Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g....

78
@suitpossum [email protected]

Transcript of Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g....

Page 1: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

@suitpossum

[email protected]

Page 2: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 3: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

What is the ‘future of money’?

Page 4: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Flavours of Futurism

Descriptive accounts of what future is likely to be

(‘Scientific’ or ‘Academic’)

Page 5: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Flavours of Futurism

Descriptive accounts of what future is likely to be

(‘Scientific’ or ‘Academic’)

Normative accounts of how the future should be

(Political, Ideological)

Page 6: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Flavours of Futurism

Descriptive accounts of what future is likely to be

(‘Scientific’ or ‘Academic’)

Normative accounts of how the future should be

(Political, Ideological)

Normative political accounts disguised as descriptive

scientific accounts

(e.g. ‘Blockchain will wipe out the banking industry’)

Page 7: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Linear (or exponential) Futurism

Dystopian past – Pinnacle of present – Utopian future

Utopian past – Precipice of present – Dystopian future

Page 8: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Holistic Futurism

Increasing the wideness of frame

Appreciation of trade-offs

Speed will increase vs. confusion will increase

Convenience will increase vs. resilience will decrease

Automation increases vs. scaled bureaucracies increase

Page 9: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Production of value

Page 10: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Humans use labour (physical, mental, emotional), ecological resources, technology & communication-management to produce value

Page 11: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

On-the-spot exchange of a specific good or service (value) for an abstract credit/claim/token

granting access to a pool of existing or potential future goods or services produced by others

Monetary exchange

Page 12: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Capitalist production<private property systems>

<money systems><markets: land, resources, tech, labour>

<+finance>

Page 13: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Money is not a store of value. It is a transferable

claim upon value

Page 14: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Bearer instrument – physical representation of

monetary claims

‘Getting rich’ means accumulating the notes

Literally moves around (Needs physical

transportation)

Ledger system – written representation of monetary claims

‘Getting rich’ means accumulating a high score on an account

Ledger just needs secure communication system and trusted

intermediaries

Two implementations of a money system:

Bearer instrument vs. ledger system

Page 15: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Elements of a ledger money system

1) Database: Thing being recorded into

Page 16: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Elements of a ledger money system

1) Database: Thing being recorded into2) Accounts: Spaces on the database allotted to particular people

Page 17: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Elements of a ledger money system

1) Database: Thing being recorded into2) Accounts: Spaces on the database allotted to particular people

3) Recording technology: The thing used to do the recording

Page 18: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Elements of a ledger money system

1) Database: Thing being recorded into2) Accounts: Spaces on the database allotted to particular people

3) Recording technology: The thing used to do the recording4) Recording agent: The agent who uses the recording tech to

write entries associated with the accounts

Page 19: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Elements of a ledger money system

1) Database: Thing being recorded into2) Accounts: Spaces on the database allotted to particular people

3) Recording technology: The thing used to do the recording4) Recording agent: The agent who uses the recording tech to

write entries associated with the accounts5) A communications system, to talk to the agent

Page 20: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Digital ledger money: The ‘ledger book’

Page 21: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

010001000110100101100111011010010111010001101001

011100110110000101110100011010010110111101101110

Digital ledger money: The recording technology

Page 22: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Digital ledger money: The recording agent

Page 23: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Digital ledger money: The communications system

Page 24: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 25: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Account

holder

Reserves

1750

1250

Total 3000

Acc IOU

BAR123 (250)

BAR456 (1500)

BAR789 (10000)

Total (11750)

Acc IOU

HSB123 (1000)

HSB456 (250)

HSB789 (7000)

Total (8250)

Loan

asset

UO-ME

BAR789 11000

Total 11000

Loan

asset

UO-ME

HSB789 7700

Total 7700

Page 26: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 27: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 28: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

The Future… according to Fintech

Page 29: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Fintech 1: Automate the user-experience layer

Page 30: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Fintech 1: Automate the user-experience layer

Page 31: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Fintech 1: Automate the user-experience layer

… or add new layers on top

Page 32: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 33: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 34: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 35: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

BRANCH >>> HYBRID BRANCH

Page 36: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

TO NO BRANCH AT ALL?

Page 37: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

The drive to replace service with self-service

Page 38: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 39: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 40: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Fintech 2: Automate financial professionals

Page 41: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 42: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Fintech as outsourced bank R&D

Page 43: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Fintech 3: Fuse it all with IoT (non-human agents)

Page 44: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

A quick detour…

Page 45: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Capitalist production<private property systems>

<money systems><markets: land, resources, tech, labour>

<+finance>

Page 46: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 47: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 48: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 49: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Robot components‘Senses’: Sensors

‘Body’: Mechanical assemblage‘Mind’: Digital algorithm

Page 50: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

What do we mean by ‘digital’

“Digital describes electronic technology that generates,

stores, and processes data in terms of two states: positive

and non-positive. Positive is expressed or represented by

the number 1 and non-positive by the number 0”

(source: http://whatis.techtarget.com/definition/digital)

Page 51: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 52: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Components of digital systems: Phase 1

Page 53: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Components of digital systems: Phase 2

Page 54: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Components of digital systems: Phase 3

Page 55: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Components of digital systems: Phase 4

Page 56: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

AlgoRobotic SystemsInputs:

Sensor Networks

(‘Senses’)

‘Mind’

Datacentres / Algorithms

Outputs:

Output devices

Actuators

(‘Body’)

Page 57: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

The INTERNET OF FULLY

AUTOMATED CAPITALISM

Automation of labour

+

Automation of management

+

Automation of exchange

Page 58: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Why companies invest in digital tech

Expand markets

Automate co-ordination, control, management

(reduce production costs / boost scale & productivity)

Attract customers with new products…(ideally by

convincing them to replace service with self-service)

Monitor customers, build data on them, influence them

Sever the management function from workers

Page 59: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Beyond centralised automationBlockchain technology

Page 60: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 61: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 62: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 63: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 64: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 65: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 66: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Private blockchains: Reducing the vision to efficiency &

cost-saving (profit optimisation)

Page 67: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 68: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

A side note on hacker culture & the drive to re-decentralise

or re-humanise digital infrastructures

Page 69: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

What does decentralisation actually mean?

Page 70: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Some alternative visions for changing the

monetary system

Page 71: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Some alternative visions for changing the

monetary system

Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers (E.g.

cryptocurrency)

Page 72: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Some alternative visions for changing the

monetary system

Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers (E.g.

cryptocurrency)

Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit)

Page 73: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Some alternative visions for changing the

monetary system

Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers (E.g.

cryptocurrency)

Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit)

Change what it is redeemable for (E.g. Local currencies)

Page 74: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Some alternative visions for changing the

monetary system

Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers (E.g.

cryptocurrency)

Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit)

Change what it is redeemable for (E.g. Local currencies)

Find ways to bypass it entirely (e.g. Gift economy)

Page 75: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

Some alternative visions for changing the

monetary system

Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers (E.g.

cryptocurrency)

Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit)

Change what it is redeemable for (E.g. Local currencies)

Find ways to bypass it entirely (e.g. Gift economy)

Alter the financial institutions that dominate the money

system (e.g. Monetary reform & alternative banking)

Page 76: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable

DECENTRALISED LEDGER COMMUNITY MONEY ISSUANCE REDEEMABILITY RESTRICTIONS

?

Hybridising

Page 77: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable
Page 78: Brett Social Banking June 2017 · Change the power dynamics of who controls the ledgers(E.g. cryptocurrency) Change who gets to issue it (e.g. Mutual credit) Change what it is redeemable