Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

21
Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 27.06.22

Transcript of Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Page 1: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS

Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen

SYKE

20.04.23

Page 2: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFSWatershed Simulation and Forecasting

System (WSFS) has a separate subsystem to automatically calculate verification graphs and scores for operational forecasts.

This subsystem is called Forecast Accuracy Follow-up System (FAFS)

Page 3: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Forecast Accuracy Follow-up System (FAFS) Verification is based on released operational

forecasts, not on hindcasting FAFS has a web interface where

hydrologists can go back to previous incidents and see how the forecasts succeeded.

Page 4: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

FAFS web interface

Lake inflowRiver peak flowAnd less important ones

• Groundwater level• Lake inflow in test model based on monthly/seasonal

weather forecast• Short meteorological temperature forecast

Page 5: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflow

Page 6: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflow

Page 7: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflow

Page 8: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflow

Page 9: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflow

Page 10: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflow

Page 11: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

Lake inflowMost important forecast verification criteria

Mean absolute error:

Relative error:Mean absolute error divided by range of observations

Nash – Sutcliffe:

Page 12: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 13: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 14: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 15: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 16: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 17: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 18: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Page 19: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flowDischarge forecast: 7 day lead time,intended to display peak timing error.

Page 20: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flowDischarge forecast: 7 day maximum discharge,intended to display error in peak discharge.

Page 21: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015.

River peak flow

Most important forecast verification criteria

Peak timing error:Mean absolute error in peak timing.

Peak discharge error:Mean absolute error in maximum discharge.