +A9H9<J>HBIJB<I

H^ UdacWTa SXbcX]VdXbW QTcfTT] cWT \TRWP]Xb\b% ? U^[[^f cWT Va^fX]V [XcTaPcdaTX] TR^]^\XR WXbcâh ^] Rd[cdaT P]S R^]ca^[ Uâ P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb cWPc PaT_^cT]cXP[[h aT[PcTS c^ eXTfb P]S QT[XTUb ^] cWT a^[T Û f^\T] X] b^RXTch c^SPh' ?UcWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h\T]c aT\PX]b a^Qdbc c^ cWTbT R^]ca^[b%cWT aTbd[cb f^d[S _aêXST bdVVTbcXeT TeXST]RT Û \TRWP]Xb\ *% bP[XT]Rh'

<â cWXb P]P[hbXb% ? \TaVT 9>G TcW]XRXch c^ cWPc Ua^\ BdaS^RZrb ;cW]^VaP_WXR6c[Pb' C^c P[[ TcW]XRXch ]P\Tb WPS P SXaTRc \PcRWX]V Û TcW]XRXch ]P\T fXcWcWT ;cW]^VaP_WXR 6c[Pb' G^\T Û f^\T] fTaT \TaT[h ]^c PbZTS PQ^dc cWTXaTcW]XRXch' DU cW^bT cWPc fTaT PbZTS% \P]h aTb_^]bTb m bdRW Pb o6UaXRP]p âoDcWTap fTaT d]X]Uâ\PcXeT4 \P]h TcW]XRXcXTb fTaT P[b^ bX\_[h ]^c X]R[dSTS X]cWT ;cW]^VaP_WXR 6c[Pb' HWXb [TPeTb \T fXcW *0-%11- ^QbTaePcX^]b Uâ cWT P]P[hbXb'6 aTVaTbbX^] Û T\_[^h\T]c ^] C=?? fXcW X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ R^]ca^[b P]S R^d]cah[TeT[ Sd\\XTb VXeTb P] TbcX\PcTS R^T"RXT]c% &)').1,% cWPc Xb bXV]XsRP]c Pc cWT*)!' HWXb bdVVTbcb cWPc% P[QTXc [^bb Û _aTRXbX^] _^cT]cXP[[h SdT c^ aTSdRcX^] X]bP\_[T bXiT% cWT dbT Û cWT bdQbTc Û f^\T] Uâ cWT P]P[hbXb X] cWXb bTRcX^] XbaT[PcXeT[h aT_aTbT]cPcXeT Û cWT \PX] 9>G bP\_[T'

?] ADEOH +% ? R^]ca^[ Uâ P bTc Û P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb cWPc PaT bW^f] c^ QT

"(

RâaT[PcTS fXcW VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b X] cWT [XcTaPcdaT' 6b cWTbT RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb WPeTQTT] bW^f] c^ P!TRc ^cWTa X]SXeXSdP[ ^dcR^\Tb aT[PcX]V c^ UPRcâb bdRW Pb \PaXcP[bcPcdb% TSdRPcX^] P]S ]d\QTa Û RWX[SaT]% ? ^][h X]R[dST Tg^VT]^db X]SXeXSdP[R^]ca^[b Uâ cWXb P]P[hbXb m PVT P]S PVT b`dPaTS' 8^[d\] * Û ADEOH + aT_âcbcWT QPbT[X]T aTVaTbbX^] fXcW R^]ca^[b Uâ PVT% PVT b`dPaTS% P]S R^d]cah [TeT[ sgTST!TRcb'

HPQ[T .n3 8^]ca^[[X]V Uâ 6]RTbcaP[ 8WPaPRcTaXbcXRb

#*$ #+$ #,$ #-$ #.$ #/$7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON

@9<< ')()//1% ')()/01% ')()/,2% ')()///% ')()//-%% ')()///%%#)(),,*$ #)(),.,$ #)(),-2$ #)(),,,$ #)(),+2$ #)(),+-$

BVY_QR )()++2#)(),0*$

3Q\SM_V^_\KVD_S^KLSVS^c

')()+++

#)(),,,$D_L]S]ÔXMO8S]RSXQ Y\;_X^SXQ

')()*-*

#)()+1/$D_L]S]ÔXMO3Q\SM_V^_\O

)()).12

#)(),/-$4\SNO B\SMO )(**1%%%

#)()+.,$

<XNS`SN_KV5YX^\YV]

3QO KXN3QO

D[_K\ON

3QO KXN3QO

D[_K\ON

3QO KXN3QO

D[_K\ON

3QO KXN3QO

D[_K\ON

3QO KXN3QO

D[_K\ON

3QO KXN3QO

D[_K\ON

5Y_X^\c8SbON 7"OM^]

I7D I7D I7D I7D I7D I7D

AL]O\`K^SYX] *0-&2+, *//&0/+ *0,&21/ *0*&1,0 *0-&2+, *0-&2+,C'][_K\ON )(*/2 )(*// )(*/1 )(*/1 )(*/2 )(*0)

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX [S ÙR XNZTaNTR N^R ^R\[^`RQ VZ \N^RZÙR_R_' $% $$ NZQ $$$VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_ N` *)!% .! NZQ *!' FX[aTU% HaO_V_`RZPR <V_UVZT [^ >aZ`VZT%HaO_V_`RZPR 6T^VPaXà^R NZQ 7^VQR F^VPR N^R bN^VNOXR_ TRZR^N`RQ S^[Y Ca^Q[PWj_ ;ÙZ[T^N\UVP 6`XN_'6T^VPaXà^NX HaV`NOVXVè V_ N YRN_a^R TRZR^N`RQ Oe 6XR_VZN R` NX' "+)*,#'

? sabc[h R^]ca^[ Uâ WXbcâXRP[ dbT Û cWT _[^dVW' 6[TbX]P Tc P[' "+)*,# s]S cWPcWXbcâXRP[ dbT Û cWT _[^dVW Xb _aTSXRcXeT Û R^]cT\_âPah VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\bP]S cWTaTUâT% Û UT\P[T [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] c^SPh' HWTh PaVdT cWPc cWXb XbQTRPdbT Rd[cXePcX^] dbX]V cWT _[^f Xb \âT [PQâX^db P]S ST\P]SX]V Uâ _WhbXRP[

")

bcaT]VcW' HWTaTUâT% ob^RXTcXTb cWPc caPSXcX^]P[[h _aPRcXRTS _[^dVW Rd[cdaT STeT[&^_TS P b_TRXP[XiPcX^] Û _a^SdRcX^] P[^]V VT]STa [X]Tbp "6[TbX]P Tc P[' +)*,% _*#'HWXb T!TRc Xb caP]b\XccTS PRa^bb VT]TaPcX^]b% P]S b^ f^\T] Û TcW]XR Va^d_b Ua^\cWTbT b^RXTcXTb PaT [Tbb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] _^[XcXRP[ P]S TR^]^\XR [XUT c^SPh'

FTVaTbbX^]b "+# P]S ",# cWTaTUâT R^]ca^[ Uâ WXbcâXRP[ dbT Û cWT _[^f X] cf^fPhb3 sabc[h% Qh dbX]V P Sd\\h X]SXRPcâ Uâ fWTcWTa _[^f Rd[cXePcX^] fPb _aTbT]cX] cWT TcW]XR Va^d_rb b^RXTch4 bTR^]S[h% Qh dbX]V P] X]SXRPcâ SPcP VT]TaPcTS Qh6[TbX]P Tc P[' "+)*,# ^] cWT WXbcâXRP[ bdXcPQX[Xch Û [P]S P]S b^X[ Uâ Va^fX]VRa^_b cWPc aT`dXaT _[^dVW Rd[cXePcX^]' ?] Q^cW b_TRXsRPcX^]b% cWT \PV]XcdSTb ÛcWT TbcX\PcTb PaT ]^c [PaVT[h P!TRcTS% cW^dVW cWT bXV]XsRP]RT Û C=?? aTSdRTb c^*)!% [XZT[h SdT c^ cWT X]RaTPbT X] ]^XbT' HWT aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc cWT T!TRc ÛVT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVT ^] UT\P[T [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] Xb X]ST_T]ST]c ÛVT]STa PccXcdSTb SaXeT] Qh WXbcâXRP[ SX!TaT]RTb X] PVaXRd[cdaT'

?] aTVaTbbX^]b "-# P]S ".# ? R^]ca^[ Uâ cWT P]RTbcaP[ \^ST Û bdQbXbcT]RT% fWXRWBXRWP[^_^d[^b P]S EdccTa\P] "+)*-# bW^f c^ QT RâaT[PcTS fXcW R^]cT\_âPahTSdRPcX^] P]S fTP[cW' <X]P[[h% X] aTVaTbbX^] "/# ? R^]ca^[ P] X]SXRPcâ Û WXbcâXRP[aT`dXaT\T]c Û QaXST _aXRT cWPc 6[TbX]P Tc P[' "+)*.# bW^f PaT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW [TbbR^]cT\_âPah eX^[T]RT c^fPaSb f^\T] c^SPh' HWT R^T"RXT]cb aT\PX] bcPQ[T X]\PV]XcdST P]S PaT bcPcXbcXRP[[h bXV]XsRP]c Pc cWT .! â *)! [TeT['

HWT aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc cWT P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb PaT ]^c _Pac Û cWT RPdbP[RWP]]T[ cWa^dVW fWXRW C=?? P!TRcb UT\P[T [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^]3 cWTaTUâT%cWT T!TRc Û C=?? ^] [PQ^da RW^XRT Xb [XZT[h c^ QT X]ST_T]ST]c Û VT]STa ]â\bPaXbX]V Ua^\ cWTbT P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb'

.% 6HQGHT @HJTHJDVLRQ LQ VKH 9DERWT ;DTNHV

>PeX]V TbcPQ[XbWTS P aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^]Uâ f^\T]% ? ]^f cda] c^ P f^\P]rb <AFB<> Û ^RRd_PcX^] c^ d]STabcP]S cWTSTVaTT c^ fWXRW C=?? RP] Tg_[PX] SX!TaT]cXP[ [PQ^da \PaZTc ^dcR^\Tb Uâ f^\T]'? aTbcaXRc \h bP\_[T c^ ^][h f^\T] fW^ PaT T\_[^hTS P]S STs]T cf^ ePaXPQ[Tbm bTaeXRT P]S PVaXRd[cdaT m T`dP[ c^ * fWT] cWT X]SXeXSdP[ aT_âcb fâZX]V X] cWTbTaeXRT P]S PVaXRd[cdaP[ bTRcâ% aTb_TRcXeT[h'

HWT aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc cWTaT Xb b^\T STVaTT Û WâXi^]cP[ VT]STa bTVaTVPcX^]X] T\_[^h\T]c cWPc RP] QT Tg_[PX]TS Qh C=??3 f^\T] fW^ PaT fâZX]V P]Sb_TPZ VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb PaT 2'2/ _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb [Tbb [XZT[h c^ fâZX] PVaXRd[cdaT' 6b cWT aTbd[cb R^d[S _^cT]cXP[[h QT Tg_[PX]TS Qh cWT bdXcPQX[XchÛ cWT [P]S c^ PVaXRd[cdaT% ? X]R[dST P \TPbdaT Û PVaXRd[cdaP[ bdXcPQX[Xch Pc cWTTcW]XRXch [TeT[ R^]bcadRcTS Qh 6[TbX]P Tc P[' "+)*,# X] aTVaTbbX^]b ",# P]S "-#' HWTTbcX\PcTS T!TRc Uâ 9@HB<KCJKH> Xb eTah bX\X[Pa% P]S aT\PX]b bcPcXbcXRP[[h bXV]XsRP]cPc .!' C^ bX\X[Pa T!TRc Xb U^d]S Uâ bTaeXRTb' HWXb Xb bdVVTbcXeT Û cWT T!TRc Û[P]VdPVT ^] fâZ&RW^XRT _aTUTaT]RTb'

"*

HPQ[T /n3 =T]STa GTVaTVPcX^] X] ;\_[^h\T]c3 6VaXRd[cdaT P]S GTaeXRTb

#*$ #+$ #,$ #-$3Q\SM_V^_\O DO\`SMO 3Q\SM_V^_\O DO\`SMO

@9<< ')()22/%% )())))01, ')()2-*%% )())++.#)()-/-$ #)()++)$ #)()-++$ #)()+)0$

3Q\SM_V^_\KV D_S^KLSVS^c ')()-*) ')()*/*#)(),2*$ #)()+1.$

<XNS`SN_KV 5YX^\YV] I7D I7D I7D I7D5Y_X^\c 87 I7D I7D I7D I7D

AL]O\`K^SYX] *0-&11- *0-&11- *0-&11- *0-&11-C'][_K\ON )(+.) )(*,, )(+.* )(*,,

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX [S ÙR XNZTaNTR N^R ^R\[^`RQ VZ \N^RZÙR_R_' $% $$ NZQ $$$VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_ N` *)!% .! NZQ *!' IUR SaXX _R` [S VZQVbVQaNX P[Z`^[X_ N^RQR_P^VORQ aZQR^ "#$&% !'

/% =VKHT 3HSHQGHQV BDTLDEOHU

G^ UPa% ? WPeT Pbbd\TS cWPc VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb PaT P!TRcX]V [PQ^da UâRT_PacXRX_PcX^] cWa^dVW cWTXa T!TRc ^] _bhRW^[^VXRP[ _Ph^!b' >^fTeTa% Pb X[[dbcaPcTSX] T`dPcX^] ,% ^]T _^cT]cXP[ X]cTa_aTcPcX^] Û cWT aTbd[cb Xb cWPc cWT ]Tc \PcTaXP[QT]Tsc Û fâZX]V Xb SX!TaT]c Uâ f^\T] fW^ b_TPZ \âT VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]&VdPVTb% eTabdb cW^bT fW^ S^ ]^c' H^ X]eTbcXVPcT fWTcWTa cWXb Xb cWT RPbT% ? ]^fR^]bXSTa fWTcWTa cWT T!TRc Û C=?? TgcT]Sb c^ ^cWTa W^dbTW^[S ^dcR^\Tb fWXRW\Ph SX!TaT]cXP[[h P!TRc cWT \PcTaXP[ ^__âcd]Xch R^bc Û fâZX]V Uâ C=?? b_TPZ&Tab'

? R^]bXSTa cWaTT ST_T]ST]c ePaXPQ[Tb' <Xabc% ? R^]bXSTa cWT f^\P]rb ]d\QTa ÛRWX[SaT] Pb cWXb \Ph QT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW WXVWTa R^bcb c^ fâZX]V% Uâ TgP\_[T SdTc^ WXVWTa RWX[SRPaT R^bcb' GTR^]S[h% ? R^]bXSTa hTPab Û TSdRPcX^] Pb cWXb Xb [XZT[h c^QT Pbb^RXPcTS fXcW WXVWTa aTcda]b c^ fâZX]V' APbc[h% ? X]eTbcXVPcT cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_QTcfTT] C=?? P]S LBFC>E<>% fWTaT cWT [PccTa Xb P] X]SXRPcâ Uâ fWTcWTa cWT f^\P]aT_âcTS qhTbr c^ Tg_TaXT]RX]V bTgdP[ â P]h Uâ\ Û _WhbXRP[ eX^[T]RT Ua^\ WTab_^dbT' 6RRâSX]V c^ cWT \P[T QPRZ[PbW cWTâh "6]STab^] *2204 =Pac]Ta P]SBPR\X[[P] *222#% \T] \Ph aTbâc c^ S^\TbcXR eX^[T]RT Pb P \TP]b Û PbbTacX]V_^fTa XU cWTh UTT[ cWaTPcT]TS Qh cWTXa fXeTb fâZX]V' HWTaTUâT% S^\TbcXR eX^[T]RTPRcb Pb P _a^gh Uâ R^]bcaPX]cb c^ fâZX]V X\_^bTS Qh WdbQP]Sb% fWXRW \Ph QTaTSdRX]V UT\P[T [PQ^da bd__[h'

HWT T!TRc Û VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb ^] cWTbT ST_T]ST]c ePaXPQ[Tb Xb aT_âcTSX] ADEOH -' 6b bTT] Ua^\ aTVaTbbX^]b "*# c^ ",# cWT T!TRc Û C=?? S^Tb ]^c bTT\c^ TgcT]S c^ cWTbT ST_T]ST]c ePaXPQ[Tb' HWXb bdVVTbcb cWPc cWT T!TRc Û C=?? ^]T\_[^h\T]c Xb ]^c cWa^dVW SX!TaT]cXP[ \PcTaXP[ QT]Tscb Û fâZX]V'

#!

HPQ[T 0n3 DcWTa 9T_T]ST]c JPaXPQ[Tb

#*$ #+$ #,$@_WLO\ YP 5RSVN\OX IOK\] YP ON_MK^SYX GSYVOXMO OÒ\

@9<< ')(+()0 *(+02 ')(-,.#)(+-/$ #*(*.2$ #)(-0-$

<XNS`SN_KV 5YX^\YV] 3QO KXN COVSQSYX 3QO KXN COVSQSYX 3QO KXN COVSQSYX5Y_X^\c 87 I7D I7D I7D

AL]O\`K^SYX] +)0&//, +)1(+*, *.1&*)+

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX [S ÙR XNZTaNTR N^R ^R\[^`RQ VZ \N^RZÙR_R_' $% $$ NZQ $$$VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_ N` *)!% .! NZQ *!' ? P[Z`^[X S[^ ^RXVTV[Z Oe VZPXaQVZT VZQVPN`[^_S[^ ÙR VZQVbVQaNX ORVZT Ca_XVY NZQ S[^ ORVZT 8U^V_`VNZ4 6TR V_ P[Z`^[XXRQ S[^ Oe a_VZT NTR NZQ NTR_]aN^RQ

'&% ?REWUVQHUU 2KHFNU

$#"$" .KE<JBFE9C .FHD 9E= 6J9E=9H= -HHFHI

5WQFVLRQDO 5RTP

? aT_âc \h \PX] aTbd[cb dbX]V cWT [^VXc b_TRXsRPcX^]' ?] PSSXcX^] c^ bW^fX]VcWPc \h aTbd[cb PaT a^Qdbc c^ SX!TaT]c Ud]RcX^]P[ Uâ\b% cWXb P[[^fb \T c^ R^\_PaTcWT TbcX\PcTS R^T"RXT]c X] cWXb _P_Ta c^ cWPc Ua^\ =Ph Tc P[' "+)*,#'

IbX]V cWT [^VXc \^ST[% cWT R^]SXcX^]P[ _a^QPQX[Xch Û fâZX]V VXeT] X]SXeXSdP[P]S R^d]cah [TeT[ RWPaPRcTaXbcXRb Xb VXeT] Qh3

+ ?"D%&$ 5 *!)'((&! !"#!! "#!# 5 #"#) $ #*)'((& $ ! !"#! $ ! "#!"1# #

fWTaT cWT Taaâ cTa\ Xb Pbbd\TS c^ QT X'X'S SXbcaXQdcTS Qh cWT [^VXbcXR 89<'

FTVaTbbX^] "*# X] ADEOH . aT_âcb cWT TbcX\PcTS \PaVX]P[ T!TRcb dbX]V cWT [^VXcb_TRXsRPcX^] fXcW cWT Ud[[ bTc Û R^d]cah [TeT[ P]S X]SXeXSdP[ [TeT[ R^]ca^[b' 9T&b_XcT RWP]VTb X] cWT Ud]RcX^]P[ Uâ\% cWT TbcX\PcTS R^T"RXT]c aT\PX]b bcPcXbcXRP[[hbXV]XsRP]c Pc .!' IbX]V P c&cTbc c^ R^\_PaT ^da TbcX\PcTS ^SSb aPcX^ Û )'00*fXcW =Ph Tc P['rb "+)*,# s]SX]V Û )'.-+ "bcP]SPaS Taaâ Û )'**-#% fT RP] aTYTRccWT ]d[[ Wh_^cWTbXb cWPc cWT cf^ TbcX\PcTS T!TRcb PaT T`dP[' HW^dVW cWT SPcPbTcdbTS QTcfTT] cWT cf^ bcdSXTb PaT SX!TaT]c% cWXb _aêXSTb bdVVTbcXeT TeXST]RT cWPccWT T!TRc Û VT]STa \PaZX]V Xb ]^c Pb [PaVT X] \h bdQbTc Û R^d]caXTb'

#"

HPQ[T 1n3 F^Qdbc]Tbb 8WTRZb

#*$ #+$ #,$ #-$>YQS]^SM >YQS]^SM >B? >YQS]^SM

#?K\QSXKV7"OM^$

#ANN] CK^SY$#?K\QSXKV

7"OM^$

7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON

@9<< ')()/*2%% )(00*%% ')().*.%% ')()/*2%%#)(*),$ #)()020$ #)()+*,$ #)()+-1$

5V_]Ô\SXQ >KXQ_KQO >KXQ_KQO>KXQ_KQO "

5Y_X^\c>KXQ_KQO "

5Y_X^\c

<XNS`SN_KV 5YX^\YV] I7D I7D I7D I7D

;S]^Y\c 5YX^\YV] I7D I7D I7D I7D

9OYQ\KZRc 5YX^\YV] I7D I7D I7D I7D

5YXÔWZY\K\c5YX^\YV]

I7D I7D I7D I7D

AL]O\`K^SYX] +//&11. +//&11. +//&11. +//&11.

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX _\RPVkRQ' $% $$ NZQ $$$ VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_N` *)!% .! NZQ *!' 8[XaYZ URNQR^_ VZQVPN`R ÙR SaZP`V[ZNX S[^Y a_RQ S[^ ÙR _\RPVkPN`V[Z' 6 SaXXQR_P^V\`V[Z [S ÙR SaXX _R` [S VZQVbVQaNX% UV_`[ê% TR[T^N\Ue NZQ P[Z`RY\[^Nê P[Z`^[X_ PNZ OR S[aZQaZQR^ "#$&% !'

AYR$YD[ FOWUVHTLQJ?] \h \PX] b_TRXsRPcX^]b% ? PRR^d]c Uâ _^cT]cXP[ fXcWX] [P]VdPVT RâaT[PcX^]

Qh R[dbcTaX]V bcP]SPaS Taaâb Pc cWT [TeT[ Û cWT [P]VdPVT' >^fTeTa cWT T!TRc ÛVT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVT ^] [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] R^d[S P[b^ QT RâaT[PcTSfXcWX] TPRW R^d]cah% _PacXRd[Pa[h P\^]V cW^bT cWPc b_TPZ cWT bP\T [P]VdPVT X] cWTbP\T R^d]cah' ? PRR^d]c Uâ cWXb _^bbXQX[Xch dbX]V cf^&fPh R[dbcTaX]V X] Q^cW cWT[X]TPa _a^QPQX[Xch \^ST[ P]S cWT [^VXc b_TRXsRPcX^]b X] R^[d\]b ",# P]S "-#' ;eT]PUcTa R^]ca^[[X]V Uâ Q^cW fXcWX] R^d]cah P]S [P]VdPVT RâaT[PcX^]% cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_aT\PX]b bXV]XsRP]c Pc .!'

$#"%" 89HB9JBFE BE 4/11 ;M <FKEJHM

?] cWXb bTRcX^]% ? ad] \h \PX] b_TRXsRPcX^] Uâ bdQbTcb Û \h 9>G bP\_[T fXcWSX!TaT]c [TeT[b Û C=?? ePaXPcX^]' ?] 5LJWTH '% ? _[^c cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT]bWPaT Û f^\T] b_TPZX]V VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb P]S bWPaT Û T\_[^hTS f^\T]Uâ TPRW R^d]cah X] \h bP\_[T' HW^dVW cWTaT Xb P] ^QbTaeTS ]TVPcXeT aT[PcX^]bWX_QTcfTT] cWT R^d]caXTb% cWXb aT[PcX^]bWX_ P__TPab c^ QT bca^]VTa fWT] R^\_PaX]V

##

$2097. "! (1*7. 6/ )64.5 )673250 *5- (1*7. 6/ )64.5 ;281 '%&& # " +< ,69587<!

,./-+ 8[aZ`^VR_ cVÙ T^RN`R^ ÙNZ *)! bN^VN`V[Z VZ D=?? N^R YN^WRQ Oe ÙR QVNY[ZQ YN^WR^' IUR_RVZPXaQR 8NYR^[[Z% DNYVOVN% JTNZQN% 7RZVZ% DVTR^VN% I[T[% ARZeN NZQ 7a^WVZN <N_['

R^d]caXTb fXcW WXVW ePaXPcX^] X] C=??' HWXb RP] QT ^QbTaeTS Qh R^]bXSTaX]V cWTbdQbTc Û 1 R^d]caXTb cWPc WPeT VaTPcTa cWP] *)! ePaXPcX^] X] C=??' FTVaTbbX^]bfXcW R^d]cah sgTS T!TRcb _aX\PaX[h aT[h ^] cWTbT R^d]caXTb fXcW WXVW fXcWX]&R^d]cah ePaXPcX^] Uâ XST]cXsRPcX^]' ? cWTaTUâT \êT UâfPaS Qh U^[[^fX]V 8WT]"+)*,# X] cTbcX]V cWT a^Qdbc]Tbb Û cWT aTbd[cb c^ TbcX\PcX^] dbX]V SX!TaT]c [TeT[bÛ C=?? ePaXPcX^]'

<Xabc% ? cTbc fWTcWTa cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT] C=?? P]S T\_[^h\T]c Xb SaXeT]Qh ePaXPcX^] X] VT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb fXcWX] cWT R^d]cah' ? ad] cWT \PX]b_TRXsRPcX^] fXcW cWT Ud[[ bTc Û X]SXeXSdP[ R^]ca^[b P]S R^d]cah sgTS T!TRcb aT&bcaXRcX]V cWT bP\_[T sabc[h% c^ cW^bT R^d]caXTb fXcW [Tbb cWP] *)! ePaXPcX^] X]C=?? P]S bTR^]S[h% c^ cW^bT R^d]caXTb fXcW \âT cWP] *)! ePaXPcX^]' ? _aTbT]ccWT aTbd[cb Uâ cWXb X] ADEOH /'

HW^dVW cWT TbcX\PcTS \PV]XcdST X] aTVaTbbX^] "*# Xb bcX[[ bX\X[Pa X] \PV]XcdSTc^ cWT \PX] aTbd[c% cWT aTSdRcX^] X] bXV]P[&c^&]^XbT aPcX^ SdT c^ [PRZ Û C=??ePaXPcX^] \TP]b cWPc cWT R^T"RXT]c Xb bcPcXbcXRP[[h X]SXbcX]VdXbWPQ[T Ua^\ iTa^'7h R^]caPbc% aTbd[cb Ua^\ aTVaTbbX^] "+# PaT bcaXZX]V[h bX\X[Pa c^ TbcX\PcX^] dbX]VcWT fW^[T bP\_[T3 Xc Xb bXV]XsRP]c Pc .! P]S cWT TbcX\PcTS R^T"RXT]c Xb eTah R[^bTX] \PV]XcdST c^ &)').1. "Ua^\ ADEOH (#' 6b XST]cXsRPcX^] bTT\b c^ QT SaXeT] QhR^d]caXTb fXcW WXVW C=?? ePaXPcX^]% X] aTVaTbbX^] ",#% ? ad] cWT bP\T b_TRXsRPcX^]

#$

TgR[dSX]V H^V^ P]S IVP]SP% cf^ R^d]caXTb fXcW VaTPcTa cWP] *)! C=?? ePaXPcX^]'HW^dVW cWT bcP]SPaS Taaâ X]RaTPbTb% cWT TbcX\PcTS R^T"RXT]c Xb XST]cXRP[ c^ cWPcTbcX\PcTS fXcW cWT Ud[[ bP\_[T'

HPQ[T 2n3 FTVaTbbX^]b Qh C=?? JPaXPcX^]

#*$ #+$ #,$ #-$ #.$ #/$7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON 7WZVYcON

@9<< ')().)* ')().02%% ')().1.% ')().)* ')().02%% ')().1.%%#)()0.1$ #)()+/,$ #)(),**$ #)()0.1$ #)()+/+$ #)()+1.$

@9<< DRK\O ')())*+. ')())..00%% ')())**..%#)()))1)-$ #)())+)-$ #)()))/*2$

DKWZVO _]ON!*)!@9<<

GK\SK^SYX

"*)!@9<<

GK\SK^SYX

3VV&ObMV_NSXQEYQY KXNFQKXNK

!*)!@9<<

GK\SK^SYX

"*)!@9<<

GK\SK^SYX3VV

<XNS`SN_KV5YX^\YV]

I7D I7D I7D I7D I7D I7D

5Y_X^\c 87 I7D I7D I7D I7D I7D I7D

AL]O\`K^SYX] *.+&--. **-&--) +,2&2-2 *.+&--. **-&--) +//&11.

,./-+ H`NZQN^Q R^^[^_ PXa_`R^RQ N` XRbRX [S ÙR XNZTaNTR N^R ^R\[^`RQ VZ \N^RZÙR_R_' $% $$ NZQ $$$VZQVPN`R ÙR _VTZVkPNZPR [S ÙR \&bNXaR_ N` *)!% .! NZQ *!'

?] cWT ]Tgc bTc Û aTVaTbbX^]b% ? ad] cWT \PX] b_TRXsRPcX^] fXcW R^]ca^[b UâoC=?? GWPaTp% P \TPbdaT Uâ cWT ]d\QTa Û _T^_[T b_TPZX]V cWT bP\T C=?? R[Pb&bXsRPcX^] Pb cWT X]SXeXSdP[' 7PcXQ^ "+)).# s]Sb cWPc X]SXeXSdP[b b_TPZX]V \X]âXch[P]VdPVTb PaT SXbPSeP]cPVTS X] _^[XcXRP[ P]S STRXbX^] \PZX]V T]eXa^]\T]cb' ?]aTVaTbbX^]b "-# c^ "/#% ? cWTaTUâT R^]bXSTa cWT T!TRc Û oC=?? GWPaTp bT_PaPcT[hUâ cW^bT R^d]caXTb fXcW #*)! C=?? ePaXPcX^]% fXcW $*)! C=?? JPaXPcX^]% P]Ss]P[[h fXcW cWT T]cXaT bP\_[T' 6b bTT] Ua^\ aTVaTbbX^]b "-# c^ "/#% PSSXcX^] ÛoC=?? GWPaTp [TPeTb cWT R^T"RXT]cb eXacdP[[h d]RWP]VTS' HWXb _aêXSTb TeXST]RTcWPc cWT \PX] aTbd[cb PaT ]^c SaXeT] Qh cW^bT fW^ b_TPZ P \X]âXch C=?? R[Pb&bXsRPcX^]% â Va^d_ T!TRcb Û ^cWTab b_TPZX]V P [P]VdPVT Û cWT bP\T STVaTT ÛVT]STa âXT]cPcX^]'

''% 2RQFOWULRQ

Bh aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc f^\T] b_TPZX]V VT]STa âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb X] GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP PaT ^] PeTaPVT . _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb [Tbb [XZT[h c^ _PacXRX_PcT X] cWT[PQ^da UâRT' HWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT P[b^ TgcT]Sb c^ VT]STa bTVaTVPcX^] X] cWT

#%

[PQ^da UâRT% X] fWXRW ? s]S Û cW^bT fW^ PaT fâZX]V% f^\T] b_TPZX]V VT]STaâXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb PaT 2'2/ _TaRT]cPVT _^X]cb [Tbb [XZT[h c^ fâZ X] PVaXRd[cdaT' ?]R^]cTgc fXcW cWT TgXbcX]V [XcTaPcdaT% ? s]S cWPc cWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT Xb [^fTa X]GdQ&GPWPaP] 6UaXRP cWP] cWPc Û cWT V[^QP[ PeTaPVT' HWXb Xb bdVVTbcXeT Û [P]VdPVT_TaWP_b ]^c WPeX]V Pb bca^]V P] T!TRc X] PaTPb fXcW aXRW [X]VdXbcXR SXeTabXch'

D] P Qa^PSTa bRP[T% cWTbT aTbd[cb _aêXST TeXST]RT Uâ cWT X\_âcP]RT Û b^RX^&_bhRW^[^VXRP[ UPRcâb P]S VT]STa XST]cXch X] Tg_[PX]X]V SX!TaT]cXP[ [PQ^da \PaZTc^dcR^\Tb Uâ f^\T]' Bh aTbd[cb bdVVTbc cWPc [P]VdPVT S^Tb ]^c SX!TaT]cXP[[h PU&UTRc P f^\P]rb \PcTaXP[ QT]Tscb c^ fâZX]V' BâTêTa% cWT aT[PcX^]bWX_ QTcfTT][P]VdPVT P]S [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] S^Tb ]^c bTT\ c^ ^_TaPcT cWa^dVW VT]STab^RXP[ ]â\b PaXbX]V Ua^\ R^]cT\_âPah aT[XVX^db QT[XTUb P]S P]RTbcaP[ RWPaPRcTa&XbcXRb' HW^dVW ? RP]]^c Ud[[h PRR^d]c Uâ VT]STa b^RXP[ ]â\b aT[PcTS c^ UT\P[T[PQ^da bd__[h% cWTbT aTbd[cb _aêXST _aT[X\X]Pah TeXST]RT Û P SXaTRc T!TRc ÛVT]STa&âXT]cTS [P]VdPVTb ^] cWT bP[XT]Rh Û VT]STa a^[Tb X] f^\T]rb \X]Sb'

HWT T!TRc Û [P]VdPVT ^] [PQ^da UâRT _PacXRX_PcX^] f^d[S WPeT X]cTaTbcX]V _^[&XRh X\_[XRPcX^]b% Tb_TRXP[[h X] R^d]caXTb fXcW aXRW [X]VdXbcXR WTcTa^VT]TXch' <a^\ P[X]VdXbcXR bcP]S_^X]c% cWTh WX]c Pc cWT ]TTS Uâ cWT T\_WPbXb Û [Tbb VT]STa&âXT]cTS[P]VdPVTb & Uâ fâZ% â Uâ \TSXd\ Û TSdRPcX^] & X] R^d]caXTb fWTaT cWTaT PaTP[aTPSh \d[cX_[T ^"RXP[ [P]VdPVTb' ?] PSSXcX^]% cWT aTbd[cb PaT bdVVTbcXeT Û cWTX\_âcP]RT Û X\_[T\T]cX]V _^[XRXTb c^ R^d]cTa cWT bP[XT]Rh Û VT]STa ]â\b% bdRWPb _^bXcXeT SXbRaX\X]PcX^] X] TR^]^\XR T]eXa^]\T]cb â \TSXP RP\_PXV]b c^ Q[dacWT SXbcX]RcX^]b QTcfTT] \P[T P]S UT\P[T a^[Tb'

#&

@343@3=13A

/JLTVNS[! 2#! 8VOUYVU A#! HUK @VIPUYVU# 8# /# (&&'% ?J[JWXFQ TK KTWYZSJ+3JTLWFUM^ FSI NSXYNYZYNTSX NS YMJ RFPNSL TK YMJ RTIJWS \TWQI NSHTRJ INXYWNGZ$YNTS%

/JLTVNS[! 2#! 8VOUYVU A#! HUK @VIPUYVU# 8# /# (&&(% AMJ WNXJ TK 1ZWTUJ+-YQFSYNH YWFIJ# NSXYNYZYNTSFQ HMFSLJ FSI JHTSTRNH LWT\YM%

/PROLU\HSK! /# F# (&&)% g6`SNOX^SKVS^c SX ^cZYVYQSMKV ZO\]ZOM^SÒ%h AÛTQTLNHFQ@YZINJX NS 8FSLZFLJ# +*0 'f)(%

/RLXSVM! 5# /#! HUK @# 3# 9XHUZVU# (&&&% g6MYXYWSM] KXN SNOX^S^c%h >ZFW$YJWQ^ 6TZWSFQ TK 1HTSTRNHX# -'+f-+)%

/RLXSVM! 5# /#! HUK @# 3# 9XHUZVU# (&&(% g;NOX^S^c KXN ]MRYYVSXQ0DYWO VO]]YX] PY\ ^RO OMYXYWSM] YP ON_MK^SYX%h 6TZWSFQ TK JHTSTRNH QNYJWFYZWJ#*&!*"0 '',-f'(&'%

/RLXSVM! 5# /#! HUK @# 3# 9XHUZVU# (&&+% g;NOX^S^c KXN ^RO 6MYXYWSM] YPA\QKXSdK^SYX]%h AMJ 6TZWSFQ TK 1HTSTRNH =JWXUJHYN[JX# '/!'"0 /f)(%

/SLYPUH! /#! HUK 3# ;H 4LXXHXH# (&&+% gB\OPO\OXMO] PY\ \ONS]^\SL_^SYX SX ^ROVKXN YP YZZY\^_XS^SO]%h 6TZWSFQ TK UZGQNH 1HTSTRNHX# ./!+"0 ./-f/)'%

/SLYPUH! /#! 2L\SLLYJOH[]LX /# 3HYZLXS_ E# 9[XSHZ A#! HUK @#

EHJ`PHXN# (&&)% g7\KM^SYXKVSdK^SYX%h 6TZWSFQ TK 1HTSTRNH LWT\YM# .!("0 '++f'/*%

/SLYPUH! /#! 5P[SPHUV ?#! HUK =# =[UU# (&')% gAX ^RO A\SQSX] YP 8OXNO\CYVO]0 HYWOX KXN ^RO BVY_QR%h >ZFWYJWQ^ 6TZWSFQ TK 1HTSTRNHX# '(.!("%

/SZVUQP! 8# 5#! 3SKLX B# 3#! HUK 1# @# BHILX# (&&&% @JQJHYNTS TS TGXJW[JIFSI ZSTGXJW[JI [FWNFGQJX+ -XXJXXNSL YMJ J!JHYN[JSJXX TK /FYMTQNH XHMTTQX%

/UKLXYVU! 9# ;# '//-% g8OXNO\# ]^K^_]# KXN NYWO]^SM `SYVOXMO0 2X SXÔQ\K^SYXYP POWSXS]^ KXN PKWSVc `SYVOXMO KZZ\YKMRO]%h 6TZWSFQ TK 9FWWNFLJ FSI YMJ 2FRNQ^#,++f,,/%

/UKLXYVU! E# 5# './-% -S 5SYWTIZHYTW^ 3WFRRFW TK YMJ @JSF 8FSLZFLJ% >YX$NYX0@Y\^R_WLO\VKXN 2ÒX_O# H%4%

/UNXPYZ! 8# 2#! HUK 8#"A# ?PYJORL# (&&.% 9TXYQ^ MFWRQJXX JHTSTRJYWNHX+ -SJRUNWNHNXY`X HTRUFSNTS% B\SXMO^YX _XSÒ\]S^c Z\O]]%

0HRLX! <# 1# (&&)% 8J]NHFQ HFYJLTWNJX+ CJWGX# STZSX FSI FIOJHYN[JX% GYV% '&(#4KWL\SNQO FXSÒ\]S^c B\O]]% GKXMY_Ò\%

0LXZXHUK! <# (&''% g@Oa ZO\]ZOM^SÒ] YX QOXNO\%h 4FSIGTTP TK QFGTW JHTSTRNHX#*0 '+*)f'+/&%

0SH[! 4# 2# '//-% AWJSIX NS YMJ \JQQ$GJNSL TK -RJWNHFS \TRJS# '*)&$'**(%

0SH[! 4# 2#! HUK ;# <# 9HOU# (&&,% gERO FD QOXNO\ ZKc QKZ SX ^RO '//&]0DVYaSXQ MYXÒ\QOXMO%h 5SIZXYWNFQ QFGTW WJQFYNTSX WJ[NJ\# ,&!'"0 *+f,,%

0SVVT! 2# 3#! AHJOY 8# 2# 1VSSPLX ?#! HUK 1# CKX_# '//.% g8OYQ\KZRc#NOWYQ\KZRc# KXN OMYXYWSM Q\Ya^R SX 2P\SMK%h .WTTPNSLX UFUJWX TS JHTSTRNH

#'

FHYN[NY^# '//.!("0 (&-f(/+%

0V]LXU! 1#! HUK D# ;VZXPKNL# (&&(% ;IJGJQJ% ?_OXMROX0>SXMYW 6_\YZK%

1HNHZH_! =#! HUK A# >`SLX# '//+% g7OWSXSdK^SYX YP ^RO VKLY\ PY\MO0 ERO OP$POM^] YP VYXQ$Ô\W NOÒVYZWOX^ KXN ]^\_M^_\KV KNT_]^WOX^%h DTWQI 0J[JQTURJSY#()!''"0 '..)f'./*%

1HTHXH! <# '///% =FWQTSX 9FQNSPJ% BK\S]0>i9K\WK^^KX%

1HTLXVU! /# 1#! HUK ?# 9# BXP\LKP# (&&+% 9NHWTJHTSTRJYWNHX+ RJYMTIX FSIFUUQNHFYNTSX% 4KWL\SNQO _XSÒ\]S^c Z\O]]%

1HTLXVU! /# 1#! 5LSIHJO 8# 0#! HUK 2# ;# <PSSLX# (&&.% g3YY^]^\KZ$LK]ONSWZ\YÒWOX^] PY\ SXPO\OXMO aS^R MV_]Ô\ON O\\Y\]%h AMJ WJ[NJ\ TK JHTSTRNHX FSIXYFYNXYNHX# /&!)"0 *'*f*(-%

1HTTLUNH! 8# (&&(% =MTSTQTL^ FSI 9TWUMTQTL^ TK 1PJLZXNN% 8VKNLKMU#305\_MUO\OS 9KX]OX%

1HTWHUZL! 4# @#! HUK 2# 6# FHUHNP`H]H"2XVZZ# (&')% 0TJX ?JQNLNTS -!JHY1HTSTRNH 3WT\YM FSI 4FUUNSJXX, 1[NIJSHJ KWTR ?FRFIFS%

1OHXSLY! 9# 9#! 5[X_HU 8# HUK ?HU 8# (&&/% gDObS]W KXN aYWOX] VKLY\WK\UO^ Y_^MYWO]%h 9NRJT%

1OLU! <# 9# (&'(% gERO O!OM^ YP VKXQ_KQO YX OMYXYWSM LORK`SY\0 6`SNOXMOP\YW ]K`SXQ] \KÔ]# ROKV^R LORK`SY\]# KXN \O^S\OWOX^ K]]O^]%h

1XH``VSHXH! ?# '/-.% - @YZI^ TK YMJ =TPTS !@ZP" 8FSLZFLJ+ 3WFRRFW FSICTHFGZQFW^% 3YVYQXK06NS^\SMO ?S]]SYXK\SK ;^KVSKXK%

2HOS! ># (&&*% AMJ LWT\YM FSI RFNSYJSFSHJ TK QNSLZNXYNH HTRUQJ]NY^% GYV% -'#<YRX 3OXTKWSX] B_LVS]RSXQ%

2P 5HXIV! 4# (&')% g6`KV_K^SÒ WY\ZRYVYQc KXN XY_X MVK]]SjMK^SYX0 K M\Y]]$VSXQ_S]^SM ]^_Nc YP 2P\SMK%h GYV% '&# ''*f'*,% D=2D6%

2PTTLUKHHS! 5# 8# '/.)% AMJ AZWPFSF 8FSLZFLJ% 9YVVKXN07Y\S] B_LVSMK^SYX]%

2P^VU! @# <E# '/.,% g@Y_X MVK]]O] KXN XY_X MVK]]SjMK^SYX SX ^cZYVYQSMKV ZO\$]ZOM^SÒ%h ;TZS HQFXXJX FSI HFYJLTWN_FYNTS# '&+f''(%

2V[NSHY! =# '//'% g;X]^S^_^SYX]%h 6TZWSFQ TK 1HTSTRNH UJWXUJHYN[JX# +!'"0 ,*&f,++%

2X_LX! <# A#! HUK <# 6HYWLSTHZO# '//-% ;ZRGJW TK 3JSIJWX# D-8@%

2[aV! 3# (&''F% DTRJS̀ X JRUT\JWRJSY FSI JHTSTRNH IJ[JQTURJSY%

2[aV! 3# (&''G% DTRJS̀ X JRUT\JWRJSY FSI JHTSTRNH IJ[JQTURJSY%

3HYZLXS_! E#! HUK @# ;L\PUL# '//-% g2P\SMKi] Q\Ya^R ^\KQONc0 ZYVSMSO] KXNO^RXSM NS`S]SYX]%h AMJ >ZFWYJWQ^ 6TZWSFQ TK 1HTSTRNHX# '(&)f'(+&%

3JRLXZ! ?#! HUK A# <J1VUULSS"5PULZ# (&&)% 8FSLZFLJ FSI LJSIJW% 4KWL\SNQOFXSÒ\]S^c B\O]]%

3UNLXTHU! A# ;#! HUK 9# ;# AVRVSV!# '//-% g7KM^Y\ OXNYaWOX^]# SX]^S^_$^SYX]# KXN NS!O\OX^SKV ZK^R] YP Q\Ya^R KWYXQ XOa aY\VN OMYXYWSO]%h 4T\ 8FYNS-RJWNHF 2JQQ .JMNSI# (,&f)&*%

CSAE Working Paper WPS/201612 · 2019-06-17 · csae working paper wps/201612 ... mi ih@l...

Documents

Transcript of CSAE Working Paper WPS/201612 · 2019-06-17 · csae working paper wps/201612 ... mi ih@l...