Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064

153

description

Eric Black, Published at www.minnpost.com Unallotment Briefs 62cv09-11693 (Gearin) Appeal A100064 pdf format, three briefs Eric wrote about yesterday were all friend of the court briefs on the anti-unallotment side. The last brief to reach the court before closing time yesterday was the one by the actual plaintiff in the case (aka the respondent in the appeal), which is by attorney Galen Robinson of Mid-Minnesota Legal Assistance on behalf of six low-income Minnesotans who receive state subsidies so they can afford special diets that their doctors say is necessary for their health. In the 2009 unallotments, Gov. Pawlenty scheduled that diet aid program for elimination. The plaintiffs succeeded at the district court in getting Judge Kathleen Gearin to issue a temporary restraining order (TRO) to keep the program going. The Supreme Court case that has generated all these briefs is an appeal by Pawlenty of that TRO. Thanks to Eric Black for Public Preview,Amicus.

Transcript of Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064

Page 1: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 2: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 3: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 4: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 5: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 6: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 7: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 8: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 9: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 10: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 11: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 12: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 13: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 14: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 15: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 16: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 17: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 18: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 19: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 20: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 21: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 22: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 23: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 24: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 25: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 26: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 27: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 28: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 29: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 30: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 31: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 32: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 33: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 34: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 35: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 36: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 37: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 38: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 39: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 40: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 41: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 42: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 43: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 44: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 45: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 46: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 47: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 48: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 49: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 50: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 51: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 52: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 53: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 54: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 55: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 56: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 57: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 58: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 59: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 60: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 61: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 62: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 63: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 64: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 65: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 66: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 67: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 68: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 69: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 70: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 71: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 72: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064

2009 Minnesota Statutes

16A.152 BUDGET RESERVE AND CASH FLOW ACCOUNTS.

Subdivision 1. Cash flow account established. A cash flow account is created in the general

fund in the state treasury. Amounts in the cash flow account shall remain in the account until drawn

down and used to meet cash flow deficiencies resulting from uneven distribution of revenue

collections and required expenditures during a fiscal year.

Subd. 1a. Budget reserve. A budget reserve account is created in the general fund in the state

treasury. The commissioner of management and budget shall transfer to the budget reserve account

on July 1 of each odd-numbered year any amounts specifically appropriated by law to the budget

reserve.

Subd. 1b. Budget reserve increase. On July 1, 2003, the commissioner of management and

budget shall transfer $300,000,000 to the budget reserve account in the general fund. On July 1,

2004, the commissioner of management and budget shall transfer $296,000,000 to the budget reserve

account in the general fund. The amounts necessary for this purpose are appropriated from the

general fund.

Subd. 2. Additional revenues; priority. (a) If on the basis of a forecast of general fund

revenues and expenditures, the commissioner of management and budget determines that there will

be a positive unrestricted budgetary general fund balance at the close of the biennium, the

commissioner of management and budget must allocate money to the following accounts and

purposes in priority order:

(1) the cash flow account established in subdivision 1 until that account reaches $350,000,000;

(2) the budget reserve account established in subdivision 1a until that account reaches

$653,000,000;

(3) the amount necessary to increase the aid payment schedule for school district aids and

credits payments in section 127A.45 to not more than 90 percent rounded to the nearest tenth of a

percent without exceeding the amount available and with any remaining funds deposited in the

budget reserve;

(4) the amount necessary to restore all or a portion of the net aid reductions under section

127A.441 and to reduce the property tax revenue recognition shift under section 123B.75,

subdivision 5, paragraph (b), and Laws 2003, First Special Session chapter 9, article 5, section 34, as

amended by Laws 2003, First Special Session chapter 23, section 20, by the same amount; and

(5) to the state airports fund, the amount necessary to restore the amount transferred from the

state airports fund under Laws 2008, chapter 363, article 11, section 3, subdivision 5.

(b) The amounts necessary to meet the requirements of this section are appropriated from the

general fund within two weeks after the forecast is released or, in the case of transfers under

paragraph (a), clauses (3) and (4), as necessary to meet the appropriations schedules otherwise

established in statute.

(c) The commissioner of management and budget shall certify the total dollar amount of the

reductions under paragraph (a), clauses (3) and (4), to the commissioner of education. The

Page 1 of 416A.152, 2009 Minnesota Statutes

2/24/2010https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=16A.152

Page 73: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064

commissioner of education shall increase the aid payment percentage and reduce the property

tax shift percentage by these amounts and apply those reductions to the current fiscal year and

thereafter.

Subd. 3. Use. The use of the budget reserve should be governed by principles based on the full

economic cycle rather than the budget cycle. The budget reserve may be used when a negative

budgetary balance is projected and when objective measures, such as reduced growth in total wages,

retail sales, or employment, reflect downturns in the state's economy.

Subd. 4. Reduction. (a) If the commissioner determines that probable receipts for the general

fund will be less than anticipated, and that the amount available for the remainder of the biennium

will be less than needed, the commissioner shall, with the approval of the governor, and after

consulting the Legislative Advisory Commission, reduce the amount in the budget reserve account as

needed to balance expenditures with revenue.

(b) An additional deficit shall, with the approval of the governor, and after consulting the

legislative advisory commission, be made up by reducing unexpended allotments of any prior

appropriation or transfer. Notwithstanding any other law to the contrary, the commissioner is

empowered to defer or suspend prior statutorily created obligations which would prevent effecting

such reductions.

(c) If the commissioner determines that probable receipts for any other fund, appropriation, or

item will be less than anticipated, and that the amount available for the remainder of the term of the

appropriation or for any allotment period will be less than needed, the commissioner shall notify the

agency concerned and then reduce the amount allotted or to be allotted so as to prevent a deficit.

(d) In reducing allotments, the commissioner may consider other sources of revenue available to

recipients of state appropriations and may apply allotment reductions based on all sources of revenue

available.

(e) In like manner, the commissioner shall reduce allotments to an agency by the amount of any

saving that can be made over previous spending plans through a reduction in prices or other cause.

Subd. 5. Restoration. The restoration of the budget reserve should be governed by principles

based on the full economic cycle rather than the budget cycle. Restoration of the budget reserve

should occur when objective measures, such as increased growth in total wages, retail sales, or

employment, reflect upturns in the state's economy. The budget reserve should be restored before

new or increased spending commitments are made.

Subd. 6. Notice to committees. The commissioner shall notify the committees on finance and

taxes and tax laws of the senate and the committees on ways and means and taxes of the house of

representatives of a reduction in an allotment under this section. The notice must be in writing and

delivered within 15 days of the commissioner's act. The notice must specify:

(1) the amount of the reduction in the allotment;

(2) the agency and programs affected;

(3) the amount of any payment withheld; and

(4) any additional information the commissioner determines is appropriate.

Page 2 of 416A.152, 2009 Minnesota Statutes

2/24/2010https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=16A.152

Page 74: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064

Subd. 7. Delay; reduction. The commissioner may delay paying up to 15 percent of an

appropriation to a special taxing district or a system of higher education in that entity's fiscal year

for up to 60 days after the start of its next fiscal year. The delayed amount is subject to allotment

reduction under subdivision 4.

Subd. 8. Report on budget reserve percentage. (a) The commissioner of management and

budget must periodically review the formula developed as part of the Budget Trends Study

Commission authorized by Laws 2007, chapter 148, article 2, section 81, to estimate the percentage

of the preceding biennium's general fund expenditures and transfers recommended as a budget

reserve.

(b) The commissioner must annually review the variables and coefficients in the formula used

to model the base of the general fund taxes and the mix of taxes that provide revenues to the general

fund. If the commissioner determines that the variables and coefficients have changed enough to

result in a change in the percentage of the preceding biennium's general fund expenditures and

transfers recommended as a budget reserve, the commissioner must update the variables and

coefficients in the formula to reflect the current base and mix of general fund taxes.

(c) Every ten years, the commissioner must review the methodology underlying the formula,

taking into consideration relevant economic literature from the past ten years, and determine if the

formula remains adequate as a tool for estimating the percentage of the preceding biennium's general

fund expenditures and transfers recommended as a budget reserve. If the commissioner determines

that the methodology underlying the formula is outdated, the commissioner must revise the formula.

(d) By January 15 of each year, the commissioner must report to the chairs and ranking minority

members of the house of representatives Committee on Ways and Means and the senate Committee

on Finance, in compliance with sections 3.195 and 3.197, on the percentage of the preceding

biennium's general fund expenditures and transfers recommended as a budget reserve. The report

must specify:

(1) if the commissioner updated the variables and coefficients in the formula to reflect

significant changes to either the base of one or more general fund taxes or to the mix of taxes that

provide revenues to the general fund as provided in paragraph (b);

(2) if the commissioner revised the formula after determining the methodology was outdated as

provided in paragraph (c); and

(3) if the percentage of the preceding biennium's general fund expenditures and transfers

recommended as a budget reserve has changed as a result of an update of or a revision to the

formula.

History: 1973 c 492 s 23; 1978 c 793 s 47; 1981 c 1 s 2; 1Sp1981 c 5 s 1; 2Sp1981 c 1 s 3;

3Sp1981 c 1 art 1 s 1; 3Sp1981 c 2 art 2 s 3; 1983 c 342 art 18 s 1-3; 1984 c 502 art 1 s 1; 1984 c

628 art 2 s 1; 1Sp1985 c 14 art 18 s 1,2,4; 1Sp1986 c 1 art 5 s 1-3; 1987 c 268 art 18 s 1-3; 1988 c

690 art 2 s 1; 1988 c 719 art 13 s 1,2; 1989 c 329 art 1 s 1; 1Sp1989 c 1 art 15 s 1,2; 1990 c 604 art

10 s 4; 1991 c 291 art 21 s 2; 1992 c 511 art 9 s 1; 1993 c 192 s 58-63,111; 1993 c 375 art 17 s 1,2;

1994 c 632 art 5 s 1; 1994 c 647 art 1 s 1; 1995 c 264 art 6 s 1; 1Sp1995 c 3 art 14 s 1-3; 1996 c 461

s 1; 1996 c 471 art 10 s 1; 1997 c 231 art 9 s 1; 1998 c 389 art 9 s 1; 1Sp2001 c 5 art 20 s 2,3;

1Sp2001 c 10 art 2 s 24; 2002 c 220 art 13 s 3-5; 2002 c 377 art 12 s 1; 1Sp2003 c 21 art 11 s 2-4;

Page 3 of 416A.152, 2009 Minnesota Statutes

2/24/2010https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=16A.152

Page 75: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064

2004 c 272 art 3 s 1; 2005 c 156 art 2 s 16; 2007 c 146 art 1 s 1; 2009 c 36 art 3 s 1; 2009 c 86

art 1 s 4; 2009 c 101 art 2 s 49,109

Page 4 of 416A.152, 2009 Minnesota Statutes

2/24/2010https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=16A.152

Page 76: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 77: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 78: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 79: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 80: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 81: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 82: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 83: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 84: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 85: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 86: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 87: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 88: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 89: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 90: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 91: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 92: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 93: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 94: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 95: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 96: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 97: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 98: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 99: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 100: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 101: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 102: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 103: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 104: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 105: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 106: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 107: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 108: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 109: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 110: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 111: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 112: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 113: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 114: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 115: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 116: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 117: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 118: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 119: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 120: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 121: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 122: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 123: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 124: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 125: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 126: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 127: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 128: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 129: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 130: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 131: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 132: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 133: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 134: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 135: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 136: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 137: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 138: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 139: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 140: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 141: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 142: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 143: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 144: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 145: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 146: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 147: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 148: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 149: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 150: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 151: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 152: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064
Page 153: Brayton Brief Unallotment A100064