Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an...

68
©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e Chapter 6: Stability 1 Chapter 6 Stability

Transcript of Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an...

Page 1: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability1

Chapter 6

Stability

Page 2: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability2

Figure 6.1Closed-loop polesand response:a. stable system;b. unstable system

Page 3: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability3

Figure 6.2Common causeof problems in finding closed-loop poles:a. original system;b. equivalent system

Page 4: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability4

Figure 6.3Equivalent closed-looptransfer function

Page 5: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability5

Table 6.1Initial layout forRouth table

Page 6: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability6

Table 6.2CompletedRouth table

Page 7: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability7

Figure 6.4a. Feedback system forExample 6.1;b. equivalentclosed-loop system

Page 8: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability8

Table 6.3Completed Routh table for Example 6.1

Page 9: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability9

Table 6.4CompletedRouth table for Example 6.2

Page 10: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability10

Table 6.5Determining signs in first column of aRouth table with zero as first element in a row

Page 11: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability11

Table 6.6Routh table for Example 6.3

Page 12: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability12

Table 6.7Routh table for Example 6.4

Page 13: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability13

Figure 6.5Root positionsto generate evenpolynomials:A , B, C,or any combination

Page 14: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability14

Table 6.8Routh table for Example 6.5

Page 15: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability15

Table 6.9Summary of pole locations for Example 6.5

Page 16: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability16

Figure 6.6Feedbackcontrol systemfor Example 6.6

Page 17: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability17

Table 6.10Routh table for Example 6.6

Page 18: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability18

Figure 6.7Feedback controlsystem forExample 6.7

Page 19: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability19

Table 6.11Routh table for Example 6.7

Page 20: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability20

Table 6.12AlternativeRouth table for Example 6.7

Page 21: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability21

Figure 6.8Feedbackcontrol systemfor Example 6.8

Page 22: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability22

Table 6.13Routh table for Example 6.8

Page 23: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability23

Table 6.14Summary of pole locations for Example 6.8

Page 24: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability24

Figure 6.9Jason is anunderwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of the Lusitania. Themanipulator andcamera comprisesome of the vehicle’scontrol systems.

Courtesy of Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution.

Page 25: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability25

Figure 6.10Feedback controlsystem for Example 6.9

Page 26: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability26

Figure 6.11The FANUC Robot M- 400 can beconfigured for 4- or 5-axis of motion. It is seen here moving and stacking boxes.

Courtesy of Fanuc Robotics.

Page 27: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability27

Table 6.15Routh table for Example 6.9

Page 28: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability28

Table 6.16Routh table forExample 6.9 with K = 1386

Page 29: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability29

Table 6.17Routh table for Example 6.10

Page 30: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability30

Table 6.18Routh table for Example 6.11

Page 31: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability31

Table 6.19Routh table for antenna controlcase study

Page 32: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability32

Table 6.20Routh table for UFSS case study

Page 33: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability33

Figure P6.1

Page 34: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability34

Figure P6.2

Page 35: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability35

Figure P6.3

Page 36: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability36

Figure P6.4

Page 37: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability37

Figure P6.5

Page 38: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability38

Figure P6.6

Page 39: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability39

Figure P6.7

Page 40: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability40

Figure P6.8

Page 41: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability41

Figure P6.9

Page 42: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability42

Figure P6.10Closed-loop systemwith pole plot

Page 43: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability43

Figure P6.11Aircraft pitch loopmodel

Page 44: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability44

Figure P6.12Block diagram of achemical process-controlsystem

Page 45: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability45

Figure P6.13a. Soft Armused forfeeding;b. simplifiedblockdiagram

Courtesy of Kazuhiko Kawamura, Vanderbilt University.

Page 46: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability46

Figure P6.14Towed vehicle roll control

Page 47: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability47

Figure P6.15Cutting force controlsystem

© 1997 ASME.

Page 48: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability48

Figure P6.16a. A magneticlevitationtransportation system;b. simplified blockdiagram (©1998 IEEE)

© Japan Air Lines/ Photo Researchers.

Page 49: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability49

Table 6.1Initial layout forRouth table

Page 50: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability50

Table 6.2CompletedRouth table

Page 51: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability51

Table 6.3Completed Routh table for Example 6.1

Page 52: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability52

Table 6.4CompletedRouth table for Example 6.2

Page 53: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability53

Table 6.5Determining signs in first column of aRouth table with zero as first element in a row

Page 54: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability54

Table 6.6Routh table for Example 6.3

Page 55: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability55

Table 6.7Routh table for Example 6.4

Page 56: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability56

Table 6.8Routh table for Example 6.5

Page 57: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability57

Table 6.9Summary of pole locations for Example 6.5

Page 58: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability58

Table 6.10Routh table for Example 6.6

Page 59: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability59

Table 6.11Routh table for Example 6.7

Page 60: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability60

Table 6.12AlternativeRouth table for Example 6.7

Page 61: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability61

Table 6.13Routh table for Example 6.8

Page 62: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability62

Table 6.14Summary of pole locations for Example 6.8

Page 63: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability63

Table 6.15Routh table for Example 6.9

Page 64: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability64

Table 6.16Routh table forExample 6.9 with K = 1386

Page 65: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability65

Table 6.17Routh table for Example 6.10

Page 66: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability66

Table 6.18Routh table for Example 6.11

Page 67: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability67

Table 6.19Routh table for antenna controlcase study

Page 68: Chapter 6 · Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e 24 Chapter 6: Stability Figure 6.9 Jasonis an underwater, remote-controlled vehicle that has been used to explore the wreckage of

©2000, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Nise/Control Systems Engineering, 3/e

Chapter 6: Stability68

Table 6.20Routh table for UFSS case study