Building Radiotherapy Capacity for ‘Treatment of Cervical ...€¦ · FIGO Stage I-III : LDR Vs...
Transcript of Building Radiotherapy Capacity for ‘Treatment of Cervical ...€¦ · FIGO Stage I-III : LDR Vs...
Umesh Mahantshetty,
Professor, Radiation Oncology & GYN DMG Member On behalf of Department of Radiation Oncology & Medical Physics
Tata Memorial Hospital
Mumbai, India
Building Radiotherapy Capacity
for
‘Treatment of Cervical Cancer in India’
NONE!
DISCLOSURES
0 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 140000 160000
Lip, oral cavity
Ovary
Colorectum
Cervix uteri
Breast
23161
26834
27415
122,844
144937
15631
19549
20789
67, 477
70218
Mortality Incidence
FIVE MOST COMMON CANCERS IN INDIAN WOMEN
ESTIMATED No. OF NEW CASES & DEATHS : YEAR 2012 *
* estimates based on GLOBOCAN 2012
AGE STANDARDISED (WORLD POPULATION) WOMEN CANCER
INCIDENCE RATES PER 100,000 POPULATION IN FEMALES
20.1 21.2 19.3
24.6 28.2 27.5
31.3 30.3 33.7
23.2 23.3
16.6
19.3 20.2 15.7 17.4
12.9 10.5
4.8 7.2 7.2 6.5 7.2 7.6 8.3 6.9
7.3
1.3 1.4 1.6 2.3 2.5 2.4 3.2 3.6 5.3 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
Breast Cervix Uteri Ovary Corpus Uteri Year
SOURCE : BOMBAY CANCER REGISTRY, REPORTS 1970- 2010
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2014 2016 Co 60 80 87 130 185 245 256 247 238 224 LA 2 6 13 23 34 68 157 308 347 Brachy 8 11 31 49 66 73 163 232 251
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Num
ber o
f uni
ts
Unit ↓Year→
COBALT
LA
BT
Radiation therapy facilities in India: Update from Atomic energy Regulatory Board March 2016
INDIAN POPULATION : 1.2 billion
International norm: 2 machines/million population
India : 0.33/million
Kannan V et al; IJROBP 94 (4) 2016
MAJOR DISPARITY - Academic Vs Corporate - Urban Vs Rural - Health care Accessibility - Manpower & Expertise
Datta et al. Telemedicine and e-Health 21 (7) July 2015
LMIC’s:
NATIONAL CANCER REGISTRY PROGRAM (NCRP)
INDIAN COUNCIL FOR MEDICAL RESEARCH 2012-2014 REPORTS
POPULATION BASED REGISTERIES HOSPITAL BASED REGISTERIES
8
TATA MEMORIAL CENTRE, MUMBAI, INDIA TERTIARY CANCER CENTRE EXPERIENCE
ADVANCED CENTRE FOR TREATMENT RESEARCH AND EDUCATION IN CANCER
TMC: Radiotherapy Paraphernalia
• TATA MEMORIAL HOPSITAL – Accelerators
1. UNIQUE 2. TRUEBEAM 3. Clinac 6Ex (Varian), 120 MLC 4. Trilogy (Varian) 5. Novalis TX (Varian) 6. Tomotherapy
– Telecobalt 1. Theratron 780 (MDS) 2. Theratron 780C (MDS) 3. Elite 80 (MDS) 4. Equinox 80 (MDS)
– Simulators 1. Ximatron (Varian) 2. Somatom CT-Sim (Siemens) 3. Fly-through (GE) 4. C-Arm 5. USG
– Brachytherapy 1. MicroSelectron-HDR V30 2. MicroSelectron-HDR V18
• ACTREC – Accelerators
1. TRUEBEAM 2. Tomotherapy
– Telecobalt 1. Bhabhatron II
– Simulator 1. Oldelf (Nucletron)
– Brachytherapy – IBU 1. MicroSelectron-HDR V30
TRENDS OF CERVICAL CANCER
TATA MEMORIAL HOSPITAL : 1941-2015*
2050
4679
9055
13642
16635 15083
12801
8780
0 2000 4000 6000 8000
10000 12000 14000 16000 18000
No.
of C
ervi
x Ca
ncer
Cas
es
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
70.0
Stage I Stage II Stage III Stage IV
10.0
28.2
54.1
7.7 9.1
17.1
63.3
10.6 11.8
19.7
68.5
6.1
28.0
65.3
9.5
35.2
51.7
3.6
9.1
28.8
44.5
5.2
13.8
29.6
46.3
10.2 10.8
27.7
51.3
8.0 10.4
35.0
47.1
7.4
17.0
39.2 34.2
9.6
1985 1989 1993 1997 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2012
Tata Memorial Hospital Cancer Registry (1985-2012)
Significant Down Staging!
120.00 108.00 96.00 84.00 72.00 60.00 48.00 36.00 24.00 12.00 0.00
dfsmonths
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Cum
Sur
viva
l
1988-1994 : 55% at 8 yrs
1984-1987: 45% at 8 yrs
1979-1983 : 35% at 8 yrs
P = 0.000
J Cancer Res Ther. 2013 Oct-Dec;9(4):672-9)
CERVICAL CANCER – RETROSEPCTIVE ANALYSES FIGO Stage IB-IIIB (N = 6234 pts)
OVERALL OUTCOME WITH RADIATION IMPROVED OVER TIME DUE TO
REFINEMENT IN RADIATION DOSES ESP. BRACHYTHERAPY
EVIDENCE BASED CLINICAL GUIDELINES
PROSPECTIVE TRIALS & INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATION
GYNAE JOINT CLINIC : 1978-1979
OUTCOME ANALYSIS
IMPROVED COMPLIANCE AND FOLLOW–UP
UPGRADATION OF RADIATION FACILITIES
CERVICAL CANCER
LESSONS LEARNT : 1995-2000
ACTION PLAN
Tata Memorial Hospital Evidence Based Guidelines
EBM MEETINGS : February
SERVICE
RESEARCH
EDUCATION
ADOTPED BY MAJORITY OF CENTERS IN INDIA
• FIGO Stage I-III : LDR Vs HDR Brachytherapy: 1996 : closed
• FIGO Stage Ib / IIb : Neo-adjuvant CT + Sx Vs CT + RT : 2003
• FIGO Stage IIIb : Chemo-radiation Vs Radiation Alone : 2003
• FIGO Stage IIb : 3D Conformal Vs Intensity Modulated RT:2004
• Locally Adv. Disease : Evaluation of PET / CT-PET : 2004 : closed
• IAEA Studies : 2# Vs 4# ICA - HDR by CT Vs No CT:600 pts closed
: HIV Positive Pts : CRT Vs RT : 53 /325 pts closed
• Curcumin Study (II/III) : Double blind placebo controlled Ph III study
• EMBRACE study : MR Based Brachytherapy in Cervical Cancers
• Vault Cancers : TOMO Based IMRT / IGRT
• INTERTECC (NCI funded): Pelvic IMRT with BM Sparing Chemo-radiation
Prospective Clinical Trials / Studies in Cervical Cancers
INVESTIGATOR INITIATED & INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATIVE
BRACHYTHERAPY IN CERVICAL CANCERS In corporation of Newer Imaging Modalities
• 2D Planning : Orthogonal X-ray Based (STD)
• 3D Planning : TMH Experience
- MRI: TMH-Initial Experience; Int. J. Gynae Cancer: 2011
- US: TMH Experience; Radio. Oncol 2012
- CT Scan: Interstitial Brachytherapy : Brachytherapy 2013
• Routine GYN Practice:
- Average 7 (3- 9) Cx ICA/ daily + 1-2 Interstitial /wk cases
- 3-4 X-ray; 2-3 CT; 1 MR Based Planning
MRI BASED PLANNING CONVENTIONAL PLANNING
CT- BASED MUPIT PLANNING
ADVANCES IN GYN BRACHYTHERAPY PLANNING
Retrospective and feasibility study : Dec 2006 - May 2008
(N = 24)
Tata Memorial Hospital Participation in International Multicentric Studies
- Refine treatment standards
- International Recognition (GYN GEC-ESTRO Reasearch Network)
A phase II Multicentric International Study by GEC - ESTRO Network
TOTAL ACCRUAL : 1400 PATIENTS
TMH CONTRIBUTION : 100 PATIENTS IN 3 YEARS
Stage IIIB
P=0.013
Stage IIB and IVA
Stage IIIB
Stage IIB Stage IVA
P=0.241
IIB IIIB IVA
31 55 08
28 45 07
24 39 06
15 27 04
12 10 02
07 05 00
01 01 00
IIB IIIB IVA
31 55 08
29 51 08
26 43 07
16 28 04
12 10 02
07 05 00
01 01 00
MR IMAGE BASED BRACHYTHERAPY EMBRACE STUDY : 1400 PATIENTS
TMH ACCRUAL: 100 PATIENTS
EXCELLANT LOCAL CONTROL RATES FOR ALL STAGES
COST BENEFIT ANALYSES : ONGOING
0 0.5
1 1.5
2 2.5
3 3.5
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Series1
Series2
0 0.5
1 1.5
2 2.5
3 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Series1
Series2
MR
CT
MR
CT
Image Based Brachytherapy in cervical Cancer CT and MRI correlation: Ongoing Research
TMH Study
Image Based Brachytherapy in cervical Cancer TAUS and MRI correlation (TMH data)
In collaboration with Peter Mac Melbourne
• Trans –abdominal Ultrasonography : Cost effective imaging modality • 32 Applications with MRI Compatible Applicator • Anterior Reference Points : 96 % • Posterior Reference Points : 72 % • Magnitude of Variation (>15%) : < 8%
Significant Correlation between the USG and MRI
Reference Points
Suggest : Use of USG for ICA Planning (21/2 D Planning)
Mahantshetty et al. Rad. Onc. Aug. 2011
Bhabhatron II
INDIGENOUS COBALT MACHINE
Simulator-Imagin HDR Brachytherapy
Siddhartha
INDIGENOUS LINEAR ACCELERATOR
TATA MEMORIAL CENTRE IN COLLABORATION WITH BARC INDIGENOUS TECHNOLOGY – COST EFFECTIVE SOLUTIONS
• INFRASTRUCTURE
- To minimize the DISPARITY between Rural & Urban set-ups
- Support Cost- effective Radiation Facilities in rural India
• COMMUNITY PROGRAMS
- HEALTH INSURANCE SCHEMES : Rural & Urban
- Enhance National Cancer Control Program Activitites
Pramesh CS et al. Lancet Oncol 2014.
• Bilateral Exchange programs
• WORKSHOPS & TRAINING PROGRAMS : ONGOING
- AROI-ESTRO TEACHING COURSES
- HANDS ON WORKSHOPS / ANNUAL PRACTICUM
• MULTI-DISCIPLINARY MEETINGS AT VARIOUS FORUMS
- ASSOC. OF Rad. Oncol of India (AROI) : CME’s / Conferences
- ASSOC. of GYN ONCOl of India (AGOICON)
- Women’s Cancer Initiative – Tata Memorial Centre India
TRAINING AND EXCHANGE PROGRAMS
IAEA , UICC, GCIG, ESTRO, ASTRO, AROI, IBS ETC….
• NCG OF INDIA : 2012 (funded by Department of Atomic Energy, Govt of India)
• Mandate: Linking of cancer centers across India
• Presently consists of 62 cancer care centres across entire length and breadth of the
country and has 4 components
- Patient Care – Uniform and evidence based cancer care across centers
- Education and Training - exchange of expertise and mentoring between the
centers, National cancer library
- Collaborative Research – Research network to conduct cooperative research
catering Country specific needs.
- Cancer Policy – Development of National cancer plan to identify and tackle
specific problems of the country
Pramesh CS et al. Indian J Med Paediatr Oncol 2014;35:226-7.
Datta et al. Telemedicine and e-Health 21 &7) July 2015
TELE-RADIOTHERAPY NETWORK
Thank you [email protected]