Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____...

28
Clean Energy in India: R&D opportuni6es and Needs Ambuj Sagar Vipula and Mahesh Chaturvedi Professor of Policy Studies Indian Ins6tute of Technology Delhi [email protected] Energy Technology R&D Needs of Emerging Economies IEA/EGRD & MOST, Beijing 28 November 2012

Transcript of Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____...

Page 1: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  in  India:  R&D  opportuni6es  and  Needs  

 Ambuj  Sagar  

Vipula  and  Mahesh  Chaturvedi  Professor  of  Policy  Studies  Indian  Ins6tute  of  Technology  Delhi  

[email protected]    

Energy  Technology  R&D  Needs  of  Emerging  Economies  IEA/EGRD  &  MOST,  Beijing  

28  November  2012  

   

Page 2: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

 

 Outline:

•     India’s  energy  sector  –  a  brief  overview  

•   (Selected)    Clean  energy  opportuni6es  (and  needs)  in  India  •     India’s  R&D  landscape  •   Clean  R&D  opportuni6es,  and  coopera6ve  approaches  –  a    personal  assessment      

Page 3: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

India’s energy sector – a brief overview

Page 4: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Trends  in  Supply  of  Primary  Commercial  Energy  (MTOE)  

 

 

Source: Draft 12th 5-year Plan 43% reduction in energy intensity between 1981 and 2011

Page 5: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Changing  Structure  of  Fuel  for  Electricity      

Source: Draft 12th 5-year Plan

Page 6: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Household  access  (to  clean  forms  of  energy)  (%)  

Source: Draft 12th 5-year Plan

Page 7: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

(Selected) Clean energy opportunities (and needs) in India

Page 8: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 

1609        181      346  

476              41          63  

449              43            89  394              58        100  

                             60      122  

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  Low-C energy futures:

Page 9: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Low-C energy futures (contd):

Page 10: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Power generation technology options:  

•   More  efficient  coal  genera6on  ü   Retrofi\ng  exis6ng  sub-­‐cri6cal  coal  power  plants  

 Economizers    Air  pre-­‐heaters    Cogenera6on  

ü   Greenfield    Supercri6cal/ultra-­‐supercri6cal  coal  power    Integrated  gasifica6on  combined  cycle  

       

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Page 11: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Power generation (contd.):  

•   Renewables  ü   Grid-­‐integra6on  and  control  ü Solar      Solar  PV  and  solar  thermal  genera6on  systems  ü   Wind  

Advanced  wind  turbines/components  Simula6on  tools  for  op6mized  wind-­‐farm  planning  Wind  power  density  assessment    

       

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Page 12: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Buildings:  

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Page 13: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Buildings:  

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Page 14: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Buildings technology options:  

•   More  efficient  appliances  ü Household  

Fans  (motors,  blade  design)  Ligh6ng  (LED-­‐based  ligh6ng  systems)  Refrigerators  (compressors,  insula6on,  design)  Air-­‐condi6oners  (compressors,  design)  

ü   Commercial  Innova6ve  air-­‐condi6oning  (hydrate  slurry  ac)  Ligh6ng  systems    

•   Building  Integrated  Management  Systems    

•   High-­‐reflec6vity  paints  and  windows    

•   Incorpora6on  of  renewables  (e.g.,  solar  water  heaters)    

     

       

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 15: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 16: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Industry technology options (steel):  

•   Raw  material  processing  ü Pulverized  coal  injec6on  ü Coal-­‐beneficia6on  technologies  ü Next-­‐genera6on  coke-­‐making  technologies  ü Sintering  machine  cooler  waste  heat  recovery  

•     Improved  core  technologies  ü   Smelt-­‐reduc6on  technologies  (CORX.  FINEX)  ü Con6nuous  cas6ng;  integrated  cas6ng  &  rolling;  cold-­‐rolling..  ü DC  arc  technology  (EAFs)  

•   Energy  recovery  and  conserva6on  ü   Top-­‐pressure  turbine  ü Coke  dry  quenching  ü Waste-­‐heat  recovery  ü Automated  monitoring  and  process  op6miza6on  

     

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 17: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Industry technology options (cement):  

•   Waste  heat  recovery  ü   Co-­‐genera6on  ü Low-­‐pressure  waster  heat  reovery  

•   Cement  formula6on  ü   Low-­‐carbon  cement  ü   Pre-­‐blending  processing  technologies  (increased  blending  percentage)  

     

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Source: Low-C Committee interim report

Page 18: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 19: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Some ‘clean energy’ initiatives :  

•   Na6onal  mission  on  enhanced  energy  efficiency  Energy  security,  resource-­‐use  efficiency,  climate  change  ü Industrial  energy  efficiency  (Perform,  Achieve,  and  Trade)  ü Market  Transforma6on  for  Energy  Efficiency  (MTEE)  ü   Financing  Energy  Efficiency      

•     Jawaharlal  Nehru  Na6onal  Solar  Mission  Energy  security,  climate  change,  industrial  development  ü Large-­‐scale  power  genera6on  (3-­‐20  GW),  off-­‐grid  (2GW),  solar  heaters  (20m  sq.  m.),  rural  ligh6ng  (20m  households)  ü   R&D  promo6on  

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 20: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Some ‘clean energy’ initiatives (contd):  

�  Na6onal  Biomass  Cookstove  Ini6a6ve  Energy  access,  health  objec:ves  ü Development  and  dissemina6on  of  clean  cookstoves  (160m  households)  –  explora6on  of  new  technologies  and  deployment  models  ü Tes6ng  facili6es;  standard  development;  monitoring  and  assessment    

   

     

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 21: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

India’s R&D Landscape

Page 22: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

ç  

Source: R&D Statistics 2007-2008

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 23: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Expenditure  on  R&D  by  major  scien6fic  agencies  

Expenditures by Ministries: Rs. 250353 lakhs (2005-06)

-  Coal: Rs. 4757 lakhs -  Heavy Industry: Rs. 26518 lakhs -  P&NG: Rs. 34152 lakhs

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Source: R&D Statistics 2007-2008

Page 24: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Clean energy R&D:    •   Range  of  clean  energy  R&D  ac6vi6es  in  public  and  private  sectors,  e.g.,  

ü Cleaner  and  more  efficient  coal  conversion  ü Energy-­‐efficient  appliances  ü Wind  energy  ü   Solar  energy  (PV)  ü   Electric  vehicles  

•   Some  interna6onal  coopera6on  on  clean  energy  technologies,  e.g.,  under  the  Clean  Energy  Ministerial,  US-­‐India    Clean  Energy  R&D  Center  

•   Ac6vi6es  generally  follow  ini6a6ves  from  different  ministries  and  agencies  –  increasing  coordina6on      

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 25: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Clean R&D opportunities and cooperative approaches – a personal assessment

Page 26: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Key point:

 High  rate  of  growth  of  Indian  economy  =>  much  of  base  yet  to  be  installed  

ü   pay  par6cular  aoen6on  to  greenfield  deployment    

Exis6ng  base/stock  also  has  large  scope  for  improvement    ü   Many  improvements  in  recent  years  (but  in  selected  areas)    

Clean  energy  access  remains  important  issue  ü   Adequacy  ü Affordability    

Significant  opportuni:es  for  clean  energy  technologies…      

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 27: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 … but need strengthened analytical and technical capabilities (esp. systems perspective)  

•   Systema6c  iden6fica6on  of  technology  and  R&D  needs  ü   By  sector  ü   By  actor  (e.g.,  size  of  opera6ons)  

 

Need  special  a@en:on  to  energy-­‐efficient  genera:on  and  end-­‐use  technologies  and  renewables;    

 

•   Priori6za6on  –  opportuni6es  exceed  resources  and  capacity    

Need  to  incorporate  broader  developmental  considera:ons  into  calculus  (energy  access,  employment,  food  security,  etc.)    

•   Beoer  understanding  of  gaps  to  be  overcome  for  successful  deployment/scale-­‐up    

•   Systems  of  collec6on  and  dissemina6on  of  informa6on  re  techs        

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________  

Page 28: Clean&Energy&in&India:& R&D&opportuni6es&and&Needs& · 2019-11-27 · Clean&Energy&R&D&India_____ Trends&in&Supply&of&Primary&Commercial&Energy&(MTOE)& & & Source: Draft 12th 5-year

 

 Cooperative R&D - some key issues:  

•   No  single  model  of  coopera6ve  R&D  –  appropriateness  of  model  would  depend  on  technology  

 

•   Role  of  public  RD&D  (driver  or  facilitator),  esp.  in  rela6on  to  uncertainty  in  early-­‐stage  private  investments  in  cleantech?    Na6onal  or  ‘interna6onal’  programs?    PPP?    

 

•   Rela6onship  to  CTC&N  and  CICs?    

•   Funding  sources  (bilateral  donors,  mul6laterals,  GCF)?  

•   Strengthening  analy6cal  capacity,  esp.  re  technological  opportuni6es  and  op6ons  analysis?  

         

       

Clean  Energy  R&D  India___________________________________________________________