Connecting What’s Next TV Channel Repack...Nov 07, 2017 · WWTO-TV Chicago, IL Trinity Christian...
Transcript of Connecting What’s Next TV Channel Repack...Nov 07, 2017 · WWTO-TV Chicago, IL Trinity Christian...
Proprietary and confidential. | 1
Connecting What’s Next
Connecting What’s Next
TV Channel Repack Radio Club of America 2017 Technical Symposium
Joe Seccia, PE
NT8H
Proprietary and confidential. | 2
Connecting What’s Next
Originally VHF only, Ch’s 1 – 19 (44 – 294 MHz)
• Band not contiguous – FM allocations and others
• Ch. 1 problematic and moved around, eventually eliminated circa 1940 due to interference with 45 MHz IF’s being used in receivers.
UHF Band allocated in 1952: 470 – 890 MHz, designated as Ch’s 14-83
Ch’s 70-83 eliminated for AMPS in 1983 (The first repack?)
Ch’s 52-69 eliminated by Telecommunications Act of 1996 that authorized today’s Digital Television. (The second repack)
• Spectrum not reclaimed until mid 2009.
National Broadband Plan of 2010 is the law that set the repack as we know it today in motion.
Brief History of US TV Band
Proprietary and confidential. | 3
Connecting What’s Next
Spectrum was sought to satisfy the projected demand on mobile broadband.
UHF TV spectrum highly sought after due to:
• Excellent propagation characteristics well suited for mobile broadband services.
• Potential large contiguous blocks of spectrum.
• UHF TV spectrum accounts for approx. 30% of spectrum allocation between 225 MHz and 1 GHz.
Recognizing that some economic groups are reliant on OTA TV and that it has long served as an important part of our communications infrastructure serving the public interest, a voluntary and market-based mechanism was needed to reclaim TV spectrum for new public interest.
Mobile Broadband
Proprietary and confidential. | 4
Connecting What’s Next
Mobile Broadband has more potential value for the spectrum than broadcast, creating a “value gap” of 10 x.
Spectrum Valuation based on $ per MHz, per person reached.
• “$ / MHz – pop”
FCC auctioned 52 MHz of the reclaimed 700 MHz band after the DTV transition for Wireless.
• > $19B raised, average valuation of $1.28 / MHz – pop
• TV Broadcast valuation calculated at $ 0.11 - $ 0.15 / MHz - pop
Market Value for Spectrum
Proprietary and confidential. | 5
Connecting What’s Next
Where are we getting our programming?
Average Prime-Time
Ratings
All Broadcast vs. All
Cable
OTA vs. Multi-Channel Video
Program Distributor Share of TV
households.
Proprietary and confidential. | 6
Connecting What’s Next
Connecting What’s Next
Broadcast Incentive Auction Authorized by Congress in 2012
Proprietary and confidential. | 7
Connecting What’s Next
Two Auctions
Reverse Auction
• With local television broadcasters selling spectrum
• FCC had a pre-determined amount of spectrum it sought in each market
• FCC will pay broadcasters to relinquish spectrum rights in one of a number of different ways
Forward Auction
• With wireless companies that wanted to acquire spectrum
to expand their services
• Companies bid on newly available 600 MHz (UHF television
spectrum obtained from the Reverse Auction)
• Amounts generated by the forward auction determines, in
part, amounts offered to broadcasters in the reverse auction
Proprietary and confidential. | 8
Connecting What’s Next
Broadcasters Eligible for Reverse Auction
All full-power and Class A commercial and non-commercial television stations in selected markets are eligible
Which Markets?
FCC wanted to auction as close
to 120 MHz of spectrum as
possible so many of the largest
markets will need considerable
numbers of television stations to
participate, recognizing it may not
be able to secure that much
spectrum in some markets
Additionally, smaller markets
that are adjacent to these
larger markets, and particular
stations in those markets
with extensive coverage in
the larger market will be
sought to participate in order to
“free up” that spectrum
Proprietary and confidential. | 9
Connecting What’s Next
Auction & Adjacent Markets
Proprietary and confidential. | 10
Connecting What’s Next
Auction Final
$10B
$20B
Proprietary and confidential. | 11
Connecting What’s Next
Reverse Auction’s Top 30 (of 175) Call Sign Market Owner Option Compensation
WWTO-TV Chicago, IL Trinity Christian Center of Santa Ana, Inc. Go off-air 304,250,040$
WNBC New York, NY NBC Telemundo License LLC Go off-air 214,023,017$
WRNN-TV New York, NY WRNN License Company, LLC Go off-air 211,680,472$
WXTV-DT New York, NY WXTV License Partnership, G.P. Go off-air 198,965,211$
WNJN New York, NY New Jersey Public Broadcasting Authority Go off-air 193,892,273$
WZME New York, NY NRJ TV NY License Co., LLC Go off-air 191,813,165$
WTBY-TV New York, NY Trinity Broadcasting of New York, Inc. Go off-air 162,402,181$
WLVI Boston, MA WHDH-TV Go off-air 162,108,481$
WGBH-TV Boston, MA WGBH Educational Foundation Move to Low-VHF 161,723,929$
WPWR-TV Chicago, IL Fox Television Stations, LLC Go off-air 160,748,259$
KVCR-DT Los Angeles, CA San Bernardino Community College District Move to Low-VHF 157,113,171$
KBEH Los Angeles, CA Hero Licenseco LLC Go off-air 146,627,980$
KRCA Los Angeles, CA KRCA License LLC Go off-air 142,337,137$
WSNS-TV Chicago, IL NBC Telemundo License LLC Go off-air 141,658,837$
WFMZ-TV Philadelphia, PA Maranatha Broadcasting Company, Inc. Go off-air 140,482,163$
WNJT Philadelphia, PA New Jersey Public Broadcasting Authority Go off-air 138,059,363$
KOCE-TV Los Angeles, CA KOCE-TV FOUNDATION Go off-air 138,003,711$
KJLA Los Angeles, CA KJLA, LLC Go off-air 135,542,845$
WYDN Boston, MA Educational Public TV Corporation Go off-air 134,987,151$
WYBE Philadelphia, PA Independence Public Media of Philadelphia, Inc. Go off-air 131,578,104$
KLCS Los Angeles, CA Los Angeles Unified School District Go off-air 130,510,880$
WXFT-DT Chicago, IL UniMas Chicago LLC Go off-air 126,107,725$
WLWC Providence, RI-New Bedford, MA OTA Broadcasting (PVD), LLC Go off-air 125,932,367$
WWSI Philadelphia, PA NBC Telemundo License LLC Go off-air 125,903,049$
WUVN Hartford-New Haven, CT Entravision Holdings, LLC Go off-air 125,568,545$
WNVC Washington, DC Commonwealth Public Broadcasting Corporation Go off-air 124,801,961$
KWHY-TV Los Angeles, CA KWHY-22 Broadcasting, LLC Move to Low-VHF 123,474,177$
WUTB Baltimore, MD Deerfield Media (Baltimore) Licensee, LLC Go off-air 122,912,964$
WDCW Washington, DC WDCW, LLC Go off-air 121,992,349$
WLVT-TV Philadelphia, PA LEHIGH VALLEY PUBLIC TELECOMMUNICATIONS CORP.Go off-air 121,752,169$
Proprietary and confidential. | 12
Connecting What’s Next
Connecting What’s Next
Repacking
Proprietary and confidential. | 13
Connecting What’s Next
Spectrum
Recovered
MHz
Highest
Remaining TV
Channel
Full Power
Stations
Class A
Stations
Total
Stations
Directly
Impacted*
84 36 593 144 737
Directly impacted stations are those currently assigned to spectrum that is to be cleared for wireless services
*Some participated in the auction, thus reducing the number of directly impacted stations
How Many Stations Directly Impacted?
Proprietary and confidential. | 14
Connecting What’s Next
TV Repack Report Card
Action as a Result of the Spectrum Auction Number
Stations Eliminated (Not Including Channel Sharing)* 145
Stations Moving From UHF to VHF* 30
Stations Relocated Within the UHF Band (US Only) 917
Distributed Transmission Stations Relocated 19
Stations Relocated Within the VHF Bands (US Only) 70
Canadian Stations Forced to Relocate 62
Total Repacked (not including VHF moves) 1068
17 LB
13 HB
Proprietary and confidential. | 15
Connecting What’s Next
Stations Not Changing Channels Impacted
IF stations…. • Share a Tower • Have stacked tower top antennas • Operate on a shared antenna and
transmission line …with a station that is forced to change channel FM stations on a shared tower with TV
Additional issues • Who will pay the cost for accommodating these stations?
• Potential increased interference from neighboring stations (0.5% of population per other station)
Proprietary and confidential. | 16
Connecting What’s Next
New UHF Band Plan
• Wireless spectrum channelized into 5 MHz pairs • TV service remains 6 MHz channels • Duplex gap between wireless uplink and downlink • Guard band spectrum between services
Proprietary and confidential. | 17
Connecting What’s Next
20 Full-power Ch. 14 assignments before repack • 8 get repacked off Ch. 14 • 12 remain on Ch. 14
30 Full-power stations repacked to Ch. 14 • 42 Full-power Ch. 14 assignments
Ch. 14 scenario
No
Guard
Band!
Proprietary and confidential. | 18
Connecting What’s Next
Unique to each Land Mobile RF situation
Ch. 14 Mask Filters
Proprietary and confidential. | 19
Connecting What’s Next
Ch. 14 Mask Filters
Proprietary and confidential. | 20
Connecting What’s Next
We’re on the clock!
Repack Timeline
Proprietary and confidential. | 21
Connecting What’s Next
Construction Phases
94 Stations
114 Stations
95 Stations
110 Stations
116 Stations
114 Stations
113 Stations
114 Stations
76 Stations
53 Stations
Proprietary and confidential. | 22
Connecting What’s Next
Repack Regions
Proprietary and confidential. | 23
Connecting What’s Next
Timeline
April 13 July 12
File electronically in LMS
FCC staff expected to process qualifying CP apps within 10 business days if:
• Station not seeking expanded coverage beyond what was specified in the PN.
• Seeking authorization for no more than 5% smaller than what was specified in the PN.
Proprietary and confidential. | 24
Connecting What’s Next
First Priority Window
Limited to:
• Unable to construct – extraordinary technical or legal circumstances
1. 25 stations were found by FCC to be unable to construct and given a July 12 waiver.
• Repacked stations predicted to experience a loss in excess of 1%
• Non-repacked stations predicted to experience a loss in excess of 1%
• Class A stations that were displaced and ineligible for repacking protection.
Aug 9 Sep 15
Proprietary and confidential. | 25
Connecting What’s Next
Two stations on same tower under same ownership / operation.
1 VHF, 1 UHF
Stacked antennas.
Site has restrictions on additional antennas, so interim antenna is not possible.
Assigned to two different phases.
Solution: Apply to change to same phase so tower / antenna work is done simultaneously.
First Priority Window Example
Proprietary and confidential. | 26
Connecting What’s Next
Stations may use this window to request, among other things, an expanded facility, a different channel or channel swap with in-market station. (Amendment if CP still pending, modification if CP granted.)
Caution!! Alternate channels considered major change; subject to public notice and opportunity for petitions to deny and subject to filing fee.
Mutual Exclusivity that results from requests must be resolved in 90 days.
Expenditures for upgrading facility that may be granted is non-reimbursable.
Second Window – change requests
Oct 3 Nov 2
Proprietary and confidential. | 27
Connecting What’s Next
Unforeseen Circumstances During Construction Period
If station is unable to construct new facility by the phase completion deadline… or
If station is unable to cease operations on pre-auction channel by the phase completion deadline…
… Propose a creative solution to assist the transition process.
Proprietary and confidential. | 28
Connecting What’s Next
Unable to construct on time
Station may seek a single extension of up to 180 days; extension application must be filed at least 90 days before deadline.
• Station may seek additional time beyond 180 days ONLY pursuant to “tolling”
– Tolling: Acts of God, delays due to administrative or judicial review, …
Extending the CP deadline does not extend the phase completion date. Unless station is granted an STA otherwise, the date the station must cease operation on it’s pre-auction channel is on the phase completion date.
Proprietary and confidential. | 29
Connecting What’s Next
Connecting What’s Next
Reimbursement
Proprietary and confidential. | 30
Connecting What’s Next
Initial Allocation • Commercial stations: up to 80% of estimated costs
• Noncommercial stations: up to 90% of estimated costs
• Actual percentage will depend on total cost of repack vs. the $1.75B repack fund
Progress Reports • Stations must report progress on implementing their channel transition plan
• First reports were due Oct. 10.
True-Up • Broadcasters must submit documentation of actual expenses and estimated remaining
expenses
• FCC will distribute additional funds or reclaim remaining funds, as appropriate
Reimbursement Procedure
Proprietary and confidential. | 31
Connecting What’s Next
Reimbursement Caveats
Stations indirectly impacted not eligible for reimbursement
• FM’s on tower
• Canadian neighbors (62 stations!)
$1.75 B broken down
• $1B authorized to borrow from treasury, $750m from auction proceeds
• Funds subject to sequester, 6 – 9%
• Key words are “up to” (80% commercial, 90% non-comm)
Proprietary and confidential. | 32
Connecting What’s Next
Reimbursement Example
Reimbursement requests totaled $2.1 B
Actual may be less due to form 399 reviews and subsequent amendments, but not expected to go down significantly.
$1.75 B allocated, $1 B available now.
Assume 6% fund sequester
Station estimate submitted is $1,000,000
Station’s initial reimbursement would be:
•(1−6%(1))
2.1× $1,000,000 × 0.8 = $358,095
Second reimbursement when forward auction proceeds fund the remaining $750m (of the $1.75 B)
Will Congress take some action and cover all the costs?
Proprietary and confidential. | 33
Connecting What’s Next
Introduced by NJ Rep. Frank Pallone in July
• Create a $1B additional fund to reimburse stations for repack costs.
• Fund a $90M viewer education effort
• Fund would be authorized to reimburse FM stations for reasonable costs incurred due to repack.
• Any left-over money available to LPTV’s
• Allow media bureau to grant permission to stay on air for situations out of a station’s control.
• No mention of indirectly impacted TV stations.
Bipartisan support in congress.
Viewer Protection Act
Proprietary and confidential. | 34
Connecting What’s Next
Introduced by Sen. Jerry Moran, R-Kan.
Bi-partisan support of Schatz (D-HI), Inhofe (R-Okla), Young (R-Ind), Blumenthal (D-Conn) and Udall (D-NM)
“… very concerned that rural America will be disproportionately harmed..”
“.. Adequate resources and an appropriate timeline..”
• Also includes additional funding to cover the 1.75 B – 2.1 B gap.
• Protects TV stations from going off air or reduced service due to circumstances beyond their control.
• Specific mention for radio stations affected by TV repack.
Viewer and Listener Protection Act
Proprietary and confidential. | 35
Connecting What’s Next
Impact on Broadcast Technical Resources Large demand on consulting engineers time
Structural analysis
Transmitter installers
Tower crews – new towers and antenna installation
Recent hurricane disasters may have crews busy that may impact early phase.
May impact planned radio projects.
In September, we suffered 3 repack related tower fatalities of a qualified high tower crew.
• Deadlines reassessed?
Proprietary and confidential. | 36
Connecting What’s Next
Resource crunch?
94 Stations
114 Stations
95 Stations
110 Stations
116 Stations
114 Stations
113 Stations
114 Stations
76 Stations
53 Stations
Proprietary and confidential. | 37
Connecting What’s Next
Connecting What’s Next
Thank You Joe Seccia, PE
NT8H