COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ......

48
COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, ROCHES BEACH, LAUDERDALE CLARENCE CITY, TASMANIA James Carley Water Research Laboratory University of New South Wales

Transcript of COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ......

Page 1: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION,

ROCHES BEACH, LAUDERDALECLARENCE CITY, TASMANIA

James CarleyWater Research Laboratory

University of New South Wales

Page 2: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

WRL -THE ORGANISATION• Part of UNSW• Established at Manly Vale 1959• Birthplace of coastal engineering in Australia

ACTIVITIES• Teaching• Research• Commercial consulting by full time project staff

PROJECT METHODS• Physical Modelling• Numerical Modelling• Fieldwork• Desktop Design

Page 3: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Coastal hazards are not new

Lauderdale CanalEntrance1924 to 2008

Page 4: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Roches Beach Studies

Page 5: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Roches Beach Studies

WRL studies• 1988: Pitt+Sherry and Prof Doug Foster• 2008: Clarence coastal study incl adaptation• 2009: Beach scraping for Cremorne & Roches• 2011: Hazard line reassessment• 2011: Trial groyne investigation• 2011: Storm damage assessment

Page 6: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Roches Beach Studies

Other studies• 1959: Prof J L Davies• 2006: Chris Sharples (Tasmania wide)• 2006: Gerry Byrne• 2006: Bill Cromer• 2007: Chris Sharples (Roches Beach)• 2007: John Hunter (Hobart extreme sea levels)• Ongoing: Chris Sharples UTAS

Page 7: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

WRL 2008 studyCoastal hazard lines and options for entire Clarence LGA developed coast

Technical reference group:Mark Hemer (CSIRO)John Hunter (UTAS)Chris Sharples (UTAS)

Page 8: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Key Coastal Hazardsand Processes

Key hazards (out of ~10)• Erosion• Inundation

• Groundwater

Key coastal processes (out of ~10)• Waves• Water levels

Page 9: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

9

Wave buoys

CAPESORELLWAVE BUOY

EDENWAVEBUOY

Page 10: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

OCEAN WAVES – Cape Sorell TAS

Page 11: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

ERA-40 DIRECTIONALWAVE CLIMATE

0

45

90

135

180

225

270

315

WAVE DIRECTION

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13Hs (m)

TASMANIAHs from C-ERA-40DIRECTION from ERA-40ERA40 142.5E 47.5S1957 to 2002 (45 years)

Page 12: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

SWAN Wave Modelling

Ocean swell waves

Page 13: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

13

Technical assessment: SWAN wave modelling fine grid

Page 14: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

SWAN output

Page 15: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Wind waves

0.1 1 10 100 1000 10000AVERAGE RECURRENCE INTERVAL (years)

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

WIN

D S

PE

ED

(m/s

for 3

sec

ond

gust

)

AS 1170-2:2002DIRECTIONAL MULTIPLIER = 1

HOBART REGION A - ANY DIRECTION

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

knot

s

Page 16: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Present day water levelsTide, storm surge, but not local waves

Page 17: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Historical events

Page 18: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Historical events

Page 19: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

IPCC (NCCOE, 2004) Sea level rise projections

SEA LEVEL RISE for ~21000.9 m from NCCOE (2004) SLR curves based on IPCC (2001)7 m IPCC (2007) for total melting of the Greenland ice sheet 70 m if all the world’s ice sheets were to melt (GACGC, 2006)

Page 20: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Sea level rise scenarios adoptedMost states (QLD, NSW, VIC, SA, WA) have adoptedSea level rise for planning to 2100 of 0.8 to 1.0 m

Year and Sea Level Rise relative to 1990 (m)

SLR Scenario 2050 2100

“Mid” range scenario 0.2 0.4

“High” range scenario 0.3 0.9

Page 21: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

WRL 2008 coastal hazard lines and areasDue to the study covering most of Clarence coast,Single values were used for setback lines and inundation for Roches Beach

Page 22: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Hazard line reassessment (2011)Long term change from photogrammetry

Page 23: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Wave climate along beach

Page 24: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Sand transport (northward)

Page 25: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Sand transport

Page 26: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Components of inundation

• Tide• Barometric setup• Wind setup• Wave setup• Wave runup

Page 27: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Inundation components

Page 28: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Inundation levels

Page 29: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Erosion and recession setbacks

Page 30: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

S1: Storm Erosion modelling

Page 31: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

S1: Erosion modelling

Page 32: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Photogrammetry lines

Page 33: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

S2: Underlying recession

Page 34: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

S2: Long term change from photogrammetry

Page 35: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

S4: Dune stability

Page 36: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Erosion Hazard Linesfor coastal setback

Page 37: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

S5: Recession due to sea level rise

Page 38: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 Detailed summary of setback allowances

Page 39: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 Hazard lines and areas

Page 40: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 storms8 June 20119-10 July 2011

1 hour wave height Hs = 10.0 mapproximately a 4 year ARI;

48 hour wave height: Hs = 7.0 m, approximately a 40 year ARI.

Site visit by Dr Tom ShandFrom WRL

Page 41: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 storms

Page 42: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 storms

Page 43: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 storms

Page 44: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

2011 storms9-10 July 2011

1 hour wave height Hs = 10.0 m

48 hour wave height: Hs = 7.0 m,

Page 45: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Storm waves 9-10 July9-10 July 2011•1 hour wave height Hs = 10.0 m•approximately a 4 year ARI;

•48 hour wave height: Hs = 7.0 m,

•approximately a 40 year ARI.

Page 46: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Water levels 9-10 July 2011

Predicted tide 1.54 m CDMeasured Port of Hobart 1.72 m CD, 0.89 m AHD< 1 year ARI ~0.2 m “storm surge”

Page 47: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

Summary / conclusions / discussion

•Rigorous contemporary coastal engineering studies have been undertaken.

•Roches Beach has receded over the last 50 years.

•Erosion, recession, inundation and potential sea level rise are the dominant coastal hazards to consider for planning.

•Numerous feasible adaptation options are available.

Page 48: COASTAL HAZARDS, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADAPTATION, … · Coastal hazard lines and options for ... EDEN WAVE BUOY. ... Microsoft PowerPoint - A655965.pptx [Read-Only] Author: dbellamy

The end