an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains...

33
Mapping outfalls in the Bronx river an important step toward a healthier river sam hope capstone fall 2018 | ira stern | leonel ponce

Transcript of an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains...

Page 1: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Mapping outfalls in the Bronx riveran important step toward a healthier river

sam hope capstone fall 2018 | ira stern | leonel ponce

Page 2: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

agenda

sustainability of clean waterBronx RiverBronx River alliancecontamination in the riverClean water actcase studiesmapping outfallsPreliminary findingsapplicability

Page 3: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

sustainability of clean water

Clean water bodies • Provide ecological services• prevent the spread of disease• promote recreational uses

One NYC• healthier harbor by improving water

managementUn sustainability goals

• #6 clean water and sanitation• #14 life below water

Page 4: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

sustainability of clean waterclean water promotes other initiatives of the Bxra

• education• Recreation• ecological restoration

the bronx river plan • “an ecologically healthy river system...

supports economic strength, public health, recreation, and a high quality of life for communities in the watershed”

Page 5: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Bronx river

¯0 2 41

Miles

Site MapBronx River

Bronx River Watershed

New York City

Bronx/Westchester Border

Tuckahoe

The Bronx

Mt Vernon

Valhalla

White Plains

New York City

Kensico Reservoir

182nd St. Dam

• The Bronx river is 24 miles long

• The watershed drainage area is 56 square miles

• Flows through 13 New York Municipalities

• NYC’s only freshwater river• Final 2.5 miles is tidally

influenced estuary • Was once considered as a

source of drinking water for NYC

Page 6: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Bronx river

1600 1800 19001700 2000

Mohegan Native Americans used Bronx River as hunting/fishing grounds

1600s European Traders used as a hunting ground for beavers

1639 Jonas Bronck bought the area surrounding the river from the Mohegans

1700s the river was used to power small mills in the area

1840 The New York Central Railroad was completed

1900s The Bronx River was used as a dumping ground for industry

1970 Beginning of activism around river. 2001 The Bronx River Alliance founded.

Page 7: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

The Bronx river allianceRegistered non-profit

• Works closely with NYC Department of parks

Governed by a Board of Directors• Appointed by each division of

BxRA

“Serve as a coordinated voice for the river and work in harmonious partnership to protect, improve and restore the Bronx River corridor and greenway so that they can be healthy ecological, recreational, educational, and economic resource for the communities through which the river flows.”

Page 8: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

The Bronx river allianceWorks through four teams

1. The Ecology Team leads river clean-up and restoration efforts

2. The Greenway Team is constructing a bike and pedestrian path the length of the river

3. The Education Program engages schools and community organizations

4. The Outreach Program works to attract community support

Page 9: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

The Bronx river allianceIn 2010 the Bronx River Intermunicipal Watershed Management Plan was published by the Center for Watershed Protection, Bronx River Alliance, NYC Department of Parks along with many other contributing organizations.

Introduced six causes of degradation to the river...

1. Disturbed Hydrology: causes runoff

2. Poor Water Quality: sewage contaminates the river

3. Aging Infrastructure: results in sanitary sewer leaks

4. Invasive Vegetation: limits ecological services

5. Degraded Habitat: diminishes diversity of flora and fauna

6. Dams: impede passage of fish and sediment flow

Page 10: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

The Bronx river alliance

¯0 2 41Miles

WQMS

kj Water Quality Monitoring Stations

Bronx River

Bromx River Watershed

New York City

Bronx/Westchester Border

Tuckahoe

The Bronx

Mt Vernon

Valhalla

White Plains

Kensico Reservoir

182nd St. Dam

kj

kjkj

kj

kj

kj

kj

kj

kj

kjkjkj

kjkjkjkj

kjkj

kjkjkjkjkjkj

kjkj

Project Water DROP

• Detecting River Outfalls & Pollutants

• Water Quality Monitoring Program

• Participants take samples at the same location every other week

• Testing for bacteria that indicated sewage pollution in the river

Page 11: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Contamination in the riverEnterococcus

• Fecal Indicator Bacteria (FIB)

• Enterococcus itself is not harmful

• Acceptable levels in recreational waters• 104-501cfl/100ml marine water• 61-151cfl/100ml fresh water

PROs1. Marine and fresh

water

2. Cheap

3. Easy

CONs1. Occurs naturally

2. Effected by runoff

3. Effected by presence of animals

Center for Disease Control and Prevention

Page 12: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Contamination in the river

US Environmental Protection Agency

CSOs• Combined Sewer Overflows

dump into waterways when rain overwhelms the system

• Bronx River only has CSOs in the City limits

MS4s• Municipal Storm Sewer

Systems are stormwater systems that are separate from the sanitary sewer systems

• MS4s are located in Westchester County

Page 13: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Contamination in the river

Page 14: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Contamination in the riverIllicit Connections

“Any connection to the County’s MS4 system unless it has been approved by the Commissioner of Public Works” – Westchester County Code of Ordinances

BxRA suspects that high levels of contamination is coming from;

• Faulty Infrastructure

• Leaky Septic

• Illicit Connections

Page 15: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Contamination in the river

Difficulties Abating Pollution

• Each municipality is responsible for keeping track of their MS4 system

• Current data on MS4 systems are outdated and inaccurate• 13 Municipalities

Page 16: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

clean water Act

• The Federal Pollution Control Act was enacted in 1948

• Clean Water Amendments of 1972 abated pollution through;

1. Federal grant program to construct wastewater treatment plants

2. Made the discharge of any pollutant illegal unless a permit is attained

Page 17: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

clean water Act

NPDES/SPDES• National or State permitting

process to discharge to waterbodies

• SPDES can be issued for an individual or group of point sources

• SWMP to reduce runoff “to the maximum extent possible”

Page 18: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

clean water ActLegal Action• Municipalities in

Westchester County are not complying with CWA

• EPA and Southern District of New York Attorney’s Office are suing Mount Vernon

• “Failed to comply with permit obligations... allowing raw sewage to be discharged into Hutchinson and Bronx Rivers”

Page 19: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

OutreachProgram

Project Water DROP 1. Monitoring Entero 2. Data Collection

1. Financial federal assistance for sewage treatment plants

2. Regulatory requirements for discharges

Mapping Bronx River Outfalls

BxRA

CWAPollution Abatement

Bronx River IMWP

1. Coordinate between Gov. and community groups

7. Pollution prevention at stormwater hotspots

6. Restore riparian buffers

5. Impliment wetland restoration projects

4. Invest in controlling stormwater run-off

3. Reduce discharges of raw sewage

2. Work with agencies to enforce regulations

10. Communicate regularly with partners and community

9. Coordinate monitoring and project tracking

8. Facilitate community education and involvement

Greenway Program

Ecology Program

Education Program

Happy, Healthy River

Page 20: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

Case studies

Case Study: Greenville, SC• Illicit Discharge Detection

Elimination Project

• Watershed spans over several municipalities

• Divided into manageable watershed study areas

• Survey techniques of outfalls and landscape around the river

Woolpert, Inc. Greenville SC Illicit Discharge Detection Elimination Project

Page 21: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

case studies

Case Study: Lake George, NY• High levels sewage contamination

• Monitored Enterococcus levels recreational beach

• Prioritized sub-basins

• Sanitary Investigation• Dye testing• Smoke testing• Camera Investigation

Lake George, NY Pollution Investigation Update June 2018

Page 22: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

interviewsMichelle Luebke: Director Ecology Team Bronx River Alliance

• Background on BxRA

• Projects they are focused on

• Capstone contributing to their work

Jonathan Tuscanes: GIS Specialist NYC DEP

• Creating a survey that produces useful data

• DEP watershed survey practices

• Creating a survey that can be used by others in the future

Page 23: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

mapping outfalls

Creating a Survey

Dry Weather Discharging is an indicator of illegal dumping

Page 24: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

mapping outfalls

Prepping for Fieldwork• Scope of surveying is

Westchester County

• Borrowed waders from BxRa

• Phone

• Tape measure

• Walk upstream

• Metro North Harlem Line • Cover two stops per day

• Plan around the weather/rain

Page 25: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

mapping outfalls

Page 26: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

mapping outfalls

Page 27: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

mapping outfalls

Preliminary Findings• 15 miles Westchester County

• 264 Outfalls

• 96% Closed pipe

• Majority concrete

• Steel

• PVC

Page 28: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

mapping outfalls3 outfalls

Page 29: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

applicabilityUpdated map of outfalls can be used inShort term;

• Data driven advocacy • Ground-truthing existing

outfall data• Additional testing at

descrepencies

Long term; • Identifying hotspots of

pollution for further investigation

Page 30: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

applicabilitySurveying Methodology• Tributaries that feed into the

Bronx River

• System for creating unique IDs for each outfall

• Data points to be collected about each outfall

• Base map that can be added to

Page 31: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

conclusion

Surveying and creating an updated map of outfalls:• Solves the gap in information

between current data and what exists

• Allow for BxRA and other organizations to continue working for healthier Bronx River

Page 32: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

thank you

Page 33: an important step toward a healthier river · 2019-01-24 · Mt Vernon Valhalla White Plains Kensico Reservoir 182nd St. Dam kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kj kjk kj kj kj kj kjkj kj kj

refrencesBronx River Alliance. Annual Report 2017. September 2018. Web. Accessed September 2018.

Bronx River Alliance. Ecological Restoration and Management Plan. May 2006. Wed. Accessed November 2018

Boehm, Alexandria B. Sassoubre, Lauren M. Enterococci as Indicators of Environmental Fecal Contamination. February 5, 2014. Web. Accessed September 2018.

Byappanahalli, Harwood, Korajkic, Nevers, Staley. Enterococci in the Environment. December 2012. Web. Accessed September 2018.

Center for Watershed Protection, Inc. Working Together for Our River : Bronx River Intermunicipal Watershed Plan. December 2010. Web. Accessed October 2018.

Department of Justice U.S. Attorney’s Office Southern District of New York. U.S. Attorney Announces Lawsuit Against The City of Mount Vernon for Clean Water Violations. June 28, 2018. Web. Accessed September 2018.

Environmental Protection Agency. Summary of the Clean Water Act. Web. Accessed October 2018.

New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. SPDES General Permit for Stormwater Discharges. January 13, 2016. Web. Accessed. September 2018.

New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Lake George Beach: Pollution Source Investigation Update. June 2018. June 2018.Web. Accessed October 2018.

The City of New York. OneNYC The Plan for a Strong and Just City. April 20, 2015. Web. Accessed October 2018.

United Nations. Transforming our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. October 2015. Web. Accessed November 2018.

U.S. Geological Survey. National Water Information System: Web Interface Bronx River at NY Botanical Garden at Bronx NY. Web. Accessed September 2018.

Westchester County Department of Public Works & Transportation. Application for Permit for Connection/Discharge to County Drainage System. Form SWP2011. Web. Accessed September 2018.

Woolpert, Inc. Targeted Watershed IDDE Investigations: Greenville, SC. Web. Accessed October 2018.