(CIVIL) - eccourts.org · BERS.IDGE ,J. \ Tho a.pplicnnt, 0 'Neill Newsan 1ic Int'Jsh of Indicn...

$: (CIVIL) - eccourts.org · BERS.IDGE ,J. \ Tho a.pplicnnt, 0 'Neill Newsan 1ic Int'Jsh of Indicn Bay, SE'.int Vincent, D. cOL1pany diroctor, seeks . an . order of nandX1UG directod$
I

SIUT VHTCErT -

IN rIIE RIGI COURT OF In~T

(CIVIL)

r SUIT NO 1i30 of 1Q73

In tho Dfttor of rn npplicotion by 0 Noill

NOlSDIJ Hc Intosh for an ardor of ~l1Cl[J1US

and

In the nJttor of 2n applicntion by the scid o noill Nmm--rl ~~c Intooh to the ReCiot-or of

joint stock CO~lponioG for a cortificctQ of

incorporation thrt u Coop~ny by tlc nOrla of

Hoalth Sorvices Linitod WlO duly il~corported

on tho 7th d[y of rmiddot[(y 1973 nncl tht the

said CODpany is liLlited

E bull lC Hughoo for ep)liccmt

N Joseph Log2l _soiotmt for rospom1ent

1973 July 29

------ -----shy

BERSIDGE J

Tho applicnnt 0 Neill Newsan 1ic IntJsh of

Indicn Bay SEint Vincent D cOL1pany diroctor

seeks an order of nandX1UG directod to the Rogistrar

of Joint stock Conpnnies colltlanding her forthwith

to certify utldor her hand thC1t a COlp8ny by bhe

of Honlth Servicos Linitcd ll U[10(

dulybullbullbullbullbullbull

bullbull

-2shy

~ duly incorj))rclcc1 l- the 7th (~y of 1973

pound1lc1 that the said Company is lirrited leave of

bullgt the Court to apply for such an order having been

-

granted to the applicant on the 21st June 1973_

The grounds upon which the relief is sought

are thatshy

(a) Early in May 1973 the IIemorandum and

Articles of Association of a Company to

be called Health Serviccs IJimited

signed by the Appliclnt al1(1 six othermiddot

persons Here delivered to t~lO 11ogisshy

trar of joint stock Conpanies for

registration pursuant to the provisions

of Section 14(t) of tho CO~~~l)anies Act

Chapter 219

(b) On the 7th day of llay 1973 tile fees

required to be paid by tho s1id Act 1lere

paid to the Registrar of joint stock

COIJpanies and a proper anc~ vlid reshy

ceipt was obtained for the S81Je

(c) The said Registrar of joint stock

Companies has since the 7th dy- of bull

~by 1973 without latlful justificashy

tion or excuse refused to issuo a

certificCte of the incorpor2tion of

tho sCid Company as she is req1-ured

to do by Section 15(1) of the Cooshy

pani8s ~ct Chapter 219 LOn

1

On tho 8th rLy 1973 the Reeintrr of joint

stock COIlp2nics (hrcin~fter ~~oforrGc~ to 3 the

Registrrr) addrossee] a letter to t~~- itorJ

for to

rogistcr the (Joupm1Y in the 3bscl1ce 0 licolCO

fron the Governor GS the ncne of tlG i[1plied

25 LI ~- 1 t lY4 bullbull I fron

t

advicoI bull I I t ~Gl-C GfOICL~c11tioncd =cc ___~rClll ~ j

cd

I tho tr1r

COUl1Gol

(0) tllO nUl1u~ lldun of ssocict

t thlt thcrcftor ~ ill

conplL~ncc uith oocton 15 the

iter

rOlorrccL to ~~ thect) 1 t

tllO C ificLtO[~lS conpulsory

(b) the [lp~lic~tion fell uithir the

bull G juscL) l amp3no1i3 itulo

i1 1

(c) bullbull

~ j

I

-4shy

(c) on a clo~r nonning the timiddottlc of tho

COLllX~ny did not the proshy

viaiom3 of the ~ ct

section 14(1) of tho ~ct for tho deliverybull

of tho fc1Crwr

aGsoci~tion

bin and ro ~3 tho GClLlO 11hilo a ion 14(2) proshy 8criboamp tho pcyablo to tho

pqny

It is convoniunt Qt this G to sot out

in oxtens9 IHcvioiOl1S of elect 15 ( 1) and 17 bull

(1) bull

f tho

IJonOrnndlll of nos(lcitL~l of tho

nrt

tu oh811

cu under his h8110 Conpany

ifJ DO

toe copc~ny thc~t Conpnny is

bull

bull 17(1)

11bull

C~ i terodshy

([~) Undur or Gh~ll 0 uoo of p

ilny n~LlO or t 9 including

ilQUOOl1S RoY11 tl or 11CrOll1l

niCht bullbullbull

-5shy

Dight cmLVey the jution

of ROyltJl or otlllT COV JllDont

patrol1c[G or sup- 11llL~sG

the GoV(rll(t Shf11 ~riting

viously givon hie JiCl)lCO in

tb t behalf n

Tho rucoilJ-G i3suod to tho applicntJ Egolicitor

r

bull is 1973 and r0~ds -- i~(llorC2 shy

CllY fror c _ C ] the SUIn

vdCOG Ltd 24060 fl ~c1c1ro[)J 1 20 f1 nono

ng(l Princo

for l~CC(UYlt ~nt Y 1 II

C01illsol for tIl Jospondont COlt middotiJ tho

moro receipt of tho foeo frOl tho co did not

11eon that roistr 1-[i011 of tho lGncr~ of ooooci8shy

end Grticloo of ~sGoci~tioll

contcntiOLl CnUl18 quoted section 9(1) of tho Rcgisshy

bull

trnrs Ordi1anc() Cap 149 L 1111ic11 pr0viclos

811all bo the duly of tho ROGistrr to

th-t it

colloct all foos p ycb10 to th~t ofpoundic01 hoioro tho

-6shy

acts in rOSi)(ct of llhich they 2rc pCy2~)le arc porshy

bull

(301111cl up to had tho

articles of]ooc t

focs th2t rl[~y ~jo11 va beon 1 co 1)1( CjTJCX to this

2pp1ic1tion bull

In tho CQOO hoyovor

nomornc1ur1 of LG()cL~tiun tnd tlC

tion boon duly d tc tho but the

bull

pcni00 on the 7th 3 1973 mu ]~i l1unbor

assiened to tho Con)~ny

Tho question to be dotol~ninJc1 i8 t conshy

stitutos rc~i3tDJ~ion of the L1e~lOr of -tfJsociashy

tiOl1 CLnd n rticl 0 of aoocci~~ticn

It dOOL not ~l1pc~r tlrt thoro ic cny specified

bJok or rUListor iihich those c10CUj1Cll-(fJ cro fornnlly

bull the ReGister of COL1Xll1i(s cOl1otitutos rcLf5tration

bull

-7shy

joction of tho vitol doeUDont-upon 11hieh the Gxisshy

tonco of the lpC-llY do)(ndfJ 011e of iT~licb IHovideo

int~r ~lio for tle vury n~1v of tho C)j middotmybullbull

I find thor()Coro tlllt sLmlt lou11bly lith tho

rmd rrticlcs of Gooeition tionjof tho Coni-n ~TOrd rociotol

bull obliGed toof 1I1y 1973

1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho

orticlao of ilJijocL~tion ITcro not duly cu intorod I

Ifill turn to tIl JGccmd linb of rec

by Counool for tlhpplient

R v EdnlmdoJll [f855il 2 E amp E 77 i8 ~uthority

for oyinC thd TLJt~o thero crc GOllcJ~l F~nclG followshy

1 Hordo nuot bo

bull confined to oubj acto ejusdoD generio 0 t~lOSO

spocified or to put it in ~nothor u~y hon Genorl

vlOrds follo11 0 cLfic rTOrao )revioUJ~lr onilllOrtod

I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -

GPI10 kind uhioh Tront boforo ~~nc1

conotitut- 8)ch cotogory 010] or CCllUU ~ thm only

or gonus

foll uithin tllo on-l uorde

vonbull

porntiOll Lr95~7t 111 E R 205 0 fJ (1)1 uhich Counshy

bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of

public procosdonJ rojoicing or jJh1~ ~i nmiddot3iul1n 9 cmd

in ony 000 tJlO FJtrocta or 1inhlc

to be obDtxmiddotuct(middotcl bullbullbull a ~ bull ~ bullbull 0 ii rl~ Jrdor dotcd0 CI bull

in effeot o1 C[(

trnffic syotOl1 joininc DtrcCCJ uithin tho

district of tho louluthority for ~ll vohicloe for

NCrcll 5 ~ 1957

October 19 1957 fur t~e rC~J)n tJ1c ducil1G corshy

bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc

should bo inter d OjUOd0rl gonorio linited

bull to Cl800 0 -L -c

rojoicinga or ilhlin ltLms it

fined to otrl-ordinlY occ~sionsbull

~1nd did not m~~blo 111

period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull

Ex pgtrto LT91gl Vul 81 KB D 914

for t i[i not roltlly t ill tht

( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t

on tll0 rCioLr 01 COi18idor1tion

tionnry po~vo3 bull

bull HovurtheloL tho follouing rLv-llt principles

tommic 1d DUCC1IYG

nre of int0~eGt shy 2-1 tilia coo-

Ii

-10shy

III think

to juctify -Chi COl) in intorshyof tho

Servicoo Linit r~ [0noc H orclr onnot

be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull

-1 tll Servicos17 ( 1 )

Ioc1 Govornshy

1lOnt 9 proc1ucoc1 in ovidellCJ c

d~ted 16th Fobru 1973 fro~ tho C--binot Sccrotlry

reInting to ~ r~~(lic n-~ttor 20ncl

bull he opined rclt) -Co Jche on-ServiceD Hlieh

- v - y one or

net in

principle )f h uCGn ir~flucncod

8( things

illtd bo n(10 ()lt justify tIlis Cocct in interforshybull

of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under

bull tho COl1pni-c otbull

by

ILgt~lth

in his vie

nont in thG 08e of ~n

tho npub1io 1th ]Jngino Lring Unit bull

bull Tho uj

opinion

convoy the mlG () f~ or

oupport ~Cing dopartn()ntCl1 001]

poclitim

not

to

0d Thore

vli11 bo ltn ordor to

bofore tho 11 -eh july ~ 1973 to cort hor

bull Linited 11 middotrao dLLly Lworported or

bull

rJ _ -- ~~ bullbull 9 bull

--1 2-shy

ti()~l to

be -c~xod in de ult cnt bull II

bull I

i t

I

bullbull

-2shy

~ duly incorj))rclcc1 l- the 7th (~y of 1973

pound1lc1 that the said Company is lirrited leave of

bullgt the Court to apply for such an order having been

-

granted to the applicant on the 21st June 1973_

The grounds upon which the relief is sought

are thatshy

(a) Early in May 1973 the IIemorandum and

Articles of Association of a Company to

be called Health Serviccs IJimited

signed by the Appliclnt al1(1 six othermiddot

persons Here delivered to t~lO 11ogisshy

trar of joint stock Conpanies for

registration pursuant to the provisions

of Section 14(t) of tho CO~~~l)anies Act

Chapter 219

(b) On the 7th day of llay 1973 tile fees

required to be paid by tho s1id Act 1lere

paid to the Registrar of joint stock

COIJpanies and a proper anc~ vlid reshy

ceipt was obtained for the S81Je

(c) The said Registrar of joint stock

Companies has since the 7th dy- of bull

~by 1973 without latlful justificashy

tion or excuse refused to issuo a

certificCte of the incorpor2tion of

tho sCid Company as she is req1-ured

to do by Section 15(1) of the Cooshy

pani8s ~ct Chapter 219 LOn

1




for to




t


cd

I tho tr1r

COUl1Gol




iter





i1 1

(c) bullbull

~ j

I

-4shy



viaiom3 of the ~ ct


of tho fc1Crwr

aGsoci~tion


pqny



(1) bull

f tho


nrt

tu oh811


ifJ DO


bull

bull 17(1)

11bull

C~ i terodshy




niCht bullbullbull

-5shy






tb t behalf n


r




ng(l Princo







bull



th-t it


-6shy


bull


articles of]ooc t


2pp1ic1tion bull

In tho CQOO hoyovor



bull









bull

-7shy







1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho






1 Hordo nuot bo




I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I




for to




t


cd

I tho tr1r

COUl1Gol




iter





i1 1

(c) bullbull

~ j

I

-4shy



viaiom3 of the ~ ct


of tho fc1Crwr

aGsoci~tion


pqny



(1) bull

f tho


nrt

tu oh811


ifJ DO


bull

bull 17(1)

11bull

C~ i terodshy




niCht bullbullbull

-5shy






tb t behalf n


r




ng(l Princo







bull



th-t it


-6shy


bull


articles of]ooc t


2pp1ic1tion bull

In tho CQOO hoyovor



bull









bull

-7shy







1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho






1 Hordo nuot bo




I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

-4shy



viaiom3 of the ~ ct


of tho fc1Crwr

aGsoci~tion


pqny



(1) bull

f tho


nrt

tu oh811


ifJ DO


bull

bull 17(1)

11bull

C~ i terodshy




niCht bullbullbull

-5shy






tb t behalf n


r




ng(l Princo







bull



th-t it


-6shy


bull


articles of]ooc t


2pp1ic1tion bull

In tho CQOO hoyovor



bull









bull

-7shy







1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho






1 Hordo nuot bo




I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

-5shy






tb t behalf n


r




ng(l Princo







bull



th-t it


-6shy


bull


articles of]ooc t


2pp1ic1tion bull

In tho CQOO hoyovor



bull









bull

-7shy







1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho






1 Hordo nuot bo




I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

-6shy


bull


articles of]ooc t


2pp1ic1tion bull

In tho CQOO hoyovor



bull









bull

-7shy







1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho






1 Hordo nuot bo




I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

-7shy







1 ~ v _ J o~id

J 80eshy

tion 15 (1 ) of

urit in tho






1 Hordo nuot bo




I t~ H lJvl the

Imiddotmiddot - ~ -



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I



or gonus


vonbull


bull

01101ting

obstructi~n of




in effeot o1 C[(



NCrcll 5 ~ 1957


bull six 1 1957 to

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

-9shy

thronged liblc






period 10 19 1957 to Oct 19 1957 to

bo L1(10 bull



( eo to

bull

rogiotcr t


tionnry po~vo3 bull


tommic 1d DUCC1IYG


Ii

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

-10shy

III think



be ruoo t

in fj(ctionbull


Ioc1 Govornshy





- v - y one or

net in


8( things


of noyl or

bull

l~ bullbullbullbull

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

1

-11shy

heItth 3

nut 10 L[ d under


by

ILgt~lth

in his vie



bull Tho uj

opinion



poclitim

not

to

0d Thore




bull


--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

--1 2-shy

ti()~l to


bull I

i t

I

(CIVIL) - eccourts.org · BERS.IDGE ,J. \ Tho a.pplicnnt, 0 'Neill Newsan 1ic Int'Jsh of Indicn...

Documents

Transcript of (CIVIL) - eccourts.org · BERS.IDGE ,J. \ Tho a.pplicnnt, 0 'Neill Newsan 1ic Int'Jsh of Indicn...