"Conceal, Don't Feel:" A Queer Reading of Disney's Frozen

9
Kade Wilson WRIT 1633: Fans and Fan Writing Practices Professor Juli Parrish “CONCEAL, DON’T FEEL”: A QUEER READING OF DISNEYS FROZEN 61 VOLUME 4 The first time I saw Frozen, I was unprepared for the effect it would have on me. I went into the theatre disillusioned by all the hype surrounding the movie and the music in it, expecting to be disappointed when it couldn’t live up to the enthused reviews of all my friends. I wasn’t. As a queer woman, I was hit hard by all of the themes in Frozen and their potential to be read as parallel to the struggle of queer individuals (especially queer youth) in society today. I couldn’t stop singing the soundtrack for weeks, blasting Elsa’s power ballad, “Let it Go,” at every con- ceivable opportunity. For a brief time, Frozen became an essential part of my self-image; I was Elsa, concealing powers to protect myself from the fear of others, and the world around me was Arendelle, beautiful but confining. When I had the opportunity to choose a topic for the final research paper in my WRIT 1633 class focused on fans and fan culture, Frozen immediately sprang to mind. As I began my research, the paper evolved from a discussion of Frozen’s fans to a discussion of the movie itself. This paper explores the many themes in Frozen that can be connected to the queer community and sheds light on some of the common queer narratives. In my analysis, I con- sider the appeal of Frozen as a queer film and the importance of media to queer audiences, especially queer youth. Delving into different strategies for constructing queer readings of Disney stories and other fairy tales has been extraordinarily rewarding, both academically and personally. I hope this paper opens up a dialogue for queer readings to be viewed as an important and necessary part of our culture, and paves the way for queer readings of other children’s texts to become acceptable in academia. INTRODUCTION Disney’s 2013 animated film Frozen was an enor- mous success, grossing over one billion dollars and ranking as the highest-grossing animated film of all time. Consequently, Frozen has a huge fan following, with many fans buying into what is called the “queer Elsa headcanon,” a fan-de- veloped interpretation of the film in which Elsa, one of the protagonists, is queer. A comprehen- sive queer reading of Frozen sheds light on com- mon queer narratives and creates a lens through which to view other texts more queerly. This paper seeks to combine much of the disparate research into one cohesive reading of a specific Disney film and then analyze why queer read- ings, and queer readings of this film in particu- lar, are so inviting and important. WHAT IS A QUEER READING? The first important question to explore is what queer readings are and how they are constructed. It is necessary to define what is meant by “queer,”

description

by Kade Wilson. Featured in WRIT Large Vol. 4, a journal of undergraduate writing published by the University of Denver's Writing Program.

Transcript of "Conceal, Don't Feel:" A Queer Reading of Disney's Frozen

  • Kade WilsonWRIT 1633: Fans and Fan Writing PracticesProfessor Juli Parrish

    CONCEAL, DONT FEEL:A Queer reAding of disneys Frozen

    61VOLUME 4

    The first time I saw Frozen, I was unprepared for the effect it would have on me. I went into the theatre disillusioned by all the hype surrounding the movie and the music in it, expecting to

    be disappointed when it couldnt live up to the enthused reviews of all my friends. I wasnt. As

    a queer woman, I was hit hard by all of the themes in Frozen and their potential to be read as parallel to the struggle of queer individuals (especially queer youth) in society today. I couldnt

    stop singing the soundtrack for weeks, blasting Elsas power ballad, Let it Go, at every con-ceivable opportunity. For a brief time, Frozen became an essential part of my self-image; I was Elsa, concealing powers to protect myself from the fear of others, and the world around

    me was Arendelle, beautiful but confining.

    When I had the opportunity to choose a topic for the final research paper in my WRIT 1633

    class focused on fans and fan culture, Frozen immediately sprang to mind. As I began my research, the paper evolved from a discussion of Frozens fans to a discussion of the movie itself. This paper explores the many themes in Frozen that can be connected to the queer community and sheds light on some of the common queer narratives. In my analysis, I con-sider the appeal of Frozen as a queer film and the importance of media to queer audiences, especially queer youth. Delving into different strategies for constructing queer readings of

    Disney stories and other fairy tales has been extraordinarily rewarding, both academically

    and personally. I hope this paper opens up a dialogue for queer readings to be viewed as an

    important and necessary part of our culture, and paves the way for queer readings of other

    childrens texts to become acceptable in academia.

    INTRODUCTIONDisneys 2013 animated film Frozen was an enor-mous success, grossing over one billion dollars

    and ranking as the highest-grossing animated film of all time. Consequently, Frozen has a huge fan following, with many fans buying into what

    is called the queer Elsa headcanon, a fan-de-veloped interpretation of the film in which Elsa,

    one of the protagonists, is queer. A comprehen-sive queer reading of Frozen sheds light on com-mon queer narratives and creates a lens through

    which to view other texts more queerly. This

    paper seeks to combine much of the disparate

    research into one cohesive reading of a specific

    Disney film and then analyze why queer read-ings, and queer readings of this film in particu-lar, are so inviting and important.

    WHAT IS A QUEER READING? The first important question to explore is what

    queer readings are and how they are constructed.

    It is necessary to define what is meant by queer,

  • 62 WRIT LARGE: 2015

    Kade is a sophomore at the University of

    Denver majoring in German and English

    with a concentration in literary studies.

    She spends her time as a member of

    DUs Queer Student Alliance, Diversity

    Committee, and Mock Trial team. She

    also laughs hysterically over cat videos or

    funny Buzzfeed posts with her roommate

    of two years. Kade grew up in Aurora,

    Colorado, with her parents, brother, and

    feline best friend.

    both as a noun and a verb. According to Caitlin

    Ryan and Jill Hermann-Wilmarth, queer refers

    not only to the community of gender and sexu-ality minorities commonly known as LGBT, but

    also to any sexuality, relationship, gender iden-tity, or gender expression that falls outside of

    what society has constructed as normal (145).

    In their words, Our use of queer theory is not

    focused on whether or not people (or characters,

    as we will see) are gay, but rather assumes that categories around gender, sexuality, bodies, and

    desire are artificially strict to begin with (Ryan

    and Hermann-Wilmarth 147). This is to say that

    queering a narrative does not entail searching

    for some type of hard evidence that a character

    is queer, but rather searches for ways in which

    the narrative breaks down traditional boundar-ies and leaves room for reading a character or

    a situation in a way that doesnt fall within the

    dominant hetero-patriarchy.

    Once we have defined queer, we can move

    onto, more broadly, defining a queer reading.

    As Henry Jenkins notes in Textual Poachers, fan audiences in general construct a variety of read-ingsincluding queer readingsof the texts

    they read and watch, adapting those texts to meet

    their needs and ideas. For Frederik Dhaenens,

    Sofie van Bauwel, and Daniel Biltereyst, queer

    readings are concerned with repositioning

    texts outside the borders of heteronormativity

    (335). To put it simply, a queer reading involves

    searching a text for themes, ideas, or messages

    that seem contradictory to what we are taught is normal. As Dhaenens puts it, the practice of

    queer reading should not be interpreted as mak-ing texts queer but rather as trying to understand

    how texts might be understood as queer (341).

    Ryan and Hermann-Wilmarth discuss several

    strategies for constructing queer-readings of lit-erature, including page-by-page analysis, holistic

    analysis, themed analysis, and gendered analysis

    (144). In this paper, I use a themed analysis to

    pick out elements of Frozen that defy traditional ideas surrounding gender and sexuality, whether

    literally or metaphorically, in order to construct

    a comprehensive queer reading of the ways that

    Frozen can be queered.

    MAGIC OR CURSE: ELSAS POWERS AS QUEERNESSThe film Frozen follows the story of sisters and princesses Anna and Elsa of Arendelle. Elsa has

    been confined to her room since childhood be-cause she cannot control her magical powers to

    create snow and ice. Elsa is finally allowed out

    for her coronation ball, where Anna meets and

    falls in love with Prince Hans, who is secretly

    Kade Wilson / LP Picard

    Queering a narrative does not entail

    searching for some type of hard

    evidence that a character is queer,

    but rather searches for ways in which

    the narrative breaks down traditional

    boundaries and leaves room for

    reading a character or a situation

    in a way that doesnt fall within the

    dominant hetero-patriarchy.

  • 63VOLUME 4

    DisneyLifestylers.com

    plotting to marry Anna, then kill Elsa and gain

    the throne. During the ball, Elsa inadvertently

    reveals her powers and escapes to the mountains.

    When later confronted by Anna, she accidentally

    shoots ice into Annas heart, to be healed only

    by an act of true love. Though Anna originally

    believes a kiss from a man she loves will thaw

    the ice, it is her attempt to save Elsa that thaws

    her heart and teaches Elsa to control her powers.

    The first description of Elsas powers comes

    from Anna. Anna calls them the magic, and

    the ice and snow are shown to be childishly play-ful and fun, with nothing inherently bad about

    them. Elsas powers only become negative when

    she becomes frightened and scared or when oth-ers react badly to what she can do. For example,

    when Elsa and Anna are playing and Anna be-gins to jump too fast, Elsa becomes frightened,

    even saying, Wait, slow down! Elsas fear then

    causes the mishap where Annas head is struck by

    ice. Queer identities are not inherently bad; they

    do not inherently harm anyone, and queer love

    doesnt have fundamental differences from het-erosexual love. However, the way society frames

    queer identities is what makes them negative in

    societys eyes. Elsas powers serve as a metaphor

    for this framing and for queer identity.

    The film establishes early on that Elsas

    powers are not a curse. When asked by the troll

    leader, the king immediately replies that Elsa

    was born with her powers rather than cursed by

    them. This definition of Elsas powers parallels

    discussions of queer identity, insisting on the

    innate nature of sexual orientation and gender

    identity rather than due to some sickness of the

    mind or spirit. The effects of society on Elsas

    powers become apparent early on, as she is slow-ly socialized to believe negative things about her-self. Though she has only ever hurt one person,

    and in an accidental, non-malicious way, Elsa has

    internalized the connection between her powers

    and harming others. She tells her parents that

    she doesnt want to hurt them, and her father

    responds that getting upset makes it worse,

    showing how Elsas perceptions of others and

    her beliefs about how they will react to her pow-ers influence how she expresses herself.

    These ideas Elsa holds about herself affect

    her well into her teenage and young adult years.

    In For the First Time in Forever (Reprise), Elsa

    distinctly calls her powers a curse, claiming that

    she cant control them, as though some external

    power is influencing her. The idea that her pow-ers are not an inborn and beautiful thing reflects

    how queer identities are painted by society today;

    these identities are demonized and described as

    the product of some external force, whether that

    be improper parenting, skewed media images,

    or sin. Elsa has also absorbed this idea, trying

    to deny and repress her identity as if it were the

    function of a curse rather than embracing the

    magical potential that her natural identity holds.

    REPRESSION AND PARENTAL INFLUENCEAnna and Elsas parents play a particularly im-portant role in Frozen. Though they die early on in the story, their short presence leaves a lasting

    impact on Elsa. Many of Elsas core feelings

    about her powers stem from the lessons her par-

    https://www.flickr.com/photos/93654615@N07/9927453736/in/set-72157635866791793

  • 64 WRIT LARGE: 2015

    ents (specifically her father) taught her, telling

    her to conceal it, dont feel it, dont let it show.

    As dictated to her by her parents, Elsa needing to

    learn control over her powers turns into a need

    to repress her powers and attempt not to feel.

    This idea is easily accessible for a queer audience,

    as much of the modern discourse surrounding

    queer sexualities and gender identities is to re-press and hide rather than to embrace and love.

    An essential part of the narrative of many

    queer youth is an attempt to not feel their

    sexuality, often as dictated to them by their re-ligion, community, or family. Elsas uphill bat-tle to keep her powers hidden is a clear parallel

    to this all-too-common situation. However, the

    harder Elsa tries to not feel her powers, the more

    she cannot control them. During For the First

    Time in Forever, Elsa is shown singing about

    repressing her powers (Dont let them in, dont

    let them see) while standing directly underneath

    an intimidating portrait of her father. The visual

    parallel between her fathers coronation and hers

    is made clear when Elsa imitates his pose and

    then breaks it as ice begins to cover the objects she is holding. Her fathers advice still has power

    over her even long after his death, and Elsa is

    still striving toward his ideals.

    In many Disney princess films, the conflict

    between father and daughter parallels the state of

    the kingdom, and the plot is effectively resolved

    through the courtship and eventual marriage of

    the princess (Do Rozario). Though this trope

    applies to Frozen, significant parts are changed. Elsas relationship with her father and his advice

    does fall in line with the state of Arendelle. When

    Elsas powers are finally revealed during the ball,

    she runs away to escape to the North Mountain,

    where she has the ultimate conflict with her fa-thers advice. When Elsa runs away, she freezes

    over Arendelle completely, demonstrating how

    negative her powers can be when she feels scared

    or threatened, in this case by both her potential

    betrayal of her fathers advice and the immediate

    reactions of the people around her. Once she has

    escaped that environment, she can think more

    clearly, and, as her ballad Let it Go demon-strates, she can reject her fathers ideals. During

    the song, she throws away her gloves, cloak, and

    tiara. The gloves and cloak, used physically to

    cover Elsa and repress her powers, symbolize the

    conceal, dont feel mentality championed by

    Elsas father. By literally letting these objects go,

    Elsa obtains freedom from the physical, mental,

    and emotional constraints of her fathers ideol-ogy. Because parental ideologies are established

    as normal, by releasing these symbols Elsa is

    queering the established rules set forth by her par-ents. Elsa sings, The fears that once controlled

    me cant get to me at all, further demonstrating

    her rejection of her fathers normative ideas.

    Additionally, Elsas continual emphasis of

    the phrase good girl (in Let it Go, she sings,

    That perfect girl is gone) leaves room for a

    queering of Elsas gender identity. Though Elsas

    rejection of her fathers idea of the good girl

    could be a way of becoming a bad girl, this

    also could be read as a rejection of the idea of be-ing a girl altogether. Elsas rejection of the ide-ology that was forced upon her from childhood

    opens many opportunities to queer her narrative.

    As she sings, Elsa builds a beautiful ice pal-ace. In contrast to the dark state of Arendelle,

    which Elsa froze while still under the influence

    of her fathers repressive ideology, the palace she

    builds while freeing herself is beautiful, show-ing what she can accomplish when free from the

    limitations others place upon her. Rebecca-Anne

    DoRozario argues that the tension between fa-ther and daughter in princess movies is typically

    resolved through courtship; however, in Frozen, it is resolved through Elsa accepting herself and

    Annas act of true love to save her at the films

    end. This rejection of heterosexual courtship,

    along with Elsas relationship with her parents,

    allows for Elsas character to be queered.

    In contrast to the dark state of

    Arendelle, which Elsa froze while still

    under the influence of her fathers

    repressive ideology, the palace she

    builds while freeing herself is beautiful,

    showing what she can accomplish when

    free from the limitations others place

    upon her.

  • 65VOLUME 4

    ELSA AS A MONSTROSITYThe first words spoken by Elsa and Annas par-ents in the film are, Elsa, what have you done?

    From Frozens beginning, Elsa is set up as the bad guy by those around her. Even from that

    very first line, other characters in the story frame

    Elsa as evil. This idea becomes essential for a

    queer reading of the film. The outsider as a mon-ster is a potent trope in queer readings and dates

    back to queer interpretations of the Disney film

    Beauty and the Beast. As Sean Griffin discusses in his book Tinker Belles and Fairy Queens, the Beast was often said to represent an AIDS victim, due

    to how he is misunderstood and constructed as a monster by those surrounding him. Griffin also

    describes how society teaches that queer individ-uals are bad objects, a concept crucial to un-derstanding how Elsas construction as a mon-ster can be read queerly (68).

    In Frozen, Elsas character is made to be a monstrosity in several ways. When the troll lead-er is showing Elsa her future, he states that fear

    will be her enemy. This line could be taken to

    mean that Elsas fear is her own enemy, which is

    later demonstrated in the film through her pow-ers becoming unmanageable when she gets up-set. However, the image the troll leader actually

    displays is one of red figures attacking Elsa, not

    of her own fear damaging her. The fear of others

    is the most dangerous part of Elsas powers and

    not her own control of them and her emotions.

    This is a familiar queer narrative. Even though

    there is nothing inherently harmful or bad about

    queer sexualities (or sexuality in general), the re-actions of others, especially those motivated by

    fear, can be potentially dangerous to queer indi-viduals, and Elsa illustrates this struggle.

    When Elsas power is first revealed to the

    public at the coronation ball, it is framed in

    a dangerous way. She shoots out spikes of ice

    around her, which could potentially harm those

    in the surrounding area. However, Elsa doesnt

    actually harm anyone throughout the entire

    movie. She often threatens others with her pow-ers, but it is always a form of self-protection.

    For example, when the Duke of Weseltons men

    attack her, she shoves one of them against the

    wall with ice, a scene that, to those just entering

    the room, makes her appear to be the aggressor.

    However, Elsas behavior is motivated by self-de-fense against physical and emotional threat. De-spite this, the immediate reactions to her powers

    are fear and anger, with the Duke calling her a

    monster immediately afterwards. These reac-tions then serve to foster more fear and anger

    DisneyLifestylers.com

    Anna here functions as a clear representative of the

    real world where people function properly in society

    through conventions like heterosexual marriage, making

    this literal outing of Elsas hand, the vehicle of her

    powers, even more dramatic.

    https://www.flickr.com/photos/93654615@N07/9927435996/in/set-72157635866791793

  • 66 WRIT LARGE: 2015

    in Elsa herself, which results in a negative cycle

    where only the dangerous parts of her powers

    are shown.

    Negative reactions from others are, unfortu-nately, an intrinsic and painful part of the lives

    of queer individuals, and these reactions under-standably create adverse feelings in the queer

    community. Expression of these feelings by the

    queer community only feeds more unfavorable

    ideas and stereotypes about queer individuals,

    increasing the antagonistic reaction to them, creating a cycle much like the one in which Elsa

    is trapped. This cycle is emphasized in a literal

    way when Elsa fashions a monster out of snow

    in order to protect herself from the emotional

    confrontation instigated by Anna. Elsas creation

    of a monster with her powers can serve as a di-rect analog for the anger and pain many queer

    individuals feel. And the fact that she used her

    powers, which can also be used for beauty and

    good, to make a monster can be read as queer.

    Elsas construction as a monster is further

    realized in the film when Prince Hans (who has

    been against Elsa from the films onset), in re-sponse to seeing Elsa pinning a man up against

    the wall, calls out to her, Dont be the mon-ster they fear you are! His statement results

    in Elsas distraction, which is enough time for

    the pinned man to shoot the chandelier on the

    ceiling. The chandelier then falls and traps Elsa,

    ultimately allowing Prince Hans to imprison

    her. Hans comment not only allows the viewer

    to see how others in the film have constructed

    Elsa as a monster, it also causes Elsa to pause

    for a moment to ask: Have I become a mon-

    Everyone deserves to see their identity represented in their

    media, and childrens media in particular is lacking in positive

    portrayal of queer characters.

    ster? The idea of being called a negative thing

    so many times that one starts to become it is also a very queer narrative. Through different

    means of socializationsuch as religion, school,

    the media, and familymany queer individuals

    are taught that non-heterosexual sexualities are

    somehow wrong, immoral, or sinful. Elsas sud-den and forced reflection on whether her powers

    are monstrous is a painful reflection of a social

    reality many individuals face, and it further con-structs her as a monstrosity. The fact that she has

    been told to conceal her powers as if they were

    a negative thing (despite her parents clear state-ment that she was not cursed but rather born with the magic) has made her internalize ideas

    about the inherent negativity of her so-called

    curse, as Elsa sings in For the First Time in

    Forever (Reprise): I cant control the curse.

    Because of the constant construction of Elsa as

    a monster by other characters in the film and her

    own internalized negativity, when she is con-fronted by Hans statement, she actually has to

    consider whether she is a monster, resulting in a

    moment painful for even non-queer viewers to

    experience.

    However, Elsa, as one of the films two main

    protagonists, cannot remain constructed as a

    monster through the films end, and the disman-tling of this construction is accomplished in an

    inherently queer way. After Elsa creates a giant

    snowstorm to free herself from captivity (anoth-er act of self-defense), the winds only stop after

    Hans falsely reports that Anna is dead because

    Elsa struck her in the heart with ice. Elsa is still

    constructed as a monster by Hans here, but the

    information is obviously false to the viewer, who

    now understands that Elsa cannot be the antag-onist of the story. Hans lie constructs him (in

    the viewers eyes) as the monster and removes

    this burden from Elsa. Once he lies to Elsa about

    Annas death, the snowstorm stops entirely, and

    Elsa doesnt even try to fight back when Hans

    draws his sword in preparation to kill her. Quite

    simply, Elsa has given up and doesnt even have

    the will to repress her power anymore.

    Elsa has become the victim of anothers con-struction of her, a plot point that is queer in its

    nature, as many queer people, especially queer

    youth, are either killed or take their own lives

    due to the false and highly damaging perceptions

  • 67VOLUME 4

    of others. Elsa has accepted her fate and is will-ing to die because she has internalized the idea of

    herself as a monster, making her a tragic hero that

    is willing to punish herself with death for a crime

    she didnt actually commit. Elsas acceptance en-tirely reverses her construction as a monster for

    both the audience and for Anna, who steps in at

    the last moment to save her sister, thus sacrific-ing herself. This act of true love serves as the

    turning point that allows Elsa to see clearly and

    bring back summer in Arendelle, and it shows

    how Hans and the Duke of Weselton, not Elsa,

    are the real monsters of the story.

    DUALITY AND FANTASY WORLDS IN FROZENFrozens opening scene has the viewer looking out into the world from underwater. From this

    moment on, the idea of inside and outside

    worlds is repeatedly demonstrated in the film.

    As Ryan and Hermann-Wilmarth discuss, queer

    identity as shown through queer readings of

    popular texts is often about creating a queered

    hybrid world, where aspects of traditional soci-ety and queer society can coexist (154). A good

    example of this is Laura Sells discussion of The Little Mermaid. Sells says, In this dualistic and hierarchical construction, the human world can

    be aligned with the white male system and the

    water world situated outside [the patriarchy]

    (177). Rather than existing underwater and on

    land as in The Little Mermaid, these two worlds exist in the case of Frozen as the so-called mag-ic and reality worlds that are constructed

    around Elsa and her powers, with reality repre-

    senting the hetero-patriarchy and magic becom-ing representative of anyone outside the norm.

    This division of worlds manifests in a con-crete way when Elsa is locked in her room and,

    in a larger sense, when both sisters are locked in

    the palace. Anna has the entire palace to roam,

    but she longs for both the outside world (repre-sentative of reality) and entrance to Elsas room

    (the mini-world that has been created around

    Elsa to maintain her powers). Elsa is trapped

    in a small world inundated with her magic, and

    despite how she may long to enter the reality of

    normal society, she must remain where her

    parents and society have placed her, supposedly

    for the good of both Elsa and those around her.

    Even once the gates to the palace are opened and

    Elsa must come out of her room, she has a clear

    conflict between her desires and what she be-lieves is necessary. In response to Annas probing

    about why the gates cant be open all the time,

    Elsa merely responds, [They] just cant, never

    providing a clearer explanation. Here, the viewer

    can distinctly see how Elsa is seeking to combine

    her real and magical worlds. She enjoys being in

    the reality world of the castle with open gates;

    however, she believes the only place she can exist

    is in her room, the magical world of ice that

    has been built around her, teaching her to feel

    shame about her powers.

    When Elsa escapes to the North Mountain

    later in the film, she literally creates her own

    world, a palace made of ice. This castle, in con-trast to the one in Arendelle, is made from and

    by her ice powers, creating another magic

    world that she uses to escape the pressures of the

    (left) Ricky Brigante

    (right) DisneyLifestylers.comhttps://www.flickr.com/photos/insidethemagic

    /8080479064https://www.flickr.com/photos/93654615@N07

    /9927416815/in/set-72157635866791793

  • 68 WRIT LARGE: 2015

    hetero-patriarchy. However, Elsa cannot exist in

    an isolated state and is confronted again with re-ality when Anna comes looking for her. In For

    the First Time in Forever (Reprise), Elsa pleads

    with Anna, trying to convince her to return to

    Arendelle. Elsa sings, You mean well, but leave

    me be/Yes, Im alone but Im alone and free/

    Just stay away and youll be safe from me. The

    song demonstrates both Elsas desire for a world

    of her own and her recognition of the problems

    of living an isolated life. Though she wants to

    have a meaningful relationship with Anna, she

    still maintains that her loneliness is justified be-cause she is free to use her powers as she wishes,

    without harming anyone else or being harmed

    by society. The solution to this problem would

    be the combination of Elsas reality and magic

    worlds, resulting in a place where she can have

    love and acceptance but also feel free to express

    her identity without judgment or anger from

    those around her.

    The film goes on, however, to reveal that

    Elsa isnt yet ready to gain her power within An-nas system (the very system that oppressed her),

    and the sudden confrontation between the real

    and magical worlds is distressing, resulting in her

    shooting Anna in the heart with ice. The con-flict between reality and magic is also demon-strated when Elsas confrontation with Anna

    during the ball escalates, culminating in Anna

    pulling off Elsas glove. Anna here functions as

    a clear representative of the real world where

    people function properly in society through con-ventions like heterosexual marriage, making this

    literal outing of Elsas hand, the vehicle of her

    powers, even more dramatic. The removal of El-sas glove creates the tension that causes her to

    shoot ice spikes in a circle around her, further

    revealing her powers to everyone. Being out-ed creates the turning point where Elsa can no

    longer pass as non-magical (or straight) and so is

    no longer safe inside the hetero-patriarchy. Her

    various outbursts show the tension between re-ality and the magic world Elsa constructs (or has

    constructed around her), demonstrating a queer

    narrative where rejection from mainstream soci-ety necessitates the building of ones own exter-nal fantasy world.

    By the end of the film, Elsas magic and real

    worlds have finally become one. She resides in the

    Arendelle palace, where the gates have opened,

    rejecting the isolation that characterized earlier

    moments in the movie. Additionally, Elsas pow-ers are widely known and, as far as the audience

    sees, widely accepted. Annas role as the vehicle

    of reality has also diminished, with the notion

    of marriage (earlier shown to create the tension

    that facilitated Elsas outburst) abandoned. Ad-ditionally, Anna is talked into skating on the ice

    that Elsa created. Even Olaf, a snowman brought

    to life by Elsa, has a place in Arendelle. Though

    summer, and thus normality, has been restored,

    Elsa creates a snow cloud to follow Olaf around,

    ensuring he doesnt melt. These examples of the

    magic and real worlds blending together demon-strate the perfect conclusion of a queer narrative:

    the comforts of mainstream society intertwined

    with the magical aspects that have served as the

    vehicle for Elsas queerness throughout the film.

    Sells writes that in The Little Mermaid, Ariels

    DisneyLifestylers.comhttps://www.flickr.com/photos/93654615@N07/9927464066/in/set-72157635866791793

  • 69VOLUME 4

    ascent into the human world is sanitized by

    Disney, changing her desire for knowledge and

    power with desire for love (180). In this way,

    Ariel is stripped of her autonomy, and the film

    sends the message that she has succeeded with-in the white patriarchy by mutilating her body

    and losing her voice. However, Frozen eschews this sanitization. Elsas desire to be accepted for

    who she is isnt diluted by a love interest. She

    wants acceptance from her friends, subjects, and

    family, particularly Anna. Elsas achievement of

    this goal on her own terms sends a dramatically

    different message than The Little Mermaid. Rather than succeeding within the realm of heteronor-mativity, Elsa queers the system and makes her

    individuality an inherent part of Arendelle. She

    isnt content with living outside society, but she

    also isnt content with giving up a part of herself

    to live in it, as Ariel does. To resolve this, she

    combines the two worlds, creating an ideal fan-tasy for many queer individualsa world where

    they can live a normal life but also have their

    queerness be visible and accepted.

    CONCLUSIONFrozen is important to read queerly because of its high visibility and popularity, in addition to

    its unique plot devices and subversion of many

    norms of its genre. Queer readings such as this

    one, particularly of popular Disney films and

    childrens films, serve an important cultural

    role. They generate important conversations,

    as they illuminate identities and ideas that are

    often obscured by mainstream media. Every-one deserves to see their identity represented in

    their media, and childrens media in particular

    are lacking in positive portrayal of queer char-acters. Though queer readings of texts such as

    this one are a strong beginning, they cannot be the end. Representations of openly queer char-acters in childrens media need to exist as role

    models and guides for children struggling with

    their identities in a world that is often uninviting

    and intimidating. But for now, Frozen fans of all ages can look to Elsa and see something beyond

    a side character or a one-dimensional stereotype.

    Elsa is a queen: powerful, beautiful, and queer.

    WORKS CITED

    Dhaenens, Frederik, Sofie Van Bauwel, and Daniel Biltereyst. Slashing the Fiction of Queer Theory: Slash Fiction,

    Queer Reading, and Transgressing the Boundaries of Screen Studies, Representations, and Audiences. Journal of

    Communication Inquiry 32.4 (2008): 335347. Web. 23 Feb. 2014.

    DoRozario, Rebecca-Anne C. The Princess and the Magic Kingdom: Beyond Nostalgia, the Function of the Dis-

    ney Princess. Womens Studies in Communication 27.1 (2004): 3459. Web. 23 Feb. 2014.

    Frozen. Dir. Jennifer Lee and Chris Buck. Walt Disney Pictures, 2013.

    Griffin, Sean. Tinker Belles and Evil Queens: The Walt Disney Company from the Inside Out. New York and London: New

    York UP, 2000. Print.

    Jenkins, Henry. Textual Poachers: Television Fans and Participatory Culture. New York: Routledge, 1992. Print.

    Ryan, Caitlin L., and Jill Hermann-Wilmarth. Already on the Shelf: Queer Readings of Award-Winning Childrens

    Literature. Journal of Literacy Research 45.2 (2013): 142172. Web. 14 Mar. 2014.

    Sells, Laura. Where Do the Mermaids Stand?: Voice and Body in The Little Mermaid. In From Mouse to Mermaid:

    The Politics of Film, Gender, and Culture. Eds. Elizabeth Bell, Lynda Haas, and Laura Sells. Bloomington: Indiana

    UP, 1995. 17592.