Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

432
¥II China Bidding IYFn f ?˝ Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis Linfan MAO Chinese Branch Xiquan House 2020

Transcript of Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

Page 1: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

'

&

$

%¥IçI

China Bidding

çIæÛYFnf�� ?Í

Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis

Linfan MAO

'

&

$

%

Chinese Branch Xiquan House

2020

Page 2: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

f��

ISêÆ|Ü9A^ïÄ�(AMCA§{I)��!ÄRïÄ

IS¥��ÆƬ£NSIA§{I¤J��¬

¥IÔ6�æéܬú�橬Ø%;[

¥Iæ�¬£CPA§�l¤ÄRæ²LÆ[

�®ïÓ�Æo��Ç!ïÄ)��

Email: [email protected]

çIæÛYFn

Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis

Chinese Branch Xiquan House

2020

Page 3: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

This book can be ordered in a paper bound reprint from:

Books on Demand

ProQuest Information & Learning

(University of Microfilm International)

300 N.Zeeb Road

P.O.Box 1346, Ann Arbor

MI 48106-1346, USA

Tel:1-800-521-0600(Customer Service)

http://wwwlib.umi.com/bod

Peer Reviewers:

Q.Z.Ping, Academy of Internet Industry, Qinhua University, Beijing 100083, P. R.

China.

J.Jiang, Beijing University of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Beijing 100044,

P. R. China.

X.H. Deng, Yuanling Data Group Co., Ltd, Beijing 100070, P. R. China.

Z.Q.Ma, Beijing Dianfang Engineering Consulting Co.Ltd, Beijing, 100070, P. R.

China.

Y.G.Zhang, Yuanling Intelligent Bidding Co.Ltd, Beijing, 100070, P. R. China.

Copyright 2020 by Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao

Many books can be downloaded from the following Digital Library of Science:

http://fs.unm.edu/ScienceLibrary.htm

ISBN: 978-1-59973-681-5 Price: 62.40$

Page 4: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

S ó

·���o�çI§çIÝI´��oÀÀºçIæ´±çIÝI�5��

{§|�ÝI¿�§J`ÀJæ(J¿¢���«�*²L1�"ù�¥§çI

ÝI´�«Å�!�{½Ãã"ølæ¢�üwçIÝI§Ø���«æ¿�

Å�§çIÝI¿vk²Lƿ§ù��´ISNõ<rçIÝIw��«i

Z��Ï"

`�iZ§P�����*l /¿Ãó0iZ§�[�3�åûXÃ�µ/¿!

¿!¿Ãó§����3�*l��¡§�[Ø�w�¦"̄ :!̄ :84¦§̄ :!

¯:84¦¶¿Ãó§¿Ãó§����3�*l��¡§�[Ø�w�¦"̄ :!

¯:P4¦§̄ :!̄ :P4¦"0

¦Æâ�§ù´êÆ¥p�éA'X§¡�N�§q½´O�Å�Æ¥�;½

�/��0§Òw�X�[��@ �*lww/rÃó�3=��*l��¡§

����£584¦§±?1e�ÚiZ§�[¼���"

l¯çIænØïÄ�§uyù�iZ¥%¹X4��nµ�´iZ5K�

Ê·5§=ë\iZ��*lþ@�iZ5K§�84�L=,Lü��!8"Ä

K§8�2vk���*l�¿�¦�å N¶�´Ãó¿�XØ¿�Xd�X�

[��@ �*lû½§¦<Ø�Zý"ù5K��*l�iZC½Ä:§Ã

I�<w+§�ÃI{Ær�§Ò´�«5K§�«ë�<@��5K"

k<`§çIÝI´�«iZ§́ �«�<iZ"·��ØÓ¿ù«`{§@

�Ù lù�Å��ïám�"çI�/ç0́ /ç�<5ë�½�A0�¿§ç

I�/I0́ /8I½8�0"

õc5§·3IS��l¯çIÝI{!çIæ¢Ö9Y~©Û�ùǧf

L·��<A�3��<±þ"·�<��k�«Ç�N¬§��Æé,��Y

~(Ju)�ƽ´éçIÝI,�«�{L«~¦�§ ´�é/Ü{½�{0

Ò�±½_%"���o�çIº´�L§5�!Aéu�`��Ù§�´�æ

(J/8�0QºçIÝI�.´�«²L5K�´�«{Ær�Qº·�<²�

L²§çIÝI���«²L5K§3IS¿vk��õê<¤ý��É ´r§

w¤�«{Ær�ÂÖ§�ISØ�<�3Øä/òù«5K*Ð��þ��r�

+�§±�ù�éþée�±`��Ù§��ѯ��CÃ'§́ ±í�I?��

�|�çIÝI¹Ä§ùA�´çIÝIÅ�uÐ��H§Ï��´ù��Ï��

�þ�çIÝI¹Ä/rL|!r/ª0§́ �I��\?Ø�¯K"ÄK§çI

Page 5: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

ii çIæÛYFn

ÝIÒ����*l� �/¿Ãó0iZÃɧÒý�¤��«iZ§�ùý

éØ´�ïçIÝIÅ��Ð%½�¿"

N�)ûçIæ/r/ª!rL|0ª�/��1²0�iZQº·�<Ó�

l¯XêÆ�Æ!²LÆÚ+n�Æ�ó§�õ�Æ��ïÄ�¢�"ØêÆ�Æ

§I�Æö�r·À�óƵØ[§Ï�·�LØ�êÆ!Ôn9�ƵØ"

�ISÓ1��@�·´æ²LÆö§́ ïÄçIÝI��?æ{Æ!5K½

nØ�;["é�Ó���¯§·�U�Õ3õ�ØÓÀ��©Û!ïÄÙ/�0½

ö/5Æ0§¤�(Ø�~kgCÕA�/�0"

·@�§çIæ´�«�*²L1�§çIÝI´çIæ¥��«²LJ

`5K"¢Sþ§l²Lƽ´+n�Æ�ó§wçI槧´�«Ôѧ�´

�«�¦"lêÆwçIæL§§§´�«²LÆ¿Âþ�J`§́ æ^½|Å

�`z] ����«|��ª"��où�ùQºÏçIæØ÷v/Wê�Ä!

÷úk10ùÔ¯O�§�õ/§§´�«ÔÑÙÛ§́ é�8Á����üy"

çIÝI�¢�§3u3½|ø�ý¥|�ÝI<é�8Á�¿�§̀ zÁ�§¿

l¥J`(½�ZÁ�½ø�<"ùl+nÆw§́ �«ÔÑ��¦¶l²LÆw§

K´�«²LJ`E|½ö5K§ ÃØçI�8´ó§ï��8¥�t!�O!

in!�ó½ÀÔæ§�´ó§ï��8±��?æ!è�æ¥�ÀÔ!

ÑÖ"

çIÝI���«½|�´5K§É{Æ!©z!S�!��ÚVÆ��¬Ê

H@��äk���åå�1�5��å"ù�¥§{Æ´3�����?§=�

¬Ù¦1�5�ÑÃ��§æ^I[�åé�'1��å"ISþ§çIÝI�õ

���«½|�½�¤5K§�²æ^Bgú�l§ÃI{Æ�Ö¶3IS§çI

ÝI¹ÄL�lçIÝI{5½§�Ù¢�E´3uæ^I[�å�å5�1�±

5�çIÝI¹Ä§Ùm�E´Jp²L�Ã!�y�8�þ§=Á��J`½´

ÔÑüy§5��´5�L§"@o§��o¢�¥JbçIõ!GÏÝIõQº�

Ï3u�õ�¯<éçIÝIù«ÔÑ��¦Ø�¡½´Øn)§\�r�çI�

ݧ=�¯<Ø�¿çI {Æ�Ýqr½Ù7L?1çI"3ù«½|+n�ª

e§�¯</r/ª!rL|0tJbçI½´GÏÝIÒ3�½§Ýþ¤�g

,§Ï�/²ó��!�¦ÃL0́ �õê<�?­óƧ ùéIkè�½´�?

æ�8¥�æ<§cÙXd"

@o§́ Ä�±Ø^??rN{Æ5½ ´rçIæ½´çIÝIw��«

½|�´5KQº·@��±�ù�´·3õc�Æ¢�¥§¡é5 uØÓk !

ØÓ�ÚÆ�Ì�N¬§=l²LÆÀ�w�{Æé�¯<�1�5½§/�Ù,

Page 6: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

Só iii

�Ù¤±,0/�Ƨ ù�¥�/¤±,0T´çIæ�²Lm�"

çIÝI�`´�«Í5¬§�Ù�IS/�F¥0kX¯<��q"õc5§

·��k�%�§������çIænØ�/�Ê0�qØ´X{çIæ¢

Öö�a�Ö§±÷vØÓÖö+�I�"�Öd�¯½Y~o(çIÝI5Ƨ

? þ,�Æn§©Ûë�<3æ¹Ä¥�%n½<5§©Û5�kS�çIÝ

I½|Ak��¬<©Ä:§&?çIÝI¹Ä¢�¥�GÏÝI!áJ�b¢�

¥I¯�¥�<5§�º��EâÚ5�kS�çIÝI½|ï�"·@�§ù�

�«&?é5�çIÝI½|´k¿Â�"

�`ù´��'uçIæ²LnØ�½|ï��Í�§���±w�´��

�¯¬§Ö¥Øy�)¹½©Æ�¬¥�|µ§X5ÜiP6¥/Ý�U�úÌ�

Ñ�F¥+¥!5nIüÂ6¥�»9�Ô!5YéD6¥��Ô��Ààk!5ù¢

�6¥�_���´§±9!m¥/�7´Ó���¯0Ú5ºs�61��£¥£

��@«½|�´¥�n�I�§Ù8�§�´éçIÝI5K?1nØ©Û§�

´ä��ü"éÖ¥Úã��¯�!!Y~§Ö�k;�¢Ú§ù�¯ÚY~þ

´©ÛçIæ5K�Ån¤I§¿��é,�<½¯�"

±eV�/0��e�Ö�Ù�ÙÛ"

11ÙÚ12Ù�Ø%§3ul÷*�¡�ºçIÝI´æÔÑ��¦§±<

�Ù��/�F¥�²â0|µ�Úf§/df\�!ÌSì?0/0�çIæÔ

Ñ¿��o§¿�IOq´�o§N�J`ÚN�?1çIæ�1��ا±9

çIÝI¤I�½|�¸�¯�§©Û�å�NYÚÜS/c>C¯�"

13Ù�111Ù´çIænØ©Û§�)æI¦(½!Á�Uå"�!çI

©���¦�?�!çIÝI|�!mI!µI!ÜÓÇ�ÚÜÓÁ�+n�çI

æÌ�¯�"���ù)çIæ¢ÖØÓ§�ÖX­3l�¯½Y~¥©Û!

Jõæng§XÚ�ºù�ÔÑ��¦ngÚÙ¥�5Æ��{"~X§dêÛ

Çýÿ<)ÚÑæI¦�EâIOÚ�¦§±5YéD6¥�Ô��Ø� ÚÑ

Á�Uå"�§±�¥ÀW�5KÚuçI©�?�§±c$øýþ�I[ü¶Ú

ÑæJ`üS�êÆnا±�?�ìiå#hùXÞÚÑmI§±­.�ç

ÚѵI��5KÚ­�5�§�3Ú�æ<rçIÝIÅ�w��«�Æ�{

½Ãã§(ܽ|ø�ýU�ïÄÙ/�0§ÝºÙ/5Æ0¿gú/A^ù�Å�

±3²Lï�Ú½|²E¥¼�²LÂÃ"

112Ù�116Ù©ÛçIÝI½|¥��{�51�§&¢�ï5�kS�ç

IÝI½|��"çIÝI¹Ä¥�GÏÝI!áJ�b¢�¥I��{1�ÂB

Ø�§�Ù��o3¥I�½|þÑy���ü��§�Ï3=pºXJ�ÏØ�

Page 7: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

iv çIæÛYFn

Ù§Û!éÙ£nÚ5�Ú�ºù�¥§�,kçI<ÌNI?Ø�½´v@ýÁ

1ÙÌNI?��ϧ�©z!S�é<�K��½ØUü½3"�d§Ö¥±P

<þäÜÁ rOá�kYÚѬ¯ÌNI?§±GÏÝI���~©ÛGÏÝ

I��Ï9Ly§ÚÑGÏÝI��E⧱çI�o<!ÜÓEb��¯�§©

ÛÝI©�Ebó²9��E⧱5YéD6¥yôh�xX��¯©ÛÝI<

!��©zÄϧ�ÑI�?�Ú�z½|O\�Ý�U��¿Â�"Ö¥�~Þ

CcxNþúÙ�çIÝI+�¥��ͶY�§XµI;[ÌÄ�ÝI<é

X!¢ª§ú�] �´¥%he�ñµI;[&E§±9>Mç��{�\µI

;[¥XÚ��µI;[&E!�¬ç�³å0\çIÝI¹Ä�Y�§l�¬�

�£�Sé²L�S��æ§&?çIÝI½|�{1�� 9)û��§�Ñü

X�çIÝI�´1N½/ª�UC§Ø�Ul��þ)ûGÏÝIÚáJ�b¢

�¥I��{¯K"Ö¥±ôܱ�/�^90ª�G϶Y§©Û�ï5�kS�

çIÝI½|�J:ÚÛ:§�Ñôܱ�¶Y�³Ñ�¯K§Ø´çIÝIÅ�

¯K ´çIÝI½|ï�¯K"ù�¥§�´��(?n�?Ú½|�'X§3

¥I<5A:�Ä:þ�õçIÝI�ݶ�´j±�Ã8{£!�Ã8�£§±

{£Ny��ng!rz{Æé��ï��r?�^"

·@�§�kçIÝI¥�/�0K\¥I<�%¥§4/�03z�<%¥å

�^§U/�01¯§çIÝI�/�0âU3¥I²Lï�Ú½|²E¥u��^

Ø´/r/ª!rL|0½´��í�I?�÷c§? âk�U�ï5�kS

�çIÝI½|"��kù�§çIÝIÅ�âÃIÄ^I[�å½´{Æ�Ù�

Ö /d£%z0/¤�½|²L��«ÊH5K½ /́�0 gú�l"·�§ù

ATâ´�ïçIÝIÅ��Ð%½8�"��§çIÝI3<�%¥Ò�U´�

«/iZ05K 4<�Oúº"

��§·�3déõc5���yÚ|±·�*lÚÓ¯L«a�§vk¦�

õc��y�|±§vk¦��·éçIænØ�?ا�ÖØ�U¡½"¤v

�§å�fôÛQé�ÖÅiÅéïÖ§��Ø��i½¹·cé§3d�¿�

�"�Ö�Щ§́ �; ú��E/�£ó§0 M���¬�¡§Ö¥�Ü©S

Nd·�<ú�Ìù§3�þ?1D�Ú�§; ú��Ó;�¹ÂÚ�Ï}

6��þ�ó�§�Ö�Ñ���; ú��]ϧ3dé¦��"�GÑL

«����¿"

f��

2020c5�25Fu�®û¤

Page 8: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

8 ¹

Só . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i

11Ù çIæµÔÑ��¦ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1

11! Úfµ�F¥�²â . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

12! ÔѵÜÝ�J` . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

13! IOµPºPåkÍX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

14! Å&µ5��Á�OK . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14

15! Y~µ�N'�Eâëê�µ"�'� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

12Ù çIæµÁ��¿� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

11! ¿�µÁ��5��y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22

12! 5�µÜÓ¾á��å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

13! A~µEPC!PPP�8æ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29

14! 1�µæ(J�µ� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33

15! Y~µ>Cæ��E�ÂI? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36

13Ù çIæµI¦�.½ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41

11! uåµæ�o . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42

12! .½µI¦�EâIO�^� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .45

13! Ø%µ¢�5�¦�^� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49

14! ¿�µÏ�!IOÚ^� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .53

15! Y~µæI¦ØOÚuزï�d . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .56

14Ù çIæµÁ�Uå�"� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61

11! m�µ"�Á�Uå . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62

12! ]�µ"��Ï�!IOÚ^� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .65

13! "�µ(½Ü�ÝI< . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69

14! J`µ(½ÝI<¶ü . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74

15! Y~µ�ï�8æØ%3ïuUå . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .79

15Ù çIæµçI©���¦ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85

11! m�µF¥ÀW��½ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 86

Page 9: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

vi çIæÛYFn

12! §SµÝI<L� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90

13! J`µµIIOÚ�{ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96

14! Á�µÜÓ^� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101

15! Y~µJ`IO¹·Úu�5��} . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107

16Ù çIæµçI©��?� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112

11! «�µIOçI©� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113

12! ÜݵçIÝI¹ÄOy�Sü . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 118

13! IOµµ"J`�{ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 124

14! �½µ¥IÜÓ^� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133

15! Y~µçI©�J`�Á��É . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139

17Ù çIæµçIÝI�|� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145

11! /ªµg1çI½�÷�nÅ�çI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146

12! m©µçI©�éúm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151

13! `²µy| t�ÝIý�¬ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156

14! ÝIµÝI©�?��4� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161

15! Y~µçIÝI|�Ø�Úu��} . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166

18Ù çIæµmI�|� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171

11! mIµimùXÞ��á@ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172

12! O�µmIO�ó� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175

13! §SµmIL§�å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 180

14! ¤JµmIP¹ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 185

15! Y~µmI�{E¤­#çI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 189

19Ù çIæµµI�|� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .194

11! µIµÝI¿��à� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 195

12! §SµµI|��6§ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 200

13! OKµÝI¯¢�µ"Ú'� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205

14! �wµµ"Ú'��P¹ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 211

15! Y~µµI�{�çI�}Y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 216

110Ù çIæµÜÓ�Ç� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221

11! (@µµI(J�@� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 222

Page 10: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

8¹ vii

12! ú«µµI(J�ú« . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 228

13! Ç�µuÑ¥IÏ�Ö . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 232

14! 5�µÖ¡ÜÓ�\¾ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 236

15! Y~µ�¿�â�Ø�ÜÓÁ�ŪY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 241

111Ù çIæµÜÓ�Á�+n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .247

11! I�µÜÓ���+n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 248

12! ?ݵÜÓ�?Ý+n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 252

13! �þµÜÓ��þ+n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257

14! |GµÜÓ�d±+n . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263

15! Y~µ{��ûÒ�ÜÓþÃ�Y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 268

112 Ù çIæµçI<�ÌNI?. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .274

11! I?µ¬¯ÌN�I? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 275

12! (JµçI<�æI? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 279

13! 1�µçI<�{ÆI? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 285

14! �'µÙ¦ë�<ÌNI? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 291

15! Y~µçI<5��Á��ÌNI? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296

113Ù çIæµGÏÝI1���� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 301

11! pϵGÏÝI�ÄÏ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 302

12! ÌNµGÏÝI�ë�< . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 307

13! �/µGÏÝI��/ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 312

14! ��µGÏÝI��� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 317

15! Y~µGÏÝI3Ä:�ó¥wuY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 324

114Ù çIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 330

11! ÄϵáJ�b¢�¥I��Ï . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 331

12! �¢µ�¿Eb1���� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 335

13! U�µ!�ÄÏ��� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 340

14! $dµ�¿¿�1���� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 347

15! Y~µ!�²EÜÓJ��Y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 353

115Ù çIæµ�{µI��� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .359

11! ¬1µµI�¬¤�{�ÄÏ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 360

Page 11: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

viii çIæÛYFn

12! iÒµ�{µ"'���� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 365

13! J`µµI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I���. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .370

14! Ø�µ¥0½²��³µI;[&E��� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375

15! Y~µµI�{�S�¯�)ØÜÓY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 381

116Ù çIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 386

11! ²�µçIÝI�´�1N . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 387

12! ª&µ<Ú½|ÌN)���� . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 392

13! �?µ²��ï��´�S��æ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 397

14! 5�µçIÝI²��´��å . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 402

15! Y~µ±�¶Yé�ï5�kS½|��g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 407

N¹1 Y~�¯¢Ú . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 413

N¹2 100�Bv100U�g¢ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 416

�z . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 417

�ö{0 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 420

Page 12: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 1Ù

çIæµÔÑ��¦

**********************************************************************

Ø£«ìý¡8§���3dì¥

— �y.�ç5KÜ�96

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 13: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

2 çIæÛYFn

11!Úfµ�F¥�²â

çIÝI�m�´çI<3¯õÝI<¥J`§�¥I<5�§ù��©Æ

�¬£±��¥ÀW§U(ënÃ�"�©Æ�¬¥§~~kù��|µ£±µ�

 {w�L[�*Õ3¢¢þ§Ã¥<X��F¥§¢¢eÕX�+�câd§Ï

��4�5�F¥"�*l���m§qlm���§gþØû§Ý23>þØ�

/�yX"ªu§�*rF¥��<+¥� dDúf§<+��(då*ϧ�

Ó�å�*ÚúfU(ën"ùÒ´~`��¥ÀW"

ã1.1 �F¥

F¥��XØ��X´��²â§âD´5g2ÜFx�S�"

[F¥Þ/Ý��¯] � 5̀ÜiP61Ê�n£�[P1ù«�¥ÀW�S

�§Ù§SXeµ

11Úµúw – I��úÌhh§c����S§�3�i�Þ§p(碧�

�F¥§EU´ç�ê¶

12ÚµF¥ – úÌb�¬å§6wU/§�mkÊÔ�D�Få§Ã,F¥§

C¹XúÌhh¶

13Úµ�� – Ì�n�¶

14Úµ�¥ – úÌ=«*w§�/Ý5��C§òF¥�L5§�Ã�3/Ý

Þþ"/ÝX�¯§r�5©lf��§VÃaÉX@¥§@¥ÚQ�E3¦�

E�S¶

15Úµ�¥ – �i�Þ§@�û<�§LLòò§Ñ5�sF¥§�1öÕ

�(§rß���§r�ù�ù§�knàp§¦� %§áÑÎò§n�<O

Page 14: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 3

O÷÷§Øc�C"C�<ѧ1ö�y��¶

16ÚµÀ¥ – @¢þFåû�¿���i§Ñ5é/Ýe~�µB<§B<§

�\�,åU"

�ܤõ�©Æ�¬o�<±Ñ���m"bX§/ÝØ´Ý<§bX§/Ý

�¦·Ø´�ÜU�²§@o§U\�����K§¦½¬�U�úÌ�´§½¬

¤Ò�é{ÐÓ�Ú{¤Z{"�{¤Ò´{¤§§Ø�_="

�¥ÀW¤Ò�´Ó�§=IåV�&Å«ì§|ï[Ì¿«ú[Ìp�g�

ÂÖ"�¥ÀW§S�ã1.2"k<`§́ Ó���´�|Ü�§́ Iåü�<3�

å�Ý�)�Ü�" �¥ÀW�IO§E´L§E /́��¨�0§Ù3y¢­

.¥´Äý¢�3L4<~¦"ù�´�õê<��¿rÙÀ��«iZ��Ï"

aq/§�k©Æ�¬¥�'Éç��|µ£±"

úw F¥ �� �¥ �¥ À¥- - - - -

ã1.2 �¥ÀW§S

�ÃØ´�ïÀW§�´'Éç�§ùÄ�Ñ´�½S�§Ñ´�½S��¢

yI´åg§ù�8Uù��çIækÉ­Óó��"½ö`§8U�çIÝI

´�¥ÀW!'Éç��S��/ªz!Ä�z ®"

@o§�o´çIÝIºçIÝI´�«Å�!�«§SL§½´�«æ5

��|�/ª"ùp§çI�/ç0́ 2 w�Ue<5ë�½´�A§ÝI�/Ý0

´k8I�/�Ñ0§çIÝI¥�/I0́ /8I0½/8�0§q�/I0́ ¤O

/qf0�/Il0"

�¥ÀW¥§/�0Ú/�0́ Ä�§/¥0́ 1N§́ D4/JW0�j�§��

/X0´�¥ÀW�/8I0½/m�0"��/§Î�´�I²dBæ!¯¶!B

3!Bæ!�Ï!�H�8Ü­"aq/§çIÝI¥§/ç0Ú/Ý0́ Ä�§Ö¡

/́1N0§¥I(J /́8I0½/m�0"

��æ��«|�/ª§çIÝIdã1.3¤«8�Ú½|¤µ

çIúw çI©� ÝI mI µI ÜÓÇ�- - - - -

ã1.3 çIÝI§S

11ÚµuÑúw"aqu�¥ÀW§�J`ÀJ¥I<9ÙÁ� uÑ��

���"�d§I3k'x0þuÑçIúw½�À½�d3ÝI<uÑÝI��

Page 15: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

4 çIæÛYFn

Ö§áÚd3ÝI<ë\çI�8��AÚ¿�"�áÚd3ÝI<ë�¿�§ç

Iúw���)çI^�!çI��!¢��m!]��¦!çI©�¼��{!Ý

I©�4����mÚ/:!éX<9éX�ª�SN"

12ÚµuÈçI©�"çI©�´çI<�����?�Ú²(�[z"�

�¥ÀWæ^�½�¤5KØÓ§çIÝII�UçI�8A:ÚI�?�çI©

�±²(J`5K"çI©����)çIúw½ÝI��Ö!ÝI<L�!I�

�ü!ÜÓÌ�^±!EâIOÚ�¦!ã�!µIIOÚ�{ÚÝI©��ª�

SN"

13ÚµÝI"��¥ÀWU�½�¤5K§̄ õ�câd3¢¢eO��F

¥aq§ÝI´½|d3ø�<�AçI!ë�¿���«¬¯1�"ØLù«¬

¯1�´3ÝI���mc3çI©�5½�/:4�Ö¡ÝI©�"ÝI©��

��)ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹!®Idæ�ü½ÝI�d!]�"�]�!I�5

U�I9Á��Y§±9Ù¦]�y²©��"Ó�§�¢yú²¿�§�¦ÝI

æ^�µÝI©���ª?1"

14ÚµmI"mI=U5½§S§�¯ µ§úmÝI©�Ì�SN����

!"�¥ÀW¥§Ý24��*F¥§�*�¯<�F¥§±9=�úf�4F¥

�§Ñ´3¯8JJ�e?1�§®²��¥ÀW�ë�öúm"çIÝI¥§Ï

ÝIæ^�µ�ÝI©�?1§I�/��¥ÀW¥�úm�K§�Éë�<iÒ

±«ú²"ùÒ´çIÝI¥Ú\/mI0§S��Ï"�d§mIL§L�úÙ

3ÝI���mcÂ��ÝI©�4�<§\ÙmIk'ó�<6¶§|�ÝI

©��µu�",�§UçI©�5½^S�¯ µ§úÙÝI<¶¡!ÝI�d!

Á�Ï�§±9çI©�²(úÙ�ÝIÙ¦SN§¿P¹3Y"

15ÚµµI"µIÒ´�¥ÀW¥�*/��m�0½'�§é¢e�câd

m! �Úó!Þ�'�!J`�L§"�¥ÀW¥§ÀW��I?<´@ �

*§Ý23���ïÆ=´ë�§��XØ��Xd�*û½"çIÝI¥§�l;

��ÝÀJ¿J`(½¥I(J§Ó���ù�ÀJL§ú²§±���*�¢

e,úfh¾ª�§Ú\dk'Eâ!²L;[ÚçI<�L|¤�µI�¬

KIéÝI©�?1µ"Ú'��Å�"�¤±Ú\µI�¬µ"§��¡§3

uu�µI;[�;�`³¦�ÀJL§�\�Æ!5�!J`§�,��¡§3

u��Æ!5�/�¤µ"!'�Ú�ÆJ` ØU?Ù�¿u�"�d§�¦µ

I�¬�UUçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§Ù

¢�´µI�¬�âçI<������*¯¢§=çI©�éÝI<ÝI��

*¯¢§=ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"Ny�´çI<½ö�¥ÀW¥��*/x

Page 16: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 5

�çi03çI©�¥�²(�ÀWIO§Ùµ"(J´éÝI(J§=é�ÝI

<J��ÝI©�?1µ"!'��(J"�d§ù�µ"!'�L§���¥À

W¥§�*��<û½F¥��X��Ƨ́ 8N�¦�(¬§Ù(J�ò�k|

uçI<"

16ÚµÜÓÇ�"ÜÓq¡�ê�!�ƧkÖ¡/ª!�Þ/ªÚÙ¦/

ª"���«¬¯{Æ1�§ÜÓ´�¯<�û����Æ"çIÝI¥ÜÓÇ�

�¢�§́ 3k�ÝI(J¥UçI©�úÙ�J`IOÀJ�ÎÜæI¦�¥

I<¿��\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"~X§�¥ÀW¥��*§́ U�½�¤�K(½�4

F¥�úf�´Ó5(<§�Ù5(´Ó"çIÝI¥§µI�¬UçI©�5

½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1�µ"Ú'�§́ UçI<�ÀJ!J`IO

?1�µ"Ú'�"�d§Ø�µI(Ø��ù�OK§µI�¬�¤�µI

�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<Ny�§T´çI<¿ã§�A���çI<J`(½¥

I<§¿��\¾ÜÓ��â½´­�ë�"ùp§çI<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ�8

�§3u3çI©�Ú¥I<4��ÝI©�Ä:þ§æ^Ö¡/ª?�Ú²(�

¯<V���|ÚÂÖ§���)ÜÓ�¯<!I�!êþ!�þ!d±½ö�Å!

Á1Ï�!/:Ú�ª!��I?!�Æ)û��{�¢�5SN"

�¥ÀW¥§�*���ÑF¥§F¥���,úf�4§�*LUS��ù

 úf5(´Ó"aq/§çI<uÑçI����§ÝI<�AçIë�¿�§Î

ÜçI©�5½�J`IO�ѧçI<A��ÙÇ�¥I¿��\¾Ö¡ÜÓ

Ø��¥§ù´¬¯� /́ª¢Å&0�K�Ny"��§�¯<¥���¥KI«

ú�A�¬¯I?"ÖL5ÜiP6�<Ñ��§/Ýv�U�úÌ5(´Ó§=Ù

Ø�l�¥ÀWS���ϧ3u�F¥�@�úÌ´��%§�3�×����

Ì¥wÑ�%�/"US�Ø#N��~<��%¤�§Ï/�%0�éu<�/É

a0§Ø�ÉaÏ´3{¤þ´�õê¬xS�¥���OK§�Û¹´�%"

[�£I] æ§�ü ½�<3�½�ý��å^�e§3øA½|¼�û¬

] §±÷v)�!²E¹Ämн´�<I�����*¹Ä§�)5�ÚÁ�

ü��!§Ùm�´¢yû¬æ"��/§æû¬�µdÏ�§�)û¬�¬

�!d�!Á�OyÚÏ�!Á�Uå!�þÚ�ÜÑÖ�¯�"d§æ�I�

�Äû¬�C!Ô6�^�"

çIæ§́ çIÝIÅ��æ�kÅ(ܧ=35��!Ú\çIÝIÅ

�§|�ÝI<¿�§çI<l¿�(J¥?1J`ÀJ§l ¢yJp²L�Ã!

�y�8�þ�æm�"

Page 17: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

6 çIæÛYFn

12!ÔѵÜÝ�J`

çIæ´æ^çIÝI�ªl] ½|¼�I�Ô§±÷v)�!²EÚ+

n��«²L¹Ä§�)çIÝI5�ÚÁ�ü��!"Ù¥§çIÝI´¢yç

IæÔÑ��¦"@o§�o´ÔѺ�oq´�¦ºÔѧ´�«�¢y�Û

8I�ÙÛ�5y¶�¦§K´)·äk��«Äu)nÚ%nì(�ME5g�

Uå§��Ly�)û¯K�Uå"3�¯þ§/ÔÑ0�c¥�/Ô0�Ôâ½�

ã§/Ñ0�/*Ñ0§́ �¯ò+���è�Ô�*Ñ"

e¡§·�w�wnI�ÏͶ�»9�Ô¥�ÔÑÔâ"

ã1.4 »9�Ôã

[»9�Ô] »9�Ô´¥I�¯¤þ�g±��õ!±f�r�ͶԸ§�

5̀nIüÂ6éùgÔ¸kX�¦�P1"ú�208c7�§ùö²½¿�§Ú��

��§��He§��¨²§½ü4Lgf4p§JÂ4�§½¦4�÷ÇYU�g

���ò%§¦�Ó+ô)§��¨²�§�÷ÇYÚ�ô^ôÀeô���Rò

ôÀ§? Ú��I"ùö�ÔÑÜÝ��Ǩ²Yº�Ìålô)Ñu§÷�ô

�g�?¶Sü�|Yº�§d��Ñu§÷ÇY�g�c?§�¦��ÑÒ�

Hò�ù;§�÷Ò$¦gû�7Åô)§x¹ò�ùö7Å��§Süǹ¥ÿ

Ö-@Í!Çcò�gû�3ÅN��"

¡éù�Àe�%�§��Ú4�(¤é�§|Âùö§ÙÔÑÜÝ����

gÚÇ��Ã�±�üA§·-±Õ!§Ê��m�ÑÒ§Ç��4�¬�§·-

°��7��£§�ÏÊ*üy"Sü±ÕÇn�°W÷�ôÜþ§HÂù�"�

4é���¯ÜÝ´§Süû�Ñ£�X�c¹§��-[w!î�¥J½�!¥

Jò¸�!̈ S�±�!�¯ò���!¿%�£ºÖ!É��£�á�|¤�è§

Yº��ÑÒ±Õ!mÑÒ§Ê!7��£°�§�¯Á��Å�Ò±����§4

Page 18: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 7

��¥§4��<7S3��§4lÇ��{<7Å��§'�Ç�<Y�73g

�§Ü�!ë��ÇoZº�73°ì"

±ÕÇ�����4�¬Ü§÷ôÜþ§�^6Àe�ù�3»9�Ô§ù�

ÐÔ�|§òâ¿�§��4é��ôé�"ù��Ü©�¬´��<§ØS.u

YþºL6½§B^c�òÔEÄ�é(å5§±Õ·�XÀü§æ^�X»ô�

ïƧ̂ �ÀÌé�}§1-�ìá¨���YÆp»"ù�E�=�ϧ<ê�

�k!̀ k�Ãê"��§ù�©Y!ºü´�ô)���ò§4�!±ÕÇWYº

¿?§JÂ�Hg§½¦ùöÇ{Üò£���"ù�Ô¸§r¦/¤�!Þ!Ç

�nI�Û"

æ´�«�*²L1�§ÙL§�±y©�5�ÚÁ�ü�^g�ë��

!§�ã1.5§Ùm�´¢yæ(J"

- -

m© ÜÓ\¾ æ(J

çIÝI5� Á�

ã1.5 çIæ�!

@o§��o`çIÝI´çIæÔÑ��¦ºù�¥§çIæ�ÔÑ´

�o§�¦q´�oº¢Sþ§çIæ�Ôѧ�Ô�¥�Ù��ã¥�ÔÑg�

�Ó§=é¢yçI�8�Û8I?1üy�ÙÛ§±¢yæ(J¶ 3�¦þ§

K´æ^çIÝIÅ�|�d3½|ø�ö=ÝI<¿�§/÷����<�|0

¢yæ(J�`z"

1.çIæÔÑ"çIæÔѧ¿�´�8Á�(J���{üüy§ ´

�¢y�8æ(J§�)ÙXÛ5�ÚN�Á�����L§üy§AO´Á�

üy§Ï�çIæ5�æ^çIÝI�¢�§́ �«ÔÑ��¦"

çIæÔÑ¥��8Á�üy§´çI<�âg�^�é�8Á��üy§

�)ÙJø�Á�^��+n"Ù¢�§́ çI<�â�8A:ÚI�éçI�8

�Á�+n§�)�8��!?Ý!�þ!] !¤^!ºx�+ng´Ú�{§�

��)±e¯�µ

1¤�8��+n"çI�8��=I�§́ |�d3ÝI<5�¿�!?1

ÜÓÇ�!Á��Â��ا±9Ù¦�'+n¯��Ä:"ù�¥§�´çI�

8¿����+n§�´�8��C��+n"

çI�8¿���+n�Ø%§3uæ^Ï1â�!.~915§²(çI�

8Eâ^�Ú>.§==¯�B\çI�8��§ÙEâIOÚ^�´�o§́

Page 19: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

8 çIæÛYFn

ÄO(Ãا�Ù¦�8�>.§AO´çI<½çI<�÷1n<Á� �8õ

UqºX�Ü©¯�§Ù��y©´Ä�ߧ́ Äkk�I�?n�§d§½|

þ´��ø�ö�±ø��´I�õ�ø�öÓ�ø��"

çI�8��C�+n�Ø%§3u�âTa�8A:Ú�U�½|ø�ýÅ

ħJÑ�8��C�+n��{½�K§�)��C�>u^��Å�!�8�

��ª(@�¯�"

2¤�8?Ý+n"�8?Ý+n§́ çI<U�8A:Ú¦^I¦ Oy�§

�¦ÝI<¥IÁ��l�m©!�¤§�)Ù�ã5½p§ !:��mOy!

+n�{§±9N��K½�{§éA�øy�?v�{�¯�"

3¤�8�þ+n"�8�þ+n§́ lçI<�Ý�½�çI�8�þ8I

+n9��Oy§�)�8�þ8I!Sü�g�9­�þiÒ�+n<§æ

^�I[IO!5�!5§§±9AÏ�/æ^�ISIO!5�!5§½´,�A

½�IO!5�!5§§�þ�Â!Ø÷v�þ8I�?n�K½�{§±9�8�

�C��§éA��þ8IN��K½�{�¯�"

4¤�8] +n"�8] +n§́ çI<�â�8A:Úg�¢SG¹§�

�8Á�O��<!á����!ïÓÔ½�ÓÔ!�@��!]7�] ��

�+nOy"���)üÜ©SNµ�´çI<g���¤�85�!Á��<!

ã!Ô�] ��Oy�+n¶�´çI<�ÝI<¥I�Jø��¤½k�¦^

�<!ã!Ô�] ��Oy�] ¦^�{§�)] �ü!] ¦^�¦!§S

9¤^+n�¯�"

5¤�8¤^+n"�8¤^+n�¢�§3u�âçI�8] OySü§é

�8��ó�¤^?1��§±é�8¢�Jøk��]7�æ"Ù¥§çI<g

���¤�8æ¤I�<!á!Ô¤^§IUì�'IO9æ�L§|�k'

;�<ÿ�½��¶ çI<|G¥I<��8¤^§IU�'¤^IO!½|

d�Y²91Eý�?1¤^���+n"7��§�÷Ed!"O�k';�<

O�½¤^+n"

6¤�8ºx+n"�8ºx+n´�ü$çIæºx��³ éçIæ

L§?1�©Û�AéüÑ"5¿§çIædçIÝI5��Á�ü��!�¤"

éA�§çIæ�8knaºxµ�´çIÝI5���{Æ{5½S�!��!

VÆ��¬1�5�ºx¶�´çIæ^�§AO´I�ÔØO(½J`IOØ

J` ���ÝI<¥I�Á�kÅ�¦ºx¶n´�8Á�L§¥Ñy�1�º

x!�£ºx!²Lºx!Eâºx�g,½<�Ï����ºx"çIæ�8

ºx+n�Ø%§3u�âØÓ/«!ØÓ<©�¸ÚçI�8A:§é±þna

Page 20: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 9

ºx¥�UÑy�1�½�/?1k�£OÚ©Û§JÑk�é5��8ºx+�

�Y§±¦ºxE¤�����z"

2.çIÝI�¦"çIæ�¢�§3uu�½|3] ��¥�û½5�^§

`z] ��" |�ïÄ!�½çIæ5�!Á��L§üy�m�§3uæ

^çIÝI¿�Å�`zÁ�L§Úæ(J"��/§��æI¦8I²(!

Eâ^�O(�½|ø�<êõ§çIÝIÅ�Ò�3ÜÓüyÄ:þ§u�Ù¿

��^§çI<3½|ø�ö¥J`ÀJ¿¼�ÂÃ"ù��´çIÝInا=

|�ÝI<éçI�89ÙÁ�¿�§çI<l¥J`ÀJ§(½¥I<¿��\

¾Ö¡ÜÓ§Ï�ù��5§Á�(J3nØþ�½´¤kë�ÝI�ø�ö¥�

�`(J"

�d§çIæÔÑ5y�I�?�Ú²(5�!Á�L§¥§=¯�!̂

�ÝI<7L÷v½�l§=¯�!̂ ��±3�½��S l½ �§��Ñ

��KK�çI�8õU§±9=¯�!̂ �3�yçI�8õUcJeÝI<

�±�Ùg�¢åÝI�A§±u�çIÝIÅ��¿��^"ùnaÏ�½^�§

I�é5�L§ÚçI<Ï"�Á�+n¯�!̂ �!�{§(ÜçIæÔÑÙ

Û�ng(½§éA�;�â�©O�çI�8¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � l

Ï�½�IÚ¿�Ï�½�I"

1¤¢�5�¦Ú^�"¢�5�¦Ú^�´�âçIæÔÑÙÛ§Ø#N

?d�d§ØO�\¾ÜÓ��¥I<!���¦Ù7L�l��¦�^�§I�

¯k²(w�ÝI<§́ ÝI¿��Ä:"éA�§ÝI<ë�çI7L�AçI

�8�¢�5�¦�^�"Ù¥§/�A0�c´�ÝI<�ÝI÷v½öØ�uç

I<�¢�5�¦Ú^�"ÄK§ÙÝIò�Äû"ù�¥§�âçI�8A:Ú

I�Ün(½Ù¢�5�¦Ú^�§́ |�çIÝI¹Ä�cJ§Ï�¢�5�¦

Ú^���XJL°!Ï�Lõ§7,��ÝI¿�§~�æÂö��§XJ�

�LÄ!L�§�lnØþwq¬O\æÂç�k�U¦Q½�8õUÃ{¢

y½´�ªkò��¢y§�´�Ø��"

2¤k� � lÏ�½�I"k� �! lÏ�½�I´�5�!Á�L

§¥N�3�½��S �! l�Ï�½�I§½´N���p �! l�ê§

���ÝIÏ�!�I� �½ l�ÑN���§½´ �! lÏ�½�I

�ÑN���p�ê§ò��K�çI�8õU"�d§�âçI�8A:!I

¦ÚÔÑÙÛ§3(�çI�8õUcJeO(.½N� �! l�Ï�!�I§

©ÛÙ �! lÚu�æÂý��§? �çIæJ`ME^�"k� 

�! lÏ�½�I´çI<ïÄçI�8A:ÚI¦JѧÝI<�A¿¿�§

Page 21: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

10 çIæÛYFn

çI<J`�Ä:§I�±@ýé�"

3¤¿�Ï�½�I"¿�Ï�½�I´�ÝI÷vçI�8¢�5�¦Ú^

�Ä:þ§U�k|u`zæ(J (½�¿�Ï�½�I"��=�éÁ�L

§ÚÁ�(J ��§�)3çI<Jø�Á�^�Ä:þ§ÝIÁ��Y!�{

Ú���`z§±9çI�8N��k� �! lÏ�½�I�`z§d�`z

�"IÚ±5¿�´§ØÓ��{½ó²��Á�(J��þ!d�±9�¤Ï�

k�½�ɧù¢Sþ´3k�ø�¥(½�ª`z�(J§¿vkÚ���{½

J`5K§I�âçIæÔÑÚçI<Ï"¢y�æ8I (½"3êÆþ§

éA��/¡��k�õ8Iûü½J`ÀJ"l÷*�¡w�çIæ§Ù��

¯þ��ÔÜÝaq§́ �«Ôѧ�´�«�¦"�¤±çIæ´�«ÔÑ�

�¦§́ Ï�çIæl��þ´�85�!Á���L§5y§ Ù¥�çIÝ

I5�´�«�¦§́ �«¢yæ(J`z��¦"ù«ÔÑ��¦§́ ±½|

²LN��Ä:§±`z�8æ(J�m�§±ÝI¿��Ãã§́ �«Äuæ

�L§��¦"�d§çI<I�U�8A:ÚI�ïÄÙ5Ƨ?1ÔÑÜÝ"

Ó�§�kÝI<�AçIæÔÑ¿ë�ÝI¿�§çIæÔÑâU¢y"ù

3çI<�ÝI<m§́ �«éáÚ�'X§́ Qk¿�qkÜ��Æ�"éA�§

ÝI<m´¿�'X§́ �«X{�¿�Æ�"ùâ´çIæ�²L¢�§�â

´çIÝIÅ��Ð%���"

[�£I] çI©�úmçIÚ��çI"úmçI§´�çI<±çIúw�

�ª��ØA½�{<½öÙ¦|�ÝI¶��çI§́ �çI<±ÝI��Ö�

�ª��A½�{<½öÙ¦|�ÝI"

13!IOµPºPåkÍX

J`IO§´çI<�3k�ÝI�A��S¼��Zæ(J úmuÙ

�§�3Ú�ÝI§éµIÚÜÓÇ�L§5½��Ó�l�5K"Á¯§5ÜiP6

�¥ÀW�@ U�úÌ%¥kvkÀW/IO0º�,k�ÄK§ù úÌÒج

3/ÝrC¢¢�òÃ¥�F¥��ÙÞþ§Ï�ù U�úÌ´�%b��§Ù

8�´¯/ÝS§́ b/�F¥5(´Ó¯/ÝS"

@o§��oØU��gd½|�ïè1�/��å¿0½ /́wÔeü0Qº

k�Ìéf`�Чþé /́`\1\Ò1\Ø1�10§eé�/`\Ø1\ÒØ

11�Ø10§î1´/ØÑØ10§Ï�¯K�'�3u1�Ø1�IO´�o"

çIæXeæ^gd½|ïè��{§é�U�ï�/è0ïØ�§Ï�çI�

Page 22: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 11

ÝI´çIæÔÑ¥éáÚ���égñ'X§ÝI<Ãl�¡çI<�ï�o

è½´�o��èâÎÜçI<��"

=@£�çI�ÝI´éáÚ�'X�Øv±�ºçIæÔÑ¥/J`I

O0̄ k�3�7�§Ï�´Ó�´éáÚ�'X��3/��¨�0��忧�

·�ÏL©Û��oI<ÊHØ�¿£�å<JÑ�/·Ú\åÓ�Kàp§\k

ÍX0ù�¯K�±��é&"

ã1.6 PºPåkÍX¯K

[PºPåkÍX] XJPºÚPåÓ�K?àp§AkÍXQºAcc§�

��WÏrþr1�K�ù�JKk'��¯§̀ �´� �Æ.�)�²�n

gôO�}��¯"

1�g§́ 3�²�Æ.�Êc�Ù3¯�þ�k¤¤��ÿ"²L� 9%

��*0�§�²�� Ó²4Z�å)��(áôO'X"

ü�����U§å)��¯�²µ/bX·Ú\åÓ�K?àp§\kÍXº0

ù´�²²)�ù�¯9���¯K"(J­mÒ´ù�§ù�o5�o"u´§�

²�2�¦���L¦§UØUØ£�ù�¯K"

/v'X§OX �§\Ò``§v�o'X�"0��S¤¦`"

u´§�²�Xÿf£�µ/XJ\Ú·åÓ�K?Yp§·�,kÍ·å"Ï

�\XJk§·��±2é��"�·�k��å§XJ·åìk§·8)8

­Ò2�vkå"0

���f§�äµ/2é��§�5\%¥��Òvk·"���§�\�)�

­�´· Ø´\å"0�ù±�§ü<2ÃÑ& 5§�²�1�gôO�wª"

���c�m§²<0�§qk� å)��5�¦���¿�Ùïáô

O'X"n±���U§��q��²£�Ó��¯K/bX·Ú\åÓ�K?à

p§\kÍ·�´kÍ\åº0

Page 23: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12 çIæÛYFn

kþg�Ô§�²%�µ/��·åØ3§�fØ�·`�o§Ø�Òz¨÷

¿�`j0"u´£��µ/XJ\Ú·åÓ�K?àp§·�,´kÍ\"0

/��oº0���¯�¯§ X�ú«wX�²Ï��²)º"

/�§·ål�)¹3�ô>þ§¬iY"c��¨��í�±3�ôpi10õ

úpQ�0

��fXù��£�§��ðD�ò�efÒd�=Òµ/\ë\gC�åÑ

Øͧ\��<í�8Ué\Påù�e¤Ã�§²U\Ò�±ù�é·"@X�

cg�\!0ü<��©Ã§�²�1�gôO2gwN"

ügôO�}�²{3�²%nþ/¤ÒK§k�cõ�møXå)r§�

Øc�å)!ôO"���cõ±�§Ù%¥��êÅì²E§²x<0�§�²q

@£å)�ù"ügôO�}��Ô4¦uɧhepÏgXµ��¨¯·/¨

Ú·åÓ�K?àp§kÍX0ù�¯K§·ATNo£�âU4¨÷¿Q?£g

��Ø�Ù{"u´§�²3ü<1�g�>�Ò�¦�{nÙ§�¦�ùØO�

¦ /̄\Ú·åÓ�K?Yp§·kÍX0ù�¯K§̀ /\¯�x¯§·�k�

ج£���0

�ù�f§£��µ/\�%j§·[�ج¯\ù�¯K"·y3ج¯§ò

5�ج¯§�k·�ج¯\ù�¯K�!0

�²�f�U§±�ªu��� vk ²¾�<"(J1�U§x<�@

ÒL5¯¦µ/¢{w�·§\�[vk ²¾¤jº0

�²�fÒ:µ/\[âk ²¾Q�No£¯º0

x<w�¦§�ù@�¦k° ¾"ÄK§Ø¬31�g�Ù�¡Ò�¦¨Ø

�J¯ù�¯K§¿�¥m<=w�²ü<ôO'Xª�"

��où���wq{ü�¯K§�²�£�vk4��!��½�ù¥�?

Û� ÷¿QºÄÙ�ϧ3uù�¯K��Ykn«�U§=/kÍPå0!/k

ÍPº0Ú/X�ØÍ0"�,§��جÀJ/X�ØÍ0ù��Y§Ï�@��

<Ò�Øþ�"�Ø+N�ÀJ§é�²ÀJ(J��ä�3��!��½�ù§

=�k��²�£�ÎÜùå)�JóIO§=e¡n��Y|µ

{��µ��Ï"�Y}!{��µ��Ï"�Y}!{�ùµ�ùÏ"�Y}

���§âU��é�@Ó"ù�´��o�����ÆQ¸rk)ù)5´²�

�¦6)ºù�¯K�§�¦�²£�/\`Qº0=/\ú�kÍX·ÒkÍX0

��Ï"��²Ø��n å)%¥¤�§�UUgC¤�£�/kÍ·å0§ßé

�¤�/kÍ\0§½´3üg�}�/eÀJ/<;0"

ù��¯�<�é&§3u)K��3å)Ã¥"XJr�¯Ì<ú�� �§

Page 24: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 13

~X§4�ùé5n I)�u!�²Ú�À§Ó�§J¯ù�¯K"4n<��Y

�g�µ/kÍ·å0!/kÍ\0½/X�ØÍ0"@o§�ù�½�±l¥ÀJ� 

£��(�I)��¿§Ï�ÀJIO3�ùÃ¥��kùn«�/§ù�´�¥

ÀW¥§¡éõ A�ö�±¤õÀW��Ï"

3çI�ÝIùégñ'X¥§çI<´I¦<!ûü<§ÝI<´ø�<!ë

�<"ÀJX½ØÀJX�û½�3çI<§Ø3ÝI<"ülçI<(½¥I<

¿��\¾ÜÓù��Ý©Û§çI<��I¦<§úÙ½ØúÙÙJ`IOþ�

U½|ø�æ"�XJØúÙJ`IO§Ùæ(J§AO´�½|þQkø�

þØ÷vI¦�§Ã{¢yæ"Ó�§XØúÙæJ`IO§ò4�/�6u

æ<g�é½|�)§Ý§�=�U3ÙÙ£�½|ø�ýæ§(J�U´

3ÙÙ£ø���SJ`"

��oæ<I�úÙJ`IO§�ÏÒ3uçIæÔÑ¥§çIÝIù�

5��¦�Sº§±9u�çI�ÝIéáÚ�'X��^¢yæm�§±�­

�þ¡@��x�O��¯Cõ"

Äk§úÙJ`IOk|u¢yæm�"çI�8�J`IO´çI<�â

çI�8A:ÚI¦§=çI�8ÔÑÜÝ(½�ÀJIO§Ù��¬úÙk|u

áÚ@÷vJ`IO�ø�ö�A§ë�¿�§�k|u@Ø÷væI¦�

ø�öÌÄ£;"/�<�B§�C�B0"çI<UúÙJ`IO�¦ÝI<�

A!ë�¿�§ÝI<UæI¦!J`IOÚÙg�¢åÝI�A§/k��¥0§

/¤çI�ÝIù�éáÚ�'X§? çI<�l¥J`ÀJ§¢yæm�"

Ùg§úÙJ`IOk|uµ"!'�ÚJ`ÀJ"�¥ÀW�û½�3�F

¥@ �*§Ù�â 6u/ú�0½ /́��¨�0�L§ÀWS�¥��c

âdédþ�±%@"�çIæXæ^ù«/��å¿0½´/wÔeü0��

{§�UÃ{¢yæm�§Ï�çIæ�8�)ó§!ÀÔÚÑÖna"Ù¥§

ó§!ÑÖ�æ(J7L��Á�½´Á�(åâ¬Ñy§5����vk/�

¬0½/¢Ô0¶=B´çIæ¥�ÀÔ§Ø�´½|þQká�!��÷væ

I¦§I�\ó!�E�§Ó�vk/�¬0Ú/¢Ô0§ØUæ /̂wÔeü0��

{æ§I�úÙJ`IO§? r¦çI<J`(½æ(J"

2g§úÙJ`IOk|uíÄ�¬Eâ?Ú"Äk§çII¦�Lk?�¬

)�å"½|²L¥§I¦´ø��cJ"ù�¥§/I¦0�<�/Ô�Ú©zI

¦0§¿�´�¤ØC�§ ´���uÐ/FÃO�0�I¦§�LX�¬d��

�"çIÝI§��½|²L¥�«¿��ª§Ùm�3uu�½|3] ��¥

�û½5�^§�{3u|�½|ø�ö¿�§d¿�¢y] �^����Z§

Page 25: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14 çIæÛYFn

d¿�íÄ�¬Eâ?Ú"

�d§çIæÔÑ��¦¥I�çI<²(¿úÙJ`IO§Ï��k²(

J`IO§çIæâk�U¢yæ(J�`z§�kçI<úÙJ`IO§

ÝI�AâU´k��¥§çIÝIù�ÔÑ��¦�âUíÄ�¬Eâ?Ú§�

cuÐ"

[�£I] ò���O��c�\��.ÜS�Óím'�Øß²ç�fp§

,�ÜþXf"c�±3�fpgdrħXJØ�%åÄÓím'§Óí¬é

¯¿÷��Ýf§��c�Ók§�3<�mXfc§Ãl�¡c�)kG¹"Å

½�¯µ@��O��c�.´k�´E,¹XºùҴͶ�Ž��c¯K§

�PºPå¯KÓ�KYpkÍX¯KÓÑ�K§=þfåÆ¥�þfÅ�"

14!Å&µ5��Á�OK

çIæ���«3½|ø�ý�J`ÀJ§Ù(JÉ�´V�1����"

½|�S§́ �´�±¤õ¢y��æ§�){Æ!©z!S�!��ÚVÆ�§Ù

m�3u�o�½�Ï�½|�S§�å�¯<�lg�!²�!ú²Úª¢Å&

��´OK"

�»�Ô�g,{K /́Ô¿UJ§·ö)�§̀ ���0"ÄÔ¥§��ok

�+Ø k�qÕÓôÞºÙ¢�´g,)�§/�~¯�~,�~¯]�0§�Ô�

3=kÙ�n"

ã1.7 �·æ�

[�·�¬�é&] �·´�«¬��+اLX1X¼x)¹�&Á"��·

+k��·�§êZ�<·§2-5��ó·"Ù¥§·�Úó·dÉ°Îu� 5§

<·d�É°�Î[�u� 5§ó·´)�ìu�Ø��_·"

·��?Ö´�ΧÓ�Ú£!+n·+"·���â+NI�§�eÉ°Î

Page 26: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 15

ó·½´�É°Î<·"Ù©���«·�Ô�-��±³�ó·Î�u�§±K

�ó·1�¶<·��I´Ú·���"���§Ù)�ìøá3·�NS§�¤

�)¦· k�¶ó·�N��§Ù�I´Ó�!æ8 �!Õ�rÁ!�n�¿Ú

N!��"d§�úKXÅ¥·�ØÉ'\�"

·+¤�õ!P@½´æ8�s®Øv±�±��·+)��§·+¬gÄ

?1] 2©�§?1©+"d�§ó·KIïE��AÏ�·�§¡���§·�

3���eÉ°Î"r·ÈÑ�§ó·�ÙAÏì�!r�§±¦Ùu�¤�äk

)�Uå�#·�"��§P·�=Ç+�Ü©ó·��,�?|ï��#·+"

�·�Xí�E£gC¤3·+"ØÓ·+��·3�æ��vk+.§�

pmUÚ²�?"�·�ÌÌ� u��·�O�·���§½´+«�/`�

��0§? u)��pme�!�ô�"

�·é<a�é&3u§«xòYI��¬©ó§I�Ü�§�I�Ú²�

?§/�8Ù !�iÙ�0́ «+�±)�Ú�û�Ä�"��§ghÚ�8Úu

�´Ô�ÚÐö§±9�¬�ÃSuÐ"éd§5Ø�6ô��¥kù��ãP1�

fó1©i§=/àµú¯�u�f0§�fé�µ/��!��!II!ff"0ú

�µ/õ.�&X�Ø�!�Ø�!IØI!fØf§�kv§Æ�  Ãº0

ù´�º�fw��¬�S��ã²;{�§̂ 8U�{`§Ò´£n��I

[�Ø%3�¬�S§=�����§���T��¯¶�f����f§¦��

��f��°¶I����I�§���I�T��¯¶�f����f§¦��

��f��°"àµúé�f*:�@�K�/�§̀ XJ"yù«�¬�S§=

BUe÷ 2õqN�§·U¯��í"Ó�§½|�´AkÙ�´�S§ù«�

S=�¯<ÊH@Ó��´1�§½¡��1�5�"çIæ���«�*²L

1�§ÙÔÑ��¦�±¢�§lØmçIÝI½|�´�S��æ"

Å&´<�á���§�´¯�¤Ò��"çIÝI½|�S�Ø%§3uç

I<ÚÝI<m��´ª¢Å/&0§µI�¬9Ù¤�*!ú�/Á1�I§

�Å����"ù�¥�/&0§U5`©)i6�)º /́<ó�&0§=`ý{!

ª¢�/&0§ù´çIÝI½|�´�Ä:"

ùp§·�éçIÝI½|�´Ä:©ÛXeµ

1.çI<Å&µçI<Å&§3uÙçIæ´ýçI Ø´JbçI§́ �

ÙçIæÔÑI� 3½|þ?1J`ÀJ"ù�§çI<Ò¬�âçI�8A

:!Eâ^�Ú5�!Á�I�?1ÔÑÙÛ§(Üg�+n²�ÚY²JÑçI

�8��!?Ý��!�þ+n!] ¦^!¤^��Úºx+ng´!�{Ú�

�"Ó�§?1½|ø�N�§(ÜýÏ�½|¿�§ÝJÑçI�8¢�5�¦

Page 27: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16 çIæÛYFn

Ú^�!k� � lÏ�Ú�I§±9¿�Ï�Ú�I§ïÄ¿JÑ=Ï�Ú

�I�±¿�§¿�(JýÏ´�o§±9µ�¿�(J`���{ÚIO§Ò¬

Ç�ÝI(J�`�ÝI<¥I§��\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§ª&Á� ج`�þl"

A�`§çIæÔÑ"yJ`IO§́ çIÝIr/ª!rL|§tJbçI

����Ï"@o§��oçIæ¢�¥�3�þ�JbçIQº�Ï3u§�

´éçI<çIæÔÑ�Øn)¶�´çI<éçIÝI�¦�Ø�Ù¶n´¥

I©zù<�§çI<?3��??ù<���¬�fp§Ø�¿|�ý�/¿�§

? çIær/ª!rL|§½´`�þl!he�ÝI<Gϱ(�|Ã<¥

I§Ù¢�´JbçI"

�d§çI<�çI�8A:ÚI�§ïÄçI�8Á�§JÑ¿�Ï�!I

OÚ^�|�/ý0çI§́ ¢yçIæÔÑ�cJ"

2.ÝI<Å&µÝI<Å&§3u�Ùg�¢åýÝI Ø´JbÝI"ù�§

Ù¥I�Ò¬�ÙÝI©�9�çI<\¾�Ö¡ÜÓª&Á�"çIÝI´éá

�Ú�§vkçIÒvkÝI"Ó�/§vkÝI§çIÒgX�Ñ�/F¥0Ã<

A�§�Ã<�s§�U\w�}"[Äå5§kn«�/¬���¥ÀW��}µ

�´¢¢þ�F¥��*���Χv<�¿A�¶�´¢ek ��Χ�/E

Ø+<0�A��c§�4F¥§�*vïÙ��Χ§Ø�¿g ¤�¶n´¢

eA���câd��/� /�u0½/��0Ý�§�ûX�Ø�Ã�F¥"�

�§�u½��s�F¥§�*Ø�¿g ¤�"

çI楧ùn«�/ѬÑy"3d©ÛXeµ

1�«�/§=ÃÝI<�A"Ù���ÏE3uçI<?1çIæÔÑÜ

Ý�§é½|ø�ý�N�Ø¿©§½´çIæÔÑÜݤ�¦ø��^���

�§½|þvkø�½´ø�<þØ�¿�A!ë�¿�¤�"éd§çI<I3

½|ø�N��Ä:þ§��8A:ÚI�?1çIæÔÑÜÝ"7��§AO

´�½|ø�êþØv±÷v¿�I��§�±|�¾üæ )û"

1�«�/§=ÝI<wq�AçI�ë�ÝI¿�§�Á��âuyÙÁ

�Uå¢SþØ÷v�¦§Ã{¢yýÏ�æ(J"ÄÙ�ϧ3uÙë�ÝI

��áJ�b¢�¥I"ù«�/§ uæ^Ö¡/ª|�ÝI¿�§=Ùk�*

ÐÝI¿�«�§�Ó�O\ÝI©�Eb��U5"¢�¥§ÝI<áJ�b

¢�¥Ikn«Ly/ªµ�´Ù]�UåØ÷v½|O\5½ Eb"~X§Ý

I<�!�1�§½´ògòÙ$]�yÖU�ÎÜ]��¦�]�yÖ�¶�´

Ùý¢�¹Øv±���Z�µ"(J§ÝI<òg?UÙ�'yÖ!y²á�½

]� Eb"~X§ÝI©�òg?UÙÜÓ�ÆÖ½´?U�'<Á{!]�

Page 28: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 17

yÖ�¶n´�¿$u¤�ë�ÝI¿�§Á��2/�/åd0§±�8Á���

çI</\d0§ÄK§ØÁ�½´ò´Á��"

1n«�/§=ÝI<GÏÝI�/§́ çIæÔÑÜÝ�I�ïÄ�§Ï�

çIæÔÑ�±¤õ¢��cJ´ÝI¿�§çI<dÝI¿�¼�æÂç

ùÒ´çIæÔÑ��¦" ÝI<GÏ1�§é|�T´ÝI¿�§́ ½|�

´¥éçI�Ð��«|溺�¦çIæÔÑ��}"

�d§çIæÔÑ�±¢�§lØmÝI<ý¢�ÝI�A�¿�§Ï��

kÝI<ý¢��AçI§ë�ÝI¿�§çIæÔÑâk�U¢y§çIÝI

�âUý�u�J`��] �û½5�^"

3.µI�¬9Ù¤Å&µµI�¬�Ý´;[\Î�Ý�*Ð�Ö¿§

Ù¢�´�¦Ùl;���ݧUçI<J`IO§=çI©�5½�µIIOÚ

�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§Jѵ"¿�§±�ÏçI<J`(½¥I(J"

5¿§µI�¬¥�Eâ!²L;[�çI<!ÝI<vk|³'X§�üØ5

gçI<½ÝI<�Ø��Z6§�*!ú�/éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§ù3

<��éß��¬¨�¥cÙI�"ùp§/�*0́ �±ÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�1

²�SN?1µ"Ú'�§/ú�0́ �æ^çI<úÙ�J`IO§=çI©�5

½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"l §µI�¬9Ù¤u

�;�`³§�*!ú�/UçI<úÙ�J`IOéÝI©�µ"!'�¿J`

í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<§́ (�çIæÔÑ�±¢���«;��Eâ�æ"

nþ¤ã§çIæÔÑ�±¢���¬Ä:´ª¢Å&"�d§çI<!Ý

I<ÚµI�¬9Ù¤§L±/ª¢Å&0�ë�çIÝI¹Ä�cJ§Ï�

ù´u�½|3] ��¥�û½5�^§=½|¿��Ä:"

15!Y~µ�N'�Eâëê�µ"�'�

µI�¬´çI<�â�8µIA:ÚI�|ï�§Ç�ÙéÝI©�µ

"!'�¿�çI<J�µI(ا=µI�wÚí�Ü�¥IÿÀ<���;�

�¬"5�þ§µI�¬�;[\Î�¬aq�qØÓ§=µI�¬�U

UçI<úÙ�çI¯¢éÝI¯¢?1µ"Ú'�§�¤µI�w"ù«5K§

�åµI�¬Ã�?UJ`IO§�Ã�3ÝI���m��ÉÝI<4��

ÝI©�§�)éÙéÝI�N��?U"

3d§·�©Ûe¡ù�Y~±�ºµI�¬�µ"!'��I"

[Y�£�] 2009c9�§,½�?æ¥%æ^úmçI�ª§�T½,úá�

Page 29: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18 çIæÛYFn

�UE¥�¾�¢ó§æ�N��"²Lµ"Ú'�§µI�¬�¤µI�

w§¿í�ÝI<A!B!C©O�1�!1�Ú1n¥IÿÀ<"

(½¥I<c§æ¥%|�k';�<éÝI©�´Ä�AçI©��¢

�5�¦Ú^�?1"�§uyÝI<AéçI©�Eâ5�Ö¥ü��(Òëê

vkJ�y²á�y²Ù÷v�¦§ Ù¦ÝI<�ÝIþ÷v�¦"u´§æ

¥%ð£µI�¬¤k¤éµI�w(Ø?12g(@"

µI�¬¤�|�§k;[JѧQ,ùü��(Ò�ëêk��ûuÿ§

k��ûØÿ§ÒØATòùü�ëê��'�ëê§ïÆ�±�µI(ضæ

<�L@�§Q,çI©�¥òùü�ëêIþ(Ò§ÝI<�ÝIÒA�3÷

v�¦�Ä:þâUë�¿�"��A�(@ÝI<A÷vùü�(Òëê��¦

âUí�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<"�d§µI�¬��Ó¿,ÒÝI<A´Ä÷vç

I©�Eâ5�Ö¥ùü�(Òëê�¦§�ÝI<AuÑÖ¡©�!̀ ²�¦"

ÝI<A��L35½�mS§��çI©�9ÙÝI©�!�'á���µ

I�¬�½¬Æ¿"µI�¬KI<<åÝI<A�ÝI©�§�ÙJ¯/ç

I©�Eâ5�Ö¥��k15��*Ò�ëê"Ù¥§168�þ13!14ùü�(Ò

ëê§��o\��ÝI©�¥vká�y²\�ÝI��N÷vùü�(Òëê

�¦º@o§\�ÝI��N�.÷v�´Ø÷vùü�(Òëê�¦º0

ÝI<A��L�mçI©�168�§w���µ/�§ùü�ëêB§·�l

5Øuÿ"ØL\����%§·���N�½÷vùü�(Òëê��¦"·8

U£��pÒSü¢�ÿùü��I��§,���æ¥%"0

µI�¬¤r�§æ¥%+�!?¿Ì+Ú�8KI<?ا@�ÝI

<A3ÝIc¿Ø�¡ÙÝI��N´Ä÷vùü�(Òëê�¦§���2gu

ÿ§Ø÷v¥I^�§ØU(½Ù���8¥I<"u´§1�U�ÝI<BuÑ¥

IÏ�Ö§�¦Ù310FS�çI<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"�dÓ�§1�UeÌ4:00§Ý

I<A��Lx5Ù¤ÝI�N�ùü�(ÒëêÿÁ�§y²ÙÝI��N÷v

çI©�Eâ5�Ö¥éü�(Òëê��¦"

fªæ¥%®\ÙÝI<B¥I§ÝI<A�æ¥%JÑ�¦"Ó�§Ù

3��äxN!���x0þuÑ�E§��æ¥%�ÝI<BGϧ(¡Ù3�

�8ÝI¥Â�Øú²��"Ù�¦¯�93k'xNþ���ndkü�µ�

´Ù®�µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<¶�´ÙÝI�d'ÝI<B$42.30�"

�¦æ¥%§��oµI�¬²µ"í��1�¥IÿÀ<v¥I§ ´ü¶

1��¥IÿÀ<¥Iº�?æ�K /́$d`k0§�gçI��od�$�v

¥I ´d�p�¥Iº

Page 30: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

11ÙçIæµÔÑ��¦ 19

�Y3xNþu�§Ù?Ø��Æ��±Y�2010c6�.§Ù�Æ�:8¥

3ÝI<A´ÄA�3�çI�8¥I"|±ÝI<A¥I�<@�§ÝI<A´µ

I�¬í��1�ÿÀ<§ÙÝI��N²uÿ÷vçI©�Eâ5�Ö¥�¤

k�¦§Ø(½ÝI<A¥IØÎÜæJ`��K¶�éÝI<A¥I�<@�§

ÝI<Av3ÝI©�¥y²ÙÝI��N÷vçI©�Eâ5�Ö¥�ü��(

Ò�ëê�¦§ØÎÜçI©�5½�J`IOÚ�¦§X(½Ù¥I��ú²¿

��K§Ï�Ù¦ÝI<þ3ÝI©�¥J�y²á� ÕÕÝI<AvJ�"

[¯K] �é�çI�8§?رen�¯Kµ

1.µI�¬�µI1�´Ä�(§Ùí��¥IÿÀ<´ÄÜ�º

2.æ¥%(½ÝI<B¥I´Ä�(º��oº

3.æ¥%|���8çIÝI¹Äk=�اqk=�Ôº

[Y~©Û] Äk§·�I�©ÛçIÝI¹Ä¥§��o���µI�!§q

��o�|ïµI�¬éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§ù�Å�´Ø´�öçI

<3çIæ¥�J`ÀJ�¯K"µI´��µ"!'�L§§ÙØ%3uéÝ

I¯¢§=ÝI©�?1µ"'�§? J`§��¥ÀW¥�JWL§aq"k'

�â¬k�O"�¥ÀW¥§JW'�´d�F¥@ �*ÚÝ2?1'�§F¥

��Xd�*gCû½§>þ�Ý2�õ�´ïÆ"Ó�/§çIÝI¹Ä¥�µ

I§́ éÝI(J�µ"Ú'�§Ï��k²dµ"Ú�p'�§âU�ÑÝI(

J�`�§çI<�âUl¥J`ÀJ§(½¥I(JÚ¥I<"Ù��¥ÀW�

�ɧÌ�Ly3µI´�Ö¡ÝI¯¢?1µ"Ú'�§3�Ö¡µ"P¹§

�¥ÀW¥�*ÚÝ2�µ"Ú'�§�õ�§́ �â¢eA��c�L§J�

k/.J�0À���/¶@o§��o�|ïµI�¬éÝI©�?1µ"Ú

'�§ù´Ä�öçI<�J`�Qº�Y´Ä½��Ï�§µI�¬´çI

<|ï�§Ùµ"!'�´�âçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1

µ"Ú'�§́ UçI<3çI©�¥úm�J`IO?1�µ"Ú'�§Ù�¤

�µI(JA�´çI<J`¿��;�Ny"Ó�§µI�¬�ÝI<vk|

³'X§µI(J�Ù¦�ª�*�ú�§Ùí��1�¥IÿÀ<�ÝI��ü

¶3Ùg�Ù¦ÝI�/`0§́ çI<J`¿��;�Ny§7,k|uçI<¢

yÙçIæÔÑ"ùÒ´��oçIÝIÅ�¥§�¦µIdçI<|ïµI�

¬KI��ϧÏ�ù��Å���Æ"

5¿§ù«µIÅ�k|uçI<¢yçIæÔÑ�cJ§́ µI�¬U

çI<úÙ�J`IO§=çI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI¯¢§=ÝI

©�?1µ"Ú'�§Ùí��¥IÿÀ<Ü�¶��§ÙµI(JKØU�Ï

Page 31: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

20 çIæÛYFn

çI<J`(½¥I(J§�ØUk�r¦çIæÔÑ�¢y§ù´çIÝI¹

ÄA��Ì���Ä�OK"

á�µI�¬9µI��Ý��§·��±£�þ¡n�¯K"

1.T�8µI�¬1�Ø�("��oùo`Q§Ï�µI�Ý�O¥§µ

I�¬´UçI<�J`IO§=çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©

�?1µ"Ú'�§ �YÝI<A�ÝI©�§éçI©�Eâ5�Ö¥�1²

��(Òëê§kü�vk3ÝI©�¥Jøy²á�"d�§µI�¬�½Ý

I<AÝI��N÷vùü�(Òëê�¦§¿í�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<vk¯¢

�â§��UçI¯¢§=çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI¯¢§=

ÝI©�µ"!'��Ä�5K"5¿§ÝI<A�ÝIduéçI©�Eâ5�

Ö¥�(ÒëêvkJøy²á�§ØUÀ�Ù�AçI"ùp§/�A0�¹Â

´²(�A§¿^¯¢á��y²"ÝI<A��L3µI�¬�¦Ù©�!`

²�§²(£�/ùü�ëêB§·�l5Øuÿ0§<yÝI<AgC¿Ø�Ù

ÙÝI��N´Ä÷vùü��(Òëê��¦"�,§ÝI<A ��3ÙÿÁ¥

y²¤ÝI��N÷vùü��(Òëê��¦§�d�ÝI®²��§Ù4�

�ÿÁ�wØU��ÙÝI¯¢ë�µ"Ú'�"�d§ÝI<A�ÝIvk�A

çI©��¢�5�¦Ú^�§ØÜ�§A�éÙÝI�±Äû"

2.æ¥%(½ÝI<B¥I��â´µI�¬í�ÝI<A!B!C�1

�!1�Ú1n¥IÿÀ<", §ÝI<A�ÝIvk�AçI©��¢�5�

¦Ú^�L²§µI�¬�¤�µI�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<ØÜ�"d�§æ

¥%(½ÝI<B¥I§¢Sþ´�â��Ø�(�µI(Ø(½�§Ó�Ø�

(§ØÎÜçIæJ`�Ä�5K"

3.|���8çIÝI¹Ä§æ¥%�3n�Ì�¯Kµ�´éµI�¬

�Ý9Ù�^n)�¹·¶�´"yéµIL§���ÚiÒ¶n´}�çI<�

�§òg(½¥I<"�Y¥§æ¥%uy1�¥IÿÀ<ÝI<A�ÝIØÎ

ÜçI©�¢�5�¦�cJe§A��¦µI�¬­#J��(�µI�w¿

í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"7��§X��8µI�¬j±C�§ØUæ¥%�

¦éÙ�Ø�µI(Ø?1��§3��iÒÜ�Ó¿�cJe§æ¥%�±­

#|ïµI�¬?1µ"Ú'�§�¦Ù�Ñ�(�µI(J¿í�Ü��¥I

ÿÀ<"3dÄ:þ§æ¥%âU�âµI�¬�¤�Ö¡µI�wÚí��

¥IÿÀ<J`(½¥I(J"

Page 32: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 2Ù

çIæµÁ��¿�

**********************************************************************

�þ�5ªúf§ý�d¯�ù1

— Hy.ºi5Á�ÖÖ«f�6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 33: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

22 çIæÛYFn

11!¿�µÁ��5��y

5�¿��8�´Á�`z§±¢yæ(J`z"@o§4d3ÝI<¿�

�o§Ù¿��Ï�½�I´�o§µ��IOq´�o�æҴ|�çIÝI

¹Ä�Ø%"3ù�L§¥§çI<(½¥I(J§�¥I<\¾ÜÓ´ÝI¿�

¤J�Ö¡Ny"I�Ú±5¿�´§çIÝI¿��1N´Ö¡§=çI©�Ú

ÝI©�§¿�½|þ��¤�¤��§XÚj!Ìè�¢Ôæ§ÙÐ?3u/x

�çi0�1²æI¦Ú�A^�!«ì¯�§kâ��§���3":�kU

Øv"AO´§Á��½|ø�^�u)Cz§¥I<Ã{«ÉÙÁ�����Æ

Ö¥qv�Ñ?n�{½�K§çI<ØU½´Ø�«ú�A��¤^�§4´E

¤¥I<e¤ÜÓ§Ø2Á�"d�§çI<��±UìÜÓ�½?1¢�§�K

��§́ çIæ(JÃ{¢y§�¦çIæ�}"

e¡ù�G¬æ¯�§=´¥I<Ï��Ã{«É ØÁ��~f"

[G¬æ�ƪ�¯�] 2000c5�§,¯�ü æ5�6t�-íG¬§±O

�ÙG¬�¥�5�-uG¬§�AI[�í�¸£n�¦"T�8�÷,çIú

i�n§|�çIÝI¹Ä§,�Oü �éG¬�ø9¡ÈÚ�'I¦§JÑE

â5�Ö"

T�8çIúw3I[�½x0uÙ�§�k6�ÝI<ïçI©�§ë�

ÝI"Ù¥§ÝI<A´{I,G¬�Eû�IS�nû§ÙÝI�d�20.00�

�/�§od�100.00��"²µI�¬µ"Ú'�§í�ÝI<A�1�¥Iÿ

À<"��§çI<(½ÝI<A¥I§�ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§¿�Ù\¾G¬æ

�ÆÖ"

��§�nû�L<X\¾Ò�ÜÓ�ÆÖ� {I§�G¬�e¾ü"(J§

��Ò3Ù� {I��U§G¬�Ï�Ù�¥¤k�nû§Ù¥I.Ò�G¬

Ñ�dd16.00��/�N��20.00��/�"��ù��E§�nû�L3{Iv

cõ�Ê3§áê¾Å¦�£IS§¿u£I�1�U`�T¯�ü §ò{I�

EûN�ÙG¬�¥Ñ�d�¯w���ÑÖ?�§�ÙûƧ�¦V�2\¾�

�Ö¿�ƧrÙ¥IG¬�d�d20.00��/�N��24.00��/�§¥Iod

N��120.00��"

T��ÑÖ?�3�Y@¥é�V�\¾�5G¬æ�ÆÖ6§c[ïÄ�

Page 34: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 23

ÆÖ��^±�w�T�nû�L§¦�<éÓ��nû�;�§��âÜÓ�½

ù«�/ØU\¾Ö¿�ÆN�ÜÓd�§Ï��¯<V�\¾�5G¬æ�Æ

Ö61²´�½odÜÓ"Ó�§ÜÓC�^±²(�½§ÜÓ�1Ïm�½|d

�ÅÄd¯�§=¥I<g1«ú"�d§�âÜÓ�½§�nûLòù5�6t-í

G¬39�30Fcx�SCy|§±�yÁÏøæ"��ûÃJ§�nû�L¡�£

ü �k'KI<®�!ïÄTÜÓ�2w�Ùû½"

1�U§¥I<�T¯�ü x��°Ö¡¼�§²(L«ª�Á1TæÜ

Ó"Ó�§«ìÙ®�çI<�B�2��Á��y7ÃIò�§±��çI<��

��Ö"

A�`§ùa¯�´æ¥²~u)�¯�"½|¿�¥§ÝI<ÝI�m�

´J|§¼�Ù²EÂÃ"��5`§éu½|d���NÅħ¥I<ج�¦

çI<N�ÜÓd�"���½|d�þÞ�¥I<Øv±«É�§¬�¦çI<

�AÞd±(�ÙÂÃ Ø /́��?=Õ0§ù´¥I<©�¸e§ÝI<ë�½

|¿��ÊH%nG��5ƧÏ�Á��Ø%3u¥I<"

k<@�§G¬æ�ƪ�ù�¯���Ï3u�nûØùª&"ù«*:

´¡¡�§k³uçIÝIÅ��uÐ"çI<[�ØU@�|�ÝI<¿��8

�´4¥I<�� ü´çI<l¥¼�ÂçÏ�ù�1¯�(Jk�½|�´

�ú²�K§Ø�U�)��Ð�Á�(J"

@o§çI<ÚÝI<´�o'XºçIæqAN�?1ÔÑÜÝQº

1.çI�ÝI"çI�ÝIwqé᧢K�p��"3²LÆþ§çI�¥

I /́I¦0�/ø�0'X"Ù¥§çI<´I¦ö§¥I<´ø�ö§�ö�â

çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§¥I<UV�\¾�ÜÓª¢Å&�

Á�§�¤çI�8"5¿§ù�¥�¥I<§́ ²LÝI¿���Ñ�ÝI<"�

d§çI<Ú¥I<�'X /́Ü��I0½¡��Ü�Æ�"@o§çI<�ÝI

<�'Xq´�oºÝI<ë�ÝI¿��8�´�¥I§=�¤çI�8§þ�

U´çI<ÀJ�ÜÓÁ1ö"

çI<�âçI�8A:ÚÁ�I�uÑçIúw§u�çI©�§û½ç

IÝI5��§çI<´Ì� ÝI<´�A!láÚë��'X"XØU�(w

�çI�ÝI�Fy'X§ù«Ì�/ 4´¦çI<ülg��ÝJÑk�½|

5Æ��¦½^�4ÝI<�A"î­�§́ Ù3çI©�½\¾�ÜÓ�ÆÖ¥

Ñy/u�^±0½/ز�^�0¶Øî­�§́ ÑyÝI<¥I�ØU½´Ø�

¿Á� �¦çIæ�}"

@o§��o3ÝIL§¥§ÝI<=BuyçIúw½çI©�¥�3u�

Page 35: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

24 çIæÛYFn

^±!ز�^�§$��{^±��õج|ƽÝ�!Þ�QºÏ�ÝI�Ø

%3u¿�"ù�§U¥I<�S�§ÝI<��3¿�¥�ѧÄk´ØU��

çI<§I�?ÐçI<" 3¥I<�g�¥§/�ÃØ��ò<0§�k<U

�ÉO<�Ñ�Ù":½´�Ø"ÝI<�d¥�_ŧ�,ج3ÝIL§¥

éçI<uÑ�çIúw½çI©�/]nyo0"XçI^����§ÝI<�

�±ØÝI§Ø¬k��"d§�­��§3uÁ�´¥I<Á�§3u¥I<´

Á�Ì� çI<´lá"XJçI©�½\¾�ÜÓ�ÆÖ¥�3/u�^±0

½/ز�^�0§�'^±þÃ�§Øäk{Æ�å"�¥I<E¤���§¥I

<��±�çI<¢�"AO´§�¦¥I<Á�ØU½´éÙÁ�E¤­���

�§�þ¡G¬æ�ƪ�¯�aq§¥I<��±UÙ/�����K0 Ê

�Á�§�ªÉ��³�§E´çI<gC"

¤±§�(@£çI�ÝI�Fy'X§́ çI<?1çIæÔÑÜݧæ

^çIÝI�¦`zçI�8�Ä:"ù�¥§çI<´Ì�§́ Ø%§I�(Ü

½|ø�¢SÚ¥I�<©�¸§�Æ5yÚÚÊSü"

2.¿��Ü�"çI<Ú¥I<\¾ÜÓ�´�o'XºI��òÜÓV�

�'X.½�/º�'X0£Partnership¤§=V�3�p&?Ä:þ§�¢y�Ó

8I æ�ºx�ú!|Ã����«Ü�'X"IS��òÜÓV�'X.½�

{Æ/ ²�§¿(ܬ¯¹Ä/g�!ú²!�dk�!ª¢&^0��K?1

n)"¢Sþ§ÃØn)¤º�'X�´n)¤{Æ/ ²�'X§ÙØ%3uX

Ûr¦�¯<3Á�L§¥@£V�3/ºx�ú!|Ã��08Ie�Ü�'X"

ù�:§̂ V[©z/;!Â!r!�!&0¥/;0�g�.½��ß"��¡§I

/ù;Â0§=3�,�<�?�§U��KUÚ�¶,��¡§I/ù´0§=� 

g�§�¯ØU1�gC§���?/�é�X�§/�<K�C0"ù«/;0�g

�§T´U¥I<g�n)çI<�¥I<½´2Â�§çI<�ÝI<�m�Ü

�'X§¢yçIæÔÑ�­�Þ�"

UÜÓd�/�©a§ÜÓk�½d!�NdÚ¤�\Å7�n«a.§çI

æL§¥§çI<�¥I<UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�\¾�ÜÓäN´=

�«§�wçI©�5½§Ï�d��ÜÓd�1u¥I<�ÝI©�¥§́ �½

d§�)�½üdÚ�½od§́ �Nd�´¤�\Å7ÜÓ§çI©�¥�ÜÓ

^�¥¬²(.½"

ùpI�?Ø�¯K´§=BçI©�ÀJ��½dÜÓ§́ ÄÜÓ�1¥d

�Ò´�¤ØC�º�Y´Ø�½�¯K�'�3uçI©�1²�½´V�\¾

��ÆÖ¥1²�/ÜÓC�^�0¥��/´Äu)§́ ÄÑy"ÜÓÁ1�X

Page 36: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 25

JÑyÜÓC�^�¥�½��/�K�ÜÓd��§�ìÜÓ�½§ÒI�N

�ÜÓd�¶��§KÃIN�ÜÓd�"Ù¥§{Æ{5CzK�ÜÓd��§�

�þIN�ÜÓd�¶ÔdY²ÅÄ´ÄN�ÜÓd�§KIwÜÓC�^�¥´

ÄòÙB\ÜÓC�^�"�d§ýé��½dÜÓ3IS4�§ ¢�¥§�

õ´�NdÜÓ½´¤�\Å7ÜÓ"

@o§þ¡G¬æ�ƪ�¯�¥çI<�æÔÑ�3�o/�º�3ç

I<�Ø/n)�½dÜÓ§±���ÀJ�½dÜÓ§ÜÓÁ1¥��«d�

þÞI?8¥I<«ú"A�`§ù«g�3çIæÔÑþ´�Ø�§Ï�Ùv

UUV[©z/;0�g��n)çI<�¥I<�'X"l §3½|Ôd�Ì

þÞ§¥I<Ã{«É�§Úu��U´½|²L�¨v§=çIæ�}"�(

��{´§çI<A3çI©�ÜÓ^�¥ò½|ÔdÅIJ(�ÜÓC�^�¥

��«�/"~X§çI©�¥²(/Ì�á�!��d�ÅÄ3ÝI�d?5%S

�Ø�N�¶�Ñ?5%�§�ÑÜ©�d�O\ÜÓd0ÒQUr¦ÝI<¿�§

qØ�u3½|d�ÅÄ�Ñ¥I<«ÉUå�Ê�Á�"

ù�¯��<��é&3u§çIæÔÑØU�8A:ÚI�?1Üݧ

�I(ܽ|ø�G¹!¥I<Á�¢�Ú�UpuÊ�Á���/?1ÜÝ"�

d§��(rº¿��Ü��'X§¿��kݧ�±/ºx�ú!|Ã��0�k

�§Ï�çIæ�m�3u¢yçI�8"

[�£I] Æ�´3�<½õ<²��éÛ§|^é�üÑC�gCé|üѧ

�Ñk|ugCûü��«n51�§©Ü�Æ�Ú¿�Æ�"Ü�Æ�§�ë�

ölg�|ÃÑu�Ù¦ë�ö!��¤�Ƨ¤�(Jéé��þk|¶¿�Æ

�´�ë�ö31ÄÀJ�Ã{�¤�å5�Ƨ�UÏL¿�?1Æ�"çIæ

´�«Æ�"��/§çI<�¥I<m´Ü�Æ�§ÝI<m´¿�Æ�"

12!��µÜÓ¾á��å

ÜÓ´�¯<�û���¿gL«, kÖ¡/ª!�Þ/ª½öÙ¦/ª"Ù

¥§Ö¡/ª�)ÜÓÖ!&�!>�!>D!Dý��±k//Ly¤1SN�/

ª"±>fêâ��!>fe���ªUk//Ly¤1SN§¿�±��N�

�^�êâ>©§À�Ö¡/ª"çIæ¥�ÜÓ�{æ^Ö¡/ª§UçI¯

¢§=çI<�çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI¯¢§=ÙÝI©�\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§±�

å�¯<Á�1�"çIÝI¹Ä¥§çI<uÑçIúw§́ F"¦<�gCu

ѾáÜÓ�¿gL«§çI©�´çIúwk'¯��?�Ú[z�`²¶ÝI

Page 37: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

26 çIæÛYFn

<4��ÝI©�§́ F"ÚçI<¾áÜÓ�¿gL«§T¿gL«SNäN(

½§���çI<�ɧ¥I<=ÉT¿gL«��å"

çIæÜÓ¾á�§çI<�¥I<´Ä�±ÒÜÓ¥�¯�?�Úû

Æ!Ö¿!?U½ö�õ§́ Ä�±C�çI�8��½´?U¥Id�ºe¡§·

�kw��¢S�çIæ5�¯�§2?1©Û"

[�ï�Ö¢5���¯] 2003c8�§,IkÑC\óè�æ^úmçI�ª§

(½Ù�ï�Ö¢ó§��óo«�ü "T�8k8[�óè��AçI§ë�

ÝI¿�"²µI�¬UçI©�5½�IOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1XÚ/µ

"Ú'�§µI�¬í�ÝI<A�1�¥IÿÀ<"

çI<�¥I<A?1ÜÓ!�L§¥§�¦òÙ¥I��¤¹�è�m�!

ç�gIÚ¡�Y�n�ó§£ÑÜÓ��§UdçI<,1u�§±BuÀJ

�;��è�«@§�y�8�þ"¥I<AØÓ¿§@�ÙÝI�d2130.00��§

38[ÝIè�¥�$§XJ2rè�m�!ç�gIÚ¡�Yó§£ÑÜÓ�

�§ÙÜÓÁ1(J�½´º�"�d§çI<Ó¿�Ö¥I<A�º�¤^§�c

J´¥I<AÓ¿ùn�;�ó§£ÑÜÓ��§Ó�§�¦¥I<A33FSJÑ

I��Ö�¤^"

Uì�m�¦§¥I<A�çI<Ñä�°Ö¡©�§Ó¿3¥I��¥§ò

è�m�!ç�gIÚ¡�Y�n�ó§UdçI<,1u�§3Ù¥Id¥Ø

~�A¤^"Ó�§�¦çI<�ÖÙddE¤���¤200.00��"çI<|�

k'�Ö<éÝI©�¥��d©�ïħ@�ÙÝI©�1²�è�ó§�d

�36.00�§Â¡�Yó§34.00�§ç�gI9SCó§80.00�§ÜO�150.00�"

ÝI<A¢����¤^200.00�§��uÙ3¥IdÄ:þõ�50.00��§ç

I<I3ÜÓÁ1��Ù|G2180.00��§'Ù¥Id�p"

�d§çI<�¥I<AÒn�;�ó§£ÑÙÜÓ�����Ö¤^?1õ

Ó!�"��§V���Ó¿§¥I��¥�è�m�!ç�gIÚ¡�Yó§

£ÑÜÓ��§dçI<,1u�"Ó�§çI<�Ö¥I<AddE¤���¤

^100.00��§¿UÙ�û���¿�\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"

ù�¯�¥§çI<�¥I<\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§QUC¥I��§qUC

¥Id�§�Ï~<�ÜÓ¾á1��Î"@o§çIæÜÓ¾á�§́ Ä�½

|ïè���±?d�d§���¯<�û��Ò�±º

ÜÓ§́ �¯<�û���¿gL«§ÙSN���)�¯<¶¡Ú4¤!Ü

Ó��!�þIO!d±!Á1Ï�!/:Ú�ª!ÜÓC�^�!��!¢���

Æ�¯�"5¥u<¬�ÚI¬{;6£±�{¡5¬{;6¤ÜÓ?1ozÔ��

Page 38: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 27

^5½§�¯<¾áÜÓ�§�±æ���!«ì�ª½öÙ¦�ª¶ÜÓ?1o

zÔ��^5½§��´F"�¦<¾áÜÓ�¿gL«§²(T¿gL«A�Î

Üe�5½µ�´SNäN(½¶�´L²²É��<«ì§��<=ÉT¿gL

«�å¶5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozÔ�n^5½§����´F"¦<�gCuÑ�

��L«§Ù¥§AO5½çIúw!ç�`²Ö������¶ÜÓ?1oz

Ô�Ê^5½§«ì´É��<Ó¿���¿gL«"

@o§çIÝI¹Ä¥§�o´��§�oq´«ìQºU5¬{;6ÜÓ?é

��!«ì�.½§ÝI<4��ÝI©�÷vSNäN(½§�çI<�ÉÙÝ

I§ÝI<=ÉÙÝI©�¿gL«��å"�d§ÝI<�ÝIÎÜ5¬{;6Ü

Ó?é���.½§́ ��"Ó�§çI<uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö§́ çI<�ÉÝI§

=���¿gL«§�«ì"�d§Uì5¬{;6ÜÓ?�5½§çIÝI¹Ä/

¤�ÜÓ§́ ¥I<�ÝIÚçI<uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö§����!��«ì�¤

�ÜÓ"

5¿§5¬{;6ÜÓ?¥�/��0�±��!#��!2��/?1õg�

«ì§=Ó¿���¿gL«�k�g"Ó�§��<!���<��Ú!/ �

�±=�"~X§èà3½|�xèæ>þá��ýf§þ¡�X/1.2�/60́

��§Ù��<´èà§���<´ïÌ"ï̯èà/z68fñØñ0́ #��"

d�§��<´ï̧���<´èà"èà£�/sXý%�ï§z61�ñ�s0

´2��"ïÌ /̀Ч�·¡ü�0́ «ì§=Uz61��d�ïü��xè"

ùp§I�?Ø�¯K´§çIÝI´Ä�gd½|þñxè��§�±õg

��Qº�Y´Ä½��Ù�Ï3uÝI /́�µ0ÝI§k��²(�/ÝI��

�m0§=ÝII��lÚ�����m§½¡��´x��m§Ù¹Â´3ÝI

���m�§çI<�±�mÝI<�µ4��ÝI©�§=ÝI�������

<§m©)�§�Ø2#N�Âd�x��ÝI©�"ÄK§éXÏx�ÝI©�

�ÝI<Øú²§��ú²�´�Ä�OK"�d§çIÝI¹Ä¥§���k�

g§=ÝI<3ÝI���mc4�����£�ÝI©�§���<©ª´ÝI

<§���<©ª´çI<"çI<!ÝI<ù«��!���'X§û½çIÝ

IÅ�/¤�ÜÓ§́ ¥IÏ�Ö�¥I<�ÝI©��¤�ÜÓ§=çI<�¥

I<�ÜÓ'X¤á"

@o§́ Ä�±�¦çI<�¥I<U¥IÏ�ÖÚ¥I<J��ÝI©�\

¾Ö¡ÜÓQº�,ØUù�{ü/@ 5̂¬{;6ÜÓ?5½ I�(ÜçIÝ

I5�A:§lXÛ�k|u�o�¯<�Ü{�ç±9I[|ÃÚ�¬ú�|

Ã?1©Û"

Page 39: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

28 çIæÛYFn

çIæÔÑÜÝ¥§çI<úÙ�çI�8^�§©�¢�5�¦Ú^�!

k� � lÏ�½�IÚ¿�Ï�½�I�3a"UçIÝI5K§¥I<�Ý

IA�´�AçI�8¢�5�¦Ú^��ÝI§́ UÙg�¢åÚçI�8�¦

J`(½�ÝI§ÙÁ�(JA�ÎÜçIæÔÑÜÝ"�ÜÓ¾á���3u

ÜÓV�ºx�ú!|Ã��§���¦ÙI"X{ü@ 5̂¬{;6ÜÓ?éÜ

Ó�5½§�¦çI<�¥I<U¥IÏ�ÖÚ¥I<J��ÝI©�\¾Ö¡Ü

Ó§éuÁ�L§ü�§çI<=I/�Ã�a!�Ã<À0��´�8�1¶�é

u�éE,��8§AO´I�¥I<�çI<�¦ÙI�çI�8KØ�1§Ï

�¥I<�ÝIØ�½��ÎÜçI<3çI©�¥úÙ��¦½�I"~X§¥

I<�ÝI©�éçI©�¥5½�k� � lÏ�!�IÚ¿�Ï�!�I�

�A§ÒØ�½´UéÜÓV�k|��K�½�§Ø�½k|u�oçI<�Ü

{�Ã"

�d§��oçI<Ú¥I<V��çI�3çI<�¥I<ÜÓ'X¤á

�Ä:þ§rçI<����¯�Ú¥I<�ÝIÓ�B\çIÝIÜÓ�¾á�

â§�¦çI<�¥I<UçI¯¢§=çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI¯¢§=ÝI©

�¾áÖ¡ÜÓ"5¿§ù«ÜÓ¾á5K´35¬{;6ÜÓ?5½���!«ì

�¤ÜÓ�KÄ:þ�[z§Ï�¥I<�ÝI¢�§́ éçI�8¢�5�¦Ú

^��¿��A"

@o§ù��5´Ä#NçI<�¥I<?1ÜÓ!�§N�½?UÜÓI�!

d±!�þ!Á1Ï��¢�5SN§Xþ¡�ï�Ö¢5�¯�@�¾áÜÓQº

�,Ø#N�Ï�çI©��¢�5�¦Ú^�´ÝI¿��Ä:§ÃØ´U¥I

Ï�Ö�¥I<�ÝI�¤ÜÓ§�´UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾á�Ö¡

ÜÓ©Û§̄ ~¥çI<�¥I<\¾�ÜÓÑ��çIÝI5�5K§Ï�Ù

?UçI��§=çI©�1²�§½´¥I<�ÝI©��A�çI�8��§

±9¥Id�§=¥I<�ÝI©�1²�ÝI�d"V�1�§áu3ÝI��

�m�çI<N�I�§=çI�8§ÝI<�gJ�ÝI©��1�§��ç

IÝI�g��!�g«ì�Ä�5K"Ó�§���ú²�´�½|5K§Ï

�éÙ¦ÝI<Øú²"

�d§�p<¬{���{�o�¯<Ü{�çu2019c1�3FúÙ5'u

"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�)º£�¤6({º12018220Ò)1

�^²(5½§çI<Ú¥I<,1\¾�ï�ó§�óÜÓ�½�ó§��!ï

�óÏ!ó§�þ!ó§d±�¢�5SN§�¥IÜÓØ��§���¯<�¦

Uì¥IÜÓ(½�|ÂÖ�§<¬{�A��±|±"Ó�§Ti{)º1�^

Page 40: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 29

�éÜÓ¾á�§�¯<��çIÝI�5�5K§ògUC¢�5SN��/3

"��?�Ú5½§�¯<\¾�ï�ó§�óÜÓ�çI©�!ÝI©�!¥I

Ï�Ö1²�ó§��!ï�óÏ!ó§�þ!ó§d±Ø��§���¯<�¦

òçI©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ�Ö��(�ó§d±��â�§�¦<¬{�A

��±|±"

5¿§�,þ¡�p<¬{��i{)º£�¤́ �éï�ó§�óÜÓŪ§

�Ù5½�â´ uçIÝI�g��!�g«ìù�Ä�5K§·^u¤kçI

ÝIÜÓ¾á�/§�)ó§!ÀÔ½öÑÖ�çIæ"

13!A~µEPC!PPP�8æ

ó§ï��8§�)ÝK]!ï�Ú$En��ã"Ù¥§ï��ã�)ó§t

�!�O!�ó!��Úá�æ�;�¹Ä"DÚ�ó§ï��ª§́ �;�²1

u�§�Ì|�!�N�;���"EPC�ª§́ �OæïE�ª�Engineering

Procurement Construction=© �§=ò�O!æ!�ó�n�;��d��

«�û¢��ï��ª§�4�/NÄ«�ûÈ45§~��O��ó.¡!`

z�O§? Jpï��þ§ áóϧü$ó§¤�"PPP�ª§´3ú�Ñ

Ö+�§�?��¬]�Ü��ª½ú�]��hE]�Ü��ªPublic- Private

Partnership�=© �§��´�?æ^¿��ªÀJäkÝ]!ï�!$EUå

��¬]��¾áÜÓ§d�¬]��Jø]7§|�ó§ï�§��¬Jøú�

ÑÖ§�?�â1��Ø(J�Ù|G�A¤^��«�)·±Ïï��ª§kÏ

uO\Ä:��Ý]]7§Jpú��¬�þÚÑÖ�Ç�ø�Uå"læÀ�

wEPC!PPP�ª§�üX�ÜÓ+n½�8+nØÓ§́ l½|¿�À�J`À

JEPC½PPP�ø�§́ EPC½PPPæÔÑ�J`ÀJ"́ Ä�±æ^çIÝI

?1J`ÀJº�,�±�ÙÔÑ�,E,§Ø%E3u(ܽ|ø�Uå?1Ô

ÑÜݧØ�ÃO��ã"

Äk§·�wEPCÚPPP�ª¥ü��}�~f"

[>�e%©�¥¯�] ,½u>�*ïó§´I[/ÊÊ0­:ó§§d�Ý

]úi!,>å8ìU55%!45%�°'~|ï�8úi§�8/� uT½Ü¡�

þ~Ô�ì"�8oÝ]��76.7·�§[ï�2�100�Z���.-uÅ|"ü�

Å|©OOyu2017c.!2018cÐÝ�u>"ó§ï�æ^EPCo«��ª§Ù

o«�¥Iü �,>å8ìeá�>åó§�O�k�úi§�óü �,�ë

©ó§úi"Ù¥§e%©Ù9ó§�óæ^]!ª�Ãe���ó󲧱n�

Page 41: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

30 çIæÛYFn

�e�ü�Ì��þ���ó"2016c11�24F@þ7:�m§T�8u)e%©

�ó²xL�¥§E¤î�·vèÏ��¥�î­¯�"��2016c11�24F22�§

¯�®E¤73<k�!2<Éú§��²L��10197.20��"Tå¯�§²IÖ�

N�|@½��åS�)�I?¯�§é�'I?ü 31<æ�-¯r���"

N�|�²§T�8e%©�óü ,�ë©ó§úiy|+n·Ï§S�E

â���3ɧ�òÙ9ó§���x5���©Ü©�ó§?1+n§

��'�óS+n��"¯�u)�F§T�óü |� ���§37Òe%©

150!Ù9·vèrÝ��� �rÝ��¹e§�5�� ØÙ��§�¦Ù9

·vèrÝØv±«ÉþÜÖ1§E¤Ù9150!9±þ·vèÚ��| NXë

Y�¥Lá"

N�|@½§T�8ó§o«�ü ,>å8ìeá�>åó§�O�k�ú

iéÙ©�ü "yk�+n��¶�Á1o«�+n�I§éÙ9ó§�ó�Y

"�Øî�§�uyT;��ó�Y¥�3­�"�¶o«�y|+n�Ý6u/

ª§�uyÚ9���T©�ü �5 ��1�"

N�|éT�8EPCo«�ü �?n¿�´§é,>å8ìeá�>åó

§�O�k�úiI-ó§o«�Ê��î�c!L�ÙS�)�N�y§¿�

�EPCo�ü v±2000��"T�8EPCo�ü �'I?<¥§3<�JÄ-

¯I?§2<�JÄ1�I?§11<É�?©"

[AN²Eª�¯�] ,N�| u,�¬¢½�o�§Ó/¡È21ú�§ï

Ó¡È25.8�²��"Ù¥§|S*¯�R��91000�§���R11000�"�8æ

^PPP�ª§u2003 c12�24Fmóï�§2008c6�28�ªeó§Ù�¬]��

�(½æ^çI�ª§o[¤A!B!C!D|¤�éÜN¥I§�½�?9Ù¢�

Å�©O\Ý5AN��Æ6!5N�|�Æ6Ú5Ü�²EÜÓ6�n��Æ"�

?¢�Å��¥I<�Ó|ï�8úi§KITN�|�K]Úï�ó�§d¥

IéÜNKITN�|30cAN²EÏS�$E!�oó�"

�8oÝ]�313900��§¢�Å��L�?Ñ]58%§=Ý]182062��§

éÜNAÑ]42%"Ù¥§éÜNAÝ]�42%¥§¤BÓ'~65%!¤CÓ'

~30%!¤DÓ'~5%"½�?��TN�|�8�uåöÚAN²E(å��

��Pkö§�¢��8ï�Jø|±5��§�)��8úiJø$d�8è/§

Ù�?mu¤�1040�/m2£��/ã10000�/m2¤¶Jø18.154·��Öb§Ø�

£�¶Jø�N�|ï�!¦^�ë��@½�Ä:��§±9ÿÁmÏm§��

8úi|GN�|¦^¤^ÚAÏC�¤�"T�8ï�óÏ;Ü��Æ(Øä"

�!��8Ý]§ï�L§¥����OC�µ�´��º�4ܺX§�

Page 42: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 31

´~�1000�Ê� §n´~�N�|¥Ü©û���§��K��8û�$

E§K�¥IéÜN3ÙÝI�é30cAN²E�ýOÂ\Ã{¢y"

T�8�,XÏ�G¦^§�$Eî­º�"�d§2009c8�29F§½�?�

éÜN¥I<\Ý5'u?�Ú\rN�|$E�o+n�Æ6§éTN�|²E

ö?1�°UE§éÜN¥I<�ïN�|�30cAN²E�§= ¼��8[

È�À�°¶�8úi�L½�?§KIN�|$E§Ùúip�<d½I]�

�?§=�?��¬]�Ü�PPPU¤�?KIN�|$E§ÙJºd�?«ú§

\wPPP�ª3TN�|ï�!$E¥�A^�}"

>�e%©�¥¯�ÚN�|AN²Eª�¯�¥�ÜӧѴæ^çI�ª

|�ÝI¿�§(½¥I<¿��\¾ÜÓ"cöE¤73<k�!2<Éú§��²

L��10197.20��§�öØü´E¤�?��¬]�Ü��Ð%vk¢y§��

´d�?«ú�8$E�Jº"k<@�§EPC�8!PPP�8Ø·Üæ^çI�

ªæ§Ï�Ù¥k�þ�Á�¯�I�?1ÜÓ!�"ù«*:´�Ø�§́ 3

rçIÝIÅ�w��«/ª Ø´�«æ�ÔÑ�¦"�(�{A�´§éI

�¥I<?1ÜÓ!��¯�ØB\çI�8�¢�5�¦§ ´��k� � 

lÏ�½�I§½´¿�Ï�½�I§ù¢SþE´çIæ�ÔÑÜݯK"

3d§·�©Û�eEPC�8ÚPPP�8æJ:"

¢Sþ§EPC�8o«�çIÚPPP�8�¬]�Ý]<�æJ:Ì�3

u§�´IS�?0\�*²L¹Ä��§+��[§çI<ÚÝI<éJéo«

��8!PPP�8�Á�?1�Æüy�Sü"~X§�?9Ù�'Ü�!Å�é

ï��8�Ý]"1!�óã"�!�óN���!�+n§çI<�ÝI<3Á

��ÒÃ{r�¶�´EPCo«�çI!PPP�8�¬]�Ý]<æ�§=k�

8cÏüy]�§X�8ïÆÖÚ�15ïÄ�w!�8���w�õUI¦§ÿ

vk�¢y�8õU��¦�O§X�Y�O!ÐÚ�O½�óã�O�¶n´

éEPCo«�çI!PPP�8�¬]�Ý]<æ¿��oØ�Ù �õæ^nÜ

µ©{§éEPC�8ÝI<J���O�Y!�ó�Y!ÝI�dÚÙ¦]�§½

´PPP�8ÝI<J��ÝK]�Y!�O�Y!ï��YÚ$E�Y�?1µ©§

\�¦Ú"��§(½�©�p�ÝI<�¥I<"¢Sþ§ù´3/r/ª!rL

|0§Ø´��ý�¿Âþ�¿�5æ"��où�`Qº�ÏÒ3u§éÝI<

J��ÝK]�Y!�O�Y!ï��Y!�ó�YÚ$E�Y��µ�vk��

�*!ú��µdIO§�U³/µ�<�;���Ú����!*!aú�?

1Ì*µ�§�Ñ��©ê"��§\�¦ÚO�ÝI<�©§�Ã<�¡�©�

p�ÝI´Ä�`"

Page 43: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

32 çIæÛYFn

@o§EPCo«�çI!PPP�8�¬]�Ý]<æA¿��o§qA�N

�|�µ�Qº3d§·�?ØXeµ

1.EPC�8o«�ü æ" EPCo«�çI¿��Ø%§3uÝ\��Ñ

'"ùp§Ý\�çI<IÝ\�]7§�)ÙÁ�I¦¤^§�Ñ�çI<¼�

�£�"ùéuó�ï��8´²(�§�éu¬^ï��8Kز("ù�´�

�oEPCo«��8Ì�^uó�+���Ï"�d§I�3(@ÝI<Á�Uå§

�)Ùé¢�5�¦Ú^���A!�O�Y!�Ñ©Û!ï�|�9<ãÔ��

�Á�Uå�I÷vI¦�cJe§(½�8�Ý\�Ñ'§?1J`"Ù¥§(½

ÝI<�Á�Uå§�±æ^Ü��½©�ãæ^nܵ©{?1J`§��§O

�Ý\�Ñ'max(I/C)§ùpI�ýÏÂçC�ÝI<��d"éu¬^EPCo«

��8§Ïvk�Ñ�§�Uëìù�J`g�"~X§3�8÷võUI¦!ï�

IOÚÁ�UåcJe§b�Ù�Ñ����½�≥ C§X�I =1E��8V�

��§¢SþE´$d`k�æg�"

2.PPP�8�¬Ý]<æ" PPP�8¿��Ø%§3uü$�)·±Ï¤

�ÚJpú�ÑÖ�þ�ǧ4�/Jøú��¬�ÑÖ�ø�UåÚú�ÑÖ�

Ç"Ù¥§Jpú�ÑÖ�þ!�ÇÏLéÝI<J��ÝK]�Y!ï��YÚ

$E�Y�µ"'�§�±µ�Ù�¢y5§ÝI¿��Ø%3$E¤^"�d§3

éÝI<Á�Uå§�)é¢��Y¥¢�5�¦Ú^���A!ÝK]Uå!E

â�Y!ï�|�Uå÷v�¦�cJe§O�PPP�8�)·±Ï¤�C¿±d

��J`�I"Ù¥§(½ÝI<�ÝK]Uå!Eâ�Y!ï�|�Uå§�±æ

^Ü��½©�ãnܵ©{?1J`§ÅÚGØØ÷v�¦�ÝI<§2l�{

<¥(½PPP�8�)·±Ï¤��$�ÝI<�¥I<"

·�2lçIæÀ�©Û�eþ¡ü�¯�"Ù¥§>�e%©ï�L§¥

u)�¥¯���Ï3u§�´3u|�EPCo«�çI�§"yéo«�S�)

�+nUå§AO´§Ùé�ó©�ü J`ÀJ�+�9�þ!S�+nUå�

"�¶�´Á�¥"yéo«�ü 9Ù©�ü �þ!S�+��k�Òr§�

?g6"N�|AN²Eª�¯���ϧ3ucÏ"yéN�|$E�ªÚJ|

�üy�©Û§3uï�L§¥�ÌÝN�ó§�O=I�Ô§K��8$EÂÃ"

Ù¢�§þ3uçIæÔÑÜÝØ@ý½´øl½|ø�¢S"

[�£I] ï��8)·±Ï§=��ï��8/lÑ)�«20�L§§�)

Ý]üy!�8ïE!�8$EÚ�¢�o��!"Ù¥§PPP ´��?��¬]

�3Ý]!ï�!$Eþ�Ü�"éA�§EPCK´ï��8��«ïE�ª§=ï

E¥��O!�ó+æd�[ä��AUå�è�½´éÜN«@��ª"

Page 44: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 33

14!1�µæ(J�µ�

çIæ1�§́ �¤�8Á���½�mSéçIæÔÑQ½8I�ïþ

�u�"ùp§/10́ �1§/�0́ �J"Ùµ�ÄOkü«§�´çIæÔÑ

éçI�8�8I�¶�´¥I<éçI�8�ÝI�A�§©O��çI�8´

Ä¢yçI<�Q½8I§±9¥I<��A´Ä¢y�u�"Ù�^3ur?�

8õUØä�õ�±YU?"7��§����é¥I<Á�ø¨�ëì"A�`§

1���<¤�!|�uÐ9½|¿����'"¢�¥~��cªo(!µ'!

�Ø�I�§́ è�½Å�éó�c1���Ø"e¡ùK_%�¯§%¹X±

ê�þz/Ư<ú¥0��ؤõ�¯"

[1��Ø��¯]zc��cª1��اúi1�?�ÇfÒC��CØSµ

Z¯Ø��lØáÐ"cc1��ا¤1[�´O<�§X41�?3úi´�

�Q�wXÙ¦?¿�k?!<ø7�§gC�?¿ë>ÑvËL§gCòþÃ1§

Ãe<��Üf¿�§�qk�o�{QºÇf�§ù£�½�âÑ1�§r�c

5pÿúiÅ'¯Õ.g�o(�Ч4úi+�ÚÙ¦?¿@�"

?p#5� �Æ)�ܧâ`á���Ø�"Çfé5�ܧr?ÖÙ�

�¨§w�¨ùgo(��Ð�§'X1�?�c�1�§'X1�?UÄ�k?§

?¿<UÄ<þø7§±9¨UÄJc=���¯§�½��Ð"

Çf¯µ/\O�No�Qº0

�Ü��`µ/?�§·�<@��Ðo(�­��´êâ§^êâ`{§^

êâÐy1�âk`Ñå§úi+�ÚÙ¦?¿â¬@Ó"0

Çf¯µ/k�¯§·�ZvkP¹§k�vkäNó�þ§No�º0

�Ü`µ/·��±ëì c�ó�þ§̂ ÚO��"'X·���ú¿��+§

þ�(Ï�n�j"�c��Ê���(ϧU���zÊ�8�ÚO§ù�Ò

�±r?¿�c�1�^êi�NÑ5"0

Çf�f@�k�n§4¨snU�mr?¿o(�Ð"nU�§�ÜXÏr

o(��Çf"o(��ÊZõi§r?¿�c¤��ó�§̄ Ãã[��^êâ

�NÑ5"Çf�wé÷¿§�Þ�ÓЧ�ivÄÒ��úi�ú¿"Ù

¥§'u1�?ó�1���ã´ù���µ

�c5§·?�úiÅ'����æ��þ�,¡��ó�"â?¿Ø�

�ÚO§·��Å'�ó!e?5��<��ó�ê286ê§)�õÞ22880�!�

Page 45: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

34 çIæÛYFn

�17260ú6!è3120{«!12180{°¶�¤úi�ú¢¿Sì²XÚ?nó�68�§

���+156 �!m'52�!>�1462�!Läì66�¶�¤úi�ú¢g5Y+

�?nó�145�§��Y9Þ28�!Sj+�31�!�Þ18�!nÏ12�¶�¤

�I?n96�§��Àæ26²��!.Ã38�!!�34�¶�Å'�ó�ú^¬æ

!u�)P�380�!¹��850�!�¾)1220|!\i)636|!¾ÖÅ15�!

¾Ö¹460Ý!­O�250Ý!�Þ�220Ý!�Y�1220�!&µ1200�!�<�356

ݧ......"

3cªo(�¬þ§ÇfAúioà�¦§þÌR�0�1�?�c�1�"

�¦ÖÑþ¡ù�A¤1�ê��§I5�|9��Ý("oà3�¬þé1

�?�c�ó��±¿©�½§@�1�?�1��Ч¤1�âѧ\Ù1�?

¼�Å'?¿1�µ'k?8NJ�¡Ò§¼�ø730000�"

@o§�o´1��ØQº1��Ø´é��Ø<3�ØÏS�¢�(J§U

Q½8I?1�Æ©Û�µd§JÑU?ïƧ±Ú�ÙØä�õ¢�1��1�"

þ¡ùK�¯�,´�KÜ�1��Ø�_%�¯§�Ù¥�kÚOí�!Ø¢¯

¦´�?§�EéXÛ?1çIæ�8�1��Øk¤é&"çIæ1��Ø

�Ø%§3uéçI�8�Ý\��Ñ´Ä¢yçIæÔÑ¥�ýϲL�

Ã!�¬�ÃÚ)��ḉ ÄJp^r÷¿Ý½öú¬�34�ê�8I?1

�Ø"Ó�§1��Ø�´uyçI�85�L§¥´Ä�3�{�51�§́ Ä

��²L5Ƨ±9ØäJpæ�Ã�k���{"

1.�Ø�I"éçIæ(J¢�1��اØ%3uéçIæ(J´Ä¢

yçIæÔÑÜÝ��Ø�µ�"Ù�I���)±eüÜ©µ

11Ü© æI¦8I�ا�)¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�

I!¿�Ï�½�I��Ø"Ù¥§¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I

q©�½þ�Ia1!a2!,!amÚ½5�I�a1!a2!,!an"̂ êÆ�þL«§�

L«�½þ�þC0 = (a1, a2, · · · , am)§½5�þC0 = (a1, a2, · · · , an)Úk� � 

lÏ�½�ID01!¿�Ï�½�I�þD02"

12Ü©¥I<3ÙÝI©�¥�«ì�§=ÙéI¦8I��A"��©�n

Ü©µ�éçI©�¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I¥��þC0��

A�þC1¶�éçI©�¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I¥�þC0�

�A�þC1¶�éçI©�k� � lÏ�½�I!¿�Ï�½�I�þ¥��

þD01!D02 ��A�þD11!D12"

13Ü© ¢�1��§=¥I<�¢�1�§©�nÜ©µ�éçI©�¢�

5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I¥�A�þC0�¢�1��þC2¶�éA

Page 46: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 35

çI©�¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I¥�A�þC0�¢�1�

�þC2¶�éçI©�k� � lÏ�½�ID01!¿�Ï�½�I�þD02¢

�1��þD21!D22"

2.�ØÚ½"çIæ1��Ø�m�§3u©Û1��þC2 !C2!D21ÚD22

�Oy8I�þC0!C0!D01!D02Ú¤�øAû«ì�C1!C

1!D11!D12 �m�

ɧµdçIæÔÑ´Ä¢yOy8I§́ ÄIN�½­#?1çIæ�¯�"

çIæ1��ØÚ½Xeµ

11Ú (½�þC0!C0!D01!D02ÚC1!C

1!D11!D12.

�þC0!C0!D01!D02Ú�þC1!C

1!D11!D12�±©O3çI©�!¥I

<�ÝI©�þ��"5¿§ùp§D01 ≥ D11§=¥I<�ÝI©�1²�k� 

� lÏ�½�Iþ3ÙN���S"Ó�§|D12| ≥ |D02|§ùp��þD12§́ 3

�þD02 Ä:þ§ò¥I<JÑ�¤k�A�J�Ñ5�¤�þD12"Ù¥§|A|L«8ÜA����ê"5¿§XuyC1 < C0 ½´C1 < C0§=L²çIÝI¹Ä

(½¥I<L§¥�3��ú²¿��K"7��§L���k'1�iÒÜ��

?"Ù¥§�9úÖ<�{�5�§L�{J�iÅ'?©"

12Ú (½�þC2 !C2!D21ÚD22.

¥I<¢�1��þ§©�½þ��½5�ü«"

£1¤½þ�"é�ØÏTS1��þC2 !C2!D21ÚD22¥z�½þ�u§?1

ê��[§(½Ù��mt�Cz¼êu(t)§O��ØÏTSu�²þ��¸�

u =1

T

T∫0

u(t)

ڸ�

maxu(t), t ∈ [0, T ], minu(t), t ∈ [0, T ],

Ù¥§1��þC2 !C2!D21ÚD22¥z�½þ�udþ¡²þ���Ù�þ�"

£2¤½5�" ½5�þ¥z��vÏL�^rÀ:u�N�¯ò§?1©a

ÚO"éú��¬½ú�ÑÖ�8§��<�!���L§±9À½^r½�Â

8µd¿�æ�"Uæ�ê���!����3%-5%(½�&«m§é�{æ�(

J{v1, v2, · · · , vn}?1ê��[§(½Ù��mt�Cz¼êv(t)"aq/§O��Ø

ÏTSv �²þ�

v =1

T

T∫0

v(t)

Page 47: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

36 çIæÛYFn

ڸ�

max v(t), t ∈ [0, T ], min v(t), t ∈ [0, T ],

¿æ^T²þ���½5�þ¥�v��"

13Ú (½¢�1��É.

©OO�1��þ�Oy8I�þ�

C2 −C0,C2 −C0Ú|D1| − |D0|,

©ÛçIæÔÑ8I�¢�1�"XJC2−C0 < 0§C2−C0 < 0½D21−D01 < 0§

L²çIæÔÑ8I�¢y§IÒr¥I<éÙ�¤�çI�8�U±¢yC2−C0 ≥ 0!C2 −C0 ≥ 0ÚD21 −D01 ≥ 0"7��§N�8I�½�¥I<)ØÜÓ"

3C2 −C1 ≥ 0 !C2 −C1 ≥ 0!D01 −D21 ≥ 0�|D22| − |D02| ≥ 0�/e§¥I<

¢�1�ÎÜÙÝI«ì§UeªO�1��Ø�Iµ

ω =1

m + n + ςs

(m∑i=1

ui2

ui1

n∑j=1

v2jv1j

+ ςs∑

k=1

dk2dk1

)

ùp§ω�1�nÜ�I§ς��¢�«ì��­§����0%-100%�m§C2 =

(u12, u

22, · · · , um

2 ), C1 = (u11, u

22, · · · , um

1 ), C2 = (v21, v22, · · · , v2n), C1 = (v11, v

12, · · · , v1n),

D2 = (d12, d22, · · · , ds2), D1 = (d11, d

21, · · · , ds1)"1�nÜ�I�N¿ï<1�µX

Jω ≥ 1§L²¿ï<1��ØÎÜÙ«ì�¶��§XJω < 1§L²¿ï<1�

�Ø�¢yÙ«ì�§I�U?"

3.1��ØA^"1��Ø�I �NçI�8¢�1�"XJω ≥ 1§UÜ

Ó�½éÙ¢�1�øy"��§XJω < 1§KL²¥I<�¢�1��¢yÙÝ

I«ì§I�?�Ú�¢Ù�¢y��ϵ�´ÙÝIL§¥�3Jb«ì!Á�

UåØv½1�iÒ��¶�´¥I<�UÙÝIÁ��²�U�±¢yÙÝI«

ì§IUÜÓ�½éÙ¢�1�?v¶n´�*�Ï��ÙÃ{¢yçIæOy

8I�§I©ÛK�§Ý9±Y�m§±æ����y8I��¢y"7��§ç

I<IN�8I�¿UN��8Ié¥I<­#�Ø"XJ¥I<ÃUå¢yOy

8I�§çI<L�¥I<)ØÜÓ§��V�Å��ÅÖ§¿éçI�8yG�

±µ�§U¢S�¹­#�½æÔÑ"

15!Y~µ>Cæ��E�ÂI?

çIæm�´¢yæ(J`z"Ù¥§çIÝI´æ^Ö¡¿��ªJ`

5�§Á�´çIæ(JdÖ¡�¢Ô�¢yL§"�d§vk5�ÒvkÁ�§

Page 48: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 37

vkÁ�½´Á��å ¢�5�K´���©"çIæ5��Ø%3u|�Ý

I¿�§Á��Ø%K3�âV�UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ

ª&Á�§¢yæ(J"ù�¥§¥I<´Á�Ì�§ÙØ%3uUV�\¾�

ÜÓ§AO´ÝI©�¥�Á��YÁ1ÜÓ§çI<K3u��Á1ÙA¦ÂÖ§

�ÜÓÒr¥I<Á�"V��1Ù´§�¦ÙI"�kù�§âU¢yçIæ

Ôѧ¢yýÏ�çIæ(J"

[Y�£�] 2017c3�13F§pé�þÑy��g¡´>CøAûóuÙ�

df§Þ�½/cnÒ��3S�Û�§¡Ù¤^>C���IþØÎÜ/cï�

IO§́ ØÜ��¬"Ó�§3>CSCL§¥§½�þiÒÜ�Qõgé¤^>

CÄu§Äu(Jþ�ØÜ�"�TøAûKI<|^<ó�½�þiÒÜ�k'

<1ª§ò�þÄu(JU�Ü�§UY3/cnÒ�¦^§î­�³¦�)·

S�"�d§3�16F§½�!½�?I¤i!�i!Si!úS�k'Ü�|¤

éÜN�|§éÞ�?1N�!Ø�!Eÿ!u�¿þ�IÖ�"3�20F§½�?

Ò/cnÒ�Þ�¯Kðm#ªuÙ¬§úÙI[>�>CiÒu�¥%én�Õ

:�Å���$Ø>C5�Äu�¬þØÎÜI[IO§þ�ØÜ��¬"

2017c6�21F§IÖ��úe3¯�Ï�¥�ѧT>C¯��³�¯Kk

±eA��¡µ�´)��!�¿�bÈb!Üó~�!±g¿Ð")�L§¥�

¿�ò�C�üà�15 ��mUI[IO)�§¥mÜ©.[/Ê�0¶�´çI

æ�!SGϧ¥I<�ï�ü !�óü <1ª¶n´�C?|�Â/

ÓJ�§�5%NÙg1Ä��¬!xu�¬!+�u��w¶o´1��{Ø5

�§i+Á�Ø� ¤�§@½Tå¯�´�å/có§ï�¥æÚ¦^���

¬��{Y�"

�d§IÖ�I¤�<¬�?�IÖ��ÑÖ¡u�§Ï�1µ"�{é�Y

>C)�è��{½�L<�8¶��v¦<�1�Ó§�{£xi{Å'§�{

�V¯I?n�'/��UÜ�122¶I?<§Ù¥�)e?16<!??58<"Uì

k'5½§��T)�è��Ür�5�¬@yyÖÚ�þ+nNX@yyÖ§�

�ÙͶûI@½§�{L�ÙE��ìÚ)�N�y"é�óü �'I?<©

O?±v±!L���]�yÖ!5cSØ�­#5þ�?v¶ü$inúiA!i

núiB�]��?§?±v±§vÂ�{¤�§�{JÄÙ��I?§Ê�2¶o

inó§���§L�ü<���yÖ§5cSØ�­#5þ"Ó�§�¦T½i

Å'é�'¥è�7�ü �19<áY��"âd§ï�1�Ì+Ü��éT½

/c>C¯���'ü !I?<?11�?v"Ù¥§in<Adó§innÜ

]�ü��ÂïÓó§!½�ú^ó§!ú´ó§!c´ó§in`?ÚÅ>SC

Page 49: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

38 çIæÛYFn

ó§in¯?�1�?v¶in<BdÅ>SCó§in]�`?ü�¯?"Ó�§

L�T�8oinó§��,!�,5þinó§�5þyÖ§�¦ÊcSØ�

5þ¶éT/cnÒ��óè���8²nÇ,!Ú,!ë,!,!�,Ú!,§

L��?ïE�5þyÖ§5cSØ�5þ�1�?v"

¯��ùp§�±xþ���÷�éÒ"̄ �¥�1ª!ɪ<!�{�V

<��Ak?n§̄ K>C3T½/c¥?1ü����"Ø�2017c5�11F§

,���/�$d¥IØU§!�oóú° !¥I�E0§±92017c6�26F�

/�$d¥I§TUU02iÅ>§�¯��Cè��¯§/¥Id®²î­$u

¤�§�§¥I�½´�?a§@Ò�UÜó~�0§@�>C�þ$���

Ï´>CçIæ^²µ"��$ÝId{¤�"©Ù��§3�I<�~�¬�¬

�þ{�{u�¥§�è�Ì���/�çIÝI¥�3�/$d¥I0y�§

Ü©çI<3çI�!�À�þ�¦§�d�Ø"E¤¢S¥Id$u$��$u

¤�d§è��¼�|d§�U3�á�æ!)��E��¡Ø ¤�§±ã+

�¬�þ5�Öº�§l Ñy/�1°Åû10y�"©ÙÚ^�[Q¼�/�

?�þø0��Cè�KI<�{�ó/)�è�vk|d�m§�%�Üó~�§

â».�0§¡õ[è�KI<L«§ù«/­d�!��þ0����§K�è�

M#ïu�È45§{N¥I²L=.,?§äó/���$d¥I�KØC§Ò

éJk�oóú° !zcPA0§Úu�Sé�$d¥I��?Ø"

[¯K] �éxNþã��ÚIÖ�é¯�?n§?رen�¯Kµ

1.çI�8�þXÛ3çIÝI¥�y§qXÛ3çIæ¥á¢º

2.�o´²µ"��$ÝId½´5���$d¥Iº>CçIæ^�$d¥

I��K´Ä´­d�!��þ§´Ä¬��)�è�Üó~�§��oº

3.T/c>C¯��³ÑéçIÝI@£þ�=¯K§����¥q�3=

é�¬ú¯�Ø�º

[Y~©Û] þãn�¯K§·��g©ÛXeµ

1.çIæ�)çIÝI5�ÚÁ�ü�L§"éA�§çI�8��þ�y

�²dü�L§µ�´ÝI¿��Á�UåJ`§́ çI�8�þ�5��y¶�

´Á�L§¥�ÜÓ�þ+n§́ çI�8�þ�¢��y"éçIæ ó§�

ö"�Ø�"Ù¥§̀ ÝI¿�J`´çI�8�þ�5��y§́ Ï�ÝI<ë

�ÝI¿��cJ´Ùä�I[5½�½´çI©�5½�]�^�§=ä�Á�

Uå§kUå�yçI�8�þ�cJeâUë�ÝI¿�"�dÓ�§çI<é

ÝI<OyÁ�¥�<!Å���!á����Oy!ãÖUå!Á�ó²Ú�

��?1J`ÀJ§̀ ¥À`§�±�yÀ½�¥I<äk¿©�Á�UåÚ�þ

Page 50: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

12ÙçIæµÁ��¿� 39

�y¶̀ ÜÓ�þ+n´çI�8�þ�¢��y§3uÜÓ�þ�y§��²d

á�!��?|u�!uÿ§á�!��Úó§�Á��u�§¥mÄu½�§�

8�ó�ÂÚeó�§�þ�?��!§l �yçI�8�þ��I[5½I

O§ÎÜÜÓ�þ�¦"

2.æ^²µ"��$ÝId{�§Ik(½ÝI<ä�çI�8�Á�Uå§

ÙÝI÷vçI©�5½¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I3çI©�

5½N���S�cJe§2òÝId��J`Ï�"IS.~¥§æ^/²µ"

��$ÝId{0�§ÜÓ¿Ø�½Ç���d�$§=çI<3mI¬ÆþúÙ

�ÝI�d�$�ÝI§Ï�ÜÓIÁ�âU¢yæ(J§ ØÓ�Á��{\

D3çI<�þ�I?¿Ø�Ó"�d§��¬ÿ�ÙÝIEâ!ûÖ�ÉéÁ�

K��d�Ly½ò�IO§Uk|u~��´\­çI<I?§Uò�IO3Ý

I<�ÝI�dÄ:þ~d½ö\d§(½ÝI<��ªd�§¿±�ªd���

J`�I"ù«�{§¢Sþ´UçI�8¢���ýÿd�?1J`"@o§�

o�/e�±æ^ÝI�d�$��KJ`QºÙcJ�½´d3ÝI<�Á�U

å!�þþ÷v�¦§�Ã�É"3d�/e§çI<�I|�ÝId�¿�"��

/§UÝI�d�$J`��{§=·^uäkÏ^Eâ!5UIO½öçI<é

ÙEâ!5UvkAÏ�¦�ÀÔæ"

ÃØ´æ^²µ"��$ÝId{§�´U$d`k�J`�{§Ñج��

/­d�!��þ0�æ(J§�ج��)�è�Üó~�§Ï�÷vçI�8

�þ�¦´ÝI¿��cJ§Ø�3Ø­Ø�"Ó�§ÝI<¥I�UçI©�Ú

ÙÝI©��çI<\¾ÜÓ§|�\ó)�!�E½öï�§/­ÜÓÅ&�0́

è��áè��§Û!)�è�¬ÏdÜó~�Q§Ø�TÝI<3±ÐÀ�Ãã

*¦½|)�"�½|�)�{K��ü½ùaè�§~X§�Y¥@[>C)�

è�ÏÜó~��¦Ù)��>C�þ$���{L�E��ìÚ)�N�y§

qÛ!Ù3½|þ�)��uÐQ"

3.Tå/c>C¯�§2g�³ÑçIÝI5Kvk���¬þ�¿©@��

n)§AO´§vU+¬3çIæ5�ÚÁ�ØÓL§¥§�yçI�8�þ�

Ãã��{"rçIÝI¿��ÓuiZ§òÁ��þ+��Óu|Ã��"ù3

Tå¯�¥Ly3µ�´>C�E�!�bÈb!Üó~�!±g¿Ð¶�´çI

ÝIL§¥1ª!ɪ!G϶n´?|u�/ÓJ�§�5%NøAûg1Ä�!

g1xu!+�u��w�§þvkòçIæ���«ÔÑ ´��iZ§�v

kòçIÝI���«�y�8�þ�k�Ãã"�d§I\r�¬òÙ���«

²L5K�@�§\rÙ���«ÔÑ�¦�@�§±u�Ùé²Lï���z"

Page 51: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

40 çIæÛYFn

T��´3Ø��¬ú¯éçIæXÛ�y�8�þ�n)"Äk§�¬�

þXKIº5¥u<¬�ÚI�¬�þ{61o^!1Ê^²(5½§)�ö!�È

ö�{«ú�¬�þI?§́ �¬�þ�I?ÌN"Ó�§{Ʋ(B�Ù3)�!

�È��¬¥�,!�b§±b¿ý!±g¿Ð§Ø�±ØÜ��¬k¿Ü��¬¶

Ùg§T��´3�Ø/�ºçIÝI5K§́ 3b/)�è�KI<��§rø

�T/c>C�þ$�!ØÜ��Ï8ÑuçIÝI�J`�{§@�´$d¥I

�KK��¬�þ§́ 3Ú�½|rçIÝIÀ��«iZ Ø´�«½|¿�

5K§Ï��{vké�§[�´¥á�¶2g§¿�´½|²L���§è�Eâ

M#!óú° !�EzcPA§́ �lg,{K/·ö)�0±·A½|�áv�

�§́ è��)���"T��@��$d¥I�KK�è��EâM#!óú°

Ú�EzcPA§́ 3�Ø/�ºè��½|�'X§́ 3�Ø/Ú�è�·A

½|²L�uЧkz³ Ã�|"

Page 52: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 3Ù

çIæµI¦�.½

**********************************************************************

X[�s�§Ê�<�a¶�5Hºå§�ðC¡�"

— /.xØ 5́*(ð6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 53: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

42 çIæÛYFn

11!uåµæ�o

æÏI¦ æ"I¦�o§3�½ý��åeæ�o§ÙÄ�ó�3u

O(£OæI�§=æI�A�£ã§�)I���!êþ!õU!�þ!ó²

��{!�m�I¦Ï�½�I"7��§�±|�;[(Üü ½�¬uÐÔÑ

�ÙÛ!½|ø�G¹?1Øy§½´�øAû�Ï!ï?§±��æI¦��!

²(!O(§ÃÜÂ"��/§æ3�½�ý��å^�e?1§L��lg�!

²�!ú²!ª¢&^�½|�´�K"UI¦8Iæ§́ æ�����A�§

�´�)¹¥h<F^¬æ���«O"

[å<3û|��¯] å<O3û¢§â`´�É3û|�L§�W�§�É�

�7�§ù=B´3�XdB$�8U�,Xd"k�éÅÓ§(´c§å<

U�4I<�X3û|"@�§�^*fB3å<�þ§å<��`U�§I<¬

ÎØgþ/<aïe§/��CöN0"nc�§ü<U(û�§(´)f"Ac��

��±"§å<l�@péÑ�^éU��*f§Bþ�No�.Øþ��.ó"

ìºf§âuyùAcgC��Nu "d�§ü<�¯f�Ø�3�"u´§�

I<ûþ§�[<�û|�gCï^#*f"

û|�á3½¥%��u�/ã§n�´�SC§o�´ÔåC§Ê�´��

åC"�[<�û|��rþn¢§I<�X¯f§å<]ÀX�A½�eþЫ

��«*f§���¬ý/3X!ÀX"w���A??ÑuX�S§å<4�

éÑ�^�A�þ�*f�þ§�3>þ§X/ýwc��B3s�þwX�Ø

��lQ0"å<%�§§·Ø��l§Ø´`·/P��MÉÖ§�To0§ýج

`{"u´§å<x��ú§û½þo�33ÔåC"

o�´¤Ùå5�U/§å<uyA��AЫ�*fÑé¤�§4�éÑ

�^�þ§uy+>A^C»�w<R¬"q��^§aú*f�ÜÂ��;§�

3�þr´ØÓÑ"2��^§aú*fc9sª�O�Nú§BØÑ�"

ªu§å<3��¬ý� é��^%¤®È§̂ �ùÄ�*f"�þ�ìº

f§NowNo÷¿"��3>þ�§/sÐkí�§Ðk¬ O§Bù^*f§

NowÑ´år<§ý�¤õ<¬0"��§ø4å<>�g·§û½ïe"��

¯d�h�a§�^*f12000.00�§�Ø�ò�"u´§Ø��/r*f�e5

���"I<3>þ§aúå<´U�ù^*f�§̄ ¨NoØï"å<`�B

Page 54: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 43

§oØU�[<A��دØÕï^*fj§þÊ�ww��C"�[<3Ê�

�X��¬ý=��§@�ù�*f���z§vk\ú�"

ù�§I<�X¯fk:\§�å<ûþ�£["å<ØZ§̀ �v3Q§

��233§4I<�X¯fé�/�>E§gClÊ�e�o�!o�e�n�§

qln�þ�o�§o�þ�Ê�§����!��¬ý��¬ý/3X!ÀX"

ü�õ���§å<£�I<Ú¯f>E�/�,é�I<Ú¯f§û½£["

I<¯Novïþ�^"å<��§Òwþ@^12000��§�B§�Ø�ï"aq

�§yX8§ï^*f½ùoJQ�

ù´)¹¥~��w�¾À¯~"ùp§I?Ø�´§��o�¯¥�å<3

û|n¢!o¢!Ê¢þþee/rn�5£�vkï�*fº�ÏÒ3uå<

=´3ý��åe�ï�^*f§�*f�Ù�!sÚ!ª��I¦¿�ᢧ=

´w�槳Bþ��aúû½§ù��F¥/��¨�0ªÀWaq"

çIæ�w�æ�ØÓ§3u´æ^Ö¡¿�5�§Ù�8aO�)ó§!

ÀÔ�ÑÖ§�õ�/wØ�I�¢Ô§Ø�UÆå<3û|½´�¥ÀW£ã�

@�§³aú|�/��¨�0ª�æ"�d§I�úÙO(�çIæI�§A

O´çI���êþ�¦§±¦¤kë�¿��ÝI<éI�n)��§¢yÝI

¿��ú²�ú�"¢�¥§�«'�@���{´çI<úÙæ�ü§±~�

ÝI<n)þ�¹·"

ùp§U�8aO�ØÓ§éæ�ü©O?ØXe"

1.ó§çI"ó§�óI�.½�{kü«µ�´*�ÐÚ�O½�óã�§

Ù¢�´ó§I��ã�(½�ó§����"ù«�{�é{ü§̀ :´Á��§

V�جéI����)�ƶ":´ØÓÝI<éã�(½�ó§��§~X§

ã��Ø!�I5º�½´=k«¿vk�[Eâ�¦�Ü §Ùó§þ���O

�~Ø��§ÚuÝI¿��I�Ø��§��ú²¿��K¶�´æ^ó§þ�

ü§ uISó§çI.~"ù«�{§I�çI<JøÝI<ó§þ�ü§ÝI<

3ó§þ�ü��?W��A�üd!Üd§?1�d"̀ :´Ú�ÝI��§d

�§z��üf8Ñ´I�¶":´ó§þO�ØO½¢¦�§ÝI<�±æ^Ø

²ï�d�E|¤õ¥I§�Á��âuyÝI<}�f���®�§�U/�

�ÖO0"¢Sþ§ó§þ�üO��ØO½¢¦§~~5 uó§ã���Ø!�

Ø!¢¦½ö¹·Ø�§E,8Ñuó§��.½ØO¤�"æ^ó§þ�üçI

�§ó§þ�ü���)SÒ!?è!�8¶¡!�8A�£ã!Oþü !ó§

þ!nÜüd!Üd�SN"Ù¥§çI�8§=I�d�ü¥��8¶¡!�8A

�£ã!Oþü !ó§þ�o�.½§nÜüd!ÜddÝI<3ÙÝI©�¥

Page 55: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

44 çIæÛYFn

�/Idó§þ�ü0¥W�üd½d�§�z�f8�#Nk���d"Ó�§ç

I<IéÝI<�nÜüdºX¯��Ú��¦"��/§�¦nÜüd�)<ó

¤!�óÅ�¦^¤!á�¤!Ù¦¤^£$,¤!�u¤!SC¤!"�?E¤!

�x¤!ÜÓ²«½öV«�ºx!I?ÚÂÖ�I��¤^¤§±9+n¤!|d

�§́ �ó«�ÜÓd�+n�N��­��â"

5ï�ó§ó§þ�üOd5�6́ ��í�5I[IO§5½�¥.IkÝ

]�ó§ï��8æ^ó§þ�üOd§�¦ó§þ�ü�)µ�µ¡¶�o`²¶

�©Ü©�ó§þ�ü�OdL¶����8�ü�OdL£�¤¶����8�ü

�OdL£�¤¶�Ù¦�8�ü�OdL¶�6�7�²[L¶�á�6�dL!

;�ó§6�dL!OFóL!o«�ÑÖ¤OdL¶�5¤![7�8�ü�O

dL�9�ܩSN"

5¿§æ 5̂ï�ó§ó§þ�üOd5�6¥?è½f8�§5�¥®²²

(�8A�Úó§þO�5K§Á���1T5�=�"�é@5�¥vk?

è�f8§çI<I3ó§þ�ü¥ëìT5���{§²(�8A�!ó§þO

�5K±�ÑÚ�I���"Ù¥§ó§þ�ü¥����8!Ù¦�8´Äü�§

Ù¤^´Ä©���A�©Ü©�ó§��üf8§±95¤![7�Ø�¿��

¤^´Ä�)3nÜüd¥§ØÓ1�!Ü���¦¿ØÚ�"�d§çI<LU

1�5½3çI©�¥²(§m�´BuOþ!Od�ÜÓ+n"

2.ÀÔçI"ÀÔæ�§Jø/ÀÔæ�ü0½´/øÀI¦�AL0´

ÀÔ§�)á�Ú��çI�Ï1�{"d�§�ü¥�z��¬8ÚêþÑ´I

�§I�|�ÝI¿�"7��§�±�¦ÝI<Jø�¬§aqå<ï*f�¯

¤ã§�¬ë�µI§±��ÀÔ?|�Â�ëìÔ"��óçIØÓ§ÀÔæ

�§ÝI<��جæ^زï�düѧ ´U�ü¬8Ñ�üd�ÄêO��

A¤^§�ÀÔæÜÓɽ|ø�G¹!ÔdÅÄ�ºx��u�ó«�ÜÓ"

��½|ø�D"§/ÛÀ�Ø0½´ÔdÅħ¥I<Ø�¿«ÉÞd���§

¬�çI<JÑÞd�¦"î­�§¬��ÜÓÁ1ª�"

ÀÔçI�§I�çI<JøÝI<ÀÔæ�ü§�)SÒ!¬8!5�.

Ò!Oþü !êþ!�ÀÏÚ�À/:�¯�§�¦ÝI<éÀÔæ�ü¥�

z�¬8W���üd�Úd§?1�d"Ó�§U�À/:�ØÓ§Xó�!ó

¥!lW!l�½�½/:�À�§©O²(ÝI�dºX�¤^¯�§�))�

�E¤!$Ѥ!+n¤Ú|d§®|G½ò|G�?�[!�¬[!�È[ÚÙ

§[¤§�y²Ù��÷vÜÓ�¦¤I�u�uÿ¤§�a�x¤!��ÑÖ¤§

±9ÜÓ²«½V«�ºx!I?ÚÂÖ¤^�§±�¦ÝI<O\ÙÝI�d"

Page 56: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 45

3.ÑÖçI"ÑÖæ�8©�üaµ�a´;�\ÎUåæ§�a´ÑÖ

Nåæ"Ù¥§ÑÖNå�æ§XÔ�ÑÖ!�?�À:�§�±ëìÀÔæ

�üJøÝI<ÑÖ�ü±.½I���¶�é;�\ÎUåæ§Xó§ï�

�8�t!�O!in§½ó§��7K!{Æ!\Î�ÑÖ�8§vkOþ5

K§æ^ÑÖ�ü�´Øæ^ÑÖ�ü§çI(J¢�´���§Ï�=B´æ^

ÑÖ�ü§ùa�8�Oþü ´/�0§Ùó�þ ´1�"d�§|�ÝI¿

��Ø%´;�\ÎUå Ø´d�¿�"�XÛµ���|�½Å��;�\Î

Uå¿vk��Ð�{§ù´ÑÖ極d;�\ÎUå�J:§�´E¤;�

\ÎUå�çI6u/ª�Ì��Ï"éA�§ISþ��æ^�«Äuõ�ÚO

©Ûêâ/(��§0��{§Uêâ(�éA�ÑÖUå�I?1µd§a,�

�§�±ëì·�çIæ��)��p��á5çIænØÄ:6���Ù"

��/§é;�\ÎUå�æ§I²(ÑÖSN!ÑÖ¤JÚ�ÂIO��

{�§rÑÖ��w����8§±ÑÖL§!ÑÖ(J�m�?1çI"7��§

é¤J©��|¤!�Ý!�ª!°ê!1N�JÑ�¦"

æI¦´æ�Ä:"5¿§ùp�/I¦0��çI<�ª�¢SI¦

Ø==´æI¦Oy"3¥I�<©�¸e§�ÑO(�æI¦/I�0´ç

I<|�çIæ���Ì��I ÃØ´ó§!ÀÔ�´ÑÖæ§�=B´æ

^�üæ§I����O(ÃØ�Ø´��N´�¯�"ù��¡§́ Ï�çI

�8Eâ^�½Eâ�¦�ØO(§X�óçIã��3�Ø!�Ø!¢¦!¹·

�ØO(�/¶,��¡§́ Ï�üæþ�3ý�!ý��/§E¤æþõ�

½´���/" ù�:§T´çI<�¥I<Ü�Æ���:�Ø%§Ï�ÜÓ

(�±¥I<�¤�çI�8�O"

12!.½µI¦�EâIO�^�

æI¦�O(.½´çIæ�Ä:§Ø=´I����O(.½§�3u

I�Sº�O(.½"ùp§/O(0�¹Â´°O!²(§�¢S½ýÏ��Îܧ

Ù�OIOØ=´çI<gC§ I�ÝI<@�"I�Ú±5¿�´§�óI3

A½�©z!�¸��¸eâUO(/L�Ù¹Â"ùp§©z�¸´�,�A½

�©z�µe{�L��¿Â§XÖ¡�¥þe©!��¥�có���¶�µ�

¸´�{�¤�6��¸!�¸Ï�§X�m!/:!|Ü!{K��*Ï�§�k

`{<��°!/ !%n!©z�µ�Ì*Ï�§±9�{�Ó�Ñy���ó

Ä�!ÎÒ§Xó!L��"lmA½��¸^�§<�éJO((½�é{�¹

Page 57: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

46 çIæÛYFn

§���ó¹·"

[êÛÇ��¯]5Ø�6¥�õP1�f�ó1§k�ã`/Ø�·§Ã±�

�f�0§�¤x{Ò´ØÃ�U·�<§ØU��f§<ØU_U �"lù�:

w§�f@ÓU·��"��·k)´Ä�±�Ñ¿w�\Òk�ƧÏ�5�

�²6¥�/U/Ø;§±�Ô�F�0L²§U/À�ÔÓ;§�³Uŧ=´�

³U�§7;Ug"

2006c3���U§·3B���U,ë\�8µ""¬Æm�éØ�¯§�¬

;[éµ"(Øk�Ƨ\�Äë�õ§·3ëÒ¥E��U�§ªu(å"

�·Ó��� *l`¢>k�ú�/`(ú0§�ì�Y�§�íéЧ̄ ·

�Ø��rr"·��ÑU,��%�§u´A�<B°�c `(ú"

Ú\ú§*l`c¡ìþk�¤m�§�ø4m§p¡øÁ800ÛǧÛÇZ

^z�! �Ø�§�«X<m��§�ѯ�_%"*lïÆ·þ�ê�ê§wg

Cù�)�·�"ù´·1�gêÛǧÙØ%3��"A�<?\ÛÇ,§U5

ݧ³ú�À¥��ÛÇm©§ ��´ mê��¶��i��� =>ê§́

êþ¡�ü�´e¡�ü�´��§ØU £"ù�§ê�gC±�éA�@�Û

ǧP4ÛÇ.�þ?Ò"ÑÛÇ,§�>þ��!�é+¯Úÿ§�þü¬a§�

£�Ü�k¡"·ê�����´1�|o�o�Ûǧk¡�¡´ÛÇx�§�

X/]��ö0i�§�¡0�¦)²§¡Ù3�ì?õõc§ÀÃ�!Ã5��§

u%]�§øl­��Ó£)k"Ó�§�¡�k�éµìØ3pYÃ�§ìYm�

q9Ô¶U)�â7k^§�� åþ��"

*l0�`·´� Æ¬§4¦�a)k¡þ�é¹Â"Úÿ�f·´Æ¬§

��¤�·)\"é·`§Æ¬`²\�1®²p§�õ?�1"�Lk¡�

)�§́ �3\�cüé�¿´`§ìÃØp$§km�Ò�pì¶YØ3�f§k

9ÔK���§Ï�]��ö3�ì?1õc§Ø3ìpì$§Ø3ì>Y*�f"

�üé�¿´`§\ékâƧékUå§�´�Åؤ٧IUYd?"Ó�§é

O�Åþ1§¢ygC�K"Úÿ�X¯·§́ Ø´é�eó��¸Ø÷¿§��

��¸"·¯ç�

·ám§k<%§k�í§]umÿ§���k����§4�¬@�"¥Æ.

��§·3�[�.Ik�óè��efó<§üc�dü �x��®¢½ï�

Æ��÷��§(��£ü l¯�óEâ+n§l��ïÓó<§�Ú�Úrþ

+nk §k�ú?LEâè�!��!�8oó§��"�©ªéè�*�'X

ª�+nØ÷§F"ÏLØäÆS§UCó��¸"u´§1995cÏLgÆ�¤��

ÆS§¼��®�ÆnÆƬƠ¶1998ce�c±Ó�Æ{�°��ƬïÄ)§

Page 58: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 47

Ó��¥I{Ƭú?ÄïEâ�¯§2002c¼����Ï�ÆƬƠ¶2003c

å§�>3çIúiZXçI�n§�>3Ƭ�ó�Õl¯êÆïħ2005cÑ

Õ§¼�¥I�Æ�Ƭ�yÖ"ùc§·rL�´§No�ÄÑ�ÛÇk¡þ

�oé�£ã�´Xd¯<��qQ"u´§ugS%/aq�§êÛÇw·n�

5ùoO�¿3��§Ø�/�Ó¯!*lí�ø4m�ÛÇ,§ïƦ��B�

Ñ�§�½��ø4m�ÛÇ,�ê�êÛÇ"

·ùc���3�g§̄ gCµÛÇk¡þ��éJ�ý��±ä½<)o§

��o�·¬k½|Qº�Xé5��²6!5´²6§±95í�ã6�DÚ©z�

�\ÆS§�<éù�:�)º´§�·k)`�{�½´k¡þ��齬�§

¢Sþ´Ú��Ì{w�xò§Ù¥ØyÐcÐé§�ØÓ�<éx¿§�±�Ñ

ØÓ�n)§ ��·�<%¥�½k¤â¦§¬3%¥Øgú/<ù{�½´

�é�éA)\§��F"â¦�(J"ù¿�X§�·k)�{�½´ÛÇk¡

þ��飱�/�2�§4<�Ñ���mÒ��§��%¥â¦(J��U5

��"

ù�§·�Ò��§�·�¤õ3u|©|^�ó�¹·§çIæK��·

���§I��ó�°O§AO´æI¦�O(.½"��5¿�´§F~^�

�3���Ø(½5§��I(Ü�¸âUO(n)"éA�§;�^�K´Ó1

m�é,��A½;�+�§�½�¤�Ö¡�ó"�d§çI<Jø�æI¦§

A�´çI�8¤3+��A�;�Lã!�x�.½"ùp§UçI�8aO�

;�A�©ãXe"

1.ó§çI"ó§ï��8�Eâ�¦§��þA�)µ�I[�Ù�ó§ï

�{ÆÚ{5¶�I[�Ù�ó§ï�IO!5�Ú5§§AO´I[r��1�

ó§ï�IO!5�Ú5§¶�/�ó§ï�{5!5�!IO!5§Ú�{¶��

'¯��Eâ�¦½`²�¯�"3dÄ:þ§ó§ï��8¥�t!�O!i

n!�óÚ­���!á�çI§éAÙA:§²(;�Eâ�¦"

1¤tçI"t§́ �âï�ó§��¦§�²!©Û!µdï�|//�!

/n�¸A�Úñèó§^�§�¤t�w���;�¹Ä"tçI�Eâ�

¦§Øó§çI���Eâ�¦§�A�)t��!t¯�9�I�¦!t

<Ú���¦§±9t¤J§�)t`²!ã�!�Ý!�ª!°ê91N

��¦¯�"

2¤�OçI"�O§́ 3ó§õUÚ�^ïÄ�Ä:þ§U�¦�¤�ó§k

/1N§=�Oã�§�3.½ó§ï����!IOÚ�{"�OçI�Eâ�

¦§Øó§çI���Eâ�¦§�A�)�85y^�!�O��!�OSN!

Page 59: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

48 çIæÛYFn

õU«y9ó²6§!�O<Ú���¦§±9�O¤J§�)�O`²!ã�!

�Ý!�ª!°ê91N!Ð�!�.!Äx��¦¯�"

3¤inçI"in§́ �âI[�'ï�IO!5�!5§Úó§�O©�§

éó§ï�L§?1Ò!i�Úµd§?1?Ý!�þ!¤���ÚÜÓ!&E+

n§�Nï�"inçI�Eâ�¦§Øó§çI���Eâ�¦§�A�)i

n��!inSN!L§in!in�Y!in<ÚÁ�uÿ¤ì���¦§±9

¤J©���¦¯�"

4¤�óçI"�ó§́ �âI[�'ï�IO!5�!5§Úó§�O©�§

|Ü<å!ÔåÚãåéó§dÖ¡©�C¤ó§¢N�ïEL§"�óçI�E

â�¦§Øó§çI���Eâ�¦§�A�)��O(��Oã�9Eâ�¦§

=Jø��Oã�ÚEâ�¦Ø��3±e�/µ�ã�½Eâ�¦¥²(1²,

1Jø�O½Eâ�¦�;�ó§½Ü ¶�ã�½Eâ�¦�3�Ø!c�gñ

½öØÓã�þéÓ�Ü �Eâ�¦Ø�¶�Eâ�¦¹·Ø�§=kVg5½

�K5§XIS`D¬ý��¦ ÃäNEâ�I!ëê�¦¶�Eâ�¦wq²

(�øl½|ø�§Ã÷vEâ�¦�ø�½ö�3÷v�¦�ø��Ù5U!�

þ!sÚÚ¦^�JZ��O¶�ã�½Eâ�¦é,�;�ó§½Ü �IO!

5�!5§�¦Ø²§½´®²-¢��IO!5�!5§¶�Ù¦IçI<3æ

¥?�Ú²(EâIOÚ�¦"5¿§ã����óçI�8�Eâ�¦§́ ó

§�óçI©��­�|¤Ü©§ÙO(ÃØ´çI<�ÝI<9¥I<�{Æ«

ì"�,´çI<��O<\¾�÷�OÜÓ§���O©�Ñy�Ø!¢¦!

¹·!gñ!Ø¿©½Ù¦"�§́ çI< Ø´Ù�÷��O<UÜÓ�½�¥

I<«úI?"çI<��âÙ��O<\¾��÷�OÜÓ��½��O<J¢

��§�éu�ó¥I<���§KUÜÓ�é5�K§=ÜÓ���¯<�ÂÖ

´é��¯<��|§dçI<�¥I<«ú"

2.ÀÔçI"ÀÔ§�)ó§ï�¥�­���!á�,±9ó§±�ÀÔ§

ÙEâ�¦��¡�Eâ5�Ö§�)µ�øÀ��"~X§��çI�§�)Ì

Å!9Å!N�9"��!;^óä!�¬��§á�çI¥�¬8!5�.Ò!ê

þ�¶�ÀÔó��¸§�)�m!|¤�å�g,^�§ø>!øY!øí!ø9

��@^�§±9ÑÖ<+�¶�ÀÔEâ5�!ëê�Eâ�¦§�)ã�¶�À

Ô�ÂIOÚ�{¶���SCNÁ9EâÑÖ�¦¶�ÀÔ)��E�9�Ô

�¦¶�ÀÔ�C!I£9�¦¶�ÀÔ$Ñ�ª¶�È�ÑÖ¶�Ù¦I�`²�

¯��"

3.ÑÖçI"ÑÖ§�)ó§t!�O!in±�ÑÖçI§çI<A�

Page 60: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 49

3éÑÖ�½|ø�N�Ä:þ§(½ÑÖEâ�¦§�)µ�ÑÖI¢y�õU

½8I¶�ÑÖ�1�I[!1�!/�IO½Ù¦IO!5�¶�ÑÖI÷v��

þ!S�!Eâ½ÔnA5¶�ÑÖ��½ö¢��mÚ/:¶�ÑÖIO!Ï�!

�Ç��¦¶�ÑÖ�ÂIO¶�ÑÖ�Ù¦�¦¯�"

çIÝI�ó´Ö¡�ó§XÛ^Ö¡�óO(LãæI¦§¦ÝI<éæ

I¦�n)��´çIæ���Ä:5ó�§�´çI<ú²!ú�/|�ç

IÝI¹Ä���Ä��¦"Ó�§ù�´�ä��æ�8´Ä·uçIæ�

OK"÷vù�OK��±?1çI§Ø÷v�§�Uæ^Ù¦�ª§X!�!�û

��ªæ§½´çI<(½æI¦�2?1çI"

13!Ø%µ¢�5�¦�^�

çIÝI�Ø%3uÝI¿�§´ÝI÷væI¦Ä:þ|�ÝI<¿�§

J`(½¥I<§�¥I<\¾ÜÓ"u´§4ÝI<¿��o§No¿�´çI

æÔÑI�X­ïįK§Ùm�´¢y`z�æ(J"Uì���ÜÓ5�

5K§�¯<3ÜÓ��½öêþ!�þIO!d±½ö�Å!Á1Ï�!Á1/:

ÚÁ1�ª§±9�¯<��|ÚÂÖ�Ì�¯��û���Ä:þ§âU\¾�

Æ"·�k©Ûe¡ù�(´çr�¥��¯§2?�Ú?Ø"

[(´çr��¯] ´Ó5(§�Ѳd��!½�!(´nÜ­§çr���

«AÏS�§�¦I�3´Ó�½�¤��å�Rx­7§�/�S�¡��B

�§çrx��§´��ª5(§Ø��¥§US�«úI?§=eå��¥§ç

r�ò�I�¶eI��¥§Kçr��Øò"´Ó5(�ØÓ�ã§çrê�Ø

�"½�çr±y7�̧k�II�|Gå�11111�§̀ ´�)�­�°ý�§

k�I|G16888�§̀ ´�)�­u[!u�!uã"(´çr��dy7\¢Ô

�¤"~X§k��½´30000�\�@4�§k�/�´68000 �\�@4�Ú�

ý�ð�§¤��8´Ó5(¥�����"

`k�éIå�c�rÚ�û§́ ¥ÆÓƧ'XéÐ"ü<[3à~§¥Æ

.���å?¢�ó§FÈ)�"2007cS!§ü<£�à~[p�I1ûÆ(´§

ƽ�cÊ�!¾´§��I�!(´"å�[Jѧ�¦½��§I��å�r

711111�¶(´�§�å�ç716888�!{¢�@4�ÄG§�88000��m§±

9ç>!X�!g1�!W�Å�o��"Ù¥§�z���±dV��50%«

ú"I�éçr@�"V���Ó¿���´r���§�¬�Ü��P§�+(

´y"

Page 61: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

50 çIæÛYFn

�cÊ��F§�rÚ�û£~Þ�½�¤ª§��~p��p"­�P

<!�*Ðlë��y"I��U�Ð�ûƧ�å�ç711111�"��§�r

I1�Ï�<3{¢��4Ã�«À½�@4�§ýGÄG±"

2007c9�eͧI��å�[ûÆ��(´[!"ù�§�û�I1Jѧ(

´çr�2O\�ý20��m��ð�§̀ ~p��Ò�Iå�I1§@�çr

��§¿¡f§�5Ý"I��fÒ:§̀ �Ê8çr§gCAc�ó�aÚ

[p�Â�aا�±��Ò*l/5�§�rnvçr§�[<®áe+�§

XJ2O\�ý20��m�ð�§I��[دØÕ�nØê§�¦UV��Ð

ûƧ3��Þ�´r"�ûI1ØÓ¿§¡XJØUù��¦�§�ûØUg�

�r"

�5§�r9ÙI1õg��ûI1ûƧå�[��Øt�"��§V��

�´�"Ó�§I��¦å�ò�11111�r7§å�j±Øò§@�r7´I�x

�å��r¬§V��dOþ{Ì"

ù�V´yX8à~§��v,��çr�½öõ )Ø´�¥�~�¯~"

ùpI�á�Ù�´§́ Ó5(L§¥�çráu�o5�§��´Ä�±ÒV�

û½�¯��¦?U§ÄKØg½Ø�ºÄk§(´çr´�/«§AO´à~

�3��«´gº�§q¡ãr!­r!­ã�"Uù«º�§I��åf�Ó§A

�å�[�½ê�ã���¾´rÔ§ÄKØg"Ùg§́ ÓgÌ"5¬{;6́ Ó

[Ì?1�Z"o�8^5½§(´IåV�L��g�§B�?Û��é¦�\

±r½§B�?Û|�½ö�<\±Z�"�d§��v,��çr�½öõ§Ø

g½Ø��§¿Ø��5¬{;6́ Ó[Ì?é´Ó�5½"@o§�¯¥I��¦

å�ò�11111��¾´çr´ÄA��{Æ|±Qº5¬{;6́ Ó[Ì?1�Z

"o��^²(B���!ïñ´ÓÚÙ¦Z�´Ógd�1�§B�/´Ó¢�

ãÔ"�éUìS��Gçr���§�ëìdc�p<¬{��Ù�5'u·^

3¥u<¬�ÚI´Ó{4eZ¯K�)º(�)6¥1�^�5½"T^²(5½§

XJ�²áu±e�/µ�´V���n(´�PÃY�§�´V��n(´�P

ÃY�(��Ó)¹�§n´´c�G¿���G<)¹(J�§<¬{�A�|

±"�d§�¯¥I��¦å�ò�11111�r7§{�|±§Ï�V�ÿ��n(

´�PÃY"

´Ó±IåV�a��Ä:"�d§5¬{;6́ Ó[Ì?æ�´Óg��K§

��3´Ó5(L§¥§ÃØ�o�ÏØg½Ø��§¿ØJÄÙ{ÆI?"çI

ÝI¹Ä�g���g«ì�A:§û½5�¥�?Û��§=çI<½¥I<

Ø��¥§Ï�çI<�çI©�1²çI§¥I<�ÝI©��AçI§®

Page 62: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 51

¤�¯¢§5��§?Û����¥1��½��½|�´�ú²�K§���

Ù¦�¥IÝI<�Ü{�Ã"

@o§ÜÓ�¢�5SN3çIÝIL§¥´N�Ny�§qA�XÛ�½ç

I<�¥I<¾á�ÜÓ´Ä�lÜÓ¢�5SNQº��/§ÜÓ¢�5SN

´çIL§¥çI©�1²�§@¥I<Á�7L�l�çI�8^�ØUC�

/e§Ø�N�½?U�ÜÓ¯�"çIæL§¥§ÜÓ¢�5SNÌ�Ny3

çI©�¥�æI¦!µI�{!ÜÓ^��Ù!¥§æ^\5(Ò½²(N�

 � l���½�p�ꧽ´Ù¦²(w�ÝI<¢�5�¦�^���ª§

ٹ´ÝI¿��.�§=��ÝI<÷v¢�5�¦Ú^�Òä�¿�]�§

Ù�Ñ�çI<ÒA��Ù\¾ÜÓ"

éæI¦§=æI�²(�ÜÓ¢�5SN�¯�§ó§t!�O!�

ó!in§±9ÑÖçI�¦ÝI<�âçI©�JøÁ��Y§ÀÔçI�¦Ý

I<JøÝIÀÔEâ5U�I��[£ãÚEâ|±]�"Ù¥§Eâ|±]�

�¦±�EûúmuÙ�<M]�½öuÿÅ�Ñä�uÿ�w§½öçI<3Ý

I<L�cNL#N�Ù¦/ª�O§±�½ÝI´Ä÷vçI©��¢�5�¦

Ú^�"

~X§,�8>FæI¦¥§¢�5�¦Ú^��µ�°Ä��µ[^ÓÚ°

ÄEâ§�½1­1150kg§�½�Ý1.5m/s§[^ÓÚCª�ŧ8�/8Õ/8�§��

XÚ��Å�Nz��XÚ¶�õU�¦µ1)ICkõU¶2)�8À��¶3)u?$1!

åÄÖ�¶4) ð�õU¶5)>FgÍ$1¶6)�ÕgÄm�!UÜm�§gÄ'�!

UÜJc'�¶�æ­m�¶7)éùÅÏÕ!́ $¶8)÷1�¨¶9)s¨��Sì²!

º÷gÄä>!Ê>ì²õU¶10) ³��¢êâgÆS!�æ{¤P¹¶11)�¢

 �&ÒgÄ?�¶12)ÑF¶13)�oµ�«ØUm�!14!m'�É{!�1!

��!$1��!jØ!j�!.�!ªà�§!S��>ì>:uÿ!Cªì!_�

$1�¶14)>F$1gêw«¶15)��£á�¶16)�æw«¶17)�Ø�-��!

��gÄ�Ø�-¶18):ª�¢w«ì!¢�EÄw«¶19)�IJ�õU¶20)^

�ÝgÆSõU¶21)��&Ò�"!»/;:�£$1¶22)Ê�Ï{¶23)��

ö�¶�Äå> µöÄ> §�6380ϧ50Hz, n�o�§Õá/�¶ì²> µ

�6220ϧ50Hz, ü�¶���C»µu«ØCg!Lº!PVC /¡§ØCg�

�¶�¥©ªVm�§º�900mm × 2100mm§u«ØCg��@C»¶�³�

º�µ2100mm× 2350mm§.��1700mm§º�p4600mm§J,pÝ28500mm§

³�op34800mm§ �0 − 25mm¶�Å�º�3500mm × 4000mm × 2500mm§

 �±2mm¶��Sº�1600mm× 1580mm§�º�1650mm× 1765mm¶�ê

Page 63: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

52 çIæÛYFn

þ6ܧøÀ�mµ2006c6�30F�2006c8�20F"

�d§ÝI<ÝI�>F�°Ä��!õU!5�º�!��SC»!�9

�@!êþ�øÀ�m�L÷vþã�¦§âä�ë�Á�¿��^�"Ù¥§ø

À�m�k� � l�I"@o§ÜÓ\¾�§çI<UÄ��þ¡(´çr�

¯¥å���{§�¦¥I<r°Ä��¥��½1­1150kg!�½�Ý1.5m/sU

��½1­1650kg!�½�Ý2.0m/sº�,ØU§ÏçIÝI�l�g���g«

ì�K§éùü�ëê�?U§¢�þ´?UæI¦§=I�¢�5�¦Ú^

�§é¥I<ÚÙ¦ÝI<Øú²§Ï�æI¦¥I²Ù�(Òëê"3ù«�

/e§ÃØ¥I<Ó¿�ħ�ÃØçI<´3¥I<Ó¿�Ä:þN�¥Id�§

Ñ��ú²�´�½|�K"

�d§çIæI¦¥�¢�5�¦Ú^�§́ ÝI<�AçI!ë�ÝI¿

��Ä:"@o§XÛ.½æI¦¥§=Ï�!�I½�¦´¢�5�¦Ú^

�§=Ø´QºXJ¢�5�¦Ú^���Lu°�§�UéJ��ÎÜ�¦¿

�(J§��LÄq�U¬��¿�(JØ÷vçIæÔÑI¦"�d§çI<

I�(ÜçI�8A:!ÔÑÜÝÚ½|¿�§Ý§¢¯¦´/(½§ÙÄ��K

´§�¯â¦3ÜÓ\¾�§�¥I<?�Ú!�!ûÆ�¯�§ØU�\æI

¦�¢�5�¦Ú^�"��§��B\æI¦¥¢�5�¦Ú^�§¥I<�

ÝIÒ7L÷v½�k|uçI<"Ó�§�Ø2#NçI<N�½´¥I<éÙ

�A�?U"

��§'��eçIÝI5��´Ó5(�ØÓ§=çIÝI5��´Ó5(

�ØÓ3=p§��o3´Ó5(¥§é��kJÑ5(^�§�5q­#JÑ

5(^�§ÄK§Øg½Ø���/§��V�v/¤´Ó§{ÆØJÄ�¥��

�I? çIÝI5K¥Ø#NQºÏ�´Ó5(�lg��K§?Û����¥§

=Ø�¿5(Ø«ú{ÆI?§��V�vk´Ó5(�¯¢½Ö¡y²©�"

�§=Br´Ó'Xw�ÜÓ'X§Ù�ª5(§=3¬�Ü��P!�+(´y

Ö�L§¥§�±´õg��!�g«ì" çIÝI5�K�dØÓ§́ �g�

�!�g«ì§Ù5�æ^Ö¡©�§=çI<!ÝI<�5�^�§©O3çI©

�!ÝI©�¥§��çI<�,�ÝI<uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§Ò´«ìÙÝI��§

/¤Ö¡ÜÓ"d�§çI<Ú¥I<¥?Û���¥§N�çI©�1²�¢�

5�¦Ú^�½öÝI©�éçI©�¥¢�5�¦Ú^���A§�5¬{;6

´Ó[Ì?1�Z"Ô�8^¥5½�l´§=)Ø´Ó'X��§L�«ú�A

I?§�)²LI?Ú{ÆI?"

Page 64: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 53

14!¿�µÏ�!IOÚ^�

æI¦�O((½´çI<uåæ�Ä:�Ø´m�"çIÝI�Ø%3

u|�ÝI¿�§±¦çI<l¥¼�`z�æ(J"O(.½æI¦´çI

æ�Ä:½/L0§²dÝI¿�`zæI¦´¢�½ /́�0"çI<(½æ

I¦�§�­��ó�3u(½æI¦¥§=I¦Ï�!�IØU¿�§=

�±¿�§qN�¿��¯�"Ù¥§ØU¿��Ï�!�I§��¡´�lÚ�

�5½�½|ø�ÊH�l�Ï�!�I§,��¡´õU½¦^I¦7L÷v�

Ï�½�I§=¢�5�¦Ú^�"�±`§��Ø´¢�5�¦Ú^�§3÷v

æI¦cJeÑ�±¿�"ùpI�?Ø�§́ N�|�ÝI¿�§Ù¿��O

�IO´�o§ýÏ¢y(Jq´�o�"

·�kw�K_%�ç­�¯§2�\&?ù�¯K"

[c�ç­��¯] �U§oàé��ú¿Ì?§̀ �~�LoÜ�Ù¦úi

Po�N§oÜc�</�jZ§K�úi��¬/�Ú«@�Ö§4ëì�'

IOç­� c�"²�§3c��f>{!�<5�Hx!�ú^¬+n!u�

�§'��§�U�ÏPoú'§«��Ö§��þ�±�É�ú¿BÌ?��§ó

]'c�p20%-40%"

Ì?%+ ¬§ëìÀ{�½A­IO§�¦A­<µ�Æ{��F�p�

.��;�9±þÆ{§1�½<¯+n;�¶�5Oµå§c#22-26�§�p1.62-

1.72�§Þ�'~1/7-1/8¶��mµÊ(à�!Û�ò§ó!Þ�!/�Z¶�Ë

þµ8ü±þ¶�UåµÙGoffice~^�ú^�¶�Ù¦µkìèÜ�° §ÃØû

µÐ§�c±þ�'²�§A3.�)`D���±"

ç­úw3�Ͷ�Õ!��rÑ�§���¬þ�ÊH�A"áá20U§Ò

Â�51°A­��"Ì?w3úp§U3%p§l½1�Æ�!Í�Æ�Ú¬Ë�

¬­�n P�§�¦Úúic¬�üy<|¤µ�¬§æ�Ð"!¡ÁÚí�§

oà��À½�ç­Ú½"

µ�¬é��á�?1î�Ð"§"���çÚ졧Û�ò!/�Z§�k

Þ�'��I§k43 ��<3Ð"�Me"Ù¥§�Øyk��¯"k A­<

Jø�ì¡þ§Í�Ä�é{§��ï�Ä�k:�f§["uyÙ´C5<¶�

k� ��p§µ�@��ŧ�á�þ`¨w´of§XA­¤õ�±�è�~

["ù�¥§k�°�k��á�"A­<g¡´�7ê126�D<§m{Xl�

gã�UÕ3ü˧̄ UØUì��e§̀ ¨y��î3�7ê2>þ"á�¥Nk

�¼[ÌÚc��"éù��<§µ�¬ÎØ3�§jû<e"

Page 65: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

54 çIæÛYFn

¡Á4��<gdu�§�¦a�ãÍ�½´�¿rþ30Ú§Ny/nAõ^0

��/ÚÄ�"½¬Ë�¬�5�;[ïƧ̀ ÏLÐ"�§�kËþ´v¢S�

y���M�I§�¦ïþü��GÞ§O�Ð��ü�Ë�§̀ UÕ4��Ò�

ÏL"ù�ïÆ��µ�¬���@Ó"

¡Á�{®�§oà�fÒW§ë`n�/Ð0§L«�Ä�m�*¡Á"

¡Áþ§k� A­<;ܧO��Þ§� r´¥�li§�kn<Õ2�ËÒ

ö/þ§vUÏL¡Á"�e�n §��Ƭ!��a¬§����Æ{"Ì?

�§ùn<§=� Ñ÷vÀ­IO§�´�doàû½j"

Ì?òµ"í�(J�oà®��§oà`§\4Ƭ!a¬Ú��)Õc�§

Ü·í§¦�¬ÐÐZoº�´À��;�)j�¡Á¥Ø´k��wX�| Z

�/�4Z�;�)íºÌ?£�`¨ËþØ1§Õ��Ò�e�@k�o'Xº

oà`§�±5úi���í§ÒÀ¨j�Ì?�fa`Ч¿A(�­#�µ"

�w§UoàÀ½�c�­#�í�ïƧr¡Áþ@��| Z�A­<��Ä

À§��oà"1"

@o§c�ç­��¯éæJ`k=é&QºÄk§c�<I�ûÐ/

�§�Ø´À{§ØU^À{�IOïþ��c�ó�<"ù¿�XæJ`´

3�I���Ä:þ�J`§LuJpIO½�¦¿Ø�½k|uJ`(½æ(

J"~X§�¯¥��p1.62-1.72�!Þ�'~1/7-1/8�§Ñ´3LuJpÀJI

O¶Ùg§J`IO´î��§µ�¬�J`IOµ"�Ñ�(Ø�´î��§ØU

ÀÓ�Z"�¯¥�J`IO!µ�¬´{�§¿vkî��1§å�ý�J`�

^§Ï��¯���§oà¿vklµ�¬J`í��� Æ¬!� a¬Ú� 

��A­<¥ÀJ§ ´lÏLÐ"�8�<¥U�| Z!/�Z��IO?1À

J�"ÀJ�§Ëþ38ü±þ��¦�vý��1§Ï�8�<¥§k3 �<Õ4ü

ËÒ����EB\ÀJ��"éd?�Ú�g��§XJËþ��Ø´8ü

´3ü±þ§c5A­��U�Ø�51�<§4oàÀJ���A��°§�ª(

½�<��U�`D"$�§̀ ؽ§gã´�7ê126�D<!m{Xl�@ â

´oà��ÀJ�@ §ÏØÙËþ�k3ü§÷vJ`IO¥�¤k�¦§�Ø

LÏÙËþ�k3ü§3Ð"�!=�Me§vUë\¡Á§oàvw�Ù�<"ù

`²�oº̀ ²�¯¥J`J�o¿Ø�Ù§��¥ÀWaq§Ì�d@p��*

�¤y3�oà§ÙJ`IO!µ�¬9µ"ØL´�|iZ§û½�3oà"

�<¯ç­ØÓ§çIÝI¹Ä¥�æI¦LÖ¡Jø�ÝI<§3çI©

�¥1²§ÝI<��A�´Ö¡�§3ÝI©�¥1²"éA�§µI�¬´

UçI©�éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§çI<J`´�âµI�¬�µ"Ú'

Page 66: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 55

�(J§=µI�w?1J`§¢�´UçI�¯¢éÝI�¯¢J`ÀJ§5K

�î�5���u<¯ç­§=�UUúÙ�J`IOÚ�{µ"§Ø�3L§¥

N�½UCJ`IOÚ�{§ØU�c�ç­��¯¥@ oà@�§òg��ú

Ù�J`IO¥Ëþ38ü±þ��¦§O\�| Z��J`IO§Ï3½|�

´¥§ù��{��ú²!ú�Úª¢&^�´�Ä��K"

çIæI�Uæ�8A:ÚI¦(½J`IO§I�µï�<h%,g§

�l�*5Æ?1ÀJ", §ù�:é��ÊÏ<5`´éJ��â`§k�gÐ

�Û�3��/�ù²`{§5AZÝ<§��Øù Ãú�ºæ§��ú�w§

Ð�Û��ü�ÕX8�Xsq��©#åJ§�äú"ݯ���$eÞ§�g

C�úçù!%2Ä"Ù¢§Ãúù´3/ù²`{���eݯ?�"� P

Úÿþc�¦Ãú§́ Ø´4�>�åÅi�6�£;�e"Ð�Û�¯¦§̈ �

Ø´åÅií§̀ Q,´åÅi§r¨��åÅiÒ1§Û5{Ú�Χ§=Ø

�4/{Ú0K�g�§=º¿+Z357f²6¥w�LÅJ�§©Û¯n3µï

�<�/·�!<�!̄ )�!Æö�0�§�Ñ�(ØâجÉ�L¡y�½/�0

�Z6"

�Æ(½æI¦¥�¿�5Ï�½�I§́ çIÝI`zæI¦§u�Ù

3] ��¥û½5�^���"�d§çI<A(ܽ|ø�G¹§UçI�8

A:ÚI¦§(½æI¦¥�¿�Ï�½�I§�)Ï�½�IaO!�½IO

Ú�{�¯�"

1.¿�Ï�½�IaO" ¿�Ï�½�INy3æI¦¥�k� � l

Ï�½�I!¿�Ï�½�I¥½|ø��3�5z�É"¢Sþ§½|¿���

�3uØÓ�ø��3�N�É"éA�§çI<�J`ÀJ§T´3÷væI

¦cJeéø��J`ÀJ§ØLØ´3��ø�½|§ ´3�AçI�ÝI¥

Ï�5z�É�J`ÀJ"~X§ó§�óçI¥�d�!AÏ!:Ü ��ó[

z!�óó²!óÏ!"�I?Ï�¶ÀÔçI§XïÓøY"æI¦¥�d�!

6þ£m3/h¤!�§pH£m¤!¶õÇ!øÀÏ!�?϶ÑÖçI¥�ÑÖIO!

ÑÖÏ�½�m!�Ç�§þ����¿�Ï�½�I"

2.Ï�½�I¿�IO"(½¿�Ï�½�I�8�§3u(½Ù �½ l

éæ(J�K�"Ù¥§k��±þz§k�ØUþz"é@�þz�Ï�½

�I§Aÿ�Ùü  �½ léI�õ^!d��þzK�¶é@Ø�þz�

Ï�½�I§A3½|N�Ä:þ§|�;�<ý�½´ý�Ù �½ léI

�õ^!d��K�"7��§��±��;�|�½Å�u�N�¯ò§æ^

ênÚO�{(½ÙþzK�§±��J`IO§Ú�ÝI<�Xk|uçIæ

Page 67: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

56 çIæÛYFn

ÔÑ`z¢y���ÝI"éd§ISþÏ1��{´(½z�¿�Ï�½�I�

 �½ l3çI�8)·±ÏS§éçI<|G¤^�K�§±?1J`ÀJ"

~X§­.Õ1�IS7K|�J`æ^��$µId{§=´ù��{�Ny"

Ù¥§d�´�«²L)¹¥����þz�I"d§(½ØÓÏ�½�I�­

�5§æ^©Ú©�ãé¿�Ï�½�I?1J`§K´ISnܵ�{�J`N

y§Ï�k���Ã{(½¿�Ï�½�I� �½ l3çI�8)·±ÏSé

çI<|G¤^�K�"

3.½|N���["ÿ�¿�Ï�½�IéçI�8õ^Úd��K�§lØ

m½|ø�§=ÝI<�¢Sø��½|d�"�d§çI<I�3½|N�Ä:

þ(½æI¦§3½|N�Ä:þ(½Ù¥�¿�Ï�½�I§ÿ�Ù �½ 

léI�õ^!d��K�"Ó�§3ÐÚ(½¿�Ï�½�I!IOÄ:þ§A?

1¿��[�(Jÿ�§�ä¿�Ï�½�I´Äà�§́ Ä�kÙ¦¿��Ï�

½�II�Ö¿§¿�Ï�½�I��½IO´Ä�ÆÜn§́ ÄÎÜæýÏ8

I½���§éçI�8¿�Ï�½�I!J`IO|�±YU?§±¢yçIæ

m�"

¢�L²§(½æI¦¥�¿�Ï�½�I!�½IOÚ�{´çIæ¥

���­��ó�§́ æ^çIÝI�¦J`¢yçIæÔÑ�'�"I�çI

<édÚ±¿©�'5�­À"

[�£I] EâIO´éÚ��Eâ¯��¾�IO§Ùé�Q�±´�¬!á

�!óä�Ô�a§��±´Vg!§S!�{!ÎÒ��Ô�a§́ l¯�ï!�

O!ó²!u��Eâó�±9û¬6Ï¥�Ó�Å�Eâ�â"EâIO��©

�Ä:IO!�¬IO!�{IOÚS�!¥)!�¸�oIO�"

15!Y~µæI¦ØOÚuزï�d

æI¦�O(ÃØ´¿�ÚÁ�¢��Ä:"çIæ�I¦ØO(§~X§

çIæ�üØ��§�3"¦½P{�!,�f8æþØO§çIæEâ�

¦!ã��3�ؽgñ§Eâ�¦½IO¹·Ø�§æ¢�5�¦Ú^�!¿

�Ï�½�IØO!J`��Ø�(�§́ E¤ÝI¿��J`Ã{¢y!ÜÓÁ

�ª�½´Á�¤^O\§Ù�çI<E¤���§k�3Á�¥¬Ñy§�k�§

�����Á�(å§çI<Ú¥I<(��â¬Ñy"ÄÙ�ϧ3uæI¦

�ØO¬ÚuÝI¿��_l"? §k²��ÝI<éÁ�L§?1ý�§lç

I<Jø�æI¦�Ø?æ�زï�d�¿�E|��¥I]�§¼�¿�Â

Page 68: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 57

Ã"

e¡ù�Y~§́ Ïó§þ�ü�æI¦Ø�� Úu�¯�"

[Y�£�] ,���颽A!B!Cn�û¬4Ã�«�øYó§§�)èï

�óÚ��!á�æ�SC�8çI§çI©�þ1²�çI��§́ Uó§�O

ã�d½«g5Y��A!B!Cn�û¬4Ã�«ï��^DN200ÌZ+§2dZ

+ï�DN100�n^���«�øY+�"çIæ^²µ"��$d¥I��K§

ÜÓa.�üdÜÓ"ó§þ�ü¥§DN100!DN200+�Æ�þ�L3.1§�¦Ý

I<�Idó§þ�ü¤�nÜüd§�¹���8¤^!5¤Ú[7¤^"

©�󧶡 ü  ó§þ �5

DN200¥$Òc+Á� m 10000.00

DN100¥$Òc+Æ� m 21000.00

L3.1 DN100!DN200ó§þ�ü

T�8n�ÝI<þä�çI�8Á�Uå§Ãd�N�¯�"�d§T�8

ÝI<¿�Ø%´d�§ÝI<Id®o�L3.2¤�"UçI©�5½�²µ"�

�$d¥I�K§çI<\ÙÝI<1¥I§¥Id�7906000.00�"

©�󧶡 ü  ó§þ ÝI<1 ÝI<2 ÝI<3

DN200¥$Òc+Á� m 10000.00 280.00 210.00 200.00

DN100¥$Òc+Æ� m 21000.00 120.00 180.00 190.00

٦�8�d � 1 2586000.00 2578000.00 2591000.00

�dÜO 7906000.00 8458000.00 8581000.00

L3.2 Idó§þ�ü

Á�L§¥uy§�«C�¢S^rØ´çI�ý��4500r ´8500r§Ù

FøYþI�AO\"éA�§DN200+�d10000mO\�20000m§DN100+�

d21000m~��11000m"(�dd¥Id7906000.00�C�9506000.00�§�ö�

�1600000.00�"�[%<�uy§XJ´ÝI<2½ÝI<3¥I§éA�(

�d�©O�8758000.00 �Ú861000.00�§@�ù��8ØA�4ÝI<1 ¥I§

A�\ÙÝI<3¥I"

[¯K] �éþã£ã§©Û±en�¯Kµ

1.T�8çIÝIL§¥§(½ÝI<1¥I´Äk�§́ ÄA�(½ÝI<3¥

I§��oº

2.ÝIزï�d��/k=§çIÝIL§¥AN���§ÜÓÁ1L§

¥qA�N�ý�º

Page 69: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

58 çIæÛYFn

3.Y~¥§ÝI<1¥I9Ù(�(Jé?�æI¦k=é&º

[Y~©Û] þãn�¯K´çIæ¥�I�ïÄ�¯�§�g©ÛXe"

1.Äk§(½��ÝI<�¥Id§´UÙÝI���d§�´U�8Á1(

å��(�dºlçIæL§©Û§�UUÝI<�ÝI�dû½Ù¥Id§Ï

�5��§��Ãl�¡ÜÓÁ�(å��d�´õ�"�ù�¯K�Jѧ¿�

vk¿Â ´çIæÔÑI��\ïÄ���¯K"ÄK§çIÝIÒvk¢S

¿Â§ØL´(½¥I<�//ª0L§§Ï�¬¯¹ÄL�Ìú²½´�dk�

¯¢§=¢S|G¤^��K¶Ùg§¢y¥Id�ÜÓ(�d����Ø%3ç

I<úÙ�æI¦´ÄO(§�Á�(J´Ä��"Ó�§3çIÝI�§�ä

ÝI<�ÝIÁ�´Ä\­½´~�çI<ÂÖ§́ ÄE¤çI<Á�½¦^¥

�¤^O\§ÿ�Ùü  �½ léÁ�9¦^�d�K�§O\ÝI<�ÝI

�d§=3çIÝI�ϦýO�ÜÓÁ�d�§¿Udd�J`(½¥I<"~

X§­.Õ1�IS7K|���$µId{§Ny�Ò´ù«g�§Ù¢�´U

Á�(å/�Ã�a�Ã�À0d��$�K(½¥I(J§�IS�/�dk�0

�K��"

�Y¥§ÏÝI<Ñä�Á�Uå§�ÝI¥vkd�N�¯�"�d§Uç

I©�5½�J`IO§�±üld��$(½¥I<§(½ÝI<1¥IÎÜú

Ù�J`5K"Ó�§�ØU(½ÝI<3¥I§Ï�Ù�d8581000.00� �n�

ÝI<��d�Ä"

2.�o´ÝIزï�dºØ²ï�d´�é�~�d ó§3ÝIod(½

�§�âçI©��G±^�ÚG±�ª§Ün/N�Id�ü¥f�8�nÜü

d§3ØJpÝI�d�cJe§±¦�8Á��U¦@!�õ/(�d±§¼

��õ|d��«�d�{"��/§ÝI<¦^زï�düÑÌ�ÄuçI<

æI¦ØO(§Ù¥§�´æ�ü§=��ØO§X�üf8æþØO§½´

P{ ÃIÁ�¶�´EâIO½�¦ØO§XEâ�¦!ã��3�ؽc�g

ñ§Eâ�¦Ø²(§=k�K5�¦ ÃäN�I!ëê§Ã�ÂIO½´æ^

�¢�ÂIO��/§ùü«�¢�Ñ´çI<úÙ�æI�ØO§ÝI</ç

I©�Á�üy�Øî� ¼�¿�Âön´ÝI�d�§Uæ�üf8Á�

�m�k�§NpcÏf8üd§Ø$�Ïf8üd�"

@o§XÛ��ÝI<æ^زï�d¼�Âç? ¢y¥Id�ÜÓ(�

dÄ���Qº��زï�d¥I��{3uæI�O(ÃØ"�d§3çI

�ã§çI<I���±eA:µ

�´æ�ü��±eA:µ��üf8�ê�çI©�¥1²�çI���

Page 70: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

13ÙçIæµI¦�.½ 59

�¶��üþO�O(§�¢SI¦þ��¶�Eâ�¦½ã�¥�'�á�!�

�!;��8§@=k«¿½´ã�þ�k²(�ëê�I§�du¬ý!�g

½È�ÑÖ��ɧAO´½|d��É��§A3çIæÔÑÄ:þ§?�Ú

[zæI¦§²(J`ëê½�I�æ"7��§�k²(6�d§�Ù�'

�¦²(�æ"

�´Ün©�ÜÓºxI?"çIæ§�k3�¯<V�/ºx�ú!|Ã

��0Ä:þâU¢y"��§Lu\�¥I<ºx�Z��§\�ÜÓÁ�ºx§

��Á�¥Ñy¥I<ÃUå«ú�ºx�§4´E¤æ(JÃ{¢y"ISþ§

éó§ï�ÜÓºx©�k¤Ù�nاÙÄ��K´§éÜÓÁ1¥@�£O

�ºx§©��A±ü$�ªÜÓ|G�8I§òºx«úö�½�k|u��½

~�ºx��³§Ý§l ~�AéÜÓºxI�|G�¤^"éd§���¦�

¯<�n�x§=£ÜÓºx"

n´�éزï�d�¾J`IOÚ�{"~X§éIdæ�ü¥�nÜü

dÚØÓÜÓÁ1�m�nÜüd!®od?1µ"!'�ÚJ`§±��ÝI<

|^زï�d¢yÙÜÓÂÃ��z"Ó�§J`Ï�!�IÚIO§A�çI

�8Á�+n���§±��ÝI<|^ÜÓÁ1�ÉÝI"

3.�Yý�%É�?§3uÝI�§ÝI<1�d��$§ÝI<3�d��p§

��âçI<úÙ�J`5KA�¥I"�ÜÓ(��§ÝI<1�(�d�q3n

�ÝI<�ÝI¥�p§́ �o�Ï��ù���æ(JQºÙ���Ï3uÝ

I<1ÝI¥$^زï�dE| çI<úÙ�J`IOédqÃU�å§=

´±�d�$��J`OK¤�"̄ K��?�Ú�ϧ3uçI<ó�þ�Ø@

ý§éæI¦�r��اÚu�é�«CI¦�^YþýOØv§�¦ó§ï

�L§¥N�øY�Y§N�DN200ÚDN100ó§þ¤�"

k<@�§ÝI<1ØA�3ÝIL§¥æ^زï�düѧ@�ù��{

��ª¢Å&��K", §vkÜyâ§L²ÝI<1�1���ª¢&

^�K§ÏÙÝIE|¤|^�§́ çI<úÙ�æI¦½I�ØO(§ ÝI

<1ØL´UgCn)�çI<�æI¦§�AçI!ë�¿�§ÎÜçIÝI5

K"3ù�:þ§I�?�ÚïÄÝI<�ÝI1�§Ï�¥I�ÝI<É¥I©

zÚS�K�"��5¿�´§¥I©z���´�¬½+NÚ�§Ny3V[/Ê

~0¥�/;0½/¥T0g�"3dÄ:þ§IS�ÝI<§ÙÊH�ÝI%n�

�Ly�µ�´�AçI§ïÄçI<�æI¦§AO´æI¦¥@ØO(

½�ا? æ�زï�d�E|¼�¿�Âö�´ïÄÙ¦ÝI<1�§±

ü$¿�éÃégC¥I|Ã��³§ù3�½§Ýþ¬puGÏÝI"

Page 71: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

60 çIæÛYFn

¤±§Ø���IÝI<13ÝI¥TØTæ�زï�d§@´ÝI<ÝI

�ÊHE|§�Ø´çI<U�m�"¢Sþ§��ÝIزï�d����{§

3uçI<O(.½çI�8�æI¦½I�§ùâ´��ÝI<3ÝI�æ^

زï�d���§�´�YéçI<|�çIæ�é&"

Page 72: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 4Ù

çIæµÁ�Uå�"�

**********************************************************************

Sì�kj�¦§0ë¤�b©Z"

— /.oûÛ.ÃK.���JO½J

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 73: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

62 çIæÛYFn

11!m�µ"�Á�Uå

Á�Uå§́ éAæI¦¤I�¢�Uå"çIædçIÝI5�ÚÁ�

ü��!|¤"Ù¥§çIÝI�Ø%3u|�ÝI<¿�§J`(½¥I<Á�

¢yæ(J"�d§|�ÝI¿�Ik1(@ÝI<´Ää�5½�]�^�§

éÙ?1Á�Uå"�§Ï��k@ä�Á�Uå�<ë�¿�§¥I�âU

Á�§âU¢yæ(J"��§XJ#N@Øä�Á�Uå�<ë�ÝI¿�§

wqÝI<êõ!¿�-�!�À(Jõ§�ÀÑ�¥I<�UØä�Uå Á�

J±¢yæ(J§¥IØL /́x\¿+0§7,��çIæ�m�"ùÒ��

¥ÀW��§F¥��X§�kww@<´Ä/�ä�º!me�S0�\�*ú"

�Ò´`§�*³mÚ �§é¢eA�If��H]�"�"aq/§æ^

Ö¡�ªéÝI<Á�Uå�"�§´çI<éÝI<|�ë�ÝI¿��"�§

´çIÝI��«7,L§"

©Û5YéD6¥�Ô���â§éçIæÖ¡5����o�k(½ÝI

<�Á�Uåké&"

[�Ô���â] �âo�§±��k´<�á���§~ó`µ/�Ø� §7

k/0"aq/§/âØ� §Jkõª0"5YéD6¥§�À��o�à�Ô§�

Ï3u�ÔÃ�ÃU�>pßU"�À²�?Ú�\º§5YéD61��£ù�£

��Ô%gµ/·%´�Ø91�Dâ§ÏjíÜXÚ[5ùpáú§Y�y�5§

à8ùNõ<ê��"·qv�©�¯§Ú[!y�ɲ��²~"X8Ø�V

ù�<§¦´®�B��Þ§7,Ðɲ"1e�¦£»·�Ã㧦LÓr§·�

XÛH'<"Øe�´�%§í%¯�§uG¦eì�B§����¶�´�?¡

þ%ØÐw§#Fc��§X8��¦Ø�"0

xX3áúYÑùì�U§r LL«!OU1��÷ã�Ñw��ÔÚÙ¦

Þ+§�Ôf��Ly´ù��/´,�ý§%SÇÔ§�(Ø�"gC�Ô§J

A�6�"0u´§31�U�Rþ§�Ôå�§àXË��xX¹Ë`µ/a�¯Í

#�dà§�ë5ì�Æ´���Y§XÛS�Nõý9"����r§�"

�3"�Ý�Æ�ê§��¦<��5eBü"0xXØÂÕf§̀ ªfYÑùìç

pB¬§�37�c5Ý�ìÆ\º"e´Ø§·�g1wò"=�cÂÉs¤

x�Õü"�Ø´3ùpg§§73A�f )�j§�kØ�Õü§m�ØÉ"

Page 74: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 63

u´§áØÂ�Ô¤x�Õf"�Ô`µ/Û�í%º�´5ìØB¯ Í#§G�

��÷��D§�F�Øve§¯ ¡�ØЧÏdØc�3"0

ù�§�Ô��ì5"���ÀäÀX�Ô`µ/\c�·þì5�§�í�

÷��D"8Fx7�¯Í#�dìƧ\qu�ù�ó�5"́ Û�nº0�Ôë

�µ/\wùT)�qØ�§�ró�5ú>·§%Ø´��þe�0

�À�ä`µ/þ\´�á1@V§9¥qv©Æ§N��ìÆ�Ì�0���À

rSfH3�>§<4�Ô§�:eÄÑ�r²��� §ë�µ/\´��~�¡

V§ºÚ[��ùp"��(<ù�]Ï\§±���§�\��§Þ�·5§ÿ

�Nõí%"8F¯Í#A5�à§q�uG¦eì�"ùùìÑB´\�º\ù

>p�U�M§Øà�\Û^�\�Ã�þ�â§��Ø�ìÆ�Ì�0ë�§�

ÀéX�Ô%�� "�î�Ô��Ø91Dâ§�XÚ[!y���æYÑùì§

�[ �§�ª��À� /·"

�Ô��)´�ì"�Dâ�Øþ§�X73�[ �§LX�L=S�)¹§

Ø�v�õª§3xX�<Ý�\º�1�U��À� /·"wL5YéD6�

<§A�vk<�%��À±e�þàk�Ô§�vk<ßÿ�À��Þr�«§

��oºÏ��ÀØ´�gC ´��[§�[�X�Ô�U´�[ �ÏÙÃ�

ÃU§Ø�Uk���§Ø�U/OU1�0§rþ<m��"

ù��¯éçIæ�é&3u§|�ÝI<¿�§LÀJÁ�Uå÷v�¦

�ÝI<ë�¿�§? (½�¥I<âkUåÁ�§âج­��ÔUåØv�

Cõ§¢yçIæm�"

çI�8©�ó§!ÀÔÚÑÖ�na§ÙÁ��/�E,§Ý��L���

�"�d§ÝI<ë�ÝI¿��^�k�µ�´I[5½]�^�¶�´çI

<�â�8A:ÚI¦3çI©�¥úÙ�]�^�§©ãXeµ

1.I[5½]�^�"I[5½�ÝI<]�^�Ì�k±enaµ

£1¤ÝI<¬¯ÌN/ "çIÝI¹Ä¥§ÝI<�¬¯ÌNLäkÕá¾

áÜÓ��|"ü Á��§�{<½öÙ¦|�"g,<Á��§�UÕá«

ú¬¯I?���¬¯1�Uå<"

£2¤½|O\^�"½|O\^�§́ B�½��ÝI<l 5̄½|O\K¡

�ü6�1�½+�§�k3Ù�{¼�O\âUë�½l¯T1�!+���8"

~Xµ

1¤ó§ï�½|O\^�"ó§ï�½|�O\^�q¡�]�+n§�;�

�ØÓ§̂ �©ãXeµ

�ó§t"ó§t]�§©�nÜ]�!;�]�ÚNÖ]�"nÜ]�

Page 75: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

64 çIæÛYFn

��`?¶ó§t;�]��âó§5�ÚEâA:�á`?Ú¯?"�âó§

5�ÚEâA:§Ü©;��Z?]�¶NÖ]�Ø©?O"��nÜ]��§«

�ó§t�Ö��ØÉ��¶��;�]��§�±«�Ó?O�A;��ó§

t�Ö¶��NÖ]��§�±«�ñèó§£n!ó§}&!=³ó§tN

Öó�"

�ó§�O"ó§�O]�§©�nÜ]�!1�]�!;�]�"nÜ]�

��`?¶1�]�Ú;�]��âó§5�ÚEâA:�á`?!̄ ?§�O1

�!;�!;�]��Z?]�§ïÓó§;�]��¶?"��nÜ]��§«�

ó§�O�Ö��ØÉ��¶��1�]��§�±«�Ó?O�A1��ó§�

O�Ö¶��;�]��§�±«�Ó?O�A�;�ó§�O�Ö§��1�]

��è�§�±«��1���SÓ?O��A;�ó§�O�Ö§ØI2üÕ+

�ó§�O;�]�"

�ó§in"ó§inè�§©�nÜ]�!;�]�Ú¯Ö¤]�"nÜ]

�!̄ Ö¤]�Ø©?O";�]�©�`?!̄ ?§�ÂïÓ!Y|Y>!ú´Ú

½�ú^;�]��áZ?"Ù¥§nÜ]��±«ú¤k;�ó§aOï�ó§

�ó§in�Ö§;�`?]��«ú�A;�ó§aOï�ó§in�Ö§̄ ?!

Z?]��«ú�A;�ó§aO�?½n?9±eï�ó§�ó§in�Ö§̄

Ö¤]��«ún?ï�ó§�ó§in�Ö§�Ø�«úI[5½7L¢1r�

in�ó§in�Ö"

�ó§�ó"ïÓ�óè�]�©��óo«�]�!;�«�]�!�óN

Ö]�n�S�"Ù¥§�óo«�©��ÂïÓó§!ú´ó§�12�o«�a

O§�?©�A?!�?!�?!n?¶;�«�©�/ÄÄ:ó§!��ó§�36�

;�«�aO§�?©��?!�?!n?¶NÖ]�Ø©aO��?"ïÓ�óè

�UÙéA;�ÚaO«ú�ó�Ö"Ù¥§�ÂïÓó§�óo«�A?è��

«ú�óü�ÜÓ�3000��±þ��ÂïÓó§"I[éïÓ�óè�¢1S�

)�N��Ý"

�EPCo«�"ó§o«�è�A�äk�ó§5��·A�ó§�O]�½

ö�ó]�§=ó§�O½�óo«�]��è�§�±l¯]�yÖN���S

��Aó§o«�"

2¤ÀÔ)�²E½|O\^�"ÀÔkó§ÀÔ!�ó§ÀÔ�©§�)Å�!

��!��ì�!7áá�!�h9Ù�¬!u(9Ù�¬!zóá�9Ù�¬!ï

Óá�!�¬ÚÙ¦ÀÔ�aO§½|O\Xeµ

�è�ó��¬)�N�y"é�­��ó��¬§XØåG!-í9Yì!

Page 76: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 65

>åc©!¥(/¡�Â!Ã�>u����§�\I[Ú�iÒ+n�¬8¹¥

��¬¢1)�N�y�Ý"

��¬r�5@y"é�9<aèxÚS�!Ä�Ô)·Úèx§±9�¸�

oÚú�S���¬§~X>�>C!$Ø>ì!>ÅÅ!ð�!�÷���¬¢1

r�5@y�ݧϡ3C@y"

�A«��S�)�iy"é�9)·S�!�x5���G¬!ØåNì!

Øå+�!>F!å­Å�!�$¢�!�.iW��Ú|£�¤S;^ÅÄ�ý�

�\A«��8¹��¬¢1S�i§�¦A«��Ñ��§NkS�Eâ5�

�¦��O©�!�¬�þÜ�y²!SC9¦^�?`²!iÒu�y²�©�"

Ù¥§G¬!ØåNì!å­Å�!�$¢�!�.iW���SC!UE!�?§

Ld��N�y�ü ¢�"Ó�§A�k�A«���?�·A�;�Eâ<

ÚEâó<±97��uÿÃã"

��¬�þ@y"éØáuþãaO�Ù¦�¬§�¦Ù7LÎÜ�æ<Nè

xÚ<�!ã�S��I[IO!1�IO§í1�¬�þ@y"

3¤ÑÖ½|O\^�"ÑÖ�8©�ó§\ÎÚ�ó§\Îü�a"ó§\Î

¥�t!�O!in½|�1O\§�L§ó§\ÎLk�¤«úó§5��Î

�ó§�O!ó§in!Ed\Îü�9±þ�`?]��"

£3¤Á�Uå9ÝI]�k�"ÝI<vk?u�I-Ê�!Ê�§½]��

vv!È(!�+§»�G��ÃUåÁ��/§Ø�3ÝI]����½���

�{ØUÝI�/"

2.çI©�5½]�^�"(½ÝI<]�^���­��§́ 3ÝI<÷v

I[5½�]�^�Ä:þ§çI<U�8A:ÚI¦(½ÙÁ1ÜÓ�Uå§3

]�ý"©�½çI©�¥�ÝI<úÙ"���);�!Eâ]�ÚUå§]7!

��ÚÙ¦Ô���G¹§+nU姲�!&�Ú�A�l�<�"~X§ó§

�óçIéÝI<Á�Uå�"�§��/§I�éè�ãÖ!�1!&�!�óÅ

�!�8²nÜ<�?1"�§Ùm�3u(�ÝI<¥Iä�Á�Uå§ Ø

¬�5YéD6¥��Ô@�§ÏÃU��À� àk`e�§Ãõ ª"

12!]�µ"��Ï�!IOÚ^�

éÝI<�]�"�æ^Ö¡�ª?1§çI<IúÙ]�"��Ï�!IO

Ú]�"�^�§±BÝI<k�é5/?�]���©�§y²ÙÁ�Uå÷v

çI�8�¦"5¿§ØÓ�æI¦I��Á�UåØÓ"Ó�§ØÓ�m!/

Page 77: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

66 çIæÛYFn

:§ØÓ�Á�^�!�¸§¤I��Á�Uå�U�Ø�Ó"�d§(½]�"�

"��o!N�"�!U�o^�!IO"�´(½ÝI<´Ää�Á�Uå�k

û^�"ØU��,§�ØU=�âÝI<÷vI[5½�]�^�äóÙ÷vç

I�8]�^�§Ï�çIæ3(@Á�Uå�Ó�§�IAé¥I<Á��U

�çI<E¤��³���¯�"

·�kw����"��¯§25©ÛN��äÝI<�Á�Uå"

[��"��¯] k��ék¶��¯§���""`¬I�k�c§Ünï

�àn�7Ù§�����"§Ñ�wXN¡"¦<XÙ à¿Ar�´þ§-�

� *loo§̄ ¦rùo:Z�o�"Ünw�oo§#ï�àn�7Ù§�

à¿A���""

oo�f§ÌÄ`µ/4è´Ø´*lº���"\é�oà¿AB§·�\�

j"0Ün¯µ/\¬�íº0ooF)`µ/NoجQ�ùqØ´£9FÂ�§ØÒ

´��"í"·�ÐA *l�LQ§��\OvïÒ1"0Ün`µ/1B���

��mU�Ðjº0oo`µ/Ox·Ü§n���Øõ"0Ün��§n���v

'X§Ð3·Ø:�XB§X4·è´*lQ§Ò�A"

n�����U§Ün¯ooµ/·��"��No�3º0oo�ûgCM�§

`µ/O�\�Ø`·��#"�"·�´�\§���0Ünfooù�

`§@�ooج��"§̀ µ/No�§·��\ج�§rÙ���·j§·é

�[à¿A���"0oo�f§a`µ/F§\kOX:§O:"�v'X�"

·¬U�§·�\U��"�"0Ün�§êþ\g§�"�1§̄ µ/��n�

�=º0oo`µ/^اk���Ò�Øõ"0

Ün£���õ�§�X�"�Ñ5§̄ ooµ/No�§ù£·��"�

�jº0oo`µ/O§�"·�´�\§��Ø3 4·�"0Ünf�

aqµ/B§q�º0oo`µ/O:짷�UU"0Ün`¯µ/�UU�oܺ0

oo`µ/·�\U�upj�gU�§BXø¯"0Ün�f§ùÌ¿�Ø�§B

�7up§�>2�þ/ÜP�10A�i§¤.��§Ðj§X4·è´*l

Q�u´§Ün`up�1§¯ooµ/ùup��õ�U=º0oo`µ/k���

Ò1"0

���L�§Ün¯ooµ/·�up��j!0oo�f§̀ µ/O§\Ø`·

Ñ�#�up·�´�\§�q�"ØL·�U2�\U�0Ün¯µ/�

U2U�oܺ0oo`µ/·�\U�ÙÊÊj"0Ün�f@�íܧ̀ µ/�o§

ÙÊÊ�º·Ño�õ��<§B�7ÙÊʺ�{í�0q��§���"�B

Øþ§Òw\U�·�Ñ�oBj"u´§�X߯µ/ù£�õ�Ffܺ0oo

Page 78: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 67

`µ/^Ø�ȧ�±Ò�"0

qLÔU§Ün¯ooµ/ÙÊÊ��jº0oo`µ/\ØJ·Ñ¯�#§

ÙÊÊ·�\§�¿��ÿuy¿Øþ§�"0ù´Üný��(J§̄ o

oµ/´Ø´\�UU§ù£\�·U�oº0oo`µ/·�\UV�f�"0(J§

�àn7Ù�V�f§3e�æ�Ù^f"���f@U§Ün�wÒW§��

��§v{B"4oo^�Ú^f§�¦S5�êÙ§{X£["

�¯�(J4<u�§��L�F<�g"Ün�ÐØ��oo¬Ø¬��"§

��ÁB�§ooQج��"§�ج��"§ë�up!ÜÊÊ!�f�ج§

�Nu*l�¡��2/�÷¦�§́ Ün��÷k¯K§́ Ün3²�oovk

Uå��"!up!ÜÊÊ!�f�^�e�3�÷¦�§�U±{X5�êÙ£[

wª"�¯�<�é&´§�;�(½�¥I<,��Á�Ø÷v�¦§­��¯

¥oo�Cõ§çI<3Ç�ÙÜÓc§LéçI�8¥IÁ��9���UåÏ

�!�I?1"�"

¥I<�Á�Uå´õ«Ï�!�I�nÜNy"çI<IUçI�8A:Ú

æI¦§òÁ�Uå"�?�Ú©)�äN�"�Ï�§JÑ"�Ü��IO§

±9�½��{Ú^�§(�ÏL]�"��ÝI<kUåÁ�"��/§éÝI

<�]�"�§�)I[5½�]�^�!ãÖ!�1!&��¦!�8KI<ÚÙ

¦Ì�<!��!���¦�¯�§U;��ØÓ§©ãXeµ

1.ó§çI"ó§çI]�"�Ì�kn��¡SNµ�´äkÕá¾áÜÓ

��|¶�´äkÁ1ÜÓ�Uå§�);�!Eâ]�ÚUå§]7!��ÚÙ¦

Ô���G¹§+nU姲�!&�Ú�A�l�<¶n´Á�Uå9ÝI]

�k�§vk?u�I-Ê�!Ê�§½]��vv!È(!�+!»�G��ÃU

åÁ��/§Ø�3ÝI]����½����{ØUÝI�/"

þã]�"�Ï��±?�Ú©)Xeµ

£1¤äkÕá¾áÜÓ��|§�©)�µ�I[û¯�Ý(á�¬¯ÌNk

�y�§XE��ìÚ|�Å��èy�¶�ÜÓ\¾<]�y²©�§X{½�

L<�°y²½´ÙÇ��÷Ö!ÜÓ\Ý<��°y²�"

£2¤äkÁ1ÜÓ�Uå§U;��ØÓ�?�Ú©)Xeµ

1¤ó§tµ�ó§t]�yÖ¶�ãÖUå§XÝI<6Ä]7!]�K

ÅÇ!�½]��¶�t�8|<��!tKI<9Ù¦;�<]�!Á

{�¶�t��!NÖ<��¶�Á�L§��§X�þ+nNX@y�¶�a

q�8�1¶�Á�&�§X­ÜÓÅ&�yÖ!t�8¼øyÖ�¶�Ù¦y

²ÝI<Á�Uå�]�"

Page 79: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

68 çIæÛYFn

2¤ó§�Oµ�ó§�O]�yÖ¶�ãÖUå§XÝI<6Ä]7!]�K

ÅÇ!�½]��¶��O�8|<��!�OKI<9;��O<]�!Á

{�¶�Á�L§��§X�þ+nNX@y�¶�aq�8�1¶�Á�&�§X

­ÜÓÅ&�yÖ!�O�8¼øyÖ�¶�Ù¦y²ÝI<Á�Uå�]�"

3¤ó§inµ�ó§in]�yÖ¶�ãÖUå§XÝI<6Ä]7!]�K

ÅÇ!�½]��¶��8inÜ<��!oinó§�9;�in<]�!

Á{�¶�Á�uÿ¤ì���¦¶�Á�L§��§X�þ+nNX@y�¶�

aq�8�1¶�Á�&�§X­ÜÓÅ&�yÖ!in�8¼øyÖ�¶�Ù¦

y²ÝI<Á�Uå�]�"

4¤ó§�óµ�]�yÖ!S�)�N�yÖ¶�ãÖUå§XÝI<6Ä]

7!]�KÅÇ!�½]�¶��8²nÜl�<��!�8²n9Ù¦l�<

]�!Á{�¶�Ì��óÅ�!NÄå��Oy¶�Á�L§��§X�ó|

��j!�þ!�¸+nNX@y�¶�aq�8�1§�)ÝI<Ú�8²na

q�8�1¶�Á�&�§X­ÜÓÅ&�yÖ!�ó�8¼øyÖ!ÜÓ�1�¶

�Ù¦y²ÝI<Á�Uå�]�"

£3¤Á�Uå9ÝI]�k�§�©)�µ�è�²E±Yk�"Ù¥§�´

vk�I-Ê�Ê�!6�½öL�N�y!6�½öL��ì¶�´vk?\ú

i��§S!�\w»�½´Ù¦Ô�Á�Uå�/¶�ÝI]�±Yk�"Ù¥§

�´çIÝI�{�Vú«¥§ÝI]�vk���½6ʶ�´vk3�?&^

&E��²�¥�\�&��1<¶ü§±9{Æ{5²(B�½��Ùë��

çI�8ÝI�Ù¦�/"

2.ÀÔçI"ÀÔ§�)ó§ÀÔÚ�ó§ÀÔçI§Ù]�"�Ì�"�n

�¡SNµ�´äkÕá¾áÜÓ��|¶�´äkÁ1ÜÓøÀUå§�)ÀÔ

)�!\ó�E!Ñ�u�!Ô6!��ÚÈ�ÑÖ�¶n´Á�Uå9ÝI]�k

�§vk?u�I-Ê�!Ê�§½]��vv!È(!�+!»�G��ÃUåÁ

��/§Ø�3ÝI]����½����{ØUÝI�/"éuN�SC�NÁ

�æ�8§�I"�ÝI<SC!NÁ��oUå"Ù¥,

£1¤äkÕá¾áÜÓ��|§��¦ÝI<JøI[û¯�Ý(á�¬¯Ì

Nk�y�§XE��ìÚ|�Å��èy�"�§Ç��n<\¾ÜÓ�§�L

Jø{½�L<�°y²½´ÙÇ��÷Ö!ÜÓ\Ý<��°y²�"

£2¤äkÁ1ÜÓ�Uå§�?�Úò"�Ï�©)�µ�¶ìmæ�§Jø

¶ìmæN�yÚS�)�N�y¶ó��¬�§Jøó��¬)�N�yÚ�¬

�þ@y"Ù¥§�9r�@y�¬�§Jø�¬r�5@y"�9A«���§J

Page 80: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 69

øA«��S�)�iy"ÝI<��nû�§A�¦Jø)��Eû�Ç��

÷Ö§éÝI<�]��¦�¹é)��Eû�]��¦¶�ãÖUå§XÝI<

6Ä]7!]�KÅÇ!�½]�¶�Á�L§��Oy§XøÀ�j!�þ+nN

X@y!È�ÑÖ�¶�aq�8�È�1§̂ rµd�¶�Á�&��y²ÝI

<Á�Uå�Ù¦á�!]��"

£3¤Á�Uå9ÝI]�k�§�©)�µ�è�²E±Yk�§vk�I-

Ê�Ê�!6�½öL�N�y!6�½öL��ì§vkè�?\��!»�§

S½´Ù¦Ô�Á�Uå�/¶�ÝI]�±Yk�§ÝI]�vk���½6ʧ

3�?&^&E��²�¥vk��\�&�1<¶ü§±9vk{Æ{5²(

B�½��Ùë���8ÝI�Ù¦�/"

3.ÑÖçI"ÑÖçI�]�"��ó§!ÀÔçIaq§Ì�kn�¡SNµ

�´äkÕá¾áÜÓ��|§"�ÝI<�¬¯ÌN�°§XE��ìÚ|�Å

��èy�¶�´äkÁ1ÑÖ�Uå§�)µ�ÑÖ]�yÖ¶�ãÖUå¶�Ñ

ÖNX!<��9Á{¶���!����¶�ÑÖL§��§XÑÖ�j!�þ

+nNX@y�¶�aq�8�1¶�ÑÖ&�9�y²ÝI<Á�Uå�Ù¦á

�!]��¶n´Á�Uå9ÝI]�k�§vk?u�I-Ê�!Ê�§½]��

vv!È(!�+!»�G��ÃUåÁ��/§Ø�3ÝI]����½���

�{ØUÝI�/"éuN�SC�NÁ�æ�8§�I"�ÝI<SC!NÁ

��oUå"

çI<A3þã]�"�Ï�©)�Ä:þ§?�Ú²(�½z��Ï�ÎÜ

æI¦�IO!̂ �Ú�{§éÝI<?1]�"�"ù�§��(½�¥I<

Òج���"��¯¥@�oo��/§Uk�Á�¢yæ(J"

13!"�µ(½Ü�ÝI<

]�"�kü«�ª§�«´]�ý"§k"���<�ÝI]�§2�ÏL

"��<u�çI©�ÝI¶,�«´]��"§3µIÐÚµ"�"�ÝI<�

]�"æ^]�ý"�§çI<IuÙ]�ý"úw§3]�ý"©�¥úÙ]�

"��Ï�!IOÚ�{§dçI<½Ù|ï�]�"��¬é��<]�?1

"�¶æ^]��"�§çI<IuÙçIúw§3çI©�¥úÙ]�"��Ï

�!IOÚ�{§dµI�¬éÝI<�]�?1"�"7��§��dçI<

½Ù�÷�çI�nÅ�éÝI<?1]�"�"]�"�IO©�/ªµ"IO

Ú]�µ"IO"nØþ§A�´/ª�SNÑÖ"�¢�¥§�Øy/ª`uS

Page 81: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

70 çIæÛYFn

N�çI¯~§e¡ùKÝI��©�L��ª��¯§Ò´Ù�"

[ÝI©��ª��¯],½#ï�¤��§ uT½��Ü��§�)��¢!

�E¢!¾�¢Ú�ú¢��8§ïÓ¡È46000m2§OyÝ]52000�"Tó§�

óçI|�]�ý"§�d3ÝI<u�]�ý"©�§�¦]���<U]�

ý"©���¦§J�]���©�"35½��mS§k81�d3ÝI<�çI

<J��µ�]���©�§©��þÝ60cm− 120cm"

35½��mS§çI<|ïdçI<�L1<!nܵI;[¥�ÅÄ�

Eâ!²L;[4<|¤�]�"��¬§U]�ý"©�5½�µ"IOÚ�

{§é]���©�?1µ"Ú'�§(½9 ë�ÝI�ÝI<"

µ";[3"�¬Æm©c`�µ"y|""X/þæÈXì�]���©�§

k ;[m©��§ùoõ��©�§I�µ"��o�ÿB§w58U�þ10:

�£Ø[",� ;[aS8���@ ;[§v'X§v'X��ù´]�

"�§vkµI@oî�"5§·k��[��«�"

��¦§9k¤Æ/ww]�ý"©�§�m�°]���©�§wA©

¨`§�[L5w�w§ùÒ´�°ØÜ����©�"Ù¦<anþc§fnd"

¦`§]�ý"©�¥�"�IOk�^5½§�]���©��ªØÎÜ1oÙ

5½�ª�§]�"�ØÜ�§ù°��©���ªÒØÎÜ]�ý"©���ª

�¦"�[wwùÜL§]�ý"©�¥4��<gC«ì§vk?uÊ�Ê�!]

��vv!È(½»�G�§vk�6�½öL�N�y!6�½öL��ì§�

CncSvku)­��ó§�þ¯K"Ó�§«ìÙ�CncSvk�¿Ý�1

�§́ LÞe¡o1§x3���þ"�[2ww§ù ��<J��]���©

�éùÜL�SN§́ Ly3ü��þ�"Ù1��éA]�ý"©�¥L��c

n1§1��éA1o1§²²´��LNy�§��©�)) ©¤ü�"�

´§]�ý"©�vN���<�± ©!?U½´Ö¿L�¯�§ùÒ´�ªØ

ÎÜ�¦"U]�ý"©��5½ØUÏL"�"

Ù¦<�f§k�n�u´§"��¬<m?1©ó§z<<16°��©

�§kUù�^5½"���©��ª´ÄÎÜ�¦§2(½9 ��<�ÝI<"

²L"�§uyk66°��©�3ùÜL�þ�3aq¯K§����½�]�"

�ØÏL"��§"��¬é�e�15°��©�§U]�ý"©�5½�µ©

IO?1µ©"Uµ©®o�����©§(½c9<¼�ÝI]�§�¤]�µ

"�w"

çI<Â�]�µ"�w�§uyNõk¶��.�óè�vkÏL]�"

�§@�(Ø¿¥§Q�Ý~¦´k<heö�§�¦]�"��¬EØÙµ"

Page 82: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 71

(Ø"]�"��¬EØ�§@�"�(Ø�(§¿w�çI<§�¤±@66[

��<]�"�ØÏL§Ø´ÙÁ�UåØ÷v�¦§ ´\�uÑ�]�ý"©

�5½�]�"�IOÚ�{¥§1²/�ªÎÜ1oÙ��©��ª�¦0§

1oÙ��©��ª¥§qvk#N��<Ö¿!?U½´*Ð��©��ª"�

d§ù66©��©�ØUÏL]�"�"

�¯�(J´F<Ï��§k:���"@��¯§¤�U§§���%

´5�êÙ�(Û"ùc3ISùÇçIæ�n§��ù�]���©�½´

ÝI©��ª§·Ò¬Þù�~f§Ï�§�F<�g§̄ K�.Ñ3=Qºª

,§k]�ý"ó�þ�§;[Ø�¿[�/µ"¯K§�;[´UìçI<úÙ

�"�IO?1�µ"§@Ø´¯K�¢�"̄ K¢�E3uçI<§3uçI<

´Äý�n)©��ª�SN�'X§́ Äý�²çI�8I��o��]�

^�§�)I[5½�ÚçI©�5½�]�^�"²(ù�:§çI<Ò¬3]

���©��ª½´ÝI©��ª@�Ù§N�]���<½´ÝI<é�A�©

��ª?1Ö¿!?U½´*¿§±÷vÙ]�"�§y²ÙÁ�Uå�m�§Ï

�/ª´1N§I��SN�¢�ÑÖ"

ó§!ÀÔ½ÑÖçI�8�]�"�Ï�§©�/ª"�IOÚ]�"�I

O§©O©ÛXeµ

1./ª"�IO"/ª"�§́ é]���©��/ª?1"�§Ùm�3u

(½]���©��/ª´Äk�"��/§/ª"�Ï�9�¦Xeµ

1¤��<¶¡"��<¶¡A�E��ì!½|O\yÖ§X]�/]�yÖ!

S�)�y�1²�¬¯ÌN¶¡��"5¿§dd��§fúiØU^1úi�½

|O\?1ÝI]���§1úi�ØU^fúi�½|O\?1ÝI]���"

ØÓ��<|¤éÜN�§A�\Ý¿J�k��éÜN�ÆÖ§²(éÜN

VÞ<Ú��<�I©ó§d���<\i§\Xü Ù"Ù¥§�{½�L<�

<\i�§AN{½�L<Ç��÷Ö"

2¤��©�\iXÙ"��©�d¬¯ÌN\i½XÙ§±L²Ù´g���

çI�8�]�"�"{<½Ù¦|��§��©�Ad{½�L</ü KI<

½Ù�÷�n<\i½\Xü Ù"5¿§�L²´��<�g�1�§��©�

Ad��<�<!{½�L<½ü KI<�<\i"�÷�n<\i�§Ad�

�<�<!{½�L<½ü KI<?1¬¯�nÇ�§Ùm�EL²´��<�

g�1�"Ù¥§��©��\i�XÙ§́ üö¿��´k�=�§w]�ý"

©�½çI©�é]���©�\i!XÙ��¦"5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozÊ�^

5½§�¯<æ^ÜÓÖ/ª¾áÜÓ�§g�¯<þ\¶!XÙ½öU�<�Ü

Page 83: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

72 çIæÛYFn

Ó¤á§=XÙ!\i½öU�<ÑL²ÜÓ¤á¶T^�5½§3\¶!XÙ½ö

U�<c§�¯<��®²Á1Ì�ÂÖ§é��É�§TÜÓ¤á§]�"��

±ëì"

3¤��©��ª"]���©�A�ÎÜ]�ý"©�½çI©�é]��

�©���ª�¦"@o§́ ¤k���©��ªÑØ#N��<Ö¿!?U½´

*¿§�´¤k��©��ªÑ#N��<Ö¿!?U½´*¿Q§ÑØ�("]

���©�k�ª§�#N��<3��?W�§~X§]�ý"��¼�SN§

�)Ù\i!XÙ�¦�§Ø#N��<éÙ�©SN?1?U§�k��©�

��ª§~X§��<Ä��¹L!Ì�<{{L!Ì�Å���!��ÚNÄå

��!«ìÖ�§Ø¨LurN�ª A�#N��<é��©��ª?1Ö¿!

?U½´*¿§±÷v]�"�¯��O"

4¤����5"����5§�����<�U4��gk���"éÜN�

��§ÙéÜN�¤Ø�2±gC¶ÂüÕ��½ö2\\Ù¦éÜNë\]�

��"

5¤Ù¦/ª"�Ï�"çI<U�8A:Ú�¦Ö¿�/ª"�Ù¦Ï�Ú

IO§A�±�½]���©�k��O"

2.]�"�IO"]�"�kn��¡¯�§�´(½]�"��Ï�§�´

(½]�"��IO§n´(½]�"��^�§=U�o^�?1"�"I�U

çI�8æI¦(½"12!¥§·�®XÚ0�ó§!ÀÔÚÑÖ�]�"�

Ï�©)"3dÄ:þ§?�Ú0�]�"�IOÚ^�"

£1¤¬¯ÌN]�"ÝI<¬¯ÌN]�"�IOÚ^�Xeµ

1¤"�IOµ¬¯ÌN/ k�"

2¤"�^�µ¬¯ÌNk�y�"Ù¥§��<´{<½öÙ¦|��§Jø

k��E��ìÚ|�Å��èy£E<�¤"Ó�§Jø{½�L<�°y²½´

ÙÇ��÷Ö!ÜÓ\Ý<��°y²�¶��<´g,<�§Jø�°y�k�

�°y�E<�"

£2¤½|O\"ÝI<½|O\]�"�IOÚ^�Xeµ

1¤"�IOµÎÜ5½|O\K¡�ü65½�O\^�§]�yÖ½)�N

�yÎÜçI�8�?�¦§ó§�ó!¶ìmæ��8ä�k��S�)�N�

y�"

2¤"�^�µ½|O\�'N�yE<��"

£3¤ÝI]�"ÝI]�"�IOÚ^�Xeµ

1¤"�IOµ½|O\ÚÝI]�k�§vk�I-Ê�Ê�!6�½öL�

Page 84: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 73

N�y!6�½öL��ì§vk?\úi��§S!�\w»�½´Ù¦Ô�Á

�Uå�/§ÝI]�vk���½6ʧvk3�?�?�&^&E��²�¥

��\�&��1<¶ü§±9{Æ{5²(B�½��Ùë�çI�8ÝI�

٦�/"

2¤"�^�µ��<J�«ìÖ§«ìØ�3þã�/"ÄK§uy�3"�

IO¥?��/�§Ù]�"�Ø�ÏL"

£4¤Á�Uå"Á�Uå´��<[^uçI�8Á��<!ã!ÔÚ�{�

Oy§�)±e¯�µ

1¤ãÖUå"�"�IOµãÖ�IÎÜçI�8�¦"~X§çI�8Ü

Ó����20000��§�¦��<�½]�Ø�u10000 �!]�KÅÇ385%±

e!6Ä]73300�±þ�¶�"�^�µU��<J��²¬O�¯Ö¤½"O

Å�"O�ãÖ¬O�L§�)]�KÅL!y76þL!|dLÚãÖ�¹`²

Ö�E<�"

2¤�8+n<��"�"�IOµ�8k <;�]�!êþÚÁ{�¦"

~X§ú´ó§�óçI§Uú´�?�¦�8²nä�ú´ó§�?ïE���

]�§±9�8EâKI<ÚÙ¦;�<�]�!êþ�¶�"�^�µ�8|

<��L!Ì�<{{L!��]�yÖ!�¡yÖE<��"

3¤Á�Oy"�"�IOµä�k���þ+nNX@y�L§��@y§Á

�|�Oy!��!��ÚNÄå��ÎÜçI�8Á��¦¶�"�^�µU�

�<�þ+nNX�L§@y©�´Äk�§J��Á�Oy!��!��ÚNÄ

å���§ÿ�ÙÁ�L§!!:��´Ä÷vçI�8I¦"

£5¤aq�8�1"aq�8§��çI�8õU!5��Ó½�C�çI�

8§Ù"�IOÚ^�Xeµ

1¤"�IOµaq�8�15�!ÜÓ�ݽêþ�¦"Ù¥§�)ÝI<!

�8Ì�<�1�¦�"

2¤"�^�µÌ�<{{L!¥IÏ�Ö!ÜÓ�ÆÖ!�ÂyÖ�"

£6¤Á�&�"�"�IOµkûÐ��¬µd¶�"�^�µ­ÜÓÅ&�

yÖ!¼øyÖ½�ry²á��"

£7¤Ù¦�¦"�"�IOµçI<U{Æ{5ÚæI¦JÑ�Ù¦]�"

�Ï�ÚIO¶�"�^�µU]�"�©�5½^�"�"

~X§L4.1¤«�§́ ,ïÓó§�óçI]�"�IOÚ^�"

Page 85: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

74 çIæÛYFn

SÒ "�Ï� "�IO "�^�

k��E��ìÚ|�Å��èyE<�

1

k��]�yÖ!S�)�N�yE<�2

vk�I-Ê�Ê�!6�½öL�

N�y!6�½öL��ì§vk?\úi��§S!�\w»�½´Ù

¦Ô�Á�Uå�/§ÝI]�vk

���½6ʧvk3�?&^&E

��²�¥�\�&��1<¶ü§±9{Æ{5²(B�½��Ý

I�٦�/

²¬O�¯Ö¤½"OÅ�"O�ãÖ¬O�L§�)]�KÅL!y76þL!|dLÚãÖ�¹

�8|<��L!Ì�<{{L!�¡yÖ!þky�E<�

�þ+nNX�L§@y©�´Äk�!Á�Oy!��!��ÚNÄå��

3

4

¬¯ÌN ¬¯ÌN/ 

½|O\ �ÂïÓó§�óo«��?!S�)�y

U1oÙ�ªJ�«ìÖÝI]�

5

6

Á�

ãÖUå

�½]�Ø�u10000�!]�KÅÇ385%±e!6Ä]73200�±

þ

<��

Á�Oy

ÎÜÁ��¦

l�ä�ó§��¡½þkyÖ§Cnckaqk ;��1

��<

�8²n

`²Ö�E<�

ÜÓ�ÆÖ!�ÂyÖCncaq�8�1Ø�u8�

Cnckaq�8�1 Ì�<{{L!ÜÓ�ÆÖ!�ÂyÖ

Á�&� kûÐ��¬µd­ÜÓÅ&�yÖ!¼øyÖE<�½�ry²á�

�1

L4.1 ,ïÓó§]�"�IO

14!J`µ(½ÝI<¶ü

]�"�(½ÝI<¶ükü«�{§�«´Ü��§=ÎÜ]�"�IO�

��<þÏL]�"�§¼�ÝI]�¶,�«´k�êþ�§="��¬éÏ

L"�IO�]���<UìúÙ�þzIO?1µ"ÚnÜüS§Uì]�ý"

©�úÙ�ÝI<êþ§J`(½üS3c���<�ÝI<"l¢Sö�þw§

Ü��{ü!́ 1§I�²(]�"�Ï�!IOÚ^�§":´�U��ÝI<

Page 86: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 75

êLõ§m��"k�êþ��±k���m�§�(½��<üS¢�þ´3"

�Ï�Ä:þ§=õÏ���«nÜüS§¿vk�«î�¿Âþ�Ð�{§�6

uçI<éÝI<,���¡Uå� O"

[" =���¯] " =��§�ü ék �½�½��ØÏ�!�I�Ø

ó1�§é�Ø(Jü3" �ó�±=����-y�ݧQ�Ý��ü

 ÚÆö¤í§�µ";[�òÙÚ\�ÝI<�]�"�§Úu��<é

]�"�(J��ƧØ�Ø6Ê�8¢�"T�8�,½&E¥%�ú�Ö¢§

ïÓ¡È8672m2§/þ8�§�8Ý]3600��"

Tó§�óçIæ^]�ý"�ª(½ÝI<¶ü"çI<|�?�]�ý

"©�"Ù¥§]�"��{æ^k�êþ�§3��<]�"�Ü��Ä:þ§æ

^nܵƧ�¦3/éè�¢å!EâC�!<G¹!�8²n�10ÚçI<

é��<Á�Uå¢/��Ä:þ?1nܵƧJ`(½ÝI<¶ü§<êØ

�L7<"��§çI<3�½x0uÙ]�ý"úw"

]�ý"úwuÙ�§k12[�óè�U�¦ï]�ý"©�"35½�

�mS§k10[�óè�4�]���©�"çI<U5½|ï]�"��

¬"Ù¥§çI<�L1<§½nܵI;[¥�ÅÄ�Eâ;[3<§²L;[1<"

"��¬Uì]�ý"©�5½�"��{§é4��10°]���©�?1Ð

"ÚnܵÆ"

²L"�§ù10°]���©��]�"�(ØþÜ�"éXÛ?1nܵƧ

"��¬?1?ا@�Q,]�ý"©�vk�ÑüSIO§@Òæ^" 

=�§�KÙ¥Uå½&��é��3 ��<§�e7[��<�ÝI<��{"

"�L§¥§uy��<A��[n?ïÓ�óè� Ù¦è�þ��?±þ"

Ó�§k� µ��N§��<B�´�?�óè�§Uåv¯K§�Á�L§¥o

OéçI<O\¤^§̀ Ù� Ó¯�in����8Ò´ù[è�«ú�§�8

�v�óÒ�çI<�(i§p�¢�ó§±"y3@�(i{��vk�ûe5§

ó§���?3ÊóG�§t�ï�ü é�ħA�½��<B&��""��

¬²?ا��Ó¿��<A!��<BØUí��ÝI<§û½éÙ�±=�"

é�e�8���<§µ"�¬l]���©�þéØÑ<K=���<�

nd"��§��Ó¿§d"��¬Ì?�8I§(½����=����

<C"âd§"��¬í��e�7 ��<�ÝI<§�çI<J�]�"�

�w"çI<Â�]�"��w�§(@"��¬�"�(J§¿uÂ�"�

�w�1�U§��wÏL�7 ��<u�çI©�"

]�"�(å�1nU§ÝI<C�½ï�1�Ì+Ü�Ý�§nd´TçI

Page 87: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

76 çIæÛYFn

<vké��<�¢/�Ò®�¦<u�çI©�§çI<(½ÝI<¶üØ

ÎÜ]�ý"©�úÙ��{§́ 3vé��<Á�Uå¢/�Ä:þ�Ñ�"

�(ا�¦çI<­#(½ÝI<¶ü"

@o§ù��8çI<(½ÝI<¶ü��{´Ä�(QºL¡þw§çI<

(½�ÝI<´]�"��¬í��ÝI<§vk¯K"̄ �åÏ´duçI<

vké]���<?1¢/�B(½ÝI<§§Sþk×\"�´§=B3]

�ý"©�¥§��çI<é��<Á�Uå¢/���§çI<(½�ÝI<

�Ø�("�ÏÒ3u§"��¬vkU]�ý"©�5½�"�Ï�!IOÚ

�{§é��<���mc4��]���©�?1"�§Ùæ^�" =��]

�ý"©��5½Ø��"Ly3§�´é��<Bæ^]���©�±¯�§

=�få`5�/O�(i0§��ÙÝI]�¶�´é��<Cæ^8I�{(½

ÙØä�ÝI]�§Ø´éè�¢å!EâC�!<G¹Ú�8²n�1�nÜ

µÆ§ ´æ^]�ý"©�vk5½�IOÚ�{§="��¬vk�ÌU

çI<�Ö¡�¦éÝI<��A¯¢?1µ"!'�Úí���Kí�ÝI<"

¢Sþ§̄ �¥¯K�åÏ uçI<§́ duçI<Jø]�"��¬�

"��â§=]�ý"©�¥vké]�"��Ï�ÚIO?1þz§¦"��

¬�Ø/n)nܵÆÒ´Æ�Ƨ? í�ÝI<�L§ØÎÜ]�ý"©��

¦"@o§çI<qA�N�(½ÝI<¶üQºçI<(½ÝI<¶ü�Ùæ^

�]�"��{k'"æ^Ü���§¤kÏL"����<þ¼�ÝI]�¶æ

^k�êþ��§çI<A3]�ý"©�¥þz]�"��Ï�ÚIO§úÙé

ÏL]�"����<�nÜüS�{§=�½����<´`u�´�u,�

���<��{"

S'X§´Cþm��«Ü6gS"~X§�ê8Üþ�−2 < −1 < 0 <

1 < 2 < 5Ò´�ê8Ü{−5,−2,−1, 0, 1, 2, 5}þ��«S'X§=��'X¶2'X,{a} ⊂ {a, b}§{a} ⊂ {a, b} ⊂ {a, b, c}´8Ü{a, b, c}þf8��«S'X§=�¹'X"

�x, y�ü�]�"�Ï�£ÛCþ½wCþ¤§¡x�S`uy�S§P�x � y"

��§K¡x�S�uy�S§P�x ≺ y"XJ"�Ï�x, ymQkx � y§qkx ≺ y§

K¡x, ymÓS,P�x ≈ y"¡x, ymk��î�S§́ �x � yÚx ≺ y¥k�=k

��¤á"y3§b�x1, x2, · · · , xn�n��½Cþ§XJ�3S'Xx1 ≺ x2 ≺· · · ≺ xn½x1 � x2 � · · · � xn§K¡8Ü{x1, x2, · · · , xn}þ�3�S§éA�8Ü{x1, x2, · · · , xn}¡����S8"���S8S§¢SþÒ´éÙ¥?¿ü�

�x, y ∈ S§kx � y½öx ≺ y§=?¿ü���m�±?1S'�"XJ��8

Page 88: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 77

ÜSþ��÷v±en�^�µ

£1¤x ≺ x, é?¿x ∈ S¤á¶

£2¤x ≺ y�duy � x, é?¿x, y ∈ S¤á¶

£3¤x ≺ y, y ≺ z�½kx ≺ z, é?¿x, y, z ∈ S¤á§K¡S��� S8"

µ©Ï� µ©IO

A.�é'�Cnc²þÀ]��,¿lp�$ü¶§1)5¶

ãÖG¹ ��5©§6)10¶��4©§11)15¶�3©§16)20¶��

10© 2©§20)25¶��1©§Ù{0©¶B.]�KÅÇ≤ 85%�§

5©¶85% <]�KÅÇ< 95%�§3©¶]�KÅÇ≥ 100%

�§0©

aq�8�1 C3c«úL3�9±þÓ�ï�5��8�§15©¶2��

15© 10©¶Ù{0©

A.Cnc¼�óû1�+nÜ�/­ÜÓÅ&^0J�¡

&� Ò�§10©;Ù{0©¶B.Cnc¼�ï�1�+nÜ��u

20© ©²ó/yÖ5�9±þ�§5©¶3�±þ�§3©¶Ù{0

©¶C.Cnc¼�7KÅ��u�AAA?yÖ�,5©¶AA

yÖ�§3©¶Ù{0©

@yNX A.ÏL�þ+nNX@y�k��,2©¶B.ÏL�¸+n

5© NX@y�k��§2©¶C.ÏL��èx+nNX@y

�k��§1©

Á�|� Á�|�Oy!��!��ÚNÄå��ÎÜçI�8Á

15© ��¦�§U`D�§15-13©!ûÐ�§12-8©!Ü��§

8-6©µ"¶Ø÷væI¦�§0©

A.�8²nú?L3�9±þÓ�ï�5��8²n�§10

©¶2��§5©¶1��§0©¶�8²n|��ó��8¼

�8²nÜ �L2�±þ©²ó/J�¡Ò�§5©¶1��§3©;Ù{0

35© ©"B. �8EâKI<«úL3�9±þÓ�ï�5�Eâ

KI<�§5©¶2��§3©¶1��§0©¶C. k ;�KI

<þä�¥?±þEâ�¡�§15©;z"���2©§��

��

L4.2 ]�"�µ©IO

@o§XÛ(½����<�S´`u�´�u,����<�SQº¢�¥§

Page 89: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

78 çIæÛYFn

k±en«~^�{:

1.�ÅÄ�{"l]�"�Ü����<¥§æ^�ÅÄ�(½ÝI<¶ü�

�{ u�?æéÀÔ�ÑÖ��çI�5½§aquç¦Ä�½´~øL§§

4z�Ü���<+���Ò轴祧5½ÄÑ�祽´~Ñ�ÒèéA�

��<¼�ÝI]�"�ÅÄ��{�Ñu:§́ l�{þ�åçI<ú²!ú�

/é�Ü���<§²�D�z� Ü���<ÝI�Ŭ"�l¢�þ§�ÅÄ

�´�«wqú²¢K´3^/�·Ø0?n½|¿�¯K§¿ØÎܽ|/`�

��0��K§́ ¥I<��¬e�«��çI<��{§�çIæJ`(½¥

I(J�m�¿Ø¬Ü§Ï�á¢çI<ÌNI?�cJ§́ D�Ù¿©�æ5

K�½�"

2.nܵ©üS" nܵ©{�¢�§´b�]�"�Ï�m�3�«�þ

p�'X§? �Nyuµ"�¬é��<�µ©þ"�,§ù«b�nØþ´

ؤá�"�d§nܵ©{�Uw��«CqJ`§�%´�«{ü!́ 1Bu

ö���{"~X§,ó§�ó�8]�ý"©��¦éÏL]�"����<U

L4.25½�µ©IO§U��<�©�p$üS"

5¿§nܵ©{é]���<�µ©(J§k�Uü���<����©�

�"�d§]�ý"©�¥A?�Ú²(ü���<�©����üS�{"~X§

3L4.2Ä:þ§5½æ^±e�KüSµ�Uì�8²n�©õ�(½ü¶k�¶

�XE�Ó§±EâKI<�©õ�(½ü¶k�¶�XE�Ó§±Cnc«ú�

ÜÓ�õ�(½ü¶k�¶�XE�Ó§±è�5þ]�7��(½ü¶k�¶�

XE�Ó§dµ"�¬Ý¦(½ü¶k�"

5¿§�¦"��¬éÏL"����<ݦ§U�¦ê�õ�üS§¢S

þ§�´nܵ©{§́ r¦ê��©ê"ݦ{E´;[ûü§�éþ¡�nÜ

µ©{{ü��÷*§=·^u@Ã{þz�+�½"�Ï�"

3.õÏ�üS{"õÏ�üS{�¢�§́ çI<3]�ý"©�¥U"�Ï

�A1, A2, · · · , An�­�§Ý§²(Ï�m�S'X§~X§A1 ≺ A2 ≺ · · · ≺ An§3

dÄ:þ§2²(z�Ï�ØÓ�/éA��üS�{"~X§b�Ï�Aikm(i)«

�/Ai1, Ai2, · · · , Aim(i)§1 ≤ i ≤ m(i)§5½ÙØÓ�/�S'XÚ�S�/§K�

±3êÆþ§��5/y²e¡ù�i;üS�n"

[i;üS�n] �X!Ydn�Ï�A1, A2, · · · , An(½§ùn�Ï��S'X

�A1 ≺ A2 ≺ · · · ≺ An§KX�Ym�±½ÂS'XX ≺ Y"

i;üS�n´·��ä¯ÔXÚYm`�'X��«��ú�n"@o§·

Page 90: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 79

�N�Uì`À�K§½Âi;üS�n¥XÚY�S'XQº¢Sþ§XJ(

½XÚY�n�Ï�m�S'X�A1 ≺ A2 ≺ · · · ≺ An§·�Äk�±3A1 ≺A2�A1 6≈ A2��/e§½ÂX ≺ Y"�e5§XJkA1 ≈ A2�´A2 ≺ A3§

K�½ÂX ≺ Y"ù���/§XJkA1 ≈ A2 ≈ · · · ≈ Ai�´Ai ≺ Ai+1�§½

ÂX ≺ Y"ùp§i´���ê§÷v1 ≤ i ≤ n"5¿§ùp�n´��k�ê§~

X§=©i;¥n = 26"ù«�{�ª¦·���XÚYm�S'XX ≺ Y"

i;üS�n�(ØL²§é]�"�Ï�üS3nØþ´�1�§I�çI

<U�8A:ÚæI¦§̄ k�¤½Só�§="�Ï�m�½S'XAi ≺ Aj½

´Ai � Aj3�o�/e¤á"ùp§1 ≤ i ≤ n, i ≤ j"�d§��/§A3]�"�

IOúÙc§��1�;[é"�Ï�ÚÏ�ØÓ�/?1`�'�§û½"�Ï

�m9ÙØÓ�/m�S'X§,�2?1]�"�"ù�¥§û½ØÓ"�Ï�m

½´"�Ï�ØÓ�/m�S'X§�±�¦;[���ÑS'X§½´©O�Ñ

��©�2?1ÚO?n§U;[���"�Ï�©���(½ÙS'X"I�5

¿�´§ØÓ�<鵩IO�rº´Ø���§çI<I¯k�Ñ©��3õ�±

S��½��S�IO"~X§çI<3çI©�¥5½�|Ai−Aj| ≤ 3�Ai ≈ Aj§

=Ai�Aj�S"'uõÏ�üS§·�3�¡16Ù13!ùõÏ�üS{��¬0

�ÝI�êÆ�.!õÏ�üS�{Ú�'¯~"

¢Sþ§3þ¡" "���¯¥§]�ý"©�¥�¦éè�¢å!EâC

�!<G¹!�8²n�1Ú��<Á�Uå¢/��Ä:þ?1nܵƧ

æ^�Ò´õÏ�üS"�ØL´vkúÙüS�{ ´Ç�]�"��¬3n

ܵÆ�Ä:þé��<üS"Ù¥§"��¬U]���<J����©�1

²�è�¢å!EâC�!<G¹Ú�8²n�1�o�Ï�é��<Á�Uå

?1`�'�ÚüS§çI<3é��<Á�Uå¢/�Ä:þ(@]�"��

¬�üS§? J`(½ü3c7 ���<�ÝI<"¯�Úu�ƽ´¯K

�¢�§́ "��¬vkU]�ý"©�¥5½�"�IOÚ�{é]���©

�?1µ"Ú'�§çI<vk�lÙ3]�ý"©�¥úÙ�§3é��<Á�

Uå¢/��Ä:þ(½ÝI<§��ú²!ú���K"

15!Y~µ�ï�8æØ%3ïuUå

Á�Uå´æI¦�±¢y�cJ§́ ÝI<]�"��Ø%"ÝI<�Á

�U姴Ù;�EU!l�<!]7!��!��G¹!²�Ú&���nÜ

Ny"çIæ�äÝI<Á�Uå(J�?3u§Á�Uå´ÝI<���nÜ

Page 91: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

80 çIæÛYFn

µd�I§Ù©)�äN�µ"Ï�½�I§�a´½þ"�Ï�½�I§,�a

´½5"�Ï�½�I"Ø+´=�aµ"Ï�½�I§Ñ¡�Xü�¯K§�´

ùÏ�½�I´ÄU��/�xÝI<�Á�Uå¶�´é½5Ï�½�I�µ

"§�õ/�6u"��¬¤�;���Ú����§�6u;[��Æûü"

é@±ÀJÝI<Á�Uå�m��æ�8§ù�:Ly�cÙ­�"ÄK§

4k�U��Á��}½´Ã{¢yýÏæ(J"e¡ù�zóEâUE,?ï

u�8§Ò´ÏéÁ�UåØ����æ�}"

[Y�£�] ,zó��þ­Vl�c�ï���[�.zó��)��§Ù)

�ó²U��ISþÓazó�?1Ù�Ú6§`z§)�UåQ�Ý?uIS+

k/ §�����­V§�XISþ�#,�zóC�Ú)�ó²��)§

T�)���¬3IS½|¿�¥w³Ñ�Ø|"�d§T�+�32�Nï�

Ä:þ§JÑ^nc��m§Ý]1500�<¬1éT�zÆ�AC�Ú)�ó²?

1`z�ïu§é�Ø%«?1EâUE§�¡J,)�U姱·AIS½|�

¿�I¦"

T�8�zóC�Uå,?Úó²`zïu�8§́ 3�kzÆC�Úó²6

§Ä:þ?1ïuÚEâUE§[æ^���Ý\¼����Ñ"�d§T�ÄNÜ

©�Ö�Z|¤ô'�|§|��ISÓazó�ë*�Nï§{��c�¤

UE�õUI¦Úïu8I"��§�EâÜ|�?�TEâUE,?ïu�8

çI©�§u2016c3�3I[�{�½�x0þuÙçIúw§��ISä�ï

uzó)�Uå�Å�ë�ÝI"35½��mS§o[zóïuÅ�A!B!C!D

ïçI©�"

T�8çI©�¥1²§�8ÜÓÁ1Ï�üc§�¦¥I<\¾ÜÓ�F

å60FSJ��8ïu¢��Y!¢�C�Ú�[Oy§�c"8��S�¤zÆ

�AC�ÙÛN�Ú)�UåJ,Øy�w§²�EâÜ!��Ó¿�§¥I<�

��,?�8UE�Eâ�¯§��zó)�Ø%«EâUEJø;�\ÎÑÖ§

�Ü�EUÜ�ücS�¤)�ó²`z!zóC���§J,30%±þ�)�U

å"Ù¥§éA�ÜÓd±|G^±§�ÜÓ\¾�30FS|GÙ¥Id10%ÜÓ

±¶J��8ïu¢��Y�30FS|GÙ¥Id30%ÜÓ±¶J�zÆ�AC�

ÙÛN�Ú)�UåJ,Øy�w�30FS|GÙ¥Id40%¶T�zÆ�AC�

UE,?Á$1¤õ�|GÜÓ�{±20%§\uÜÓ(�yÖ"

3çI©�5½�ÝI���mc§ko ISl¯zó)�\ÎïÄ�ÝI

<4�ÝI©�§ÙÝI�d©O�µÝI<A�d860.00�§B�d1318.00�§C�

d1180.00�§D�d1226.00 �"mI�§dT�Ì+)�Eâ�B���<!ï�

Page 92: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 81

Ì+Ü�|ï�nܵI;[¥¥�ÅÄ��Eâ;[n<!²L;[�<�{|

¤�µI�¬§UçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"

µIæ^ÐÚ"�!ÝI<ïu�YgãÚµI�¬�¦!�[µ"!�¤µI

�wÚí�¥I<��!§?1µ"Ú'�"

ùo ÝI<�ÝI©�þÏLÐÚ"�"3ÝI<ïu�Ygã�!§Ê

 µ�éÝI<�ïuL§!Á�Úzó)��[9Ù�ÜØ%«EâUEOy�

?1�¦��Ï"��§µI�¬éÝI©�?1�["��'�"n zó

Eâ;[��@�§ÝI<B ��d�,�p§�Ùïu�Y!<��ÚÁ��

[Oy���§�±�&ÙïuUå§ïÆéÙ?1ÜÓÇ�§@�ù�k�U¢

yJ,T�30%±þ�zó)�U姷AIS¿�I¦"T�B��K@�§l

ÝI<J��ïuOyÚÙ± �ïu�1§=éÙ¦zó�UEïu�1þw§

o ÝI<ÑU�¤ïu?Ö§©ØÑp$"Ù¥§k�ÝI<�Lgã�`�Ð

�:¶k�جL�§gã`���:§ùÑØ´¯K"TB���X`§T�8]

7�è�gÊ"�5µIc§���2��§Ï�8]7;ܧZ�Ø��|§UÀ

d$�Ø�Àdp�"y3§Q,o�ÝI<ÑkUå�¤T�8ïu§��oØ

ÀÝI<AQºÙd�'ÝI<B�458.00�§'ý��640.00��3ïu²¤;

Ü�cJe§TB��ïÆí�ÝI<A�1�¥IÿÀ<"o µI;[�É

TB��ïƧ��í�ÝI<A �1�¥IÿÀ<§¿�¤µI�w"

²µI(Jú«�§T��ÝI<AuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§UçI©�Ú¥I<

�ÝI©��¥I<A\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"¢�L§¥§¥I<AUìÜÓ�¦§J�

�8ïu¢��Y!¢�C�Ú�[Oy§¿u\¾ÜÓ��c"Ê���T�

J�zóC��#!ÙÛN�Ú)�UåJ,Øy�w§T��UìÜÓ�½|

G¥I<AoO80%�ÜÓd±"²¢��[§¥I<AJ��EU�YU¢y

ýÏ8I"��§T�m©Ø%«zóC��#!,?UE�ÙÛN�§�¤Ø%

«EâUE"�3Ø%«UE�¤§|�)�Á$1L§¥§uy¥I<Aïu�

zóC��#!ÙÛN�¿�¢yJ,30%)�Uå��Ñ8I§�¬�¢¬Ç 

p§Ù�ÑUå�UEc�)�Uå�'§=Jp14%�m"Ó�§N���k³

Ô?nC�Uåî­Øv§Ü©k³íN!¢Y��ü\�¸¥§́ E¤�¸À/§

�UÏL��Ü�|���Â"

d�§UV�\Ý�ÜÓ�ÆÖ§T�®�¥I<A|G80%d±§=688.00�"

Ï�ÑUå=J,14%§�k³Ô?nØ�I§T��¦¥I<AJÑ�zóC

�k³Ô?n�Y§¤^d¥I<A«ú"¥I<ØÓ¿§¡®UÜÓ�½Á1

ïuÂÖ§�¤zóC��#!ÙÛN�Ú)�UåJ,Øy�w§XïuN�

Page 93: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

82 çIæÛYFn

��zóC�k³Ô?n§I�,1�÷¿|G620��ïu¤^"V�ÒïuN

���zóC�¢ïÔÂ8�?n��¤��¿�§T����Gò¥I<Awþ

{̧@�Ù�Á1ÜÓÂÖ§E¤ó�ÊóÊ�§�¦{��½¥I<A��®

|G�ÜÓd±50%§¿���'²L��300��"

Ò�Y�z(J ó§{�k�U\�¥I<A��T�Ü©®|G�ÜÓd

±§��ÙÜ©²L��§�Òæ ó§�Y´�g�}æ§Ly3ÙJ,30%)

�Uå�EâUEá�§E¤T�3�m�²Lþ��½��§�è�·AIS½

|¿��uÐÉ��½§Ý�K�"

[¯K] �éþãY�£�§©Û±en�¯Kµ

1.çIæ�^�´�o§´Ä·^u¤kæ�8º�ï½M¿a�8æ

´Ä·^uçIæ§IS´N�5½�§��oº

2.�Y¥,T�B��ïÆ¿���$d¥I´Ä�(§��oº

3.�Yæ(J,é±Á�Uå�Ø%�æ�8k=髺qAN��yù

a�8�æ(Jº

[Y~©Û] éþãn�¯K§�g©ÛXe:

1.çIÝI�A:§3uçIÝI5K¥��ÝI<4�ÝI©�����

m§���m�Ø2#NçI<N�æI¦§�Ø2#NÝI<N�ÙÝI¢�

5SN"ù�:§��¡�çIÝI�/�g50½/��d0A�"¤±§¿�

¤k�æ�8Ñ·Auæ^çI�ªæ"¦^çIæ�^�§́ çI<UU

�8A:!æI¦ÚçIÝI�A:§O(JÑçI�8½I�§�)ÙçI�

�!EâIOÚ�¦§±9çIæ�J`IO!ÜÓ^�"�d§�ä���ï�

8½M¿a�8´Ä�±æ^çIæ§cJ´Ù´ÄÎÜçIæ�^�"ÎÜ

�§�±æ^çI�ªæ¶��§ØÎÜ�§A�æ^�çI�ªæ½´�Ù

^�ÎÜçIæ^��2æ^çI�ªæ"�ï½M¿5�8��þäk±e

A:µ�æI¦wq²(§�¢Sþég5"��=k��å5�I�éu�

8��§JØÑEâIOÚ�¦½´�UJÑõU½�K5�¦§��~´Ì*�

äÏ�½�I"~X§�¦���uÐ���§ïĤJ?uIS+kY²§½´

�¦I�Ô{*��§�±��¸����§4�/�6µ�<�;���¶��

�g5�AÒU¢yæm�§I©O�ë�<�Ï!?اJÑïÄg´½)û

�Y¶�Ië�<�r��Æ�©z.%"~X§é�¬!)�C�ïu!�#½6

Y��,?UE!¢½5y!¢½I�!¢½H��¶�æm�´éïu!M¿(

JJ`§ 35�¿�L§¥§é�ï!M¿(J=Uýÿ§��g5µ"�±À

½I�½(J¶�ÊH�9�£���"¤±§é�ï½M¿a�8æ§Ø�

Page 94: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

14ÙçIæµÁ�Uå�"� 83

�é{ü�8§IS�Ì6¿�´ØÌÜæ^çI�ªæ"

ISé�E�8æÎÜe�^����§²(5½�±Øæ^çI�ªæ

µ�8IØ(½5��½�8�IØ´þz§J±(½µ"IO�¶��9I[

S�ÚI[���¶�ÎÜ�¦�ÝI<3ü[9±e�¶�{Æ{55½��±

ØçI�Ù¦�/"Ó�§²(A�æ^nܵ�{J`§�¦çI<�ÄEâ´

���15!k?5Ú«úü �mu^�!<��!]&�?!+nUå�Ï

�§�Ä�ﲤ¦^�Ün5!�E�8�M#5Ú8I��¢y5§��nÜ

µ�Ï�!�IÚIO§5½�$�dØ���¥I���nd"

2.Y~¥§o�ÝI<��dÑ$uÝ]�§�T�B��ïÆ¿��T�8

�d�$�ÝI<A¥I¿Ø�(§�Ï3u�ï�8�æJ`§́ 3ý��å

eÁ�Uå�J` Ø´d�J`"Äk§T�8�E,�E�8"Ù¥§Qk�

ÆïÄqkÁ��[§́ 3�kzÆC�Úó²6§Ä:þ§æ^ISþk?�)

�C�Úó²§éT�Qk)�C�!ó²?1ïuÚEâUE§�'ïu��[

¯�õ!�N¯�õ§�I�Ú�^uT�)�Uå�J,§́ ��E,�XÚó

§¶Ùg§=BT�8^�ÎÜæ^çI�ªæ§ÙJ`�´�ïUåJ` �

ÝI�d"ISéu�E�8çI�¦æ^nÜ5µd'�"Ø���8çI�¦

§²(�¦ÝI©��A�)µ�Cc�²EuÐÚ�ïG¹¶�Eâ�Y9`

²µ¹�Y��15!k?5!M#5§Eâ!²L!�þ�I§ºx©Û�¶��

E¤JJø�ª95�¶�«ú�8Uå`²§�)�çI�8k'��E¤J½

�¬mu�¹!«ú�8Ì�KI<�]{9�1�¹!�';���EèÎ�¹

9+nY²!¤ä���ï��!¤ì�¹!��¤�8¤Ê��]7�¹9y²

�¯�¶��8¢�|�/ªÚ+n��¶�k'Eâ����²�§���TE

âUEïu�8�}��y§Ï�T�B��3vkéþãïuUå¿©'�!Ø

y^�e§ïÆ¿��µI;[NÚ§±ÝI<A��d�$Ç�Ù¥I§��

E,��ï�8´Á�Uå�ÀJù�Ä��J`OK§? ���Ø%«zÆ

�AC��#!ó²N�Ú)�Uå,?UE�8�}§Ï�Ù���ï�8æ

�J`OK"

3.Á�Uå�ÀJØ%�æ�8§́ �@�8¢��6u¥I<ìè9¤

�å�æ�8"~X§E,��ï�8!¢½5y!H�!²â¬æ�"�Y

Ø%«zÆ�AC��#!ó²N�Ú)�Uå,?UE�8�}�(J§é±Á

�Uå�Ø%�æ髧3uØA2j±/�g50çIæ Aæ�(¹�æ

�ª§I�rz¿I<Á�UåЫ!�Ï!��u�ÚnÜJ`"é@�

��a�úÃa�8§O\ú¯ë�!µÆÚiÒ��!§±(�ÜÓÇ��Uå

Page 95: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

84 çIæÛYFn

�r��A<"Ó�§rzÁ�L§�ÏÚL§��§O\'��!!Ì�ó²½

óS�¥mÄ�:ê!: Ú�§rzL§+�§±B9�uy¯K!9�)û

¯K§Òræ(J�¢y"

Page 96: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 5Ù

çIæµçI©���¦

**********************************************************************

Ø�pì§Ø�U�p�¶Ø��M§Ø�/�þ�"

— ÔI.͹5@f6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 97: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

86 çIæÛYFn

11!m�µF¥ÀW��½

çI©�´çIæ�¦�Ö¡Ny§́ çI<3çIúwÄ:þ?��§�

3�ÝI<²(ÝI��Ö!ÝI<L�!µIIOÚ�{!EâIOÚ�¦!ã

�!ÜÓ^�ÚÝI©��ª�5K�¦�©�"nØþ§çI©�´çIúw§=

�����[z§Ù/ §EáuçI<�d3ÝI<uÑ�����©�"5¿§

ù�:��¥ÀW5K�½�¤ØÓ§I�çI<UçI�8A:ÚI�§²(ç

IÝI5K"

�¥ÀW3KÀ�¬¥§��=´Ny�!�F¥Ú¯<��|µ§�uù�

S��½5K´�o§K"yî>�Ðy"ùp§l�¬1�5�Ñu§é�¥À

W5KEÛXeµ

¯K1. ´Ä�w�¯<´= �*�ÀW§�m´�o§/:q3=pº

�¥ÀW´Ä�úwUe§3KÀ�¬¥~�<¤�À"l�nþ©Û§��

I��'Éç�@�§3¢��½´~�b�Üw«§w�¯<§½ö´%��D§

hew�¯<§́ X[�= �*��F¥§́ �o�m3�o/:�F¥§±á

Ú¯<�A"�,§@�duì�Eâ"y§w«Ø¬N�*�ì§�Oë�*x

��جk"@�§�r<[��*��ØÑ!��Ø\�§̄ <qN��¡§�F

¥@ �*´���{�´Î§§́ §R�´8ĺ�O´ÑØ�¡��Oc5A

��<´ÀXù[�r<[�/ §́ Ñu\KÍ���{"

¯K2. ´Ä�w�¯<A��^�§Xc�!�p!�m§´Ä#N¢e�s

½ï Ø<F¥§½´�3�*�A�<G*�Uº

v��=�ÜKÀ�¬Ðy�¥@ L[�*úÙA­^�"w53�¥ÀW

5Kþ§ØØpL!c�§ØØ«¡!Lk§�ØØdD½´Î§§Ñ�±3¢e�

sF¥§\�@�<�Ñ1�³�Vï§�O�ج<ì<°�"Ó�§ÀJ�3

�*Ã¥§ØúÙA­^�جÑ�¯K"���UÑy�§́ ¢eA­<¥vk

�*%¤�§�F¥�جØ�"��(¬Ñy§¢e�s¦��<�F¥�§Ø

´�*wþ�"d�§U�¥ÀW5K§�*Ø��¥§Lg�@ s�F¥�§s

�F¥�@ §�LH��*§ÏA­<XJvï�*Χ½´8ħ��±ø�

���§Ø^ c¡n"��§Q,Us�F¥§L²A­<S%�¿H��*"@

o§L[�*XÛòF¥��%¤�@  Ø´¦<§ôUL°Qº�Ð��{§�

Page 98: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 87

,´�*�Ù%¤�@ heG*§r�¥ÀW�§S§��f�<w§Ï�/I

1�·§xð�ó0́ @�´Ó5(�Ì6§r¤�<DwØ®�Å;BÚ��

pè<��¯"

¯K3. ¢es�F¥�¤�½´�*¤�§5(´ÓؤNo�º

U�¥ÀW5K§�*LÑg�@ s�F¥�<§s�F¥�<�LH��

* ÃØé�´p´L§́ L´¡§±9dD½öΧ§ù¢�þÒ´ª¢Å&�

K�Ny"��§ÃØ´�*�´s�F¥�<�¥§=ØÅ&§Ø�¿g½´Ø

�¿�§I��é��û§��é�@�)Ø´�"7��§�é��½�ãÔÖ

�"Ù¥§́ Ä�ò�½�£F¥Ø�§KÀ!©Æ�¬¥vkù«|µ§�O´Ã

Iò£§Ï�@�F¥�U®»DØs"�ù«¤�1�§3�½��¬+N§X

�F¥�*¤3�¼x½~fp¬É��½�gI½´¨v§̀ ؽ���`Ѽ

x½~f§Ï�d��¥´1���S�ù��¬1�5�"� 5̀ÜiP6¥§

/Ý¥´vkÉ�gI½´¨v"ù��¡´Ï�/Ý´�/pݧ́ Ø�U�ú

Ì�5�F¥+¥�§U�IéÙÃl�å¶,��¡§½ö�Ì��§3u@�U

�úÌ´2»û����êb��§�×��U�I�3��Ù7mé£ú̧

/Ý�äéU�I�kõ§a��5Ø9Q§qÛ5gI½´¨vQ"

çIÝI´�`z¢yæ(J§éçI�85�|��½|¿�§±;��

¥ÀW¥�UÑy�v`�Ù½´v���Ù �5�¤�1�"�d§çI©�

´UäNçI�8�A:ÚI¦?��çIÝI5K§Ùm�´3�lçIÝI�

�5KcJe§æ^Ö¡�ª§²(çI�8äN�æI¦!ÝI¿�!J`I

O!ÜÓÇ��5K"��¥ÀW5KØÓ§çI©�´çIÝIL§¥�°çI

<�Ö¡¯¢§́ 1²çI<�æI¦!ÝI�¦!J`IOÚÜÓ^���°

­�©�"

��/§ó§!ÀÔ½ÑÖ�8�çI©�A²(±eSNµ

1.çIúw½ÝI��Ö"çIúw½ÝI��Ö�8�§��¥ÀWÜb&

E8���§3uáÚ@a,��d3ÝI<§UçI©��¦?�ÝI©�¿

ë\ÝI¿�"��/§çIúw½ÝI��ÖA{²��§��A�)µ�çI

�8^�§�)çI�8�¶¡!�8"1!ØO½�YÅ'!]75 ¶�çI�

�!¢�/:¶�Á�Ï�¶��þ�¦¶�]��¦¶�¼�çI©���m!/

:��{¶�4�ÝI©��/:Ú���m¶�éX�ª�¯�§±¦d3ÝI

<�âg�¢å§�Ñ´Äë�ÝI�û½"

2.ÝI<L�"ÝI<L�§́ çIÝI¹Ä�Ì�§S5K"��/§ÝI

Page 99: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

88 çIæÛYFn

<L�A²(±e¯�µ�oK§�)çI�8V¹!çI<¶¡!çI�8V)!

çI��!çI�8]75 Úá¢�¹!Á�Ï�!�þIO!ÝI<]�^�

�¶�çI©��¤§�)çI©�|¤9Ù©�!?U¶�ÝI©��¤§�)Ý

I|¤!ÝI�d�¦!ÝIk�Ï9ÝI�y7!]�"�!ÝI©�?��¦

�¶�ÝI§�)ÝI���m!ÝI©��µ�IP!ÝI©�4�!?U��£

�¦�¶�mI§�)mI�mÚ/:!mI§S±9mIë��^��¶�µI§

�)µI�¬|¤!µI�K!µI§S!í�¥IÿÀ<ê�¯�¶�ÜÓÇ

�§�)µI(Jú«!¥IÏ�!Á�ú�ÚÜÓ\¾�¦�¯�¶�Ù¦¯�§

XéçI<!ÝI<ÚµI�¬�VÆ�å!>fçIÝI²�9©�ÑÑ�ª

�¦�"

5¿§ÝI<L���Ø�¤ÜÓ©�"�d§çI<XJF"ÝI<L�¥

�Ü©SNkÜÓ�åå§~XçI��!�d��Ú�dSN�§A3ÜÓ^�

½´\¾ÜÓ�3ÜÓ;^^±¥²(§±¦ÙäkÜÓ�åå"

3.æ�ü9�¦"æ�ü´çI���.½§��A�)æ�ü`²!

ó§�ó!ÀÔ½ÑÖæ�üL§�)Ù�üf89SN.½!æ5�!.Ò

Úêþ§±9�d�¦�"Ù¥§�ó§�ó�d§A�)¤I<ó¤!�óÅ�¦

^¤!á�¤!$,¤!�u¤!SC¤!"�?E¤!�x¤!+n¤!|d![

7Ú5¤�§±9ÜÓ²«½V«�ºx!I?ÚÂÖ¶�ÀÔ�d§A´ÙU/æ

�ü0JøÀÔ�¤k¤^§�)Ù)��E¤!$Ѥ!+n¤Ú|d§®|G

½ò|G�?�[!�¬[!�È[ÚÙ§[¤§�y²Ù��÷vÜÓ�¦¤I

�u�uÿ¤§�a�x¤!��ÑÖ¤§±9ÜÓ²«½V«�ºx!I?ÚÂ

Ö¤^�¶�ÑÖ�d§A´ÙUÑÖæ�ü§JøÑÖ9�'�@�¤k¤^§

�)<ó¤!��¦^¤!á�¤!+n¤Ú|d§±9�«$,¤!u�uÿ¤!

�x¤!ÜÓ²«½V«�ºx!I?ÚÂÖ�9¤^�"

5¿§çI©�´���N§A�¦ÝI<éæ�ü�çI©�¥�ÝI<

L�!Ï^ÜÓ^±!;^ÜÓ^±!EâIOÚ�¦�Ü©�å�Ön)"

4.EâIOÚ�¦"EâIOÚ�¦´æI�Eâ.½"Ù¥§�ó§ï�

�8EâIOÚ�¦§A�)I[!1�!/��Ù�ó§ï�{ÆÚ{5!ó§

ï�IO!5�!5§Ú�{!�'¯��Eâ�¦½`²"kã��§Jøã�

�¶�ÀÔEâIOÚ�¦§���)øÀ��§��çI�§A?�Ú²(øÀ

���)�ÌÅ!9Å!N�9"��!;^óä!�¬��!ÀÔEâ5�!ë

ê��¦!ÀÔ�ÂIOÚ�{!ÀÔ�C!I£9�¦!ÀÔ$Ñ�ª!SCN

Á9EâÑÖ�¦!ÀÔ)��E�9�ÔÚÈ�ÑÖ�¯�¶�ÑÖEâIO

Page 100: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 89

Ú�¦§���)ÑÖ�õU½8I!I�1�I[!1�!/�IO½Ù¦IO!

5�!I÷v��þ!S�!Eâ½ÔnA5!ÑÖ��!¢��mÚ/:!ÑÖI

O!Ï�!�Ç��¦!�ÂIO§±9Ù¦�¦�"

5.ÜÓ^�" çI�8ÜÓ^�´¥I<Á��^�§NyuÜÓÌ�^±

¥"ÜÓÌ�^±��A��)±eSNµ���5.½§�)c�½Â!ÜÓ©

�`k^S!ÜÓ)�^��¯�¶��¯<�|�ÂÖ"I²(�¯<�|!�

¯<ÂÖ¶��þ�¦§�âI[IO!5�!5§±9çI�8I¦§JÑçI

�8�þ8IÚ�¦�¶�Á1Ï�!/:ÚÁ1�ª"²(I�Á1/:!çI

<Oy�ÜÓÁ1Ï���¦"��/§ÜÓÁ1�ªdÝI<3ÝI¥²(§7

��§çI<��±3çI©�¥éÁ��ªJÑ�¦§±ÎÜçIæÔѶ�

ÜÓd±½�Å"²(ýG±!ÜÓd±½�Å|G±Ï!G±§SÚ�{�¯�§

Ó�§éýG±!ÜÓd±½�ÅJÑ|G�¦Ú^�¶�ÜÓC�"ù´çIÝ

IL§¥L²(w�ÝI<�­�¯�§=ÜÓ�¢�5SN3�o�/!�o^

�e�±N�§I²(ÜÓC�>u^�!C�§S!(@§±9éA�ÜÓd�!

Á�Ï��¢�5SNN��{�¶��Â�u�"JÑçI�8��Â�u�I

O!�{!§SÚ(J?n�¯�§±9�Â�u�ØÎÜÜÓ�¦�?n�{�

¯�¶�Á��y"²(���¯<�,���¯<JøÁ��y�/ª!ê�!

ú�SN9I?�¶���!¢���Æ"²(���/!��I?Ú��?n!¢

�?n§S!Ï�§±9ÜÓ�Æ�å»Ú�{�¯�"Ó�§ÜÓ^�¥�A²

(ÜÓÁ1�9�Ø�|å«a!@½�{§±9ÑyØ�|å�§�¯<�g�

ÂÖ9I?©ú�¯�"

6.ÝI©��ª"çI©�¥�ÝI©��ª§́ çI<éÝI<?�ÝI©

��ÑÑ�ª�¦"��/§ÝI©��ª�)µ�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹¶�{½

�L<�°y²½Nk{½�L<�°y²�Ç��÷Ö¶�ÝI�y7£±³y

½�¼�ª¶�éÜN�ÆÖ£éÜNÝI�J�¤¶�Eâ!ûÖ � lL!æ

�ü�dL¶�]�"�]�§�)ÝI<Ä��¹L!CcãÖG¹L!Cc

aq�8�¹L!Ccu)��zÚ®à�¹L!�8+nÅ�!Ì�<{{L!

[Ý\¤ì!��!��ÚNÄåL¶�Á�|�Oy½¢��Y¶�©��89

¢�OyL¶�ÝI©��Ù¦�ª�¦�"

çI©�¥5½ÝI©���ªkü�8�§�´3�­�¯�§I�²d

ÝI©��ª��ÝI1�§XÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹!æ�ü�§�#NÝI<

35½���?W�ÝISN Ø#NÙ?U�©SN§�´3ÝI©��Ó/�

é��ÓÝISN§Bu?1î�'�"�d§Ø�1�«8�5½�ÝI©��

Page 101: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

90 çIæÛYFn

ª§A#NÝI<ÀÙÝII�?1Ö¿!?U½´*¿§Ø¨LurNÝI©

��ª�¦"5¿§ÝI©��ª´Aµ"Ú'�I� ���§A��µ"Ú'

�¯��éA§Ù���¦A!|§Ø¨�C¾�u�¦"

7.µIIOÚ�{" çI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{§´çI<J`�Ö¡N

y§́ µI�¬éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'��Ì��â"��/§µIIOÚ�

{�)µI�{ÀJ!ÐÚµ"IOÚµ"!�[µ"IOÚµ"!µI(J�S

N"Ù¥§µI�{©�nܵ�{Ú²µ"��$ÝId{ü«"ÐÚµ"©�

/ªµ"!]�µ"!�A5µ"§́ µI�¬UÐÚµ"IOéÝI<´Ää

�ë�¿�]��µ"Ú'�"7��§ÐÚµ"�§�A�|�éÝI<Á�|

�Oy´Ä÷v�¦�µ"¶�[µ"´µI�¬éÏLÐÚµ"�ÝI§U�

[µ"IO?1µ"Ú'�¿J`í�¥IÿÀ<�L§"

I�AOÚ±5¿�´§þ�¯�¥�ÝI<L�!æ�ü9�¦!EâI

OÚ�¦!ÜÓ^�§±9ÝI©��ª�¦¥§A�±28��ªI²IÝI<

�A�¤k�¦Ú^�§�)ÝIÚÁ�L§¥7L�A��¦Ú^�§±�Ù!

O(/w�ÝI<ÝI7L�A�¦Ú^�§±�Ø�"�°���çI©�§�

L�¹µ¡Ú8¹"Ù¥§µ¡�k�½�ªÚSN§��I²(çI�8¶¡9

?Ò!çI<¶¡ÚúÙ�m"Ó�§\XçI<ü Ù"7��§çI<�ü 

KI<\i"kçI�nÅ��§1²çI�nÅ�¶¡§\XçI�nÅ�ü 

Ù§Ùm�3uæ^Ö¡/ªO(�½çIÝI5K§±��çI<½ÝI<��

�¥§?1��½I?JÄ"

12!§SµÝI<L�

ÝI<L�§́ ÝI<ë�çI�87L���§¿UÙ�¦?1ÝI�A�

§S55K½�¦"ØÓ�æI¦§Ùæ(Jk�UØ��§�çIÝI�§

S55KÄ���§Ñ´3�̵çIúw→çI©�→ÝI→mI→µI→ÜÓÇ�ù�Ä�§SÄ:þ§ÀØÓæI¦ÛÜO\½N�"~X§æ^]�ý"

�§òçIúwN��]�ý"úw§3çI©�u�c§O\]�ý"úw→]�ý"©�→]���©�→]�"�→çI©�"��/§ÝI<L�´çI<�éçIÝI§S �½��¦ÝI<�l�5K§́ ÝI<ë�çI�8ÝI�

oj§Ù¦Ü©§Xæ�ü9�¦!EâIOÚ�¦!ÜÓ^�!ÝI©��ª

�§́ ÝI<L�¥,�¯�½�¦�Ö¿½[z"

çIÝI5K´ÝI<ÝI7L�l�5K§aqu�¥ÀWS�¥¢e��

Page 102: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 91

�F¥�A­<��§I��lS��å"��/§��ÝIoj§ÝI<L��

)±eSNµ

1.oK"oK§́ çI�8V)ÚéÝI��5�¦§�)µ�çI�8V¹§

XçI<!çI�nÅ�¶¡!/�ÚéX�ª§çI��!OyÁ�Ï�!�þ

IO§çI�8]75 Úá¢�¹¶�ÝI<]��¦§�)Ù¬¯ÌN!½|

O\!ÝI]�k�§Ø�3{Æ{5B�ÙÝI�/§Á�Uå§XãÖUå!�

8+n<��!Á�Oy!��!��ÚNÄå���ÎÜI¦§ä�aq�8

�1§kûÐ�Á�&��¶� t�8y|�ÝIý�¬´Ä|�§|���m!

/:�¶�´Ä#N©�"#N�§5½çI�8=�ÌN!�'�5ó�#N

©�§²(5½�©�SN!©�7�Úé©��]��¦���5^�¶��A

Ú � l�¦"²(5½çI©�¥=�Ü©!=^±�¦½^��¢�5�

¦Ú^�§½´k� � lÏ�½�I§�¦ÝI©�éçI©��¢�5�¦

Ú^��Ñ÷v5½�k|uçI<��A§ék� � lÏ�½�I§�¦Ý

I©�� � lÎÜçI©�5½� l��ÚÌÝ"ÄK§ÝI<�ÝIò�

çI<Äû�"

2.çI©�"ÝI<L�¥çI©�^±§3uO(.½=©��¤çI©

�§±��ÝI<ÝI��â"Ó�§��µI�¬µ"Ú'�!çI<�¥I

<\¾ÜÓ��â"��/§´­�çI©��Ù¶¡��çI©��|¤©�§

XUçI©��Ù¶¡§5½çI©�dµ�ÝI��Ö¶�ÝI<L�¶�æ

�ü9�¦¶�EâIOÚ�¦¶�ÜÓ^�¶�ÝI©��ª¶�µIIOÚ�

{�¤§Ó�²(§3þãçI©�5½^�euÑ�çI©�©�Ú?U�¤ç

I©�"~X§5½çI©��©�½?U3ÝI���mc15Fu�¤kïç

I©��ÝI<�§�¤çI©��"

3.ÝI©�"ÝI<L�¥�ÝI©�^±§3uO(.½=©��¤ÝI

©�§±��µI�¬µ"Ú'�!çI<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ��â"

1¤ÝI©�|¤"ÝI©�|¤Ü©�3.½=©��¤ÝI©�"��

/§±çI©�¥/ÝI©��ª0�Ù5½�¯���ÝI©�"~X§5½Ý

I©��)e�SNµ�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹¶�{½�L<�°y²½Ç��÷

Ö¶�éÜN�ÆÖ¶�ÝI�y7£±³y½�¼�ª¶�Eâ!ûÖ � l

L!æ�ü�dL¶�]�"�]�§�)ÝI¢��Y¶�©��89¢�O

yL¶�ÝI<L�cNL�¦�Ù¦]�"d§�I²(ÝI<3µIL§¥

�Ñ�ÎÜçI©�5½5K�©�(@§�¤ÝI©��|¤Ü©"

2¤ÝI�d"ÝI�d^±§3u5½ÝI�d��!�d�{!d��¤Ú

Page 103: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

92 çIæÛYFn

�'�¦"Ù¥§�d��A��ÓuçI��§Od�{Úd��¤UìçI�

81�+nÚ.~�1"~X§,ó§�óçI�8§5½�ÝI�d^±�µ�

�d��"U�çI©�/ó§þ�ü0Ù��¦W��AL�"X3ÝI���

mcÝI<?UÝI¼¥�ÝIo�d§AÓ�?Ud?/Idó§þ�ü0¥�

�A�d§Ud?éÝI©�\i!XÙÚ�µ�¦?1\i!XÙÚ�µ§3Ý

I���mc4�¶��d�{"z�f8LW\üd½d�§��#Nk���

d"XJÝI<�,�f8vW\üd½d�§Ù¤^À�®©�3ó§þ�ü¥

Ù¦�'f8�üd½d��¥§Ø��LÝI<L�cNL¥1²��pÝI�

d¶�d��¤"ÝI</Idó§þ�ü0¥�üd½7�§A�)�¤�f8ü

 ó§þ¤I<ó¤!�óÅ�¦^¤!á�¤!Ù¦£$,¤!�u¤!SC¤!

"�?E¤!�x¤§±9ÜÓ²«½V«�ºx!I?ÚÂÖ�¤§±9+n¤!

|d�¶��d^�"ÝI<A¿©)T�8�oN�¹±9K��d�Ù¦�

�?1�d"çI<3 ty|¥0��|/Ú±>�¸�¹§øÝI<3ÝI�

ë�§çI<ØéÝI<âd�Ñ��äÚûü«úI?"

[çI���Ư�] ,ó§�óçI�8æ^ó§þ�üOd"çI©�¥�

ÝI<L�5½�çI�� /́ó§�óãp¶�1.5m±S�è�!/Ä�Ä

:!ÌN(�!¡!�I!¢/¡!C?C»!�üY!æÏ!>íÚ��󧧱

9Tó§5yù�S��S+�!Ézó§0"çI©�Jø�ó§þ�ü¥§vJ

øÉzó§þ§ÝI<Uó§þ�üW��d§Ø¹Ézó§�f8�d"T�8

çI<Ú¥I<\¾ÜÓ�§ÜÓ���çI©�çI����"�8Á1(å�§

V�3ÜÓ(�d±þu)�Æ"¥I<JѧçI©�Jø�ó§þ�üvkÉ

zó§þ§ÝIv�d"�d§çI<A��|G¥I<Ézó§§=32.00��

�¤^¶çI<@�§çI©�1²�çI��¥�¹Ézó§§T)¤^A�¹

3¥Id§ØU2�O\¤^"V��d3(��u)�Ƨ�Ý�Oþ{̧�

²1n<N)§V���Ó¿§U¢Ss¤�80%§=25.60��éÉzó§?1(

�"ù��¯éçIæ�é&´§ÝI��A��çI����§�ÝI�d�

�´Ä�çI����KØ�½"nØþ§ù�ö�A���§�Jøæ�ü�

çI�8§çI��´ÜÓ��§ æ�ü1²�f8´ÝI�d��§�ö©

l"d�§XJ�ö��þ�3�ɧ4´��¥I<�ÜÓ����d��Ø�

� 3Á�L§¥½´V�(��u)�Æ"

3¤ÝIk�Ï��y7"ÝIk�Ï´ÝI<�ÝIk��±YÏ�§±Bu

çI<3ÝIk�Ïm�¤mI!µIÚÜÓÇ�ó�"5¿§çI©�5½ÝI

k�Ï¿�¦ÝI�A�§ÝI<�ÝIÒ«ìÏ�"ù�§Uì5¬{;6ÜÓ

Page 104: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 93

?1ozÔ�8^§=(½«ìÏ����Ø����5½§ÝI<3ÝIk�

Ï�SØ���ÙÝI§Ø�N�ÙÝI©��¢�5SN"

��/§ÝIk�Ï��§ÝI<��d�é½|�~d� p¶ÝIk�Ï

�á§ÝI<��d��Cu½|�~d�§�çI<k�U3ÝIk�ÏS�¤

ØÜÓÇ�ó� �¦ÝI<ò�ÝIk�Ï��/"d�§L�I?3çI<§

3uçI<5½�ÝIk�ÏØv±¢yÜÓÇ�¤�"�d§çI<�¦ÝI<

ò�ÝIk�Ï�§ÝI<�±Ó¿§��±ØÓ¿"ÝI<Ó¿ò�ÝIk�Ï

�§A�Aò�ÙÝI�y7�k�ϧ=ÙÝI±Yk�§Ø��¦½�#N?

UÙÝI©�¶áýò��§ÙÝIgÄ��§ÏL��3çI<§ÝI<k�Â

£ÙÝI�y±9±y7½ö|¦/ª4�ÝI�y7���Õ1�±|EÂ\"

@o§çIÝI¥§��oÃã�åÝI<3ÝIk�ÏS�yÙÝI±Yk

�§? çI<|�µI�¬µ"ÚÜÓÇ�Q§ùÒ´ÝI�y7��y�^§

=ÝI<^ÝI�y7ú�§3ÝIk�ÏSØ�£ÝI"ÄK§çI<�±Øò

�ÙÝI�y7§±�ÖçI<���"ÝI<�ù«ú�I?Ì�kü��¡µ

�3ÝIk�ÏS��ÝI©�¶�3Â�¥IÏ�Ö�§Ã��ndØ�çI<

¾áÜÓ§3\¾ÜÓ��çI<JÑØU�É�N\^�§½öØUìçI©�

�¦J�Á��y7"5¿§ISþrÝI�y7À�ÝI�ú�§��æ^Õ1

�¼�ÓÝI©�4�"ISòÝI�y7½5�ÝI©��|¤Ü©§Ùú�7

�Ú/ªÎÜçI©�5½§�¦ÝI<34�ÝI©��Ó�4�"�,§�#

NÝI<ÏLÕ1=â§�ÝI©�¥ANkÝI�y7�=â³y"

[ÝI�y7ò���~] ,½Aúimu���4â�óçI�8§ÝI�

y7�80��"Búi¥I��Ù¦ÝI<Þ�Ùë\��8��÷�n<���

]��b"�d§A úi�¢���Búi�¥I]�§Øò�Ù®�B�ÝI

�y7§nd´Búi��]�Eb§��çI©�1²�/ÝI<3ÝI¹Ä

¥GÏÝI!áJ�b�,ÝI�y7Ø�ò�0�5½"�d§BúiòAúiwþ

{Ì"{̲"n�§�ûAúi��Búi�ÝI�y780��§¿«ú�z¤§

nd´þã�½*�5¥u<¬�ÚIçIÝI{¢�^~6£±e{¡5çI

ÝI{¢�^~6¤éØ�ò�ÝI�y7��/§@�Búi3ÝIL§¥�E

Ù�÷�n<���y², ¥IÃ�§A�{«úÙ�çI<E¤���"��Y

¥§Aúi¤Þyâ§ØUy²Búi��÷�n<��y²Eb�¯�AúiE¤

��"�d§{�|±Búi��z�¦§�ûAúiò�Búi�B�ÝI�y

780��9Ù�)��±|E§Y��z¤^dAúi«ú"

4¤]�"�]�?�"éÝI©��ª¥]�"�]�§XÝI<Ä��¹

Page 105: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

94 çIæÛYFn

L!ãÖUå!Ccaq�8�¹L!�zÚ®à�¹L�^�§JÑ?��{Ú

Jø�'á�½]�§±y²ÝI<�]�ÎÜ�¦"

5¤ÝI©�?�"éÝI©�?�JÑ�¦§�¦ÝI<�ÝI3÷vçI©

�¢�5�¦�Ä:þ§�±JÑ'çI©���¦�k|uçI<�«ì§±B

uçI<J`ÀJ"Ó�§éÝI©��\iÚXÙ!ÑÑ�ª!�<!C¾!°ê

�JÑ�¦§±BuµI�¬µ"Ú'�"

4.ÝI"ÝI^±Ì�I²(n�¯�§©O´µ�ÝI©��C�¦"5¿§

ÝI©���CØ´ÝI©�§=´1²ÝI<¤ÝI�çI�8§mIcÙÝ

ISNØ�¦<�¡�8�§�ÐdÝI<gÌû½§çI<بLuî�ÙµC

ÚIP�ª�¦¶�4�ÝI©�����m"ù´çIÝI5K¥��­���

m:"�d§çI<I3d²(5½ÝI���m§±9�1Û/��mIO§�

©¨�¦"~X§,çI©�5½�ÝI���m�µ2020c8�26FþÌ10:00�

£�®�m¤¶�ÝI©�?U��£�¦"çIÝI5K#NÝI<3ÝI���

mc�±Ö¿!?U½ö�£Ù®4��ÝI©�§�Ø#NÝI<3ÝI���

m���½ö?UÝI©�"�d?I�²(ÝI<3ÝI���mc��½ö?

U�ÝI©�/ª�¦§AO´Ù�4��ÝI©�\i!XÙ�¦§A��éÝ

I©��\i!XÙ��§±L²´ÝI<ý¢¿g�L«"3ÝI���mc�

£ÝI©��§ÝI<AÖ¡w�çI<§±BçI<|��YmI¯�"

5.mI"mI^±Ì�I²(ü�¯�§�´mI�mÚ/:"Ù¥§mI�

mA��ÝI���m��§=35Kþ§ÝI©���C3ÝI���m�±

µ§ÝIm©)�"mI/:Aæ^Ö¡/ª¯kw�ÝI<§±BÙk¿v��

më�mI¬Æ¶�´mI§S§=çI<|�mI�6§ÚúÙ¯�"��/§m

I§Sk8��!§�g�µ�\ÙmIVƧúÙ3ÝI���mc4�ÝI©

��ÝI<¶¡§\ÙmI<!�I<!P¹<!iI<�k'<6¶¶�ÝI<

½öÝI<�L§½öçI<�÷�úyÅ�u�ÝI©���µ�¹§(@[m

I�ÝI©��ÝI<�ý¢¿gL«¶�çI�8�kI.�§úÙI.¶�U

ìd?5½�mI^S§�¯ µÝI©�§úÙçI�8¶¡!ÝI<¶¡!Ý

I�y74��¹!ÝI�d!�þIO!Á�Ï�!�8KI<9Ù¦²(I�

úÙ�SN§¿P¹3Y¶�ÝI<�L!çI<�L!iI<!P¹<�k'<

3mIP¹þ\i(@¶�\Ök'VÆ�¦§\ÙmI(å"

6.µI"µI^±Ì�I²(ü�¯�§�´µI�¬9Ù|ï¶�´N�

µI§m�´w�ÝI<µI�Ì�5K"Ù¥§µI�¬�m�´UçI<�

J`IOéÝI?1µ"Ú'�§�¤µI�w"�d§µI�¬dçI<�L

Page 106: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 95

ÚµI�9�k'Eâ!²L;��;[|¤"��/§çI<�LA�ÙGçI

�8�'�Ö§;[�µI;[;�©aIO¤�;�;[§<ê�Ê<±þüê§

±BLû�æ^ݦ�ª(½µ"(Ø"5¿§�ÝI<�3|³'X§�UK�

µIú�5�<ØU?\µI�¬"XJrçIÝI¹Äw��|N�m¯§ç

I<ÚÝI<´$ħKµI�¬´à�"¤±§µI�¢�§3uµI�

¬XÛú²ú�/éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§XÛ¢yµI(J��ÆJ`"a

q�à�§µI�¬�UUçI<úÙ�5K§=çI©�5½�µI�{!

µ"Ï�!IOÚ§SéÝI¯¢§éçI<3ÝI���mc�Â�ÝI©�?

1µ"§�çI<J�Ö¡µI�w¿í�küS�Ü�¥IÿÀ<§±BçI<

J`(½¥I(J"ùp§üS´µI�¬µ"'��§UçI©�5½�üS

Ï�½�Ií��¥IgS§k|uçI<J`¢yæ(J"@o§́ Ä�±�

¦µI�¬í��¥IÿÀ<ØüS dçI<,1�¾J`5K§3µI�

¬í��Ü�ÝI<Ä:þJ`Qºùül¢yæ(Jþw�ÃØ�§̄ K�¢

�3u§çI<�J`IO�´µIIO��Ü©SN§A�3çI©�¥�ÝI

<úÙ"µI�¬UúÙ�üS�{éÜ�ÝI<üS§Ny�E´çI<J`

IO§�ö¿Ã�É"¢�¥§�<��3Ü�ÝI<¥�ÅÄ�¥I<§wq

ú²§¢Kræ¹Ä�Óu/�·0§¿�´²LJ`§�Ø��§Ï�Ù��

½|²L�m�"

7.ÜÓÇ�"ÜÓÇ�^±Ì�w�ÝI<(½¥I<�L§§X´ÄI�ú

«¥IÿÀ<§́ Ä�é¥IÿÀ<�Á�Uå?1¢S(@§±9ÜÓ\¾�¦

�k'¯�§�)µ�¥IÿÀ<ú«"ú«�8�§́ �u�ÝI<9Ù|³'

X<éçIÝI¹Ä�iÒ�^§JÑÉƽÝ�±ÌÜÙ�ö�¥IÿÀ<Á

�Uå"�"ÜÓÇ�cé¥IÿÀ<Á�Uå§AO´Ù²E!ãÖu)��C

z½ö�3�{1��"�¢�§́ 2g(@¥IÿÀ<�Á�U姱B¥I<

Á�UåÎÜ�¦¶�¥IÏ�"�´çI<UúÙ�(½¥IÿÀ<�{(½¥

I<¶�´�¥I<uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§Ó�ò¥I(JÏ�Ù¦ÝI<¶�Á��

y7"Á��y7´ÝI<¥I�§UçI©��¦�ê�Úú�/ª�çI<4

��Á��y§=¥I<��ÜÓ�½éçI<E¤�³�§çI<�±Uì�½

dÁ��y7¥¼��½�²L��¶�ÜÓ\¾"ÜÓ´çIÝI5�¿�¤J

�Ny§çI<Ú¥I<U5¬{;6ÜÓ?'u¥IÏ�ÖÚ¥I<�ÝI�¤

ÜÓ�5½§UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾áÖ¡ÜÓ§²(V��|ÚÂÖ"

ù�¥§çI<�¥UC¥I(J½´¥I<�¥�ï¥I�8§Ø�é��¯<

\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§�X�¥ÀWS���§�¥���L��é��¯<Ó¿§Ud

Page 107: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

96 çIæÛYFn

?�½�ê���é��¯<��"

8.Ù¦"UçI�8A:Ú�¦§Ö¿Ù¦¯�"~X§éÝI<ë�ÝI�

1��å�JѲ(�¦"æ^>fçIÝI�ª�§éÝI©�?�!\i!X

Ù�ÑÑ�ªÚ\�JÑ?�Ú�¦�"

13!J`µµIIOÚ�{

��/§IO´ïþ¯Ô�OK½ºÝ§�{´�¢y8Iæ��å»!Ú½

ÚÃã"µIIOÚ�{§aquv¥|þ�à�5K§́ µI�¬µ�ÝI(

J`�!�åµI�¬1��OK!§SÚ�¦§́ µI�¬µ"Ú'�ÝI

©���â"Ó�§µIIOÚ�{�´çI<Ú�ÝI<¿�J`§íÄ�¬E

â?Ú�Ny"µIIOÚ�{�Ø%§3u�âçI�8A:ÚæI¦§3½

|N�Ä:þ(½µI�Ï�!IOÚ�½^�§±9üSÏ�Ú�{§¿3çI

©�¥1²"��/§µIIOÚ�{�Ù§�)c�½Â!µI�{ÀJ!µII

O!ÐÚµ"!�[µ"ÚµI(J�§©OEÛXeµ

1.oK"�)�¾�K!��5�¦Úc�½Â�"Ù¥§c�½Â§́ éµ

IIOÚ�{¥��;�â�½Â§±O(.½Ù¹Â"��/§I�éµI�

{!µIÏ�!µIIO!µI^�!�d �Ç!�â�Ø!?�d!�¿$d!

Eâ l!ûÖ l!µId�!µIÄOd!nÜüSÚ¥IÿÀ<�c�?1

½Â"~X§,çI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{é�¿$d�½ÂXeµ

�¿$d§��d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d§½ö3�kI.�²w$uI.�

ÝI<ØUÜn`²½Jø�'y²á���d"

2.µI�{ÀJ"µI�{§��±ÝI(JüS��{·¶§©�üÏ�ü

SÚõÏ�üSü�a§ØÓ�æI¦A�éAuØÓ�µI�{"¥I<��

¦3æJ`g�þ��uÙ¦I[½´IS7K|�"~X§IS�çIÝI{

5½¥I<�ÝIA�ÎÜe�^���µ�U���Ý/÷vçI©�¥5½

���nܵdIO¶�U÷vçI©��¢�5�¦§¿�²µ"�ÝId�

�$§�ÝId�$u¤��Ø"ùü«�{§©O¡�nܵ�{Ú²µ"�

�$ÝId{"Ù¥§1�«�{§¢Sþ´­.Õ1�IS7K|�íÂ��$

µId{§áuüÏ�üS{¶1�«�{§=/U���Ý/÷vçI©�¥

5½���nܵdIO0§¢Sþ´õÏ�üS{§Ï�ù�¥�/��0Ú/n

ܵdIO0L²§Ù¤��õÏ� �ü�Ï�"¢�¥§@«rnܵ�{n

)�nܵ©{§�\üÏ�üS{§¢Sþ��õÏ�üS{3çIæ¥�

Page 108: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 97

J`�^"

µIIOÚ�{¥§A²(w�çI�8æ^�µI�{§́ ²µ"��$Ý

Id{�´nܵ�{§́ üÏ��´õÏ�üS"

3.µIIO"µIIO§́ �äÝI´Ä�AçI!́ Ä�`�IO§±9�

½^�"��/§µIIO�)µ�ÐÚµ"IO¶��[µ"IO¶�nÜüSI

OnÜ©SN§©ãXeµ

£1¤ÐÚµ"IO"ÐÚµ"IO§q©�/ªµ"IO!]�µ"IOÚ�

A5µ"IO�n�SN"

1¤/ªµ"IO"�)µ�ÝI<¶¡A�E��ì!½|O\]�/]�y

Ö!S�)�y�1²�¬¯ÌN¶¡��"Ó�§fúiØU^1úi�½|O

\^�?1ÝI§1úi�ØU^fúi�½|O\^�ÝI"ØÓÝI<|¤é

ÜN�§A�\Ý¿J�k��éÜÝI�ÆÖ§²(éÜNVÞ<ÚÝI<�I

©ó§d�ÝI<\i§\Xü Ù"Ù¥§�{½�L<�<\i�§AÓ�N{

½�L<Ç��÷Ö¶�ÝI©�d¬¯ÌN\i½XÙ§±L²ÝI´Ù¬¯1

�"{<½Ù¦|��§ÝI©�Ad{½�L</ü KI<½Ù�÷�n<\

i½\Xü Ù"5¿§�L²ÝI´ÝI<�ý¢1�§ÝI©�AdÝI<�

<!{½�L<½ü KI<�<\i"�÷�n<\i�§AdÝI<�<!{½

�L<½ü KI<?1¬¯�nÇ�§Ùm�3L²´ÝI<ý¢�¬¯1�"

�]�"�aq§ÝI©�\i�XÙ§́ üö¿��´k�=�§wçI©�é

ÝI©�\i!XÙ��¦"5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozÊ�^5½�ÜÓ)�^�§

�¯<æ^ÜÓÖ/ª¾áÜÓ�,g�¯<þ\¶!XÙ½öU�<�ÜÓ¤á"

3\¶!XÙ½öU�<�c,�¯<��®²Á1Ì�ÂÖ,é��É�,TÜÓ¤

á§=XÙ½\iÑL²ÜÓ¤á§çI©�édI3ÝI©��ª¥²(5½¶

�ÝI©��ªA�ÎÜçI©�éÝI©���ª�¦"Ù¥§=�ª�#N

ÝI<3��?W�§Ø#NÝI<éÙ�©SN?1?U¶=�ª#NÝI<

éÝI©��ª?1Ö¿!?U½´*¿§±÷vÝI�O�§A�3ÝI©��

ª¥²(5½¶�ÝI��5§���ÝI<�U4��gk�ÝI"éÜNÝI

�§ÙéÜN�¤Ø�2±gC¶ÂüÕJ�½ö2\\Ù¦éÜNÝI¶�Ù

¦/ªµ"IO"çI<U�8A:Ú�¦Ö¿�/ªµ"�Ù¦Ï�ÚIO§±

�½ÝI©�k��ÄO"

5¿§éÝI©��/ª�¦¨{'²§��±÷vµI�¬µ"Ú'�

��K"

2¤]�µ"IO"ùp§]�µ"IO�]��"IO§́ éÝI<�]�"

Page 109: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

98 çIæÛYFn

�½´E"§©ãXeµ�ÝI<¬¯ÌN/ k�§"�ÝI©�¥Jø�¬¯

ÌNk�y�"ÝI<´{<½öÙ¦|��§Jøk��E��ìÚ|�Å��

èy£E<�¤!{½�L<�°y²½´ÙÇ��÷Ö!ÝI©�\Ý<��°y

²�¶ÝI<´g,<�§Jø�°y�k��°y²�E<�¶�½|O\ÎÜ

5½|O\K¡�ü65½�O\^�§]�yÖ½)�N�yÎÜçI�8�?

�¦§ó§�ó!¶ìmæ��8ä�k��S�)�N�y�§"�ÝI©�¥

�½|O\]�/]�yÖ!S�)�N�y£E<�¤�¶�½|O\ÚÝI]�

k�§vk?u�I-Ê�Ê�!6�½öL�N�y!6�½öL��ì§vk

?\úi��§S!�\w»�½´Ù¦Ô�Á�Uå�/§ÝI]�vk���

½6ʧvk3�?&^&E��²�¥�\�&��1<¶ü§±9{Æ{5

²(B�½��Ùë�çI�8ÝI�Ù¦�/§"�ÝI<é½|O\ÚÝI]

�±Yk��«ìÖ¶�Á�Uå§�)çI�8Á��<!ã!ÔÚ�{�Oy

�§�¦ãÖUå!�8k <;�]�!êþÎÜÁ�I¦§ä�k���þ

+nNX@y�L§��@y§Á�|�Oy!��!��ÚNÄå��ÎÜçI

�8Á��¦§"�ÝI<Jø��þ+nNX�L§@y©�´Äk�§J��

Á�Oy!��!��ÚNÄå���§ÿ�ÙÁ�L§!!:��´Ä÷vçI

�8Á��¦¶�aq�8�1§�)ÝI<Ú�8Ì�<�15�!ÜÓ�Ý

½êþ�¦§"�ÝI©�¥�Ì�<{{L!¥IÏ�Ö!ÜÓ�ÆÖ!�Â

yÖ�¶�Á�&�§�¦ÝI<kûÐ��¬µd§"�ÝI©�¥�­ÜÓÅ

&�yÖ!¼øyÖ½�ry²á��¶�Ù¦�¦§Ud?5½�Ù¦]�"�

Ï�!IOÚ^�§éÝI©�?1]�"�"

3¤�A5µ"IO"�A5µ"§́ éÝI´Ä�AçI©�¥¢�5�¦Ú

^��µ""ùp§¢�5�¦Ú^�dçIÝI5�ÚÁ�L§¥§@çI<

æ^28��ªI²�§�¦ÝI<7L÷v�Ø��çI<¯�/?d�d0�

^�Ú�¦�¤"

�A5µ"IO���)µ�ÝI��"�¦"�ÝI©�¥�ÝI��´Ä

�uçI��§k� � lÏ�½�I3N����S¶�ÝI�d��"�¦

"�ÝI©�¥��d��´Ä�uçI��§́ ÄUæ�ü�d¶�Idæ

�ü"�¦ÝI©�¥�Idæ�ü��ÚêþÎÜçI©�¥�æ�ü�

¦¶�Á�Ï�"�¦ÝI©�¥�Á�Ï�ÎÜçI©�Á�Ï��¦§��Ø

��uçI©��¦¶��þIOÚ�¦"�¦ÝI©�¥��þIOÚ�¦÷v

çI©�¥éçI�8��þIOÚ�¦¶�ÝIk�Ï9�y7"�¦ÝI©�

1²�ÝIk�ÏØáuçI©�¥éÝIk�Ï��¦§ÝI�y7�/ª!7

Page 110: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 99

�Úú�ÎÜçI©�éÝI�y7�¦¶�EâIOÚ�¦¥�'�Eâëê½

�I"�¦ÝI©�1²�Eâëê½�I÷vçI©�éçI�8'�EâIO

ëê½�I�5½§ÝI©�¥kçI©��É��Ay²]�¶�ÜÓ^�¥�

¢�5�¦Ú^�"�¦ÝI©�éçI©�¥ÜÓ^��¢�5�¦Ú^��Ñ

�A§Ø�3ÝI©�¥V\N\?Û^�±��Ù�A�cJ¶�Ù¦¢�5�

¦Ú^�"�¦ÝI©�÷vd?²(�Ù¦¢�5�¦Ú^�"

£2¤�[µ"IO"�[µ"´éÏLÐÚ"��ÝI©�§�â�[µ"I

O5½�Ï�!IOÚ�{?1µ"§O�ÝI�üSÏ�"~X§üÏ�üS{

¥�²µ"��$ÝId{Únܵ©{§±9õÏ�üS{¥�ëþO�ÚµÆ

�"5¿§µ"Ï�©�üa§�a´�þz�§�a´Ø�þz½¡�Ì*µ"Ï

��§I³/µI�¬¤�Ì*�ä�ÑüSëþ�"éu�þz�µ"Ï�§

µIIOIUþz5KÚæJ`��§�ÑéAüSëþ�N�½´¼ê'X"

~X§U�[µ"IOúÙ�òdÏ�ÚòdIO§O�ÝI<�µId�"é@

Ø�þz�µ"Ï�½´Ì*µ"Ï�§�/`\1\Ò1Ø1�1§`Ø1\

ÒØ11�Ø10��U�§N�3|�§Sþ~�µI�¬¤��¿5§́

¢�¥�I�)û�¯K"

[Ì*µ"Ï��¯~] ,ó§�óçI�8é/�ó�Y0ÐÚ(½�µ"I

Oµ/�ó�Yk?§���éó§�þ!óÏÚ�óS�)�k¿©�æ�11-12

©¶�ó�Y�1§��éó§�þ!óÏÚ�óS�)�k�æ�8-10©¶�ó

�Y�1§���éó§�þ!óÏÚ�óS�)�Ä�k�æ6-7©¶�ó�Y

Ä��1§���éó§�þ!óÏÚ�óS�)�Ä�k�æ4-5©¶�ó�YØ

�1§½���éó§�þ!óÏÚ�óS�)�Ã�æ0-3©0§|�k';[é

þãµIIOïħ@�Ù¢�´rµ����/��µI�¬§ò/�ó�

Y0µ"y©Ê��?§=µA.�ó�Yk?!��k¿©�æ¶B.�ó�Y�1!

��k�æ¶C.�ó�Y�1!��Ä�k�æ¶D. �ó�YÄ��1!��Ä

�k�æ¶E.�ó�YØ�1½��Ã�æ"�d§;[|ïÆTÏ�µ"IOØ

¨æ^µ©«m§ AéØÓµ"�?�ÑÚ��©�IO"ïÆò/�ó�Y0

�µ"IO?U¤µA : {11, 11.5, 12}©¶B : {8, 9, 10}©¶C : {6, 6.5, 7}©¶D :

{4, 4.5, 5}©¶E : {1, 2, 3} ©"Ó�§éÌ*µ"Ï�µ"©�½?!�Ø�µ"�©nÚ"Ù¥§½?Ú�Ø�ãØéµI�¬úÙ��?��©IO§�¦µI

�¬¤éÓ�µ"Ï��¤kÝI(Jî�'�§(½�ÝIéAuù�µ"

Ï���?§XB+§B½B−§W��?µ"(J¶�ØdµI�¬U/�êÑl

õê0�Kéµ"�??1�ا8N��É~�?§(½Tµ"Ï��µ"�?"

Page 111: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

100 çIæÛYFn

��§úÙµ"�?éA�©�§dµI�¬½ó�<éTÌ*µ"Ï��?

��¤©�"ù��{k�)û�ê¤Øú�µ"y�§/¤µI�¬ª�

���(Ø"

£3¤nÜüSIO"��/§üÏ�nÜüSIOUÝIüSëþ�Ú�¦?

1üS"~X§æ^nܵ©{½´²µ"��$ÝId{�§UÝI<��©d

p�$üS§½´UÝI<�µIdd$�püS�"

õÏ�üSIO´éæI¦�õ�Ï�?1üS§¢y/U���Ý/÷

vçI©�¥5½���nܵdIO0§=õ�Ï�Ó�J`�IO§IUéA

�õÏ�üS5KüS(½`�½�S'X"��/§b�ÝIA!B`���½

ëþkX1!X2!· · ·!Xn�§üSIOI5½ÑëþX1!X2!· · ·!Xnm�S'X§

±9Û�A(X1, X2, · · · , Xn)�B(X1, X2, · · · , Xn)��S§Û�A(X1, X2, · · · , Xn)`

uB(X1, X2, · · · , Xn)�"�{ü�§́ 3nܵ©{½´²µ"��$ÝId{Ä

:þÚ\�SÚÙ¦üSÏ�§±Å�X{±üSþê���J`"

[nÜüS�¯~] 3ÝI÷væI¦�Ä:þ§,ó§�ó�8çI©�5

½�nÜüS5K�µ

�©`uÝI�d§ÝI�d`kuÁ���©�33 ©±S�§½ÝI�d

�35��±S�ÝI��S"

ù�§T�8�üSÒØ´üX�U�©?1üS§ ´Ó��Ä�S�^�

e�üS§=i;üS5K�A^§��e�Ù13!"

4.µI§S"µI§S´éµI�¬UçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§é

ÝI©�µ"Ú'��§S55½"���)ÐÚµ"!�[µ"ÚnÜüS�n

��!"

£1¤ÐÚµ""µI�¬UÐÚµ"IOéÝI©�?1µ"§k��ØÎ

Ü�¦�§A�ÄûÙÝI"Ù¥§µI�¬�±�¦ÝI<J�]�"��¦

�k'y²Úy����§±BØ�"Ó�§uyÝI©��éçI©��¢�5

�¦Ú^��Ñ�A§½éçI©�� � l�ÑN����§½öuyÝI<

kGÏÝI!áJ�b�1�§��½|�´5K�§µI�¬A�ÄûÙÝI"

£2¤�[µ""µI�¬�â�[µ"IOéÏLÐÚµ"�ÝI©�?1

µ"§(½ÙüSëþ"µIL§¥§é@¢�þ�AçI©��¦§�3�O

/��3¦�½öJøØ���Eâ&EÚêâ��¹�ÝI©�§�Ö�ù

¢¦½öØ��جéÙ¦ÝI<E¤Øú²�§µI�¬A�Ö¡�¦�3ù

[� ��ÝI<3µI(åc�±Ö�"©�!̀ ²½Ö�Ø��ÑÝI©�

����Ø�UCÝI©��¢�5SN§¿�¤ÝI©��|¤Ü©"ÝI<á

Page 112: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 101

ØÖ��§µI�¬3�[µ"��±UþzIOé[� ��Ø|uTÝI<

�þz½öÄûÙÝI"

µIL§¥§µI�¬uyÝI<��d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d§¦�ÙÝ

I�d�U$uÙ�O¤��§A��¦TÝI<�ÑÖ¡`²¿Jø�A�y²

á�"ÝI<ØUÜn`²½öØUJø�Ay²á��§µI�¬A�@½T

ÝI<±$u¤��d¿I§¿ÄûÙÝI"

£3¤nÜüS"µI�¬é?\�[µ"�ÝI§UnÜüSIOÚÝI�

üSëþ?1üS§?�ÝIüS�AL"

5.µI(J"�âÝI�nÜüS(JÚçI©���¦§µI�¬í�ü

S3c�ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<§?�µI�w"

�°���µI�w§���)µ�µIÄ��¹ÚêâL!µI�¬¤

¶ü!mIP¹¶�ÎÜ�¦�ÝI�AL!ÄûÝI��¹`²¶�µIIO!µ

I�{½öµIÏ��AL¶�üSëþ®oL!ÝI<üSëþO�L¶�²µ

"�ÝI<üS¶�í��Ü�¥IÿÀ<¶ü!\¾ÜÓc�?n�¯¨¶�©

�!̀ ²!Ö�¯�V�¶�µI�w�Ù¦¯��"

14!Á�µÜÓ^�

çI©�¥�ÜÓ^�§́ çI<�âçI�8A:ÚI�JÑ�§�3²(

�8Á�§�)ÜÓ��!�þ!Á1Ï�!/:Ú�ª!d±½ö�Å|G!��

I?!�Æ)û�ª�Á��Ö¡^�§²(�¯<V��g��|ÚÂÖ"��

/§ÜÓ^��)oK!�¯<�|�ÂÖ!�þ�¦!Á1Ï�!/:ÚÁ1�

ª!ÜÓd±½�Å!ÜÓC�!�Â�u�!Á��y!Ø�|å!��!¢��

�Æ�ÜÓÁ�¯�"Ó�§çI©�¥Aæ^28��ª§I²ÜÓ^�¥§=

^�½�¦´¢�5�¦Ú^�§±BÝI<�A"

[ÜÓ^�ز��¯] ,¯�ü |��Ö�Ô¢ó§�óçI�8"çI<

?��çI©�¥§rÜÓ«�©�¥��ÆÖ!ÜÓ;^^±ÚÜÓÏ^^±�

�ÜÓ^�§��ÆÖÚÜÓ;^^±¥I�UçI�8²(�/�þ���§v

k²(äN^�Ú�¦"²µI�¬µ"§ÝI<A�1�¥IÿÀ<"

çI<(@ÝI<A�¥I<§�ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§Ó�§ò¥I(Jw

�Ù¦�¥I�ÝI<"��§V�?1ÜÓ!�§�é�­�^±´´�ؤ

��¿�§AO´d±|G^±"çI<3!�¥U�~�ÜÓ|G�{JѧT

ó§ýG±�\�ÜÓd�10%§?ݱU��¤��65%|G§�þ�y7�\

Page 113: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

102 çIæÛYFn

�ÜÓd�3%¶{±�Ø�þ�y7�3ó§eó�Få30FS�g(�§�þ�

y7�~Ad¥I<«ú�"�I?¤^�§3"�I?Ϫ��Få30FS�g

5ò�"¥I<AØÓ¿§¡Ù®3ÝI©�¥1²§�¦çI<�G�ýG±´

¥Id�30%§�ÝG±�¥Id�85%§�þ�y7�1%"

V�k�!ngÑvk�¤��¿�"�d§k<ïÆ��ÝI<A�¥I

]�§�ü¶3Ùg�ÝI<B\¾ÜÓ"çI<\Î�/1�iÒÅ�§���

�E´§��ÝI<A�¥I]�§\ÙÝI<B¥Ivk{Æ�â"Ø�®§çI

<�Uþ�§�¥I<A2g!�"��§V�þ�Ñ�½4Ú§Ó¿ó§ýG±�

\�ÜÓd�20%§?ݱU��¤��75%|G§�þ�y7�\�ÜÓd�2%§

¿\¾�óÜÓ"

�¯¥§çI<��oØU��ÝI<A�¥I]�º�Ï3uçI<éýG

±!ó§?ݱ|G!�þ�y7��'~�vkJѲ(�¦§ÝI<A�ÝI

¢�5�AçI©��¦"Ó�§ÝI<A«ìÁ1T�8�ó�çI<®�Ù

uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§�ÉÝI<A�ÝI"d�§��ÝI<A�¥I]�§7,

��ú²Úú��K"¢Sþ§éuýG±!?ݱÚ�þ�y7�ݧçI<X

J@�7L�1Ù5½�ݧI�3ÜÓ^�¥²(Ù�¢�5�¦Ú^� ÃI

2�¥I<!�Ù�ݧù��´çIæ��¦"éu@çI©�¥v²(�

¢�5�¦Ú^��¯�§ÜÓ\¾�§duçI<®²�É¥I<�ÝI§Ø

U2r��¦¥I<?U§Ø�V�3�yØUCçI�8¢�5�¦Ú^�Ä:

þ§�¤��¿�"�d§UçI�8A:ÚI�3çI©�¥JÑÜÓ^�§́

çIæ�¦�Ny"

éuÜÓ^�¥��Ì�¯�§·�©ãXe"

1.oK"oK���)c�½Â!�ó©i!�l{Æ!ÜÓ©��`k^S!

ÜÓ�ÆÖ!©�Jø�ì+!éä!ÜÓ=4!;|��£��!���^±"Ù

¥§c�½Â´éÜÓ�9�;�â�?1½Â§±O(.½ÙSº�ò§¢y

ÜÓ�½�O(5"~X§,ó§�OçIÜÓ^�¥§éu�<�L§½Â�du

�<?·§¿3Ç���ÚÏ�S�Lu�<1¦�|ÚÁ1ÂÖ���KI<¶

ÜÓ©��`k^S§́ éÓ��¯ØÓÜÓ|¤©��½Ø���§±=�°©

��O�½´`k��gS§���½´±üS3c�©��O"~X§,ó§�

óçIÜÓ^��½§ÜÓ©��`k^SXeµ�ÜÓ�ÆÖ¶�¥IÏ�Ö¶�

ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹¶�;^ÜÓ^±¶�Ï^ÜÓ^±¶�EâIOÚ�¦¶�

�óã�¶�Idó§þ�ü¶�Ù¦ÜÓ©�"

2.�|ÂÖ"�|´�¯<3ÜÓ¥�d�£�§ÂÖ´�¯<3ÜÓ¥�d

Page 114: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 103

�GÑ"UìÜÓ�é5�K§���ÂÖ´,����|¶����|´,��

�ÂÖ"�|ÂÖ^±§3uO(.½�¯<�g��|ÂÖ§±¢yÜÓm�"

��/§çI<ÂÖ§Ì��)�Å{Æ!uÑÁ�m©Ï�!�nk'y�Ú1

�!|GÜÓd±!JøÄ:5]�!|�ÜÓ�ÂÚÜÓ²(�½�u�<Ù¦

ÂÖ¶¥I<ÂÖ§Ì��)�Å{Æ!�{B[!¢yæI�ÚÜÓ²(�½

�¥I<Ù¦ÂÖ"

3.ÜÓ��" ÜÓ��´ÜÓI���.½"çI<Ú¥I<\¾�Ö¡Ü

Ó§ÜÓ��A��çI����§ÎÜçI©�¥æI¦�5½"~X§,�

�çIÜÓ^�¥§éÜÓ����¦�µ/¥I<A�â��I¦�ALÚ�¦!

��Eâ5�ÖÚ��ÏÑÖOy�ÜÓ©��½§�ï�Jø¥I��!EâÑ

ÖÚ��ÏÑÖ"0

4.�þ�¦"�þ´�¬÷v5½I�Úd3I��A�ÚA5�oÚ"çI

�8�þ�¦§́ çI<éçI�8Á�ÎÜ{Æ!{5!5�Ú5§�L§Ú(

JJÑ��¦§�)�¬�L§u�!¤¬�ÂÚV�I?y©"�þ�¦���

)üÜ©§=�þ8IÚÁ��þ�Â"Ù¥§�þ8I±I[IO!5�Ú5§

þ5½��þ�?IOÚæI¦�O§0�/`�`d0�K§��Ny3ÝI

<L��Ù§�)�þIOÚ5U�I�¦�¶Á��þ�§�)L§u�!Á

�(J�ÂÚ�þ�y§±I[{Æ{5!�þ�ÂIO!5�þ�u�!�Â�

{Ú"�I?!�þ�?�{�O"

[�ó�þ�¦�¯~] ,ó§�óçIÜÓ^��½��þ�¦�µ/ó§�

þ�ÂÜ�§ÎÜI[y1�ÂIO"Ï«�<�ÏE¤ó§�þ�Ø�ÜÓ�½

�ÂIO�§çI<k��¦«�<�ó��ÎÜÜÓ�¦��§ddE¤�¤^

O\Ú£½¤óÏòØd«�<«ú¶Ïu�<�ÏE¤ó§�þ�Ø�ÜÓ�½

�ÂIO�§u�<«údu«�<�óE¤�¤^O\Ú£½¤óÏòا|G

«�<Ün|d§�½�"�I?Ï24��§�¦¥I<UÜÓ�½«úI?Ï"

�?EI?ÚIÖ�^~5½��þ�yI?"0

[ÀÔ�þ�¦�¯~] ,�.��çIÜÓ^�¥§5½���þ�©�m

�u�!�ØÚ�Ân��!"Ù¥§m1u�´éæ��êþ9*u�¶�

Ø´|���Á$1§éÙEâ5U�Ø�I�u��ÿÁ¶�´3���ØÄ

:þ§é�G����Â"��/§��Eâ5U�Ø�I�§A3�½�mS\

ÝÜÓ���ÂyÖ§±y²��÷vÜÓ�¦"Ó�§�¦¥I<�y§Ù��

��Èج�³?Û1n��Ü{�ÃÚ�¬ú¯|ç��9ÙÜ�´�#!�

�!�¦^L�§�y3Ù�O¦^Æ·ÏS§XJçI<uy��du�O!�

Page 115: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

104 çIæÛYFn

E!I£��Ï�3v±�9<�!ã�S��"�½Û�§¥I<A9�?�½

öÖ¿I£!?n!������Ø"�½Û�"

5.Á�Ï�"Á�Ï�§́ çI<�âæI¦JÑ�§�3÷vçI<¦^

�Ï���¦"ÜÓ^�¥§A3ÝI<L�5½�Á�Ï��¦Ä:þ§²(Á

�Ï��Ø�{§�d±|G^±�@§���)µ�Á�?ÝOy?�9N��

¦§Xó§�óÜÓ^�¥§�¦¥I<?��[��ó?ÝOyÚ�ó�Y`²

�xçI<½Ù�÷�in<1O�¶�Á�ò´I?§�)çI<Úu�Á�ò

´!¥I<Úu�Á�ò´§±91n<½É~���íÿ^�Úu�Á�ò´Ú

I?©��¶�Á�Jc§©�çI<�¦Ú¥I<ÌÄÁ�Jc�ü«�/"�

�/§çI<�¦Á�Jc�§½Á�JcU�u�<�5�Ã�§çI<A«

ú¥I<ddO\�¤^§¿�¥I<|G�½��Aø7¶�Á�6ʧ�)ç

I<�Ï!¥I<�ÏÚ1n<�Ï�Á�6ÊÚI?©�§±9UYÁ�^�"

7��§I?�«úé�²E���"

6.d±|G"ÜÓd±|G^±´ÜÓ^�¥�­�^±��§�´ÝI<U

ÙãÖUåë�ÝI§O�Á�¤�Ú�'¤^|ѧ? �¤ÝI�d�­�ë

�"d±|GÌ�kn��I§=µ�ýG±¶�Á�L§G±¶��ª(�±"Ù

¥§ýG±Ì�^u¥I<Á�O�§�)�á�!��æ§Á���!���

O��§5�þáu/±§I�3L§G±�U�½'~�£¶Á�L§G±´3

�½�G±Ï½Á�/�?ݧU®Á��¤�8�d��½'~|G¥I<�±

�"5¿§���çI�8�ýG±½Á�L§G±�ݧ3ÝI<ykãÖUå

Øv±÷v�8Á��§ÝI<I���¬Ê±½�Õ1�±¿|G�'¤^"�

d§ùü��I´ÝI<�'5�d±|G�I"

[d±|G�¯~] ,ó§�óçIÜÓ^�¥§éd±|G��½�µ�ýG

±��\�ÜÓd�10 §ÜÓ\¾�28FS|G§�¦¥I<3Â�ýG±3FS

�çI<J����ýG±�¼§3zg|Gó§?ÝAG±¥�'~�£§��

�Ü��¶�¥I<IJ�?ÝG±��ü§�ªÊ°"G±��ü�ª�L5.1"

󧶡µ �±<µ G±?Òµ

�8¶¡ �G± Ù¥ \O{gG± �5

7�£�¤ ���¤: �C�:

�¢�: ��±:

inó§�µ çI<µ c � F

L5.1 ?ÝG±��ü

Page 116: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 105

WL�§?ÝG±U�Ý�¤�W�§Nin<\Ý�©�ó§�ÂÜ�üÚ

©�ó§�¤��L"Ù¥§C��¢�±�A®²çI<(@§�±�)�'~

�ýG±���!3% ��þ�y7ÚV�(@�Ù¦�~±�"çI<U�ÝG

±��85%§u(@�28FS|G¥I<"

eó(��§¥I<3ó§�ÂyÖ�u�14US�in<J�eóG±��

ü§�ªÊ°§1²eó(�ÜÓod!®|G�ó§d±!A�£�ýG±!A

�3��þ�y7!A|G�eóG±7��§çI<3(@eó(�od�28F

S|G{±§�~�þ�y7¶�ª(��§¥I<A3"�I?Ϫ�yÖ\u

�28FS§�in<J�5°�ª(���ü§N�'y²á�"çI<3é�ª(

��(@�28FS|G¥I<{±"

7.ÜÓC�"ÜÓC�§���ÜÓ¢�5SNC�§�)ÜÓ��!Á1Ï

�!�þIOÚÜÓd±�C��§́ ÜÓ^�¥�­�^±��"~X§ó§�

óçI~��C��/§Xµ���ÜÓ¥?Û��ó������ó�Ø2I�

¢�¶�UCÜÓ¥?Û��ó���þ½Ù¦A5¶�UCÜÓó§�Ä�!I

p! �½º�¶�UCÜÓ¥?Û��ó���ó�m½UC®²in<1O�

�óó²½^S¶���¤ó§I�J\��ó��¶ÀÔçI~��C��/§

Xµ�ÜÓ�eJø�ÀÔ´;�ï��E�§C�ã�!�O½5�¶�UCÀ

Ôêþ½�þA5¶�UC$ѽ�C��{¶�UC�À�m½/:¶�UCç

I<Jø��@ÑÖ�"

çI©�¥�ÜÓC�^�§Ø%3uÜÓd±!Á�Ï��C��{§AO

´ÜÓ���C�§I�çI<�âçI�8Eâ^�Úd��¤§�ÑC���

ÜÓd±!Á�Ï�O��{½�K"ù�¥§�´C��½C�¯��uå§�

´C�Od�{½�K"�9Á�Ï�N��§UÁ�Ï�C��½V�ÂÖ"ù

p�Ø%´�Ñd�C�^�"��/§æ^æ�üçI�§3ÜÓ^�¥�Ñ

C�¯���d�K�µ�Idæ�ü¥k·^uC�ó��f8�§æ^Tf

8�üd¶�Idæ�ü¥Ã·^uC�ó��f8§�kaqf8�§�3Ü

n��Sëìaqf8�üd§C���¤^§(½C�ó��üd¶�Idæ

�ü¥Ã·^½aqf8�üd§U¤�\|d�K§dçI<�¥I<û½C�

ó��üd§Ù¥§+n¤Ç!|dÇ![7Ú5¤�ØC"

5¿§ÔdÅÄÚå�ÜÓd�Cz��ØÀ�ÜÓC�§ À�U�½?1

ÜÓd�N�"ù�:§3çIæ¥cÙI�Ú±­À§Ï�Ù��K�ÝI�

d�Á�¢�"¢�¥§éÔdÅÄÚå�d�Czkü«N��{"�«´Uì

ÜÓ^��½��{?1d�N�"~X§Uu¦â¢N�á�!���d§½´

Page 117: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

106 çIæÛYFn

Uæ^d��ê!d�&EN�d���§O\ÜÓd�¶�«´3�½d�ÅÄ

��SØN�§�LÅÄ���§é�LÜ©�±N�"~X§�½Idæ�ü

¥�f8üd§3?3%±S�Ø�N�§�L?3%�§�LÜ©�d±O\ÜÓd

�"ù«�{§��¬��ÝId��éu¢Sd� p§Ï�ÝI<�d�§I

��Ä�Uk3% �ºx¤^"

8.Á��y"Á��y§́ ¥I<�çI<J��½�Ý�Á��y§̂ uÖ

�çI<Ï¥I<ØU�¤ÙÜÓÂÖ �É���"��æ^d�[3IS5þ

�&�ÐÕ1½´ú�Å�§éçI©�5½�¥I<�Á�I??1��y§½

´d¥I<æ^Õ1®¦!|¦��çI<?1�y"ÃØ´=�«§¥I<�¤

ÜÓÂÖ�,3ÜÓ5½��mS§çI<rÁ��yò�¥I<"¢�¥§éuÜ

ÓÁ1Ï��!ú��Ý��çI�8§��±Uì��ÜÓ�4~ú���ª§

=¥I<�¤�½ÜÓ�½´ÜÓÁ1�½Ï��§¥I<U��ÜÓ�­#�n

Á��y§O�Ù®J��Á��y"

9.Ø�|å" Ø�|å´çI<Ú¥I<35�L§¥Ø�ý�!3Á�L

§¥Ø�;�¿�ØU�Ñ�g,/³Ú�¬5âu¯�§X/�!°�!¦¼!

Y/!ÖÏ!�Ä!Ô�§±9ÜÓ^��½�Ù¦�/"ÜÓ^�¥§�´²(

Ø�|å�«a�^�§�´u)Ø�|å�§ÜÓ�¯<�I?"V��¯<A

æ�k���§;�Ú~����*�"?Û��vkæ�k�������*�

�§Aé*�Ü©���«úI?"Ó�§ÜÓ���¯<ÏØ�|åØUÁ1Ü

Ó�§A�9�Ï�é�§UÜÓ^���½)ØÜÓ§þõ)ûV��Å�ÚÅ

ÖI?"

10.��!¢���Æ)û"ÜÓ�¯<Uª¢Å&��KÁ�´çIæ(

J¢y�^�"�d§ÜÓÁ1¥?Û����ÜÓ�½ØÁ1ÜÓÂÖ§Ñ�U

¬E¤Á��}§çI�8Q½8IÃ{½´k²L�d�¢y"�d§��!¢

���Æ)û§́ ÜÓ^�¥�­�^±��"Ó�§�´)ûÝI<�¿$dÝ

I çIÝIL§¥qÃ{(½§¥I<Á��/�/åd0�k�Ãã"��/§

ÜÓ^�I�²(�¯<����/Ú��?n�{"Ù¥§���/�)µ�¥

I<���/§�)¥I<�²çI<Ó¿§hgòÜÓ��ܽܩ�|=4�

Ù¦<§½òÜÓ��ܽܩÂÖ=£�Ù¦<¶���þ�¦§¦^ØÜ�

á�½Á��þ�Ø�IO�¦§qáý�ØØÜ�¯�¶�UUÁ�?ÝOy9

��¤ÜÓ�½�ó�§®E¤½ýÏE¤óÏòض3"�I?ÏS§�Ué�

Â�¤��"�SN½"�I?ÏSu)�"�?1?E§ qáýUçI<�«

2?1?Ö¶Ã{UYÁ1½²(L«ØÁ1½¢�þ®Ê�Á1ÜÓ§±9¥I

Page 118: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 107

<ØU�½Á1ÜÓ^�²«�Ù¦ÂÖ¶�çI<���/§�)ØUÜÓ�½

|GýG±½ÜÓd±¶çI<�ÏE¤ÜÓÁ�Ê�¶Ã{UYÁ1½²(L«

ØÁ1½¢�þ®Ê�Á1ÜÓÂÖ§±9çI<ØU�½Á1ÜÓ^�²«�Ù

¦ÂÖ"

u)���§Å����k��¦���3�½�Ï�SU�§�����J

¢²L!ã���"7��§XÑy���¯<Ã{UYÁ1½²(L«ØÁ1½

¢�þ®Ê�Á1ÜÓ�/�§,���Ï�Ù)ØÜÓ§¿Uk'{Æ5½)û

V�mÅ�ÚÅÖ"ÜÓÁ1¥§�¯<u)�Æ��ûØ���§�±J�®à

Å�®à½´�k+`��<¬{�Jå�z§?1àû½�û"Ù¥§®à´�

àªÛ§�z´ü"ª""

15!Y~µJ`IO¹·Úu�5��}

çI©�´çIÝI5K�Ö¡Ðy§3¢�¥´�rVAê"çI©�SN

à�!5K��ÚJ`IO²(§Îܽ|ø�¢SG¹´çIæ�±¤õ�

'�§�´çIæÔÑ�¦�Ny"��§çIÝI5KØ��§AO´J`I

O��ú²!ú��K½´IO¹·Ø�!��ز§4´��ü¶3c�¥Iÿ

À<�ÝI�UØ´¢�þ��` ´/ª�`§́ µI�¬µI/r/ª0í

���`§? ÚuÝI<Ý�!wG½´çI<gCS%Ø�¿òÜÓÇ�ü¶

1��¥IÿÀ<§ù�´çIæ¢�¥�4çI<ÞÛ�¯" )ûù�¯K

���{3çI©�§3çI©�¥�J`IO"e¡©Û�ù�Y~§=´Ï�

J`IOv��3çI©�úÙ§�úÙ�µIIO¥¹k�� ���5��}"

SÒ µ"Ï� ©� µ"IO

1 ÝI�d 60 0-60©

2 �ó|��O 30 0-30©

ä��?ïÓó§aïE�]��k�5þ§C

3 �8²n 10 nckaq�8�1�r�¤3/�½,«�§

10©§½Ù¦«�6©§r�Ø3½«�§0©

L5.2 µ©IOL

[Y�£�] ,½��ï�ó§è/²��8§�)5yù�S�¢ï�Â

� Ø!ä7£-!Y�£W!|/²�!ì·\�ÚUè$�B�§V�Ý

]1280��§]7�Ü5 uIk�½,�/�muúi"çI<æ^úmçI�

Page 119: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

108 çIæÛYFn

ªÀJ���óè�«ï"T�83I[�½x0þuÙçIúw§k8[�óè

�35½��mSïçI©�"çI©�5½§µI§S©�ÐÚµ"!�[

µ"Úí�¥IÿÀ<§�¤µI�w��!§æ^nܵ©{§µ"Ï�Úµ"

IO�L5.2"

T�88�ÝI<3ÝI���mc4�ÝI©�"��§çI<|�m

I§¿3mI¬ÆþúÙL5.2cü�µ"Ï��µ"IO§�L5.3"

SÒ µ"Ï� ©� µ"IO

µIÄOd=ÏLÐÚ"��ÝI�d�â²þ�,

1 ÝI�d 60 �d �Ç=(ÝI�d-µIÄOd)/µIÄOd,

ÝI�d�©=60-200×|�d �Ç|�SN��55©"�ó|��O�)çI©�¤

2 �ó|��O 30 ��8�4©¶küNïÓ¡È500m2Oè§50Å�

ó�Y�6©;��ó|��O20©"µ"`D�,16

-20©;ûÐ�,10-15©;Ü��,5-9©;ØÜ��,0-4©

L5.3 mIúÙ�µ"IO

T�8²µI�¬µ"§í��n¶¥IÿÀ<�g�ÝI<1!ÝI<2Ú

ÝI<3§ÝI�d©O�1246.00��!1181.00��Ú1268.00��"çI<��3

I[�½x0þú«µI(J"µI(Jú«�1�U§ÝI<2±T�8µIæ

^�µIIOvk�ÝI<úÙ�d§�çI<JÑÉƧ¡ÙÝI�d1181.00�

�38[ÝI<¥�$§A�ü¶1���o �1�§�¦çI<�Ñ)º"çI

<�E¡§çI©�1²µIIOÚ�{(²/ÝI�d0Ú/�ó|��O0

�µ©IO3mI�úm§¤kÝI<ÑvkédJÑÉƧ�)ÝI<2"Ó�§

µI�¬´UÝI<��©dp�$�gSí��¥IÿÀ<§ÝI<2ü¶1

�´Ï��© �1���Ï"

ÝI<2éçI<��EØ÷¿§@�T�8�3heö�§AO´çI<3m

I¬ÆþúÙ��ó|��Oµ"IO¥§ék50ÅOè§üNïÓ¡È3500m2�

ó�Y�§�6©��§²w´3ì�,�ÝI<"u´§��8¤3/1�iÒÜ

�Ý�§¿ÏL'X§ÝI<2�¦�8Ì+Ü�é7L3çI©�¥úÙ�µI

IOÚ�{�Ñ)º"TÜ�éçI©�7LúÙ�µIIOÚ�{�Ñ�)º

�µ/µIIOÚ�{��çI©�¥�­�|¤Ü©§A�3çI©�¥�ÝI<

úÙ"Ó�§çI©�¥vkúÙ�µIIOÚ�{Ø���µI��â§Ø�3

µI�¦^"�uçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{¥=¯�7LúÙ§ëì5¥u

<¬�ÚIIO�óçI©�(2007�)6��¦?�"0

Page 120: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 109

ÝI<2ò�8Ì+Ü��Ö¡)º9����8¤3/1�iÒÜ�§1

�iÒÜ�@½T�8çI©�5½�8²nr�¤3/�æ^ØÜn^���!

ü½d3ÝI<½ÝI<"Ó�§T�8µI¦^çI©�¥vkúÙ�IO§

��ú²!ú���K"@½T�8çI!µIÃ�§�¦çI<­#çI"

[¯K] �éþãY�£ã§©Û±en�¯Kµ

1.�YçI©�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ�{¥�3=¯K§mI¬ÆþúÙ�

µIIOÚ�{q�3=¯K§��oº

2.��o1�iÒÜ�@½çI<3�Yæ^ØÜn^���!ü½d3Ý

I<½ÝI<§��o1�iÒÜ�@½��8çIÝI¹Ä��ú²!ú��

�Kº

3.�YçI©�é�8²n�µ"IO¥§X��/r�¤3/�½,«�10©§

½Ù¦«�6©§r�Ø3½«�0©0��¦§U¤/ä��?ïÓó§aïE�

]��k�5þ§Cnckaq�8�1�§10©¶vkaq�8�1�§0©0§m

I¬Æþ�Ø2úÙéÝI�d!�ó|��O�µ"IO �dµI�¬µ"

´Äk¯K§qk=é&º

[Y~©Û] ��¥ÀWS�¥d�*³ú�ÀJÅWØÓ§çI<�J`IO

´Ö¡�§A��ÀÓ;�A3çI©�¥�ÝI<úm§±BÝI<k�é5/

�AÚ¿�§? ¢yæ(J"µI�¬��I§́ ^çI<3çI©�¥ú

Ù�J`IOéÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"

1.�Y¥§ÃØ´çI©�¥úÙ�§�´çI<3mI¬ÆþúÙµIIO

Ú�{Ñ��çIÝIÄ��K"Ly3µ�çI©�é�8²núÙ�µ"IO

/ä��?ïÓó§aïE�]��k�5þ§Cnckaq�8�1�r�¤3

/�½,«�10 ©§½Ù¦«�6©§r�Ø3½«�0©0¥§�8²n3ØÓ/

���©Ø��§´�«/�ÜÀ§´3/±Ñ�Ø=<0§7,��ú²!ú�

��´�K¶���¥ÀW¥§�*�±�¦s�F¥�A­<y|£�¯K|µ

ØÓ§mI¬ÆþúÙ��ó|��Oµ"IO¥§é/küNïÓ¡È500m2O

è§50Å�ó�Y�6©0��UçI�8�¦ÝI<�AÚë�¿��Ä�5K§

Ï�ù´��è/²��8��óçI§�,è/²���U3Ùþï�50ÅOè§

�ù50ÅOè��óØ3�gçI��S§́ �¦µI�¬æ^�çI�8Ã'

�^�§=/50ÅOè0éÝI?1µ"Ú'�§��çIæUçI�8�¦

ÝI<�AÚë�¿��Ä�5K"

2.½|�´�Ä��K´g�!ú²!ú�Úª¢&^"çIÝI¥�ú²�

K§�¦çI<��¤kÝI<²�Ŭ§�kÓ���|Ú�AÂÖ§Ø�A¿

Page 121: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110 çIæÛYFn

��½öA¿ü½,��½,A�d3ÝI<½ÝI<¶ú��K§�¦çI<Õ

3�*!ú#�á|þ§éÝI<ú²!��§±�æçIÝI¹Ä�¯<�Ü{

�Ã"

1�iÒÜ�@½�YçI<æ^ØÜn^���!ü½d3ÝI<½ÝI

<§3u�{1�"5çIÝI{61�l^5½§çI<Ø�±ØÜn�^���

½öü½d3ÝI<§Ø�éd3ÝI<¢1ÜÀ��"ù�¥�ØÜn^�§�

çIÝI¹Ä¥§��{nÚ¯n�^�§=��úm!ú²!ú�Úª¢&^��

K����3��ÝI<¿��^�"éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~6?�Ú²(

ØÜn^��Ô«Ly/ª§=µ�ÒÓ�çI�8�d3ÝI<½öÝI<Jø

k�O��8&E¶��½�]�!Eâ!ûÖ^��çI�8�äNA:Ú¢S

I�Ø�·A½ö�ÜÓÁ1Ã'¶��{7L?1çI��8±A½1�«�½

öA½1���1!ø���\©^�½ö¥I^�¶�éd3ÝI<½öÝI<

æ�ØÓ�]�"�½öµIIO¶��½½ö�½A½�;|!ûI!¬ý!�

�/½öøAû¶��{7L?1çI��8�{�½d3ÝI<½öÝI<�¤

k�/ª½ö|�/ª¶�±Ù¦ØÜn^���!ü½d3ÝI<½öÝI<"

�Y¥§çI©�¥úÙ�±�8²nr�¤3/�µ©5KÚçI<3mI¬Æ

þúÙ�é�ó|��Oµ"5K§é/küNïÓ¡È500m2Oè§50Å�ó�

Y�6©0§©Oáuþã1n!1�«�/§áuæ^ØÜn^���ü½d3Ý

I<½ÝI<1�"�d§1�iÒÜ��±�{@½��8çIÝI¹Ä��

ú²!ú���K§¿�â5çIÝI{¢�^~61l��^5½§=�{7L?

1çI�8�çIÝI¹Ä��çIÝI{9Ù¢�^~�5½§é¥I(JE¤

¢�5K��ØUæ�ÖÍ���±Å��§�½�YçI!ÝI!¥IÃ�§A

��{­#çI½öµI"

3.�YçI©�§XJ��/r�¤3/�½,«�§10©¶½Ù¦«�§6©¶

r�Ø3½«�0©0��¦§U¤/ä��?ïÓó§aïE�]��k�5þ§

Cnckaq�8�1�§10©¶vkaq�8�1�§0©0§mI¬Æþ�Ø2

úÙéÝI�d!�ó|��O�µ"IO ´�¦µI�¬UçI©�5½

�µIIOÚ�{§=L5.2¥éÝI�d!�ó|��Oµ©IO?1µ"§3

/ªþ¿vk¯K§=µI�¬¤�âgC�UÐÚ�äéÝI�dÚ�ó

|��Oµ©§~X§k�µ�@�T�8�óEâ{ü§éÝI�d�µ"æ^

$d`k�K§é�d�$�ÝI<2µ©�60©§éÙ¦ÝI�dUì�½'~

�~©ê¶k�µ�@�A�O�k��d�²þd§O�ÝI<��d�²þ

d� �ǧU�d �Ç��360©Ä:þ�~©ê¶�k�µ�ò�©y©

Page 122: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

15ÙçIæµçI©���¦ 111

�60©!55©!50©!45©!40©!35©!30©Ú25©§8Iû½ÝI<��d�

©±«ú²§½´µI�¬ûÆ��µ"IOéÝI�dÚ�ó|��O?1µ

©§þ�±§Ï�çI©�¥�µ"IO=�Ñ©ê��§=0-60©Ú0-30©§/

ªþÇ�µI�¬ù�µ""

�ù��5§Ã{NyçI<�J` C¤µIr/ª§��çIæÔÑ

g�§=Ú�ÝI<UìæI¦¿�¿l¥¼�ÂÃ"@o§çI<´Ä�±3

mI¬Æþ½´µIL§¥§�¦µI�¬UL5.3úÙ�µ"IOéÏLÐÚ

µ"�ÝI©�µ©Qº�,Ø�±�Ï�®LÝI���m§2úÙL5.3�µ

"IO7,Ø�¤çI©�§aqu�¥ÀWS�¥§�*®²�ÑF¥§â,

�å§A�¦¢eA­<c#315-23��m§�pØ$u1.6m��/��§áuç

I<�ÑF¥±���¥�/§¢eA­<7,ØZ§¬�¦¢þ�*����"

Ó�§d�úÙ�µ"IOQ,Ø2áuçI©�§qXÛ�¦µI�¬3µI

��lQ"

�YéçI<?�çI©��é&´§µIIOÚ�{��çI©�¥�|¤

Ü©§7L3çI©�¥úÙ"Ó�§µIIOÚ�{A�¿©NyçIæ��

¦§´UçI�8æI¦Ú½|ø�G¹?1�J`§ÙJ`��Úµ"IO!

^�.½O(§éÝI�d��*5µ"Ï�½�IØU�3#NµI�¬µI

��gdu��gdàþ¶éÌ*µ"Ï�A3µI§Sþ§�¦µI�¬éÓ

�Ï�½�I�ÝI?1î�'�§2?1µ©"7��§ëìµ"Ì*Ï��¯

~¥�;[ïƧ�¦µI�¬U½?!�Ø�µ©nÚ(½Ì*µ"Ï���

©§±4�/u�µI�¬8Nûü�;�`³"

Page 123: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 6Ù

çIæµçI©��?�

**********************************************************************

UØó o�1§/Ø� zÔ)"

— /.ox5þS²��¤Ö6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 124: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 113

11!«�µIOçI©�

çI©�§��çIÝI5K�Ö¡1N§́ çIæÔÑ��¦�8¥Ny"

@o§�âçI�8A:ÚI�?�çI©�§Ò¤|�çIÝI¥��­�¯

�§Ù«ú�I?Ì�Ny3§�´÷vÔÑÙÛÚ)�²EI�¶�´÷væ

I¦¶n´Îܽ|ø�¢SG¹"ù�¥§çI©�Q�NyçIÝI5KÚæ

�J`§q�ÎÜ¢S§�ØU��ú²!ú��Ä��K§ØUæ^u�^±!

ÜÀ5^±½´��½|�´�K§r��¦ÝI<½¥I<�l"�d§?�ç

I©�´çIæ¥��U½|�´5K�ÝI<Æ�!J`§5½µI�¬é

ÝI©�µ"Ú'�5K�XÚó�"

¢�¥§ØÓ1��âõc�çIæ¢�²�o(!Jõ§|��S;�<

?��açI©�«�©�"I[uÐU��¬Óó�Ú&EzÜ!4�¢�

ï�Ü!�Ï$ÑÜ!Y|Ü!ûÖÜ!I[#ªÑ�2>oÛ!I[c´Û!¥I

¬^Ê�Û�Ü�éÜ?�¿�Ù�k�½r�5�§�éó§ï��8¥�t

!�O!�ó!inÚ­���!á�æ�IOçI©�§5�ó§ï��8

çI©��?�"d§ã�Ü|�?��?æÀÔÚÑÖçI©�«�©�

�§�çI<?�çI©�JøB|"

ùp§I�rN�§çI©�´U�8A:ÚI�?��§äk/��8�?

�0A:§Ï�çIÝI�¿�´�5z�É�¿�§ �açI©�«�©�§�

)I[uÐU��¬ÓÙ¦Ü�?��IOçI©�!1�Ì+Ü��u�IOç

I©�½«�©�§Ñ´1�½´,�açI�8�5�Jõ§�Ø´çI©�"

�d§çI<I3O(n)IOçI©�½«�©�SNÄ:þ§U�8A:ÚI

�?�çI©� ØU_8�1½´ì�ì�S.5�{"��¥ÀW¥��*�

ÑF¥�����aq§e¡ùKIf�´é¯�_%�¯§́ é�(¦^�ª�

���éÐ��º§=«�©��Ñ�´çI©��5§çI©�7LçI�8A

:ÚI¦?�"

[�´^���¯] ,�/�úiu�oàÜ¡r§�Æ.���õc§��3

�/�+��©§l���È<§�Ú�Úr��/�úioà§ý�¢¯�k

¤§�dLA��·"�õca¯�§®²43�%�,�Õ��"ÃG�e§�U

âuÛ�§é5�ú¿�©��o§4¨�aåú��´é¯§éA[x0r��

Page 125: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114 çIæÛYFn

e§wUÄé�%¥�å "Üo�¦�o§�´é¯���k©æ§�UÐy¯

�k¤/}��PÊ0�`³"

�U�§�oU�´�ªåúÐ�´é¯"Ù¥§�¦�A´^��µ�mZ§

�á¢^§�#38�±e§�p158m-165m§a¬±þÆ{§¬Ø[LFf§!é`

ä!ÃØûµÐ�å¬��"Üow��©÷¿§�U± ç­ó�²�§Û�

ú��´k=�:Øþ§Ø�%§�2ék²��<rr'§��®ò>3[�

ç­²�´L�<¯ÜPÌ?"

Üoheé�PÌ?[p"»~�`µ/Øпg§s´wX·¤��§�·w

w·��´é¯§ddÚ"·Ò�&s�©)"0PÌ?í`Xµ/®²éЧ·�

vUå2U"0Üo��`µ/Ø^^J§\~�ç­é¯§kA�c²�§rL�

x'·r�´�õ"0�G§PÌ?Øcøú§a�þPsº§@ýwAH�o�

��´é¯§üVqüV§�q�"íØ/�á¢^0§¿U<¯ç­.~§3A

´^�"�^Á)\þ�é/knc±þ²�ö`k04��Üoµ/·Òù:Y²

"0Üo`µ/\�¯·�%"0

1�U��ú¿§Üo���oµ/���§u�À½�A[�´x0§8UÒ

�þ�§²U��"0�oUÜo�§Q§?U�u��´x0r1"�Eé¯3�

SDm§}��PÊÜ¡r�´�ëYAF§<����{s!�Ñ´Ü¡r§

Ø=´Ü¡r3�/�.XÛ¤õ!XÛ`D!XÛka§�´7�¦ÀJnc±

þ´Ó¤�<"�,§�k<@�¦ù��¦ØÎÜ~n§~¦¦k%�1�½´

)n"�"k�U§¦�� Ðl5�§é¦��´�Þ�¡§ø§é¦knc±

þ´¤`k��{JѦ¯§¦â2ק4�oÏ�¤kx0§r/knc±þ²

�ö`k0�é��"�d�§c5A´�§1´4�á�§�o�P3þ�Ò®

k360<�õ§Ñ´(´Ôlc�l´�"

�¯�(�4<u�"��Ø��u¯§́ �o�Ï��ù����´(ÛQº

�,´PÌ?/Ü)o�0�@é/knc±þ²�ö`k0Ú�¯<Ü¡r�Ã

�§=Ö¡©iL�¹Â�ý¢J¦�Ø��"�´��¯¥§Ü¡r��±Ø�

c5A´�å¬�¡§½´�¡�¡vwþ!vkú� ª��´§¿3�ã�m

�2guÑ�´é¯ ÃI«úI?§çIÝI���«Ö¡5��ª§KØ#N

çI<ògª�çI§Ø�´ÑyØ�|å"ÄK§çI<I�«ú��ï

]�ý"©�!çI©��d3ÝI<�²L��"=B´ÑyØ�|å§çI<

3uÙçIúw!uÑÝI��Ö�½öuÑ]�ý"©�!çI©��ª�çI

�§�A9�uÙúw§½ö±Ö¡/ªÏ�����½ö®²¼�]�ý"©�!

çI©��d3ÝI<§ò�¤Â��]�ý"©�!çI©�¤^Ú¤Â��Ý

Page 126: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 115

I�y7�7±9Ù3Õ1��±Â\"�d§çIÝI�î�5��pu)¹¥

��´é¯"

@o§çI©�«�©�§�)I[uÐU��¬ÓÙ¦1�Ì+Ü�|�?

��ó§t!�O!in!�óÚ­���!á��IOçI©�k=§Ù¥

q5�=¯�§çI<|�?�çI©�qA5¿=¯KQº́ Ä�±ÆS

�¯¥�PÌ?Ø+æI¦A: ³/± ²�V\/knc±þ²�ö`k0

Qº·�<��5¥u<¬�ÚIIO�óçI©�£2007�¤6Ú5¥u<¬�Ú

IIO�óçI]�ý"©�£2007�¤69Ù�@¦^�H�Ì�?�;[§éI

OçI©�?�9ÙA^�kN¬§3ISù)IOçI©���2rN§IOç

I©�´�çI<?�çI©�Jø��58B§çI<I�UçI�8A:Ú�

¦§3�5Ä:þ?�çI©�"

1.IOçI©�"IOçI©�´I[uÐU��¬Óó�Ú&EzÜ!4�

¢�ï�Ü!�Ï$ÑÜ!Y|Ü!ûÖÜ!I[#ªÑ�2>oÛ!I[c´Û!

¥I¬^Ê�Û�Ü�§�é5çIÝI{61n^5½��{7L?1çI��

8aO§=ó§ï��8�t!�O!in!�óÚ­���!á��æ éÜ

?��§�3JõÓ�a�8çI©��5§�3¦^þ�k�½r�5�çI©

�IO©�"���2017c12�§ISó§ï��8�IOçI©�NX©�ï�

®²ÐÚ�¤§k��Ùµ

£1¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIO�óçI]�ý"©�£2007c¤6Ú5¥u<¬�

ÚIIO�óçI©�£2007c¤6¶

£2¤5¥u<¬�ÚI{²IO�óçI©�£2012c¤6¶

£3¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIO�O�óo«�çI©�£2012c¤6¶

£4¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIOtçI©�£2017c¤6¶

£5¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIO�OçI©�£2017c¤6¶

£6¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIOinçI©�£2017c¤6¶

£7¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIO��çI©�£2017c¤6¶

£8¤5¥u<¬�ÚIIOá�çI©�£2017c¤6"

Ù¥§14-8�IOçI©�§́ 35¥u<¬�ÚIIO�óçI©�£2007c¤6

Ù!!̂ 8Ä:þ§(ÜçIÝI�#�ü{5ÚI�aOÚ;�A:?�§OV

5çIÝI{¢�^~6Ú>fçIÝI�k'�¦§é�{5�çI©�?�§

u�çIÝIÅ�3�oI[|Ã!�¬ú�|ÃÚçIÝI¹Ä�¯<�Ü{�

Ã!Jp²L�Ã!�y�8�þkXØ��«��^"

ù�¥§�óIOçI©�k�@�]�ý"©�§t!�O!inÚ­��

Page 127: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116 çIæÛYFn

�!á�æIOçI©�¥�]�ý"©�6""Ó�§I[uÐU��u2008c

|�?�5¥u<¬�ÚI2007�IO�óçI]�ý"©�¦^�H6Ú5¥

u<¬�ÚI2007�IO�óçI©�¦^�H6§Ù¦;�IOçI©��¦^

�H6""

2.IOçI©�)û=¯K"IOçI©��Ø%3uJõÓ�a�8ç

I©��5§�éçI�8;�A�5�çI©��?�§±÷vçIÝI{Æ5

½Ú�¦"Ù¥§�óIOçI©�Ú{²�óIOçI©�lÙ§�O�óo«

�I5çI©�ÔÙ§t!�O!in!��Úá�æIOçI©�8Ù§©O

�¹±eSN:

£1¤çIúw½ÝI��Ö"çIúw½ÝI��Ö�{A1²çI<�¶¡

Ú/�!çI�8�5�!êþ!¢�/:Ú�m±9¼�çI©���{�¯�"

IOçI©��ÑçIúw9ÝI��ÖSN�ª�¦§�)çI^�!�8V¹

�çI��!ÝI<]��¦!́ Ä�ÉéÜNÝI!�OçI�¥IÖ�!çI

©�¼��m!/:!�{!ÝI©�4����m!/:§±9´Ä|�>fçI

ÝI!uÙúwx0!��çI(@ÚéX�ª��ª^±"

£2¤ÝI<L�"ÝI<L�§́ ÝI<�AçI!ë�ÝI¿�7L���

çIÝI5KÚ�¦"IOçI©�òçI�8V¹!çI��!çI�8]75

Úá¢�¹!Á�Ï�!�þIO!ÝI<]�^�!çI©�|¤!ÝI©�|

¤!ÝI�d!ÝIk�Ï9ÝI�y7!]�"�!ÝI©�?�!ÝI©��µ

�4�!mI�mÚ/:!µI�¬9µI!ÜÓÇ�L§9�¦!�a�¯<

VÆ�å!́ Äæ^>fçIÝI�§±9çI<Ö¿�Ù¦¯���ªz§��

ÝI<L���ªSN"

£3¤µI�{"µI�{§=µIIOÚ�{"IOçI©�©O�ÑnÜ

µ�{Ú²µ"��$ÝId{§±øçI<ÀJ§Ù¥§5½/ªµ"!]�

µ"Ú�A5µ"�ÐÚµ"IO!�[µ"IO!µI§S!µI(J�¯�9

�ª�¦"

£4¤EâIOÚ�¦"éuEâIOÚ�¦§ó§t!�O!�ó!inÚ

��!á�IOçI©�æ^ØÓ��{Ú�ª�¦µ

1¤tIOçI©��¦²(t·^IO!5�!5§§¤J©��¦!u

�<Jø���!��!]�9ò�§u�<Jø�)¹!�Ï!ÏÕ�B|^�!

t<g�ó�^��¯�"

2¤�OIOçI©��¦²(�OIO!5�!5§§¤J©��¦!u�<

Jø���!��!]�9ò�§u�<Jø�)¹!�Ï!ÏÕ�B|^�!�O

Page 128: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 117

<g�ó�^��¯�"

3¤inIOçI©��¦²(inIO!5�!5§§¤J©��¦!�÷<

Jø���!��!]�9ò�§�÷<Jø�)¹!�Ï!ÏÕ�B|^�!in

<g�ó�^�¯�"

4¤�óIOçI©��¦²(ã�8¹!ã�§±9çI<�â�8A:ÚI

�§�¦�l�I[IO!5�!5§�¯�"

5¤��!á�IOçI©��¦²(��!á�I¦�AL!Eâ5U�I!

u��Ø�¦!�þIO!�ÂIO!EâÑÖÚ��ÏÑÖ�¦�¯�"

£5¤ÜÓ^�"IOçI©�æ^Ï^ÜÓ^±!;^ÜÓ^±!ÜÓ�ÆÖ

9�¦²(ÜÓ^�"Ù¥§Ï^ÜÓ^±Uìt!�O!in!�ó!��Ú

á�Á�?1�5Jõ§²(Á����¦§�;^ÜÓ^±´�x§I�çI<

UçI�8A:ÚI�²(;^ÜÓ^±§�Ï^ÜÓ^±�¤�°���ÜÓ^

�"IOçI©�ÜÓ^�þNkÁ��y7£Õ1�¼¤�ª§Ù¥�óIOç

I©��NkýG±Õ1�¼�ª§Ó�²(ó§þ�ü£I�¤SN9�ª�

¦§�)ó§þ�ü`²!ÝI�d`²!ó§þ�üL!OFóLÚá�!��!

;�ó§6�dL�"

£6¤ÝI©��ª"IOçI©��ѱ/ÝI¼0�Ä�ÝI©��ª9

SN�¦§�)ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹!{½�L<�°y²½Ç��÷Ö!éÜN

�ÆÖ!ÝI�y7!Id½¤^�d�ü!]�"�]�§XÝI<Ä��¹L!

CcãÖG¹L!Cc�¤�aq�8�¹L!�3?1Ú#«���8�¹L!

Ccu)��z9®à�¹�!ûÖÚEâ �L!Á�|�Oy§Xtj�!

�O�Y!in�j!�ó|��O!�8+nÅ�§±9ÝI<L�cNL5½

�Ù¦]���ª�¦§±�BÝI<?�ÝI©�"ù�¥§=�ª½´=

Ü Ø#NÝI<UĽN�dçI<?�çI©�²("

3.N�¦^IOçI©�"IOçI©�3¦^þ�k�½r�5§5çIÝ

I{¢�^~61�Ê^5½§�{7L?1çI�8�çI©�Ú]�ý"©�§

A�¦^IÖ�uÐU�Ü�¬ÓÙ¦k'1�iÒÜ��½�IO©�"âd§

I[uÐU���Ù�IOçI©�¦^Ï�¥§²(�¦IOçI©�¥�/Ý

I<L�0£ÝI<L�cNLÚÙ¦NLؤ!/µI�{0£µI�{cNLØ

¤Ú/Ï^ÜÓ^±0§3¦^þA�Ø\?U/Ú^¶IOçI©�Ù¦SN§

��5�Ú�§øçI<?�çI©�ë�§Ør�"

�d§çI<3IOçI©��5Jõ�Ä:þ§I�(ÜçI�8A:Úæ

I¦§?�Ú²(ÝI<L�!µI�{ÚÏ^ÜÓ^±�©±�SN§²(

Page 129: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

118 çIæÛYFn

çI©�Ù¦Ù!�SN"Ù¥§IOçI©�¥�ÝI<L�§¢Sþ´çIÝ

I{Æ3Ù�å��8þ�çIÝI5KÐy§µI�{´çIÝI{éµI5½

�5K[z§Ï^ÜÓ^±/�ISþ�¤Ù�ÜÓ^�§X=Iè7ó§��

¬�FidicÜÓ^��§(ÜIS{Æ{5N�ÚÖ¿�õ§��kÙ·^��"~

X§5¥u<¬�ÚIIO�óçI©�£2007 c¤6·^u�.ó§ï��8��

óçI§éuï�óÏØ�L12��!Eâ�é{ü��.�ó�8çI§Aæ^

5¥u<¬�ÚI{²IO�óçI©�£2012c¤6?�ÙçI©�"aq/§5¥

u<¬�ÚIIO��çI©�£2017c¤6·^�.¤@��çI§¥�.��æ

§I�éÏ^ÜÓ^±¥�þ^±·�{z½?Uâ·^"�´Ï�ù��ϧI

[uÐU��3�ÙIO©�¦^Ï�¥§²(w�çI<��âçI�8�äN

A:Ú¢SI�§3;^ÜÓ^±¥éIOçI©�¥�Ï^ÜÓ^±?1Ö¿!

[zÚ?U§�Ø���{Æ!1�{5�r�55½§±9²�!g�!ú²Úª

¢&^��´�K§=½|�´.�"

12!ÜݵçIÝI¹ÄOy�Sü

çIæ´½|²L¥��«�*²L¹Ä§́ ½|ÌNm��´§lØm¹

Ä5K�üy�½|ÌN�ë�"IOçI©�¥§/ÝI<L�0®UçIÝI{

9�8;�A�éçIÝI¹Ä��5?1Jõ§éuçIÝI¹Ä¥�,��

!½¯��o�m!3�o/:Ú|�=<ë�§̂ �´�o�¯�´çIÝI

¹Ä¥��5§I�çI<UçI�8A:ÚI�?1ÚÊOy�Sü"5¿§ç

IÝI´��kXî�§SL§�¹Ä§ùaquPQ©�/n��0§=�m!/

:!<Ô£�§±9çIÝI¹Äë��^�"e¡ùKJó�_%�¯§=´J

ó^�ØO(�¦>M|Ñ�����(J"

[>MJó��¯] k�K>MJW�_%�{§̀ k� åf5��[´Ó0

�¤§ó�<í�>MJó§̀ ��rIOÚé�^�Ñ\�>M§>M¬gÄ

�¨ÀJ§�±;�^�ØÜ·����"ù åfÁÁ§3>MþÑ\^�/�

R!�k�0"����¦¨§>M�Ñ�|Ï(J /́�Ú0"åfØÑ|Ñ�(

J§UC^�Ñ\/�k¤���f!�kéõa0§��¦�>M2gw«|Ï(

J/Õ10"åfØ�"§�X�U´Ï�Ñ\�^�´Ô�§v�é<��ϧ2

gÑ\/���¤!�kS�a0§>Mé¯w«|Ñ(J/cAù0"åf%�§�

U´gC�¦^���¤�"u´§û½rfâ¤k�Jó^��åÑ\>M/�

R!k�!k¤���f!kéõa!��¤§�kS�a0">M�%�¬�§w

Page 130: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 119

«(J/cAù3Õ1pe�Ú0"

ùK_%�¯�À�§́ >MeXX/UJó^�3ê⥥|¢ �,Ø�

9´Ó±a��Ä:§ÙÀJ(J��o�ØX�¥ÀWQº�¥ÀW¥��*´

wX¢eA­<§³/��¨�½´ú� �Ñ�F¥"�dØÓ§>MJó´U

Jó�Ö¡^�Ú¥�?1gÄçÀ§�Jó^��O(�Ä��K�çÀ(J"

�¯¥§åfÑ\�Jó^�/�R!k�!k¤���f!kéõa!��¤§�

kS�a0¢K´¹·�§ù�´��>M|Ñ��(J/cAù3Õ1pe�Ú0

��Ï"ùK�¯éçIæ�é«3u§çI<I�UçI�8A:ÚI¦§O

(.½çIÝI§Só���5z^�§X�m!/:Ú<Ô§¿(ÜçI©�«

�©��5�Ä:þ§3çI©�¥w�d3ÝI<"

1.çI��"çI��´çI<éçI�8���.½§́ çI�8���!

A�£ã!EâIOÚ�¦�Ö¡Lã§��A3çI©�1²�æ�ü½æ

I¦¥(½§��Ö13ÙçIæµI¦�(½"5¿§çI��Ny3çI©�

¥§�´ÝI<L�¥�/çI��0§�´æI¦¥�/æ�üL0½æ¯

��.½§�ö3©i�xÚæ�üþþI�Ú�§n)Ú��.½þ��"~

X§,ó§�ó�8çI©�1²�çI���/ÓçI©�1ÊÙó§þ�ü1

²�ó§��§�18Ùã�Ú1ÔÙEâIOÚ�¦�@n)0"

2.�þIO"UI[!1��Ù�IO!5�Ú5§§(½çI�8��þ�

?½�ÂIO¶I[!1��Ù�IO!5�Ú5§þvkçI�8��þ�?½

�ÂIO�§�1/��Ù�IO!5�!5§½�{§(½çI�8��þ�?

½�ÂIO¶I[!1�½/��Ù�IO!5�!5§Ú�{þÑvkçI�8

��þ�?½�ÂIO�§çI<3½|N�Ä:þ§UæI¦Ú½|ø�G¹

(½çI�8�þ�?½�ÂIO"~X§,��çI©�1²��þIO�/Ü

�§ÎÜ1ÊÙøÀ�¦Eâ5U�Ø�IÚ�¦0"

3.Á�Ï�"Á�Ï�§�çI�8m©Ú�¤�Ï�"çI©�¥kü«�

{(½Á�Ï�§�´�ÑçI�8�m©!�¤�m¶�´�ÑçI�8m©�

mÚÏ��¦"çI©�1²�Á�Ï�AÜn§Ï�ØÓ�çI�8I�ØÓ�

Á�Ï�"~X§ØÓ�ó§ï��8¤I��~�óÏØÓ§3± ���Ù�

5ï�ó§óϽ�6¥½´��ó|��OÃþþ�±��¶ØÓÀÔ�~�

\ó�E±ÏÚÔ6Ï�§ÏL½|N��±¼�"ùpI�5¿�¯K�§Á�

Ï�ÚçI�8��þIOm�3gñ"Á�Ï�Lá§7,��¥I<\�\:

�¤�8Á�§�½§Ýþ¬K�æ�8�þ§Ï��8I�/°H[T0 /ú

óÑ[¹0"Ó�§Á�Ï�L�7,K�¦^§Ã{u�ÙQ½�õ^"�d§ç

Page 131: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

120 çIæÛYFn

I<I�UçI�8A:ÚI¦§�NÁ�Ï���þIOm�'X§±��d�

*"ÑÖÏ���UÑÖI¦¤I�m�á(½"~X§ó§in�ÑÖÏ���

´�8óÏ\þ"�I?ϧ,inçI©�þ1²/inÑÖÏ�µ28��0�"

4.ÝI]�"çI©�1²�]�^�§� 5́½|O\K¡�ü6¥�¦�§

7Lä�½|O\^�âU²E�^�¶�´çI<�â�8A:ÚI�(½�]

�^�§�)¬¯ÌN/ !½|O\]�!Á�Uå!aq�8�1!Á�&�Ú

Ù¦�¦�"IOçI©�¥§ÝI<L��©¥®²²(éÜNÝI!{Æ{

55½�ÝI]�^�"�d§çI<=IU�8A:ÚI�§ëì14ÙçIæ

Á�Uå�"�§²(]�"��Ï�!IOÚ^�"7��§�Ñ]�"�Ï�!

IOÚ^��AL§XL4.1"

|�]�ý"�§çI<AuÙ]�ý"úw§3]�ý"úwþ1²�m©

Ú(å�muÈ]�ý"©�§��Ø�u5F§±¦d3ÝI<k¿©��m

ï½+^]�ý"©�§?�¿J�]���©�"çI<U]�ý"©�5½�

]�"�IOÚ�{§éd3ÝI<4��]���©�?1"�§J`(½ÝI

<¶ü§�ÙuÑÝI��Ö"7��§çI<��±ëìµI�¬§|ï]�

"��¬éd3ÝI<4��]���©�?1"�"

5.çI©�uÈ"çI©�I²(çI©�uÈ�m©!(å�m!uÈ/:

ÚuÈ^�§3çIúw½ÝI��Ö¥1²§çI<UçIúw1²��m!/

:Ú^�uÈçI©�"çI©��uÈÏ��Ø�u5F§3çIúw1²�m©

�muÈçI©�§ÙuÈ(å���±3ÝI���mc5½�,�A½�m§

~XÝI���mc3 Fª�§±�yd3ÝI<k¿©��mï½+^çI©

�ÝI"d3ÝI<´{<½öÙ¦|��§A�¦Ù±ü 0�&±y²Ù´{

<½öÙ¦|�¶́ g,<�§±�°y½Ù¦�°y²©�ï"

6. ty|ÚÝIý�¬" ty|ÚÝIý�¬§éçI<ÚÝI<ÑØ´

r�5K§çI<�±|�§��±Ø|�§=BçI<|� ty|½ÝIý�

¬§ÝI<�±ë\§��±Øë\§'�3uçI<�äÝI´ÄI�|�"ù

p§ ty|�8�§3u4ÝI<�G�8y|Á�^�§=�8±>�¸!�

Ï!ø>!øY!øí!/þ/eæNÔ§±9~cíÿ�§±¦Ùk�é5��

½�8Á�Oy¶ÝIý�¬�8�§3u±¡é¡��ª§ÒÝI<éçI©�

,¯�½^±JÑ�¦¯?1)º½`²§±¦ÝI<�(n)çI©�"7�

�§çI<éçI©��ÑÖ¡©�½?U"

��/§XJ�8Á��y|^�k'§X�ó½øÀ/:�ó§S�§ÒA

�|�ÝI< t�8y|"ÝIý�¬´Äðm§�´wçI©�5½�çIÝ

Page 132: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 121

I5K´Ä��!Lã´ÄO(!́ ÄI�?�Ú`²½N�§�´wÝI<éç

I©�5½�çIÝI5K´Än)§́ ÄJѦ¯§½´é�8y|ÚçI<

Jø�Ù¦Á�^�k¦¯§I�çI<¡é¡/�±)�½©�"

|�ÝI< t�8y|�§çI<A�3çI©�¥²( t�8y|��

m"�8¤3/ u¢½�§A?�Ú²(¢½S�8Ü�mÚ/:§±9c

ty|��Ï�ª�¯�¶|�ÝIý�¬�§çI<A�3çI©�¥²(Ý

Iý�¬ðm��mÚ/:"7��§w�ÝI<?\ÝIý�¬/:¤I�y�

½ÃY§±BÝI<��Lë\"

7.çI©��©�Ú?U"çI©��©�§́ çI<AÝI<�¦§�3Ò

ÝI<éçI©�,¯�½^±�Øn)§?�Ú�)º½`²�©�§́ �«

�Ä1�¶çI©��?U§́ çI<3uÑçI©��uyçI©��,¯�

½^±I�N�½?U�âU¢yæm� uÑ�©�§́ �«ÌÄ1�"��

/§çI©��©�½?U´3ÝIý�¬ðm�§ÝI���mc��½�mu

ѧ±ØK�ÝI<?�ÝI©��O"~X§ISé�{7L?1çI��85

½§çI<é®uÑ�çI©�?17��©�½ö?U�§A�3çI©��¦

J�ÝI©����m��15Fc§±Ö¡/ªÏ�¤kçI©�ÂÉ<§¿²(

d�©�½ö?U�SN�çI©��|¤Ü©"

5¿§çI<3uÑçI©��©�Ú?Uc§I�|�k';�<éÝI

<�¦¯�±�ä§?1©�!`²½?U§I��½�O��m"éd§ççI

©�¥§©O²(ÝI<éçI©�ÚÁ�^�JѯK����mÚçI<uÑ

çI©��©�Ú?U��m"��/§çI<uÑçI©��©�Ú?U��m

A�3ÝI<JѯK����m���½�m§X3F§Ó�÷vçIÝI{�

r�55K§Xé�{7L?1çI��8§�´3ÝI���mc15FuÑ��

¦"~X§,�{7LçI�8�çI©�§5½ÝI<4�ÝI©�����m

�2020c5�31F§�¦ÝI<JѯK����m�2020c5�12F§1²çI©

��©�Ú?U�uÑ�m�2020c5�15F§=÷vù��¦"

8.©�" ��çI�8´Ä#N¥I<¥I�©��¦<�¤�ûuçI�

8��§I�çI<3éaq�8Á�N��Ä:þ(½"5¿§çI�8ÌNÚ

'�5ó�Ø#N©�§Ï�¥I<éçI�8ÌN½'�5ó��©�§áu�

«¯¢þ�=�1�§3æ½ó§ï��{Æ{5¥þéÙ�±B�"Ó�§é

çI�8��ÌN!�'�5ó�§={ÆØB�©���/e´#N�´Ø#N

¥I<©�§dçI<û½"�d§çI<I(ÜÁ��A:§±¢yæJ`�

m�(½´Ä#N¥I<é�ÌN!�'�5ó�?1©�"Ó¿©��§çI©

Page 133: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

122 çIæÛYFn

�¥A?�Ú²(=�ÌN!�'�5ó�#N©�§²(N�©��7���

Ú�É©��1n<]�ÚØ�2g©���¦§Ï�¥I<Ò©��8�çI<

«úI?§©�<ÒÙ«ú��8«úë�I?"~X§,C»ó§�óçI5½

/ØNÖ§Ø�©�0§,ó§�óçI5½�N�©��8�/è�m�!�Y

ó§!C»ó§ÚNÖ0§�¦3ÝI©�¥1²"

9. l" l§�ÝI©�éæI¦¥�Ï�½�I� �§~�uÀÔæ

Úó§�óçI"5¿§ÝI©�éçI©�Ø#N l�Ï�½�I l�§

ò�À���AÝI �Äû"Ó�§ÝI©�éæI¦Ï�½�I� l§�

U3çI©�N����ÚÌÝSâk�"�d§çI©�AÄuéçI�8õ^

Ú¿�üy�Ä:þ§��N� l�Ï�½�I��ÚÌÝ"Ó�§3µI�{

¥�éü  l�éçI�8�K�§(½Ùd�ò�½©êò��§±¢yæ

J`"~X§,ó§�óçI©�^²µ"��$ÝId{µI§éó§?ݱN

��?ݱ l���75% ≤��¤�≤ 85%§�Ñ.��Ø��É"Ó�§5½

3�?ÝG±80%Ä:þ§z����¤�1%�§3ÙÝI�dÄ:þN~4��§

zõ���¤�1%�§NO8��§Øv1%�U1% O"aq/§,ó§�óçI©

�^²nܵ©{µI§éþã?ݱ l�Ñ�µ©IO�/3�?ÝG±80%

Ä:þ§z����¤�1%�§�1©§�p5©§zõ���¤�1%�§�1©§�

p�5©§Øv1%�U1%O0"

10.ÝIk�Ï!ÝI�y7ÚÁ�ú�"ÝIk�Ï´ÝI���m�ÙÝ

I±Yk��Ï�§(�çI<3ÝIk�ÏS�¥I<\¾ÜÓ"��/§ÝI

k�ϱ30F�ü 4O§X60F!90F!120F�¶ÝI�y7§́ ÝI<éÙ4

��ÝI&Å«ì§Ø3k�ÏS��ÝI�Ñ��y¶Á�ú�§́ ÝI<¥I

�UçI©��¦4���3éÙÁ��Ñ��y"

ÝI�y7I²(ÝI<J��ÝIú�¯�!�y/ªÚ7�"IS.~�

¦�ú��Ý��Ø$uÜÓ��d�2%¶ISçI§ÝI�y73�Ýþ��Ø

�LçI�8��d�2%"Ó�§éó§ï��8¥�t!�O!�óÚ­��

�!á��æ���pþ�§=t!�OçIÝI�y7�pØ��L10�

�¶�óÚÀÔçIÝI�y7�pØ��L80��"ÝIú�/ªþ§IS.~

��æ^Õ1�¼�ªJ�¶ISçI§ó§ï��8ÝIú�/ª�)y7!Õ

1�¼!�ç|¦!Õ1®¦½y7|¦�¶�?æÀÔ�ÑÖçI§ÝIú�

/ª�|¦!®¦!�¦½ö7KÅ�!ú�Å�Ñä��¼��y7/ª"

Á�ú�3/ªþ§��æ^Õ1�¼½ú�Å��Ñú�"ê�þ§­.Õ

1�±�8�¦ú���ÜÓd�10%§ISçI�8§5½Á�ú�Ø��L¥

Page 134: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 123

IÜÓ7��10%"

11.ÝI©�?�"éÝI©��ÑÑ�ª!�<!\i½XÙ!©þ!C¾!

µC!B�°ê±9µ@þA�²�SNJÑ�¦"��/§±÷vµ"Ú'��

�KéÝI©�JÑ�¦"~X§,çI©��¦/��!B�æ^�C�ª©m

C¾§µ¡þ\X��½B�i�0"Ó�§�¦/3µ@�µ�?\bµ^§\X

ÝI<ü Ù"µ@þ�²çI<¶¡!çI�8¶¡!4�/�ÚÝI©�3Ý

I���mcØ�mé�i�0�"

12.ÝI���mÚ/:"ÝI���m´çIÝI5K¥�éuçIm©�

m���­���m§́ çIÝI5K¥§¢�5^�Ú�¦Ø2#NN�½?U

3�mþ�©Y*"ISþ§ÝI���m±�8¤3/�m�O¶ISçI��

±�®�m�O§²(�,c,�,F,�,©,¦§±O(�äÝI<4�ÝI

©�´3���mc4�§û½´ÄÉnÝI©�"~X§,çI©�5½�ÝI

���m�/2020c8�25FþÌ10:30©00¦£�®�m¤0"

çI©�uÑ�§(½õ��m�±ÝI����â3uçI�8ÝIE,§

ݧ=ÝI<?�ÝI©�¤I�Ün�m"��/§ÝI©�?�ó�þ���

8ÝI�m�±�é á§?�ó�þ���8I�ÝI<v��m?�ÝI©

�§ÙÝI�âäk�¢y5"��5¿�´§ISéu�{7L?1çI��8§

{Æ5½�lçI©�m©uÈ�Få�ÝI���F�§�áØ��u20F��

¦§́ �{7L?1çI�8¤IÝIÏ���$�§�ýØ´(½ÝIÏ���

�ºÝ§Ï�ÝIÏ�IÑÖuÝI�þ"ù´çI<(½ÝIÏ�ÚÝI���

mA��Ì���5K§é@EâE,!;�5r½´Øy!̀ z¤I�m��

çI�8§A�D�ÝI<¿v�ÝI©�?��m"~X§éA?ïÓó§��

OçI§ÝIÏ��±345F±þ¶�?9±e�ÝIÏ��±330F±þ�"

13.mI"3mIþ§çI<kn�¯�I�3çI©�¥²(§=µ�mI

�mÚ/:¶�mI§S¶�mIë�<9^�"Ù¥§ÝI����mÓ�´m

Im©��m§÷vÝI��3ÝI���m±�)�ù�ÜÓ¾á5ƧmI/

:I3çI©�¥1²¶mI§S3çI©�«�©�§XI[uÐU��¬ÓI

Ö�k'Ü��u�IOçI©�þþkmI§S5½"çI<I�²(�Ì�k

ü�¯�§�´²(mI�éÝI©��µ�¹�u�<§́ ÝI<½öÝI<�

L§�´çI<�÷�úyÅ�"¢�¥§~^�´ÝI<�Lu�¶�´ÝI©

�mé�k�gS"��UçI©�4��k�gS!_gS½ö�ÅÄ�ÝI©

�mégSþ�"

mIë�<§���)̱<!�I<!iI<!P¹<ÚÝI<�L"Ù¥§

Page 135: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

124 çIæÛYFn

ÝI<�Lë�mI¹Ä§́ émIL§��y§Ù«ú�Ì��I§�´�GÙ

¦ÝI<�ÝI§=���¶�´iÒçI<|�mIÎÜ{Æ5½"ÝI<�L

ë�mI§A´ÝI<�ü KI<½±kü KI<�k�Ç�Ú�°y²§±

�LÝI<3mIÁ1Ù�I"

14.µI"µI�9ü�¯�§=µI�¬|ïÚµI�{"Ù¥§µIL§

dµI�¬KI§¿ØéÝI<úm"��/§µI�KÚN�µI3«�©�

�/ÝI<L�0Ú/µI�{0�Ù�©úÙ"çI©�I?�ÚUçI�8A:

ÚI¦²(¿w�ÝI<�¯�§�´µI�¬|ï§�´J`IO"Ù¥§J

`IO3e�!?Ø"'uµI�¬�|ï§çI<I�â5µI;[;�©a

IO6ÚçI�8µI¤I�;�!ó�þ(½;[�;�Ú<꧲(;[5 "

~X§,¥%�ú¢ó§�óo«�çI§µI�9ïÓ(�!C»C?!>í!�

üY!Ϻ�NÚEd�;�§T�8çI©�1²�µI�¬�¤�/µI�

¬d7<�¤"Ù¥§çI<�L2 <§Eâ!²L;[5<§dèïó§1<!>

íó§1<!�üY1 <!Ϻ�N1<ÚEd1<|¤§;[dçI<3½nܵI

;[¥æ^�ÅÄ���ª(½0"

15.µI(Jú«"µI(Jú«Ì�^u�{7L?1çI��8§ú«µ

I�¬í��¥IÿÀ<ÝIk'�¹§�ÉiÒ"��/§çI<A3uÙç

Iúw�Ó�x0ú«µI(J§�)¥IÿÀ<üS!¶¡!ÝI�d!�þ!Á

�Ï�!½|O\]�!�8KI<9ÙyÖ§±9JÑÉÆ��{�¯�§3ç

I©�¥1²µI(J�ú«x0§Ï�Ø�u3F"

5¿§é�9I[S�!I[�� æ���çI��8Ø�3ú¯x0þú

«"é�{�±ØçI��8´Äú«§±9N�ú«dçI<û½"~X§3ç

I<�Õþú«!Å�w�ÝI<µI(J�"

16.Ù¦¯�"UçI�8A:ÚI�Ö¿�Ù¦¯�"~X§æ^>fçI

ÝIXÚ�§w�ÝI<>fçIÝI�´²�¶¡!5þ�P!ÝI©��?�!

ÑÑ�ª§ÝI©��\�!4�!DÑ!�Â�(@§±9mI�§3�ë\mI§

)�ÝI©�ÚµI�§3�éÝI©�©�½ö`²�¯�"

13!IOµµ"J`�{

µI�¬éÝI©��µ"Ú'�§́ �âçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�

{?1�"ù�¥§µ"�m�§́ éÝI´ÄÎÜæI¦�µ"¶'�´éÎ

ÜæI¦�ÝI?1�p`�'�ÚüS"5¿§ù«µ"Ú'�´UçI<ú

Page 136: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 125

Ù�çI¯¢§=çI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{?1�§Ny�´çI<J`"

�*²LÆ¥§ræÀ��«�*²L¹Ä¥��¤ÀJ1�§b�æ<´�

�n5²L<"é��n5²L<5`§Ù�¤ÀJ�IO3uû¬�^§Uû¬

�^��z��K?1û¬ÀJ§ù´çI<?1çII��l�²L�K", §

�½û¬�^�Ò´²LÆ¥�JK"�d§²LÆ¥Qk�Ñyü«�^b�§

�´Äê�^nØb�§�)u�Ê­VÔ�c��m�=I§@�û¬�^�±

Oþ!ê�z¿�±\o¦Ú"5¿§nܵ©{æ^�²LÆb�§�´Äê�^

nض�´Sê�^nØb�§ÙJÑ��Ï3u<�uyû¬�^���«%n

y�´Ã{Oþ�§Ï�Ø�Ué��^�Oþü §@��±rû¬�^éAu

��ê��b�²¢�u�´Ø�U¤á�"ù�§3��­Vn�c�Ò�)

Sê�^nاb�µ���5§=�éz�«û¬ÑU`Ñ Ð^S¶��D4

5§=�¤öéØÓû¬� Ð´kS�§ë0���"eA�uB§B�uC§KA�

uC¶�Ø¿©÷v5§=�¤ö@�û¬êþo´õ�Ð"é8ÜØkïÄ�

<�½��§Sê�^nØb��¢�´b�û¬�^�¤�� S8ܧù'�

ÎÜ<��%naú"

çIÝI�Ø%3u¿�§¿��m�3uJ`§=éÝI�^üS§J`(

½¥I(J"@o§XÛéÎÜæI¦�ÝI?1üS§? J`§́ çI<3

çI©�¥��I�ïÄ�¯"û¬�^¢Sþ´�«�¼§=¼êþ�¼ê"·

�k©Û�ec$øý�ü¶§2£�ù�¯K�?Ø"

[c$øý��ü¶] 1313c$¬u2016c8�5F-21F3nÜ�p�9S©

Þ1§8�16F§��#ªúÙ����8�15F24 �§c$øý� �cʶ�I

[ü¶�L6.1"

ü¶ I[9/« 7ýê Õýê Ôýê øýoê

1 {I 26 21 23 70

2 =I 15 16 8 39

3 ¥I 15 14 17 46

4 �Ûd 9 11 10 30

5 �I 8 5 4 17

L6.1 c$øý�

ù�¥§4<�)¦¯�´¥I�=I�üS§���8�15F24�7ýê�

�§Ñ´15¬"�øýoêþ§¥I46¬§=I39¬§��o=Iü31�%4¥I

ü31nºløýoêþw§NowÑAT´¥Iü1�!=Iü1n"

c$øý��ü¶§´�«~���{ü�üS�{§=14Ù14!0��

Page 137: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

126 çIæÛYFn

/i;üS�n0�A^"¦^=©c;�<Ñ��N���ì��=©üc"~

X§economy ²Lù�c§ké1��i1e¤3�è§3é1��i1c¤3�è§

,�2wi1o¤3�¡§dþ�e^g�ìf8n§Ò�±éN´/uyeconomyù

�üc§ù´Ï�§=©c;üS5K´Uì26�i1a,b,c,d,· · ·,z�gS§éüc?1üS�"aq/§Ç�c;UìÖÑa,b,c,d,· · ·,z�gSüS"

c$¬øý�þI[ü¶5K§́ U7ýê!Õýê!ÔýêÚI[?èü 

?1üS�§=7ýêõ�üc¡!��ü�¡§7ýê���UÕýêõ�üS§

Õýê���2UÔýêõ�üS§X7ý!Õý!ÔýêÑ��§UI[?è��

üS"ùÒ´���2016c8�15F24�c$¬øý�þ=Iü31� ¥Iü3

1n��ϧÏ�üI�7ýêÑ´15¬§�3Õý�êþ§=I16¬ ¥I14¬"

çIæJ`�¢�§́ éÎÜæI¦�ÝI?1üS"¢�¥§nܵ©

{Ú²µ"��$ÝId{§́ {ü/±ÝI<��©½µId?1üS"�3²

LÆþ§çIæ´æ^õ�µ"Ï�éÝI?1�`�µ�§�)ÝI�d!Á

�Uå!Á��Y!�1Ú&��?1nܵ"§/¤éÝI`�µ��üÏ�

üSÚõÏ�üSü«�{"

1.üÏ�üS{"üÏ�üS´b�J`Ï�m�3�«�þ��§�±æ^

Ú�ºÝ½þ�\Úµ�ÝI`�§ù¢SþÒ´²LÆ¥Äê�^b�"çIæ

¥����{kü«§=µ�æ^,�µ"Ï��ÝI��üSëþ¶�é�µ

"Ï�?1�þ��§���Ú��üSëþ"Ù¥§1�«üÏ�üS�¦^k

Xî����5^�§�k�üSÏ��Ù¦Ï�ØK�æ(J�âU¦^"

~X§�$ÝId{§=éÏLÐÚµ"�ÝI§U�d�$��K(½¥I<�

�{"ù«�{wq{ü§����·^uäkÏ^Eâ!5UIOÚ�Úø�¿

v§çI<qvkAÏ�¦��8¶1�«�{Ò´~��²µ"��$ÝId{

Únܵ©{"

£1¤²µ"��$ÝId{"²µ"��$ÝId{ u­.Õ1!æ³mu

Õ1�IS7K|��/�$µId{0§�¦òÜÓÇ�äk�$µId�Ø�

½´�d�$�ÝI"Ó�§�¦çI©�A²(5½3µI¥I��Ä�¤kd

�ò�Ï�§±9N�$^ùÏ�5(½ÝI�µId§�)ûÖ!Eâ ��

 l"~X§éu��æ§ÙûÖòdÏ��)Sº$¤Ú�x¤!G±�m!�

ÀÏ!$E¤�!È�ÑÖ!�'�Ô�§EâòdÏ��)���Ç!��@5!

"��!S�5Ú�¸�Ã�"~X§L6.2¥�Ñ��Y"æ�8�òdÏ�

ÚòdIO§µI�¬=IUL¥ò�Ï�ÚIO§éÝI<ÝI�Y"�§!

ýG±Ú�À�m?1d�ò�§?�µId��AL¿Ud$�p�gSí�¥

Page 138: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 127

IÿÀ<"

SÒ ò�Ï� ò�IO

5½�?!ÑY�»Ú30mÄ:þ§�§zO\10mN~ÝId5

1 �§ ��§z~�10mNOÝId8��§Øv10m�ØO¶�u20m

½�L50m�ÝIò�áý

2 ýG± ýG±310%Ä:þ§zO\1%ÝIdNO1��§Øv1�%

U1%O¶z~�1%ÝIdN~0.5��§Øv1%�ØO

3 �À 3Oy�ÀÏ60F�Ä:þ§zJc1FÝIdN~0.3��¶z

í´1FÝIdNO0.6��

L6.2 d�ò�

²µ"��$ÝId{¥§ÝI<�µIdO�úª�µ

C = K +s∑

i=1

mi,

ùp§C =ÝI<�µId§K =ÝI<�ÝI�d§mi´1i�òdÏ��d�ò

��§s´òdÏ��ê"

²µ"��$ÝId{�¢� /́�Ã�a�Ã�À0ª�æ§rÁ�L§

Ú(Jé�^��UK���¤d�§U¤�d�$��K(½¥I§́ �«�*

µd�{"�,3²LÆ[�ú¥§?Ûû¬þéA��d�§�XÛ(½òdÏ

�§XÛ(½òdÏ��ü  léæ�^�K�´�JK"¢�¥§���U

æ^½|N�!¢��[½´õc²�§ÿ�½��òdIO§́ �«Cq�J`

�{"

£2¤nܵ©{"nܵ©{´µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µ"Ï�ÚI

O§éÝIµ©§Uì�©dp�$�gSí�¥IÿÀ<��{"Ù¥§µIÏ

�©��*ÚÌ*ü«Ï�"�d§nܵ©{�õ�§́ �6uµI�¬¤

�;���Ú����éÝI?1µ"Ú'�§́ �«Ì*µI�{§XL6.3¤«

�,ó§�óçI�8µ©IO"

��/§nܵ©{¥ÝI<�©�O�úª�µ

N = L +s∑

i=1

Ki,

ù�¥§N =ÝI<��©§L =ÝI�d�©§Ki�1i�µ"Ï��©§s´µ©

Ï���ê"aqud�ò�IO§nܵ©{¥XÛ(½µ©Ï�§XÛ(½µ

©IO±¦�Ï��µ©IO�N��´�JK"

Page 139: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

128 çIæÛYFn

µ"IO

µIÄOd=ÏLÐÚ"���$ÝI�d§ÝI�d�©=60×µIÄOd/ÝI�d

�óÜÝ�ÆÜn�1�§1-3©

�{k?�1�§12-15©¶�1�§6-11©¶Ä��1�§2-5©¶Ø�1�§0-1©��é�þ¿©k�æ�§3©¶k�æ�§

1-2©¶Ã�æ§�0©

��éS�!��¿©k�æ�§2©¶k�æ�§1©¶Ã�æ�§0©

�óÅ�!NÄå��÷vï��¦�§2-3©§Ä�÷v�§1©§Ø÷v�§0©

Oy�1§��é?Ýk�æ�2©¶Ä�k�æ�1©¶OyØ�1½��é?ÝÃ

|�¢���8¼��Ü?`�ó§�§2©¶Cnc|�¢�LÓ�5��aq�8§

ë�¢���8¼��Ü?`�ó§�§1©¶Cnc|�¢�LÓ�5��aq�8§

�8²nÜ<��à�§Ñkþky�6©¶z"��þky�2©§����

µ"Ï� ©�

ÝI�d 60

�ó|��O

�óÜÝ 2

Ì��ó�{ 15

�þ�y�� 3

S����� 2

2

] ��Oy 3

?ÝOy���

�æ�§0©

UÜÓ�Ýz5000��1©§�p2©

UÜÓ�Ýz5000��1©§�p1©

4

3

6

�8

²nÜ

�8²n

EâKI<

٦�<

L6.3 ,ó§�óçI�8µ©IO

µ©IOm��N���,�±æ^�g©Û{§O�ÝA���©ÛÚN

�§���µ"Ï�Û�´3©§Û�qA�´5©¿vkþzIO§�U´Ì*¹

ä"¢Sþ§@«@�µ"Ï�m�3�þ��!�±½þ�x�b�3nØþÒ

Ø�½¤á"Ó�§ØÓµI�¬¤�;���Ø�§éÌ*µ"Ï�µ©I

OݺºÝ�Ø�§́ E¤�©�p�ÝIØ�½´�`ÝI§= l²dÝI¿

�J`(½¥I(J�æm�"

d§nܵ©{4�/�6uµI�¬¤�Ì*�ä�û½§�½§Ý

þ´r¤ÝI<�µI�¬¤heGÏÚ1ªÉª¯K§ù3<��ßþ�

�¬�¸ecÙXd§Ï�ù«Ì*µ©IO�ÓuçI©�¥vkJ`IO§Ý

I<�ù«he1�k|uÙ¼�µI�¬�ûеdÚ¥I§Ø|u5�kS

�çIÝI½|�ï"

@o§üÏ�üS{´Ä�±¢yCqJ`Qº�Y´�½�§ùÒ´3²µ

Page 140: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 129

"��$ÝId{Únܵ©{Ä:þuÐ 5�õÚüS{"

£3¤õÚüS{"nܵ©{�":§3ué�«µ"Ï���©¦Ú§¢

Sþ´3^µ"Ï��²þ�©(½�`ÝI(J§³7��é�µ"Ï��J

`¶²µ"��$ÝId{§=´ý�/�Ã�a�Ã�À0��$d�§çI�8

¦^!�?Ú���¤�|Ñ¿Ø3�"

çI�8�J¦8Ikü«§�´çI�8)·±Ï5d'�`¶�´�8Á

�Uå�`"��/§ó§�ó!ÀÔÚ±Nå�Ø%�æ��uUçI�8)

·±Ï5d'�`�Kæ¶ó§t!�O!inÚ�ï!ïu�±�å�Ø%

�æ��uÁ�Uå�`�K槩ÚJ`Xeµ

1¤)·±Ï5d'�`{")·±Ï5d'�`{�cJ´ÝI9Á�Uå

÷v�¦�cJe§O�ÝI�5d'"J`Ú½Xeµ�(½ÏLÐÚ"���

dØ�L�pÝI�d�ÝI?\e�Ú¶�æ^µ©�{!ݦ�{½´çI©

�1²Ù¦�{§éÝI<Á�UåÚ(JüS§J`(½ü¶3ceZ¶�ÝI

?\e�Ú¶�O�)·±Ïü �m�¤^§�)ÝI�d!ÝI �9d�N

�!$E�oÚ¦^¤��ü �m�¤^§~X§��çI�O�ëþ

Φ =B +

∑1 +∑

2 +∑

3 +∑

4

T,

ùp§B =ÝI�d§∑

1 =ûÖ^� lN�d�¦Ú§∑

2 =Eâ^� lN�

d�¦Ú§∑

3 =¦^¤�¦Ú§∑

4 =$E�o¤�¦Ú§T =)·±Ï¶á�Úó

§�óçI�§O�

Φ = B +∑

1 +∑

=�T = 1¶�U)·±Ïü ¤^d$�p�^SüS§J`í�¥IÿÀ<"

2¤Á�Uå�`{"Á�Uå�`{�cJ´ÝIÎÜæI¦§d�çI<

kUå|G§? UÁ�UåüS!J`��{"J`Ú½Xeµ�æ^µ©�{!

ݦ�{½´çI©�1²Ù¦�{(½ÎÜæI¦�ÝIüS§J`(½ü¶

3ceZ¶§~X§n¶±þ�ÝI?\e�Ú¶�(½ÝI�dØ�L�pÝI

�d�ÝI?\e�Ú¶�(½ÝI<Á�Uå�üSëþ§�±æ^µ©�{!

ݦ�{½´çI©�1²Ù¦�{"UÁ�UåüSëþ��éÝIüS§J`

í�ü¶3c�ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<"

2.õÏ�üS{"õÏ�üSaquc$7ý�@«�{§́ nܵ�{�¢

��¦§�µ"Ï�'c$7ý�üSÏ�õ§�éE,"çIÝI¹Ä¥ÝI<

��êk�§éµ"Ï�üS�§Ui;üS�néÝI�p'�§�ª�±¢y

éÝI�nÜüS"

Page 141: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

130 çIæÛYFn

1¤ÝI�^�."ÝI�^�±æ^/ª�þ(A1, A2, · · · , Am)�x"Ù¥,ë

þAi, 1 ≤ i ≤ m�(½ÝIA�,�á5½A�§d/ª�þ(Ai1, Ai2, · · · , Ain(i))�

x§ùp§n(i)���ê§Aij, 1 ≤ j ≤ n(i)�(½ÝIA�á5!A�½ëê"ù�§

��ÝIA��^¢Sþ´��Smarandache­U�m§=

A =m⋃i=1

Ai =m⋃i=1

(Ai1

⋃Ai2

⋃· · ·⋃

Ain(i)

)=

m⋃i=1

n(i)⋃j=1

Aij,

½´L«��^Ý

A =

A11 A12 · · · A1n(1)

A21 A22 · · · A2n(2)

......

......

Am1 Am2 · · · Amn(m)

çIæJ`§¢�þ´�¦µI�¬UìçI©�¥1²�µIIOÚ�

{§éÝI(JR1, R2, · · · , RkU�^Ý=�^?1üS§~X§R1 � R2 � · · · �Rk§¿(½�^�`�ÝI(J¥I"

2¤õÏ�üS{"õÏ�üS�¢�§́ (½��üSÏ�A1, A2, · · · , AmÚAi1,

Ai2, · · · , Ain(i)§1 ≤ i ≤ m�S'X"ù�§�â14Ù�i;üS�n§Ò�½�±

¢yéÝI(JR1, R2, · · · , Rk��^üS"

¢�¥§éõÏ�üS§~^���{Xeµ

²��üS{"²��{�cJ´kvõ�êâÚO"��/§æI¦Ø

Ó§I�âÙEâ!²LÏ�½�I�§©ÛI�Ô¦^õU9I�U?¯�§?

(½Taµ"Ï��·^��"ù�üSL§Q�9�Æûü§��9çI<�

²�Ú%n��"

`ÀüS{"`ÀüS´¢�¥(½Ï�A!B`�'X��«{ü�{§́

æ^��Á�gêÀJ�`�Y��«�{§küÏ�0.618{!õÏ�0.618{!�

©{!Fibonacci`À{�"Ù¥§�{ü�´üÏ�0.618{"

;[ûüüS{";[ûü´¢�¥�~^�ûü�{§�A^uµ"Ï��

üS§�±k�u�;[�+Nûü`³§÷væI¦";[ûü��k±eL

§: �¤áûü|";[<ê���Û꧱B3k�Æ��±æ^ݦ�{§U

/�êÑlõê0��Kûü¶�ݺüS�â"7��§|�;[ÆS!?اï

ĵ"Ï�ÚIO¶�;[üS";[|¤�â�<Æ£!²�ÚIO§éµ"

Ï�üS¶�®o;[üS(J§Ñä;[8Nûü¿�§øçI<�¾J`IO

¦^"

Page 142: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 131

;[üS(J¢Sþ´��`ÀÝ"b�kn�Ï�A1, A2, · · · , AmI?1ü

S§K;[I��¤��n×n�`ÀÝ[Aij]n×n§ùp§Aij§1 ≤ i, j ≤ n�Ai, Ajm

'X�ûüý�§=Ai � Aj�Aij = 1¶��§Ai ≺ Aj�Aij = 0"5¿§ùp½Â

�Ý3Ìé��þ��þ�0§�÷vXAij = 1KAji = 0 �^�"

�;[|<ên ≥ 2�§ØÓ;[i�¤�`ÀÝ[Mi]Ø�½����§d�

I�ò¤k;[�`ÀãL®o���`Àݧ? �¤8IÏ��üS"®o

�{kü«§�«´Ý¦Ú®o¶,�«´\�¦Ú®o§=D�z�;[�½

���p1, p2, · · · , pn ≥ 1§,�§O�

[bij]n×n = p1 [M1] + p2 [M2] + · · ·+ pn [Mn] ,

n(Ai) =n∑

j=1

bij,

¿�ân(Ai)§1 ≤ i ≤ n���éÝIÏ�üS§=n(Ai) ≥ n(Aj)�§Ri � Rj"

ù�¥§�I(½µ"Ï�ÚÝIR1, R2, · · · , Rk��S^�§±éÝI(JnÜü

S§J`(½¥I(J"

[nÜüS�¯~]nܵ�{�¢�´nÜüS"�d§æ^�oÏ�Úëþ!

�o�{üS´�I�ïÄ�¯K"�{ü�§́ 3nܵ©{½´²µ"��$

ÝId{Ä:þÚ\�S§±Å�X{±üSþê���J`"

¯~1.,ÀÔæçIæ^²µ"��$ÝId{"¢�5�AçI��d�

$Úg$�ÝI�ÝI1ÚÝI2§�d�g�458565.00�Ú458566.00�§=�1�"

�lÁ�Uåþw§ÝI2¥I�k|uçI<"d�§XJU²µ"�ÝIdüÏ

�üS§ÝI1=Ï1���üS3ÝI2�c¡"ùaJ¦ê���üS�4àY

~´���"���aqy�u)§çI<�¾nÜüSIO�5½§²µ"�Ý

Id�310000.00�±S���S§U/Á�Uår�`k0�KüS"ù�§T�

8í��1�IÿÀ<Ò´ÝI2 Ø´üX²µ"��$ÝId§=ÝI1"

¯~2. ,ó§�OçI§J`IO�ÄÝI�d!�O�Y!Uå��¢y5

�3�Ï�§Ï�üS��O�YUå��¢y5"Ù¥§��d"5½ÝI�d

LØ�L�pÝI�d§ÄK§éÝI�±Äû¶��O�YK"é�O�Y²¡

ÙÛ!õUy©!�¸!!U�O�?1nÜ'�§Uz©��©¶�Uå��¢

y5Lëê§d[�<!�O�¸�^�UL = L1 × L2 × L3O�"Ù¥§L1�

[�<êþ"5½�8�O|;�à�§<ê15±þ�1.5§8-14<�1.0§7<±

e�0.5¶L2�<Á{ëê"5½[�<k�1�L2 = 1.2"[�<¥§zÑ

y1�Ã�1�§\¦Xê0.9¶L3�Uå��ëê"5½[�<ÃØûÁ{�1.0§

Page 143: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

132 çIæÛYFn

zÑy1�kØûÁ{�<§\¦Xê0.8§zk��¼�L1�ø��<§\¦

Xê1.2"��§O�ÝI<nÜ�©T = K×L§5½|T1 − T2| ≤ 20�ÝIT1§T2�

S§U�O�Y�©�p$üS¶XÝI<�O�Y�©E�Ó§KUÝI�dd

$�p�^SüS"T�8kA!B!C!DOo�ÝI"²µ"§o�ÝI��dþ

3çI©�1²��pÝI�d�dS§�O�Y�©�g�90§92§84§79§Uå

���5O�(J�g�1.94§1.8§1.8Ú1.44"�ª§ÝIA!B!C!DnÜ�©T�

g�174.6§165.61§151.2§113.76"Ù¥§ÝIA�B§B�C��©�320±S§�

�S§�ÝIB�O�Y`uA§ÝIA��O�Y`uC§UüS5K���ª�

üS(J�

ÝI<B�ÝI�A�ÝI� C�ÝI�D�ÝI"

¯~3.,Å>��çIæ^5d'{?1µ"§=æ^N = K×(B/C)×100O

�ÝI<�©§ùp§K���5Xê§d����5\¦ÙøÀ��5Xê �§

Ù¥øÀ��5døÀ�Y!<9È�ÑÖ�§Uz©��©�ر100¶B�ÝI

d§C���¦^�ê"üSIO5½§|NA −NB| ≤ 5�ÝI�S§U�d�©d$

�püS"o�ÝI<ë\ÝI§ÙN�O�(J�g�64.8§59.81§61.33,52.31§

�L6.4"

ÝI< 1 2 3 4

��5 0.9 0.85 0.92 0.8

��Ʒ 50 54 48 52

ÝId£��¤ 36 38 32 34

L6.4 üSëþO�(J

5¿§ÝI1Ú3�©�!ÝI2Ú3�©���u5"UüS5K§�ª�üS(J�

ÝI3�ÝI1�ÝI2�ÝI4"

�d§ÝI33o�ÝI¥�`"

[�£I]êÆ`z´�3�½�å^�e§¦)8I¼ê����(½���)"

��êÆ`z¯K½Â�: �½��½ÂuDþ�8I¼êf : A → R§Ïé��Cþx∗ ∈ D§¦�éu¤kD¥�x§f(x∗) ≥ f(x)(��z)£½öf(x∗) ≤ f(x)(��z)¤§

Ù¥D�Cþx��å8ܧD¥�Cþ�¡�´�1)"

À�å^�Ú8I¼ê�ØÓ§êÆ`z?�Ú©��55y!�ê5y!�

g5y!��55y!Ä�5y!lÑ5y!Ã��5y!õ�5y�©|"~X§

�g5y�8I¼ê´�g¼ê"çIæ¥�8I¼ê§~��´�5¼ê§�

éõ8IJ`�§��´��5¼ê§�9��55y½õ�5y"

Page 144: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 133

14!�½µ¥IÜÓ^�

çIæ�m�´¢yæ(J�`z§dçIÝI5�ÚÁ�ü�L§�

¤"ÜÓ^�§́ çI<�¢yæI¦§UÜÓÁ15ÆÚ+nI¦�¦ÝI<

¥I�Á��l�^�"Ø��ÜÓ^�§ÝI¿�Ò´�|L§iZ"ÜÓ^�

��ØÜn§�ÝI¿�Ø��§Á�Ø�UUÝI¿��(J¢yæI¦§æ

m��ª�Uá�"�d§ÜÓ^�´ÝI¿��Ä:"Ó�§ÜÓ^��´Ý

I¿�(J¢���æ"

5¿§ÜÓ^�Ø�ÓuÜÓ^±§Ï�ÜÓ^�´çI<JÑ�ÜÓÁ�^

�§�Ø´�¥I<�¤��§�\V�ÜÓ¥�^±"@o§IOçI©�½ç

I©��«�©�¥´ÄJø���ÜÓ^�QºÜÓ^�IUçI�8A:Ú

I���§́ çI�8��5Ny§ IOçI©�½«�©�´,�+�½;�

çI©��5§=�UNyÜÓ^���5"ùÒ´��oIOçI©�Ú«�©

�r/Ï^ÜÓ^±0��ÙÜÓ©���Ü© ÜÓ;^^±K´�x��Ï"

¢Sþ§Ï^ÜÓ^±\ÜÓ;^^±�uÜÓ^�"�d§çI<3IOçI©

�½«�©�Ä:þ§��3Ï^ÜÓ^±Ä:þ§UçI�8Á�I¦§rÜÓ

;^^±Ö¿�õ=�¤çI�8�ÜÓ^�"Ø��{ü���5^±§Ü

Ó��!d±|G!C�^�!��Ú¢��Ê��ÝI'X��;�§3d©Û

Xe"

1.ÜÓ��"ÜÓ��´éÜÓI����.½"çIæ¥kçI��!Ý

I��!�d��!¥I��ÚÜÓ���Ê���§3nØþA���"Äk§Ý

I�AçI�Ä:´éçI����A§�ö7L��"ÄK§ÝIÒ´��AÝ

I �Äû¶Ùg§¥I��A��ÝI����"XJØ��§ÃØ´¥I��

�u�´�uÝI��§Ñ��5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozl�l^5½§=«ì�

SNA�����SN��§«ìé���I�½öêþ�Ñ¢�5C��§�#

���5½§��ú²�´�½|�K¶1n§¥IÏ�Ö«ì�¥I���½´

ÜÓ��§Ï�¥IÏ�Ö§=«ì�¥I<�ÝI§=��§Uì5¬{;6ÜÓ

?1ozÔ��^5½�¤ÜÓ"�d§U5¬{;6ÜÓ?ÚçIÝI5K¥�

�g���g«ì�A:§�±í�ÑçI��!ÝI��!¥I��ÚÜÓ��

A���"ù�¥§��I�?Ø�´§�d��´ÄA��çI����"�¦

�d���çI���� u¬¯�´¥�/�dk�0��K§=ÜÓÁ�¥U

¥I<�ÝId�|GÙÜÓ±"ùpI�?Ø�´§XJ�d���çI��Ø

��§7,E¤Á��§Ü©�8Ïv�d Ã{�1/�dk�0�K§I�¯<

Page 145: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

134 çIæÛYFn

é@v�d��8­#ûÆd�§ùüXlÜÓÁ�þwq�vk�o¯K§�

XJ(ÜÝI¿�w§é@�ÌUçI���d�ÝI<7,Øú²§��ú

²�´�K"�d§çIæ¥�9�çI��!ÝI��!�d��!¥I��Ú

ÜÓ��A���§XJØ��§7,��ú²�´½ 5́¬{;6ÜÓ?�5½"

��5¿�¯K´§çI©�¥�çI��Ny3ü�/�§�´ÝI<L�

¥�/çI��0¶�´æI¦½æ�ü¥5½�f8½æ�8§�öL3

Sºþ����"ù�§ÜÓ���çI�����Ò^n¤Ù§��1nÙçI

æµI¦�.½"¢�¥§E¤ÜÓ���Æ��ϧ��þ uçI©�éç

I���.½ØO(§�3õ«n)§ÝI<UÙ¥�«n)ÝI¤�"éd§ç

I<3çIæ¥A�Ú±¿©�­À"

2.ÜÓd±|G" ÜÓd±|G§´çIÝI¥��­��¯�§Q�]�

"�¥"�]���<½ÝI<�ãÖUåk'§q�ÝI<�ÝI�dÚÁ�k

'"��/§̂ uÜÓd±|G�]75 !]7á¢ÚÜÓ^�¥�ýG±!?

ݱ½L§G±!�þ�y7´ÝI<��'5�^�§�´çI<�âÔÑÜÝ

I�­:Êy�¯�§Ï���¡§ÜÓd±|G´çI<�å¥I<Á��­�

Ãã¶,��¡§UÜÓ�½|G¥I<d±´çI<���Ì�ÜÓÂÖ§ØÁ

1ò�¤çI<��¿«ú�¥I<���I?"ÜÓ^�¥�d±|G§AÌ�

²(�e¯�µ

1¤]75 Úá¢�¹"]75 §I�²(w�^uÜÓd±|G�]75

§́ IÃ]7�´çI<gʧ́ �Ü�IÃ]7�´Ü©Iç±9IÃ]7

ÚçI<gÊ]7´õ��¶]7á¢�¹§�3w�ÝI<]7� �¹§±�

äçI<|GÙÜÓd±��U5"~X§,çI©�W��]7á¢�¹�/g

Ê]7100%Õ1�±§®�¥Iï�Õ1\Ý�±�Æ0"

2¤ýG±"ýG±^u¥I<�ÜÓ¢��á�!��!��Ú|�NÄå

¢��§I;±;^§;^¯�½+�3ÜÓ^�¥�½"ýG±�ݧ��´\

�ÜÓd�10%-30%"~X§,ó§�óçI�8�ÜÓ^��½/ýG±��Ý

�\�ÜÓd�10%§;^u«�<�ÜÓó§�ó�á�!ó§��!�ó�

�Ú?ï����§±9|��óèÎ?|"ýG±7L;^uÜÓó§0"@o§

ÜÓ^�¥´Ä�±Ø�ýG±½ýG�Ý�0QºülÜÓ¾áþw§ùv�o

Ø�±"�lçIæw§ÜÓ^�¥§XJ�½ýG�Ý�0§ÒI�¥I<k¿

©�ãÖUå§y76���÷vÜÓ��±þG±Ï¤I]7§ùéu�¥.ó

§ï��8§½´KŲEaè�§X�óè�ÚÜ©5�\óè�A�Ø�U"

�ª���§́ ÝI<òK]¤�§X�±|E�1n�¤^\��d¥§\�Ü

Page 146: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 135

Ód��~�d p"�d§U\�ÜÓd�½'~ýG¥I<�½±�§éçI

< ó§�½§Ýþ�±å�ü$ÜÓd��^"

ýG±35�þ´/±§çI<3�GÜÓ±��±�'~�£"�ýG±�

�ýG¥I<�§XÛ�å¥I<òýG±;^uÜÓ�8 Øé�§^§́ çI

<3ÜÓ^�¥I�X­ïÄ�¯�"��/§�¦¥I<3Â�ýG±�Ó�§

�çI<J�ýG±�¼§Ùú�7��ýG±7��Ó"

3¤G±ÏG±"G±Ï´ÜÓý½�G±Ï�§±±!�!G½ÜÓ^��½

�/�Ü �G±±Ï§�½G±Ï"��±¥I<3��G±ÏS¢��ÜÓ�

8�d��~ÜÓ�½�±���G¥I<§��±UAG±���½'~�G¥

I<"~X§,�.��çI�ÜÓ^��½/¥I<UÜÓ�½�GÜÓÄ1�

��§çI<3�ÂÜ��Â�¥I<J��þy²©�¿²"ØÃØ�28 FS§

çI<U\�ÜÓd�50%�~ýG±10%Ú�þ�y710%��{±§=\�Ü

Ód40%|G¥I<¶3Â��Ü���²|C�§�ØÜ��28FS§U\�

ÜÓd�50%�~ýG±10%Ú�þ�y710%��{±§=\�ÜÓd40%|G¥

I<"�þ�y7312��"�I?Ϫ���28FS§çI<ò�þ�y7{±

�g5|G¥I<0"

4¤�þ�y7"�þ�y7§́ ¥I<éÁ�(J��þ�y§�Ý310%±

e"Ù¥§ó§�ó��32%-5%§��æ5%-10%"�þ�y7^u"�I?Ï

Suy�¥I<I?E¤�çI�8"��?E!��½�ó­�§çI<�Ï�

�çI�8"��§�'¤^dçI<«ú§¥I<kÂÖ¢�"��?E!��

½�ó­�""�I?Ï3÷§¥I<�çI<���ÏA����{�þ�y7§

±9ÏçI<�Ï��"��8�?E!��½�ó­�¤^"

3.ÜÓC�"ÜÓC�´�Á�L§¥u)ÜÓ�½�/Ú^�§IéÜÓ¢

�5SN§XÜÓ��!ÜÓd±!Á�Ï�½�þIO�?1C�"Ù¥§ÝI<

�'5�§́ ÜÓd±ÚÁ�Ï��C�^�"

£1¤ÜÓC�^�"ÜÓ^�¥§A²(�½u)Û«�/I�éÜÓ¢�5

SN?1C�"��/§ÜÓ�eC��85�!5�½êþ!�þ�¦§UC¢�

/:½øÀ/:§UCó²½$Ñ!�C�{§½´�¢�ÜÓ O\�ó�½

¯��§�U�9ÜÓ¢�5SN�C�§��15Ù14!?Ø"

£2¤ÜÓd±C�"ÜÓd±C��3o«�/§�´ÜÓC�^�Úå�Ü

Ód±C�¶�´ÔdÅÄÚå�ÜÓd±C�¶n´{Æ{5CzÚå�ÜÓd

±C�¶o´Ø�|åÚu�ÜÓd±C�"

1¤ÜÓC�^�Úå�ÜÓd±C�"ÜÓÁ�¥§u)ÜÓ^��½�C

Page 147: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

136 çIæÛYFn

�^�§Xó§�ó¥Ñy��OC�§UC,�©�ó��A5§Xr,�/<

/¡U�skñ/¡�§UÜÓ^��½�C��/Ú�d�K½Od�{§òC

��8Á���dO\ÜÓd±"

2¤ÔdÅÄÚå�ÜÓd±C�"ÜÓÁ1ÏS§Ï<ó!á�Ú��½|d

�ÅÄK�ÜÓd��§ÜÓ^�A�½ÜÓd��C�^�Ú�{§O�½��

C��d§O\ÜÓd±"��/§ÀÔÚÑÖUd�ÅÄÌÝ´Ä�ÑÜÓ^�

�½���§�ÑÜ©O\C�ÜÓd±"�ókü«�{§�«´Ed+nÅ�

uÙ�d�N�XêN�¶,�«´U¥I<�âÝI¼N¹��¦J��ÝI¼

N¹þ1²�d��êÚ�­§O�C�ÜÓd±§úªXeµ

∆P = P0 ×

[A +

(m∑i=1

Bi ×Fti

F0i

)− 1

],

ùp§∆P�IN��ÜÓd���¶P0 �¥I<A���ÜÓ7�§��Ø�)

d�N�!ýG±�|G!�£Ú�þ�y7��3!��¶A�çI©�¥ÝI¼

N¹�ª¥1²�½��­¶Bi�¥I<UÝI¼N¹�¦ÝI�Ñ�1i��N

Ïf�C��­¶Fti�G±±ÏS�½�ã1i��NÏf�d��ê§Foi�ÜÓ

^��½�ÄOFϽ�ã1i��NÏf�d��ê"ùp§1 ≤ i ≤ m§=ÜÓ

d�P3�G±Ï���µ

P = P0 + P0 ×

[A +

(m∑i=1

Bi ×Fti

F0i

)− 1

]3¤{ÆCzÚå�d�N�"{ÆCz��¥I<3ÜÓÁ1¥u)�¤^

Cz§çI<AU{Æ5½éÜÓd±C�"

4¤Ø�|åÚu�ÜÓd±C�"Ø�|å���<ú�!ã���!¤^

O\ÚÁ�òØ�§��dÜÓV�U±e�K«ú§C�ÜÓd±µ�çI<®

²�ɯ���³§±9�¯�E¤1n<ú�Úã����§dçI<«ú¶

�¥I<���!�����d¥I<«ú¶�çI<Ú¥I<�g«úÙ<ú

�!Ù¦ã���Ú�'¤^¶�Ø�|å��ØUXÏÁ��§¥I<ÃI|G

��7¶��Á�6ÊI�ì+Ú�n!?E®Á�¯��§¤^O\ÜÓd±§

dçI<«ú¶Ø�|å�¦���¯<ØUÁ1ÜÓ�§A9�Ï�é�)ØÜ

Ó§UÜÓ^�§þõ?nV�Å�ÅÖ"

£3¤ÜÓÁ�Ï�C�"ÜÓC�^�Ñy§~X§çI<�UÜÓ�½9�

|GÜÓ±§½´çI<�¦UCÜÓI��þA5�§½Æ{5Cz�§�UI

�C�ÜÓÁ1Ï�"Ø�|åu)�§¥I<ØUUÏÁ��§AÜnò�Á�

�"

Page 148: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 137

4.��" ��§=çI<½¥I<¥�����ÜÓ�½§ØÁ1V�\¾

�ÜÓÂÖ�1�"��/§�����ª¢Å&�½|�K§A�UÜÓ�½

Ú{Æ5½«ú�A���I?"çIÝIL§¥§XÛ��¥I<��§ØÁ�

Qºkü«)û�{§�´çI©�¥�ÜÓ^�²(.½ÜÓ����/Ú?n

�{¶�´�¦¥I<J�Á�ú�"

1¤���/"���/A3ÜÓ^�¥1²§15Ù14!¥®éÜÓÁ1L§

¥������/?1~Þ"ÜÓ^�¥§�A(ÜçI�8A:ÚÁ�¢S§

3��ÜÓ���/Ä:þ§?�ÚÖ¿�õ���/§AO´¥I<Á��ÙÝ

I���<!ã!ÔÚ�{Ø��§K�Á�(J��/§²(.½Ù¥=�/

áu��§±9��?n"~X§ÝI�§[��8²n!�8EâKI<!�8¢

��Ù¦Ì�<ÚÅ���ÒØ §UCQ½�ó²½�{§UCÔ6�ª�

Ø����§vkÚ�5½§'�3uÙ´ÄK�Á�¢�§́ Ä3ÜÓ^�¥

²(�½Ù����/"

5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozÔ��^5½���§²(���SNA�äN(½§

²É��<«ì��<9ÉT¿gL«��å"éAuçIÝI§Ù5½=ÝI<

�ÝI§²çI<uÑ¥IÏ�Ö«ì�§ÝI<=ÉÙÝI��å"¥I<Á�

�ØUÙÝI©�1²�¯�Á�§=Á�����Ø��§�´ u¥I<3Ý

I�²�ØU¢����§�kÌ*þ�¿�ÐÀ1�¶�´ u�*þ�Ø��§

¥I<ÑyAÏG¹§Ø2#NÙUÝI©�1²�OyÁ�"~X§[���

8²n½EâKI<`�!\ó�u)�¿��*�ϧØU¢�ÙÝI�Á�O

y�"��/§ÜÓ^�¥�±òþã�/Ñ.½����/"�Ä�ØÓ���

�/´Ä��½|�´�KÚ�U�)�(J§1�«�/½5�î­���/§

1�«�/½5������/§3ÜÓ^�¥ÀØÓ�/�½?n�{"

2¤��I?"½|�´�Ä:3uª¢Å&§���UÜÓ�½«úUYÁ

1!æ�ÖÍ��?E!��!­�§��é�Ï�� ;É��Ü�����I

?"�d§ÜÓ^�¥Aýk�½�����A��é�|G�½ê����7½

�½�³���O��{"~X§,çI©�¥�ÜÓ^��½§çI<ØUÜÓ

�½ýG±!G±ÏG±!ó§eó(�±�§ØA|G¥I<ó§eó(�±§

�AUÓÏÕ1¹Ï�±|Çþ220%�¥I<OGöjó§d±Ïm�|E��

�I?"

ÜÓ^�¥§é¥I<Á��ÙÝI©�1²�¯�ØÎ�K�½�UK�Á

�(J�§�±?�Ú�½���/Ú��I?"

[��I?�¯~] ,ó§�óçI©�¥�ÜÓ^�§�½�¥I<��I?

Page 149: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

138 çIæÛYFn

Xeµ�móòØ"¥I<z´òmó1U§U\�ÜÓd±�0.3%|GçI<�

��7¶´òmó�L10U�§çI<k�)ØÜÓ¶�'�!:óÏòØ"zò

Ø1U§U\�ÜÓd±�0.3%|GçI<���7§òØ10U±þ�§«�<A`

ó¢y!:óϧ¤^gn¶��þ��"uyá�!���ÜÓ^��½�IOØ

ÎÜ�§¥I<A«úòÀ!�óÚ£½¤óÏòØI?¶eó�Â�Ø�ÜÓ^�

�½��þIO�§¥I<�çI<�B"½(�od2%���7¶�[�<�

�"¥I<3ÙÝIÖ¥«ì��8²nÜÌ�+n<§X�8²n!�8B²

n!�8EâKI<�§X3Á�¥�ÝI©�1²�<Ø��½I���§A

¯k��u�<Ó¿§U10��/<«ú��I?§¿�yO�<3ÙÆ{!Eâ

�¡Ú+n��!Uå�ÝI©�1²�éA<��";�ó��ÝI©�¥1

²�<Ø��½I����§A��u�<Ó¿§U5��/<«ú��I?§¿

�yO�<3ÙÆ{!Eâ�¡Ú+n��!Uå�¡��ÝIÖ¥éA<�

�¶�[Ý\�Å�����"R�$ÑÅ�!�èÅ�ÚC1ð��Ì�Å��

�§Á�¥æ^�$u¥I<3ÝI©�¥«ì�Ç�§çI<òéÙuÑî­´

w¿U5��/�?1�±§¥I<A33 FSÃ^���Eâ5�Ú���ÐÇØ

$uÝI©�¥1²���Úêþ§÷v�ó)�I�"X3FSE,ØUUÙÝ

I©�1²���Úêþ���§u�<òéÙU10 ��/�?1�±"î­K�

Á��§çI<k�\Ù�Ù)ØÜÓ¶�S��o����"¥I<�UUÙ3

ÝI©�¥1²�S��o���§Uz�ü ó§2���±§¥I<A31FS

Ã^�UÙ«ì?1���¤§�Ø�Ïd K�ÜÓÁ�"

3¤��ý�"ÜÓ´�¯<Ü��Ö¡Ly"�r¦ÜÓ�¯<ª¢Å&�Á

�§A�3ÜÓ^�¥²(�½���/Ú��I?"5¿§ÜÓ^��¦¥I<

J�Á�ú�§�Ý��Ø�L¥Id½\�ÜÓd�10%§Ó�§çI<�A�

�¥I<JøÜÓ±|Gú�§��V�Á1ÜÓÂÖ��y"

5.¢�"¢�§́ du���¯<ØÁ1½Ø��Á1ÜÓÂÖ ¦,��;

É���§É��JÑ����¦§�)çI<�¥I<¢�!¥I<�çI<¢

��ü«�/"

1¤çI<�¥I<¢�"¥I<��E¤çI<�Ã���§çI<k�Uì

ÜÓ�½^����¢�7�Ú£½¤ò�"�I?Ï"çI<�¢�±UÜÓ^

�½²V��û���§~X§ÀÔçI¥§ÜÓ^��½UÀÔ�¢S ��¹!

��§ÝÚï�¤��7�§²V�û½ü$ÀÔd�4��§½´ó§�󥧥

I<JÑ���8²n§UÜÓ^�U10��/<�§�l¥I<Á�A�ÜÓ±�

~�§þ�¤çI<�¥I<�¢�¯�§�±UìÜÓ^��½3G±¥�Ø"

Page 150: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 139

2¤¥I<�çI<¢�"çI<��E¤¥I<Á�ØU½öÉ��Ã��

�§¥I<k�UìÜÓ�½^���¢�7�Ú£½¤ò�Á�Ï�"�d§Ü

Ó^�¥§A�½çI<�=ÂÖØÁ1½ò´Á1�³¥I<�ççI<U

ì�oIO��¥I<§²(¥I<¢��JÑ!Ï�Ú?n�{�¯�"��/§

ÜÓ^�¥²(�çI<���/þ�U�¤¥I<�¢�"~X§ó§�óÜÓ

Á��§çI<Jø�á�Ú���5�!êþ½�þØÎÜÜÓ�¦§½duç

I<�Ïu)�ÀFÏòØ9�À/:C���¹�§��¥I<���§çI<

A«ú¥I<ddO\�¤^Ú£½¤óÏòا¿A�¥I<|GÜn|d"�

d§¥I<�±UÜÓ^���½§�çI<4�¢�Ï�Ö§JÑ¢�¯�Ú7

�§¼���"

²çI<Ú¥I<lÐ�û§é¢�¯�Ú7��¤��¿��§O\ÜÓd

±¶�ؤ��¿��§�±�k+`��®àÅ���®à½´�<¬{�Jå

�z"3®à½�û(JúÙc§®à3®àÌþ½´"�3{Ìþ§��±

é�ÆV�N)§±¦V�z)�Ƨ�¤�£"

15!Y~µçI©�J`�Á��É

çIæ´ÔÑ��¦§éA�§çI©�´çIæ�(µ"��où�`

Q§Ï�çI©�´çIæÔÑ�¦�Ö¡Ny§́ çIæL§§�)5�Ú

Á��üy§́ æ^ÝI¿�`zÁ�¢�æ(J"Ù¥§Á�üy´Ä:§Ý

I¿�´�¦§�öÚ�uçIæ¢�§̀ z¢�æ(J"�¦u��Ч*

ÑÑÛ§7½U�)Ð�ÂÃ"��§ØU��n)çIæ�¦§Ø��çIæ

¥ù«¿��Á�'X§çIÝIr/ª!rL|§"y²LJ`ng½´"y

Á�^��å§çIæÔÑ�¦�õ^�Ø�k�u�§�ØU¢yæ(J�

`z"î­�§$�¬K�çI�8�¢�"ù�¥§�î­�3uïÓ�OçI§

AO´éïÓ/k�½�¦�q`Ø�Ù§X{*�����³a(�¦�¯�

�´Xd§~Xe¡ù�ïÓ�OçI�¯~"

[Y�£�] ,½[ï���²�{¤�Y,§���{¤�Y�800{��

£þ¤§±�/�Ͷ{¤<Ô¢¹!¬;!s�!åعÚ/���©i�Y

�̧ܩ�ûB{¤©Ô"T�8ïÓ¡È46852m2§�?Ý]3·�<¬1§Ù

ó§�Oæ^úmçI�ªJ`(½¥I<"çI���)�Y�O!ÐÚ�OÚ

�óã�O§±9ï�L§¥��ó�Ü�¯�§µI�{æ^nܵ©{§éÏ

LÐÚ"��ÝIæ^nܵ©§Ùµ"Ï�ÚIO�L6.5"

Page 151: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

140 çIæÛYFn

µIÄOd�ÏLÐÚ"���$�d§U15×£ÝI�d/µIÄOd¤O��d�©

ÙÛÜn!õU«yEØ�Y,I¦!�±>�¸

ïÓE.È�!{*��§k��íE§¿S�m

õU©«!<6|�9ç��ÏÎÜ

(�/ª�ƧÅ>XÚõUÜn!�¢y§é�

Y,õUk�æ

ÎÜ�Y,���O�IO!5�Ú�¦

ÎÜ�Y,��!!U�O�IO!5�Ú�¦

Od�8�!���â!��LÚO��(

��OKI<k5þïÓ�yÖ§CÊc«úL�.ú�ïÓ�OKI<�§2©§Ø÷v�0©¶�ïÓ!(�!�üY!Ϻ�N;�<à�§kó§�±þ�¡§ìè�I²ß�§10©§z"��;�½´�¡Ø÷v�¦�§�3©§����

Cnck45000m2±þú�ïÓ�O�1�§z�2©§�p4©¶C5ck�?9±þ�Y,

�O�1�§z�3©§�p6©

ÑÖ«ìéó§ï��k�æ

µ©IO

�N!�Ï6�9m�!��må!FìmåÜn

ÙÛÜn§ÎÜ�Y,A:

�Y,¦^�¦

SÒ µ©Ï� ©�

1

2

3

ÝI

�dÝI�d 15

�O�Y

o²¡ 8

ïÓE. 12

õU©« 10

ïÓ(�9Å>

12

�� 8

��!U 5

Ed�� 5

�OUå

�Oìè 12

�O�1 10

ÑÖ«ì 3

L6.5 µ©IO

µI§S�ÐÚ"�→�["�→nÜüS→í�¥IÿÀ<→µI�w"Ù¥§nÜüSU�©dp�$�gSí�¥IÿÀ<"

T�88�ÝI<3ÝI���mc4�ÝI©�"ÝI©��)ÝI¼9

ÝI¼N¹!{½�L<�°y²½Ç��÷Ö!éÜN�ÆÖ!ÝI�y7!�

O¤^�d�ü!�Y�.!Ð�!�Y�Oãþ9`²Ú]�"�]�§�)Ä

��¹L!�O]�!̱<{{9]�y²!�8�O<���¹!è��1

±9ÝI<@�I�J��Ù¦©�"

µI�¬dçI<�L1<Ú4 ½t�OµI;[¥�ÅÄ�4<|¤§

��íÀÙ¥k�½(��ïÓ�ë,�µI�¬Ì?�"µI�¬¤�

�Ó¿8�ÝI<ÐÚµ"Ü�"ù�§3ë,�ïÆe§�[µ"æ�l�Y�.

Page 152: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 141

ÚÐ�\ç©ÛÝI<J���O�Y`�§2?1nܵ©"3éÝI<4�

��Y�.µÆL§¥§µI;[mu)�Æ"Ù¥§ü ;[@�²�ïÓ�

âÑLy§́ ­Ë�Eº½o�5kºª��ÂË!/æ�!ÁùÎfÚxÚ�Ä

�§ïÆëì�®�ûïÓ/ªÀJ��ïÓ�YA¶,ü ;[ØÓ¿§@�

<a®?\���­V§ïÓE.�Úw��A�§A±�ÀÖö%(!ÀÂÀú

�O§ÌÜëì,>ÀDx��OÀJ�YB"�d§V�FØC����§���

`Ñ,��§�ÑÃõ �"�d§çI<�LJ2µI;[§nܵ©{�Ø%

3uéÝI?1nܵ©§±©êØ=<"

µI;[�ÂçI<�L�ïƧ�çI<�L�å£�Sf>�mÝI<

4��ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹!�Y�OãþÚÙ¦ûÖ©�§UìL6.55½�µ©

IOé�ÝI?1µ©§�¤���ó�<?1ÚO®o"úÙ®o(J�§4 

µI;[�Oúº§®o�©�p�§QØ´�YA�Ø´�YB§ ´�.µÆ¥

���!vkM¿��YC§Ù�Y¥!Öö/�¿!?ø^�Ú�ú¢E.gXÈ

7§�ÝI�d�$"

µI;[Ø�É®o(J§�¦ó�<EØ®o(J§vk�ѯK"ù

�§4 µI;[Ú�¿�§í���ïÓ�YA�1�¥IÿÀ<"µI�¬

Ì?ë,ïƧr�¤�µ©L9®o�¢§4ó�<2u��gµ"L�±é

ÝI­#µ©"ó�<�[­#u�µ©L��§1�iÒÅ��Ñ�<5�

µIy|§�|�±��¿²(w�µI�¬§5çIÝI{61n�l^1�±

5½§?Ûü Ú�<Ø��{Zý!K�µI�L§Ú(J"Ø�®§µI�

¬�UU®o(J�¤µI�w§í��YC�ÝI<�1�¥IÿÀ<"

çI<�LéA!B!Cn��Y�ÝIµ©�89©!85Ú82©§@�µI(JÑ

<¿�§Ï�µI;[åÌ�YAÚ�YB§��d�ØØ>§No¬�Ñ�YC�

ÝI�©�pQ"£�ü �§çI<�L"�µI�¬¤�µ©P¹§uy

ÀJ�YA�ü ;[§��YA!B!C�ÝI�d!�O�YÚ�OUå�µ©

�92©!62©!88©§nÜüS�1�!1lÚ1�¶ÀJ�YB�ü ;[§��

YA!B!C�ÝIµ©�61©!90©!89©§nÜüS�1l!1�Ú1�"®o�§

�YA!B!C�ÝI�©�79©!77.8©Ú87.2 ©§ Ù¦5��Y�ÝI��©®

o�82©!81.5©!79.5©!77.4©!76©"�d§�YC�ÝIü¶1�"

çI<(½ü¶1���YC�ÝI¥I§�¥I<\¾�÷�OÜÓ§�¦

Ùëì�YA!�YB�ngéÙ�O�YïÓE.?1�ÌÝ?U§�A�ïÓ

(�!Å>�OÑl�YN�"¥I<Jѧù��u�­#?1ïÓ�Y�OÚ

�@ïÓ(�!Å>�O§ó�þ��§�¦3�O�Y�õ�ãU¢S|Ѥ^

Page 153: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

142 çIæÛYFn

(�§çI<L«@Ó§¿�\V�\Ý��÷�O�ÆÖ"

T�8Á1(å�§(�¤�460�"Ù¥§U¢S|Ñ�O�Y�õ¤^�¥

I<ÝI���dpÑ48.59��"

[¯K] �âþãY�£ã§©Û±e¯Kµ

1.�YJ`��´Ä²(§æ^ÏLÐÚ"���$�d��µIÄOd´Ä

�(§��oº

2.�YµI;[Ø�ÉÙµ"��®o(J§�¦ó�<2u��gµ"L

�±éÝI­#µ©±(½�YAü¶1�§XJ1�iÒ<�éù«1���§

(JwqéçI<k|�´´Äk�§��oº

3.µI;[é�YA!B!Cµ©éçI<3çI©�¥(½J`IOk=é

&ºqAN�(½�OçI�J`IOâU;�aq¯�u)º

[Y~©Û] çIÝI�Ø%§3u|�ÝI¿�"�d§çI<A�U�8A

:ÚI¦§(ܽ|ø�²(çI�8�J`���J`IO"ØÓaO�çI�

8§ÙJ`��Ø��§éA�J`IO�Ø��"��/§ó§\Χ�)�Oç

Iáu�åaçI�8§æA´ÄuÁ�Uå�ÀJ"

1.nܵ©{áuüÏ�J`§́ Äu�µ"Ï�m�3�þp�'X�b�

5½�Ï�©��§�ù«b�¢�þ¿Ø¤á"~X§L6.5µ©IO¥§��

oÝI�d15©§�O�Y60©§�OUå25©§ùnö�mØ�U�3�þ'X§

�U´çI<Ì*þ/r��0§��m�3�þ'X��±¦Ú'���§=¦

^�*²LÆ¥�Äê�^b�"

L6.5µ©IO¥�3±e¯Kµ�J`��ز("µ©IO¥§é�O�Y

ÚÑÖ«ì�µ"´Ì*µ"§J`IOwq(½¢Kز(§Ù¢�´Ç�µI

�¬µ"¥gdàþ¶��,ÝI�d=�15©§�æ^ÏLÐÚ"���$�

d�µIÄOdµ"�OçI�8Øþ§́ /$d`k03�Y¥�Ny§́ �y

ÝI<�Ñ$d§ØÎÜ�OçI´Äu�OUå�ÀJ¶�ÝI�d!�O�Y

Ú�OUånö�©¦Ú§¢Sþ´3^nö²þ�J` Ø´µIÏ�J`§=

��²þ�Øu)Cz§~X§�YC�ÝI�d�$�§�O�Y��½�OU

å�f§Ø¬K��YCo�©1�"

¢Sþ§nܵ©{Ñ�3þã�1n�¯K§=J`��ز(§́ 3æ^

µ"Ï��©�²þ�J`§ù3ÑyÉ~§X�Y�/�¬E¤�©�p�Ø�

½´µI;[ú¥��`"

2.�YµI;[Ø�ÉÙµ"��®o(J§�¦2u��gµ"L�±éÝ

I­#µ©±(½�YAü¶1���{§=B1�iÒ<Ø�{�|��§µ

Page 154: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

16ÙçIæµçI©��?� 143

I�¬�1�Ó���çIÝI5K§=UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§

éÝI©�?1XÚ/µ"Ú'�"ù�¥§I�?Ø�¯�kü�§�´µI�

¬¤�¬¯]�§A�´��¬¯1�Uå<§UéÙ¬¯1�«ú¬¯I

? Ø /́�-IU0¶�´µIL§¥§́ Ä#NµI�¬éµ"�g�Ñ�µ

I(JØ÷¿2µ�g§µÑ�(JEØ÷¿UY2µ§���Ñ�µI(J4µ

I;[!çI<½Ù¦|³'X<÷¿��Qº�,Ø#N�ù=B´3gd½|

þïè�Ø#N"bX§,<3èà�è;fpÀÐ�ï�è�§�2�¥§�2

3è;fp]nyo�§7,¬ÚåèàÚ¦<��a§Ï�¦�±Øï§ØU�

ï��2�¥"éµI�¬¤ ó§3ÙgC�µ"(Øþ\i�1�§=L

²lù��åéÙµ"(Ø«ú¬¯I?"ù«�/e§é®o(J�Ø÷¿§�

¦?1�gµ"?UÙþ�g�µ"(اáu;.��¥1�§ùéu����

¬¯1�Uå<�,´Ø#N�"ù¢SþL²§µI�U?1�g§Ø�uyµ

I�¬��UçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�µ"Ú'��5K§

K�µI(J��Ø´ØUU��"d�§µI(JA�Ã�§A�­#|ïµI

�¬µI"

3.µIL§¥§ÀJ�YA�ü ;[��YA!B!C�µ©�92©!62©!88©§

nÜüS�1�!1lÚ1�§ÀJ�YB�ü ;[��YA!B!C�ÝIµ©

�61©!90©!89 ©§nÜüS�1l!1�Ú1�§�½§Ýþ´Ü©I</·

þØ�X�Oþ�0�%�Ly"Ù¥§ÀJ�YA�ü ;[��YA�p©!�

YB�$©§ÀJ�YB�ü ;[��YA�$©!�YB�p©�´ù«%�3

å�^"

�Xþ¡©Û�§�Y�OçIÑy¯K����ϧ3uæ^�nܵ©{

´�«3²LÆþJ`��¹·�üS�{§çI<Ø��J`J�o�3çI§

ÝI<Ø��çI<�J`�o�3ÝI§µI;[vkJ`��§u´§gdu

�§UgC�n)�çI<ÀJ�O�Y§3µI;[¿������±@�´8

N�¦�(¬"@o§µI;[¿�Ø��¬�)�o�J§Ù®o(J´Ä�´

3J`Qº�YÃ<�¡�ùÒ´�YéçI<3çI©�¥(½J`IO�é&§

=çI©�¥�J`IO��7L²(!Ï�7L�ߧIO7L(ÜçI�8A

:ÚæI¦O(§µI�¢y"5¿§nܵ©{���":3uJ`��ز§

´3æ^µ"Ï��²þ�©�äÝI`�"�»ù�ðÛ���3uUìçI�

8�µ"A:§æ^õÏ�üS{J`§½´æ^õÚüS{CqJ`"

±Äu�OUåJ`�~§�YõÚ{J`IOÚ�{Xeµ

11Ú. �O�YJ`"æ^µ©�{!ݦ�{½´çI©�1²Ù¦�{(

Page 155: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

144 çIæÛYFn

½ÝIüS§J`(½ü¶3ceZ¶§~Xco¶�ÝI?\e�Ú¶

12Ú. ÝI�d3�p�dS"(½�dØ�L�pÝI�d�ÝI¶ü¶

13Ú. (½ÝI<Á�Uå"�±æ^µ©�{!ݦ�{½´çI©�1²

Ù¦�{§(½ÝI<Á�Uå�üSëþ¶UÝI<Á�UåüSëþ���é

ÝIüS§í�ü¶3c�ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<"

ù�§́ 3éz�µ"Ï�J`§�k�;�æ^µ"Ï�²þ©üS�":§

z�ÚÑ´J`§��§±Á�UåüS§í�¥IÿÀ<"d�§Q,µI;[@

��YC�ïÓE.�O��!vkM¿§311ÚJ`L§¥Ò�±üØK§Ø¬

¤�1�¥IÿÀ<§qÛ5éÙ�O�Y�ÌÝN�§õ|GÙ48.59���ÜÓ

d±Qº

Page 156: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 7Ù

çIæµçIÝI�|�

**********************************************************************

ز��»��§N�rsÀ&�"

— /.��!�5þ,m«w6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 157: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

146 çIæÛYFn

11!/ªµg1çI½�÷�nçI

çIæ¥�¬¯ÌN´çI<ÚÝI<"Ù¥§çI<ÚÝI<©O´?1

çIÚ�AçI�{<½öÙ¦|�§UÕá«ú¬¯I?"U5¬{;6oK?

�5½§çIæù�¬¯1�§́ äk¬¯1�Uå�çI<uÙçIúw½Ý

I��Ö!uÈçI©�±3çIÝI¹Ä¥²(Ù¬¯�|ÚÂÖ�1�§Ùç

Iæ�¿gL«A�ý¢§Ø���{ƽö�¬ú�|Ã"éA�§çIæ

¬¯{Æ1��¢�§�±´çI<g1¢�§��±ÏL�n<§=çI�nÅ�

?1¢�"çI�nÅ�3çI<��÷��ÚÏmS§±çI<�¶Â¢�çI

æ1��§çI<éçI�nÅ���n(J«ú¬¯I?"Ó�§çI�nÅ

�ØÁ1�I �çI<E¤�³�§A��{«ú¬¯I?¶çI�nÅ�Ú1

n<Gϧ�³çI<�|Ã�§dçI�nÅ�Ú1n<Kë�I?"5¿§5¬

{;6oK?1�z8�Ô^5½§�n<��½öA����n¯��{E,¢

��n1�,½ö��n<��½öA����n<��n1��{���éL«

�,��n<Ú�n<A�«úë�I?"

çI<�÷çI�nÅ�çI�§A\ÝÖ¡�÷�Ƨ1²çI�nÅ�¶

¡!�n¯�!��ÚÏm§¿dçI<{½�L<\¶½ö\XúÙ§²(V�

�|ÚÂÖ"AO´§çI�nÑÖ¤��ÝÚ|G�ª"

[çI�n¤��~] çIúiA�,{�?u2014cÐ\¾5{ÀY?n�

�8�÷�n�ÆÖ6§�½dAúi�n{ÀY?n��8çI§�½çI�nÑ

Ö¤d¥I<«ú§¿3çI©�¥úÙ§T�8çI�nÑÖ¤�1�I[uÐ

Oy�¬<u�5çI�n�Ö¤61�{6£Od�[2002]1980Ò¤5½�O

¤IOe220%�§d¥I<+�¥IÏ�Ö��Aúi�B"

µI�¬²Lµ"§í�Búi�1�¥IÿÀ<"çI<(½Búi¥I§Aú

i�Ùu�XkçI<ÚAúiúÙ�¥IÏ�Ö"

¥I<Búi3Â�¥IÏ�Ö��{�?\¾ï�ó§�óu�«�Ü

Ó§?|móï�"���Ø�¿UçI©���½�Aúi�BçI�nÑÖ

¤17.20��§nd´{�?3�Ù\¾ÜÓL§¥§q4Ù4|�50.00��¥�

)çI�nÑÖ¤"Ó�§Aúi´�{�?GÑ��nÑÖ§´�{�?\¾�

çI�n�÷�ƧA�{�?Â�çI�nÑÖ¤"Aúié{�?�¦|Gç

Page 158: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 147

I�nÑÖ¤§{�?Ø�|G§nd´V�\¾�çI�n�÷�ÆÚçI©�

þþ1²§çI�nÑÖ¤d¥I<�B"�õg¢��J§A úiòBúiÚ{

�?wþ{̧�¦Búi½{�?|GÙçI�nÑÖ¤17.20��9Ùò´�B

çI�nÑÖ¤�|E13312.00�"

{�²"n@�§Aúi�{�?\¾��÷�n�ÆÖ¥�½§çI�n¤

d¥I<«ú§Búi��TçI�8�¥I<§3ÙÝI¼¥²(«ì§�Åç

I©�5½§3+�¥IÏ�Ö�Ó�§U�I[uÐOy�¬<u�5çI�

n�Ö¤61�{6£Od�[2002]1980Ò¤5½�IO§�çI�nÅ��B§

=BúiÓ¿�BçI�nÑÖ¤�¿gL«"�d§ÄuAúi�{�?�m¤

\¾��÷�n�ÆÖ§±9{�?uÑ�çI©�ÚBúi4��ÝI©�§3

çI�nÑÖ¤�|Gþ®3Aúi!Búi!{�?m�¤dBúi|G�¿g

L«§�Ø��{Æ!1�{5�r�55½"BúiJÑ��{�?4|50.00�

�¹çI�nÑÖ¤§Ad{�?|GAúiçI�nÑÖ¤�ÌÜvkÖ¡yâ§

L²��Y�z¯��3Ã'"

�d§{��"�ûçI�nÑÖ¤17.20��Ad�wBúi��wAúi�

B§Ó�§�â5¬{;6ÜÓ?18zÔ�8^5½§=/±<�Uì�½�Ï�

��/±�§AUI[k'5½§ëì¥I<¬Õ15½�7KÅ�OÂ}Ï�±

|E�IOO�çI�nÑÖ¤�|E§A�8694.00�"

çI�n´�«¬¯�÷�n§́ �çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä"5¿§çI�

n�´çI<�/çIÝI5�0�n§Ø�)Á�"¤±§çI�nØ´çIæ

����¿Âþ��n§=´Ö¡5��n"�d§k7�éçI�nÅ��{Æ

5�Ú�^?ا? 3IÀJçI�nÅ��§UçI�8A:ÚI¦§ÀJ·

¨�çI�nÅ�`z¢yæ(J"

1.çI�nÅ��5�"çI�nÅ�§́ �{¤á�l¯çI�n�Ö¿J

ø�'ÑÖ��«�¬¥0|�"çI�nÅ����¬¥0|�§A�äk?�

çI©�Ú|�çIÝI¹Ä�;�Uå§ÑÖuçI<ÚÝI<§�É�?k'

1�iÒÜ�!çI<!ÝI<Ú�¬�iÒ"çI�nÅ����¬¥0|�§

Aä�µ�äkÕá{<]�¶��1�Å'ÚÙ¦I[Å'vk1�äá'X½

öÙ¦|Ã'X¶�k�½�E�|¤ÚmÐó§çI�n�Ö¤I��9�ú^

�¶�kè��|�Å�ÚSÜ+n�5Ù�ݶ�ä�?�çI©�Ú|�µI

��A;�åþ�^�§±BÙmÐçI�n�Ö"

ù�¥�I�?Ø�§́ çI<�çI�nÅ��'X"çI<�Ù�÷�ç

I�nÅ�m´��n<��n<'X"çI�nÅ��âçI<��÷mÐ�n

Page 159: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

148 çIæÛYFn

ÂÖ§¤±§çI<ÚÙ�÷�çI�nÅ�mÓ�´Ü�'X"éçI< ó§ç

I�nÅ�´Ù?1çI��ó<§L«úÙ�n1��{Æ�J"/Q÷�=&

�0§¿U/�dk�0�K|GÙçI�nÑÖ¤"7��§��±�½d¥I<

�BçI�nÑÖ¤§�L3çI©�¥1²çI�nÑÖ¤�IO½ê�§±B

ÝI<«ì¿3¥I��B"5¿§çI�nÑÖ¤§ÃØ´çI<��|G�´

�½d¥I<�B§¢�E´çI<|G�ÑÖ¤§/�fÑ3��þ0§�ØL¥

I<�B�§́ ¥I<UçI©��5½§k1|G�çI�nÅ� ®"

çI<�çI�nÅ�Q,´Ü�'X§Ó�A�XV[©z¥/;0�g�§

�(w��ö�m�'X§Ï�çI<�÷çI����Ï3u�ãçI�nÅ�

�;�Uå¢yæ(J�`z Ø´{ü/r/ª!rL|"�d§çI<AU

çI�nA�¼��Ü{²EÂ\§v�|GÙçI�nÑÖ¤§ØA��§�Ø

¨rçI�nÑÖ¤��(½çI�nÅ��Ì�Ï�"ÄK§́ u��çI�n

Å��ÝI<m�heGÏ1� ��çI<�Ã"5¿§�,5¬{;6oK?1

�z8�o^5½§�n<ØÁ1½öØ��Á1�I§E¤��n<�³�§A

�«ú¬¯I?"�n<Ú�é<�¿Gϧ�³��n<Ü{�Ã�§�n<Ú

�é<A�«úë�I?"�¢�¥§�nÅ��1n<�heGÏ´��éJÞ

y�¯�§çI< �U/�á߸é�gCÜfp0")ûù�¯K�Ø%§3

uÀJ5��çI�nÅ�§V�±/;0�g�Ü�"

çI�nÅ�´±çI<¶Â|�çIÝI¹Ä"�d§çI<�çI�nÅ

��Ü�Aïá3�pÖ�!��;áÚp&Ä:þ§A±çIÝI�¦`zæ

(J�m�"@«±�çI�nÅ�´�ý§Ñ¯�±í�I?��{´k³�§

´3�Ø/n)¬¯�÷�n�Ý"Ó�§@«òçI�8�÷�çI�nÅ�/¯

Ø'C!pp!å0§�¯�í���{§é`zæ(JÓ�k³§Ï�U5¬

{;6oK?1�z8��^5½,�n<3�n��S§±��n<¶Â¢��¬

¯{Æ1�§é��n<u)�å§=´çI< Ø´çI�nÅ�é�n(J«

úI?"

2.çI�nÅ���^"çI�n´��;��Eâ²L¹Ä§ÙÑÖwq=

�n|�5�§¢�´|�5�¿�`z¢yæ(J"Ù¥§UØÓ�8A:Ú

I¦?�çI©�!|�çIÝI¹Ä´çI�n;�Uå�Ø%Ny"�d§ç

I�n7LéçI�8�EâIOÚ�¦kXß��§$�pu�÷<n)?�Ü

Ó^�§�{|�ÝI<¿�ÚµI�¬µ"Ú'�"ù�¥�Ø%3u©Û½

|ø�G¹§(½¿�Ï���{§¢yçI�8æJ`"

çI�nÅ��;�UåÌ�Ly3µ�ÙöݺçIÝI{Æ{5!�üÚ

Page 160: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 149

�'5K¶�ÙGçI�8�½|ø�Ú¿�G¹¶�ÙGI[!1�9çI<E

âuÐÔÑ!ÙÛ§éçI�8A:!EâIOÚ�¦k��n)¶�ÙöݺÜ

Óüy§UUçI�8A:ÚI¦§�½|¿�G¹!ÜÓÁ�+nÚçI<S

��Ý�·A§k�é5/JÑÜÓ^�¶�ÙöݺçIæÔÑ��¦§�é

ØÓ�æI¦Ú½|ø�§��çI�8�J`IOÚ�{§�)êÆ�²L`

z�{¶�ÙöݺçIÝI¹Ä�|�ÚACUå§�ÏçI<�¥I<\¾Ü

Ó�"

çI�nÅ��ÑÖ���)çIæ�YÚÜÓüy§?�]�ý"©�!

çI©�§|�]�"�§|�ÝI< ty|ÚÝIý�¬Æ§|�çI�8�

mIÚµI§�ÏçI<(½¥I(J!uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§±9�ÏçI<�¥I

<UìçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�\¾Ö¡ÜÓ�¯�"

çI<�÷çI�nÅ��§��A�éçIÝI5��L§§=é]�ý"

úw!çIúw½ÝI��Ö!]�ý"©�ÚçI©�!é]�ý"©�ÚçI

©�©�½?U�?�Úu�§|�y|�ÚÝIý�¬§�ÂÝI§|�mI

ÚµI§�ÏÜÓ\¾�?1�÷§±B¢yçIæ(J"

3.çI�nÅ��ÀJ" çI�nÅ�±çI<�¶Â?1çI�¬¯�K

7,�ѧ�÷XØ�÷X�nA�dçI<`�§¦<Ø�éÙ�÷1�?1

Zý§�)�{�½�nÅ�½´�nÅ�ÀJ�{§X~Ò!�ÅÄ�(½çI

�nÅ��§ÄK§�½��¬¯�÷�K§Ï�´çI<éæ(J«úI?

Ø´/¦<0"ù�¥I�?�Ú?Ø�§´é@�?Ý]�8çI�nÅ��

ÀJ´ÄA�d�?½ÙÜ��½½´��¯K§Ï�ùa�8k�?Ý]"¢S

þ§ùa�8��8{<§�«´�?Ü�½Å�ú?§,�«½|ÌNú?"1

�«�ÀJ�Ò�LX�?1�§ÈTéÙõÆ"1�«�ÀJ´�8{<�gÌ

ÀJ§�1�«�8¥§�?´Ý]<§́ ²dÝ]Á1�?�²L�ILy"d

�§�?XJéçI�nÅ��ÀJ���½½ö��§´3^�?@�/÷*0

wØ��çZý��dçI< Ø´�?«úI?�/�*¯Ô01�§��?

�U½ ØÎ"Ó�§çI<ÌNI?/Ó{�Ú�pí�§Ø|u`z¢yæ

(J"�d§U쬯�K©Û§çI<A�k�gÌÀJçI�nÅ�§�÷Ù

�nçI¯¨"

@o§çI<A�N�ÀJçI�nÅ�QºçI<A�ÄuçI�8;�A

�ÚæI¦§J`ÀJçI�nÅ�"

1¤ÄuçI�nUå�ÀJ"�÷çI�nÅ�çI�Ì��ϧ3uçI<

Uå�j"§8�´u�çI�nÅ��;�`³ÚUå§�ÖçI<3çIæ

Page 161: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

150 çIæÛYFn

Uåþ�j"§�)éçI�8;�A��n)!½|ø�G¹�rº!çIÝI

{9�'5K!üyÜÓ^�!ýÏ8IÚJ`üÑ�"Äk§éçI�8;�A

��n)Úrº§́ çI�nÅ�|�ÝI¿�§üyÜÓ^�§�åÁ��^�¶

Ùg§UæI¦�{JÑçI�8�ûÖ!Eâ¿�Ï�ÚJ`IO§́ çI�

nÅ��çI<�÷§¢yçIæýÏ8I�Ø%ó�¶1n§çIÝI¹Ä´

��5K�éE,�½|�´¹Ä§çI�nÅ��{�5/|�çIÝI¹Ä§

´�oçI<�Ã�Ä�"�d§çI<´ÄuçI�8�;�A�ÚæI¦8

I§éçI�nÅ��UåÀJ"

2¤ÀJçI�nUå�Ï�"çI<ÀJçI�nÅ�Uå�I�±©�ü

Ü©§�´çI�nÅ���YO§�´çI�nÅ��;�Uå§U/�âo�0

ÀJ"Ù¥§çI�nÅ���YO§´çI�nÅ�9Ù<�¬�Ú¬5, ´

�¬1�5�é�<ó1��å§Ý§Ly3çI�nÅ�9Ù<± ��n1

�¥´Ä�1Ü�§́ Ä??¦Ù¤U/ÑÖuçI�8§??�çI<|ÃX�§

�oçI<��çØ�3he��Ò!*l!�¬1n<½ÝI<heGϧ½

´Ù¦�³çI<�Ã�1��§́ çI<ÀJçI�nÅ��cJ§�dÙ½|

� §$�heDª¼�"

çI�nÅ��;�Uå§Ly3Ù�nçI�8�;�U姵"Ï�Ì�

kn�¡SNµ�´äkÕá¾áÜÓ¬¯ÌN�°§XE��ìÚ|�Å��è

y�¶�´Á1çI�n�Uå§�)µ�çI�nÑÖNXÚ�ݶ�ÑÖL§

��§XçI�nÑÖ�Y!�þ+nNX@y�¶��8|Eâ!²L�;�<

��!<��Uåy²�¶�aqçI�n�8��1Ú�÷<µd§AO´

é�8²n�ÑÖUå�µd¿�¶�éçI�8;�A�ÚæI¦�n)Úr

º¶��Ï!|��NU姱9éçIÝI¹Ä¥�âu¯��A:?nUå

�"

5¿§çI<ÀJçI�nÅ��´Ä�±rçI�nÑÖ¤����ÀJÏ

�Qº�,�±��çI<´ÄuçI�nUå ?1�ÀJ§çI�nÑÖ¤�

�ب��Ì�ÀJÏ�§��Ø�LçI<5½�çI�nÑÖ¤þ�=�§�

Ø�±çI�nÑÖ¤�d�$�ÀJ�K"Ó�§çI<(½�çI�nÑÖ¤

þ�AÜn§v±|GÙ|�çIÝI¹Ä!è��~m|Ú1��Ün|d"ç

I�nÑÖ¤L$§~X§�çI<ò1000õ���ó§�ó�8çI�nÑÖ

¤�þ�½�3000.00�§k�$��¦�¤ÑÖ ÀJçI�nÅ�§��Éú³

���½´çI<gC§Ï�½|�´l5vk/�¤Ìê0"

3¤çI�nÅ��ÀJL§"aquÁ�Uå"�§çI�nÅ��ÀJÚ½

Page 162: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 151

���µ�?��8©�§�)�÷��ÚA�!]�^�!�8§S!�¤½�

d�¦!�A©�?�!4����m!µ"ÚÜÓ\¾�¯�¶�uÑ�8úw"

�8úw3x0þúÙ½½���¶�u��8©�¶�çI�nÅ�?�!4�

�A©�¶�µ""çI<|ïµ"�¬§7��§��1�;[ë\"µ"�

¬U�8©�þ�µ"IOÚ�{é�A©�"�Ú'�§nÜüS¶��8|�

F"Ø¢�8|<��ÚUå(@§é�8²n!Eâ!ûÖÌ�<;�EU!

çIÝI|�!�ÏÚACUåÿÁ§(@½N�üS(J¶�(@SÜ+n"é

üS3c�çI�nÅ�?1�Ú^rr�§(@çI�nÅ��Ö+nN�!

�Æ?nUåÚÑÖ�Ý!ÑÖ�þ"7��§N�üS¶��÷üS3c�çI

�nÅ�§\Ý�÷çI�n�Æ"

12!m©µçI©�éúm

N�@£çI©��çIúw½ÝI��Ö�'XÚ/ §́ kkçI©��

´kkçIúw½ÝI��ÖQºlçIÝI¹Ä|�^Sþw§çI<�½´k

uÙçIúw½ÝI��Ö§2uȽe1çI©�"�¢�þ§́ çI<?��

¤çI©��âUuÙçIúw½ÝI��Ö§Ï�Ù¥�çI��!]�^�Ú

çIÝI�mSü�¯�§LUçI©�(½�¯�uÙ"Ó�§çI©�¥�1

�Ù3.~þ�½´����§=çIúw½öÝI��Ö§�çI<uÙ�çI

úw½ÝI��Ö3SNþA���"@o§çI<3|�L§¥§XJvk�l

çIúw½ÝI��Ö�çI©��ù«'X§ ´3uÙçIúw½ÝI��Ö

�§3çI©�¥N�½?U®²úÙ�SN§3¬¯'Xþ´�o�JQºùa

qu§�¥ÀW¥�@ �*3D¢þ��m�/�ÑF¥��¥�£F¥�Þ

ħùØ�U§Ø��*Ã¥k�^VXF¥�-f�3�¥ÀW5K¥ýéØ#

N"ÄK§�F¥@ �*Ò´J�b¿§¬;�­<��ï"Ó���K§�·^

uçI<|�çIÝI¹Ä"

1.çIúw½ÝI��Ö" çIúw½öÝI��Ö��������A1

²±eSNµ�çI�8¶¡!SN!��!5�Ú]75 ¶�ÝI]�Ú&�

�¦§±9´Ä�ÉéÜNÝI¶�¼�çI©���m!/:Ú�ª¶�4�Ý

I©�����mÚ4��ª¶�çI<9ÙçI�nÅ��¶¡!/�!éX<

9éX�ª¶�æ^>fçIÝI�ª�§�¯>fçIÝI�´²����Ú�

{¶�çI<�{½@�Aw�d3ÝI<�Ù¦SN"çI©��,3{nþ�

�çIúw½ÝI��Ö§=�����[z§�Ùéúm§Ø+´ém©u

Page 163: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

152 çIæÛYFn

È�´3�Õþ�¤e1§Ñ%¹XçIæO�ó�ÒX§d3ÝI<�±¼�

çI©�§UçI©���¦?�ÝI©�O�ÝI§¿�XçI!ÝI�ªm©§

ùÒ´��oÝI���m´±çI©�uÙ�m Ø´±çIúw½ÝI��

Ö�uÑ�m�ÄOO���Ï"

[çIúwN���¯] ,½��.N�|,æ^ISúmçI�ª(½�O

ü §çI<Uì�'5½§u2014c3�8F3k'x0þuÙçIúw"Ù¥§

5½�]�^��µ�3¥u<¬�ÚI¸S5þ�Õá{<§5þ]�7Ø�

u3000��<¬1¶�äkï�1�Ì+Ü��u��ÂïÓó§�O`?]�¶

�Cnc�¤Lï�5�Ø�u�N�|,ï�5�n�±þ��O�1¶�ÏL

ISO9000�þNX@y¿¤õ$1Êc±þ"T�8ÏçIÝI��OySüÿ

�ᢧçIúw¥�ÝI���mÚmI�m1²/,1Ï�0§¿m©uÈçI

©�"

çIúwuÙ��1nF§k��d3ÝI<ïçI©�"Ù¥§k��

d3ÝI<Jѧ]�^�¥/5þ]�7Ø�u3000.00��<¬10Ú/Cnc�

¤Lï�5�Ø�u�N�,ï�5�n�±þ��O�10�p§3�I��S

�vkA[�Oü ÷vù��¦§K�d3ÝI<ë�¿�§ïÆN�"çI<

�ÉTd3ÝI<ïƧu2014c3�12 FuÑçI©��©�Ú?U§òþ

¡�5þ]�7N��1000��<¬1§Cncaq�8�1dn�N����"

T�8���ÝI���m2014c3�30F§�kü[ÝI<4�ÝI©�§

vk��çI©�5½�mI^�§çI<\ÙçI�}§rÂ��ÝI�y7Ú

ÝI©��µØÄ/ò��ü[ÝI<"

çI<zgØ�Ù)�´§®²3çI©�¥ò5þ]�73000�N��1000�

�§aq�8�1dn�N����§��oE�k�ÐïçI©��ü[ÝI

<4�ÝI©�§�½ÎÜN��]�^��Ù¦8[�Oè�§��oÑØÝI

Qº¢Sþ§ù´Ï�çIúwÚçI©��©�Ú?U�ɯØÓ"çIúw¡

�¤kd3ÝI<§ çI©��©�Ú?U=¡�ïçI©��d3ÝI<"

�¯¥§duçIúwvk�U]�^�§5þ]�7��¦E´3000��!Cn

c�¤�aq�8�O�1E´n�"@Ø÷vçIúw1²�]�^��d3

ÝI<Ø�Uc5ïçI©�ÝI§ÝI<¢SþE´÷vçIúw5½]�^

��d3ÝI<§ùÒ´�¯¥��o�kü[ïçI©��d3ÝI<4�Ý

I©���Ï"

çIúwÚçI©�¥1²�/çIúw0½/ÝI��Ö0§üö3SNþ

A���"�çIúwuÙ3c§çI©�3�"@«MF"uuÑçI©�©�

Page 164: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 153

Ú?U�N�çIúwÌ�¯�*�ÝI<����{´1ØÏ�§Ï�üö�É

¯+NØ��"�d§3çIúwuÙ�§XJ7LN�çIúw1²�Ì�¯�§

�U­#uÙçIúw"ùp§çIúw�Ì�SN§���)çI��!]�^

��¯�"

5¿§çIÝI5K¥§ÝI<´UçI©���¦?�ÝI©�§?1ÝI"

ùp�d�c§́ ÝI<A�ïçI©�â#NÝI"ÄK§ÝI<�UdÙ¦

d3ÝI<he=4§¼�çI©�?�ÝI©�"ù«he=41�3{Æþ¿

vkB�"�d§çI<�B�d3ÝI<mhe=4�§A3çIúw½ÝI�

�Ö¥²(5½§ÝI<�kïçI©�âk]�ÝI"

2.çI©�uÈ"çI©�3çIúw½ÝI��Ö1²��mÚ/:§U1

²�^�uȽe1"ù�¥§d3ÝI<³/�o^�Ú]�ï½e1çI©

�3çIúw½ÝI��Ö¥1²"

1¤çI©�Èd"¢�¥§²~ÑyçI©�ÈdÛp§Äë2000-3000��

@çI©�§½´çI©�Èd100-200�§�Ù¤NEâ]�!ã�Èd2000�-

3000��y�§4<¯'Ø®"@o§çI©�´Ä�±�ȧÙÈdõ�â´Ü

nQºÄk§çI<½çI�nÅ�3çIÝI¹Ä¥�Âô�o!Ny3=p

I�EÛ"çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä�ÂÃNy3¥I(JJ`§́ Ï`z¢yæ

(J ¼ÂÃ"çI�nÅ��nçI�8�ÂÃÌ�NyuÙÂ��çI�n

ÑÖ¤"ÃØ´çI<�´çI�nÅ�§ØA/ÏçI©��uÈ J|§Ï�

çI<ÚçI�nÅ�ÑØ´E�û"�d§çI©��±�¤+½´�ÖçI<

½çI�nÅ�<M!��ÚeM�¤�|ѧ±áÚd3ÝI<ë�ÝI¿�"

2¤çI©�ï^�"½|�´�ÊH5K´�Ã�a�Ã�À§çI©�u

È�Ø~"d3ÝI<�ïçI©�§ÃØ´�ÝI!�ÆS!�ïĽ´�

Ù¦8� �¿Ñaï§q�vk�ond�±áýÈñ�¦§�~^�ndÃ

� /́]�ØÎÜ�¦0"

I�EÛ�§́ ùp�/]�0́ �ÝI]��´�ï]�"nØþù§ùp

�/]�0A�´�/ï]�0 Ø /́ÝI]�0"ÄK§çIÝI¹Ä¥ÒØ

A�2?1]�"�"~X§,ó§�óçI�8UÝI]�"��¦²(ï^

�ÒØÎÜù�Ä�5K"T�8çIúw5½§d3ÝI<ïçI©�I�Ñ

«µ�ü 0�&¶�E��ìÚ|�Å��èy¶��ÂïÓó§�óo«��

?!S�)�yÖ¶�ISO9000@yÖ¶�[��8²ny9Ù�¡yÖ¶�±n�

9±þ�½?`�ó§yÖ���§¿Jø�@E<�c çI<¤3/ïçI

©�"ù�¥§�-��áu]�"�^�§ÃI��ïçI©��^�§Ï�\

Page 165: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

154 çIæÛYFn

­çI<éï<�]�"�§áux�Vv§��çIÝI¹Ä¥�]�"�

¯�­U§��ÝI<34�ÝI©��¦�Ù¥��§~X§�ÂïÓó§�

óo«��?yÖ�E<�§çI<½µI�¬éÙÝIÏ]�Ø÷v�¦§�

±Äû�´Úu�ƧÏ�çIúw1²Ø÷vù�^�Øä�ïçI©�]

�§ çI<®²uÈçI©��ÝI<§́ 3Ù]�÷v�¦�cJeï�ç

I©�§çI<½µI�¬q³�oéÙÝI�±Äû"�,§�±)º§̀ ]

�"��â�´ÝI©�§ØwÝI<ïçI©��J��©�"�ù«`{k

��ÙJ§Ï��¦ÝI©�3ÝI���mc4�¿�;�ÝI���mc�

A���§�,�)ÝI<3ïçI©��4��©�"

@o§A�XÛ��/ï]�0±Ba,��d3ÝI<c5ïQº¢S

þ§çI<I�(@ïçI©�´ï<ý¢¿g�L« ØU´6ÏçIÝI

¹Ä�1�" (@ï<ý¢¿g§éçI�8d3ÝI<´{<½öÙ¦|�

�§��Ñ«ü 0�&=�y²¶ég,<�§��ÙÑ«�°y�k��°y

²©�§L²Ùï¿�=�"

3.çI©�©�Ú?U"çI<éçI©��©�´AÝI<��¦ ?1�

©�½`²§́ �«�Ä1�"çI<éçI©��?U´çI<��«ÌÄ1�§

´Ùé®uÈ�çI©�¥1²¯�N�!?U�Ù¦¯��1�"ù�¥�9ü

�¯Kµ�çI©�©�Ú?U�ɯ"çI©�©�Ú?U´éçI<®uÑ�

çI©�?1�©�Ú?U§�¤çI©�§ÙɯA´®lçI<½çI�nÅ

�?¼�çI©��d3ÝI<§ÃØÙ´ÄéçI©�JѦ½¯K¶�çI

©�©�Ú?UuÑ��m"çI©�©�Ú?UA�3çI©�1²�©�Ú?

UuÑ��muѧ±¦ÝI<k¿v��mUçI©���¦?�ÝI©�"{

ÆéçI©�©�Ú?U�uÑ�mk5½�§çI©�1²�©�Ú?U�uÑ

�mA�ÎÜ{Æ5½"

[©�?U�uÑ�mØv] ,�{7L?1çI�ó§�ó�8§çI©�þ

1²�©�Ú?UuÑ�m�´3ÝI���m15FcuÑ"çI©�uÑ�§Ý

I<JÑ�çI©�I�©�Ú?U�¯�õ§çI<�¤çI©�©�Ú?U

�§å�8�mI�m=�e5F�m"�XÏmI§�åÝI<3mI�ØÝ

�§çI<3u�çI©�©�Ú?U�§�¦z�ÝI<�eÖ¡«ì§«ìÙ

k¿©�Uå§Ø¬Ï�çI©�©�Ú?U�10FuѧK�ÙÝI"3çI<

�¦��mS§ÝI<AvkUçI<��¦4�«ìÖ§vk+�çI©�©�

Ú?U§ÝI<BK���ÝI���mc1Fâ5+�"mI�§ÝI<A��d

AOp§ÝI<B��d·¥§�µI(Jú«¥§ÝI<AÚBþvk�µI�

Page 166: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 155

¬í��¥IÿÀ<"u´§ÝI<AÚB3µI(Jú«ÏS�çI<JÑÉƧ

�éçI<�EØ÷¿�1�iÒÜ�Ý�"ÝI<A�Ý�nd§́ Ù3T�8

çI¥É�çI<Øú���§=vkÂ�çI©�©�Ú?U mI¬þ�Ù

¦ÝI<)§çI<3ÝI��5FcuÑçI©�©�Ú?U§Ùþ���

;��ó�8§X��ó§¥�ëÒ�´XÚ§�¦ÙÝI���Ù¦ÝI<Ø

��¶ÝI<B�Ý�nd§́ çI<vkUçI©�1²�3ÝI���m15F

c ´35FcâòçI©�©��?Uu�ÝI<§K�Ù?�ÝI©�"ÝI

<AÚB�Ý�Ö¥§�¦k'1�iÒÜ�\ÙµI(JÃ�§çI<­#çI"

T�8iÒÅ�ÉnÝ��?LN��y§(@ÝI<A3�Y¥É�ز��

�§�(@çI©�þ1²�çI©�©�Ú?UuÑ�m´3ÝI���m15F

c çI<´35FcuÑ�§��çIÝI{5½��m§�¦çI<­#çI"

�¯¥§çI<��çIÝI{�r�55½§1�iÒÅ�@½T�8ç

I�{§�¦çI<­#çI"¢Sþ§=Bülú²!ú�Úª¢&^�½|�

´�K©Û§çI<�A�­#çI"��où�`Qº�Ï3uµ�ÝI<A�

;�L²�gçIÝI¹Ä��ú²ú��K§Ï�ÝI<AÉ�Øú²��§

Ù���çI©��Ù¦ÝI<Ø��§"�çI©��©�Ú?U§�Ï´ÝI

<AvkUçI<��¦§4�ØÏçI<�10FuÑçI©�©�Ú?U Ý�

�«ìÖ"@o§çI<´Ä�ÏdØu�ÙçI©�©�Ú?UQº�,Ø�±§

Ï�Ý�áuÝI<�Ã�o§çI<�¦ÝI<�ïÝ��áu/u�0�¦§

7,��ú²ú��½|�´�K¶�ÝI<B�Ý�§wqÙ®²«ìØÝ�§

´v¥Iq?1Ý�§��ÙØÝ��«ì§��ª¢Å&��´�K§¢KØ´"

Äk§çI<�¦ÝI<«ì�ïÙÝ��§áu/u�0�¦§��ú²ú��

½|�´�K§́ çI<��ÝI<�Ã3c§ÝI<�¥ÌÜÙ�Ã3�§�,

AÉ��o¶Ùg§çI<�¦ÝI<«ì¯�§́ çI<�¦ÝI<�ÏùXÙ

áJ�b�¯¢§=çI©�©�Ú?U´3ÝI���m5FcuÑ�ù�¯¢§

��ª¢Å&�½|�´�K"�¯¥çI<�1�§¢�þ´éçI©�©�Ú

?U�uÑ�mdçI©�1²�ÝI���m15FcN��5Fc§éu��{

7L?1çI��8§��ÝI<ØL«ÉÆ=�§ÝI<L«ÉÆ�§X�¯¥

�ÝI<A½´éu�{7L?1çI�8§çI<ù�ÄÆ��Ò��¬¯�´

�K"

çIÚÝI´éáÚ��gñ'X"çI<3çI©�5½çIÝI¯��O

(§ÝI<?�ÝI©���m�¿©!Øy�[�§3Ù¥I��k|u¢yæ

(J"��§ÝI<?�ÝI©���m�á!Øy�Ø¿©§Ù¥I�Á�C

Page 167: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

156 çIæÛYFn

êÒ��§æ(J¢yØ��U5Ò��"�d§çI<�éçI�8¤IÝ

I©��?��m§A3½|N��Ä:þÜn(½"çIÝI{Æ{5éÝIÏ

�k�¦�§3�l{Æ5½�Ä:þÜn(½"

4.çI©�ÉÆ"çI©�ÉƧ́ ÝI<9Ù|³'X<@�çI©�,

^±5½��ÙÜ{�ç�çI<JÑ?U�A^±!ÌÜÙ�Ã�¦�1�"

5¿§ÝI<9Ù|³'X<éçI©�JÑ�ÉƧ́ ÝI<½Ù|³'X<g

C@�çI©�¥�,^±��Ù�ç�¢�þ´Äý���Ù�ÃKØ

�½"ù�¥�Ø%§3uçI©�´Äý���ÝI<9Ù|³'X<��ç

©�ü«�/?nµ�çI©�SNÜ{§Ø�3��ÝI<9Ù|³'X<�Ã

¯�§=BÝI<JÑ?UçI©�,^±��¦§çI<AéÙJÑ�ÉÆ)

º½`²§�Ñ�E§ØK�çIÝI¹Ä�~?1¶�çI©��3^±��{

Æ5½��ÝI<9Ù|³'X<�Ã�/�§Ø+´ÝI<9Ù|³'X<JÑ

�´çI<gCuy�§ÑA�3çI©�©�Ú?U¥§�{é�A�{¯�?

1?U§UçI©�1²�çI©�©�Ú?UuÑ��m§u��z�¼�çI

©��d3ÝI<¶�mØv�§�Aò�ÝI���m"Ó�§çIÝI{Æ{

5éÉÆ?nk5½�§lÙ5½"

13!`²µy| t�ÝIý�¬

y| t½ÝIý�¬Ø´çIÝI{Ær�¯�"Ù¥§|�y| t��

/§3u¥I<Á��y|k'§I�Ùk�é5/Uìy|g,G¹ÚçI<J

ø^�?�ÝI©�ÝI¶ðmÝIý�¬��/§3uÝI<éçI©�½y|

g,G¹½çI<Jø�^�JÑ�õ¦Â§AO´§�3n)¹·ÚØ�§K�

ÝII�Ú��¯�"�3þã�/�§çI<A�|�ÝI<y| t!ÝIý

�¬§Ï�ÝI<é�8y|^�n)����§éçI©�^±rº��O(§

ÙÝI©�?��k�é5§�k|uÁ�¢�çI�8"� ty|ÚÝIý�

¬´çIÝI¹Ä¥§çI<|�¤kïçI©��d3ÝI<3�å�¹Ä§

k�½�|�5Ƨ�k�½�VÆ�å"�kØ&§́ uÚuÝI<Ý�"î­

�§$���çI�8�}§e¡ù��¯Ò´�~"

[ ty|��¯] ,à�UEó§�óçI§çI©�½u2012c10�12Fþ

Ì8µ303½©z2|8Ü�§c �8¤3/?1 ty|"�d§çI<SüY

|ó§�ë+Ú#ç­��ú¿©�oï|� ty|"Ù¥§ë+KIy|é�

8±>�¸!�Ï��!à�6þ!|o>.±9~cíÿ��ÝI<0�§oï

Page 168: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 157

KIÝI<�L��P!ð8Ú�ÏSü"

,ÝI<¥�� åÆ)��LÚåoï�5¿§�P��ü<�Aé§a

úéЧp\�&§uyü<k� �Ó��&Ðl"u´§ü<�U�{K=

�ù �Ó�&Ðl��þ"@ ÝI<�L�ù �&Ðl´u�§��ÿ�å

ÚY!H�!a-��"Ø�Øú¥§oïU�þù ÝI<�L"l8Ü:�þ

�n�§2��8y|§oï�¨/KØl�"���&Ðl���ÿ��õ¯§

ü<�´�ØgB�MM��§Ú5Ù¦ÝI<�L'5"

ë+´�ìp���§�Ñé­"ÝI<�LfXë+éà�r�!|o��

Ú YÏ6þ�0��§��r ÒfØ�Ù"oï�@ å�L��(§K�

åë+���ÝI<�Lf�y|�¹0�"ù�§��� ÝI<�L�²<Ñ

Ãŧ±�Û��À�òoïÚ@ å�L���|µû�e5"

ty|�§ÝI<UçI©�Ú ty|�¹?�ÝI©�§¿uÝI��

�mc4�§ë\mI"µI(Jú«�§�²¤3úi�ÝI¶á�ì§uyí

��1�¥IÿÀ<T´�oï/KØl�@ å�L¤3úi"��úi+�Ó

¿�§�²�k'1�iÒÜ�Ý�§Ó��iÅ'Þ�§���½çI<�@

 å�L¤3úi3ÝI¥Gϧ��ú�§�¦�½çIÃ� ­#çI§¿l

ÃÅpNÑ ty|�ûe�@Üì¡�y§¡¤k�|<Ñ��y§l�n�

þ����8y|§oï�@ ÝI<¥�å�L3�åk`k��§ì¡û��

ØL´Xì��§hep�Ø��w�ù ÝI<õ�çI�8&E vw�Ù¦

ÝI<§�ì¡ý¢/P¹çI<�Loï�1�¥IÿÀ<�ÙG§Ý§/w¨

è��õðD§Ø´çI<he�Ï1�¥IÿÀ<�ÝI§ù[úiqN�U�

í��1�¥IÿÀ<�0

1�iÒÜ�ÉnÝ���J§ü³�Üì¡J�½çI<�1�¥IÿÀ<

Gϧz�?n"iÅ'ÉnÞ��?1N��y§̄ oï3 ty|L§¥´

Ä�ÝI<¥�@ å�L�´!�º)�"oï`µ/´�¨�´�U§�·��

�´�&Ðl� ¯§�çI�8Ã'"0iÓ�¯µ/kyây²\�´3��

&Ðlí§'X§¹Ñ½¦<�yº0oï�f§̀ µ/@�vk"0iÅ'ίë

� ty|�Ù¦�L§�õê<y¢§ ty|@Uoï�1�¥IÿÀ<�@

 å�L�´!�º)�§/Ù�ØU2Ù0"��§iÅ'@�oï�1���

çIÝIVÆ�¦§�¦çI<éoï?12�!{§ïÆT�8­#çI"

�¯�(Û4<)¦§ØÒ´ ty|�çI<�L�ÝI<�Lõ`A

é§�U��'�m%o§�u­#çIo�çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä�OK´�

ÀÓ;§ú²!ú�/é�z� ÝI<§cÙ´3�úm|ܧù´çIÝI

Page 169: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

158 çIæÛYFn

D�çI<���VÆ�¦"ù��¦�Ly´§çI<guÑçIúw½´ÝI

��Ö�uÑ¥IÏ�Ö�m§çI<�?Û<ØU�ÝI<½Ù|³'X<�

he�>§ØU�ÂÙ"R!�¤½´Ù¦�UK�çIú�5�1�"

@o§çIÝI¹Ä¥§N�|�ÝI< ty|ÚÝIý�¬§Ù¥§qI

�5¿=¯�Qºéd§·�©ÛXe:

1. ty|"çI<3|� ty|c§I�?1e�O�µ�á�O�§�

)�PL!y|Ä:]�!êâ�Â8��n�¶�<O�§�) t|�<§0

�<!0�SNÚ;��¦!P¹<!Ú�<�¶��ÏO�§�)XÛ��y|§

<�?Ñy|�^�§±9Ê�|O��¶�y|^�O�§X t1r´�!1

r�´!)�\ó^�!�Ï^�!/þ!/eæNÔÚS��o^��¶� ty

|ë�<^�ÚVÆ�¦�"

��/§ ty|�|�§S�µ�3çI©��½�mÚ/:ð8d3ÝI

<¶�|�d3ÝI<c �8y|¶��â(½� ty|´�§0��8±>

�¸!�Ï!ø>!øY!øí!/þ/eæNÔ§±9~cíÿ�¶�d3ÝI<

ty|§J¯§çI<�|£�½P¹¶� t(å§|�d3ÝI<£�8Ü

/:"·�©Ûe¡ù�¯~§?�ÚN¬ ty|�VÆ�å"

[|� tØî>�¯~] ,ó§�óçI§½u2015c8�10FþÌ9µ003ç

I<�ú¢c2|8Ü�§çI<|�c �8¤3/ ty|"

3þÌ9µ00�§çI<Å�:¶d3ÝI<´Ä��L��8Ü/:§uyk

ü�d3ÝI<��L�v��8Ü/:"çI<3�ùü�d3ÝI<�L>{

éX�(@¦�310©¨����8Ü/:§3�Î�|d3ÝI<�§òÑu�

mò�15©¨§��|�d3ÝI<c �8y| t"

çI<U¢y5y�´�ÚO�Ð�0�SN§�Xd3ÝI<>r>0�±

>�¸!�Ï!/þ/eæNÔ�¯�§d3ÝI<Ò�'¯�JѦ¯§çI<

Å�?1©�½`²"

ty|(å�§kü�d3ÝI<Jѧþg ty|��¯�vwc[§

AO´/e+�ÚÀ>I�S��o���§F"çI<#NÙ2g ty|§¿

ÒÙ'%�¯K2g0�"çI<édL«Ó¿§35½��m§ùü�d3ÝI

<3çI<�|�e2g?1 ty|§c[P1�'Ä:êâ"

ù��¯¥§kü«1�I�?Ø"�´çI<38ÜÝI<�L�§́ Ä�

±:¶(@ÝI<´Ä��Lë\ ty|º�Y´Ä½�§Ï�çI<ù�1�

¢Sþ�³A����ÝI<&E§K�ÝI<¿�¶Ùg§çI<´Ä�±ü

Õ|�,��½,A�d3ÝI< ty|º�Y�´Ä½�§Ï�ù«1�E¤

Page 170: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 159

ÝI<éy|^�n)��ɧ�c¡�¯¥�oï1�Ã�§/¤¯¢þ�Øú

²"�d§çI<|�d3ÝI< ty|§�´L���&EØ��³¶�´D

�d3ÝI<)y|^�²��Ŭ§=�oØ|�§�o|��L��¤k

ïçI©��d3ÝI<ë\§D�Ù)y|Á�^��²�Ŭ"

2.ÝIý�¬"ÝIý�¬�8�´8¥`²çI�¦§©�ÝI<éçI©

�Úy|Á�^��¦¯"��/§çI<3|�ÝIý�¬I�?1e�O�ó

�£�PL!<O�!?U½©�¯KO�!̂ �!�ÏO�¤µ�<9©ó§�

)̱<!;�Eâ�ÑÖ<�¶�]�O�§�)ë\ÝIý�¬�PL!E

â]�Úêâ!ÝI<JÑI�çI<©�¯K�£E�¶�¬Æ|�§S¶�¬

|9m¬^�O�¶�<�?\¬|^�§±9Ê�|O��¶�¬Æë�<^�

ÚVÆ�¦�"

ÝIý�¬|����§SXeµ�\�§ó�<�P�¬<¶�0�ç

I<�¬WU¶�8¥`²çI©�k'­�¯�¶�8¥©�35½�mSd3

ÝI<ÒçI©�!y|Á�^�JÑ�¦¯¶�ë\ÝIý�¬�ÝI<�LJ

¯§çI<�|�±£E½P¹¶�\Ù5¿¯�§ÝIý�¬Æ(å"

� ty|aq§|�ÝIý�¬�kVÆ�¦§�kI�5¿�¯K"·�

k©Ûe¡ù�¯~§2?�Ú8B"

[|�ý�¬Øî>�¯~],ó§ï��8�N��çI§½u,FþÌ9:003

çI<1��ú¢o¢¬Æ¿ðmÝIý�¬"çI©�5½§ÝI<7L�<ë

\ÝIý�¬"ÄK§áÂÙÝI©�"

¬Æm©c§çI<3¬Æ¿\���\�?§�¦d3ÝI<3�Ü\�

Lþ�g\�§3e�'éX&E"

̱<\Ù¬Æ�ªm©�§�g0�çI<�¬+�!�Oü �LÚë\

¬Æ���ÝI<§d�Oü �Lé�NXÚ�O���V)50�§rN

Ù¥�EâJ:§ÌÅ�,�¶¬ý)���6CªÅ"��§dçI<�;�<

éÝI<3çI©�5½����mcÝI<JÑ�¦¯Å�?1©�"�X§

̱<�gίd3ÝI<´Ä�kI�©��¯K§¿éJÑ�¯Kd�Oü 

½çI<;�<�|©�½P¹3Y"¬ÆuþÌ12:00:(å"

ù��¯¥§kn�¯�I�?ص�´çI©�UÄ5½ÝI<7Lë\Ý

Iý�¬§ÄKáÂÙÝI©�¶�´UÄ4d3ÝI<3�Ü\�Lþ�g\�§

±93¬þÅ�ίÝI<�L´Äk¦¯I�©�¶n´�O�LUÄ3ÝIý

�¬þrN�NÌÅ�,�¶¬ý��6CªÅ"

Äk§ë\ ty|ÚÝIý�¬´ÝI<��|§=ÝI<k�ë\ ty

Page 171: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

160 çIæÛYFn

|ÚÝIý�¬§��±gÌû½Øë\ ty|½ÝIý�¬"çIÝI5K´§

ÝI<��´3ÝI���mc4�µCÎÜçI©��µ�¦�ÝI©�§ç

I<ÒA�Én§N�Ùë�ÝI¿�"�d§çI©�5½ÝI<7Lë\ÝI

ý�¬§ÄKáÂÙÝI©��5½§�³ÝI<�|§���çIÝI5K"

Ùg§4d3ÝI<3�Ü\�Lþ�g\�§±93¬þÅ�ίÝI<�

L´Äk¦¯I�©�§�³A����ÝI<¶¡9Ù&E§Ï��¡\��

ÝI<¬�¡3c¡\��ÝI<&E§�)éX�ª�§́ E¤ÝI<�m�h

e�*½GÏ1�§K�ÝI¿�"

1n§�O�L3ÝIý�¬þrN�NÌÅ�,�¶¬ý��6CªÅ§á

u�O�½¬ý!�û¯K§��5ï�ó§t�O+n^~61��Ô^5½

�§Øï�ó§kAÏõU�¦ I�½á�!��½ó²)��§�Oü Ø

��½)��½øAû"éA�§çI<XJ�É�O�L�¿�§áu±ØÜn

^���½öü½d3ÝI<�1�§¬E¤ÝI¿�Ø¿©§? K�æ(J

J`"éd§çI<A|�;�<éçI©�¤N��Oã�?1"�"XJ�

O©�þL²��NÌÅ�,�¶¬ý��6CªÅ§A�¦�Oü éÙ�O©

��{N�§¿3çI©�©�Ú?U¥§²(�ÉÙ§�û)��6CªÅª�

�NÌŧ���NÌÅ�ëê÷v�O�¦¶XJ�O©�þ¿�1²�NÌÅ

�,�¶¬ý��6CªÅ§=´�O�L3ÝIý�¬þ��<1�§çI<A

3çI©�©�Ú?U¥?�Ú�¦ÝI<UçI©���¦ÝI"7��§��

±�|Å�½´3çI©�©�Ú?U¥Å��O�L�Ø�ó`"

3.¦¯�£E�n"ÝIý�¬(å�§çI<A9��nÝI<éçI©�

½y|Á�^�JÑ�¦¯9çI<��E§�¤çI©�©�Ú?U"éÝIý

�¬þvk½´ØU9��Ñ£E�¯�§A9��k';�<�û§�Ñ��

�£��§8\çI©�©�Ú?U§3çI©�1²�çI©�©�Ú?U�u

Ñ�mc§±Ö¡/ªu�¤kïçI©��d3ÝI<"5¿§çI©�©�

Ú?Uu��§Aéu��m!/:Ú�Â<P¹§½´�¦ÝI<��Â<\i

½´æ^Ù¦�ª(@§±y²çI<Á1©�Ú?U�u�ÂÖ§y²ÝI<

Â�çI©�©�Ú?U"

[�£I] ty|,�çI<|�ÝI<é�8�¢�y|���Á�^�,�

)|/²�!±>�¸!�´!/þ!/eæNÔ!øY!ø>!øí!íÿ!<©

S��?1�y|r�!t�N�"

ÝIý�¬§́ çI<|���3©�ÝI<éçI©�Úty|¥¤JÑ

�¦¯½¯K�¬Æ"

Page 172: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 161

14!ÝIµÝI©�?��4�

ÝI´éçI��A§3�A�Ä:þ¿�§Ù�L´ÝI©�"�d§ÝI

<UçI©���¦?�ÝI©�§éçI©�¥1²�¢�5�¦Ú^��Ñ�

A§Ug�¢åÚçI©�1²�J`5K¿�§́ ÝI�Ä�OK"ù�¥§O

(rºçI©��¦§/�C�*0§@�Ó1Úg·§�½üѧ�Æ?�ÝI©

�§́ ÝI�Ä�OK"ÝI´�«�Ä1�§́ AçI�¦ ?�¿4�ÝI©

��1�§�9n�Ì�¯�§�´N�û½ÝI§�´N�?�ÝI©�§n´

N�4�ÝI©�"

1.û½ÝI" d3ÝI<3k'x0þw�çIúw½´Â�çI<�ÝI

��Ö§½´ïçI©��§N�û½´ë��´Øë�ÝIQºÝI<û½

ÝI�Ä�6uÙg�UåÚçI©���¦"��/§U±enÚ�½ÝI�ħ

L§¥k��Ø÷v�§�ïÝI½´�áçI<��"

Äk§ÝI<A3çIúw½ÝI��Ö¥ÆSçI��§�½´ÄkUåÁ

�§(@´ÄÎÜçIúw½ÝI��Ö1²�]�^�"Ó�§(ܽ|ø�G

¹§©Û¿�éç(@U�Ñ�§UçIúw½ÝI��Ö��¦ïçI©

�¶]�Ø÷v½öØU�Ñ�§ØïçI©�½´�áÝI"7��§�±>

{\ν´���çI<k'ó�<\Χ)çI�8Ä��¹§�äçI<

J`¿�"

Ùg§ÝI<AÆSçI©�¥�ÜÓ^�§(@g�¢å§=µ�;�!Eâ

]�ÚUå¶�]7!��ÚÙ¦Ô���G¹¶�+nUå¶�²�!&�Ú�A

�l�<�÷vÜÓ^��¦�§û½ÝI¶Ø÷v�§A�ï½ö�áÝI"

1n§ÝI<AÆSçI©�¥�µI�{§(@Ù¥�ÐÚ"�IO§X]

�"�IOÚ�A5"�IO9^�Ñ÷v�§û½ÝI¶k��Ø÷v�§�ï

ÝI½´�áçI<��"

ÝI<û½ÝI�ÄA��X¢¯¦´��K§ØU�k�3%n"þã�/

¥k��Ø÷v�§ØUÝI"ÄK§ÝI<�ÝI(J§�o´Ù¦ÝI<��

�§�o´±¦<¶ÂÝI§½´±Ù¦�ªáJ�b§¢�¥I"=BÙ3çIÝ

IL§¥��uy§Á���4´uy¿�±¨v"~X§5çIÝI{61Ê�o

^5½§ÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI½ö±Ù¦�ªáJ�b§¢�¥I�§¥IÃ�§

�çI<E¤���§�{«ú��I?¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"Ó�§

é�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI<kc±¤�1�ÿ��¤���§5½?¥I

�87�Z©�ʱþZ©��±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦�

Page 173: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

162 çIæÛYFn

�I?<?ü v±ê�z©�ʱþz©��±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿

?vÂ�{¤�¶�!î­�§��Ù�c�ncSë\�{7L?1çI��8

�ÝI]�¿�±úw§��dóû1�+nÅ'L�E��ì"

2.ÝI©�?�" ÝI©�A�UçI©�éÝI©��?��¦ÚJ`I

O?1?�§©O?ØXe"

£1¤ÝI©�ÐÚµ"¯�"ÐÚ"�IO¥§���)/ª"�IO!]�

"�IOÚ�A5µ"IO�¯�§ÝI©�?��§���÷vçI©���¦§

ØUk�¦"Ó�§UçI©��¦Jø�Ay²]�"

1¤/ªµ"¯�"/ªµ"�)ÝI<¶¡!ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹\iXÙ!

ÝI©��ª!ÝI��5�/ªµ"Ï�"Ù¥§ÝI<¶¡´ÝI<�E��

ì!{<Å�^èyÚ]�yÖ�y²ÝI<¬¯ÌN/ ©�þ1²�¶¡§�

ÝI<¶¡A���¶ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹\iXÙ§�ÝI¼!ÝI¼N¹Uç

I©�éÝI¼!ÝI¼N¹\i!XÙ�¦\i!XÙ¶ÝI©��ª�ÝI©

�UçI©�5½��ª?�½W�"5¿§çI©��N�ÝI<?UÝI©�

�ª�/�§ÝI<Ø�?U¶ÝI��5§�çI©��²(�ÂÝI<4��

ÀÝI�§��ÝI<�U4��°k��ÝI©�"ë\éÜNÝI�§ÝI<

Ø�2±gC¶ÂüÕ½\\Ù¦éÜN3�çI�8¥ÝI§ÄK��'ÝIþ

�"

[ÝI¼UÄ��¯] ,�8çI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{5½§ÝI©���

ªA÷vçI©�18Ù��ª�¦"Ù¥§5½ÝI<?�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹

�§=#N3Ù¥���?W��ASN§Ø�?U",ÝI<?�ÝI©��§@

�Ù¥�¦«ì�¯�§=/X·�¥I§·�«ì3Â�¥IÏ�Ö�§�3¥

IÏ�Ö5½�Ï�S�\�\¾ÜÓ¶�3\¾ÜÓ�Ø�\�JÑN\^�¶

�UìçI©��¦J�Á��y7¶�3ÜÓ�½�Ï�S�¤ÜÓ5½��Ü

ÂÖ0¥§UçI©�J�¥I7�10%�Á��y7482.00����¦§ú���

p"u´§TÝI<34��ÝI¼¥íØù��¦§=«ìo��¦¥�ü

�§=/X·�¥I§·�«ì3Â�¥IÏ�Ö�§�3¥IÏ�Ö5½�Ï�

S�\�\¾ÜÓ¶�3ÜÓ�½�Ï�S�¤ÜÓ5½��ÜÂÖ0§µI�

¬uy�§@�TÝI<�UçI©�²(Ø#N?U��ª¯�§��çI

<�|§éÙÝI�±Äû"

2¤]�µ"¯�"é]�"�Ï�§ÝI<3(@÷v]�"�Ï��¦�

cJe§ÝI©�ANk�4<&Ñ�y²]�½á�"~X§,çI©�éÝI

<¬¯ÌNJÑ��¦ /́ä�k��E��ì!|�Å��èyÚS�)�N�

Page 174: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 163

y0"�d§ÝI<I�3ÝI©�¥y²Ù¬¯ÌN�°§JøE��ì!|�Å

��èyÚS�)�N�y�E<�¿\XúÙ"5¿§ùp�/k�0´�ÝI

<�¬¯ÌN]�k�§vk?u�I-Ê�!Ê�§ÝI]�!S�)�N�y

�6�½L�§]��vv!È(!�+½»�G��"

3¤�A5µ"¯�"éÐÚ"�IO¥1²�¢�5�¦Ú^�§XçI�

�!Á�Ï�!�þIOÚ�¦!ÝIk�Ï!ÝI�y7��¦ÝI�A�Ï�§

ÝI©�¥7L�Ѳ(�A§=��Ó¿¿Nk4çI<&Ñ�`²½Á�|�

�Y"5¿§é¢�5�¦Ú^���AØU�ò�§ØU3ÝI©�Ù¦/�½

´Á�^±¥O\�^�§�¦çI<Jø�^�½´�¦�â�A"ÄK§

Ò´��A§çI<�±��áýÙÝI"

éÐÚ"�IO¥1²�k� � lÏ�½�I§ÝI lA�ÎÜçI©

�1²� l��ÚÌÝ"�Ñ ���½�p ��ê�ÝIò�Äû"

£2¤ÝI©��[µ"¯�"�["�IO´ÝI¿��J`IO§ÝI<I

UÙ¥�µ"Ï�§Xd�!Á�|�!ûÖ^��©Û�`ÝI:½�`��§�

½ÝIüÑ"

1¤ÝI�düÑ"ÝI�dAkU�[µ"IO1²�çI��!O¤IO

Ú�dºX�SN§±9ÝI<�¢å�O�çI�8d�§2UçI©�1²�

d�énÜüSëþ�K�?1ûü"~X§�çI©��¦�dØ�L1²��

pÝI�d�§O��çI�8d�A3�p�dS"�L�§ÝI©�Aæ�k

���ü$Á�¤�§±¦ÝI©�¥1²�ÝI�dØ�L�pÝI�d¶�ç

I©�æ^²µ"�ÝIdüS�§Aæ�k���4�/ü$Á�¤��§\þ

�$|d�ÝI�d¶�çI©�æ^nܵ©üS�§�d±K�CµIÄOd

�`"Ù¥§µIÄOdæ^k��d�²þêO��§I�±O�Ñ�çI�8

d�!�c\È�¿�éÃ�dª³½­�§(Ü1�S�d5ÆnÜÿ�§��

±ýÿ�µIÄOd-1%�0%�m�O�d"~X§çI�8�ý�d�´100�

�§1�S�d5Æ´3ý�dÄ:þe28%§¿�éÃ�²þd�Uýÿ­�

´98��§KÝI��±

(100 + 98)/2× (1− 9%) = 90.09��(100 + 98)/2× (1− 8%) = 91.08�

�¨"µIÄOdæ^k��d��$�d�§ëìþ¡1�«�/¶�üS5K

´3üSëþÄ:þU/$d`k0üS�§ëìþ¡1�«�/§3ØK�üS

ëþ�`Ä:þ¦þü$ÝI�d�"

2¤�*µ"Ï�"�*µ"Ï�§=O�ÙüSëþ�IO´�*�§́ kÚ

Ã�'X"~X§,ú´ó§�óçI©�é�8²nµ©IO�/�8²nµ�

Page 175: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

164 çIæÛYFn

äkú´ó§;���±þÆ{!p?ó§��¡�1©¶ú´ó§;�;�Æ{

½ó§��¡�0.5©§Ù¦0©¶�CÊc���8²nz|�¢�L1�Óaó§

�1©§�p3©0Ò´�*µ"Ï�"ÝI<[��8²n¼�ù4©�^�´µ�

[��8²nA´ú´ó§;��p?ó§�§ÝI©�INkT�8²nú´ó

§;��Æ{yÖÚp?ó§��¡yÖ¶�C5cS���8²n|�Óaó§

n�±þÁ��1"5¿§çI©��¦�´���8²n��1"�d§I3Ý

I©�¥NkÙ���8²n|�¢��ÜÓ©�£E<�¤§±9y²Ù´Ù�

8²n�©�§XÜÓ;^^±!eó�ÂÖ!̂ ry²!ÝI<<¯Ü�Ñä�

�8²n?·©��"

[�¡Eb��¯] ,ó§�óçI�8§çI©�1²�é�8²n�¡�µ

©IO�/p?ó§��§2©¶ó§��¡�§1©¶Ïnó§�9±e�¡�§0

©0"µIL§¥§µI�¬uy,ÝI<[��8²n��¡yEb"T�8

²n��¡¢Sþ´ó§�§Ï��¡yÖþX�<Ù /́¥?�¡µ"�¬0§

�Ù�¡�9K�Ùw«�/p?ó§�0§ØÎÜ�¡µ½�¦"µI�¬@

½TÝI<ÝI�3�¿Eb1�§ÄûÙÝI"

3¤Ì*µ"Ï�"Ì*µ"Ï�§=dµI�¬�âÙ;�!Æ£Ú²�?

1�ä�ѵ"(Ø�Ï�"~X§ÝI©�¥tj�!�O�Y!in�j!�

ó|��O!øÀ!ÑÖ�Y�"Ì*µ"Ï��µIIOJ±þz�ا=´�

Ñ�?IO§X`D!ûÐ!Ü�!ØÜ�½´A!B!C!D!E�?§éA�?�Ñ

üSëþ§X©ê���½IO"?�Ì*µ"Ï�éA�ÝI©�§I�ÝI<

ÆS!ݺ1�Eâ!ÑÖk?Y²ÚÝI©�Ðy/ª§=�(n)çI©�¥

/`D0½/A�0�Sº§UçI©��¦§k�é5/?�ÝI©�"7��§Ý

I<�­�1�;[½´µI;[?1?���"

Ì*µ"Ï�éA�ÝI©�?�¢Sþ´�¦ÝI<3ÝI¥Ðy1��

k?EâÚk?�{§I�ÝI<±Yݺ§Øä�#"

4¤ÿÁÝI"UçI©�1²�µIIO§ÿÁÝI(J"éÝI(JÿÁü

Sá��§�©Û�Ï"Ù¥§Ì*µ"Ï����§|�;�åþ?�ÚïÄ�

[µ"IO§U?ÝI©���A¯�¶�*µ"Ï����§¢¯¦´/ïÄ´

Ä�±æ���ÖÍ"ÖÍؤ½´vkÖÍ���§�U�ïÝI"

£3¤ÝI©��ÑÑ"ÝI©��Ñѧ�9ÝI©��ª!�<!\iXÙ!

C¾�¯�"

1¤ÝI©���ª"ÝI©�AUçI©�1²�ÝI©��ªÚ�¦?1

?�"Ù¥§#Ng½�ª�§ÝI<A±�SUªW��ª�O¶Ø#NUĽ

Page 176: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 165

N��§ÝI<AUçI©��¦3#NW�ÝISN�/�W�§Ø�é�ª¥

�?Û¯�?1N�½íU"

2¤ÝI©�\iXÙ"ÝI©�A^ØñÚ�á�Ö�½�<"çI©�5½

\Tü Ù�§3�ª5½?\Xü Ù¶5½ÝI<d{½�L<\i�§Ad

{½�L<�<\i§ØUd\X{½�L</\¶Ù0�O§�ØUd¦<�\§

Ø��ª¥²(�±N�dÇ��n<\i§d�AN{½�L<Ç��÷Ö"Ý

I©�ÑyæU!1m�i½íØ�UÄ�§UÄ�?AdÝI<�{½�L<½

ÙÇ���n<\i½Xü Ù"

ÝI©����°§B�d��E<§°ê�çI©�1²�êþ�O"��

ÚB��µ¡mþ�þA�Ù/IP/��0½/B�0�i�§3µ¡þ\XÝI

<ü Ù!{½�L<½Ç��L\i"

3¤ÝI©�C¾"ÝI©�����B�A©OC¾§¿?�8¹"8¹?ü

±µ"Ï�k�gS�O"��/§ÝI©�8¹�AG�ÜJ«L§1²éA]

�µ"Ï�!�A5µ"Ï��]�ÚÝI©��è"Ù¥§Ì*µ"Ï�Ü©�

ÝI©�§A±Ì*µ"Ï�k�gS?8"çI©��¦ÝI©�©þ�§~X

�¦/ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹!ûÖ©�ÚEâ©�©mC¾0�§ÝI©�¥�Ý

I¼9ÝI¼N¹!ûÖ©�ÚEâ©�I©þC¾§UçI©��¦©O��µ

¡§µ¡þ\XÝI<ü Ù§{½�L<½Ç��L\i"

3.ÝI©�4�"ÝI©�A3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc§UìçI©

�5½��µ�¦µC�4�"

1¤ÝI©��µCÚI£"ÝI©�AUçI©���¦©��µ§¿3µ@

�µ�?\XÝI<ü Ù§d{½�L<½ÙÇ��L\i§µ@�¡\bI£§

XçI�8£Iã/I�¤¶¡!çI�8?Ò!çI<!çI�nÅ�¶¡!3,

c,�,F,�,©,¦£ÝI���m¤cØ� µ�¯�"

2¤ÝI©��4�"ÝI©�A3çI©�1²�ÝI���mcÚ4�/

:x�çI<½çI�nÅ�"?U½�£®4�ÝI©��§ÝI<A3ÝI�

��mcÖ¡Ï�çI<½çI�nÅ�§UçI©���¦\i½XÙ"Ù¥§

?U�ÝI©�A­#UìçI©��5½?1?�!�µÚIP§I²/?U0

i�§O��AÜ©�ÝI©�§3ÝI���mc4�§±��ÝI©��|¤

Ü©"

çI<½çI�nÅ��ÝI<ÑäÝI©�\³y§1²ÝI©�µCÚ

I£G¹�§ÝI<Aþõ��"7��§�3ÝI©�4��éÝI©��µC!

I£�¹ûì§P¹ÝI©�µC4���G¹"

Page 177: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

166 çIæÛYFn

15!Y~µçIÝI|�Ø�Úu��}

çIÝI¹Ä´��î>�|�ó�"çIÝI|�§S§́ çI<UçIÝ

I5K§|�çIÝI¹Ä�9���ó�gS½Ü6'X§́ çI<I?�Ny"

Ó�§çIÝI|�§S�´¢yçIæ(J�|��æ"çI<3|�L§¥§

ó�o{��!Ü6'X·Ï½´��{Æ{5�'5½�§�ö��Q½�çI

æ8IÃ{¢y½´IO\çI<I?âU¢yæ(J§­ö��çIæ�

} I­#*yçIæÔѧ­#|�çIÝI¹Ä"ù�¥§çIÝI{Æ{

5¥5½�r�¯�§çI<3|�çIÝIL§¥7L�l"éA�§çI©�

3{Æ{5Ä:þ§UçI�8A:ÚæI¦O\�¯�´çI</x�çi0

�ÝI<«ì�¯�§A��l§çI<Ø�l½ö��çI©�1²5K�§4

´ÚuÝI<�Ý�§$�çIæ�}"

[Y�£�] ,p�ú´ï�k�úi|�`/�¯/�^p�ú´ï��8§

�V�8��§oÝ]�18·�"Tp�ú´ï�k�úiæ^úmçI�ª(½

ó§�ó«�ü §æ^�|�§SÚL§¥Ñy�¯�Xeµ

£1¤uÙçIúw"2018c10�8F§çIúw3Ùè��ÕþuÙ§Dý¿�

>{��IS�Ͷ�ú´�óè�§�¶ë�çI¶

£2¤?�çI©�"çI©�?��¤�§çI<���S;[Úü[�¶

ë�ÝI�d3ÝI<"�(@¶

£3¤uÈçI©�"2018c10�10F§çI<��¶�d3ÝI<uÈçI©

�§çI©�d��100�/@§ã�3000�/@§È�Øò"Ó�§�¦ïçI©

��§J�50%�ÝI�y740��"5½ÝI<ïçI©�ØÝI�§ÝI�

y7Øò�¶

£4¤ ty|"2018c10�15FÚ16F§çI<©ü1|�ïçI©��d

3ÝI< t�8y|¶

£5¤ÝI��"2018c11�2FþÌ10:00:c§çI<3½ú�] �´¥%

�ÂÝI©�"Ù¥§d3ÝI<AïçI©���3ÝI���mc4�ÝI

©�§ÝI<B�UçI©��¦2018c11�1FeÌ4:00c4�ÝI�y7 ´3

mIy|4�§éÙÝI©�§çI<Ø�Én¶

£6¤mI"2018c11�2FþÌ10:00:�§çI<3çI©�5½½ú�]

�´¥%n¢1�mI¿|�mI"Ù¥§ÝI<C�{½�L<�ë\mI¬§ç

I<éÙÝIØ� µ¶

£7¤µI"2018c11�2FeÌ1:30§�{|ï�µI�¬UçI©�5½�

Page 178: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 167

µIIOÚ�{§é²dmI��ÝI©�?1µ"§(½Ü�ÝI¶ü§æ^�

ÅÄ��ª(½Ü�ÝI�nÜüS§J`í�cn¶�¥IÿÀ<¶

£8¤ÝI�y7ò�"2018c11�4F§çI<�ÝI<ò�ÝI�y7"Ù

¥§ÝI<A!B!CïçI©���ÝI§Ù50%�ÝI�y740��Ø�ò�¶

£9¤\¾ÜÓ"2018c11�5Få§çI<�ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<?1ÜÓ

d�!�§V���Ó¿3ÝI�dÄ:þ§2`¨50��¶

£10¤uÑ¥IÏ�Ö"2018c11�12F§çI<�ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<u

Ñ¥IÏ�Ö§Ùþ1²�¥Id�´1�¥IÿÀ<�dÄ:þe250����

d�"

T�8çI�§úiA!BÚC�1�iÒÜ�Ý�"úiA!B!CÝ�ÚÞ��

�¦§́ ò�úiA!B!C�ÝI�y7!�½çIÃ�§�¦çI<­#çI"1

�iÒÅ�²�\N�§(@çI<3|�çIÝI¹Ä¥�{�K�¥I(J§

�¦çI<­#çI§ò�¤Â��úiA!B!C�ÝI�y79ÓÏ�±|E"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±en�¯Kµ

1.�YçIÝI|�§SSü�3=¯K§��oº

2.�YçIÝI|�L§¥�3=¯K§��@�K§��oº

3.�YéçI<|�çIÝI¹Äk=é&§��oº

[Y~©Û] �âY�£ã§éþãn�¯K�©ÛXe:

1.�Y3|�§Sþ�3ü?�ص�´11Ú�12Ú'X� "çIúw´

�d3ÝI<w�§çIÝI¹ÄéÄ!çI©�ï�mÚ/:§±9ÝI��

�m�¯��w«§�k�çI©�§=çIÝI5KÚ��OySü(½§âU

uÙçIúw§w�d3ÝI<çIéÄ�mÚ^��"�d§çIúwuÙA3

çI©�?��¤�?1¶�´18Ú!19ÚÚ110Ú§=µI!ÝI�y7ò�!

uÑ¥IÏ�ÖÚ\¾ÜÓ�'X·Ï"µI�¤�§çI<A�µII�¬�

¤�Ö¡µI�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<(½¥I<§�Ù\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§2�g5

ò£¥I<ÚÙ¦ÝI<�ÝI�y7§±9±y7�ªJ��ÝI�y7�ÓÏ

Õ1�±|E§Ù�(�Ü6'XA�µI→uÑ¥IÏ�Ö→\¾ÜÓ→ÝI�y7ò�"ÄK§¥I<Ø�çI<\¾Ü½´\¾ÜÓ�JÑçI<ØU�É

�^�§��Ù¥I]��§ÏÝI�y7®ò�§é¥I<vk��§Ãl�o

çI<�Ã"

2.�YçIÝI|�L§¥�3¯K�¯�©ÛXeµ

¯�1. T�8��{7L?1çI�ó§ï��8§A�ÏLI[�½��

r!&E�ä½öÙ¦x0uÙ"5¿§5çIúwÚú«&EuÙ+n�{6£I

Page 179: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

168 çIæÛYFn

[uÐU��2017 c-110Ò¤§��8çIúwA�3/¥IçIÝIú�ÑÖ

²�0½ö�8¤3/�?>fçIÝIú�ÑÖ²�þuÙ§Tp�ú´ï�k

�úi�è��ÕØ´I[�½�uÙ�{7L?1çI�8�çIúwx0"

¯�2.�<¯ç­ØÓ§ÝI<ë�çI�8ÝIÒ´UçIúw½ÝI��

Ö5½��m!/:Ú^�ïçI©�§vkÝI�¶�`"

¯�3.çI©�?��¤�§çI<��ü[�¶ë�ÝI�d3ÝI<"�

(@Øþ§Ï�çI©�´çI<uÑ����úw�[z§çI<ÃI3çIú

wuÙ�2�¦ÝI<�¿�§éÙ¦ÝI<k�ú#"XJçI<@�çIÝI

¹ÄÜ©¯�§XEâIOÚ�¦!ÜÓ^��I��¦d3ÝI<¿�§A�´

3çIÝI¹ÄO��ã§=çIúwuÙc�¦Ù¿�"

¯�4. çI<uÈçI©��§ã�Èd3000�/@�È�Øò§�¦ïç

I©��§J�ÝI�d50%�ÝI�y7§5½ÝI<ïçI©�ØÝI�§Ý

I�y7Øò�Øþ"Äk§çI<�ÂÃNy3J`Ø3uçI©�uÈ"=B

´uÈçI©�§ÙÈd�Û�uÖ�çI©�<M!��ÚeM�¤�|Ñ"Ù

¥§ã��UVÂÙ7§=3¯�ÝI<ò�ã��§çI<Aò�Ùã�Ù7¶

Ùg§û½ÝI�Ä´d3ÝI<��|"ÝI���mc§ÝI<Ñ�±4�!

Ö¿!?U½´�£ÝI©�§ ÝI�y7��ÝI©��|¤Ü©§3ÝI�

��mcÑ�±4�"�d§çI<�¦ÝI<ïçI©��J�50%�ÝI�

y7§��ÝI<�|"�A/§5½ÝI<ïçI©�ØÝI�§ÝI�y

7Øò�§�{��ÝI<�|"��8çI�}���pϧT´çI<Øò

�A!B!C�ÝI<40��ÝI�y7¤�"

¯�5.çI<©ü1|�ïçI©��d3ÝI< ty|Øþ§Ï�çI

<Ã{�yÙ3 ty|�D4�d3ÝI<�çI&E��"

¯�6. ÝI<B3mIy|4�ÝI�y7§çI<±ÝI<B�UçI©�

�¦�32018c11�1F£mIc�F¤eÌ4:00c4�ÝI�y7§éÙÝI©�

çI<ØÉnØþ§Ï�3ÝI���mc§ÝI<Ñ�±4�!Ö¿!?U½´

�£ÝI©�§ù´ÝI<��|"

¯�7. mI�§ÝI<C�{½�L<�ë\mI¬§çI<éÙÝIØ�

µØþ§Ï�çI<®Én§A�é®Én�ÝI©��¯ µ"Ó�§ÝI<ë

\mI´Ù¬¯�|§=���§�¡Ù¦ÝIúm¯�ÚiÒ�§iÒmIL§

Ü{5�Ny"5¿§¬¯�|�{�±Ìܽ�ï"�d§çI<�¦ÝI<7

L��Lë\mI§��ÝI<¬¯�|§5½ÝI<{½�L<7Lë\mI

¬§ÄK§Ø µÙÝI©���{§��3ÝI���mcÉn�ÝI©�Ñ

Page 180: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

17ÙçIæµçIÝI�|� 169

A�¯�± µÚ\Ö�5K"

¯�8. çI<ò�ÝI�y7�§Øò�ÝI<A!B!C4��50%�ÝI�

y740��Øþ§�¯�4¥�©Û"5¿§çI<Øò�ÝI<�ÝI�y7��

�u{Æ5½�/§=ÝI���ÝI<��ÝI©�§½¥I<Ã��ndØ�

çI<¾áÜÓ§3\¾ÜÓ��çI<JÑN\^�§½´¥I<ØUçI©�

�¦J�Á��y7�"

¯�9.çI<�ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<?1ÜÓ\¾�§V���Ó¿3ÝI

�dÄ:þ2`¨50����{Øþ§Ï�çI<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ��K´Uç

I¯¢§=çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�¾áÖ¡ÜÓ§Ù`¨50�

���d�§QØáuçI©�§�ØáuÝI©���Æ"�Ydu´3uÑ¥

IÏ�Öc§çI<�ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<?1ÜÓ!�§Ù1���ú²ú�

�½|�´�K§��5çIÝI{61o�n^5½§=çI<3(½¥I<c§

Ø��ÝI<ÒÝId�!ÝI�Y�¢�5SN?1!�§!�K�¥I(J�§

¥IÃ�"

¯�10.¥IÏ�Ö1²�¥Id�´1�¥IÿÀ<�dÄ:þe250��

��d�Øþ§Ï�¥IÏ�Ö´«ì§´çI<�ÉÝI<�ÝI�¿gL«"

ù�§Uì5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozl�l^5½§çI<3¥IÏ�Öþ«ì�

SNA��¥I<�ÝISN��"Ó�§çI<é¥I<�ÝI�ÜÓI�!ê

þ!�þ!d±½ö�Å!Á1Ï�!Á1/:Ú�ª!��I?Ú)û�Æ�{�

C��§Ø´«ì ´#��§��çIÝI5K¥§�g��!�g«ì�5

K§�³¥I<�Ã"ù� 5́¬{;61ÔzÊ�n5½§½�p<¬{�5'

u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�)º£�¤6({º12018220Ò)

1�^§5½�¯<\¾�ï�ó§�óÜÓ�çI©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ�Ö

1²�ó§��!ï�óÏ!ó§�þ!ó§d±Ø���§���¯<�¦òç

I©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ�Ö��(�ó§d±��â�§<¬{�A�|±�

�Ï"

3.�YéçI<|�çIÝI¹Ä�é&´§çI©�´çIæ�¦�Ö¡

Ny§|�çIÝI¹ÄK´çIæ�¦�¢�§́ d�¡üyr�¢N¢��

L§"�lçIÝI5K§¢yçIæ(J�`z´��"

1¤�lçIÝI5K"çIÝI���«½|�´5K§É�«�¬1�5

�§X©z!S�!��!VÆÚ{Æ�5���å"ù�¥§{Æ´3�����

?§́ .�§́ 3Ù¦�¬1�5�Ã��§æ^I[�åé�'1���å"ç

IÝI´�«½|�´5K§ù«�´5KNy3çI©�¥§=çI©�3�l

Page 181: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

170 çIæÛYFn

©z!S�!��!VÆÚ{Æ��¬1�5�Ä:þ§UçI�8A:ÚI¦§�

¾çIÝI5K§J`(½çIæ(J"ÃØ´�¾çIÝI5K�´|�3ç

IÝI¹Ä§�l{Æ5K´çIÝI�Ä���¦§́ `z¢yçIæ(J�

cJ"

2¤̀ zçIæ(J"̀ zçIæ(J§�´Ö¡üy§=çI©�1²�

J`IO´²LÆ¿Âþ�J` Ø´r/ª!rL|½�iZ¶�´|�ÝI¿

�§Ï�¿�´çI<¼�ÂÃ�cJ§�´J`¢yçIæ(J�cJ"�d§

çI<I��m%�§�/� ØE0Ø�´\Ù��ÝIÃ�§Ï�3êÆþé

N´y²§õ��ÝI<ë�¿��ÀJ(J§�½Ø'�����"@o§ùp

�/� ØE0q´�o¿gQ§́ ÝIØ÷væI¦§=]�½´Á�UåØ

÷v!Ø÷vçI�8¢�5�¦Ú^�½´ÝIØ´�` ´he<�ö�½´

ØKI4Ù¤��`ÝI�¿g"

Page 182: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 8Ù

çIæµmI�|�

**********************************************************************

''WЧ3à�³¶��Ôå§�fÐÆ"

—5�²-'W6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 183: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

172 çIæÛYFn

11!mIµimùXÞ��á@

mI�Î�(´¤ªþ§#Jim#hÞþ�ùXÞaq§́ méÖ¡ÝI©

�§=ÝI�I�L§"ù�¥§mI�/m0i§%¹XÝI7L´�µÝI"ù

�y�´r¤ª/r§S!rL|0§§S�¡�®�(J§"yZ�Ú �aØ

Ó§Î�Iå´� /́I1�·!xð�ó0§im#hùXÞ��á@c§I�U

Ø��#h´{´Î§å�UØ��#J´d´�§Dpæ/r�´r¤ª"�

uE²{νd�§@�k3´r¤ª�§#JÚ\´�§im#hÞþ�ùXÞ

/V8o"0âU�¡§�d�®/n8Ê~0r¤§=B#h´�Îl%½#J´

�����U%@§Ï�´Ó®5(�¤"�´ù�:§��©Æ�¬Ã��Ñ

��m§üÌÑ@E <���¯"

[�?�ì] � 5̀ù¢�6¥§_��Ú�?��pméO��§�Ø�-<

¹6§�è<����ò\��¤�0â�§��¹ë��kØM8§́ <�Dw

Ø®�O��¯§́ 5ù¢�6�a<�|µ�x"_��Ú�?�Ø´%�p¤

o§No´�|�ìQº́ /I1�·!xð�ó0Ú/K�0��Ô"

5ù¢�6́ ù�£��§`´_����¾X§¾�³³���§�£Ø�

Ч_1éoXé�f_�`§·�F§Q6,TO�<�����·§ùk)

��Ð(§̀ �����7·�<�ɦ§�ÀÀUâЧØ,�ù·�Ø4"_

��X`§P����¦¤[´A��§æk_P��ØD¦�n"_1���§

`1½��ù¾�U­q�U§NoкU´�S�¥�Bæ!̄ ¶!B3!Bæ!

�Ï!�H�8Ü­�n�½5Ø9§��»~5"_1�X`§��¾X§�Ø�

�¦¤�§ØL´ÀÀU§·�ü[�¿§̄ f�qk7�����n§́ ´Ø^

Ü�§=�]ÐFf§UX4�[©�Lr"`X]���Ff§�WZ��Ñ

Ø^§Uûp��f§̂ ��éJ�§l<�f�5§ìH>5Ý~,§���K

gá§Ò�´��"_1q`§�l�VØ^�§�Ø^ü6R§���ЧL

õѧ2{R�<"

No4_���¿Q§�ÚÂÑ�Ì¿§æ /̂K�0��{"_1¯NoK

�º�ÚÂ`§Ø+�73²xزx§�[�3å5§̀ ´P��Ìò��hN

�¦§y¦� ��"�´¦Ø+Ø��§ù���Ø^K"e´¦kU

��¿g§Ò��¤±ò"u´§1�U§�Ú¯@�§�ÁÁ_��§r?

Page 184: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 173

pmé_��`§öå�73�U§P�®J3F��\��"̀ �\��~~

ÐØЧ_����X"�ÚÂßØߦ%g§q`P�`\Ðâ�\��~~

Q§e�´ùoä§Ø�\�"_���Ú`§·Ø䧷�yy�~~§�¦�

%"�ÚÂ��aÉ4_��`§�~~@��§̈ g,³@§Ø��\�"

é_���´rL§§5ù¢�6́ ù���µ�����l��?5§[p[

WHÑ�§��éû�üX?5"Þ��#<Ñ�§_���#<�XùXÞ§U

h2XùÉX"Þ�7r~U/§�Ñ_1~o~§q�Ñ_�ÅO�,§1r

.§x\É�"�k�Kgá�¯§è´U7)Î~"_�Ï�_1�Ì�_��´

�§Øc��§Ø&ÀU�`"_��käí§r�#<c`§~~кÐU

Ø�§XXùùXÞ��o��ÃÒ��mùXÞ§r@�_1:�Ñ��e

ƧaÑÃ��"_�����§S%U¥Ø4§þc�mùXÞ§ ú�w§

Ð�´Å�s§%pØ&§gC�ñ�§�ÃÞú§�w§�Ø´Å�so�_�

�ww¯Q<§�3@p�{<�´X"Q<`´��h"_��¯��hQ§Q

<`P��Ì4\��´��h§Ø´��h"_���f§æ��x³§�

�((��é�~~�§�X¡��Ù§.XQ<�á�§�**No5�§·

P�P�´�·��~~§No�¤�**�d���?�3,�mÂp@®´

·3�I§%���X��!���§{v`�§Büú��§� /́�µ�Ã�º

ѧÉXn�\��0"

mI§aquÎ�´r¤ª(å�im#hfùXÞ��á@§ØLÎ�´r

¤ª¥§�k� #hf"_��imùXÞ§uy#hfØ´�?� ´Å�s§

Ø�¿��UL\��"çIÝI¹Ä¥kõ�ÝI<ë�ÝI§mI´éÙÝI

�Ì�¯��±úm§4¦<�¡"

1.mI�õ^"mIÒ´méÝI§́ /úm0�K�Ny§́ UçI©�5

½�mI�I�úm�¯�§XÝI<¶¡!ÝId�ÚçI©�5½�Ù¦Ì�

SN�?1úm"çIÝI¥§ÝI¿�´ïá3ÝI�5z�Éþ�¿�§mI

�¢�§́ òÝI&E�ë�<úm§çI�8�kI.�§úÙI."mIL§

A�P¹¿����"��/§mI��^Ì�Ny3ü��¡µ

1¤���"aqu´r¤ªþ�¯�l§mIë�<Ï�GÝI&E �yÝ

I"ù�¥§ÝI&E�úm´ë�<�����æ§ÝI<3dÄ:þâUéç

I<(½�¥I<?1iÒ§́ rçIÝI¹Ä�u�1e§(�çIÝIú²ú

�/?1�cJ"

2¤iÒ�"1�Ü��{1�§éçIÝI¹Ä¢�iÒ§�{�?�{1�§

cJ´{ÆÇ�1�Ü�éçIÝI¹Ä?1iÒ§=5çIÝI{6��3"¢

Page 185: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

174 çIæÛYFn

Sþ§çIÝI���«½|�*²L¹Ä§éçIÝI�k��iÒØ´5gu

1�iÒ§ ´çIÝI¹Ä���ë�<§=çI<�gÆÚÝI<�iÒ§a

q´r¤ªþ�¯�l�y"Ù¥§ÝI<émI�iÒÌ�Ny3n��¡§�

´çI<´ÄUçI©�5½�§S?1mI¶�´çI<´ÄUçI©�5½�

¯�mI§́ Äé5½�¯��±úÙ¶n´mIL§¥§çI<´Ä3ÝI��

�m��3#NÝI<��?UÝI©����çIÝI5K�1��"

2.mIë�<"çIÝI¹Ä�|�ö´çI<§mI�Ø~§dçI<U

çI©�5½��mÚ1²�/:̱"

1¤mI̱"ùp§mI̱´KIݺ½?n§Ì±mIù��L§�¿g§

dçI<���ó�<KI§�)mI̱<!�I<!P¹<�§UçI©�

5½�mI§SÚ¯�§?1ÝI©�� µ!\ÖÚP¹§|�mI¹Ä§�Â

ÝI<�ÉÆ¿�|�E�¯�"��/§mIó�<¿ØI�Ñ«çI<��

�©�§��UUçI©��5½§SÚ¯��¤mI=�§́ �*úÙÝI&E

�|µ§Ï�mIL§¥Ø�3çI<�Ì*Ly§Ó�§ÝI<3�çI<�ϧ

ïçI©�!ë\ ty|!ÝIý�¬�L§¥§ATU�ä�ó�<´Ä

�çI<��§ù´mIL§¥��¿Ø�¦ó�<Ñ«çI<��Ö��Ï"

2¤ÝI<�L"ÝI<ë�mI§�´��Ù¦ÝI�¹¶�´iÒmIL

§"¤±§mI�,dçI<̱§�%´3ÝI<iÒe?1�"�d§ë\mI

�ÝI<�L§ÒØA=´��§ ´�U�LÝI<ë�¿iÒmIL§"�d§

ÝI<�Lë\mI§A±kÝI<{½�L<��÷Ö!�<�°y²§±�L

ÝI<ÌÜ�Ã"~X§��ÝI�d½´çI<N��gÝI�d§3mIL

§�ÉÙ¦ÝI<��!?UÝI©��§�I(å�§ÝI<k��çI<J

ÑÉƧ�¦çI<�|�E§3mIP¹þ\i(@"��/§ë\mI�ÝI

<�L�UØ´�< ´õ<§ÝI<�L;�{½�L<Ç��÷Öþ1²�@

�ÝI<ó�<§Ù¦<¿Øäk�LÝI<ÌÜ�Ã�/ "�d§�,Ý

I<k�ÑRmI§��±gÌû½Øë\mI§�Ùë\mI�±�{ÌÜÙ�

çØë\mIÒI�ïÙAk�ç̄ �ØU2ÌÜÙmI��Ã"

3¤Ù¦ë�<"Ù¦ë�mI�<¥§�a´iÒ<§±1�iÒ<

�̧çI<���Vu!i<Ú�¬iÒ�9"Ù¥§1�iÒ<´Ä

�mIy|iÒd1�iÒ<gÌû½¶1�a´Ù¦<§�)ÝI<�Ñ�

vk{½�L<Ç��÷Ö�<ÚçI<­��Ù¦<§XxNPö�"��

çI�8�mI#N=<ë\§́ Ä#Nûì!��½´1n<*��§dçI

<3çI©�¥½´\ÙmIVÆ�²("��/§çI<���ó�<ÚÝI

Page 186: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 175

<�L´mIA�ÑR<§�=BXd§ÝI<��±gÌû½Øë\mI"Ù

¦<´Ä�±ë\½´I�ë\mI§dçI<û½"

3.mI�µI¥I"'umI§�I�?Ø�§́ mI�µI½¥I�'X¯

K"¢Sþ§mIÒ´UçI©�5½�úm¯�éÝI�±úÙ§=´�«�´

raq�¤ª§�öm¿vk7,�ÏJ'X"nØþ§ÝI´éçI��A§ú

m�´Øúm§ØK�æ(J§Ï�ÝI<3ÝI���mc4�ÝI©��1

��LÙÝI1�§®¤�¯¢"¤±§mIÒ´UçI©�5½§éÝI&Eú

Ù����!§�µIvk7,�Ü6'X§Ï�µI´UçI¯¢§=çI©�

5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§J`í�¥I

ÿÀ<"éd§�±?�ÚÚ�Ñn��¯Kµ�ÝI<´Ä7Lë\mIºÝI

<3ÝI���mc4�ÝI©��1�§L²ÝI<®²�AçI?1ÝI§

ë\½´Øë\mI¿ØUĽÙÝI�¯¢"�d§çI<|�mI�ÂÖ§́

��¤kÝI<��Lë\§Ør�§́ Äë\dÝI<gÌû½§́ ÝI<��

|§çI<Ø���§Ø�´ÏEâ�ÏÝI<Ø��LÃ{mI§X>f�´X

ÚmI�¶�çI<´Ä�±5½ÝI<ë\mI�<aO§XÝI<�L7L

´Ù{½�L<½�8²nºÝI<Q,�±Øë\mI§çI<�,ØUéë\

mI�ÝI<�L�±��"ÄK§çI<Ó�´��ÝI<��|¶�ÝI<�

�<vk��{½�L<Ç��÷Ö§́ Ä�Ïd ØméÙÝI©�ºÝI<

ë\½Øë\mI¿ØK�ÙéçI��A§�,ØUÏ�ÝI<��<v��

{½�L<Ç��÷Ö ØméÙÝI©�§áýÙÝI§Ï�ÝI<®²3ÝI

���mc4�ÝI©�§�AçI"�d§é�ë�mI�ÝI©�§��

Ä��K´éçI<3çI©�5½�ÝI���mcÂ��¤kÝI©�§mI

�ÑA�¯�± µÚúÙ"

12!O�µmIO�ó�

mIc§çI<I�O�mI�ó�<!mI|¤!��ÚÝI©�"Ù¥§

ÝI©��O�§�)ÝI©���ÂÚì+ü«I?"é3ÝI���mc4�§

�÷vçI©�éÝI©�µCÚI£5½�§çI<7LÉn§¿é®�Â�Ý

I©��±ì+§�yÙ3ì+L§¥Ø¿�!Ø��ÚØ��§=ÝI©�µC

�µ�Ð"��§é@Ø÷vçI©�µC½I£5½�§çI<AáÂÙÝI

©�§�ÝI<`²áÂ��ϧ#NÝI<3ÝI���mcéÝI©�2gµ

C½��I£§2g4�"��/§çI<3çI©�¥éÝI©�µC½I£5

Page 187: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

176 çIæÛYFn

½��E,§çI<�ÂÝI©���I?Ò��"�ÃØçI©�¥éÝI©�

�µC½öI£�5½´E,�´{ü§çI<I��âçI©�éÝI©��µ

CÚI£Á1�Âc�u�I?"çI<�Á1u�I?½´u��Ø� §K�

�¡µI½¥I(J�§4´puÝI<Ý�§î­�§����çI�}"e¡

ùKÝI©�Én��¯§Ò´ÏçI<ÉnØA�Én�ÝI©�§���ç

I�} ­#çI"

[ÝIÉn��¯] 2003c3�§,½Ý]3600��,ï�¤úá��¾�¢ó

§§æ^úmçI�ª(½ó§�óü "çI©�5½§ÝI©�dÝI¼9Ý

I¼N¹!ûÖ©�ÚEâ©��nÜ©|¤"éÝI©��©þ�µC§çI©

�´ù��¦�§�¦ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹L�ûÖ©�ÚEâ©�©m§üÕ�

µ§4�ÝI©��Ó�4��çI<"

T�8ÝI���m�2003c3�30F§�k7�ÝI<ÝI"Ù¥§ÝI<A�

ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹§�Ù¦ÝI©�µC3���C�S§*þwÙ�µÚI

£�Ч�ÂÝI©��ó�<duØ�ÙçI©�¥éÝI©�©þ�µC�

�¦§�Âe5"

mIL§¥§çI<UçI©�5½�§S|�mI"ÝI<3éÝI©��

µu��§vké�ÝI©���µÚµC/ªJѦ§@��µ�Чæ§

u´?\ÝI©�µC µÚ�I�!"

�I��ÝI<A�ÝI�§duÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹�Ù¦ÝI©�µC3

���C�S§mI?1Øe�§çI<�?éØ�TÝI<üÕ�µ�ÝI¼

9ÝI¼N¹§Î¯ÝI<A��L/\��ÝI¼ÚÝI¼N¹�3=0§ÝI

<A��LÕå5§�XÌR�e¡@�©��§`/Ò3@��fp§�mÒU

w�0"ó�<òT�C��m§�ÑÙ¥�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹§O��I"ù

�§e¡k��ÝI<�LÞÃJÑÉƧ̀ TÝI©��µCØÎÜçI©��

¦§/UçI©�©þÚµC�¦§ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹A�Ù¦ÝI©�©mµ

C§üÕ�µ"�ù°ÝI©��ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹�Ù¦ÝI©�µC3�

��C�S§ØÎÜ�¦§ØU?\�I"\���§·ÒÝ�"0ù�§Ù¦ÝI

<�L��AL5§ªªL«T°ÝI©�ØU?\�I"�G§Ì±<:a�

«y|1�iÒ<XÛ?n§T1�iÒ<�Eµ/��µCÜ��ħ±9´

Äë�ÝI¿���µI�¬µ�"0̱<�ÝI<�L)º§`²�«1�

iÒ<§T°ÝI©�µCØÎÜçI©��¦ù�¯�§��µI�¬?n§

dµI�¬�½ÙÝI´Äk�"Ù¦ÝI<�L�1�iÒ<�Ñû½§

BØ2L«ÉƧmI�±UY?1"mI(Jw«§ÝI<A�ÝIÝ��Чü

Page 188: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 177

´ÙÝI�d�©§ÒòÙ¦ÝIQ����§ØÑ¿�½¥I"çI<é�Ù§

ÝI<A¥I�{§Ù¦ÝI<�½¬JÑÉƧ�k'1�iÒÜ�Ý�"

çI<�µI�¬0��8&E�§òÝI<AéÝI©��©þÚµCØ

ÎÜçI©��¦§±9mI�Ù¦ÝI<Q4å�é µÝI<A�ÝI©��

�¹§X¢�µI�¬�0�"µI�¬�>&å�§��çI©��¦§

ÑäÄûÝI<A�ÝI�û½§é�e�6[ÝI§UçI©�5½�µIIO

Ú�{?1µ"Ú'�§J`í�n[¥IÿÀ<"

µI(Jú«ÏS§ÝI<A��ÙÝI�µI�¬3ÐÚ"��!�±

Äû§ndE´mI�§Ù¦ÝI<éÙÝIJÑ�©�µCØÜ�§²²Ø²

/�½1�iÒÅ�Ý�§Ý�nd´§ÝI©��µC´ÄÎÜçI©���¦§

çI<�kuó�"·úi�ÝI©�²LçI<��µu�§?1�P¿?

\�I§çI<®@�·úiÝI©��µC§µI�¬q³�oÏÝI©�

µC Äû·úi�ÝI"u´§ÝI<A�¦½1�iÒÅ�@½µIÃ�§I

¤çI<­#|ïµI�¬µI"

½1�iÒÅ�ÉnÝI<A�Ý��§35½��mS�Ñ1�?nû½§

@½T�8µI(Jk�"ÝI<Aé1�?nû½Øѧ�{�IÖ�ï�1�

Ì+Ü���1�EÆ"2003 c11 �§ï�Ì+Ü�e�T�8�1�EÆû½§

@½T�8çI<AáÂÝI<A�ÝI©�§3®�ÂÙÝI�cJeµI�

¬q�âµCØ÷v�¦ÄûÙÝIØÜ~n§Ï�mI�ÝI©�®² µ§µ

I�¬wØ�ÝI©��µC§çI<3|�çIÝI¹Ä¥�3L�"âd§

1�EÆ��1�?nû½§�¦çI<­#çI"

Uy15çIÝI{¢�^~6�1l��^5½§T1�EÆ�(Ø®Ø2

�(§Ï�ÝI<gC�µCØÎÜçI©���¦§ØU/�<kwG0���

s"ÝI©�©þÚµCØÎÜ�¦�I?<´ÝI<A§Ø´çI<"çI<d

uÉn�{AáÂ�ÝI©�§A�{É�1�?v"éuµI(J´Äk�§

Ø%3uçI<��51�´ÄK�µI(J"�Y¥§çI<��Ø1�§�

´ÉnA�áÂ�ÝI<A4��ÝI©�¶�´3µI��¦µI�¬Äû

ÝI<A�ÝI§¿vkK�µI(Ø"

�¯(ÛF<Ï�§%¹X/çIÝIÃ�¯0§[!û½¤}��n§�2g

­�O�ó��­�5"@o§çI<|��gmII�?1=O�ó�Qº�

�/§çI<|�mI�O�ó�Xeµ

1.mI|¤O�"mIaqm¬§ḵ<Úf¯§�kiÒ<"mI|¤O

�§=UçI�8mIA:ÚI¦§O�¬|Ú^�"¬|���ë\mI�<ê

Page 189: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

178 çIæÛYFn

k'§���çI©�5½mI§SÚúÙ¯�k'"��/§mI¿AkÌR�§

ÌR�ekS«�!"ÌR�þ§Ì±<�WU�R´�3�å�´©m§ÝI<

9f¯�«�vk5½§÷vçI<̱mIÚÝI<ë\mI=�"

mI|S���§A±÷vçI©��¦�úÙ�ÝI¯�Ы�O"��/§

mI¿SA�k�ÑXÚ!ÝKXÚÚ>M��§±B�IÚ>M¹\§òmI(

JÅ�úÙ3¶4þ"ÌR�þ´ÄO�ç�!ÌR�eS«þ´ÄI�O��)

dçI<gÌû½"çI©��±��ÝI<��ë\mI�<ê§��±�¦Ý

I<g1O��)§±BmI�P¹"�ý�ë\mI�<êõ�§~X§k50�

ÝI<ïçI©�§z�ÝI<�2-3<ë\mI§<ê�õ�Òk150<§\

þçI<�ó�<!iÒ<§<ê�õ�U��160<�õ"mI¿A��kk

�!Ã�{Ù§±Bu̱<!�I<!iÒ<ÚÝI<�Luó"

çI<A3mIéÄc��8��§émI|SXÚ!��?1ÿÁ§(�I¦

^�XÚ!��k�"éu3ú�] �´¥%|�mI��8§çI<AJc�

ý�mI¿§ÙGÙ�Ñ!¹\ÚÝKXÚ"

2.mIó�<O�"mIÌR�þ�ó�<§�)̱<!�I<ÚP¹

<§±9�Ü̱<!�I<ÚP¹<�Ù¦ó�<§X©��$! µÚD4

<§±9XÚA:<�§O�Ð7���$! µÚ�?óä�"

��/§Ì±<!�I<ÚP¹<dçI�8|Ì�<ú?"7��§��

­�çI<Ì+çIó��k'KI<ú?"XÚA:<A´�AXÚ�;�<

"éu3ú�] �´¥%mI��8§XÚA:�o<dú�] �´¥%

k'�ú�"

é�{7L?1çI��8§iÒ<´1�iÒÅ�KkçI�81�iÒ�

I�ó�<"çI<A3mIc�ÙéX§��ÙémI¹Ä?1iÒ¶é�{

çI�8±��8§Øáu1�iÒÅ������§éçIÝI¹Ä�iÒ±

çI<SÜVÆiÒ�̧�dçI<SÜ�VuiÜ��ú�"

3.ÝI©�O�" mI�¢�´méÝI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���m

c4��ÝI©�§�XÝIÉn��¯¥ùã�§ÝI©�O�´mI�­��

��O�ó�§�9ü�O�¯�§=ÝI©��ÂÚì+"Ù¥§4��ÝI©

�êþØ÷vçI©�½{Æ5½�§~X§5çIÝI{61��l^5½§ÝI

<�un��§çI<A��{­#çI§=Ø�|�mI"

1¤ÝI©��Â"ÝI©���§I�çI<���ÝI©��Â<Ù

�çI©�éÝI©�©þÚµC��¦§é3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc4

��ÝI©�§éÝI<�°!ÝI©�©þ!�CÚI£?1��"÷v�¦�§

Page 190: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 179

û½Én"��§AáÂ"éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~61n�8^5½§�ÏL

]�ý"���<J��ÝI©�§±9}Ïx�½ö�UçI©��¦�µ�Ý

I©�§çI<A�áÂ"Ó�§�¦çI<AX¢P1ÝI©��x��mÚ�

µ�¹§¿����"ù�¥§/�ÏL]�ý"���<0�çI<|�]�ý

"§�ë\½´�ÏL]�"��d3ÝI<ØäkÝI]�§/}Ïx��ÝI©

�0�çI©�1²�ÝI���m�4��ÝI©�§ùü«�/3¢�¥´u

�ä"́ uÑy���§́ /�UçI©��¦�µ�ÝI©�0§ÙØ%3uçI

©�éÝI©���µ�¦§I�ÝI©��Â<Ù�"A�� ��É�§

áuæ^ØÜn^���!ü½d3ÝI<�1�§ØA��É �ɧK�Ý

I¿�§��ú²ú���´�K"

k<QïÆ��éÝI©��µ��¦§@��µ´ÝI<3mIc�oÙÝ

ISNØ���«/ª§AdÝI<gÌû½´Ä�µ±9No�µ§±~�ç

I<3ÝI©�Én¥�I?§Xy�´r¤ª¥§å�ÞþØ^ºXùXÞ"�

ù��5§��ÝI¿��b�§=ÝI<�m�pØ�¡é�ÝI§�3�5z

�ɧ? âU¢yJ`�ÔÑg�"

@o§çI<�Ø/�Â�{A�áÂ�ÝI©�§¬É��o1�?vQº

éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~618�o^5½§çI<�É�ÏL]�ý"�ü 

½ö�<ë\ÝI½ö�ÉA�áÂ�ÝI©��§dk'1�iÒÜ�I-U

�§�±?10��±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�

{��?©"�Â1�?v�§çI<´Ä�½´­#çIQ?�Y´Ø�½§�À

çI<�{1�é¥I(J�K� ½§Ï�5çIÝI{¢�^~61l��^

5½§�{7L?1çI��8�çIÝI¹Ä��5çIÝI{695çIÝI

{¢�^~6�5½§é¥I(JE¤¢�5K�§�ØUæ�ÖÍ���±Å�

�§çI!ÝI!¥IÃ�§A��{­#çI½öµI§=XJçI�8Ø´�{

7L?1çI��8§½´çI<��{1�é¥I(J�E¤¢�5K�§ØK

�çI�8�k�5§ÃI­#çI"

2¤ÝI©�ì+"éÝI©��ì+§�çI<éÝI���mc®�É�Ý

I©��ìwÚ�y"ù��Ny3n��¡§=µ�éÝI©��µCÚI£�

ì+§ØÏÝI©��£Ä ¤�½»�§�³ÝI¯�"~X§,��ü |�

���çI�8k5�ÝI<§çI<3ü �p��|�ÝI©��§Ó�

�ÝI<?\ü �nÃY§̂ ð��$ÝI©��ÙS�¬Æ¿å¥§Ï©�è

�Ø5�§l�þKe5ü�ÝI<�ÝI©�§ÙµC�ÜO�§ÝISN®�

³uú¯À�e"�d§çI<3|�mIc§k«@�ا�ÎÝI<�L¿�"

Page 191: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

180 çIæÛYFn

Ù¥§ÝI©�µC�Ð�ÝI<ØÓ¿mI§�µ¤��ü�ÝI<Ó¿mI"

�d§çI<rÝI©�ò��ÝI<§\ÙçI�}¶�éÝI©����5?

1ì+Ú�o§=ØUE¤ÝI©��¿�¶�éÝI©�1²�¯�?1ì+Ú

�o§ØUÏçI<ó�<��¿½L�1���ÝI��Ø%¯���§�

³ÝI<�Ã"5¿§çI<éÝI©�ì+�±þn�I?´mI�§ÝI<�

L?1ÝI©��µu��Ì�¯�"

k<�Ø/@�§�±3çI©�¥5½§ÝI<=U3mIc��ã�mS§

~X§mIcü���S§3mIy|�ÂÝI©�§Ù¦�mVØÉn"ù«5

½wq~�çI<éÝI©��ì+I?§���ÝI<3ÝI���mcÑ

�±4�ÝI©���|"~X§çI©�´Ä�±5½áÂeM�çI<�ÝI

©�º�,ØU§Ï���ÝI<4�ÝI©���ª�IS.~N�ÝI<e

MÙÝI©�§��e43ÝI���mcx�çI<§çI<ÒA�éÙµC

?1u�§÷vçI©��¦�§çI<7LÉn§ù� 5́çIÝI{61��

l^Ú1��Ê^§5½ÝI<3çI©��¦J�ÝI©�����mc�±4

�!Ö¿!?U½ö�£®J��ÝI©�¿Ö¡Ï�çI<��ϧçI<I�

�´�y Ø´��ÝI<ÝI"

[�£I] ì+§´�é,�ÀܽÔN?1ì�+n"ÝI©��ì+§�ç

I<é�Â�ÝI©�?1ì�Ú+n§Ùm�3�yÙ3mIcØ¿�!Ø��!

Ø��§´ÝI<ÝI�ý¢¿gL«"

13!§SµmIL§�å

mI�Ä�§S§́ 3ÝI<�L½�÷�ú�Å�u�ú�§(@ÃØ�d

ó�<�¯ µ§úÙÝI<¶¡!ÝId�ÚçI©�1²I�úÙ�ÝI©

�¥�Ù¦Ì�SN"Î�´r¤ªþ§���§S�µH#e�→ª»�→þ��r→8Ä1r→ÅÓé~→x\É��8��!"aq/§mI���)µmIm©→úÙÝI<→\Ùó�<→ÝI©��µu�→ µ�I→\i(@�§�´8��!§��!ÑkI5¿�¯�§©ÛXeµ

1.mIm©"mIm©�m�ÝI���m�éA§=ÝI���m�ª�Ò

´mI�m�m©"@o§́ Ä#NÝI���Ø|�mIQºl�nþùv�o

Ø�§�ù7,\­çI<éÝI©��ì+I?"Ó�§ÝI<4�ÝI©�

Úë\mI��±�g�¤�¯�§IÝI<õg �uçI<½mIy|§éV

�ÑÃÃ?"ùÒ 5́çIÝI{61n�o^5½§mIA�3çI©�(½�

Page 192: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 181

J�ÝI©����m�Ó��múm?1§/:A��çI©�¥ýk(½/:

��Ï"

[ÝI��ò���¯] ,�{7LçI�ó§Å>���8§kA!B!Cn�

ÝI<ïçI©�§35½�ÝI���mc3©¨§�kA!Bü�ÝI<4

�ÝI©�"çI<�>{ίÝI<C§¡×3´þ§�����±��§�

¦çI<òmI�mí�30©¨"çI<�ÝI<A!BûƧXJmI�mØí

�§��8ÝI<ê3n<±e§Ø÷v{½�mI<ê��§ÝI©�I�µØ

Ä/ò�§�XJí�30©¨§ÝI<ê�n<§�±mI§ïÆÝI<A!BÓ¿

mI�mí�30©¨"�G§ÝI<AÚB��Ó¿mI�mí�30©¨"

��30©¨§ÝI<C4�ÝI©�§çI<�Â�|�mIÚµI¹Ä§Ý

I<C�µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<§ÝI<AØ@�§�k'1�iÒÅ�

Ý�§¡T�8®²ÝI��§�çI<|�mI��¿ò�30©¨ì�ÝI<C§

�ÂÙ´�4��ÝI©�¿í�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<§��5çIÝI{61n

�o^5½§�¦\Ù�gçIÃ�"1�iÒÅ�N��y¥§çI<F)¡§

ÝI<AÚBÑÓ¿ò�mI�m§´Ïv�µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<

Ý�§ïÆÒ£Ý�"1�iÒÅ�<¯§kéçI©��'^±�?U©�

íºçI<`@�vk§́ 3�ÝI���mc3©¨�Þ(@�"1�iÒÅ�<

�X`§vk?UçI©��Ö¡á��yáuògò�ÝI���mÚmI�

m§��5çIÝI{61n�o^5½�§mIA�3/çI©�0(½�J�Ý

I©����m�Ó��múm?1§��8�{ØUmI I­#çI"

ù��¯L²§çI<ò�ÝI���mÚmI�m�1�§áuéçI©�

?U§5çIÝI{¢�^~61���^5½§©�½ö?U�SN�UK�ÝI

©�?��§çI<A�3ÝI���m��15Fc§±Ö¡/ªÏ�¤k¼�ç

I©��d3ÝI<¶Øv15F�§çI<A�^òÝI©�����m"ùp§ç

I<ò�ÝI���m½´mI�mØK�ÝI©�?�§�,ØI��l15F�

�¦"�Q,´éçI©��?U§ÒØU���Ã�§ L�ÑäÖ¡©�?U

ÝI���mÚmI�m§ÃI�¦ÝI<�¿�"��/§çI<í´ÝI��

�mA3ÝI<�vÑu�c§=ÝI���F1-3Fc�¨"

��/§mI�ªm©�§I�\ÙÝI���m®²��§òáÂd�4�

�ÝI©�"Ó�§\ÙmIVƧXmI�§�¦ë\mI�¤k<rÃÅ=�

·Ñ�ª§|SØO[t!�O!�اØ��fÃŧ±9´Ä#N��!ûì!

¹Ñ�§(²=<�±ë\mI§±9´Ä#N�f!*�½ë�mIÙ¦¯�

�§w�Ø÷v�¦�<l|�"

Page 193: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

182 çIæÛYFn

2.úÙÝI<"mIúÙÝI<�8�§́ £½ë�¿��ÝI��"��/§

çI<3\ÙmIVÆ�§úÙçI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc�Â=

ÝI<4��ÝI©�§U4��k�úÙÝI<¶¡"úÙÝI<¶¡�§A

�¦ÝI<�LÑ«¿4�{½�L<�Ç��÷Ö§(@ÝI<�L"

3.\Ùó�<"mI0�ó�<9Ù�I�8�§́ 0�ë�mI�ó�

<§±BiÒÙ1�§(@mI(J"��/§mIÄk0�����WU§X�

��1�iÒÅ�<!çI<SÜ��Vui<Úk'KI<�§\ÙçI

<���̱<!�I<!P¹<Ú�ÜmI� µ!D4�ó�<�§±9�

�<�ó��I�§�ÂiÒ"

4.ÝI©��µu�"ÝI©��µu��8�§́ �²��§(@[mI�

ÝI©�´ÝI<4��ÝI©�§çI<éÙ¦�ì+I?§ÝI©�v�<

Jc µ!¤�½���"@o§Xk�¢�ÝI©���µu�§1�iÒ<!

Vui<ÚçI<�ó�<UÄ¢�éÝI©���µu�Qº�½ØU§

Ï�ù<éÝI©���µu�§�õ´w�wÝI©�´Ä�µ�Чkvk

m�½��§¢yØ�µu��8�"U¢�ÝI©��µu�8��<�k

üa§�a´ÝI<§,�a´çI<­��úyÅ�"çI<­�ú�Å�éÝ

I©��µu��§/ªþ'ÝI<gCu�ú�§�I�|G�½�ú�¤^"

�d§¢�¥§�õdÝI<�Lu�"

ÃØ´ÝI<�L�´ú�Å�éÝI©�?1�µu�§u��I?ÌN´

çI<§́ çI<é�Â�ÝI©��ì+I?§(@[mIÝI©��µCÚI

£�ÝI<4���G¹��§ÝI<�LI³/Ã¥�ÝI©�\³y!úy

Å�<I³/çI<Jø�ÝI©�\³yéÝI©��µ?1u�"

ÝI©��µu��§ÝI<é[mI�ÝI©�Ø(@XÛ?nºÝI<Ø

(@[mI�ÝI©�§L²çI<�U�qØ�½v¦�éÝI©��ì+I

?"5¿§duÝI<Ø(@[mI�ÝI©�§ÝI©�ØU?\ µ�I�!§

I�Ò/µ�±���"(@ÝI©��µ�ÝI<Ø�u3<�§mI�±UY

?1¶�u3<�§çI<I�ª�mI§\ÙçI�}"

1�iÒÅ�½´çI<Vui<(@ÝI©�µC�3�Jc µy

â�§çIÝI¹Ä��ú²ú�Úª¢Å&��K§çI(JÃ�§çI<I­

#çI½´�{æ^Ù¦�ªæ§�{�Vé�'I?<?1?n¶�¢çI<

�ÝI<GÏ�¤���§�{JÄk'I?<�-¯I?"

5. µ�I"éÝI©� µ�I§�Î�´r�����!§#Jim#h

Þþ�ùXÞaq§́ mI�4<-Ä�|Ü"ù�¥§ µ<UçI©�1²

Page 194: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 183

�mI^S µÝI©�µC§D4<rÝI©���D��I<§B�D�P

¹<ÚiÒ<§̂ g�I"��/§�I<IéÝI<¶¡!Iã/I�¶¡Ú?Ò!

ÝI�y74��¹!ÝI�d!�þ8I!Á�Ï�!/:§±9çI©�þ1²

mI�úÙ�Ù¦¯�§iÒ<éì�I<��IÚP¹<�P¹(J§uyØ�

��§±���O9���"5¿§�I��K§́ �I<UÝI�¯¢§X¢\Ö

ÝI§ØUV\�<�Ì*�ä½´UÐ"

[�Id��¯] ,Ikè�æ^úmçI��ªïð�§�8̱<Ú�I

<d�<ú?"�LÝI<A!B�ÝI�§Ì±<�mÝI<C�ÝI¼�ÝI¼

N¹���§uyJøü«ÝI�Y"�´�C?�§�d�468.00��§,�

�´IS|C§uÄÅ�?�§�d�259.00��§Ù¦ÝI<�ÝI¼9ÝI¼

N¹þ,�k���d"̱<k:Ø�¤�§̄ ÝI<C��Lµ/\úi��ª�

d´=��º0ÝI<C��LwwÙ¦ÝI�YÚ�d§£�µ/·úi��ª

�d´259 �@��0̱<�¦P¹<3>MþP¹ÙÝI�Y�IS|C!�d

�259.00��¶ÝI<D3ÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þW���d§���tzº�Î

�"�"©§���2650000.00�"̱<�¦ó�<�éÝI<D �©��

dL§uyÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þW����7���d®o(J��§�¯ÝI

<Dµ/\úiÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þ1²�ÝI�d§��´2650000.00 �§��

´tzº�Î�"�"©§����i"0ÝI<D��Ll�«þÕå5§(@

�µ/·úi3d�²§ÝI�d´tzº�Î��"�"©"0�¦P¹<P¹Ù

ÝI�d�§U��ê�P¹§Ì±<L«Ó¿§U2650000.00�?1�I§¿§Q

P¹<Uù�ê�?1P¹"

̱<�gίÝI<é�I(J(@�§ÝI<AÚBJÑÉƧ@�çI<

̱�I¥§#NÝI<CÀJIS|C!�d�259.00��ÚéÝI<D�AÏì

�§#NÙ3�d��ê�¥V\��/�0i§¢�´#NÝI<3ÝI���

m��g�d§éÙ¦ÝI<Øú²§��UÝI<3ÝI©�þ1²�ÝI¯

¢§X¢úÙ��K§�¦çI<��"é´ÄA���§±9XÛ��§Ì±<<

lØO§>{\Îúi­�æ�¯§r�I����¹X¢�Ù�®�"æ

�¯²(w�¦§mI´çI©�1²�mIúÙ¯�§éÝI©�1²�ÝI

(J§X¢úÙ§ØU#NÝI<éÙÝI©�þ1²�d�?1N�!ÀJ½´

�g�d���çIÝI5K�1�"ÄK§ÝI���m���Ò��¿Â"

̱<¯µ/·A�XÛ�ÝI<CÚD��dQº0æ�¯£�µ/j±UÝI©

�1²�¯¢X¢�Ñ��K"ÝI<Ckü�ÝI�Y!ü��d§X¢�ѧ=

�Y��C?�!�d468.00��§�Y�IS|C!uÄÅ?�§�d259.00��¶

Page 195: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

184 çIæÛYFn

ÝI<D��d§��Ú��ê�Ø��§��"���i§�´X¢�§=�

�tzº�Î�"�"©§��2650000.00�§¿X¢P¹=�"0̱<f²x�§

£�mIy|§Uæ�¯�ïƧ­#�ÑÝI<CÚD��d§��mIP

¹"ÝI<C ÚD�kØ�¿§�5KÒ´5K§�Ð3mIP¹þ\i(@"

ùK�¯émI�é&3u§mI´UìÝI¯¢§X¢�IÚúÙ§=ÝI

©�1²�mI¯�´N�ÒN��I¿P¹§Ï�mIL§¥§çI<�I?3

uéÝI¯¢úÙ§ÝI<UìÙÝI©�1²�(J(@§UÝI¯¢úÙ´m

I���Ä��K"aq/§é�þ8I!Á�Ï�!/:±9çI©�1²mIú

Ù�Ù¦¯�§X¢úÙ"çI<ØU��çI©�1²�çIÝI5K§³/Ì

±<½�I<��<Ì*�ä½UЧ��ÝI<3ÝI���m���!?UÝ

I�Ŭ§Ï�çIÝI5K=´�¦çI<X¢úÙ§¿vk�ØUD�ÝI<

3ÝI���m�§�âÙ¦ÝI�¹N�½´?UÙÝI©�1²�¯�"ù�

�KÓ�%¹§�I��ó7L�*§±¯¢��â?1�I"~X§,ÝI<14

��ÝI�y7�30��§�uçI©��¦�50��§ÝI<24�50�ÝI�

y7"�I¿P¹�UÄ�ѵ/ÝI<1ÝI�y7ØÜ�§ÝI<2ÝI�y7Ü

�Qº0�,ØU§Ï�/ØÜ�0Ú/Ü�0́ �½ÝI�y7�(ا�½�Ø

3mI 3µI"�d§�I��U�ѵ/ÝI<1�ÝI�y7®4�§�y�

Ý30��¶ÝI<2�ÝI�y7®4�§�y�Ý50��"0�u�äÝI<1ÚÝ

I<�ÝI�y7´ÄÜ�§́ Äk�§́ µI�¬�I��S�¯�"

çI�8�kI.�§3 µ!�ѤkÝI<�ÝI§(@ÃØ�§çI<

A<Ñ�µ�Ð�I.�diÒ<ÚÝI<�L��§,� µ§úÙçI�8�

I."5¿§I.´çI<Uk'½�½d�ÄOÿ�Ñ�çI�8d�§́ µI

��d�ë�§�Ø´J`IO½�â"éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�^5

½§I.�U��µI�ë�§Ø�±ÝI�d´Ä�CI.��¥I^�§�Ø

�±ÝI�d�LI.þe2Ä����ÄûÝI�^�"

6.\i(@"mI§ØÓ�ë�<�IØÓ"�¦ë�<3mIP¹þ\i(

@§́ y²ÙÁ1�I�Ly"Ù¥§Ì±<!�I<ÚP¹<3mIP¹þ\

i§L²ÙUìçI©�1²�¯�§Á1mI�I¶ÝI<�L3mIP¹þ

\i§́ Ù(@mI�Ü55"��§ÝI<�L�±3mIP¹þØ\i§¿�

|�çI<JÑÉƧ�¦��"çI<áØ���§ÝI<�±3mI��k'

1�iÒÅ�Ý�§ÌÜÙ�öiÒ<3mIP¹þ\i§́ émIÜ{��½§

=3mIL§¥vkuy�{�51�"

��5¿�´§�Ikè¯�ü �Vui<ë\mI§5�þáuS

Page 196: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 185

ÜiÒ§��ØI�3mIP¹þ\i(@§�ب3mI¬þ\ÖÙi½iÒ

¿�Ö§Ï�Vui<ë\mI´émI��y§�I´éié�U{ÆÚ

VÆ�¦?1i"�õcc§·3çIÅ�|�,���.Ikè�)���ç

I"3mI\i(@�!§Tè�i¿Ì?\ÖÃp�i¿�Ö"Ù¥�é(

Ø5�{�·�8PÁg#§Ò´µ/²Li§·(@�gçIÝI¹ÄÜ{k�§

�±UY?1"0·3|þ��Ò¯ç§i¿Ì?��½´é·��y§�q�

â�o�äçIÝI¹ÄÜ{k�Qº�V´ÏÙ3mI¥vuy�3�{�V1

�"�âdU /̀çIÝI¹ÄÜ{k�0íºùØ´3± V�!L@e(Øq´

�o�¢Sþ§XJè�5Ù�¦VuiÜ�ë\mI�<§�3mI�\Öi

¿�Ö§�õ� /́mI¥vkuy�{�V1�§�±UY?10§�ýØU^

�½�{�éçIÝI�L§e(اÏ�/ú��¢0§ çI<!ÝI<3çI

ÝI¹Ä¥�1�§¿�/¯Ãã[0�ÑU/ú�0"

[�£I] ��§L«�,��mÊ�?1§rN/Ê�0"ÝI��§�çI©

�þ1²�ÝI���m±�§Ø2�ÂÝI<4��ÝI©�"5¿§ÝI<A

µI�¬��¦éÝI©��Ñ�©�½`²§́ éÙÝI©��?�Ú©�½

`²§Ø��ÑÝI©����½öUCÝI©��¢�5SN"ÄK§7,��

ÝI����¦"

14!¤JµmIP¹

mIaquÎ�´rim#h�ùXÞ§w�Ùý¢�¡�§mIP¹´ém

IL§�P¹§�)émI§S!ÝI©���µu�9(Ø!�IP¹!ÝI<

émI�ÉÆÚçI<��|�E§±�IP¹�Ø%"@o§mIP¹�µI´

�o'XQº́ µI�âíºATØ´§µI�¬�µI�â´çI©�¥5½

�µIIOÚ�{¶́ ÝIíºAT�Ø´§mIP¹�ØL´mIúÙ�ÝI¯

��8¥Ðy"��/§çI<òmIP¹Jø�µI�¬§�¦µI�¬é

mIP¹þÝI<JÑ�I�?�Ú£��¯K§�ék'ÝI©�§�Ñ(Ø5

¿�"lù�:w§mIP¹��´µI�¢Ú"aq/§e¡ù�IdP¹��

¯§ùã,/��ó§�óçImI�!Ñy�{¯�§�mI(@�!¥vk

<émIL§¥Ñy��{1�JÑÉƧ? /¤�°�Ø�mIP¹§��

µI�¬­#µI�(Û"

[IdP¹��¯],ó§ï��8�óçI§�kA!B!CÚDo�ÝI<"T

�8çI�§ëa�´XÚ�v�¤�O§çI©��Ñ�6�d�240��"

Page 197: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

186 çIæÛYFn

�IL§¥uy§ÝI<C3ÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þW���d§����]8

z�"�"©§���1600.00��"�d§Ì±<|�ó�<�éÝI<C�I

dó§þ�ü§uyÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þW����7��Idó§þ�ü��§

�ÝI<C�¦µ/\úiÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þ1²�ÝI�d§��´1600.00�

�§��´�]8z�"�"©§����i"0ÝI<C��L�f§̀ ;l�

«þÕå5§̀ µ/@´)ا·úi3d2g�²§ÝI�d´�]8z��"�

"©"0¿�2�¦P¹<UÙÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹þ���ê�P¹§Ì±<L

«Ó¿§U1600.00��?1�I§¿§QP¹<Uù�ê�?1P¹¶ÝI<Dé

ëaXÚvkUçI©��Ñ�240.00���6�dW�§ ´120.00��"̱<

uy�§�¯ÝI<D/O<ÑU240���6�dW�§\úi��oU¤120�

�0§�¦ÝI<D(@Ù�d1548.00��¥§�¹ëaXÚ240.00 ���6�d"

ÝI<DL«@Ó§¡��3mIP¹þ\i(@"mIP¹�L8.1"

ÝI< ÝI�d �þIO óÏ ÝI�y7 ëaXÚ �5

£�¤ £�¤ £�¤ £�¤

A 1645.00 Ü� 14 4�§30� 240.00

B 1626.00 Ü� 13 4�§30� 240.00

C 1600.00 Ü� 14 4�§30� 240.00

D 1548.00 Ü� 15 4�§30� 240.00

L8.1 ,ó§�IP¹

�I(å�§ÝI<�LéL8.1�P¹?1\i(@"Ù¥§ÝI<C3�

59��/·i�ÝI�d����]8z��"�"©0§ÝI<D3�59��

/·iéëaXÚ�d�240.00��0"

T�8µI�¬dçI<�L1<!�?k'Ü�|ï�µI;[¥�ÅÄ

��²L;[1<ÚEâ;[3<|¤";�©óþ§3 Eâ;[KIÝI©��

EâÜ©§=�ó|��O�µ"§çI<�LÚ²L;[KIÝI©��ûÖ©

�Ú�d�µ""

çI<�LÚ²L;[UìçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{§è<Äk"�¤

kÝIûÖ©�§é�Aµ"Ï�?1µ©¶3é�dµ"�§uyIdó§þ�

üf8�õ§����"�üU�ZØ�"u´§ûþé�d�µ"§Ø^���

�'�§Ò�âmIP¹þ��dÚçI©�1²�O�úª§��O��©§�

ê:��3ü §1n /o�Ê\0"

è<�¤�dµ"�§Eâ;[��¤�ó|��Oµ""çI<�LÚ²L

Page 198: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 187

;[�Eâ;[úÙÝI<�dÚûÖ�©§4P¹3µ©Lþ¶Ó�§è<±E

â;[éÝI�ó|��Oµ©�²þ�§��ÙéÝI�ó|��O�µ©"µ

©®oL²§ÝI<C��©�p§Ùg´ÝI<D!ÝI<B"

µI(Jú«�§ÝI<B�çI<JÑÉƧ¿�k'1�iÒÜ�Ý�§

ÙÝ�nd´µ/ÝI<DéëaXÚ�d§?U6�dL¥�240.00���120.00�

�§vkUó§þ�üW�§A�Äû¶ÝI<C3ÝI¼�ÝI¼N¹þW��

�d§����]8z�"�"©§���1600.00��§çI<mI��¦Ù��§

3mIP¹��¥O\-�.i§ØÎÜ����Ø���§±���O��â�

Ø?��K"0ÝI<B�¦1�iÒÅ��½µI(JÃ�§�¦çI<­#ç

I"1�iÒÅ�²��mIÚµI]�§r��¯<)§(@çI<3mIL

§¥�3#NÝI<3ÝI���m��g�d��{1�§I-çI<U�mI

P¹"Ó�§éµI�¬¥�²L;[�¡Ô2§@½µI�¬éÝI�d�

µ"vkUçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ""�d§�¦�µ

I�¬­#O�µIÄOdÚ�d�©!í�¥IÿÀ<Ú�¤µI�w§Ò£

ÝI<B ­#çI��¦"

ùK�¯L²§�,mIP¹QØ´çI©�§�Ø´ÝI©�§�mIP¹

´µI�¢Ú"mIP¹XJ�3­��ا4´Ú�µI�¬÷X���Ø�

���µ"Ú'�§���Ø(Ø"@o§AN�@£mIP¹��^§qA�X

Û�ÐmIP¹Qº©ÛXe:

1.mIP¹��^" mIP¹´çI<̱mI�¤J5©�§´UçI©

��¦úmÝIÌ�¯�±9çI<I.�§3ë\mI�<iÒe�¤��°P

¹"7��§mIP¹�±þ�úÙ§�Âú¯�Î"mIP¹�Ì�¿Â3u§§

��/P1mIL§!ÝIÌ�¯�§±9mI¥ÝI<JÑ�ÉÆÚçI<�

�|�E§NyçI<|�çIÝI¹Ä�/úm0�K§4ÝI<�&çI<

´úm!ú²!ú�/|�çIÝI¹Ä"Ó�§mIP¹¦ÝI<éÙ¦ÝI<

ÝI�Ì�¯�k¤)§���C�*§égCÝIUÄ¥Ik����ä½ý

ÿ§éçI<|�mI!µIÚ(½¥I(J/¤�«k��iÒ�^"

5¿§mIP¹´mI�P¹§éµI�õ´�«¢Ú�^§Ï�µI´Uç

I¯¢§=çI<úÙ�çI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI¯¢§=ÝI<

4��ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§�mIP¹vk'X"�d§nØþ§mIP¹Ø

�(§ØA�K�µI(J"�¢�¥§µI�¬éÝI©��µ"Ú'�§A

O´éÝI�d�µ"6u/ª�ÊH§IdP¹��¯¥@«�âmIP¹O�

ÝI�d�©��{§¿�´�Y ´Ñy3�õó§�óçI�8¥"æ^�

Page 199: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

188 çIæÛYFn

ó§þ�ü^��±©Û�ÝI<3Idó§þ�ü¥æ��ÝIüѧ�±�¡

ÝI<D3Idó§þ�ü¥§òçI©�¥1²�ëaXÚ6�d240.00��N

��120.00��§µI�¬��¡ÝI<ØUçI©�ó§þ�ü§=I�½�

d���d�§A�ÄûÙÝI"éuÝI<C3ÝI¼þW���d§����

�L²�d�Ø��§=B´æ^ó§þ�ü©Û^��Ãl�¡§IµI�¬

éÝI�d?1�\©ÛâU<ѵ"(Ø"�çIÝI¹Ä§́ 3Ü6þ�X�

^g����!½L§§?Û���!Ñy��Ñ�UK�æ(J¢y"éçI

< ó§UçI©�1²�mIéÝIúÙ¯��IÚP¹§́ çI<|�mI�

I?"

IS�Ü��Ù�çIÝI+n�{5½§ÝI<�mI�AL!ÝI(²

£d�C�½Ù¦(²¤ÑA�3mI��¿�ѧÄK3µI�Ø�@�§½´5

½�k�Ñ�d�`¨â´Ü{!k��§Ñ´3rmIP¹��µI��â§́

3�Ø/n)çIÝI5K§Lu§�mIP¹�/úm0�^§́ 3^�?@�

wØ��ÃZý�*²L1�§éçIæÔÑ�¦�u�jÎvkÃ?§Ù¢�

´\­çI<̱mI�I?§¿�çIÝI5KA�Xd"

2.�(P¹mI"�(P¹mIL§Ú(J§́ mIP¹�¢�§Ù��IO

/́X¢P¹0"ù�¥�/X¢0�mI���!Ú¯��5¡8"~X§éÝI

<�Ñü«±þ��d§A�UÝI<3ÝI©�¥1²��ü«±þ��dX

¢P13mIP¹þ"@o§mIP¹¥��I§́ ÄP¹<A��â�I<�Ñ

�ÝI¯�?1P¹Qº�~�¹�±Xd§�nØþ§mIP¹A´UÝI©�

1²�¯�P¹"

1¤P¹L�"çI<���P¹<§AUçI©�1²�mI§SÚ�I¯

�§3mIc�FO�ÐmIP¹�ª§��ÎÜmIXÚ�¦�L�"~X§ó

§ÀÔmIP¹¥��IP¹^L�ª�L8.2§ó§�óÚÑÖçI�8�mI

�IP¹aq"

ÀÔ¶¡µ I�?ÒÒµ mI�mµ c � F � ©

ÝI< ÝI�d �þIO øÀÏ ÝI�y7 �5 \¶

£�¤ £�¤ £�¤ £�¤

̱<µ �I<µ P¹<µ iI<µ

L8.2 ÀÔ�IP¹L

Page 200: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 189

2¤mIP¹"P¹<AUÃ¥±k�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹§fX̱<�\Ö

�k'{�!�µu�!�I<�Ñ�ÝI¯�ÚÝI<�ÉƧ̱<��|�

E�¯�§3¯kO�Ð�mIP¹�ª¥§éìÃ¥�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹§X

¢P1"uy�I<#NÝI<�g�d½´?UÝI©�1²¯��§AÌÄ�

̱<½�I<«¿§9���XÚP¹êâ§N�¶4w«&E"

5¿§3>fçIÝI�´XÚmI�§çI<?�çI©�c§A¯k)

>fçIÝIXÚéêâ8���ªÚÐy¯�§±¦XÚ¶4w«�mIP¹�

>fçIÝI�´XÚЫ¯�!SN��"

3¤P¹�U"mIP¹�U���^�§́ mIP¹�Ø/P1ÝI¯�§

ÝI<JÑÉÆ"d�§Ì±<ÚP¹<A�2�éÝI©���"�I(JØ�

3�Ø�mIP¹�3�Ø�§UÝI©�����mIP¹¶�I�3�Ø�P

¹Ø�3�Ø�§�I<A­#éÝI?1�I§mIP¹þAé���/3�5

9X¢`²"

3.mIP¹\i"mIP¹��o�¦\i§ÝI<�LØ3mIP¹þ\i

´ÄK�ÙÝI(Jº��/§Ì±<!�I<ÚP¹<3mIP¹þ¬��\i§

¯KÌ�Ñ3ÝI<�L�þ§=ÝI<�LØ\i§´Ä�±\ÙÙÝIÃ�º

�,ØU�ÝI<�LØ\i`²ÙéçI<̱mI�kÉÆ�éçI<��|

�EØ÷¿§O�3mI��1�iÒÅ�Ý�§´�oÝI<�|��«�ª"

@o§çI©�5½émIP¹\iI?�§́ Ä�±²(5½/ÝI<�L7L

3mIP¹þ\i§ÄK§ÙÝIUÃ�?n0Q§�,�ØU§Ï�ÝI<ë\

mI´Á1Ù�|�Ly"Á�§ÝI<Ñk�gÌû½Øë\mI§çI<qk

�ondr��¦Ù3mIP¹þ\i(@§ÄK§ÄûÙÝIQ�ù�r�ÝI

<��Lë\mIÃ�"d�§çI<I��§́ ��gC̱mI��L§¥´

Ä�3�{�51�§�³ÝI<�Ã"çI<uygC1��(��{Æ5½

�§A3mI(åcémIP¹�'¯�?1N�§(�´X¢P¹�ÝI¯�¶

mIL§�uyçI<̱L§¥�3�{�51��§Ø^ú%§Ó�I�X¢

P1§O��'yâá�§AéÝI<�Ý�"

15!Y~µmI�{E¤­#çI

mIP¹Q,´ÝI¯¢�méP¹§µI´±çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ

�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§mIP¹ÒØATéµI(J½´¥I(JE¤

K�"@o§�o´ÝI©�ºÝI©�´çI<3ÝI���mcÉn�ÎÜç

Page 201: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

190 çIæÛYFn

I©�µC�¦�ÝI©�"¢�¥§�çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä��çIÝI

{§éA�mé�ÝI©�Ømé!Ø�I§A�£��µI�¬µ"�ÝI©

�Ø£�½ò��ÝI<§±9�I¥�¦ÝI<�L?UÝI�d�¢�5S

N§E¤ÝI<ÝI���m���!?UÙÝI©�§¦�µI�¬µ"'�

�ÝI©�ØÎÜ{Æ¿Âþ�ÝI©�"e¡ù�,�Æ�Æ¢�ó­#çI�

Y~§Ò´ÏmIL§¥çI<éA�mI�ÝIØmI§é�¢�5�AÝI#

NÝI<?U��A5ÝI ���çI�}"

[Y�£�] ,�Æ#ï�Å�Æ¢§Ý]o�1.26·�§çI���ïÓSC

ó§Ú�S¿ó§"çI©�5½æ^]��"|�úmçI§æ^28��ª

I²çI��!�þ�¦!EâIOÚ�¦!óÏ!ÝIk�Ï!ÝI�y7��¢

�5SN"Ó�§w�ÝI<mI�I��|�y�y�¶¡§�yØÜ��ÝI

©��Ã�ÝI©�§Ø?\�I�!"

çI<3ÝI���mcÉn8°ÝI©�§?\mI"̱<\ÙmIV

Æ�§Å�úÙ8�ÝI<A!B!C!D!E!F!GÚH�¶¡§�¦ÙÑ«{½�L

<Ç��÷Ö"ÝI<H ����LÑä{½�L<Ç��÷Ö§�T�L��

���Ù�°y§Ã{�yÙ�ÝI<�L¶3éÝI<k'y²!y����?

1��L§¥§ÝI<G[���8²n�UJøïE�yÖ"çI<k'<û

Æ�§û½éÝI<GÚH4��ÝI©�Ø� µ"

󧶡µ***�Æ�Æ¢ mI�mµ2008c4�5F10�0©

SÒ ÝI<¶¡ ÝI�d ÝI�y7 óÏ \¶

£�¤ £�¤ £�¤

1 A 9988.00 4�§80� 23 ***

2 B 9868.00 4�§80� 24 ***

3 C 9928.00 4�§80� 23 ***

̱<µ*** �I<µ*** P¹<µ*** iI<µ***

L8.3 �Æ¢�IP¹L

ÝI<�LéÝI©��µu�§þL«ÃÉÆ�§çI<éÝI<A!B!C!D

!EÚF|�mI§?\�I�!"�IL§¥uy§ÝI<Fvk3mIc�F4�

ÝI�y7 ´34�ÝI©��4��ÝI�y7§çI<�|\ÙÝI<F�

ÝI©��Ã�ÝI©�,Ø?\�I§S¶ÝI<D�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹§Qv

k\XÝI<ü Ù§qvk{½�L<½Ç��n<\i§çI<�|\ÙD �

ÝIÃ�§Ø?\�I¶ÝI<C3ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹þ1²�óÏ25��§�Ñ

Page 202: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 191

çI©�5½óÏ24��§Ì±<�¦ÝI<C ��LéóÏ(@"ÝI<C�

�L¡/@´)ا·úi�óÏ´23��0§�¦P¹<U23��P¹ÙÝIó

Ï"çI<�̱<L«@Ó§w�P¹<3mIP¹þO\ÙÝIóÏ�23 �

�§/¤�IP¹§�L8.3"ÝI<C��L3é�IP¹\i�§3/�5095

²/(@óÏ23��0�é{"

çI<òÝI<A!BÚC�ÝI©��dµI�¬µ"§Ù¦Ã�ÝI©�

ò��ÝI<"µI�¬²µ"§(@ÝI<C�1�¥IÿÀ<"µI(J

ú«L§¥§ÝI<9Ù|³'X<vk�çI<JÑÉƧ�vk�k'1�i

ÒÅ�Ý�"çI<(½ÝI<C�¥I<§�ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§V�[\¾

ó§u�«�ÜÓ"

çI<�ÝI<C\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§c 1�iÒÅ��Y�§1�iÒÅ�

�¦çIÝI¹Ä6ʧ¡½iÛf=L5�°Þ�§Þ�T�83mI¥§é

A�?\mI�ÝIØmI§mIL§#NÝI<CN�ÝI¢�5SN§=ó

Ïd25��N��23��§��A�áÂÝI<3ÝI���m�4��ÝI©

�"�d§1�iÒÅ�I��mI!µIk'©�!]�§N�¹Ñ¹�§±(½

mI!µIL§¥´Ä�3�{�5¯�§�¦çI<��1�iÒÅ��?n(

J§éçI<ÚÝI<C¤\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ6Ø��Y"

1�iÒÅ��éÞ�¯�§N�T�8mI!µI¹�]�§uyçI<

̱mI�§(¢�3Þ�<¤ã��{1�§́ çI<̱mI��{1�é¥

I(JE¤¢�5K��ØUæ�ÖÍ���±Å��§�â5çIÝI{¢�^

~61l��^A�­#çI"����§1�iÒÅ��çI<e�1�?n

û½§�¦çI<�{­#çI"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±en�¯Kµ

1.�YçI<3mI¥O\�|�y�!§û½ÝI<G!H�ÝI©��Ã�

ÝI©�!Ø µ´Ä�(§��oº

2.�Y�I¥�3=Øþ�?§�IP¹´Ä�(§��oº

3.�YçI<=òÝI<A!BÚC�ÝI©��dµI�¬µ"§Ù¦Ã�

�ÝI©���ò��ÝI<´Ä�(ºéçI<̱mIÚòÝI©�£�µI

�¬µ"qk=é&§��oº

[Y~©Û] mIÄ��K§́ éçI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc�Â

�¤kÝI©�§�¯ µ!\ÖÚúÙ"

1.�YçI<3mI¥O\�|�y�!§±ÝI<G[���8²n�UJ

øïE�yÖ§ÝI<H���{<�L������°y§û½ÝI<GÚH�Ý

Page 203: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

192 çIæÛYFn

I©��Ã�ÝI©�!Ø µ��{§��mI´éçI<3ÝI���mc

�Â�ÝI©�?1 µ!\ÖÚúÙ�Ä��K§Ø�(�̄ KÑ3mI�!§�

pÏ3çI©�"@o§çI©�¥1²§mI��éÝI<�|�y§w�Ý

I<mI��yØÜ��ÝI©��Ã�ÝI©�§Ø?\�I�!§́ ¯kw�

ÝI<�§mI�ù��qk�oØ�±Qº̄ K3u§çI©�´Ä�±ù�5

½§ù�5½éçI<q´ÄkÃ?"Äk§mI�§çI<�±éÝI<k'y

Ö!y�?1��§=�²���vk¿Â§Ï�mI¿Ø´�µ�ÝIÜ��ħ

éÝIÜ��Ä�µ�3µI§Ø3mI¶Ùg§çI©�ù�5½§~�ÝI

<ꧠ�ÝI¿����§K�çI<J`(½¥I(J§éçI<¿ÃÃ?§

ù� 5́çIÝI{61n�8^§5½çI<3çI©��¦J�ÝI©���

��mcÂ��¤kÝI©�§mI�ÑA��¯�± µ!\Ö��Ï"

2.�Y�IL§¥�3�Øþ�?Xeµ�çI<ÏÝI<F34�ÝI©�

�4��ÝI�y7§Ø´3mIc�F4� \ÙÝI<F�ÝI©��Ã�Ý

I©�,Ø?\�I§SØþ§Ï�IS�ÝI�y7´ÝI©��|¤©�§3

ÝI���mcÑ�±4�§́ ÝI<��|¶�ÝI<D�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹§

Qvk\XÝI<ü Ù§qvk{½�L<½Ç��n<\i§çI<�|\

ÙD�ÝIÃ�§Ø?\�IØþ§Ï�mI´X¢P1ÝI§µ�ÝIk�½Ã

�3µIØ3mI¶�çI©�1²óÏ24��´¢�5�¦Ú^�§ÝI<C�

óÏ�25��§ÝI<C��L¡´)Ø�¦��§mIP¹þP¹ÝI<C�ó

Ï�23��Øþ§́ 3ÝI���m�#NÝI<��!?UÝI©��1�"�

Y�IP¹L8.3Ø�(§�´A�P18�ÝI<A!B!C!D!E!F!GÚH�Ý

I§ØA�P¹ÝI<A!BÚC�ÝI¶�´vkX¢P1ÝI¯¢"ÝI<C�ó

Ï´25��§́ ÝI<C��L3mI�¡´)اò25��U¤23���§éd§

L8.3vkX¢P1"�YçI<vk�{̱mI§mIP¹vkX¢P1mI§

´E¤çI�}����Ï"

3.�Y8�ÝI<A!B!C!D!E!F!GÚH4�8°ÝI©�§çI<=ò

ÝI<A!BÚC�ÝI©��dµI�¬µ"§òÙ@�Ã��ÝI©�Ø�

µ!��ò��ÝI<��{Ø�(§Ï�µI´éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§¿

�´éÏLmI�ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"

��/§ÏLmI�ÝI©��ÝI©�3��þA�´���§=çI<Ì

±mI�§éÙ3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc�Â�¤kÝI©�Ñ�¯

µ!\ÖÚúÙ§vk�mé½´�\Ö��ÝI"nØþ§mIÒXÓÎ�´r

/im#hÞþ�ùXÞ0@��!§¢¯¦´/éÝI���mc�Â�ÝI©

Page 204: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

18ÙçIæµmI�|� 193

�?1�¥ µ!\ÖÚúÙ"@o§��o3¢�¥¬u)ÏLmI�ÝI©�

�ÝI©�3��þ�Ø��Qº�Ï3u§�<3�Ø/n)çIÝI�¦§

±� /́·�/�·�Ì0§��´x�çi�3çI©�¥�5KÒk�§E¤Ï

LmI�ÝI©��ÝI©���Ø��§��mIÐ%"

@o§çI<UÄ3ÝI©��Â���ÝI<k'y���§éØÎÜ�¦

�ÝIØ��ÂQºnØþA�v�oØ�±§�ù����8�´�o§́ k|

uçI<J`oº�,Ø´§Ï�ÝI´�µÝI§��Q,I���§Ò�½´

?3ÝI©��"�d§3ÝI©��Â���ÝI<k'y����(J§�

U´~�ÝI¿�"Ó�§ÝI<k'y���Ø�¤ÝI©�"=BI���k

'y���§@�´µI�¬3µ"Ú'�¥�¯�§�çI<�ÂÝI©�Ã

'§ùÒ 5́çIÝI{¢�^~61n�8^§5½�ÏL]�ý"���<J

��ÝI©�§±9}Ïx�½ö�UçI©��¦�µ�ÝI©�§çI<A�

áÂ��ϧÏ�3dÄ:þ§çI<2O\ÝI©��áÂ^�§�¬E¤çI

æÔÑ�¦�¢�(J�ò�"

�YéçI<̱mIÚòÝI©�£�µI�¬µ"�é&kn§�´Ï

LmI�ÝI©���A�çI<3ÝI���mc�É�ÝI©���§ØA2

ü½½´��®�É�ÝI©�?\ µ!�I�!¶�´mIP¹A�l±ÝI

¯¢�O��K§éÝI¯¢ÚmI¥Ñy¯�X¢P1¶n´çI<£��µI

�¬µ"'��ÝI©�§A�´Ù3ÝI���mc�Â�¤kÝI©�§

Ø=´ÏLmI�ÝI©�"

Page 205: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 9Ù

çIæµµI�|�

**********************************************************************

c¡Ãhû%§§�(�Rg9õ¶

öN�´°S¯§ár�mí'º"

— y.��5ár�6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 206: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 195

11!µIµÝI¿��à�

µI§́ µI�¬�âçI©�¥úÙ�J`IOéÝI©�?1µ"Ú'

�§J`í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<�µ�½µ�"çIÝI¹ÄXJ'��|­.�

m§@o§çI<ÒÐ'´ISv�§́ 'm5K��½ö§ÝI<Ð'´�IÀ

��¥è§UìçIÝI5KH¥§µI�¬éH¥§ÝI(J?1µ�§́ �

�Ù5§�¦Ù�"õc5§­.�D�X�«-�!ì(!��!©ÈÚ?��<

a° §��<�Ã�����åþ"

[­.��ç¯�] ­.�à�¤þ�ç¯���24­<¯ç§Òë·ù

�Ø´¥��<�Q�¯� �ú«"2002c¸F­.�§̧ Iè3ûm¥}�

�Iè§�,¯Øæ�§�%v±4I<¯çØ®§/¸IÑUH¤­.�æ�§¥

I��nn�I§NoÒØ1º1§·��½10Q�ݤ�=ü¥Iv¥èrÑ

æ³!r�­.��Ð``"

¸Iè¼�­.�Õý�§·�ÐÏLƬƠة�FØȧ̧ I¤þ,�

Æ� �Ç5Æ��¯§����@ �ǧA Æ)Rm��§�2±¸Iv¥

è¼�æ��K§¡7¸I<�©È° §�@ �Ç©ª� Ø�{K"Ù�Ø

ÈÒ�³Ñ¸F­.�þà��ç¯�§¡¸IÂï��Ì০��vºÝ

î­�罹���n6¥è�¸I§�ë=�¿�|èÚÜ�ßèÍ?­.�

or"@c�ç¯�Ì�§́ 5g��õ��à�#X짦�Ïd3¸F­.

�þ/�Ô¤¶0"AO´@|1/8ûm§̧ Ièé¿�|è§÷03B«S��

�§´�²w�:¥§�#Xì%�v÷0bO§òÙve"�X§�DpH\

�â°ç�?¥§q�#Xìr�� �lf§\ÙÃ�"@|'m§̧ I¥3

m|þHåõÅv¥§¿�|¥���Þ»É6§à�#Xìéd%À Ø�§

¿�|èÏ#Xì�ç}�§̧ IèKÏ#Xì�ç¼�"̧ F­.��ç4

�hÑ�§ISvéõ p+�¯I§�Ì�#Xì?3¯I¶ü�"3��

õ�IS�|émþ§#Xì�ç1���vÊm20|"Em�§¦EØgÂñ§

�2ÏL�a�´öp'm"2003c§=Ã�=�ISvé��#Xì�ISà

�]�§ù �¶»»�ç�ÒdòÑv¥à�Í�"

­.�þ§à��±3�là�5KcJe§é$Ä3m|þ�1�gdà

�§Ï�­.�=B´v¥/­.0��§ª8��´�|iZ§à�U5K1¯=

Page 207: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

196 çIæÛYFn

�"µI�¬��ÝI¿��à�§��¡I�u�Ùgdà��§±¢yJ`

m�§�,��¡§q�3�½§Ýþ��Ùgdà��§Ï�Ùª8´É�uç

I<§́ �çI<éÝI?1µ�"

µI�¬§́ çI<Uì�8µ"A:ÚI�|ï��¬§́ ÝI¿��

à�"µI�¬dçI<�LÚk'Eâ!²L��¡�;[U�½��¤'~

|¤"@o§��oØU4çI<gC �2¤á��µI�¬éÝI©�?1

µ"Ú'�§ÆSÜ�I[��{Qº�ÏÒ3u¥I´��<��¬§�½§Ý

þ<�$�pu5K"3ù«�/e§XÛØÉ<�­��Z6?1�ÆJ`Ò´

��A�\&?�¯K§ Ú\µI�¬Å�§�½§Ýþk|u¢yçIæ

��ÆJ`"Ì�Ly3µI�¬¥�;[¤µ�äk�A�;���ÚûÐ

�����§UlÙ;��ÝUçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ

"Ú'�§J`í�¥IÿÀ<¶��çI<!ÝI<vk|³'X§U�*!ú

�/µ"Ú'�ÝI©�¶��lµIó�VÆ�"5¿§5çIÝI{6òçI�

8y©�üa§�a´�{7L?1çI��8§,�a´�{7L?1çI�8

±�æ�8"5çIÝI{6=´é�{7L?1çI�8§�¦ÙµI�¬

¥Eâ!²L��¡�;[Ø��u¤oê�n©��§ù�5½�m�3uu

�;[�;�`³§�*!ú�/éÝI?1µ""@o§ù��5´Ä�öç

I<?1çIJ`��|Qº�Y´Ä½�§Ï�µI;[´�âçI©�¥5½

�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§́ UçI<®3çI©�¥úÙ�

J`5K?1�µ"Ú'�§ØUgdu�§ÙµI(JT´çI<J`¿��;

�Ny"�d§dçI<��LÚk'Eâ!²L��¡;[|¤�µI�¬K

IµI§�ÎÜ¥I�I�"

ùp§éÙ¥�çI<�LÚk'Eâ!²L;[?�Ú©ÛXeµ

1.çI<�L"çI<�L´�LçI<ë�çI�8µI�g,<§Ùéµ

I�Ñ�µ"(Ø�{Æ�JdçI<«ú"Äk§�o��<U�LçI<Á1

µ"�Iºl¬¯'Xwküa<§�´{½�L<§�´{½�L<��÷�n

<"µI´��¯Ãã[!;�UåI¦p�Nå�Ñ��µ�¹Ä§{½�L<

Ø�Uk�më\§�U´�÷�¦<�¤"�÷�o<�LçI<ë\µI´¬

¯�÷'X§d{½�L<\Ý�Ç��÷Öû½§�±´çI<½çI�nÅ�

ó�<§��±´�{U¼�Ç��1n<¶Ùg§çI<�LA�ä��o

��;���½�¡ºçI<�L;���§́ UUçI©�5½�µIIOÚ

�{éÝI©�?1µ"!'�ÚJ`§=µ�UO(n)çI©�¥5½�µI

IOÚ�{¶�Ul;�þn)ÝI©�1²�¯�¶�U�âµIIOÚ�{§

Page 208: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 197

éÝIl;�þ�ä`��§ù´çI<�Lë�µI�Ä��¦"çI<�Lr

N�´Ù3µI�¬¤¥�/ �L�çI<§́ ÄIäk;�Eâ�¡KØ

´Ì�¯�§�ä�Ä��;���ë\µI´(½çI<�L�cJ"

@o§çI<UÄØ��Lë\µIºùül/ªþw§q�vk�oØ�±§

¯K�'�§3uçI<�Lë\µIå=�^§ù�^´Ä´�k�ḉ

Äé¢yæ(JJ`kÃ"çI<�Lë�µI��^Ì�Ny3n��¡µ�

´�LçI<�µI�¬0�çIæI¦ÚJ`IO§±9çI�8�Ù¦�

¹¶�´�¡éÝIµ"!'�ÚJ`L§§f�;[éÝI�µ"¿�§±9Ü

Ó\¾�I�¥I<?�ÚûÆ(½¯�¶n´�LçI<ë�éÝI�µ"!'

�ÚJ`"Ù¥§1�«Ú1n«�^§�kçI<��Lë\µIâU�¡½¢

�§�âU�¥I<þõ\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§¦ÜÓÁ1ºxü$��$"�d§�á

¢çIæÔѧçI<A���Lë�µI§�GÝI�µ"Ú'�L§"

2.k'Eâ!²L;["k'Eâ!²L;[¥�/k'0§�çI�8�9�

Eâ½²LµI;�§Ù¥�/;[0§́ �3,�+�½;�þäk�p;�EU

½�p;�EÅ�<"

1¤µI;�©a"I[uÐU��!ã�Ü�10�Ü�Ûu2010c�Ù5µ

I;[;�©aIO£Á1¤6"3dÄ:þ§I[uÐU���u2018c�Ù5ú

�] �´µI;[;�©aIO6§±í?�I��SµI;[] �Ü��"µ

I;[;�©aIO§ë�I¬²LÚOaO!p���;�y©!ó§\Îa

O!ïÓ�]�9�I;�Eâ]�©a�§�âµI�;�A:éµI;�?1

�ܧéçI�8�9�µI;[;�©�ó§!ÀÔÚÑÖn�a§UìEâ!

²L�A:ÚµISNy©µI;�aO§±÷vµI;[;�aOy©ÚÀ�I

�"��µI;[;�©aIO�åúöÚ?¾Ì±<§·éµI;�y©kX�

�N¬"P�k�g�uÐU���Ó��¥Ií�Û�¦¿�§A ]�í�;

[åÌÙ¥�/í�t0�3�;�©aÄ:þ2?�Ú[z§Þ�~f§̀

ïuí�¥(§3�G�EcI�A�;��;["��âUÝ��E§ù�:3

µI;[©a¥��NyØÑ5"·3¬þ)º�§çI��í�¥(�ïu§3

µI;[µ"�§�vïuÑ5Q§�õk�ïu�Y"d�I�µI;[µ��§

´ÝI<�í�¥(ïug´!UåÚ�@�¢�§=�¢y5§¿Ø´µ�í�

¥(ïu�O(J"A ;[f�·�)º§â��ïuí�¥(çI�µ"�í

�¥(ïu(Jµ��«O§Ø2j±�[zí�;��µI;[;�©a"

@o§µI;[;�©a)û�o¯KQºµI;[;�©a�Ø%§3u

?�Ú£�/k'Eâ!²L;[0¥�/k'0�i"��/§(½;[ë�µI§

Page 209: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

198 çIæÛYFn

A�(½@�çI�8µ"�·A�;[ë�µI"��o /́�çI�8µ"

�·A0§�/k'0aq§vk�½IO"~X§ïÓó§�óçI�8�µI§�

��9ïÓÄ:!ïÓ(�!>íì²!�YüY!Ϻ�N!>F!C»C?Úï

Ó²L�k';�§́ z�;�ÑÀ�´=ÀÌ�;��;[§£�Ø�"̄ K¢

�3u§ùp´ó§�óçI§µ"�Eâ©�´�ó|��O§=kèïó§�

SCó§�«O§ÃIU©Ü©�ó§ÀJ;["

2¤µI;[¥"µI;[;�©a�8�§3uÚ�µI;[¥�;�©a§

¢��è��§±BçI<UµI;�(½µI;[§3é;[�¤u)�Æ�±

µI;[;�©a?1�O"~X§5µI;[;�©aIO£Á1¤6Ò´�I[

nܵI;[¥�ï� ?1�µI;��Ü�©a"

µI;[¥35�þ§́ �«;[] ¥§Ùm�´�çI<(½µI;[J

øúÃÑÖ§�?Ú½|ÌNÑ�±|ïµI;[¥§��Ù3½|þäkv�

ú&å§��çI<@�§�¿l¥(½µI;["Ù¥§�?|ï�µI;[¥

ú&å�p§Ï´3^�?ú&å�Ù�Ö"¢�¥§�?|ï�µI;[¥3é

çI�8¦^�?Ý]�§�k�½�r�5"@o§ù��5´Äý«XÙµI

;[´3�L�??1µI§ÙµI(ØÓ�äkr�5Qº�,Ø´�ùp§�

?|ï�µI;[¥Ó�´�«/B¬0;[] ¥§́ dçI<U5½3µI;

[¥¥(½µI;[§µI;[�ÉçI<­�ë�µI§́ ÑÖuçI<éÝI

?1µ�§�Ñ��«;[µ�¿�"

éµI;[�+n§­3éÙë�µI�1��Ø"éA�§éµI;[¥�

+nØ%3uÄ�+n§=���«µI;[] ¥§��áB÷v�¦�;[\

¥§Ó�§�â1��Ø(J§é¥S��´«��;[�±´w!�½�Ï6Ê

½´��µI;[]�§XISvé?v#Xì@��?v"

3¤(½µI;["N�(½µI;[�k|uæ(J�¢y´�A�ïÄ

�¯K"Äk§(½µI;[��|<´çI<§Ï�´çI<3�¾çIÝI5

K§́ çI<3?1çI§éçI(J«úI?¶Ùg§U/I�é�0�K§æ^

�o���ª(½� ;[ë� ,� ;[Øë�µI�û½�3çI<"5ç

IÝI{61n�Ô^5½§���8æ��ÅÄ��ª§AÏ�8�±dçI<

��(½"ùp§�¦çI<3µI;[¥¥�ÅÄ�µI;[�nØb�´µ�

µI;[¥SkçI<I¦�µI;�;[�<ê¿v¶�µI;[¥SçI<I

¦;��µI;[Uå÷v½ö`uµII�"ù�¥§1�«b��±ÏLØä

áBÎÜ�¦�;[\¥)û§�1�«b��U³ÙEâ]�ÚÁ{�ä§́ Ä

÷vµII¦§�kÙë�µI�âU�¡"¤±§�¦�ÅÄ�(½µI;[§¢

Page 210: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 199

�þ´3\�µI;[¥�+nI?"Ó�§3�½§Ýþq��çI<(½µ

I;[��|§́ u/¤çI<�µI;[pØ&?§µI;[<ar< çI<

íI�µI;[�(Û"

µI;[¥Q,´�«ÑÖuçI<­�;[�] ¥§�?éµI;[¥�

+nÒA£8Ù� §±�çI<Jø¹�1�Ø�;[¶þ�Ø%§çI<�â

µII¦Ú;[1��Ø(J§l;[¶þ¥gÌÀJ(½µI;["

@o§çI<A�XÛUµII¦(½µI;[QºÄk§çI<AUçI�

8A:!µ"Ï�ÚE,§Ý§(½µI¤I;�aO"Ù¥§(½µI;���

�Ä��K§́ µ"I�ù�;� ÙqØU�¦;�¤O�§@Ò�½I�ù�

µI;��;[ë�µI"~X§ïÓó§�Y�OçI§�,��9éïÓ�Y

�Edµ�§���ïÓ�UO�§ÃI2üÕ­�ó§Ed;��µI;["

, §ó§�óçI§Ùó§�ó¤^�µ�9ϧ¿�Eâ;[UO�§çI

<I�­��';��èï½SCó§Ed;[µI¶Ùg§µI;[êþAUµ

I;��ó�þÚµI�m§nÜ(½"��/§µI;�ó�þ�!µI�má

�§I��;[êþõ"��§�±·�~�;[êþ§�µI¤I�;�§z�;

���k��;[�""

3.µI�¬�¤"µI�¬�¤¥§çI<�L�Eâ!²L�k'�¡

�;[m�'~©��õ�éÝI�µ�k|¿vk½Ø§±µI¯��;�A:

û½"5çIÝI{6é�{7L?1çI��8§�¦k'Eâ!²L;[�'~

Ø��u¤oê�n©��§́ Ñuu�;[;�`³§?1ú²!ú�Ú�Æ

J`��Ķéu�{7L?1çI�8±��8§çI<�±gÌû½µI�

¬¥�Eâ!²L;[êþÚ¤Ó'~"

¢�¥§�<�2���~�µI�¬¥k'Eâ!²L��¡;[�'

~§@�µI;[�gdàþ�L�"¢Sþ§5çIÝI{6D�µI�¬��

I§́ UçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§¤¢�/;

[gdàþ0§5 uçI<?��çI©�§5 uçI©�¥5½�µIIO

Ú�{Ø´J`"~X§,çI�8æ^nܵ©{§éÌ*µ"Ï�IO.½�

/`D�§13-15©¶ûÐ�§9-12©¶Ü��§4-8©¶ØÜ��§0-3©0§�XÛ.

½`D!ûÐ!Ü�½ØÜ�¿vkÚ��IO"Ó�§13-15©�Ч9-12©�Ч

�Ò´çI<D��µI;[gdàþ�"3µI�¬�¤¥O\çI<�L�

êþ§Ã�´�õ/NyçI<�¿ã§�¿Ø�½´æ(J�J`"¤±§I

�\r�´çI©��?�Y²§ïÄÛ«J`U¢yçIæÔÑ ÃIÅ(3

çI<�L3µI�¬¥¤ÓR "

Page 211: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

200 çIæÛYFn

12!§SµµI|��6§

µI´éÝI<�ÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�1²�ÝI¯�§UçI¯¢§=ç

I©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{?1µ"Ú'�!nÜüS§J`í�üS3c�

ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<�1�"ù�¥§µIÌN´µI�¬§µI�N´çI<

3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc�Â�ÝI©�§±9AµI�¬�¦§ÝI

<35½�mSéÙÝI©��Ñ�©�½`²"µI�¬�µIÌN/ §û

½Ù3éÝI¯¢µ�¥�­��^§Ùµ"(Ø�NÝI�¿�(J§́ çI

<J`(½¥I(J�Ì��â"�d§�*!ú�/Á1µ"Ú'��I§�Å

����´éµI�¬���1�OK"ùp§/�*0́ �±çI©�1²�µ

IIOÚ�{§=çI¯¢éÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�1²�¯�?1µ"¶/ú�0

´�æ^Ó��µ"IOںݧéÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§ØU³�<Uн

´��,"

[µINÖ¤��¯] ,�>�Ô]æ�8§çI<�÷,çI�nÅ�|�

úmçI§çI�nÅ�3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc§��Â15°ÝI©

�§?\mI"�~�mI�ó�þ§çI�nÅ�̱mI�§=�mÝI¼

9ÝI¼N¹�µC?1�I"mI�§òÝI©�£�µIy|§æè3¿SÀ

H�þ§±�µI�¬µ"Ú'�"

µI�¬¤?\µI¿§"XæÈXì�ÝI©�§;[¥k�m©�¥§

aq�µ/ùoõÝI©�§�µ"��o�ÿâU(åB"0ù�§� ²�'�

´L�;[ÕÑ5§̀ µ/v'X§kw*§é@µCØî!\iXÙk×\§

I£Ø�ß�§]Ñ5��>§��Äû"0Uù�5K§;[Ø�¬�Ò]9°

ÝI©�Ñ5§Ù¥§k�ÙvX3ä¿?§k�i\�½´I£K§½´µ

C��ÝI©����³3¡�"�µI�¬]Ñ9°ÝI©�§çI<�

L¯µI;[µ/ù9°ÝI©���o��>þº0µI;[£�µ/ù9°ÝI©

�Ø^µ"§��Äû"0çI<�L¦¾µ/��o��Äûº0µI;[)ºµ/Ý

I<êõ§µCØÜ����Äû§�±~�ó�þ"0

�µI;[���Äû9°ÝI©�¥§çI<�Lé�3|�çI�nÅ�

¯�`µ/Noµ"�vm©Òr9°ÝI©�]Ñ5���>§���ÄûQº

ù�µ"ÎÜ{Æ5½íº���§���ë\µ"�ŬB�0

çI�nÅ��¯�r�µI;[¡c)�¹§̀ ѵI;[µ/ù9°Ý

I©��ÝI<§k�ÑÖUå�´ér�§k��4>�øLÀ§�JØ�§�

´é§�ѵ�µj"0�´­�Ùë\µI�çI�nÅ��¯�u{§µI

Page 212: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 201

;[B¢{¢`µ/·����k5�µ�§Ñµó�þ��§�mØ"XJs��

4·�éù16°ÝI©�µ"§ÒI�\�\:§¥Ì�½>Eا�OI�µ

"��þ10:âUµ�"ù�§s�z µ�O\1000��NÖ¤j"0�µI;[

´vó�þ�§�O\µINÖ¤§Â¯�%¥kê§�µI;[ûþµ/z<O

\500�1غ0µI;[�8���§£�`µ/500��1"0ù�§µI�¬é

çI<�Â�16 °ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§�U�mõ�:Ò�¤µI�w§

í�¥IÿÀ<"

¯�3�z µ�õ|G500�NÖ¤�§%¥�~���)Øm"�U5�

·��ú¿§ºXw`µ/µI;[y3�Ø�{§ÄØÄÒr�°ÝI�Äû§

�õ�NÖ¤§\�AT�Ù:µI;[�ü§+�+�0¦��·��3�Ük'

Ü�|ïI[nܵI;[¥"·`µ/µI;[Äû�°ÝI��â´çI©�¥

5½�µIIOÚ�{§3µI§S¥�ÐÚµ"½´�[µ"�!Äû"sI�

w�·§µI;[Ñy=«1�I��Ù#�µI;[+n�{"0¯�rþ

¡ù��¯ù�·f§�¯·µ/µI;[�ù«1��ØI�+�+íº0

·`µ/ù«1�35çIÝI{6¥Ò®².½�é�Ù"µI�¬§�

)µI;[��I§́ UìçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"

Ú'�"é�o´çI©�§��vk¦¾¶�Nõ<é�o´ÝI©�§K¿Ø�

½é�Ù"0¯�`µ/�ÙB�0·`µ/Ð�Q,�Ù�o´ÝI©�"y3·¯

s§=©�´ÝI©�X`�º0¯���µ/AT´çI<½öçI�nÅ

�§Ï�´¦��Â�ÝI©�"0·`µ/Ð�2�X¯1��¯K§µI;[´Ä

kéÝI©��ÀJ�§Ò´é�Ü©ÝI©�µ"§é�Ü©ÝI©�ص"º0

¯�k:¹·µ/ù�:�ýv�L"0·`µ/5çIÝI{6¿vkD�µI

�¬ÀJµ"ÝI©���|§{Æ�¦µI�¬�§́ éÝI©�?1µ"

Ú'�"�é{`§��çI<½çI�nÅ�rÝI©�£��µI�¬§µ

I�¬Ò7LéÙ?1µ"Ú'� ØUÀJ"0

¯��X¯µ/·ù�Yf¥§µI;[´±9°ÝI©�µC!\iXÙ½

I£k×\§A�´3/ªµ"¥éÝI?1Äû§ATØ�véÝI©�?1µ

"jº0·¯¦µ/ÝI©��µC9Ùþ�I£´ÝI©�§́ ÝIµ"¯�íº�

,Ø´§@´ÝI©��Â�^���"d§mI��¿´méÝI©��µC§

µI�¬qNUw�ÝI©��µCÚI£Q"¤±§ÝI©��µCØáuÝ

I©�§ØáuµI�¬�µ"Ú'��Æ"0¯��X¯µ/ù«�/���

´u)§No?nµI(JQº0·£��µ/U5çIÝI{¢�^~61l��

^5½§é¥I(JE¤¢�5K�§�ØUæ�ÖÍ���±Å��§çI!Ý

Page 213: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

202 çIæÛYFn

I!¥IÃ�§A��{­#çI½öµI"sù�Yf§Ø�]Ñ��@9°ÝI

©�UçI©�5½7LÄû§�½é¥I(JE¤¢�5K�§́ µI�¬

�µI1��{E¤K�¥I(J§L�{éµI�¬?1?v§­#|ïµI

�¬µI"0

�����µI|�§S§��A��)µI�¬|ï!µIO�!ÐÚµ

"Ú�[µ"!nÜüS!�¤µI�wÚí�¥IÿÀ<��!§©ãXe:

1.µI�¬|ï" çI<UçI�8µIA:ÚI¦(½µI;�Ú¤I

;[<ê�§UµI;[¥+n5½§(½�µI;��µI;[§w�ÙµI�

�mÚ/:"5¿§Ï�µI;[�§Ø¨w�ÙµI�8�¶¡½?Ò"æ^µ

I;[¥XÚÏ��§XÚÄ��gÄ�ÑÏ�µI;["

µI�¬´3µI�F|ï�"çI<�LÚ­��k'Eâ!²L��¡

�;[35½��mS��µIy|§\ݵI�¬¤�PLÚ«ìÖ§í

À½çI<�½Ì?��\wµI�¬¤á"ù�¥§µI�¬¤�PL§

P1çI<�LÚµI;[¤3ü !�¡!éX�ªÚ3µI�¬¥��Ö

�¯�¶\Ý«ìÖ§́ �¦µI�¬¤«ì§�ÝI<Ø�3|³'X§ù

p�/|³'X0�¬¯þ�/|0½/³0�'X§Ï�µI�¬¤XJ�,

�ÝI<�3|³'X§́ E¤TµI�¬¤éÝI�µ"k�ú#"

@o§µI�¬�çI<´�o'XQºµIdµI�¬KI§́ Ä¿�

XµI�¬´ÕáuçI<ÚÝI<�1n�Qºù´éµI�¬�Ú5��

ØÖ"Äk§µI�¬´çI<�éÝI?1µ"Ú'�|ï�§�,´É�u

çI<§�çI<ÑÖ¶Ùg§µI�¬�Ì�ó�´éÝI?1µ�§Ø#N

µI�gdu�§ ´UçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§=çI<úÙ�J`I

O?1µ�"lù�:þ©Û§µI�¬ÑÖuçI<§UçI<�J`IOé

ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§øçI<?1ÀJ¶1n§µI(J´Äkr�5§=

çI<7L�1Qº5�þ§µI�¬�¤�µI(J´�«\Î5�µ�(J§

Øäkr�5"�µI�¬´çI<|ï�§µI�¬?1�ÝIµ�´Uç

I<úÙ�J`IO?1�µ�§́ çI<J`�ý¢¿gNy"�d§µI�

¬�¤�µI(J�Øäkr�5§�ÙNy�´çI<J`A��1§Ø�µI

�¬��çI<3çI©�¥úÙ�J`IO"

2.µIO�"çI<|�µI�¬µI�O�ó�§�)µIy|9��O

�!µI9Ï<ÚµIL�9]�!çI©�!ÝI©�O��¯�"

1¤µIy|9��O�"µIy|^uµI�¬éÝI©��µ"Ú'�§

±9éµI­�¯�8N?ا3ÙÛþA�äk°��Ø��§QU÷vÕáµ

Page 214: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 203

"§�pmØZ6§qBuµ�8N?ØÚûü§æ1¿v!S�B$�A:"7�

�§µIy|A��>M!ÝK���§±øµI�¬¦^"

2¤µI9Ï<"µI9Ï<��dçI�8|<ú?§ÙÌ��I´9

ϵI�¬�¤µIó�§�)éçI©�,�^±¯�ºÂ)¾§ µ�©u

ÝI©�§©uµIL�!®oµI(J�¯�"7��§��½�ϵI�¬

ö�|S��Ú��"µI9Ï<I�½k½I"5¿§µI9Ï<vkµI

�§3µIy|Ø�uL��½ü½,�ÝI<�óØ"ÄK§I�«úÙóØ�

{ÆI?"

[õ¿J«ÚÞ�],Ø>�Ø���æ�µI�¬§dçI<�L1<!E

âÚ²L;[4<|¤"µIL§¥§çI<�8KI<uyµI;[ë,éÝI

<AÝI���µ©AOp§ Ù¦;[éÝI<A�µ©K�é�$§3µIy|

J2ë,´Ø´µ�§�¦ë,ëìÙ¦µ��µ©§éÝI<A�ÝI2"�

""ë,wwÙ¦µ�éÝI<A �µ©(J§éØ��/rgCéÝI<A�

µ©Ne5§¦ÝI<AüS3cn¶�"µI(å�1�U§ë,�µÞ�

&w�çI<i¿§̀ /ù��8·®²µ�©ê§�\���8KI<�

�·N�©ê"·@��8KI<3�{ZýµI¹Ä§I�éÙ�{�V?n"0

i¿Ó�Â�Þ�&§��´µI;[wG§é­À§�¦�8?�Ñ)º"�

8?|�k';�<"�ÝI<A�ÝI©�§uyë,´ÝI©�þ1²�Ý

I<A�Eâ�¯§�{A�£; �£;§±d�dþ�i¿"i¿�Ó�

²(w��8?µ/ë,�{ØUë\��8µI�¬§́ ë,�Â1�?v"�

8|I�«ú�I?§�´3|ïµI�¬�´Ä²(w�Ù�ÝI<�3|³

'X�§A�£;¶�´�8|3µIL§¥´Äuyë,´ÝI<­��Eâ

�¯"ùü�¯KXJµI��ᢧ�8||��gµI��ÒØî>§I�É

�?n"0îî§i¿�Ó��X`µ/ë,�Þ�§́ �8KI<3µI���

{Zý1�"XJµI�uyë,�{A�£;§ÒA��¦ë,£;¶XJvu

y§�,ë,�{¯¢3k§�Ï�vuy§ØU@½ÙµI�{§?Ûü Ú�

<�Ã��¦ë,N�ÙéÝI<A®²�¤�µ©"3d�/e§�8KI<�

1�§�¤�{ZýµI¹Ä§Ð3vkéµI(JE¤¢�5K�"0��§i

¿Ó�é�8?�Ú�8KI<�±�¡1µ§�¦��I?<�Ñ��u�"

3¤µI]�O�"µI]�§�)çI©�9Ù©�Ú?U!çI<|�?�

�I.©�£XJk¤!mIP¹!µI�«L�§�)µI�¬¤\�L!/

ªµ"L!]�µ"L!�A5µ"L!d�µ"L!Á�|��Yµ"L�µI

P¹L�!úv�!)$ÚÝI©�O�§±9Ù¦µIL§¥�9�©�]��"

Page 215: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

204 çIæÛYFn

Ù¥§çI©�©�Ú?U§A�´3çI©�1²�mcuÑ�©�Ú?U"é

�{7L?1çI��8§©�½ö?U�SN�UK�ÝI©�?��§A�´

3ÝI���m��15FcuÑ�¶ÝI©�§A�´çI<3çI©�1²�Ý

I���mc�Â�¤kÝI©�§UmIP¹þÝI<�gS§éÝI©� m

�C!̂ gè�§±B�é"d§çI�8�kI.�§O����I.©�"

4¤µI�mO�"çI<�âçI�85�ÚEâE,§Ý�Ï�Ün(½µ

I�m§±¦µI�¬k¿©��mUìçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝ

I©�?1µ"Ú'�"µI�¬n©��±þ�¤@�"yv�mïÄç

I©�Úµ"'�ÝI©��§çI<AUìµI�¬¿�·�ò�µI�m"

5¤µI)¹O�"µI)¹O�§�µI�¬� !4!1O�§�)µI

�¬;[��µIy|��Ï�ª§́ ÄI��x§êØÑÖÚ7���4�S

ü§Ù¦ó�½)¹O�¯��"

3.µI|�§S"�����µI|�§SA��)µ�µI�¬¤\�¶

�µI�¬¤íÀ½çI<�½Ì?�§\Ý�ÝI<Ø�3|³'X�«

ìÖ¶�\ÙµIVƧ8¥�+µI�¬¤�ÏÕóä¶��µI�¬0

�µI9Ï<¶��µI�¬0�çI�8&E"7��§|�µI�¬Æ

SçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{¶�µI�¬?1ÐÚµ"Ú�[µ"¶�

AµI�¬�¦§uÑÝI©�©�`²¯K§�¦ÝI<?1©�`²§£�

�µI�¬¶��µI�¬�¤�µI�wÚí�Ü��¥IÿÀ<¶�r

NµI�5¿¯�§\ÙµI(å"

1¤çI�8&E"çI<�±3µIL§¥�µI�¬ÒçI©�¥��

­�&EÚêâ§�)çI��!EâIOÚ�¦!æ�ü!µIIOÚ�{!

üS�{!ÜÓÌ�^±�SN?1`²§�Ø�±²«½V«�ª $½ü½A

½ÝI<"

2¤ÝI©�©�`²"µI�¬�¦ÝI<ÒÙÝI©�?17��©�

`²�§çI<�ܵI�¬�¦ÝI<?17��©�`²§�)òµI�

¬�¦ÝI<©�`²¯��Ö¡©�x�ÝI<§�ÂÝI<AµI�¬�¦

éÙÝI©�J��Ö¡©�`²§=xµI�¬?�Úµ""

3¤�µI�w"çI<�µI�w�§AéµI�¬�¤�µI�w?

1/ªØ�§�)µI�wSN!µI�¬¤\ià�§æU?k�\!O�

Ã�â�اí��¥IÿÀ<êÎÜ{Æ{5ÚçI©�5½±9{Æ{55½

�Ù¦¯�"uyµI�wØ÷vþã�¦�§çI<A9��¦µI�¬?1

��"éµI(رkÉÆ��êµI�¬¤Ø3µI�wþ\i�§çI<

Page 216: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 205

A�¦T¤�ÑÖ¡ØÓ¿�Únd§¿�¦µI�¬3µI�w¥éd`²

¿P¹3Y"

13!OKµÝI¯¢�µ"Ú'�

µI�¬UìçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1XÚ/µ

"Ú'�§I�µI�¬ÆSçI©�§O(rºçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{§

A)ÚÙGçI©��±eSNµ�çI�8I¶�çI��Ú�85�¶�ç

I�8EâIOÚ�¦!ã��Eâ©�¶�æ�ü¶�ÜÓ^�¶�µIIO

Ú�{!üS�{!µI§SÚµIL§¥�Ä��'Ï�¶�ÝI©��ª9k

'�¦¶�µII�ݺ�çI©�Ù¦SN"7��§µI�¬Af�éçI

©�k'SN�0�§±?�Ún)çI©�"Ó�§µI�¬AÙGçI<J

ø�µIL�9ÙSN§¿�çI©�¥5½�µ"¯�?1'ì"7��§g1

�OµI^L¿�ó�<<M±÷vµII�"5¿§µI�¬µI�â´ç

I©�¥�µIIOÚ�{§µ"Ú'��é�´ÝI©�§́ ÝI�¯¢"e¡

ùK�¯§=´ÏçI<�Lhe�ÏÝI<��?UÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹���

çIæ�}"

[ÝI¼����¯] ,ó§ÀÔçI3,½ú�] �´¥%mI"mI�§

ÝI©�3�´¥%��k<�Åì+", §3µIL§¥u)�Æ"̄ ��

åϧ́ ÝI<A �ÝI©�¥�ÝI¼9©��dLþ1²�ÝI�d482.00�

�!øÀÏ�145F�mIP¹þ�ÝI�d518.00��!øÀÏ186FØ��§±m

IP¹�O�´±ÝI©�¥�ÝI¼9©��dLþ1²�¯��O§k�Æ"

µI�¬�«1�iÒÅ�<§�E´±ÝI©�1²�¯��O"

µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§

�çI<J�Ö¡µI�w§í�ÝI<AÚB©O�1�!1�¥IÿÀ<"µ

I(Jú«L§¥§ÝI<B�çI<JÑÉƧ¡mIP¹1²�ÝI<A��

d518.00��!øÀÏ186F§µI(Jú«¥w«�´482.00��!øÀÏ�145F§

�ö��oØ��§́ mIP¹�Ø�´µIL§#NÝI<A?UÙÝI¢�

5SN"çI<�E¡§µI�¬´�âÝI<A�ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§Ù

ÝI¼9©��dLþ1²�ÝI�d482.00 ��!øÀÏ�145F§µI�¬

�{UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§ÝI<A�

�©�p§�µI�¬í�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<"

ÝI<BéçI<��EØ÷¿§�1�iÒÅ�?1Ý�"1�iÒÅ�

Page 217: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

206 çIæÛYFn

ÉnÝI<B�Ý��§�¦çI<)º�öØ����ϧ4çI<JøÝI

<A1k�d518.00��!øÀÏ186F�@°ÝI¼9©��dL§��kÝI�

d482.00��!øÀÏ�145F�ÝI¼9©��dL"1�iÒÅ�ίë\m

I�Ù¦ÝI<�L§�éÙ�gP¹�ÝI<A�d´518.00��§øÀÏ´186

F§�çI<3mIP¹þ1²���§1�iÒÅ�ÐÚ�½´k<he�ÏÝ

I<A��?UÝI¼9©��dL"u´§1�iÒÅ�N�ú�] �´

¥%�¹���§uyµI�F§çI<�L´1�����µIy|"çI<�

L?\µIy|�§l�����ú©�p<ÑA�©�O�æ�3/þ�ÝI

©�"1�iÒÅ�ίçI<�L§�¦(@´Ä�ÏÝI<A��?UÝI

¼9©��dL"çI<�LwX¹�§«@Ù3ÝI<A�¦e§�ÏÝI<A�

�?UÝI¼9©��dL"éd§ÝI<A�±@�"1�iÒÅ�@½µIÃ

�§�¦çI<�{­#|ïµI�¬µI"Ó�§@½çI<�LÚÝI<A�

3GÏÝI1�§�{éÝI<A ?11�?v§w�VuiÜ�éçI<�

L��{�V1�?1?n"

µI�Ä��K§́ UçI<úÙ�J`¯¢§=çI©�¥5½�µIIO

Ú�{§éÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�¥1²�¯�?1µ"Ú'�"ù�¥§µI�

¬vkçI5K��½½?U�§=´É�uçI<§UìçI<úÙ�J`I

OéÝI©�§=ÝI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc4��çI<�Â�

ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�!J`í�¥IÿÀ<"þ¡ùK�¯§%¹XmIP¹

3ÝI<éµI(JiÒ¥��^"

µIL§��©�ÐÚµ"!�[µ"ÚnÜüS§ÐÚµ"ØÜ��ÝI©

�Ø�?\�[µ""ÏLÐÚµ"�ÝI<�n��§Ø�?æÀÔ�ÑÖç

I§µI�¬A�UYµ"§í�¥IÿÀ<½´Äû¤kÝI"

1.ÄûÝI�/"µIL§¥§uyÝI�3�{�51�½öÝI©�Ñy

çI©�5½Äû�/�§µI�¬AéÙÝI�±Äû"��§ÝI©�vk

Ñy�{�51�½´çI©�5½Äû�/�§Ø�ògÄû"Ù¥§ÝI©�

�3e��/���§�{7LÄûµ�ÝI¼Ãü XÙ�Ãü KI<½öÙ

Ç��n<\i½öXÙ�§½ö�k�n<\i�Ãü KI<Ñä�Ç��÷

Ö¶�éÜNÝI�NéÜN���ÓÝI�ƶ�vkUìçI©��¦J�Ý

I�y7¶�ÝI¼�UçI©�5½��ªW�§SNØ�½ö'�i,�Ã

{E@¶�ÝI<ØÎܽ|O\K¡�ü�¦�^�½öçI©�5½�]�^

�¶�ÝI<¶¡½ö|�(��]�ý"�Ø����Jøk�y²�¶�ÝI

<J�ü°½öõ°SNØÓ�ÝI©�§½ö3Ó�°ÝI©�¥éÓ�çI�

Page 218: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 207

8kü�½öõ��d§��(²=����ª�d�§�çI©�#NJ��À

ÝI�ض�GÏÝI!±1ªÃã*�¥I!±¦<¶Â½öÙ¦áJ�b�

ªÝI�¶��d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d½ö3�kI.�²w$uI.§�ÝI

<ØUÜn`²½öØUJø�'y²á�§µI�¬@½TÝI<±$u¤�

�d¿I�¶�áØ(@µI�¬UçI©�5½�?��KéÝI�d?1�

�â�Ø?�§½öÃ��ndØUì�¦éÝI©�?1©�`²¶11©vkéçI©�JÑ�¢�5�¦Ú^��Ñ�A¶12©çI©�¥5½��±ÄûÝI<ÝI�Ù¦�/"

ÝIÄû�½Ã��§Ø�#NÝI<��½ö?UÝI©� ¦Ù¤���

k�ÝIë�ÝI¿�§Ø�í��¥IÿÀ<"

2.ÐÚµ""ÐÚµ"§���)/ªµ"!]�µ"!�A5�n�µ"�

!§m�´(½ÝI<´Ää�Á�Uå§́ Ä�AçI"

1¤/ªµ""/ªµ"�8�§́ éÝI©�þ1²�¶¡!�ª!\iXÙ

ÚÝI<�°�L¡¯�"�'�§GØ@Ø÷v�¦�ÝI"�d§µI�

¬UçI©�¥1²�/ª"�Ï�ÚIO§éÝI©�´ÄÎÜçI©�5½/

ª?1"�§W�/ª"�L"é/ªµ"Ø÷vçI©��¦�ÝIL�±Äû§

µI�¬I3/ª"�L¥5²ÄûÝI�¯�Únd§±9éA�ÝI©��

è"

/ª"����)±eSNµ�ÝI<¶¡"I"�ÝI<¶¡�ÝI©�¥

�E��ì!{<^èy!½|O\]�yÖ!)�½�EN�yÖ!S�)�y

Ö��'yÖþ1²�¶¡���5¶�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹""�ÝI¼9ÝI

¼N¹�ª!SN!\i½XÙ�çI©�5½��ª!SN9�¦���5§́

Ä~�ÝI<5½ÂÖ�¶�ÝI©��ª""�ÝI©��ª�çI©��¦

�ª���5§´ÄéçI©�5½Ø#NN�½?U��ª?1N�½?U§

~�ÝI<ÂÖ�¶�éÜNÝI<"çI©�Ø�ÉéÜNÝI�§ééÜN

ÝI�±Äû¶�ÉéÜNÝI�§"�éÜNÝI<´Ä4�k��éÜÝI

�ÆÖ§ÙSN´Ä�çI©��¦��§́ Ä�3~�ÝI<ÂÖ��/�¶�

�d/ª""�ÝI�d�/ª!1«§±9�d´Ä��§́ Ä�çI©���

¦���¶�Ù¦/ªµ"Ï�""�ÝI©��çI©��¦"��Ù¦/ªµ

"����5"

2¤]�µ""]�µ"�Ø%3u(½ÝI<�¬¯/ ÚÁ�Uå"µI�

¬UçI©�¥5½�]�"�Ï�ÚIO§éÝI©�´ÄÎܽ|O\K¡

�ü�¦�O\^�ÚçI©�5½]��¦Å�"�§W�]�µ"L"éÝI

Page 219: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

208 çIæÛYFn

<,�"�Ï�ØÎÜ]�"�IO�§µI�¬A�éÙÝI�±Äû§3]

�µ"L¥P¹ÙØUÏL]�ý"�¯�Únd"]�µ"���)µ�ÝI<

Õá¾áÜÓ�y²©�§Xk��E��ìÚ|�Å��èy!{½�L<�°

y²½´ÙÇ��÷Ö!ÜÓ\Ý<��°y²�¶�½|O\K¡�ü�¦�^

�§Xk��½|O\yÖ!S�)�N�yÖ�´ÄÎÜI[ÚçI©�5½�

]�^�¶�ãÖUå§X"�ÝI<6Ä]7!]�KÅÇ!�½]��´ÄÎ

ÜçI©�1²��I�¦�¶�Á�L§��§X<��!Å���ÚNÄå

Oy�´ÄÎÜçI©��¦§Á�|�OyéÜÓ8I¢�k�æ§́ Ääk�

þ!�¸+nNX@y�§́ Ää�aq�8�1�¶�Á�&�§́ ÄäkçI

©��¦�­ÜÓÅ&�yÖ!¼øyÖ!ÜÓ�1�¶�çI©��¦�Ù¦y

²ÝI<]��]�"

3¤�A5µ""µI�¬UçI©�1²��A5µ"Ï�ÚIO§éÝI

©�´Ä�AçI©��¢�5�¦Ú^�?1"�§W��A5µ"L"�A5

µ"Ø÷vçI©��¦�§µI�¬LéÝI�±Äû§3�A5µ"L¥5

²ÄûÝI�¯�Únd"

�A5µ"���)±eSNµ�ÝISN"µI�¬"�ÝISN´Ä�

ÓuçI©�5½�çI��¶�Á�Ï�"µI�¬"�ÝI©�1²�Á�

Ï�´ÄÎÜçI©�5½�Ï�Ú�¦¶�EâIOÚ�¦"µI�¬éÝI

©�1²�EâIOÚ�¦´Ä÷vçI©�5½�EâIOÚ�¦?1"�§A

O´Ù¥�'�EâëêÚ�I¶�ÝIk�Ï"µI�¬"�ÝI©�1²�

ÝIk�Ï´ÄØáuçI©�5½�ÝIk�϶�ÝI�y7"µI�¬"

�ÝI<4��ÝI�y7/ª!êþÚú�I?´ÄÎÜçI©���¦¶�Ü

Ó^�"µI�¬éÝI©�´Ä�AçI©�ÜÓ^�¥�¢�5�¦Ú^�

?1"�§(½ÝI©�´ÄNkçI<¢�þØU�É�^�½�¦¶��A5

µ"�Ù¦Ï�"µI�¬"�ÝI´Ä¢�þ�AçI©�5½�Ù¦�A

5Ï�½�¦"

3.�[µ""�[µ"´éÝI¿��µ"Ú'�§���)ÝI�d��â

�Ø?�!²L©�µ"!Eâ©�µ"!ûÖ©�µ"!(½üSÏ�9Ùþz

�§?1nÜüS��!"

1¤ÝI�d�â�Ø?�"ÝI�d��â�ØØ�LÝI<�ý¢¿gL

«§Ï�b�ÝI<´��¬¯1�Uå<"�d§µI�¬I�éÝI�d�

�â�اUçI©�¥5½��K?�"��/§çI©�5½�?��K�µ�

^C.ËêiL«�ê��^©iL«�ê�Ø���§±©iê��O¶�üd

Page 220: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 209

�æ�üþ¦È�®odØ���§±üd�O?�®od§Ø�üd7��ê

:k²w�Ø�§d�A±®od�O?Uüd"

ÝI�d�3�â�ØI�?��§µI�¬LW�ÝI�d�â�Ø?�

L§1²��d!?�d�Ú?��Ï�¯�§¿�¦ÝI<(@"ÝI<(@?

��d��§µI�¬Uì?���d�éÙUYµ"¶ÝI<Ø(@?�d�

�§éÙÝI�±Äû"µI�¬O�?��d��ÝI�d��É�LçI©

�5½���½ÌÝ�§AéÝI�±Äû§µI�w¥X¢P1ÄûÝI�¯�

Únd"

2¤�d©�µ""é�d©��µ"Ú'�§́ µI��­�ó�§�ù3¢

�¥´�����"é�d�µ"§́ é�dd��¤�©Û¶é�d�'�§́

ÒÓ�Odf8��¤?1î�'�Ú©Û"µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µI

IOÚ�{é�d©�?1µ"Ú'�§́ 3é�dd��¤©ÛÚf8î�'�

Ä:þ§©ÛÝI�d��¤§X<ó¤!á�!��¤!+n¤Ú|d§±9�U

Û¹�Á�ºx§(½ÝI<d�Y²Ú|d"é��dÉ~��8§µI�

¬A©ÛÙ�)�Ï9�U�5�Á�ºx"7��§µI�¬A�¦ÝI<?

17��©�`²§±~�ÜÓÁ��ºx§¿3µI�w¥J«çI<\�½Á

�¥ý��Uu)�ÜÓºx95¿¯�"éçI<?�I��§µI�¬A�

ë�I�§éÝI<��d?1©ÛÚ'�"

éçI©�5½�6�d�8½´�� l��½ÌÝ��d�8§ÝI 

l�ÑN�� l��½ÌÝ�A�Äû§µI�¬L3µI�w¥X¢P1Ä

û�nd"

3¤Eâ©�µ""éEâ©��µ"¢�§´(@ÝI<´ÄݺÁ���

{§́ Ää�Á���!��Ú�A<�Á�Uå§éÙEâ©��p'�(½

Á�Uå�`�"µI�¬UçI©�5½�Eâµ"Ï�ÚIO§éÝI©�

¥�Eâ©�?1µ"Ú'�§Å�"�ÝIEâ©�´Ä¢�þ�AçI©�

�¦§±9ÝI�EâY²ÚüS"éÓ�Eâµ"Ï�½�Iµ"*:Ø���§

µI�¬¤m�±?1¿©�6§±�(@£TEâµ"Ï�½�I§�*!

ú�/?1ÝIEâ©�µ"§W��AL�"7��§��±æ^ݦ��ª(

@ÝIEâµ"Ï��`�"

ó§tj�!in�j!�ó|��O�Eâ©�§Ðy�´ÝI<Á�ü

yUå§�O�Y´ÝI<éó§I�Ô�O½��§EâÑÖOy½ÑÖ�Y´

ÝI<éÑÖ�Oy«ì§I�(ÜÝI<Oy�<!ã!Ô!�{Ú�¸éÙ�

�d�'XÚ�¢y5?1nܵd"

Page 221: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

210 çIæÛYFn

4¤ûÖ©�µ""éûÖ©��µ"§́ éÝI<÷vçI©�5½�<!

�1Ú&���¦�¢Sµd"µI�¬UçI©�5½�ûÖ©�µ"IO§

éÝI©��¥ûÖ©�?1µ""Ù¥§çI©�5½��*µ"Ï�§µI�

¬�±Sü;<§éÝI©�¥�ûÖ©�Ü©"�§?1Ú�µd"

5¤ÝI©�©�`²"ÝI©�©�`²´µID�ÝI<éÙÝI©�?

�Ú)º`²�Ŭ§�صI�¬éÝI©��¦¾§±ÏéÝI�Ñ�(�

ä"5¿§ÝI<Ø�ÌÄ�çI<½µI�¬JÑ©�`²§=´3µI�

¬�¦ÙéÝI©�,�¯�©�`²�§ÝI<âUAµI�¬��¦éÝI

©�?1©�`²§=µI�¬uyÝI©�¥�3¹Âز(�SN§AÖ¡

�¦ÝI<?17��©�!̀ ²�Ö�§uѯK©�Ï�Ö"��/§ÝI©�

¯K©�Ï�ÖA1²¯K©�Ï�ü?Ò!ÝI<¶¡!I�©�`²�¯KÚ

ÝI<4�©�`²��m!/:��ª�¯�"�¦ÝI<©�`²�§©�`

²�¯KA²("µI�¬JÑ�ÝI©�I�©�!̀ ²�Ö�¯KØ��Ñ

ÝI<J��ÝI©���½UCÙÝI©�¢�5SN"Ó�§µI�¬A(

½ÝI<é¯K©�`²��ª!¼��'y²á���U5Ú�¤©�`²�Ü

n�m"ÝI©�¯K©�Ï�Ö�¤�§µI�¬A��çI<9ϵIó�

�|§dÙKI<\i�æ^çI©�5½�ªux�ÝI<"çI<9ϵIó

��|35½�mSÂ�ÝI<�Ö¡©�`²�§A9�=xµI�¬"35

½��mS§ÝI<ØUìµI�¬�¦éÙÝI©�?1©�`²�§µI�

¬�±UìØ|uTÝI<�¥In)�¤µ""éÃ{n)ÝIý¢¿ã�§

�±ÄûÙÝI§¿3µI�w¥P1Äû�nd"

6¤nÜüS"éÝI?1nÜüS§́ µI�¬éÝI?1/'�0��Ô§

Ï�k'�âk�O§́ J`í�¥IÿÀ<�Ä:§�´çI<J`(½¥I<

��â"Äk§µI�¬AUçI©�¥5½�üSÏ�9Ù(½�{ÚÝI©

�9Ù©�`²�(J§(½üSÏ��§?�üSÏ�'��AL"5¿§µI�

¬é��üSÏ�?1þz�§Aòþz�Iïá3Ó�Ä:½öÓ�IOþ§

±¦�Ñ�üSÏ��äk�'5¶Ùg§µI�¬UçI©�5½�üÏ�½

õÏ�üS�{§Uµ"Ï��S'XÚüSÏ��§aquc$øý�§éÝI

?1nÜüS"

@o§çI©�´Ä�±Ø�¦µI�¬éÝIüS UdçI<üSQº

ül/ªþw§ùvk�oØ�±"�µI�¢�§́ éÎÜæI¦�ÝI?1

'�§? J`(½¥I(J"µI�¬XJØéÝI?1üS§ÒÔ��3

�¿Â§���u�µI�¬;�`³J`��Ým�"

Page 222: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 211

4.µI�w"µI�w§́ µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{é

ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'��P¹"µI�¬UÝInÜüS(JÚçI©���

¦§J`í�üS3c�ÝI�¥IÿÀ<§X¢P1µI�¬�µ"Ú'�L

§!í�¥IÿÀ<�nd§±9çI<(½¥I<!?1ÜÓ!�I�5¿�¯

��"5¿§µI�w´µI�¬éÝI�;�µ��¤J©�§́ çI<J`

(½¥I(JI�l��â©�§I�÷vý¢5!��5Ú�J�5�A:"

�çI<J�Ö¡µI�w�§µI�¬¤lmµIy|�§L��k'

µI]�!L�!P¹�9Ù¦^¬�"çI<AéµI�¬¤­�µIVƧ

�¦Ùé��µIL§ÚµI(J��"7��§µI�¬AéÙµI�wk'

¯�?1)º½`²§�ÏçI<½1�iÒÅ�?nÝI<éµI(J�Éƽ

�"

14!�wµµ"Ú'��P¹

µI�w´µI�¬�çI<J��§�3X¢P¹ÙUçI©�¥5½�

µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§�ѵ�(J��w"µI�w�

�AdµI�¬�N¤\i§±«Ó¿µI(Ø"@o§µI�¬¤ØÓ

¿µI(اØ3µI�wþ\i§́ Ä�½¿�XµIÃ�§I�­#|ïµI�

¬µIíº�Y´µI®²(å§ØI�|�­#µI§çI<I�UµI�

¬�¤�Ö¡µI�wÚí��Ü�¥IÿÀ<(½¥I<"5¿§µI�¬¤

áý3µI�wþ\iqØÖ¡`²ÙØÓ¿�Únd�§À�Ó¿µI(J"

ù«�/éçI<UµI�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<(½¥I<vkK�"̄ K�'

�§3uÑyµI�¬¤ØÓ¿µI(اØ3µI�wþ\i�§TµI�

¬¤±Ö¡/ª`²ÙØÓ¿�Únd§µI�wþÓ��5²TØÓ¿

��§̄ ¢þ/¤ü«±þ�µ"(ØÚí�¿�§I�çI<�lª¢Å&�

�K§UæI¦(½¥I(J"

[µI�w\i��¯] ,IkÝ]úi3,½°�ï�l�§�Bul��Ö

+n§TÝ]úi3½«|�ï���ïÓ¡È12000m2��ú�Ö¢"T�83

½ï�Ûu�«��´¥%|�mI§k6�ÝI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���

mc4�ÝI©�"çI<Uk'5½�{|ïµI�¬§µI�¬dç

I<�L1<§½ï�ÛµI;[¥�ÅÄ�²L;[1<!Eâ;[3<|¤"Ù

¥§çI<�L´� ó§ï�²�´L!ÙGçIÝI{Æ{5�]�;["

µIL§¥§çI<�Luyo �/µI;[¥¥�ÅÄ��;[3�åû

Page 223: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

212 çIæÛYFn

Ƨ¿�¦Ù¿�§µ"í��/�[�óè�A¥I"çI<�LØÓ¿§@�¯

õÝI<¥§AUçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"

Ó�§@��/ù[�óè�A�dp§ÙÝI©�?�Y²Ðy�EâC�!<

¢å!�1Ú[��8²n�§Ñ�ØXë�ÝI�Ù¦A[�óè��dÚ¢

år"�d§çI<�LïÆUçI©�¥5½�µ"Ï�!µ©IOÚµII�

�į�§éÝI?1�*!ú�/µ"Ú'�§UÝI<�©�p$üS§J`

í�üS3c�ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<"µI�¬Ù¦¤éçI<�L�ïÆL

«@Ó"

µIæ^ÐÚµ"!�[µ"!nÜüSÚí�¥IÿÀ<�µ"§S§6�Ý

I<þÏLÐÚµ""µI�¬UìçI©�5½�µ©Ï�§=ÝI�d!

�ó|��O!�8+nÅ�ÚÙ¦ûÖ^�§é6[ÝI<4��ÝI©�?1

µ©§W�µ©L"�¤3ÙgC�¤�µ©Lþ\i�§�dó�<®o"µ

©®o�§çI<�Luy©ê�p��´ÝI<A§éÛ%§Ï�ÝI<A�ÝI

�d p!�ó|��O?�Y²$e§��kI?%�µI;[Ø�U�ÙµÑ

�p�©"u´§çI<�L�é�ÅÄ��o µI;[�µ©L§uyo 

µI;[3�ó|��O�Ì*µ"Ï�þ¯��c/�ÝI<Aµ�p©§éÙ

¦ÝI<µ�$©½´��5/µ©"

µI�wU®o(J�¤�§3éµI�w\iL§¥§çI<�Láý3µ

I�wþ\i§�eÖ¡�ØÓ¿�Únd§~Þo µI;[3µIL§¥

�««1,ÚØÓ¿µI(Ø�nd§²(�¦3µI�wX¢P1ÙØÓ¿µI

(Ø�¿�Únd"

µI(å�§�/�?� Ì+ï��+�c çI<�8|�ú¤3/§�

çI<�8KI<ûƧF"ì��e�/è�§//�ã�v�oa§��vk�

o��Ý]�8§�óè�FfL�qJ"ù��8§ì��e·��/ù[ü¶

1���óè�j�0�/��?+�Ñ¡§çI<��8KI<(½¥I<�§v

2j±çI<�L�ØÓ¿�"

�¯�ùp¿vk(å§̄ �þ��úi+��§úi+��KþÓ¿çI<

�8|(½ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<§=ÝI<A¥I"�Ó�§�¦úiVui

Ü�0\d¯§��/V�iÅ'�ú¼§±çI<�L3ÙØÓ¿�Únd¥

Û�y�§�¦VuiÅ'é��8µIL§?1�ÜN�"T�8móØ��

��§VuuÅ'é�/ï�ÛçIÝI+n�ú¿Ì?ë,?1V5§éÙ�

'�{¯¢?�Ú�?§nd´o µI;[3iÅ'N��yL§¥§þÞy

ë,3µIm©c§ro ;[é��åm¬§²(�«µI�§7LrÝI<Aí

Page 224: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 213

��1�¥IÿÀ<§ë,�1�áu�{�{"Ó�§�¦µI;[¥+nÅ�§

éµI;[��{1��{?1?v"

µI(Ø´µI�¬¤µ"(J�®o§µI�w´µI(Ø�)L§�

P¹"���¹e§µI�w�(Ø´���§=BµI(ØØ��§Xþ¡�w\

i��¯¥¤ã§�ØK�çI<(½¥I(J"µI�wP¹����!�ý¢§

�k|uçI<l¥(½¥I(J"@o§µI�w��o�¦µI�¬�N¤

\iQºµI�¬¤3µI�wþ\i§́ éµI®o(Ø�@�"µI�

¬¤Ø3µI�wþ\i§L²ÙØ@�µI®o(ا=kØÓ¿�§I�

JÑÖ¡�ØÓ¿�§�ãÙØ@�µI®o(Ø�nd"5¿§µI�¬¤

������¬¯1�Uå<§�oÓ¿µI®o(ا3µI�wþ\i§�o

ØÓ¿µI(اJÑØÓ¿µI(Ø�Ö¡¿�Únd§¿3Ùþ\i§«ú¬

¯I?§ØUQØ3µI�wþ\iÓ¿µI®o(اqØ4�ÙØÓ¿µI(

Ø�Ö¡¿�Únd"ùÒ 5́çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�n^5½�§µI�

¬¤áý3µI�wþ\iqØÖ¡`²ÙØÓ¿�Únd�À�Ó¿µI

(J��Ï"

çI<�âµI�¬J��µI�wÚí��Ü�¥IÿÀ<§UæI¦

ÚµI�¬�w�(اJ`(½¥I(J§ù´µI�¬µI§�çI<J

�µI�w�¿Â¤3"��/§µI�wA�X¢P1±eSNµ

1.µIVã"µIVã´éçI�8!mI!µIL§ÚµI(Ø�V)5o

(§�)µ�çI�8Ä��¹§X�8¶¡!çI��!çI�ª!]75 !Á

�Ï�!EâIOÚ�¦�¶�µI��mÚ/:!µI�¬|¤9;[�)�

ª!µI§S!µI�{!µIÏ�ÚIO!ÄûÝI�/!ÝI¿�§Ý�¶�µ

I(ا=UçI©�5½�üS�{éÝI�üS(J§µI�¬í�üS3

c�ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<§éA�üS!ÝI�d!Á�Ï�!�þIO§±9k|

uçI<�Ù¦¯��¶�?�ÚïƧé¥IÿÀ<ÝI©�¥�3�¯K9ç

I<\¾ÜÓcA5¿�¯KJÑïÆ"µIVã´µI�V)5o(§å/jÞ

8Ü0��^"��/§µIVã�����\i9§�¦µI�¬Ì?�Ú

���\i"

2.µI�¬\�L9«ìÖ"µI�¬\�L´µI�¬�|¤P¹§

�)çI<�L!k'Eâ!²L�;[6¶!Eâ�¡!éX�ª!µI�¬

?�Ú\i¶«ìÖ§́ �¦µI�¬¤3µIm©c«ì�ÝI<Ø�3|

³'X"~X§«ìÙØ´ÝI<½ÝI<Ì�KI<�C�á§�ÝI<vk²

L|Ã'X§±9�ÝI<Ø�3Ù¦|³'X½�{A�£;��/"µIL§

Page 225: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

214 çIæÛYFn

¥§µI�¬¤�ÝI<m�3|³'X�§A�ÌÄJÑ£;"�{A�£

; Ø£;�¤ë�µI�§Ùµ"(ØÃ�¶Ùµ"(Øé¥I(JE¤¢�

5K��§¥IÃ�§A�­#µI"çI<½1�iÒÅ�uyµI�¬¤

�ÝI<�3|³'X�§A�9���§Ù®²�Ñ�µ"(ØÃ�§dO�Ù

�Ù¦¤­#?1µ""Ó�§�¦Ùl|cé�G�µI¯���"

3.mIP¹"mIP¹��mI�X¢P¹§́ µI�¢Ú"µI�wA�é

mIP¹�ü«�/�Ñ(Ø5¿�"Ù¥§�´�émIP¹�¦µI�¬µ

��¯�"~X§mI�§ÝI<�Lé,��ÝI<��8²n?�½�1JÑ

ÉƧ½´@�ÙÝI�3Eb1��§µI�¬A�émIP¹P1��/§k

�é5/éÝI©�?1µ"§�Ñ(Ø5¿��¶�´uyÝI©�1²�ÝI

¯¢�mIP¹Ø��§©Û´mI�Ø�´�Uk<he��?UÝI©�"

mI�ØØK�µI§µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�

?1µ"Ú'�§µI�wX¢P1üö�É=�¶~¦k<he��?UÝI

©��§AX¢w�çI<½1�iÒÅ�§û½´UYµI�´µIª�"û½

UYµI�§µI�wIX¢P1üö�ɧ�ºµI¦^�ÝI©�"7��§3

µI¦^�ÝI©�þO\I£§±B¯��é"

4.µ"Ï�ÚIO�AL" µ"Ï�ÚIO uçI©�¥�µ"Ï�Úµ

"IO"5¿§çI<3çI©�5½�mcuÑçI©�©�Ú?U§N�µ

"Ï�½µ"IO�§µI�¬IòçI©�§±9Ù©�Ú?U¥�µ"Ï�

Úµ"IO®o§8¥Û�§±B��"

5.ÐÚµ"P¹L"ÐÚµ"P¹´éÝI©�/ªµ"!]�µ"Ú�A5

µ"�P¹"��/§/ªµ"!]�µ"Ú�A5µ"©OP¹3ØÓ�L�§µ

"Ï��µ"(Ø¿� /́ÎÜ0½/ØÎÜ0§µ"(Ø /́ÏL0½/ØÏL0"

k��µ"Ï�ØÎÜ�§µ"(ØÒ´/ØÏL0"Ù¥§µ"Ï��µ"(Ø

/ÎÜ0�§A5²ÝI©�Jø�y²á�!]��aO!�è��¶µ"Ï��

µ"(Ø/ØÎÜ0�§A�[`²ÝI©�"��y²á�½]�§±9�½/Ø

ÎÜ0�nd§Ó�§3ÝI©��A/��ÐI£§±B��"7��§µI�

¬�±�¦ÝI<J�k'y²Úy����§±BØ�Ù�ÝI©�¥Jø�

y²Úy����5"ÝI©�¥Jø�y²½y��!Ã{E@�ÝI<ØU

35½�Ün�mSJøk��y²½y����§µI�¬�±��ÄûÙÝ

I§3ÐÚµ"P¹LþX¢P¹"

6.�[µ"P¹L"�[µ"P¹§́ 3ÝIÏLÐÚµ"Ä:þ§éÝI©

Page 226: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 215

��["��µ"Ú'�P¹"5¿§µ"´'��Ä:"/µ"0´µI�¬

UçI©�¥5½��[µ"Úµ"IO§(½ÝI©�1²��[µ"Ï�3÷

vçI©��¦�Ä:þ§?�Ú(½ÙÝI�Eâ!²Lµ"Ï�÷v�§Ý½

ê�§IµI�¬éÝI©�1²�ÝI¯¢?1©ÛÚïħUÝI¯¢(½¶

/'�0´ØÓÝI©�éÓ�Eâ½²Lµ"Ï�1²�ÝI¯¢��p'�§

û½ØÓÝI3Ó�µ"Ï�þ�S'X½´üSëþ"çI�8�kI.�§µ

I�¬A�ë�I.§©ÛÝI�d�¤9�U�3�زï�d"

µIL§¥§µI�¬uyÝI<��d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d½ö3�k

I.�²w$uI.§¦�ÙÝI�d�U$uÙ�O¤� ��ÜÓ�UÃ{�

~Á1�§A��¦ÝI<�ÑÖ¡`²¿Jø�'y²á�"éÝI<ØUÜn

`²½öØUJø�'y²á��§@½TÝI<±$u¤��d¿I¿ÄûÙÝ

I¶éÝI<UÜn`²�§µI�w¥Aé�½ÝI�d´$u�´Ø$uÙ

�O¤�X¢P¹§NÝI<�'y²á�Ú`²½«ì§J«çI<3ÜÓÇ�

ÚÁ��\rÜÓ+n"~X§\¾ÜÓ�§3;^ÜÓ^±?�Ú[zÁ�^±§

�¦¥I<J�Á��y�"

7.üSëþ�AL"µI�¬UçI©�5½�üSÏ�9(½�{§3é

ÝI©��[µ"�Ä:þ(½�ÝIüSÏ�éA�ëþ�§Xd�!©ê½¦

ê�"µI�wAX¢P1üSëþ�(½L§Ú(J§éÝIéA��üSëþ

?1®o§?�üSëþ�AL"7��§AòµI�¬¤Õá(½�ÝIü

SëþL��N�§±<yüSëþ�AL"

8.nÜüS"µI�¬UçI©�5½�üS�{ÚüSëþ§éÝI?1

nÜüS"µI�wAX¢P¹nÜüS(JÚüSL§"Ù¥§üÏ�üS�§±

çI©�¥5½�üSëþ��?1üS¶õÏ�üS�§AX¢P1üSëþ�

�!�½�S�^�Únd!üSL§ÚüS(J"

9.í�¥IÿÀ<"µI�¬UçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{!ÝInÜü

S(J§J`í�ü¶3c�ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<"5¿§ÝInÜüS�S�§

í��¥IÿÀ<A�¿�"~X§ÝI<1ÚÝI<23nÜüS¥ �1�Ú1

�§�ÝI<1ÚÝI<2´�S§KµI�wA�Ó�í�ÝI<1ÚÝI<2�1

�¥IÿÀ<§(²üSØ©k�§dçI<UnÜüS(½ÝI<1½ÝI<2�

¥I<"

10.µI�w�Ù¦¯�"µI�w´çI<J`(½¥I<Ú��\¾ÜÓ

��â§édk|�P¹ÑAB\µI�w§�)µ�µIL§¥§µI�¬�

Page 227: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

216 çIæÛYFn

¦ÝI<éÙÝI©�©�`²�¯�§±9ÝI<UµI�¬�¦J��ÝI

©�©�`²��ÝI©���Ü©§AB\µI�w§��ÜÓÇ��^�¶�

µI�¬3éÝI©�µ"Ú'�L§¥uyÝI©�¥�3�/�²0½´Ù

¦�UE¤çI<�ÃÉ��³�^±½¯��§A3µI�w¥w�çI<3?

1ÜÓÇ�½\¾ÜÓ�I­:!�¯�§±�Á�¥É��³�"

µI�w��µI�¬X¢P¹µI��w§́ 3çI©�(á�çIÝI

5KÄ:þéÝI�;�µ��w§́ çIæÔÑOy�u�"Ó�§çIæ

ÔÑýÏ8I²Lµ"Ú'�§q´éçIæýÏ8I�µ"�u�"µI(å

�§æJ`8I�±¢y§I2�2x§UJ`^�Á�¶æJ`8Iv¢y§

I?�Ú©Û�ϧ�¾éü§/�}´¤õ�10§o(�JpæEâUå"Ä

k§I�©ÛçIæÔÑ´Ä��§́ ÄÎܽ|ø�¢S§o(|�ÝI¿�

����¶Ùg§©Û´3�yÝI¿��´3r/ª!rL|§/¯�h���0§

��+¬çIæ�¦�²Lƿ§ØäJp|�ÝI¿�J`�U姱38

�çIæ¥u�Ù²L�^"

15!Y~µµI�{�çI�}Y

µI�¬´çI<|ï���éÝI?1;�µ���¬§Ù1�É�ç

I<uÑ�çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{��å"¢Sþ§µI�¬´3ç

I©�§=çI<úÙ�J`IOe§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"3ù�:þ§

µI�¬´/ìÙ�¯0�µ��I§vk5K�½�§=´UçI<3çI©

�¥úÙ�µIIOÚµI§S§=çI<J`I¦éÝI©�§=ÝI¯¢?1

µ"Ú'�§�¤µI�w§í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<±ÑÖuçI<J`(½¥I

(J"µI�¬�ù�A�§k�/(ܵI;[�;�`³ÚçI<�Lé

æI¦���n)§�ïJ`¢yæ(J�µ�ûüÅ�§;�v¥|þà

��ç¯�"��§µI�¬9Ù¤��ù�µIÄ�5K§½´ÙµI1

�É��{Zý§7,��µI(J�ý§K�J`¢yæ(J"e¡ù�Y~§

=´ÏµI�¬��µI5K ���çI�}"

[Y�£�] ,½Ý]5000��é�¤úá��?1U*ï§æ^úmçI(

½ó§�óü "T�8k5�ÝI<A!B!C!DÚE3çI©�1²�ÝI��

�mc4�ÝI©�§ë�mI§ÙÝI�d©O�4560.00��!4380.00�

�!4460.00��!4590.00��Ú4480.00��"mI�§çI<�{|ï5<|¤

�µI�¬§\ݵI�¬\�LÚ«ìÖ§«ì�ÝI<vk|³'X"

Page 228: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 217

µI�¬ÄkÆSçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{"� µI;[@�§��

8��óJ:3�y���Eâ§XCT!Ø^��!DRXÚ!CR!óªX1Å!

NÀÂÅ��Å!pØ�ò��.�E��SCþ��ܧïƵ"Ï�ü��

E�ܧ©�10©§d��ó|��O35©U�28©§ÝI�d55©U52©§~e

�10©©���E�ܧ٥§�E�Ü�ó�Y7©§C5cz�ó�¤��§�

Ü�¤CT!Ø^��!DRXÚ!CR!óªX1Å!NÀÂÅ��Å!pØ�ò�

n«±þy��E�1©§�p3©"µI�¬��Ó¿ù�?U§@�ù��?

U�ÎÜy����A:"

ÝI<þÏLÐÚµ""��§µI�¬?1�[µ"§Å���ÝI<

�è�E��ì!]�yÖ!S�)�N�y!ïE�yÖ!���8�1!¼øy

ÖÚ�8²nÜÌ�<��yÖ����§ÝI<A����¤���ÜÓ�

ÆÖ§Ù�ú/åµIy|éC§�¦µI�¬��Ù�£��ÜÓ�ÆÖ�2

éÙ��§µI�¬L«@Ó§UÙ�£�CÊc�¤�n¤���ÜÓ�ÆÖ

�éÙ��"µI�¬�âéÝI<��(JP¹§éÝI<�1!J�!�8

²nÚ�8+nÅ��µ"Ï�?1µ©§ÝI<A �©ê�p"

éÝI�dµ"L§¥§AçI<�LïƧµI�¬�ÝI<uÑéÝI

©�©�`²�¼�§�¦ÝI<3J��Ö¡ÝI©�©�`²þ§W�3��

dÄ:þe2�½ê���ª�d"ÝI<A!B!C!DÚE35½�mSUµI�

¬�¦4�Ö¡�ÝI©�©�`²§Ùþ1²�ÝI�d©O�4410.00�

�!4360.00��!4460.00��!4450.00 ��Ú4430.00��"µI�¬UÝI<

��ª�d§(½µIÄOd�4422.00��§3dÄ:þO�ÝI�d� �ÇÚ

�©§ÝI<A��d�÷©"

é�ó|��Oµ©L§¥§µI�¬¤ë,âu%9¾§Ø�Ø;:�

�120òÙx��sͧµI�¬Ù¦¤a,!�,!o,Ú±,UYé�ó|

��O?1µ"Ú'�"Ù¥§é�ó|��O/Ì��ó�{�Eâ��0§çI

©�5½�µ©«m�[5,15]§a,!�,Úo,�ÝI<A�µ©^g�20©!24©

Ú25©§éÝI<B!C!D ÚE �µ©K�5©½6©"

µ©®oUë,!a,!�,!o,Ú±,�µ©(J®o"Ù¥§ë,é�ó

|��O�©�µ©�a,!�,!o,Ú±,�²þ©�§a,�ë,W�µ©

L�§dµI�¬Ì?3ë,µ©LÚµ©®oLþ�\"µ©®oLw«§Ý

I<A��©�p§µI�¬í�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<§ÝI<E�©gp§�1

�¥IÿÀ<"

µI(Jú«Ïm§ÝI<E�çI<JÑÉƧ¡µI�¬3µIL§¥

Page 229: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

218 çIæÛYFn

�¦ÝI<3��dÄ:þe2§2g�ª�d��{§��çI©�1²�Ý

I��§́ 3ÝI����ÉÝI§��{Æ5½"çI<�E¡§µI�¬�

¦ÝI<3ÝI©�©�`²¥W��ª�d§¿vk`�½�e2§ÝI<´3

Ùþ(@ÝI�d"Ó�§µIdµI�¬KI§�çI<Ã'§çI<´Uµ

I�¬�¤�Ö¡µI�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<(½¥I<"ÝI<EéçI<

��EØ÷¿§�1�iÒÅ�?1Ý�"

1�iÒÅ�ÉnÝ��§I-6ÊçIÝI¹Ä§N�µI¹�§��

µI�w§r�ÝI<N��y§¼�ÝI©�©�`²�]�§@½�gµI

¹Ä��{Æ{5�5½§K�¥I(J§\Ù¥IÃ�"û½éµI�¬¤

�{?1?v§6Êë,!a,!�,!o,Ú±,�5<6���µI]�"Ó�§

�¦çI<�{­#|ïµI�¬µI"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±e¯Kµ

1.µIL§¥§µI�¬=1��B�1�§�YµIL§Ñy=¯

K§��oº

2.�YéÝI<A�ÝIµ"¥�3�o¯K§��=�K§��oº

3.�YµI�¬AN�µI§éçI<|�µIk=é&º

[Y~©Û] �âY�£�Ú�'5½§én�¯K©ÛXeµ

1.5çIÝI{61Ê�8^5½§µI�¬¤3µIL§¥ÂÉÝI<

�ãÔ½öÙ¦Ð?�§vÂÂÉ�ãÔ§?3000�±þ5��±e�v±§��ú

?µI�¬¤�]�§Ø�2ë\�{7L?1çI��8�µI¶�¤��

�§�{JÄ-¯I?"5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ô�^5½�µIL§¥µI�

¬¤�B�1�kµ��ÝI<�3|³'X§�{A�£; Ø£;¶�ò

l�ŧK�µI��~?1¶�ØUìçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{µI¶�

he�>ÝI<¶��çI<�Î(½¥I<�¿�½ö�É?Ûü ½ö�<²

«½öV«JÑ���½öü½A½ÝI<��¦¶�é�{A�Äû�ÝIØJ

ÑÄû¿�¶�V«½öp�ÝI<�Ñ©�!̀ ²½ö�ÉÝI<ÌÄJÑ�©

�!̀ ²¶�Ù¦Ø�*!Øú�Á1�Ö�1��§²(5½dk'1�iÒÜ

�I-U�¶�!î­�§B�Ù3�½Ï�Së\�{7L?1çI��8�µ

I¶�!AOî­�§��Ùú?µI�¬¤�]�"

�YµIL§¥Ñy��{�5¯K½Øþ�?Xeµ�N�!?UçI©�

¥µ"Ï�ÚIOØþ§Ly3µI�¬O\/�E�Ü0µ"Ï�§N��ó

|��O!ÝI�d©�§O\�E�Ü�ó�YÚ�1©��¯�§Ï�µI�

¬Ø´çI<§vkçI5K�?U�Ú�½�§ÙµI��â�U5 uçI

Page 230: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

19ÙçIæµµI�|� 219

<3çI©�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ�{¶��âéÝI<����(J Ø´ÝI

©�1²¯�éÝI<�1!J�!�8²nÚ�8+nÅ��µ"Ï�?1µ©

Øþ§Ï������8�´�yÝI©�¥�Aá��ý�§¤�����Ø´

ÝI©�§ØU��µI�N¶��¦ÝI<3ÝI©�©�`²¥�ª�dØþ§

Ï�ÝI®²��§µI�¬ù�1�¢Sþ´#NÝI<3ÝI���?UÝ

I©��¢�5SN§��ÝI���m�AáÂÝI<ÝI�5K¶�µI�

¬¤¥�a,!�,Úo,�ÑçI©�5½�/Ì��ó�{�Eâ��0

µ©«m[5,15]�ÝI<Aµ©Øþ§��UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§

éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'��5½¶�µI�¬¤ë,âu%9¾;:x �

�sͧë,��ó|��O�©�µ©�a,!�,!o,Ú±,�²þ©�§d

µI�¬Ì?3ë,µ©LÚµ©®oLþ�ë,\iØþ§5çIÝI{61

o�o^5½§µI�¬¤A��*!ú�/Á1�Ö§�Å����§é¤

JÑ�µ"¿�«ú�<I?§=µI�¬¤A�dÙ�<¢�µI1�§Ø

��÷�n<�ÙéÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§ë,ØU�÷µI�¬Ì?�1

ÙI§µI�¬Ì?�Ã��ë,\i"�Yë,Ïâu%9¾;:x ��s

ͧA�9���ÎÜ�¦�<O�ë,µI§ë,®�Ñ�µ"(ØÃ�§d

O�ë,µI�<­#?1µ"§®oµI(Ø"

2.�YµI�¬éÝI<A�ÝIµ"¥�3±e¯Kµ�ÝI<A���

Ù�¤���ÜÓ�1§µI�¬Ó¿�Ù�£��ÜÓ�ÆÖ�2éÙ��Ø

þ§éÙ¦ÝI<Øú²§k�ú#¶�µI�¬¤a,!�,Úo,�ÑçI

©�5½��ó|��O¥�/Ì��ó�{�Eâ��0Ï��µ©«m�[5,15]§

=µ©þ�15©�ÝI<A�/Ì��ó�{�Eâ��0µ©�20©!24©Ú25©

�{§��µI�¬¤A��{UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§�*!

ú�/éÝI©�Jѵ"¿�§çI©�vk5½�µIIOÚ�{Ø���µ

I�â�5½"

3.�YµI�¬�(�µI�{´UçI©�¥5½�µI§S!µIIO

Ú�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"=µ�UçI©�¥

5½�µ©IOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ©§ØUO\½~�µ©Ï�§ØUN�

½?Uµ©IO¶�ÝI<�1!J�!�8²nÚ�8+nÅ��µ"Ï�§A

UÝI©�þ1²�¯�?1µ©"��¥uyÝI©�1²¯����Ø��

�§A?1©Û�ä§(@ÝI©�"�Ã{?1µ"Ú'��§½´(@ÝI©

��3áJ�b1��§A�{ÄûÝI¶�éÝI�dµ"§A±mIP¹þÝ

I<A!B!C!DÚE��d4560.00��!4380.00��!4460.00��!4590.00��

Page 231: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

220 çIæÛYFn

Ú4480.00���¢Ú§©ÛÙ�d��¤§X<ó¤!á�!��¤!+n¤Ú|

d§±9�UÛ¹�Á�ºx�Ä:þ?1µ©¶�é�ó|��O�Ì*µ"Ï

�§A�´3(@÷vçI©�I¦�cJe§éÝI(J?1î�`�'�Úü

S§UçI©�5½�µ©«mÚüS(J?1µ©¶�ë,âu%9¾;:x

��sͧçI<A(½� ÎÜ�¦�<O�ë,ë�µI§ë,®²�Ñ�

µ"(ØÃ�§dO�ë,µI�<­#?1µ"§?1®o§�¤µI�wÚ

í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"

�YéçI<�é&3u§µI´UçI<úÙ�¯¢§=çI©�¥5½�

µIIOÚ�{§éÝI¯¢§=ÝI<3ÝI���mc4��ÝI©�?1µ

"Ú'�§µIØ���ù�Ä�5K"ÄK§¬��çI�}"�ö¥IÃ�§ç

I<L|�­#µI¶­ö§ÜÓÃ�§Ã{�oçI<�Ü{�Ã"

Page 232: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 10Ù

çIæµÜÓ�Ç�

**********************************************************************

ZpÓ���V§zc9Â���"

— /.oEó5Y_%¹.½´A6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 233: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

222 çIæÛYFn

11!(@µµI(J�@�

µI�¬�¤µI�§�çI<J�Ö¡µI�w§í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"

çI<Â�µI�¬�µI�w�§A�UµI�¬L�l�§=UçI©�

¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'��5K§éµI(ØÚí��

¥IÿÀ<�±(@"�{7L?1çI��8§çI<�A�3k'x0þú«

¥IÿÀ<§�ÉÝI<Ú�¬1n<�iÒ"ù�¥§éµI(J(@§́ çI

<�ɵI(J�1�Ly"��/§çI<A��ɵI�¬�{�¤�µI

(J"@o§çI<3�o�¹e�±Ø�ɵI(JQº�k�«�/§Ò´µ

I�¬9Ù¤µIL§¥�3�{1�"~X§é�{A�Äû�ÝIØJÑ

Äû¿�§ØUçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§½

öV«!p�ÝI<éÝI©��Ñ©�`²�§K�¥I(J�§¥IÃ�§A

��{­#?1µ"Ú'�"5¿§µI�¬9Ù¤��{µI1�K�¥I

(J§¥IÃ��§�@´3çI<(@µI(J�uy§�´3ÜÓÁ���±

uy§uy��@�Bu?n§��§AO´çI<®Ç�ÜÓ½´çIæQ¤

¯¢§�J?n"

[µI(J(@��¯] ,Ikè��¤���­w¾�?1Ϻ�NXÚU

E§æ^úmçI�ªæ35�eæªCª�N"çI©�Eâ5�Ö¥1²�

'�Eâëꥧ�)�NU��?3?§·^¡È�≥ 65m2§�eþ≥ 9000W§

�9þ≥ 9000W§>9\9õÇ≥ 4500W§¿SÅDÑ≤ 38dB(A)§¿ÅDÑ≤45dB(A)§½ªÅU�'≥ 3§Ì�ºþ≥ 1450m3/h§> 220/50V/hz§¿SÅSC

�mµ°×p×�= 550mm × 1500mm × 400mm§­þ≤ 60kg§¿ÅSC�mµ

°×p×�= 1000mm× 1150mm× 410mm§­þ≤ 100kg�Eâ�I"

T�8k5�ÝI<A!B!C!DÚE3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc4�Ý

I©�§þ�IS�¶¬ý"ÝI<4��ÝI©�1²§ÝI<AÝI��Nëê§

�e!�9þ!·^¡È!Sź��÷vçI©��¦§¿SÅDÑ≤ 50dB(A)§

¿ÅDÑ≤ 60dB(A)"

mI�§çI<|ï5<µI�¬"Ù¥§çI<�L1<§ïÓ²L;�¶

�?nܵI;[¥¥�ÅÄ�4<§��e�ææ�N��;�"µI�¬é

ÝI<ÝI��NEâëê?1ÐÚµ"§(@ÑÎÜçI©�¥�æI¦"u

Page 234: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 223

´§UçI©�5½�µ©IOéÝI<A!B!C!DÚE�ÝI?1µ"�©§U

ì�©dp�$�gSüS§í�ÝI<A!BÚC��gí��1�!1�Ú1n

¥IÿÀ<"

çI<Â�µI�w�9�éµI(Ø�±(@§¿u1�U3uÙçIúw

�Ó�x0ú«µI(J§�)¥IÿÀ<A!BÚC�¶¡ÚüS!ÝI�d!

�þ!�ÀÏ!¥IÿÀ<�]�Uå!JÑÉÆ��ª�¯�"5½�ú«ÏS§

ÝI<9Ù|³'X<v�çI<JÑÉƧ�v�1�iÒÅ�Ý�§çI<�

{(½ü¶1��ÝI<A�¥I<§�ÝI<AuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§�Ù\¾

�NæÖ¡ÜÓ"Ó�§çI<ò¥I(JÏ�¤k�¥I�ÝI<"

ÝI<AUìÜÓ�½§|�ÜÓ1².Ò��N��¤I��á�!¤¬!�

¤¬æÚ\ó�E§3ÜÓ�½�øÀÏ�S§XÏò35�eæªCª�N$-

T���GSC"çI<�É�N���§UìÜÓ�½|GÝI<AÜÓd±§�

3ÜÓd±�10%��N����þ�y7§�ÜÓ�½�"�I?Ϫ��21

|G"

T�8eó�Â�§?1XÚÿÁ§uy�N¿SÅDÑ349dB(A)-50 dB(A)§

¿Å�58dB(A)-60 dB(A)§rIþUf�¿SÅÚ¿ÅuÑ�DѧK�­

w¾<>E"�Â|��Oã�'é�uy§T�8�O�¦¥§¿SÅ�DÑ≤38dB(A)§¿ÅDÑ≤ 45dB(A)" y|¢ÿDÑ�§¿SÅ49dB(A)-50dB(A)§

¿Å58dB(A)-60dB(A)§��Ø÷v­w¾���O�¦§I��ó­�"

çI<�¦ÝI<Aò�ù35��N��"ÝI<AØÓ¿§¡ÙÝI©�¥1

²�¿SÅDÑ´50dB(A)©�§¿Å60dB(A)©�§çI<�ÉÙÝI¿��

\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§�Â(JL²DÑ¢ÿ�ÎÜÜÓ�¦"çI<��çI�Y§u

yçI©�1²�DÑ�§©O´¿SÅDÑ≤ 38dB(A)§¿ÅDÑ≤ 45dB(A)§

��O�¦��¶��ÝI<A �ÝI©�§Ùþ1²��N.Ò¿SÅÚ¿Å

�DÑ��(´50 dB(A)©�Ú60 dB(A)©�§�ÜÓ\¾.Ò��"̄ Kw5´

Ñ3µI�!"�d§çI<�£o ë�µI�;[§Î¯µ"Ú'�¥´Äu

yÝI<AÝI��NDÑ�ØÎÜçI©�5½§;[¡µI�@�Ñ´��)

���N§Ø¬�3�þ¯K§vÅ�"�'�Eâëê§í�ÝI<A �1�¥

IÿÀ<´Ï�Ù�©�p"Ó�§µI;[`§çI<@�µI�¬�Ñ�µ

"(ØØ�(§�±Ø�É �¦­#µI"Q,çI<�ÝI<A¾áÖ¡Ü

Ó§Ò`²çI<@�µI(Ø´�(�§̀ ²çI<�ɵI�¬�µ"(

اA�Uì�ÝI<A�ÜÓ�½«úÜÓI?"

�¯ù�ùp§çI<ý /́�¡Ãb!Ä�Ã�0"Ø�®§çI<��J\

Page 235: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

224 çIæÛYFn

Ý]§�¦SCèr e��N��SC�ÊϾ�§U­w¾���O�¦§­

#æ35 ��N"éA�§­w¾��UEò´n��eó"�d§çI<JÄ

��S�'I?<�I?§òo µI;[µIØ@ý�1��"�½nܵI;

[¥+nü ?n"

�¯�(ÛF<Ï�§ù�¥���Ä��¯K´§XéçIæ(J«úI

?ºQ,´çI<æ§éæ(J«úI?�ÌN�,´çI<gC��~�¹

e§µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§�*!ú�/éÝI©�?

1µ"Ú'�§�¤µI�w¿í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<§±øçI<J`(½¥I

(J§ù´ïá3µI�¬�{Á1Ù�IÄ:þ�"@o§XJµI�¬

µIÑyØ�*!Øú�§½´vkUçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©

�?1µ"Ú'��1�§A�«ú�oI?Qº5çIÝI{¢�^~65½1

�?v§́ dk'1�iÒÅ�I-U�§=´�!î­�§B�Ù3�½Ï�S

ë\�{7L?1çI��8�µI¶�!AOî­�§��Ùú?µI�¬¤

�]�"@o§Ã<Ý�½´1�iÒ¥vuyµI�¬��{Á�§�Xµ

I(@��¯¥¤ù�§(J�½´çI<gC �¦<«ú§Ï�çI<|ïµ

I�¬�8�§́ �ÏÙUìçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§=çIæI¦

ÚJ`IO§éÝI?1µ"Ú'�"

k<@�§µI�¬¥Ø´kçI<�Lë\§éµ"Ú'��L§X�

ݧ��o��3Â�µI�w�?1(@QºnØþ§çI<�LXJ3µI¥ý

�u�çI<�L��^§Ù3µI�wþ�\i1��Ò�LXéµI(Ø�

(@1�"�¢�¥§kõ�çI<�L3µI¥å�çI<�L��^§qk

õ�çI<�L�k'EâÚ²L;[�;�Uå!µ"Ú'�Uå�±²QºA

�´��q���Ø^`�çI<�í�I?§Ø��Lë\µI �dµI;

[µ"�)�µI(J"ùÒ´çI<éµI(J(@�7�¤3§́ éµI�

¬�¤�µI(JlEâ�²L�(@§±��ÑyµI(@��¯¥@«(Û"

��/§çI<éµI�¬�¤�µI(J(@§́ (@µI�¬´ÄU

ìçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§Ùí��¥IÿÀ

<´ÄÜ�§́ Ä��`¿�(J§Ì�kn�¯�§=ÝI]�!ÝI�AÚÝ

I¿�"

1.ÝI]�(@"5¿§µI�¬´�âçI©�¥5½�]�"�IOÚ

�{éÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�1²�¯¢?1]�"�"Ü�Ò´Ü�§ØÜ�Ò

´ØÜ�"Ø#Nò��Ü��ÝI@½�ØÜ�§�Ø#Nò��ØÜ��ÝI

@½�Ü�ÝI"çI<uyµI�¬éÝI]�"�ØÎÜçI©��¦�§

Page 236: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 225

A9��wk'1�iÒÜ�§�¦µI�¬­#?1"�"

1¤éÝI]�ØÜ��(@"ÝI]�ØÜ�§=ÝI©�vk?\�[µ

"§́ µI¥I�î�"�¯�"ÝI<]�ÎÜI[½öçI©�5½�]�^

�§�µI�¬µ"�@½ÙØÎÜÝI]�^�§~�ÝI¿�§K�µI

(J"Ó�§éÝI<Øú²§��´u��ÝI<Ý�"

éµI�¬@½]�ØÜ��ÝI§çI<I��âçI©�¥5½�]�

"�Ï�Ú"�IO§éìµI�w¥]�"�L¥P¹�ØÜ�nd§Å���

ØÜ�nd´ÄÎÜçI©�5½§ÝI©�9ÝI<AµI�¬J��ÝI©

�©�`²´Äv±y²ÝI<]��3]�"�L¥�P¹¯�§=ÝI<�]

�ØÎÜçI©��¦"��]�"�L¥P¹�ØÜ�ndؤá�K�µI(

J�§A��¦µI�¬±¯¢��⧭#?1]�"�"

2¤éÝI]�Ü��(@"ÝI<]�"�Ü�?\�[µ"�§ÝI<�

�جÏ�]� Ý�§�K�µI(J�§çI<IUçI©�¥5½�]�"

�IOÚ�¦§Å���ÝI©�´ÄJø¿©yâ§y²Ù]�ÎÜçI©�

��¦"ÝI©�¥"��Ay²½´ÝI©�®y²ÝI<�]�ØÎÜçI�

¦§µI�¬#NÝI<3ÝI©�©�`²½´J�]�y²á���� (

@Ù]�Ü��§ØÎÜÝI���Ø�2g#NÝI<?U½��ÝI©��5

½§µI�¬@½ÝI]�Ü��(Øؤá§I�µI�¬­#?1]�"

�"5¿§µI�¬éÝI<­#?1]�"�A±ÝI©�1²�¯¢��â§

�É1�iÒÅ��{¢��iÒ"

[]�y²e¤�¯~] ,çI�nÅ��n���çI�8§çI<(@µI

(Ø�§UçI�nÅ��8²n�J«§uyµI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<

ÝI<B�ÝI©�¥"�]�y²©�ÚISO9000�þ@yÖ§UçI©�5½§

TÝI<B�]�"�ØÜ�§�ØA�í��¥IÿÀ<"çI<��1�iÒ

Å�Ó¿§ð£µI�¬¤§éÝI<B�ÝI]�2g"�(@"µI�

¬¥�;[¤E"�§��@�µI�§ÝI<B�ÝI©�¥k]�y²©�

ÚISO9000�þ@yÖ�E<�§¿Jø�è��"µI�¬E"�§éÝI

<B�ÝI©���!B�?1u�§uy�èk"�§"��@A�T´PÁ¥

ÝI<½�]�y²©�ÚISO9000�þ@yÖ§Ùþ�k�e¤©��í�"é

d§µI�¬�1�iÒÅ�?1�w"1�iÒÅ�N�µIy|¹�]�§

uy´çI�nÅ���8²n§3µI(åc�U��?\�µIy|§e¤

ÝI<½�þã]�y²©�"��§1�iÒÅ�éTçI�nÅ��{?1

?v§\Ù�µI(Øk�"

Page 237: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

226 çIæÛYFn

2.ÝI�A(@"éÝI�A�(@§́ µI�¬�¤�µI�w¥§éÝ

I©�1²�ÝI�AçI©�¥�¢�5�¦Ú^�!k� � lÏ�½�I

�(@§́ çIæ§cÙ´ÀÔçI¥����­��ó�"~X§þ¡µI(

@��¯¥§XJçI<@ý/éÝI�A?1(@§Ò�½¬uyÝI<AÝI

��NDÑØÎÜçI©�1²��¦§ÒجÑy��8eó�Â�âuy�N

DÑØÎÜ�O�¦�¯�"

çI<uyµI�¬éA�Äû�ÝI�JÑÄû¿��§A9��wk'

1�iÒÜ�§�¦µI�¬­#?1µ""��/§çI<éÝI�A�(@

�)±e¯�µ

1¤ÝI��(@"çI<éÝI���(@§́ (@µI�w¥§éÝI<�

ÝI��½Idæ�ü´ÄÎÜçI©�1²�çI��½æ�ü�"�(

اù´çI<(@µI�w���­�ó�"ÝI��Ø�uçI��½æ�

ü�§��AÝI§ÝIk�¶ÝI���uçI��½æ�ü�§���AÝ

I§A�ÄûÙÝI"5¿§�½ÝI��´ÄÎÜçI©���¦§AéÝI<

�ÝI��½Idæ�üÅ�?1"�"çI<uyµI�¬�µI�w¥§

òÝI���uçI��½æ�ü�ÝI�½��AÝI�§A��¦µI�

¬­#?1"�(@"

2¤ÝIÁ�Ï�(@"çI<éÝIÁ�Ï��(@§́ (@µI�w¥§é

ÝI©�1²�Á�Ï�´ÄÎÜçI©�5½�Ï�Ú�¦�"�(Ø"5¿§

çI<uyµI�¬3µIL§¥�¦ÝI<?UÁ�Ï�§r��ØÎÜçI

©�Á�Ï��¦�ÝI�½��AÝI�§A��¦µI�¬­#"�(@"

3¤ÝIEâIOÚ�¦(@"çI<éÝIEâIOÚ�¦(@§́ (@µI

�w¥§éÝI©�1²�EâIOÚ�¦´Ä÷vçI©�5½�EâIOÚ�

¦�"�(اù´çI<3(@ÝI��Ä:þ§éÝI´Ä÷vçI©�¥5

½�EâIOÚ�¦�(@§́ çIæ¥��;�ó�"ùp§çI<éÝIE

âIOÚ�¦�(@´�âçI©�¥1²�EâIOÚ�¦§AO´'�Eâë

êÚ�I§Å�éÝIEâIOÚ�¦?1(@§uy�3��½õ�'�Eâë

ê½�IØÎÜçI©��¦�§A��¦µI�¬­#?1"�(@"5¿§

þ¡µI(@��¯¥§çI<��ØÒ3uvkéÝI<AÝI��NEâëê

?1(@"

4¤ÝIk�Ï(@"çI<éÝIk�Ï�(@§́ (@µI�w¥§éÝI

©�1²�ÝIk�Ï´ÄÎÜçI©�5½�ÝIk�Ï�"�(Ø"ÝI©�

1²�ÝIk�ϧA��çI©��¦�ÝIk�Ï��§=ÝI©�1²�Ý

Page 238: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 227

Ik�ÏØáuçI©��¦"çI<éµI�w(@¥§uyÝI©�1²�Ý

Ik�ÏáuçI©�5½�ÝIk�ϧ½´µI�¬#NÝI<3ÝI©�

©�`²¥ò�ÝIk�ϱÎÜçI©��¦ �½ÝI<�ÝIk�ÏÎ

ÜçI©��¦�§A��¦µI�¬­#?1"�(@"

5¤ÝI�y7(@"çI<éÝI�y7�(@§́ (@µI�w¥§ÝI<

4��ÝI�y7/ª!êþÚú�I?´ÄÎÜçI©���¦�"�(Ø"Ý

I<4��ÝI�y7ú�/ª!êþÚú�I?A�ÎÜçI©��5½"çI

<éµI�w(@¥§uyÝI<4��ÝI�y7ú�Ã�!ú�/ªØ´çI

©��É/ª!ê��uçI©�5½�ê�§½´ÝI<3ÝIú�¥ �ú

���ÚI?§ µI�w(@ÙÝI�y7Ü��§A��¦µI�¬­#?

1"�(@"

6¤ÝIÜÓ^�(@"çI<éÝI©�¥ÜÓÁ�^��(@§´(@µ

I�w¥§ÝI©�´Ä�AçI©�1²�ÜÓ^�¥�¢�5�¦Ú^��"

�(Ø"ÝI©�1²�ÜÓÁ�^�§A�´3ÎÜçI©�1²�ÜÓ^�Ä

:þJÑ�ÜÓÁ�^�"çI<éÝIÜÓ^�(@�m�§3u(@ÝI©�

¥1²�ÝI¼9ÝI¼N¹!�d©�!ûÖÚEâ � lLÚÁ�|��Y

¥§́ ÄòçI©�²(d¥I<«ú�Á�I?=�çI<§±9´ÄNkç

I<¢�þØU�É�^�½�¦�¯�"çI<uyµI�wé�3þã¯K�

ÝIvk�{Äû�§A��¦µI�¬­#?1"�(@"

7¤Ù¦�A5µ"Ï�(@"çI<�âçI©�¥5½�Ù¦�A5Ï�§

éµI�w¥�Ù¦�A5µ"Ï��"�(Ø(@§uyÝI©�ØÎÜçI©

��A5�¦§�µI�w(@ÙÝIk�§½´uyµI�¬^çI©�1

²��A5µ"±Ï���ÄûÝI^��§A��¦µI�¬­#µ""

3.ÝI¿�(@"çI<éÝI¿��(@§́ éµI�w¥(½�üSÏ�

�ÚüS´ÄÎÜçI©�5½�üSÏ�(½�{ÚüS(Ø(@"ù�¥§ç

I<uyµI�¬?\�[µ"�ÝIØ�(!üSÏ���(½Ø�(�K�

üS(J�§½´µI�¬üS��çI©�¥5½�üS�{§K�üS(J

��±U��§A��¦µI�¬­#üS¶éK�üS(J�ØUU��§~

X§nܵ©�§µI�¬¤�ÑçI©�5½�þe.�éÝI?1µ©�

�K�ÝIüS�§A��¦1�iÒÅ��½TµI�¬¤�µI�{§­

#|ïµI�¬µI"Ó�§éµI�w¥�3��É~¯�§~X§çI©

�5½,��Ì*µ"Ï��µ©«m´[3,9]§µI�¬¥§�õê¤�,�

�ÝI<�ÝIµ9©§éÙ¦ÝI<�ÝIµ3©§ÒI�µI�¬?�Ú�Ñ

Page 239: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

228 çIæÛYFn

)º½`²§Ï�|�ÝI¿��Ä:§́ ÄuÝI��5z�ɧvkü�ÝI

����§Ø�µI�¬@½ÝI<´GÏÝI"@��{§ÒI�éÝI<�

ÝI±GÏÝI�d?1Äû§ ÃI2éÙ?1µ©"

12!ú«µµI(J�ú«

µI(Jú«§́ éµI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©

�µ"Ú'�§�Ñ�µI(J�ú«§±�ÉÝI<9Ù|³'X<�iÒ§́

çIÝI¹Ä/nú0�K¥�/úm0�Ny"ùp§c�/ú«0́ òµI(Jw

�Ue§ÝI<9Ù|³'X<@�µI(J��Ù�Ã�§�±�çI<JÑÉ

ƽ´�1�iÒÅ�Ý�"@o§µI(Jú«´éµI�w�©?1ú«§�

´=éµI(Ø?1ú«QºXJI�éµI�w�©?1ú«§µIL§ÒA�

��¬úm§4�¬�¡µI�¬éÝI©��µ"Ú'�§�¡µI(J�)

�L§§ùØ|uéµI�¬¤�<�Úã���o"�d± §ò�k;[

�¿ë�çI�8�µI§Ø|uµI�¬Å��mÐ"¤±§µI(Jú«Ò

´éµI�¬µI®o(J�ú«§Ø�¹éÝI©��µ"Ú'�L§§@´

31�iÒe�¤�"

@o§éµI�¬µI®o(J�ú«§qA�ú«��o§ÝQº·�k

we¡ùK�¯"

[µI(Jú«��¯] ,ÀÔçI�8æ^nܵ©{§çI<�{|ï

d7<|¤�µI�¬µI"µI®o�§UìçI©�¥5½�µ©Ï�Úµ©

IO§ÝI<AÚÝI<B��d©O�462.00��!448.00��§�©Ñ´92.60©§

¿�1�"�d§çI<�LïƧµI�¬A?�Ú(½ÝI<AÚB�üS§

±�çI<(½¥I<�u)�Æ"µI�¬²L?�ÚûƧû½Ý¦(½Ý

I<AÚB�í�^S"²Lݦ§ÝI<A�4¦§ÝI<B�3¦"µI�¬í

�ÝI<AÚÝI<B©O�1�!1�¥IÿÀ<§�¤µI�w"

çI<3Â�µI�w�1�F§3k'xNþú«µI�¬í��¥Iÿ

À<üS!�©!ÝI�d!øÀÏÚk'Eâëê!�I�¢�5SN"ú«Ï

S§ÝI<B�çI<JÑÉƧ¡UìçI©�5½�üS�{§Ù�ÝI<A�

�©Ñ´92.60©§A�¿�1�§��o3µI(Jú«¥w«�ÝI<A´1�

¥IÿÀ<"çI<�E¡§µI�¬3û½ÝI<AÚÝI<BüSk��?

1ݦ§ÝI<A�4¦§ÝI<B�3¦"�d§µI�¬í�ÝI<AÚÝI

<B©O�1�!1�¥IÿÀ<"

Page 240: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 229

ÝI<BéçI<��EØ÷¿§�1�iÒÅ�?1Ý�§nd´µI�

¬í�¥IÿÀ<�§vkUçI©�5½�µ©IOÚ�{í�§ ´æ^ç

I©�¥vk5½�/ݦ{0(½ÝI<üS§��5çIÝI¢�^~61o

�Ê^¥/çI©�vk5½�µIIOÚ�{Ø���µI��â0�5½§�

¦1�iÒÅ��½�gµI(JÃ�§�¦çI<­#|�µI"d�§çI<

SÜ�<�éµI(J�)ÉƧ@�ÝI<AÚBJø�ÀÔEâ5UþA�

��§�ÝI<B��d�ÝI<A �14��§`¨3%§��o�rÝI<Aí�

�1�¥IÿÀ<§ØÎÜæ5ƧïÆéµI�¬í�¥IÿÀ<�L§?

1"�"

1�iÒÅ�N�µI¹�?1"�§uyµI�¬éÝI<AÚB�üS

L§¥§(¢¦^çI©�¥vk5½�/ݦ{0üS"�d§1�iÒÅ��

¦çI<|�µI�¬éµI(J§UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{?1­

#®o"Ó�§éçI<�L3µI��¦µI�¬Ý¦û½ÝI<AÚB�ü

S§±9çI<ú«µI(J�§vkú«ÝI<AÚÝI<Bü¶1�!1��n

dJÑ1µ§�¦çI<U�"

ùK�¯Úu�Æ��ϧ3uÝI<AÚÝI<B�©�ӧѴ92.60©"U

çI©�¥®²úÙ�üS�{§ÝI<AÚÝI<BA�ü¶Ø©k�§¿�1

�" �¯¥�çI<ú«µI(J�§qvkú«��oÝI<AÚB��©�

Ó�§µI�¬%í�ÝI<A �1�¥IÿÀ< Úu��Æ"@o§µI(

JA�ú«=SN§Ùú«éçI<(½¥I(Jqk=K�Q?

µI(Jú«���Ä��K§́ /X¢ú«0µI(J"~X§µIú«��

¯¥§µI�¬æ^çI©�¥vk5½�/ݦ{0üS§çI<3µI(J

ú«¥§vkú«ÝI���üS3©ê���§́ UìÝI<�¦õ�?1�ü

S§ÒØ´X¢úÙ"3nØþ§ÝI<9Ù|³'X<ØA��¡µI�¬é

ÝI�µ"Ú'�L§"µI�¬�{éÝI?1µ"Ú'�§=UìçI©�

¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI?1�µ"Ú'�§´�61�iÒÅ��y�§

=µIL§¥§1�iÒÅ��±�|Å�µI�¬��{1�§(�µI�

¬�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"ù�§ÝI<Ã¥kçI©�§�¡µIIO

Ú�{§ÙG¿�5K"Ó�§ÝI<ë�mI§��Ù¦ÝI<�ÝI(J"�

d§�±�äµI�¬�µI(J´Ä�{�Ñ!µIL§¥´Äk<�{Zý§

±9ÙÜ{�ôÄ3µIL§¥É����"

Ó�§ÝI<ë�ÝIL§¥§éÙ¦ÝI<�ÝI1�½´²E1�§��

çI<k��[�)§�±éú«¥�¥IÿÀ<�²E1�½´ÝI1�?1

Page 241: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

230 çIæÛYFn

k�iÒ§BuçI<éÝI<Á�Uå�2g(@"ùp§éÝI<Á�Uå�

2g(@§́ �µI�¬�¤µI�§µI�w¥í��¥IÿÀ<3²E!ã

ÖG¹��¡u)��Cz§½ö�3�{�51�§��Ù�UK�½Ô�Á

�Uå��/"~X§çI<Â�Ù¦ÝI<é¥IÿÀ<�ÉƽÞ�§½´ç

I<3é¥IÿÀ<r�!N�½)L§¥uyÙÁ�UåØ÷vçI©���

¦½´Øä�Á�Uå"éd§çI<A�3(½¥I<§uÑ¥IÏ�Öc§|

��µI�¬UìçI©�5½�IOÚ�{§éÂ8�¥IÿÀ<3²E!ã

ÖG¹��¡u)��Cz½´�{�51��y²á�?1"�§±(@¥Iÿ

À<�Á�Uå´ÄEÎÜçI©�¥5½�^�"µI�¬"��§(@¥I

ÿÀ<Ø2ÎÜ5½�Á�Uå�§��Ù¥I]�§düS3Ù��¥IÿÀ<

¼�¥I]�¶µI�¬"��§(@¥IÿÀ<EÎÜçI©�5½�Á�U

å�§çI<Ø���Ù¥I]�"

@o§�o��çI�8A�éµI(Jú«§N�ú«QºéµI(J�ú

« u5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�o^§=�{7L?1çI��8§çI<

A�gÂ�µI�w�Få3FSú«¥IÿÀ<§ú«ÏØ��u3F�5½"

1.µI(Jú«�8"5¿§5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�o^5½7Lú«

µI(J��8§́ �{7L?1çI��8§=é�{7L?1çI��8§ç

I<A�3Â�µI�w�Få3FSú«¥IÿÀ<"ùp§«©n«�/éú

«�ª?�Ú©ÛXe:

1¤�{7LúmçI�8"�{7L?1úmçI��8§çI<A�3I

[�½x0þuÙçIúw§µI(Jú«��éçIúw�8�µI(J�ú

«§��A�ÀJuÙçIúw�x0ú«µI(J"~X§�{7L?1çI�

ó§ï��8§ÙçIúwÚú«&EA�3/¥IçIÝIú�ÑÖ²�0½ö

�8¤3/�?>fçIÝIú�ÑÖ²�uÙ"

2¤�{?1��çI�8"�{?1��çI��8§çI<Ø3½ØU3I

[�½x0þuÙçIúw§ ´�n�±þä�«úçI�8�Uå!]&ûÐ

�A½�{<½öÙ¦|�uÑÝI��Ö§��Ù�AçI§ë�ÝI¿�"~

X§�9I[S�!I[����{7L?1çI��8"d�§µI(JÃI½

ØU3I[�½�úmx0þú«µI(J§çI<IUì�é���ª§òµI

(Jw�ÝI<§�ÉÝI<9Ù|³'X<�iÒ"

3¤�{�±ØçI�8"�{�±ØçI�8§��{7L?1çI�8±

�æ�8"ùa�8´ÄçI§́ æ^úmçI�´��çIdçI<gÌû

½"=Bæ^úmçI�ª§́ Äú«¥IÿÀ<dçI<�{û½§Ï�ú«�

Page 242: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 231

¢�§́ �ÉÝI<9Ù|³'X<�iÒ§4ÝI<�¡µI(J"3ù«�/

e§éuúmçI�8§�¨3uÙçIúw�x0þú«µI(J"

2.µI(Jú«SN"��/§µI(Jú«A�X¢1²±eSNµ

1¤ÄûÝI�ú«"ÝI<3ÐÚµ"¥§ÃØ´3/ªµ"!]�µ"�´

3�A5µ"¥�Äû�§çI<AX¢ú«ÙÝI�Äû��âÚnd"

2¤¥IÿÀ<ú«"çI<3¥IÿÀ<ndú«¥§AX¢ú«µI(J¥

�ÝI<¶¡!üS!ÝI�d!�þÚÁ1Ï�§AO´§(½�ÙüSÏ��"

Ù¥§¥IÿÀ<�¶¡!ÝI�d!�þÚÁ1Ï��§A��mIP¹��"Ø

���§çI<A�3µI(Jú«¥§X¢ú«µI�¬@½ÝI¯��L§

Únd"Ø+´üÏ�üS�´õÏ�üS§çI<A�UµI�¬�µI�w§

ú«(½�ÝI<¤küSÏ��"

çI<AX¢ú«¥IÿÀ<�AçI©��¦�]�ÚÁ�Uå"çI©�

�¦ÝI<���8KI<�§�8KI<�6¶9Ù�'yÖ¶¡Ú?Ò§±9

çI©�5½I�ú«�Ù¦SN"

3¤ÉÆJѱ�Ú�ª"éµI(J�ÉƧ´ÝI<9Ù|³'X<@�

µIL§��{Æ5½§��ÙÜ{�Ã��«ÍLå»"çI<3µI(Jú«

¥§A�X¢úÙ�ÉÝI<ÉÆ�±�Ú�ª§�)çI<Sü�ÉnÉÆ�é

X<!ú^>{!ú^>f&�ÚJÑÉÆ�¯�!ndÚ�¦�"~X§çI<�

±�¦ÝI<9Ù|³'X<æ^Ö¡�ªJÑÉƧ²(ÝI<JÑÉÆ��m

�§�¦ÝI<�ÉÆ�)e�SNµ�ÉÆ<�¶¡!/�9k�éX�ª¶�

�ÉÆ<�¶¡!/�9k�éX�ª¶�ÉÆ�Ä�¯¢¶�ÉÆ<��'�¦

9Ìܶ�k��¢Ú�'y²á�"Ó�§ÉÆ<´{<�§ÉÆLdÙ{½�

L<½öÇ��L\i¿XÙ¶ÉÆ´Ù¦|�½g,<J��§ÉÆLdÙÌ�

KI<½ÉÆ<�<\i§¿Nk��°y²E<��"

3.µI(JÉ~�ú«"���/e§��çI�8�)��¥I<"çI<

F"(½õ�¥I<�§I�éçI�8y©�Iã½öI�§±¦µI�¬U

çI�8�Iã½I�Uí�1�!1�½1n¥IÿÀ<"@o§Ñyí��

¥IÿÀ<¿�§½´µI�¬�ê¤éµI(JkØÓ¿�§±Ö¡/ª`

²ÙØÓ¿�Únd§çI<A�XÛú«µI(JQº�Yé{ü§çI<I

�X¢úÙµI(J�=¿�1��§úÙ¿�1���âÚnd¶µI�¬¤

éµI(JkØÓ¿�§±Ö¡/ª`²ÙØÓ¿�Únd§òµI�¬\

Ý�µI(JÚT¤�ØÓ¿�ÚndÓ�úÙ"

Page 243: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

232 çIæÛYFn

13!Ç�µ¥IÏ�Ö�uÑ

¥IÏ�Ö§́ çI<3(½¥I<��¥I<uÑ��É¥I<ÝI�Ö¡

³y"35�þ§5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozÔ��^5½§�¯<¾áÜÓ§æ��

�!«ì�ª½öÙ¦�ª§¥IÏ�Ö´çI<�ÉÝI<4����§=ÝI

<�ÝI�¿gL«"5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozl�o^5½§±Ï��ª�Ñ�

«ì§)���m·^�{1�zn�Ô^5½§=çI<�«ì����<�)

�§ÜÓ¤á"�çIÝI¥§¥IÏ�Öù««ìkÙAÏ5§=¥IÏ�ÖuÑ

�§çI<UC¥I(J�§½ö¥I<�ï¥I�8�§A��{«ú{ÆI?"

�¤±ù�5½§�´��oçIÝI¹Ä�î�5§=çI<(½¥I<�¢�

´?1ÜÓÇ�§��(½¥I<§uÑ¥IÏ�Ö�Ø�ògUC§Ø�òg�

�Ù«ì¶�´ÝI��Nk«ìϧ=ÝIk�ϧ3«ìÏSÝI<Ø���

ÙÝI§I%«ÝI<ÉÙÝI����å§=�ÉçI<�«ì§/¤ÜÓ'X"

5¿§uÑ¥IÏ�Ö´��4Ùî��ó�"çI<�âµI�¬�{�¤�

Ö¡µI�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<(½¥I<§�¥I<uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö§éç

I<Ú¥I<Ñäk{Æ�åå§=¥IÏ�ÖuÑ�§çI<UC¥I(J½ö

¥I<�ï¥I�8§=�¥�§L��{«ú{ÆI?"

[�8²n�Á��¯],Ikè���ó§ï��8çI§²µI�¬µ"§

ÝI<A�í��1�¥IÿÀ<"çI<3k'xNþéµI(J?1ú«§ú

«ÏSÝI<9Ù|³'X<véµ�(JJÑÉƧçI<(½ÝI<A�¥I

<§�ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§±9ÜÓ\¾��mÚ/:"

çI<�ÝI<A3ûÆÜÓ[!�§iÅ'=5�µÞ�&§Xü¶1�

�ÝI<B�Þ�§¡ÝI<A�Ñ��8²n3Â�¥IÏ�Ö�F�*l�à§

�x�Ñ�Á§<®í¢§Ø2ä�ú?�8²n�Uå§�¦çI<£uÑ

�¥IÏ�Ö§��ÝI<A�¥I]�"�d§çI<6Ê�ÝI<A\¾ÜÓ§

�¦ÝI<AÖ¡`²[��8²n��NG¹§ÝI<A35½�mS§X¢w

�çI<Ù[��8²n��NG¹§«@T�8²n<®í¢§Ø2·Üú?

�8²n��"

çI<�æÜ�²LûƧ��Ì�KI<@�§��ÝI<A�¥I]

�§�¦Ùò�¥IÏ�Ö§�ÝI<BuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§�ÝI<B\¾Ö¡Ü

Ó"�ÝI<A���ò�¥IÏ�Ö§�3çI<�ÝI<BuÑ¥IÏ�ÖL

§¥§�2�çI<JÑÉƧ¡�,Ù[��8²n�Ní¢§��±­#À�

� ä�Ó�Uå��8²nKI���8¢�"éd§çI<Ø�@�"

Page 244: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 233

�õg�û�J§ÝI<A³/Ã¥�¥IÏ�Ö§���GòçI<wþ

�/<¬{�§¡çI<éÓ��çI�8�ÝI<AÚÝI<B©OuÑ¥I

Ï�Ö§áu/�å�g0§�¦{��½ÝI<B�¥IÃ�§�¦çI<£Ù

�ÝI<BuÑ�¥IÏ�Ö"

Y��Æ��:§3u¥I<[��8²nÑ�Áí¢§́ Ä7,��¥IÃ

�"d§çI<�ÝI<AÜÓ'X¤á�§çI<´Äk�|ü�¡)ØÜÓ§

\ÙÝI<B¥I"�d§3{�"��̱e§?1N)"²L"�N)Ú

{Æ\0§çI<¿£�Ù3�£ÝI<A�¥IÏ�ÖcJe�ÝI<BuÑ

¥IÏ�Ö��Ø1�§é<¬{��N)�±@�"

��§çI<�ÝI<Bw�<¬{��N)"²(3y1{Æe§=³�

8²nÑ�Áí¢�¯§Ø�ÝI<A�ØÑ�[��8²nUå����8²n§

=ÝI<AØ2ä�Á�Uå§ØU�½ÝI<A�¥IÃ�"3ù«�/e§�Ø

U\ÙÝI<B¥I§�¦ÝI<Bò�¥IÏ�Ö"ÝI<BL«n)§��¦ç

I<��Ù�½�²LÖ�§¡ÙÂ�¥IÏ�Ö�§®²��8¢�s¤300õ

�ægáÚYY§ùÜ©gáÚYYÓ^Ù300õ��6Ä]7"��§V�

²LûƧÝI<BÓ¿ò�çI<u��¥IÏ�Ö§�çI<I3���S§l

ÝI<BÃ¥U?ÀdïÙ®��8¢�æ�gáÚYY"

ùK�¯´F<Ï��§�Ï3uçI<��ÜÓÇ�5K uÑü°¥I

Ï�Ö"@o§�¯¥XJÝI<AUçI<��¦§U�ò�¥IÏ�Ö´Ä

�k�¡��ÆQº�,ج2k�ƧÏ�ÝI<Aò�¥IÏ�Ö�1�§Ø

+Ù´Ä�{A�¥I§þáuÌÄ�ï¥I1�"ù�§ÝI<B��1�¥I

ÿÀ<§�{A�¥I"

��/,çI<A3ÝIk�Ϫ�c(½¥I<§uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§¿�¥I

<\¾ÜÓ"ÑyAÏ�¹§çI<ØU3ÝIk�ÏS(½¥I<!\¾ÜÓ�§

A�±Ö¡/ªÏ�¤kÝI<ò�ÙÝIk�Ï"ÝI<Ó¿ò��§A�Aò

�ÙÝI�y7�k�ϧ�Ø��¦½�#N?UÙÝI©�¶áýò��§Ù

ÝI��§�ÝI<k�£ÙÝI�y7§±9Ù±y7½ö|¦/ª4��Ý

I�y7�3Õ1�)�|EÂ\"

1.¥I^�"�"é¥I^��"�§́ çI<éçI�8½Iã!I�[(

½¥I<�ÝI?1"�§(@ÙÎÜçI©�¥5½�¥I^�§́ 3µI(J

ú«�§çI<(½¥I<�7²�!"�d§çI<A|�k'<?1¥I^

�"�§UçI©�1²�J`^�(½¥I<§�)�Ù11!ù��ÝI¿�

(@§=UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{(@nÜüS§µI(Jú«ÃÉÆ

Page 245: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

234 çIæÛYFn

½Ý�§½´ÉƽÝ�®þõ?n�§UçI©�1²�J`5K(½¥I<"

1¤nÜüS"�"éµI�¬µ"Ú'��¤�ÝInÜüS�"�§��

Ù11!éÝI¿��(@aq"ùp§çI<�Ì�ó�Ø´�éµI(J§ ´

µI(Jú«Ïm§ÝI<9Ù|³'X<�çI<JÑÉƽ´�1�iÒÅ

�Ý�§UCµI�¬�еI(J��/"~X§ÝI<½Ù|³'X<�

çI<JÑÉƧÞy¥IÿÀ<ÏÅ�ÅÖ�(i§�¦ÙÁ�UåØ2÷v�

¦§½öÞy¥IÿÀ<3ÝI¥�3/±g¿Ð0§�µI�¬UìçI©�5

½�IOÚ�{"�(@ÙØäkÁ�Uå��/§±9Ù¦I3(½¥I<c"

��¯��"

2¤J`"�"J`"��8�§3u(@¥I<�ÝI´�`ÝI§nÜüS

1�"üS1��¥IÿÀ<�ï¥I!ÏØ�|åJÑØUÁ1ÜÓ!çI©�

5½A�J�Á�ú� 3çI©�5½Ï�S�UJ�§½ö�k'Ü��¢�

3K�¥I(J��{1���/§ØÎÜ¥I^��§çI<�±�g(½ü¶

3Ùg�¥IÿÀ<�¥I<"7��§��±­#çI"

�<@�§µI�¬ØéÝI?1nÜüSk|uçI<J`§±�ù�

�±�Ð/u�çI<�Ì*UÄ5§¢yÙ¿ã§ù´éµI�¬�Ý�Ø)§

´3e�µI�¬§¢yçI<gCéÝI?1µ"Ú'�"Äk§µI�¬

´çI<UçI�8µ"Ú'�|ï�§�3UçI<3çI©�¥5½�µII

OÚ�{§éÝI©�µ"Ú'����kçI<�Lë��µ��¬¶Ùg§

k'�âUk�O"éÝI?1'��8�´J`§́ µI�¬µI���Ä�

�K"µI�¬XJØéÝI?1nÜüS§��uµI�¬=´UçI©�

¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"§��?1�p'�§I¦�;

�(ܧ?1�ÆJ`�µI�K�Ø�Ny¶1n§J`´çIÝI½ö¿��

��"ÃØ´µI�¬éÝIüS£ù´çIÝI�Ð%¤§�´çI<éÝI?

1üS§m�Ñ´J`"µI�¬éÝI?1nÜüS§́ æI¦�;�µ"

Ú'��(ܧ¢y`³pÖ"çI<gCéÝIüS§́ üXlI¦Ñu��«

{üüS§Ô��T´µI;[�;�'�`³"~X§�çI<æ^�ÅÄ�

�ª(½¥I<�§́ 3±/ª½iZ���ÆJ`�µ"Ú'�Å�§́ 3Ø^

çIæ�ÔÑ�¦"�d§µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�üS5K§éÝI?

1nÜüS§k|uu�çIÝIÅ�3½|¿�¥�J`�^§k|uçI<J

`(½¥I(J"

2.¥IÏ�"çIÝI�8�§́ (½¥I§�¥I<\¾ÜÓ"çI<(½

¥I<�§�¥I<uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§Ó�ò¥I(JÏ�Ù¦�¥I�ÝI<´

Page 246: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 235

çIÝID�çI<���Ì�ÂÖ§́ çIæ¥/5�0�¤JLy��"@

o§çI<�¥I<uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö§�Ù¦�¥I�ÝI<uÑ�¥I(JÏ

�ÖA�)=Ä�SNQº�'SN3d©ÛXe"

1¤¥IÏ�Ö"¥IÏ�Ö��A1²SN9�¦Xeµ�çI�8¶¡9?

Ò¶�¥I<¶¡¶�¥ISN9¥Id±¶��þIO¶�Á1Ï�Ú/:¶�Ü

Ó\¾/:!�m9k'�¦¶�çI<ü ÙÚ{½�L<\i¶�çI©�½

{Æ{55½�¥IÏ�ÖÙ¦SN"

5¿§¥IÏ�Ö35¬{;6ÜÓ?¿Âþ´çI<�«ì§́ �ÉÝI��

�¿gL«"�d§¥IÏ�Ö1²�SN§A��¥I<�ÝISN��"çI<

uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö§?U¥I<3ÝI©�þ1²�ÝI��!�þ!d±½ö

�Å!Á1Ï�!Á1/:Ú�ª!��I?Ú)û�Æ�{�¯��§́ éÝI

���¢�5?U§��5¬{;6ÜÓ?é«ì�SNA�����SN���

5½"�d§¥ISN�¥I<�ÝI©�1²�ÝISN§A��çI©�1²

�çI����¶¥Id±�¥I<�ÝI©�þ1²�ÝI�d¶�þIO�¥

I<�ÝI©�1²��þIO§A�÷v½´`uçI©�¥�¦��þIO¶

Á1Ï��¥I<ÝI©�1²�Á1Ï�§Á1/:�çI©�1²�/:"

@o§¥IÏ�Ö�.´�LX�«ìQº�,´çI<�«ì§=/ÜÓÇ

�0"�d§¥IÏ�Öþ\XçI<ü ÙÚ{½�L<\i��ϧ3u²(Ü

ÓÇ�<§=´çI<�ÉÝI�ý¢¿gL«"@o§çI<UÄ�÷çI�n

Å�3¥IÏ�Öþ\Xü Ù�uÑ¥IÏ�ÖQºéd§çI<XJÇ�çI

�nÅ�\Xü Ù�§�,k�§�5¿§XJçI<édvÇ�çI�nÅ�§

KçI�nÅ��1�áu���n§�k²LçI<J@Ç��§¥IÏ�Öâ

k�"�²çI<J@Ç��§dçI�nÅ�éuÑ�¥IÏ�Ö«ú¬¯I?"

d§IS�1�iÒÅ�3¥IÏ�Öþ\Xü Ù��^q´�oQºw,§

1�iÒÅ���çIÝI¹Ä�iÒ<§3¥IÏ�Öþ\Xü Ù§Ø´L²

çI<�É¥I<�ÝI§ ´éçI<(½¥I<�1��±�½§=çIÝI

¹Ä¥§1�iÒÅ�vkuy�{�51�§(@¥I(Jk�"

2¤¥I(JÏ�Ö"çI<3�¥I<uÑ¥IÏ�Ö�Ó�§Aò¥I(J

Ï�¤k�¥I�ÝI<"¥I(JÏ�Ö���)±eSNµ��¥I<¶¡¶

�çI�8¶¡Ú?Ò¶�¥I<¶¡¶�çI<ü ÙÚ{½�L<\i¶�{

Æ{55½�¥I(JÏ�Ö�Ù¦SN§±9çI<éÝI<�AçI!ë�Ý

I¿�����"

¥IÏ�Ö�ÝI<�ÝI��éA§A�æ^�é�ª��Ku�"¥I(

Page 247: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

236 çIæÛYFn

JÏ�Ö§�±æ^�é�ª��Ku�§��±/Ïpé�u�"~X§éuú

mçI�8§çI<�±3uÙçIúw�x0þ§r1¥I(JÏ�Ö"

3.É~�/?n"çI<(½¥I<L§¥§uy¥IÿÀ<Ø÷vçI©�

¥5½�¥I^�½´Ù¦ÝI<JÑÉƽÝ�§Þy¥IÿÀ<�3�{I�

��Ù¥I]��§çI<A?1N��y§Â8�'yâ½á�"yâ½á�L

²µI�¬�3�{�51�§K�¥I(J�§é�{7L?1çI��8§

çI<A���k'1�iÒÅ�§­#|�µI�¬µI§UµI�¬�{

�¤�µI(J(½¥I<§uÑ¥IÏ�Ö¶yâ½á�L²´¥IÿÀ<Á�

UåØ2÷vçI©�5½�Á�^�§½´�3�{�51�Ô�Á�Uå�§

çI<A�J��µI�¬UìçI©�5½�IOÚ�{?1"�(@§±û

½´ÄéÙ?1ÜÓÇ�"µI�¬AçI<��¦(@¥IÿÀ<Ø2äkÁ

�Uå�§çI<�{��Ù¥I]�¶µI�¬(@¥IÿÀ<EäkÁ�U

å�§çI<(½üS3c�¥IÿÀ<�¥I<"

çI<uy¥IÿÀ<Ø÷vçI©�¥5½�¥I^�§½´Ù¦ÝI<J

ÑÉƽÝ� UC¥IÿÀ<üS½¥I]��§́ ÄI�2gú«vkÚ�5

½§dçI<g1û½"��{7L?1çI�8�µI(JI�ú«"@o§é

u�{7L?1çI��8§çI<3(½¥I<L§¥§|��µI�¬½´

#|ï�µI�¬§UC�Ðú«�µI(J�§�{�,I�ú«UC��

µI(J"ù�:§é�{7LçI�8±�çI�8Ø·^§Ï�ùa�8´

Äú«µI(J3{Æ{5¥vk�¦§ ´dçI<g1û½"

[�£I] ¥IÏ�Ö§´çI<3(½¥I<�§�¥I<uÑÏ�§�3«

ìÙÝI!�É���¿gL«½Ö¡³y§��A�):¥I�8!¥Id�!Á

�Ï�!�þIO§±9\¾ÜÓ��m!/:�¯�"¥IÏ�ÖéçI<Ú¥

I<äk{Æ�å"¥IÏ�ÖuÑ�§çI<UC¥I(J�§½ö¥I<�ï

¥I�8�§A��{«ú{ÆI?"

14!5�µÖ¡ÜÓ�\¾

¥IÏ�Ö´çI<«ì¥I<ÝI�¿gL«§L²çI<�¥I<mÜÓ

'X¤á"çI<�¥I<�{\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§́ 3¥IÏ�Ö�É¥I<�ÝI§

V�3�l{ÆÄ:þ§æ^Ö¡/ª²(V�Ò¬¯�|ÚÂÖ��á!C�!

ª� �û����Ƨ́ çIæ5��!�Ö¡¤J"çIæÜÓ\¾�Ï

~�ÜÓ\¾aq§�I?�Ú�û�SN�§Ï�çI<3ÜÓ¢�5SNþ®

Page 248: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 237

�É¥I<��A§I�ÜÓ!��§́ UçI©�1²�I¦Ú¥I<3ÝI

©���A§V�ÜÓ��¢�5SNþ�û��§\¾Ö¡ÜÓ¿Á1ÜÓ)�

ÃY§±k��åÜÓÁ1§¢yæ(J"

[æ�ü��¯] ,�{7L?1çI�ó§ï��8æ^ó§þ�üOd§

çI<Ú¥I<\¾�ÜÓ�üdÜÓ"Tó§ÜÓ(��§çI<Ú¥I<éó§

þ�ü¥���f8�(�u)�Æ"Tf8nÜüd�420.00�/m3§3ó§þ�

ü¥1²�ó§þ�17500.00m3§3Idó§þ�ü¥1²�ó§þ�7500.00m3§

¢S�¤ó§þ�18000m3"çI<@�(�A3\�ÜÓdÄ:þ§O\500m3�

ó§þ(�§=O\ÜÓd±500× 420.00 = 210000.00�"

¥I<éçI<�(�(JØ�@�§@�ÙIdó§þ�ü¥1²�ó§

þ´7500.00m3§̀ ²ÝI´U7500.00m3�I�þ?1�ÝI"y¢S�¤ó§þ

´18000m3§A3\�ÜÓdÄ:þ§O\10500m3�ó§þ(�§=I�O\ÜÓ

d±10500 × 420.00 = 4410000.00�(�§=d��§�çI<@��d±��Ò

�4200000.00��õ"

çI<@�§çI©�1²�Tf8ó§þ�17500.00m3§̀ ²Tf8�I�

´17500.00m3§çI<�É�¥I<�ÝI§�É�Tf8ó§þ´17500.00m3

Ø´7500.00m3"¥I<@�§Tf83Idó§þ�ü¥�7500.00m3§L²´Ù

ÝI�éTf8ó§þ�ý¢�A§çI<XJ@�ÙÝIvk�AçI©���

¦§�±Ø�ÉÙÝI"�çI<¯¢þ�ÉÙÝI¿��\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§L

²çI<@�ÙéTf8U7500.00m3��A"Tf8¢S�¤ó§þ�18000m3§

çI<ÒA��âV�\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§3\�ÜÓd±Ä:þ§O\Tf8¢S

�¤ó§þ�Idó§þ�ü¥ó§þ��d±10500× 420.00 = 4410000.00�"

·�3d©Û�eçI<Ú¥I<�nd§w=����k�n§? �çI

æÜÓÇ�±é&"

Äk§U5¬{;6ÜÓ?5½§ÜÓæ^��Ú«ì�ª�§¥I<�ÝI©

�ÚçI<uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö�¤ÜÓ"5¿§çI©�áu�����ƧØ3

5¬{;6ÜÓ?5½�ÜÓ�Æ¥§ùÒ 5́IO�óçI©�6£2007�¤¥5

½�óÜÓ©��¤Ú)ºgS�µ�ÜÓ�ÆÖ¶�¥IÏ�Ö¶�ÝI¼9Ý

I¼N¹¶�;^ÜÓ^±¶�Ï^ÜÓ^±¶�EâIOÚ�¦¶�ã�¶�Id

ó§þ�ü¶�V��½�Ù¦©����Ï"5¿§TÜÓ©��¤¥²(�þ

ü /́Idó§þ�ü0 Ø´ó§þ�ü"

Ùg§5çIÝI{6¥��o�¦çI<Ú¥I<UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI

©�\¾ÜÓ§ Ø´UçI<uÑ�¥IÏ�ÖÚ¥I<�ÝI©�\¾ÜÓ§

Page 249: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

238 çIæÛYFn

Ï��ö¾áÜÓ��J§́ ÜÓÁ��1¥I<�ÝI§ù3çI©�5½�¢

�5�¦Ú^�þ§���¦���Avk¯K§�3çI©�5½�¢�5�¦

Ú^�±¯�þ§Ø�½k|uçI<§Ø�½|u�oI[|ÃÚ�¬ú�|

çÏ�¥I<�ÝI´U¢yÙg�|Ã��z?1�ÝI"

1n§ó§þ�ü´çI<�I�þü§�½´çI©�5½�¢�5�¦Ú

^�§çI<é��AÝIA�´Äû Ø´�É"ù«ÄûNy3çIÝI�ü�

�!"�´µI�!¥§µI�¬uy¥I<éTf8�ÝIó§þ�7500.00m3§

A��¦¥I<?1©�`²§=´©i�Ø!{e�10000.00m3ó§þ�¹3Ù

¦f8ÝI¥§�´éTf8{e�10000.00m3ó§þØÝI�§ÝI<écü«

�/�©�`²XJµI�¬�§A�3µI�w¥X¢P¹¶µI�¬X

Jécü«�/�©�`²Ø�ɧ½´Ñy1n«�/§=ÝI<éTf8{e

�10000.00m3ó§þØÝI�§A��{Äû ج#NÙë�ÝI¿�¶�´ç

I<?1ÜÓÇ�§½´�¥I<\¾ÜÓ�§'éó§þ�üÚIdó§þ�ü§

Ó��±uy�ö1²�Tf8ó§þØ��§Ó��±�¦¥IÿÀ<½¥I<

éd©�`²"�¢¥IÿÀ<éTf8{e�10000.00m3ó§þØÝI�§̀ ²

µI�¬vk�{Á1µI�I§A�­#µ"Ú'�¶�¢¥I<¢�þ�A

çI�§A�3ÜÓ;^^±¥?�Ú²(Tf8{e�10000.00m3 ó§þ�¹

3ÜÓ=��/�!=��½A�f8§±¦çI©�¥�ó§þ�ü���Ny

3ÜÓ©�¥�Idó§þ�ü"

�Y¥§çI<uÑ�¥IÏ�Ö§�¥I<\¾ÜÓ�¯¢§L²çI<�

É¥I<�ÝI§�)¥I<éTf817500.00m3ó§þU7500.00m3ó§þÝ

I�¯¢"�d§çI<�nd�{Ø�½U��kå|±"��§¥I<�F

ond%�U��æ&"@o§çI<´Ä�±Ï¥I<�ÝI���AÝI§Ì

Ü¥IÃ�§? ÜÓÃ�QºçI<�,�±ù�Ìܧ�ÜÓÃ�éçI<Ò

�½k|íº(Û�U´�Ã|���¡§5çIÝI{618�o^5½§¥IÃ

��§A��ìçIÝI{5½�¥I^�lÙ{ÝI<¥­#(½¥I<½ö�

ì�{­#?1çI"�YçI<��5½(½¥I<§áu7LçI �çI�

/§AU5çIÝI{61o�Ê^5½1�?v§=�±?�8ÜÓ7�0.5%±

þ1%±e�v±"Ó�§é�ܽöÜ©¦^Ik]7��8§�±6Ê�8�

1½ö6Ê]7ÃG§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{��?

©¶,��¡§5¬{;6ÜÓ?1Êz"Ô^5½§ÜÓÃ��§ØK�ÜÓ¥k

')û�Æ�{�^±��姱95¬{;6ÜÓ?1ÔzÊ�n^5½§=ï

�ó§�óÜÓÃ�,�´ï�ó§²�ÂÜ��,�±ëìÜÓ'uó§d±��

Page 250: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 239

½òdÖ�«�<"ù�§Uì�p<¬{�5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY

�·^{ƯK�)º61�^§=ï�ó§�óÜÓÃ�§�ï�ó§²eó�

ÂÜ�§«�<�¦ëìÜÓ�½|Gó§d±�§A��±|±�5½§çI<

ÌÜÜÓÃ��"�(J�UéçI<�Ã|"¢Sþ§�Y)û�Æ��Ðå»

Ø´®à½�z§ ´V�lÐ�û§3Ì�¤Ú)"

�¯¥§çI<��ØØ´3ÜÓÁ1�㧠´u)3çIÝI5�§=Ü

ÓÇ�L§¥§vké¥IÿÀ<´Ä�AçI©�¥5½�¢�5�¦Ú^�

?1"�Ò?1ÜÓÇ�§E¤Á�(å�V�3(�d±þ�Æ"¢Sþ§X

JçI<@ýÁ1ÜÓÇ�5K§Òج3(��Ñy�Æ"�¢�¥�¯K3

u§kõ�çI<rçIæw¤´�«ÔÑ��¦ Ø´3r/ª!rL|º�

U��q��ùâ´çIæ�I�)û�¯K"�YéçI<�é&3u§çI

<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ´��î��1�§ýØ´Þ1��V�\i¤ª§V�KI

<3ÜÓ�ÆÖþ\iXÙùo{ü§I�3�c?1�þ�\�O��ÜÓ!�

ó�"

��/§çIæÜÓ\¾§�)ÜÓ\¾O�!ÜÓ!�ÚÜÓ\¾�n�

^gq���!§©ãXe"

1.ÜÓ\¾O�"çI<éÜÓ\¾�O�§�)!�O�!!�OyÚÜÓ

©�O��¯�"çI©��¦¥I<J�Á��y7�§çI<AUçI©�5

½�ê�9Ö¡@��Á��y7�ª�¥I<Â�"Ó�§çI<Uì{Æ{5

�5½§�¥I<J��A�Á�ú�"

1¤!�<O�"çI<I��âçI�8A:ÚI¦§¤ádEâ!²LÚ

{Ö<|¤�!��|§�¥I<?1ÜÓ!�"��`D�!��L§Aä�

ûÐ�%n��Ú´L�ÜÓ+n�;��£§äkûÐ��ÏÚACUå§!�

¥âg¯$!�AÅ�!ÙG!�E|§UU!�Ì�§Ú�¥I<UÜÓ8I

g�"!��L��<��§K�X!�8I�¢y§Ï�!��m�´r¤V�

�Ü�§�R¯�pߦ!<�ôÂ�1�"7��§çI<��±­�Ü;[

ë�ÜÓ!��'ó�"

2¤!�OyO�"!�Oy´æ<JÑ�ø!�V�¦^�§S5©�"!

�OyA²(5½!�§S!!�SN!!��m!ë�<�"�½�Æ!±� �

¢�!�Oy´æ<¢yÙýÏ8I�'�5Ú½"

Äk§!��|Ié¥I<�ÝI©�éçI©�¥1²�ÜÓ^�!EâI

OÚ�¦¥�¢�5�¦Ú^���A?1(@"!��|uy¥I<�¢�5�

AçI©��¦�§A9��k'KI<®�§��ÝI<�¥I]�§Â£®u

Page 251: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

240 çIæÛYFn

Ñ�¥IÏ�Ö§­#?1ÜÓÇ�"7��§A��1�iÒÅ�Ó¿"

Ùg§!��|Aé¥I<�ÝI©�éçI©�¥1²�ÜÓ^�!EâI

OÚ�¦¥��¢�5�¦Ú^���A?1Å�©Û§©Û¥I<��AéçI

�8Á��K�§±9�UE¤�çI<Âý�Ã��"

1n§!��|A�¾!�üѧéçI�8ÜÓÁ1¯�!d��¤!!�

üÑ!!�§S�¯�?1¯k5y½O�"ù�¥�Ø%3u!�üÑ��¾§

=é=¯��8I!�¥�±4Ú§=¯�!�8I7L¢y�§̄ k?1ü

y"Ó�§ýÿ!�¥�UÑy�¯KÚ¯�§ïÄr�¯���{§�¾!�E

|)û"5¿§ÜÓ!�±¢yçI�8�m�§Aj±/8���0�!�üÑ"

3¤!�]�O�"!�]�O�§�)çI<Ú¥I<�!��L9Ö¡y²

©�!çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�!!�P¹L�§±9ÜÓ©�O��¯�"�

�/§ÜÓ©��±UìçI�8aO§À^k'Ü�½1��¬�Ù�ÜÓIO

©�"!��|IUçI©�¥�ÜÓ^�§±9¥I<3Ù�ÝI©�¥��A§

U�k|uçI<�K�¤ÜÓúY§±��ÜÓ!�Ä:"Ù¥§�ÜÓ¢�5

SN�¥I<�ÝI©�1²�SN¶�ÜÓ�¢�5SNUÜÓ^�1²�§�

k|uçI<�Kú["5¿§ÜÓÖ¿![zSNØ��çI©�Ú¥I<�Ý

I©��¢�5SN�l"ÄK§ÜÓÃ�"

2.ÜÓ!�"ÜÓ!�§=çI<Uì!�Oy¥[½�!�¯�§Å��¥

I<?1!�"ÜÓ!�¥A�lçI<�çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�1²�¯

¢§o�¿��Ü�!̀ ³pÖÚºx�ú§�l{Æ!S���¬1�5�§3l

Ð�¨�¥?1"

1¤!�m©"V�!��L0�§²(ÜÓ!���K!�mSü§(@çI

©�1²�!¥I<ÝI©�1²�¢�5�¦Ú^��"

2¤�¢�5�¦Ú^�!�"çI<!��LÅ�JÑ¥I<�ÝI©�é

çI©�¥��¢�5�¦Ú^��A�çI<I¦Ø���?§V�!��|<

�û§±�¤�£"

3¤!�P¹"!�L§¥ASü;<P¹"7��§zg!�(å�§dV�

!��L3�#¹þ\i(@"

!�¥§!��LÙGçI�8A:!æI¦Ú!�¯�!8I§́ ÜÓ!

�8I¢y�Ä:§Ùö��ó�Ï!!�í¨rºÚ!�E|�A^§́ ÜÓ!

�8I¢y�'�"ÜÓ!�A�Ìd´�J!ÌSì?�K§j±/8���0§

�¯KØÅ(§�±4Ú§�é�¯K§AO´K�æ(J��­�¯�þØ

4Ú"~X§!�¥�l¥I©z/;0�g�§� g�§±/p¨p|0�d`

Page 252: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 241

Ñ¥I<æBçI<é�ÜÓ^±�ïÆ�"

5¿§duçI<®²�¥I<uÑ¥IÏ�Ö§�É¥I<�ÝI§é

çI<Ú¥I<²L�û§ØU�¤����¢�5�¦Ú^��§A±¥I<�

ÝI©�1²��A�O"

3.ÜÓ\¾"ÜÓ\¾§́ çI<�¥I<UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�/

¤�§V���Ó¿�ÜÓSN\iXÙ�L§§́ çIÝI�(J"V�\ÝÜ

Ó§L²çIæ5��ª�ÚÁ��m©"

1¤ÜÓ\¾O�"ÜÓ\¾�O�ó�§́ 3V�û½�ÜÓ\i�mcI�

O��ó�¯�§�)ÜÓ©�!\i/:Ú|¤O�!ë\<O��"

��/§çI<Ú¥I<!�(å�§çI<�!��L�â!�V��¤�

�£§�ª[½ÜÓ©�"Ù¥§¢�5SN�çI©�1²�§¥I<�ÝI©

��ASN§�¢�5SN²V�!��L�û����ÜÓ^±§ØU�û��

�§±¥I<�ÝI©�1²�SN�O"ÜÓ©�O��°ê§±ÜÓ�½�°

ê�O"

2¤ÜÓ\¾"V��L(@ÜÓ©��§d{½�L<©O3ÜÓ©�þ\

i§\Xü <Ù"{½�L<Ï�ØU�|§�÷¦<�n�§�n<A±k{

½�L<�Ç��÷Ö§�Ù�°yÖ�E<��å��ÜÓ\i��"

4.ÜÓ�Y"ÜÓ�Y§�çI<Ú¥I<\¾ÜÓ�§�â{Æ{5�5½§

A��n1O!�Y½�P�)�ÃY�§çI<Ú¥I<�AòÜÓJ��'1

�Ü�½Å�?11O!�Y½�P§U5½�B+n¤^"

15!Y~µ�¿�â�Ø�ÜÓÁ�ŪY

çIÝI��çI<��«ÔÑ�¦§́ æ^ÝI¿���¦¢yÙçIæ

ÔÑÜÝUå�nÜNy"çIÝI5�L§¥§çI<´Ì�§ÝI<´�l"�

Á�L§¥§çI<´I¦< ¥I<´Á�ÌN§ù´çIæ���A:"Ó

�§çI�ÝI���«éáÚ��'X§çIÝIL§¥§Øü´çI<k�¦§

ÝI<3�AçI!ë�ÝI¿�¥Ó�k�¦§L§¥�3X�þçI<�ÝI

<Ì�Ì]�!½¯�"��/§çIÝIL§¥§çI<�o%�¿!ó�Ø@

ý½öØUìçIÝIS35K�¯§4´u��çIæ(JÃ{¢y½´3�

½²L��eâ�U�¢y"ùé@±r/ª!rL|�çI�8§Øá¢g�

ÌNI?§½´rçI�nÅ�!µI�¬���ý½í�I?nd�çIæ

�8cÙN´u)"e¡ùK÷¥ï��8æ�Y~§=´çI<vk3ÜÓ

Page 253: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

242 çIæÛYFn

\¾¥á¢ÌNI? ��ï�L§¥Úu�z§wqçI<��I(i§�¢

KÑK÷¥ï��XϦ^Ú¤^��"

[Y�£�] 2004c§,�Ý]7000��ï���y�z÷ ¥§T�8dèï

ó§ÚÅ>�NzSCüÜ©|¤"Ù¥§èïó§±�;ØÓ«a÷ �÷ó�

̧Xy�·vèÙó(�¶Å>�NzSC´÷ \¥!�;!Ñ¥�Ñx!ð§

ð�!¡­!���XÚ9ÙgÄz��C��æÚSC"

çI<�÷IS�[çIÅ��n��8çI"çI�nÅ�UT÷¥ï��

8�A:ÚI¦?�çI©�§ÜÓa.��½odÜÓ"Ïm§çI<JѧT

�8ï�L§¥�U¬Ñy�þ��OC�§�¦çI©�¥��4500.00����

pÝI�d§çI�nÅ�âd3çI©�¥1²�pÝI�d�4500.00��"

T�8çI�nÅ�u2004c7�3�{�½x0þuÙçIúw§UçI

úw1²��muÈçI©�"T�8k7�ÝI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���

mc4�ÝI©�§ë�mI"Ù¥§k4�ÝI<��d�L4500��§µ

I�¬éù4�ÝI<�ÝI�±Äû�§�en�ÝI<�ÝI"Ù¥§ÝI

<A��d�4326.00��§d�þÓ`³"Ó�§ÝI<A�Ùów,��ÚÅ>

�Nz�ó�Y¼�µI;[�ÊH@Ó"²nܵ©§ÝI<A�©�p§�

µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<"

çI<Â�µI�w�1�F§3ÙuÙçIúw�x0þéµI(J?1

ú«§ú«ÏmvkÂ�ÝI<9Ù|³'X<�ÉƧvkÂ�k'1�iÒÜ

�ÚiÅ'�¦6ÊçIÝI¹Ä�Ï�"u´§çI<(½ÝI<A¥I§�

ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§u2004 c8�.�Ù\¾�óSCÜÓ"

5�L§é^|§T÷¥u2004c9�Ðmó§?\ï�¢�"Ù¥§ó§±U

ÜÓ�½§U�|G§=Uinó§��ÂÜ��ó§þéAd±�85%|G¥I

<AÜÓd±"2004c12�G±�§®G�¥I<Aó§±3816.00��§ãÖ<@

�ó§±|G��Ý�¯§9���8KI<?1®�§¡T¥I<�{±Øv

±�¤ÙóÚÅ>�Nz���æÚSC"d¯Úå�8KI<´ú§¤á�

8ÜEd<Úinó§�|¤�"��|§"�10�-12��G±�âÚG±P

¹§vk�ѯK§Ï�z)G±Ñkinó§�é®�ó§þ�Eاk��é

¥I<A��ó§þ?1Ø~§Ø�3��ó§þ¯K§ nÜüd5 u¥I

<A�Idó§þ�ü§�úþAT�vk¯K"

k�U§�|KI<�w¥I<A�Idó§þ�ü§Ã¿¥uyÙ¥���

3²w��â�ا=ó§þ�20.00m3§nÜüd�3.00�/m3§��ü¥w«�

ü�ÜOØ´60.00� ´39.00�"u´§TKI<ð8¤k�|<EØIdó

Page 254: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 243

§þ�ü¥�üd�Üd§uy¥I<A�Idó§þ�ü¥�3�þ��â�ا

Ñ´ü�ÜO�uó§þ×nÜüd�O�(Jùa�Ø"r¥I<A3Idó§

þ�ü¥�¤k�â�ØÅ��§2®oÙÝId�§A�´6582.00��§ Ø

´4326.00��§́ ¥I<A/µIr/ª!rL|ÚçI<Ø'5�â�Ø 3Ù

ÝI�§�¿���/�²0§Ï�ï�ó§ÜÓd±|G§ó§þ´²inó§�

�Â�¢S�¤§ üdK´¥I<3Idó§þ�üþ1²�f8nÜüd"

¥I<A�ù«1�®Ø´çIÝI5K¥��â�ا ´�«�¿ÐÀ1

�"�d§"��|9��çI<k'KI<®��§��Ó¿�¥I<A)ØÜÓ§

�¦Ùò�õ|G�ó§±"çI<�¥I<A�û�J§���Gò¥I<Aw

þ{̧�¦{Ì�û¥I<A3ÝI¥±áJ�b�ª¢�¥I§\Ù¥IÃ�§

�¦�Ù)ØÜÓ§ò�õ|G�ó§d±"

{�²L8���"n§æ&çI<Jø�yâ§�½¥I<A}�§nd´

Ù3T÷¥ï��8ÝI¥�3²w�ÐÀ1�§¥IÃ�§�ûÖ�¦Ù�çI

<330FS)ØÜÓ§¿ò�õk+�ó§d±"

(i�I§çI<�¥I<A�â{��ûÖ)ØÜÓ"²­#|�çI§

�óè�B¥I§?|�¥I<A?1ó§��§÷¥ï�Eó"T�8���½�

eó�m��cõ§÷ Â�;��ÏdE¤�½K�"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±en�¯Kµ

1.ÜÓÁ13�o�¹eçI<7L�¥I<)ØÜÓºuy¥I<�ÝI�

3�{1�½¥IÃ�§çI<Jå®à½¬¯�z)ØÜÓ´ÄéçI<¢yæ

(J�k|§��oº

2.ÝI�d¥��â�ØNo?n§Ù�¥Id�'X´�oº��o�Y@

½¥I<A�1�´ÐÀ Ø´�â�غ

3.læL§©Û§�YéçI<|�çIæk=é&º

[Y~©Û] �â�Y�Y�£�§©ÛXeµ

1.çI<�¥I<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ�¤5�´J§ª¢Å&�Á�§¢yçIæ

�8´¢"¤±§�~�¹eØ�3)ØÜÓ¯K"@o§�o�¹eçI<7

L�¥I<)Ø\¾�Ö¡ÜÓQº�Y´¥I<Ô�ÜÓÁ1Uå½´�kÁ�

Uå�Ø2�¿Á��§A�)ØÜÓ"d�§ÏÜÓ¥I<Ô�Á�U姽´

�kÁ�Uå�Ø2�¿Á�§7,¢yØÜÓ�½�çIæ(J§ÜÓ®²

¤¯¢þ�/���©0"�{)ØÜÓ§þõ?nV��Å�ÚÅÖ§k|u�

oçI<�Ü{�Ã"Ó�§Ï¥I<Ô�Á�Uå½´�kÁ�Uå�®Ø�

¿Á�§²V�lÐ�û§́ u�¤�£§çI<Ï)ØÜÓE¤������"

Page 255: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

244 çIæÛYFn

ù�¥�I�?Ø�¯K§́ 3ÜÓÁ�L§¥§uy¥I<�ÝI�3�{

�51�½¥IÃ��§AN�?néçI<�k|"�,§çI<�±�{Jå

®à½¬¯�z§Þy¥I<3ÝIL§¥�3�{�51�½¥IÃ�§�¦)

ØÜÓ§�ù���(JÒ�½k|uçI<íº�Y´Ä½��lï�{£�¬

w§A��{�?ÝI<��{1�§�çI<´�?ÝI<�{1��ÌNíº

�,Ø´§k��?ÝI<�{1��§́ 1�iÒÅ�"1�iÒÅ�3�{é

çIÝI¹Ä?1iÒL§¥§vk\ÙÝI<��{1�§çI<3Á�L§¥

uy¥I<3ÝI¥�3�{1�§Õ31�iÒ5�çIÝI½|��ݧ�½

¬é¥I<�ÝI1�1�?v§\Ù¥IÃ�§? ÜÓÃ�"�e5§ÃØ´

)Ø�´Ø)ØV�\¾�ÜӧѬE¤çI<��")ØÜÓ�§çI<I�

­#|�æ§(½ÎÜ�¦�¥I<½«@<UYÁ1ÜÓ¶UYÁ1ÜÓ�§

ÏÜÓ®²\ÙÃ�§ÃÉu3�1��Ã�ÜÓ§���oØçI<�Ü{�

Ã"Ó�§ÃØ´®à½�z§lÙm©��á@§X�Y¤«§Ñ¬��çI�

8�Á�Êî§çI�8XÏu�²L�ÃÚ�¬�Ã�Oyá�"ùéçI<

ó§Ø´��q´�o�¤±§l�oçI<g��éۧÁ�L§¥uy¥I

<3ÝI¥�3�{1�§´ÄJ�®à½�z)ØÜÓ�û½�3çI<gC§

Ï�çIÝI¥1�iÒÅ�vk\Ù¥I<�ÝI1��3�{1�§Ù¥IÒ

À�k�§ÜÓÁ�¥§��rXú:�3N�r¦¥I<ª&Á�þ Ø72Å

(ÙÝI1�´ÄÜ{þ"3ù�:þ§Ø�¥I<Ô�Á�Uå I�)ØÜ

Ó§r¥I<3ÝI¥��{�51���=üÙÁ��Äå§â´çI<3ù�

:þ��ZüÑ"

2.ÝI�d¥��â�ا́ �ÝI<��d©�¥�3O�½®o���â

�ا~X§2× 3 = 6�¤2× 3 = 4§½´2 + 3 = 5�¤2 + 3 = 4�§́ �«

ÿ£)ؽL�"��/§b��d©��?�<´��¬¯1�Uå<"�~

/§�°�d©�I�²L?�!"ØÚ"½�õÓ�é½v§�3�â�Ø��

U54�"�d§ÝI<��d©�¥�3��â�Økü�wÍA�§�´²w

�)ا�´�â�Ø?4�½�â�Ø��Ý4�"

éÝI�d©�¥��â�صI�I�?1��§Ï��â�ØØ´���

�¬¯1�Uå<ý¢¿g�L«"��/§é�d�â�Ø�?��K�:�^ê

iL«�ê��^©iL«�ê�Ø���§±©iê��O¶�üd�æþ�

¦È�od�mØ���§±üd�O"eüdk²w��ê:� §±od�O

?Uüd"

¥IdÒ´¥I<�ÝI�d"5¿§�3�â�Ø�ÝI�dØ�LÝI<

Page 256: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

110ÙçIæµÜÓ�Ç� 245

�ÝI�d§�k�ìþã?��K?����dâ´ÝI<�d�ý¢¿gL

«"¤±§²�â�Ø?���ÝI<XJ¥I§¥IdA´Ù�d©�²�â�

Ø?��d�§é¥I<�)�åå§�¦ÝI<?1Ö¡�©�(@§Ï�ùâ

´ÝI<ý¢¿g�L«"�d§ÝI<XLáØ©�(@�â�Ø?�(J�§

¢�´ÄûÙ����¬¯1�Uå<�Ñ�(J§µI�¬�,A�ÄûÙÝ

I"�Y¥§XJµI�¬µI�?1�â�Ø?�§½´çI<?1ÜÓÇ

��?1�â�Ø?�§Ñ¬uy¥I<A��d´6582.00��§UçI©�5

½��pÝI�d§A�Äû§ÒجÑyéÛú,"�Y¥I<A�ÝI�¤

±U¥I§T´Ï�µI�¬µIL§¥§A�©ÛÝI�d��kµI�

¬©Û§çI<A�3\¾ÜÓ�é¥I<�AçI©���¦?1é'Ú©Û§

��kçI<©Û¤�"

�Y¥§@½¥I<A3Idó§þ�ü¥��Ø´�«�¿ÐÀ1�§ Ø

´�â�ا�Ï3uIdó§þ�ü¥�3�þ��â�ا�2256.00���

õ§�Ø´²w�)ؽ´L�1�§ ´¥I<A��«�¿1�"ÝI<A´/

�â�ØùXÙÝI�d�ý¢¿g§́ Ì*þ��«�¿1�§Ù8�´¢�¥

I§�´�«ÐÀ1�"

3.çIæd5�ÚÁ�ü��!�¤"Ù¥§5�=çIÝI5�§�)çI

<uÑ����!ÝI<�AçI4���!mI!µI�¬UçI©�5½�

µIIOÚ�{µ"'�ÝI©�ÚçI<?1ÜÓÇ��^g����!|¤§

´çIæÔÑ�¦�Ny¶Á�§́ çI<!¥I<UV�\¾�ÜÓÁ1�g

ÂÖ§¢yæ(J"5¿§çIæ�±¤õ¢y�cJ§́ çIÝI¹Ä�ë

�<�lçIÝI5K§=çI<U5KçI§ÝI<U5KÝI§µI�¬U

5KµI§�¦ÙI§çIæù«J`Å�âUý�u�Ùõ^"�ù3æ¢

�¥§[��U´�«�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|�n�½b�"ÄK§�ÃI

éçIÝI¹Ä�±1�iÒ"

k�ud§�YéçI<|�çIæ�é&§3uçI<��æ�I?Ì

N§I3æ�L§á¢çI<I?§Ì�Ly3µ�UçI�8A:Ú½|ø�§

JÑæI¦ÚJ`Ï�9IO§?�çI©�¶��{�ÂÝI<4��ÝI©

�§|�mI¿X¢P¹¶��{|ïµI�¬§�¦ÙUçI©�¥5½�µ

IIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1XÚ/µ"Ú'�¶�UçI©�5½�µIIO

Ú�{§±9ÝI©�1²�¯¢(@µI(J"7��§ú«µI(J¶�J`

(½¥I(J§�¥I<UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�\¾Ö¡ÜÓ¶�Á1Ü

ÓÂÖÚÜÓ+n�I§Òr¥I<Á�§¢yæ(J"

Page 257: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

246 çIæÛYFn

5¿§5�´Á��Ä:§́ çIÝI�¤JNy¶Á�´5�¤J§=æ

(J�¢yL§§�ö�9�¤"Ù¥§5�¥�?Û��½L�§Á�¥Ñ¬�

³Ã¢"éA�§5�(J2ЧvkÁ�¢��5�[�´���©"ù´çI

æ¥çI<�I�²x��n§�´�YéçI<�é&"

Page 258: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 11Ù

çIæµÜÓ�Á�+n

**********************************************************************

æÚÀje§a,�Hì¶ìíFIZ§�j���"

— ÀA.>�²5ØË.ÙÊ6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 259: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

248 çIæÛYFn

11!I�µÜÓ���+n

ÜÓI�§́ ÜÓ�¯<�|ÚÂÖ�Ó����N§́ ÜÓ¤á���§v

kI�§ÜÓØU¤á"çIæÜÓ�I���§́ �V�3ÜÓ¥�½�çI

�8Á���§=çI<Ú¥I<éçI�8Á��)�o�Ø�)�o��Ón

)§́ ÜÓ?Ý!�þÚd±+n�l�Ä:"5¿§çI楧çI<Ú¥I<

\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§ÙI�Ò´¥I��½çI��§�½´ÜÓ�¢�5SN§L

�l5çIÝI{61o�8^5½§=çI<Ú¥I<Aª¢Å&�Á1V�U

çI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾á�Ö¡ÜÓ§Ø�21¾á�lÜÓ¢�5SN

�Ù¦�Æ"�d§çI<Ú¥I<Á��Ä:´¥I��§V��U3ÜÓÁ�

¢SI��§UÜÓ¥��½�ÜÓC�^�)��éÜÓI���?1C�§y

�ÜÓI����.�§l .½�¯<�|ÚÂÖ"

[ÜÓ����¯],Ik]7Ý]�ó�ï��8§æ^úmçIu2008c9�

(½ÝI<A¥I§çI<UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©��¥I<A\¾Ö¡

ÜÓ§ÜÓþ1²�«����µ³:üY!Ä�|o!èïó§!�üY!æÏ!

��!>í£�)ÄåÚr!f>ó§¤Ú>Fó§§Ù¥§èïó§�)�A�8

C»C?§>íó§Ø�)|S10kvC>Õ��SCÚNÁ§±9��S�)�6

Y�9�SC"

ï�L§¥§çI<�¥I<AlÐûƧ�¦ò³:üYÚf>ó§U�ç

I<��u�!|G�'¤^"Ó�§¥I<A¡Ùä�ï�Ì+Ü��u���

SCó§�?]�yÖ§2Ú\C>ÕÚ)�6Y���óè�§�ó|/�d�§

ØBuy|+n§�¦çI<ò|S�10kvC>ÕÚ)�6Y�9ó²��SCØ

2çI �d¥I<��«@§¤^�1�A�ý��¤IOe25%O�"V��

�Ó¿�§\ÝÖ¿�Ƨ²(��¥I<A«���S�³:üYÚf>ó§§

¤^120.00��§UdçI<,1u�"Ó�§²(|S10kvC>Õ�CØì!�>

@Ú)�6Y�ó²��§dçI<æ§C>Õ��SC§¤^68.00��Ú)�

6Y�9ó²��SC§¤^86.00���\¥I<A�«���"

T�8u2009c12�eó§2010cÝ\¦^""O<u2010cm©é�8¤

^|Ñ?1"O§uyçI<\Ý�³:üYó§Úf>ó§,ü°ÜÓ�Æ

áu¥I<A�¥I��§�ü°ÜÓ�\�ÜÓdpu¥I<A�¥Id"Ù¥§

Page 260: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 249

³:üY󧧥I<A��d´36.50��§çI<,1\Ý�ÜÓd±�42.50�

�¶f>󧧥I<A��d�126.00��§çI<,1\Ý�ÜÓd±�141.60

��"Ó�§"OuyT�810kvC>Õ���SC!�S)�6Y�9ó²��

SCþ�çI§ ´d¥I<A��?1��óSC"�d§"O<é�'ÜÓ

Ú¤^|G?1"O§�¦çI<k'<é�'¯�)º`²§�¤"O�w

þ�"OÜ�"�w¥²(1²T�8ÜÓÁ�L§¥"Ouy��9çIæ�

¯K§�)µ���5çIÝI{61o�8^Ú5çIÝI{¢�^~61o�Ê

^5½§3ÜÓÁ1L§¥,1\¾�l¥IÜÓ¢�5SN��Ƨr�Ad

¥I<AÁ��³:üYó§Úf>ó§UdçI<,1u�§�çI<,1u�

d�pu¥I<A�¥Id§�vɪ¶�ògò�{A�çI�10kvC>Õ��

SC!)�6Y�9ó²��SCØçI �d¥I<A�óSC§5;çI�"

�8"O�wþ�½"OÛ�§²L1=x½VuiÚI]�§²½�?1

«§T�8½5��{|�ó§ï�§éçI<!¥I<9ÙÌ�I?<��{1

�§�¦U5çIÝI{61o�Ê^Ú1Ê�Ê^5½§=ÜÓ��0.5%?1?v"

Ó�§éçI<ü KI�Ì�+���§?�Ú�?Ù�U�9��@ɪ¯K§

éçI<�æ!ï�ÚÜÓ+n�Ü���I?<��ü?!v±3000-5000�?

v§��´«§̄ �3½Ikè�¥?1Ï�"

�¯¥§�'I?<É��?v´îx�§Ù¢�3uçIæÜÓ�î�5§

3uçIæÜÓ�Ù¦�ª¾á�ÜÓ�ØÓ"5¬{;6ÜÓ?¥5½�ÜÓ

´Äu�¯<g�Ä:þ�§���¯<�û��§Ò�±éÜÓ¥�¢�5SN

C�"çIæÜÓ�dØÓ§Ï�çIæÜÓ²dçIÝI¾á§ÙÜÓ��

Ù¦�ª¾á�ÜÓ�î�§I��lú²ú��Ä��K§=çI<Ú¥I<�

{UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾áÖ¡ÜÓ�´ÜÓÁ1§çI<Ú¥I<Ã

Ø´3\¾ÜÓ�§�´Á1ÜÓL§¥§Ø2#N�¯<òg?UÜÓ�¢�5

SN§Ø�ÜÓÁ1L§¥ÑyÜÓ�½�C�^�§½´{Ʋ(�±C�Ü

Ó�^�¤Ò"�¯¥§³:üYÚf>ó§Q,áu¥I<A�¥I��§=ç

I��§çI<ÒØU�¥I<A�û§,1u��Ù¦�óSCè�§ÄK§�

½��ú²ú���´�K§Ï�³:üYÚf>󧮲áu¥I<A�¥I�

�§�ì5çIÝI{61o�l^5½§¥I<AA�UìÜÓ�½Á1ÂÖ§�

¤¥I�8"�,§²çI<Ó¿§¥I<A�±ò³:üY!f>ó§��ÌN!

�'�5ó�©��¦<�¤§�¥I<A´ùü��8�I?ÌN§�çI<K

I"Ó�§10kvC>Õ!�S)�6Y�áu�{7LçI��8§çI<�{X

JUg1ï�½öSC§�±ØçI§�Q,çI<3Ö¿�Æ¥²(r10kvC

Page 261: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

250 çIæÛYFn

>Õ!�S)�6Y�9ó²���SC�\¥I<A�«���§Ò`²ÙØä

�g1ï�½öSCUå§ÒI�|�çI§ùÒ´�¯¥rT�8½5��{|

�ó§ï���Ï"

�¯¥§̄ K�¢�3uçIæÜÓ���+n"��/§ÜÓ��+nÌ

��)ü�¯�§=ÜÓI���ÚC�+n§©ãXeµ

1.ÜÓI����(½"ÜÓI����(½§=�¯<UìÜÓ�½§éÜ

ÓI�3n)þ�¤�£"çI<Ú¥I<\Ý�Ö¡ÜÓ¥§küa©�(½Ü

ÓI���§�´Idæ�ü§XIdó§þ�ü!IdÀÔæ�üÚIdÑ

ÖI¦�ü§�)ÜÓI����Úêþ¶�´ÜÓ�½��üf8éA�EâI

OÚ�¦§�ö"�Ø�"

1¤Idæ�ü"Idæ�ü´ÜÓI���§́ ÜÓ�­�|¤Ü©§ç

I<A�3Á�céIdæ�üþ�çI©�¥1²�æ�üþ?1Øé"u

yIdæ�üþ�uI¦þ�§9��Ö½,1æ"��/§æ�üdf8

¶¡!5�.Ò½A�£�!Oþü !æþO�5K!êþ�|¤§́ æI�

���½þ�x"5¿§æ�üf8�æþ(½�kü«�/§�«´æf

8�EâIOÚ�¦O(ÃاæþO(éAuTf8�I¦þ¶�´æf8

�EâIOÚ�¦Ø²(!k×\½´�اæf8þ´ý�þ"é1�«�/§

çI<I�O(rºÙSºÚæþ§��%¥kê¶é1�«�/§Ï´ý��

æI¦þ§ØO(§Á�IU¢SI¦þ?1N�"éd§çI<Øü´I�O

(rºÙSºÚæ�þ§�I��¡(½æf8O(�EâIOÚ�¦�5�

æf8þÚd�K�"

��/§ó§þ�ü±ã�1²�f8§UÚ��ó§þ�ü5K�OO�ó

§þ"Ù¥§ó§ã�ز(!�üOd5�¥vk?\�f8½´vkó§þO

�5K�f8§dçI<3çI�Ö¿A�£�!ó§þO�5KÚó§þ§�¦

ÝI<�A"Á��§çI<I�Ù�Taf8¤3�ó§Ü Úó§þ�O�5

K§±(½Taf8���¶ÀÔæþülæ�üw§́ O(�"�ÀÔæ

�f8þþ´��þ§́ 3¢SI¦þÄ:þ\þ�½'~�$Ñ!¥�½¦^�

Ñ��æ�üþ"�d§ÀÔI���Á��J:§Ø3uUæ�üÁ�§@

´�«{ü�êþØ�§ 3u÷v¢SI¦"�d§"Ñ!�1þÀÔæ§ÜÓ

Á��§~Ñy¯�Öþ½ÈØy�¶ÑÖæ�üf8�Á���ج�3�ü

þØO¯K§Ï�ÑÖf8±��ü §æþÑ´1�§ÙJ:3uf8A�ÚÑ

ÖIO�.½"

ÜÓÁ1L§¥§çI<Ú¥I<éÜÓI�3��þn)Ø�� u)�Æ

Page 262: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 251

�§�±UçI©�¥5½�æI¦Úæ�ü§±9¥I<3ÝI©�¥�A

�Idæ�üÚÁ�Oy§3lÐ�û�Ä:þn)"7��§V��±3�û

���Ä:þ�{\¾ÜÓ½öÖ¿�Ƨ±²(ÜÓI���"

2¤EâIOÚ�¦"EâIOÚ�¦§́ æ^çI�8¤?�1�EâIO!

â�½�½�¤��{éIdæ�üf8���Eâ.½§Ùm�§3u~��

ó¹·§éæf8���?1O(.½"

ÜÓÁ1�§çI<I�Ù�ÜÓ�½�Idæ�üf8�Eâëê!Eâ

IOÚ�¦§�)I[!1�IO§ÜÓ�½�æf85�!.Ò!º�½êþ§

±9�Oã�þéæ�üf8�EâIOÚ�¦�"Ó�§çI<Aݺæf

8ÎÜ�½�EâIOÚ�¦§X*8ÿ!��!u�!uÿÚ�Â��IOÚ

�{§±O(�äæf8´ÄÎÜÜÓI¦"

çI<Ú¥I<éÜÓf8�EâIOÚ�¦3n)Ø���§A±3I[!

1�EâIOÚ�¦�Ä:þ§ëìUìçI©�¥5½�EâIOÚ�¦§±¥

I<�ÝI©�¥1²�ÝI�A�O§éÜÓ�½�EâIOÚ�¦?1n)"

7��§�­�1�;[§UÜÓ�½�EâIOÚ�¦91�.~?1)º§±

O(.½ÜÓ�½�EâIOÚ�¦§¦V�3n)þ��"

3¤æf8�>."O(.½æf8�>.§́ ÜÓI���+n¥���

­�¯�§Ù¢�E´3.½æf8�ÜÓ��"æf8�>..½�9ÜÓ

+n�ü��¡§�´ÜÓ�Ù¦ÜÓ�>.§�´æf8�Ù¦ÜÓaqf8

�>."

Äk§ÜÓÁ1L§¥§çI<I�)û�ÜÓ�Ù¦��½�'ÜÓ�>.

©�§=�ÜÓ�Ù¦ÜÓ�Ôn>.��§½´�ÜÓ�Ù¦ÜÓ��£�þ�

U�9Ó��æf8�§��½�'?Á�´áu�ÜÓ�´3Ù¦��ÜÓ

¥§çI<A�3ÜÓI���þ?1O(.½§±�E¤>.?�Á��pí�

Ã<Á�"

Ùg§ÜÓÁ1L§¥§çI<I�)ûæf8�ÜÓ½Ù¦ÜÓ¥aqf

8�>.¯K"¢Sþ§�ÜÓ�Ù¦ÜÓ>.¯K)û�§ù�¯K¢�3uæ

f8�Ù¦aqf8�«O.½"�d§ÜÓéæf8�EâIOÚ�¦�.

½I��ß!O("�¯<éæf8�EâIOÚ�¦n)þØ���§A�k

3n)�¤��§? «©æf8�Ù¦aqf8"

2.ÜÓI����C�" ÜÓÁ1L§¥Ñy{Æ{5½ÜÓ¥�½�ÜÓ

C��/�§�Uu)ÜÓI���C��/�§çI<�±�¥I<uÑC�¿

�§`²ÜÓI�C���!êþ!�mÚ�þ�¦"7��§N�'ã�ÚEâ

Page 263: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

252 çIæÛYFn

]�§�¦¥I<J�¢�C�ó��Á�OyÚ��"¥I<J��Á�OyÚ

����çI<@��§V�\ÝÖ¿�ƧC�ÜÓI���"çI<Ç�1n

�§Xin<uÑC��«�§¥I<�±lÜÓ�½�1n<¼�C��«"�

�/§ÜÓ�½�C��/§�)U�8õUI���½O\ÜÓó�!UCÜÓ

ó���þ½Ù¦A5!UCÜÓó��ÄO½º�!UCÜÓ¥®(@�ó²½

^S�"~X§ó§�ó¥��OC�§ÀÔæ¥C�ã�!�O½5�!UC$

ѽ�C�{!UC�À/:§½´ÜÓ�1L§¥ÑyØ�|å�§þ�U��

ÜÓI����C�"

5¿§ÜÓI���áuÜÓ�¢�5SN"�üX�g�5�ØÓ§çIÝ

I¥§çI<Ú¥I<\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§ÃØ´ÜÓ\¾�´ÜÓÁ1§ÑØ#N

çI<Ú¥I<ògUCÜÓ�¢�5SN§~X§þ¡�¯¥§��¥I<A¥I

��S�³:üY!f>ó§§Ø²dçI ògO\10kvC>ÕÚ�S)�6Y

�SC§UCÜÓI���§Ï�ù«UCáuçI<Ú¥I<,1¾á�lÜ

Ó¢�5�Ù¦�Æ"ù�¥�/ògUC0ÜÓ�¢�5SN§́ �ÜÓ�½�

ÜÓC�^��Ñy§=´�¯<V��û��ÒUCÜÓ¢�5SN��/"

��§ÜÓ¥�½�ÜÓC�^�Ñy§çI<Ú¥I<�âC�^��äN�/

ûÆ¿UCÜÓ¢�5SN§Òáu�ÜÓ�½C�ÜÓ �ògC�ÜÓ¢�5

SN§�ÒØ��ÜÓÁ1�{Æ5½"

12!?ݵÜÓ�?Ý+n

ÜÓ?Ý+n§́ �æ^�Æ��{éÜÓ?Ý8I?1+n§�)3`z]

���Ä:þ§?�ÜÓ?Ýo��OyÚæ�üf8��Oy"ÜÓ�1L

§¥§Ü�¸ÚÁ�^��Cz§́ uE¤¢S?Ý�Oy?Ýu) �§I�

éÜÓ?Ý?1��§9�uy¿Å�ÜÓ?Ý� �§Òr¥I<U��ó½�

GÜÓI�"?ÝOy+n§~^�óä´�äOyãÚî�ã"Ù¥§(½'�

´»9Ùþ�'�ó�§́ ÜÓ?Ý+n¥§84/Ì�gñ0�Ø%+ng�"�

�/§ÜÓ+n´do?ÝOy�½Ñ�8] !¤^¦^Oy§2rùOy©

)�c!GÝ!�Úͧ��¢���â���IO"çIæÜÓ¢�¥§çI<

�¾ÜÓ?Ý8IÚo��Oy§ÜÓ¢�Oyd¥I<?�§çI<3dÄ:þ

�¾Á�^�JøOyÚ'�!:+nOy§¿3ÜÓ¥�½�¯<òÏ�G�I

?"e¡ùK�p<¬{�é,ó§�8óÏòØ��Y§�±��çI<éÜÓ

?Ý+n�¡�ë�"

Page 264: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 253

[eóòØ��¯] ,½��.Ô¥%ï��8§çI<Ú¥I<\¾�Ö¡

ÜÓ¥§�½oóÏ�370F{U"Ù¥§p§ óÏ�¦§�)ó§Ñ±0.00�150F

{U§30F{US�¤è�m�§?0.00±þ�eó�ÂÜ��220F{U"móF

ϱin<uÑ�Ö¡Ï��O"ÜÓ�½�óÏ?v§�«�<òØóÏ1��

±S§U10��/Uv±§òØ�L1 ��±þ§U10��/Uv±"Ó�§çI<k

�ª�ÜÓ½�½Ù¦�óè��ó"óÏ?vo�Ø�LÜÓd±�2%"ÏØ�

|å9çI<�Ï��óÏòاU¢SòØ�m�n\y§̂ òóÏ"

2006c10�30F§Tó§in<�¥I<uÑmóÏ�§Ï�¥I<u2006c10

�31Fmóï�"Tó§u2007c8�31FÌNµº§Óc12�25FÌN(��ÂÜ

�§?\C»C?¢�"Tó§/e¿�/þ��u2008c12�28F�G§/þn

�o�u2009c6�8F�G§eó�Âu2009c7�2F|�§�Â(ØÜ�"

¥I<Ï�çI<ó§d±Åª§3ó§eó�Â�Jå�z§òçI<w

�k+`��/�<¬{�"TY²�"�²§ÏóÏòØé¥I<E¤���

¤^1321.00��§�"@�çI<Ú¥I<þAéóÏòØ«úI?§V½dç

I<«úÙ¥60%=792.6��"çI<Ú¥I<þL«ØÑ�"�û§��p<¬

{�Jåþ�"�p<¬{�3�"@½óÏòØ��1321.00���Ä:þ§I

O\óÏòØ��188.6797��§=óÏòØ���O1509.6797�"�p<¬{�

�½T��¤^¥§çI<«ú90%§=1358.7113��§d¥I<«ú10%I?§

=150.9680��"TYéÜÓÁ�?Ý+n4ä´«�^"

�p<¬{�²"�§@��YÜÓ�½óÏ�370U§=g2006c10�31Få

�2007c12�30F�§¢SóÏ�976U§=g2006c10 �31Få�2009c7�2F"

óÏòØ590U"Ïm§çI<�±V�\¾��#¹!Ö¿�ÆC�Ü©�óS

N§�¿�Jøk�yâ§y²þãC��óÏòØ�'X§��Jøyây²X

¥I<�ÏE¤�óÏòاÙòØóÏ�u590U�Ìܧ"yyâ|±§Ø�æ

&"V�éóÏòØI?y©9���Æ��§�d§�p<¬{��µ�Xeµ

Äk§çI<A«úóÏòØ�Ì�I?"nd´¥I<3ä��ó^���

¹e§UÜÓ�½�¤éA��ó�8"Äk§UÜÓ�½§T�8�óÏ�©

�üã§=�K"±eÜ©�óÏ�150U§�)Ù¥�AÄÚè�ó§30U§�K

"±þ�ó§eó220U"þãü��ãÏ¥I<E¤óÏòØ�yâØv"Ly

3�K"±e�ó�ã§ÜÓ�½�lè��¤�ó�2007c3�21Få�§¥I<

3è��ó��¤�K"�ó��mØv3��§��ÎÜ�óÏ��¦¶Ùg§�

K"±þ�ÌN(�µº�ã"U2007c3�21FçI<�÷1n��¤è��ó

�2007c9�¥I<(�µº§Ù¢S�óÏ��150õU"âd§��@�§��

Page 265: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

254 çIæÛYFn

(�µº§¥I<¿Ã��óÏò��¯¢¶1n§ÌN(�µº�ó§eó�ã"

�â�"�²�¯¢§óÏòÏ��Ï´çI<n!o�çû��Ø(½ÚçI<

�÷���ó§ò´eó§±9Ùg��8ûü��ÏE¤"éd§��©�û�

uúi�8KI<3õgó/~¬¥é��Ø(½K���ó§�ó9Ù¦�ó

�¯¢�±«@§�uúi3"n¥éþ㯢�±Ä@§yâØv"Ó�§¥I

<õg?U�ó?ÝOy§N�ó§eó�m§çI<9inúiþ�JÑÉÆ"

âd§AT(@3T�ãÿ©yây²¥I<�kò�óÏ�¯¢"

Ùg§çI<ÌÜ�¥I<öò�ó�ndØU¤á"Ly3ó§�óL§¥µ

�2006c12�28Fó/~¬V�¥§�,L²¥I<<ó!Å���Øv§�®�

=�m�§�çI<¿Ã¿©yây²¥I<�<ó!Å���Øv��Ù�÷

�è��óò´¶�çI<ÌÜ¥I<©�ÙÜ©��ó§!SCó§§�¿�J

øÙ©�Ü©�ó��óÏöò�yâ¶�¥I<«���ÀY+�ó§!�´ó

§���ó§�m�¿Ø�pK�§�çI<¿�Þy§y²þãó§E¤óÏò

ض�¥I<u2007c9�19FJ�çI<��w§�N4p�óò´��Ï´V�

�\Ýp�ó�#¹9çI<õg?U�O§��ó§p�óÊî�¯K§¢

�çI<,1çI4p�óü !N�4p�OÚSC*1>F��Ϥ�§çI

<JÑÙ¿�K�4p�ó!ØéT�òÏKI��¦§��Jø�A�yâ�±

y²§éd§�p<¬{�édØ�æ&"

nþ¤ã§�p<¬{�@�§çI<é�8óÏòØ«úÌ�I?§¥I<

éóÏòØA«úg�I?§�ûdçI<«úòØóÏ90%�I?§¥I<«ú

òØóÏ10%�I?"ùK�¯±çI<��¥I<óÏòؤ^90% wª§%

¹XÜÓ?Ý+n¥§á¢çI<Ú¥I<I?�­�5"Ù¥§�"\�çI<

«úóÏòØ���60%§��p<¬{�U��90%§Ù�Ï3uçI<Jø�y

âØ¿©§Øv±y²¥I<A�éóÏòØ«úI?"~X§çI<JÑ¥I

<2007cS!�b��Ùè��óò´§�¥I<���ó�yâ§ÌÜÙ4p?

U�O�K�4p�ó§�¿�Jø�A�yây²Ù1��K�¥I<�ó�"

@o§ÜÓ?Ý+n¥§çI<A�æ^�o���{ÚÃã§âUk�éÜ

Ó?Ý?1+n§3®à½�z¥¼�Qº©ãXeµ

1.�äã���´"ÜÓ?ÝOy���§�~^�óä´�äã½î�ã"

Ù¥§�äã�±�8,/l¥�¡óS�m!óSÜ6'X§? �¡'��

´Ú?Ý���'�óS§�<�¤íÂ"¢Sþ§�äã´êÆ¥?Ø�k�ã"

3êÆ¥§k�ã´8Ü�9Ù�p'X��«AÛÄ�L«§́ �äãÄ:(�"

�V���8ܧÙ(k�ÈV ×V = {(a, b)|a, b ∈ V }"�X�(k�ÈV ×V��

Page 266: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 255

�f8§¡X�Vþ�'X8"½Â��8Üé(V,X)�VþéA���k�ã§P

�G = (V,X)§Ù¥V¡�k�ãG�º:8§X¡�G�l8"��Bå�§k�

ãG�º:8Úl8�P�V (G)ÚX(G)§±rNk�ãG"

�½��ãk�G§é?¿��º:v ∈ V (G)§3²¡þÀJ��:p(v)§�

5½lp(v)�p(u)�3�^k�l§��=�(v, u) ∈ X(G)"ù���k�ãG3²

¡þ�L«p(G)§¡Ù�G���ã)"XJ��k�ãG÷v^�µ(v, u) ∈ X(G)

��=�(u, v) ∈ X(G)§KG¡�Ä�ã§L²G¥Ó��3v�uÚu�v�ü^l§

=Ùläké¡5§��L«�uv ∈ X(G)§éA�ã)K^ë�v�u��^Ã�

�ãL«"ã11.1¥§�Ñü�ã~§Ù¥(a)´k�ã§(b)´ã"

j jj

jj

r r

r r*-

~

- - jj

3

(a) (b)

ã11.1 k�ã�ã

3��k�ãG�z^lþD���ê�§=�½��N�ω : X(G)→ R§¡�D�ã§q��äã§{¡�ä"ã11.2¥�Ñ���äã«~"

l - l6?

l

l- l

l-

?

l-

l-

6

- l12

25

168 10

12

ã11.2 �äã

3k��䥧��5 u¢S�¯K§́ �½��k��äãGÚÙþ?¿

ü:v, u ∈ V (G)§(½v�u�m����½���´"~X§ã11.2¥§å:Úª

:��á´��´36§��´��´43"@o§ÜÓÁ�Ï�´�oºÜÓÁ�Ï

�Ò´ÙéA��äãþ©:�ª:���´���"

Page 267: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

256 çIæÛYFn

ãØ¥k�«�{§¡��8�{§�±��5/O�k��äãþ?¿ü:

���´9Ù��§T�{Ú½Xeµ

�G´��k��ä§æ^�ê1, 2, · · · , nIPG�º:§�Ù©:Úª:©O

�º:1!n§�l(i, j)�D��ωij"K��´�{Xeµ

STEP 1. �Щ�0 ← {1}§P ← {2, 3, · · · , n}§R = {J1, J2, · · · , Jn}§é��i = 1, 2, · · · , n§Ji = 1"

u11 = 0¿�é��j ∈ P, u1j = ω1j"

STEP 2. 3P¥Ïé��!:v1¦�u1k = max{u1j, j ∈ P}"�0← 0⋃{k},P

← P − {k}"eP = ∅=STEP 4§Ù¥∅L«�8"STEP 3. é��j ∈ P?�u1jXeµ

XJu1j < u1k + ωkj§K�u1j ← u1k + ωkj§Jj ← k¶

XJu1j ≥ u1k + ωkj§K�u1j, RØC¶�£STEP 2"

STEP 4. ­ESTEP2-STEP3§��P = ∅O�ª�"

2.ÜÓ?ÝOy+n"ÜÓ?ÝOy�½k©:Úª:§Ly��äã�áu

ü ü®�ä§�±æ^�8�{O�ÑÜÓÁ1Ï�§=�äãþ©:�ª:�

����9��´§q¡�'�´»§Ùþz��óSÑ´Á�Ï����'�ó

S"5¿§��óSò´Á1¬K�e��óS§k�UUCÜÓÁ1�'�´»"

1¤ó§ï�?Ý+n"çI<Ú¥I<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ�§UÜÓ�½Jøã�

�Eâ]�!|�Eâ�.!uÑmóÏ�§±9ÜÓ�½�¥I<Á�^�"¥

I<UÜÓ�½�SNÚÏ�§?��[�ó§?ÝOy��äã½î�ãÚÁ�

`²§�xçI<(@�§�ÜÓ?Ý��Oy§́ çI<+nó§ï�!��Ü

Ó?ÝÚp§ !:��â"�âÜÓ?Ý����½§¥I<�AU�!G?�

���[�©�㽩�?ÝOy§�çI<�Y"

çI<�â(@½�Y�ó§ï�?ÝOy!©�㽩�Oy§(½'�ó

SÚÜÓ?Ý'�+n:§é¥I<Á��¢S?Ý?1Ø�§òØ�(JÏ�¥

I<¿����§Ù/ª�)�Ø�uµ�uÑó§?ÝØ�ü¶�uÑó§ï�

?Ý�#¹¶�ï�éR¬!~¬V�¥1²ó§?ÝØ�¯��"7��§�¦

¥I<\Â"

5¿§ÜÓ�½dçI<Jø�á�Úó§��§A3ÜÓ¥1²Jø�á�

Úó§���¶¡!5�!êþ!d�!�À�ª!�À/:"çI<AUï�?Ý

ÚI¦Oy§�{|�¤Jø�á�Úó§��æÚ$ѧ3ó§¦^c�G¥

I<"��/§çI<A3á�Úó§���ÀcÏ�¥I<§�¦¥I<3�½

Page 268: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 257

��mSA�À/:§?1�Â"�Â�§UÜÓ�½§�G¥I<�+Ú¦^§�

n�GP¹"

2¤ÀÔ�G?Ý+n"çI<Ú¥I<\¾ÀÔæÜÓ�§¥I<UÜÓ�

½?1\ó�E§UÜÓ�½?1u�½ÿÁ§(@ÀÔÎÜÜÓ�¦§UÜÓ�

½��C!IP§(@÷vC$^��§3ÜÓ5½�C$FÏ�c§��´C$

c)U½�$c)US±>�½>D½Dý/ªòÜÓÒ!ÀÔ¶¡!êþ!�ê!

f­!NÈÚ�$FÏ�Ï�çI<"5¿§ÀÔ?Ý�½|ø�k'X"3�á

�ø�¿v!d�²­�§¥I<��¬U��G"��§�á�ø�;Ü!½|d

�Þdª³²w½´ø�u¦�§¥I<��¬´ò�G"d�§çI<I�xr

¥I<�À§Ó��ÐÀÔ�É�#¹"7��§Sü;<A¥I<?xÀ"XJ

¥I<vUìÜÓ�½��m�ÀÚJøÑÖ§çI<�±3ØK�ÜÓ�e�Ù

¦ÖÍ����¹e§�âÜÓ�½§lÜÓd¥�ØØÏ��¤"

3¤ÑÖ?Ý+n"çI<Ú¥I<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ�§UÜÓ�½Jø¥I<Á

�^�"¥I<UÜÓ�½�SNÚÑÖÏ�§?�ÑÖOy§�)ÑÖ�m!ª

gÚ�þIO"çI<(@�§UÙþ1²��m!/:Úªg§Ø�ÑÖ(J"7

��§Ø�(JAÏ�¥I<§r¦ÙU?ÑÖ"

3.?ÝOy�N�"ÜÓÁ1L§¥§¥I<�UUÜÓ?ÝOy�¤ÜÓó

��§A9�±Ö¡/ªòò´Á��¯¢!�Uöò�mÚ�Ï�Ï�çI<§

çI<3Â�¥I<Ï��§A¦¯é�¹?1µd§¿(½´ÄÓ¿ò´Á1!

´ÄÂ�ØÏ��¤�"çI<�¦¥I<æ�k���§±¢�ÜÓ?Ý8I�§

¥I<Aæ���\¯Á�?ݧ¿«ú\¯?ݤO\�¤^"du¥I<�Ï

E¤Á�òØ�§¥I<A|GçI<}ÏÁ���7§Ø�ØéÙÁ��8�"

�?EI?"

13!�þµÜÓ��þ+n

ÜÓ�þ§́ ÜÓI�Ô�|�kA5ÎÜ5½�¦�§Ý"çI<éÜÓI

�Ô��þ+nØ%§3ué¥I<Á��þ�+n§�¦çI<éØÓ�æI

�Ô§ÙGI[!1��Ù�IO!5�Ú5§§±9/��Ù��þ+n�{½5

½"Ó�§�A�Ù�¥I<g�éÁ���þ+��{§~X§ISO9000¥é¥I

<Á�JÑ�l��þ+n�Kµ��¤(½����¦�±��¶��á��Ú

�y¢�8I§ïá±�þ�¥%�è��¸¶�éó?1�ÔÚ]�µ½¶�

Page 269: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

258 çIæÛYFn

ïá!��Ú�±©�z�L§¶�ïá¿�±¢^k��©�z��þNX¶�

ÏL+nµ"!"ر9Å�!ý���§±YU?�þNX�k�5¶�±"Ø

�w!Å���!ØÜ�¬!��Ý�±9Ù¦5 �¢SêâÚ&E���þ+

nûüÚ1Ä��â¶�·�/(½ø�A÷v��¦¿òÙ©�z�§��/�

C�*0§æ^Ñu!Äu!¥m�ÂÚ�ª�Â��þ+n�!§á¢�þI?§

±¦ÜÓÁ��)�I�Ô�þÎÜ�¦"e¡ùKxù¨¥��¯§=´��Ä

�ï�§SÚ�þI?�¤�"

[çôx¨¥¯�] 2003c9�§,{?½móï���­:ó§§3½«S�

^àþÝ]800��§,ï��ë�HWÚ�W�ªà¥«ªg+·vèJ;ÿx§

x�140�§ÌÿÀª120�§x¡o°6�§À°5.5�"T�8d½�?�çI<§

½ï�Û�ï�ü "

T�8�²eó�Â=Ý\¦^"2004càÌ!§½�?Þ�9°²nU!¬§

|�9°'m"��'m»�É~�§�f/J+0�(ã�§x����ħxþ�

<+¯� <"�(¿vk�2��3�1p��?+�"�?¬Æ�Ç�û½§#

Nxþ1<UYÏ1§9°m�~?1"��§T½3à¥|�-�ës§<�2�

gf��xuÑ�ä�(ѧ̄ � <"1�U§k<uy�xÀàxÿþ�hÖ

�á?³Ñ6cm���è§Ààë�gÿ�x¡�.\eiýä�3�§þiýä

�ü�§�T½�?EÃ<|�u�!�?§�³Ñ�î­�þÛ�Òù��î§

¿�Úå�?k'Ü�­À�äx?E"Òù�§2005c1�4FeÌ6µ00õ§/ñ

�0�(ã�§¦^¥�çôxâ,�N¨¥§40õ¶Ã�)·:�àS§14¶É

úö2?��"�éTå¯�§IÖ�¤á¯�N�|�¤¯�N��w§(

@ù´�å­��I?¯�"

N�|@�ªx�Ì��Ï´µ�L\£e¯K"Ìÿg��£e�{�ا

ØU�yg��k�£½9þ!Éå§eÞÜ �g��ÑyÜ©½�Üwѧ¦

L\g��e���¶�Ìÿg+Å�¯K"Ìÿg+3ó�\ó¥§é�Å¿Ê

H�3�«!�Åß!�LÜ!í�!YU�î­"�§�þ�Ø�I[�ó�Â5

�5½�Å¿�ÂIO¶�g+·vè¯K"Ìg+S·vèrÝ���O�¦§

ÛÜk¦/y�§3Ìÿ`�?$�Ñy1�õ���ɧL\/ó�o�3î­

�þ¯K"

N�|@�T�8��Ä�ï�§S§Ly3µ�T�8Xd½,t�Oï

Ä��ò>ó§�h<�O§!��ã\Ñã§�?1�O"�§Ìÿg(��á

�!Å��þ!�Þ �9£e�þþò(�¦"3¤xO�s��Ö1�§Ì

ÿ«1åØ÷v�A5��¦¶�T�8çIÝIr/ª!rL|§éÁ�"yk

Page 270: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 259

�+n§¥I<ò���8=��,�óÞ�ó¶�'�óS9­�Ü ��ó�

þÃ<r'§ò��O�³Ä:ògU�*�Ä:§á�9���ØU5½|�Ä

u!Á�Úuÿ§Ìÿg+�²Å��þuÿÜ�Ò�GSC§�8�|�eó�

ÂÒÝ\¦^�"Ó�§�ê+�ZÜ�{�Ã�8çIÝIÚï�§�3�À@

}§́ E¤¯��Ì��Ï"

T�8²LuÅ'å�§{��ª\�§é�½�ÖP�?ÃÏä-§�ö

�£�|ª�§¿?vÂã�24.00��§J��Ü8±8Ô9�{¤�¶é½��

BÖP�?k-§�Ï�c�1§�ö�£�|ª�§¿?vÂã�15.00��§J

���¤�8±12.00��¶é½ï�Û�Û�!BÛ��10¶�w<§©O�?k

Ïä-½¿?v7§J�8±½�{¤�¶é�OoKI<§�½�t�O�ò

>oó§�§dÌ+Ü���Ù�É�ò><��§��Ù�O]�¶é¥I<

�8²n!©�ûKI<§�?kÏä-10c§¿?v7<¬150���"

¯���Ô´ïÛ��aq/§�k#ª��¥�ØåNì!uí+��¿Ú

u�¯��§4­<aÉ�ÜÓ�þ+n�­�¿Â"ª,§́ çI<Ú¥I<\

¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§¥I<´ÜÓI�ÔÁ��ÌN§éÙÁ��þKI§�çI<�

�ÜÓI�Ô��ÉÌN§éÜÓI�Ô��É«úÌNI?"@o§çI<3Ü

ÓÁ1¥§XÛé¥I<Á��þ?1+nQºÌ�dn��¡µ�¥I<Á�^

���æ¶�á�Ú���¶�¥I<Á��þu���Â"

1.Á�^��æ"ÜÓ�½dçI<Jø¥I<�Á�^�§çI<A3ÜÓ

½�'ó�m©Á1cJø§�)Á�Ü^��ÜÓI�Ô�å^�üa"

1¤Á�Ü^�"Á�Ü^�´ÜÓ�½dçI<Jø�§�3�æ¥I<

Á��Ü^�"~X§ó§ï�¥§çI<�¥I<Jø�ó|/95�«�S

øY!üY!ø>!øí!ø9!Ï&!2Â>À�/e+�]�§í�ÚY©*ÿ

]�§��ïÓÔÚ�ÓÔ!/eó§�k']�Ú�¦§�Ï¥I<�n{Æ5

½�k'�óy�Ú1��¶ÀÔ楧çI<Jø�ÀÔ¦^�¸]�!C�

|!�Ï¥I<�nÀÔÏ1!æ�½�+ÃY�¶ÑÖÜÓ¥§çI<UÜÓ�

½Jø¥I<��ú|¤9eæ��§7���ú��§X>M!�<Å!E<Å!

�úS«!©�@�§¥�±9?\�ú|¤7��Ï1y�Ú�'Eâ]��"

2¤ÜÓI�Ô^�"ÜÓI�Ô��å^�§́ O(.½I�Ô§(�Á��

^�§�)nÜ©§�´ÜÓI�Ô�ÄO:!ÄO�ÚYO:!Ip���I�

Ô�ÄO^�¶�´ÜÓI�Ô�Eâ.½§Xã�!EâIOÚ�¦��3�å

I�Ô9Ù>.�^�"çI<A(�Jø�ÜÓI�Ô�Eâ�¦O(ÃØ"5

¿§çIæ�EâIOÚ�¦�Á1ÜÓ��EâIOÚ�¦Ø���§A±ç

Page 271: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

260 çIæÛYFn

Iæ�EâIOÚ�¦�ÄO§X¢P1¢��É�nd¶n´ÜÓI�ÔÁ�

d±�|G"çI<AUÜÓ�½�G±±ÏÚ�{§|G¥I<ÜÓ±§�)L

§G±Ú�ª(��"

çI<AéÙJø�ÄO:!ÄO�ÚYO:!Ip§±9I�ÔEâ�¦�

Ö¡]��ý¢5!O(5Ú��5KI"çI<JøI�Ô�ÄO^�ÚI�Ô

.½^��Ø��¥I<�ó½E¤Á����§çI<A�«úddO\�¤^

ÚÁ�òØ"

2.á�Ú���þ�Â"���á���Âkü«�/§�´çI<g1æ

�á�Ú���§�´¥I<?|á�Ú����Â"çI<�÷1n<?1á

�Ú���þ�Â�§�dÉ÷�1n<�çI<Á1�þ�Â�I"

1¤çI<æá�Ú���þ�Â"çI<æ�á�Ú��§AUÜÓ�

½|�á�Ú��$Ñ!�ÂÚ�+§�¦øÀûJø�A�uÿ�w!Ñ�Ü�

y��þy²©�§�âI[½ÜÓ�½��þ�ÂIOÚ�{§|�Ùæ�á

�Ú����þ�§�)µ�éæ�á�U5½I���u�uÿ�§çI<

AUI[5½½ÜÓ�½����{��§xku�uÿ]��¢�¿?1u�ÿ

Á§Ü���É"u�ÿÁØÜ��§Ø��ÉÚ¦^¶�éæ��I�?1m

�u�!?1SCNÁÚ�Ø�§çI<A3m�*u�!SCNÁ�§UÜÓ

�½��Ø�IÚ�{|��§Ü��uÑ�ÂÜ�yÖ"�ØØÜ��§Ø�

�ÉÚ¦^§A�¦øÀûò�­�"

5¿§ÜÓ�½çI<�¥I<Jøá�½��§�çI<Jø�á�½��

�5�!êþ½�þØÎÜÜÓ�¦�§çI<AKI��½­#Jø"çI<�

¥I<�û��TÜ©á�Ú��Ud¥I<æ�§�d¥I<æ§çI<U

�½|G¥I<�A¤^§«ú¥I<�Á�òØ"

2¤¥I<Á�á�Ú���þ�Â"çI<UìÜÓ�½§é¥I<UÜÓ�

½éÙJøÁ��á�!��Jø7��Á�]�Ú�©P¹Ä:þ§?1u�!

Ä�Ú�§�)��á�!���Ü�y²½�¬Ü�yÖ§�¦¥I<UI[

�Ù��'�þ�Â5½½ÜÓ�½§é?|á��Ä�u�Ú��?1u�ÿ

Á§éu�ÚÿÁ(J(@§±9éu�½ÿÁØÜ��á�Ú���¦¥I<ò

��"é¥I<Jø�Á�Úu�(Jk¦¯�§½���¥I<Á�Úu�¤J

���5�¦¥I<­#Á�Úu��§�UÜÓ�½dçI<�¥I<�Ó?1

Á�½u�"­#Á�Úu��(Jy²T�á�!���þØÎÜÜÓ�¦�§

ddO\�¤^ÚÁ�òØd¥I<«ú¶­#Á�Úu�(Jy²T�á�!�

�ÎÜÜÓ�¦§dçI<«úddO\�¤^ÚÁ�òØ"

Page 272: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 261

��ÜÓI�Ô��É<§çI<k�B�¥I<3Á�¥UY¦^ØÜ��

á�Ú��"çI<uy¥I<3ÜÓI�Ô¥¦^ØÜ�á�Ú���§A�

¦¥I<á=U�§k�¿A�áý¥I<3ÜÓÁ�¥¦^ØÜ�á�½��§

�¦¥I<��"Ó�§çI<k�3¥I<��ØÜ�á�½���2g?1u

�Úu�§��Á�ÎÜÜÓ�½��þIO"7��§çI<�±�÷1n�é

¥I<¦^�á�Ú��?1u�uÿ"

3.Á��þu���Â" UìÜÓ�½§çI<k�é¥I<�Á�9Ùó

²!á�Ú��?1u�Úu��§¥I<A�çI<�u�Úu�Jø�B§�

)çI<�y|§½�E!\ó/:§½ÜÓ�½�Ù¦/?1wÚ���©P

¹§�«¥I<?1��Á�!EØÚ��5Uuÿ§JøÁ��¬!J�Á��

w�§çI<éÁ��þ�Â�÷1n<¢�§Xó§ï�Ú�8�÷in<?1

�þu���Â�§Á��þ�u���ÂdÉ÷�1n<¢�"

£1¤ó§�þ�Â"çI<éó§ï��8��þ+n§�)éóS�þ�Â!

©�ó§�þ�Â!©Üó§�þ�ÂÚü ó§�eó�Â�¯�"

1¤Û-ó§�þu�"²¥I<gu(@�Á�I�ÔÛ-Ü ä�CX^

�§�¦çI<(@�§Xó§ï��8�Û-ó§�Â�§¥I<AÏ�çI<

3�½��mSu�§¿ANkguÜ�P¹Ú7��u�]�"çI<(@Û-

Ü �þÎÜÛ-�¦§\i�âU?1Û-CX§çI<u�(@�þØÜ��§

¥I<A39�?�!�ó­��§­#?1Û-Ü u��Â"

2¤Á�L§�þu�"Á�L§¥§çI<uy¥I<Á�,�©�½óS�

þØÜ��§�±�¦¥I<á=æ���?1Öͧ��TóS½©�ó§�þ

��ÜÓ�¦��þIO"5¿§duçI<Jø�Á�ÄO]�!êâ½ÜÓI

�Ôã�!Eâ�¦�3�ا½´çI<Jø�á�!��ØÜ�E¤Á�(J

ØÜ�§I�¥I<æ���ÖÍ�§çI<A«ú¥I<ddO\�¤^ÚÁ�

òØ"

3¤eó�Â"eó�§́ ï�ü !�O!inÚ�óü éT�8Á�´

ÄÎÜ5y�O�¦±9ïÓ�óÚ��SC�þ?1�¡u�"eó�Â�)8

��!§=µ�JÑeó���w¶�"�eó�Â�w9eó�Â^�¶�|�

ü ó§�¶��óÏm$1¶�Á$1¶�eó�|�"

��/§çI<Â�¥I<UÜÓ�½J��eó�Â���wÚ�Â]�

�§A(Ü�8¢S�¤�¹§"����w���SN"çI<"�@�Øä�

eó�Â^��§A3ÜÓ�½Ï�SÏ�¥I<§�Ñ3?1eó�Âc¥I<

UÜÓ�½�I�¤�ó�¯�"¥I<�¤Ï�¯��§2g�çI<J�eó

Page 273: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

262 çIæÛYFn

�Â���w"eó�Â¥§I�é©Üó§!��Ú;�XÚÁ$1ÿÁ�§¥

I<UÜÓ�½|�ó§!��Ú;�XÚ�Á$1ÿÁ§Á$19ÿÁ(J��

eó���w�SN§�xçI<"

çI<�âÜÓ?ÝOySü§3�Üó§eócI�¦^®²eó�ü ó

§�§½¥I<JѲçI<Ó¿�§�?1ü ó§�Â"I�Ý\�óÏ$1

�§I²çI<|��ÂÜ�§y²U(�S��§�3�óÏÝ\$1"

çI<|��O!inÚ�óü éÜÓó§?1eó�§"�ó§Eâ]

�´Ä÷vI[5½�ÂIO!éó§?1�N�Â"²�§çI<@�ÜÓó

§�3ØÜ�?§ØÓ¿�Âó§�§AuÑ�«§�¦¥I<éØÜ�ó§?1

�ó­�½ÖÍ"¥I<3�¤ØÜ�ó§��ó­�½ÖÍ�§A­#J�eó

�Â���w¶²L�Â�Ó¿�Éó§�§çI<UÜÓ�½�¥I<uÑó§

�ÂyÖ§|�eó�|ÚÔ�+nO�"

£2¤ÀÔæ�þ�Â"ÀÔæ��þ�Â�ó§ï��8¥�çI<æ

á�Ú���þ�Âaq"��/§á�æ¥I<�G�§çI<AUÜÓ�

½éá��5�!�þ�?1u�"ÜÓ�½d1n�u�Å�u��§1n�Å

��u�(JéV�þäk�åå¶�.½¤@��æ��þ�§�)m�u

�!SCNÁ!�ØÚ�Â��!"Ù¥§3m�u�¥§çI<Ú¥I<A�Ó\

Ýêþ!*u��w§A�²u�(J§�)u�Ü�½uy�?Ûá"!��

½Ù§�ÜÓ�½ØÎ�/¶�Ø´éÜÓ���ØÿÁ§±(½ÜÓ��´Ä�

�ÜÓ�½�Eâ5U�Ø�I"

Ï¥I<�Ï�Ø�U��ÜÓ�½�Eâ5U�I�§¥I<A3ÜÓ�½

½V�Ó¿�Ï�Sæ�k���§�ØÜÓ��¥�3�"�§2g�Ø"²L

�ا��E�U��ÜÓ�½��$Eâ5U�Ø�I�§V�AÒÜÓ��Y

Á1?1�û§�ûؤ�§çI<�±)ØÜÓ¶²L�ØÜÓ����ÜÓ�

½��$Eâ5U�Ø�I�§çI<A\ÝÜÓ���ÂyÖ§�ÉÜÓ��"

£3¤ÑÖ�þ�Â"çI<UìÑÖÜÓ�½�ÑÖ¯�!�m!ªgÚÑÖ

IO§3�ØÏSé¥I<�ÑÖ�þ?1u�Ú�§�ÐÑÖu�Ö¡P¹§

�¥I<uÑÖ¡Ï�§JÑÑÖ�3�"�ÚI��U¯�§�¦¥I<3e�

��ØÏS�U§��÷vÜÓ�½�ÑÖIO"

ÑÖ�þ�Â�¥I<Âý´�ÜÓ)Ø!��§çI<A�¥I<�Ó?

1�§��/±¯¢��â!±ÜÓ�½�O-0§�¥I<|GÜÓd±½�¥

I<)ØÜÓ"

Page 274: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 263

14!|GµÜÓ�d±+n

¥I<Á1ÜÓ���8�3u¼�Âç=ÜÓd±"�d§çI<UÜÓ

�½�d±|GÚ^�§�¥I<|GÜÓd±§́ çI<3ÜÓÁ1¥���Ì

�ÂÖ"Ó�§ÜÓd±|Gq´çI<+nÜÓÁ1�ÃãÚ�÷"@o§çI

<3ÜÓÁ�¥A�N�?1ÜÓd±�|G+n§A�N�A^ÜÓd±|G§

�å¿r¦¥I<Á�QºÜÓd±¥�Odf8kü«§�«´üdf8§I�

çI<�¥I<�Ó�¿(@Á��¤þ§UÁ��¤þO�d±¶,�«´o

df8§±ÜÓ¥�½�odf8|G©)L¤L«��ã5½©�Oþ�|±5

]�§±9¤��Á�/�8I½©�ãI�¤�Á�þÚk'Oþ]�O�ÜÓ

d±"3ÜÓd±|GaOþ§çI<|GÜÓd±�)ýG±!L§G±Ú�ª

(��aO"çI<éÜÓd±|G�+n­3Á�L§G±"�íÄ¥I<ª&

Á�§çI<�±3ÜÓ¥�½§½´Á��O\Ö¿d±|G/ø¨0̂ �§±r

¦¥I<Á�"

1.ÜÓýG±"ýG±´çI<�¥I<?1ÜÓÁ�O�§X�á�Ú�

�§O�����±9NÖèÎ?|Á��"ýG±35�þ´/±§I�3Á�

L§G±¥�£"��/§ýG±I�À¥I<?1ÜÓÁ�O�¯��õ�9¤

I¤^ ½§�ÝU\�ÜÓd��½'~3ÜÓ¥�½"Ù¥§ó§�óýG±

�\�ÜÓd�10%-30%§t!�OÚinýG±�\�ÜÓd�10%-20%"À

Ôæ��Ø�ýG± ´ÄÏG±§�\�ÜÓd�10%-60%"~X§{üÀÔ

ÄÏG±�\�ÜÓd�10%§°�¤ìæ�±�60%�"

ýG±UÜÓ�½�ÝÚ^�|G"~X§ÜÓ�½\�ÜÓd�200.00��§

ýG±�\�ÜÓd�15%�§KýG±�Ý�30.00��"5¿§ªcÁ���

8§ÜÓ�½ýG±UcÝ|G�§©O3ÜÓ\¾�30FS§½´zc���°

UOy�¤�|GýG±"~X§\�ÜÓd�2000.00��§ýG±�\�ÜÓd

�10%§ÜÓÁ1Ï��üc"ÜÓm©Á1��cOy�¤��800.00��§KÜ

Ó�11�c�ýG±�80.00��§1�c��|G�ýG±�120.00��"

ýG±A�´;±;^"�d§¥I<�çI</|ýG±�Ó�§A��ç

I<J�ýG±�¼§Ùú�7�A�ýG±7��Ó§ú�I?�ýG±;^u

V��½¯�§Ø�é�¦^"éu�.�8§ýG±�¼�ú�7���âÜÓ

Á�?ÝÚýG±�£�7�Åc4~"

2.Á�L§G±"Á�L§G±´ÜÓd±|G+nØ%"©�±ÏG±Ú/

�?§G±�§©ãXe"

Page 275: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

264 çIæÛYFn

£1¤G±ÏG±"G±ÏG±��^uó§ï��8§́ �ÜÓ¥�½ÜÓ

OþÚG±±Ï§¥I<3z�G±±Ï"§�çI<J�G±��ü§N�A�

|±5y²©�"��/§G±��ü�)µ����gG±±Ï"®Á�ÜÓ�

d±¶�ÜÓ�½O\Ú�~�C�7�¶�ÜÓ�½O\Ú�~�¢�7�¶�

ÜÓ�½A|G�ýG±Ú�~���ýG±¶�ÜÓ�½A�~��þ�y7¶

�ÜÓ�½AO\Ú�~�Ù¦7��"ùp§ÜÓ�½ÔdÅÄæ^d��ê½

�dX¢B\Á�L§G±§�´ÔdÅÄ3ÜÓ(���g5|G§éA�Á�

L§G±�O�k�½�É"

1¤ÔdÅÄB\L§G±"ÜÓ�½ÔdÅÄB\G±ÏG±�§çI<Q�

O�¥I<�¤�ÜÓd�§Ó�§���Äá�!��Ú<ó��d�"

[d��êG±O�¯~] ,Y|ó§�8çI�§çI<�¥I<\¾�Ö

¡ÜÓ¥§'ud±�½�SNXeµ�ÜÓa.µ�Nd�ÜÓ¶�\�ÜÓd

�82000��¶�U�|G?ݱ§?ݱ����¤��üf8�ÜÓd�!��

(@�ÜÓC�7�!¢�7�!��d�N��§�ØýG±Ú�þ�y7¶�

ýG±�\�ÜÓd�10%§U�Ó'~l�?ÝG±¥�£¶��þ�y7�\

�ÜÓd�5%§d��¤ÜÓd�¥�3¶�d�N�æ^d��ê{§=

∆P = P0 ×

[A +

(m∑i=1

Bi ×Fti

F0i

)− 1

]éA�d��êÚ�­L�L11.1"

¶¡Ä�d��ê �­

�Ò �ê� �Ò #N�� (½�d��ê5

½�Ü© A 0.10�0.18 0.16 çI©�

C�ܩ

YY

�ó��

F01

F02

F03

F04

160

155

145

120

B1

B2

B3

B4

0.15�0.2

0.1�0.15

0.1�0.2

0.35�0.5

0.14

0.18

0.12

0.40

ÜO 1.00

�?d��

�?d��

�?d��

�?d��

L11.1 d��êÚ�­

TÜÓÁ1L§¥§ëYo��A!B!C!DÁ�7�£ü µ��¤êâ�

Page 276: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 265

L11.2§Ù¥§C�Ú¢�7�UÄOFd�Y²Od"

�Ý A B C D

����\O�¤�

�üf8�ÜÓd�9000 15000 24000 25000

��u)�C�7� 110 -160 180 120

��u)�¢�7� 50 0 -10 80

ÜÓ�½AO\½

�~�Ù¦7�0 0 0 0

��·^�d��ê

Ft1

Ft2

Ft3

Ft4

170 175 181 187

163 166 165 163

150 159 159 158

125 120 124 122

L11.2 ëYo��Á�êâ

KT�81B���G±�O�Xeµ

1B��Ï�¤�ÜÓd�: 15000 − 9000 = 6000��§P0 = 6000 − 160 =

5840��§K

∆P = 5840×[0.16 +

(0.14× 170

160+ 0.18× 163

155+ 0.12× 150

145+ 0.4× 125

120

)− 1

]= 5840× [0.15 + (0.149 + 0.189 + 0.124 + 0.417)− 1]

= 5840× 0.029 = 169.36

Nd�1B���Ï�¤�ÜÓd�5840 + 169.36 = 6009.36��"A�ýG

±6009.36× 10% = 600.936��§A��þ�y76009.36× 5% = 300.468��"�

1B �AG±�

6009.36− 600.936− 300.468 = 5107.956��"

ÜÓ�½á�!��Ú<ó�dX¢O\G±ÏG±�§çI<UÜÓ�½O

�¥I<G±Ï�¤�ÜÓd��§Uá�!��Ú<ó��d�(½G±ÏAG

±"~X§,ó§�óÜÓ�½�ýG±�\�ÜÓd�10%§�þ�y7�\�

Page 277: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

266 çIæÛYFn

ÜÓd�3%"¥I<313���Á�ÜÓ�d��260.00��§á��d12.00�

�§���d-5.00��§<ó¤�d3.00 ��"çI<3��A|G¥I<�ÜÓ

±�

260− 260× 10%− 260× 5% + 12− 5 + 3 = 231.00��"

2¤ÔdÅÄØB\L§G±"ÜÓ�½ÔdÅÄØB\G±ÏG± ´3(

��U5½Ú�N��§çI<3G±ÏG±O��Ø^�Äá�!��Ú<ó¤

�d�N�§=´3(��Uì5½?1Ú�O�"

[eóNdG±O�¯~] ,ó§�ó�8§çI<|�úmçI�§�¥I<

�{\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ¥§k'd±|G��½Xeµ�\�ÜÓd�2800��"Ù

¥§á����¤ÓÜÓd��62%¶�ýG±�\�ÜÓd�30%§̂ u¥I<á

�Ú����¶�Á�?ݱU�O��|G¶�����ÜÓd�¤¹á��

��¤Ø�uýG±7�§�e�å��ÜÓd�¤¹á����¤�uýG±7

��§m©l���¤�ó§(�d±¥�'~-�ýG±§-�'~�á���

�¤ÓÜÓd��'­§�eó(���Ü��¶��þ�y7�ÜÓd��3%§

l�?ÝG±£Ø�)<ó!á�Ú���d�N�¤¥U3%�3¶�ÜÓ�½§

<ó¤�½�Z§á����¤3eó(���âk'5½��g5N�"

T�8�co�m©�ó§«�<¢S�¤ÜÓd�£��¤�L11.3"

�° o Ê 8 Ô l Ê

ÜÓd� 420 480 560 540 470 330

L11.3 �ÜÓd�

Tó§Ê�°eó�§5½á����¤3eó(��þN6%"@o§çI<

z�A|G�¥I<�ÜÓ±O�Xeµ

Äk§(½ýG±å��°"Tó§ýG±7��2800��×30%=840��§á

����¤�840���éA�ÜÓd��840��/0.62=1354.84��"¥I<Ô-

Êùn���¤�ÜÓd��1340�<1354.84��§8-Êùo���¤�ÜÓd

��1900�>1354.84��"�d§UÜÓ�½§çI<o�ÚÊ�G±ØI�ýG

±§8��Ê�G±I�'~�ýG±"O����°AG¥I<ÜÓd±Xeµ

o�G±�µ420− 420× 3% = 407.40��¶

Ê�G±�µ480− 480× 3% = 465.60��¶

8�G±�µ560− 560× 3%− 560× 30% = 375.20��¶

Ô�G±�µ540− 540× 3%− 540× 30% = 361.80��¶

l�G±�µ470− 470× 3%− 470× 30% = 314.90��¶

Page 278: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 267

Ê�°G±µ330− 330× 3%− 330× 30% + 2800× 62%× 6% = 325.26��"

ù�§çI<z�A|G¥I<�ÜÓd±£��¤§�L11.4"

�° o Ê 8 Ô l Ê

ÜÓG±� 407.40 465.60 375.20 361.80 314.90 325.26

L11.4 çI<�G±�

£2¤/�8IG±"/�8IG±§�ÜÓ�½UìÜÓÁ��¢S/�?Ý

G±§~^u�.ó§�ó!ó§t!�O!inÚ��æ§ÙÁ�L§G±O

��éuG±ÏG±{ü"

~X§,��æÜÓ�\�ÜÓd�268.00��§ÜÓ¥�½�G±/�8

I�µ�ÜÓ)��30 FS§�¥I<|G\�ÜÓd�10%¶�¥I<UÜÓ�

½�G�ÜÜÓ���§çI<330 FS�¥I<|GÜÓd��60%¶�çI<

�¥I<\ÝÜÓ���ÂyÖ�30 FS§�¥I<|GÜÓd��25%¶�"�

I?Ï3÷�28 FS§�¥I<|GÜÓd��5%"çI<3éTÜÓd±|G

+n�§(½ogG±�Ý©O�µ26.80��!160.80��!67.00��Ú13.40��§

UÜÓ�1�/�?ÝÚÜÓ�½^�?1|G=�"

£3¤�ݲþG±"ÜÓ�½U�Ý�Ø(J²þG±�§~X§Ô�+nÜ

Ó§çI<AU�ÝG±�9�Ø(J§(½|G¥I<�ÜÓ±"

~X§,Ô�+n�¬�Ô�úi\�ÜÓd�96.00��/c§=8��/�§

ÜÓ�½�Ì�¬éÔ�+n�Ý�ØAAA�§¤^þ23%¶AA�§¤^þ

20.00%¶A�§¤^þ2-5%"2016c§T�«�Ì�¬Uì�½��د�Ú

IO§éÔ�+n��Ø(J�L11.5§

�° � � n o Ê 8 Ô l Ê � �� ��

�Ø(J A A AA AA AA AA AAA AA AA AA AA AAA

L11.5 Ô��Ø(J

KA|GÔ�úi�+n¤�L11.6£ü µ��¤"

�° � � n o Ê 8 Ô l Ê � �� ��

�Ô�¤£�¤ 7.6 7.6 8 8 8 8 8.24 8 8 8 8 8.24

L11.6 �Ô�¤

ù�§2016c¢S|GÔ�úi�+n¤�95.68��"

çI<3é± {gÁ�G±y?1®oÚEØ¥uy�!¦½­E�§çI

<k��±?�§¥I<�k�JÑ?���"²V�EØÓ¿�?�§A3�g

Page 279: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

268 çIæÛYFn

G±ÏG±¥|G½�Ø"

3.Á�(�" �¥I<�¤�ÜÜÓó��§çI<UÜÓ�¦?1��

§(@ÎÜÜÓ�¦�§A?1Á�(�"��/§¥I<JÑçI<�ÏA|

G�¥I<�d±"çI<3ÜÓ�½Ï�S§é{g®GÜÓd±!A�±�Ú

¢�±�?1"ا(@ÃØ�§�3�þ�y7�UÜÓ�½|G¥I<�{d

±""�I?Ï3÷�§UÜÓ�½|G¥I<�{��þ�y7"ÜÓd±k�

Æ��ûØ���§UÜÓ�½J�®àÅ�®à½<¬{��û"

15!Y~µ{��ûÒ�ÜÓþÃ�Y

çIæL§¥§çI<Ú¥I<UìçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�\¾Ö¡

ÜÓ§ª¢Å&/Á1ÜÓ§́ çIæ�m�"ù�¥§çI<Ú¥I<�U�

{¾á�°k�ÜÓ"¢�¥§~Ñy�¯<\¾ü°½õ°Ö¡ÜÓ§�°ÎÜ

çIÝI{Æ5½§�k'1�iÒÅ��Y§¡��ÜÓ§��¯<¿ØÁ1¶,

�°vk�1�iÒÅ��Y§¡�ÒÜÓ§�¯<U\¾�ÒÜÓÁ1"��/§

@�²L1�iÒÅ��Y��ÜÓk�§ÒÜÓÃ�§�¯<V�u)�Ƨ®

à½�z�§�â�ÜÓàû½�û"�XJ�ÜÓ�5�L§�{§=çIÝI

L§¥��çIÝI{�5½§�{A�½Ã�§=Ò�ÜÓþÃ��§qA�X

Ûàû½�ûQºd�§��Aëì�¯<ý¢¿g�L«Ú¢SÁ1�ÜÓ§�

�ÜÓd±(��â"�Ã{(½¢SÁ1�ÜÓ�â�§�±nÜ�ÄÜÓ�Ƨ

(ÜÁ��þ!�¯<�L�Úª¢&^��K§�±Ün©�çI<Ú¥I<�

I?"e¡ùKY~§=´�¯<��çIÝI{5½§JbçI§�¯<3ÜÓ

Á��qu)�Æ�{��~"

[Y�£�] ,IkÝ]��/�mu�8I�=]ï�§��y�8mu?

ÝÚÂçmuûk1ÀJ�[¢å�r��óü A§�Ù3=]�!ï�

?ÝÚÜÓ6½d���¡�û��§u2009c9�28F\ÝTó§�ó«�Ü

Ó§�½�8ÜÓ����óã1²���§móFÏ�2009c9�30F§eóFÏ

�2011c9�15F§zò´eó�F§UÜÓod�0.02%?1?v"V�ÜÓ��

½§ó§Ed�1�2008c½�9�'©�§ïÓSCó§¤(�oEdü3%§\

�ÜÓd�12863.25��"�ó9�Â�ã±ÜÓ6½d�G±�â"�l�4Ã

/þÜ©6½1200�/m2§�l�±e4Ã/þÜ©6½1000�/m2§/eÜ©6

½1625�/m2"Ù¥§á�Ú��dmuû@�@d§�¦�óü AJcþ�á�

Oy§á�!��æcdmuû(@á�d�§?|�dï�!�óÚinn��

Page 280: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 269

Ó(@?|êþ§±`��@dü�OOd"�OC�!ó§Uû9y|\y±m

uû¬\1Eü�O§ü�C�od32000�±S�ØO¤^§d�óü AÃ^

��ó¶ü�C�¤^32000�±þ�§U�2008½���AO~§Ì�á�d�

±`�Ó�Ï�@dü�O"T�8vkýG±§�óü A=]ï��ÌN(�

�ÂÜ�30FS|Gè�!/ÄÄ:ÚÌN(�ÜÓd±70%§�Yó§ÜÓd±

U�|G70%§�OC�!á�d�3eó�Â�Få60FSG�"2009c9�28F§

ï�!�O!inÚ�óü é�óã�?1¬"ÚEâ�.§u9�30Fm©Ä�

|G!è�m�Ú/e(��ó"

2009c10�30F§muû<V�\¾�ÜÓ�½ï�Û�Y§½ï�ÛØ��

Y§nd´T�8áu�{7L?1çI��8§�²çIÜÓÃ�§�¦mu

û�{|�T�8çI��¥I<\ÝÜÓ§21�Y"2009c11�5F§muû

3½ï�Û�nçIÝIÃY§�óü A�o[ûÆЧ�ÓÙÝI��óè�

ë�ÝI§�¿�pÝI�d1305.00��"2009c12�5F§muû(½�ó

ü A�Ù�/�mu�8�¥I<§�ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö¿\ÝÖ¡ÜÓ§1²

��/�muïÓ¡È�110998²��§«�����óã�1²�èï!Yæ!

>í!>F!��!Ϻ�ó§��óSC§móFÏ�2009c12�8F,eóFÏ

�2011c12�7F§óÏ�730U§\�ÜÓd±�14168.25��§�½�ÜÓd±N

��{�U�óã�(�"Ù¥§á��d!�OC�!UûÚy|\yU¢N�§

�12008c�ïÓSCó§ý�½�9V��ƽ�½"V�\¾�T°ÜÓ�Æ

u2009c12�30F3½ï�Û?1�Y"

2011c11�30F§muû|��O!inÚ�óü Aéó§?1eó�§(

@Ü�§\ueó�ÂyÖ"Óc12�.§�óü A�muûJ�(��w§

�¦muû|GÜÓ�{±4526.00�"T�8û¬��ÈØn�§AO´Ù¥�¹

��i¢Ú�@û����çû§́ ´Ã<¯9§�¦muû3|G�óü A�

=]±��§�Y�8ÜÓ±|G�kò´"

T�8eó�Â�C�c§muû��vk|G�óü A�¦�ÜÓ±�"�

õg�û�J§�óü A���GòTmuûwþ{̧�¦{�U2009c12�5F

\¾�ÜÓ§�-muû�Göj�ó§±4526.00��§�¦UeóFÏ�2011c11

�30F§�-´ò|GÜÓ±|E604.00��Ú¶ó��¤375.00��"muû?1

��§�¦�-�óü A�U�Ù1�g\¾ÜÓþ1²�Fϧ=2011c9�15F

eó��muû192.95����¤§��Ï�óü A}Ï�Geó�Â]�E¤

muûK]��1606.00��§�Gó§eó�Â]��"

²d�p?<¬{��"Ú�p<¬{��"§@��Yáu�{7L?1ç

Page 281: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

270 çIæÛYFn

I��8§�¯<V�u2009c9�28F\Ý�Tó§�ó«�ÜÓ§áu�çk

½§��çIÝI{r�5½�1�¶V�u2009c12�8F\¾�Ö¡ÜÓ§�²

L|�çIÝI\¾§3ï�1�Ì+Ü��Y,�muû3Á1çÝI�Ic§®

�¦�óü A�óÄ�|G!è�m�Ú/e(��ó§"Ó�§�óü A�

Ù¦o[ÝI<�ÝI©��3õ?É~��§�²w�GÏ1�§TÖ¡ÜÓ

�{A�@½Ã�"²LØ¢§{�@�2009c12�5F\¾�ÜÓd±14168.25�

�§�2009c9�28F\¾�ÜÓd±§�31305.00��d�§�öþ�Ã�ÜÓ§

�óü A¢S´UìÙ�muû32009c9�28F\¾ÜÓ3Á�§�AUÙ

¢SÁ1Ø�ÜÓd±§(@muûò´|G�ÜÓ{±�3958.00��§¶ó¤

�169.00��"{�@�§J�eó�Â]�´�óü �{½ÂÖ§Ù3A½�

¹e�k|F�§¿Ø¿�X�±��ØÁ1�Geó]��ÂÖ"

�d§�p<¬{��"�ûµ�muû�û)��Få15FS�G�óü

 AjG�ó§±3958.00��,¿g2012c1�30FåUì¥I<¬Õ1ÓÏÓa�

±|Ç|G|E�G��F�¶�muûu�û)��Få15FS�G�óü AÊ

ó¶ó��169.00��¶��óü Au�û)��Få15FS�muû�G�Ü

�ó]�;�Ò£muûÚ�óü A�Ù¦�z�¦"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±e¯Kµ

1.�o�Ã�ÜÓ§k@�/Ú�³5º�Y{�"n¥§��o@½mu

ûÚ�óü A\¾�ü°ÜÓþÃ�º

2.�Y{���ovk�v�óü A��muûò´eó��º�{A�ç

I �çI�ï�ó§�óÜÓ§́ Ääk�å�¯<�{Æ�å§́ Ä�±Á1º

Á1(å�§çI<qA�N�|G¥I<�ÜÓd±º

3.�Yl5��Á��3=¯K§çI<l¥éæqk=é&º

[Y~©Û] �â�'5½ÚY�£�§yék'¯K©ÛXeµ

1.Ã�ÜÓ§́ �ÜÓ/ªþwq¤á§=�¯<V�\ÝÖ¡�Ƨ�ÏÙ

j"k�ÜÓ��§3{ÆþØU�¯<�m�Ü¿D�ÜÓ{Æ�å�ÜÓ"5¬

{;6oK?1�zo�8^!1�zÊ�n^!1�zÊ�o^²(5½§ke�

�/���ÜÓÃ�µ�1�<��é<±Jb�¿gL«¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶

���{Æ!1�{5�r�55½"�´§Tr�55½Ø��T¬¯{Æ1�

Ã��ض�1�<��é<�¿Gϧ�³¦<Ü{�Ã�¶���úSû�

�¬¯{Æ1�"5¬{;6oK?1�zo�Ô^!1�zo�l^!1�zo�

Ê^!1�zÊ�^!1�zÊ��^5½§e�¬¯{Æ1�§�¯<¥���

k��¦<¬{�½ö®àÅ�C�½ö��µ�Äu­�Ø)¢��¬¯{Æ1

Page 282: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 271

�¶���±ÐÀÃ㧦é�3��ý¢¿g��¹e¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶�

1n<¢�ÐÀ1�§¦��3��ý¢¿g��¹e¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶��

�½ö1n<±�½Ã㧦é�3��ý¢¿g��¹e¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶

���|^é�Ñu�(G�!"y�äUå��/§�¦¬¯{Æ1�¤á�w

�ú²�"

Ó�5½§5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ��^5½§äk�����¯<g��

½öA�����¯d�Få�cS!­�Ø)��¯<g��½öA�����

¯d�FåÊ�FSvk1¦���§½´�¯<É��½§g�½1�ª��F

å�cSvk1¦���§½´�¯<����¯d�²(L«½ö±gC�1�

L²�ï����§����«"Ó�5½§�¯<g¬¯{Æ1�u)�FåÊ

cSvk1¦����§����«"

éÃ�ÜÓ�?n§5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�Ô^5½§¬¯{Æ1�Ã�

�§1�<ÏT1����ã�A��±��¶ØU��½övk7����§A

�òdÖ�"Ó�5½§kL����A���é�Ïd¤É����"éu��

ÑkL��§A��g«ú�A�I?"�Y¥§muûÚ�óü A\¾�ÜÓ

Ã�§áuV�ÑkL�"

�Y{�@½muûÚ�óü A\¾�ÜÓÃ��nd´µ�2009c9�28F

\¾�ÜÓÃ�§Ï��Yáu�{7L?1çI��8§��çIÝI{r�5

5½§U5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�n^5½§Ï¬¯{Æ1�Ã���ÜÓÃ

�¶�2009c12�8F\¾�ÜÓÃ�§Ï�YçIÝIL§¥��çIÝI{�

B�55½§�óü A�Ù¦o[ÝI<�ÝI©�õ?É~��§�GÏÝI

1�"Ó�§U5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�n^5½§Ï¬¯{Æ1�Ã� @½

ÜÓÃ�"

2.�Y�"Ú�"{�þ@½muûÚ�óü Au2009c9�28F!12�8F

\¾�ÜÓÃ�§Øäk{Æ�åå§�¯<ØU±Ã�ÜÓ¥�½�eóFÏ�

�ÌÜÙ�Ã��â"ù«�/áuÜÓ¥Á�Ï�ز(§U5¬{;6ÜÓ?

1Êz���^5½§ÅÖ<=�óü A�±��Á1§Å�<=muû��±

���¦Á1§�A��é�=�óü A 7��O��m"

Xþ©Û§�{7L?1çI�ï�ó§§u�<�«�<�²çIÝI \

¾�ÜÓ§Ïáu5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�n^5½�¬¯{Æ1�Ã��/§

=��{Æ!1�{5�r�55½¬¯{Æ1�Ã�§g©éÜÓV�vk{Æ

�åå"ùpI�©Û�§́ ÜÓ@½Ã��§�,éÜÓV�Øäk{Æ�å§́

Ä�±Uì�°Ã�ÜÓÁ1Qº�,�±��¯<V��,�±ëìÃ�ÜÓ�

Page 283: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

272 çIæÛYFn

�½Á1ÙÂÖ§ù«Á�1�¢Sþ´�«g·�å1�§{Æþ¿Ø@�Ù�

½�¬¯{Æ1���å"éd§5¬{;6ÜÓ?1Êz"Ô^5½§ÜÓÃ��§

ØK�ÜÓ¥Õá�3�k')û�Æ�{�^±��å§=�¯<Á1Ã�ÜÓ

u)�Æ�§¿Ø±�¯<��½��®à½�z��⧠´d®àÅ�½{�

?1àû½�û§�±ëì§��±Øëì�¯<��½§�Ï3uÙ�½Ã�"

@o§Ã�ÜÓÁ1(å�§çI<´Ä�±ëìÃ�ÜÓ��½|G¥I

<ÜÓd±§¥I<q´Ä�±�¦çI<UÃ�ÜÓ�½|GÜÓd±Qºl

{nþ½¢¯¦´��Kw§�,�±�Uì5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ÔzÊ�n^5

½§ï�ó§�óÜÓÃ�§�´ï�ó§²eó�ÂÜ��§�±ëìÜÓ'u

ó§d±�òdÖ�«�<"Ó�²(§eó�ÂØÜ��²?E��ï�ó§

eó�ÂEØÜ��§«�<ØU�¦ëìÜÓ'uó§d±��½Ö�"�,§

Ïu�<L���ï�ó§ØÜ�E¤���§u�<�A«ú�A�¬¯I?"

5¿§�Y¥§�óü AJÑ��z�¦§´3eó�ÂÜ��Ä:þ§UìÙ

�muûu2009c12�8F\¾�Ã�ÜÓ?1��¦"5¿§�Y<¬{�¿v

kU�óü ��z�¦§�-muû�Göj�ó§±4526.00��Ú¶ó��

¤375.00��§ ´U¢¯¦´��K?1Ø�§�ûmuû�G�óü AjG

�ó§±3958.00��,¿g2012c1�30FåUì¥I<¬Õ1ÓÏÓa�±|Ç|

G|E�G��F�§�ûmuû�G�óü A¶ó��¤169.00��"Ó�§�

û�óü Au�û)��Få15FS�muû�G�Ü�ó]�§¿Ò£muû

Ú�óü A�Ù¦�z�¦"ù¿©Ð«éÜÓ�Æ?1¬¯"����Ä��

K§=3�l{ÆÄ:þ§¢¯¦´"

ùpI�?�Ú?Ø�¯K´§Ã�ÜÓÁ1(å�§ÜÓ�¯<Ø´±Ã�

ÜÓ�ëìé�§ ´�gJÑØÓ�®à½�z�¦§~X§¥I<�¦UÙ

Á��¢Ss¤§=ÜÓÁ1¥á�!���ÌÝÞd��(J(�§ çI<�

¦UÃ�ÜÓ¥��½§~XÔdÅÄd¥I<«ú��ª(�"d�§çI<�

�z�¦´Ä�½¬��®àÅ�½<¬{��|±Qº�Y´Ø�½�Ï�5¬

{;6oK?1�zÊ�Ô^5½§¬¯{Æ1�Ã����ÑkL��§A��

g«ú�A�I?§®à½�z�±nÜ�ÄÜÓ�Æ:§(Ü5�L�ÚÁ��

þ§U¢¯¦´��K§Ün©�çI<Ú¥I<�I?§�±àû½�û"5¿§

ù�àû½�û�cJ´Ï�ÜÓÃ�"

3.�Yl5��Á�§�3�¯K½Øþ�?9ndXeµ

Äk§muû|�=]ï�Øþ"=]ï�6Ï�óè��~)�²E§\

�]7±=(JÚãÖ¤^§Âòw~�§�³è����|Ã"éu=]

Page 284: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

111ÙçIæµÜÓ�Á�+n 273

ï��8§�óü �õ´±öj�óó]!©�û¤^!À±¤^½´±Õ1�

±5WÖ§Úu�¬²E�S®ÏÚ²LŪ�Ø­½Ï��u)"

Ùg§�Y´IkÝ]?1�ó§ï��8§áuçIÝI{5½��{7L

?1çI��8§muû��óü Au2009c9�28F\¾ÜÓØþ§Ï��{7

L?1çI��8ØçI§½´��{ƽ{5�r�55½?1çI§K�¥I

(J�§¥IÃ�§�¯<\¾�ÜÓÃ�"Ó�§�¯<u2009c9�28F\¾Ü

Ó¥§�½ü��OC�od32000�±S�ØO¤^§d�óü AÃ^��ó¶

ü�C�¤^32000�±þ�§U�2008½���AO~§Ì�á�d�±`�Ó

�Ï�@dü�O§½ØÎܽ|�´¥/�dk�0�K§Ï��OC�=ÜÓ

I�ÔC�§I?<´muû"

1n§çI<%N�óü A|�GÏÝI§�ɵI(JÚ�óü A¥I

Øþ§�Á1çI<�ÌNI?§Ï�{�¯�"��uy§�óü A�Ù¦o

[ÝI<�ÝI©��3õ?É~��§�²w�GÏ1�§�çI<��{Á1

Ù�I ´�ÉÝI<�GÏÝI(J§��{ÆB�55½"

1o§muûu2009c12�8F��óü A\¾ÜÓ�§vkuy�óü A�

¿�pÝI�d1305.00��§�¦�ÜÓ\¾I?§ù�´E¤ÜÓd±�Æ�

Ì��Ï"�,§¯��åÏ´çI<%N�óü A|�GÏÝI§@�Ù=´

��¤ÜÓ�Y ®"ÏØ�§�YXØ´¯��¢ÝI<m�3GÏÝI§�½

ÜÓÃ��{§�~�¹e§�YÜÓ=�ÜÓ§T´®à½�z��â"

1ʧÜÓÁ1¥§muûØÁ1ÜÓÌ�ÂÖ§UÜÓ�½|G�óü A�

ÜÓd±9ó§(�±§́ T�8Úu�Æ���pÏ"�,§muû�¤±vU

UÜÓ�½Á1ÜÓ±|GÂÖ§́ Ï�T�8ï��3]7"�§�¦�óü 

=]§�¯K�¢�§3u��Ä�ï�§S§é�/�mu½|�Ø�¤�"

�YéçI<�é&3u§�{|�çIæ�5�ÚÁ�§́ éçI<�Ã

��Ð�o"ù�¥§�)µ��{JÑçI�8§¼�I[k'�8"1!ØO½

�YÃY§á¢çI�8�]7½ö]75 ¶�3é½|ø�N�Ä:þ§Uç

I�8A:ÚI�§JÑ¿�Ï�ÚJ`IO§�{|�çIÝI¹Ä¶��{|

�mI§X¢?1mIP¹¶��{|ïµI�¬µI§Á1éµI�¬J�

�µI�wÚí��¥IÿÀ<�(@9"ØI?¶�Á1ÜÓÇ�I?§�{�

¥I<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ¶�UÜÓ�½§Á1ÜÓÂÖ�"�Y¥§muûXJÁ1

þãçI<3çIæ¥�Ä��I§Ø¬k�¡�ÜÓ�Ƨ½´=BkÜÓ

�Ƨ�ج¤�{��û�}��"

Page 285: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 12Ù

çIæµçI<�ÌNI?

**********************************************************************

Õ±�� ��§Õ±õ� Ø�"

— ÜA.�Æ5nI�.ÞÖ.kÌD6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 286: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 275

11!I?µ¬¯ÌN�I?

¬¯I?§�¬¯ÌNéugCÏ��ÜÓ§ØÁ1¬¯ÂÖ½ö�³I[�!

8N�ã�§�³¦<�<�ã�!<��|¤E¤{Æ�J§�{A�«ú�{

ÆI?"ù�¥§¬¯ÌNq¡�¬¯{Æ'XÌN§=¬¯{Æ'X��¯<§©

�ú¬£g,<¤!{<Ú�{<|�"Ù¥§�l±�±þ�ú¬§äk��¬¯

1�Uå§�±Õá?1¬¯¹Ä�§́ ��¬¯1�Uå<¶�8±�±þØ÷

�l±��ú¬§�±gC�NÄÂ\�Ì�)¹5 �§À���¬¯1�Uå

<"{<´äk¬¯�|UåÚ¬¯1�Uå§�{Õá�k¬¯�|Ú«ú¬¯

ÂÖ�|�§�)E|{<!�E|{<ÚAO{<"�{<|����«|�/

ª§0ug,<Ú{<�m§�{<|�´Øäk{<]�§�´U�{±gC

�¶Âl¯¬¯¹Ä�|�§�)�<Õ]è�!ܺè�!Øäk{<]��;

�ÑÖÅ��"¬¯{Æ'X¥§�{�k�|���¡��|ÌN§«úÂÖ�

��¡�ÂÖÌN"5¿§ÜÓ'X¥�¬¯ÌN§Q´�|ÌN§�´ÂÖÌN"

le¡ùKÏ÷� räþÁ r§P<Ø&Oá�kY¥§�±wѧ��

¬¯ÌN�P<Ú~�¬3�"!�"Ú2"¥é¬¯ÌNI?@£þ�Cz"

[P<þäÁrOkY],½�«��3A?ì~µ«S�^à��ü�«50õ

� rä" räØp§Ø�<¬hg�÷æÁ§~�¬õg!�§�ÎÃ�J"̄

u��´ r¤Ù�G!§2017c5�18F��§� cCs`�~¬±,hg÷þ

µ«à>�� räÁ r§duä{ Dä�§��±,läþOá§;:x

��?1£�§Ã�k�"¯�§±,�A fårµ«+�¬§=~�¬wþ{

̧F¡±,�k�E¤90���²L��§�¦~�¬«ú70%§=63��"nd

´§Tµ«��I[3A?Àiµ«§3à�ü�«�� rä´u�÷§�zc�

� r¤Ù�S§~k*µ<�÷ rä!æÁäþ� r§ ~�¬�æ�S

�ºx����§k�+nI?§I�é±,�k�«úI?"

TY²�"!�""n§@½±,Ú~�¬ÑkI?"@�±,������

¬¯1�Uå<§�²Ó¿hgþäæÁ r§A�UýOÙ�x�J§A�é

g��³«ú95%�I?¶�ûµ«+�¬=~�¬�w�±,÷ räk�x§

L«ú5%�I?§���w²L��4.5��"

Y�\��§Q3�¬þÚu9Æ"Y�¥��²w�¯¢´§±,�1�3

Page 287: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

276 çIæÛYFn

5�þáuÜ�~¬8Nã�§/\Ü·�ÀÜOk§·vé\�·�JfÚäÒ

Ø�§\No�kndV¢·�)aº0�4<Ø)�´§�¯{�¾�û~�¬

+n�I§\�Ù���w4.5��§Ï��¬þù«�º�í"

éY��"!�"�û��Ƨ3u±,cCs`§������¬¯1�U

å<§�´he÷þ räÜÁ rá/�k§́ Ä�±rI?8(� rä��

Ø(¢½´~�¬vé±,�S�´«º�,ØU���äk��¬¯1�Uå�

<�±Õá?1?Û¬¯¹Ä§é�J«ú¬¯I?§A��l�¬1�5�§A

�¿£�þäÁ r´�«Ü�8Nã��1�§éÙ�Upu����J«úI

? Ø´rI?8Ñu räØ(¢½´~�¬�éÙ�S�´«"

-<!¤�´§2020cЧT½¥?<¬{�2"���"�û§�û~�

¬���S��æÂÖ§ØA«ú��I?§�£8�¬�ú²�Âå�Ak�

r?�^"2"{�@�§~�¬��µ«�+n<§�kÂÖ�æi��;�³§

�A�uµ«+nÚ��Uå���S"~�¬¿��~¬½i�Jø�¤æÁ

r�¹Ä§±,��äk��¬¯1�Uå�<§A�Uý��÷ rä§æÁ

r��x5"T~~5¬�þ§²©5½~¬�gú�o8Nã�Ú|ç�)

ú���ÚÉzä7�"±,hgþäæÁ r�1�§��~5¬�§�³

8N|Ã"2"{�@�§±,Ïhg÷äæÁ rOáL�§�J�,-<ÛJ§

�Ù1���~5¬�ÚúSû�§~�¬¿���S��æÂÖ§ØA«ú�

�I?"�d§2"{�@�§�"�û@½¯¢�Ù§�·^{Æ�ا?n(J

Ø�§A�±��"2"Ò£±,få�¦~�¬«ú��I?��¦"

1.¬¯{Æ1�"¬¯{Æ1�§́ ú¬½ö{<�á!C�!ª�¬¯�|

Ú¬¯ÂÖ�Ü{1�"¬¯{Æ1�A�ä�µ�1�<äk�A�¬¯1�U

å¶�¿gL«ý¢¶�Ø��{Æ!1�{5�r�55½§Ø��úSû�"~

X§P<þäÁrOkY¥§P<÷þ räÁr´�«¬¯1�§�´�«��

~5¬�1�5��1�"

¬¯1�©�¬¯{Æ1�!Ã�¬¯1�!���¬¯1�Ú�å�½�¬

¯1��"ùp§Ã��¬¯1�l1�m©åÒvk{Æ�åå§�)µ�ì

¯1�Uå<¢��½´��¬¯1�Uå<�{ØUÕá¢��Ã�¶�1�<

��é<±Jb�¿gL«¢��¬¯{Æ1�Ã�¶���{Æ!1�{5�r

�55½�¬¯{Æ1�Ã�½´��úSû��¬¯{Æ1�Ã�¶�1�<�

�é<�¿Gϧ�³¦<Ü{�Ã�¬¯{Æ1�Ã���/¶����¬¯1

�§�)µ�Äu­�Ø)¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶���±ÐÀÃ㧦é�3�

�ý¢¿g��¹e¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶�1n<¢�ÐÀ1�§¦��3��

Page 288: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 277

ý¢¿g��¹e¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶���½ö1n<±�½Ã㧦é�3

��ý¢¿g��¹e¢��¬¯{Æ1�¶���|^é�?u�(G�!"y

�äUå��/§�¦¬¯{Æ1�¤á�w�ú²�"

¬¯{Æ1�3/ªþ§�±æ^Ö¡/ª!�Þ/ª½öÙ¦/ª§{Æ!

1�{55½½ö�¯<�½æ^A½/ª�§A�æ^A½/ª"5¬{;6ÜÓ

?1oz8�Ê^éÖ¡/ª²(5½§Ö¡/ª´�ÜÓÖ!&�!>�!>D!

Dý��±k//Ly¤1SN�/ª"±>fêâ��!>fe���ªUk

//Ly¤1SN,¿�±��N��^�êâ>©,À�Ö¡/ª"Ó�§3ÜÓ

?1ozÔ��^5½ÜÓ¾á�ª§=�¯<¾áÜÓ§æ���!«ì�ª

½öÙ¦�ª"Ù¥§��´F"Ú¦<¾áÜÓ�¿gL«§T¿gL«A�Î

Üe�5½µ�SNäN(½¶�L²²É��<«ì§��<=ÉT¿gL«�

å"éA�§«ì´É��<Ó¿���¿gL«"

¬¯ÌNl¯¬¯{Æ1�§�{�k{Æ5½�¬¯�|§X¶��!Ô�!

Å��"ùp§Ô�§��|<�{éA½�Ô�k��|�Úü¦��|§�)

¤k�!̂ ÃÔ�Úú�Ô�¶Å�§��{¤á�ÜÓ§ÜÓ�¯<ÏÜÓ!��

1�!ÃÏ+n!Ø��|±9{Æ�Ù¦5½§�|<�¦A½ÂÖ<�½öØ

��½1���|"¬¯ÌN«ú¬¯I?��ªÌ�kµ�Ê��³¶�üØ�

N¶��Ø�x¶���ã�¶�¡E�G¶�?n!­�!��¶�UYÁ1¶�

����¶�|G��7¶��ØK�!¡E¶�¶11©�r�k�§{Æ5½¨v5���§�ìÙ5½"

2.çIÝI{Æ1�"çIÝI´�«¬¯{Æ1�§çI<ÚÝI<�{�

k¬¯�|§�{A«ú¬¯ÂÖ"Ù¥§çI<��¬¯ÌN§́ �{JÑçI

�8!?1çI�{<½öÙ¦|�§́ �{«úçIæ(J�I?ÌN¶ÝI

<´�AçI!ë\ÝI¿��{<!Ù¦|�½ög,<"

çI<�{Æ1�§Ly3µ��{JÑçI�8§¼�I[k'�8"1!Ø

O½�YÃY§á¢çI�8�]7½ö]75 ¶�3é½|ø�N�Ä:þ§

UçI�8A:ÚI�JÑ¿�Ï�ÚJ`IO§�Å5çIÝI{61�8^!

1�Ô^!1�Ê^!1��^!1��n^!1��o^!1��Ô^!1��Ê

^!1n�Ê^5½§�{|�çIÝI¹Ä¶��Å5çIÝI{61n�o^!

1n�Ê^Ú1n�8^5½§�{|�mI¿X¢P¹mI¶��Å5çIÝI

{61n�Ô^!1n�l^!1n�Ê^!1o�^!1o��^!1o��^!

1o�o^5½§�{|ïµI�¬µI§éµI�¬J��µI�wÚí�

�¥IÿÀ<�(@9"ØI?¶��Å5çIÝI{61o�n^!1o�Ê^!

Page 289: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

278 çIæÛYFn

1o�8^5½§Á1ÜÓÇ�I?§�{�¥I<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ¶�UÜÓ�½§

Á1ÜÓÂÖ§¢yæ(J"

ÝI<�{Æ1�§Ly3µ�UçIúw½ÝI��Ö1²�^�§¼�ç

I©�¶�UçI©���¦?�ÝI©�§éçI©�JÑ�¢�5�¦Ú^�

�Ñ�A¶�3çI©��¦J�ÝI©�����mc§òÝI©�x�ÝI/

:¶�ë�mI§UçI©���¦u�ÝI©��µ�¹§3mIP¹þ\i(

@¶�AµI�¬�¦§éÝI©�¥¹Âز(�SN�7��©�½ö`²¶

��É¥I§�{�çI<\¾Ö¡ÜÓ¶�UÜÓ�½Á1ÂÖ§�¤¥I�8"

3.ÌNI?ØU=£"çI<�{JÑçI�8!?1çI§éçIæL§

Ú(J�{«ú{ÆI?"@o§çI<�ù�ÌNI?UÄ=£§~X§æ^�

÷�n��ª=d�n<«úQº�Y´Ä½��¬¯{Æ1��±ÏL�n<¢

�§���n<�ÌNI?ØÏ�÷�n ��"5¬{;6oK?1�z8��^

5½§�n<3�n��S§±��n<¶Â¢��¬¯{Æ1�§é��n<u

)�å§d��n<�{«ú¬¯{Æ1��I?"Ø��n<ØÁ1½Ø��Á

1�I§½ö��é<�¿GÏE¤��n<�³�§�n<«ú¬¯I?"~X§

3P<þäÁrOkY¥§é{��û(J��1<´�wÚ�w§=±,�få

Ú~�¬§ Ø´V�­��FoÆ�"

¢�¥§²~kçI<�<±�÷�n�``§~X§±/Xç�Iºç

I�nÅ�ç�§·ØöXµ�IºµI;[µ�§·vë\"çI(JØЧ�

·k�o'X0í�ÙçIæ�ÌNI?"ù«``3{nþ´Ø¤á�"Äk§

/̀ØÃ0Ø´nd§l¯çIæ§éçIæ�5KÒATçÏ�´����

¬¯1�Uå<¶Ùg§/�÷0́ çI<gC?1�¬¯{Æ1���÷§çI�

nÅ�3çI<�÷���S�nçI¯¨§�n(JéçI<u)�å§dçI

<«ú�n(J§Ø�çI<uyçI�nÅ�vk�{Á1�n�I§½´�Ý

I<GÏ�³çI<�Ü{�ö1n§µI�¬´çI<�{|ï�§Ù�

L�´çI<éÝIµ"!'�ÚJ`"ù��¡Ly3§µI�¬¥�çI<

�L§�L�´çI<ë�µI¶,��¡§µI´UçI<3çI©�¥5½�

µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©��µ"Ú'�§µI(J�L�´çI<J`"çI

æ<����¬¯1�Uå<§A��ɵI(J§Ø�´uyµI¥�3

�{1�§K�µI(J ­#|�µI"

[�£I] çIÝI¹Ä¥�g,<þ���¬¯1�Uå<"5¬{;6oK

?1�zo�o^5½§Ã¬¯1�Uå<¢��¬¯{Æ1�Ã�"ùp�ì

¯1�Uå<§�Ø÷l±���¤c<§½öl±�±þ�ØUE@gC1��

Page 290: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 279

¤c<§X° ¾<�"

12!(JµçI<�æI?

çIÝI§́ Ö¡5��«¿��ª"çI�8küaµ�a´�ì{Æ5½

?1çI§,�a´çI<g�?1çI"¢Sþ§çI���«|�½|¿�

��ª§��æ�8��o�çI§�õ�´Ï�æ�8�A:ÚI¦·Üç

I§çI<ÏLçI�±`z] ��§̀ zÔÑÙÛ"çIæ´35��ã|

�ÝI¿�§̀ :Ny3§S5�ÚL§î>§�éÙ¦æ�ªß²Ú�&Ýp"

���Ï�Ù§S5�ÚL§î>§çIæ35�/ªþ§́ u4<Ø)�/ª

'm�­�§��éçIæÔÑ�¦�n) ´Û�½�&u/ªü§�Ñæ

m�´¢yæ(J"ù�:§cÙLy3éçIÝI{Æ�æ(J'Xn)

þ�¹·§���<�/ª /ª§±çIÝI/ª��çIæ(J§¦ç

I<|�ÝI¿��m�½´Ø%I?��ò�§�¦`³�Ø�Ak�u�§ù

´��-<Û%�¯"¢Sþ§çIæ�m�½Ø%I?´`z¢yçIæ(

J§éA�§çIÝI{Æ�m�´�5�çIÝI¹Ä§Ø´�çIÝI/ªá

{§�,�Ø´�çI<í�I?§Ï�çI<�ÌNI?ØU=£"

[ËAUE��¯] 2013c5�§��,���Ik]7Ý]�o(,?Ê(Ë

AC?UE�8§V�Ý]6000��§Oyu2014c6�.eó§8�16F­#m�"

TËAUE�8��O!in!�óÚá�!��æ3½ú�] �´¥%?1

çI§ËA�Ì�,�.Ikè�§Tè��÷ÙÔ�¥%KITËA,?UE"

T¥%²L|�Nï§éËAUEJÑõUI¦§3ÛçIÅ�¥¥�ÅÄ�

�[çIÅ��nËAC?UE�8§dTçIÅ�3½ú�] �´¥%ï��

>fçIÝI�´XÚþuÙçIúw!u�çI©�!�ÂÝI©�!3�|�

mI!|�µI!(½¥I(J!\¾ÜÓ�¯�"¥%�¦çIÅ�U$d`k

�K(½¥Iü §�)µ�æ^nܵ©{(½�O!inü Ú�óü ¶�

æ^�$ÝId{(½C»á�Ú¤¬!�¤¬¶���ÛÌ++�3mI¬þ�

`¶�d½ú�] �´¥%;[¥�ÅÄ��µI;[|¤µI�¬§¥%Ø

��Lë\µI"Ó�§��Ûi¿�<ë�µIiÒ¶�(½µI�¬í�

�1�¥IÿÀ<¥I§�Ù\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"duT�8�O!in!�óÚá�!

���çIÝI¹Ä3>fçIÝI�´²�þ|�§L§þÎÜ{Æ5½"

�8ï�L§¥Ñn�¯µ�´Ûk'?¿Jѧn�êe!�¬eC»�

g�$§I��Oü ­#?1êe!�¬e�O"d�§n�êe!�¬e/¡!

Page 291: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

280 çIæÛYFn

p¡Úº&®�¤¶�´�óü ��S�)�§S§in<Õ�vuy§��

�ïÓÄ�Ü©¢�¨¥§�ü<­ú�S�¯�§½ï�Û�¦�8Êó���

�U"Ó�§��,�O�Y®ØU¢�§I­#?1�,�O¶n´¥%|�çI

Å�æ�ËAC»�!�»�§2013c10�-12�SC§32014c3�uy�Ü©

�L�m�!C/î­§I Ø�­#¾À!�ó­�§E¤��²L��1800�

{�§óÏòØ5��"

T�8u2014c11�5F|����§½��Ì+Ü�éËA����u�

�§uy�»�4ÜØÎÜ5��¦§vUÏL�§�¦é¤k�»�NÁÜ��

21|����Â"�d§�óü NÁ¤k�»�"Ù¥§���!���>F

m!¢Fm�»�C/î­§¥%�¦�û­#Jøü»�»�§u2014c11�

.ÏL���Â"T�8u2014 c12�15FÏLeó�§2015c2�15F­#E

�"E��Ø��c§�Ln©�����Y9Þ%¦Yy�î­§X/nÃ0�

¬§I�­#¾��Y9Þ§|���"

TËA�ÐOyÝ]6000��?1,?UE§ï�L§¥Ï�óÚçI<C»

�!�»�æ�¯�§UC�O�Y!JpC»IO!��?nC»�!�»�

�§E¤��²L��2000õ��§ËA��cE��ÐÚ����§=����

�1200{��"

��5¿�´§TUE�8��O!in!�óÚá�!��æ5�ÎÜ5ç

IÝI{65½�§S§çI<±�´/çIÅ�çI!µI;[µI0§Øë�!

Ø0\Ò�±í�I?!ØúI?§±�çIÝI§SÜ5Ò/�¯�30§ù´�

«��A��g�"���§çI<�ÌNI?ØU=£"~X§3ùKËAUE

��¯¥§Ùæ(J§=,?UE��ËA!ò´�cE�Ú,?UE¥�²L

���(J§�Udù[ËA�¤kö«ú§ù�´çI<3çI楫ú�Ì

�I?§=çIæ(J"ùK�¯Ó���2<�g¢§çI<«ú�æI?

k=A�¡Qº��/§�)æý�!æI¦!æJ`ÚÁ���¡§¿²d

æ�1��Ø u�"

1.æý�"æý�´çIæ�]7�y§Ù?�ÌN´çI<§́ çI

<Uæ�8I¦?��æ�8]7�±Oy"æý�A���¬²LuÐY

²�·A§�çI<uÐÚÔÑÙÛ���"æý��)æI¦!æ]75

!êþ!.Ò!üd!æ�8å©Ú���m�"�d§çI<Aéæ�8�

½|ø�!d�ÚÑÖ��¹?1N�§�âü �U!½k!½I¦Ú]��

�!ï�IO��Æ!Ün?�æý�§²çI<�ûüÅ�1O"UìI[k

'5½§çI�89Ù]7I�Á1�8"1!ØO½�YÃY�§çI<AUã

Page 292: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 281

�Ü��ý�?�+n�{?�æý�"

éý�?�§5¥u<¬�ÚIý�{61��Ê^5½§IÖ�ã�Ü�ä

N?�¥ý�§|�¥Ú/�ý���1§JÑ¥ý�ý�¤Ä^�Y§½

Ï�IÖ��w¥Ú/�ý���1�¹"1��8^5½§�Ü�?��Ü�

ý�§|�ÚiÒ�Ü�ý���1§½Ï��?�?ã�Ü��wý���1�

¹"�ü ?��ü ý�§UìI[5½Süý�|ѧ¿�ÉI[k'Ü��

iÒ"

æý�áu¥ý��Æ�§d�I<¬�L�¬"�Ú1O§áu/��

?ý��Æ�§d�?<¬�L�¬"�Ú1O"ý�{5½§IÖ�ã�Ü�A

�3zc�I<¬�L�¬¬ÆÞ1�o�ÊFc§ò¥ý�úY�ÐÚ�YJ

��I<¬�L�¬ã�²L�¬?1ÐÚ"�¶IÖ���I<¬�L�¬�

'u¥Ú/�ý�úY±9¥Ú/�ý��1�¹��w"

�I<¬�L�¬Ú/��?<¬�L�¬éý�úY9Ù�w!ý��1�

¹­:"�e�SNµ�þ�cý��1�¹´ÄÎÜ�?<¬�L�¬ý�ûÆ

��¦¶�ý�Sü´ÄÎÜý�{�5½¶�ý�Sü´Ä0�I¬²LÚ�¬

uÐ����ü§Â|�ü´Ä�¢�1¶�­:|ÑÚ­�Ý]�8�ý�Sü

´Ä·�¶�ý��?�´Ä��§́ ÄÎÜ�{1o�8^�5½¶�ée?�

?�=£5|Ñý�´Ä5�!·�¶�ý�SüÞ/�ÅÖ´ÄÜ{!Ün§́ Ä

k��OyÚ­½���]75 ¶��ý�k'­�¯��`²´Ä�ß�"5

½<¬�L�¬ã�²L�¬�<¬�L�¬ÌRìÑä"�(J�w"æý

�²�?<¬�L�¬1O�§ã�Ü�A�3��FS��Ü�1Eý�"�Ü

�A�3��ã�Ü�1E��Ü�ý���ÊFS�¤á�ü 1Eý�"çI

<�¤çI�8æý�?�!1EÚ�±ó�§�±¢�çIÝI|�ó�"

2.æI¦"æI¦´çI�8õU9ÙL÷v�^�.½"çI<A�?

1½|N�§é[çI�8I¢y�õU§L�Å�I[!1�!/��'IO!5

�!5§§�þ!S�!Eâ5�!ÔnA5�¦§æêþ!�G½¢��mÚ/

:§�ÂIO±9Ù¦Eâ�¦§]���IO��Æ!Ün/O((½"7��§

��k';[ë�åú!Øy"

£1¤ó§ï��8"çI<IÜn(½ó§õU!ï�SN!ï�5�Úï�

IO§?��8ïÆÖ!�15ïÄ�w½�8���w§UI[Ý]�8"1�

ÝÁ1�8"1!ØO½�YÃY�§|�t!�O!�ó!in±9�ó§ï�

k'�­���!á���çI"

1¤ó§t"ó§t�æI¦§��A�)�8V¹!t��9SN!

Page 293: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

282 çIæÛYFn

t�â!Ä:]�!t<Ú���¦!Ì�ÜÓ^±�§±9I[!1�!�

8¤3/IO!5�Ú5§§t¤J©���Ý!�ª!1N!°ê��¦§Jø

tÄ:]�ÚJøt¦^���!��±9Ù¦B|^��"

2¤ó§�O"ó§�O�æI¦§��A�)�8V¹!�O��9SN!

�O�â!�8¦^õU��¦!�O<�¦!Ì�ÜÓ^±�§±9I[!1

�!�8¤3/IO!5�Ú5§§�O¤J©���Ý!�ª!1N!°ê§±9

�O¤JÐ�!�.!â�!Äx��¦§Jø��8ÄO:!ÄO�ÚÄOIp!

ó§t�w!/e+�!+�]�!��ïÓÔÚ�ÓÔ!/eó§�k'�©

]�§±9Ù¦�ï�ó§k'��©]�ÚJø�O¦^���!��±9Ù¦

B|^��"

3¤ó§in"ó§in�æI¦§��A�)�8V¹!in��9SN!

in�â!in<ÚÁ�uÿ¤ì���¦!Ì�ÜÓ^±�§±9I[!1�!

�8¤3/IO!5�Ú5§§in¤J©���Ý!�ª!1N!°ê��¦§�

8ÄO:!ÄO�ÚÄOIp!ó§t�w!�O©�§�ó|/9��ïÓÔ

Ú�ÓÔ!/eó§�/e+��©]�!í�!Y©*ÿ]�ÚJøin¦^�

��!��±9Ù¦B|^��"

4¤ó§�ó"ó§�ó�æI¦§��A�)I[!1�!�8¤3/ó§

ï�IO!5�Ú5§!�85y^�!ã�8¹!ã�!��Ú�¦!�'¯�E

â�¦½`²!Ì�ÜÓ^±�"5¿§ã��çI�8�Eâ�¦§́ ó§�ó

çIæI¦�­�|¤Ü©§ÙO(ÃØ´çI<�ÝI<�{Æ«ì"XJ�

O©��3�Ø!¢¦!¹·!gñ!Ø¿©�?½Ù¦"�§¬�����ó¥I

<��§�{dçI<«ú"

£2¤ÀÔ"ÀÔ§�)ó§��Úá�§±9ó§±���Úá�"��/§

��Úá��æI¦I�²(�¯�Xeµ

1¤��"���æI¦§��A�)�8V¹!øÀ��½æI¦�AL!

Ì�ÜÓ^±§I[!1��EIO§�)ÙÌÅ!9Å!N�9"��!;^ó

ä!�¬��!ÀÔEâ5�!ëê��¦§�)Eâ©�!ã�!��ó�^�!

�¸�¦�§��SCNÁ9EâÑÖ�¦§���E�9�Ô�¦§���C!

I£9�¦§��$Ñ�ª!�{§��æ�|¤Ú�ÂIO!9È�ÑÖ§±Ù¦

I�`²�¯��"

2¤á�"á��æI¦§��A�)�8V¹!øÀ��½æI¦�AL!

Ì�ÜÓ^±§I[!1�á�IO§á�Eâ5U!�I��¦§á��C!I

£!$Ñ�ª!�{§á�æ�|¤Ú�ÂIO!�{§±Ù¦I�`²�¯��"

Page 294: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 283

£3¤ÑÖ"ÑÖ�æI¦§���)ÑÖI¢y�õU½ö8I§I�1�

I[!1�!/�IO½öÙ¦IO!5�!5§§I÷v��þ!S�!Eâ!¦

^��¦§¢���mÚ/:§ÑÖÏ�!�Ç��ÂIO§±9Ù¦ÑÖ�¦�"

3.æJ`"æJ`´çIæÔÑ��¦§́ æ�²Lm�"Ù��:

3uu�½|3] ��¥û½5�^§²d½|¿�Å�J`ÀJ§? Jpæ

]7�¦^�ç�y�8�þ"5çIÝI{61l^òæJ`�D�çI

<§5½çI<´��{JÑçI�8§?1çI�{<½Ù¦|�§́ çI�8

�æ5K��¾ö§=çI<�{(½æ�ª§�{(½J`5K§�{|�

çIÝI¹Ä§�{(½¥I(J§�¥I<\¾ÜÓ§�{Á1ÜÓÂÖ§¢y

çIæ�8�"

5¿§çIÝIáu�g��!�g«ì��´�ª§=/��d0"¢Sþ§

çIÝI´����g��!�g«ì�Ö¡¿�5��ª"ù�:�±d©Û~

���g5�çI5��ª§=¿�5!�!¿�5�û!ÎdæÚü�5

�Ñ"Ù¥§¿�5!�Ú¿�5�û¥�!��!§¢Sþ´3²(æ�8�

EâIOÚ�¦§=�øAûÒEâIOÚ�¦?1!�§²(��çIÝI��§

�¦øAû�g5�AÚë�¿�¶Îdæ´�g5d�J`��{§=±d�

����J`üSÏ�§ØUüÕw��«æ�ª¶ü�5 æ��ÒØ´¿

�5æ"

5çIÝI{61o��^5½¥I<�ÝIAÎÜe�^���µ�´U

���Ý/÷vçI©�¥5½���nܵdIO¶�´U÷vçI©��¢

�5�¦§¿�²µ"�ÝId��$¶�´ÝId�$u¤��Ø"ùp5½

�(½¥I<�^�§1�«¡�nܵ�{§1�«¡�²µ"��$ÝId{"

ùp§ÃØ /́���Ý�÷v0� /́²µ"�ÝId��$0Ñ´�«²LJ`§

Ù¢�3u�âçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI(J?1J`ÀJ"

1¤nܵ�{"çI<æ^nܵ�{�Ø%§3u(½���Ý/÷vç

I©�¥5½���nܵdIO��{§=nÜüSÏ�ÚüS�{§�14Ù

14!Ú16Ù13!?Ø�J`�Ó§ù´nܵ�{�¢�§¿Ø�Óu¢�¥

�nܵ©{"T�{J¦µ"Ï��nÜ�`§3êÆþ�Óuõ8I`z¯K§

¿vk�«Ð�¦)�{§Ø��AÏ�/"¢�¥§nܵ�{�<�{z�

nܵ©{§=�¦µI�¬é÷vçI©�¢�5�¦�ÝI©�§Uìç

I©�¥5½�µ©IOO�ÝI<�ÝI�d!ûÖÜ©!EâÜ©Ú٦ܩ

®o�©§UÝI<���©dp�$�gS(½¥I<��{§¢Sþ´b�µ

I�¬¤;���Ú������§éÝI<ÝI(JüS�@Ó��" ù

Page 295: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

284 çIæÛYFn

�b�w,´Ø¤á�§Ï�µI�¬¤m�3�N�ɧéJ¢y¤kµI

�¬¤éÝI(J�`�üS@Ó��"�d§ù«�{ØUw�´²LÆ¿

Âþ�J`½=´�«Cq¿Âþ�J`§Ù¢�E´3A^�*²LÆ¥�Äê

�^b�§ Ø´Sê�^b�"

2¤²µ"��$ÝId{"²µ"��$ÝId{�8\nܵ�{§ùp�

ØL´r²µ"�ÝId��nܵ�{¥�üSÏ�"çI<æ^²µ"��$

ÝId{�cJ§́ �ÆÜn/(½çI�8¢�5�¦Ú^���$IO§±9

EâÚûÖ l�òdIO§ù´­.Õ1�IS7K|�æ^�µI�{"­.

Õ1æOK¥§ISçIÚIS¿�5çIæ^�µI�{��$µId{"T

�{5½§µI´3(½z�ÝIé/±<�)�¤��Ä:þ§é�ÝI<�µ

Id�?1'�§ÜÓATÇ�äk�$µId�Ø�½´�d�$�ÝI"'u

òdÏ�§T�{5½§çI©�A²(5½3µI¥I��Ä�¤kd�ò�Ï

�§±9N�$^ùÏ�(½ÝI�µId"7��§æ<A?1²Lÿ�±

(½�òdÏ�éA�ò�d�§�)ÙûÖ!Eâ �� l"~X§éu��

æ§T�{~Þ�ûÖòdÏ��)Sº$¤Ú�x¤!G±�m!�ÀÏ!$

E¤�!È�ÑÖ!�'�Ô�§EâµdÏ��)���Ç!��@5!"��!

S�5Ú�¸�Ã�§́ �«nÜÝI�d!ûÖÚEâ l¿±d�Ï���ë

ìÔ§J`(½¥I(J��{"

4.ÜÓÁ�"Á�¥�/�0́ çI<�¥I<�{\¾�ÜÓ§́ çI�8

d/J0�/¢0�¢�L§§�´éçIÝI�1�u�"ÜÓÁ�A�̪¢&

^�K,�âÜÓ�5�!8�Ú�´S.Á1ÜÓÂÖ"

1¤ÜÓ��"¥I<A�UìÜÓ�½�ÜÓ���¤¥I�8§çI<UÜ

Ó�½?1d±|G"5¿§¥I<Ø��¦<=4¥I�8§�Ø�ò¥I�8

�)�©O�¦<=4"UìÜÓ�½½ö²çI<Ó¿§¥I<�±ò¥I�8

�Ü©�ÌN!�'�5ó�©��¦<�¤§d¥I<Ò©��8�çI<KI§

�É©��<Ò©��8«úë�I?"

2¤Á�Ï�"Á�´UÜÓ�½�Ï�Á�§Ø%3uçI©�¥Ak²(�

Á�Ï��¦§�)Á�m©�m"Á�Ï�����çI©��¢�5�¦Ú^

�§¥I<�ÝI©�A÷vçI©�5½�Á�Ï�"l §çI<Ú¥I<\

¾�ÜÓ¥A�)Á�Ï��¦"çI<I�UÜÓ�½�Á�Ï�Ú'�!:§

é¥I<�Á�?Ý?1+n"

3¤Á��þ"Á�´UÜÓ�½��þIOÚ�¦?1Á�"ùp§�þIO

Ú�¦kn��?§�´I[!1��Ù�r�5�þIOÚ�¦¶�´I[!1

Page 296: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 285

��Ù�í�5�þIOÚ�¦¶n´ÜÓ�½��þIOÚ�¦"çI<éÁ�

�þ+n�Ø%§3uUìI[!1��Ù�r�5�þIOÚ�¦!ÜÓ�½�

þIOÚ�¦é¥I<�Á�(J?1�§�)¥m�Â"

4¤Ø�|å"Ø�|å´�çI<Ú¥I<3¾áÜÓ�Ø�ý�§3Á�L

§¥Ø�;�u)¿ØU�Ñ�g,/³Ú�¬5âu¯�§X/�!°�!¦¼!

Y/!ÖÏ!�Ä!Ô�Ú;^ÜÓ^±�½�Ù¦�/"u)Ø�|å�§çI<

Ú¥I<A9�Â8Ø�|åE¤���y⧫ú�g�Ø�|å��§�çI

�8E¤�1nö<ú�Úã����§��dçI<«ú"7��§ÏØ�|

åE¤ØUÁ��§V��±�û��)ØÜÓ"

5¤�Æ)û"çI<Ú¥I<Á��Æ�Ø%3uÜÓd±�ƧåÏLy3

V�éÜÓ��!Á�Ï�Ú�þ´ÄÎÜÜÓ�½§3@£þØ��"ÜÓÁ1

¥u)�Æ�§çI<Ú¥I<�±lÐ�û)û"�û)ûؤ�§�3ÜÓ¥

�½æ^®à½ö�z)û"5¿§®à��z�UÀJÙ���ÜÓ�Æ�)û

�ª"Ù¥§®à7Lk®à�Ƨ�1/�àªÛ0¶�z´�k+`��<¬{

�å�§�1/ü"ª"0"

13!1�µçI<�{ÆI?

çI<�{ÆI?§́ �5çIÝI{69�'{Æ!5çIÝI{¢�^~6

9IÖ��'1�{5!/�5{5ÚÜ�5Ù�5½�çI<{ÆI?§́ çI

<|�çIÝI¹Ä7L�Å�{Æ5K"�Å{Æ5K§́ çI<��¬¯ÌN

?1çI§=`z¢yçI�87LÁ1���{ÆÂÖ"��§çI<|�çI

ÝI¹ÄØÁ1{ÆÂÖ§½ö��{Æ5½|�çIÝI¹Ä§ÙÜ{�Ã�Ø

�{Æ�æ§çIæ(JÃ{¢y§½´3�½�²L��e¢y§Ó���É

��½�{Æ�à"e¡ùK�~§=´éçI<�{�ÝI<GÏ!�{¼|É

��-¯?v¯~"

[�{çI��~] 2018c5�20Fþ̧,½<¬u�Jåú��T½,«

�ë,!«ã�ÛNïa,ɪY§ë,!a,!�,��`Ô�úi!¯�'

úiGÏÝIY!̀ Ô�úiÚ¯�'úiü 1ªY?1�"\�§@½�w

<ë,�ɪ�!GÏÝI�§ê�¿v§�1kÏä-13c§¿?v7220��"

�w<a,�ɪ�!GÏÝI�§ê�¿v§�1kÏä-11c§¿?v7170�

�"�w<�,�ü 1ª�!GÏÝI�§ê�¿v§�1kÏä-5c§¿?v

770��"�w`Ô�úi!̄ �'úi�ü 1ª�§��?v7100��"Ó�§

Page 297: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

286 çIæÛYFn

UYJ��w<ë,!a,�{ɪ¤�±"

{�²"n�²§2012c5�§«�?û½d«¢+Û���Ìü §«ã�Û

���ü §ò`«�´y©�8�Iã§æ^çI�ª¢�2013-2015c«¢½�

´�×�'ó�"2012ce�c§�?«���w<ë,�a,!�,ûÆ�û½

öpd�8§¿d�w<�,äNKI|��I�¯§/¤ë,±ÙLxo,¶

Â�`Ô�úi!̄ �'úiÜ�§\ÝÜ��Ƨ�½²EºxU25%:25%:50%'

~�B�y7§U�y7�B'~©ù"2012c11�8F§�w<ë,"½çI©�

�§da,���,$�"�Jp`Ô�úiÚ¯�'úi�¥Iǧa,Uë

,�Ç¿§?UçI©��µ©IO"2013c12�2F!12�15F§̀ Ô�úiÚ

¯�'úi©O¥Iü�Iã!��Iã��´�×�'�8"�8¥I�§�w

<ë,!a,!̀ Ô�úiÚ¯�'úiU�½©OÝ\40��!40��!80�

�Ú24�§��¥IIã��´�×�'�8�y7"2013 c7��2015c§U�

Æ�½'~§�w<ë,Úa,¼��8©ù340��"

2015c5�§2013-2015c«¢½�´�×�'�8ÜÓ=ò�ϧ«�?é

Ä2016-2018c�´�×�'ÑÖçIó�§«�?�â�w<ë,JƧò�5

8�IãÜ¿���IãçI"�w<ë,!a,Ú�,²ûÆ�§û½UYÜ�§

Uë,40%!̀ Ô�úi30%!a,20%!�,10%�'~N�©ù'~"çIÝI

ó�m©�§ë,|^����çI©����a,§a,!�,�Ï`Ô�úi

?UÝI©�,|�A[ÝI<�I"2016c3�17F§`Ô�úi¤õ¥I§¥I

7�5600.00��/c"�w<ë,Úa,©OÝ\120.00��Ú60.00����y7"

��2016c11�§�w<ë,Úa,�¼��8©ù320.00��"

�"{�@�§�w<ë,!a,|^�w<ë,�«��B|§��wü 

`Ô�úi!̄ �'úi*�|ç�ÓÂÉü�wü ���ãÔ�O756.00�

�§Ù1��¤Éª�"�wü `Ô�úi!̄ �'úi�*�Ø��|çÏ

L�w<�,��I[ó�<ãÔ�O96.00��§Ù1��¤ü 1ª�"�w

<�,���wü `Ô�úi!̄ �'úi1ª���I?<§Ù1��¤ü

 1ª�"�w<ë,!a,!�,Ú`Ô�úi!̄ �'úiGÏÝI§�³¦<

�Ü{|çÙ1��¤GÏÝI�"�"{��â��w<���¯¢!5�Ú

�!§±9é�¬��³§Ý�Ñþã�û"

çIÝI5�L�lçIÝI1��å§�$�Ý´�lçIÝI�{Æ�

å"�Y¥§ë,!a,��I[ú�<§�a,Ú`Ô�úi!̄ �'úiGÏ

Ü*§�{|�`«�´�×�'�çIÝI¹Ä§ÙçIæ(J2Ч�çI

ÝI5�L§�{§́ 3^Ü{��ùXÙhe�{�´!¼|�8�§Ù¥I

Page 298: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 287

(JÃ�§�{L�É�{Æ�ৱÚw{Æ�%î"

@o§çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä§k={ÆI?QºçI<|�çIÝI¹

ħL«ú�{ÆI?Xeµ

1.JÑçI�8"�{JÑçI�8§?��8ïÆÖ!�15ïÄ�w½�

8���w§UìI[k'5½Á1�8"1!ØO½�YÃY§��1O£5çI

ÝI{61Ê^¤"Ó�§3þ��15ïÄ�w½�8���w�Ó�§ò�8ç

I��!çI�ª!çI|�/ª�þ��8Ý]"1!ØOÜ�"1ØO£5çI

ÝI{¢�^~61Ô^¤"

2.(½æI¦"UçI�8A:©a?�çI�8æI¦Ö§(½J`Ï

�ÚIO"Ó�§�¾çIó�Oy§�)<©ó!?ÝOyÚ��O�"

{ÆI?µçI<��çIÝI{5½§é7L?1çI��8 ØçI�§

ò7L?1çI��8z��"½ö±Ù¦?Û�ª5;çI�§I-�ÏU�§

�±?�8ÜÓ7�0.5%±þ1%±e�v±¶é�ܽöÜ©¦^Ik]7��

8§�±6Ê�8�1½ö6Ê]7ÃG¶éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��

I?<�{��?©£5çIÝI{61o�Ê^¤¶çI<±ØÜn�^���

½öü½d3ÝI<�§éd3ÝI<¢1ÜÀ���§r��¦ÝI<|¤éÜ

N�ÓÝI�§½ö��ÝI<�m¿��§I-U�§�±?���±þÊ��

±e�v±£5çIÝI{61Ê��^¤"

3.?�çI©�"�âçI�8�A:ÚI�?�]�ý"©�!çI©�"

çI©�A��)çI�8�Eâ�¦!éÝI<]�"��IO!ÝI�d�¦

ÚµIIO�¤k¢�5�¦Ú^�±9[\¾ÜÓ�Ì�^±"I[éçI�8

�Eâ!IOk5½�§çI<A�UìÙ5½3çI©�¥JÑ�A�¦"£5ç

IÝI{61�Ê^¤"çI<é®uÑ�]�ý"©�½çI©�?17��©

�½ö?U��UK�]�ý"��©�½öÝI©�?��§çI<A�3J�

]�ý"��©����m��3Fc§½öÝI���m��15Fc§±Ö¡/

ªÏ�¤k¼�]�ý"©�½çI©��d3ÝI<"Øv3F½ö15F�§ç

I<A�^òJ�]�ý"��©�½öÝI©�����m£5çIÝI{61

��n^!5çIÝI{¢�^~61���^¤"

4.uÙçIúw"3I[�{�½x0þuÙçIúw"çIúwA�1²ç

I<�¶¡Ú/�!çI�8�5�!êþ!¢�/:Ú�m±9¼�çI©��

�{�¯�£5çIÝI{61�8^¤"

5.uÈçI©�" �{uÈçI©�½ö]�ý"©�§ÙuÈÏØ��

Page 299: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

288 çIæÛYFn

u5F"Ó�§]�ý"©�!çI©�Â��¤^A��uÖ�<M!eM�¤�

|ѧØ�±E|�8�£5çIÝI{¢�^~61�8^¤"

6.]�"�"|�]�ý"�§çI<A�ëìµI�¬|ï]�"��

¬§]�"��¬9Ù¤A��ÅçIÝI{9Ù¢�^~k'µI�¬9

Ù¤�5½¶]�"��¬A�Uì]�ý"©�1²�IOÚ�{§"�]

�ý"��©�¶�ÏL]�ý"���<ØäkÝI]�"|�]��"§A�

3mI�dµI�¬UìçI©�5½�IOÚ�{éÝI<�]�?1"�

£5çIÝI{¢�^~61�l^-1��^¤"

7.ÝI©��Â"çI<Â�ÝI©��§A�\Â��§Ø�mé¿X¢P

1ÝI©��x��mÚ�µ�¹§����"é�ÏL]�ý"���<J��

ÝI©�§±9}Ïx�½ö�UçI©��¦�µ�ÝI©�§çI<A�áÂ

£5çIÝI61��l^!5çIÝI{¢�^~61n�8^¤"

{ÆI?µ13�-17��{ÆI?´§ke��/���§dk'1�iÒÜ

�I-U�§�±?10��±e�v±µ��{A�úmçI æ^��çI¶�

çI©�!]�ý"©��uÈ!©�!?U���§½ö(½�J�]�ý"�

�©�!ÝI©����ØÎÜçIÝI{ÚÙ^~5½¶��É�ÏL]�ý"

�ü ½ö�<ë\ÝI¶��ÉA�áÂ�ÝI©�"Ó�§çI<kc±1�

�!1n�!1o�¤�1����§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?

<�{��?©£5çIÝI{¢�^~618�o^¤"

8.��"çI<Ø��¦<ß³®¼�çI©��d3ÝI<¶¡!êþ±9

�UK�ú²¿��k'çIÝI�Ù¦�¹£5çIÝI{61���^¤"

{ÆI?µçI<�¦<ß³®¼�çI©��d3ÝI<�¶¡!êþ½ö

�UK�ú²¿��k'çIÝI�Ù¦�¹�§½ö�³I.�§��´w§�

±¿?���±þ���±e�v±¶éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?

<�{��?©¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"¤�1�K�¥I(J�§¥

IÃ�£5çIÝI{61Ê��^¤"

9.mI"çI<A�UìçI©�5½��m!/:�{|�mI§úÙÝI

<¶¡!ÝId�ÚÝI©��Ù¦Ì�SN§¿��P¹£5çIÝI{61n�

o^1n�8^!5çIÝI{¢�^~61o�o^¤"

10.µI"çI<A��{|ï�µI�¬"ÙµI�¬dçI<�LÚ

k'Eâ!²L��¡�;[|¤§¤<ê�Ê<±þüê§Ù¥Eâ!²L��

¡�;[Ø��u¤oê�n©��"���8A�lµI;[¥S�';��

Page 300: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 289

;[¶ü¥±�ÅÄ��ª(½§AÏ�8²1O�±dçI<��(½"7��§

çI<��µI�¬JøµI¤7I�&E§�Ln©���µI�¬¤@

�µI�mØ�§A·�ò�µI¤I�m£5çIÝI{61n�Ô^!5çI

ÝI{¢�^~61o�8-1o�l^¤"

{ÆI?µ�{7L?1çI��8�çI<ØUì5½|ïµI�¬§½

ö(½!��µI�¬¤��çIÝI{9Ù¢�^~5½�§dk'1�i

ÒÜ�I-U�§�±?10��±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦�

�I?<�{��?©¶�{(½½ö���µI�¬¤�Ñ�µ"(ØÃ

�§�{­#?1µ"£5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ô�^¤"

11.µI(Jú«"çI<A�gÂ�µI�w�Få3FSú«¥IÿÀ<§

ú«ÏØ��u3F"�{?nÝI<ÉƧ�Ük'1�iÒÜ�?nÝ�£5ç

IÝI{¢�^~61Ê�n^¤"

12.(½¥I(J"çI<�âµI�¬JÑ�Ö¡µI�wÚí��Ü�

¥IÿÀ<(½¥I<"Ik]7Ý]Ó��½Ì�/ ��{7L?1çI��

8§çI<A�(½ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<�¥I<"ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<�ï

¥I!ÏØ�|åØUÁ1ÜÓ!ØUçI©��¦J�Á��y7§½ö��¢

�3K�¥I(J��{1���/§ØÎÜ¥I^��§çI<�±UìµI�

¬JÑ�¥IÿÀ<¶üüS�g(½Ù¦¥IÿÀ<�¥I<§��±­#ç

I£5çIÝI{61o�^!5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�Ê^¤"çI<(½¥

I<�§A�ÙuÑ¥IÏ�Ö§¿w�Ù¦�¥I�ÝI<"¥IÿÀ<²E!ã

ÖG¹u)��Cz½ö�3�{1�§çI<@��UK�ÙÁ�Uå�§A�

3uÑ¥IÏ�Öcd�µI�¬UìçI©�5½�IOÚ�{"�(@�§

2�{(½¥I<£5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�8^¤"

{ÆI?µ�{7L?1çI�8§çI<��çIÝI{5½§�ÝI<Ò

ÝId�!ÝI�Y�¢�5SN?1!��§��´w§éü ��KI�Ì+

<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{��?©"T1�K�¥I(J�§¥IÃ�£5çI

ÝI{61Ê�Ê^¤"

13.ÜÓ\¾"çI<UìçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�§�{�¥I<\¾

Ö¡ÜÓ§�k'1�iÒÜ�J�çIÝI�¹�Ö¡�w§9�ò�ÝI�y

7£5çIÝI{61o�8^!1o�Ô^!5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ê�Ô^¤"

{ÆI?µçI<�¥I<ØUìçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾áÜÓ�§

½öçI<!¥I<¾á�lÜÓ¢�5SN��Æ�§I-U�¶�±?¥I�

87�0.5% ±þ1% ±e�v±£5çIÝI{61Ê�Ê^¤"çI<3µI�

Page 301: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

290 çIæÛYFn

¬�{í��¥IÿÀ<±(½¥I<�§�{7L?1çI��83¤kÝI

�µI�¬Äû�g1(½¥I<�§¥IÃ�"I-U�§�±?¥I�87

�0.5%±þ1%±e�v±¶éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{

��?©"çI<ke��/���§dk'1�iÒÜ�I-U�§�±?¥I

�87�1%±e�v±¶�¦<E¤���§�{«ú��I?¶éü ��KI

�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{��?©µ�Ã��ndØuÑ¥IÏ�Ö¶

�ØUì5½(½¥I<¶�¥IÏ�ÖuÑ�Ã��ndUC¥I(J¶�Ã�

�ndØ�¥I<¾áÜÓ¶�3¾áÜÓ��¥I<JÑN\^�£5çIÝI

{¢�^~61Ô�n^¤"

14.ÜÓÁ1"UÜÓ�½§�{Á1ÜÓÂÖ§Ø�ògC�!¥�½öª

�ÜÓ"�¯<A��̪&�K,�âÜÓ�5�!8�Ú�´S.Á1Ï�!�

Ï!���ÂÖ"3Á1ÜÓL§¥, �¯<A�;�L¤] !À/�¸Ú»�

)�"£5çIÝI{61o�l^!5¬{;6ÜÓ?1Êz"Ê^¤"

{ÆI?µ��¯<��ØÁ1ÜÓÂÖ½öÁ1ÜÓÂÖØÎÜ�½�§A

�«úUYÁ1!æ�ÖÍ��½ö�������I?¶��¯<��²(L«

½ö±gC�1�L²ØÁ1ÜÓÂÖ�,é��±3Á1Ï�3÷�c�¦Ù«

ú��I?¶��¯<���|Gd±!�Å!u7!|E,½öØÁ1Ù¦7aÅ

Ö�,é��±�¦Ù|G¶��¯<��ØÁ1�7aÅÖ½öÁ1�7aÅÖ

ØÎÜ�½�,é��±�¦Á1,�{Æþ½ö¯¢þØUÁ1!ÅÖ�I�Ø·

ur�Á1½öÁ1¤^Lp§½´Å�<3ÜnÏ�S��¦Á1�ض��

¯<��ØÁ1ÅÖ½öÁ1ÅÖØÎÜ�½,�âÅÖ�5�Ø�r�Á1�,é

��±�¦ÙKúd1n<O�Á1�¤^¶�Á1ØÎÜ�½�,A�Uì�¯

<��½«ú��I?"é��I?vk�½½ö�½Ø²(,��¯<Ò�þ!d

±½ö�Å!Á1/:�SNvk�½½ö�½Ø²(�,ØU�¤Ö¿�Æ�,U

ìÜÓk'^±!ÜÓ5�!ÜÓ8�½ö�´S.(½,�±ÜnÀJ�¦é�«

ú?n!­�!��!òÀ!~�d±½ö�Å���I?¶��¯<��ØÁ1Ü

ÓÂÖ½öÁ1ÜÓÂÖØÎÜ�½�,3Á1ÂÖ½öæ�ÖÍ���,é��k

Ù¦���,A�����¶��¯<��ØÁ1ÜÓÂÖ½öÁ1ÜÓÂÖØÎ

Ü�½,E¤é����,�����A���uÏ��¤E¤���,�)ÜÓÁ1

��±¼��|ö�´,Ø��L��ÜÓ��¾áÜÓ�ý��½öA�ý�

��Ï��ÜÓ�UE¤���"£5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ÊzÔ�Ô^!1ÊzÔ�

l^!1ÊzÔ�Ê^!1Êzl�^!1Êzl��^!1Êzl��^!1Êz

l�n^!1Êzl�o^¤"

Page 302: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 291

15.�8�Â"çI<A�|�é¥I<Á���Â"�¤A�3�ÂÖ

þ\i§«ú�A�{ÆI?"7��§��I[@���þuÿÅ�ë\�Âó

�"Ù¥§ï�ó§eó�ÂA�ä�e�^�:��¤ï�ó§�OÚÜÓ�½�

��SN;�k���Eâ�YÚ�ó+n]�;�kó§¦^�Ì�ïÓá�!ï

Ó���Ú���?|Á��w; �kt!�O!�ó!ó§in�ü ©O\

Ý��þÜ�©�; �k�óü \Ý�ó§�?Ö"çI�8�ÂÜ��§��

�G¦ £̂5ï�ó§�þ+n^~61�8^¤"

14!�'µÙ¦ë�<ÌNI?

çI<�ÌNI?§��¡I�çI<��çIæ�¬¯ÌN§á¢Ù¬¯

{ÆI?§,��¡§�I�çIÝI¹Ä�Ù¦ë�<§=çI�nÅ�!ÝI

<ÚµI�¬��{ë�½�AâUú²ú�/¢yçIæ(J"ù�¥§ç

I�nÅ�´çI<��÷çIÅ�"3�n��S§çI�nÅ�±çI<¶Â

¢��çI�n1�§éçI<u)�å¶ÝI<3çI©�5½�ÝI���m

c4�ÝI©�§�AçI§ë�ÝI¿��Ly§́ çI�±¢y�cJ¶µI

�¬´dçI<�{|ï�§m�´UçI<�çI¯¢§=çI©�¥5½�

µIIOÚ�{§éÝI<�ÝI¯¢§=ÝI©�?1µ"Ú'����µ��

¬"çIÝI¹Ä¥§çI<£�)çI�nÅ�¤!ÝI<ÚµI�¬Å{�

5´¢yçIæ(J�cJ"��§?Û����{�51�§~X§ÝI<�

GÏÝI1��§Ñ�U��çIæ�}§Ã{J`¢yçIæ(J"

[GÏÝI��~] ,½¥?<¬{��â5¥u<¬�ÚI-{61223^

11±!125^11±5½§u2006c5�16Fé�w<�,!Û,|�½"ì«p

�ú´ÝI<GÏÝIY§�Y7�12000��§?1�"\�§�?�w<�,�

GÏÝI�§�?kÏä-2c§¿?v73��¶�w<Û,�GÏÝI�§�?

kÏä-1c"6��§¿?v72��¶�w<�,!Û,�Ù¦Ô[úiJø��

I¤�O140��§�±v§þ�I¥"

{�²"n�²§2005c7�16F§�w<�,w�,½"ì«p�ú´çIú

w§B±AúiÚBúi�¶ÂïçI©�"32005c7�23F§�w<Û,�

>{��,¿Ï�,�[ÝI<��[�½�ËAû!ÝI¯¨"�,!Û,Ú

Ù¦7[úi�<ûƧÛ,JÆòó§���,¤�L�Aúi!¦¤�L�Bú

iÚCúi5�§û½ùn[úi¥I��z[�Iúi20��§¿�||G�z

[�Iúi10��"ë¬�Ù¦úi�Lë,Úa,QL«�é¿�§�,��=

Page 303: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

292 çIæÛYFn

7,�<±Éå�%�§�ó/XJ¦�Ø�ïÝIÒO�rѬƿ0§ë,Úa

,�½Ó¿�I"1�Uþ̧�,!Û,r�kÝI�d��^x���Iúi§

�¦¦�U�^þ�d�ÝI"mI�§²çI<|�µI�¬µI§ùn[ú

i¤õ¥I§�çI<\¾ÜÓ§ùn[úi�¥Id���~�dpÑ500-800�

�"çI(å�§Tn[úi�z[�Iúi|G{e�10��"

{Ì"n@½�,!Û,���¯¢ke�yây²:�´Ôy"k5²ÝI�

d�7Ü�^§y²�,!Û,�(r�kÝI�d��^��Ô[�Iúi§¿�

¦¦�U�^þ�d�ÝI§kA!B!Cn[úi�ÝI©�§kçI<uÑ�¥

IÏ�Ö�¶�´y<yó"k�Iü 1 Ú�Iü 2�ë,!a,�y²§y²

�,��=7,�<Q±ÉåéÙ�%�§�óXJ¦�Ø�ïÝI§ÒO�rÑ

¬Æ¿§¦��½�ï¿I§y¢�Â��,ÚÛ,�Ó��20��<¬1§k�

,�Ù{5[úiÝI�Ly²§Â�Ld�,ÚÛ,�ÓJø�20��<¬1�

I¤§y²�,��=7,�<(Q±Éå%�Lë,Úa,"

{�@�§�w<�,!Û,§|^²Lp¾�Ã㧿^�kç�¬5��É

åÃã�½¦<Ó¿§�¦<GÏÝI�d§�³I[�Ü{|ç�!î­§�{

�¤GÏÝI���Ó��§�ü<þ´Ì�§7L�{éÙ��1��±¨+"

�o�¬�ú²�Â!�²L+���{1�§´�¬²L�S�k��

æ"ù�GÏÝIY�ûÖþ§vkw«éA!B!Cn[¥Iü �?v§�v

kéÔ[�Iü �?v§ùÑáu,Y?n�¯K"�YéçI<�é&3

u§A!B!Cn[¥I<´3Ù¦Ô[ü �I�/e¥�I§ÙÁ�UåØ�½

´�`§¥Id���~�dpÑ500-800��§�³çI<Ü{�Ã"�d§ç

IÝI¹Ä�ë�<§=çI<£�)çI�nÅ�¤!ÝI<ÚµI�¬¤�

{Á�§́ çI<�{«úÙÌNI?Ø�½"�^�"@o§çIÝI¹Ä�Ù

¦ë�<��¬¯ÌN§qk=¬¯{ÆI?Qº©ÛXeµ

1.çI�nÅ�"çI�nÅ�§́ �¤çI<�÷�n¯�§¢yæ(J

�`��¬¥0|�"5¿§çI�n¢�þ´5�½¿�L§�n ���¿Â

þ�æ�n§Ï�ÙØ�9çI�8Á�"5çIÝI{61��^5½§çI<

k�g1ÀJçI�nÅ�§�÷Ù�nçI¯¨,²(5½?Ûü Ú�<Ø�

±?Û�ª�çI<�½çI�nÅ�"5¿§ù�¥�/k�0Ú/g10§¹Â

´çI<����¬¯ÌN§�÷�ÄdçI<gCû½§Ï�´çI<éçIæ

(J«ú¬¯{ÆI?"

{ÆI?µ5çIÝI{61�Ê^²(5½§çI�nÅ�A�3çI<�÷

���S�nçI¯¨§¿�ÅçIÝI{'uçI<|�çIÝI�5½§=�

Page 304: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 293

Ù13!çI<�{ÆI?¥�13�-113�I?§Ù¥§112�!113�´�Ïç

I<(½¥I(J!�ÏçI<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ"

d§5çIÝI{61Ê�^²(çI�n�{ÆI?§5½çI�nÅ��

�çIÝI{5½§�³A�����çIÝI¹Äk'��¹Ú]��§½ö�

çI<!ÝI<GÏ�³I[|Ã!�¬ú�|ýö¦<Ü{�Ã�§?Ê��

±þ��Ê��±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<?ü

 v±ê�5%±þ10%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿?vÂ�{¤�¶�!î­

�§B�Ù3�c��cS�n�{7L?1çI��8¿�±úw§��dóû

1�+nÅ'L�E��ì¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"5½çI�nÅ�

�¦<E¤���§�{«ú��I?"Ó�§²(¤�çI�n1�K�¥I(

J�§¥IÃ�"

5çIÝI{¢�^~618�Ê^?�Ú²(çI�n�{ÆI?§5½ç

I�nÅ�3¤�n�çI�8¥ÝI!�nÝI½ö�T�8ÝI<Jø\Î

�§�É�÷?�I.�¥0Å�ë\É÷?�I.�8�ÝI½ö�T�8�Ý

I<?�ÝI©�!Jø\Î�§�ìçIÝI{1Ê�^�5½JÄ{ÆI?"

2.ÝI<"ÝI<´á¢çI<¬¯ÌNI?§¢yæ(J`zØ�½"�

�é<§Ù�I´�{�AçI§=UçI<uÑ�çI©�?�¿J�ÝI©�§

éçI©�¥5½�¢�5�¦Ú^��Ñ�A§ë�ÝI¿�"

ÝI<ë�çIÝI¹ÄA�ÎÜI[5½�]�^�½çI©�5½�]

�^�§=µ�äkÕá¾áÜÓ��|¶�äkÁ1ÜÓ�Uå§�);�!Eâ

]�ÚUå§]7!��ÚÙ¦Ô���G¹§+nU姲�!&�Ú�A�l�

<¶�vk?u�I-Ê�§ÝI]����§ã���+!È(§»�G�¶�

3�CncSvk¢�¥IÚî­��9­�ó§�þ¯K¶�I[5½�Ù¦]

�^�"

ÝI<ë�ÝI¿��Ø%3�Ùg�¢å§UìçI<uÑ�çI©�?�

¿J�ÝI©�§�yÙÝI©�ý¢k�§Øæ��{Ãã{¤!ü@Ù¦ÝI

<§Ø�çI<!çI�nÅ�ÚÙ¦ÝI<�¿GϧØ�çI<!çI�nÅ

�!µI�¬9Ù¤1ª½öJøÙ¦Ø��|Ã*�¥I§=�Å5çIÝ

I{69Ù¢�^~¥éÝI<ë�çIÝI¹Ä�VÆ�å"

{ÆI?: ÝI<GÏÝI!áJ�b¢�¥I�{ÆI?Xeµ

5çIÝI{61Ê�n^5½§ÝI<�pGÏÝI½ö�çI<GÏÝI

�§ÝI<±�çI<½öµI�¬¤1ª�Ãã*�¥I�§¥IÃ�§?

¥I�87�0.5%±þ1%±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I

Page 305: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

294 çIæÛYFn

?<?ü v±ê�5%±þ10%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿?vÂ�{¤�¶

�!î­�§��Ù�c��cSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI]�¿�±

úw§��dóû1�+nÅ'L�E��ì¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"�

¦<E¤���§�{«ú��I?"

5çIÝI{¢�^~6é5çIÝI{61Ê�n^5½?�Ú²(§Ù18

�Ô^5½§ÝI<�pGÏÝI½ö�çI<GÏÝI�§ÝI<�çI<½ö

µI�¬¤1ª*�¥I�§¥IÃ�¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?¶ÿ

Ø�¤���§�ìçIÝI{1Ê�n^�5½?v"ÝI<�¥I�§éü 

�v±7�UìçI�8ÜÓ7��ìçIÝI{5½�'~O�"²(5½ÝI

<ke�1����§áuçIÝI{1Ê�n^5½��!î­1�§dk'1

�iÒÜ���Ù1c�2cSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI]�µ�±1ª

*�¥I¶�3cS2g±þGÏÝI¶�GÏÝI1��³çI<!Ù¦ÝI<½

öI[!8N!ú¬�Ü{|çE¤��²L��30��±þ¶�Ù¦GÏÝI

�!î­�1�"5½ÝI<g�^5½�?v�1Ï�3÷�Få3cSqkT

±¤��{1����§½öGÏÝI!±1ª*�¥I�!AOî­�§dóû

1�+nÅ'L�E��ì"{Æ!1�{5éGÏÝI�d1��?v,k5½

�§lÙ5½"

5çIÝI{61Ê�o^5½§ÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI½ö±Ù¦�ªáJ

�b§¢�¥I�§¥IÃ�§�çI<E¤���§�{«ú��I?¶�¤��

�§�{JÄ-¯I?"5½�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI<kc±¤�1�ÿ

��¤���§?¥I�87�0.5%±þ1%±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<

ÚÙ¦��I?<?ü v±ê�5%±þ10%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿

?vÂ�{¤�¶�!î­�§��Ù�c�ncSë\�{7L?1çI��8

�ÝI]�¿�±úw§��dóû1�+nÅ'L�E��ì"

5çIÝI{¢�^~6é5çIÝI{61Ê�o^5½?�Ú²(§Ù1

8�l^5½§ÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI½ö±Ù¦�ªáJ�b¢�¥I�§¥I

Ã�¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?¶ÿØ�¤���§�ìçIÝI{1Ê�

o^�5½?v"�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI<�¥I�§éü �v±7�

UìçI�8ÜÓ7��ìçIÝI{5½�'~O�"5½ÝI<ke�1��

��§áuçIÝI{1Ê�o^5½��!î­1�§dk'1�iÒÜ���

Ù1c�3cSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI]�µ��E!CE]�!]�

yÖ½öÙ¦N�y�¢�¥I¶�3cS2g±þ¦^¦<¶ÂÝI¶�áJ�b

¢�¥I�çI<E¤��²L��30��±þ¶�Ù¦áJ�b¢�¥I�!î

Page 306: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 295

­�1�"Ó�5½§ÝI<g�^5½�?v�1Ï�3÷�Få3cSqkT

±¤��{1����§½áJ�b¢�¥I�!AOî­�§dóû1�+nÅ

'L�E��ì"

3.µI�¬" µI�¬��I§3uUìçI©�(½�µIIOÚ�

{§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§�Ì�*!ú�!�ÆÚJ`��K"µI�

¬�¤µI�§�çI<JÑÖ¡µI�w§¿í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"5¿§ù

p�/Ü�0�i§=ÝIØÜ��ÝI<ØUí��¥IÿÀ<"µIL§¥§µ

I�¬�±�¦ÝI<éÝI©�¥¹Âز(�SN�7��©�½ö`²§

�´©�½ö`²Ø��ÑÝI©����½öUCÝI©��¢�5SN"

{ÆI?µ5çIÝI{61Ê�8^5½§µI�¬¤ÂÉÝI<�ã

Ô½öÙ¦Ð?�§µI�¬¤½öë\µI�k'ó�<�¦<ß³éÝ

I©��µ"Ú'�!¥IÿÀ<�í�±9�µIk'�Ù¦�¹�§��´w§

vÂÂÉ�ãÔ§�±¿?nZ�±þÊ��±e�v±§ék¤��{1��µ

I�¬¤��ú?µI�¬¤�]�§Ø�2ë\?Û�{7L?1çI

��8�µI¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"

5çIÝI{¢�^~6é5çIÝI{61Ê�8^5½?�Ú[zÚÖ¿§

Ù1Ô��^5½§µI�¬¤ke�1����§dk'1�iÒÜ�I-

U�¶�!î­�§B�Ù3�½Ï�Së\�{7L?1çI��8�µI¶�

!AOî­�§��Ùú?µI�¬¤�]�µ�A�£; Ø£;¶�òl

�Ŷ�ØUìçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{µI¶�he�>ÝI<¶��ç

I<�Î(½¥I<�¿�½ö�É?Ûü ½ö�<²«½öV«JÑ���

½öü½A½ÝI<��¦¶�é�{A�Äû�ÝIØJÑÄû¿�¶�V«½

öp�ÝI<�Ñ©�!̀ ²½ö�ÉÝI<ÌÄJÑ�©�!̀ ²¶�Ù¦Ø�

*!Øú�Á1�Ö�1�"

5¿§éuçI<£�)çI�nÅ�¤!ÝI<ÚµI�¬9Ù¤3çI

ÝI¹Ä¥��{�51�§k'1�iÒÜ�½1�?vÅ'�{éÙ�Ñ1�

?v§5çIÝI{¢�^~61l��^éÙ�9��{7L?1çI�8�

¥I(J´Äk�?1.½§5½�{7L?1çI��8�çIÝI¹Ä��

çIÝI{9Ù¢�^~�5½§é¥I(JE¤¢�5K�§�ØUæ�ÖÍ�

��±Å��§çI!ÝI!¥IÃ�§A��{­#çI½öµI§?�ÚÚw

çIÝI{�î�5"çI<Iéd5¿�´§T5½Ó�*��{7L?1ç

I�8ÜÓÃ���/§Ï�ÝI<!µI�¬¤�he�{1�§3çIÝ

I5�L§¥Ø´uy§ ´3ÜÓÁ�L§¥âuyÙ5�¥��{1�"d

Page 307: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

296 çIæÛYFn

�§AUì111Ùù�ÜÓ�Á�+n�{§\ré¥I<�Á�+n§±¢yç

Iæ(J�m�"d�§üXÌÜ¥IÃ�!ÜÓÃ�½´)ØÜÓ§éçI<

¿Ø�½�k|"

[�£I] çIÝI¹Ä¥�ë�<´çI<!çI�nÅ�!ÝI<ÚµI�

¬"Ù¥§çI<´?1çI�{<½öÙ¦|�¶çI�nÅ�´�ÉçI<

�÷§?1çI��¬¥0Å�¶ÝI<´�AçI!ë�ÝI¿��{<!Ù¦

|�½ög,<¶µI�¬´çI<�{|ï�§UçI©�¥5½�µIIO

Ú�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'��µ�Å�"

15!Y~µçI<5��Á��ÌNI?

����¬¯ÌN,çI<�ÌNI?,´3½|¿�Å�e,�lçIÝI5�

5K§={Æ��¬1�5�`z¢yæ(J"@«='5çIÝIL§½/ª§

Ø'%æ(J�/æ0Ø´²LÆ¿Âþ�æ§ /́/ª0½¡�/iZ0"

��§�'5æ(J �ÀçIÝI�1��å§$��¢y(JØJ±�Á{

�æ§=Bæ(J2ЧÏÙ5�L§��{Ƨ���´5K§7,�É�

{ƽ½|²L��à"�d§çI<�ÌNI?§NyuçIÝI5�ÚÁ�ü

��!"çIÝI5�1�ÉçIÝI{�å§Á�´çI<Ú¥I<�{\¾�

Ö¡ÜÓ�Á1§É/�ìZ70§=ª¢Å&�K��å"�d�A§çI<�Ì

NI?§�´«úæ(JI?§�´5�ÚÁ��VÅ{§�l½|�´5��

å�I?"

[Y�£�],½��Ik]7Ý]�÷h\óï��8§oÝ]26000��§d

Tè�ï�+n�ú¿|�úmçI"T�8�ó�çIúwu2017c3�10F3

I[�½x0þuÙ§ÓFm©uÈçI©�§k12[d3ÝI<ïçI©�"

ÝIL§¥§d3ÝI<A�[��8²na§3�gúià¬þ��§o²

n�ú¿�Ö�ô´çI<ï�+n�ú¿Ì?ë¯�Ð¥ÓƧü<´���å

a-!H�f���§��y3ü[<�Ø�rÄ"3�ô�0�e§a§@£

믧/���¨0§ü<Åì¤�Ã{Ø!�*l"ë¯Nìa§§3å¤U9

��¹e§�ÏÙÝI§¿Ø�rSÜ�&Ew�a§"hep§a§éä,

n[ÝI<B!C!D�I§Nìùn[úi§¥I�ò��8©��Ù�ó§�

��%N"

3çI©�5½�ÝI���mµ2017c4�5FþÌ9:00c§12[ïçI©

��d3ÝI<þ4�ÝI©�"²LµI�¬µ"Ú'�§�¤µI�w§

Page 308: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 297

í��1�¥IÿÀ<�ÝI<A§ÝI�d�24836.00��"

çI<Â�µI�w�§9�3uÙçIúw�x0þú«µI(J"35

½�ú«ÙS§çI<vkÂ�ÝI<9Ù|³'X<�ÉÆ"u´§ë¯|�

ï�+n�ú¿k'<§©O�ÝI<A?1ÜÓd�!�§�¦ÝI<AnF

S§3�ÝI�dÄ:þ2e21%-3%"ÝI<AUçI<�¦§unFS2g�

d�24588.00��"(@ÃØ�§çI<�ÝI<AuÑ¥IÏ�Ö¿��\¾

Ö¡ÜÓ§Ù\�ÜÓd�24588.00��"

T�8)�Ú)¹«u2017c4�16Fmóï�"ï�L§¥§��éë¯�

Ï�a�§�8²na§umó��,�U����믧w�¨çIÝI/ºÞ0

®L§2vk<'5çIÝI¥¯�§¿�|x�¨30.00��y7��Å�"Ñ�

í`�§ë¯Âe30.00��y7§¿3Ù��nU�mS§©O�\Ù[<¶e

�Ê�âr"2019c3�§"OÅ�uya§3Ù|��ó�þ���8¥�3I

k]�6�Ú1ª¯K§£xuÅ'áY"�"uÅ'�¦a§é"Ouy�

¯K?1)ºÚ`²"3r���üô³¡c§a§X¢"xþ���8�ó¥

�Ik]�6�Ú1ª¯K§���áõLy,�ÌÄ"x3�g÷h\ó�8

ÝI¥�he$�§±9�Tï�+n�ú¿ë¯1ª30.00���¯¢§Jø�

��±Õ1Úüâ��/"uÅ'�âa§�øã,3Ø¢�±üâ��1�U

D�믧�¢3a§1ª�ÙÕ1�±õÑ30.00���¯¢§�{�éë¯

å�"²L"�§ë¯��{�?kÏä-5c§¿?v720��§J�Ùɪ§þ

�I¥"

a§Úë¯�-Õ�§T÷h\ó�8�?3ï�¥"çI<­#?·ï�+

n�ú¿Ì?,¥I<A­#���8²n"T÷hï��8cÏO�¿Ø¿©§

cÙ´÷h\ó���À.§́ 3mó�â?1�§E¤ï�L§¥Ø�ÊóÚ�

ó§�OC�õ!Uûõ§ï�óÏ�ÏçI<¾À�Ïöò"

çI<u2018c11�.|��O!inÚ�ó?1�8�eó�Â"eó�Â

(Ø´Ü�"��§çI<Ú¥I<A?1ó§eó(�"V�Ï3Øó��!�O

C�±�¤^@½þ�)�Ƨ�ؤ��¿�"2019c3�§¥I<A���Gò

çI<wþ{Ì"d�§�p<¬{��Ù5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY

�·^{ƯK�)º(�)6®²)�"��5¿�´§¥I<A3�¦¥§Øü´

�¦{Ì�ûçI<|GÙØó��¤640.00��§�OC�¤^864.00��§��

¦{ÌòçI©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ�Ö��(�ó§d±�â§(@¿�ûÙ

¥Id�24836.00��§=çI<uÑ¥IÏ�Öc�¦Ù`¨�248.00��§½¥

IÏ�Ö!ÜÓ�ÆÖþ1²�\�ÜÓd24588.00���{A�24836.00��"

Page 309: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

298 çIæÛYFn

{�²L"n§UìV��ï�I?éØó��!�OC�¤?1Ø�§�Ø

¥I<A�I?§çI<A«úØó��¤586.45��!�OC�¤^760.63�

�"éu¥Id�\�ÜÓd§{Ì�â5çIÝI{61o�8^Ú�p<¬{

�5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�)º(�)61�^5½§=

�¯<\¾�ï�ó§�óÜÓ�çI©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ�Ö1²�ó§d

±Ø����/§�{�½¥Id=\�ÜÓd�¥I<�ÝI©�1²�d�§

=24836.00��"

��§{��"\�¥§@½çI<Ú¥I<A\�ÜÓd�{A��24836.00�

�¶�-çI<3�ûÖ)�15FS§|G¥I<A�ÜÓ{±!Øó��¤586.45�

�Ú�OC�¤^760.63��"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±e¯Kµ

1.�o´�Iº¥I<A3ÝIL§¥§he4ÝI<B!C!D�I�1�´Ä

�{§�{AÉ��o?vº�Y{��û¥§��oØJ¥I<A�B!C!DGÏ

ÝI�¯§XJ{�@½¥I<A�B!C!DGÏÝI§´Ä¬K��û(Jº

2.�Y¥§çI<�¦µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<§=ÝI<A3�Ý

I�dÄ:þ2e21%-3%§ÝI<AU�¦e2248.00��§V��û��§{

�"n���o@�Ã�º{�éù�¯��@½éçI<|�çIæk=é

3.��@�§çIÝIL§¥§çI<!ÝI<Ú�¬1n<ÊH'5Ùë�<

�1�§cÙ´1ª!ɪ1�§�Y¥§ï�+n�ú¿Ì?ë¯Éª30.00�

�§�{��"�?kÏä-5c§¿?v720.00��§J�Ùɪ§þ�I¥�¯

`²�o§éçI<Á1¬¯ÌNI?k=é&º

[Y~©Û] �âY�£�§éþã¯K©ÛXeµ

1.�I´GÏÝI¥��«�ÓÝI1�§=ÝI<�m²LûƧUÚ��

��ÓS½¥I<ÝI�1�"ë��I�ÝI<�¦��Ó�S½¥I<�å§

�¤GÏÝI1�"�Y¥§¥I<AÝIL§¥§|�ÝI<B!C!D�I�1

�§��5çIÝI{61n��^1�±§=ÝI<Ø��pGÏÝI�d§Ø�

ü@Ù¦ÝI<�ú²¿�§�³çI<½öÙ¦ÝI<�Ü{�Ã�5½"¥I

<A�GÏÝI1�XJ�¢§ò�ì5çIÝI{61Ê�n^5½§�½Ù¥I

Ã�§?¥I�87�0.5%±þ1%±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦

��I?<?ü v±ê�5%±þ10%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿?vÂ�

{¤�¶�!î­�§��Ù�c��cSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI]

�¿�±úw§��dóû1�+nÅ'L�E��ì¶�¤���§�{JÄ-

Page 310: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

112ÙçIæµçI<�ÌNI? 299

¯I?"Ó�§�¦<E¤���§�{«ú��I?"

@o§�Y{��û¥§��ovkJ9¥I<A�B!C!DGÏÝI�¯§

=´ÒV��Æ�¤^?1\�QºÄk§¬¯"�¥§j±/¬ØÞ(ØÄ0��

K§Q,�wÚ�wvk�ûGÏÝI��¦§{��,جѤ<åÚÔå��

¢¥I<AGÏÝI�¯¢"Ó�§¬¯"�¥�k���K§=/XÌÜXÞy0§

=çI<ÌÜ¥I<A 3ÝIL§¥�ÝI<B!C!DGϧ7LÞy±y²¦�

3ÝI¥GÏ"d�§çI<����¥I<A3ÝI¥�ÝI<B!C!DGÏ�´

®²3Ñ-�믧¦<¿Ø�¡§çI<�,ÃlÞy¥I<A3ÝI¥�GÏ

ÝI1�¶Ùg§�YçIÝIL§¥§1�iÒÅ�3Ù�{¢��iÒ¥§v

kuy¥I<A3ÝI¥�ÝI<B!C!DGϧvk\Ù¥IÃ�"

�Y¥§XJçI<Þy¥I<A3ÝI¥�ÝI<B!C!DGϧ{�æ&

çI<Jø�yâ§@½¥I<A�B!C!DGÏÝI�§¬�ì5-{61�z

��n^5½§@½¥I<AÚÝI<B!C!D�GÏÝI�§JÄ¥I<AÚÝI

<B!C!D �-¯I?§1�iÒÅ��¬�â5çIÝI{61Ê�n^5½§

é¥I<AÚÝI<B!C!D�±1�?v"�é�YÜÓd±�Æ��ûجk

K�§Ï��,V�\¾�ÜÓÃ�§�T�8eó�ÂÜ�"ù�§�â5¬{

;6ÜÓ?1ÔzÊ�n^5½§ï�ó§�óÜÓÃ�,�´ï�ó§²�ÂÜ�

�,�±ëìÜÓ'uó§d±��½òdÖ�«�<§½´dc�p<¬{��

Ù�5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�)º61�^§ï�ó

§�óÜÓÃ�§�ï�ó§²eó�ÂÜ�§«�<�¦ëìÜÓ�½|Gó§

d±�§±9�p<¬{�5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�

)º(�)61�^§�¯<\¾�ï�ó§�óÜÓ�çI©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ

�Ö1²�ó§��!ï�óÏ!ó§�þ!ó§d±Ø��§���¯<�¦ò

çI©�!ÝI©�!¥IÏ�Ö��(�ó§d±��â�§<¬{�A�|±

�5½§é�YÜÓd±�@½�KvC"

2.�Y¥§çI<3(½¥I<c§�¦¥I<A3�ÝI�dÄ:þ2e

21%-3%§¥I<AU�¦e2248.00��§�,V��û��§�çI<�1

���5çIÝI{61o�n^§=3(½¥I<c§çI<Ø��ÝI<Ò

ÝId�!ÝI�Y�¢�5SN?1!��5½"Ó�§çIÝI¥��g��!

�g«ìA�§û½¥IdÚ\�ÜÓd´¥I<ÝI©�þ1²�d�"�Y

¥§¥I<AUçI<��¦e2�248.00��§=�g�d24588.00�����

g���5K§®Ø2áu¥I<A�ÝI©�"ù��´5çIÝI{61o�

8^�{n§=�¦çI<Ú¥I<UìçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾áÖ¡Ü

Page 311: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

300 çIæÛYFn

Ó§Ø�21¾á�lÜÓ¢�5SN�Ù¦�Æ"

�Y¥§{�é¥Id½\�ÜÓd�@½§éçI<|�çIæ�é&3

u§|�çIÝIL§¥IïÄù«�g��½/��d0�A:§õ3çI©�

?�Y²þeõŧõ3J`IOþeõÅ"Ó�§î��å¤kó�<�1�§

�{�5|�çIÝI¹Ä§Ø�he�>ÝI<9Ù|³'X<§Ø��ÝI<

GϧØ�ÂÝI<½öÙ|³'X<���ãÔ½öÙ¦Ð?§�³I[|Ã!

�¬ú�|ýöçI<ÚÙ¦ÝI<�Ü{�Ã"

3.�Y¥§çI<�ï�+n�ú¿Ì?ë¯Éª30.00��§�{��"�?

kÏä-5c§¿?v720.00��§J�Ùɪ§þ�I¥�¯§̀ ²/{�¡¡!

Õ Ø¦0§���{�¯¢�3§́ @¬É�{Æ��à"éd§çI<9Ùó�

<[�ØU�k�3%n��{l¯"ÄK§ÒX�Yë¯�(Û��§±�3

çIÝIL§¥Øɪ§̄ �2é��ÒV��á�ÉÐ?¤Òv¯K§�� A

�"çI<�ó�<XJù�@�§@o§(Û�U�ë¯��§́ O��/§�

´�m@��¯"

�YéçI<Á1¬¯ÌNI?�é&3u§çI<9Ùó�<�{!�5!

�VÁ1çIæ�I§́ çI<Á1ÌNI?���"ù�¥§�ª&�<´1

��Ö§´�<!ü ½|�3½|þáv�Ä:¶��{!�5!�V�¯´O

K§Ï��<!ü ½|��{!�5!�V�¯´Ù^A½|5K��S§? )

��cJ¶�J`´��§Ï�çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä�8�3uÝI¿�§3

udÝI¿�¥J`§ù´çIæ½çIÝI���A�"

Page 312: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 13Ù

çIæµGÏÝI���

**********************************************************************

°S��C§Uãe'�"

— �Ç5xÚ�?�?Þ²6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 313: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

302 çIæÛYFn

11!pϵGÏÝI�ÄÏ

çI�ÝI§́ éáÚ��gñ'X"çIæÔÑ��¦�±¢y�cJ^

�§́ ÝI<�AçI§?1¿�§�¿�§Ý�-�§çI<`z¢yçIæ(

J�§ÝÒ�p"�d§ÝI¿�´çI`z¢yæ(J�Ä:"éA�§GÏ

ÝI§=ÝI<mhe�ûQ�|ÃÚ¥I<§Ø¿�§́ éçIÝI�é|§ù

«é|�¢�§�»çIÝIÅ��Щ§¦`z¢yçIæ(J�g�á�"

�d§ÃØ´çI<�´çIÝI1�iÒÅ�§ÑAïÄGÏÝIÅn§? k

�é5�éÙ�±��½�Â"@o§ÝI<��o�GÏÝIQº�,´¥I|

æ,"¢Sþ§lÆ�À�w§GÏÝI´ÝI<¼�¥IÂÃ��Z�{§�

%´�«��½|�´�S��{�{"

[GÏÝI��{] 2004c8�§,½Ý]8000��,ï��ú�¥)A:?�

¥%§�)¾Óuÿ!P3¢�¿!Ó ���!�E!¾�ÚÆâ�6�ïÓÚ�

@����"T�8çI©�5½�µI�{�nܵ©{"Ù¥§µIÄOd�

k�ÝI��d�â²þ�§,�O�ÝI�d�µIÄOd� �ǧ�d �

Ç(½ÝI<��d�©"5½�d �Ç3[0§-1%]��100©§3dÄ:þ§z

pÑ��z©:�4©§z$��z©:�2©"~X§�d �Ç3£-1%§-2%]m

�§�98©§3£0,+1%]m�§�96©�"

T�8��kÔ�ÝI<3çI©�5½�ÝI���mc4�ÝI©�"

mI�§Ñy��4<¯çØ®�y�§Ô�ÝI<��d�©§kü��d�

100©§n��d�99©§ü��d�98©"çI<Q~¦Ô�ÝI<´GÏ

ÝI§�;�|�µI�¬éÔ[ÝI<�ÝI©�?1"�§vkuyGÏÝ

I�?ÛÀjê,§�U�{�¤µI�w§í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"çI<éµ

I(Jú«�§ÝI<9Ù|³'X<vkJÑÉÆÚÝ�§u´(½ü¶1��

¥IÿÀ<¥I§¿�Ù\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"

T�8ÝI�dLu8¥§4<~¦´GÏÝI�£u��vkyâ§��T

�8\Ù¥I(J��üc§�8ï��¤±�§·�� �óü *l�·ùã

T�8ÝI¥�Dª§â¦·m�²ÝI<��he5K§�²��oGÏ

ÝIY��?J"

@�§·�3��ó§�8þ?ï��8�¯�ú¿�Ì?"k�U§�óü

Page 314: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 303

 ·Ù£�� Bo²n5ó/u�ó�§·��å3 ,¯����ÑÚ§¦�

ÒXÛJp¥IÇ�·&?"·�¦0�AN�ÆSçI©�§N��AçI©�

�¢�5�¦Ú^�§N��¾Æ�üÑ?1ÝI¿�"̀ X`X§¦�ä·�

{µ/fƬ§s`�ù�{vk^§¢SÝIØ´ù�Ý�"0·�1§̄ ¦µ/@

\�¢S´N�Ý�IBº0¦`µ/·�o|�ÝI�<Ñ@£§·�k·�gC

�ÝI5K"0{Þ]å§ù�´·ùc�'%�/�"·¯¦µ/\�gC�

k5K§�o5KBº0�·a,�§¦¯·µ/·�\Þ�~f§s��4�½ú�

¥)A:?�¥%@��8íº0·`µ/��B"0¦�X¯·µ/s��@��8´

NoÝ�Iíº0·`µ/Ø��§s��º0¦`µ/ù��8�ÝI§�mD`��

��{Q�0��·)ºÝI<gC�ÝI5K§¦rÙfª�ÝI�{é·?1

£�§̀ µ/ù��8§â`mIc�U�þ§ë�ÝI�ëo�Ù¦�ÝIÌ+P

o�>{§̀ ·�-�-Bº0¦�X`µ/ù´1�Ú§Ï�Ñ@£"�,§Ù¦P

o�±5-§�±Ø5"�Ø5�7L(²§±Be�gÝI��±UYÜ�"0

¦`§ù��8ëo��>{�§3�½��mS§Ù¦ÝI<�PoÑ�

�½�Õ�/:"ëoVÞ̱§¯��ÝI<Poµ/ao§s�ù�gé�X

ܺ0�[Ñ%ìØ\§ao£��µ/é�1��rÃ"0ëo�X¯µ/�o§\�

é�Xܺ0�o�{µ/·é��BÖP"0ëoUY¯Ù¦Po�§uy�[é

�Ñ´+��f¤§�o´1���rç�o´�!V�KI<"�g�§é

�´ó¬ÌR"

·¯�oµ/¦�þ5k¯é�X§ùØAT´\�ÝI�Å�íº0¦`µ/Ñ

´�fS~cÝI�<§$��ª´���"ù�Ú�8�§´wX�çI<�'

XM§±Bû½X¥I!X�I"�,§�I�ØUx�§¥I�I���I��½

¤^"0�o�X`µ/(J§ù��83ù�Úk�§Ï�Ñ´é�+��f¤

§ÑrN3�chep�Ø�ó�§+��Ñ�A��ÝIü31�§�½4

Ù¥I"0

��Øn�õ��vk(J§k�PoX:§̀ µ/·�r§·��ÝI

�d�vWþ§�v�µQ"0¦ù�`§áêÚ�Ù¦A Po�X:§�r"

ù�§ëo:4A Po§4�[Or§̀ µ/·Ñ�Ì¿§w�[@�Ø"�[Ñr

�Ñ��d`�`§2½ÝIüÑ"·k`§·��ÝId´5134.00��"0�G§

Ù¦ÝI<m©X¢`gCO���d§k5085.00���§�k5156.00���§�

d�p�§́ 5365.00��"ëo�X`µ/ù�§4�X¥I�دº§krµIÄ

Od�½e5§·ïÆ���3�ê5688.00 ��"2�L5§í�ü�100©!n

�99©!ü�98©��d§ùATéN´"�[é·�ïÆ@�غ0Ù¦A P

Page 315: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

304 çIæÛYFn

oÑL«@Ó"Ø�¬�§éA100 ©!99©Ú98 ©��dí�Ñ5"ëo4Ñ

Ö<5ÔÜ�Ú���Ýf§3zÜ�þ�e���d§Q¤���ì�\�Ý

¥§2~�~§̀ µ/�w«ú²§4�Uz[6�gS8I",�§U8��d�

ÝI§?�ÝI©��ÝI"1غ0ë\¬Æ�Poéù��{ÑL«@Ó§�

g?18I�§¿U�þ1²�d�?1ÝI"�d,·ªu²ù��8�ÝI(

J§��oÔ�ÝI<��d�©§kü��d�100©§n��d�99©§ü��

d�98©"�,§ù=´���m6D��{"

ùc§·��3�g§Q,y1{Ʋ(B�ÝI<�GÏÝI§ �5¥

u<¬�ÚI-{6¥§�;�5½/GÏÝI�0§��oÝI<�cu/ck

Ue��Øé0§GÏÝIQº[g�uy§ù�¥k©z!S���ϧk¥I|

Ã�°¦§kGÏÝI´he1�§uyJ�?�J�¯K§����Ï3uçI

<|�çIæ/r/ª!rL|0"éd§·�©ÛXeµ

1.©zS�"Äk§¥I©zØü½¿�"¥I�½|g�Òk§«1�Ò´

�´�¿�"¥I��¬?\à��ϧk¬�k�þ�{�¬����§=�)

�©½|�/Ô-Ô0�´"����dÔ/À10Ñy§½|Åì�/gd½|0§

¿±E¥/Ã�0!�´d�§aq8U�/¿�5!�0§�Ùh�5pu/¿�

5!�0"d��?�m©uÙ/½-0§�å�´§�oïñV��Ã"çIÝI

�Ý´�«Í5��´�ª§ÙØ% /́¿�0"

Ùg§¥I©zù¦/¥T0§=é¥I<ÊHK��Ø4à§�<�ÔØ Ø

­!NÚò¥�V[��IO§Ä:´V[/;!Â!r!�!&0g�"ùp§/;0

�O<§/UO<=�;0§3�¦<�?�U��KUÚ�§õ��?/�O<X

�§�¯�<�C¶/Â0�/ãÂ0§O<kJ�ÑÃ�<¶/r0́ /«<±­0§

é¦<kr§´���¬�;Ù�ÝÚ��5�§¢�´�ï�¬�S¶/�0�

/�G0§�£!�¦�¶/&0�/Åó0§�<?¯�ª¢ØЧó1��"¤±§

¥I©zØ|±�¯<Ï�Ch|©�\k·¹§=¿©¿�§ ù¦/¥T0§¿

dd/¤¥I�¬´<�ßþ��¬§<3�¬þÑkgC��f½+N§Ú�¥

I<�¯�Ä+N|ç/¦�Ó��É0§? ¦�[÷¿"¤±§@«�¦ÝI

<3¼�¥I�8�§¿©¿��g�3¥I©zÚ�eJ¢y§Ï�¥I<�¯

ùÄ�pûƧØr4à§ù�´��oISGÏÝI�IS½|þÊHî­��

�g�Ï"Ó�§çIÝI�Ý¿Øü½è�m�Ü��é�§#NÝI<é�§±

éÜN�°ÝI§�x�çi/\ÝéÜN�Æ´�«é��ª§heûÆÝI§

? /�*uÐ0Ó��´�«é��ª§�X�¯¥@Ô�ÝI<��{§��

´8I��§Ï�ë�<Ñ@�´3/�*uÐ0"3ù�:þ§{Æ�r�åk�

Page 316: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 305

w�ñxÃå"

2g§¥I©zù¦�N�ɧ@ÓØÓ¬x!ØÓ/�<��N�ɧùÄ

¦�Ó��ɧùÄ^��Ýw��N1�"@o§çIÝI�Ý´Ä�Óu½|

¿�Qº�Y´Ä½��Ï�çIÝIØL´½|�´��«�ª§XJØ�Ä�

¬���ݧølçI�8A:Ú½|ø�G¹§{ü//� �0§r��¦�

+��çI�87LçI§±çIÝI��½|�´Ù¦�ª§7,�¥I©z�

ng�->§¦{Æ�å�ò�§ùÒ´��oISGÏÝIÂBØ���ϧÏ

�GÏÝI /́�*0��«Ly/ª"

2.çI<�Ï"g,¿��{K´`���§́ ·ö)� Ø´aõ"çIÝ

IJ¦�§T´ù«`���§²d½|¿�íÄ�¬?Ú"Äk§çII¦�L

Xk?��¬)�å"½|²L¥§I¦´ø��cJ"ù�¥§/I¦0�<�/Ô

�Ú©zI¦0§¿��¤ØC§ ´��¬?Ú/FÃO�0�I¦§3�½§Ý

þ�L�¬k?)�å Ø´L�½=�Eâ¶Ùg§ÝI¿�´ÝI<�Á�§

=ÙEâ�+nUå�¿�§Ï�çIÝI5K�¦çI<3çI©�¥úÙµI

IOÚ�{§=3¤k÷vçI/I¦0�ÝI¥§?1/û¬�^J`0§ù��

Ò´�«/`���0L§" �}´¤õ�1§�¥I�ÝI<�)�§·A½|

¿�§7,¬ïu½Ú?k?)�Eâ§U?)�ó²§J,Ù½|¿�¢å§?

íÄ�¬)�å�cuж2g§çIÝI´ISþ|^½|`z] ���Ï

1�{"ÃØ´Iè��¥I5§�´ISè�¸ë�ÝI¿�§�½§Ýþ

¬uyÙ�Iè�m��å§r¦Ù3è�Eâ?Ú!�¬ïuÚ<âÔÑ��

¡eóŧíÄ�¬)�å�cuÐ"

@o§Q,çIÝI�g,{K��¦��§́ �«/`���0�½|¿�

Å�§��o¥Ik�ÝI<Ø·A ���uGÏÝIQº�Ï3u§�çI

<|�çI�§r/ª!rL|�õ§ý�´/`���0��"ù��¡§´Ï

�çI<4u{Æ5½½´�/�!Ü�éçIÝIA^���*�§Ø�Øç

I§çI<AG�¯§/r/ª!rL|0¶,��¡§½|¿��m�3u`z]

��§�3çIÝI¥§qkõ�çI<@ýïÄçI�8A:ÚI¦§U½

|ø�G¹JÑ¿�Ï�ÚJ`IO§|�¿�5æQºA�´��q���õ

êçI<±�l{ƧS55½§/r/ª!rL|0§±(½¥I< Ø´`z¢

yçI�8�m�"�d§IS��çIÝI¹Ä§wqçI<3|�ÝI<¿

�§¢K´3|�ÝI<�iZ!''X§¿�g,�/`���0"3ù«�/e§

çI<r|�çIÝI¹Äw�´|��|iZ¹Ä§ÝI<rë�çIÝI¹Ä

w�´3ë�iZ" iZ´±���Ñ�m�§qÛLÄ^I[�å§={Æé

Page 317: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

306 çIæÛYFn

��iZL§?1�åQº·�§ùâ´GÏÝI3IS�E����Ï"

3.ÝI<�Ï"ÝI<GÏÝI�,´�|Ã"=B´�I�§� /́�<

�B�C�B0§±B3e�gI��§Ù¦ÝI<�±�gC�I§? ¼�¥I

�8"¢Sþ§çIÝIL§¥§�I�ïÄ�´ÝI<§AO´¥I�ÝI<3

ò/I0ÝÑ��á@§́ N�?1�ÝIûü§́ UçI©��¦O�ÝI]�§

�dU¤�\|d§O�Ñõ�Ò´õ�oº�½Ø´�Ï�ùØ´ÝI¿� ´

�Æ)UP���¦3�¤��"�d§@«@�ÝI<´gCrgC'3��ç

�S§�.û,��/?1ÝI§�õ´��nØb�§AO´ISçI�8�

ÝI<§Ï�¥I�½|©z3�½¿Âþ´'X©z§½ö¡��¬'XE,�

ä§́ 3�o½|�S¥�I�ïÄ�1�"@o§ÝI<GÏÝIéçI<�|

Ãk=ú³§é½|ú²�Â��Sk=»�Qº

1¤çI<�³"GÏÝIéçI<����³§3uÝI<m�¿�´b�§

¥I(JØ´�`(J§Á�¥�UÑyµ�¥Id p§Ï�¥I<|�GÏÝ

I�m�´¼���|d§Ó�I|G�I<�½�¤^¶�¥I<Á�UåØ÷

v�¦½´Á�Uåkj"§Oy�Ï�S�¤ØçI�8§½´çI�8��

þk"�§çI�8�õ^�Ø��~u�¶��¬ØûK�§=çI<��¬�

NìØUXÏ¢y§E¤Ø7���¬ØûK��"

2¤�´�S»�"GÏÝIé�´�S�»�§3u�³�{ÝI�ÝI<

�ç»�ú²ú��½|�´�S§́ çIÝI+��«;.�/�1°Åû

10�1�§7LéÙîx�Â"ÄK§�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|�´Ê33

n�G�§½|�´�S¬r�ÃS½�5uÐ"

4.1�iÒ�Ï"�{�?ÝI<�GÏÝI1�§́ 5çIÝI{69Ù¢

�^~D�1�iÒÅ��oçIÝI½|�S����I"@o§��o3¢�

¥§�þGÏÝI1�¿vk�1�iÒÅ��? ´3�8Á1¥½´Á1(å

�ÿ`Ñ5�Q§ù´Ï�ÝI<ë�GÏÝI�§k��d5K§=ë�GÏ

ÝI�<&Å«ì§3çIÝIL§¥/�k�Ø`0"ÝI<3ù�:þ�&Å

§Ý�pu�l{Æ5K§Ï�´ÝI<��½�¤5K"���¥I<m©Á1

ÜÓ§ù«he�½�Ò(å§ë�GÏÝI�ÝI<�ÃI2�GÏÝI1��

�§$�k��¯<3�*lÕË�§�ÚwgC½´ØÑí¦<é,<�§�§

¬�ØgB�î�`µ/¦k�oUåÜ�þ�g3A�8ÝI�§�Ø´·ÚÙ¦

A�<�¦ÝI§¦��¥ØI�0d�3e�¯K§�X·�®3112Ù¥?Ø

�§́ çI<XÛ?n¥I<§́ ±GÏÝI�dÌÜ¥I½ÜÓÃ�íº�,Ø

´§ ´±k|u¢yçIæ(J��K"

Page 318: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 307

@o§��o1�iÒ3�?GÏÝI�¯KþLy�é¯åQº�Ï3uµ

�1�] Ú�å�k�5§Ø#N1�iÒÅ�Ѥ�þ�<åÚÔå§��?

ÝI<�GÏÝI¯�¶�1�iÒ<Ø�ÌÄ��§@�/¬ØÞ(ØÄ0�

K§=�kÝI<9Ù|³'X<Ý�½Þ�§�JøGÏÝI�Ä�¯¢!k�

�¢Ú�'y²á��§1�iÒâ¬Én§â¬�?GÏÝI"�Ò´`§1�i

ÒÅ�جÌÄ�?GÏÝI¯�§ù�Ç�1�iÒ�m�¿Ø¬Ü¶�Â8G

ÏÝI�yâ§�)<yÚÔy´��4Ù(J�¯"��¡§ë�GÏÝI�<

&Å«ì§Ø�¥I<vkçyNì�|çÄK§ýجÝ�½uÞ¶,��¡§

éÝI©���p'�§��uyØGÏÝI§Ø�´ÝI©��?�</M�

4¼H0§Y²��§3e²w�GÏÝI/Àjê,0"�d§��ÝI<G

ÏÝI�Xú:Ø31�iÒÅ�§ 3çI<gC§3çI<N�u�çIÝI

�õ^"

12!ÌNµGÏÝI�ë�<

GÏÝI�ÌN§�)ÝI<!çI<½çI�nÅ�§±9µI�¬¤

�¬¯ÌN§=ÝI<�çI<½¥0Å�!ÝI<�µI�¬¤!ÝI<�

ÝI<m�§þ�Uu)GÏÝI1�"ù�¥§X�Ì!X�9k�é²w§�k

�GÏÝI¯�©ØÑÌg§́ ��Ó|à GÏ"ØÝI<m�GÏÝI?1|

é�½Ö�§GÏÝI¯���Ѭ��Xk1ªÉª¯��u)§́ çIÝ

I+��¯<he@}�´�à8:"

�â�ÝI<GÏ�ÌNØÓ§©ÛXe"

1.çI<½¥0Å�"ÝI<�çI<½¥0Å�Gϧ́ �ÝI<ÝIL§

¥§�çI<½¥0Å��,ó�<Gϧ�ÏÙ¥I"

1¤çI<"ÝI<�çI<Gϧ́ GÏÝI¥�~���/§Ó�§�´G

ÏÝI¥��¯K½Ä:¯K"�¯K)û§Ù¦�GÏÝI¯K3Eâ�¡Ñ

�±k�)û§Ï�ÝI<GÏÝI�¢ylØmçI<�|±�%N"@o§Ý

I<´XÛé�çI<¥�Ì�I?<�Qº��´ÏLÙ�«�¬'XÚ�§

½´~c3çI<|��çI�8þÝI ÅÚïá¿uÐ�"m©=´@£§Ñ

y3���Ûþ¶,�´Ý٤ЧÀ,�¤3�Ù1ªxr¶��§çI<�Ù

GÏÝI§rçIÝI¥��{L����¯�w�ÝI<"~X§�Ù�³I

.½Ù¦ÝI<�d!3µI!½I�!�ÏÝI<¥I"ÝI<¥I�§<Ñ�

½ê��y7½Ô¬��a�"

Page 319: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

308 çIæÛYFn

[�çI<Gϯ�] 2012c12�16F§,½¥?<¬{�é½u�ú��½

1�¥ÆÄï�ú¿Ì?�,�GÏÝI�!ɪ�§�{�?�,kÏä-Êc§

¿?v710��¶�?Aúi{<�Lo,�GÏÝI�!1ª�kÏä-Êc§¿

?v730��"�YϽ1�¥Æ#ï3Ò��¢!?12Ò�Æ¢ÚÆ) ,�U

Eó§çI�§Búi�½iÛÞ�§¡mIL§¥õguyÙÝI©�kJc

µè,§�n��8zgÑ´Aúi¥I§@�çI<�Aúi�3GÏÝIv

¦§Þy3mIy|ûì�ÙÝI©��µ�Jc µ�yâ"½iÛÉnÞ�

�§D�½1�¥Æ�'I?<!Aúi{½�L<o,§¼�<y!Ôy§y

¢½1�¥ÆÄï�ú¿Ì?�,�AúiGÏÝI�¯¢§�Vé1�¥ÆÌ

+Äï�B��ÚÄï�ú¿Ì?�Ñ?©�§òY�£x½<¬u�áY¿J

åú�"

{�²"n�²§�w<�,u2008c�2012c4�ú?1�¥ÆÄï�ú¿

Ì?§Ïm|��1�¥Æ2Ò�Æ¢C?UE£Ý]820��¤!#ï3ÒÆ)��

¢£Ý]1200��¤!Æ) ,UE£Ý]120��¤��8ï�çIL§¥§�,

�AúiGÏÝI§k��Aúi�³I.d�§JcméB!C!Dn[ÝI<�Ý

I©�§òn[úi�ÝI�dJcw�Aúi"Ó�§ÂÉo,�Ð?¤25�

�"�,!o,éþ㯢ø@د§{��{é�,!o,�Ñþã�û"

5¿§ÝI<�çI<GÏ�¢�§3u´çI<?1çI§éÀJ¥I<ä

k�½�û½�"�d�é§çI<�ÝI<GÏ���3uɪ§3u�{¼�

�'�Žö<�­�"éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~61o��^²(5½§B�

çI<�ÝI<GÏÝI§�Þ8«çI<�ÝI<GÏ�1�§=µ�çI<

3mIcméÝI©�¿òk'&E�³�Ù¦ÝI<¶�çI<��½öm��

ÝI<�³I.!µI�¬¤�&E¶�çI<²«½öV«ÝI<Ø$½ö

�pÝI�d¶�çI<Ç¿ÝI<��!?UÝI©�¶�çI<²«½öV«

ÝI<�A½ÝI<¥IJø�B¶�çI<�ÝI<�*¦A½ÝI<¥I æ

��Ù¦GÏÝI1�"ù8«�/�²�¢§=�{UGÏÝI�éçI<k'

I?<?1?n"

2¤¥0Å�"çIÝI¥§ÝI<�üa¥0Å�´uGϧ�´çI�nÅ

�§�´É÷?�I.�Ed\ÎÅ�"ÝI<�çI�nÅ�Gϧ́ Ï�çI

<�÷�nÅ�çI�§�õØ2L¯çI[! dçI�nÅ�ûü§äkçI

<�/ ¶�I.?�ü Gϧ´ uI.´çI<éçI�8�d�Ï"�§

ݺ\ÎÅ�?��I.�§�±éÝI�Ñ�éO(�ûü§±B¥I"��/§

ÝI<¼�I.d�I�|Gé��½�¤^"$�§�I.?�ü ��{�

Page 320: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 309

ÉÝI<��÷§�ÏÙ?�ÝI�d©�"

[��nÅ�Gϯ�] ,½<¬{��"�²§2015c5��6�§,çIúi

�8²nÇ,3ú?¢«�ó§ï��8çI�nÏm§�ÝI<A��8²n�

,Gϧ��,ß³,Ê[ë�ÝIúiéX<&E§�,|^Ç,Jø�&E§

�ë�T�8ÝI�5[úi��8²n�|G10000�§!`Ê[úi�ïÝI"

d§�,�GÏÙ¦o[ÝIúiéTC?ó§�8?1�I"Ç,3çI©�

¥§�¿��ü½Ù¦d3ÝI<�]�^�§�ÝI<A¥I�EB|"�ª§Ý

I<A¼�¥I]�§¥I7��1200{��"�"{�@�§�w<Ç,��ç

I�nÅ���8²n§�³A�����çIÝI¹Äk'��¹Ú]�§�Ý

I<GÏÝI§�³I[|ÃÚ�¬ú�|ö�w<�,��ÝI<§|�G

ÏÝI§�³çI<|ç�!î­"Ó�§Ù���çI<�÷�çI�nÅ�

¥�Ç,Gϧ�³I[|ÃÚ�¬ú�|öü�w<�1�®�¤GÏÝI�§

ú�Å'����¶¤á"�w<Ç,!�,�Y�X¢øãgC�1§�Ìg�

@�§�l�?v"nþ¤ã§�"{��{�ûÇ,!�,�GÏÝI�§�?k

Ïä-6��§¿?v72 ��"

5¿§ÝI<�¥0Å�Gϧ́ ÝI<@�¥0Å�3çIÝIL§¥�±

�Ù¥IJøB|^�§BuÙ?1¥I$�¶�d�駥0Å��ÝI<Gϧ

ÃØ´ü �´�<§Ñ´��{¼��Å"éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~618�

Ê^�±B�§5½éçI�nÅ�3¤�n�çI�8¥ÝI!�nÝI½ö�

T�8ÝI<Jø\Î�§±9�É�÷?�I.�¥0Å�ë\É÷?�I.�

8�ÝI½ö�T�8�ÝI<?�ÝI©�½Jø\Î�§�ìçIÝI{1Ê

�^�5½JÄ{ÆI?§=é¥0Å�?Ê��±þ��Ê��±e�v±§é

ü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<?ü v±ê�5%±þ10%±e�

v±¶k�{¤��§¿?vÂ�{¤�¶�!î­�§B�Ù�c��cS�n

�{7L?1çI��8¿�±úw§��dóû1�+nÅ'L�E��ì¶�

¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"Ó�5½§�¦<E¤���§�{«ú��I?§

¤�1�K�¥I(J�§¥IÃ�"

2.µI�¬¤"nØþ§ÝI<¼GµI�¬¤�&E§?1Âï�

�U5Ø�§Ï�µI�¬´3µIy|�||ï�"@o§¢�¥§��o¬

ÑyµI�¬�ꤧ�)çI<�LÚk'Eâ!²L��¡�;[3µI

L§¥§�ÏÝI<¥IQº�Ï3uÝI<¯k�GµI�¬¤�&E"

1¤çI<�L"ÝI<ÂïµI�¬¥�çI<�L§�´ uçI<�Ý

I<GÏ"��û½ÝI<¥I���/à�0�!§çI<g,¬�¦Ùë�µ

Page 321: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

310 çIæÛYFn

I��L�ÏÀ½�ÝI<¥I¶�´Ï�§=BçI<v�ÝI<Gϧ�çI

<�;�<3²?"lçI�8;�þ§X�U�µI§²LÐÚ�ä§2\þ

he�f§ÝI<���±�½çI<[�µI�<"d§²d�«Ãã. 

ØÓk �çIó�<§́ ÝI<3ÝIL§¥���Ì�ú'ó�§8�Ò´

�Ù3µI!½I�`Ð{§�þ^|"

2014c6�§·��[>�úiø>Û¥�±þ+n<ùçIÝI{9µI

1��å§ø>Ûi¿Ì?3·Ç�(å§?1o(��ã{§2g\�·

éÝI<éÏçI<�L�ù«@£"@U§i¿Ì?é·�Ç�L«�½�§

`µ/·3ùp�¦3��Ó�5¿§Ø���{Æ5½"Þ�~f§þü��4�

�g>���æ§3mIc��U§\��¥kü �?<§�ÝI<3��

´�)�´���>þ@�j�Ap�åÕj�§¯�k<w�·��k§þ�

�4��g>���æ§mIc�U��þ§\��¥k� B??<�ÝI

<334´þ��[à[�p¯�§�k<�·®�"·3ùpØ:¶§��¦�

Ô�O2Ñyaq1�§eØ�~�0@Uf��¥�+n<¥§kn©���m

´ø>Û;[¥S�;["

2¤µI;["µI;[´�µI;[¥p(½ë�µI�;["Ø@EâE

,!;�5r½öI[kAÏ�¦§æ��ÅÄ��ª3µI;[¥¥(½�;[

J±�?µIó���8§nØþ§µI;[¥SÓ�;��;[<ê¯õ§q

´æ^�ÅÄ��ª(½�§ÝI<A�éØ�çI�8�µI;["@o§¢�

¥§��o�¬ÑyÝI<ÂïµI;[¯�Qº·�k©Ûe¡ùåµI;[&

E��¯�"

[;[&E��¯�] 2010c§,½iÅ'éL�nc�çI�8|�u�§

uyÙ¥k�aó§çI�8§zg¥I�Ñ´ü�ÝIü ��§�µI�¬

éùü[ü �µI(J4Z§ØÎܽ|¿�5ƧÏ�ùü[¿�½S3ù�

+���`è�"iÅ'é�ë�µI�;[ί¥§�;[�¡§Ø��

k<��o¬�¦��>{§¡��¦�=òë��o�8�µI§�¦¦�µI

��±'짿Nì��½�¤^§�¦�îcáý"««,�L²§µI;[Ä�

�3���/"iÅ'��é½�´¥%�µI;[¥+n9;[Ä�XÚ?1

u�§vuyµI;[¥+n9ÙÄ�L§�3¯KµµI;[´UÙ�Å?Ò?

1��ÅÄ�§�ÑXÚgÄÏ�;[�<"¿�§��XÚ?\;[Ä�§>M

¶4gÄC�綧Ä��¤�§¶4gÄw«/µI;[Ä��¤0§Òë;[Ä

�ó�<ÑØ��ÄÑ�µI;[´X§qNo�U�³Q���§iÅ'£

½;[�³¯K�UÑy3�ÑÏ��!"u´§Sü;<÷X>&�´u�§u

Page 322: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 311

y¥mk�?�<���^|�§e¡ë���)èC�"²LÿÁuy§Ä

��µI;[&E§)è�Ò�±�¡Ù6¶ÚéX�ª§�ªy¢µI;[�

�¯�"

2011c§·�É��§�ÜI[Ì+Ü�|ïI[nܵI;[¥§åúµI

;[;�©aÚ+n�{"XÚNÁ�¤�§Ì+XÚï��� ?�¯·µ/f

Ƭ§sw4�ù�µI;[¥2جu);[��j§1�Ñ>{Ò��ÐA

Ü�0·��§m �q/é¨`µ/�w\Ò´lÆ����Å'�§y3�E

⧵I;[Ä�XÚ�½Ø¬k¯K"�µI;[��³kÐõ«å»"0·�X

`µ/·�µI;[§ë\µI@Ac§zgµI(å�§Ñk;[5�·�¡c§

º4·�Ã`��7��{§,��¦�·��¶¡§3eÃÅÒè§s`·3;

[¥�&E�³v�³º0̈ �fé¯çµ/ù�B�s�&E�U@Ò3�¬þ6

D�0·��@�§�/çIÝI½|þÑk<3�¿Â8µI;[�&E§ù�

¥kÝI<§�kçIÝI½|þ��/�^�0§±BÙ3I��Ué�µI

;[§�,�ÝI<¥IJøB|§�,��)·�<�&E"

ù«�{§Ø�3Cc�2��y¢"l2016cå§zcѬk�#¶>{

��·§̀ /�¯s´f��foíº0·�fù¡�Òé�ɧÏ�C�cvk<

¡�·/fo0"�q��§¶i´é�§Ò��/´§sk�o¯Bº0é��

f§p,/£��µ/B�·�k��çI�8�3Ä�;[§�¯Ä�soºs

Uw�·oº0·�w>{Òè´17**mÞ�§Ò��k¯K§Ï��/µI;[¥

+n�{§k;���Å�;[éX§Ø#N^ÃŧcÙ´ÃIJø�°yï

�Òè�ÃÅ�;[éX"Ó�§µI;[&E3¥I(J(½c´���§Ø#

N�f"2ö§·®²�õcØ�µI;[§qNo¬Ä�·�µIQº`²é

�<��´·3�õcc�&E§́ /�^�03½|þéµI;[Q�·u´�

�£ýµ/éØå§ØUw�\�0

ÝI<heé�µI;[�8�§́ �ÂïµI;[§±(�Ù3µI¥�

gC/`{0§? �¥IJø�B"d�§2@�µI;[�½´3ú²!ú�!

�ÆÚJ`/éÝI?1µ"Ú'�ÒØ�½�(§¦�¥m@�ÝI<he

Âï�<§�¬Uìù��K?1µIíº�,ج�@o§́ ÄkEâÃã�y

ÝI<Ã{�GµI;[&EQºÁ��e§{Æ�r�55½3dÑØ+^§q

No�UüX��EâÃã��ÝI<�GçI<�L½µI;[&EQ"éd§

7LN�+ng´§£8çIÝI��5¡8§=rzçI<�æÌNI?§d

çI<��8A:ÚI�§3µI;[¥¥ÀJ¿(½µI§Ï�`�.§�?|

ï�µI;[¥´�«] ¥§́ ÑÖ Ø´�åçI<"

Page 323: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

312 çIæÛYFn

3.Ù¦ÝI<"ÝI<�ÝI<GÏ�Ä:´Ùó�<m�pÙ£§ù3¥

I�<©�¸e´~�§/´éÃ�´*l0§©�Ü©ÝI<GÏÚ¤kÝI<G

Ïü«�/"5¿§Ü©ÝI<GÏ�§¥I(JEäk�½�¿�5§́ J`(

J§�¤kÝI<GÏÝI�§¥I(J´ÝI<mGÏ��©�(J§vk¿�§

$�¬��çI<�Ã"~X§ò�¥Id��§I�3çIæ�?1­:��"

éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~61n�Ê^²(B�§�ÞÊ«�/�ÝI<mG

ÏÝI1�µ�ÝI<�m�ûÝI�d�ÝI©��¢�5SN¶�ÝI<�m

�½¥I<¶�ÝI<�m�½Ü©ÝI<�ïÝI½ö¥I¶�áuÓ�8ì!

�¬!û¬�|�¤�ÝI<UìT|��¦�ÓÝI¶�ÝI<�m�*�¥

I½öü½A½ÝI< æ�Ù¦éÜ1Ä"

13!�/µGÏÝI��/

GÏÝIØ+k=ë�ÌN§�ªINy3ÝI<�ÝI©�§Ï�ÝI©

�´ÝI�Ö¡1N"¢Sþ§½|O\K¡�ü¥�¯�§�¦½|²Eö��

�A�½|O\]�§âU3½|þ²E§=¢�� /́�y�<0�]�½]�+

n"nØþ§½|²EöA�ûJÙ½|O\]�½]�§ØAT4¦</^gC

�]�½]�l¯²E¹Ä"�è�²E�m�´*|§�]�½]�¤��«D

"] §Ñu½Ñ/�¼�|Ã��ÿ§Ò3�½§Ýþr¤½|þ]�½]�

�/^1�"AO´§ÀçIÝI��«iZ�§�´Xd"GÏÝI�Ä:´ÝI

<m½²½V//¤d3�|Ã�ÓN§%N¤m]�½]��/^1�§¢

�´/5�I§3çIÝIiZ¥�Ñ"ù«|Ã�ÓN¦�GÏÝI¤��U"

�«´ÝI</^Ù¦¤�]�½]��I§,�«´ÝI<k1SÜ�û§(

½�gÝI�¥I<Ú�I<§±9�IÖ�¤�¯�§8�Ñ´ÏLÝI<m�

�û�* ¼�¥IÂÃ"

�âÝI©�?�<�ØÓ§GÏÝIkn«�/µ

1.¥I<?�¤kÝI©�"ù´GÏÝI�~��§�´�y¥I<¥I�

­þ��/§ÙÄ:´ÝI<�m®/¤���é�½é�½�f§ÝI<òÝ

II��E��ì!]�yÖ!�1Ú<�Jø�¥I<§d¥I<|�<U

�gGÏÝI�m�?�ÝI©�§2�d�ÝI<XÙ!\i§Ñä{½�L<

Ç��÷Ö�§Ú�µC§3ÝI���mc4��ÝI©��Â/:"

ù«�/§¥I<¬e�åí?�gC�ÝI©�§ÃØ´ÝI�d!ûÖ©

��´Eâ©�§Ñ´¤kÝI©�¥�`�ÝI"Ù¥§ÝI�d´UçI©�

Page 324: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 313

¥5½�µIIOÚ�{¥��dµ"�{§3Ù¦ÝI�d�÷eµ"���`

�d"éA�§Ù¦ÝI©�¥�ûÖ©�½Eâ©�§k¿£/Ñy�$?�

ا�´µI;[�úÒUuy��Ø"? §¥I<4gC�ÝI©�3µI¥

�ѧdµI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<"�ÝI<�ù«GÏÝI�{§�½

§Ýþ¬k�Ù¦ÝI<�½|/�"

[EâIÛÉ��¯] 2005c6�§,½ï�ó§çIÝI+n�ú¿�1�i

Ò<3é��ïÓ¡È28000m2��i¢�óçI�iÒ¥§uy��ÛÉ�¯

�§ÝI¥§T½�[k¶�ïÓ�óè�§ÙÝI©�¥��ó|��O=55�§

©�?�¥Ñy�þ�$?�ا́ ?Û��;��ó<Ñݺ��£"~X§�

ó�{¥"���| �O!ÁG�ó½Â�ëY5UF²þ§Ý$u"e5Co£I

[�ó�Â5�5½�´"þ5Co¤?\ÁG�ó§Ã�þ+nNX�", §c�

UmI�TÝI<¥I�,��16000m2�4â§Ù�ó|��Ok468�§SN

?���!�ó�{Úó²k?§ó§�þ!S�Ú��+nNXè�§��k�

é5§µI�¬��@�Ù�ó|��O�`"

Ó�´�[ÝI<§c�üUÙÝI©�¥��ó|��O?�Y²�É��

o¬ùo�Qº̄ �§1�iÒ<é�Tè��o²n§rü°�ó|��O<

�¦w§̄ ¦´Ø´¦�úi?�§?�Y²No�Éùo�Q"ù o²n�w

Xü°?�Y²�,ØÓ��ó|��O§òþù�x�"ØL§¦���´

(@´¦�úi?�§)º`§1�°�ó|��O´úi� Pó§�?��§

1�°´�c5�� �Æ)?�§²�Øv§EâUå��"

¯�he)§o²n£�úi�1�Uþ̧ð8úi²E!EâÚ)��

�¿Ì�<m¬§3¬þ�d¯�uX?§rEâ��Ïë�(�¦±

��I§7L¯k��¦�Ó¿§�²(w�é�§?��ó|��OØU2��

$?�ا4<�{§K�úi��¬(�"

¢Sþ§To²n3�wXü°�ó|��O�§�½��§@°?�Y²p

��ó|��O´gC<?�§ @°Y²$e��ó|��OØ´gC<?�§

´�I^�"¦é�Ù§ýéØU«@§�U/�á߸é�Üp0§�U£úi?

n"ÄK§��@½GÏÝI§vA��±´�¯§�É�6Ê��ücÝI]�

�1�?v§K�úi�)�"

¥I<?�¤kÝI©�§Ð?´�±rºÝI/¿�0Û³§":´�ز¿

¬��$?�ا�)5çIÝI{¢�^~61o�^�Þ�8«�/§=µ�

ØÓÝI<�ÝI©�dÓ�ü ½ö�<?�¶�ØÓÝI<�÷Ó�ü ½ö

�<�nÝI¯¨¶�ØÓÝI<�ÝI©�1²��8+n¤ÑyÓ�<¶�

Page 325: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

314 çIæÛYFn

ØÓÝI<�ÝI©�É~��§½öÝI�d¥y5Æ5�ɶ�ØÓÝI<�

ÝI©��p·C¶�ØÓÝI<�ÝI�y7lÓ�ü ½ö�<âr=Ñ�§

À�ÝI<�pGÏÝI"�1�iÒÅ��?�ÚÖ¿5½Ù¥14«�/"~

X§2À�5½ØÓÝI<?��ÝI©��¢�5SN�3ü?±þ[!�Ø�

��§@½�GÏÝI�"

5¿§þã@½GÏÝI�/§́ ÑuÝI©���p'�§�éGÏÝI�

Ö¡yâ 5½�§�é�´ÝI¥�$?�ا¿Ø´GÏÝI���"�ó�§

ù8«$?�ØéN´;�§ÝI<���\I?%=جÑy"

2.¥I<��ÝI©�?�"¥I<��ÝI©�?�§=ÝI<ÒÝI�¢

�5SN�û���§U¥I<���?�¿4�ÝI©�§�<!C¾!�µÚ

4���gÕá�¤§ýéجÑy5çIÝI{¢�^~61o�^�Þ�8«

@½GÏÝI��/"

2001c3�§·3�[çIÅ�?�8²n§|���Aó§çI§Ô[ÝI<

��dAO©Ñ"Ù¥§�p�d1450.00��§�$�d860.00��"I.1130.00�

�¥§�p275.00 ��§üÅ��275��§üÅOè80.00��§~¦T�8�3

GÏÝI�/§@��p�d1450.00��Úgp�d1425.00���ÝI<´�I

�§�¦µI�¬?1ÝI©���p'��§�éGÏÝI�yâ"(J§µ

I�¬éØÑ?Ûyây²�gçI�3GÏÝI1�"�c���U§·3½

ï�Ì+Ü��n,���8�çIÃY§� I¬P���·¡c§9�/ºX

·�Ã`µ/fƬ§��\ýp,§þgAó§Ø´\|��çIí§·�ë\Ý

I�0·��§ØÙB�é�í/¯¦µ/s´=[úi�º0¦�`§·�åÒ

´�d1450.00���@[úi"B¯¦µ/þg\�´�I�jº0¦�f§aF)

`µ/شش§ýé´·�gCÝ�I�0·`µ/Ø�U§\�úi��dج�

@o�"0�·Ø&§\�A�8®móï�Ê�õ�§¦�·`¢{µ/ÝIý

´·�gCÝ�§ØL�d´UO<��ê��d�0

ùcïÄçIÝI�ü§·��@�§GÏÝI�¤±uyJ!�?�J�

�ϧ3uGÏÝI´ÝI<m�«he1�§ @½GÏÝI7Lk<yÚÔy"

XJ«@GÏ´��¬¯1�Uå<m�1�§nØþÒجk<y§�ج3Ý

I©�¥3eÖ¡yâ§Ø�ë�GÏÝI�<�m�Y"@o§3ù«�/e§�

?GÏÝI�k�o¿ÂQº�,k¿Â§�´´«�^§Úw{Æ��î§�´

�?ÝI©�1²�@/$?0�GÏÝI1�"ù�´·ùcj±@�§)

ûGÏÝI�/{�03çI<gC Ø31�iÒ��Ï"

GÏÝI¥§d¥I<��Ù¦ÝI<Uì�û���ÝI�d�¢�5S

Page 326: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 315

N§?�ÝI©�k��cJ§Ò´Ù¦ÝI<fl¥I<���§¿�ÜÙÝI

âU¢yQ½�¥I"@o§�´Ñy��½A�Ø�Ü�§$��Ï�ÝI<§Ù

�U¥Iíºd�§�»¥I<GÏÝI�ÙÛ§Ø�½�U¥I"

[GÏ�Y��¯] 2002c10�§,½�¤oÝ]12000���Æ�*ïó§�

ó|�úmçI§�kÔ�ÝI<ÝI"µI�¬�¤µI�§�ÝI<úÙµ

I(J�§ÝI<A ��L�|O¯§Ù¦A[�í��¥IÿÀ<�ÝI<��

L��Xåò"Ø�®§1�iÒÅ��´§°ÑO¯�ÝI<�L"

¯��åϧ3umI�§uyÝI<AÚB�ÝI¼þ§ÝI<¶¡�<��

�XÙqØ��"çI<|�µI�¬;�éùü[ÝI<�ÝI©�?1µ"

Ú'�§uyü[��d�,k�ɧ�Ù�dÖ¥�¤k©Ü©�ó§�d�§

��´�ê:��3ü §��´�ê:��3n "Ù¥§�ê:��3ü �

@°�dÖ§́ 3�ê:��3n ��dÖÄ:þ§U/o�Ê\0�K?1�

�d§ü°ÝI�d©�´É~���"µI�¬û½éÝI<AÚB�ÝI§U

GÏÝI�±Äû"�ÞO¯�ÝI<A��L§�¦çI<)ºÝI<B�ÝI§

��o^¦�úi�¶¡"ÝI´ÝI<gC�¯�§çI<qXÛU)º�ù

�¯Q�ÝI<A��LéçI<��EØ÷¿§�îÄÙ¦ÝI<��LO¯"

ù�¯�%É�?§3uÝI<¶¡ùo­��¯�§ÝI<B3?�ÝI©

��No¬Ñ�Qºù3�nþùØÏB�üc�§ùå¯��ý�ªu2ÑY

¡"¢Sþ§T�8ÝI�§k8�ÝI<�û��§�ÓÝI<AÝI§(�Ù

¥I"�Ù¥§ÝI<C��L£�úi§�Ì+Po®��§Po�|é�ÝI

<AÝI�¯�Äû§̀ µ/³�o�¦�ÝIº·�@¤Æ����!B��~

3�åÕ˧éÙ�0�X§Poq`µ/\3p¡é�[§r¦��I�ᢧù

�4�ÒU¥I"0ÝI<C ��L%+ ¬§�´éÝI<A��L§¡��é

Ø�<?ÝI�d§�¦¦�Jø�e�dÖ§��N��e?1�d"Ó�§q

heé�ÝI<B§¡�¿�ÏÙ?�ÝI©�"ÝI<B�§��´�I§k<�

X?ÝI©�§�I¤Ø¬��©a§ÛW Ø�Q"(J§ÝI<C3�ÏÝI

<B?�ÝI©��§�¿3ÝI¼þòÝI<B�¶¡�¤ÝI<A�¶¡§3

Ù�dÖþ/o�Ê\0��¤�d©�§Ú�µI�¬�¢ü[ÝI<3©Ü

©�ó§þ�d�� ÄûÙÝI�(J"T�8duÝI<C��Y§�ÏÝ

I<A�Ú�ÜݧUCçI�8�¿��Û§µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ

<§QØ´ÝI<A§�Ø�ÝI<C§ ´��vkë�GÏÝI�ÝI<D"

lù�¯��±wѧÝI<mïá3¥I|ÃÄ:þ�é�¿Ø�½éO

�§�û���¥I�Û��U¬Ï�[ÝI<��Y �»"�d§Ø�ÝI<

Page 327: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

316 çIæÛYFn

�m´~c3�åÜ�§/&Å«ì0§ÄK§¥I<��Ù¦ÝI<?�ÝI©�§

Ø�½U¢yÙ¥I�(Û§ù�´½|þ§��oÝI<��¿d¥I<?�Ù

¦ÝI<�¤kÝI©���ϧÏ�ù«GÏÝI�¿��Û§�½¬Uì¥I

<�ÙÛ?1§Ø¬� "

3.�¬1n<��GÏÝI"�¬1n<��ÝI<GÏÝI§́ uù��

¬1n<3çI�8¥�/ Ú�¬K�å§ÝI<�&ù��¬1n<¬�ÏÙ

¼�çI�8�¥I]�§¥I�U.~|GÙ�½�Ð?¤"��/§ù��¬

1n<�U´çI<!¥0Å�¥éçI�8äkû½��<½´I[Å�§�

)�åÅ�!�½�?Å�¥k�½�å½�¬K�å�+�§½´+�±>�

<§�)Ù�á!±>*l½eá"ù«GÏÝI§ëÝI<gCÑØ�¡´3

GÏÝI§=´Ñué�¬1n<��&§UÙ�-ÝI"

3�GÏÝI¯��pu+�§~X§ïÓ!ú´!½�ó§�+�§�+

nÜ�@�æ^�ÅÄ��ª�±)ûGÏÝI¯K"e¡ùK¯�L²§=B´

�ÅÄ�§E,¬u)GÏÝI¯�"

[Ü�~Ò¥��¯] 2019c12�20F§,{u�Jåú��{�ÏÛó§�

�B���,ɪ!GÏÝIY§²�"{�ཧ�û�,�ɪ�!GÏÝI

�§�{�?kÏä-oc§¿?v7<¬126��"

2018c9�18F17�30©N§{ú�] �´¥%Ì?�,Éü ���{ú

SÛ-��è�Y§¡�UþÌ3{�´¥%|�2400�Ý]�{ú´ó§¿I¥§

k146[è�ë�¿I§�mIL§¥§uyy|¦^�Òè¥k<�UÄ!�b,

�"mIL§¥§mÑ�ü�Ò襧��´14Ò§��´26Ò"y|ú«�§ó�

<uyùü�Òè¥�­þ²w'²�^�Ò襭"²Lé�U�ÜÒè¥?

1Ká¢�§2gw«ü¥²w ­§êi/�w«Ø�~§²w�<�ækÔ�"

ó�<á=µ�¤kÒ襧¿31��m�Y"

úSÅ'���Y�§û½áY��"²��§uy{�ÏÛó§�B���

,!�,�ÐÐ�,!Aúi¯� ,ÚBúi<Ü,k��v¦§D��Y�

ÉÕ¯"²LN�§uyù´�å�,°%O��GÏÝI¯�"¦/ÅÜ��´

¥%�ú�²§éX��<��p��çIÒ襧���,d\�´¥%�¥"

mI�§ ,|��úikn[�¤õÄѧ\O7���1440��"Yu�§ú

SÅ'3�,��S�¼Ùl�´¥%���~Ò¥�@"

Y���L§¥§ ,ÌÄuÞ�,�Ù¢ª26��§úSÅ'N��'y

â�§ò�,�vɪ¯K9á�£�{i�¬?�Ú"�§d{u�é�

,9�'<Jåú�"

Page 328: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 317

Ä\~Ò(½¥I<��{ØáuçIÝI�{§�Ø´çIæÔÑA�¦

^��{§Ï�§´³/<�/$í0(½�8«@]� Ø´¥I(J§Ø´�

«²L5K"��<%r§w�´�«/ú²!ú�0�{�§±��±{zçI

ÝI��¡§�»ÝI<GÏÝI�ÙÛ"éd§·��±�é¿�§�Ï3uÄ

\~ÒØ´²L5K§́ 3��½|²L5Ƨ́ �?½çI<Ø��!B(B�

�Ly"

ùåÜ�~Ò¥¯�2gL²§Ä\~ÒØ�Ul��þ)ûÝI<�GÏÝ

I¯K§Ï�/�p�º! p�à0§üX3�´/ªþ�UCØ�Uý�)ûG

ÏÝI�S%��§7L3gÆ�¡\±Ú�"Ó�§é�+�ZÜÚ�¯<1

�\±î��å"éd§5¥I��VÆ?©^~6¥§é��í'VÆ1��Ñ

²(?©5½"~X§é�+�ZÜ|^��½ö�Öþ�K��¦<*�|

çpN!%N�<��ó!få9Ù�ó��áÚÙ¦A½'X<ÂÉé�ãÔ§

�p|^��½ö�Öþ�K�*�h|§½�é�9Ù�ó!få9Ù�ó��

á!�>ó�<ÚÙ¦A½'X<*�|Ãt���´�§5½��´w½öî

­´w?©¶�!�­�§����S�Ö½ö3w?©¶�!î­�§�

�mØ7?©�"

14!��µGÏÝI���

GÏÝI����ϧ3uë�<rçIÝI¹ÄÀ��|iZ§rçIÝI

{Æw�iZ5K§ë�<UiZ5K1¯ �Ñ{Æ�î�5§ùA�´{Æ�

�H"�1�Ì+Ü�!/��?QÁãUC�´1N§~X§��çI<��L

ë�µI§Ú\>fçIÝI�´XÚ½æ^Ä\~Ò(½¥IÿÀ<½¥I<§

\�éGÏÝI1���?Ú�Âåݧ±Úw{Æ��î"�¢�L²§�´/

ª½1N�UC§éGÏÝI£nwqk¤��¢KÂ�$�§Ï�/ª½1NØ

´ÝI§Ø�U)ûGÏÝI�¢�§Ù���U´uyGÏÝI3/ª½1N�

¡Ñy��$?�Ø"@o§qA�XÛ)û½��GÏÝIQºÙ��3u£

8çIæ�Щ§=²Lm�§òÙ��½|þ�«/`���0�g,{K§±

íÄ�¬?ÚÚuÐ"L13.1¥§éØÓ;��çI�8GÏÝI�/�J`é'

?1ÚO©Û"

1.çIæn5£8"çIæ´²LJ`Ôѧ́ u�½|¿�3] ��

¥�û½5�^§̀ z] ��"@o§çIÝI´÷*²L1��´�«�*²

L¹ÄQºÄk§çIæ´�*²L¥��«�¤ÀJ1�"��o`çIæ

Page 329: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

318 çIæÛYFn

´�«�*²L¹ÄQº·���§½|²L���«²L|�/ª§d½|ÌN!

½|�N!�´1NÚ½|{5����¤"çIÝI���«½|J`Å�§́

çI<�æI¦ÚÝI<ø�G¹?1ÀJ§J`(½¥I(J¿�¥I<\¾

Ö¡ÜÓ!Á� ¢yæm�����*²L¹Ä§́ u)3çI<�¥I<m

��O�´§¿Ø�9I¬²Loþ!I¬²L�¤!��uÐ�ã���(�!²

LuЧÝ�÷*²L¯�½�I"ùp§çIÝI´�«5�Å�§k/½|½

>fçIÝI�´²�´�´«1N§±øçI<ÚÝI<\|�´§çI�8´

çIÝI�´��N"3ù«¿Âþ§çIÝI{9�'{Æ{5§́ �ï5�k

S�çIÝI½|5K¶Ùg§çIÝI���«5�Å�½�{§¿vké½�"

üXïÄçIÝI§¢�þ´3ïÄ�«5��{§¿vk²LÆ¿Â"ù��´

�ã�m±5§ISéçIÝIÅ�@£þ���Ø«"Nõ<�Ø/±�§��

UçIÝI5�5K§\rçIÝIL§��§Ò�±u�çIÝI3`z] �

�þ��^§? Ø�\ïÄçIæ�²Lm�"ù3�½§ÝþE¤çIÝ

Ir§S!rL|§¦çIÝIüC��«{Æ�æe�/iZ0Å�§ù´ISç

IÝI��H"

çI+� GÏÝI J`�{ �Ï©Û

ó§

t 4�

nܵ©{

;�¿�²w

;�¿�²w

;�¿�f§J`زw

;�¿�f§J`زw

;�¿�²w

J`��²(

;�¿�²w

;�¿�²w

J`��²(

J`��ز(

�O 4�

in k

�ó

4�

p

4�

�� 4�

A«á� 4�

nܵ©{/�$µId{

nܵ©{

4� �$µId{ÊÏá�

k nܵ©{

ó§±�ÀÔ4� �$µId{ J`��²(

k nܵ©{ J`��ز(

J`��ز(ó§±�ÑÖ k nܵ©{

L13.1 ØÓ;��8GÏÝI©Û

Page 330: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 319

@o§A�XÛr¦çIæn5£8ÙЩQºÄk§I3�Ì�*²L5

ÆcJe§�ïçIæ²LnØ"5¿§çIæ´±ÝI¿��Ä:§±¢y

æ(J`z�m��²L1�§ÙnØ7,´3yk²LnاX�*²LÆ!

+nÆ!Æ�Ø!̀ znØ�Ä:þõÆ�nÜ���Ô"¢Sþ§5çIÝI{6

1o��^5½�(½¥I(J�K�Ò´��²LJ`5K"T^5½§¥I<

�ÝIA�ÎÜe�^���µ�U���Ý/÷vçI©�¥5½���nÜ

µdIO¶�U÷vçI©��¢�5�¦§¿�²µ"�ÝId��$§�´

ÝId�$u¤��Ø"ùp§ÃØ /́���Ý/÷v0� /́²µ"�ÝId

��$0§Ñ´�«²LJ`§́ k�I¦8I!õø�^�e�êÆ`z¶Ùg§

3çIæ²LnØ��e§|�ÝI¿�§¢yæ(JJ`§Ï���='5

çIÝI5�§S½/ª§�ѲLJ`�çIÝIÒ´iZ§Ã{l��þ)û

GÏÝI¯K"

Ó�§dL13.1ÚO�(J��±wѧ�çI�8;�¿�²w�§ÃØæ

^nܵ©{�´�$µId{§ÝI<��جGϧÏ�/ÛÀ�Ø0¶�Ý

I;�¿�زw�§æ^�$µId{�جGϧÏ�çI<�J`��²(¶

æ^nܵ©{�¬ÑyGÏÝI§Ï�J`��ز(§cÙ´ó§�óçI"

2.çI<�g·�å"çI<�ÝI<Gϧ́ GÏÝI��¯K§Ù¯K�

��E´çI<ÌNI?Øá¢��Ï"�þ�GÏÝI¯�§��ÑkçI<½

�nÅ�ó�<�Kf§��´��çI<½�nÅ�Ì+<�%N§3ç

I�8¿�Ï�ÚJ`IO��þ§k|uGÏÝI¥I"�d§�ïk��<

g·�åÅ�§́ l Þþ)ûGÏÝI���"ù�¥§�)µ

1¤+�ZÜ1�OKÚVÆ�å"+�Zܧ�)Ù�<9Ù�ó!få9Ù

�ó��áÚÙ¦A½'X<��{Æ!{59Ù¦�ü55½½öƯ5K�§

|^����'Ü�!Å�½<æ�V«!Ç¿!�ç�!1^f!�½!r-�

�ª§Zý½�ÃçIÝI¹Ä§́ çI<�ÝI<GÏ� Þ§7L��k�£

n"é+�ZÜ9Ù�ó!få9Ù�ó��áÚÙ¦A½'X<3çIæ�{

�5�V1��£nØ%§��¡3uÙg·�å§,��¡3uiÒ§3uæ^

EâÃã§rÙ�«!V«!Ç¿!�ç�!1^f!�½Úr-�1��u�1

e§Ö¡3è§�É�¬9óiÒ"

2¤ó�<1�OKÚø¨Å�"ùp�ó�<§�)çIæ��I?<

!m�I?<Ú��ó�<"�©ØÓk �¾ó�<3çIæ¥�1

�OK§�)ÙA¦�æI?!�ü S!<�>!�ÏOK!P¹Ú��«

ì�"~X§5½çIúwuÙ�¥I(J(½�mã§çIæó�<Ø�h

Page 331: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

320 çIæÛYFn

e�>d3ÝI<9Ù|³'X<"7L�>�§�uúm|Ü�kü<±þ3|

�y§̄ ��¤¿\Ý�#¹�§òó�<�9çIæ�1��u�1e§�

É�¬9Ù¦ó�iÒ"

�õ�1�OKÚø¨Å�§r+�ZÜ9Ù�ó!få9Ù�ó��áÚÙ

¦A½'X<§±9ó�<�9çIæ�1��u�1e§́ )ûçI<¥�

,<�ÝI<Gϧ?1g·�å���"éA�ø¨Å�§́ Ù1�ÎÜ�

¦��æ§=��1�OK�1��²y¢§�{�5�Vé�¯<?1?v§�

ö?1VÆ?©§X´w!v±!ü?!��½´Nló�k �§­ömØü !

å�§JÄÙ-¯I?�"

3¤éçI�nÅ�<�1��å"çI<�÷�nÅ�çI§¿�´�÷ç

I�gÃØ+§EIéçIÝI¥�'�¯�¦�¦I§Ï�çI<L«úçIæ

(J�I?"ù�¥§�´çI<ÀJ�nÅ��§I�éçI�nÅ�+n�

ݱ9éçI�n(J��UK�!�8²n�;���!�1Ú����!ÏÃ

Uå�?1©ÛÚÀJ§�¦çI�nÅ�Ò�n1�§�)çI�nÅ�óÚ

�8²n�1��Ñ«ì§\Ý1��åÖ¶�´éçIÝI¹Ä¥�'�¯�¦

�¦I§�)µ�JøO(ÃØ�æI¦¶�éçI©��"�§AO´çI©

�^±�Ü{5!]�^�!ÜÓ^�ÚµIIO��{§©ÛÙéæ(J�K

�"ÎÜçIæÔÑ¢y�§(@çI©�"ÄK§A�¦çI�nÅ�?1Ö

¿!?UÚ�õ¶�ë�y| t!ÝIý�¬§±�yÝI<)Á�^�¶�Ñ

RmI¬§±(�mIÜ{k�§(�mIP¹ÎÜ�¦¶�ë�µI§(�µI

�¬UçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§±9¥I

ÿÀ<´Ü��§́ UçI©�5½�J`Ï�Ú�{?1�J`í�¶��Éç

I�nÅ�=��µI�¬�¤�µI�w§é�w?1(@"(@L§¥§u

yµI(JØÎÜçIÝI{D�µI�¬�I�§A��¦çI�nÅ�|�

µI�¬Ø�"7��§�{?U½­#|ïµI�¬µI¶�éçI�nÅ

�åú�¥IÏ�Ö!¥I(JÏ�ÖÚÜÓ�?1"�§(@ÃØ�\XçI<

ü Ù¶�"�¿�ÂçI�nÅ�J��çIÝI¹Ä�Y�"ù�¥§Ø�~

éçI�n��Ö�å§Ó�I�åçI�nÅ���8²n�<Ø��ÝI

<9Ù|³'X<he�>½l¯Ù¦�U�³çI<�Ã�1�"7��§éç

I�nÅ�<�Ø�1��±J«!I-U�½�¦��!��²L��!)Ø

çI�nÜÓ�"

3.GÏÝI��Eâ"çI<�ÝI<GÏ��¯K)û�§��GÏÝI3

Eâ�¡éN´¢y"ù�¥�Ø%§3u£8çIæ/`���0�²L��§

Page 332: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 321

?1J`��"

1¤î�]�"�"]�"�§/ªþ´"�ÝI<�ÝI]�§¢�´éÝI

<Á�Uå�"�"ÝI<|�GÏÝI��Äuü«�ϵ�´çI<�,<

Ïɪ½�ÝI<��¬'X§heNìÙ¥I¶�´çI�8´ÝI<g@�

�³å����§F"|��û(½¥I<Ú�I<"�d§GÏÝI�û�)�

¥I<§Á�UåØ�½ÎÜçI�8I¦§Ø�½U¢yçIæ(J"î�]

�"�§�´�\r]�"�§(�ÏL]�"��ÝI<Á�UåÎÜçI�8

I¦"�d§çI<I�UçI�8A:Ú¢SÁ�I¦§(½]�"�Ï�!IO

Ú^�§î�éÝI<?1]�"�¶�´á¢¥I<�Á�Uå"éµI�¬

í��¥IÿÀ<§çI<A(Ü¢SG¹§éÙÁ�Uå2g(@"7��§A

|�é¥IÿÀ<ÝI©�Oy���!��!<Ú�1?1¢/Eا±(�

Ùý�ä�çI�8�Á�Uå"

2¤�pÝI�d"ÝI<�Ù¦ÝI<!çI<½´µI�¬¤?1G

ÏÝI�´Ñy�1�§́ ò�¥Id§�{¼���|d"ùAT´GÏÝI�

~�§=¥I<I�<Ñ�½�¤^éÙ¦�I�ÝI<Ö�§�he�ÏÙ¥I

�<Ð?"Ó�§¥I<gC��¼��½���|d"@o§XÛ��GÏÝI

ò�IdQºé{ü§çI<�±���pÝI�d"�pÝI�d�LXçI<

ÒçI�8U|G�¤^�ݧaquï<Ãp�aê"ÝI�d�ÑçI

<Ã¥�aê§Á�(J2ÐçI<�Ãa|G"ùl½|�´w§Îܽ|ú²

�´�K"éd§5çIÝI{¢�^~61��Ô^²(5½§çI<�k�pÝ

I�d�§A�3çI©�¥²(�pÝI�d½ö�pÝI�d�O��{"@

o§�pÝI�dA�No��Qºkn«�{§�´^æý����pÝI�

d¶�´|�½|N�§̂ ½|N�d���pÝI�d¶n´±ÝI�d��ë

ìÔ(½�pÝI�d"~X§±ÝI�d��â²þê½´�$ÝI�dþ2�

½�Ý���pÝI�d�"

5¿§þ¡�1¤Ú2¤́ ½|¤kæOK§=æ<�ý�v±|G¤�<§

¤�<Á�Uå÷v�¦§́ ��GÏÝI��$8I"

3¤æJ`"çIæ�Ø%3u|�ÝI¿�§GÏÝIK´�ÝI¿��

|ï"@o§��oGÏÝI�±¢y�çI�|ïQº�Ï3uçI<|��Ý

I¿�Ø´²LÆ¿Âþ�¿�§J`��½IOز§́ 3r/ª!rL|½�

iZ§ÙâÑLy3uéÝI�d�µ"Ú'�"

[�d&f��¯] 1997c8���U§·��3�[Ik�óè�l¯Eâ+

n§?�ÝI�ó|��O§�Üúi²EÜ�ÝI��]�8"mIc�U§�

Page 333: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

322 çIæÛYFn

ú¿Ï�ë�ÝI�<�þ7:30©m¬§²n�f�®�§u�ÝIO��¹"

¬Æ�²n����9:30©âðm"��²n÷òÏù/r?¬Æ¿§�wÒ

´3¡�¦<ÕË"¦�>ÄXë§�>fXÝIEâ|!�d|ÚûÖ|�

®�"·®��ó|��O�é{ü§Ï�²n´ÆïÓ²L�§é�óEâØ´

S1"·®��§¦$XÞ§¦§ÄXë§�Ø�{§·^éá��m®�ó§?

Ý�äOy!óÏÚ'�!:��§A©¨Ò�¤Eâ|®�§�3�>fÙ¦

|�®�"�d|� Ó¯®�`§²L�d|Ê<O��ÊU§®o��ó§

Ed´1352.00��"ù�§��¦�/�åÞ§̄ µ/´õ�º0@ Ó¯q`�

Hµ/1352.00�"0¦`µ/��j§´Ø´k¦�Bº�����0�d|�A�<

`;�£��ú¿§�mã�ÚO�úvØé�d�8"��õ���§A�<£

�¬Æ¿�¦®�µ/vk¦�B"0ù�§¦qu{µ/´Ø´Ìá½|Îd�§r

dÎ$§No�@oõQ§2��0A Ó¯2g£��ú¿Ø�§qL��õ

��£�¬Æ¿�¦®�`µ/Ìá�d´½|Îd(Ü&Ed��§Ø$B"0ù

�¦`¢{µ/\���·8U�ò��oùoùíº·8U�þ�<Õü|

˧wwO<��d´õ�§NoO<��d'4�pAz�Qº�[�Ñ�E

d´1586.90�§�k�[´1645.60�§\�gCww§�õ��0A�<�w§X

�Øcó�§Ù¥��ÿf�:�§�²n?óµ/Po§�Øs½�êj§s´

�1[B"0¦`µ/Ðj§·T��e§4�Ò�1616.00 �§\�O�ÝI©�

�j�0A�<Xº­K§U1616.00 ����d?�ÝI�d©��"@o§²

n��oû�U1616.00���dQºÏ�çI©�5½§µIÄOd´ÝI�d�

�â²þê�60%+I.�40%§�d �Ç3µIÄOd�[0§-1%]��©�p"

ùc·��3g�§ÝI<GÏ�µ"Ï�´�o§�,´ÝI�d§Ï�

ÝIEâ©�!ûÖ©�¥�]�!�1!<ÚJ�ø��§��vk�UGÏ"

@o§é�d�µ"¥§��oæ^�d��â²þê�§ÝI<�¿GÏÝIºÏ

�ù«J`�{Ø´²LJ`§ ´�«/¥T0?­óÆ3µ"�dþ�A^§́

�«%nþ�S¤ÀJ"±þ¡ùK�¯�~§úiEd<�Ñ��d1352.00�

�§�,�d��!d�·¥�¥ØI§Ï�l²þ���§ÙÚ��§T´GÏ

ÝI§Ï�3ù«�/e§�kGÏÝIâ´¥I�­þ§ÝI¤��$��{"

aq/§ÝI<�µI�¬¤GÏ�µ"Ï�´�oº�,´Ì*µ"Ï

�§AO´@«æ^©êµ��Ì*µ"Ï�§Ï�¥I<�&/`\1\Ò1Ø

1�10��n"3ù«�/e§ÝI<�½k�µI�¬¤GÏ�¿�§�

êµI¤�¬/Å�ÝI<Gϧ�{¼�µIÂÃ"@o§́ Ä�±òçI�

8�µ"Ï��Ü�*z§? �ØÝI<�µI�¬¤GÏ1�Qºù=U

Page 334: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 323

w�´�«n��XJU¢y§½ö`¤k�µ"Ï�Ñ�±½þz§Ò�d>

M��O�Ñ(J ÃI2|ïµI�¬éÝI?1µ""�ù«�{q£�

²LÆ¥/Äê�^b�nØ0��اÏ��õêµ"Ï��U�é'�§ØU

ýéþz§ùÒ´µI�¬�3�d�"�d§��µI�¬¤�ÝI<G

ϧØ3uo�/�¦µ"Ï��Vþz§@´Ø�U���¯�§ A�´òÌ

*µ"Ï��µ"§d½þU�½5µ"ÚüS§ùâ´²LÆ¥�J`g�§=

£8�/Sê�^b�nØ0"

nþ¤ã§3Eâ�¡��GÏÝI���§3uJ`§3uçI©�¥5½

�µIIOÚ�{´�«J`§ùÒ£��Ö16Ù13!?Ø�üÏ�ÚõÏ�

J`�{"5¿§çIÝI¢Sþ´�«õÏ�J`�¦§üÏ�J`�,{ü§

´uö�§�%´�ïéÙ¦Ï��J`§½´<�b�µ"Ï�m�3½þ'

X¶õÏ�üS{�Ø%§3u(½µ"Ï��mÚz�µ"Ï�ØÓ�/m�S

'X§? aquc$øý��üS�{§éÝI�`�'�nÜüS"Ù¥§n

ÜüS´ÝI(J�üS§́ çI<J`(½¥I(J��â"

��/§µ"J`�Ú½Xeµ

11Ú. ÐÚµ""éÝI©�?1/ªµ"!]�µ"Ú�A5µ""Ù¥§

]�µ"�Ø%§3u(@ÝI<¥I�Á�Uå§�Aµ"�¢�´(@ÝI´

ÄÎÜæI¦"�ó�§ÏLÐÚ"��ÝI§ÙÁ�(JÎÜæI¦§=

÷vþ¡1¤Ú2¤��¦"

12Ú. �["�"�["��¢�§́ (½ÝI©�þ1²�éAuçI©�

¥5½�µ"Ï��ÝI(J§�nÜüS�O�"7��§UçI©�5½��

{éµ"Ï�?1þz"

13Ú. nÜüS"UçI©�¥1²�µ"Ï�S'X!üS�{ÚÝI<é

µ"Ï��ÝI(J§?1nÜüS"Ù¥§éÌ*µ"Ï�§̈ 3�p'�!½5

µ"�Ä:þ§U`u½����üS§Ø¨|�½þµ""7��§dµI�

¬8N?اû½Ì*µ"Ï��üS(J"

14Ú. J`(½¥I(J"çI<UìÝI�nÜüS(J§J`(½¥I(

J§=U`�gSü��§(½ü¶3c�ÝI�¥I(J"

çIæ´J`�§çI<ÃI2�ÄÝI<m�GÏÝI§�Ø^ú%ÝI

<�µI�¬¤�GÏÝI"3ù«�/e§ÌÄ�3çI<§��çI<9

²�+n!$EÅ�Ø�ÝI<�³Ù¦ÝI<¶¡§ÝI<m=B�3GÏ�´

ÛÜGϧ��Ø�½U¥I§g,Ò�»ÝI<m�he�½§Ï�¥I<I

�|G�I<�½¤^"Ó�§�)ûÝI<ÚµI�¬¤GϯK§=Ý

Page 335: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

324 çIæÛYFn

I<U¥I§�½´ÙÝI�`"XJØ´§ ´µI�¬¤��çI©�

¥5½�µIIOÚ�{3éÙµ"§áuµI1��{§K�µI(J�§µI

(JÃ�§�±­#|�µI�¬éÙµ"Ú'�§Å�µI(J§�{µI�

¤�{É�?v"

[�£I] GÏÝI§�ÝI<�ÝI<!ÝI<�çI<�ó�<�m§½

öÝI<�µI�¬¤�m§æ�Ø��Ãã§éçIÝI¯�?1Gϧ±

ü@¿�éýö�³I[|Ã!�¬ú�|ýö¦<Ü{�Ã��«he�*

1�§´�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|¥�«I�­:£n��{1�"

15!Y~µGÏÝI3Ä:�ó¥wuY

GÏÝI´ISçIÝI5�¥���%�"¢�u��2y¢§GÏÝII

�1�iÒ\��?åݧ�XJMF"u1�iÒÜ�éGÏÝI��? éÙ

�£§́ Øy¢�"��¡§çIÝI¥�3�þ�GÏÝI¯�§�Ø�´ÝI

¥Ñy��$?�ا½�¯<�û���Q�|Ã�çy /¶pÌ0§é�¯

<�{�?�¿Øõ�§Ï�GÏÝIuyJ�?�J§JÒJ3GÏÝI´�¯

<�he�´§�¼�-<&Ñ�yâJ", §ù«�/�çI�8�Á��

ãKk¤UC§d�éN´uyGÏÝI¯�§�éN´Â8<y!Ôy"l�o

½|�´�Sw§k<ÞyGÏÝI§��yâ(=§1�iÒÅ��½��{é

�¯<?v"�¯K3u§1�iÒ3�?GÏÝI�Ó�§I�u?gC3éç

IÝI1�iÒL§¥vkuyGÏÝI§́ Ä�3��1�"¤±§Á�L§¥§

1�iÒÅ���ج2'5�8çIÝI¥´Ä�3GÏÝI"�¯K�'�3

u§çI<uy¥I<3ÝI¥�3GÏÝI¯K§�8®3Á�§́ Ä�k7�

JÄ¥I<�GÏÝII?"l�o½|�´�SÑu§d�çI<A�Þy§�

¦1�iÒÅ�é¥I<�GÏÝI1��{�?"�JÄ¥I<�GÏÝII?

�½k|uçI<¢yæ(Jí§k|u�oI[|ÃÚ�¬ú�|Ãíº�Y

´Ø�½§ù´��vk½Ø�¯K§'�wJ¯<´Õ3/ªú��´Õ3çI

æ²Lm�þ"XJ´Õ3çIæ²Lm�þ§�Yé²(§=JÄ�´ØJ

Ä¥I<�GÏÝI1�§'�3u´Äk|u¢yçIæ(J"

[Y�£�],Ý]8ì3�^ôàþÝ]20·�,ï�¤Y>Õ§u2015c9�

|��ó§�óçI§Ô�ÝI<ÝI"²µI�¬µ"§í�,ó§ÛAúi

�1�¥IÿÀ<"çI<(½Aúi¥I§u10�þÍ�Ù\¾�óÜÓ§Ù

þ1²��Æ)ûå»´V�lÐ�û¶�ûؤ�§þã�8¤3/k+`��

Page 336: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 325

<¬{��û"Aúiu10�eÍ?\�óy|§�¤O�ó��§u10�eÍm

óï�"d�§à��Åì?\ YG!"

2016c1�§�ó?0.00±e�Y>Ä:ó§L§¥§âu¬ó�+e¯�§E

¤n�õ<Éú"¯��åϧ´�óy|S�ü�¬óèÏ�ó�8Úu�Ƨ

V��ؤÚ) u)�Ì"¬ó�3N�§Ã¥<kóä§y|�e�·Ï|¡

�� �"�´�§́ �ÑÄA��´§���e§�d�®²kn�õ<

Éú§y|�¡H,"́ �D�8��ÞO¯�¬ó§�éù8�¬óæ�Õ

35F�?v"�/�?ï�Ì+Ü���óü e�Êó-§�¦�óü |�

�U�Eó"̄ �3�/�¬E¤��K�"

�e¯�þ��Ý]8ìoܧA oà3�ú¬þ��@�§¬óèÏ�s

�ó�8�e§̀ ²�óü +n·Ï§�8²ny|�N!��Uå�§î­K�

Ikè�3�ê¬x/«��¬/�§A��¦�óü )ûÐÉú¬ó���

Úõ�¯K§2��[�ó+nUår�è�?|�ó"�±�ond�¦�óü

 ò|§üX±+nØõ¬ó�e�díºq�Ø¿©��3ù��ÿ§�e¥

Éú<�õ�@����óÞÏ%¥�ز§é�ï�ü 7y|��8²n§¡

é��e�¬óè´T�óü � Bo�'Xr§�ó¥~~É�ÙØ�"/·

w�sù[�óü ´No¥Iù��8�j§´�,n[è�GÏÝI¥�

I�0§�óÞ��`Ñ@n[ë�GÏÝI�ü ¶¡"Ó�§�w��8²n§

T�óü �Âï� ë�µI�;[§¡ù ;[3Â�µIÏ��§QÌÄ

�>{�¦éX§¦�ù ;[¯L�§́ ù �óÞm��x�¨§/Ø&§s�

�±�¦��ÝI©�ÚµI�w0"

T�8²n£�8ìúioÜ�§NÑT�óü Ú�uÞ�,n[ë�G

Ï�ÝI<�ÝI©�ÚµI�¬�¤�µI�w§|�dA �Ö<|¤�

"��|§�p'ì"�"uyo°ÝI©��(�3GÏÝIè,§AO´3�

ó|��O��þó§!g5·vè!��!|e��ó�{!�þ�y��ÚS�

����¥§�pm�3o�8ã�©iA���§k�����"âd§�Ö<

@��±�½ÝI©�É~��§�±@½o[ÝI<GÏÝI"Ó�§uy�ó

ÞuÞ�@ ;[§3µI¥(¢�3�T�óü �p©�¹"~X§çI©�

¥5½§éÌ��ó�{µ©«m[6,15]!S�����µ©«m[0,2]Ú?ÝOy�

��µ©«m[0,3]§�TµI;[éÙÝI�g�Ñ�µ"(J´15©!2©Ú3©§

K�µ©®o(J"

"��|@��óÞÞ�¯Kᢧþ�8ìoà�ú¬�«é�óü �?

n"T�8Ï�?3à� YG§�´só���Ï"oà�ú¬��úiVu

Page 337: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

326 çIæÛYFn

iÚ�8+nÜÌ�KI<ë\"¬þÑyü«ØÓ�¿�µ

¿�1µ)ØÜÓ"òÂ8��<yÔyþ�1�iÒÜ�§�{éT�óü

 Ú@ µI;[?1?v§\Ù¥IÃ�§�Ù)ØÜÓ�|��|§­#çI

(½�óü �2�ó"

¿�2µÁ1ÜÓ"�¦�óü 9�éT�8+n�Ñ�U§N�!¿¢�

8+nåþ§þ��/�?9�Eó§rÊó����£5"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±e¯Kµ

1."��|@�o[ÝI<GÏÚ¥I<�@ µI;[GÏ�yâ§���

½GÏÝI��{Ìyâ§{̴Ĭæ&ùyâºÓ�§1�iÒÅ�´Ä¬

?v@ µI;[ºçI<UÄ3çI©�¥�ÑùÌ*µ"Ï��©�«m

�1-1éA'Xº��oº

2.¿�1Ú¿�2éTY>�8�ï�K�´�oºé�¬K�q´�oº

3.XJ´ù[Ý]8ìoà§sÀJ¿�1�´¿�2º̀ Ñnd"

[Y~©Û] �âY�£�§éþãn�¯K©ÛXe:

1.Äk§"��|@�o[ÝI<�GÏyâ§=o°ÝI©�3�ó|��

O��þó§!g5·vè!��!|e��ó�{!�þ�y��ÚS����

�¥§�pm�3o�8ã�©iA���§k�����§Øv±���½ÝI

<GÏÝI��yâ§=ü³ù�ó|��O��ã½Aã©i��ØU�½Ý

I©�´É~��"~X§2+3=5§ÝI©�Ñ�2+3=5§��§NoU@�´GÏ

ÝIQ§Ï�2+3Ò´�u5§=�(�ÒAT��§ØáuÉ~��§Ø��Ø�

�§Ï���(�Y��§ �Ø�YZZ�§ùÒ´��oISk��°5½Ø

ÓÝI<?��ÝI©��¢�5SN�3ü?±þ[!�Ø���§@½�GÏ

ÝI�nd"ùp�/ÝI©�É~��0´��Vǯ�§=ØÓÝI<�ÝI

©��~�¹ØA����Ñy����/"~X§,�ÝI<;k��1!;

|!Eâ!I£���"é�ó|��OÑy�Ó�ãI[IO!5�½5§5½

��é��§½´ëìÓ��>f��ó|��O ?��ÝI�ó|��O§�

3ãá�q½�Ó�§ÑØv±@½ÝI<´Gϧ�U´~¦§I�Ù¦<y!Ô

y�yGÏÝI1�"

Ùg§1�iÒÅ�ýجϵI;[é¥I<�ó|��O¥�Ì��ó�

{!S�����Ú?ÝOy���§UçI©�¥�µ©«mþ�µ©15©!2©

Ú3©�K�µ©®o(J ?v@ µI;[§Ï�ù«1�¿ØU@½�{§1

�iÒÅ�qXÛéù ;[�µI1�?1?v"

�,§çI<XJ3çI©�¥5½Ì��ó�{!S�����Ú?ÝO

Page 338: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 327

y�����©«m�1-1éA'X µI;[áØ�1§��éÙµ"��p�

©§1�iÒÅ��{AI-µI;[U�§éÙ?11�?v§Ï�ÙvkUç

I©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"y3�¯K´§çI

<UÄ3çI©�¥�ÑÌ*µ"Ï��©�«m�1-1éA'X§�,´ØU§X

JçI<U�Ñù«éA'X§qÛLµI�¬¤éÙ�ÑÌ*�äQ�ù�

�´Ì*µ"Ï� /́Ì*0�§I�µI�¬¤éÙ�ÑÌ*�ä��Ï"

@o§��oØUéù«Ì*µ"Ï�?1þzµ"Qº�Ï3u§<aég

,@£þ�Û�5§=B<aé,�ag,¯Ô�ѽþ�x§@�´<agC

éÙ�@�§¿Ø�½´Ù�5¡8"ù3óÆþ§Ò´Pf35��²6m��

/���§�~�¶¶�¶§�~¶0�¹Â¶3²LÆþ§/Sê�^nØb�0�

�/Äê�^nØb�0�N�§�´<aéû¬�^@��ù«<y"ù3�½

§ÝþL²§µIIOÚ�{¥�Ì*µ"Ï��3�7,5§=çI<Ø�Uò

¤kµ"Ï�þ5½��*µ"Ï�§ I�µI�¬¤u�;�`³§éÌ

*µ"Ï�?1�ä�ÀJ"

2.¿�1´òçI<Â8��<yÔyþ�1�iÒÜ�§�{éT�óü 

Ú@ µI;[?1?v§\Ù¥IÃ�§? ��óü )ØÜÓ§­#çI(

½�óü ?|�ó§éTY>Õï��K�©ÛXe:

Äk§1�iÒÅ�UÄ@½o[ÝI<GÏÝIQºXþ¡©Û�§1�i

ÒÅ��â"��|Jø�yâ§ÿØv±@½ÝI<mGÏÝI§�Øv±@½

¥Iü �@ µI;[GÏ"U¥IÃ�)ØÜÓ�g´§çI<I�UYÂ8

GÏÝI�yâ§y²¥Iü 3ÝI¥�3GÏÝI�¯¢§Uì5¬{;6o

K?1�zÊ�n^5½§�¦<¬{��?ÜÓÃ�"ù�¥�3�Ø%¯K§

E´<¬{�UÄ@½çI<Â8�GÏÝI�<yÔy"

Ùg§çI<�¥I�óü \¾ÜÓ§=L²V�´�«Ü�'X"çI<

���¦1�iÒÅ�½ö<¬{�@½½�½¥Iü 3ÝI¥´GÏÝI§¥

IÃ�? ÜÓÃ�§³7�»ù«Ü�'X"¥Iü �³7¬ânå�§Jø

<yÔy§y²Ù3ÝI¥Ø�3GÏÝI1�"ÃØ1�iÒÅ��@½�´<

¬{���û(J§́ =���§Ñ¬K��Á�"V�XJ�1�z§çI<l4

��G�@�Uå§�8Á�ÒLÊ� Ò/µ�§��{��"(J�\�§�

«�/´çI<��¥I<}�§¥I<�{É�1�Ú-¯?v§çI<�{­

#(½�[�óü ?|�ó¶,�«�/´¥Iü �� çI<}�§¥Iü

 ­#Á�"ÃØ´=�«�/§çI<�¥I�óü �/Ü�0ØE�3§qX

ÛUk�¢yçIæ(Jºùq£��Öc¡ùL�Á�¥ÜÓ)Ø�Ä�

Page 339: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

328 çIæÛYFn

�K§=5¬{;6oK?1�zo�l^�1�zÊ�^5½�§��½ö1n

<±ÐÀ!�½Ãã,¦é�3��ý¢¿g��¹e¾áÜÓ���§½´ÜÓ�

��¯<ÃUåUYÁ1½´Ø�¿UYÁ1ÜÓ�§ÌÜ)ØÜÓ§�{«úÏ

ÜÓ)ØE¤���"

¿�1éT�8ï����K�§́ ÜÓV�ÏGÏÝI��Æ E¤çI�

8ò´Á1Úeó�Göò"U�á"��mO�§�"\�I�8����m§ç

I<����¹e­#çI§�¯3l�°|�¥Iü ?|�ó"d�§®Ø´Y

>�8Ä:�ó��ZG! ´öYpuG!§Û!çI�8�Á�(J�¢y"

Ó�§ÏV�ÜÓ)Ø��ƧY>ÕòÏeó§çI<��²L�����´l

��òÏu>Úþ�§̂ r��òÏl��¦^��¬K�"Ù¥����±oÑ

��Xe:�®�Ä:�8§b½�6500.00��Øv±²ÉöYÀ§ÏÜÓ�Ƨ

TÜ©Ä:��ó��OIp§É�öYÀ§L� ؽ\�¶�N�Y>ÕÄ

:¤^U1%��650.00��¶�>ÕòÏl��u>Â\§¤^���120000.00�

�"=dn�¤^§��²L��Ò�127150.00��"

¿�2´�¦�óü éÙ�8+n9��U§�Ñ�U�wþ��/�?Ì

+Ü�§¦¯Eó§rÊó����£5§́ lçI<æ|ÃÑu��«?n�

{"":´�éT�óü GÏÝI��{1�?1?v§�¬�ú²�Â3�½

§Ýþv��ÌÜ"¿�2éTY>Õï��K�Ì�´Êó��§�T�8Êó

´�óü gC�¬ó�+eE¤�"�d§Éú¬ó��£!¶ó���þd�

óü gC«ú"Ó�§�óü �Kkæ�k���§¢�Q½ÜÓ?Ý8I�

ÜÓI?§¿«úddO\�¤^ÚóÏòØI?"çI<«ú��ª��§�U

´�óü ÏÊó E¤�òÏu>Úþ�§��mAT�uÊó�m��á"ç

I<UÜÓ�½§�±���óü òÏeó�����"

3.þ¡é¿�1Ú¿�2�©ÛL²§¿�1�çI<�5���ã�§Ø��Ø

�®Ø¨æ^"��TÝ]8ì�oà§ÀJþ¡¿�1½¿�2c§Aé¥I(J

�Ñ�ä§�ä¥I<3ÝI¥´Ä�3�¿ÐÀ1�§´Äò�Id"Äk§

T�8çIÝIL§¥§=B´GÏÝI§¥Id�äk�½¿�5§Ï�Ø´¤

kÝI<GÏÝI¶Ùg§T�óü Ñy�¬ó�+e§=´y|+nØõ§¿

�ÃUåÁ�§Ø¨æ^¿�1 A�ÀJ¿�2§=�¦�óü �U§¦¯Eó"

Ó�§|�ðmV�p?O��ó)��N¬§�¦�óü N�!¿¢�ó|�

�+nU姲(V�úioà?O�VÞ<"�,éÙGÏÝI1�Ø3�±1

�½-¯Jħ�A�V«Ù®²�<uÞ§çI<®�¡ÙGÏÝI1���Á

��=ü"~X§çI<�T�óü oà3¬�§ü<3�å�he�6¥§Ø

Page 340: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

113ÙçIæµGÏÝI��� 329

²¿�J�é/k<uÞ§`\�3ÝI¥�Ù¦n[ÝI<GϧØL���8

�¤Ð§·�Ø2�Ä0�{"7��,`Ñ@n[ÝI<�¶¡"��¥I<§�

óü oà�½Ã�ùé{�Sº§£�úi�§�½¬\réT�8��ó+n§

XÏ�G�8Ý�"ùâ´çIæA�J¦�(J§�´¯�¥§Ý]8ì@ 

oàA�æ��üѧÏ�3çIæ�Á��ã§/Ü0K�I§/©0Kü}§�

óü 3ÝI��GÏÝI§T´çI<=üÙÁ���ä"

Page 341: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 14Ù

çIæµáJ�b¢�¥I���

**********************************************************************

pþ¨�§Þ­���.f¶ìmÆ�§�k�þJ¥�"

— ².)9.éé

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 342: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 331

11!ÄϵáJ�b¢�¥I��Ï

çIÝI�Ý�ïá§r½|�´�8�u�1e§z)U�m�ÐϽ|

he�´��ì"@�§~k�<�X�è�«@�Ö!0�ó§�d¢�a

ã"1992c§·��3�óè�?Eâè�"k�cÁU§á��·�ú¿§w�

·`5��KI,÷°¢½mu��P�§Ã¥k108·���8§43�®´

�§¿g´�å���ù �P�§��ó§"è<äXg1��/�P�04?

�Ù�!"@´�mÊÏç�¤§/�P�0�B��ç�a§·Nowù �Ø�

´Ãpk108·���P�"���§@��108 ·�§����uyX8�1080·

�"!vAé§Òm��·è�Ð?¤§·.Xá�`;r§�wé�Ò´

$?¢f"1999c·3ôÖƬƠÏm§� *l`½�«k�¡O諧4·

�¦��4§wUÄ���8"@´T½� Ø�gà�B½�3 �Ì8�Oè

«"é�KI���§��ÚÜC�Á"V�¬!3�ú¢¬Æ¿pÞ1§p9þ

!÷�8�ÐãÚ+�À��졧Sfþ{�X�8�â��."é�o²

nk0��85 §±9B½�gà�z�§¦�XÛ<��8�mu��"�

·�kª¿§o²n`¢{§¡Ù3{I����¦®3000�{�§®®�

!�ârþ§=��½�I��õU§4·�k/�¦�200���]7±=§e�

�®�âÒ�§�X�.þ�Oè`§\��±�B]ÊÅ�ó"·�*l¦

�úÚ`;r§q��ó§¢f"

@o§çIÝI´XÛz)he�´�QºÙ'�3uçIÝI¥�úm�

K§/x�çi0ª�Ö¡/ª§=çI<uÙçIúw!uÈçI©�§ÝI<U

çI©���¦?�¿4�ÝI©�§çI<�¥I<UçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI

©�\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"Ö¡1N�`:´ù¦Ö¡�y§�EI±�¯<ª¢Å&�

Ä:§ØáJ�b½?1JbNì"áJ�b´�«ÐÀ1�§���<!�¯

��K§{5�¥I©z¤(À"V[/;!Â!r!�!&0¥�/&0=´ù«

g�§3¥Ikó��Í�¥ØyØã"~X§5Ø�6�f¾�¥P1�f�{�

/ÆXкÐU�º0§±95�Æ6¥é/ª&0�Øã/¤¢ªÙ¿ö§ÈgÐ�0

�"QXd§��o3çIÝI¹Ä¥§��3áJ�b¢�¥I�1�Qº u

ÝI<g@�kUå�¤çI�8§ ½|O\K¡�ü]���ÝI]�^�§

½´çI©�¥�Ù¦��5^�§��ÙÝIØU½¥IØU§? 3ÝI¥Ñ

Page 343: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

332 çIæÛYFn

yEb!!�½´$dsI�áJ�b1�"ù��¡§%¹X½|O\K¡�ü

���I� �§,��¡§¿�X��8çI<3çI©�¥5½�J`^�

øl¢S§́ iZ Ø´J`"e¡ùKçI�o<��¯§K´þ¡½|¢f�

¢D½´Ù3çIÝI¹Ä¥�C«"

[çI�o<��¯] 2001c7�§H�,¯�ü Ý]60��ï��úgÄz

XÚ"²|�µI�¬µ"í�ÚçI<(½§IS�¶�,^�muû¥I"ç

I<Ï�¥I<c5+�¥IÏ�Ö§Ã�¥I<3ÝI©�þ3e�ÃÅÒè§

®ÊŧÃ�Ùþ��ú>{§́ ,ËA�>{§¡3��õUcÒ®²ò�"-

�%¯§¥IÏ�ÖuÑéØ�¥I<"

çI<3pé�þ��¥I<5þ/�§p,/Ï�¦�¥I�¯§Ø�é�

��Ù3IS�¤kÝI�8�§¡vkë\ù��8�ÝI"çI<�§sn

�õU�¤�8çI§\Ù¥I<¥I§é�Ø«@ÝLI§@No1µ/s�4�

�ÝI©��3·��Y@��XQ§No`vÝIQºXJ\�¥IáØ5\¾

ÜÓ§\�4�����ÝI�y7Øò�§��J¢\�ù«JbÝI�·�E

¤����0é�²n`µ/sù��8·��(vë\"U·�úi5½§ÝI�¯

k3oÜ�P§,�úiâU3ÝI©�þ\XúÙ"0�çI<Ø&§é�²n�

X`µ/ù�§·r·�úi�úÙX3�Ü�þ§̂ Æ�¼/ªu�s�Øé"0ü

U�§çI<Â�Túiu5�Æ�¼�§òÙþ�<Ù�¥I<ÝI©�þX�

úÙ'é§uyüö3<Ù�¥mÜ �3�½�[��ɧâ��çI-�o<

"éØ�1�¥IÿÀ<¥I\¾ÜÓ,çI<��(½ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<

¥I§��\¾Ö¡ÜÓ§�,1�¶�¥Id'1�¶pÑ�õ��"

ùKçI�o<��¯��´�«�o�¹§é<éØ�§�Å´3�U,Ò

è§ÃÅqÊÅ"XJ´�I�§?�ÝI©�Ø@ý§tJbÝI��UÑy

ù«�¹§�ÙÝI¥I§̀ ²�oº̀ ²�¯<´3@ý�ÝI§Ø´�I�"

Q,ÙÝIØ´�I�§ÒAT3ÝI©�þ\Xý�ü Ù!éX�ª§±B¥

I�\¾ÜÓÁ�§��oh�bÙ!ÝI�q�´Qº�O´,<�!3ù[

^�muúi¶e��Ö§½´3<��8�=��ù[^�muúi§���v

!þ§��h�bÙÝI§�gC^�muUåqا������õ�ÝI�

y7�´"

��/§çI©�5½�ÝI^�§©�]�!EâÚûÖ^�"Ù¥§Eâ^

�´çI�8�Eâ.½§́ ¥I<Á�9(J�u�§ÝI<´3�AÙ¥�¢

�5�¦Ú^�Ä:þ?1�ÝI§�Xþ¡çI�o<��¯¥¤ã��§ÝI

<ØU�ØcEb§Ï�Á�I�éÙ/�²��0�ÝI</�Ø��0"�d§

Page 344: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 333

ÝI¥�áJ�b1�§Ì�8¥3çI©�¥5½�]�ÚûÖ^�§�)1�

N�y�!ãÖG¹½ö�1!�8KI<½öÌ�Eâ<{{!NÄ'Xy²!

&^G¹�§©�I[5½�]�y²©�ÚçI<U�8A:ÚI¦§3çI©

�¥�¦ÝI<J��y²©�"

1.I[5½�]�y²©�"I[5½�]�y²©�§�I[�Ù�½|O

\K¡�ü¥��8|�çIÝI¹Ä�§½|ÌNL¼�I[k'Ü��u�½

|O\]��§â#NÙë�½|²E¹Ä§?1ÝI§́ r��"çI<éÝI

<?1ÐÚµ"�§A(½?\�[µ"�ÝI<ä�I[�u�½|O\]�y

Ö"ÝI<éI[5½�]�y²©�Ebkü«�/§�´gC½�÷¦<UI

[�u�]�yÖ�ª§��by½bÙ§±ÏL]�"�¶�´É4½u/¦<

�]�yÖ§=!�¦<ÝI§ÏL]�"�§¥I�|G�½�!�¤^"

[]�Eb��¯] 2002c4�§,FÀY?nUå6�ë�ÀY?n�AN²E

�8|�úmçI§çIúw1²�ÝI]�^�§kµ�ÝI<A�ü�è�{

<½Ø�Lü[è�|¤�éÜN§äkF?n5�6�ë±þ½�ÀY?nyÖ¶

�è�À]�31·�<¬1±þ§kûÐ�ãÖG¹§äkU÷v��8ï�!$

E�]7¢åÚK]Uå¶�äkÝ]!ï�!$EF?n5�6�ë±þ½�À

Y?n���1¶�Ã�{!�5ÚØû½|1�P¹"çI©��¦ÝI<J�

�]�"�]�kµ�ÝI<�E��ì!{<Å��èyE<�£E<�\Xú

Ù¤¶�ÝI<��ÖUå§�)è�0�!]�G¹!�8�1�[�¹0��¶

�Cnc²¬O�¯Ö¤½"OÅ�"O�ãÖ¬O�L§�)]�KÅL!y7

6þL!|dLÚãÖ�¹`²Ö�E<�£E<�\XúÙ¤�"

ÝI<`´�½�[ÀY?nè�"µIL§¥§µI�¬¤Ü,@�Ý

I<`3ÙÝI©�¥§J��FÀY?nUå6�ë�]�yÖ´b�§�¦éÙ

ÝI�±Äû"µI�¬Ù¦¤þØÓ¿§@�ÝI<`Jø�]�yÖ�E

<�´çÚE<�§Ø�UEb"Ü,j±@�ÝI<`�FÀY?nUåyÖ´

b�§nd´I[k'Ü�vk�uLFÀY?nUå6�ë�]�yÖ§�k5�

ë!8�ë!10�ëù�?yÖ"

3Ü,�j±e§µI�¬uþÌ10:20©�m�ÝI<`uÑ©�Ï�Ö§

�¦ÝI<`ueÌo:c§��I[k'Ü��Ù�u�FÀY?nUå6�ë

�yÖ�µI?Ø�"ÝI<`��÷�n<Â�µI�¬�¦©��Ï��§

¡@°yÖ<��½Ø��§I��ü���m��mâU<£5§�¦µI

�¬�ü��2µI"3|iÒµI�½uU�­:�8�ú¿Ì?�f§ü�

��2µI§ùØ´÷`o���>{��ù[è��{½�L<§�¦Ù�÷�

Page 345: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

334 çIæÛYFn

n<3eÌo:±cUµI�¬��¦§J�ÙÀY?nUåyÖ�µI�¬

�"

@UeÌ2:00:�m§�´¥%� Ó�r­:�ú¿Ì?�Ñ�§̀ ��k

<:X�¦"Ïú%µIÉ��{Zý§·�Xù Ì?rѬƿ"��§�

ÕX� I�c§��Ì?���Ø´§̀ o²n�>{�¦§r¦Ïë�

î§4¦Ö73eÌ2:00:�ùp`²�¹"�X§¦`@�yÖý´Ø3�½

�+nÜ�§<Ø£5Ø�"�r`µ/o²n�«§XJÏdK�µI�?§§

�±Äû·��ÝI§·�vk¿��0­:�Ì?£�¬Æ¿§�µI�¬=�

ÝI<`�£E¿�"µI�¬�¦­:��Ó��Ï�éI[k'Ü��u

�FÀY?nUåyÖaO§y¢µI�¬¤Ü,�¿�´�(�§±ÝI

<`ØUµI�¬��¦§©�ÙÝI©��d§éÙÝI�±Äû"

�¯ù�ùp§k<¬�)¦¾§��oÝI<`Ø�¿JøÙFÀY?n

Uå6�ë�yÖ��QºµI�¬ÄûÝI<�nd§��oØ�/FÀY?n

Uå6�ëyÖEb0Qºù´3|�µI�¬µI�§�?ÝI<é1�N�

yÖEb�I�5¿�¯�"@Ò´§XJÝI<3ÝI©�Jø�yÖ´ý�§

Q,´ë�çI�8�ÝI§¦�½¬UµI�¬��¦J��'y����§

±øµI�¬��"�XJyÖ´b�§¦¬J���b�yÖ����µI�

¬��íº�,ج�Ø�ù�ÝI<�{<�L½Ù�÷�n</M�4¼H

0§Ï�1�N�y�Eb§{<�L�«ú{ÆI?"5¥u<¬�ÚI-{6

1�z��Ê^!1�zn��^5½§ïñ?Ñ�N�y!?Ñ���/y²±

9Ù¦{Æ!1�{55½�²EN�y½ö1O©�§6Ͻ|�S§�!î­

�§?Êc±ekÏä-½öÕ¸§¿?½öü?�{¤���±þÊ�±ev7¶

�!AOî­�§?Êc±þkÏä-§¿?�{¤���±þÊ�±ev7½ö

vÂã�§éÙ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<§�ì5½?v"ÝI<

�,�Ù-{�þã5½§J��°b�]�yÖ��J§��'ÙÝI�µI�

¬Äû§Ø¥I�î­"�d§çIÝIL§¥§çI<½µI�¬uyÝI<

31�N�y�þEb§[�Ø�MF"uÝI<¬ÌÄ<Ñ@°b�]�yÖ"

@o§�¯¥§µI�¬��oØ3µI�w¥�eÝI< /̀FÀY?n

Uå6�ëyÖEb0§ù�ÄûÙÝIndØ´�¿©í�µI�¬=BÙ¤

;�Y²2p§�Ø´1�N�Ü�§�Ø´i{�½Ü�§q³�o@½ÝI<

�1�N�y�Eb§@Ø /́Ú»��í0�¤±§µI�¬±ØUÙuÑ�©

��¦�d§éÝI<`�ÝI�±Äû§́ µI�¬«úI?����«?n

�{§�´�«/¥T0��"

Page 346: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 335

2.çI©��¦�y²©�"ÝI<3ÝIL§¥§éI[5½�]�y²©

�Eb¯��,k§�oNþw¿Øõ�§Ï�ÝI<�±ÏLéùayÖ�É4

½öu/��ª)û§Ùºx�éJøby��"ÝIL§¥Ñy��þEb¯�§

8¥3çI©�¥�¦ÝI<J���y²á�½]�§küaµ�a´é]�

y²©�Eb"~X§ÝI<3ãÖ!&^G¹!êâ½�IþEb§?UÙ¥�

ãÖêâ½ö�I�¶,�a´é�[µ"¥�J`k'�µ"Ï�Eb"~X§

ÝI<3�8KI<½öÙ¦Ì�<���]�!�1ÚÁ{þEb�"ÝI<

ÊH�k��«ÙÆ%n´§çI<½µI�¬XJuyÙ3ùµ"Ï�þE

b§�õ´ÄûÙÝI§½´ØO�©ê�ýج�5O��/"�XJçI<½

µI�¬vuyQºØÒk�U¼�¥I]�í�ÝI<¢Sþ´3ÙµI�

¬µI/r/ª!rL|0§ÙçI<UµI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<(½¥I

< ج?�Ú"�ÙÝI©�§ùéIS�õêçI�8 ó§ÙµI!½IØ

�´Xdí�

b�y²©�Úý��3�å'é§�½�±�OÑy²©��ýb"çI<

éuçI©��¦�y²©�ÝIEb¯��?n§�éI[5½�]�y²©�

Eb¯��?n�/aq"d�§�,ج�ÝI<Ì�I?<�5O��/§

�Ó�§XJÝI<3ÝI©�Jø�y²©�´ý�§¦�½¬UµI�¬�

�¦J��'��§±øçI<½µI�¬��"�XJJø�y²©�´b�§

ÝI<ýجòb�y²©������çI<½µI�¬�'é"ÝI<¬X

]�Eb��¯¥@ Ç��n<��§é��)�,��ndöò 4çI<½

µI�¬&ѧÙ3á�mSvk�{<�����çI<½µI�¬Ø�§

µIØ�UÏÑyù«�/ Êî"�Ð�)û�{§́ µI�¬Ö¡�¦ÝI

<J��A�y²©�Ø��§7L5½��J���Ø��Ün���m§²(

ÝI<ØUU�¦J��Ay²©�Ø��§UØ|uÝI<µ"§½´��UÄ

ûÝI?n§±¦µI�~?1"ù«�/§ÝI<%�ܲ§Ø¬3¯��çI

<JÑÉƧ�ج�1�iÒÅ�Ý�"

12!�¢µ�¿Eb1����

ÝIáJ�b�m�3u¼�¥I]�§¢�¥I"ù�¥§¢�¥I�ÌN

´ÝI<§́ S϶çI<ØUçI�8A:ÚI���µIIOÚ�{§µI�

¬µIr/ª!rL|§́ áJ�b¢�¥I�±¤õ¢��Ï"¢Sþ§Ý

I<�áJ�b¯�§���éA�ý�é'§éN´uy"��X�ÆEâ�?

Page 347: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

336 çIæÛYFn

Ú§Ebó²�3uЧ�bÙ!�by��¬Î§y��n§���ÝI<áJ

�b§�*þE¤�½(J§���3g�þ­À§1ÄþᢧÃ�ÝI<3Ý

I©�¥Eb��{§±¯¢��â§ÒØJ3çI楧�ØÙØû�J"

[ÜÓEb��¯] 2001c8�§,�Ý]ï��^�áú´§�8ï�SN�)

V�o��ú´!��1200m�xùÚú´�@��"�d§ÝI]�^�¥§�

¦ÝI<Cncä���1200m±þ�xù�1âUÝI"T�8]�ý"úw3

I[�½x0uÙ§²|�]�ý"§J`(½Ô[ÏL]�ý"�d3ÝI<

ÝI"3çI©�þ5½�ÝI���mc§Ô[ÝI<þ4�ÝI©�"mI

�§çI<�{|ï�µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI?

1µ"Ú'�§�gí�n¶¥IÿÀ<"

çI<Â�µI�w�1�U§3�½x0þú«µI(J"µI(Jú«�§

1�¥IÿÀ<��ieÞ�1�¥IÿÀ<§¡TÝI<3ÝI©�¥1²

�H�8ªà�x��1´b�"Â�Þ��§�8ü òÔ[ÝI<�ÝI©�

£x�ie§d ,�è|�<éÞ�¯�?1"�§uy1�¥IÿÀ<

ÝI©�¥(¢kH�8ªà�x�ÜÓ�ÆÖ"�ÆÖþ1²��x�Ý1315m§

Ed6465��§Ùþ�XÙ!\i!>{�©�ߧwØÑk?ÛEdè,""�

Ïm§ ,�¦ÙÏÃ�o��ÆÖþ1²�ï�ü éX>{?1éX§é�

y¢�x��óü �´1�¥IÿÀ<§0��óÏmÚ�xÏ�±5��

¹""��|@�ùå´�åé1�¥IÿÀ<�Áw§ ,û½éÙ�±Ò£§

�¦ÙÏÃ�oÏ�Þ�<"�(J""�(å�§ ,�Ù¦A Ó�Ñ�§�

,�¤¢½�Y"

����§ ,£��ú¿§uy�úSþ{�X�µ&§�m�w§�´Þ�

ù��81�¥IÿÀ<§�´Þ��H�8ªà�x�1´b�" ,�1§N

o£¯§Ø´"�o§NoqÞ�§v�v§�vk#yâ" ,½5�o§

¯´Äþ�g�"�(JvÏ��Þ�<§/Ï��§¦�5<��§·�J25

<§�±¯¢��â§Ø�=³ßÿÞ�"0�o)º`" ,f�§Mfpé"�

L§c[/L�H§=�/�kÕ�º�§>{(@�x��óü ´1�¥

IÿÀ<§y<yóØ´�¡§́ >{(@�§́ Ø´ù�/�k¦ÉQ� ,é

ÏÃ`/·4�ú¿Sü��f§\Ú��è<²U�@��4H�8§é�ªà

�x§é�ï�ü �<�¡)�e§�Ð)¹"0

1�U�@§�oÚ��m�¨ H�8§é��ÆÖþ1²�ªà�x�´

§uy@^à´�^°ÝØv30���à§àþ¡�x§\þÚx�ØL300m§

=5�1315m��x�w�ùp§�oÚ��@�Ø^2éï�ü �<ί§Ï

Page 348: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 337

��x�ý¢�¹®v±y²1�¥IÿÀ<��1Eb"è<û½m�£½p�

,®�§��1�¥IÿÀ<�¥I]�"

Ò3�o!��m�c H�8�Ó�§1�¥IÿÀ<¼��<c H�

8¢/N��&E§s3�oÚ��£½p� ,®�c§�µÞ�&w�i

e§¡T�81�¶�1Ô¶8[ÝI<Gϧ�¦ie�{�?ÙGÏÝI1

�"T�8ÏÜÓ�1�¿Eb§�{��1�¥IÿÀ<�¥I]�§éÙ?1

?v"@o§́ ÄA\Ù1�¶¥IQº1�¶Þ�1�¶�1Ô¶GÏÝI§Ó

��3�{1�§\Ù1�¶¥I§k��¢1�¶´Ä�3GÏÝI�¯¢"

�d§ ,|�k'<§U1�¥IÿÀ<Þ�&Jø��Y�¢?1J�§

««,�L²§1�¶�1Ô¶m�3GÏÝI1�"Äk§1�¶�Þ�&¥¡§

1�¶Q[Ñ50��Âï§�¦Ù�I"�áý�§Q�ó�é1�¶��8²n

�±�E§�éÙ�}Ï�ï"�m!/:��1�¥IÿÀ<[��8²n�y

¢¶Ùg§ ,Qheé�¯�¥�1o¶Ú1ʶÝI�¯<§y¢T�8(¢

´1�¶VÞ¦��I?1�GÏÝI" ,�¦�<�e�°Ö¡á�y²GÏ

ÝI1�§�<��£ýµ/@�ØU�§X�X��½|5K§±�3½|pÒ2

Ã{)��0

Yf�C�c§�8ï����z�Øc"�GÏÝIü³�w�ycØv

±æ&§�¦(@1�¶�1Ô¶´GÏÝI§ØU4ù«1��¬�No?n§

,éÅ("u´§éA 1�;[§UI[�IO!5�éÝI©�?1@ý"

�§éÑ1�¶Ú1n¶ÝI©�¥�3��I[r�5IOÚ5��¯¢§@�

é1�¶Ú1n¶�ÝI�{A�Äû§�¦çI<­#çI" ,ØÃb%/é

·`µ/Ãe�Y�Ó�g��5�5�­§ú%=�UgC½[<É��E§®k

<�Nlk �0

·��@�§çIÝI���«½|J`5K§I��´½|ÌN�lª¢Å

&��´�K§ù�´çIÝIu�²L�Ã�Ä:"þ¡ùK�¯L²§¿Ø´

¤k�½|ÌNÑ�lù��¦"Á�§�·�é½|ÌN�´�ý¢5��k~

¦��ÿ§�½|�´��ê<½çV³åÝ���ÿ§çIÝI���«¬¯�

´�ݧqNo�Uu�ÙAk��^"�d§çIÝIÅ�7Lk5�kS�E

û�¸��÷"éd§�Ö���Ù�¬;�?Øù�¯K"

çIÝI���«Ö¡«1�¬¯�´1�§ª¢Å&��´�K��õê½

|ÌN�ɧ́ ½|ÊH@Ó�5K"3ù�5KÚ�e§·�25©ÛçIÝI

¥�áJ�b1�ÒkÙ�Ì"¢Sþ§ÝI<áJ�b¢�¥I§�ªI3Ý

I©�¥²d�¡½êâz©�LyÑ5§ù©�Ì�Ny�çI©��¦�]

Page 349: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

338 çIæÛYFn

�y²©�ÚûÖ©�Eb§´ÝI<@�ÙEbó²v±Ð¢µI�¬¤§

Ó�§çIÝI¹Äq3r/ª!rL|�/e��Ô"�d§��©Û�ÝI<

Ebó²§\réÝI©�¥'Xµ"(J�©�ý¢5"��Ø¢Ò�±��"

1.ÝI©�Ebó²" ÝI©�¥k']�y²©�½ûÖ©��Eb©�

ü«�/§�«´ÝI<Øäk,�]�y²½ûÖ©�§�EO<�]�y²½

Ù¦ûÖ©�����b�]�y²©�½ûÖ©�§þ¡�<Ù!\i�ÑX�

E¶,�«´ÝI<äk,�]�y²½ûÖ©�§�Ù5�!êþØ��÷vç

I©��¦§½öØv±¼��`µ"(J /ÏÝI©�¥�]�y²½ûÖ©

�=I�E<� Eb§©�±en«�/µ

1¤E<Eb"̂ aq�]�y²©�!ûÖ©�E<§r?U¯��<½�[

�©�iN�3�Ü�^þ§b3I?U�/�§�4�©�þ�I?U�¯�§

2gE<"d�§E<(J¬wyÑ�Üb��^>�"N�E<Å�çxé'ݧ

=N�xÝ~�çݧ2gE<§ÒwØÑ5UÄ�è,"

2¤PSãEb"ò]�y²©�!ûÖ©�×£C¤ã�©�§|^ã�?n§

~XPhotoshop�^�§3>M¥é×£ã�?1©�?n§�KI�?U�¯�§

���<?USN§½ö�<Ñ5§�[�©��iNò?USNW�3?U?E

<§��?U��]�y²½ûÖ©�"

3¤ ©�Eb"IOz§Ý�p�]�y²½ûÖ©�§AO´ ©�´êâ

z©��§ÝI<é>fêâ©��?U!Eb��B§=Ié ©�)�!?U

�Aêâ�2­#?6§=)¤ÝI¤I�]�y²½ûÖ©�§ ?6XÚ3p

é�þ��´úm�§~X§>Mþ¤�¤��J�yÖ½´ISÏ1�©�?6

XÚ§XlatexÑ�XÚ�§Ã?6XÚ�<éw«(J�\ïÄ=��¤"7��§

��±­��>Mç��pây"

2.ÝIáJ�b��"Ø+´�¡©��´êâz©�Eb§UÄ�ܩѬ

3eù�½@��UÄè,"Ù¥§�Juy�´]�y²½ûÖ©�� ©�E

b§ÏÙLy/ª�ý¢©�����§©ØÑý�"�b�Ò´b�§���ý�

�3�å§�úÒ�uy"�d§±e���±k���ÝI<�áJ�b1�"

£1¤1�N�¯�úm"ÝI<3ÝI©�¥áJ�b�¢�§́ ÄuÝI<

�&EéçI< óØ顤�"Ù¥§½|O\K¡�ü¥§½|ÌNL���

A�1�N�]�â#N²E�¯�§A�|^pé�ïáÚ�B$��α�§

��¬úm"ù�ÎÜ5¥u<¬�ÚI�?&Eúm^~65½§T^~1�Ê

^²(5½§é�9ú¯|ÃN�!I�ú¯2��¡½öI�ú¯ë�ûü��

?&E§1�Å'A�ÌÄúm"T^~1��^é£Ê¤¥�1�N���n(

Page 350: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 339

J§£8¤¥1�Å'@�äk�½�¬K��1�?vû½§£�¤¥­�ï��8

�¢��¹§±9£�n¤�¸�o!ú�¥)!S�)�! ¬�¬!�¬�þ�

iÒu��¹�§�¦1�Å'A�ÌÄúm"

1�N�91�?v¯��{úm§́ çIÝI¥@½ÝI<]�y²½ûÖ

©�´ÄEb�'é�â"2009c§I[uÐU���ÊÜ�Û!IÖ�{���

�Ù�5çIÝI�{1�P¹úw61�{618^!1Ô^5½§éçIÝI

�{1�¤�Ñ�1�?nû½§�)µ�´w¶�v±¶�vÂ�{¤�¶�6Ê

½ö��çI�n]�¶���3�½�ÏSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI

]�¶���ú?µI�¬¤�]�¶�6Ê�8�1½J£®ÃG]7¶�

6ÊSüI[ï�]7¶�6Êï��8�"�1O¶�1�Ì+Ü��{�Ñ�

Ù¦1�?nû½§AgçIÝI�{1�1�?nû½�Ñ�Få20�ó�FS

é?1P¹úw"

1�N��1�?v&E�¢�úm§3�½§Ýþ���ÝI<31�N�

¯�þ�EbJøB$Ï�"çI<3|�çIÝI¹Ä§(½ÝI]�c§A

éçI�8�9�½|O\^�!1�"19&EúÙ±�?1)§3]�"�

L§¥ÝºÝI<�½|O\]��¹"7��§\ν|O\1�N�Ü�½�

¦ÝI<Ö¡©�½`²"

£2¤çI©�?�¯�"ÝI<3ÝI¥�áJ�b1�§AO´éçI©�

¥�¦��y²©�Eb1�§kÝI<ت¢Å&��ϧ��kçI<��

ϧXçI<çI©�?�Ø@ý§ lçI�8A:ÚæI¦§*��¦ÝI

<Jø�y²©���§½´J` lÁ�¢S�"

~X§3éÝI<�½�ÏS��1µ"þ§k�±�8�ê§k�±�85

�§�k�±ÜÓ7��J`Ï�½IO§�.=�«k|uçI<J`§vk½

Ø"¢Sþ§±�1µ�ÝI<Á�Uå§́ Äu�«/.50�K§=Q,ÝI<

± ¢�Laq�8§�½U¢�ÐçI�8�b�"ý´ù�íº3<â6Ī

��8U§|��8¢��Ì�<X®lÝI<`�§=BÝI<kaq�1§

�ØUä½Ùý�U¢�ÐçI�8§ÏÙ3aq�8Á�<þ®²�ò�"

�d§çI©�¥±aq�8��J`Ï���§�é�ØA�´ÝI<§ ´Ý

I<[�Ñ��8KI<9Ù¦Ì�<"=BçI©�¥5½�J`´�é��

8KI<9Ù¦Ì�<§�ب l¢S���*�"~X§,�ÂïÓó§�

óçI©�5½§Cnc[��8²nk��ïÓ¡È312000m2�aq�81©§

�p3©"y3kü��8²n§��´ncS�¤��80000m2�aq�8§,

��´ncS�¤n�15000m2�aq�8§ùü��8²n=���`DQº

Page 351: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

340 çIæÛYFn

´@��¤n�15000m2�aq�8��8²níº�,Ø´"3ù«�/e§Ý

I<�¥I§¬�@�ncS�¤��80000m2aq�8��8²n3ÜÓ�1

þEb§Ï�ÝI<@�ù��8²n�`D§y|+nUåÚÁ�(J�Ð"

�d§UçI�8A:ÚI¦?�çI©�§́ Ú�ÝI<ý¢/ÝI�cJ"

ù�¥§cÙ´µ"Ï�9J`IO"µ"Ï��§Øv±J`½´J`�¥I(

J�UÃ{¢y¶J`µ"Ï�õ§AO´�çI�8Ã'�µ"Ï�½´ lç

I�8J`I¦�µ"Ï�Lõ§�½§Ýþ¬ÚuÝI<3ÝI¥áJ�b§ù

´çI<|�?�çI©��A��±5¿�"

£3¤ÝIáJ�b�¢"ÝIáJ�b�ª´Ly3ÝI<4��ÝI©�/

ª1Nþ§��µI�¬½çI<3µI½(½¥I(J�§�Æ/@ý"�½

'é§Ò�±uy"

1¤1�N�½1�?v¯�Eb"uyÝI©�¥�31�N�½´1�?

vEbè,�§31�Ü�½1�?vÅ'�½��Õþ�Î"7��§�k'1

�Å'\Χ½�¦ÝI<Ö¡©�½`²"

2¤çI©��¦�y²©�Eb"��/§ÝI<éçI©��¦�y²©�

EbØæ^ ©�Eb ´E<!PS½´>M?U�'êâ��{§¬3eUÄè

,§��@ýµ"Ú'�§ÒUuyÝI©�¥�3Ûɽ���Æ�y�"~

X§�Ó�°y²©�§Ù¦�E<�Ñé�ߧҴù��þ�i½ã�Ø�ß

½´AO�ߧ½´y²©���Ø�߶��µã�!>.��� ¶�,��

iN�Ù¦A�Ø��½´k��è,¶�y²©�þ©iÚiNØÎÜ�ÜPz

5Æ�§Ñ���~��Æ~£"éd§µI�¬½çI<A��ÝI<uÑ©

�¼§�¦Ù35½��mSJ���?1Ø�"�X·�3þ�!©Û�§d�§

ÝI<XJý�´Eb§¬é��/)�,�0�nd Ã�öò§äجr@°

Eb©�J��µI�¬½çI<�"�d§µI�¬½çI<3uÑ�¦Ý

I<J���Øé¼��§þ¡Ik��Ün�4�������m§²(w�Ý

I<áØU�¦J���Øé�§ÄûÙÝI½À�Ù�ï¥I,±��ÙÃ�ö

ò,K�µI½çI<(½¥I(J"

13!U�µ!�ÄÏ���

!�§=è�!�²E§́ �Å�½|�lá½�Nu,�Å�½|�"Ù¥§

#N¦<¦^gC¶Â�è�¡��!�<§¦^�!�è�¶Âl¯²E¹Ä�

è�½�<¡�!�<"çIÝI¹Ä¥§!�Ñy3½|O\K¡�ü��8§A

Page 352: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 341

O´ó§ï��8çI§ÝI<æ^É4½öu/��ª¼�Ù¦ÝI<�]�!

]�yÖÝI§=±¦<¶ÂÝI§¥I�§UY±�!�<¶Â�¤çI�8§�

{¼�ÂÃ��«²E1�"!��A�§3uÝI<�Øä�çI�8�]�½

]�§́ �¼�çI�8²LÂç̂ ¦<�]�!]�yÖÝI±y²Ùäkç

I�8�Á�U姥I�½Á�L§¥§�B�!�<�½¤^"5�þ§!�

Ø´è�²E¹Ä¥�©|Å�§Ø´½|�´¥�²�½©�§ ´çIæ¥

�«áJ�b1�"IÖ��Ù�5ï�ó§�þ+n^~61�l^!1��Ê

^Ú1n�o^²(5½§l¯ï�ó§t!�O!�ó!in�ü A��{

���A]�yÖ§¿3Ù]��?N����S«@ó§§B�t!�O!�

ó½inü #NÙ¦ü ½ö�<±�ü �¶Â«@ó§"I[{Æ{5¥§

éó§ï��8¥�!�1�§æ��´�«"N=��Ý"�¢�¥§�?!�

1��§¿Øõ�§¤�½|£n¥�P�J¯K"

[]�/^��¯] 2012cÁ��U§·�3�ú¿U��°©�§� t>å

ï�Ý]�*l5��ú¿"»~��§·¯¦§ÐAcv³¡§��3a�o"

¦0�`§ùüc3H���{¢¢���BT=]ï��8"·¯¦´Ø´>åï

��8§¦£�`Ø´§́ ½�/e+�UE§oÝ]32000��"·¯¦§sØ´

�>åÝ]�í§vk½�]�§Noq�å½�ï�"¦Ø;¯/w�·§́

^�,�.Ikè��]�3|�¢�§Ï�BT�8|dpu�~�ó|d"

·�f§`;J2¦µ/sùØ´!�í§����?v��0¦�f§��

`µ/fƬ§s[��ØÑ·´!��·\ÎLÆ�§́ Æ��·Ñ�Ì¿"0·

�f§¯¦µ/Æ�´No�sÑ�Ì¿º0¦0�`§Æ�4¦k��!�<\¾

��NÖ�Ƨ�mºX���8Á�Ï"ù��{§Æ�`§s´è�ó§è�

ó<Xè��]�Ú]�yÖÝI!«@�Ö§Xc`s´!�"f�Æ��¦

Ñ�ù�Ì¿§·¯�§­þýkp<§�<�¦M�é!�1�.½�]�

½]�yÖ�/É40½ö/u/0§Ø��ù Æ���é{Ò�»"

l�o½|�SÑu§!�<vk¼�½|O\K¡�ü¥�8�]�½]

�§ØU�{l¯K¡�ü¥�8�)�²E¹Ä§7Léù«áJ�b1��±

îx�Â"éó§ï�+�§ó§�¬��þ!S�'X�¬ú�|ç!�1��

4<ú%�§́ ó§�¬�þ$�ÚØS�"Nõ<@�§!�<vk���A�

]�½]�yÖ§̀ ²1�Ü�éÙUåØ�@�§́ Ãy¢�§b�Ù��YO

$e§Á�¥�Q�|Ã�½¬Üó~�§�½¬±g¿Ð§ÙÁ�(J�½´Ø

Ü��¬§¬K��!�<��¬(�"$�§ró§�¬�þ$e��ϧ8(

�!�"ù«*:�*þk�ú#§Ï�½|Ly´§��¡§́ !�1���½

Page 353: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

342 çIæÛYFn

|O\K¡�ü��¦§I�éÙîx�¶�,��¡§�GÏÝI3�+�

¥�Eaq§!�1�3ó§ï�+�§AO´ó§�ó+�ÂBØ�§��5�

õ§��o´ù�QºXJ!��ª¬��ó§�¬��þ$�§ÃI1�Å'é

Ù�1îx�§�ÃIçI<3çIÝI¹Ä¥éÙ­:��§�!�<Ò�½

¬gú-�ù«1�§Ï�Ù�U¬��!�<�5/O��/0½Á�ºx"ù

p§I�g��¯K´§��o�!�<Ø�-� ¬#NÙ!�ºù�¥�,k

!�1��?J�¯K§�½|Ly`²§!�<¢��ó§�½´ØÜ��¬´

�«�Øb�§Ø��!�<¤@Ó"

ùc§·��3g�§XÛ3çIÝI¹Ä¥uy¿�?ÝI<�!�1�§

(Ø´çIÝI¹Ä¥Ø�U�Ñ!�§=±¦<¶ÂÝI§�Ø�Ué!�ÝI

?1?v§Ï�!��ÝI©��áJ�bØÓ§́ !�<Ú�!�<m��«h

e1�§�3ÝI©�þLy��!�<�ÝI1�§Ø�´V��Ü�'X»�§

qNo�U@½Ù!�1�Q�ù´1�Å'é!�1�£nþ���Ø«§Þ~

5`§I[uÐU���ÊÜ�Û�Ù�5ó§ï��8�óçIÝI�{61o

�l^5½§ÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI§́ �ÝI<!�Ù¦�óü §½lÙ¦ü

 ÏLÉ4½u/��ª¼�]�½]�yÖ§½ödÙ¦ü 9Ù{½�L<3

gC?��ÝI©�þ\X<ÙÚ\i�1�§l!�1�@½þ§É4½öu/

´!�1�§�!�<3ÙÝI©�þ�\iXÙ´#N!�1�"��!�<�

�����¬¯1�Uå<§XÛ³/ÝI©��äÙÝIØ´gC�¬¯{Æ1

� ´/�çG0§ÙÝI©��3Ly�´Ù3Á1����¬¯1�<�¬

¯I?§qXÛU@½�!�"�d§·��@�§éó§ï�½|¥�!�1�§

3çIÝI¹Ä¥éJ��k�£n§Ø��¯<V�ÑyØ�N)�gñ§�ù

«�/Ñy�VÇ��q�"

þ¡]�/^��¯L²§!�1�Ó�´uyJ!�?�J"�d§I�l

½|�´Ñu§ïÄ!�<Ú�!�<m�¬¯'XÚ|ä3§�éÝI<GÏ

ÝI���aq§±J`¢yçIæ(J�m�§3çIæ5�ÚÁ�L§¥

?1��§©ÛXe:

1.!�1��ÄÏ"¥I<�ª&©zébk���� Ûý�§ÏÙ³<³

C§�éó§ï�+��!�1�¿Øü½§ÏÙ�½|�´�û¬¢Ô�bk�

�ØÓ§��/J0y ®§½|þ�!��¥I©z¿Øgñ§�ÎÜ|Ã���

?­�K"

1¤!��©zÄÏ"¥I<ù/;!Â0"ùp§/;0�/O<0§Ú���¯

ØU1�gC§�� g�¶/Â0�/¨0§́ Ï�!Ï/!Ï<�¨�¿�§?

Page 354: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 343

/�CEr0§¢y�¬�Ó"½|O\K¡�ü¥�]�½]�+n§Ù¢�´�

?��*²L¹Ä5y$1;,§́ é�*²L¹Ä�1�Zý§¿Ø�½Îܽ

|²L�$15Æ"Pf35��²6¥ù/�0§ù�l/�01¯�k/�0§L

y31�ÊÙ�/ý|ï|§�MÃk0Ú1Ê�ÔÙ�/{-_Ú§�Mõk0"

�d�A§!�´é�?½|O\�|ï§́ ¥I©z¥�/Â03½|²L¥�

ò�ÚLy§3<��?­%n¥¿Øü½"

[yôh�xX��¯] yô��4¢{â�Ùi§���?úÖ<§3��

±é®/)�j0�´ÐlxX�<�§1��m���§Ø´�Üc5�²?

*Û7�8ÓxX�<§ ´xX´·%J73§X8��U��§·Ø�Í

¦§�8�7kæ"u´§yôí¡�{ù¬�3�âZú§4�Ƭ­4Û

7§̄ ê���ÀM~�xX�&"5YéD61�Ô£´ù�£��µ

yô�µ/xxØ�§73´%J37§·�X^5·5Í\"X8�Ye¯u

�x�®g<3L²�Op§øÑ\�Ô<"L²?���Û2Ó§�XeZ

<§ÁX��?�d§¿�²©Ö§5P\�Ô<§�\�Ä"U3E3·Ãp§·

�í`�{ZX§��Û*3{é���p�·"±d�ê 5§��xx"-n

�8O§r�þO."eدr�§��$oº·£�Ú¦�eeú©§�{Ø£

�§B�<ë�e5§\�Ø�ùz§1kÕ�§X�GÛ�>��3Ø5Í\"0

xXfv§̄ �¯�µ/p3��J��0yô�µ/xx§\>�õ`§��Sür

´§Ø��槷B£��"0

��§xX!Ç^�<|�B¶�(��Ô§�òþùì§üÌÑùìÐÇ�

�¯"�ù�¥�k4<)¦���¯§Ò´yôùÂíØb§��½Ø´(?ú

¥���VÅ{�ú¬"ÄK§äج±{-3Zú�d§heäX¯ê��xX

�<Ϻ�&�ù`²�o§̀ ²3yô�%¥§73���uÓ¯8<§=ù´

73�/ ±)�j0ù����"

5YéD6¥L��§T´(?1��/�0 1�§ùìÐÇ�/OU1�0§

£8g,$=5K"@o§dùÜ©Æ�¬�±wѧ3­<�%¥§(?��¬

uÐ�'X§́ /̂U0K/§0§_/�0K/�0§́ /TÑÃ�ÒÑÃ0�OU1

�§4�¬£8U�"ùl,«¿Âþ§<yPf�/{-_Ú§�Mõk0�*

:§)º]�½]�!��©zÄϧÏ��-3�½§Ýþ�å<�1�

<��5´/ÃÕÃå0§AO´3@K�<a)��+�§�Û¹½|O\]

�½]�+n´�ê<A��2y"k]�!]�yÖ�Ø�½k] ½Uå¶�

�§k] ½Uå��Uqvk]�½]�yÖ§r¤!���)"

2¤!��½|pÏ"½|��5´Å|"!��½|pϧ3u!�é!�<

Page 355: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

344 çIæÛYFn

Ú�!�<þU�)|ḉ ��p¨p|�¯�"ÄK§ù«1�جÑy§½ö

Ñy��½|5K¤áý"@o§]�½]��!�éV�|Ã�K�´�oQº

!�¥§!�<�|ÃNy3³/!��]�½]�§?\½|O\K¡�üy½

�@+�l¯)�²E¹Ä§¼��A²L|öé�!�< ó§Ù|ÃÌ�

Ny3n��¡µ�¼�]�½]�yÖ!�¤^§O\²E/�ÚÂ\¶�O\

�1§*�Ù�¬K�¶�÷v]�½]�cu�I��"!�é�¯<V��|

ð¦§\�!�1�uyJ§�?�J�G¹§�½§Ýþ§p�½|V�Ì

N!� ¼�½|²EÂÃ"

2.½|O\�ÝU�"½|!�����ϧ3u1�Ü����]�½]�

+n§AO´3ó§ï�+�"@o§��o3ó§ï�+�§AO´ó§�ó+

��3�þ�!�1�QºÏ��ó´U�O��¦|�½|NÄå?1ó§ï�

���¹Ä"Ù¥§�O´ó§õ^ïÄ�ã�Ðy§ �ó´ó§õ^�¢N¢

y"!�§¢Sþ´!�<�<ó] !Uå��?�u�]�!]�3½|�´

þ(Ü��Ô"Þ�~f§Cc3½|þÑy�!�<§�õ´U�m�ÐÏ��

�óÞ§²LA�c½|�'X!��xr§È\�þ�<ó"¦��ô1

�Å'½ï�ü Ì�KI<§=�8] §mÃp´��rk]�!]���ó

è�KI<§�^=�[]�!]�«@�8Ò^=�["

ó§ï�+�!�1��¢�§́ �?3½|+nþ�� �� §́ �?r

½|O\�]�!]��¤�«D"/] 0§+ØT+�¯"@o§�?3½

|²L¥T+�o§ØT+�o§ùÒ´�?�½|�>.¯K§́ �z²LN�

U��Ø%¯K"ù�¥§U����Ä��K§́ Uì½|ÌNUgÌû½!½

|Å�Uk�N!!1�|�UgÆ+n!1�Å'æ^¯�iÒU)û�

¯�§Ø2�á"1��K§���Ý/~�é)�²E¹ÄÚ�¬Ô¬�N�"

�(?n�?�½|'X���k��{§́ U�z²LN�U���Kí1

½|O\K¡�ü§¿U½|I¦?1±Y5�`zN�"é�\K¡�ü�¯

�§î�¢�O\"1"Ó�§�õ½|ÌN1��Ä�+n§uy½|ÌNN�

¦<!��§�²uy=éÙ�1B\§Â£�u�]�½]�yÖ"é½|O\

K¡�ü±�1�!+�!�Ö�§�a½|ÌN�{²�?\§Ø��5,�

½|O\1�"1"U�z²LN�U��Ä��K§�ØK¡�ü¥@ÃI1

�N�½"1�¯�§~�ó§ï�+�¥�½|O\+n§́ �.)û!�¯K

���"

3.!�1����" !�§´vk]�½]��½|ÌN?\½|O\K¡

�ü²(�1�N�½"1+�l¯)�²E¹Ä§¿¼�²LÂÃ��«�{

Page 356: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 345

�½|%N�1�§ÙØ%3u½|ÂÃ"@o§XÛ��!�1�½éÙ�?

Qº2013c5�§3�IuUXÚÇ�ZÜ�Ô�þ§�ÆJ¯§̄ �No)û

!�¯K"·�XÆ3�þ?1©Û�£�"·w�Ƨ5çIÝI{61Ê

�o^²(5½§ÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI§áJ�b¢�¥I�§¥IÃ�§�ç

I<E¤���§�{«ú��I?¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?¶ÿ��¤

���§�{éÙ�±1�?v§vKØ�¢Øîx"�d/¤m²é'�´§¢

�¥§A�vk�åÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI��?"��o´ù�§J�`´�^

{Æ5½éÝI<å�%��^íº�,Ø´§Ï�±¦<¶ÂÝI§nØþü

³ÝI©�þ�\iXÙ�½Ø§L(ÜÁ�?1@½"

[!�öY�Y��¯] ù´·�� +��·ù��¯"��õcc¦Q3Ü

Ü,�uU�?Ý]?�§²~I����«({Nï"@�§)¹Ô]��é«

y§�Ð�ç�´ÒX�ÞSÕ��PË"zg§{úSÛ�Ñ�gÑ¡À�/�

kAÚ��[�B§ç�·ù +��1<"ËSþ§Û�Ø�Õå5�·ù +

�YX�ÞS§̀ Xµ/¯§��¯§ù´�Ð�eËè�09��Ø�"È È�§

è<Ò¤*l"k�U§ù Û�é�·�ù +�§F"U�Xɱ�e{p

�²LuЧ̀ ¦�3{p���f�§I��:ï�]7§�4�p�Ý]10�

¬a"·�ù +���§�8ÎÜÉ«�ü§Ò�ù��8110���¤^"

ï�]7� �§ù úSÛ�é�¦3{p�� ËS*l§4¦|�f�

�ï�"¦ù *lZ���§@�Û�kЯ??�XgC§Ò<X¦x�úi

�úSÛ\ÜÓ§¿l¥<Ñ1��x�Û���a�¤"�8ï��¤�§xx

é�33§̀ µ/3B§\<·�úi��Ö§o��·3e:a"033`µ/ù��

8��â10�¬a�Û�é4Ø�§·�1�¬��a�¤"�e�a§Ñs3ó

§þ§v�o({"0xxØ&§\�Ü�<q'�ñ�§�µ�G§r33w

þ{̧�¦�û33|GÙ+n¤4500�"{Ìé10�¬a���N�§uy

33�úSÛ�m1ªÉª1��"@��²LuÐY²§1���Ø´�ê8"

��§33Ï1ª��-4c§úSÛ��l­�?6ckÏä-§mØú�§73

è<��Æ�Ø�"ù�´§73!��(i§Û�ɪ1��­��·�ù 

+��o("

ùK�¯·3Nõ|Ü�ÆùL§ÏÙ%¹X�«�8Á�¥é!�1��

?�Ä��K"5ï�ó§�þ+n^~618��^5½§���^~�5½§t

!�O!�ó!ó§inü #NÙ¦ü ½ö�<±�ü ¶Â«@ó§�§I

-U�§vÂ�{¤�§ét!�Oü Úó§inü ?ÜÓ�½�t¤!�

O¤ÚinÅ71�±þ2�±e�v±¶é�óü ?ó§ÜÓd±2%±þ4%±

Page 357: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

346 çIæÛYFn

e�v±¶�±I-Ê��î§ü$]��?¶�!î­�§L�]�yÖ"@o§

lçIæL§©Û§qA�XÛ��!�1�§XÛuy!�1�Qº·3�Ô

�þ�Ñ�g´Xeµ

1¤çIÝI�!"çI<?1ÜÓÇ��§A(@¥I<�Á�Uå§Ø¢¥

I<3ÝI©�¥Jø�Ùä�I[5½�]�^�ý�§�¢[��8²nÜ<

!NÖ<Ú©���'�¹"5¿§!��©|Å�Á�!©�Ú=��«O"

ÜÓÇ��§¥I<©|Å�Á��§ØNÖ󫧥I<�Ñ��8+n<§

A�´¥I<ü �ó§�{�Ù\ÝNÖÜÓ¶¥I<[©���8§�{

�U´çI�8¥��ÌN!�'�óS��8§�L3ÙÝI©�¥1²"Ó�§

y1{Æ¥²(B�=�1�"5çIÝI{61o�l^5½§¥I<Ø��¦<

=4¥I�8§�Ø�ò¥I�8�)�©O�¦<=4"5ï�ó§�þ+n^

~61�l^!1��Ê^!1n�o^5½§t!�O!�óÚinü §Ø�

=�½ö�{©�Ù«@��A�Ö"

2¤ÜÓÁ��!"ÜÓÁ�´uyÚ�?!�1��'�§Ï��!�<�

�Ø�!�<+nçI�8�ãÖÂ|§́ d!�<gC?1+n"u´§çI<

rÜÓ±�|G�¥I<�§�½�m±S§!�<�½¬�¦¥I<3�ØV�

�½�+n¤�§òÜÓ±��Ù�½ârþ§��´!�<gC�úiâr"¤

±§·3�Ô�þéÇ�Æ`µ/÷Xù�g´§Ç��§s��uy!�1�é

N´§��Ç�z�)ÜÓ±���=��0

é!�1�@½,4ïÜ2014c�Ù�5ïÓó§�ó=��{©���{1

�@½�?+n�{£Á1¤6£ï½120142118Ò¤1��^5½§�3e�l«

�/���§áu!�µ�vk]��ü ½�</^Ù¦�óü �]�«@ó

§�¶�k]���óü �p/^]�«@ó§�§�)]��?$�/^]�

�?p�§]��?p�/^]��?$�§�Ó]��?�p/^�¶�;�©

��u�ü Ø´Tó§��óo«�½;�«�ü �§�ï�ü ����u

�ü �ض�NÖ©��u�ü Ø´Tó§��óo«�!;�«�ü ½

;�©�ü �¶��óü 3�óy|�7��8KI<!EâKI<!�þ+

nKI<!S�+nKI<¥�<±þ��óü vk¾áNÄÜÓ§½vkïá

NÄó]½�¬�P�x'X�¶�¢S�óo«�ü ½;�«�ü �ï�ü

 �mvkó§±ÂG'X§½öó§±|G³yþ1²�ü ��óÜÓ¥1²

�«�ü Ø��§qØU?1Ün)º¿Jøá�y²�¶�ÜÓ�½d�óo

«�ü ½;�«�ü KIæ½u��Ì�ïÓá�!���9ó§��½u

���óÅ���§dÙ¦ü ½�<æ!u�§½ö�óü ØUJøk'æ

Page 358: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 347

!u�ÜÓ9u¦�y²§qØU?1Ün)º¿Jøá�y²�¶�{Æ{5

5½�Ù¦!�1�"

éuçI< ó§)û!�¯K�)ûGÏÝI�/aq"d�§­��Ø3

uuy!�1�§ù3Á�¥´��N´�¯�§ 3uuy±�XÛ?n§Ï�

ÜÓ�3Á1"´Êîe5)û!�¯K§�¥I<)ØÜÓíº·@�Ø´�Ï

�=B´!�§ÜÓ�´ÝI¿���Ô§ I��â!�<�Á�¢SUå9Á

�(J§û½´Ä±!��d)ØÜÓ§Ï�çI<±`z¢yçI�8�m�"

14!$dµ�¿¿�1����

¤�§�½|ÌN�)�û¬9Jø�@ÑÖ�¤Ñ¤ÔzNÄ!¹NÄ¥7

�NÄd��À1Ly§Ì��)��!á�!-����¤^!��òΤ^Ú

NÄó]½�Å�"ù�¥§ÔzNÄd��À1Ly�½|<!ã!Ôd�Y²

kX��'X§¹NÄd�K�²E9+nY²�'"¤±§¤��{ün)¤�

¤û¬)�ö9Ù�@ÑÖJøö¤7I�¤^|Ñ"5¿§¤�´�éu½|Ì

NgC)�!\ó½�Eû¬�¤^"çIÝI¹Ä¥§ÝI<��d¿Ø´¤�§

´ÝI<�¤çI�8�Oy¤�"çI�8�¤�§�kçI�8Á�(åâ

U�¡"çIÝI¹Ä¥5½ÝI<Ø�±$u¤���d¿I§3uÝI<$u

Ù¤���d¿I´�«�¿�Ø��¿�1�§��½|ú²¿�Úª¢Å&�

�´�K§K�çI�8�Á�(J"@o§çI<qXÛU�¡ÝI<��d

$uÙ¤�QºU¤��¹Â§çI<Ø�U�¡§�õ´~¦½ú%ÝI<��

d$uÙ¤�§�kÝI<gC�ÙÙ¤�"ù�¥�Ø%§3uÝI<35�Ú

Á�¥´Ä(@ÙÝI�dØ$u¤�§Ø(@ÙÝI�d§�¦çI<3ÙÝI

�dÄ:þ?1\d�§�¤ÝI<�d$uÙ¤��¯¢"¤±§�¦ÝI<Ø

�±$u¤���d¿I´�«ÝI�d��K§=ÝI<�ÝI©��²4�§

=Ø�2(²Ù�d$uÙ¤�"ÄK§ÝI<=��çIÝI{�r�55½§

I«úÝIÃ��¬¯I?"@o§�d$uÝI<�¤�§µI�¬µ"¥´

ÄUO(�½Qº�©Ûe¡ù��d$u¤���¯"

[�d$u¤���¯] 2003c9�§,�á�?ú´ó§ï�§æ^úmçI�

ª(½�óü "T�83ÝI���mc§�k12[ÝI<4�ÝI©�"µ

I�¬µIL§¥§uyÝI<R��dÉ~$§®$uÙ¦ÝI<�d���

¤"µI�¬~¦ÝI<R��d$u¤�§éÙ�d©�|�@ý�µ"Ú

'�"

Page 359: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

348 çIæÛYFn

µI�¬3©ÛÝI<R��d�U$uÙ¤��§uyÝI<Réú´=�

��f��d$uÙ¦�d§�16.00�/m3§ Ù¦ÝI<��d§k�42.30�/m3§

k�42.60 �/m3"²LEاµI�¬(@§�´Ï�ÝI<R3��8ÝI¥

é�f��d�16.00�/m3��ÙÝI�d$uÙ¦�d���¤"éd§µI

�¬�ÝI<RuÑ�¦¼§�¦ÝI<R)º¿Jø�A�y²á�"35½

��mS§ÝI<RéµI�¬��¦?1Ö¡©�§��µI�¬%¥

�¦Ä§¡Ù��ú´=��f�½|d�342.00 �/m3-43.00�/m3m§�¦�

3ÝI¥§é��8¢�¥�þ�=��fæ��Ø´�½|þ�ï ´Ò/�

á§)º`¦�3ÝI¥§���{¤]�§uyú´�IB+�B++ã>þ§

k�^¢ïn�õc�à�" �§3ë�y| tL§¥§ÝI<R�<3>þ

ÁX��§uy/L��35cmeÒ´�f�"²Ly|UIO��§¦�£¢�

�÷�[k]��¢�¿uÿ§(@�f����I÷v�O�¦"ÝI<R3©

�`²¥§NkT¢�¿éx��f�uÿ�w§Ó��k16.00�/m3�üd©Û

L§y²Ù�dØ$u¤�"

µI�¬²Lµ"§�ÉÝI<R�©�`²§@�ÝI<R��dØ$

uÙ¤�"T�8æ^�´²µ"��$ÝId{J`§ÝI<R�µI�¬í

��1�¥IÿÀ<"çI<UµI�¬�í�§(½ÝI<R¥I§�Ù\¾

ó§u�«�ÜÓ"2003c10�15F§¥I<R?|�ó§UÙ�ó�Y§35y

�IB+�B++ã§åú´30m-50m�¢ïà���f§?1ú´�óï�§UÜÓ

�½�ï�óϧu2004c3�20Feó§|�Ï�¤ª"

T^ú´Ï��Ø������U§ú´B+�B++ã1�`«�{�?Iè

Ü�é�çI<§¡/��Lk?´0§éçI<3á�mS�¤ú´ï�§E4u

¬�1��\7ü"��§5<<Ñ5¥u<¬�ÚIYè�±{6Ú5¥u<¬

�ÚI¶�] {6§¡Tú´ï�¥§35y´B+�B++ã���f�1�A�

�ÌYè�±{Ú¶�] {§Ù¥§¶�] {1n��^5½§mæ¶�] §

7L�ÅI[éYè�±�{Æ5½§é�/!ú�!�/Ïæ¶É�»��§m

æè�A�Ï/�¨/æ�E�|^!�ä«ú½öÙ¦|^��"{IèÜ�5

<`µ/vk²LIèÜ�1O§òg3B+�B++ãì·>þ3e@o����§�

G�ÈY¬K�±>ì·�­½5§�»�@�ã���§A�{r�Wþ§E

�!�äÚ«ú§£E����"0

çI<d�â�,�ק¥I<R�5´�ùo���/�0§(JgC�ý

Òa?�§X�I?QºçI<Äk��µI�¬§%µI�¬µ"�v

kuyÝI<R��/�0§��cõL�§/QG0�µI�¬QØÑ�§Q�

Page 360: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 349

¥I<Rj§X4¦�4Xú«�ó§�@o���/�0"çI<é�¥I<R§¥

I<R�ØZ§/·ÝI´ù�Ý�§ÜÓ�´ù�\�§³�o4·�óü «ú

I?�0T�8çI<Ú¥I<R�û�J§{IèÜ��ú´B+�B++ã>��ó

�����vk��£n§u´§éçI<e�1�?v-§�¦Ù3���S

¡E�G§¿?v±20��"��§çI<|�é��?1£W§3Ùþ«ú!«

ä"d�§çI<ÿ�15%�m�ÜÓ±�|G�¥I<R§u´§±d�dØ2|

G¥I<R�ÜÓ±"¥I<RÏçI<áØ|GÜÓ{±§rçI<wþ{̧

çI<±¥I<R�ó¥»���§áØÁ1?EÂÖ�d|F"¢Sþ§çI

<Ú¥I<3�¯¥ÑkL�§I�«ú¬¯I?"V�3�Y¥L«úI?��

�§d{�"n�\�"

I�?�Ú©Û�´§�¯¥§¥I<R¿��¥§Á1ÜÓÂÖ§(�ú

´Ï�"@o§¥I<R�ÝI�d´Ä$uÙ¤�Qº�Y´�½��ÝI<Ø�

±$u¤���d¿I¥�¤�§́ �ÝI<�{Á1çI�8�¤^|Ñ"�¯

¥§¥I<RáØ�{Á1ÜÓÂÖ§=3Ù���f�¡E���G§±�éY

è��E¤ú³§¢�´�d$u¤�§¦�TÜ©d�"çI<v@ýÁ1"

�ÂÖ§�É¥I<R�ÝI§¦���»�Yè���ÝI�±¥I§çI<

�,I�«úI?"@o§µI�¬´Ä�A«ú��I?QºµI�¬´U

çI©�5½�IOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"§�ÝQ~¦¥I<R��d$

u¤�§XJk��¤?�ÚJ¯¥I<R§�¦Ù«ú��f�E¤���£

W9��¡EI?§(Ø�½´¥I<R��d$u¤�§�ϵI�¬¤é

Yè�±{ÆØÙ§vU@½¥I<R�ÝI�d$u¤�§A�`kµ"�ÝØ

�I?"�çI<��ÜÓ�¯<�É¥I<R�ÝI§/¤ÜÓ'X§L²

çI<�ɵI�¬�¤�µ"Ú'�(J§é¥I(J«ú¬¯I?"

¢�¥§ÝI<$u¤��d¿Ikü«Ly§�«´ÝIL�1�§=ÝI

<��d¥�3­��¢¦½L�§��Ù�dØv±�¤çI�8¶,�«´Ý

I�¿1�§=ÝI<|^çI©�¥�3�¢¦!L�ÚçI<��$d¥I�

d3%n§æ�/$d¥I§pd¢�0üѧ¥I�2±çI�8/��0çI<

�éÙ?1\d½Ö�"�ÃØ´=«�/¥I§þ¬3�½§ÝþE¤I[|

Ã!�¬ú�|ÃÚçI<�Ü{�ÃÉ��³"çIæL§¥§éÝI�d$

u¤����§©�çIÝI5�ÚÁ�ü��ã��"

1.çIÝIé�d$u¤����" çIÝI�ãéÝI�d$uÙ¤��

��§©OdµI�¬ÚçI<¢�"

1¤�dØ�$uÝI<¤��{n"Äk§ÝI�dØ�$uÝI<gC�¤

Page 361: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

350 çIæÛYFn

�´½|�´�Ä��¦§´�´ö3/g�!²�!ú�!ª¢&^0�KÄ:

þ?1��´§ù�¥§ª¢&^´½|�´�Ä:"éd§5¬{;6oK?5½§

¬¯¹ÄA��Ìg�!ú²!�dk�!ª¢&^��K§çIÝI¹Ä���

«¬¯�´1�§L�Å/ú²!ú�0!/ª¢Å&0Ú/�dk�0�¬¯�´�

K"Ùg§ÝI<�d$uÙ¤�§Ø|uJp²L�ÃÚ�y�8�þ§́ E¤

¥I<Á1ÜÓL§¥Üó~�!±g¿Ð§½ö<¥I�8��çI<�O\

¤^§�¦çI�8�þÃl�y"ÝI�d$u¤�áu�¿¿�1�§��

úm!ú²!ú�Úª¢&^�çIÝI�K§k³u�¬Ì½|²LN��ï

�"éd§5çIÝI{6��B�55K§Ù1n�n^5½§ÝI<Ø�±$u

¤���d¿I§±�åÝI<�ÝI�d1�"éA/§5çIÝI{¢�^~6

1Ê��^£Ê¤5½§ÝI�d$u¤�½´puçI©��½��pÝI�d

�§µI�¬A�ÄûÙÝI"

5¿§ÝI<Ø�±$u¤���d¿I�I?ÌN´ÝI< Ø´çI<½

Ù¦1n<§=ÝI<3ÝI���mc4�ÝI©���=L²§��çI<�

ÉÙÝI§KÙ=ÉÝI©�L«¿g��å§UÙ��¯�§�)��d±!�

þÚÁ1Ï��ÝI¢�5SN§ª&Á�¥I�8"�d§5çIÝI{6¿��

¦çI<(½ÝI<¤�? �½Ù�d´Ä$uÙ¤�§Ï�Q´ÝI<�¤�

Ò�½¬k�ɧçI<±91n<�Ãl�¡Ù¤�"

2¤çI©�?�é�d$u¤����"çI<��ÜÓ�¯<§éçIæ

�8«úÁ�(JI?"�d§çI<3?�çI©�¥§I�k�é5�éÝI

�d$uÝI<¤�?1��"�)µ�çI��"çIÝI¹Ä¥§çI��§=

I�.½�ØO!¹·§́ E¤ÝI<éI�n)þ�Ø��§ÝI<�éT�8

½f8k��d§k�Ø�d"��d�§Ò�UE¤$u¤���/¶�Eâ�

¦"Eâ�¦´çI�8�Eâ.½§K�ÝI�d"�Eâ�¦�3�ؽc�

gñ!Eâ�¦¹·Ø�§=k�K5�¦ ÃäN��I!ëꧽ´Eâ�¦²

(§�½|þ÷vEâ�¦�û¬l5U!�þ!sÚÚ¦^�Jþ�3���É

��/�§ÝI<´3�O(n)çI�8Eâ�¦^�e?1�ÝI"Ó�§Á

��çI<�½¬éÙN�!?U½?�Ú²(k'Eâ�¦ �UçI^�§E

¤ÝI<�d$uÙ¤�¶�Á�^�"çI�8Á�^�´çI<3ÜÓÁ�¥

Jø¥I<^�§X|/^�!/e!/þæNÔ!©Ô!�ä!��ïÓÔ!�Ï

^�!Y!>!Ï&^��"ùÜ^�§��'XÝI<�d9ÜÓÁ�§��

�d�¦Ø²(§ÝI<3ÝI��n)�çI<�¦Ø���§́ E¤�d$u

ÝI<�¢SÁ�¤�"

Page 362: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 351

�d§çI©�?��é�d$uÝI<¤����Ø%§3uO(.½çI

�8"çI�8.½��O(§�d$uÝI<¤���U5Ò��"��§K´

uE¤ÝI<$u¤��d"AO´§ÝI<�¿�±$uÙ¤���d¿I§¥

I�/�/åd0§½´Á�L§¥/±¥I�8��çI<0\d§¢SþÑ´3

|^çI��ØO!Eâ�¦Ø²½´Á�^��3¦É�çI�8.½þ�3×

\ ¢��§�d§����d$uÝI<��O¤�§çI<?�çI©��A

��çI��O(!Eâ�¦�Ù!Á�^�²("é@çI��ØO!Eâ�

¦Ø�½´Ü^�ز�§��بmÐçIæ"é@�3þã"�q7L

?1çI��8§çI©�A3ÝI�d!¤Ç9d��¤²(�Ä:þ§��Ü

ÓC�^�Úd±C��O��â!�KÚ�{§±�ÖçI��ØO!Eâ�¦

Ø�½´Ü^�ز�"�"

3¤µIé�d$uÝI<¤����"µI�¬¿Ø�¡çI�8�¤�

´õ�§ÙéÝI�d´Ä$uÙ¤����§�U´~¦§? �¦ÝI<gC

y²ÙÝI�dØ$u¤�"��/§3µIL§¥§µI�¬uyÝI<��

d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d½ö3�kI.�²w$uI.§@�ÙÝI�d�U$

uÙ¤��§A��¦TÝI<�ÑÖ¡`²¿Jø�'y²á�"ÝI<ØUÜ

n`²½öØUJø�'y²á��§dµI�¬@½TÝI<±$u¤��d

¿I§ÄûÙÝI"

ùp§µI�¬��I3uµ"Ú'�§=éÝI�d?1µ"§�Ù¦Ý

I�d'�§½ö�I.'�§uyÝI<�d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d½ö²w$

uI."ùp�/�U0=~¦§A��¦TÝI<�ÑÖ¡`²¿Jø�'y²

á�§=D�ÝI<���ÞyÂÖ§y²Ù�Å{Æ5½§ÝI�dØ$uÙ

gC�¤�"ÝI<ØUÜn`²½öØUJø�'y²á��§=L²ÝI<Ø

Uy²gCÁ15çIÝI{6é/ÝI<Ø�±$u¤���d¿I0�B�

55½"5¿§ÝI�d´Ä/²w0$uÙ¦ÝI�d½ö/²w0$uI.dµ

I�¬�ä§�µI�¬¤;����'"�ØUâd@�µI�¬A«

ú�d$uÝI<¤��{ÆI?§Ï��d$uÝI<¤����I?<´ÝI

<gC Ø´µI�¬§�ÉÝI<¥I�I?ÌN´çI<"��/§µI�

¬@½ÝI<±$uÙ¤���d¿IÌ�k±e�/µ�µI�¬éÝI�

d�â�Ø?��§�¦ÝI<é?���d�±(@ ÝI<Ø(@¶�ÝI<

ØUµI�¬��¦©�!̀ ²§̀ ²ØÜn½´Ã{Jøk'y²á�|±Ù

`²¶�ÝI<Ö¡�¦\d§±�ÖÙ¢¦½�dL$�L²�d$uÙ�O¤

��Ù¦1�"ù�¥§¿vk�¦µI�¬(½çI�8�¤�d´õ�"�

Page 363: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

352 çIæÛYFn

¤±ù�5½§��¡§ÝI<Ø�±$u¤���d¿I´{ÆD�ÝI<�r

�5ÂÖ§ÝI<L�Ŷ,��¡§�d´Ä$uÝI<��O¤�§=´Ä$

uÙ\ó!)�½�E¿Jø�@ÑÖ�¤Ñ¤ÔzNÄ!¹NÄd��kÝI<

gC�Ù§µI�¬Ã{(½Ù�¤çI�8�¤�"¤±§µIL§¥§µI

�¬�U´'�ÝI�d§3~¦�d$uÝI<¤��§�{�¦TÝI<é

Ù�l{Æ5½�1��Ñ`²!Jø�'y²á�§́ ��ÝIL�1� ��

��d$u¤�"

[�1©a¥I�Ûª] 2017c3�17F§,½ï�CX�½1�«y�êâ¥%§

=�Ö��ÑÖ�8§ý�7��495��",�O�úi±1©a�ÝI�d¥

I§T¯�3½|þÚåZ,�Å"�S�;[ÊH@�§T�O�úi1©a�

ÝI$uÙ¤�§A��{�±Äû"T�83ÝI���mc§kÊ[ÝI<4

�ÝI©�"µIL§�¥§Ê[ÝI�<EâþÑvk¯K§Ñ÷væI¦"

µI�¬vkéT�O�úi�ÝI�±Äû§í�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<§1�

¶��d�170��"çI<(½T�O�úi¥I§�Ù\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"

�<Q�Ý@�T�8µI�¬v�{Á1{Æ�I§=é��495��

Ý]��8§vkÄûù���d1©a��O�úi�ÝI"@o§çIÝI{5

½�dØ�$uÝI<�¤�§́ ÄØ#NÝI¿�Qº�,Ø´�5çIÝI{6

1n�n^´éÝI<�1��å§=��ÝI<�{?1ÝI§ÙÝI�dÒ

A�Ø$uÙ¤�§ù´{Æ�¿"~X3ù�1©a¥I�¯~¥§��ÝI<3

µI�¬�ÙuÑ�¦�§U`Ñéù�495����8ï��d��1©a´

Ün�§«ìÁ��1©a�¤�8ï�§ÒØA�òÙÝIÀ�´$u¤���d

¿I§Ï�ùp�¤�Ø�uk/]��d�oÚ§ ´4ÝI(@Ù�{Á1

{ÆÂÖ"¢Sþ§�Ö�ùaæ�8§Ø´üX/ï1�§́ aquBOTA

N²E�8æ"ÝI<'5�¿�´��Ú^�mu¤^§ ´Ù�8$=�§

/�?ú&å�ï�ê⥧3½|mu�ã¼�²LÂÃ"

4¤ÜÓÇ�"�d$uÝI<¤��ÝIXJ¥I§��K�çI�8Á�

¦I[|Ã!�¬ú�|ÃÚçI<Ü{�ÃÉ��³"�d§çI<3(½¥I

<9\¾ÜÓL§¥§Aæ�k���é¥IdL$§k�UK�Á���/?1

��µ�5çIÝI{6�o�8^5½§çI<Ú¥I<A�g¥IÏ�ÖuÑ�

Få30FS§UìçI©�Ú¥I<�ÝI©�¾áÖ¡ÜÓ"Ó�§çI<Ú¥

I<Ø�21¾á�lÜÓ¢�5SN�Ù¦�Æ"�d§¥IÿÀ<½¥I<3

ÝIk�ÏS�çI<JÑÞd�¦§½ö3\¾ÜÓ��çI<JÑÙ¦N\^

�§¢Sþ´��ÝI���1�§L²ÙÝI�d$u¤� ��ª¢Å&�K§

Page 364: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 353

çI<�±�â5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ô�o^5½§��Ù¥I]�§é¤J

��ÝI�y7Ø�ò�§¿�{lÙ¦¥IÿÀ<¥(½¥I<½­#çI¶�

éÝI�d²w$uÙ¦ÝI�d§½ö²w$uI. µI�¬��{éÙÄ

û�ÝI§XJ¥I§çI<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ�§A3çI©�Ä:þ§�¦¥I

<4�Á�ú�§?�Ú²(ÜÓC�^�!�K!§SÚOd�{§�½ÜÓ�

��/���?n��{�¯�¶�G±�ª§±L§G±U�½'~�3§Á�

�¤��g5(��O"Ù¥�§�3'~dçI�8Á�A:û½§��3�3

ýG±!�þ�y7Ä:þ§±�±ØK�¥I<Á���K§~X§U15%-25%�

3"ù�§��¥I<3Á�L§¥Øª&Á�§�éÙ��UÜÓ�½?n"

2.Á�é�d$u¤����"Á�L§¥§çI<Ú¥I<ÑAUìÜÓ�

½Á1gCÂÖ"��¡§çI<A�ÜÓ�½§�ÜÓÁ�JøÜÓ�½�^�§

±;�¥I<ØÁ�½¢�þÊ�Á��1�´dçI<¤�¶,��¡§\ré

¥I<ª&Á��+n§�)µ�î�C�!UûÚ\y+n§UÜÓ�½u�¥

I<´Ä�3���/ÚÜÓI?"7��§éAÏ���/?�Ú²(I?§\

ÝÖ¿�ƶ�\rá�!��!¤¬½�¤¬�þ�\|u�!uÿ§±9�E!

SCL§§AO´Û-�8�u�ÚÄ�§��¥I<Á�L§¥±g¿Ð§K�

çI�8��þ¶�UÜÓ�½�¦¥I<J�ýG±ú�"©g|GÜÓd±�§

Aé{gG±?1®o!Eا±��ÜÓd±��!¦Ú­E¶�î�Á�?Ý

���+n§©)Á�Oy¿·��ÐÁ�F�§�)m©!�¤�m§±9L§

¥�Aϯ�!�dÚ?nP¹�§AO´¥I<ØÁ�½´¯¢Ê�Á�§E

¤Á�OyØUXÏ¢y��*¯¢9�'y²á�¶�é¥I<Á�¥/�/å

d0§<çI�8��çI<§¢�ØÁ�½Ê�Á��§�{)ØÜÓ"çI<d

�XJ¯k�3ÜÓL§G±�½'~�±�§~X§15%-25%§KéÒr¥I

<ª&Á�äk�½�åå"Ó�§�±�{�oÅ�<�Ü{�Ã"

15!Y~µ!�²EÜÓJ��Y

áJ�b¢�¥I1�¥§ÝI<3ÝI©�¥¦^�E!CE�1�N�y

�!Jb�ãÖG¹½ö�1!Jb��8KI<½öÌ�Eâ<{{!NÄ'

Xy²!Jb�&^G¹�§3ex�çiyâ�§���¯¢'�Ò�±�½Ù

áJ�b1�§çIæ¥�J?n�´±¦<¶ÂÝI½!�1�"�,5çI

ÝI{61Ê�o^5½§ù«�/¥IÃ�"Ó�5½�çI<E¤���§�

{«ú��I?¶�¤���§�{JÄ�¯<�-¯I?"�çIÝI¥§Ã{

Page 365: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

354 çIæÛYFn

ülÝI©�þ�\iXÙ�/ª?1@½"��/§!�1�Ø´3çIÝI¥

uy§ ´3Á�¥uy§AO´Á�¥§!�<��!�<�mÑyØ�NÚ

�²LŪ§Oþ{Ì��ÿ"d�§U5çIÝI{6Ú5¬{;6oK?�5½§

Ï¥IÃ�§!�<�çI<\¾�ÜÓÃ�§!�<��!�<m�!��ÆÃ

�"@o§éu�½�Ã��ÜÓ§!�<3ÜÓÁ1¥«ú�o¬¯I?§�!

�<3ÜÓÁ1¥qA«ú�o¬¯I?Q"<¬{�3"nù�aÜÓŪ�§

´�â5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ÔzÊ�n^§U�p<¬{�5'u"nï�ó§�

óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�)º6£�¤Ú£�¤§±¯¢��⧫©!�<

Ú�!�<�¬¯I??1"n§�e¡ù�!�²EÜÓJ��Y"

[Y�£�] 2011c3�§,Ik�/�muúi3,½l�mu$�4Ã�8§

ïÓ¡È76842m2§g,<Ü,�T�/�muúi�{½�L<±oéÙ£§[

!�è�`«@T�8�ó"2011c11�15F§Ü,�è�`\¾T�8«@ó§

�ÆÖ§�½3«@Tl�$�4Ã�8¥§è�`KIÝI!�n�'ÃYÚ�

ï�ü \¾�óÜÓ§Ü,$��/�muúi§4è�`¥I§dÜ,±è�

`�¶Â|�ó§�ó§è�`U�8�ª(�±§�Ø[7ÚN���§�Ü

,Â�1%è�+n¤^"

T�8çI©�1²�çI���Ä:!ÌN(�!C?C»!�YüY!æ

Ï!>íÚ<�ó§��óã�þ�SN"Ü,ÏL�/�muúi�±o$�§

Jc��Ù¦ÝI<��d"µI�§3±o�V«e§µI�¬�è�`µ�

p©§è�`¤õ¥I"2011c11�24F§è�`��/�muúi\¾T�8�

óÜÓ§¿UìÜ,�è�`�¯kû½§dÜ,|�T�8�ó§U�½�è�

`|G1%�+n¤"2012c5�22F§�/�muúi±�Y]7óä�§Ã{¢

yÜÓ8��d§�è�`uÑ)ØÜÓÏ�Ö§Ï�è�`)Øþã�óÜÓ§

T�8�ó�=Ê�"

è�`��/�muúiéó§±(�©Ü��§è�`��p?<¬{�J

å�z§²"n��Ѭ¯�û§@½T�8�óÜÓ�Ã�ÜÓ§�/�muú

iA�è�`|Gó§±9��¤1262.00��§è�`A|G�/�muúiá�

±Ú>±33.00��§è�`l�/�muúi®+�ó§±1229.00��"�óL

§¥§Ü,±�8KI<�°§lè�`+�688.00��󧱧è�`U½�

/ï�+nÜ�5½§�à¬ó|Gó]510.00��"2013c�2017c§ÏTó§ö

já�!��øÀû±�§è�`3��å�zY�¥��'�|<wþ{̧{

�@½è�`A��'�|<|G±�oO1314.00��"�d§è�`�{�å�

�¦§�-Ü,��è�`ó§±1263.00�"

Page 366: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 355

TYX!�²EÜÓJ��Ū""nL§¥§Ü,ÌÜÙ�è�`\¾�«

@ó§�ÆÖ�¥0�Ƨ�!��ƧÓ�§@�è�`��/�muúi\¾!

)ØÜÓ§Adè�`«úÙ��'�|<���ÂÖ"�d§{�"n�@�§

lT�ÆSN¥�½�/è�``k�ÄdÜ,éó§�8�²E«��§Ü,U

ó§�ª(�±�1% �è�`þ�¤^0w§Ù5�²wØÓu¥0�Ƨ A

½5�!�²E§V�/¤!��óÜÓ'X"5¥u<¬�ÚIïÓ{6£±e{

¡5ïÓ{6¤1��8^5½µ/B�ïÓ�óè�±?Û/ª#NÙ¦ü ½ö

�<¦^�è��]�yÖ!E��짱�è��¶Â«@ó§0§�Ü,�è

�`\¾�«@ó§�ÆÖÃ�§�¿ØK�V�mÒ�ód±?1(�½J�"

Ü,|��ó¥§éöjá�±!ó§±�§��è�`¤�õå�zY���

w§«úk')��ûÖ(½��GÂÖ§±93�óL§è�`¢S|Ñ�N

Ö¤��'ÅÖAd!�<Ü,«ú§è�`���!�<§3é«ú�X�G

±I?�§k��Ü,J�"Ü,��!�<§è�`��/�muúi\¾��

óÜÓ�)اشÜ,��!�<ØÁ1G±I?�{½¯d"�d§�ûÜ,

«ú��I?§{nþ¿ÃØ�"

{�@�§è�`��Ü,|��ó|Ñ668.00��+510.00��+1314.00�

�=2492��§Ü,�óA�ó§±�1229.00��§�ö�1263.00��=�Ü,A

��è�`�ó§±ê�"{�éè�`�¦Ü,��ó§±1263.00����z

�¦�±|±§�ûÜ,u�û)���ÊFS��è�`ó§±1263.00�"X�

U��û�½�ÏmÁ1�G7aÂÖ§A��ì5¥u<¬�ÚI¬¯�z{6

1�zÊ�n^�5½§\�|G´òÁ1Ïm�ÅÖ|E"

[¯K] �âY�£�§©Û±e¯Kµ

1.�YçIÝI¥�3=¯K§��o{�@½è�`��/�muúi\

¾�ÜÓÃ�º

2.�o´!�1�ºó§ï�+�¥§!�<��!�<A«ú={ÆI?º

�Y{���o@½Ü,�è�`\¾�«@ó§�ÆÖØ´¥0�ƽ©��

Æ ´!��Ƨnd´�oºé�½!�1�k=é&º

3.�Yè�`��§���!�<vÉ�?Û?vwª§{���où��

ûºè�`3�Y������§Tó§,á�ûå�è�`§�¦|Göj�À

±350��§d�Ü,Cñ[�§U�ûÖ|Gè�`�¤�ÃA§è�`´ÄkI

?|GTá�ûÀ±§��oºé�!�<qk=é&º

[Y~©Û] �âY�£�§éþã¯K©ÛXe:

1.�YçIÝI¥§�3�¯Kkµ�Ü,�è�`\¾«@ó§�ƧdÜ

Page 367: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

356 çIæÛYFn

,±è�`�¶Â|�ó§�ó�±¦<¶ÂÝI¶�çI<�±oJcw�Ü,

Ù¦ÝI<��d§�5çIÝI{¢�^~61o��^~Þ�/çI<3mI

cméÝI©�¿òk'&E�³�Ù¦ÝI<0�/§áuçI<�ÝI<GÏ

ÝI¶�µI�§±oV«µI�¬�è�`µ�p©§��5çIÝI{¢�

^~61o�l^¥�çI</Ø�±²«½öV«��ª��½öü½A½ÝI

<0�5½"

{�@½è�`��/�muúi\¾ÜÓÃ��nd§́ T�8�çIÝI

¥�3þã�{1�§=�3±¦<¶ÂÝI1�§U5çIÝI{61Ê�o^§

ÝI<±¦<¶ÂÝI�¥IÃ�"Ó�§�â5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ÔzÊ�n^§

U�p<¬{�5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·^{ƯK�)º£�¤6

1�^5½§vk]��¢S�ó</^k]��ïÓ�óè�¶Â�§A��â

5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�n^5½§=��{Æ!1�{5�r�55½\¾�

�¬¯{Æ1�Ã�§@½ÜÓÃ�"

2.!�§�Å�½|�lá½�Nu,�Å�½|�§±TÅ�¶Âl¯½|

²E¹Ä"~X§3ó§ï�+�§���óè�#N¦<3�½ÏmS¦^gC

è�¶Âé«�ó§�1�§¦<´!�<§Tè�´�!�<"

IÖ��Ù�5ï�ó§�þ+n^~61�l^!1��Ê^Ú1n�o^§

B�t!�O!�óÚinü #NÙ¦ü ½ö�<±�ü �¶Â«@ó§

�Ö"T^~18�^!18��^©Oé!�<Ú�!�<5½{ÆI?µ�!

�<{ÆI?µ���]�yÖ«@ó§t!�O!�óÚin�Ö�§�±�

5§?ÜÓ�½�t¤!�O¤½öinÅ71�±þ2�±e�v±¶é�óü

 ?ó§ÜÓd±2%±þ4%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§�±vÂ"��!�<{

ÆI?µt!�O!�ó!ó§inü #NÙ¦ü ½ö�<±�ü ¶Â«

@ó§�§I-U�§vÂ�{¤�§ét!�Oü Úó§inü ?ÜÓ�

½�t¤!�O¤ÚinÅ71�±þ2�±e�v±;é�óü ?ó§ÜÓd

±2%±þ4%±e�v±¶�±I-Ê��î§ü$]��?¶�!î­�§L�]

�yÖ"

@o§�o´�¬¥0|�§�o´©�Qº�¬¥0§��½|¥0§´�

@0u�?�è�!û¬)��²E½�<�ü �m§�½|ÌNJø&E\

Î!�Ô!²L!{Æ��«ÑÖ�|�½Å�§±Jø¥0ÑÖ§¼�ÑÖ¤�A

�¶©�§́ �¥I<ò¤«@�ï�ó§��ÌN!�'�ó��{©��äk

�A]��1n<�1�§T¥I<¿ØòÑ«�'X§Ù�1n<Ò1n<�¤

�ó�¤J�çI<«úë�I?"5¿§©��=��«O"¤¢=�§́ �¥

Page 368: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

114ÙçIæµáJ�b¢�¥I��� 357

I<ò«�ó§�Ü=��1n<§½´ò¥I�8�ÌN!'�ó�©��1n

<�1�"

�Y{�@½Ü,�è�`\¾�«@ó§�ÆÖ�!��Æ�nd§́ Ü,

�è�`\¾�«@ó§�ÆÖ§Ï��Æ¥�½�/è�``k�ÄdÜ,éó

§�8�²E«��§Ü,Uó§�ª(�±�1%�è�`þ�¤^0"35�þ§

ù°«@ó§�ÆÖØÓu���¥0�Ƨ�Ø´©��Ƨ ´Ü,|^è�

`�]�!]�yÖ«@T�8��ó�Ö"�d§{�@½T�Æïá�Ü,�

è�`�'X�!�²E'X"

�Yé�½!�1��é&3u§!�<´±�G�!�<�½�+n¤�A

�\¾�!��Æ"�ÜÓ±�\âr�ØÓ§kü«�/µ�ÜÓ±�\�!�

<âr§�!�<�ØV��½�+n¤�§3�½Ï�S�\!�<�½âr"

ù´çIæ+�¥!��~���/¶�ÜÓ±�\!�<âr§!�<3V�

�½�Ï�Sò+n¤|G�!�<"ù«�/§��çI<�¥I<\¾ÜÓ�§

Ø¢¥I<Õ1ârÒ�±uy§Ø�´çI<�!�<3ÜÓ\¾�GÏ�í§

�Ù3Ç�Ú"O¥´�½�±uy�"

3.�Y{��û���É~�?§3ué�!�<è�`vkÉ�?v"@o§

{���o�ù��ûQ§́ Ä�!�<Ø«úÙ4¦<!��I?QºXJù�

n)§@Ò��A�"Äk§{�²"n,@½è�`3�Y¥��!�<§1

�Ì+Ü�I��{éè�`?1?v§?ÜÓd±2%±þ4%±e�v±"Ó�§

�±I-è�`Ê��î§ü$Ù]��?"@½è�`!��!î­�§��±

L�Ù]�yÖ§=B�Ù2«@ó§�ó�Ö¶Ùg§{�"nY��1�Ü�

��½|�{1�§IÌÄ��ØÓ"{�ÉnY���K��§́ ¬¯"�¥�

/¬ØÞ(ØÄ0�K§=�wå�´{�éÄ"�§S�kû^�"Ó�§{�"

����A��wå�������§{�Ø�é�w�JÑ�z�¦�¯�?1

"�"�Y¥§è�`���w�{�å��wÜ,§�¦{��-Ü,��è�

`�ó§±1263.00�"{��âV�\¾�«@ó§�ÆÖ§éÜ,�â�ÆÖ´

ÄA��è�`�ó§±1263.00��Ñ�û"{��â5ïÓ{61��8^5½

�/B�ïÓ�óè�±?Û/ª#NÙ¦ü ½ö�<¦^�è��]�yÖ!

E��짱�è��¶Â«@ó§0§�½Ü,�è�`\¾�«@ó§�ÆÖ

Ã�§�̱¯¢��â§é�w��z�¦?1"�§¿�¿�X{�|±è�

`#4Ü,!��1�§ ´Ò�w��z�¦?1�û§ù´{�3�Y¥�{

"���I"

�Y¥§Ü,±è�`¶Âé\Ý�©�!á�Ú��æÜÓ§è�`�

Page 369: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

358 çIæÛYFn

�ÜÓ�¯<§�{«úÜÓÌNI?"3Ü,|G©�û½á�!��øAûÜ

Ód±�§è�`UÜÓ�½�{Kk|GÜÓd±ÂÖ"ÄK§áuè�`��§

«ú��I?"5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ÊzÔ�Ô^5½§�¯<��ØÁ1ÜÓÂÖ

½öÁ1ÜÓÂÖØÎÜ�½�§A�«úUYÁ1!æ�ÖÍ��½ö����

���I?"�d§è�`3�Y������§Tó§,á�ûå�è�`§�¦

|Göj�À±350�� Ü,ÃUå|G�§è�`�{Kk|GTá�ûÀ±

�I?"ù�(Jé�!�<é&3u§3½|O\K¡�ü�¦ä�]�!]�

âUl¯)�!\ó½�E�+�§Ø�#N¦</^½öu�gC�]�½]�

yÖÝI§½´l¯)�²E¹Ä§Ï�!�1���½|O\��Ý�¦§á

u�{�51�§A�gú-�"

Page 370: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 15Ù

çIæµ�{µI���

**********************************************************************

S�2fZ�m§�2Ue»¬è�ô§º�ØÄSXì"

— /.Ú75dÂ�¢º¤»y6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 371: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

360 çIæÛYFn

11!¬1µµI�¬¤�{�ÄÏ

k�´§�Ø� §7k/"ùéçI<!ÝI<�ó�<Xd§éµI;

[�´Xd"µIdçI<�{|ï�µI�¬KI§́ éÝI(J�µ�§́

�âçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI¯¢§=ÝI©��µ"Ú'�"µ

I�m�´�¤µI�w§í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<§? ÑÖuçI<J`(½¥

I(J�8�"µI�¬¥�çI<�LÚµI;[þ´�¬¤��§äk�

¬á5§Ùë�µI�8��kØÓ§�õ´�Á1�¬ÂÖ§�²Lï��zÙ

h²â�¶�Ù¥�k�ꤴAG�¯§±¼�µINÖ¤�8�¶4�êK

´�ö�µI§¢yÙhe��{�´8��m�§IéÙÚ±­À§\réµI

�¬¤�(½9ÙµI1��åÅ��ïħ±¦µI�¬Å��Ð/ÑÖ

uçIæ§ÑÖu²Lï�"e¡ùKµI;[ɪ��?kÏä-��¯§́

·2012c�,�uÐU��§ùÇçIÝI{�§x·�Å|�Ó�3´þ�·ù

ã��/u)���¯"

[µI;[ɪ��¯] 2011c3�§,��^ú´ï��8�óçI§mI�,µ

I3Ù�¬¢½�ú�] �´¥%Þ1§�ie�ë�éT�8µI�iÒ"

µI=ò(å�§çI�nÅ��µI�¬¤u�NÖ¤§z<��&µ"ù

�§µI�¬Ì?����Ä�§Úå�3iÒ�i<5¿"��¦�

m@�&µ§3p¡¹¢�e§<Ñ5�ÜÕ1k§w�wq�£&µp"

��L§§i<3,���m�iÀ¶4þw����Ù§Az��NÖ¤u

�Õ1k§ùØÎÜ~n"

u´§i<Jc��µI;«�Ñ�§�@ µI;[rÑ5�,ò¦:

e5§4¦<Ñ5@�&µ.ù ;[ô�/l�p<Ñ��&µ,(@´Ùë�µ

I�NÖ¤�§i<�m&µ§uyp¡(¢´�ÜÕ1k"��§i<

�Xù µI;[��´¥%>þ�[Õ1�gÏ@Å�Χuykpk20��

�y7§Bòù ;[�£ie?�Úί"

²Lί��§ù µI;[´�¢�¤Í¶p���ǧ58�"i<

�Ù0��ü§4ÙX¢`²k¥20����¹"3r���üô³¡c§¦X

¢���§¡3µIcÂ�L��))<�>{§�¦Ù3µIL§¥§̀ ÑÙ

¦µI�¬¤�,ÝI<í��1�¥IÿÀ<"N즧XJµI�¬ò

Page 372: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 361

Túií��1�¥IÿÀ<§çI�nÅ�ò3y|u�NÖ¤�§�¦u�Ü

�k20��!�è´6�8�Õ1k"é'X20���Az�µINÖ¤��ɧ¦

"x`²Ø4ã��|Ãp¾§Ä%"̀ ù´¦1�g3µI¥�ÏÝI<§Ð

3ù[ÝI<�ÝI¢år§3µIL§¥�\Ú�Ù¦µI�¬¤§Ò¦�

ù ÝI<¤�1�¥IÿÀ<"

1�U§iÅ'D�çI�nÅ�3y|u�NÖ¤�ó�<"²L"

�§çI�nÅ�T ó�<«@´3µIc�U�p§hepÂÉ,�¬1

n<ªµ�5000�y7§�¦ÙO�ü�&µ§��´�nÅ�O��§CkNÖ

¤800�y7�&µ¶��´Ck�¬1n<�¦�Õ1k§w�ÙkS�k2000�

�&µ"�«¦§XJTÝI<�µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<§�ù ;[

u�CkÕ1k�@�&µ¶XJØ´§Òu�¦Ck�nÅ�NÖ¤@�&µ§

3µI(å���ò�@Ük§¡���kpk2000�"iÅ'U�nÅ�ó�

<£ã�@ �¬1n<�6¶!ó�ü �é§uy´b�§�Ãd<"i

<D�µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<§¡l��çI�nÅ��ó�<1

ª§�Ø���ok�¯§N�Ùó�<ì¡4çI�nÅ��@ ó�<E

@§þØ´1ª�@ �¬1n<"

¯�§�ie�â�Ñ�3�1ªÉª¯¢§òY�£�½<¬u��½

<¬{�Jå�z"{�²L"n§@½ù µI;[��I[ó�<ɪ�§

�{�?Ù4ckÏä-§¿?v710000�¶@½çI�nÅ��@ ó�<�

�I[ó�<ɪ�!1ª�§J�Ùɪ5000�þ�I¥§�ØÙ¦?v"{

�\��§µI;[¤3�p�éÙmØú�§1�Ü�é@[çI�nÅ��

±´w!]�ü?�?v§çI�nÅ�)Ø�@ ó�<m�NÖÜÓ"

Nõ<f�ù��¯�§%¥Ñk�¦¾§̄ ·§@ µI;[´Ø´k:

f�B§No3��ÅeÂÕ1k§�ØùO<uyº·��`§ùc§1�Å

'3çIÝI¹Ä¥�|uyçI<!ÝI<½µI�¬¤��{¯�§k=

��Ø´�¯</M�4¼H0§Ñy�²w�$?�اâ4<3/�¡0

þuy�" @Y²�p��{¯�§qk=��´²d//ª0½úm|Üu

y�Q�-v-{Ø´8�§Ù�^´ÏL¨+��§�oI[!8NÚ�<|ç

�o�¬�S§±´«¦<gú/�VÅ{"

@o§ù��5§́ Ø´çIÝI¥���{1�§XGÏÝI!áJ�b¢

�¥IÚµI�¬¤Éª��he1�§ÒÃl£nQº�,Ø´�¯K

�'�E,3u§çI<|�çIÝI¹Ä´�J`¢yçIæ(J§� /́r

/ª!rL|0§ù´¯K Þ"k<F)`§=BçI<�çI3r/ª!rL|§

Page 373: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

362 çIæÛYFn

çI<Ø´ÝI<§�Ø´µI�¬§³�o8IçI<"ùpØ´8I§́ ©

Û¯K� Þ§Ï�çI<|�çI/r/ª!rL|0��J´4<rçIÝI

¹Än)��|iZ"Q,´�|iZ§iZ�m�´±�Ñ�m�§qÛLÉ{

Æ�åQ§�ØyçI<!ÝI<ÚµI�¬¤¥��<±�Á{!� r

x§ùÒ´çIÝI¹Ä/r/ª!rL|0��J"�uL§¥uy�1ªÉª�

´Xd§@ØL´iZ�/çÞ0 ®"@«±�çIÝI§�«¿�5�/ª�±

���¯<1ªÉª§AO´��µI;[ɪ��{�Ò´�Ø�"Á�§ù

ckõ�e?±þ(Ïɪ?\O<§é¦��� �åÚ����Ø´A�p

uµI;[íº@��o�ÂBØ�º¤±§̄ K��Ø3u/ª�å§ 3uç

Iæ3²Lþ�n5£8§3u�¯<�©z?��gÆ"

DÚ©z¥§/�<0́ �/�<0�é§́ �fk�k �<"�f�5´²6

Í�5�Ê-©óD6¥é/�<0�.½�µ/Å�<ö§�U/ÜÙ�§�F�Ü

Ù²§�o�ÜÙS§�< ÜÙ38"kUe U6�§�U ÁU�"0éA

�§5�Æ6¥�º�§́ N�?1��<�L§§=/�Ô!��!¿ª!�%!?

�!à[!£I!²Ue0"ù�¥§/�Ô0́ U©Eõ�§́ �«d�*¶/�

�0́ Æ�õ�¶¿ª´Ø�gCТgC¶/�%0́ à�%g§/C¤Ø�§Õ�

u<0¶/?�0́ ?�gC�ó1¶/à[0́ 5�gC[Ì<�ó1¶/£I0

´£ngC�I[�Uå¶/²Ue0́ ²½Ue§Ù¥�/Ue0́ ¥u¬x�õ

è§Ø´��¥"é�<½µI;[ ó§?1U��/�Ô!��!¿ª!�%!?

�0ÒéØN´§ù3½|²L�8UcÙXd"Qk� �Æ�Ç3üù¥J

�§¦3�ÆpQ�L���¯òN�§̄ ò�¯K´µ/XJ\ 5́xfå6�¯

¥�U�§\AÀJg��S�´�­;º0�¯¥§�S´U��ô<"-¦¹�

¿�´§n©��±þ�å)3¯òpÀJ�´g��­;§́ %k xN�@

��uí�Noõ�Ø©Qº�ǽ5A�å)§)í/¯¨���o3¯ò¥

ÀJg��­;"(J§A å)¯��c/`µ/P�§�S´��=d�:§�

¦k�oB§[p¡�¸��ºww<[�­;�P˧�Âzm!ûXZ/!Ú�

¤+�§gL�=B´ ��´Lº§�±�¯Ìn�c�0ù �Ç�a����

H�­<�:õC|!�¯Ø@ý§"y&�§�'5úc|ç��XØN ¼"

2k§CcxN����?��V5½�-�p+§U`Ñ´�?p(§Ù?

��'µI;[p§�=��Ø´Äë�À½ÉªA��½¤zþZ�Qº3ù�

�«�¬¨�¥§/��8/0§qNo�U4µI;[/üúتI¯0��%

�ú§�²Lï��zÙâ�§ùØÎÜ/U/À�Ô�F�0��n�

¢Sþ§µI;[´�«ë\µI�]�§¿�´J�I\"@o§;[��

Page 374: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 363

\\µI;[¥´Ñu�«�o%�Qº[Äå5§;[��\\µI;[¥k±

eA«%�µ�J�"@�µI;[´�«J�§�3¦<¡cî�§��<¶

¡þ<X/IÖ�AÏ9b¼�ö0aq§�<�3¶¡þ<X,µI;[¥�

/µI;[0§rNgC´;[¶�Áz"4gC;��£ÑÖu�õ�̧*��

¬K�å¶��'"±�Ó¯´µI;[§gCØ´§vk¡f¶�NÖ¤"µI�

±¼��½�NÖ¤§�abÖ[^¶�ö�"µI;[k�½gdàþ�§�½§

Ýþ�ö�çI�8§he¼��{ÂÃ�"ù�¥§��\\µI;[¥�12«

<�%�´��~�§´µI;[¥|ï�I��;[a.¶11«<@�µI;

[´�«J�§?\µI;[¥ë�1-2gµI�Òuy´<ØÑÃ�J�§��Ø

¬2ë\µI¶13«<\\´�¡f§S%¿Ø�½�µI§�õ´���µIN

Ö¤¶14«<\\8��²(§́ ��a" 15«<K´�ö�µI(J\\�

µI;[¥"@o§IS�«µI;[¥�|ï§́ ÄGØþ¡13«�15«<

Qº�Y´Ä½��vk��µI;[¥3"1;[\¥]��§"���<�\

¥ÄÅÚ����§@��Ø�£k<ïÆéd�%nÿÁ§�vGâ�¤"ù�§

µI;[¥;[¥§þ¡5«<þk§±14«<Øõ"

y3§I�£���¯K§Ò /́µI�¬¤�¿µIíº0éõ<�U¬

@�ù�¯K¯�k:%%�§J�Ø�¿íºù´3�e§©ÛµI�¬¤

�µI1��I�g����¯K"µI�¬dçI<��LÚµI;[�¤"

@o§çI<�L�¿ë\µIí§µI;[�¿ë\µIíº©ÛXeµ

1.çI<�L"çI<�L´ÉçI<���§�LçI<ë�µI§Ø�3

�Ø�¿¯K§́ ó���"¢Sþ§ù´�«ÑåØ?Ð��Ú"µI(JÎÜ

çI<Ì�KI<��{�Ч�XJØÎܧÄk´É�Ì�KI<�I�"Ù

g§ÃصI(JXÛ§��çI�8¯�u�ѯ§çI<�L ¤�/O�

�0"¤±§Ø�çI<�L��½ü½,ÝI<§kë\µI�S3Äå§��

Ø�Ïë\µI"ùÒE¤çI<�L©¤±eüaµ

11aµó�AG."ù�açI<�L3µI�§±AGµI§�¤µIó

��A:"µI�§ù�açI<�L��ØuL¿�§UçI©�5½�µII

OÚ�{"7��§f�;[¿�½´ì�;[�µI(Ø"

12aµÌÄÑÂ."ù�açI<�L3µI�§���kÌ�§¦�U´�

X¢yçI<S½¥I<�µI?Ö§½´¢ygCheÀ½¥I<�µI¿ã§

3µIy|Ly¹�§�µI;[�«¿½´�µI;[he�!"

[µIV«��¯] 2004c3�§·\\,½ï�ó§µI;[¥§��óEâa

;["ù�c5���U§T½�¤p��S+��óUE�83µI;[¥¥�

Page 375: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

364 çIæÛYFn

ÅÄ��·�µI;[§3½ï�ó§�´¥%µI"ù´·\ÀµI;[¥�ë

�µ"�1n��8"@�§·�%í�'�p§�%�é�å/;[0ù�¡Ò"

çI<�L´ù¤p��Äï?�§�?\µIy|�µI;[��ºÃ"Ù¥§

k��P;[§��¦ºXP;[�ç̄ µ/PܧP�¾ùã�mÐ:vkº0a

ú¦�éÙG"

\��§çI<�L�3·é¡§P;[�3·�mÃ>"çI<�L{ü0

��8�¹�§m©Eⵧ=�ó|��OVI�µ"§y|é�·"��õ�

��§çI<�LÕå5§Ãp<X�°�ó|��O§̀ µ/� ;[§3ÒI��

Ø�§�[@ýw�w�0Ù¦;[f�§%+ ¬/::Þ"·f¦`��§îÞ

UYµ"XÃp�@°�ó|��O"2��Þ§uy¦Ø`{§3·X·w"·

�1§́ gC�o/���Øéí§vú�B�·��°EâIUYµ""ù�§

��¦7LSf§r�·mÃ>�@ P;[>þ§è<�(�!Aé�§£�

� þUYµ""Ø�¬�§P;[^�Ã--·§�(`µ/fo§3ÒI§Oµ

��0·ªu²xL5çI<�L��o·X·w��ϧÏ�¦@é/3ÒI0

v��·��A§@�·´�/1Þ�0§IP;[2J2�H"

ùã�¯�5ù�� /�l¯æ�Ó�§̈ �1µ/\�@pµINoùæ

�§çI<�L��Õå5V«�e3ÒI�0·¯µ/\�@pçI<�LNo�;

[D4S½¥I<º0̈ ��µ/é{üo�ó�<^��íL5�ÝI©�¥§�

þ¡�@°ÝIÒ´S½���[Ñ��B"0ùc§·��3�g§XJµI�

kd5K§µIÒ¤/{�0½´éú¯�Т§@���¶µI;[q�k�

o¿ÂQ�

2.µI;["µI;[��´�ÅÄ��)�§nØþ´pØ�£§�¢�L

²§ù¿Ø�½�("ÒµI;[ë�µI�8�ØÓ§©�±ena§́ �eµ

I;[�yG§�´µI�Ýï�¥�I�g¢�"

11aµÈ4µI."ùa<ë�µI§±¼�µINÖ�Å�m�"ùA�

´µI;[¥��õ꧱ò>�Ds3[§q3�;�+�äk�½Uå�<

�Ì"ùa;[µI§±r/ª!rL|�Øõ§��µINÖ¤�§Ø�gC�

5ºx§NoXÑ1"��YO���§3|Ãp¾¡c�¬�ÝI<Âï§�!

m©ùã�µI;[ɪ��¯¥�@ Ì?�Òáuù«�/"

12aµ�4µI."ùa<Ì�´3�<§cÙ´3ü ½|�¥ÓâÌ

�k �<§ü �~�ÖÑaØL5§=k�më\µI��Q,\ÀµI

;[¥§qØÐÌÄòÑ"ÄK§¬4<±�´��o�ØmØ�§·��Òá

uù«�¹"Â�µI�ÑÏ�§11g!12g�Váý§Ï�ëY5gØë\âÉ

Page 376: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 365

�VÆ?©Q¶13g!14gq�Ð`þü k¯øØm�¶15g§Ø�®§g�

énd�ë\�gµI§�Nowù�Ø´���VÅ{�<Ak�1�"��o

¬´ù�§Ï�vk=��3�;[�ü |±;[�eÃ>ó�ë�çI�8�

µI§ @�Ù´3|^ó��m/�¯0"

13aµö�µI."ùaµI;[ë�µI´�¢yÙhe�´§�)É,

ÝI<½�¬1n<�÷§½´µIc;[m�heûƧ~X§;[m�&�S

ûÆ4=�ÝI<¥I§±9�{¼|�©��Y�"d�§ë�µI�;[8�

²(§Ò´Ý�µI(J"µI¥§LyÙ�<4�9�§éQ½¥I<�ÝI�

\7ü§éÙ¦ÝI4å]�§±K�¦<µI�"

12!iÒµ�{µ"'����

µI�¬¤ë�µI§5K´UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝ

I©�?1µ"Ú'�"ÄK§Ò´�{µI"µI�¬�{µI��Ï´çI

ÝI¹Är/ª!rL|§AO´�ê½�NµI;[heɪ§Ly´ÙéÝI

©��µ"Ú'�Ø�*!Øú�§ù3µI¢�¥´urº"µI¥§µI�

¬9Ù¤��{1��Ì�Lykn«µ�?UçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{§

N�Ùµ"Ï�½µ"IO¶�ØUçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1

µ"'�§é�{A�Äû�ØJÑÄû¿�§½´é�{ØA�Äû��±Ä

û¶��ÉÝI<éÙÝI©�1²�¢�5SN�?U!N�½Ö¿�"duµ

I�¬µI�5K§́ �âÖ¡�çI©�éÖ¡�ÝI©�?1µ"'�§(

JNy3Ù�çI<J��Ö¡µI�w"�d§éµIL§�\riÒ§́ ��

µI�¬�{µI1��k��{"

[�ûµI(J��¯] 2012c3�26FþÌ9:40©§ë,!a,Ú�,�,½�

?�ÖÑÖ¥%�äªà�ÅÄ�ë\,�Ö¢C?UE�8�µI§�m´e

Ì1:30©§/:�½ú�] �´¥%o�402¬Æ¿"þÌ11:20©�m§ë,�Ý

I<A�Ì�KI<±,�>{§è<~3�åæò§¡k�{òÝI<Aí��1

�¥IÿÀ<§�I�Ù�ܧ<Ñ�½�¤^ÂïÙ¦µI;["è<û½§̄

¤�§ë,�8��§Ù¦�Ü�;[z<�2��"

û!Ð�§ë,3ÃÅþ�;[�&+puÑ�^&E§¡gCeÌ1:30©�

�½ú�] �´¥%µI§¯´ÄkÙ¦;[ë\§±B�Óc "Ø�¬�§

ë,�ί��a,Ú�,��A§¡eÌ��ë�µI§n<m©3�&¥h

�"ë,3�&þw�a,Ú�,§¡®²�ÝI<Aû!ЧòÙµ"í��1

Page 377: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

366 çIæÛYFn

�¥IÿÀ<§z<�±��2���Ð?¤§̀ µ/yX8§çIÑ´hçV½§ç

IÑ´üZ�<w§éA�;[��f§he<XÐ?¤§¦�UZ4���o

ØUZ"0ù�{��a,Ú�,�@Ó"

µIL§¥§ë,!a,Ú�,�pV«!�ܧ̀ Ñ�3¦�¥m�o,ë

\"ÝI<A�ÝI�d�p§�©'�p�©�3©"�d§o µI;[éçI©

�¥5½�µ"Ï�§=C»�OÚ�ó|��O�Y�©IO15©�35©òg?

U�15©�40©§¿©O�ÝI<A�C»�OÚ�ó|��Oµ©38©!39©!40©

Ú40©"®o�§ÝI<A��©�p§�µI�¬í��1�¥IÿÀ<"µI

(Jú«Ïm§a,!�,Úo,lë,?¼�2��§ë,gC¼�8��Ð?¤"

çI<@�ÝI<AJ��C»�O�YØ´�`�Y§�ÙÝI�d p§

éµI�¬�µ©P¹?1@ý"�§uyë,!a,!�,Úo,�µ©�Ñ

çI©�¥5½�µ©IO"u´§�½ú�] �´iÒ+nÛÝ�§¡o µ

I;[3��8µIL§¥§�ÑçI©�¥5½��p�©IO�ÝI<Aµ

p©§Ùµ©K�µI(J§�¦1�iÒÅ�@½µIÃ�§­#|�µI"

½ú�] �´iÒ+nÛ<�gD�o µI;[§(@çI<�Ý�

¯¢§\wµI(JÃ�"çI<­#|ïµI�¬éÝI©�?1µ"§ÝI

<B�1�¥IÿÀ<"ÝI<Aé�ë,§�¦ò�14���Ð?¤§ë,ØZ§

¡®3µI¥òÝI<Aí��1�¥IÿÀ<§�¤É÷¯�§ÝI<AA

�|Go µI;[�NÖ¤"

V��û�J§ÝI<A�½ú�] �´iÒ+nÛÚ½iÛuÞ§¡µ

I;[ë,�Ù¢ª14��Øò"ù��ÿ§½ú�] �´iÒ+nÛ�<â²

x��oë,!a,!�,Úo,�ÑçI©�¥5½�µ©IO�ÝI<Aµ

©§�ܽiÛ2gD�o µI;[§�{N�ë,!a,Ú�,3�&¥

��UP¹§(@n ;[3µI¥�3�{1�§Ø¢Éª7�§£�½u

�Jå�z"½nܵI;[¥�{��ë,!a,!�,Úo,�µI;[]

�§Ø�2ë\�{7L?1çI��8�µI"½{�²L"n§@½ë,��

I[ó�<ɪ�§�?kÏä-nc§�-nc¶a,!�,��I[ó�<

ɪ�§�?kÏä-�c§�-�c¶o,��I[ó�<ɪ�§�?k

Ïä-�c§�-�c"

éµI�¬¤3µIL§¥��{1�§iÒ��� §Ñ�±�|uy§

I-ÙU�"ùp§éµI�iÒ§�)1�iÒÚçI<SÜVui|��µ

IiÒ"@o§��o¢�¥§�µI;[��{µI1�vk�|U�§ ´

��k<Ý�½Þ�âuyQºÌ�´ u1�iÒØ� §½´çI<3�µ

Page 378: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 367

I�w�v|�Øé§�¦Ù�{µI1��Ø�Å�§�Ø�µI(J��µI

(Jú«!ÑyÉƽÝ�âuy"k�§$��Á�L§¥§ÏçI<�¥I<

m�)�Æâuy"�d§éµI�¬9Ù¤�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�

���Ì�8¥3±en�¯�:

1.�{?UµIIOÚ�{���"µIIOÚ�{�5K�½�3çI<§

Ø3µI�¬"µI�¬��I´UìçI©�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ�{µ

I"5¿§ùp�/çI©�0§�)üÜ©SN§�´çI<UçIúw��¦u

È�çI©�§�´çI<3çI©�1²�ÝI���mc�½�mSuÑ�ç

I©��©�Ú?U"Ø3þã��S�©�§Ø�¤çI©�"

1¤çI<½�nÅ��{?U���"µIm©c§çI<½çI�nÅ�<

Ñ�°�çI©�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ�{Ø���µI�{§�¦µI�¬Ý

¦ÏL�§UÏL�µI�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"5¿§µI�¬ÏL

�ù°µI�{vk{Æ�å§�ØU��µIIOÚ�{§Ï�çI<½çI�

nÅ�3d�<Ñ�µI�{Ø2áuçI©��Æ"

2¤µI�¬�{?U���"µI�¬�{?UçI©�¥�µIIO

Ú�{§k�´ÏçI<�L�JƧk�´µI;[�JÆ"kü«pϧ�´

µI;[@�çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{�3�½"�§K�J`¶�´ç

I<�L½µI;[�ÝI<�3he�´§��yA½ÝI<¥I§âmI(J

JÑ�?U"��/§JÆ<3µI�¬�ªµIc§éµIIOÚ�{JÑä

N�?U�Y§µI�¬8Nݦ§U/�êÑlõê0��K§û½´ÄUJÆ

<�ïƧ?UçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{"

çI<!çI�nÅ�½µI�¬3µIm©c?UçI©�¥úÙ�µI

IOÚ�{§́ �«²w��{1�§��k<iÒµI§½´çI<�µI�

w�§éµI�¬¦^�µ"Ï�ÚIO�çI©�¥1²�µ"Ï�ÚIO?

1Øé§Ò�½Uuy§��9�?n"

2.áØ�lµIIOÚ�{���"µI�¬9Ù¤Ø�lçI©�¥5

½�µIIOÚ�{§Ly3µ�O\½~�çI©�¥úÙ�µ"Ï�½üSÏ

�"~X§é�{A�Äû�½´çI©�¥²(Äû�ÝIØJÑÄû¿�§½

´±çI©�¥vk5½�µ"Ï�½IOéÝIJÑÄû¿��¶�UCçI©

�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ^�§UCüS�{"3�ûµI(J��¯¥§ë,!a

,!�,Úo,éÝI<A�µ©§=áuù«�/"

µI�¬¤3µI¥Ø�lçI©�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ�{´�«�

{1�§Ny3Ù�¤�ÐÚµ"!�[µ"P¹L¥"çI<3�µI�w�§

Page 379: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

368 çIæÛYFn

�çI©�'éÒ�±uy"

[�{µI�¯~],ó§�óçI©�1²��8+nÅ�µ©Ï�Ú�p©

��10©"©��8²n3©!EâKI<2©ÚÙ¦Ì�<5©",µI;[éÝ

I<R��8+nÅ��¤Xeµ©P¹Lµ

µ"Ï� �8²n EâKI< Ù¦Ì�< J�yÖ ÜO

µ© 3.5 2 4.5 2 12

L15.1 �8+nÅ�µ©P¹L

çI<�µI�w�§²L�çI©�¥úÙ�µ"Ï�ÚIO'�§uy

TµI;[éÝI<R��8²nµ©pÑþ�3©§O\çI©�¥vk5

½�µ"Ï�/J�yÖ0Ú©�2©§��{ÆD�µI�¬��I§�|�¦

TµI�¬¤?1��"ù µI;[áØU�§nd´ÝI<RCnc¼�

�J�yÖ'Ù¦ÝI<õ§ çI©�¥�µIIOvUNy§[��8²n�

1AO`D§çI©�¥5½�pµ3©���§�Ù¦ÝI<��8²n.Øm

�g§ØÎÜJ`��K"

��§çI<�1�iÒ<®�ù µI;[�µI1�"1�iÒ<

éù µI;[?1�¡Ô2§�¦ÙUçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI

<R��8+nÅ�?1µ©"

3.ÝI<�{��?UÝI©����"µI�¬µIµ"�´ÝI©�§

=çI<�{�Â�ÝI©�"mI�§ÝI<�âçI©�¥úÙ�µIIOÚ

�{§UÐÚ�äÙÝI´ÄU¥I"uyÙØU¥I�§k�ÝI<MF"u

��½?UÝI©��¢�5SN§±��¥I�8�"

1¤ÝI<�{��½?U���"ÝI<3mI�§ÌÄ��½?UÝI©�

�¢�5SNkü«Ly/ª§�«´ÝI<ÌÄ�çI<½µI�¬uÑÙé

ÝI©�1²�¢�5SN�?U§çI<½öµI�¬�{A�á§Ï�Ý

I®²��"µIL§¥§µI�¬XJ�ÉÝI<éÝI©�1²�¢�5

SN?U§¿UÝI<?U�SNµI�§µI�¬�µI1��{§K�µI

(J�§µI(JÃ�¶,�«´ÝI<²dçI<�L!µI;[½Ù¦ó�<

�ÏÙ��Ü©ÝI©�"

[ÝI©����¯~] ,Å>��çI�83½ú�] �´¥%mI�?

1µI"µI?1¥§µI�¬uyÝI<Z3ÝI¼þ1²��d681.16��§

�mIP¹þ�751.16 ��Ø��§�ö��70.00��"±681.16��O�TÝ

I<��d�©§�¤kÝI<�d��p�©59.5©¶±751.16��O�Ù�©§

Page 380: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 369

�52©"�.A±@��d�O§µI�¬<ؽ̿§Î¯çI�nÅ�"çI

�nÅ��E¡§A±ÝI¼þ1²��d�O"̄ ��o�mIP¹þ1²�Ý

I�dØ��§�E¡´�I<�I���§r681.16���¤751.16��"

µI�¬UçI�nÅ�ó�<��«�¤µI§ÝI<Z�í��1�

¥IÿÀ<"�çI<�Laú¯�¿¥§ùü�êi�O�©²w§No�U�

�Q��d§çI<�L3µI(å�§9��1�iÒÅ��w§¡~¦´k<�

ÏÝI<Z��ÝI¼§Ùý��ÝI�dA�´751.16��"¦w�1�iÒÅ

�§¡¦´mI��iÒ<§y¢ÝI<Z3ÝI¼þ1²�d�´751.16��"

éd§1�iÒ<�w�´¥%S�i�¹�§uy´çI�nÅ��ó�

<�k?\µIy|"i�¹�þw«§Ù3�nÝI©��§l�����ú

©�S<ÑA�©�§Y3Ù¥�ÀÝI©�¥§qlù�ÀÝI©�¥]Ñ

A�ÝI©�C3Ùú©�S§�¿ØU�½´���ÝI<Z�ÝI¼"

�d§1�iÒÅ�ίçI�nÅ��ó�<§<Ñi�¹��¦Ù)

º�Ï"3i�¹�¡c§T¶ó�<«@�ÏÝI<Z��ÝI¼�¯¢§¡�

ÝI<Z��8KI<´õc*l§�É÷�ÏÙ��ÝI¼"1�iÒÅ��{

éTçI�nÅ�v±10��§éTó�<v±5000�§Â£ÙçI�nk 

yÖ§@½�µI�¬�Ñ�µ"(ØÃ�§�¦çI<|�µI�¬éµI

(J­#®o§í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"

ùK¯~L²§\réÝI©�§AO´mI�ÝI©��ì+§́ ��ÝI

©��¦<��½?UÝI©����廧 yâ3�§X¯~¥�´¥%�¹

�]�§́ �¢´Äk<��!?UÝI©���Z�{"

2¤µI�¬V«½p����"µIL§¥§AµI�¬¤ïƧµI

�¬�ÝI<uÑ�kV«½p�5��©�¼§�{�¦Ù?UÝI©�¥�

¢�5SN§~X§ÝI�d½Á�Ï��"ÝI</%+ ¬0§��Ѭ�Aµ

I�¬��¦"µI�¬�{UÝI<?U��ÝI©�?1µ"§í�¥I

ÿÀ<"

[V«p��¯~] ,ü G¬çI�8§µI�¬²LÐÚµ"§@�ÝI

<KÝI�G¬�çI©�¥�Eâ5�Ö�¦�ó¹!¦^�¸!ëê!9�Ç

��Χ�@�Ùd�25.00��/��k�½�4|�m"u´§µI�¬�Ý

I<KuÑ©�¼§�¦Ù?�Ú`²µ�´Ä�3yk��dÄ:þe22%¶�

´Ä3çI©��¦�øÀ���§�¤õx���§20m�Y""35½��

mS§ÝI<K9�?1£E§«ì3�ÝI�d�Ä:þeN2%§�¤õx�

��§20m�Y""µI�¬UìÝI<K��g�d?1µ"§í�ÝI<K�

Page 381: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

370 çIæÛYFn

1�¥IÿÀ<"

¯~¥§µI�¬�ÝI<KuÑ�©�SN§�5¬{;6ÜÓ?1ozl

�l^5½���¢�5SN§́ 5çIÝI{61n�Ê^²(5½Ø#N©�

�SN"µI�¬�ù«1�§�Óu�ÝI<A�ÝId�!ÝI�Y?1!

�" ÙN�ÝI<K3�ÝI�d�Ä:þeN2%§�¤õx���§20m�Y

"�1�¢�§́ 3ÝI���m�2g�ÉÝI�1�§��çIÝI5K§�

�5çIÝI{61o�n^'u3(½¥I<�c§çI<Ø�ÒÝId�!Ý

I�Y�¢�5SN�ÝI<?1!��B�55½"

ÝI©�«1�§́ ÝI<ÝI�¯¢§́ µI�¬µ"Ú'�§í�Ü�

�¥�ÿÀ<�| "��ÝI<�{��?UÝI©��¢�§3u�lçIÝ

I¥��g5��5K§�{3uéÝI©��ì+§±9µI�¬�¦ÝI<

éÙÝI©�©�`²¯��Ü{5iÒ"

13!J`µµI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I���

µI�¬9Ù¤3µI¥��{1�§¬3µIL§½µI�w¥3eP

1§��éµIL§@ý/iÒ§́ uyµI�{�¯¢§é�{<�{¨?¿

Å�µI(J"ù«�/جK�µI(J"J?n�§́ µI�¬¤heÂ

ÉÝI<ªµ§UçI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§¦�

Ù1ª�ÝI<¥I"3ù«�/e§Ø��¯<ÌÄwu§çI<�,éµI(

JØ÷§�8Ø�µI�¬¤�{µI�¯¢§1�iÒÅ��{�ØU@½

çI�8�µI(ØÃ�"¢Sþ§µI�¬¤��çI�8ÝI(J�à�

§�ÝI<¬æ^�«Ãã¼�µI�¬¤&E§�Ù1ª" lçI<

À�w§XJéçI<�L���ó��� §µI;[��q´�ÅÄ��)�§

ÝI<éϵI�¬¤�Ò´��(J�¯�"¹�§=BÝI<Ué�µ

I�¬¤§XJT¤UjÅ�<�ŵI�¬¤�����§Ø�{

�ÏÙ¥I§ÝI<�8I�Ãl¢y"�¢�¥§Ø=ÑyLçI<�L§$�

µI;[heNìÝI<¥I¿Âɪµ§ùqA�XÛ)ºQºéÐ)º§ù�

,´Ï�çI<�L½µI;[&E���"ù�:§3113 Ù12 !¥®²?1

©Û"¢�¥§���/©�ü«§�«´�Ä��§=ÝI<½�¬1n<�

{¼�µI;[�&E§�k�«§́ çI<�L½µI;[ÌÄ�ÝI<��"

[µI;[����¯] 2019c10�§,½3ó§ï��8çIÝIEû�¸;

�£n¥§�?� ïÓ�óa;[�,§Úå1�Ü��´ú"â�,��§

Page 382: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 371

¦ë�µI�çI�8æ^�Ñ´nܵ©{"��µI;[�ÅÄ�XÚ�ÑÏ

��§¦��¬UmI�m§3�þ|ÏçIúw§l¥�äÑXÚÏ�¦ë�µ

I�çI�8",�§Î¯½S�Ì��óè�´Äë�T�8ÝI"��é

��½�E�§¦w�é�´T�8�µI;[§é���¬ÌÄ�¦�¡§F"

¦�Ïé�¥I"V�!þ¤^ê�ÚG±�ª�§�,�ÙG�Ù¦;[>{é

X§éÏÙ¦µI;[ûÆ"��/§â�,��§¦ù�Ué�2-3��åë�

µI�;["µIL§¥§�,ÚÙ¦GÏÐ�µI;[¬3Ì*µ"Ï�þ�©

Ù§A�<UìÌ*µ"Ï���©IO�þ�½´�0.1-0.2©��{§�Q½¥

I<�p©§(�í�TÝI<�1�¥IÿÀ<"�,«@§k�§ÏçI©�

¥5½�ÝI�dÓ��­��§~X§�d�©385©±þ Q½¥I<�d�

©�å���§��U¢yØQ½ÝI<�¥I"

µI;[ÌÄ�ÝI<���pϧ�,´Ù��{¼�|çÝ�çI�8

�µI(J"��/�GÏÝI¥Ñy/IÞ0aq§�Ý]�8�õ�/«§

�ÑyµI;[/²V<0y�";[¼�ë�µI�&E�§Ø^��¯¥�

�,@��éÏÝI<§�Ø^éÏÙ¦µI;[§�I�w�²V<=�§Ï�

²V<Ã¥kµI;[¥¥�þ�ÝI<ÚµI;[&E"²V<¬3éá��m

SÏ�µI;[§3µI¥�=��ÝI<¥I"

µI;[��o�±¢yQ½ÝI<¥I§¼��{|ÃQºéd§1�iÒ

Å�ÚçI<qA�XÛéÙ��Qº©ÛXe:

1.µI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I�¢y^�" µI�¬¤ÂÉÝ

I<ªµ�4à�/§́ µI�¬¤ÌÄ�ÝI<éX§Ø+´ÙgCéX�

´ÏL²V<��¬1n<éX"3ù«�/e§ü³µI;[¥&EEâ¶-Ä

��¯<Ú\rµI;[¥$E�+n§Ãl)û"éd§�<@�§A�\r

éµI;[¥¥;[�{Æ!;��£�ÔÚVÆ�å"���Ú�Ô[��U�

å@�VÅ{�µI;[§é@b/µI ¢K�{¼�ÂÃ�<¿Ø¬å�

�^"3ù«�/e§I?�Ú©ÛµI�¬¤�ÝI<éX�8�§±9(

�Ù¥I�¢y^�"

1¤µI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I�8�"�êµI�¬¤ÌÄ�

ÝI<éX���8�§́ �¼��{ÂÃ"@o§ÝI<´Ä�¿|GQº�,

�¿�ÝI<¥I�§3ù�:þýéù/&^0§ýéج/��0§�½¬U�½

Ð�ê�§v�|G��ÏÙ¥I�µI�¬¤§cÙ´µI;[§ÏÝI<

F"�Ùïá�ÏÜ�'X§3�YÝI¥�I�Ù�a"

¢Sþ§�êÝI<�¥I§3ÝI¥�~��%�kn«µ���çI<¥

Page 383: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

372 çIæÛYFn

�Ì�<ïáh�§%NÙ¥I"��çI�nÅ�<ïá'X§3çI�8

&Eþ¢y/pÏkÃ0"��´ÏL¥m<½Ù<0�§9±7��ãÔ1ª¶�

��Ù¦ÝI<GϧU½|d5K©�¥I�8Ú|ö��ÂïµI�¬¤

§AO´;[¤"ù�¥§ÝI<�1ª�ݧéçI<Ì�<�1ª�Ý

�p§éµI�¬¥�;[¤1ªg�§�I¤^U�I<ë�?�ÝI©�

�ó�þ§±9�/�Id5Kû½"

5çIÝI{61Ê�8^5½§µI�¬¤ÂÉÝI<�ãÔ½öÙ¦

Ð?�§��´w§vÂÂÉ�ãÔ§�±¿?3Z�±þ5��±e�v±§��ú

?µI�¬¤�]�§�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"@o§��oµI�

¬¤§�);[¤Ek</cukUe��Øé0 ÂÉÝI<�ªµ§$

�´ÌÄ¢ªQº�ÏÒ3u§µI;[¢��¤^§=ÓÝI<�«@çI�8

[s¤��é��Ü©"�,§XJ´;[�²V<ö��ÝI<Gϧ¢yÙ¥

I§�ݬ�p§k�/�$�U¥I��1%±þÂ�¤^"

2¤µI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I¿¢ª�¢y^�"��o�êµI

;[cuhe�ÝI<éX§�ÙNì¥I¿¢ªQº�Ï3uµI;[3µI¥

�gdàþ�"@o§q´XD�µI;[�gdàþ�Qº�,´çI<§́

çI<3çI©��µIIOÚ�{¥¤D��§Ï�µI�¬�{´UçI©

�¥�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"��§�Xþ�!?Ø�§́

uuyµI�¬¤µI��{1�§Å�µI(J§¿�{éµI;[?1?

v"�¢�þ§ù«�{�/��k@/f�0�µI;[3ÙheNìÝI<

¥I�â¬Ñy"é@h²�<§K´3�lµI5K�cJe§|^µI;[

�gdàþ�¢y�§ùâ´·�ùpI�?Ø��/"

�d§µI;[cuheéÏÝI<§NìÙ¥I¿¢ª§Ù���Ï´çI

<|�çIÝI¹Ä¥ lJ`OK§´3/r/ª!rL|0§3çI©��

µIIOÚ�{¥D�µI�¬���gdàþ�"~X§çI©�¥5½�

µI�{�nܵ©{§Ù¥q���õ�Ì*µ"Ï�§�3µI§Sþ§v

kéÌ*µ"Ï�U15Ù13!ïÆ�§Sµ"§ ´dµI�¬¤gdu�

�§Ò´3��êµI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥IJø^�"

2.µI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I���"éµI�¬¤heNìÝ

I<¥I�����§3uçIæ´²LÆ¿Âþ�æ Ø´3r/ª!rL

|/�iZ§3uçIæ�J`§Ï�/`���0́ g,�ÊH{K§çIÝI

¹Ä���«½|�´5KI��Ì" lù�m�7,´3��g,{K§çI

ÝI¹ÄØ´3�iZq´�oQ��±`§�êµI�¬¤heNìÝI<

Page 384: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 373

¥I¿Âɪµ��Ï�3ud§Ï�3iZ¡c§S�!.~Úd5K��åå

3�¯<�%8¥pu{Æ"@o§ù��5§́ ÄéµI�¬¤heNìÝ

I<¥I¿ÂɪµÒ��Ã�Qº�,Ø´����Ø%§�´µI+n§�

´çIæ�n5£8§=J`"

£1¤µI+n"µI´éÝI�µ�§�\ε�Ã�"@o§��o3��

�\ε�¥§µ�;[heNì\ÎÑÖJø<¤�¿¢ª�A�vk§ 3ç

IÝI¥ù�¯K%3�½§Ýþî­Qº̄ K���§3uçI<|��ÝI´

Ä´²LÆ¿Âþ�/¿�0"

1¤µI�¬"µI�¬é�u\Î�8�µ��¬"üöØÓ�?3u§

µ��¬¤d�8uåü gÌ(½§ çIÝI¹Ä¥§µI�¬�,d

çI<|ï§��õçI�8¥�;[¤´dµI;[¥¥�ÅÄ��)�§�

çI<gÌ(½"ùÒkü�¯KI�?ا�´µI;[¥�5�´�o§�´

AN�+nµI;[¥"

Äk§µI;[¥ÃØ´�?|ï�§�´�¬|�½Å�|ï�§́ �«;

[] ¥§�/Y¥0Ã�"I��§3¥¥�å�¥Y±÷vI�"ù�¥I�?

ا́ �?|ï�µI;[¥¥�;[§3bþ/I[0½/�½0µI;[�I\

�§́ Ä�LX�?1�º�,Ø´�µI;[ë�µI§́ ������¬¯1�

Uå<§éÙ¤JÑ�µ"¿�«ú�<I?"3ù«�/e§�?|ïµI;[

¥�¿ÂÛ3Qº�,´3u/B¬0§ÑÖuçI<(½µI;[§ÒXÓ3Y¥

�Y��"@o§/�ÅÄ�0́ Äk�ù�B¬ÑÖ�ЩQºQ,çI<(½µ

I;[�Óu3Y¥�Y§@ÀY!9Y�½ØUØ^§/�ÅÄ�03�½§Ý

þ�åçI</�Y0§3��çI<gdÀJµI;[§¢yÙS½¥I<�Ó

�§���çI</�Y0§=ÀY!9Y�å�§3�½§Ýþ¤Ò@�{

�V�µI;["¢Sþ§/�ÅÄ�0;[\�µI;[¥�ï�Jݧ=¥S

¤k<þ÷vçI�8µ"§�);[;���Ú��YO§ù3�½§ÝþØ

�U¢y"Ù¥§;����±é��<Á{!Æ{!�¡�?1ÐÚ�ä"@o§

��YOQ§No�ä,No(½��<�½�VÅ{§Øl¯�{�51�ºù´

?Û��µI;[¥ï�ü ÑÃ{@½�¯§Ï�;[´�¬<§Ù�¬1�4

ÙE,§ï¥ü Ø�U3\¥��Ñ���OOK"�d§I­#"ÀµI;[

�/�ÅÄ�0§A��uçI<"Q,´çI<?1çI§Q,´çI<«úÌN

I?§ÒA�r(½µI;[��|��çI<§dçI<UµII�(½!�Ø

;[1� Ø /́�ÅÄ�0§�Ø;[òþbX�/I[0½/�½0I\§£8

Ù�5¡8"Ó�§~�ï¥ü §�)�?I?§£8/B¬0�Щ"

Page 385: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

374 çIæÛYFn

Ùg§I\rµI;[¥�+n"éµI;[¥�+n§|^y�Eâ§�ç

I<(½µI;[§/B¬0́ ��¡§�'��§3u/+0§3uXÛéµI;[

¥¥�;[?1+n"µI;[¥��àI��¬m�§�y@ÎܵI;[^

��<��\À;[¥"Ó�§é;[�µI1�|�1��اGØ@3�Ø

ÏS1�ØÜ��;[§éµI;[¢�Ä�+n"

2¤µIiÒ"�{éµI?1iÒ§́ 1�iÒÅ��oçIÝI½|�S�

Ny"5¿§1��i{¥�/¬ØÞ(ØÄ0ØÓ§IÌÄé½|ÌN�´1�?

1iÒ§�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�§±Úw{Æ%î"�3ù�:þ§1�

iÒÏ<å!Ôåþ�É�§�ké��å§�3�l/¬ØÞ(ØÄ0ª�iÒ§

ØU�|/I-U�0§ù3�½§Ýþ�?�êµI;[�gdàþÚ�{

�51�"3ù«�/e§çI<�Vui<ÌÄéµI¹Ä?1iÒ§½´

Ú\�¬iÒ�§́ é1�iÒ�k�Ö¿"

3¤µI(J(@"éµI(J�(@§́ çI<éçIæ(J«úÌNI?

�­�L§§�´uyµI¹Ä¥´Ä�3�{1�§µI�¬´ÄUçI©�

¥5½�µIIOÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§�)µ�ÐÚ"�¥§éÝ

I©�/ª!ÝI]�!�A5�µ"´ÄUçI©�¥5½�µ"Ï�ÚIO?

1"�§ÐÚ"�Ü�½ØÜ��nd´Ä¿©!á�´Ä��!(Ø´Ä�("

AO´§�{A�Äû�§́ ÄJÑÄû¿�¶�{ØA�Äû�§́ ÄqéÙ

ÝI?1Äû�¶��["�¥§µI�¬´Ä�ÉÝI<éÝI©�¢�

5SN�?U½N�¶é�U$u¤���d§µI�¬´Ä�¦ÝI<Jø

Ö¡`²!Jø�'y²á�§Ù(Ø´Ä�(¶µ"Ï�üS��(½´Ä�

(§Øâ´Ä¿©!®o´Ä�(�¶�ÝInÜüS´Ä�(§́ ÄUçI©�

¥5½�üS�{?1üS�¶�í��¥IÿÀ<´ÄJ`¶�µI�wSN´

Ä��!\i´Äà�Ú`²!N�´Ä�¢�§uyµI�w�3¯K�§�µ

I�¬Ø¢§�¦ÙU�"ØUU��K�µI(J�§µIÃ�§A3�w1

�iÒÅ�(@�§­#|�µI"

£2¤çIæn5£8"çIæ´���*²L¹Ä§I��l�*²L5

Ƨ=/`���0"çIæ�n5£8§�¦çI<òçIÝIÀ��«æÔ

Ñ��¦§3ÝI¿�Ä:þJ`"

1¤çIæJ`"çIæJ`NyuçI<úÙ�çI©�§=µIIOÚ

�{"ØÓ�çI�8§ÙJ`�{¿Ø��§�7LkJ`Ï�!IOÚJ`�

{§J`Ï��k²Lƹ§�{U²LÆ¥�/`!�0gS?1ÀJ"5¿§

iZ¥�k/`!�0½/�!K0�©"3²LÆ[�ú¥§/�Ô�û¬0§Ñ�

Page 386: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 375

3½|�´d�"çIæ´½|²L¥��«�´�ª§3ÝI÷vçI©�¢

�5�¦�cJe§²µ"��$ÝId{±²µ"�ÝId���J`Ï�§é

u��n5²L<5`§d�$�`ud�p�§Ï�ÑU÷væI¦§�sa

´�«²LÆJ¦"�´§nܵ©{@��©p��½`u�©$§AO´é@

�¹�þ�Ì*µ"Ï��çI�8§q´Ñu�o�ÏQº́ ÑuéµI�

¬µ"�&?§�ù´�«k^��ÀJ Ø��´Äu²L(J�ÀJ§Ï�µ

I�¬¤�;���Ú��Y²¬��K�µI(J§ùÒ)º��oIS

çIÝI¯Kõ��ϧÏ�ISçI�8�õæ^nܵ©{§́ ÄuµI<�

ÀJ Ø´Äu²L(J�ÀJ"

@o§çI楧XÛ(½ÙúÙ�µIIOÚ�{´²LÆJ` Ø´i

Z¥��KQ?¯K�'�§3uÀJ�J`Ï�´Äk²Lƿ§J`´ÄU²

L(JJ`"çIæ´�«õÏ�ÀJ§J`�¢�3uéõÏ�?1üS§(

½ÝI`�gS§�Ò 5́çIÝI{61o��^5½�¥I�K¥�nܵ�

{§Öö�ë�14Ù14!Ú16Ù13!"

2¤µI|�"µI�¬3uéÝI?1`�µ�§J:Ø3�*µ"�I§

@´éÝI¯¢�@½§µI;[�;����½÷v�¦"|�µI�J:§3

uéÌ*µ"Ï�µ"§~��he�<�Z6"�d§çI<I����´§�

´~�Ì*µ"Ï�½´~�ÙéµI(J�K�"~X§æ^�*Ï�üS!õ

Ï�üS{§5½Ì*µ"Ï��­Ó'�u15%½´ �ØÓ<éÓ�Ì*µ

"Ï��µ"(J���¶�´é@7L�¹Ì*µ"Ï��çI�8§3µI

¥©Ú|�Ì*µ"Ï��µ"§=k|�½5§2|�½þµ""|�½þµ"

c§ØéµI�¬úÙ½þµ"�IO§ ´3Ù�¤½5µ"�úÙ½´d>

Mܤ§? ~�µI�¬��u,�ÝI<�µ""

14!Ø�µ¥0½²��³µI;[&E���

çIÝI¹Ä¥§�êçI�8�¥0Å�3µI|�¥é,��½,A�Ý

I<�±AO'ì§Ed\ÎÅ��ÝI<GÏ!�³I�d�½´�ÏÝI<?

�ÝI©�§he�{¼�ÂÃ�¯�§�2�xN�ѧ�Öc¡��Ù!¥

®k?اØ2­E"ùp§­:©Û�eçIÝI¹Ä¥�>f�´²�">f

çIÝI�´²�§��çIÝI�´��«êâz©�1N§ÙgÄ3è�XÚ

A:§Q4<�éÙ5�çIÝI¹Ä¥�´ÌN�1�M�4�þ"§@�Ù

�±k�)ûÝI<GÏÝI!áJ�b¢�¥I�ت&�´1�§��´Ï�

Page 387: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

376 çIæÛYFn

ù�:§>fçIÝI�´²�3�/��í2Ú�?|±"éd§·�7Lk�

��2�@£"·��@�§>fçIÝI�´XÚ´/¡¢NXÚ�êâz½>

fz§́ �´1N/ªþ�Cz§¿�çIÝI�¢�§Ø�U)ûçIÝI¥�

@��g¯K§ÙCcA^¥����¤1§~X§éGÏÝI§�=´é@

/f�0�GÏÝI1��±gÄç�§Ï��´1N/ª�UC§�õ´O\

ÝI<�{�JݧØ�U)û½|ÌN3�½|+nö3/cÚPà0¥/P

à0é/c0�|ïS%"�Û¹§iZ¥�/c0k��3he�ÏPà¼|"éA

�§>fçIÝI�´XÚ�$E!+n´<§́ <3éXÚ?1$E�o�+n"

�<�S%ÑyÛ­�§qXÛUÏL�´1N½|¤�/ªCz���Q§�X

e¡ùK¯~.

[�ñ;[&E��¯] 2018c11�20Fȩ,½¥?<¬{�é½���B

ÌR!½ú�] �´¥%�Ì?Ü,�ü Éª�!ɪ�Ú�À��Y?1

�"úm\�"é�wü ½ú�] �´¥%±ü Éª�§�?v7<¬

130��¶é�w<Ü,±ü Éª�!ɪ�Ú�À�§ê�¿v�?kÏä-

8c§¿?v740��¶J��wü ½ú�] �´¥%Ú�w<Ü,��{¤

�§þ�I¥"

�"{�²"n�²§�wü ½ú�] �´¥%|^Ù+n½ú�] >

f�´²�!Ä�µI;[�B|§õg�¦<*�|Ã""n¥§Ü,ÌÄ��

Ù��¯¢"�é½1�`«S�­�ó§ï��8§çI<3µI;[¥XÚ

S�ÅÄ�µI;[�§Ü,±ú�] ¥%Ì?��°§����XÚ+n?

\µI;[¥XÚ§¢�µI;[Ä�(J",�§���´¥%<3ÝI<¥

m§U2��-5��/<Ø�§�ñÄ���{A���µI;[&E§��5çIÝ

I{61n�Ô^¥µI�¬¤�¶ü3¥I(J(½cA����5½§5

�AO��"

�"{�@½§�wü ½ú�] �´¥%�ñµI;[&EÂÉÝI<ã

Ô§òÜ<¬1520�{�§�w<Ü,�T¥%Ì?§́ ��KI�Ì+<§�

â5çIÝI{61Ê��^5½§A�{JÄÙ-¯I?"Ó�§�w<Ü,|

^Ùú?ú�] �´¥%Ì?���B|§heÂɦ<�ãÔ½öÙ¦Ð?§

òÜ<¬180�{�§ê�ã�§�{A±Éª�JÄÙ-¯I?¶�w<Ü,±

�{Ók�8�§¦^�ü ]7�Ù�<ï����ܧòÜ<¬140�{�§

ê�ã�§�{A±�À�JÄÙ-¯I?"

ù´�Kú�] �´+�4<�¯�¯�", §â·¤�§ú�] �´

²�!µI;[¥$EÅ�½´>fXÚEâ|±ü 3�¬þ�ñµI;[&E

Page 388: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 377

�¯�§ù®²Ø´1�g"̄ ���<��g�¯K´§çIÝIÅ�ľ´

=pѯK§��o�«½|�´5K§çI<!çI�nÅ�!ÝI<!½|+

nö!$EEâ|±ü ��2ѯK§�f�.3=pº·@�§�f3�¯<

"y�<�¯��K§"y5�kS�çIÝI½|¨�"@o§�o´ú�]

�´¥%§3çIÝI¹Ä¥´�«�o�Ú§�{A«ú=I?§éÄ��µ

I;[A«ú=I?Qº©ÛXe:

1.ú�] �´"] §��½�¬uÐ�Ï!�½Eâ^�e,�«�S�

Ôå!ãå!<å�Ô���o¡§äk«�!�m!EâG¹A�§�)g,] !

�¬] ÚEâ] �"ú�] �´§�|^½|¿�Å��´ú�] §Ùm

�´¢y] ��Z|^§=��] Ñ^¼��Z�¬�Ã"��/§ú�]

�´æ^çI!ûñ!!ý§±9�?æ¥��çI�ª�´"ú�] �´²

�§́ ���?VÞ�ï�êâz�´¬à8/½½|§=3pé�Å�e�û¬

��²�§́ )��6Ï!ø��I¦m²L'X�oÚ§d½|ÌN!�N!½|

{5����¤"

1¤çIÝI>f�´²�">f�´²��A:§3up�!B$§!��´

¤�"Ó�§é�´êâ9?U3è§́ u�éI?<"çIÝI>f�´²�§́

UìI[Ú��EâIOÚêâ5�§ïá�çIÝI�´>fÑÖXÚ">f�

´²���A�ì5¥u<¬�ÚI@y@�^~6�k'5½?1uÿ!@y§�

±Eâ¥á§XÚ�OþA��aI�©lmu�óä^��oNé�§Ø���

½öü½ÎÜEâ5�5½�óä^��Ùé�"

I[uÐU���Ü��Ù�5>fçIÝI�{61Ê�o^5½§çI<

½ö>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ��3±e�/�§À���½öü½d3ÝI<§

�ìçIÝI{1Ê��^5½§=I-U�§�±U���±þÊ��±e�v

±?1?vµ�|^EâÃãé�k�Ó���½|ÌNJøk�O�&E¶�á

ý½ö���¬ú¯!½|ÌN�¤5þ¿¼��{7Lúm�çIÝI&E¶�

�5��5þ�P!ÝI�¶�c�^�¶��¿��aI�©lmu¿ÎÜEâ

5�5½�óä^�ØoNé�¶��¿é4�½ö)�ÝI©���æN"

Ó�§5½çIÝI>f�´²�$Edú�] �´¥%½�¬1n�ú?

�§A�æ^����°£O!����!\�!¾Ó���Eâ§���Ç�ö

�§�y�´²��S�!­½!��§��ç�?\XÚtUêâ"

[ç�\�;[¥��¯] 2019c8�§ÜH,�úSe�½,½úSÛ¤õ»

¼�åç�\�µI;[¥§¢�GÏÝIÚé�I[ó�<1ª!ɪX�Y

�§£xå��'Y�24�§�Yó§�87�C20·�§Ì���v¦<ÏL�

Page 389: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

378 çIæÛYFn

��{¼|C2000��"

²¬´ÐÚ��§½úSÛu�c5�2F§± ,�vé�I[ó�<1ª

áY§�Yv¦< ,Q´µI;[¥S;[§�´ó§u�«��/�^�0"

,3��µI;[�6¶!>{�§³/3�S�<ó'X§æ^<¯<��ª§é

¯é�µI;[§3>{¥��'ìÙ�½�ÝI<"²Lµ"§ü¶1��¥I

ÿÀ<J,´�½�ÝI<"3µI(Jú«Ïm§ü¶1��¥IÿÀ<�¦<

Ý�§��¥I]�§ ,��d<��8£"3Y���L§¥§�Y¬´Û

�aúùåçÝIY�¥ÛõX��ã����8ì§T8ìöp�Sê��ï

�ó§�çIÝI"

@o§ ,´XÛ��µI;[&E�Qº́ �²"n�²§́ >Mç��,

\�µI;[¥�{¼��"Þ~5`§�cSU§�,3�þw�½Su´U

Eó§�çIúwþ�mI�m"�,|^ݺ�\�Eâ§3mIc8��S§̂

�á�m�{\�µI;[¥§��µI;[¶ü!>{&E�§�=ux�Ù�

��,Ú ,"/�§sÐ��¯´ÜP�íº0§T�83o µI;[c µI

y|�L§¥§kn �� ,�5�>{§F"3µI¥U'ì,ÝI<§¿

NìÐ?¤§¼�é��|±"

��5¿�´§\�µI;[¥�>Mç��,´�;Æ{§�O�Å;��

�Ñ�§QÏ7KÀ¢¼-"-÷º��§�,3�[çI�núió�§3�Sk

�½�<ó] §ÙGçIÝI��6§"2010c§�,l�¤��¶>Mç�§

�¦XÛݺ�ç�\�Eâ§X�Ø��"��/§çIúwuÙ�§�,¬3

�þ��'5ó§çI?ݧÙ�3mIm©c8���§µI;[¥XÚS¬�

)µI;[¶ü"d�§�,\�µI;[¥¼�µI;[&E§=��é�½�

���,Ú ,�<"�,KIGÏÝI§�ÝI<û½¥I��¤'~§ ,

KI�µI;[éX§�é�'ì�,ö�ÝI�A[ÝI<§N쯤�k�½

�Ð?¤"µI(å§�,éX�ÝI<¥I��U�üUS§ ,ÌÄ�µI;

[�>{§�½�¡/:§�||G�µI;[�½�1��2��Ø��Ð?¤"

ùå¯�§�µI;[¥ï�vå´¨"I�5¿�´§�,\��µI;

[¥êâ´\��§Ù\�¢Sþ´)�"@o§��oç�\�µI;[¥XÚ

��±)�Ä��µI;[&EQº̀ ²ÙÄ�Ú\��?Øv§éN´)�§c

Ù´�õêµI;[¥æ^�5\���{"?è+�¥)��J�§́ �kêâ

>©uÑÚ�Â<��)��{�\�"�Ô�Ká�>Àì¥~Ñy��d

è§̂ V��½����`��è�)��§Ò´ù«�/"µI;[¥¦^�´

�«úm�èÅ�§Ø�Uæ^ù«\��{"�XÛJpµI;[¥\�§AO

Page 390: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 379

´§µI;[&E�\�§́ ��A��\ïÄ�¯K"ÄK§çIÝI¹Ä¥Ò

�¬k�õ�>Mç�\�µI;[¥§�¤¢/�p�º p�à0§¼�µI;

[&E"

2¤ú�] �´¥%�I"ú�] �´¥%§́ �?|ï��3�ú�]

�´²�I�JøÑÖ�ü §KIú�] �´²�9�äXÚï�!$1Ú+

n§�?\ú�] �´²���´¹ÄJø|¤!��ÚÑÖ"

ú�] �´¥%35�þ§��´ëúü §Øäk1�"1Ú1�iÒ�

U§�Ùó�<ëìúÖ+n§AÁ15¥u<¬�ÚIúÖ{61��^

5½�ÂÖ§=µ����Å�{Ú{ƶ�Uì5½���Ú§S@ýÁ1�I§

ãåJpó��Ƕ��%�¿�<¬ÑÖ§�É<¬iÒ¶��oI[�S�!J

�Ú|ö�§u�ŧ��¦I§ÑlÚ�1þ?�{�Ñ�û½Ú·-¶��

ÅI[��Úó���¶��ÅVƧ�Å����§���Å�¬ú�¶���

í'§ú���¶�{Æ5½�Ù¦ÂÖ"~X§5çIÝI{61n�Ô^¥§µ

I�¬¤�¶ü3¥I(J(½cA����5½·^u�a��<§�,�

�)ú�] �´¥%"éd§5>fçIÝI�{61Ê�8^5½§>fçIÝ

IXÚ$EÅ��¦<ß³®¼�çI©��d3ÝI<�¶¡!êþ!ÝI©�

SN½öéÝI©��µ"Ú'�±9Ù¦�UK�ú²¿��çIÝI&E§ë

ìçIÝI{1Ê��^'uçI<���5½�±?v"�d§{�é�ñ;[

&E��¯¥�Ü,�{?1�û"

ú�] �´¥%�m�´ÑÖ"�d§I÷vµ�ÑÖ¤L"��é�´<

�ÝÚK!9�!ýª§Ø�Ø}!kr��¶�ÑÖó!"©²^�§ó!��!

ª�§L�g,!��§LãO(¶�ÑÖÞ�"Þ�àB§Ä�©²§�^��§

Øc:��±9٦ة²�Þ�¶�ÑÖÅ�"�n�«ÃY!Jø�«ÑÖØ

öò§ë\�´¬ÆJcu�!O�Ð¥%��´<Jø���!��!L�§¬�

u�!�n��!��§(��ÐÃ�¶���J,"ØäÆSú�] �´{Æ{

5Úk ;�Eâ!EU§ä�A:?�Uå¶��VÅ{"���´¥�G��

{�51�"

3¤ú�] �´¥%B�1�"ú�] �´�K´úm!ú²!ú�Úª¢

&^§ú�] �´²����´�1N§I[uÐU����o�Ü�éÜ�Ù

�5ú�] �´²�+n61�{61�l^5½§²�$1ÑÖÅ�9Ùó�

<Ø�l¯±e¹Äµ�1¦?Û"1!�Y!i+!?v�1�iÒ+n�U¶

��{l¯½r��½çI!ûñ!�?æ�n!ó§Ed�¥0ÑÖ¶�r�

�ú�] �´�8?\²��´¶�Z�½|ÌNÀJ�{ï�Ú$1�ú�]

Page 391: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

380 çIæÛYFn

>f�´XÚ¶��{�Ùè�Ú<��'yì]�¶�ÏL��5þ�P!

�á©|Å�!]��y!ÝI£¿ï¤N�!r�ú����5^�{N½öü½

Ù¦/«½|ÌN?\�/«ú�] �´½|¶��{�¦è�{½�L<�|

�n�'ÃY¶�Ù¦��{Æ{55½��/"

T�{1n�8^!1o�n^Ú1o�o^5½§½|ÌN½�¬ú¯@�

ú�] �´²�$1ÑÖÅ�9Ùó�<�3�{�51��§��{��?

k'Ü�Ý�!Þ�"²(5½§ú�] �´²�$1ÑÖÅ�9Ùó�<�

¦<ß³�{A����ú�] �´&E�§d�?k'Ü�I-�ÏU�§¿

�±Ï�1µ¶�!î­�§�{JÄ��I?<Úk'+��I?¶�¤���§

�{JÄ-¯I?"ék'1�iÒ+nÜ�!ú�] �´²�$1ÑÖÅ�9

Ùó�<ÞhÍ6!E^��!áJ�b! ��ŧ��{Á1�I�§5½�

{��?©¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"�!m©ùã�ú�] �´¥%

�{�ñµI;[&E�Y§�´3Â�½|ÌN�Þ��iÅ'�?�§d½

u�Jå�ú�§�{é�w½���BÌR!½ú�] �´¥%�Ì?Ü,

?1��û"

2.¥0½²��³µI;[&E���"é¥0Å�½²��{�³�{A�

���µI;[&E���Ø%§E3uçIæ�J`§UCçIær/ª!

rL|§\réµI(J�Ø�§Ïù«�/����µI�¬¤éXÝI<§

NìÙ¥I¿¢�Ð?��/��"

Á�§µI�¬¤³�oNìÝI<¥Iº�Ï3uçI©�¥5½�µ

IIOÚ�{Ø´J` ´iZ"AO´§µIIO¥¹k�þ�Ì*µ"Ï�§

=çI<D�µI�¬¤/gdàþ�0�3µI|�¥qvéÙ\±��

½�å"��où�`ºXJçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{´²LÆ¿Âþ�

J`§µI�¬áØ�1§�½´�«�{1�§�{iÒ½´çI<Á1(@

µI(J�I?Ò�½Uuy§Å�µI(J§é�{�µI�¬¤�{?v"

�ó�§=Bù«�/eE�3µI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I§Ùí��¥

IÿÀ<�A�´3²LÆþw�`�ÝI§çIæ(JجÉ�K�§çI<

�Ø^'5µI�¬¤´ÄÂÉÝI<ªµ"�XJçI©�¥5½�µII

OÚ�{Ø´J`§́ iZ§@heNìÝI<¥I�µI�¬¤|^Ùg

dàþ�§3{ÆN����Sí��1�¥IÿÀ<Ò�UØ´�` K�çI

æ(J"

�d§£8çIæ�²Lm�§/J`0â´��µI�¬¤��§±9

µI�¬¤heNìÝI<¥I���"

Page 392: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 381

15!Y~µµI�{�S�¯�)ØÜÓY

µI�¬��I´�{éÝI(J?1µ�§�¤µI�w¿í�Ü��¥

IÿÀ<"ùp§�{µ��¹Â§́ µI�¬UçI<úÙ�çI©�¥�µ

IIOÚ�{§éÝI<3ÝI���mc4��ÝI©�§?1µ"Ú'�"ù

´µI�\ε����«O"@o§��o3çIÝI¹Ä¥¬ÑyÝI<�µ

I�¬¤§�);[¤1ª§µI;[¥�k�ê¤ÌÄ�ÝI<éX§

heNìÙ¥I¿¢ªQº�Ï3u§ÝI<�µI�¬¤m��´1�´�

«he1�§uyJ§¼�<yÔyØ´"Ó�§�µI;[�����3½||

Ãp¾¡c�¿�k'"ùa¯��)�è15 uçI<§ uçI<|�çI

ÝI¹Ä�r/ª!rL|§ l½|²L¥/`���0�g,{K§Ù�J´

g,�¨v§dçI<«úçI�8Á��J§�'I?<É�{Æ�à"

[Y�£�] ,IkÝ]�.ó�ï��8§Ý]18000��§OyóÏ28��"

T�8ó§�óçI3½ï�Ûu�«��´¥%?1"çI©�5½�µ©IO

�L15.2§5½µI�¬UÝI<��©§dp�$�^SüS§�gí�üS

3cn �ÝI<�¥IÿÀ<"

µ"Ï� ©� µ"IO

ÝI�d 60µIÄOd=ÏLÐÚ"���$ÝI�d§ÝI�d�©=60×µIÄOd/ÝI�d

�ó|��O

�ó�Y��5 5 �Y���1�§1-5©¶Ø�1�§ÄûÝI

Ì��ó�{ 15 U�ó�{9��µ"§0-15©

�þ�y�� 2 U�þ��9�yµ"§0-2©

S����� 2 US�����9�yµ"§0-2©

] ��Oy 2 U] ��Oyµ"§0-2©

?ÝOy��� 2 U?ÝOy9���yµ"§0-2©

�8+n�

�8²n 4 U�8²nCnc��1µ"§0-4©

EâKI< 2 UEâKI<Cnc��1µ"§0-2©

Ù¦Ì�< 6 U�8²nÜ<��µ"§0-6©

L15.2 ,ó§�óçIµ©IO

Page 393: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

382 çIæÛYFn

3çI©�5½�ÝI���mc§k7�ÝI<4�ÝI©�§mIP¹1

²�¯��L15.3"çI<�{|ïµI�¬§µI�¬dçI<�L1<§

½ï�ÛµI;[¥�ÅÄ�²L;[1<!Eâ;[3<|¤"Ù¥§çI<�L

´� éçIÝI�'�ÝØ�©ÙG��ó<"ÝI<�ÝIþÏLµI�

¬�ÐÚµ""

SÒ ÝI<¶¡ ÝI�d£�¤ ÝI�y7 óÏ£�¤ \¶

1 A 16886.00 4�§60�� 26 ***

2 B 16616.00 4�§60�� 24 ***

3 C 16615.00 4�§60�� 25 ***

4 D 15868.00 4�§60�� 24 ***

5 E 16425.00 4�§60�� 25 ***

6 F 16746.00 4�§60�� 26 ***

7 G 16526.00 4�§60�� 27 ***

L15.3 mIP¹L

�[µ"¥§o µI;[��@�ÝI<A�ó¢å�r"²�[µ"§Ý

I<��©�L15.4.

ÝI< A B C D E F G

�d�© 56.38 57.30 57.30 60 57.97 56.85 57.61

�ó|��O 28.00 23.00 22.00 21.00 21.00 21.00 22.00

�8+n� 11.00 10.00 10.00 8.00 9.00 11.00 10.00

ÜO 95.38 88.30 89.30 89.00 87.97 88.85 89.61

L15.4 ÝI<�©L

µI�¬U®o�µ©(J§�gí�ÝI<A!ÝI<GÚÝI<C�1

�!1�Ú1n¥IÿÀ<"1�U§çI<3k'xNþú«µI(J"ú«Ï

S§vkÝI<9Ù|³'X<Ý�§çI<(½ÝI<A�¥I<§�ÙuÑ¥

IÏ�Ö§1²�¥Id�16886.00��§��\¾Ö¡ÜÓ"

ÝI<A\¾ÜÓ�§UÜÓ�½?||�ó§�ó§ó§?Ð��õ��=

uyÙ�óUåf§ï�óÏ¢�"T�8�ó��ý�g5·vèüeXÚ�§

u)ð�L3��L:å­þØv§åL��¯�§ü¶�ÜåL�¬ók�!i

Å­ú��J"̄ �u)�§ï�+nÜ�éy|?1S��{u�§uyy|+

n<¥§�k�8²n´¥I<A��§Ù{<þ´y|¢S|��ó�úi

`�<"�d§�{<��¥I<A�ÝI©�1²��8+nÅ�§Å�

Page 394: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 383

Øéy|<§uy�ÝI©�þ1²�<¿Ã�É"u�<@�¯�é¿¥§

3?nú�¯��Ó�§�¦¥I<A��8²nÚÙ¦Ì�<X¢`²ÙÝI

�¹"

²�¢§úi`è�]�Ø÷vçI�8�¦§é�¥I<A!�§!�¤´�

8¥I7��1.5%"úi`�7y|��L�µI;[¥¥�o,ÙG§�¦Ù3

µI¥�a§Nì¥I��Ù20���Ð?¤"o,Ó¿�3�ÙÙG�;[>{

éX§é�ë�µI�Ü,Ú�,§�¦�Üí�ÝI<A�1�¥IÿÀ<§N

ìz<2���Ð?¤"Ü,!�,3µI¥§uyçI<�LéµI´1§Ó�§

çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{¥§k40©�gdàþ"u´§̀ Ñ,�¶E

â;[3µI¥�ܧ3�ó|��Oµ"�§vkéÙ[�<!LC��ÚL

C�Y@ý"�§�§Ù�ó�Y`DK�Ù¦µI�¬¤��ä§�ÝI

<AµÑ�p©§¤õí�Ù�1�¥IÿÀ<"úi`�o,|G20��Ð?¤§

o,��Ü,!�,z<|G2��¤^"

�{<(@ù´�åúi`!�¥I<A§¿�n µI;[1ª��{¯

�§U5çIÝI{61Ê�o^Ú5ï�ó§�þ+n^~6§@½¥I<A�¢

�¥I§¥IÃ�§¿é¥I<AÚúi`�{?11�?v"Ó�§ò�{u�¥

uy��'I?<1ªÉª1�£�úSÅ'N��y"úSÅ'N��y�§ò

<yÔy=�½u�Jå�z"{�²"n§@½úi`�1ª�§@½o,!

Ü,Ú�,�ɪ�§�{JÄÙ-¯I?"�ûúi`��I?<kÏä-ü

c§¿?v730��¶�ûo,kÏä-nc§�-�c¶Ü,Ú�,��I[ó

�<ɪ�§�?kÏä-�c§�-�c¶J��{¤�þ�I¥"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û±e¯Kµ

1.�o´�ó|��O§k=Ä�SN§Ù3�óçI�8µI¥��^´

�oº

2.1��{<@½úi`!�¥I<A�nd´�oº�YÜÓ´Ä�±U

YÁ1ºXØÁ1§çI<N�|G¥I<A�±�§́ Ä�±�¦¥I<A���

�º��oº

3.�YéçI<��µI;[heNìÝI<¥Ik=é&º��oº

[Y~©Û] �âþãY�£�§éþã¯K©ÛXe:

1.�ó|��O´�â�8�óA:Ú+nI¦?��§�3���ó�8�

�¹Ä�Eâ!²LÚ|��nÜ5©�§́ �óEâ��ó�8+n�(Ü��

Ô§́ �ó|��j+5©�"�ó|��O�SN§���)µ�?��â¶�ó

§V¹¶��óÜݧ�)�óIãy©!�óy|²¡Ù�!?ÝOy�¶�Ì�

Page 395: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

384 çIæÛYFn

�ó�{¶�] ��Oy§�)Ì�Ô]Oy!Ì��óÅ���Oy!NÄå

Oy�¶�Ì�Eâ��§�)�þ�y��!?ÝOy�y��!S�!���

�!G!5�ó��!©²�ó���¶�N¹§�)�ó²¡oã!�ó?Ý�ä

Oy�"

ÝI�ó|��ONy�§́ ÝI<�Eâ¢åÚ�ó|�Uå§�)Ù3<!

á!Ô�¡�|�N��Sü!+nUå§́ ÝI<é�óçI�8Á�Uå�u

�"�d§ó§�óçII�é�ó|��O?1µ"§±�½Ù´ÄkUå|�

�8�ó§¢yçIæm�"5¿§�ó|��O�ÝI�dk��'X§́ Ý

I�dSN�| 5©�"

2.�Y1��{<@½úi`!�¥I<A�nd§́ 4�¢�ï�Ü2014c

�Ù�5ïÓó§�ó=��{©���{1�@½�?+n�{£Á1¤6£ï½

120142118Ò¤1��^¥5½�§�óü 3�óy|�7��8KI<!EâK

I<!�þ+nKI<!S�+nKI<¥�<±þ��óü vk¾áNÄÜÓ§

½vkïáNÄó]½�¬�P�x'X�§@½�!�1�§Ï��Y¥§�8

y|+n<¥§�k�8²n´¥I<A���§Ù{<þ�úi`�<"

¥I<A�ÝIáuáJ�b¢�¥I§ÏÙÝI©�1²�Ì�+n<§

Ø�8²n§þ�úi`�<§ úi`qØä��A�]�§áuáJ�b

¢�¥I1�"Ó�,¥I<A±�µI�¬¤1ª�Ãã*�¥I�§�{¥

IÃ�"�d§Ù�çI<\¾�ÜÓ§U5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�n^�5

½§=��{Æ!1�{5�r�55½§ÜÓÃ�"

Ã�ÜÓéÜÓV�g©vk{Æ�åå§çI<3�¡ÜÓÃ��§ØU2

�¦¥I<A�¤T�8�ó§Ï�V�\¾�ÜÓé¥I<Avk�åå"@o§

éu¥I<A®�óÜ©§qA�XÛ|GÙd±Qº�â5¬{;6ÜÓ?1Ôz

Ê�n^§çI<�±ëì�p<¬{�5'u"nï�ó§�óÜÓŪY�·

^{ƯK�)º£�¤6£{º12004214Ò¤1�^§=ï�ó§�óÜÓÃ�§

�ï�ó§²eó�ÂÜ�§«�<�¦ëìÜÓ�½|Gó§d±�§A�|±

��K§é¥I<A®��8�ÂÜ��Ü©�d±�±|G§Ï�d���ó§�

����ó§eó�§Ø�3eó�ÂÜ��ħ�Uëìù�5½|Gd±"

5¿§Tó§�óÜÓ@½Ã��§ÏÃ�ÜÓØäk{Æ�åå§ó§I�

6Ê�ó§çI<­#|�çI§(½Ü��¥I<?|�ó§7,�çI<�5

�½�²L��"5¬{;6oK?1�zÊ�Ô^§¬¯{Æ1�Ã�!���½

ö(½Øu)�å�,1�<ÏT1����ã�,A��±��¶ØU��½öv

k7����,A�òdÖ�¶kL����A���é�dd¤É����¶��

Page 396: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

115ÙçIæµ�{µI��� 385

ÑkL��,A��g«ú�A�I?¶{Æ,k5½�,�ìÙ5½"�d§�Yç

I<�±�{�¦¥I<A��ÏÙ3ÝI¥�!�1�!�µI;[�*¥I�

�{1�¦ÜÓÃ�§��ÜÓÁ1ØU!¥ä�ÙE¤���?1��"

3.�Y�$�d´ÝI<D�15868.00��§ÝI<A��d16886.00��§�

ö��1018.00��"¥I<A��óLC�Y�3­�S�Û�§@o§��oÝ

I<AEU¥IQº�Ï3u§!�3ÝI<A¶e�úi`�7y|�KI<h

e�µI;[o,�ϧ�µI;[Ü,Ú�,1ª§¦Ü,!�,�Ø�¯¢

/3é�ó|��Oµ"¥§�ÙµÑ28©p©§éÙ¦ÝI<��ó|��Oµ

©21©-23 ©§±�ÖÙ�ÝI<D��d�©��3.62©"@o§µI;[��o

3{Æ5½e§�±¤õ¢yÝI<A�1�¥IÿÀ<�Q½8IQº�Ï3u§

çI©�¥�µIIOÚ�{D�µI;[40 ©�gdàþ�"

éçI<��µI;[heNìÝI<¥I�é&3u§çI<|�çI§Ø

Ur/ª!rL|§ A�´Uµ"Ï�éÝI?1nÜüS§?1²LJ`"X

ÙØ,§Ò¬Ñy�Y¤ã�/§=wqçIÝIL§é5�§¢K4he�ÝI

<�*�µI;[�Ã�§E¤çI<²L��"@o§A�XÛ��µI;[

he�ÝI<Nì¥I§K�çIæ(JQº���{3uçI£8Ùæ�²

LЩ§=çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{´²LÆ¿Âþ�J`"Ó�§\r

éµI�iÒ�|�+n§3�½§Ýþ��½ö��;[�gdàþ"

Page 397: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

#"

!

ZB-CHINA¥IçI

————

1 16Ù

çIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï

**********************************************************************

#�à[1˶,´c3�v/K¶

ì­YE¦Ã´,7Vs²q�~"

— Hy.ºi5iìÜ~6

********************** f��. çIæÛYFn **********************

—————————————————————

c©Chinese Branch Xiquan House and Linfan Mao, 2020. All rights reserved.

Page 398: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 387

11!²�µçIÝI�´�1N

²�§́ ��[Ôâ�§��<��6!�´!ÆS§l¯,�ó�¤I���

¸½1N"3½|�´¥§²�¢�þ´½|�O¡§kü«Ly/ª§�«´k

/½|§=DÚ¿Âþû¬���|¤§X[ä½|!Ìè½|�¶,�«´J[

½|§=pé�þ�ï�²�\Ô6§X=�!®À!Cpnn�"²��m�3u

�J�¬²LÚ©z)¹§·A�¬uÐI�"ù�¥,�?´²��ï�|�ö§

�´½|�S�±ö"¢y��k�-y!��gd6Ä!d��A(¹!¿�ú

²kS!è�`����#��¥IAÚ�¬Ì½|²LN�´²LN�U��

m�"

çIÝI�´²�§�)çIÝI�´���!>f�´XÚÚ$EÑÖXÚ§

´�¢�Ú���ÝÚIO!ä�m����çIÝI�´>fÑÖXÚÚ5�ß

²�$1Å�§�½|ÌN!�¬ú¯!1�iÒ+nÜ��Jøú�] �´n

ÜÑÖ�NX§Ùm�3uu�>f�´ú�ÑÖXÚ�ÍÝ�^§ÏLë�>f

�´Úi+XÚ§�Ü��½|&EÚi+&E�§¢ypépÏp@§�É�¬

ú¯iÒ"çIÝI�´²�þ§ÌN´çI<ÚÝI<"çI�nÅ�ÚµI�

¬§�ÉçI<��÷½|ï§�çIÝI¹ÄJøÑÖ¶�N´çI�8§́

çI<ÚÝI<�´�I�"d§çIÝI�´²��$1§��)Ù$1ÑÖ!

Eâ|±ü §±9�{é²�$1¢�iÒ�1�Å�"

çIÝIé²Lï�¥u�Ù�z�cJ§́ ²�þ��´ÌN§±9²�$

1ÑÖ!Eâ|±ü Ú1�iÒ�iÙ�§�l�å5K"��§KÒ¤�«

Í�§�«Æ�<����Í� ��ÙAkd�"¢�L²§çIÝIÅ�$

1±5§²�þ��a�ÚþÑyL�{�5§³/çIÝI�´ª�hK!��

\��¯�§́ ��çIÝIÅ�§,8¿»§�´��?��Eºù�¥k��

Ä�¯KIg�§Ò´çIÝI²�þÑy��«¯K§�.´çIÝIÅ�þ�

¯K�´¥I<��5þ�¯Kº·@�´¥I<�5þØ·AçIÝIÅ��¯

K§Ï�çIÝI´�«�{§́ ¥5�§'�3<§3¦^�{�<§Ø¨Ï�¢

 §�Xe¡ùK!m�¯%¹�ón"

[�7´Ó���¯] k�U�CUç§~¬`Ú~¬¯3ìe~>��fpÑ

Ú"ù�§��� �Úÿlìþ��ÜÜ��e5"è<�G§~¬`�r.

4�Úÿ§̄ ¦Ñ�o¯�"

Page 399: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

388 çIæÛYFn

�Úÿ'&ØS/`µ/Ø�Ø�3§·�3ìþ�ä�f§Ø��Ñ��

f7f�0è<�f§ý´Ð�§é�Úÿ`µ/��f7fk�oÐù�§J�§�

¬¯<ºw�·�§\´3=p��ä�§·�è�ww"0�Úÿ�f§!{`µ/�

Ì�´Ø��j��Iùc��·`§@ÀÜ´Ó�§¬k<�"0�ü ~¬

Å�X§�Úÿ ìþ��µ/Ò3@þ¡�0̀ �§Ò��eì"

è<÷X�Úÿ�e5�ì´ þr§é��Úÿ�ä��/�§��A�ä

�¿3�>§èpîX���f§�fþ�Xf®²�»§p¡³Ñ�ðð�7f"

~¬`Ú~¬¯p,4§%�µ/ùo���f7f§A�f�sØ�"0

ù�ÿ§~¬`8X�f>`µ/5§4�è<�å^år�fáÑ5§$�ì

e�<��"0~¬¯aéÙ��§̀ µ/OÜ�·�y3r�7$£~fp§Ø�S

�§�´��Uçj�~ó�§Ø�MÜÒûMBPí�0~¬`�f§k�n"è

<u´�3�f>þÅX"

ÅX§ÅX§è<aúÜf�"~¬¯é~¬``µ/�m�@@§\eì£

[p�á:�è5§·3ùpÅX"·�3ùp¯��§����<·��ÿ2r

�7$£~fp"0~¬`Ø�%§̧ Ë`µ/·Ø3§\�wÐ�0

~¬`�> ìer§�>�§²²´·:4��Úÿ§³�o��7f��

�~¬¯²©º�´ù��f7fÑ8·õÐ"~¬`r�§~¬¯�§Òùo�

�f7f§���~¬`©r��§�´ù��f�7Ñ8·��<TõÐ"u´§

~¬¯3NCé����o�Ff§3þì�´�wÐ��Ûõ�/�§��

~¬`þì"

2`~¬`£�[p�Ð�è§gCk3[p¯�"é��-f�~¬

¯��è§�>�X§�>r��Ó�ëÜ3�è¥"%�§~¬¯�k§ù��f

7fØÒ8·��<í�%nù��X§���p,"�´þ�,Ø��§ì�

X�­§�~¬¯x�"ù�ÿ§~¬¯õ3ì´>���ä��¡§�~¬`r

L§lä�aÑ5§ìX~¬`��MÒ´�Ff§�|�k~¬`",�§�

m~¬`C��-f§��¯å5"vLõȧ~¬¯aúÜfÒ�»����

Û§²x�èkÓ§�®²�"�kc§~¬¯�å�Úÿ�{§�I���ý

é§�7ý�´Ó�B§·�ÐNoÒزxQ�

�A@é/�7�Ãd§�Ó3<%�0ª,§�7���«½|�´��d

Ô§�Ãé�§́ <D�Ù[B�d�§¤�ãL���"Ó�§�´<��g§

E¤Ù3�|ܤ����pÏ"�kL��Ø´�7 ´<gC�S%"3ù

�:þ§V[ù?1/;!Â!r!�!&0§�[ù?�/U<Ü�!�{g,0§Ã

[ù?%§+�!+�!+°!+Ú§ù¦/Ú=´�!�=´Ú0§ÃØ´3¦<5

Page 400: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 389

£8�5½g,"

aq/§çIÝI���«ÎÜg,/`���0�Å�§�Ãé�"ùcÑ

y�¯K§Ø3çIÝIÅ� 3<%§́ <%?�þѯK"Ó�§éu½|

þ��*�´1�§�?�Ø�+!No+!+��o§Ý§E´ù�¥�I�ï

Ä�¯K"�?é²L¹Ä�N�!i+§Jøú��¬�ÑÖ§́ �?²L�U

�Ny"çIÝI�´²��$1ÑÖü küa§�a´ú�] �´¥%§,

�a´�¬1n�>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ�"ù�¥§ú�] �´²�§́ �

?�Ùéú�] �´§�)çIÝI¹Ä�i+ �ï�²�§I�l¥I<5

A:Ú�´5ƧØäéÙ?1`z§±�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|"

1.½|ÌN�o"éçIÝI½|ÌN�o�Ø%§3u½|ÌN�{�k�

²EgÌ�§?Ûü Ú�<§�)çIÝI²�iÒÅ�!$EÑÖÅ�ÚEâ

|±ü Ø��{ZýçIÝI¹Ä"~XµçIÝI�´²�Ø�k±e1�µ

�Ø��{����½ü½ØÓ¤k�è�ë�çIÝI¹Ä¶�Ø��{�½d

3ÝI<½öÝI<�¤k�/ª½ö|�/ª§Ø�éØÓ¤k�ÝI<æ�Ø

Ó�]�"�IO¶�Ø��{�½è��À�µ!c²þ«��8êþ½ö7�!

l�<!B[�!E�|¤¡È�5�^�§Ø����L�8¢SI��è�

5þ]�!]�o�!À]�5�!E�Â\!|d!Ç&�Ý�ãÖ�I¶�Ø�

�{�½²w�ÑçI�8äNA:Ú¢SI��Lp�]�]�!Eâ!ûÖ^

�½ö�1Úø��¦¶�Ø�òI[®²²-���]�]���ÝI^�!\

©^�½¥I^�§Ø�3I[®²²-��]�]��+�§òÙ¦]�]��

�ÝI^�!\©^�½¥I^�¶�Ø��{òA½1�«�!A½1���1!

ø���ÝI^�!\©^�½ö¥I^�§Ø�ò�?Ü�!1��¬û¬½ö

Ù¦Å�éÝI<�Ñ�J�øyÚaõúÃy²���ÝI^�½¥I^�¶�

Ø��{�½½ö�½A½�;|!ûI!¬ý!��/!øAû½öu�uÿ@

yÅ�¶�Ø��{�¦ÝI<3�/5þ�áfúi!©úi½©|Å�§½ö

�¦ÝI<3�/Pk�½�ú¡È§3�/�B�¬�x�¶�Ø���vk{

Æ{5�â�ÝI�¶!]�ý"½çI©�"��¯c"ؽö"1�!¶�Ø

�é=IJøk']�y²©�!yì!y�E<��§�¦7LJø��§Ø�

éU5½�±æ^/õyÜ�0>fyì�§�¦ÝI<7LJø��yì¶11©Ø�3mI�!�¦ÝI<�{½�L<7L�|§áØ�ɲÇ��÷�ÝI<�

L�|ë�mI¶12©Ø�²«½V«µI;[éØÓ¤k�ÝI<æ�ØÓ�µIIO!¢�Ø�*ú�µd¶13©Ø�r�çI<æ^Ä\½~Ò��ª(½¥IÿÀ<½¥I<¶14©Ø��5Â�ÝI�y7!Á��y7§½´�¦�U±y7/

Page 401: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

390 çIæÛYFn

ªJ�§½öØU5½½öÜÓ�½���y7¶15©{ü±5þ<!�1êþ�5�^�½öA½1�«���1ø�µdè��&^�?§½ö��éØÓ¤k

�è��¤ÜÀ�&^µd�I¶16©Ø�3çIÝI²�þ§æ�Ù¦�{�5^�§�)3�´XÚ¥æ�EâÃã§�{ZýçIÝI¹Ä�"

2.²��´5K"²��´5K§=çI<½çI�nÅ�3çIÝI�´²

�þ|�çIÝI¹Ä§ÝI<3²�þ4�ÝI©�§?1ÝI§±9µI�

¬¤3²�þë�µI�A��Ì�²�{K"çIÝI�´²��ÑÖSN!

ÑÖ6§!ó�5�!¤IOÚiÒ±�A��{(½§ÏLçIÝI>fÑÖ

XÚ��¬úÙ"Ó�§çIÝI�´²�A�òçIúw!]�ý"úw!]�

"�(J!�´L§&E!¤�&E!Á�&E�çIæ¯�§ÏLçIÝI�

´²��>fÑÖXÚ§�{9���¬úm§U5½c�§��çIÝI�´L

§¥�)���]�!>f©�±9ÑÀª�çIÝI�´�Yá�§uyçIÝ

I¹Ä¥k�{�51��§A��3�'yâ¿9��k'1�iÒ+nÜ��

w§�{?n"

3.²��´+n" çIÝI�´²��$1A��ÌÑÖ�U§�Ìm�ß

²!] ��!p�B¬!Å{ª&�$1ÑÖ�K"

1¤ú�] �´¥%"�{�á�ú�] �´¥%��ú�] �´²�

$1ÑÖÅ�§KIú�] �´²�£¹>fçIÝI�´²�¤ï�!$1Ú�

o§�{�5�ú�] �´¹ÄJøú�ÑÖ"½|ÌN½�¬ú¯@�ú�]

�´²�$1ÑÖÅ�9Ùó�<�3�{�51��§�±�{��?k'

Ü�Ý�!Þ�"�â²�$1ÑÖÅ��5�§Ù¤©OB\1�¯�5¤

Ú²EÑÖ5¤+n§äN¤�8Ú¤IOUìk'5½�1§áu1�¯

�5¤�§Uì�?�?�[Â\+n�k'5½�1"I[uÐU����o

�Ü�Û�u�5ú�] �´²�+n61�{61o�o^5½§k'1�i

Ò+nÜ�!ú�] �´²�$1ÑÖÅ�9Ùó�<ÞhÍ6!E^��!

áJ�b! ��ŧ��{Á1�I�§�{��?©¶�¤���§�{JÄ-

¯I?"

2¤>fçIÝI�´²�"ú�] �´¥%!�¬1n�>fçIÝI$E

Å��±U1�!;�aO§ï�Ú$E>fçIÝI�´²�§ÏL�{?1�

uÿ!@y§�çIÝI¹ÄJø�´ÑÖ"�é>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ��{

��½ü½d3ÝI<�1�§I[uÐU���lÜ�Û�Ù�5>fçIÝI

�{61Ê�o^5½§>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ��3±e�/���§À��

�½öü½d3ÝI<§�ìçIÝI{1Ê��^5½§I-U�§�±?��

Page 402: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 391

�±þÊ��±e�v±µ�|^EâÃãé�k�Ó���½|ÌNJøk�O

�&E¶�áý½ö���¬ú¯!½|ÌN�¤5þ¿¼��{7Lúm�çI

ÝI&E¶��5��5þ�P!ÝI�¶�c�^�¶��¿��aI©lmu

¿ÎÜEâ5�5½�óä^�ØoNé�¶��¿é4�½)�ÝI©���æ

N�"

é>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ��¦<ß³®¼�çI©��d3ÝI<�¶

¡!êþ!ÝI©�SN½öéÝI©��µ"Ú'�±9Ù¦�UK�ú²¿�

�çIÝI&E�1�§5>fçIÝI�{61Ê�8^5½§ëìçIÝI{1

Ê��^'uçI<���5½§��´w§�±¿?���±þ���±e�v

±¶éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{��?©¶�¤���§

�{JÄ-¯I?"Ó�5½§c±¤�1�K�¥I(J�§¥IÃ�"éçI

ÝI¹Ä�¯<Ú>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ��ÏçI<!ÝI<GÏÝI�§5>

fçIÝI�{61Ê�Ô^5½§�ìçIÝI{1Ê�n^ÚçIÝI{¢�

^~18�Ô^éGÏÝI�?v5½?v§=¥IÃ�§?¥I�87�0.5%±

þ1%±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<?ü v±ê

�5%±þ10%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿?vÂ�{¤�¶�!î­�§��

Ù�c��cSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI]�¿�±úw§��dóû

1�+nÅ'L�E��ì¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"�¦<E¤���§

�{«ú��I?"

éçIÝI¹Ä�¯<Ú>fçIÝIXÚ$EÅ��E!tU!�¤çIÝ

I&E§½ö±Ù¦�ªáJ�b�§5>fçIÝI�{61Ê�l^5½§�ì

çIÝI{1Ê�o^ÚçIÝI{¢�^~18�l^5½?v§=¥IÃ�§

�çI<E¤���§�{«ú��I?¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"é�

{7L?1çI��8�ÝI<kc±¤�1�ÿ��¤���§?¥I�87

�0.5%±þ1%±e�v±§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<?ü

 v±ê�5%±þ10%±e�v±¶k�{¤��§¿?vÂ�{¤�¶�!î­

�§��Ù�c�ncSë\�{7L?1çI��8�ÝI]�¿�±úw§�

�dóû1�+nÅ'L�E��ì"

d§>fçIÝI²�$EÅ���5½§�¦ÝI<5þ�P!Â�¤^!

�¦ÝI<ï�½�óä^�§½´kÙ¦��çIÝI¹Ä�¯<Ü{�Ã�

�/�§k'1�iÒÅ�I-U�§¿Uìk'5½?v"é>fçIÝIXÚ

$EÅ���{Á1Щ¹\&E�yÂÖ§E¤çIÝI¹Ä�¯<���§5

½ÙA«ú�A���I?"

Page 403: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

392 çIæÛYFn

12!ª&µ<Ú½|ÌN)����

²�´�´�1N§́ �½|ÌNm��´Jø²�½|¤"½|ÌN3²�

þ�´§�lg�!²�!ú²!ª¢&^Ú�lúSû���´�K§¢y�´

V�/�dk�0��´(J"ùp§�dk�´�«Ôk¤��%n÷v�3

Ly§���Ã�§[Ø÷v/¤m²�é'"kù���©\¢�§�±4<3

¿�¥��%n÷v"ù�¢�k�Ü�\Úü�+��<§̀ Ú¯"5K´l`

m©§¦�±3\¥m?¿�þ� §ÀJ¦@����@�¬§�XJ¯@�`

À�@¬��§�±3`ÀJ�@¬\þ2?¿�þ� §̂ �´¦�l�e�ü

¬¥§ÀJ�¬\"Ó�/§`XJ@�¯À�\��§��±�lÓ�5K§3

¯ÀJ�\þ?¿�þ� §À�¬"ù�L§��?1e�§��ü�<Ñ@�

©��\��ª�"ù�Ò´%nÆþ��\��u��~f§Ùb�´<5�g

h§Ñ�3�´¥���¬���\"@o§XJ<5Ø´gh�§qA�´�«

N���´|µQ§'X*3è<©\§**4X33§gC�´l¥����¬

\§�e�3�33º� 5̀ºs�6¥Òkù�Aã�´|µ�£�48<Øn

)"@´½|�´¥�n�I§º¥�I"

[½|¥�n�I]5ºs�61��£kAã´ù�£��§/^ÚõÊú5

��[O½§��k���¸Ã¥<X��Ô¬`§ùoÐ���§%�dùoB

¨§s�·NoUS%ïrQ�Ø+N�§s2Jp:dñj"s�´2Ø$ñd§

@Ò´k¿Ø�ü1ñ�·"/^�f§éõÊú`µ/Êú§��ïÀÜ�§

�kñö\d§ïö�d"ù���Чñö�?Ld§�ïö¿Ø�d§%½X4

é�\d"ù«½|?d�ª§¢áª¤�ª�0

ù�§�f@ ñÀ�<`§Q,�ï·�À§Ò®«�'ì§NcØó�"

fâ·Ñ�d®²ép§Ø�P7`·ñ�§ý4�3·aúî#§¹�·ù

�À�Ø´��¢d§Ù¥�kJp"~ó`�е/ûU�d§Ò/�a0"�P

7sØ�Ø~d§��¦·\d§ù�î±ÆC§·�À¢3ØÐñ�s§��O

�û[j�

�f@��¸q`§P7s�ùoÐ���Ô¬%ñùoB¨�d§�`�3

�îuÆC§ùØ4·���</¦%�<§íC9<0��íº�¯o´�*d

ÃÐâú²B"X�Üfpvk�\®§�3·qNoU4<yáQ"è<qûþ

�ã�m§ñÀ�<Ò´Ø�\d"�¸�Ùí§UìñÀ<�mdG±�§�

<���ÀÔÒ�r"ñÀ�<ØZ§3@p�½�a�õ§Ø4@��¸

r"ù�§́ >rL5ü�P<N)"��§�¸G�±�<rl¤Ô¬§ùâ�´

Page 404: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 393

l�"/^ÚõÊúw�§é�/�¬ºØúVV:Þ"

è<÷X��UYr§�>þk��àÅ3���fþïÀܧGLÕf�<

XÀÜ�r"�Ì�LàÅ�Õfc[�w§®�®§aþc:4àŧ̀ P7

sOr"·�ùp��Ñ´æ^¥�¤Ú�Õf?1�´�§P7sG�·�´þ

�Õf§�©þ�'·��dõ"P7·[¥k{÷§Ø3�´þ�ãB¨§�r

õG�Õf<r"ù�§��@ àÅ`§ØÒ´Õf¤Úí§ÛI66O�"Q

,kõ{§�=U·25s�þïÀÜ�2��´��"̀ �q�r"�Ì:4¦§

`ùNo1��c�k� P7ì�·�)¿§̀ ´òõG�Õf�3·ù§�2

5ïÀÜ�2�"��8�Ø�¦�<K§�?éØ�¦8�§ùØ´4·j5

)Åo�8UP7sq�Xd§1��Ø5§æØ´4�3·�5)§C¼Cê8

�kc@ P7§=�kõÅ2�a�P7s§æØ´e�­q4·C¼Cê8�

P7s�â�3y�§�ÙF�ïÔ2�§ÛØXÒ38F(�"Û¹�m��§T

´õ�ù´�PØ�"V�qí4Ð�¬�§àÅ�Ð<ü«À �"=B

ù�§ñÀ�<E�� /̀a���õ0"ÃGàÅ®²r�"ù�§rL5�

�çõ§�Ìgóg��`µ/ù�����ùÒ´c­?<B¨§8­C¤���

§TXkù�A"0¦�¡`X§�¡^®¡Ð§òõ{�Õf¦êx�çõ"

�J%8<Øn)5ºs�6¥ùã£�§@�´�ö¿�½n�¥�½|�

´|µ"�¢Sþ§ù�´�f/�CEr0g�e<��~1�Ly"2018c6�§

·���)¹�/�ë\ÓÆଧ@´��Ü�ÉzÇ370%±þ�¢½"�U

��§·Õg5�¢>þ�àn½|§�� P<3´>þñ#m��)7�"·

¯d§vk?d§��4P<�·¡þü6§±BeÌ£®�£["��P<¡

�§̂ ���CÐ�§q8��r�?���¥§̀ µ/c�<§\éñ�§2�

\\:�0¦{�¥�/ñ�0́ �/�§́ /ª¢0�¿g§�V´P<ú�¦��

d�k:Jd ·vvd"·%¥�1§ùØ� 5́ºs�6¥�@«�´|µí§

�,ù3�û��J�/�éJ��§�3<�<mù/r0§ù/°±�<!î

�ÆC0��ÿ§ØÒAT´ù«�´|µí�

ùq�9���ØØ>�óƯK§Ò´<5�õ�´��º/<�Ч5�

õ0§�f@�<5�õ§@f@�<5��§ùÒI�/¨��õ0", §<5�

Ãõ��©§Ïõ�Ñ´<gC�y½§½ö`<´õ���ÓN§'�3uÚ�

<%�õ�´��§ù��¬uÐ¥���ng´���"

çIÝI��½|�´¥��«¿��ª§A^�§́ /<5�gh0ù�¡§

ä¢õ�¶Ù�y�§́ ÝI<¿�"ÝI<¿��-�§çI<�ÂÃÒ��"

�XJ½|ý�k/r0§X� 5̀ºs�6£±�@�§ÝI<�¿�|µ�¬Ñ

Page 405: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

394 çIæÛYFn

yíº�½Ø¬§Ñ±�ý�÷v§qÛ5ÝI<�sQ��ù��5§çI<�Â

ÃØÒ�Ø��æíº�,ج�ñÀ�±ñÑ`�Ô¬�J§ïÀ�±õGÕ

f�4§ùâ´<��ý¤¦§qÛE¦¦Q§�,ù«�ý��´|µl8U�

<�FÃ��§�U3/º0¥â¦"

@o§çIÝIÅ�¥§éë�<�<5´N�b��§3½|¢�¥§qk

´N�Cz�QºA�`§çIÝIÅ�b��§́ <5�/õ0§Ï�<õ§çI

<¬�oI[|Ã!�¬ú�|ÃÚ�¯<�Ü{�ç¬Jp²L�Ã!�y�

8�þ¶Ï�<õ§ÝI<¬�AçI§ë�¿�§�Ù�y�§´<5gh½´

/�0��¡§��Ch|�±/à�\k·¹0§ù�¥I©zAZc5���§

q�qØ�©¬Ü"3ù«�/e§·�A�XÛn)çIÝIÅ�§·Aù«½

|�´�ªQºØ%3u�¯<�?��¦ý"

1.?�¦ý´��"çIÝI¹Ä¥§çI<½çI�nÅ�?1çI!ÝI

<�AçIÚë�ÝI¿�!µI�¬µI!²�$1Å�JøÑÖ§±91�

iÒÅ��{iÒçIÝI¹Ä�1�§́ ±Ùó�<½¤��L§́ Ù<5

¥/�0�3Ly"@o§XÛ4��¯<�ó�<½¤/?�?�!�â8

ý0§́ �ï5�kS�çIÝI½|�Ä:§́ �ï�¬�S�Ä:"éçIÝI

¹Ä¥�<?1 ó§V[5�Æ6?�¥�l^8§=/�Ô!��!ª¿!�

%!?�!à[!£I!²Ue0¥§U÷vc8^§=/�Ô!��!¿ª!�%!

?�!à[0v±"

1¤�Ô"�Ô§=²F¯Ô§�¯Ô�n"�¦<{Ù¯!öÙÔ§=Ô¡n§

O��£§/ó��Æ��§3=Ô ¡Ùn�0"ù�¦µ�çI<�çI�nÅ

�²EçI�8A:ÚæI¦§²EçIÝI5KÚÜÓÁ�+n¶�ÝI<²

EçI�8A:Úg�¢å§²EÝI�AÚ¿�5K¶�µI�¬9Ù¤²

EçI�8�EâA:Ú�¦§²EµI5K¶�çIÝI�´²�$EÑÖÅ�

²EçI�8�´A:§²E²�õU9ÑÖNy¶�1�iÒÅ�²EçI�8

�´A:Ú{Æ5K§²EiÒ:"

2¤��"��§=²´�!Eõ�"�¦lí�¯Ô�n¥&²<�%��§

=ý�"�¦çIÝI¹Ä¥�ó�<½¤§3E²çI�8A:!E²Ù3

çIÝI¥��ÚÚ5KÄ:þ§²E´�§²Eé�§�¡Ù3çIÝI¹Ä¥§

AT��o§�oØU�"ù¢SþÒ´8U<�`�/�Å����0§Ø}Ý"

3¤¿ª"¿ª§=¿gª¢§ØÐ<§½ØgЧ/ªu¥§/u§��f7

&ÙÕ�0"ù�¦§�çI<�çI�nÅ�´ý�çI§ Ø´JbçI½r/

ª!rL|§Ø±ØÜn�^���½öü½d3ÝI<§Øéd3ÝI<¢1Ü

Page 406: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 395

À��½ö��ÝI<�m¿��§Ø�¦<ß³®¼�çI©��d3ÝI<�

¶¡!êþ½ö�UK�ú²¿��k'çIÝI�Ù¦�¹§½ö�³I.§Ø

�ÝI<GÏÝI§Ø�{�ÝI<ÒÝId�!ÝI�Y�¢�5SN?1!�§

�{(½¥I(J§�{�¥I<\¾¿Á1ÜÓ�¶�ÝI<´ý�ÝI§ Ø

´áJ�b¢�¥I§½´GÏÝI§Ø�çI<½µI�¬¤1ª*�¥I§

¥I��{�çI<\¾¿Á1ÜÓ�¶�µI�¬9Ù¤´ý�µI§Ø´

3r/ª!rL|½Ø�*!Øú�/µI§½´ÂÉÝI<½Ù|³'X<�ª

µ§ØUìçI©�5½�µIIOÚ�{µI½´he�ÝI<�*µI§é�

{A�Äû�ÝIØJÑÄû¿��¶�çIÝI�´²�$EÑÖÅ�U5½�

I§�çI<½�nÅ��çI!ÝI<�ÝIÚµI�¬�µIJø²��´

ÑÖ§Ø�{���´æN§Ø�{��½öü½d3ÝI<§�¦<ß³®¼�

çI©��d3ÝI<�¶¡!êþ!ÝI©�SN½öéÝI©��µ"Ú'�

±9Ù¦�UK�ú²¿��çIÝI&E§Ø�ÏçI<!ÝI<GÏÝI§½

ö�E!tU!�¤çIÝI&E§½ö±Ù¦�ªáJ�b�¶�1�iÒÅ�

�{éçIÝI¹Ä?1iÒ§�{�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�§ Ø´Þh

Í6!E^��½ ��ŧé�{1�Ø�{�?§½öØUì5½?nÝ�!Ø

�{úwéçIÝI�¯<�{1��1�?nû½�"

4¤�%"�%§́ ¦gC��!�!¿�.Kܧ�¤¢/�?Ù�ö§k�

Ù%¶��Ù%ö§kªÙ¿0§=3%��Nþú�ª²!ä ­§Ø�Ô�¤

Ä"ù´çI<½�nÅ�!ÝI<!µI�¬9Ù¤!çIÝI�´²�$

EÑÖÅ�½´1�iÒÅ�9Ù<�<���§Ï�%�âU��§âU,,

����<"

5¤?�"?�§=?��%§�Jõ l!ÆÆu©§¿��±r§=ØäJp

gC�¬�?�§Ï�<�éugC�O�<¬k O¶éugC���<¬k 

ë¶éugC¹��<¬k �¶éugCÓ��<¬k %¶éugC�À�<

¬k �"Ïd§é�k<UUO,<qw�@<�":§��,<qw�@<�

`:"?�§�´�?�§�´�?�§/�âo�0â´?��n�(J§́ çI

ÝI¹Ä¥§çI<½�nÅ�!ÝI<!µI�¬9Ù¤!çIÝI�´²

�$EÑÖÅ�½´1�iÒÅ�À<Ú^<�'�¤3"

6¤à["à[§+nÐgC�[ÌÚx<§Ï�+�ØÐ[<½x< U�+

�ÐO<�§g�vkÑyL"���<o�35º8Ø.:ò6¥��é/جà

[¬�(§�Ï�{kî°0`�Ч38Uw5§à[¢SþÒ´�¦�çIÝ

I¹Ä�'��+�ZÜ+Ð�>�<"~X§5¥I��VÆ?©^~6 1

Page 407: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

396 çIæÛYFn

l�Ê^!1l�8^!1l�Ô^§é+�ZÜ|^��½ö�Öþ�K�

�¦<*�|ç�<��ó!få9Ù�ó��áÚÙ¦A½'X<ÂÉé�ã

Ô§é�p|^��½ö�Öþ�K��é�9Ù�ó!få9Ù�ó��á!�

>ó�<ÚÙ¦A½'X<*�|Ãt���´§±9pN!%N�ó!få9

Ù�ó��á!�>ó�<ÚÙ¦A½'X<|^ZÜ�<��½ö�Öþ

�K�*�h|��V1�§�!���§��´w½öî­´w?©¶�!�­

�§����S�Ö½ö3w?©¶�!î­�§��mØ7?©�§́

à[§±�å+�ZÜ9Ù�><�1�"

2.�ÙÅV´1�"�lçIÝI5K§́ éçIÝI¹Äë�<§±9Jø

çIÝI�´²�$EÑÖ½´�{iÒçIÝI¹Ä�1��å"

1¤çI<"çI<´?1çI�{<½öÙ¦|�§A��{|�çIÝI¹

ħá¢çI<�ÌNI?§�)�{JÑçI�8!uÙ]�ý"úw½çIú

w§�{?�!uÈ]�ý"©�!çI©�§�{�Â]���©�!ÝI©�§

|�]�"�§|�mI§�{|ïµI�¬µI§�{?1ÜÓÇ�§Á1ÜÓ

ÂÖ�"��/§çI<I�÷vµ�´·��{<½öÙ¦|�¶�k�çI�

85�ÚE,§Ý�·A�Eâ!²L!ãÖÚ�8+n��¡;�Eâåþ§U

|�çI�8Á�§��5�ÚÁ�¥�ºx¶�k?�çI©�§JÑçI�

8¿�Ï�Úµ�IO§k|�çIÝI¹Ä�Uå¶�kl¯Óa�8çIæ

�²�¶�ÙGÚݺçIÝI{9k'5K"çI<Øä�þã^�¥�,��

¡Uå�§A��÷½\Î;�<"çI<AÄuª¢Å&��K§|�çIÝ

I¹Ä"

2¤çI�nÅ�"çI�nÅ�§́ á¢çI<ÌNI?§�ÏçI<¢yæ

(J�¥0Å�"çI<�çI�nÅ��'X§́ ��n<��n<�¬¯'

X"�d§çI<k�g1ÀJ�nÅ�§�÷Ù�nçI¯¨"ù�¥�/k�g

1ÀJ0§=çI<��¬¯ÌN§�÷�ÄgCk�û½§¿éçI(J«ú¬¯

I?"éA�§çI�nÅ�g�A�­ÀÙ;�Uåï�§ãåJpÙ�nÑÖ

��þÚ�ǧ�)µ��âI[y1{Æ{5Ú�5��¦§�½Ú�1�è�

SÜk'çI�nÑÖ�5�Úó�5§¶�\rçI�nÑÖl�<����

ï�§ïáÚ�õçI�n�Ö����NX¶�ïáÚ�õçI�nÑÖ�þ+

nNX§Jp¿±Y5U?çI©�?�Y²¶�±Y5U?çI�nÑÖ|¤�

�¸!�@ÑÖ���Y²�"çI�nÅ��nçI�8�Ø%§3u3çI<

�÷���Su�;�`³§Jø�nÑÖ§¢yçI<�æm�"

3¤ÝI<"ÝI<´�AçI!ë�ÝI¿��{<½öÙ¦|�§Ù�I´

Page 408: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 397

�{�AçI§=UçI<uÑ�çI©�?�¿J�ÝI©�§éçI©�5½

�¢�5�¦Ú^��Ñ�A§ë�ÝI¿�"ÝI<ÝIA÷vµ�äkÕá¾

áÜÓ�¬¯�|¶�äkÁ1ÜÓ�Uå§�)Ù;�!Eâ]�ÚUå§]7!

��ÚÙ¦Ô���G¹§+nU姲�!&�Ú�A�l�<�§�±�A

çI§ë�ÝI¿�¶�vk?u�I-Ê�!ÝI]����!ã���+!È(

½»�G�§vk�{ØUÝI½´ÃUåÁ���/"ÝI<�ÝIA�lª¢

Å&�Ä��KÚçIÝI{Æ{5�5½§UçI©���¦ÝI"

4¤µI�¬¤"µI�¬¤µI§́ UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ

�{éÝI©�§=ÝI¯¢?1�*!ú�/µ"Ú'�§�¤ÙµI(J§é

¤JÑ�µ"¿�«ú�<I?"µI�¬¤ë�µI§I÷vµ�´çI<

�Ç��L½´çI<3µI;[¥¥­��çI�';�+�;[¶�ÙGçI

�8µ"�9�;�+�ÚçIÝI{9�'5K¶�U@ý!ú�!ª¢!í

'/Á1µI�I¶��Nèx§U�?µIó��¶��l{½ÂÖ§�ÝI

<�3|³'X�§A�ÌÄ£;§Øhe�>ÝI<§ØÂÉÝI<½öÙ¦|

³'X<�ãÔ½öÙ¦Ð?§Øß³éÝI©��µ"Ú'�!¥IÿÀ<�í

��¹±9�µIk'�Ù¦�¹�"µI�¬¤µI�Ø%§3u�lµI

5K§UçI©�¥1²�µIIOÚ�{§u�g�;�`³§ª¢Å&/éÝ

I©�?1µ"Ú'�§�çI<J`¢yæ(JJøÜ��µ"Ú'��w§

í�Ü��¥IÿÀ<"

13!�?µ²��ï��´�S��æ

�?,´�«�½Ú¢�ú�ûü§¢ykSÚ£��åÅ�"�?�²L�

U§́ ��I[²L�uЧé�¬²L?1+n��U§Ì�Ly3µ�÷*N�

�U§�½Ú$^ã�[Â�üÚÀ1�ü§é��I¬²L$1?1m��!÷

*�N�¶�Jøú��¬ÚÑÖ§ÏL�?+n!�½���ü!Oy��!Ò�

5y��ªé��I¬²L¢1m���¶�½|i+�U§éè�Ú½|?1+

nÚiÒ§±(�½|$1�Ï!ú²¿�Úú²�´§�o½|ÌN�Ü{�Ã"

�?�U�½ §û½ÙéçIÝI¹Ä�1�iÒÚú�] �´�iÒ�+

n�I§�´�{�ï5�kS��´²�§�´�o²��ú²¿���´"�

�ï5�kS�çIÝI²��� ¶�§́ »�½|�´�S§AO´�ç�

³å0\çIÝI¹Ä§�IGI!Ó6�B!d�Ó�!!��ä�§4�/»�

½|�´�S"

Page 409: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

398 çIæÛYFn

[ç³åö��´«] 2019c§,½úSÅ'3�?µI;[ɪY�L§¥§

�¤��10õ<|¤�ç³å��ìº"ìºSÜ©ó²(§kKI�l�8§

|�GÏÝI�§k�çI�8Ì+�Ï1ª�§k�{��µI;[&E�§k

�µI;[éä§1ª�"ù�§Tìº3ó§çI¥|^GÏÝI!��¥Id

�!��µI;[&E§±9�h�Ã{§¼�¥I]�§2=Ã�ñ¥I�8§è

��¥I§�<30%�m�|d|G�Tìº"TìºÏL��ùúi�I§é

XU¥I!¥Id�´õ�§A�kû½5"

úSÅ'²L"Õ�²§Tìº�3±e��¯¢µ�|��I"Tìºg1

5þõ[úië�ÝI§Âï�S�1�úi�ºÝI§?��I¤§Nì�

ù�Iúiê���¤^¶�^ç³åÃã%½Ù¦úi�ïÝI§±¢yÙÝ

��úi¥I§�{¼�ÂÃ"é@Ø��Ü�ÝI<§heéü Ì+½Ù�

X�á?1z��h§½¦ÙÒ�¶�^ç³åÃã�½!. µI;[¥Ì+J

øµI;[&E"âT��ìº��§�¢�µI;[&E§Tìº/�Þ�x0

é�µI;[¥Ì+�>Õ�§�>`²5¿�§¿3�Sþ{�Xü�Àܧ�

´10���y7§2Ò´�Üì¡"ì¡þ§́ ù Ì+<4�å�Õ3r���

�§�Ù/w«XÙ´3=�r�ÒÖ"�Þ�x�¿gé²(§�·µI;[

&E§<r10��a"�اÒ<\å���´"µI;[¥Ì+Ø�®§òÄ��

µI;[&ElXÚ¥NѧÂɪµ§\\T��캧k�ɪCz��¶

�ÂïµI;["â��ìº��§��sþ1���2��§µI;[¥�õêÑ

�¿�ܧµI���¬/ ��ú4��ú0§±¦Ý��úi�í��1�¥I

ÿÀ<¶�TìºÝ��úi�¤çI�8UåØv�§3½|þ�ñ"

ù´��4<�¯�Yf�çIÝI���«¬¯�´1�§XJÄ���´

�¸Ú�´�S�Ø��æ§qÛ!ÙUr?²Lï��uÐQ"·3S%p��

�¯�¥�@ Ì+�¯§Ï�·�ØU{ü/`¦�{§̀ ¦vk�K"Á�§¦

�´��<"3��µI;[&E�gC�å�)·É�%���ÿ§qNo�U

4¦�léµI;[&E���5½§�gCå��)·uØ�Qº��µI;[

¥�Ì+§¦�,���³µI;[&E�{§�A���ɪ�(Û�½´O�

�/§�qUNo�º4¦Ú[<�ç³å|ïíº5�f6¥�/)§·¤��¶

§½·¤��"�öØ��o§�) �Âö�0´�f�J¦§�·�No�

U^�f�1�OK��¦��ÊÏ<Q§AO´3)�k�ÀJþ§ùØÎÜ<

5"�d��§̄ �N�Ñ�§T´�?3�¬+n�Uþ§½´�oçIÝI�

´�Sþ�"�"�ó�§çIÝI�´Äu5�kS��¬ �ï"�mù��

¬Ä:§çIÝIØ�U5�kS"

Page 410: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 399

1.çIÝI�¬Ä:" çIÝI´Äu5�kS�½|²L �ï��«Î

Üg,/`���0�¿�Å�§Ä:´�¬G�5�kS"

1)kS�¬"���¬´kS�§Ì�Ly3n��¡µ��¬(��é­½"

�¬(���é­½§�¦¤k�¬¤�B\�½�¬'XNX§�uÙ(½�

�¬/ "¤9�«�¬/ m�'X��¬¤²("�¬�SLy�ØÓ��

¬8ì!+NÚ�<�m��?½^S¶��¬5��±�1"�¬5�´�ï�

¬�S�Ä:§�¬5�½1�OKINyÙ¤�L!�o��¬�S§�Å��

où5�!5K§=´�¬+NÚ�<�ÅÚ�o�¬�S"�«�¬'XNX

�¤��«�¬�S¿U�±e�§L�l�¬5�½1�OK§±�å+NÚ�

<1�¶�Àâ½ÃS��"�¬�S´�«��Ï�§3�¬+n¥u�X­�

��^"���¬�Àâ½ÃSI���3�½��S§±�o�¬�S§? �

cuÐ Ø´{¤þ��ò"

2¤�?+n"�?§��I[�+nÅ�§�{éI[�£!²LÚ�¬ú�

¯Ö?1+n§«úX�£!²L!©zÚ�¬��¬£n�U"ù�¥§�£�

U§q¡�Ú£�U§́ ��?��oI[Ú£�?�|çé�oI[S�§é

S�±�¬�S§Ny3:��¯�¥�U§�oI[ÕáÚÌ���!�¥I�S

�!��5�Ѷ���U§�­.Ù¦�I�~��£!²L 5§ïá9�

lÐ'X¶�£S�U§�±�¬�S!Ø�IÚ�³�¬S��¹Ä!�æ<

¬��£�|Ú)·ã�S�!�o�{Ú{Æ�î¶�¬Ì�£ï�§í?I[

����õÚ¬Ì�£�uÐ"5¿§�£�U´�?���Ä��U"

3¤½|�¸"½|�¸§́ ½|ÌN3½|²L¹Ä¥¤�9�N�Å�5Ï

�Ú^�"�o�¬�S§�y½|�´kS?1§́ �?²L�U�äNNy"ù

�¥�Ø%§3u�(?n�?Ú½|�'X§=(½=¯�d�?+§=q

´d½|g,N!"½|²L¥k��Ä��K§́ áu�?��?+§áu½|

�½|+"�?�Ã��!+�Lõ§X] ©�!û¬d��(½�Ñ�+§Ò´

�«+�²L �½|²L"�d§��¡I�u�½|3] ��¥�û½5�

^§,��¡�I�Ð/u��?�U"éd§5¥u<¬�ÚI1�N�{6£±

e{¡51�N�{6¤1��^5½8a§=µ����9I[S�!ú�S�!

²L÷*N�!)��¸�o±9��'X<�èx!)·ã�S��A½¹Ä§

I�Uì{½^��±1O�¯�¶�k�g,] mu|^!ú�] ��±9

��'Xú�|Ã�A½1��½|O\�§I�D�A½�|�¯�¶�Jøú

¯ÑÖ¿���'Xú�|Ã���!1�§I�(½ä�AÏ&�!AÏ^�½

öAÏEU�]�!]��¯�¶���'Xú�S�!<�èx!)·ã�S�

Page 411: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

400 çIæÛYFn

�­���!��!�¬!Ô¬§I�UìEâIO!Eâ5�§ÏLu�!uÿ!

u¼��ª?1"½�¯�¶�è�½öÙ¦|���á�§I�(½ÌN]��

¯�¶�{Æ!1�{55½�±�½1�N��Ù¦¯�§�±�{�½1�N

�"=B´þã8a¯��±��1�N�§T{1�n^?�Ú5½§ÏLe�

o«�ªU�±5��§=µ�ú¬!{<½öÙ¦|�UgÌû½�¶�½

|¿�Å�Uk�N!�¶�1�|�½ö¥0Å�UgÆ+n�¶�1�Å

'æ^¯�iÒ�Ù¦1�+n�ªU)û�§�±Ø�1�N�§±~��?

é½|Zý§��(?n�?Ú½|�'XC½Ä:"

éA�§?�Ú�z1�"1�ÝU�§~��*¯Ö+n§r@UÏL

½|N!!1�gÆ)û�¯���½|½1�gÆ)û§`z½|�Eû�¸§

�z{���!�+(Ü!̀ zÑÖU�§���Ý/~��?é½|] ���

��§���Ý/~��?é½|¹Ä���Zý§\rÚ5�¯¥Ú¯�i+§

XåJ,�ÖÑÖUåÚY²§�¢ü$�Ý5�´¤�§���Ý/-u½|¹

åÚ�¬MEå§OruÐÄå§́ u��?²L�U§�(?n�?Ú½|'X

�Ny§Ï���k���?§́ ��U£n¿�õu£n½|��?"

2.çIÝI�´²��S" �?éçIÝI²�+n�Ø%3u�ï{£�

?§�{1�§��/{kÇ�7L�§{ÃÇ�Ø��0"@o§çIÝI{Ç�

�?éçIÝI¹Ä=1��UQº©ÛXe:

1¤çI�8"1"5çIÝI{61Ê^5½§çI�8UìI[k'5½I

�Á1�8"1ÃY�§A�kÁ1"1ÃY§��1O"ù�^´çI�8éÄ

çIÝI¹Ä�cJ"~X§é�?Ý]�8§IÖ��Ù�5�?Ý]^~61�

�^5½§Ý]Ì+Ü�½öÙ¦k'Ü�A��âI¬²LÚ�¬uÐ5y!�

'+�;�5y!���ü�§le��¡é�?Ý]�8?1"�§�Ñ´Ä1

O�û½µ��8ïÆÖJÑ��8ï��7�5¶��15ïÄ�w©Û��8

�Eâ²L�15!�¬�ñ9�8]7�Ì�ï�^��á¢�¹¶�ÐÚ�

O9ÙJÑ�Ý]V�´ÄÎÜ�15ïÄ�w1E±9I[k'IOÚ5��

�¦¶��ì{Æ!1�{5ÚI[k'5½A�"��Ù¦¯�"aq/§éè

�Ý]�8§IÖ��Ù�5è�Ý]�8ØOÚ�Y+n^~61o^5½§é

'XI[S�!�9�I­�)�åÙÛ!ÔÑ5] muÚ­�ú�|Ã��8§

¢1ØO+n§Ù¦�8¢1�Y+n"éIÖ��Ù�5�?ØO�Ý]�88

¹6S��8¢1ØO§�¦è�UìI[k'�¦?��8���w§��8Ø

OÜ�§�n�8ØOÃY¶T^~1o�o^¢1�Y+n��8§�8ü 3

móï�c�A��â�'{Æ{55½�nÙ¦�'ÃY�"

Page 412: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 401

2¤��çI"1"5çIÝI{61��^5½§IÖ�uÐOyÜ�(½�

I[­:�8Ú�!g£«!�`½<¬�?(½�/�­:�8Ø·¨úmçI

�§²IÖ�uÐOyÜ�½ö�!g£«!�`½<¬�?1O§�±?1��

çI§=I[­:�8½´�?<¬�?(½�/�­:�8A�úmçI§�I

[­:�8²I[uÐOyÜ�1O§½´�?<¬�?(½�/�­:�8²�

?<¬�?1O§�±æ^��çI�ª"

3¤1�iÒ�{"1�iÒ´1�Ü��o½|�S§�{?1��«é½

|�´�ÌÄ1�"5çIÝI{61Ô^5½§çIÝI¹Ä9Ù�¯<A��

É�{¢��iÒ"T^Ó�²(1�iÒ�U§=k'1�iÒÜ��{éçI

ÝI¹Ä¢�iÒ§�{�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�"Ó�§Ù18��^5

½§5çIÝI{61ÊÙ5½�1�?v§Ø{Æ^±¥®é¢�1�?v�Å'

�Ñ5½�§dIÖ�5½�k'1�iÒÜ�û½"k'1�iÒÜ��â�

^éçIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�?1?v§=çIÝI¹Ä��5çIÝI{61

l^-1Ê^!1��^-1��^§1���^-1��o^§1��8^-1��l

^§1n�^-1n�o^§1n�8^-1o�l^�{Æ5½�1�§�â5çI

ÝI{61o�Ê^-18�^§±95çIÝI{¢�^~618�n^-1Ô�l

^?1?v§mä1�?nû½Ö"

4¤g1çI�Y+n"5çIÝI{61��^5½§�{7L?1çI��

8§çI<g1�nçI¯¨�§A��k'1�iÒÜ��Y"I[uÐU��

�Ü�éÜ�Ù�5ó§ï��8g1çIÁ1�{61o^5½§çI<g1�

nçI¯¨§A�äk?�çI©�Ú|�µI�Uå"Øä��§çI<ØUg

1?1çI§ I��÷�nÅ�çI"

5¤çIÝIÖ¡�w"5çIÝI{61o�Ô^5½§�{7L?1çI�

�8§çI<A�g(½¥I<�Få�ÊFS§�k'1�iÒÜ�J�çIÝ

I�¹�Ö¡�w§�É�YiÒ"

3.çIÝI¥��?" �?3çIÝI�´¥��^§3u�oçIÝI�

´²���S§3u�l{kÇ�7L�§{ÃÇ�Ø����K"5çIÝI{6

3�Ý�Oþæ�çI<!ÝI<�{�´§µI�¬UçI©�¥5½�I

OÚ�{éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�§k'1�Ü�éçI<!ÝI<��´Úµ

I1�?1iÒ§�{�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�§ù´�?3çIÝI�´

²�þA�u���U"�d§�?éçIÝI�´²��+n§�´��{kÇ

�7L�§ÌÄ¢�Ù{½�U¶�´��{ÃÇ�Ø��§ØU��51�N�

{6§òg*�Ù1�iÒ��§�{Zý!�ÃçIÝI¹Ä"~X§��{�Ù

Page 413: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

402 çIæÛYFn

Ü�!/��çIÝI5K½�{¿r�çI<!ÝI<ÚµI�¬¦^§Xr

��¦æ^Ù�½�µIIO½�{§r��¦çI<�ÅÄ�(½¥IÿÀ<½

¥I<§B�çI<��Lë\µI½µ"�¶��{Zý!�ÃçIÝI¹Ä§X

|�ÝI�¶½´��{Æ5½"�!"1çI©�§��çI�8µI!µ"�¶

�ØÁ1{½�I§éçI<!ÝI<½´µI�¬¤¥���{1�§�

?g6½´À Ø�§�X/¬ØÞ(ØÄ0�áÒ§Ø�{�?çIÝI¹Ä¥

��{1�¶�X/M#0çIÝIEâ�áÒ§/>fçIÝI�´XÚ§�{�

�ÝI�¶�!§�¦ÝI<�B�½ê���¶¤§�{ñã�"

çIÝI+�´�?0\�*²L¹Ä��\!̄ K�õ���+�§́ �z

²LN�U�?\�Y«§�I��zU����;.�L"ù�¥§�?��½

|5K��¾öÚ½|�S��oö§�<¬ÑÖ´�?��§/�¬%ö�Ue0§

�I�?|¤<g��/�Ô!��!¿ª!�%!?�!à[0§=��?�§Ï

��kù�§âU¢y�<¬ÑÖ�m�"

14!5�µçIÝI²��´��å

g,)��5Æ´·ö)�!fSr "<�Ì*UÄ5§û½<a3�E

ó䧷Ag,!MEd��Ó�§�±g·�å§�g,�NuÐ"<a�¬ù«

g·�å¡��¬1�5�§´�¬+N½�<3�¬¹Ä¥�Ì�5KÚOK§

´<�ÊH�É�äk���åå�1�IO§�)<a�¬uÐ¥/¤�©z!

S�!��!�ü!VÆÚ{Æ��å"<��全�¬§±���I\"�o

´��º��=«�§́ <�ÆS�J¦�;.«�"çIÝI¥�J`§�,´

²Lþ�J`§E3�½¿Âþ�k����^§́ ±¥I���§íÄ�¬Eâ

?Ú§Ú+���uÐ"çIÝI�ù«�¬Ú+�^§́ 3�¬1�5��åe§

±ÝI¿�?1²LJ`��þ"3ù�:þ§çIÝIØÓu�¬þ�µÀµ

`§�ö~k�½�Û�5½´|æ,§'Xe¡ùK�¯¥¤ùã��/"

[��Ͷ�<��)] ,/��{?½§Ð ½�{U½Ê±c§½©é�|

��|�c'm§�6ù��¯"�w��þ?©é§ØAFk£E§1«¡¹

Ä�±t§þ?©é|±§�Ñ��§©é´�Yâ�§vka§¹Ä²¤d½©é

gÊ"

kþ?©é|±§½©é�Ó�&%÷÷�§3½�[Ͷ��þr��

8�cë\'m�2w"ØLá���õF§½©éÒÂ��Zõ°A��¬"

©éÓ�am§��¹Ä���¬�A !¤"�P!©a§|�;["�§Ø½

Page 414: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 403

W��|�¬Ì?7ú´� Í¶�<§"Xþþ��ÀA�v�§�òÉ��Ч

Ï�þ?©évk|±�©a§¹Ä´²¤gÊ"

ù�U§7úw��°A��¬§4Ù¦Ó��eÃ¥�ó�§̀ µ/ù°�¬

ék¿g§�[f·g�g"0�y�¶i�/��0"�f7úg�µ/��§��

Ñ5§��´gCÑ5�¶§�ØÑ5§X�vk�{"0�[ýX�ùfXe©§

��Uvk(§k<¯µ/vº07ú`µ/v�0@<`µ/ù=´�yÜ�X�

�º0<L@°A��¬�w§Øó(§�ö´�/� k¶�/�úiP�§�

a©R§½pkÐA�û¬�¢�´¦mu�§â`�þL�Ænc?§U�¤ù

�®²éØ�"ù�§k<"Xù�A��¬âuÛ�§̀ µ/7Ì?§4�öa

©R7Ϥ^§4��5��6ù��¬µ�ø�"ù�§|�ùg¹Ä�¤^Ø

Òkí�0ÐÌ¿§7ú�X"

`ZÒZ§U�¬þ��ö>{§7ú�a©R��>{µ/ao§öUöU�

sA���¬5��6¼ø�0é��>{�§�ý´�öa©R"k�´§<"�

o��o"a©Rr�[p¡§þ�Ænc�§[p¢3øØå¦UYþƧ�

У[�Ú§�Ó��åþìv�§�XI1«/�)"����<?¢�ó§�

)¿§�Ú�Ú/k:ÈO�§?\�/�+�§Ø��efÒ/o~��0§

����¢�/mu§a´���õ§�%p��Ja´�5�r§k�´/¡�

Ò�ea0"¦���{ø���þLnc�Æ�ÒK§�3gCÞþ@þ��

©z<�1�§W���%pþ�ÒK"

��7ú�5�>{§a©Rp,4§̀ µ/·�U�©Æ§��Ñ�Ò´s

�ù�<�ù�§¥Ì·3©z�ËA�|�¬�¤k<§ÑL�%�0

ùU¥Ì§a©R3©z�ËA��|�¬¤k<§mü´d�§�[�Õ

�p,"¦X˧§a©R¯7úµ/Ì?§·�@Ä5��6�.¼��oøBº0

7ú`µ/ao§s�%�s�@Ä5��6¼ø´|�¬��Ó¿�§�ù�¹Ä

�ùtؤ�0a©R�fµ/��oº07úù�÷.µ/¢{�s`j§ao�ù

g�¹Ävka§þ?©év7Ï�©a"½©és´���§´��Yâ�§v

k�a�±�"0a©R�f§:µ/@No1§ùoÐ���úùħNoUØ

�e�Qºù�§s����§w�ùg¹Ä��I�õ�a"07ú�|�¬Ù¦

A�<rµ"!øG<M!|/u�!\D�¤^§̄ �/-�-§̀ µ/��¬

aÒ�Øõ"0a©R�f§�§<åË���Õe�§̀ µ/·±�I�õ�

aQ§â��¬a"ù�§·7Ïs�ü�¬a�0

¹Ä²¤kXá§�[]X�%ªu�±�e"£��ú¿§|�¬m©

;Ü�µ"ó�"�35��6ù��¬ATµ�oøþ§k�Æ"Ø��Y²§

Page 415: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

404 çIæÛYFn

ù��¬µ�oø�ØÜ·§�ص�ØÜ·§.¾<[7Ïa!k<3µ"¬þ

�ÿïÆ/�Ø����yø�5��6ùÄ�¬j0§�êþÒk<�éµ/4

�â���§<[�eÒ�ü�§µ�yøØÜ·j§��Aµ�n�ø�0��§

|�¬��Ó¿§�5��6µ�n�ø"

7ú>{Ï�a©Rµ/ao§s�5��6@Ä�y¼�n�ø��¯s7

Ï|�¬�ü�¬a�o�ÿ�±5�Bº0�f>{@>�a©Rþ-Xµ/n�

ø§éЧéÐ�·ùAUÃÞk:;§LAUs�25�ÐØÐ"̂ B¯�駼

��ø��ö7Ïõ�aQº0̀ �§>{@ÞÒvk(Ñ"7ú<X>{§�

Uv£L 5§²{X§�µn�ø§é�ØZB�

7ú4¤k<�eÃp�ó�§;�?Ø5��6ù��¬�¼ø¯K"¦

`µ/vka§ùg¹ÄøGÑ<ØÑ5§�OJ\D��[uL¿�§w5��6

ù��¬�.Tµ��oøº0|�¬�Ó��w§�(§vaÒ�عħÛ!

�J©z§Û!���{U½�u´§¤k<Ñ�eµ"IO§�e%¥�U

²§��Ó¿�5��6µ��ø"

7ú2�>{�a©R§̀ µ/ao§|�¬q@ý/?Ø�e§��Ó¿Ç

�5��6ù��¬��ø"0ù�§>{@Þ�a©Ròþ�ms§�í/í`

`µ/µ��ø§ØÐjºØLQ,´|�¬��í��§·�´�¿+É�"�ø

¹Ä�t��­�:§�k>�!>À�Pö�|§aØ·��±2O\"ù�§

seÌÒ�±�<5·ùp§k<rn�7ϤO��ø¹Ä"0

7úeÌ�<rn�¬a7Ϥ+£5§SüX�«¤^m�§­�A ©

ƵØ"�ø@U§A ©ÆµØ^gþ�uó§é5��6ù��¬uLµ

ص/5��6ùÄ�y§ÐÖ²�§[Ö��"�Ö�k�§�Ö�kón�0�

ø¤ª���§d½>À�� Í¶�ÂṈ̃§^ßþ�^5(ÑK{5��6

ùÄ�y§>�!>À��ÓÚ?1Âx"áá�AU�m§�ø�¬¤�þ

�9��bf§èAþ��l�õ�"<���§Ð ½Ñ� Í¶�<a©R"

�5§Ð ½Þ��«©z¹Ä§ÑÌÄ��a©R3¬þ�üù§ù5��6ùÄ

�y�M�L§§z�-Ä�§a©R�¬�ØgB/K{5��6ùÄ�y"u

´§� Í¶��<Ò3Ð ½�)"

ùK�¯%¹X�o�nºk<`§|�¬Øù����§�5��6ù��¬

µ���ø§íÑ5� Ø´�<�/Ͷ�<0§AÉ�gIºý´ù�íºXJ

´§<­mqkõ�ù��~f§qkõ�ù��µI(J3u)�·�3é|�

¬1�µd�§́ ĦK�o§́ Ä l<5�OKº�<�)�^�ÿØä

��§!1�OK´�!§Øäky¢¿Â"éA�§�¬1�5��åØ�Ak

Page 416: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 405

��å�^"5¥T6m�k/U·�¢5§Ç5�¢�§?��¢�0�Øé§)

· uU/§[«U/��"3)��Ø�o��§�f`µ/�¬;<§Ã¦)±

³;§kà�±¤;"0�f`µ/)§½·¤��¶Â§½·¤��"�öØ�o�§

�)�Âö�"0@o§��Ͷ�<��)�¯¥§|�¬´Ä���f!�f

'u)�;�*gQº�,vk�Ï��a©R�5��6µ���ø���´�

yµ"5K§́ |�¬gC½�iZ5K ®§¿�´U/�Â"ÄK§|�¬<

�ù@Ò�a¢!aུ¯S��gà§Ð ½q=p�¬kͶ�<�)

Qºaq/§çIÝI¹Ä¥§k�µI�¬¤��o lJ`OK§��u

,�¿��`�ÝIQºÏ�çI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{¿�U/�§Û

¹ÙJ`IOÚ�{�µI�¬¤�/n*0��UØÓ½´µIIOÚ�{

��Ò´3r/ª!rL|Q�ù�§�Òl<5þ)º��oçI<!çI�

nÅ�!ÝI<¥�ó�<!µI�¬¤ÚçIÝI�´²�$EÑÖ!i

Ò<���çIÝI�´�1�OK§%%Sn�!ä¢��ϧÏ�3�

<w5§çIÝI´�|iZ �U/5K§ÃÀçIÝI�1�5�"

Uêdâ�I¦�gnا<aI¦Äk´÷v)n§X Ô!Y�)nI¦¶

Ùg´÷v<�S�!)¹­½!�;Û£!;¾�S�I¦§1n´÷v��§X

lÇ!O����I¦¶1o´÷v�­§X¤Ò½g·d���<aú!¦<@

���­�¶��´÷vg·d�"<aØÓ�g�I¦÷v§�l��¬1�5

�´Ø���"��5`§�XI¦�gOp§Ù�l��¬1�5�¯��Ò�

õ"@o§çIÝI¥k=1�5�§Ù�åk�gSq´XÛü��QºçIÝ

I���«�*²L¹Ä§I�É©z!S�!��!�ü!VÆÚ{Æ��å"5

¿§{Æ´�¬1�5�������?§=3Ù¦5�é1���å���§æ

^I[r�åé1���å"

1.©z"©z§�<©�z§́ <a{¤uÐ¥ME�Ô�ãLÚ° ãL�

oÚ§́ óÆg���«Ly/ª§�)m�!&�!S�!��!©Æ!²â!�

Æ!�Ý�"{Æ��^3uæ^I[�år��å<��¬1�§ ©zK�´

�zÚ�姦<lS%Ø�{!Ø�{§�l�¬1�5�§¢y/£IS�0�

8�§~X§Pf5��²61��Ù/ÊÚ-<8_§ÊÑ-<�:§Ê�-<�

W§¶­V�-<%u´§J��À-<1�¶´±�<§�JØ�8§��*�

d0�§́ 3é<a1��z§��äá<a�¬�Ó�d�*§? N�Ú�å

<��¬1�"

2.S�"S�§q¡�º�S.§́ �½����¬)¹�ÓN3�Ï�Ó)

¹¥Åì/¤�!���ÓN¤�gú¿£�Ó�Å qؤ©�S.�º�"

Page 417: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

406 çIæÛYFn

<�1�ÉS��K���"��/§��S�~�À�Éà1�§=ØÜS�1

�"~X§̄ ��</��où��0§�~��£� /́O<Ñù��§·Øù�§

ؤÉaí0"~ó`§/\���0§ÙLy��´é��/«!��¬x�k�

�¬1�5K�ÑlÚ�­"@o§½|�´¥�/d5K0´Ä´S�Qº�Y

´Ä½��Ï�d5K�¤±/d0§�Ï3uÙ´3�o�ê<|à he@�

�1��å"~X§�Ài«êØAl��|G�ꤥ§U�½'~���i

½´iÅ�1�§�¡/£�0§çIÝI�´²�¥�GI!�I�§Ñáud5

K§áu���¬1�5��Ø��¿�1�"��d5K�¤±�3§�UkÙ

�3�Ün§�Ù�³�§́ �õê<|ÃÚ�¬ú�|ç7LÏLI[�Ù{

Æ�±�ÂÚB�"

3.��"��§́ <�éõ��!J��·Y!�Â���Â�*g!�K±

9dd/¤��«äk�¬ÊH�åå�1�OKÚ5�"ùp§/�0�ýn§=

�»�¯�Ô�{K§/�0´/�0�1N§́ <ÏLa�¤?1�^Ag,!�

¬Ú<aI��1�"<a�d�*¥§{ÆÚ��Pk�Ó�Ä:"��¡§{

Æu��^�cJ´Ù���¬����$�ݧ½ö`§{Æ�SI����

d��S�Ä:¶,��¡§�¬��Ø%d�´{Ær�¢��§={Æ�o�

$�Ý���d�"��/§��þB�½N�1�§{Æ�B�½N�§~X§á

J�b¢�¥I1���ª&�<���OK§çIÝI{éd�ÑB�55½"

�é�AÏ1�§��þØN�§�{Æþ½NN�"~X§3ú��þ�P<

4�½´Éå�3/þ�P<¶�k�1�§��N� {ÆB�§~X§h[

ÅÄ�Ókú����"

4.�ü"�ü§�I[��Å'!�|�ÚÙ¦�¬�£8ì�¢yÙ¤

�L��?!��|Ã�¿� �Ñ��½�ÏS¯Ì8I!1Ä�K!ó�?Ö

Ú�ª§±9æ��Ú½Ú���"�ü�{Æ�'X´Fy�§­�ü�{ÆØ

ÎÜ/�{£I0�m�§Ó�/§­{Æ��üKØÎÜk¥IAÚ��¬ÌÂ

½|²Ly¢§�Fy?nüö�m�'X"

5.VÆ"VƧ́ 3�½�¬^�e/¤�!,��¬|�¤7L�Å�Ù

§!̂ ~!ú��oÚ§́ �¦T�¬|�¤38N)¹¥�Å!�1ÚÁ1�

�«�¬1�OK§Ù¹Â´{Ý!5Ý!5K"VÆ�{ÆkX���Ó��ó

Ü6(�§Ñd1��ªÚ1��J|¤"VÆ�{Æ�«O§Ì�Ly3VÆ�

Ø%3gƧ=g��ŧ {ÆrNÜ�å"Ó�§VÆ´d�¬|�3�l

{Æ5½�Ä:þ�½�§�3�¬|�SÜäk�åå¶{Æ´dI[�åÅ�

�½§é�Nú¬!{<½öÙ¦|�k�åå"

Page 418: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 407

6.{Æ"{Ƨ́ ²I[�åÅ�"ÆÏL¿dI[�Ù¢��§̂ ±5½�

¯<�|ÚÂÖ�äkÊH�åå��¬5�§ù�¥§/{0́ ����ݧ/Æ0

K´�äN�1�OK"çIÝI{Ƨ�I[y1çIÝI{Æ5�/¤��N

z�N§Ù�¤�µ��{¶�5¬{;6¶��I<¬�L�¬9Ù~Ö�¬�

Ù�5çIÝI{6!5�?æ{69�'{ƧX¬¯�z{!ïÓ{�¶�I

Ö��Ù�5çIÝI{¢�^~6!5�?æ{¢�^~69�'1�{5§X

5ï�ó§�þ+n^~6!5ï�ó§S�)�+n^~6!5ó�)�N�y+n

^~6�¶��!g£«!�`½!�!g£«�?¤3½!²LA«¤3/�½Ú

IÖ�1O���½�<¬�L�¬9Ù~�¬�½¿�Ù�çIÝI/�{5¶

�IÖ�Ü��Ù�çIÝIÜ�5Ù¶��!g£«!�`½Ú��½<¬�?

�Ù�k'çIÝI�5Ù½�{¶��?�?9ÙÜ�½Ù�ÑÅ'�{�½�

kÊH�åå�çIÝI�{½5�5©��"þãØÓ{Æ3�åþ��?5½

�?Ò��{Æ u?Ò��þ §X�¥�{Æ u�Ú�¥{Æ�þ {§Ó

�§¡�Ú�¥�{Æ���e {"

{Æ´dI[r�å�y¢��"@o§��o5çIÝI{6¥�B�¯�§

~X§GÏÝI!áJ�b¢�¥I!1ªÉª�§3çIÝI�´¥�ku)Qº

ù��¡`²{Æ�½äk�½�¢�5§I�(Ü�¬uÐé{Æ?1/á!U!

¢!º0ó�¶,��¡§̀ ²{Æ�¢�Ø´�á�§I�Ù¦�¬1�5�§X

��!VÆ��Ó�åú¬½{<âU�)�^"�d§5�çIÝI¹Ä§Øü3

u�õ�åçIÝI�´²�þ�´1��{Ƨ�3uJp�¯<���?�§

Ï���´�ï5�kS�çIÝI�´²�Ä:§́ �¬Ä:"

15!Y~µ±�¶Yé�ï5�kS½|��g

�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|§́ ��?­��!E,�XÚó§§Q�9�

çIÝI½|�Ýï�§��9½|ÌN!çI�nÅ�!µI�¬!²�$E

ÑÖÅ�!iÒÅ��ë�<��N��JpÚ��?�"5�kS�çIÝI

½|A�§́ �«�?÷*N�!1�5�Ú�Ú½|ÌN�{²E§�lçIÝ

I½|1�5��$1Å�"�d§I?�Ú(Ü¥I�<©A:§�\ïÄçI

æ5ÆÚçIÝI½|�´A:§�õçIÝI½|5K§�¡�zçIÝIN

�ÚÅ��U�§±¦çIÝIÅ�3²Lï�¥u�ÙAk��^"ù�¥§�

´çIÝI�´²���ï§�)²�þ�'�´5K"�j±�Ìm�ß²!]

��!p�B¬!Å{ª&�ÑÖ�K§�/¯<k�0½���´EâæN¶�

Page 419: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

408 çIæÛYFn

´1�iÒ�/{kÇ�7L�!{ÃÇ�Ø��0§�{Á�§�?çIÝI¹Ä

¥��{1�§�o½|�´�S¶n´½|ÌN9ë�<�ÙÅVÚgƧª&

�´"ôܱ�¶Y�³Ñ5�§Øü´çIÝI¹Ä¥�GÏÝI½´,��Ú

�{�5¯K§�´çIÝI½|ï�¯K§I�l5�kS�çIÝI½|ï�

�ݧ?1�\©Û"

[Y�£�] â�1§ôÜ�±�½V�!iÛu2010c�?21åGÏÝI

¶Y§�Y7��2·�!ë�GÏÝI�è�100{["�7XçIÝI½|§/`

öØ�§�öØ�0§çIÝI¥�%�Ø�qÞ§GÏÝIy��?��"Ù¥§

�ú¢���(��{Zý§́ ��çIÝI1�Û­�Ì��Ï��"

çI<!ÝI<ª&"�§�he�´!�¥IØJÃã§�µI;[Ô��K§

Ö�V�ö��óä"

±�½V�!iÛuy§�Y�8¥§�®/¤1�(!çIÝI1�

iÒ!çI<!¥0Å�ÚÝI<m�­½�|Ã�ÓN§|�GÏÝI§¥Iö

=�=?7%§�Y(l¥��3%�Ð?¤"

â±�½V�!iÛ�¢§ÝI<GÏÝI�cJ§́ ®�çI<!çI�

nÅ�!+nÅ��ÏЧ4�ÝI<�Øþ¶§�o´�¶�/�éØ�<§é

��é�{r\íK"(ò\çIÝI¹ÄÌ�k3«a.µ�´1�+nÜ

��ÝI<S�(öpçIÝI1�"~X½,«ï�ÛçI�KI<o,�Ý

I<�,�(§öpçIÝI¿Âɦ<r7¶�´(ö�çIÝI¹Ä"~X§

,«ï�Û�¾,ÉÙ�7¤÷§Süeáö�S íu��8çIÝI§¦Ù�

7¤õ¥I¶n´(3ó§¢�L§¥±�*h1�"çI�nÅ��ÝI<G

ϧöpçI�8§üÞÂ�¤^"çI<�ç�Q½�ÝI<§Ç¿ÝI<|�

�IGI§çI�nÅ�KF"�I�<�õ�ЧçI©��±õñA�°"ù

�¥§k�çI�nÅ��5�ÝI<ß³&E!�ÝI<þ�½�çI©�§k

��5öpçIÝI¹Ä"d§ó§ï��8çI�nÅ��Ö8�+n´½ï

�Û§I�"�Ù]�¿Â��½+n¤§$�k�O(3çIÅ�Ók�°"

ÝI<�çI<!çIÅ�!+nÅ��ÏÐ�§æ^GÏÝI¼�¥I]

�"~X§GÏÝIVÞ<Gúim©/^A[�]�|�GÏÝI§�uykÙ

¦ÝI<�3GϧÒUz[2���m�d�ïL5"GúiÝI��8¥§wþ

�k�õ�ÝI<§�¢Sþ´Gúi��<3ÝI"¥I�§�ê¬gC���

8§80%�Ѭ=�Ñ�"¥I<�{=�§J�¥I�87��10%�ÃY¤§�

Ø3%�¤^|ѧ�kI�o7�7%�|d�m§=Ã=�7%�|d"��ïÓ

�ó�5ã���þÛ�§õ�=��ei�óè���¼�|d)�§ó§�þ

Page 420: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 409

3�½§Ýþ¬É�K�"

±�½V�Ï�¡§TY�Y7�2·{�§�Y�V7��1600{���õ§

®J��V±200{��§��?�£²L��3000{��"TY�9�+�Z

Ü22<£�?±þZÜ12<¤§®é�'I?<Ú6¶GÏÝI<?1�?"

TåY�þ�IÖ��§ÚåIÖ�p�+�Ó���ä§3�wþ1«§�

¦k'Ü�3çIÝIN�!Å�þæ�k���§��GÏÝI§Úýaq¯�u

)"��§2011c11�30F§IÖ�1183g~Ö¬Æ"ÆÏL5çIÝI{¢�^

~6¶2013c2�4F§I[uÐU��!ó&Ü!iÜ�lÜ�Û�Ù5>fçIÝ

I�{6§±æ^>fçIÝIEâ)ûçIÝI+��âѯK¶2015c8�10F§

IÖ��úeúÙ5�ÜïáÚ��ú�] �´²�ó��Y6§Ùm�´u�

½|3] ��¥�û½5�^Ú�Ðu��?�^§±�Ü��] !Ú��Ý

5K!M#N�Å��­:§±&Ezï��| §�ÓÚ��ú�] �´²�

NX§í?ú�] �´{�z!5�z!ß²z§Jpú�] ���ÇÚ�Ã"

[¯K] �âþãY�£�§©Û�e¯Kµ

1.±�¶Y�³ÑçIÝIÅ�¥§1�(!çIÝI1�iÒ!çI<!

çI�nÅ�ÚÝI<�=¯KºµI;[�{µI´Ä�±)ûº

2.±�¶Yé�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|k=´«§qk=é&º

3.AXÛw�çIÝI½|ï�¥�/ª�SN!�£�{£'X§XÛ�ï

5�kS�çIÝI½|Qº

[Y~©Û] �âY�£�§éþã¯K©ÛXe:

1.½|kS$1���Ä�Ly§́ ½|ÌN!ë�<ÚiÒ<U½|$15

K�iÙ�§?Ûü Ú�<Ø��{ZýçIÝI¹Ä"±�¶Y�³Ñ5�§

´çIÝI½|$1¥�a�ÚØ�iÙ�½´" �� §rçIÝI�´²�

�¤Í�§��{Æ{5�r�55½§_½|�S1¯"Ì�Ly3µ�1�=

��§�+nI[$1¥�ú�¯Ö§�k1�Å'½ö�?âk�¢�"1�(

§́ 1�Å'�ìÙ(½��U��+��Ö§+�Ùeá�15½�ó��I§

�o½|�S"±�¶Y¥�1�(§X,«ï�Û�Û�¾,§��úÖO

KÚ����§_XçIÝI½|�S§SüÙeáö�çIÝI¹Ä§±¦Ù�

7¤õ¥I¶�1�iÒÅ�§́ U�?Ü�1��U�5½§�{éçIÝI¹

Ä¢�iÒ§�{�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1��1�Å�"±�¶Y¥�1�

iÒÅ�§X½,«ï�ÛçI�KI<o,§éçIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�Ø�

Ø�?§��ÝI<�,�(§_XçIÝI½|�SöpçIÝI¿Âɦ<ª

µ¶�çI<§́ ?1çI�{<½öÙ¦|�"±�¶Y¥�çI<§Ø=Øk

Page 421: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

410 çIæÛYFn

�A^çIÝI¥�J`Å�§¢yJp²L�Ã!�y�8�þ�æm�§�

´_X½|�S�ÝI<Gϧ4heGÏ�ÝI<¥I¶�çI�nÅ�§́

�ÉçI<�÷§3�n��S§±��n<¶Â¢�çI�n1���¬¥0Å

�"±�¶Y¥�çI�nÅ�Ø=Ø�{Á1Ù�nçI�I§ ´��çIÝ

I{�5½§öpçI�8§�{�³A�����çIÝI¹Äk'�¹Ú]�§

�ÝI<Gϧ�³I[|Ã!�¬ú�|ÃÚ¦<Ü{�ö�ÝI<§́ �A

çI§ë�ÝI¿��{<½öÙ¦|�"±�¶Y¥ÝI<�ÝI§�A´?1

ÝI¿�§��õ�ÝI<wþ�´3¿�§¢�þ´GÏÝI§́ _X½|�S

���<ÝI"3ù«�/e§\�çI�nÅ��ÝI<GϧçIæ(J´

k|uGÏÝI¥�¥I<§I[|ÃÚ�¬ú�|ÃÉ�³"

=�6±�¶Y¥�µI;[�{µI§Ø�Uk�)û1�(!çIÝI

1�iÒÅ�!çI<!çI�nÅ�ÚÝI<m/�^90ª�GÏÝI¯K§Ï

�Ù�I´UçI©�¥5½�µIIOÚ�{§éÝI©�?1µ"Ú'�"Ý

IL§¥§ÝI©�¥��ØÑyØÓÝI<�ÝI©�1²��8+n¤Ñy

Ó�<!ÝI©�É~��§½öÝI�d¥y5Æ5�É�GÏÝI¥�/f�0

a�اµI�!Ø�UuyGÏÝI"�Û¹µI;[µI¥�Ø@ý§r/ª!

rL|§$��êµI;[ÂÉÝI<ªµ§�ÏÝI<¥I"3ù«�/e§³

/µI;[��{µI§Ø�Ul��þ)û1�(!çIÝI1�iÒ!çI

<!¥0Å�ÚÝI<m�GÏÝI¯K"

2.±�¶Y�³Ñ5�§Øü´çIÝI¹Ä¥,����{�5§ ´1�

(!1�iÒÅ�!çI<!çI�nÅ�ÚÝI<�/�^90ª�GÏÝI!

ÝI<m�GÏÝIÚ1ªÉª¯K§́ ½|ÃS�XÚLy§I�l½|Eû�

¸ï�þ)û"

çIÝI½|Eû�¸ï��Ø%´�?�{1�!�¯<�{�´"±�¶

Yé5�kS�çIÝI½|ï��é&3uµ

�´çIÝI½|Eû�¸ï��Ä:3{£"çIÝI¹Ä¥§çI<!Ý

I<!µI�¬9Ù¤´�´¥�/$Ä0§�?´�´�S��oö§�I

´�{iÒ§�?�{1�"�çIÝI½|�ïL§¥§/����M�0!/á{

@}0§±9�/�1�Ü�Ø��½����¯��ku)"�/�çIÝ

I1�iÒÜ��X/ú²!ú�0½/M#0áÒ§��þ {�Ù��l½|

�´OK��´5K"¦�¥§k��{��çI<�çr�5½çI<Ø��

�Lë\µI¶k��d3ÝI<��»9§��þ {�Ù��34Ù|Ã+

N¼Ã�½|�´5K¶k�Ø�çI�8äNA:Ú¢SI¦§r��¦çI<

Page 422: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

116ÙçIæµ½|Eû�¸��ï 411

�1Ù�Ù�µI�{¶k�²©ì��/è�§é��/è��±ÜÀ½¢�Ø

²����"çIÝI½|Eû�¸�ï�Ä:§́ é½|þ�/«!�Ü��u

�/²0½/V05K§±{Æ�O-?1/á!U!¢!º0§±�õçIÝI½|

{5"éçIÝI½|¥��þ {�5K?1�n§Ú��5çIÝI{69Ù

¢�^~ù�{�;�þ5§́ �ï5�kS�çIÝI½|Eû�¸�Ä:"

�´çIÝI½|Eû�¸ï��Ä:3u?nÐ�?Ú½|�'X§±�Ð

/u��?�{1�§�o½|�S��U"ùp§�{1�kü�¹Â§=�{

�ÙçIÝI½|5K§�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|Ú�{éçIÝI¹Ä?1

iÒ§�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�"5çIÝI{61Ô^²(5½§k'1�

iÒÜ��{éçIÝI¹Ä¢�iÒ§�{�?çIÝI¹Ä¥��{1�"é

A�§5çIÝI{618�n^²(5½§éçIÝI¹Ä�{Kk1�iÒ�I

�I[Å'ó�<ÞhÍ6!E^��½ö ��ŧ�¤���§�{JÄ-

¯I?¶Ø�¤���§�{��1�?©"�d§5çIÝI{¢�^~61Ô�

Ê^?�Ú5½§�8"1!ØOÜ�Ø�{"1!ØO�8çI��!çI�ª!

çI|�/ª�§éü ��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{��?©¶

ék'1�iÒÜ�Ø�{Á1�I§é��çIÝI{Ú�^~5½�1�Ø�

{�?§½öØUì5½?nÝ�!Ø�{úwéçIÝI�¯<�{1��1�

?nû½�§é��KI�Ì+<ÚÙ¦��I?<�{��?©¶é�8"

1!ØOÜ�Úk'1�iÒÜ��ó�<ÞhÍ6!E^��! ��ŧ�

¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?"�éI[ó�<�{Z�çIÝI¹Ä�§5çI

ÝI{¢�^~61l�^²(5½§I[ó�<|^�ÖB|§±��½öm

�!²«½öV«�?Û�ª�{Z�çIÝI¹Ä§ke��/���§�{�

�PL½öP�L?©¶�!î­�§�{��ü?½ö��?©¶�!AOî­

�§�{��mØ?©¶�¤���§�{JÄ-¯I?§�)µ��¦é�{7L

?1çI��8ØçI§½ö�¦é�{A�úmçI��8ØúmçI¶��¦

µI�¬¤½öçI<±Ù�½�ÝI<��¥IÿÀ<½ö¥I<§½ö±

Ù¦�ª�{Z�µI¹Ä§K�¥I(J¶�±Ù¦�ª�{Z�çIÝI¹Ä

�§±éI[ó�<�{ZýçIÝI¹Ä1�?1£n"

1n§5�kS�çIÝI½|Eû�¸lØmë�<�ÙÅV/�A�ë

�"çIÝI½|þÑyGÏÝI��kç�5��¯�§�½|²LuÐ¥Å{

¿£��!/¿ª!�%0"�Ú/~7ÌÂ0�1k'§Ï��ä´|ï½|¿�

��k�Ãã"Ó�§§�´�ê<¥�hK§�{¼|��k��{§Ù¢�´

3�½|�Sé|"�d§I�I[�åÅ�!i{Å�Ú1�Ì+!1�iÒÜ

Page 423: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

412 çIæÛYFn

��Óë�§�Óéħ�âÙ5½�Igú�o½|�S§�.�ØçIÝI½

|þÑy�GÏÝI!�I!áJ�b¢�¥IÚ]�!���ç�³å9Ù�o

Ð"�kù�§âU�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|�¸§Ï��?Ú£��U��

´�o�¬�S§ ç�³å]Ô��´�¬�S"

3.çIÝI´�«½|J`��{½Å�§�vk²Lƿ§�k�Ù�æ

Ü3�å§â´�«¢yÔÑ��¦"±�½V�!iÛé±�GÏÝI¶Y

��?§�½§Ýþr¤>fçIÝI�´²�Ñy§r¤IÖ�eû%æ^

>f�´�Üú�] �´²�"A�`§>fçIÝI�´²��íѧ3�½

§Ýþ��?GÏÝIJøB|§�±gÄ£OØÓÝI<�ÝI©�dÓ�ü

 ½ö�<?�!1²��8+n¤ÑyÓ�<!ÝI�y7lÓ�ü ½ö�

<âr=Ñ�/f�0a1�"�´§·�A��2/@£�§éçIÝI¹Ä¥

��{�5¯K§>fçIÝI�´²�=´�«aqu¢N½|��´1N§́

�«£IØ£���{§Ø�Ul��þ)ûGÏÝI¯K§�²d>fçIÝI

�´²�¢�´çIÝI¹Ä§�´ÑyçIÝIr/ª!rL|  læ�m

�"Ó�§��´upu>Mç�\�XÚ§���´¥�Å�§XÝI�d!µI

;[&E�§½´��GUµI�¬�µ"(J§Ù��½GU1���¢N½

|�Û-§�?�J�

3ù«/³e§qA�XÛ�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|QºÄk§�(@£

//ª0�/SN0�'X"çIÝI¥��´²�½½|´1N§´�«/ª½

/I0§¢yæ(J /́SN0½/�0"çIæ�²Lm�´çI<3½|þ|

�ÝI¿�§l¥J`ÀJ"�zçIÝI½|�1�N�U�§£8çI<?1

çI�{½�|§́ l�Ý��þ)ûçIÝI½|þ�{�5¯K���§Ï�

�k/J`0âÎÜg,/`���0�{K§ÎÜ<a�¬?Ú�5ƶÙg§5

�kS�çIÝI½|ï�§�ë�<�ÙÅV/ë�!Jø�´ÑÖ½ö´�{

éçIÝI¹Ä¢�1�iÒ�Ø�©"éd§5¥�¥'u�¡í?�{£I

eZ­�¯K�û½6¥²(�ѧ7Lj±�Ã8{£!�Ã8�£§����

¬ú�!����![Ì{�Ú�<¬�§±{£Ny��ng!rz{Æé��

ï��r?�^"Ó�§rz��é{£©z�| �^§¢y{ÆÚ���9�

¤!{£Ú�£��ÃÚ§Ï��kù�§âU�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|½²

�§ÑÖu�¬Ì½|²Lï�"

Page 424: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

N¹1. Y~�¯¢Ú

Y~�¯¢Ú

Y~�¯¶¡ Ù! ºn

1.F¥Þ/Ý��¯ 11Ù11! �¥ÀW�çI§Sé'

2.»9�Ô 11Ù12! çIæÔÑÜÝ

3.PºPåkÍX 11Ù13! kÍX�IO3J¯<%¥

4.�·�¬�é& 11Ù14! �S´çIÝI�´��æ

5.�NæY 11Ù15! '�Eâëêµ"�'�

6.G¬æ�ƪ�¯� 12Ù11! ½|ÔdÅĺxy©�K

7.�ï�Ö¢5���¯ 12Ù12! ÜÓ\¾Ø�N�¢�5SN

8.>�e%©�¥¯� 12Ù13! EPCçIæJ:�J`

9.AN²Eª�¯� 12Ù13! PPPçIæJ:�J`

10.1��Ø��¯ 12Ù14! çIæ1��Ø�{

11./c>CæY 12Ù15! >C�E�þd�E<«ú

12.å<3û|��¯ 13Ù11! æI¦´çIéÄ^�

13.êÛÇ��¯ 13Ù12! O((½æI¦´¿�Ä:

14.(´çr��¯ 13Ù13! æ�¢�5�¦Ú^�

15.c�ç­��¯ 13Ù14! ¿��Ï�!IOÚ^�

16.�«øYó§Y 13Ù15! ó§þØO�ÝIزï�d

17.�Ô���â 14Ù11! Á�Uå"��­�5

18.��"��¯ 14Ù12! ]�"��Ï�!IOÚ^�

19.ÝI©��ª��¯ 14Ù13! ��©��ª��^��g

20." =���¯ 14Ù14! i;üS´J`�Ä��{

21.zó�EâUE�}Y 14Ù15! �ï�8¿�Ø%3ïuUå

22.çI���Ư� 15Ù12! O(.½çI���­�5

23.ÝI�y7ò���~ 15Ù12! �y7Øò�=�u{½�/

24.ÜÓ^�ز��¯ 15Ù14! ÜÓ^�éçIæ�­�5

25.J`IO¹·�Y~ 15Ù15! J`IO¹·�çI�}

26.�´^���¯ 16Ù11! S.5g�����³

27.>MJó��¯ 16Ù12! �5z�É´J`�Ä:

28.c$øý��ü¶ 16Ù13! nܵ�{�õÏ�üS

Page 425: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

414 çIæÛYFn

£YcL¤Y~�¯¶¡ Ù! ºn

29.�OçIY~ 16Ù15! µI�Æ�µ©(J��g

30.çI�n¤��~ 17Ù11! çI�nÑÖ¤X|G

31.çIúwN���¯ 17Ù12! N�'�¯�I�­#úw

32. ty|��¯ 17Ù13! |� ty|�î�5

33.ÝI¼UÄ��¯ 17Ù14! ÝI¼Ì�¯��î�5

34.�¡Eb��¯ 17Ù14! áJ�bÝI�Äû

35.çIÝI|�Y~ 17Ù15! çIÝI|�§S�î�5

36.�?�ì 18Ù11! mI�­�5

37.ÝI©�Én��¯ 18Ù12! �{A�áÂ�ÝILáÂ

38.ÝI��ò���¯ 18Ù13! ÝI��ò�áçI©�?U

39.�Id��¯ 18Ù13! X¢�I�­�5

40.IdP¹��¯ 18Ù14! X¢P¹�­�5

41.mIL§�{Y 18Ù15! mIP¹�µI�'X

42.­.��ç¯� 19Ù11! à��µI¤�­�5

43.µINÖ¤��¯ 19Ù12! µI�é�´ÝI©�

44.ÝI¼����¯ 19Ù13! ÝI���Ø���ÝI©�

45.µI�w\i��¯ 19Ù14! ýnØ�½o´3õê<Ãp

46.µIL§�{Y 19Ù15! µI�{�­#µI

47.µI(J(@��¯ 110Ù11! µI(J(@�­�5

48.µI(Jú«��¯ 110Ù12! ¿�1�AX¢ú«

49.�8²n�Á��¯ 110Ù13! çI�8/�å�g0��J

50.æ�ü��¯ 110Ù14! ÝI?U�üþ�(��Æ

51.�¿�â�ØY 110Ù15! Id�¿�â�ØÚu�z

52.ÜÓ����¯ 111Ù11! ÜÓ��Ø��{C�

53.eóòØ��¯ 111Ù12! eóòØ�I?�¢�

54.çôx¨¥¯� 111Ù13! Á��þ+n�­�5

55.Ò�ÜÓŪY 111Ù15! Ò�ÜÓþÃ���~

56.P<þäÁrOkY 112Ù11! ��¬¯1�<�ÌNI?

57.ËAUE��¯ 112Ù12! çI<«úæ(JI?

58.�{çI��~ 112Ù13! çI<çI�{ÆI?

59.GÏÝI��~ 112Ù14! GÏÝIë�<�{ÆI?

60.çI�{Y 112Ù15! çI�{�{Æ�J

Page 426: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

N¹1. Y~�¯¢Ú 415

£YcL¤Y~�¯¶¡ Ù! ºn

61.GÏÝI��{ 113Ù11! GÏÝI�{¥Û¹�<5

62.�çI<Gϯ� 113Ù12! �çI<GÏ�/

63.��nÅ�Gϯ� 113Ù12! �çI�nÅ�GÏ�/

64.;[&E�³¯� 113Ù12! �Ñ�´�¦<����

65.EâIÛÉ��¯ 113Ù13! �IÝI©�Y²$e��Ï

66.GÏ�Y��¯ 113Ù13! �I<ÚNØ��Ø�½¥I

67.Ü�~Ò¥��¯ 113Ù13! ~ÒÄ\Ø�½U��GÏ

68.�d&f��¯ 113Ù14! GÏÝI´&f�d�?z

69.GÏÝIÁ�wuY 113Ù15! Á�uyGÏÝI�?n�K

70.çI�o<��¯ 114Ù11! bÙby�½|�Ï

71.]�Eb��¯ 114Ù11! çIéN�yEb�n5?n

72.ÜÓEb��¯ 114Ù12! ýb�3�å��¢

73.]�/^��¯ 114Ù13! )û!�3½|O\�ÝU�

74.yôh�xX��¯ 114Ù13! yôh�xX´l��u{Æ

75.!�öY�Y��¯ 114Ù13! Á�¥�±uy¿�?!�

76.�d$u¤���¯ 114Ù14! �d$u¤�3Á�¥��

77.�1©a¥I�Ûª 114Ù14! ª&Á���dØ´$u¤�

78.!�²EÜÓY 114Ù15! !�<Ú�!�<�{ÆI?

79.µI;[ɪ��¯ 115Ù11! Ì?�y|ɪ��?

80.µIV«��¯ 115Ù11! µI�5�kd5K

81.�ûµI(J��¯ 115Ù12! µI;[¢ª!�ûµI(J

82.µI;[����¯ 115Ù13! µI;[ÌÄéXÝI<

83.�ñ;[&E��¯ 115Ù14! ,�´¥%�ñµI;[&E

84.ç�\�;[¥��¯ 115Ù14! ç�\�;[¥��;[&E

85.µI�{�S�¯�Y 115Ù15! S�¯�ÚÑ!�!;[ɪ

86.�7´Ó���¯ 116Ù11! çIÝI�{1��Å�¤�

87.½|¥�n�I 116Ù12! r£e�½|�´s'h|

88.ç�³åö��´« 116Ù13! �¬�S´çIÝIkS�Ä:

89.��Ͷ�<��) 116Ù14! I¦�géµ"1��K�

90.±�GÏÝI¶Y 116Ù15! �ï5�kS�çIÝI½|

Page 427: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

N¹2. 100U�Bv100U�g¢

100U�Bv100U�g¢

·O3ÁFÒe¼á�Ff§

¹«�g§u?¯��<)¶

��c�]m§�Ãqeq³�§

·�^��Ë/Y·@Ø)�%X§

@o¯§çI®?\î¤�ÁU"

·O3 ú�ì·§kN���§

Õg³L@®²î:�»9c�¶

wXàYc1�Çħ�4��§

[�XU/<Á§�´fØ�¶

S8�)�3ùî¤�100U"

·O3Á��X§æ�¬»§

ÚünÙFÐl¬%s!¶

fXI�º����§

£ÁXçI@¯W� c§

g¢�Zy3ùBv�100U"

·O3I´ºÏÍ�Ø���§

rk�½ÿ�� ¯£g¶

�xÈììKz§Ð³�/)í\,��!§

·�^�n9ɧxrùBv�100U§

8ÚçI�Sæsm§£8æ�� "

2020c5�20Fu�®û¤

Page 428: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

�z

[1]5IO]�ý"©�¦^�H6?�|. ¥u<¬�ÚI2007c�IO�óç

I]�ý"©�¦^�H. �®µ¥IOyÑ��§2008"

[2]5IOçI©�¦^�H6?�|. ¥u<¬�ÚI2007c�IO�óçI©

�¦^�H. �®µ¥IOyÑ��§2008"

[3] F�J. F�JÈ)´²[M]. À�Ñ��§2012"

[4] F�J. F�JÈ)Pf[M]. À�Ñ��§2012"

[5] F�J. F�JÈ)�Æ¥T[M]. À�Ñ��§2012"

[6] I[uÐÚU��¬{5i§IÖ�{��ú¿ã7i§iÜ�{ii.

¥u<¬�ÚIçIÝI{¢�^~ºÂ[M]. �®:¥IOyÑ��§2012"

[7] I[óû1�+noÛ½|5�+ni. �#ÜÓ{Æ{55Ù9á{i{1

�)º�8[M]. �®:óûÑ��§2001"

[8] º<A. �ÃËP-�4�)��²[M]. �®µì(Ñ��§2004"

[9] º<A. �X�5-�ÃX´`7f²[M]. �®µì(Ñ��§2004"

[10] f��. Smarandache Multi-Space Theory[M]. 11�§{IµPhoenix:Hexis,

2006¶12��êÆïÄ)�§§{IµColumbus: The Education Publisher

Inc. ,USA, 2011"

[11] f��. ó§ï��8çIænØ�¢�[M]. {IµRehoboth: American

Research Press, USA, 2007"

[12] f��.�zN�U�§XÚ�ïçIÝI½|$1Å�[EB/OL].�®µ¦´n

Ø�§2011-02-28§http://www.qstheory.cn/lg/zl/201102/t20110228 69927.htm

[13] f��.GÏÝI�²L1�©Û9½|éü[J].¥IçIÝI£Sr¤. 2011c

15Ï"

[14] f��.l²LÆÑu.�ïçIænØNX[N].�®µ�?æ&E�§2012-

02-17"

[15] f��. �z1�"1U�\rçIÝI1�|�gÆ�ÑÖ[J]. �®µçI

æ+n§2013c14Ï"

[16] f��.çIÝI{¢�^~AOc|�ÂEÛ[J].�®µçIæ+n§2013c

12Ï"

Page 429: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

418 çIæÛYFn

[17] f��.5�ÌN1�r?1�èxuÐ))!çÝI½|�3�¯K9)û

�{[N]. �®µ¥Iï��§2013c3�1F"

[18] f��.ÝI<Ø�±$u¤��d¿I�{n�¢�[J].çI�ÝI§2014c

11Ï"

[19] f��. ØçIæ8�'X[J]. çI�ÝI§2014c15Ï"

[20] f��. æ�nÅ�ë�Á��´Ù�UNy[J]. �®µ�?æ&E

�§2014c8�11F"

[21] f��.�{£I,5�ú�] �´�+n[J].çIæ+n,2014c112Ï,16

-21"

[22] f��. 4·��þ¼���–êÆ|Ü�Smarandache­�m£Let’s Flying

by Wing – Mathematical Combinatorics & Smarandache Multi-Spaces¤[M].

Chinese Branch Xiquan House, USA, 2017"

[23] f��. ] ���ªU��M#–5'uM#�?��] �ª���¿�6

^©ºÂ�)Ö[M]. �®µ²L�ÆÑ��§2018"

[24] f��.5IOçI©�6)û=¯K[J].çI�ÝI§2018c11ϧ7-10"

[25] f��.!5IOçI©�6�ÝI<]�^�[J].çI�ÝI§2018c12ϧ7-

11"

[26] f��.5IOçI©�6��d�¦[J]. çI�ÝI§2018c13ϧ8-10"

[27] f��.!5IOçI©�6�>fçIÝI[J].çI�ÝI§2018c14ϧ7-8"

[28] f��. !5IOçI©�6�ÜÓ^�[J]. çI�ÝI§2018c15ϧ6-9"

[29] f��.!5IOçI©�6�nܵ�{[J].çI�ÝI§2018c16ϧ6-9"

[30] f��. !5çIÝI{6�5�?æ{6ü{Ü�[J]. çI�ÝI§2018c

18ϧ7-11"

[31] f��. #��!#uÐ: !çI�nÅ�=.,?��±YuÐ[J]. çI�Ý

I§2018c112ϧ7-13"

[32] f��. é1��3�I<�~�¬"ÆÏL�5çIÝI{6£?¾¤A0�

�1 �2|�éÙ?U[J]. çI�ÝI§2019c11ϧ7-10"

[33] f��. ¥�U�ÏL5�z�?æ�ÝU��Y6Ú�æ�Ý�U�

��[J]. çI�ÝI§2019c12ϧ8-11"

[34] f��. !�zIkó�è�æ�ÝU�[J]. çI�ÝI§2019c14ϧ9-

11"

[35] f��. !á¢æ<ÌNI?[J]. çI�ÝI§2019c15ϧ8-11"

[36] f��. !ú²ú��K�æJ`[J]. çI�ÝI§2019c17ϧ8-11"

Page 430: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

�z 419

[37] f��.rzçI<I?�çI�ª1�"1[J].¥IçI§2019c130ϧ21-

25"

[38] f��. ÝI�y7�{n�¢� lEÛ[J]. ¥IçI§2019c133ϧ42-

48"

[39] f��. XÛ�ÐçIæ(J�1��Ø[J]. ¥IçI§2019c134ϧ35-

39"

[40] f��. ¢½H��M¿5�8æ{Æ©Û[J]. ¥IçI§2019c145Ï"

[41] f��!oR¹. çIÝI{^©EÛ9Y~©Û[M]§�®µ¥IïÓó�Ñ

��§2013"

[42] f��!Üd. çIænØÄ:[M]§�®µ¥IïÓó�Ñ��§2013"

[43] Narsingh Deo, Graph Theory with Applications to Engineering and Computer

Science[M], Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N.J.,1974"

[44] Paul E.MoodyͧÁ{j!Ó¦²!ÜÆ=ȧûü–¼��Zûü��{[M]§

�®µ<¬�ÏÑ��§1988"

[45] $�ÓÌ?. ïÓó§�ó|��O¢~A^Ãþ[M]§�®µ¥IïÓó�Ñ

��§?¾�1999c§1n�2008c"

[46] µI;[;�©aIO�H?�|. µI;[;�©aIO£Á1¤¦^�

H[M]§�®µ¥IOyÑ��§2011"

[47] ¤L. ISó§ÜÓ�n�¢Ö[M]. �®µ¥IïÓó�Ñ��§�®µ2002"

[48] �IçI���Y²�Á9��á���¬. çIæY~©Û£12�¤[M].

�®µ¥IOyÑ��§2012"

[49] H.SteinhausͧÜ1²È. êÆ�sº[M]. þ°��Ñ��§1981"

[50] J.E.Stiglitz,AmartyaÚJ-P.Fitoussiͧ_ô²Ú�°èÈ. é·�)¹�Øÿ-

��oGDPO�Ø�u�¬?Ú[M]. �®µ#uÑ��§2014.

[51] 5¥u<¬�ÚIçIÝI{6åú�|ÚI[uÐOy�¬�ü{5i.

¥u<¬�ÚIçIÝI{�Ö[M]. �®µ¥IuÑ��§1999"

[52] �XÌ?. ½|²LVØ£1o�¤[M]. �®µ¥�¥�Ñ��§2008"

[53] ¿�A�. �8æ�ÜÓ+n£1��¤[M]. �®µ>fó�Ñ��§2010"

[54] Üè. �?ær?¥�è�uÐ��ª��{[J].¥IçI§2019c127Ï"

[55] Ü�!�­[. p?�*²LÆ[M]. �®µp���Ñ��§2009"

[56] Ü�+. �*²LÆ[M]. �®�ÆÑ��§2007"

Page 431: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

�ö{0

f��§���Ï�ÆóÆƬ!¥I�Æ�êÆƬ�!�Ç?p?ó§

�§êÆ!²LÆÚ+n�Æ�ó§ÕáÆö§IS�¶�|ÜÆ[!óƵØ[§

ISêÆ|Ü9A^ïÄ�£AMCA§{I¤��!ÄRïħIS¥��ÆÆ

¬£NSIA§{I¤J��¬§¥IÔ6�æéܬú�橬Ø%;[§¥I

æ�¬£�l¤ÄRæ²LÆ[§ISÆâÏrInternational J.Mathematical

Combinatorics£{I¤Ì?!<ÝBulletin of the Calcutta Mathematical Society?

6ÜÆâ�¯§�®ïÓ�Æo��Ç!ïÄ)��!PPP¥%;[�¬�"Ù

õc�ïÄ8¥3êÆ�A^êÆ!nØÔn!E,XÚ!] ��!çIÝI�

æÚï��8+n�+�§́ 8õÆ�����ÕáÆö"3ISúmuLØ

©120{�§Ñ�3ÜêÆïÄ)�á!4Üæ²LnØ;ͧõÜÆâØ©8¶Ì

?5] ���ªU��M#6!�IçI���Y²�Á9��á5çIæY~

©Û6�"ë�5¥u<¬�ÚIçIÝI{¢�^~6?��Øy§́ 5¥u<

¬�ÚIIO�óçI©�6£2007 �¤!5µI;[;�©aIO£Á1¤6£2010

c�¤!5ú�] �´µI;[;�©aIO6£2018c¤�Ì�?�;["Qk�

ú?¥I{ƬÄï�ú¿Eâ�¯!¥IçIÝI�¬B�Ö�!¥I¢½£n

y�zïÄ�B��"2017 c¼�{IAlbert Nelson Marquis Who.s Who�u�

/êÆ�ó§0ª)¤Òø"

Page 432: Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis - CTBA

Á�: çIæ´�«�*²L1�"���o�çI§qA�N�?1çI§ISNõ<é

d���kØ)½¦¾§��¢�¥��çIÝI¹Är/ª!rL|§ lçIæm

�"�Ö±æ²LnØ�Ä:§±��çIæÐ%!¿ÛçIÝI5K!�ºæ²Ln

Ø�Äŧ±�¯½Y~©Û�Ú�§df\�!l÷*��*§XÚ�ºçIæ�ngÚ

²LÆ5K§o(çIænØ"Ó�§±<��¬á5Ú?��Ä:§¿ÛGÏÝI!áJ�

b!!�!�¿$d¥I�¢�¥I1����g�ÏÚéü§�ï5�kS�çIÝI½|"

�Ö·Üul¯çIæ�ÜÓ+nnØïÄ!çIÝI½|ï�Ú+n§±9çIæl�

Å�Ú<n)çIÝIÅ��ë�"Ó�§�Ö����p�Æ�çIæ�ÜÓ+n�'

;����)½öïÄ)�ƽë�^Ö"

———– çIæÛYFn ———–

Abstract: Bidding is a kind of purchasing behavior of microeconomics in a market.

However, lots of people do not understand why we need bidding and how to purchase

goods by bidding in a market, which results in sometimes only the form or procedure

of bidding remained but the departure of the procurement purpose in China. Based

on the microeconomics, this book introduces the bidding principle by explaining its

ideas and rules in cases analyzing from the macro to the micro and from the easy to

the difficult cases. Meanwhile, it analyzes the causes of collusive bidding, win a bid

by fraud or linked a unit illegally, spiteful low price in human’s social attribute and

moral cultivation with countermeasure, and also presents how to construct an orderly

market of bidding in China, which refers to researchers on fields of bidding, contact

management and market construction, and also to the employed professionals in

bidding. Certainly, it contributes also a textbook or reference to students in bidding

or contact management.

———– Bidding Principle in Cases Analysis ———–

Price: 62.40$