Board of Commissioners...
Transcript of Board of Commissioners...
This month we will recognize Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack, who is retiring from our board after 11 years of exemplary service.
Board of Commissioners Meeting
Location:
Multnomah County Building
501 SE Hawthorne Blvd
Portland, Oregon 97214
Date & Time:
December16, 2014 6:15 PM
PUBLIC NOTICE:
Home Forward BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
will meet on Tuesday, December 16, 2014
At 6:15 pm At the Multnomah County Building 501 SE Hawthorne Blvd., Portland In the Commissioners Board Room
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
1
MEMORANDUM
To: Community Partners
From: Michael Buonocore, Executive Director
Date: December 10, 2014
Subject: Home Forward Board of Commissioners December Meeting
The Board of Commissioners of Home Forward will meet on Tuesday, December 16, 2014 at the Multnomah County Building, 501 SE Hawthorne Blvd., in the Commissioners Board Room, Portland at 6:15 P.M. The commission meeting is open to the public. The meeting site is accessible, and persons with disabilities may call 503-802-8423 or 503-802-8554 (TTY) for accommodations (e.g. assisted listening devices, sign language, and/or oral interpreter) by 12:00 pm (noon), Friday, December 12, 2014.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
2
AGENDA
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
3
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS MEETING
MULTNOMAH COUNTY BUILDING COMMISSIONERS BOARD ROOM
501 SE HAWTHORNE BLVD. PORTLAND, OREGON
December 16, 2014 6:15 PM
INTRODUCTION AND WELCOME PUBLIC COMMENT General comments not pertaining to specific resolutions. Any public comment regarding a specific resolution will be heard when the resolution is considered. MISSION MOMENT
Topic Presenter
Golf Program Felicia Poe
CONSENT CALENDAR
Following Resolutions:
14-12 Topic Presenter/POC Phone #
01 Authorize Contract for Moving Services During the Renovations of Group 1 & 2 of 85 Stories
Mike Andrews Myriam Demezas
503.802.8507 503.802.8501
02 Authorize Contract for Agency-Wide Legal Services
Rebecca Gabriel
503.802.8502
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
4
03 Authorize the Executive Director to Execute Documents to Acquire the Limited Partner’s Interest in St. Francis Limited Partnership, Transfer the Property Ownership to Home Forward
Molly Rogers 503.802.8437
04 Authorize Execution of Documents to Refinance the Existing Loan for St. Francis Apartments
Molly Rogers 503.802.8437
MEETING MINUTES
Topic
Minutes of November 18, 2014 Board of Commissioners Meeting
REPORTS / RESOLUTIONS
Following Reports and Resolutions:
14-12 Topic Presenter/POC Phone #
05 Authorize Recognition for Harriet Cormack
David Widmark
06 Authorize Recognition for John Keating
Michael Buonocore 503.802.8423
REPORT Kindergarten Registration Update Melissa Sonsalla Rachel Langford
503.802.8492503.943.5671
07 Authorize Change Order #3 for the Purchase of Construction Materials at Gallagher Plaza & Northwest Towers
Mike Andrews April Berg
503.802.8502503.802.8326
08 Authorize Change Order #3 for the Purchase of Construction Materials at Hollywood East & Sellwood Center
Mike Andrews Leslie Crehan
503.802.8507503.802.8463
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
5
REPORT Insights and Parting Thoughts Steve Rudman
ADJOURN
EXECUTIVE SESSION The Board of Commissioners of Home Forward may meet in Executive Session pursuant to ORS 192.660(2). Only representatives of the news media and designated staff are allowed to attend. News media and all other attendees are specifically directed not to disclose information that is the subject of the session. No final decision will be made in the session. THE NEXT MEETING OF THE BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS The next Board of Commissioners meeting will be Tuesday, January 20, 2015 at 6:15 PM. This meeting will take place at the Multnomah County Building, 501 SE Hawthorne Blvd, in the Commissioners Board Room.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
6
CONSENT CALENDAR
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
7
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Mike Andrews, Director Development and Community
Revitalization 503.802.8507
Myriam Demezas, Relocation Program Manager, Development
and Community Revitalization 503.802.8501
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Authorize the Executive Director to Execute Contracts with Willamette Express Ltd. and Supportive Services Moving and Hauling to Provide Packing and Moving Services During the Renovations of Group 1 & 2 of 85 Stories
Resolution 14-12-01
The Board of Commissioners is requested to authorize the Executive Director to enter into contracts with Willamette Express Ltd. in the amount of $125,000 and Supportive Services Moving and Hauling in the amount of $175,000. This action supports Strategic Operations Plan Goal 2: We will increase the number of housing units for our community through preservation, development and acquisition. It specifically supports Priority Initiative 1: Evaluate and reposition existing projects, with an emphasis on preserving the public housing high rises. ISSUE Staff of the Development and Community Revitalization Department issued a formal Request for Bids (RFB) from qualified firms soliciting costs to provide packing and moving services to residents in Group 1 (Gallagher Plaza & Northwest Tower) & Group 2 (Sellwood Center and Hollywood East) of the 85 Stories project. Based on the Relocation Plan, Development staff established a pre-bid estimate of $300,000 for both permanent and temporary moves of t residents while their homes are under construction. Home Forward made the commitment to provide packing and moving services starting with permanent moves now and through the construction period in 2015.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
8
2
Types of relocation vary between buildings as do moving services to be provided. Given the variety and quantity of moves and the special needs of residents, it was decided that having two moving companies who are able to provide different combinations of services would be most effective. Additionally, having two moving service providers gives us the ability to follow a tighter moving schedule. Both moving companies have committed to consider Home Forward residents for any new hiring the companies have during the approximate one –year term of the contracts. The Procurement and Contracting Department will assist this Section 3 hiring effort by connecting with Home Forward GOALS coordinators, by posting information about this opportunity within the lobby area of the four buildings and referring prospective hiring candidates to the moving companies. There will be a single point-of-contact within Home Forward managing these contracts. As moves are needed, this staff member will schedule moves, matching up resident needs and the construction schedule. The fees for service are based on hourly rates established in the procurement process.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
9
3
RESOLUTION 14-12-01
RESOLUTION 14-12-01 AUTHORIZES THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR TO EXECUTE
CONTRACTS WITH WILLAMETTE EXPRESS LTD AND SUPPORTIVE SERVICES MOVING
AND HAULING FOR PACKING AND MOVING SERVICES FOR THE 85 STORIES PROJECT
WHEREAS, packing and moving services will be required for the relocation effort of the 85
Stories Project, and
WHEREAS, a competitive formal RFB process to select multiple qualified moving companies to assist in the relocation effort has been completed, and
WHEREAS, the two qualified and responsible moving companies that submitted the most
favorable pricing are Willamette Express Ltd. and Supportive Services Moving and Hauling,
and
WHEREAS, a $300,000 estimate for the packing and moving services for the 85 Stories
Project has been established; and
WHEREAS, approval by the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward is required prior to
the execution of Contracts over $100,000;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward
authorizes the Executive Director to execute a contract with Willamette Express Ltd for
$125,000 and with Supportive Services Moving and Hauling for $175,000 for packing and
moving services for the 85 Stories project.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
10
4
ADOPTED: DECEMBER 16, 2014
Attest: Home Forward:
Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
11
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Rebecca Gabriel Business Services Department 503.802.8502
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Authorizing the Executive Director to Execute Contracts with Stoel Rives LLP, Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC and Bittner & Hahs PC for an Aggregate Amount up to $800,000 for Agency-wide Legal Services
Resolution 14-12-02
The Board of Commissioners is requested to authorize the Executive Director to execute contracts for an amount up to $800,000 in the aggregate to Stoel Rives LLP, Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC and Bittner & Hahs PC for agency-wide legal services. ISSUE Staff of the Procurement and Contracts Department issued a formal RFP soliciting proposals from qualified firms for the provision of agency-wide legal services on September 22, 2014. The RFP was intended to identify legal firms and attorneys to assist with six areas: General Counsel, Landlord/Tenant, Public Procurement and Contracts, Real Estate, Employment and Litigation. The term of any new contracts will be five years beginning January 1, 2015. Proposals were received on October 15, 2015 from six law firms. The firms submitting were Stoel Rives, Miller Nash, Harrang Long Gary Rudnick, Bittner & Hahs, Warren Allen, and Kilmer Voorhees. The RFP indicated that firms could propose legal services in any or all of the six areas of law identified. In addition, the RFP allowed for selection of one or more firms.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
12
2
A selection committee of staff from the various departments that routinely utilize the services of law firms and a Board member reviewed the proposals and evaluated each proposal. The Selection Committee identified two firms that are well qualified to provide employment law and construction defect litigation; Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC and Kilmer Voorhees Luarick PC, respectively. The Selection Committee interviewed Stoel Rives, Miller Nash, Bittner & Hahs and Warren Allen on November 7, 2014. Upon conclusion of the interviews, the Selection recommended awarding contracts to Stoel Rives for General Counsel, Public Procurement and Contracts, Real Estate law and Litigation, to Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC for employment law and to Bittner and Hahs for Landlord Tenant law. The Committee felt that these firms have the required skill and expertise to represent and advise Home Forward competently. In addition, the Selection Committee recommends entering into retainer agreements with both Miller Nash and Kilmer Voorhees Luarick PC to serve as conflict attorneys in the event a selected law firm is not able to provide services to Home Forward on a specific issues due to conflict. Based on a review of the last five years of agency legal services, the Selection Committee recommends an aggregate amount for these agency-wide contracts of $800,000 over the five year term. In the event the retainer firms are needed, the Miller Nash services will be
included within in the $800,000 aggregate amount. Prior to authorizing work with the
Kilmer Voorhees firm, which will be litigation in nature, the Board will be consulted and
authorization will be sought. The Selection Committee recommends contract award of up to $800,000 in the aggregate to Stoel Rives LLP, Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC, and Bittner & Hahs PC for agency-wide legal services. In addition, the Selection Committee recommends entering into retainer agreements with Miller Nash LLP and Kilmer Voorhees Luarick PC to serve as conflict attorneys.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
13
3
RESOLUTION 14-12-02 RESOLUTION 14-12-02 AUTHORIZES THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR TO EXECUTE CONTRACTS FOR AN AMOUNT UP TO $800,000 IN THE AGGREGATE WITH STOEL RIVES LLP, HARRANG LONG GARY RUDNICK PC, AND BITTNER & HAHS FOR AGENCY-WIDE LEGAL SERVICES WHEREAS, as an agency, Home Forward will require the assistance of law firms for a wide variety of legal services such as General Counsel, Public Procurement and Contracting, Landlord/Tenant, Litigation, Real Estate and Employment law over the next five years; and, WHEREAS, a competitive formal RFP process to select multiple qualified law firms to assist Home Forward has been completed; and, WHEREAS, the firms of Stoel Rives LLP, Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC and Bittner & Hahs PC have been selected by the selection committee; and, WHEREAS, the selection committee also recommends the establishment of retainer agreements with Miller Nash LLP and Kilmer Voorhees Laurick PC to serve as conflict attorneys in the event the primary firms are unable to represent Home Forward in a matter; and, WHEREAS, a total aggregate contract amount of $800,000 will be available for the three legal contracts, which will include five (5) year terms;
WHEREAS, approval by the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward is required prior to
the execution of Contracts over $100,000;
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
14
4
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Executive Director is authorized to execute contracts for an amount up to $800,000 in the aggregate with Stoel Rives LLP, Harrang Long Gary Rudnick PC, and Bittner & Hahs PC for legal services and to establish retainer agreements with Miller Nash LLP and Kilmer Voorhees Laurick PC to serve as conflict attorneys. ADOPTED: DECEMBER 16, 2014 Attest: Home Forward: ________________________________ ______________________________ Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
15
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Molly Rogers, Director of Asset Management
503.802.8437
CC: Erik M. Olson, Asset Manager
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Authorize the Executive Director to Execute Documents to Acquire the Limited Partner’s Interest in St. Francis Limited Partnership, Transfer the Property Ownership to Home Forward, Resolution 14-12-03; and Execute Documents to Refinance the Existing Loan, Resolution 14-12- 04
The Board of Commissioners is requested to authorize the Executive Director to execute documents to acquire the limited partner’s interest in St. Francis Limited Partnership (LP), complete the transfer of ownership to Home Forward, and to refinance the existing loan. This includes the following actions, represented by two resolutions:
Home Forward’s acquisition of Enterprise Community Partners’ interest in the St. Francis Limited Partnership for $1.00
The execution of the documents and agreements needed to acquire the limited partner’s interest
The execution of assignment and assumption documents for the Portland Housing Bureau loan
Home Forward’s assumption of the partnership’s commitment to the extended low-income use agreement from Oregon Housing and Community Services Department
The dissolution of the partnership and transfer all of its assets to Home Forward Prepayment of the existing Network for Oregon Affordable Housing (NOAH) loan Selection of PNC Real Estate as the lender on the new loan
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
16
2
The execution of the documents and agreements needed to obtain the HUD-insured 223(f) fixed Mortgage Loan at a principal balance not to exceed $4.2 million and an interest rate not to exceed 5.5%
The execution of any other documents deemed necessary by our counsel to effectuate this transfer and refinance
This activity aligns with Strategic Operations Plan Goal 2: We will increase the number of housing units for our community through preservation, development and acquisition. It specifically addresses Priority Initiative 1: Evaluate and reposition existing projects, with an emphasis on preserving the public housing high rises. ISSUE In 2002, Home Forward entered into a Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) Limited Partnership called St. Francis Limited Partnership for the purpose of constructing the St. Francis Apartments, located at the corner of SW Main and SW 11th Avenue in downtown Portland. The property consists of 132 total units with 106 studio units, 16 one-bedroom units, and 10 two-bedroom units. All units are under long-term rent restrictions between 30% and 80% of Area Median Income. Enterprise Community Partners is the Limited Partner and Home Forward is the General Partner. Originally, Home Forward used a financial structure that combined tax credit equity, a Mortgage Loan from NOAH, and a subordinate loan from the Portland Housing Bureau. The tax credit equity provided by the limited partner was in exchange for 10 years of tax credits and tax losses. At the end of the 15-year LIHTC compliance period, it is anticipated that the limited partner would exit the partnership and Home Forward would take sole ownership of the asset. St. Francis LP is now in the end of the 12th year of the LIHTC compliance period and after a review of current low interest refinancing opportunities, we are requesting approval to exit the partnership early and transfer ownership of St. Francis Apartments to Home Forward. This will provide an ownership structure that would be complimentary to a refinance scenario using a HUD-insured 223(f) loan. At today’s interest rate of 3.5%, we can achieve approximately $75,000 per year in debt service savings over the life of the new loan. The basic terms of the proposed new loan are (subject to change):
New principal amount of approximately $4,011,000 to retire the existing $3,778,000 million loan + closing costs (see below)
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
17
3
Interest rate of approximately 3.5% per annum + .45% of principal balance for HUD Mortgage Insurance Premium; the rate to be fixed at closing
35 year fully-amortizing loan, non-recourse to Home Forward Prepayment penalty in first 10 years of loan term; amount to be negotiated
Below is a summary of (approximate) sources and uses of the refinance transaction:
St. Francis New loan amount $4,010,900
Balance on existing loan ($3,778,000) Prepayment penalty ($37,780)
HUD fees ($56,102) Origination fee ($40,109)
Title, legal, appraisal fees ($99,000) Cash to close $91
The Partnership Agreement states Home Forward has the right to purchase the limited partner’s interest for the greater of the fair market value or the amount of taxes owed. In this instance, the fair market value is estimated to be $0 and the exit taxes are $0. Home Forward staff requested that Enterprise Community Partners execute an Assignment of Partnership Interest for St. Francis Limited Partnership for no monetary consideration. Enterprise Community Partners has approved our request and are in the process of advancing legal documents related to the transfer of ownership for Home Forward review and execution, if approved. Home Forward will be responsible for paying the normal transaction costs related to unwinding the partnership which are estimated to be approximately $20,000. The closing of the transfer of ownership interest is expected to occur in the first quarter of 2015. The St. Francis Apartments is a valuable asset in good physical condition. It has successfully provided affordable units in downtown Portland while servicing the outstanding senior debt. If the new loan rates stay at or below current levels and the future refinance is successful, the property could provide cash flow to Home Forward and continue repaying all outstanding debt. Accordingly we recommend approval of this resolution to purchase this property.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
18
4
FINANCIAL IMPACT AND RISK Home Forward will retain approximately $30,000 of the savings generated by this refinancing in the form of an asset management fee. The remaining savings will be used to pay for resident services and/or make payments on our outstanding PHB loan. The risk is that interest rates will rise prior to closing such that this transaction is no longer beneficial and we will lose some or all of the lender fees and third-party costs. This situation will only occur if interest rates rise substantially over the next 90-120 days.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
19
5
RESOLUTION 14-12-03
RESOLUTION 14-12-03 AUTHORIZES THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF DOCUMENTS BY
HOME FORWARD, ON ITS OWN BEHALF AND IN ITS CAPACITY AS GENERAL PARTNER OF
THE ST. FRANCIS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, TO EFFECTUATE THE TRANSFER OF THE LIMITED
PARTNER’S INTEREST IN THE PARTNERSHIP TO HOME FORWARD AND THE SUBSEQUENT
DISSOLUTION OF THE PARTNERSHIP AND DISTRIBUTION OF ITS ASSETS TO HOME
FORWARD
WHEREAS, Home Forward seeks to encourage the provision of long-term housing for low-income
persons residing in the City of Portland, Oregon (the “City”);
WHEREAS, ORS 456.120(18) authorizes Home Forward to enter into partnership agreements and
to make loans to partnerships to finance, plan, undertake, construct, acquire and operate housing
projects;
WHEREAS, ORS 456.065 defines “housing project” to include, among other things, “any work or
undertaking . . . to provide decent, safe and sanitary urban or rural housing for persons or families
of lower income”;
WHEREAS, Home Forward serves as the General Partner of St. Francis Limited Partnership, an
Oregon limited partnership (the “Partnership”), which Partnership owns and operates St. Francis
Apartments in Portland, Oregon (the “Project”);
WHEREAS, the limited partner in the Partnership is Enterprise Community Partners (the “Limited
Partner”);
WHEREAS, Home Forward desires to acquire the Limited Partner’s interests for a nominal fee
(estimated to be $1.00);
WHEREAS, upon the acquisition of the Limited Partner’s interests, Home Forward desires to take
such steps as may be necessary to dissolve the Partnership and distribute its assets to Home
Forward;
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
20
6
WHEREAS, in order to acquire the Limited Partner’s interests, dissolve the Partnership, and
distribute the Partnership assets to Home Forward it will be necessary for the Partnership and/or
Home Forward to obtain the consent of the Oregon Housing and Community Services Department
(the “Allocating Agency”), NOAH (the “Lender”), and Portland Housing Bureau to execute such
assignment and assumption agreements and other transfer documents as may be reasonably
required by such parties;
WHEREAS, Home Forward has received informal approval from Enterprise Community Partners to
exit but is awaiting Limited Partnership Purchase Agreement and Assignment and Assumption
Agreement documents outlining transfer conditions; and
WHEREAS, ORS 456.135 authorizes Home Forward to delegate to one or more of its agents and
employees such powers as it deems proper;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED,
1. General Approval of Transfer of Partnership Interests. The Home Forward Board of
Commissioners hereby approves the acquisition of the Limited Partner’s interests in the
partnership and further approves taking such steps as may be reasonably required to then
dissolve the Partnership and distribute its assets to Home Forward.
2. Approval of Partnership Documents. The documents as may be reasonably required to
effectuate the transfer of the Limited Partnership Interests to Home Forward are hereafter
referred to as the “Partnership Documents”. The Chair of the Board, Home Forward’s
Executive Director and their respective designees (each, an “Authorized Officer” and,
together, the “Authorized Officers”), and each of them acting alone, are authorized and
directed to execute and deliver, on behalf of Home Forward (acting on its own behalf or as
general partner of the Partnership), the Partnership Documents substantially in the form on
file with Home Forward; provided however, any Authorized Officer may approve on Home
Forward’s behalf any further changes to the such documents including material changes,
and such Authorized Officer’s signature on the final Partnership Documents shall be
construed as Home Forward’s approval of such changes. The Authorized Officers (and
each of them acting alone) are further authorized and directed to execute and deliver, on
behalf of Home Forward (acting on its own behalf or as general partner of the Partnership),
any other documents reasonably required to be executed by Home Forward or the
Partnership to carry out the transactions contemplated by the Partnership Documents.
3. Approval of Transfer Documents. Home Forward anticipates that certain assignment,
assumption and consent documents will be required by the Project Lenders and the
Allocating Agency pursuant to which Home Forward will agree to assume and be bound by
the bond and loan documents and regulatory agreements and/or covenant affecting the
Project (collectively the “Transfer Documents”). The Authorized Officers (and each of them
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
21
7
acting alone) are authorized and directed to execute and deliver, on behalf of Home
Forward (acting on its own behalf or as general partner of the Partnership), the Transfer
Documents. The Authorized Officers (and each of them acting alone) are further authorized
and directed to execute and deliver, on behalf of Home Forward (acting on its own behalf
or as general partner of the Partnership), any other documents reasonably required to be
executed by Home Forward or the Partnership to carry out the transactions contemplated
by the Transfer Documents.
4. Approval of Dissolution of the Partnership and Distribution of Assets. Home Forward
further authorizes the Authorized Officers (and each of them acting alone) to take such
steps and to execute and deliver such documents as may be necessary to dissolve the
Partnership and distribute the assets of the Partnership to Home Forward. Such
documents may include but are not limited to a certificate of dissolution, such deeds, bills
of sale and/or other assignments as may be required to distribute all Partnership assets to
Home Forward and the filing of those tax returns as may be necessary to effectuate the
transfer of Limited Partnership Interests, the dissolution of the Partnership assets and the
distribution of such assets to Home Forward.
5. Ancillary Documents. The Authorized Officers (and each of them acting alone) are
authorized on behalf of Home Forward (acting on its own behalf or as general partner of the
Partnership) to execute, deliver and/or file (or cause to be delivered and/or filed) any
affidavits, certificates, letters, government forms, documents, agreements and instruments
that any such Authorized Officer determines to be necessary or desirable: (i) to give effect
to this resolution and/or (ii) to consummate the transactions contemplated herein.
6. Expenditures. Home Forward is authorized to expend such funds (and to cause the
Partnership to expend such funds from the operating reserve) as are necessary to pay for
all filing fees, application fees, registration fees and other costs relating to the actions
authorized by this resolution.
7. Acting Officers Authorized. Any action required by this resolution to be taken by the Chair
of the Board or Executive Director of Home Forward may, in the absence of such person,
be taken by the duly authorized acting Chair of the Board or acting Executive Director of
Home Forward, respectively.
8. Effective Date. This resolution shall be in full force and effect from and after its adoption and
approval.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
22
8
ADOPTED: DECEMBER 16, 2014
Attest: Home Forward:
__________________________________ ________________________________
Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
23
LOAN COMPARISON
ASSUMPTIONS
Property St. Francis Apartments
Location 1024 SW Main Street
Units 132
Capitalization Rate 6.00%
1HUD 223(f)
Fixed
Refinance
INTEREST RATE
Index HUD Rate
Current Base Rate 3.500%
MIP 0.450%
All-in Rate (actual) 3.950%
Constant 5.409%
Underwriting Rate 3.500%
LOAN TERMS
Term (years) 35
Amortization (years) 35
Prepayment Period 10
Minimum DSC 1.176
Maximum LTV 85%
LOAN SIZING
Requested Loan $4,010,900
Maximum DSC Loan $4,450,600
Maximum LTV Loan $4,439,200
Maximum Per Loan Sizing Constraints $4,010,900
Debt Service (actual rate) $216,969
Debt Service Payment on Current Loan $292,000
Annual Savings in DS with Refi $75,031
Current Principal Balance $3,778,000
HUD MIP Fee (1%) $40,109
HUD Inspection Fee $3,960
Appraisal/PNA/Phase 1 (estimate) $21,500
Title / Survey estimated $25,000
HUD App Fee (0.30%) $12,033
Legal/Processing (estimate) $32,500
Home Forward Legal (estimate) $20,000
Prepayment Penalty (1%) $37,780
Origination Fee $40,109
TOTAL Uses $4,010,991
Cash Out ($91)
Principal Balance At Maturity Fully Amortizing
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
24
St Francis - 223(f)
Project Summary
P R O J E C T I N F O R M A T I O N L O A N T E R M S
Date November 6, 2014 Term 35 years
Project St Francis Assumption Assumable
Project Address 1024 SW Main Street Liability Non-RecoursePortland, OR 97205
Owner Home Forward E S T I M A T E D M A X I M U M M O R T G A G E
Owner Address 135 SW Ash Street Mortgage Amount $4,010,900
Portland, OR 97204Based Upon
Contact Donna Kelley Lowest of
Phone 503-802-8485 Debt Serviceable $4,450,600
Fax Value Limited $4,439,200
Email [email protected]
Statutory Limitation* $16,988,900
Application Amount $4,010,000
D E B T S E R V I C E L O A N L I M I T
Mortgage Rate 3.50000%Mortgage Insurance Premium 0.45000% Net Operating Income $283,132Amortization Curtail 1.45949% Debt Service Coverage Ratio 1.17600Mortgage Constant 5.40949% Income Available for Debt Service $240,759DEBT SERVICEABLE LOAN AMOUNT $4,450,600
V A L U E L O A N L I M I T
Net Operating Income $283,132 Value for Loan Estimation Purposes $5,222,660Capitalization Rate 6.00% Maximum Loan-to-Value 85.00%Capitalized Value $4,718,870VALUE LIMITED LOAN AMOUNT $4,439,200
T R A N S A C T I O N C O S T L O A N L I M I T
MIP $40,109Existing Debt $3,778,000 Financing Costs $57,142Repairs Third Party Reports $63,240Replacement Reserves Closing Charges $72,500
Total Estimated Transaction Costs $4,010,991ESTIMATED TRANSACTION COST LOAN AMOUNT $4,010,900
C A S H F L O W A N A L Y S I S
Estimated Mortgage Amount $4,010,900Debt-Service Constant 5.40949%Estimated Annual Debt-Service on Maximum Mortgage $216,969 Net Operating Income $283,132ESTIMATED CASH FLOW $66,163
ESTIMATED DEBT SERVICE COVERAGE RATIO 1.30
PNC Real Estate
Permanent Loan Proforma
Project SummaryPage 2 of 4
11/6/2014; 9:12 PMHome Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
25
St Francis - 223(f)
Debt Service
I N C O M E & E X P E N S E A N A L Y S I S
Rental Income
Unit Type Number of Units Square Footage NRSF Rents Rent per SF Income/Month
Studio 101Studio 5
1 BR 14 1 BR 2 2 BR 10
Non-Revenue Producing Units Non-Revenue Producing UnitsUnit Type Number of Units Square Footage
Number of Units Square Footage NRSF Rents Rent/Square Foot Income/Month
Totals 132 $64,310
AveragesOperating Income Operating Income
PUPM PUPA Monthly Annualized
Gross Rental Income $487 $5,846 $64,310 $771,720Laundry $65 $777 750 $9,002Parking $94 $1,133 1,093 $13,121Other $92 $1,110 1,071 $12,847Commercial $63 $758 8,342 $100,109
GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME $571 $6,856 75,421 $905,051
Less Vacancy/Collection Loss 5.00% $32 $381 4,195 $50,345
EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME $540 $6,475 71,225 $854,705Operating Expenses
% of EGI PUPM PUPA Annualized
Administrative 5.47% $30 $354 $46,747Management Fee 4.00% $22 $259 $34,188Advertising & Promotion 0.04% $0 $3 $355Maintenance & Repair 8.47% $46 $548 $72,386Payroll & Related 26.84% $145 $1,738 $229,416Utilities 13.56% $73 $878 $115,881TaxesInsurance 3.09% $17 $200 $26,400Replacement Reserve 5.41% $29 $350 $46,200
TOTAL EXPENSES 66.87% $361 $4,330 $571,573
NET OPERATING INCOME $283,132
D E B T S E R V I C E L O A N A M O U N T
Mortgage Rate 3.50000%Mortgage Insurance Premium 0.45000% Net Operating Income 283,132Amortization Curtail 1.45949% Debt Service Coverage Ratio 1.17600Mortgage Constant 5.40949% Income Available for Debt Service $240,759DEBT SERVICEABLE LOAN AMOUNT $4,450,600
PNC Real Estate
Permanent Loan Proforma
Debt ServicePage 3 of 4
11/6/2014; 9:12 PMHome Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
26
St Francis - 223(F)
Settlement Requirements
S O U R C E S
Item Amount
PNC Loan Amount 4,010,900
TOTAL SOURCES $4,010,900
U S E S
Item Amount
Mortgageable Transaction Costs
Exisiting Debt 3,778,000
Estimated Repairs
Intitial Deposit / Cash Avaliable for Capital Improvements
HUD Application Fee 12,033
PNC Financing Fee 40,109
PNC Processing Fee 5,000
First Year's MIP 40,109
Mortgagor Legal estimate 20,000
Mortgagee Legal estimate 27,500
Appraisal estimate 8,500
Environmental Fee 3,000
Engineering (PCNA) 5,000
Title costs estimated 20,000
Survey estimate 5,000
Inspection Fee 3,960
Prepayment Penalty (1%) 37,780
Seismic / Termite 5,000
Subtotal $4,010,991
Subtotal
TOTAL USES $4,010,991
NET PROCEEDS (CASH REQUIRED) ($91)
PNC Real Estate
Permanent Loan Proforma
Settlement RequirementsPage 4 of 4
11/6/2014; 9:12 PMHome Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
27
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Molly Rogers, Director of Asset Management
503.802.8437
CC: Erik M. Olson, Asset Manager
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Authorize the Executive Director to Execute Documents to Acquire the Limited Partner’s Interest in St. Francis Limited Partnership, Transfer the Property Ownership to Home Forward, Resolution 14-12-03; and Execute Documents to Refinance the Existing Loan, Resolution 14-12- 04
The Board of Commissioners is requested to authorize the Executive Director to execute documents to acquire the limited partner’s interest in St. Francis Limited Partnership (LP), complete the transfer of ownership to Home Forward, and to refinance the existing loan. This includes the following actions, represented by two resolutions:
Home Forward’s acquisition of Enterprise Community Partners’ interest in the St. Francis Limited Partnership for $1.00
The execution of the documents and agreements needed to acquire the limited partner’s interest
The execution of assignment and assumption documents for the Portland Housing Bureau loan
Home Forward’s assumption of the partnership’s commitment to the extended low-income use agreement from Oregon Housing and Community Services Department
The dissolution of the partnership and transfer all of its assets to Home Forward Prepayment of the existing Network for Oregon Affordable Housing (NOAH) loan Selection of PNC Real Estate as the lender on the new loan
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
28
2
The execution of the documents and agreements needed to obtain the HUD-insured 223(f) fixed Mortgage Loan at a principal balance not to exceed $4.2 million and an interest rate not to exceed 5.5%
The execution of any other documents deemed necessary by our counsel to effectuate this transfer and refinance
This activity aligns with Strategic Operations Plan Goal 2: We will increase the number of housing units for our community through preservation, development and acquisition. It specifically addresses Priority Initiative 1: Evaluate and reposition existing projects, with an emphasis on preserving the public housing high rises. ISSUE In 2002, Home Forward entered into a Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) Limited Partnership called St. Francis Limited Partnership for the purpose of constructing the St. Francis Apartments, located at the corner of SW Main and SW 11th Avenue in downtown Portland. The property consists of 132 total units with 106 studio units, 16 one-bedroom units, and 10 two-bedroom units. All units are under long-term rent restrictions between 30% and 80% of Area Median Income. Enterprise Community Partners is the Limited Partner and Home Forward is the General Partner. Originally, Home Forward used a financial structure that combined tax credit equity, a Mortgage Loan from NOAH, and a subordinate loan from the Portland Housing Bureau. The tax credit equity provided by the limited partner was in exchange for 10 years of tax credits and tax losses. At the end of the 15-year LIHTC compliance period, it is anticipated that the limited partner would exit the partnership and Home Forward would take sole ownership of the asset. St. Francis LP is now in the end of the 12th year of the LIHTC compliance period and after a review of current low interest refinancing opportunities, we are requesting approval to exit the partnership early and transfer ownership of St. Francis Apartments to Home Forward. This will provide an ownership structure that would be complimentary to a refinance scenario using a HUD-insured 223(f) loan. At today’s interest rate of 3.5%, we can achieve approximately $75,000 per year in debt service savings over the life of the new loan. The basic terms of the proposed new loan are (subject to change):
New principal amount of approximately $4,011,000 to retire the existing $3,778,000 million loan + closing costs (see below)
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
29
3
Interest rate of approximately 3.5% per annum + .45% of principal balance for HUD Mortgage Insurance Premium; the rate to be fixed at closing
35 year fully-amortizing loan, non-recourse to Home Forward Prepayment penalty in first 10 years of loan term; amount to be negotiated
Below is a summary of (approximate) sources and uses of the refinance transaction:
St. Francis New loan amount $4,010,900
Balance on existing loan ($3,778,000) Prepayment penalty ($37,780)
HUD fees ($56,102) Origination fee ($40,109)
Title, legal, appraisal fees ($99,000) Cash to close $91
The Partnership Agreement states Home Forward has the right to purchase the limited partner’s interest for the greater of the fair market value or the amount of taxes owed. In this instance, the fair market value is estimated to be $0 and the exit taxes are $0. Home Forward staff requested that Enterprise Community Partners execute an Assignment of Partnership Interest for St. Francis Limited Partnership for no monetary consideration. Enterprise Community Partners has approved our request and are in the process of advancing legal documents related to the transfer of ownership for Home Forward review and execution, if approved. Home Forward will be responsible for paying the normal transaction costs related to unwinding the partnership which are estimated to be approximately $20,000. The closing of the transfer of ownership interest is expected to occur in the first quarter of 2015. The St. Francis Apartments is a valuable asset in good physical condition. It has successfully provided affordable units in downtown Portland while servicing the outstanding senior debt. If the new loan rates stay at or below current levels and the future refinance is successful, the property could provide cash flow to Home Forward and continue repaying all outstanding debt. Accordingly we recommend approval of this resolution to purchase this property.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
30
4
FINANCIAL IMPACT AND RISK Home Forward will retain approximately $30,000 of the savings generated by this refinancing in the form of an asset management fee. The remaining savings will be used to pay for resident services and/or make payments on our outstanding PHB loan. The risk is that interest rates will rise prior to closing such that this transaction is no longer beneficial and we will lose some or all of the lender fees and third-party costs. This situation will only occur if interest rates rise substantially over the next 90-120 days.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
31
5
RESOLUTION 14-12-04
RESOLUTION 14-12-04 AUTHORIZES THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF THE NECESSARY
LOAN DOCUMENTS BY HOME FORWARD TO EFFECTUATE THE REFINANCING OF THE
EXISTING NOAH LOAN ON ST. FRANCIS APARTMENTS WITH A NEW FHA-INSURED
MORTGAGE MADE BY PNC BANK AND RELATED ACTIONS
WHEREAS, Home Forward seeks to encourage the provision of long-term housing for low-income
persons residing in the City of Portland, Oregon (the “City”);
WHEREAS, ORS 456.120(18) authorizes Home Forward to finance, plan, undertake, construct,
acquire and operate housing projects;
WHEREAS, ORS 456.065 defines “housing project” to include, among other things, “any work or
undertaking . . . to provide decent, safe and sanitary urban or rural housing for persons or families
of lower income”;
WHEREAS, Home Forward serves as the General Partner of St. Francis Limited Partnership, an
Oregon limited partnership (the “Partnership”), which Partnership owns and operates St. Francis
Apartments in Portland, Oregon (the “Project”);
WHEREAS, Home Forward desires to acquire the Limited Partner’s interests and take such steps
as may be necessary to dissolve the Partnership and distribute its assets to Home Forward;
WHEREAS, financing for the Project included proceeds from a loan (the “NOAH Loan”) from the
Network for Affordable Housing (“NOAH”);
WHEREAS, Home Forward desires to refinance the Project with a new non-recourse, FHA-insured
mortgage loan (the “Mortgage Loan”) to be made by PNC Bank, National Association (the
“Refinancing Lender”), which Mortgage Loan will be evidenced by a promissory note to be issued
by Home Forward (the “Mortgage Note”) and secured by mortgage/deed of trust and other
security instruments on the Project (a “Mortgage”);
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
32
6
WHEREAS, ORS 456.135 authorizes Home Forward and/or St. Francis LP to delegate to one or
more of its agents and employees such powers as it deems proper;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED,
1. Authorization to Utilize Refinancing Lender and Submittal of the Application for the
Mortgage Loan. Home Forward is authorized and empowered to apply for, negotiate, enter
into, execute and deliver all such documents with and to the Refinancing Lender as may be
required or advisable and as deemed reasonable and appropriate by the Refinancing
Lender and the Authority to obtain the Mortgage Loans, including but not limited to,
execution of any HUD Previous Participation Certification (HUD-2530) on behalf of any
principal or affiliate of Home Forward, as well as any additional documents required by the
Refinancing Lender or Home Forward for purposes of submittal of loan applications to the
Refinancing Lender and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”).
2. Prepay the Existing NOAH Loan. The proceeds from the Mortgage Loan will be used to
prepay the existing NOAH Loan. The Executive Director is authorized and directed to take
all actions required of Home Forward to repay the NOAH Loan in full.
3. Authorization of Mortgage Note and Related Documents for Mortgage Loan. For the
purpose of obtaining the funds to refinance the Project, Home Forward or St. Francis
Limited Partnership, as applicable, shall execute the Mortgage Note in the aggregate
principal amount of not to exceed $4,200,000, with such terms and conditions no less
favorable to Home Forward than those set forth in Exhibit A, which terms and conditions
are incorporated herein by this reference; provided that the mortgage interest rate may
increase to a rate not to exceed 5.5% per annum. The Board finds that it is in the best
interest of Home Forward to execute (or guaranty the payment of) the Mortgage Note for
the purposes set forth in this resolution. Further, Home Forward and/or St. Francis Limited
Partnership is authorized to execute and deliver any and all loan and security instruments
and other documents necessary or convenient to close the Mortgage Loan, including but
not limited to the Mortgage granting Lender a security interest in the Project, a security
agreement, an assignment of leases and rents, and financing statements (together with any
other documents required by Lender to close the Loan).
4. Expenditures. Home Forward and/or St. Francis Limited Partnership is authorized to
expend such funds as are necessary to pay for all filing fees, application fees, registration
fees and other costs relating to the foregoing transactions authorized by this resolution
(“Transactions”).
5. Authorization of Officers and Acting Officers. The Chair of the Board and Executive Director
of Home Forward, and each of them acting individually (without the necessity for joint
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
33
7
action), is hereby authorized to take such actions and sign any documents on behalf of
Home Forward or St. Francis Limited Partnership, as applicable, as the Chair of the Board
or Executive Director of Home Forward may deem necessary and appropriate to
accomplish any of the Transactions, and all such actions and documents, when signed,
shall be deemed approved by Home Forward or St. Francis Limited Partnership, as
applicable. Any action required by this resolution to be taken by Home Forward or St.
Francis Limited Partnership may, in the absence of the Chair of the Board or Executive
Director of Home Forward, be taken by the duly authorized acting Chair of the Board or
acting Executive Director of Home Forward, respectively.
6. Ratification. Home Forward hereby ratifies and affirms all things previously done by or on
behalf of Home Forward in connection with any of the Transactions.
7. Effective Date. This resolution shall be in full force and effect from and after its adoption and
approval.
ADOPTED: DECEMBER 16, 2014
Attest: Home Forward:
__________________________________ ________________________________
Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
34
LOAN COMPARISON
ASSUMPTIONS
Property St. Francis Apartments
Location 1024 SW Main Street
Units 132
Capitalization Rate 6.00%
1HUD 223(f)
Fixed
Refinance
INTEREST RATE
Index HUD Rate
Current Base Rate 3.500%
MIP 0.450%
All-in Rate (actual) 3.950%
Constant 5.409%
Underwriting Rate 3.500%
LOAN TERMS
Term (years) 35
Amortization (years) 35
Prepayment Period 10
Minimum DSC 1.176
Maximum LTV 85%
LOAN SIZING
Requested Loan $4,010,900
Maximum DSC Loan $4,450,600
Maximum LTV Loan $4,439,200
Maximum Per Loan Sizing Constraints $4,010,900
Debt Service (actual rate) $216,969
Debt Service Payment on Current Loan $292,000
Annual Savings in DS with Refi $75,031
Current Principal Balance $3,778,000
HUD MIP Fee (1%) $40,109
HUD Inspection Fee $3,960
Appraisal/PNA/Phase 1 (estimate) $21,500
Title / Survey estimated $25,000
HUD App Fee (0.30%) $12,033
Legal/Processing (estimate) $32,500
Home Forward Legal (estimate) $20,000
Prepayment Penalty (1%) $37,780
Origination Fee $40,109
TOTAL Uses $4,010,991
Cash Out ($91)
Principal Balance At Maturity Fully Amortizing
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
35
St Francis - 223(f)
Project Summary
P R O J E C T I N F O R M A T I O N L O A N T E R M S
Date November 6, 2014 Term 35 years
Project St Francis Assumption Assumable
Project Address 1024 SW Main Street Liability Non-RecoursePortland, OR 97205
Owner Home Forward E S T I M A T E D M A X I M U M M O R T G A G E
Owner Address 135 SW Ash Street Mortgage Amount $4,010,900
Portland, OR 97204Based Upon
Contact Donna Kelley Lowest of
Phone 503-802-8485 Debt Serviceable $4,450,600
Fax Value Limited $4,439,200
Email [email protected]
Statutory Limitation* $16,988,900
Application Amount $4,010,000
D E B T S E R V I C E L O A N L I M I T
Mortgage Rate 3.50000%Mortgage Insurance Premium 0.45000% Net Operating Income $283,132Amortization Curtail 1.45949% Debt Service Coverage Ratio 1.17600Mortgage Constant 5.40949% Income Available for Debt Service $240,759DEBT SERVICEABLE LOAN AMOUNT $4,450,600
V A L U E L O A N L I M I T
Net Operating Income $283,132 Value for Loan Estimation Purposes $5,222,660Capitalization Rate 6.00% Maximum Loan-to-Value 85.00%Capitalized Value $4,718,870VALUE LIMITED LOAN AMOUNT $4,439,200
T R A N S A C T I O N C O S T L O A N L I M I T
MIP $40,109Existing Debt $3,778,000 Financing Costs $57,142Repairs Third Party Reports $63,240Replacement Reserves Closing Charges $72,500
Total Estimated Transaction Costs $4,010,991ESTIMATED TRANSACTION COST LOAN AMOUNT $4,010,900
C A S H F L O W A N A L Y S I S
Estimated Mortgage Amount $4,010,900Debt-Service Constant 5.40949%Estimated Annual Debt-Service on Maximum Mortgage $216,969 Net Operating Income $283,132ESTIMATED CASH FLOW $66,163
ESTIMATED DEBT SERVICE COVERAGE RATIO 1.30
PNC Real Estate
Permanent Loan Proforma
Project SummaryPage 2 of 4
11/6/2014; 9:12 PMHome Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
36
St Francis - 223(f)
Debt Service
I N C O M E & E X P E N S E A N A L Y S I S
Rental Income
Unit Type Number of Units Square Footage NRSF Rents Rent per SF Income/Month
Studio 101Studio 5
1 BR 14 1 BR 2 2 BR 10
Non-Revenue Producing Units Non-Revenue Producing UnitsUnit Type Number of Units Square Footage
Number of Units Square Footage NRSF Rents Rent/Square Foot Income/Month
Totals 132 $64,310
AveragesOperating Income Operating Income
PUPM PUPA Monthly Annualized
Gross Rental Income $487 $5,846 $64,310 $771,720Laundry $65 $777 750 $9,002Parking $94 $1,133 1,093 $13,121Other $92 $1,110 1,071 $12,847Commercial $63 $758 8,342 $100,109
GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME $571 $6,856 75,421 $905,051
Less Vacancy/Collection Loss 5.00% $32 $381 4,195 $50,345
EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME $540 $6,475 71,225 $854,705Operating Expenses
% of EGI PUPM PUPA Annualized
Administrative 5.47% $30 $354 $46,747Management Fee 4.00% $22 $259 $34,188Advertising & Promotion 0.04% $0 $3 $355Maintenance & Repair 8.47% $46 $548 $72,386Payroll & Related 26.84% $145 $1,738 $229,416Utilities 13.56% $73 $878 $115,881TaxesInsurance 3.09% $17 $200 $26,400Replacement Reserve 5.41% $29 $350 $46,200
TOTAL EXPENSES 66.87% $361 $4,330 $571,573
NET OPERATING INCOME $283,132
D E B T S E R V I C E L O A N A M O U N T
Mortgage Rate 3.50000%Mortgage Insurance Premium 0.45000% Net Operating Income 283,132Amortization Curtail 1.45949% Debt Service Coverage Ratio 1.17600Mortgage Constant 5.40949% Income Available for Debt Service $240,759DEBT SERVICEABLE LOAN AMOUNT $4,450,600
PNC Real Estate
Permanent Loan Proforma
Debt ServicePage 3 of 4
11/6/2014; 9:12 PMHome Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
37
St Francis - 223(F)
Settlement Requirements
S O U R C E S
Item Amount
PNC Loan Amount 4,010,900
TOTAL SOURCES $4,010,900
U S E S
Item Amount
Mortgageable Transaction Costs
Exisiting Debt 3,778,000
Estimated Repairs
Intitial Deposit / Cash Avaliable for Capital Improvements
HUD Application Fee 12,033
PNC Financing Fee 40,109
PNC Processing Fee 5,000
First Year's MIP 40,109
Mortgagor Legal estimate 20,000
Mortgagee Legal estimate 27,500
Appraisal estimate 8,500
Environmental Fee 3,000
Engineering (PCNA) 5,000
Title costs estimated 20,000
Survey estimate 5,000
Inspection Fee 3,960
Prepayment Penalty (1%) 37,780
Seismic / Termite 5,000
Subtotal $4,010,991
Subtotal
TOTAL USES $4,010,991
NET PROCEEDS (CASH REQUIRED) ($91)
PNC Real Estate
Permanent Loan Proforma
Settlement RequirementsPage 4 of 4
11/6/2014; 9:12 PMHome Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
38
MINUTES
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
39
1
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS MEETING HOME FORWARD
501 SE Hawthorne Boulevard – Portland, Oregon November 18, 2014
COMMISSIONERS PRESENT Chair David Widmark, Vice Chair Jim Smith, Treasurer Jorge Guzman, Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack, Commissioners Dan Anderson, Benita Legarza, Brian Lessler, Charlene Mashia STAFF PRESENT Michael Buonocore, Mike Andrews, April Berg, Peter Beyer, Robert Dell, Dena Ford-Avery, Rebecca Gabriel, Shelley Marchesi, Kitty Miller, Rodger Moore, Molly Rogers, Ian Slingerland, Melissa Sonsalla, Celia Strauss COUNSEL PRESENT Steve Abel Chair David Widmark convened the meeting at 6:15 PM. PUBLIC COMMENT No one requested to deliver public comment. MISSION MOMENT Catholic Charities & St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church April Berg introduced Valerie Chapman, Pastoral Administrator of St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church, and Trell Anderson, Director of Housing and Community Development for Catholic Charities. Anderson pointed out that Richard Birkel, Catholic Charities’ new Executive Director, was in attendance as well. Chapman said that she was excited about the partnership between her church, Home Forward, and Catholic Charities for the St. Francis Park Development. She noted that some people had been surprised that the church had sold the land for the development. However, the church had been working for fourteen years to find a way to develop the under-utilized property. The project that had
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
40
2
been put together by the current team was a perfect fit. It had been presented to the church parishioners the previous Sunday, and they were very excited. Because of the parish’s commitment to social justice, it had pursued development of affordable housing to balance the ongoing market-rate housing being developed nearby. Chapman expressed her thanks for the opportunity to develop the planned project and the risks taken by Home Forward. Anderson echoed the gratitude expressed by Chapman. He reviewed how Home Forward joined the team after a previous attempt to secure funding had failed. With each team member driven by its own social mission, the development was re-focused on themes of hospitality, respect for nature and the environment, and social equity and justice. The themes have been carried through each step of the development. Anderson expressed his appreciation for the partnership with Home Forward and St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church, the risks undertaken to get to this point, and the opportunities that the team has produced. Chapman distributed flyers for the daily dining hall operated by St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church. Chair David Widmark said that it was great that the site would be developed and thanked Chapman and Anderson for partnering with Home Forward. CONSENT CALENDAR RESOLUTION 14-11-01 Authorize Revolving Line of Credit with Columbia Bank RESOLUTION 14-11-02 Authorize Approval of the Fiscal Year 2016 Moving to Work Plan Celia Strauss read the titles of the items on the Consent Calendar. Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack moved to adopt the items. Vice Chair Jim Smith seconded the motion. The vote was as follows: Chair David Widmark – Aye Vice Chair Jim Smith – Aye Treasurer Jorge Guzman – Aye
Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack – Aye Commissioner Dan Anderson – Aye Commissioner Benita Legarza – Aye
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
41
3
Commissioner Brian Lessler – Aye Commissioner Charlene Mashia – Aye MEETING MINUTES Minutes of October 21, 2014, Board of Commissioners Meeting Chair David Widmark pointed out corrections made to the meeting minutes, as requested by Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack. Chair Emeritus Cormack said that she wanted the record to reflect that anyone could contribute to the scholarship being established in Steve Rudman’s honor. Commissioner Dan Anderson moved to accept the minutes as amended; Treasurer Jorge Guzman seconded. The vote was as follows: Chair David Widmark – Aye Vice Chair Jim Smith – Aye Treasurer Jorge Guzman – Aye
Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack – Aye Commissioner Dan Anderson – Aye Commissioner Benita Legarza – Aye Commissioner Brian Lessler – Aye Commissioner Charlene Mashia – Aye RESOLUTION 14-11-03 Authorize Intent to Issue Revenue Bonds for St. Francis Park April Berg and Peter Beyer presented the resolution. Berg reviewed how the Board had authorized Home Forward’s participation in the project, the purchase of the land, and the selection of the architect and the construction manager/general contractor. Berg summarized the costs of the project, the plan to apply for 4% Low Income Housing Tax Credits in the spring, and the place of the revenue bonds at issue in the project’s financing. Commissioner Dan Anderson noted that the resolution had been considered at the last meeting of the Board’s Real Estate and Development Committee. Commissioner Brian Lessler moved to adopt the resolution. Commissioner Charlene Mashia seconded the motion.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
42
4
The vote was as follows: Chair David Widmark – Aye Vice Chair Jim Smith – Aye Treasurer Jorge Guzman – Aye
Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack – Aye Commissioner Dan Anderson – Aye Commissioner Benita Legarza – Aye Commissioner Brian Lessler – Aye Commissioner Charlene Mashia – Aye RESOLUTION 14-11-04 Authorize Changes to the Administrative Plan for Step Up Preference Ian Slingerland presented the resolution to the Board. He summarized that the changes to the plan would authorize a preference that could be used to move participants in the Shelter Plus Care Program to a regular Housing Choice Voucher if they no longer needed the ongoing services included with Shelter Plus Care. He reviewed how Shelter Plus Care was a permanent supportive housing program that matched ongoing housing assistance with ongoing supportive services. It was aimed at persons with disabilities who were experiencing homelessness. It had the goal of getting participants into housing, establishing their housing stability, and matching them with supportive services from among twelve different local providers. It was funded through six different grants from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), totaling over $4 million in housing assistance. The Shelter Plus Care Program served 516 households (653 individuals). HUD’s funding was based on its measure of participants’ housing stability. Home Forward participants achieved a 93% stability rating, while HUD’s benchmark was an 80% stability rating. Because of the success experienced by some households, they no longer need the program’s ongoing supportive services. Slingerland noted that the Administrative Plan articulated Home Forward’s policy for Housing Choice Vouchers. The resolution at issue would help to determine who would be served by the scarce resources Home Forward administers. It would create a preference that could be used by up to 25 households per year—transferring them from the Shelter Plus Care Program to the Housing Choice Voucher program, freeing the Shelter Plus Care funding for new participants. The authorization would apply for the years of 2015 and 2016. Slingerland introduced Bobby Weinstock, a Housing Advocate with Northwest Pilot Project (NWPP), one of the service providers for the Shelter Plus Care Program. Weinstock
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
43
5
pointed out that NWPP had received 100 calls over the previous week from older adults experiencing a housing crisis. He said that the Board’s approval of the resolution would allow NWPP to help at least some of those callers who need housing and services. Many of the current Shelter Plus Care participants had been in the program for years and, since housing was good medicine, no longer needed ongoing care. Thus, the resolution would allow for the efficient use of the Shelter Plus Care resource. Weinstock thanked the Board for its attention. Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack discussed with Slingerland that Shelter Plus Care was part of HUD’s Continuum of Care Program, which was directed at homeless clients. Chair Emeritus Cormack said the proposal made a good deal of sense. She noted discussions in previous years about being able to help more people by having participants graduate into market rentals or other systems. She voiced some concern that the proposal would obligate more vouchers from Home Forward’s pool of Housing Choice Vouchers, without additional funding to that program. Doing so would make it harder for another applicant to obtain a Housing Choice Voucher. Commissioner Charlene Mashia asked how many households could take advantage of the preference. Slingerland replied that the preference was limited to 25 households over the next two years. The maximum number of households would, thus, be 50. For context, Slingerland noted that 50 vouchers from Home Forward’s Housing Choice Voucher pool were awarded to new applicants from the general waiting list each month. Treasurer Jorge Guzman asked if the households that could take the preference were considered “working families.” Slingerland said that was not a requirement and expected that most participants would not be categorized as “working families.” He added that households taking the preference would need an income equal to what Social Security benefits it could receive, which would ensure the household was utilizing as many resources as possible. In response to Commissioner Brian Lessler, Slingerland said that the preference would cease after 2016, without further action by the Board. Commissioner Dan Anderson said the initiative was thoughtful and well-targeted. He appreciated its evaluation strategy. Slingerland affirmed that he wanted to be sure that the preference did not result in reduced housing stability. Commissioner Anderson said that he shared Chair Emeritus Cormack’s concern over Home Forward’s Housing Choice
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
44
6
Voucher funding. He acknowledged that it was a balancing act and that it being only a two-year commitment made it a milder concern. Commissioner Dan Anderson moved to adopt the resolution. Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack seconded the motion. The vote was as follows: Chair David Widmark – Aye Vice Chair Jim Smith – Aye Treasurer Jorge Guzman – Aye
Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack – Aye Commissioner Dan Anderson – Aye Commissioner Benita Legarza – Aye Commissioner Brian Lessler – Aye Commissioner Charlene Mashia – Aye REPORT Stephens Creek Crossing Construction Management/General Contractor Closeout Report Mike Andrews presented the report to the Board. He summarized how the report was part of a process mandated by state law whenever a public agency used an alternative form of construction procurement. The conventional procurement approach was to select the lowest hard bid. The two acceptable alternative approaches were procurement of a construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC) and procurement of a design-builder. Home Forward had used the CM/GC process on previous projects and was using the design-build approach for its 85 Stories project. While maintaining competition, both alternative approaches allowed consideration of factors in addition to cost during the selection process. Both approaches required steps prescribed by law, including the instant final report and its content, to ensure that competition was not stifled. The report summarized the results of using a CM/GC for Home Forward’s Stephens Creek Crossing redevelopment—tracking how the results aligned with the findings approved at the beginning of the project. To match previous final reports, the Board would accept it by motion. Andrews noted that the report covered control of the project’s budget, but added that Home Forward project budgets were often designed to adapt as amounts from different sources are settled. Thus, the budget for Stephens Creek Crossing was increased, and the project did meet its available budget, though not the precise amount originally projected. The redevelopment also met its goals for target business participation and workforce training and hiring. A low, hard bid approach would not have achieved the
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
45
7
same outcome. Andrews also noted that the project’s permitting and sequencing plans changed significantly after the procurement, and the CM/GC arrangement allowed those changes to be accommodated while containing costs. Lastly, Andrews highlighted that the CM/GC arrangement for Stephens Creek Crossing helped manage resident relations, allowing some residents to move back sooner, which secured more equity for the project. Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack recalled the state legislature authorizing the alternative approaches in the 1980s. She said that the approach worked well at the Oregon Convention Center and at Home Forward’s HOPE VI redevelopments. She encouraged distribution of the report to those involved in state procurement regulations. She felt the alternative procurement methods allowed Home Forward to be nimble, helping it get things done on time and on budget. Andrews responded by noting that the alternative methods still allowed for consideration of pricing when choosing subcontractors, which ensured that competition was not stifled. He clarified that, when arrangements could be made to attract more equity to a project, the added funding must still remain with the project; it could not transfer to other projects. Commissioner Brian Lessler concurred that the alternative approach allowed competition at the subcontractor level, while providing a general contractor to help you through the process. Andrews added that, even when the CM/GC sought to self-perform, its bid would be evaluated against other potential subcontractors. Commissioner Lessler reviewed the earthwork and permitting complications that occurred for Stephens Creek Crossing. He felt the project’s CM/GC, R&H Colas, effectively worked around the complications. Andrews pointed out the work of the R&H Colas Superintendent and Home Forward’s Project Manager. He said that the CM/GC approach created a partnership, whereas the low, hard bid approach could create an adversarial relationship as price is argued over every change in the work. Commissioner Dan Anderson expressed a desire that the lessons Home Forward had learned could be transferred to other agencies. Chair David Widmark noted that the Stephens Creek Crossing redevelopment had been a community effort. He appreciated that adjacent neighbors were embracing the new community. Commissioner Dan Anderson moved to accept the report. Commissioner Brian Lessler seconded the motion.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
46
8
The vote was as follows: Chair David Widmark – Aye Vice Chair Jim Smith – Aye Treasurer Jorge Guzman – Aye
Chair Emeritus Harriet Cormack – Aye Commissioner Dan Anderson – Aye Commissioner Benita Legarza – Aye Commissioner Brian Lessler – Aye Commissioner Charlene Mashia – Aye ADJOURN There being no further business, Chair David Widmark adjourned the meeting at 7:04 PM. EXECUTIVE SESSION The Board of Commissioners of Home Forward did not meet in Executive Session pursuant to ORS 192.660(2). Attached to the Official Minutes of Home Forward are all Resolutions adopted at this meeting, together with copies of memoranda and material submitted to the Commissioners and considered by them when adopting the foregoing resolutions. Celia M. Strauss Recorder, on behalf of Michael Buonocore, Secretary ADOPTED: December 16, 2014 Attest: Home Forward: _______________________________ _______________________________ Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
47
RESOLUTIONS
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
48
Placeholder for Resolution 14-12-05
Recognizing Harriet Cormack
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
49
Placeholder for Resolution 14-12-06
Recognizing John Keating
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
50
STAFF REPORT Kindergarten Registration Update
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
51
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Rachel Devlin, Strategic Initiatives
Program Director
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Kindergarten Registration
Rachel Langford, Education and Youth Initiatives Program Director
Melissa Sonsalla, MTW Program Analyst
This briefing is intended as a follow-up to the June 2014 presentation regarding efforts
under the Families Forward initiative to increase the number of Home Forward children
registering for kindergarten on time. The briefing is informational only; no action is required.
This activity supports Strategic Operations Plan Goal 3: We will strengthen our relationship
with the people we serve by increasing mutual accountability and by improving our ability
to connect them to vital services in the community.
ISSUE
In June, the Board received information about Home Forward’s successful efforts to
increase the percentage of families registering their children for kindergarten on time in
Portland Public Schools. That report highlighted Home Forward’s unique positioning to
impact registration rates due to knowing where many families of young children live prior to
the school districts becoming aware of them.
As a result of our demonstrated success in the Portland Public Schools, this spring, the
other five Multnomah County school districts agreed to sign data sharing agreements with
Home Forward to examine kindergarten registration rates. As anticipated, outcomes for
the East County districts were similarly strong.
Outcome Data
The registration rate for Home Forward kindergartners has increased steadily since Home
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
52
2
Forward began this effort, jumping from 68.8% in 2011 to 82.0% in 2013.
Percentage of Kindergarteners in Each
District who Live in Home Forward Housing
2011 2012 2013
Centennial 8.5% 7.9% 6.3%
David Douglas 11.5% 10.7% 10.1%
Gresham 3.9% 3.3% 2.2%
Parkrose 7.4% 7.1% 8.5%
Portland 6.0% 6.2% 6.2%
Reynolds 7.2% 7.6% 6.3%
Total 6.7% 6.7% 6.4%
Home Forward has seen registration rates for our families increase in five of the six
districts. In the sixth district, Parkrose, outcomes may be skewed by the small number of
total registrants – less than 25 per year.
Additionally, new detail in the data sharing agreements now allows Home Forward to
compare our kindergarteners with other low-income children (defined as those qualifying
for free/reduced meals)1. In 2011, before beginning our efforts, Home Forward registration
rates were lower than those of other low-income families. Home Forward’s families now
1There are some data quality problems that Home Forward is working with the districts to resolve. The
issues will be more apparent in the attachment to this report and may have skewed some of the numbers,
but the overall trends demonstrate fairly consistent success.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
53
3
register at a higher rate than other low-income families, and the gap between our students
and higher income students has narrowed significantly.
Our success is consistent across all races, ethnicities and languages, with one exception.
For the second year in a row, Hispanic families – specifically those identifying as English-
speaking as opposed to Spanish-speaking – are registering at rates that are both lower
than other Home Forward families and non-Home Forward families. Staff will explore this
anomaly over the next year to determine how outreach to Hispanic families could be
improved.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
54
4
Attached to this report is a district-by-district analysis of registration rates, as well as more
detail on the disaggregation of data by race, ethnicity and language.
Next Steps
Home Forward presented this data to the six school districts in November and was met
with great enthusiasm. Outreach for the fall of 2015 is underway, and Home Forward
intends to continue this effort indefinitely, expanding to include families on our waiting lists.
However, given that we have demonstrated consistent success and that the data analysis
work is significant, Home Forward and the districts have agreed that we no longer need to
complete a full analysis of outcomes on an annual basis. We may continue to look at
certain sub-populations, such as Hispanic families, as we fine tune our approach.
But the success of this effort has demonstrated to the school districts that Home Forward
has the capacity to help further their goals in certain areas, and they are eager to identify
additional ways to partner with us. As a result, Home Forward is currently negotiating
another set of aggregate data sharing agreements that will include at least attendance and
disciplinary data, and may be broadened to include performance data. What Home
Forward learns from that data will be used to inform our next investments in youth and
education-related programming.
ATTACHMENTS
Attachment A: District Information
Attachment B: Race/Ethnicity & Language Information
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
55
5
Attachment A: District Information
Centennial School District
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Home Forward 51.7% 29 66.7% 33 69.2% 26
Non-Home Forward, FARM2 29.2% 24 57.1% 21 72.3% 311
Non-Home Forward, Non-FARM 49.5% 521 57.0% 567 81.3% 139
David Douglas School District
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Home Forward 72.2% 90 82.4% 74 80.5% 87
Non-Home Forward, FARM 81.3% 604 83.5% 643 70.7% 692
Non-Home Forward, Non-FARM 88.1% 236 89.8% 206 69.6% 289
2 FARM refers to children who qualify for Free and Reduced Meals at school, a measure of low-income
students in schools. To qualify, these families generally have incomes below 50% of Area Median Income.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
56
6
Gresham Barlow School District
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Home Forward 51.9% 27 82.6% 23 82.4% 17
Non-Home Forward, FARM 78.6% 486 75.1% 551 67.9% 535
Non-Home Forward, Non-FARM 81.7% 432 73.2% 403 72.6% 387
Parkrose School District
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Home Forward 81.8% 22 69.2% 13 80.0% 20
Non-Home Forward, FARM 69.5% 200 67.6% 37 65.8% 187
Non-Home Forward, Non-FARM 73.8% 103 68.1% 235 80.6% 67
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
57
7
Portland Public School District
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Home Forward 72.6% 212 78.0% 236 85.2% 223
Non-Home Forward, FARM 75.7% 1944 77.0% 2039 71.6% 1216
Non-Home Forward, Non-FARM 86.7% 2304 84.8% 2415 92.2% 2181
Reynolds School District
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Home Forward 61.3% 62 76.8% 69 77.8% 54
Non-Home Forward, FARM 63.4% 710 68.3% 745 79.5% 733
Non-Home Forward, Non-FARM 75.6% 270 79.0% 276 75.2% 355
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
58
8
Attachment B: Race/Ethnicity & Language Information
Home Forward Students by Race/Ethnicity
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
Black 66.7% 180 78.9% 213 83.0% 176
White 75.0% 112 78.7% 89 91.4% 116
Multi Racial 56.7% 30 73.3% 45 75.9% 54
Hispanic 69.4% 98 78.2% 78 59.1% 44
American Indian* 20.0% 5 42.9% 7 81.3% 16
Asian* 86.7% 15 90.0% 10 85.7% 14
Pacific Islander* 50.0% 2 66.7% 6 85.7% 7
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
59
9
Home Forward Students by Language
Kindergarten On-Time Registration Rates
2011 2012 2013
On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students On-Time Rate # Students
English 66.2% 346 74.3% 338 80.0% 315
Somali/Oromo/Maay-Maay 81.8% 22 88.1% 42 93.9% 33
Spanish 69.0% 29 81.1% 37 72.7% 33
Other 91.7% 12 100.0% 13 89.7% 29
Russian/Ukrainian* 79.2% 24 92.9% 14 100.0% 13
Vietnamese* 77.8% 9 100.0% 4 100.0% 4
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
60
RESOLUTIONS
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
61
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Mike Andrews, Director, Development and Community Revitalization 503.802.8507
April Berg Assistant Director, Development
and Community Revitalization 503.802.8326
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Authorize Change Order #3 for the Purchase of Construction Materials at Gallagher Plaza & Northwest Towers Resolution 14-12-07
The Board of Commissioners is requested to authorize the Executive Director to execute Change Order #3 for up to $1,100,000 to the Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for Group 1, Gallagher Plaza and Northwest Towers. This change order is to authorize the purchase of construction materials with long lead times. This is necessary to meet the construction schedule with a start date of February 2, 2015. This activity supports Strategic Operations Plan Goal 2: We will increase the number of housing units for our community through preservation, development and acquisition. ISSUE In the fall of 2008, Home Forward began investigating conversion of its traditional public housing portfolio to project-based Section 8. In the spring of 2011, the Board of Commissioners discussed a subsidy change plan that had been developed to allow Home Forward to maintain control of the properties, leverage outside investment to address capital improvements, and access a more stable operating subsidy. In February 2013, HUD approved disposition of Sellwood Center, Gallagher Plaza, Hollywood East, and
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
62
2
Northwest Towers. In April, Home Forward was awarded 649 Tenant Protection Vouchers (the second step in the conversion process). The four buildings completed subsidy conversion on September 1, 2013. In December 2013 Home Forward authorized a Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for Group 1, Gallagher Plaza and Northwest Tower. The necessary long lead building materials for Group 1 include: OKO skin, VPI windows and custom color architectural sheet metal, up to the amount of $1,100,000. The renovation work planned at these three buildings will address deferred capital needs, reduce long-term operating costs through improving building systems, enhance livability and services for residents, and preserve low-income housing by leveraging outside capital.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
63
3
RESOLUTION 14-12-07
RESOLUTION 14-12-07 AUTHORIZES THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR TO EXECUTE CHANGE ORDER #3 FOR UP TO $1,100,000 TO THE DESIGN BUILD CONTRACT WITH WALSH CONSTRUCTION, INC. FOR GROUP 1, GALLAGHER PLAZA AND NORTHWEST TOWERS WHEREAS, Home Forward awarded Walsh Construction Company the Design Build contract to undertake design and construction services for Gallagher Plaza, and Northwest Towers Apartments; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for design and preconstruction services at Gallagher Plaza, and Northwest Towers is progressing on schedule for a February 2, 2014 construction start date; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s resident meetings and relocation planning has commenced and is on schedule for a February 2, 2014 construction start date; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s planned construction scope requires material with long lead times to be ordered and purchased in December 2014 to support a construction start date of February 2, 2015; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s early purchase of construction materials is needed to support the construction schedule and the planned start date of February 2, 2015; and WHEREAS, approval by the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward is required prior to the execution of Contracts over $100,000; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward authorizes the Executive Director to execute Change Order #3 for up to
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
64
4
$1,100,000 to the Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for Group 1, for Gallagher Plaza and Northwest Towers. ADOPTED: DECEMBER 16, 2014 Attest: Home Forward: _____________________________ _________________________________ Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
65
MEMORANDUM
To: Board of Commissioners
From: Mike Andrews, Director, Development and Community Revitalization 503.802.8507
Leslie Crehan Senior Project Manager 503.802.8463
Date: December 16, 2014
Subject: Authorize Change Order #3 for the purchase of Construction Materials at Hollywood East & Sellwood Center Resolution 14-12-08
The Board of Commissioners is requested to authorize the Executive Director to execute Change Order #3 for up to $950,000 to the Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for Group 2, Hollywood East and Sellwood Center. This change order is to authorize the purchase of construction materials with long lead times. This is necessary to meet the construction schedule with a start date of February 2, 2015. This activity supports Strategic Operations Plan Goal 2: We will increase the number of housing units for our community through preservation, development and acquisition. ISSUE In the fall of 2008, Home Forward began investigating conversion of its traditional public housing portfolio to project-based Section 8. In the spring of 2011, the Board of Commissioners discussed a subsidy change plan that had been developed to allow Home Forward to maintain control of the properties, leverage outside investment to address capital improvements, and access a more stable operating subsidy. In February 2013, HUD approved disposition of Sellwood Center, Gallagher Plaza, Hollywood East, and Northwest Towers. In April, Home Forward was awarded 649 Tenant Protection Vouchers (the second step in the conversion process). The four buildings completed subsidy
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
66
2
conversion on September 1, 2013. In December 2013, Home Forward authorized a Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for Group 2, Hollywood East and Sellwood Center. The necessary long lead building materials for Group 2 include: water heaters, shower surrounds and a generator for Hollywood East and VPI windows, Swiss Pearl Siding and custom color architectural sheet metal for Sellwood Center, up to the amount of $950,000. The renovation work planned at these three buildings will address deferred capital needs, reduce long-term operating costs through improving building systems, enhance livability and services for residents, and preserve low-income housing by leveraging outside capital.
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
67
3
RESOLUTION 14-12-08
RESOLUTION 14-12-08 AUTHORIZES THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR TO EXECUTE CHANGE ORDER #3 FOR UP TO $950,000 TO THE DESIGN BUILD CONTRACT WITH WALSH CONSTRUCTION, INC. FOR GROUP 2, HOLLWOOD EAST AND SELLWOOD CENTER WHEREAS, Home Forward awarded Walsh Construction Company the Design Build contract to undertake design and construction services for Hollywood East and Sellwood Center Apartments; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for design and preconstruction services at Hollywood East and Sellwood Center is progressing on schedule for a February 2, 2014 construction start date; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s resident meetings and relocation planning has commenced and is on schedule for a February 2, 2014 construction start date; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s planned construction scope requires material with long lead times to be ordered and purchased in December 2014 to support a construction start date of February 2, 2015; and WHEREAS, Home Forward’s early purchase of construction materials is needed to support the construction schedule and the planned start date of February 2, 2015; and WHEREAS, approval by the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward is required prior to the execution of Contracts over $100,000; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Commissioners of Home Forward authorizes the Executive Director to execute Change Order #3 for up to $950,000
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
68
4
to the Design Build contract with Walsh Construction, Inc. for Group 2, for Hollywood East and Sellwood Center. ADOPTED: DECEMBER 16, 2014 Attest: Home Forward: _____________________________ _________________________________ Michael Buonocore, Secretary David M. Widmark, Chair
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
69
STAFF REPORTS
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
70
Contract # Contractor Contract Amount Description Department Execution Date Expiration Date
C1015L R&H / Colas Construction $ 351,659.00 CMGC for Hope VI Revitalization; GMP #9
Traffic SignalDCR 8/12/2014 4/30/2014
Contract # Contractor Contract Amount Description Department Execution Date Expiration Date
C1383 Glea Livingston $ 2,160.00 Foot care at BCC Prop Mgmt 2/24/2014 1/31/2015
C1493 Tacoma Housing Authority $ -
IGA with Tacoma housing Authority, Seattle
Housing Authority and King County Housing
Authority for Social Science Research Review
and Services
Executive 8/28/2014 8/27/2019
T1479 WJE Engineering & Architects, P.C. $ 50,000.00 On Call Building Envelope Consulting Services,
RFP 07/14-254DCR 10/10/2014 9/30/2017
T1480 Forensic Building Consultants $ 50,000.00 On Call Building Envelope Consulting Services,
RFP 07/14-254DCR 10/10/2014 9/30/2017
C1489 NW Enforcement $ 19,800.00 Security Patrols for Williams Plaza, Gallagher
Plaza and Medallion Apts, RFP 6/14-253Prop Mgmt 10/13/2014 10/31/2015
C1484 Bryan Hargrove $ 3,000.00
Bless Field at New Columbia, Asset
Managenent Review, Develop Field
Maintenance Plan, Create Field Use Operational
Plan & Community Member Field Use Rules
Resident Services 10/20/2014 3/31/2015
C1442 RDH Building Sciences, Inc. $ 33,000.00
Structural rehab emergency services and water
ingress mitigation for the affected building at
Fairview Oaks, Emergency
DCR 10/29/2014 10/31/2014
C1491 Delaris $ 34,000.00 Landlord Portal Assessment, Special
Procurement - ITDBS 10/29/2014 12/5/2014
C1497 Vertex $ 4,000.00 Test, Adjust and Balance the Blower at Holgate
ApartmentsDCR 10/30/2014 11/15/2014
C1476 Background Investigations, Inc $ 95,850.00 Tenant Screening Services, RFP 05/14-248 Prop Mgmt 10/31/2014 9/30/2019
C1483 Neudorfer Engineers $ 8,950.00 Holgate House, Testing, Adjusting & Balancing
for HVAC System, Informal 2 bids & 1 no-bidDCR 11/4/2014 12/31/2014
C1498 Delaris $ 4,000.00 Support and update HomeForward.org drupal
based websiteExecutive 11/7/2014 3/31/2015
C1502 Asset & Property Management service LLC $ 5,000.00
Perform a physical / capital needs assessment
for headstart facilities: Carlton Ct, Dekum Ct,
and Humboldt Gardens, Infomal
Prop Mgmt 11/20/2014 3/31/2015
Contract # Contractor Contract Amount Description Department Execution Date Expiration Date
C0639-5 Human Solutions, Inc $ 74,000.00
Extends contract thru 12/31/14 - Resident and
Community Services - Rockwood Station and
Rockwood Landing
Prop Mgmt 1/6/2014 12/31/2014
C0646-2 Bruce International $ - Extends thru 12/31/14 -
Interpretation/Translation ServicesProp Mgmt 6/12/2014 12/31/2014
C1108-2 Ash Creek Associates, Inc. $ 3,800.00 $3,800 increase for additional analysis on Beech
Street projectDCR 7/23/2014 1/13/2013
Procurement & Contracts Department
MONTHLY CONTRACT REPORT
Contracts Approved 10/1/14 - 11/30/14
CONSTRUCTION & MAINTENANCE SERVICES
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
AMENDMENTS TO EXISTING CONTRACTS
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
71
C1457-1 Alive MMA $ 102.30
Brazilian Ju jitsu classes for all ages at
Stephens Creek Crossing, Reimbursement for
added insurance costs to name HF as additional
insured
Prop Mgmt 8/14/2014 11/30/2014
C1429-1 Louise Williams $ 1,500.00
Update Family metrics database to accurately
represent the residents at each property with
resident services
Prop Mgmt 9/30/2014 8/31/2014
C1391-1 Abby Ahern $ 600.00 To cover two additional makeup workshop DBS 10/10/2014 12/31/2014
C1092-2 Brand Navigation LLC $ 46,000.00 On Call Graphic Design, Annual renewal Executive 11/6/2014 12/19/2015
C1289-2 Gerding Edlin $ 14,725.00 Design Build Agreement for Beech Street
ProjectDCR 11/13/2014 7/17/2014
T1479-1 WJE Engineering & Arcgutects, P.C. $ 95,000.00 On Call Building Envelope Consulting Services,
RFP 07/14/254DCR 11/14/2014 9/30/2017
C1487-1 MH Operable Solutions LLC $ 2,500.00 Assist and Train Home Forward staff on repair
broken windowsDCR 12/1/2014 1/30/2015
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
72
HOUSEHOLDS SERVED REPORT
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
73
Rent Assistance Vouchers - Home Forward Funded 9,089 7,834 1,255 Tenant Based Vouchers 01 - Tenant Based Vouchers 5,917 5,917 Project Based Vouchers 02 - Project Based Vouchers 1,316 1,316 Hi Rise Project Based Vouchers 601 601 Single Room Occupancy (SRO)/MODS 03 - SRO/MODs 499 499 Family Unification Program 88 88 Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (VASH) 04 - VASH Vouchers 330 330 Rent Assistance - PORT IN From Other Jurisdiction 06 - Portability 338 8,751 338
Short Term Rent Assistance Programs 1,177 94 1,083 Shelter + Care 05 - Shelter Plus Care 494 494 Locally Funded Short Term Rent Assistance 589 589 MIF Funded Short Term Rent Assistance 22 22 Alder School 41 41 Work Systems Inc. - Agency Based Rent Assistance 11 31 31
Total Rent Assistance 10,266 7,928 2,338
Public Housing Units Occupied 1,939 1,939 Traditional Public Housing units Occupied 12 - Traditional Public Housing 1,272 1,272 Public Housing units Occupied - Local Blended Subsidy 13 169 169 Public Housing units Occupied - in Owned Affordable 14 - Public Housing in Affordable Owned60 60 Public Housing units Occupied - in Tax Credit Affordable 15 - Public Housing in Tax Credit Affordable438 438
Affordable Housing Units Occupied (excluding PH subsidized) 3,902 3,301 Affordable Housing Units - Tenant Based Vouchers 16 498 498 Affordable Housing Units - Shelter + Care 17 112 112 Affordable Housing Units - Project Based Vouchers 18 260 260 Affordable Housing Units - Hi Rise Project Based Vouchers 601
^ Affordable Housing Units - HUD Multi-Family Project Based 19 342 342 Affordable Housing Units - VASH Vouchers 20 84 84 Affordable Housing Units - Family Unification Program 21 7 7 Affordable Housing Units - Section 8 Port In 22 42 42 Affordable Housing Units - Unassisted 23 1,956 1,956
Special Needs 519 519 Special Needs Units (Master Leased) ** 283 283 Special Needs Shelter Beds (Master Leased) 236 236
Total Households Occupying Housing Units 6,360 1,939 3,820
Total Housing Supports Provided to Household 16,626 9,867 6,158 Household Occupying Affordable Unit/Receiving Home Forward Rent Assistance (1,492) (1,492) Households Occupying Affordable Unit/Receiving Shelter Plus Care (112) (112) Total Households Served 15,022 9,867 4,554
Notes:^
Consists of Grace Peck Terrace, Multnomah Manor, Plaza Townhomes, Rosenbaum Plaza, Unthank Plaza** Special Needs are physical units as occupancy levels that are not reported to Home Forward by service providers master leasing these properties.
Households ServedHouseholds Served Through Housing Supports November 2014
Rent Assistance
Subsidized Housing Units
Moving to Work Programs
All Programs Non-MTW Programs
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
74
Households Receiving Shelter Plus Care Only
10657%
Public Housing Units Occupied 193913%
Affordable Housing Units - HUD Multi-Family Project Based
3422%
Affordable Housing Units - Unassisted195613%
Special Needs Units (Master Leased) **2832%
Special Needs Shelter Beds (Master Leased)
2361%
Households Receiving Rent Assistance and Occupying Affordable Housing Units
149210%
Households Receiving Rent Assistance Only759751%
Households Occupying Affordable Unit/Receiving Shelter Plus Care
1121%
Total Households Served: Rent Assistance and Occupied Housing Units November 2014
^ Consists of Grace Peck Terrace, Multnomah Manor, Plaza Townhomes, Rosenbaum Plaza, Unthank Plaza
Total Households Served 15,022
** Special Needs are physical units as occupancy levels that are not reported to Home Forward by service providers master leasing these properties.
* Includes Local Blended Subsidy
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
75
DASHBOARD REPORT
Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
76
Home Forward - Dashboard Report For November of 2014
Property Performance Measures
1 40 40 0 1 0 15 15 10 0 0 40Occupancy
Number of Physical Rentable Vacant OccupancyProperties Units Units Units Percentage Studio/SRO 1 Bdrm 2 Bdrm 3 Bdrm 4 Bdrm 5+ Bdrm Total
Public Housing 34 1,342 1,342 28 97.9% 80 653 342 257 10 0 1,342Public Housing Mixed Financed Owned * 2 65 65 5 92.3% 0 15 40 10 0 0 65Public Housing Mixed Finance Tax Credit * 5 572 572 7 98.8% 275 93 90 62 45 7 572
Total Public Housing 41 1,979 1,979 40 98.0% 355 761 472 329 55 7 1,979Affordable Owned with PBA subsidy 5 349 349 6 98.3% 72 191 46 40 0 0 349Affordable Owned without PBA subsidy 21 2296 2,296 29 98.7% 991 615 508 156 26 0 2,296
Total Affordable Owned Housing 26 2,645 2,645 35 98.7% 1,063 806 554 196 26 0 2,645Tax Credit Partnerships 18 1,945 1,945 28 98.6% 566 495 451 278 138 17 1,945
Total Affordable Housing 44 4,590 4,590 63 98.6% 1,629 1,301 1,005 474 164 17 4,590Eliminate Duplicated PH Properties/Units -7 -637 -637 -12 -275 -108 -130 -72 -45 -7 -637
Combined Total PH and AH 78 5,932 5,932 91 98.5% 1,709 1,954 1,347 731 174 17 5,932Special Needs (Master Leased) 32 283 283Special Needs (Shelter Beds) 2 236 236
Total with Special Needs 112 6451 6451* property/unit counts also included in Affordable Housing Count
Financial 09/30/14Six months ending 9/30/2014
Properties Units Properties UnitsPublic Housing $170.43 $274.39 $444.82 $365.32 $101.68 -$22.17 13 778 21 564Affordable Owned $813.51 $174.96 $988.48 $456.40 $8.35 $523.73 24 2,500 2 145 12 5 9
Tax Credit Partnerships $434.27 $60.26 $494.53 $338.11 $7.74 $148.68 18 1,945 0 11 3 4
Public Housing Demographics
# of % of Average Average Unit Adults no Family with Elderly DisabledPublic Housing Residents Households Households Family Size Size Children Children Not Elderly
0 to 10% MFI 546 27.1% 2.2 1.8 13.5% 13.6% 0.7% 6.4% 9.5% 10.9% 1.5% 0.4% 0.2% 4.6%11 to 20% 789 39.1% 1.9 1.6 28.1% 11.0% 9.1% 19.3% 11.6% 20.3% 1.7% 1.0% 0.4% 4.1%21 to 30% 386 19.1% 2.2 1.8 11.7% 7.4% 5.9% 6.8% 4.1% 10.8% 0.9% 1.2% 0.3% 1.9%51 to 80% 46 2.3% 3.0 2.2 0.8% 1.4% 0.1% 0.2% 0.8% 0.5% 0.0% 0.1% 0.1% 0.7%Over 80% 11 0.5% 3.4 2.5 0.1% 0.4% 0.0% 0.0% 0.2% 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.1%All 2,018 100.0% 2.1 1.7 60.1% 39.9% 18.4% 36.1% 29.8% 47.8% 4.3% 3.2% 1.3% 13.8%
Waiting List Not Reported0 to 10% MFI 6,496 41.2% 1.9 1.5 2.1% 13.9% 14.3% 18.4% 2.0% 1.0% 0.5% 3.6% 1.4%11 to 20% 4,307 27.3% 2.2 1.6 2.8% 11.7% 9.1% 12.5% 1.2% 1.0% 0.4% 2.5% 0.7%21 to 30% 2,483 15.7% 2.3 1.7 2.0% 5.1% 5.0% 7.1% 0.5% 0.8% 0.3% 1.5% 0.5%31 to 50% 1,851 11.7% 2.6 1.9 1.2% 2.7% 3.6% 5.1% 0.4% 0.6% 0.2% 1.4% 0.4%51 to 80% 482 3.1% 2.7 1.9 0.3% 0.6% 0.9% 1.2% 0.1% 0.2% 0.1% 0.4% 0.1%Over 80% 161 1.0% 2.5 1.9 0.1% 0.2% 0.4% 0.3% 0.1% 0.1% 0.0% 0.1% 0.0%All 15,780 100.0% 2.1 1.8 8.4% 34.3% 33.3% 44.7% 4.3% 3.6% 1.6% 9.4% 3.1%
* Race and enthnicity are not required fields on the Waitlist Application in YardiOther Activity
#'s,days,hrsPublic Housing
Names pulled from Wait List 141Denials 19New rentals 17Vacates 12Evictions 3# of work orders received 682# of work orders completed 607Average days to respond 9.8# of work orders emergency 6Average response hrs (emergency) 19
Per Unit Per Month# of
Properties DCR Not Applicable
# of Properties not meeting DCR
Asian
Race % (head of household)
SubsidyRevenue
TotalRevenue
PropertyRevenue
Unit Mix
NOI# of Properties/units Positive Net Operating Income (NOI)
Black African American
WhiteNative
AmericanHispanic/ Latino
Hawaiian/ Pacific Islnd
Fiscal YTD ending 9/30/2014
Operating Expensew/o HMF
# of Properties
meeting Debt Coverage
# of Properties/units Negative Net Operating Income (NOI)
HAP Management Fees (HMF)
% Family Type (head of household)Households
1Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
77
Home Forward - Dashboard Report For November of 2014
Rent Assistance Performance Measures
Utilization and Activity
Average HUD Subsidy Remaining Waiting List Voucher Average HUD SubsidyVouchers Vouchers Utilization Voucher Over(Under) Waiting List Names New Vouchers Vouchers Inspections Utilization Voucher Over(Under) New Vouchers VouchersAvailable Paid Percentage Cost Utilized Size Pulled Leased Terminated Completed Percentage Cost Utilized Leased Terminated
Tenant Based Vouchers 6,962 6,335 91% $591 -$19,246 2,113 2 15 34 543 93% $594 $24,155 437 470Project Based Vouchers 2,002 1,917 96% $586 $40,927 8 15 28 97% $553 -$234,012 246 275SRO/Mod Vouchers 512 499 97% $446 7 9 10 97% $447 $96,512 99 88
All Vouchers 9,476 8,751 92% $582 $21,681 30 58 581 94% $577 -$113,346 782 833
Demographics
# of % of Average Average Unit Adults no Family with Elderly DisabledTenant Based Voucher Participants Households Households Family Size Size Children Children Not Elderly
0 to 10% MFI 1,126 18.2% 2.1 2.0 8.9% 9.3% 0.5% 3.0% 8.1% 7.5% 0.6% 0.6% 0.1% 1.3%11 to 20% 2,357 38.2% 2.1 2.0 25.7% 12.5% 10.8% 15.4% 12.2% 19.7% 1.1% 2.8% 0.2% 2.1%21 to 30% 1,546 25.0% 2.2 2.0 15.6% 9.5% 7.9% 9.6% 7.2% 14.7% 0.5% 1.5% 0.1% 1.0%31 to 50% 1,005 16.3% 2.8 2.4 6.5% 9.7% 3.0% 4.3% 6.3% 7.9% 0.3% 0.9% 0.1% 0.8%51 to 80% 135 2.2% 3.2 2.7 0.8% 1.4% 0.3% 0.3% 1.1% 0.8% 0.0% 0.1% 0.0% 0.2%Over 80% 9 0.1% 3.2 3.0 0.0% 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 0.1% 0.1% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%All 6,178 100.0% 2.3 2.1 57.5% 42.5% 22.5% 32.6% 34.9% 50.7% 2.6% 5.8% 0.5% 5.5%
Waiting List Not Reported0 to 10% MFI 795 37.6% 1.8 0.8% 8.4% 14.0% 16.7% 1.6% 1.0% 0.6% 2.3% 1.5%11 to 20% 566 26.8% 2.1 2.7% 9.4% 9.0% 12.0% 1.1% 1.2% 0.4% 2.3% 0.8%21 to 30% 388 18.4% 2.4 2.6% 4.7% 5.5% 8.8% 0.4% 0.7% 0.4% 1.7% 0.8%31 to 50% 259 12.3% 2.5 1.4% 2.1% 4.1% 5.3% 0.2% 0.8% 0.3% 1.2% 0.4%51 to 80% 70 3.3% 2.7 0.3% 0.5% 1.2% 1.3% 0.2% 0.2% 0.1% 0.2% 0.0%Over 80% 35 1.7% 2.4 0.1% 0.5% 0.4% 0.7% 0.0% 0.2% 0.1% 0.3% 0.0%All 2,113 100.0% 2.1 8.0% 25.7% 34.2% 44.8% 3.6% 4.0% 1.8% 8.0% 3.5%
Short Term Rent Assistance
Shelter Plus Care 494 $307,770 $623Short Term Rent Assistance 683 $405,013 $593
Resident Services
Resident ProgramsHouseholds
Served/Participants
Congregate Housing Services Public Housing 113 $106,119 $939* as of previous month
# HH Eviction
Health and Safety Stabilized
Unduplicated Number Served
# Events# Event
AttendeesResident Services Coordination Public Housing 14 52 2046 140 2400
GOALS Program Public Housing 210 $215,569 2 1 $9,673 1 $0 $961Section 8 265 $397,299 10 1 $16,390 2 $0 $1,763
Terminations or Exits
Escrow $ Disbursed
Escrow $ Forfeited
Current Month Activity
Avg Annual Earned Income Increase Over
Last Year
% Family Type (head of household)
Current Month Status
Housing Program Served
Average Funds per Participant
# of Households Participating
$ Amount of
Assistanc
Monthly Funding Amount
NewEnrollees
Households
Average Cost per Household
Calendar Year To Date
Black White Native Asian
Race % (head of household)
Hawaiian/ Hispanic
# of Participa
nts
Escrow $ Held
# of Graduates
2Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
78
Home Forward - Dashboard Report For November of 2014
Agency Financial Summary
Six months ending 9/30/2014
Subsidy Revenue ####### $21,004,254 $19,524,784 $1,479,471Grant Revenue ####### $3,089,293 $2,904,979 $184,314Property Related Income ####### $4,825,061 $4,069,956 $755,105Development Fee Revenue $0 $0 $0 $0Other Revenue $261,088 $793,743 $644,490 $149,253
Total Revenue ####### $29,712,351 $27,144,209 $2,568,142
Housing Assistance Payments ####### $16,546,896 $17,342,726 ($795,830)Operating Expense ####### $10,279,873 $9,650,634 $629,239Depreciation $706,932 $2,135,026 $2,090,802 $44,223
Total Expense ####### $28,961,795 $29,084,163 ($122,368)Operating Income $686,058 $750,556 -$1,939,954 $2,690,510
Other Income(Expense) ####### -$1,117,500 -$692,304 ($425,196)Capital Contributions $126,211 $599,126 $444,882 $154,245
Increase(Decrease) Net Assets $595,492 $232,182 -$2,187,376 $2,419,559Total Assets ####### $217,100,995 $211,544,634 $5,556,361Liquidity Reserves ####### $22,855,099 $22,744,934 $110,165
Development/Community Revitalization
New Development / Revitalization Construction Construction Current Total Cost PerUnits Start End Phase Cost Unit
Stephen's Creek Crossing 129 Aug-12 Apr-15 Sitework / Construction $51,636,304 $400,281Stephen's Creek Crossing 129 Aug-12 Apr-14 Construction $51,636,304 $400,281Lifeworks Northwest 32 May-13 Aug-14 Finance Structuring $10,346,567 $323,330St. Francis Park tbd tbd tbd Concept tbd tbd
Capital ImprovementHighrise Rehab - Group 1 343 Feb-15 Mar-16 Predevelopment $49,464,308 $144,211
Gallagher 85Northwest Tower 258
Highrise Rehab - Group 2 396 Feb-15 Mar-16 Predevelopment $48,016,944 $121,255Sellwood 110
Hollywood East 286Dekum Court Comprehensive Rehab 41 TBD TBD Predevelopment $2,000,000 $48,780Holgate Exterior Seal Project N/A Apr-14 Jul-14 Construction $350,000 N/AWilliams Plaza Masonry Repairs N/A Aug-14 Jan-15 Construction $759,704 N/ARockwood Station Windows & Siding Phs IIIN/A Feb-14 Oct-14 Construction $1,904,343 N/AUnthank Plaza N/A Mar-14 Jul-14 Construction $161,503 N/AGladstone N/A Apr-14 Oct-14 Investigative $264,800 N/A
Prior YTDIncrease
(Decrease)Month Fiscal Year to Date
3Home Forward Board of Commissioners December 2015
79