ASIM Workshop on Fundamentals of Modeling and Simulation...
Transcript of ASIM Workshop on Fundamentals of Modeling and Simulation...
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular Modeling and Simulation in Process Engineering
Hans Hasse1, Jadran Vrabec2
ASIM Workshop on Fundamentals of Modeling and Simulation
1Lehrstuhl für Thermodynamik, TU Kaiserslautern2Lehrstuhl für Thermodynamik und Energietechnik, Universität Paderborn
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Technology Vision 2020: The U.S. Chemical Industry
Chemical & Engineering Science
Manufacturing & Operations
Supply Chain Management
Information Systems
Engineering Computational Technologies
ComputationalMolecular Science
=> Link between Engineering and Chemistry=> New processes, products, materials
Process Modeling & Simulation
Operations Simulation & Optimization
ComputationalFluidDynamics
Fields of Major New Developments
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
(fs) 10-15
(ps) 10-12
(ns) 10-9
(μs) 10-6
(ms) 10-3
100
10-10 10-9 10-8 10-7 10-6 10-5 10-4
(nm) (μm)
Time / s
MesoscaleMethods
Continuum Methods
Semiempirical QM
Ab initioQM
MolecularForce Fields
Length / m
Molecular Modeling and Simulation Methods
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Further progress from new simulation methods and software
Moore‘s Law
GFL
OPS
/ G
IPS
Year
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Bridging Scales
QuantumSystems
Molecular Systems
ContinuumSystems
Born-Oppen-heimer MD
MD LargeSystems
Mesoscale Systems
HybridCFD
COSMORS
Examples
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular Methods in Chemical Process Industries
Current Applications @ Evonik Degussa:CatalysisThermo-physical dataPolymersCrystallizationParticle technology
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
COSMO-RS @ Evonik
Quantum chemistry based method for prediction of thermo-physical properties
Quantitative predictions
Quantum chemistry based predictionof energy of molecular interactions
Crude classical assumptions for entropy
Close co-operation between engineersand quantum chemists
Benchmark against phenomenolgicalgroup contribution methods (UNIFAC)
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Force-Field Methods @ Evonik
Example: MD simulations of Water-Polymer interface
Qualitative results
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Mesoscale Methods @ EvonikExample: Simulation of particle morphologies
α = 1
α = 4
α = 16
Semiquantitative results
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular methods are:already used especially attractive if no sufficiently accurate
- experiments - calculations with phenomenological methods
are possiblerecognized as a future key technology
Industrial Applications of Molecular Methods in Process Engineering
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular Modelling (Force Fields)
Geometry:Bond lengths and angles
Electrostatics:Position and strengthof dipoles, quadrupoles,partial charges
Dispersion and Repulsion:Parameters of Lennard-Jones potentials
Many parameters
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Model Parameters from Quantum ChemistryGeometry
HF with small basis set (z.B. 6-31G) or DFT methodsElectrostatics from electronic density distribution
MP2 with small polarizable basis set (e.g., 6-311+G**)Molecule embedded in dielectric cavity for modeling dense fluid phase (COSMO)
Dispersion and RepulsionRequires simulation of arrangements of at least two moleculesCCSD(T) or MP2 with large basis sets (TZV or QZV)Very high computational effort Unsatisfactory accuracy
Fit to thermo-physical data preferred
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular Dynamics (MD)Numerical solution of Newtonian equations of motionDeterministicStatic and dynamic properties
Molecular Simulation Basic Methods
Monte-Carlo (MC)Statistical MethodEnergetic acceptance criteriaStatic properties only
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Direct Simulation of Phase EquilibriaExample: Vapor-liquid equilibirum of Ethylene Oxide @ 375 K
3500 molecules
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Phase Equilibrium from Grand Equilibrium Method
( ) ( ) ( )μ ≈ μ + ⋅ −l l li i 0 i 0p p v p p
Pseudo grand canonical simulation(Specification of V, T) ( )μ l
i p
Specs: T, x
Result: p, y
Liquid Vapor
Simulation:Chemical potentialsPartial molar volumes
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
10
20
30
40
Exe
cutio
n tim
e / 1
000
s
Number of processorsSX-8
XC6000Cacau
StriderMozart
1 2 4 8 16 32 64
High Performance Parallel Computing
Strider
SX 8
Cacau
XC6000
Own parallel FORTRAN codes: ms2 thermo-physical propertiesls1 nano-scale processes
Scaling on selected hardware platforms:
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Polar Two Center Lennard-Jones ModelsQ
ε
L
σ
4 Model parametersε energyσ sizeL elongation
μ dipoleorQ quadrupole
dispersionrepulsion
polarity
μ /
Models of 80 simple pure componentsParametrization: VLE data only
Simulation Exp. (corr.)
typ. deviation < 2%
Vapor pressure
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Pure Component Models: ExtrapolationsJoule-Thomson Inversion
p / M
Pa
T / Kred: critical data
Symbols: SimulationLinies: Reference EOS
Ethylene
Oxygen
Nitrogen
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Ethylene Oxide
Worldwide annual production about 18 Mio. tonsUse: PET and anti-freezeProperties:
- explosive- toxic- highly flammable- cancerogenic- mutagenic
Explosion @ Sterigenics Intl., Ontario, CND (2004):4 wounded, hall destroyed
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Industrial Property Simulation Challenge 2007
Industrial Fluid PropertiesSimulation Collective
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular Model of Ethylene Oxide
3 LJ Sites (one for the oxygen atom, one for each methylene group)1 static point dipole along symmetry axisRigid, non-polarizableAdjustment of five parameters (σO, εO, σCH2, εCH2, μ) to experimental VLE data
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
IFPSC Challenge 2007 : Problem DescriptionDevelopment of a new molecular model for Ethylene OxidePrediction of 17 properties in 3 categories
Benchmarked to “reference data”
Vapor liquid equilibria /thermal propertiesSaturated densitiesVapor pressureEnthalpy of vaporizationCritical propertiesNormal boiling temperatureSecond virial coefficient
Second derivatives/surface tensionHeat capacityIsothermal compressibilitySurface tension
Transport propertiesShear viscosityThermal conductivity
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Deviations from Reference Data
uncertaintyof reference
Round-Robinmodel
new modelscore:331/350
deviation from experiment / %-40 -20 0 20 40 60
sat. vap. thermal conductivitysat. liq. thermal conductivity
sat. vapor shear viscositysat. liquid shear viscosity
surface tensionsat. vap. isoth. compressib.
sat. liq. isoth. compressib.sat. vapor isob. heat capacitysat. liquid isob. heat capacity
critical temperaturecritical density
normal boiling temperatureenthalpy of vaporization
vapor pressure2nd virial coefficient
sat. vapor densitysat. liquid density
deviation from experiment / %-40 -20 0 20 40 60
sat. vap. thermal conductivitysat. liq. thermal conductivity
sat. vapor shear viscositysat. liquid shear viscosity
surface tensionsat. vap. isoth. compressib.
sat. liq. isoth. compressib.sat. vapor isob. heat capacitysat. liquid isob. heat capacity
critical temperaturecritical density
normal boiling temperatureenthalpy of vaporization
vapor pressure2nd virial coefficient
sat. vapor densitysat. liquid density
deviation from experiment / %-40 -20 0 20 40 60
sat. vap. thermal conductivitysat. liq. thermal conductivity
sat. vapor shear viscositysat. liquid shear viscosity
surface tensionsat. vap. isoth. compressib.
sat. liq. isoth. compressib.sat. vapor isob. heat capacitysat. liquid isob. heat capacity
critical temperaturecritical density
normal boiling temperatureenthalpy of vaporization
vapor pressure2nd virial coefficient
sat. vapor densitysat. liquid density
deviation from reference / %
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
IFPSC Party 2007
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Ethanol
3 LJ sites plus 3 point chargesPoint charges model both electrostatics and H-bonding
δρ = 0,3 % δp = 3,7 %
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
H-Bonded-Species in Methanol + CO2Geometrical H-bonding criterion of Haughney et al.Equimolar mixture @ 350 K, 0.1 MPa
Legend:Donor: light blueAcceptor:single: orange double: red
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
1H-NMR Spectroscopy of H-Bonding Mixtures
ppm
293,15 K
338,15 K p = 15 MPa
Experiment
Simulation
Methanol - CO2
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Overview Pure Component ModelsNon-polar, 1CLJ
Neon (Ne), Argon (Ar)Krypton (Kr), Xenon (Xe)Methan (CH4)
Dipolar, 2CLJD
Kohlenmonoxid (CO)R11 (CFCl3)R12 (CF2Cl2)R13 (CF3Cl)R13B1 (CBrF3)R22 (CHF2Cl)R23 (CHF3)R41 (CH3F)R123 (CHCl2-CF3)R124 (CHFCl-CF3)R125 (CHF2-CF3) R134a (CH2F-CF3)R141b (CH3-CFCl2)R142b (CH3-CF2Cl)R143a (CH3-CF3) R152a (CH3-CHF2)R40 (CH3Cl)R40B1 (CH3Br)CH3IR30B1 (CH2BrCl) R20 (CHCl3)
Dipolar, 2CLJD (contd.)
R20B3 (CHBr3)R21 (CHFCl2)R12B2 (CBr2F2) R12B1 (CBrClF2)R10B1 (CBrCl3)R161 (CH2F-CH3)R150a (CHCl2-CH3) (1,1,2) CHCl2-CH2ClR140a (CCl3-CH3)R130a (CH2Cl-CCl3)C2H5Br (CH2Br-CH3)(1,1) CHBr2-CH3CH2F-CCl3(2,2,2) CHClBr-CF3R112a (CCl3-CF2Cl) CHF=CH2CF2=CH2C2H3Cl (CHCl=CH2)CHCl=CF2 CFCl=CF2CFBr=CF2
Quadrupolar, 2CLJQ
Flour (F2)Chlor (Cl2)Brom (Br2)Iod (I2) Stickstoff (N2)Sauerstoff (O2)Kohlendioxid (CO2)Kohlendisulfid (CS2) Ethan (C2H6)Ethylen (C2H4)Ethin (C2H2)R116 (C2F6) C2F4C2Cl4Propadien (CH2=C=CH2)Propin (CH3-C≡CH) Propylen (CH3-CH=CH2)SF6R14 (CF4)R10 (CCl4)R113 (CFCl2-CF2Cl)R114 (CF2Cl-CF2Cl)R115 (CF3-CF2Cl) R134 (CHF2-CHF2) (1,2) CH2Br-CH2BrCBrF2-CBrF2CHCl=CCl2
Dipolar, 1CLJD
R32 (CH2F2) R30 (CH2Cl2)R30B2 (CH2Br2)CH2I2
Polar, Muti-CLJ
iso-Butan (C4H10)Cyclohexan (C6H12)Methanol (CH3OH)Ethanol (C2H5OH)Formaldehyd (CH2=O)Dimethylether (CH3-O-CH3)Aceton (C3H6O)Ammoniak (NH3)Methylamin (NH2-CH3)Dimethylamin (CH3-NH-CH3)R227ea (CF3-CHF-CF3)Schwefeldioxid (SO2)Ethylenoxid (C2H4O)Dimethylsulfid (CH3-S-CH3)Blausäure (NCH)Acetonitril (NC2H3)Thiophen (SC4H4)Nitromethan (NO2CH3)Phosgen (COCl2)Benzol (C6H6)Toluol (C7H8)Chlorbenzol (C6H5Cl)Dichlorbenzol (C6H4Cl2)Cyclohexanol (C6H11OH)Cyclohexanon (C6H10O)
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Unlike interaction A-B:Electrostatics fully predictiveLennard-Jones parameters from combination rules
Molecular Modelling of Mixtures
( )AB A B+= /2σ σ σ
AB A B=ε ε εξ ⋅
A A
B B
σA, εA
σB, εB
σAB, εAB
or
Fit to one experimental data point p(T,x) oder H(T)
ξ = 1Predictions
ModifiedLorentz-Berthelot
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Vapor-Liquid Equilibrium ofHeptafluoropropane + Ethanol
Simulation, =1 + ExperimentPeng-Robinson EOS ξ
InternationalFluidPropertiesSimulationChallenge2006
Data basis:=> VLE @ 283 KProblem:=> H-bonds
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Simulation, ξ = 1□, ∆ Experiment Simulation, ξ fitted
InternationalFluidPropertiesSimulationChallenge2004
,
Henry’s law constant von Oxygen in Ethanol
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Extrapolation to multicomponent mixtures
+ Experiment
PR-EOS, kij fitted to binary subsystems
Simulation, ξ fitted to binary subsystems
R14 + R23 + R13
Fully predictiveNo ternary parameters
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
MD Simulation of Nanoscale Processes: Condensation
N = 40 0001 CLJ
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
N = 40 0001 CLJ
MD Simulation of Nanoscale Processes: Condensation
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
EthaneSimulation Class. nucleation theoryLaaksonen et al.
Prediction of Nucleation Rates
Carbon DioxideSimulation Class. nucleation theory Laaksonen et al.
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Molecular Simulation of Hydrogels
Examples for applications:Super-absorberContact lensesDrug DeliverySensorsActors (e.g., micro-valves)Biocatalysis
200 µm3 actors
flow channel
What are Hydrogels?Three-dimensional hydrophilic polymer networksExtreme swelling/shrinkingVery sensitive to surroundings & conditions
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Swelling of HydrogelsParameters:
Temperature pH-valueSalt(s)Solvent(s)Co-polymersCrosslinker
Influence of temperature
Theta-temperature
PNiPAM, MBA
PNiPAM by electron-microscope
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
• Mainly PNiPAM (numerous experimental data)
MD-Simulation of Hydrogels
• Solvents: Water, Ethanol, aqueous NaCl solution• Temperatures: 260 K - 340 K• Force fields from literature
PVA PNiPAM PAA
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
39
MD-Simulation: Collapse of Hydrogel
primitive PVA-network
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Legend:Default Water model of force field
- Temperature dependence not observed+ Temperature dependence observable++ Temperature dependence reasonably predicted
Force Field Study
PNiPAM Water: SPCE Water: TIP4PGromos96 UA - -Gromacs53a6 UA - +OPLS AA ++ +
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
41
MD-Simulation PNiPAM-Chains
T < TΘ
T > TΘ
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Survey of Coordinated Research ProgramsDFG SPP 1155:Molekulare Modellierung und Simulation in der VerfahrenstechnikProcessNet Arbeitsausschuss MMS:Molekulare Modellierung und Simulation für das Prozess- und ProduktdesignDFG SFB 716:Dynamische Simulation von Systemen mit großen TeilchenzahlenDFG TFB 66:Molekulare Modellierung und Simulation zur Vorhersage von Stoffdaten für industrielle Anwendungen BMBF IMEMO: Innovative HPC-Methoden und Einsatz für hochskalierbare Molekulare Simulation
SFB 716
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
SummaryMolecular Modelling and Simulation in Process Engineering
used in industry high potential is recognizedfuture key technologytruly interdisciplinary field
Co-operation between EngineeringNatural ScienceComputer ScienceMathematics
Lehrstuhl für ThermodynamikProf. Dr.-Ing. H. Hasse
Thanks to co-workers…
Jürgen StollThorsten Schnabel Gimmy FernandezBernhard EcklIsaiah HuangMartin HorschThorsten MerkerGabriela GuevaraJonathan WalterStephan DeubleinCemal Engin
…and colleagues from industryJohannes Vorholz (Evonik)Robert Franke (Evonik)Bernd Eck (BASF)Manfred Heilig (BASF)