Anger in Upper and Lower

CanadaCauses of the 1837 rebellions

Lower Canada = French = present day QuebecUpper Canada = English = present day Ontario

What do we know about the people in these 2 colonies? (think: last unit, gr. 9 . . .)

This unit is about how the colonies of Upper and Lower Canada both rebelled

against their government.

Why? What happened?

Types of Government

What is representative government?

What is Responsible Government?

What did the Colonies have?

O Government is elected by voters – represents the people

O Voters have the power to vote out/ remove a government that does not please them (responsible to the people)

O Run by Britain/ Governor and small group of aristocrats (oligarchy)

Types of Government

What is an oligarchy?

Who are the oligarchies in Upper and Lower Canada?

Are the Colonies Democratic?

O Rule (governance) by a small, select group of people

O Upper Canada: Family Compact

O Lower Canada: Chateau Clique

O Colonies are NOT democratic –Government is not representative or responsible

Types of Government

O What is the government in both colonies?

Governor (represents Britain)

Executive Legislative Council Council(Both councils appointed by Governor

– all members are part of the Family compact or the Chateau

Clique)

Legislative Assembly(elected by Male Property owners in

colony)

Type of Government

O Why is this colonial government not democratic?

O Governor and his councils (Family Compact/ Chateau clique) could Veto all laws passed in Elected legislative assembly (and often did)

Stop: answer in small groups!

1. What do the following words mean:A. OligarchyB. DemocracyC. Representative governmentD. Responsible government

2. Why was the government in Upper and lower Canada not responsible?

3. What group had all the power in Upper Canada? In Lower Canada?

Answers

1. Oligarchy: a small group with all powerO Democracy: Power held by the peopleO Representative Gov.: people vote

representativesO Responsible gov.: responsible to the will of the

people; representatives have power to make change, and people can vote them out

2. Gov. not responsible as governor general and legislative / executive council are not elected and can veto all passed by elected legislative assembly

3. Upper Canada: Family Compact, Lower Canda: Chateau Clique

Upper Canada

What did the Family Compact Veto?

What are the Colonists angry about?

Who is Robert Gourlay?

O Roads/ development in crown and church land

O Ignore land speculation/ problems with absentee landlords

O No landO No roads (crown/ clergy land in the

way)O Family Compact has all the power

O Land agentO Created petition for change in

policyO Arrested and deportedO Unifies opposition

Upper Canada

O Who is William Lyon Mackenzie?

O Leader of protest/ for reform

O Newspaper: “Colonial Advocate” prints articles against gov. and family compact

O When Family Compact ransacked his office he sued

O Elected to Legislative Assembly 1828

O Leader of Reform/ rebellion

Stop: answer in small groups!

1. Who was a Rebellion leader in Upper Canada?

2. What was Upper Canada mad about? (why rebel?)

answers1. Who was a Rebellion leader in Upper

Canada? William Lyon Mackenzie

2. What was Upper Canada mad about? (why rebel?)

O No land available to immigrantsO No roads (crown/ clergy land in the

way)O Family Compact has all the power (not

responsible government)

Lower Canada

O What issues anger Lower Canada?

1. Discrimination against the French by the English

2. No Representation in Government

3. High Taxes

Lower Canada

O Who were the Chateau Clique?

O What is the problem with the Chateau Clique?

O Ruling Oligarchy – controls business and government

O All English Speaking/ British

O English/ protestant Minority (less than ¼ of pop.) has all the political/ economic power in a French Catholic colony

O Feel like Church and Seigneurs sold out to English

O Angry that Legislative Assembly is powerless (Veto power of councils/ Governor like upper Canada) and taxes are high

Lower Canada

O What Land Problems does Lower Canada face?

O How does Nationalism contribute to anger in Lower Canada?

O Unlike Upper: No land speculators

O Settled for 200 years = land less fertile/ crops fail

O Can only feed familiesO Import Wheat from Upper Canada

= Economic deficit/ failureO Alternative (forestry) restricted by

Seigneurs

O Want to protect language/ religion/ culture form British rule

O Fear assimilation through English immigration (become outnumbered)

Lower Canada

O What events anger the French?

O 1. 1822: -church/ seigneurs attempt to Unite Upper and Lower Canada and make English official Language Fails

O Anger and Betrayal

O 1832 :Ship brought Cholera to Lower Canada

O Paranoid – fear Britain is using biological warfare

Lower Canada

O Who is Louis Joseph Papineau?

O Who is James Craig?

O Leader of reform movementO lawyer/ SeigneurO Speaker of Legislative

Assembly in 1815O Leader of Parti Canadien

O 1807 –British Governor of Lower Canada

O Anti- French , arrested anyone against the government

O Closed reform newspaper “Le Canadien”

Lower Canada

O What are the 92 resolutions?

O What is the British response to the 92 resolutions?

O Protesters shot by British soldier in Montreal

O Papineau creates “92 resolutions” demanding reform (gives to Governor)

O Reply is 3 years laterO “10 resolutions” denying

rights to Legislative Assembly

O Leads to Rebellion

Stop: Answer in small groups!

1. Who was a Rebellion leader in Lower Canada?

2. What was Lower Canada mad about? (why rebel?)

3. What triggered the Rebellion in 1837?

Answers1. Who was a Rebellion leader in Lower

Canada? Louis Joseph Papineau

2. What was Lower Canada mad about? (why rebel?)

O Government not representative (english minority),or responsible (veto power)

O Fear of losing Language / religion / cultureO Economic difficulties and upper class

(seigneurs) don’t allow access to lumber for more $

3. What triggered the Rebellion in 1837?O 92 resolutions are ignored, then denied by

British Gov.

Assignment1. Complete a Venn Diagram comparing

the CAUSES of the Rebellions in Upper and Lower Canada (what were they upset about?)

2. READ p. 73 – 76 (including the Comic) and fill out the timeline of WHAT HAPPENED in the rebellions in both Upper and Lower Canada

THIS IS DUE NEXT CLASS