Concerned/Cautious #1

16
David Anderson Matthew Anderson Alison Baur Hannah Faulkner Dan Massello Laura Harvey Teal Waterstrat

description

Concerned/Cautious #1. David Anderson Matthew Anderson Alison Baur Hannah Faulkner Dan Massello Laura Harvey Teal Waterstrat. gCORE Fall 2011 Evergreen MES. Who we are and where we fit in. Concerned/Cautious #2. Concerned #2. Alarmed #1. Cautious/Disengaged/Doubtful/Dismissive. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Concerned/Cautious #1

Page 1: Concerned/Cautious #1

David Anderson

Matthew Anderson

Alison Baur

Hannah Faulkner

Dan Massello

Laura Harvey

Teal Waterstrat

Page 2: Concerned/Cautious #1

addae

dander

mander

andrusys

aubrey

baur

blessing

bush

colemandochow

elswick

faulkner

gallaghe

garver

harvey

henson

huck

joneskarboski

marnia

martin

masello

mcbee

mounts

narog

perez

peterson

potter

proie

rambo

redfern

roberts

sargent

spang

starr

thelen

ramsdell

beaman

waterstr

wolt

zimmer

Axis 2

Axis 3

score

1234

Page 3: Concerned/Cautious #1

• Concerned and Cautions make up greatest portion of American attitudes

• Foggy area between concerned and cautious

• Impressions from interview did not always match categorization according to survey results

Introduction to the Six Americas

                                                                                                   

Page 4: Concerned/Cautious #1

Large amount of individual diversity in responses, but commonalties were present

Keywords•Outdoors

•Local mountains

•Glaciers

•Weather

•Complex/complicated

•TV•Internet•Long term

Themes•Many participants long term residents of PNW•Acknowledge climate change is occurring •Doubting level of anthropogenic influence•Distrust of media•Mixed trust in science•Climate too complex to understand•Personal experience shapes opinion•Government seen as : -helpful for education -problematic if too much regulation

Page 5: Concerned/Cautious #1

Experiences in the outdoors

Pertinence of Anthropogenic Role

Proficiency of Personal Knowledge

Accuracy of Media Coverage

Accuracy of Scientific Research

Effectiveness of Government Response

Negative Outlook Positive Outlook Mixed Outlook Not Applicable

5 1 1

2 4 1

2 2 3

3 2 1 1

32 1 1

2 5

Page 6: Concerned/Cautious #1

WORDLE PLACE HOLDER

Concerned-Cautious 1 – Compiled Wordle

Page 7: Concerned/Cautious #1

6 out of 7 subjects were very active in the outdoors through work and recreation•Mountains

•Ocean/Puget Sound

•River rafting

•Sailing

•Kayaking

•Hiking

•Bicycling

•Forestry

•Gardening

Page 8: Concerned/Cautious #1

Perception of Changes in Climate

• 6 out of 7 subjects noted some change in the climate/weather during their time in the Pacific Northwest

• Less extreme winters and summers• Harder rains• Wetter summers• Receding glaciers, less snow/ice• Shorter logging season

Page 9: Concerned/Cautious #1

Anthropogenic Climate Change Beliefs• 1 out of 7 believe that the major changes

to the climate are mostly human caused • 5 out of 7 believe that a portion is caused

by humans (with the rest being natural fluctuation)

• 0 out of 7 believe its entirely natural• 1 out of 7 did not voice an opinion

Page 10: Concerned/Cautious #1

• 5 out of 7 subjects do not go out of their way to research climate change

• 1 out of 7 subjects doubts their knowledge of climate to be accurate, and perceives information sources to be inaccurate

• 4 out of 7 subjects have confidence in their GCC knowledge, but perceive common information sources to be inaccurate

• 2 out of 7 would be interested in climate change if it directly affected them

Page 11: Concerned/Cautious #1

• General distrust in media (3 out of 7)

• Distrust in certain media (1 out of 7)

• General trust in media (2 out of 7)

•Friends (3 of 7)•Magazines (2 of 7)•Television (2 of 7)•Internet (2 of 7)•Newspaper (1 of 7)•Journals (2 of 7)

Page 12: Concerned/Cautious #1

• 4 out of 7 voiced at least some distrust of science

• 2 out of 7 did not mention perceptions of science

• 1 of 7 trusted the Scientific Community• 1 of 7 showed concern that data can

be manipulated• 1 of 7 showed concern that scientific

methods are inappropriate for climate studies

• 1 of 7 showed concern about extreme viewpoints in science

Page 13: Concerned/Cautious #1

• 3 of 7 believe if government action is taken, it should not be radical

• 1 of 7 believe community leaders should help plan for any sort of disaster, not just something like climate change

• 2 of 7 believe community leaders should do more to educate public on GCC

• 5 of 7 believe government action will be received poorly by public

• 2 of 7 believe government action should not infringe on the subject's way of life or finances

Page 14: Concerned/Cautious #1

Questions 11 and 12 presuppose that subjects believe in climate change, and that the government and community leaders should be doing something about it.

"11. Could instituting government policy have an impact on climate change?"

"12. Do you believe community leaders are helping their communites prepare for climate change?"

Future research should consider alterative questions that allow respondents to provide answers in line with their beliefs.

Page 15: Concerned/Cautious #1

• While subjects might believe that climate change is happening, the threat is not viewed as immediate.

• Most subjects do not fully trust science or the media for information on climate change

• Some subjects noted preoccupation with their personal lives

• Opinion and personal experience are more influential than climate change media/info

Page 16: Concerned/Cautious #1

A Very Big Thanks To:

The Evergreen State CollegeJudy Cushing

Martha HendersonCarrie Leroy

The Six AmericasUnnamed Interviewees (n = 7)

KirstenJeremy Littell

Wordle, Moodle, Doodle, and Google (really! These people make millions)

Uncopyrighed Images on the InternetThe MES incoming class support group