An appeal to the public: in a case of cruelty, inflicted ... on a cexid ofm3r=jaqux'bb, at t11e...

$: An appeal to the public: in a case of cruelty, inflicted ... on a cexid ofm3r=jaqux'bb, at t11e mapxie\v sciyool in fiawiline-st. by -cvm.clouci~~ browing tiie metikod and means made$
MFLICTED O N A C E X I D OF M3R=JAQUXbB

A T T11E

MAPXIEV SCIYOOL IN FIAWILINE-ST

BY -CVMC L O U C I ~ ~

BROWING TIIE METIKOD AND MEANS M A D E USE OF

BY A FEW OF BIR CLOUGIIS IARTIZANS

TO SUSTAIN I I Ih l I N OFFICE

AGAINST

THE WISHES OF TXIE IEOPLE

TOGFTIIER

WITII OTIX1R MATTER

-4s--

n O S T O N

PUBLISHED FOR TIIE IIXEFIT OF THE PUBLIC

1 8 3 2

TIIPla te decision o f t h e Sc~ool Conln~ittee and the injustice of tha t decision has induced rile to lay tile following pages before you I Ilavc two olbjectc in v i e w F i r s t in showing what c rue l barbarity has b e e n carr ied on in tlic Naylrcw School fbr tlic last two years under Iflr Clough-and secondly t o sllow tlrc ilielns t h e manne r and mctltod madc nse of by a Sew ooi 3rr(llougliu

t o sustain llirn in otficc aga i r~s t tlie wslres oi t h e people i n tha t district TVitli tllcsc o1jects i n icv 1 proceed with t he case of n OIL

P r e v i o ~ ~ qto the Mouitorial Sys lcm goi-ig into o ) c ~ a t i o r ~ my son mcnt to tllc Dernc-s t rcc t Sclool Grtcca o r eigll- ecen ~nontlis under tile inn1ruction of 3Ir ko)insor nuid Rir liitney-during illis tiinc Ilc u7as r evcr s t ruck a blow to leave a marlc by t l ~ c s c riiastcrs lie 1cnrit Ilorc rn t11~ first t l ircc montlis under tircse instructors ellail Iic did undcr Mr C lo i~g l l in one yelr llci~tlic boys syslenl vent into ope ratio^^ lie ~ J S tratgtsScrrcil to t h e

f i l a y l ~ e wScllool unde r RTr Clougli 11ctc re t~ld t o pass througli scncs of liurnilintion and dcgrnd~iior s ~ l c i i ns

being w l ~ i l ~ ~ ~ e c l a new rrrling (Slicok tiifor riot Setcliin day the olcl one was fillcci anti fi)r 11ct gciirig lilrcl ics-soris tha t n o boy could ge t ant1 n nurl~icr of lirinoi oKcnccs Tlc stood it from nlnntll to )110t1 1anti1 hi fatal day arrived that almost scaled his ire-On tlt ti^ Ile was re i ld i~ig and calnc to tlre wovtl cl~~ictc~iickind could not pronounce it t he boy liad i~~r~ziitrcntnn i ~ his s p e e c l ~ (born s o ) h e was s c ~ tu p l J r r Cloi~t~ and bent I I ~ s tarted ou tthis in l~nruan lnnn until tlo ilicii

of his back through tlriclc clotllcs Ilow tllc boy g31

home I could not conceive Ilr co111Jhard ly s t a n d Cbn I

e n t e ~ i ~ ~ gr i le I ~ o i ~ s c II( j r is t rnlclr out t o i n fo rm his motIlcr [ ~ i l i c vcd t l ~ c rilisttr woi i ld ki l l 11in1 I ar r i ved

honic soon n i i c r and t i le firit oljcct t i l i l t came to my was rlry wi fe nt tcgtrnpt i~lgt o ~t lmnister some medi-

c ine to cool his Ilccr~tccl I)lclz t l i c srcne ivi ls tlistrcssing

to my IitrriIy-as soon ~ s1111 bny cori i t l speak so as to

t e l l i v l ~ o c l i t l it I stirtod to l i r l t l J l r C l o t ~ g h resolved to

t iavo ~csengc 0 1 ~ ~ c l i lt hi i r t l i c aitctr11~t I wls soon at 1

tilt s t l ~ ~o lIir~rrst lnd rnct I I)oy c i ~ i ~ l i i l g out of the yarcl

1 i r ~ e ~ ~ i i r r ( liS 3Ir (IIJII~II WIS i r ~t l ie S~IJOO t l ~ eboy said

i l e 11icl 1~ielt gcilic iI)oiit t v n r ~ i i r ~ i i t c s 1 cnrnc l tac l i and atternl~icel t o cu rily t i i r i r icr 11rit rliy aicfite was go l le on r e l l c c t i t ~ p ~rrd t l ~ i r i l i i i ~ g I f(iv i ~ ~ i i ~ i i i c s Imndc u p rny m i n d to t ~ i ~ ~ ot l ic~course-t11lt conrsn I itnvc pursued

to t i le gt-rst ~~t time i n ~rnrrilsItir~g arid cxi)osirig I c rue l

and c i i ld ic t ivc ~ n t s t ( r - c t ~ ~ ~ l ~ y to s ~ I ~ o l i ~ r s u ~ l l l e a r d of in nrodcrri tirl~c~ I Iirroiv ortrr) CLSC ( C Y C C ~ ~a case o f D 3fr Arrinlcl i n Xe~-f11111~1~I i i r ( ) i t s c x ( 1 1 i i l

Illc ltli ly o f in ~cs t ig i t io t l ~rr~vccl l l i n t t he Schoo l

C o n ~ r n i ~toe 1sLa t o cs~r~l i r~c rrry casc w i t h a numl ter of

otl iers i t c)ccti~)iccl sevcr ~ l licitroorls bu t a n r ~ r n b c r

o f p u ( ~~ ta~ s o ~ i l e lnot co r~ io i ) r v ~~ d t l ~ c y s ~ i t l t l iey shou ld

get n c satiiIicriiri [rorn tile sc l io r~ l ci)riiniiltcc(too rr i ly j

M r Cior ig l i i~rn~rlrt n t iu r r i l~cr oI I)ojs i r l h i s dcfcncc-

I f I c111 t ~ i i c l ~ ~ r ~ t ~ ~ ~ i c l IIII~III~~IICYal l l o a boy gave

their -vitItiric Ilrorc rg~irlst hEr C l o i ~ g I ~ tlrln in l i i s favor

T i l e m i ~ r l i ~ r ~ roftile cllss n c l i r ~ o ~ v l c ~ d g c dthat r r ~ y son

cou ld riot sliirtci t ivo I e t ~ c r s i n t h ~ t ~vo rd li s c c o ~ l dboy ac lltno i l ( dgc~~ lI ~ e f ~ i ct l l c l ~ r ~ ~ r t l t l iat 111yson was a re-

marka l l i c good l ~ o y -a tllii-(1 ~ t l t l ILIII~II tnsnercd t o tho

8al71C ~ I I I~ [ ) I I I ~L~ N o i v for the s i ~ t i s ~ i i c l i o ~ io r the p ~ ~ b l i c

1 w i l l g i ve MI CIo~ig I i s story I lc says I le to ld tilo boy t o ca l l t l ie ict tcrs arld h e r c i ~ c a f c d l y cal led them

Alld ccccntly four I~urrtlrecl citicn+ as cpcciiijle as any i l l tile city havc I~ctiiior~cci 1) I l i ( gt liiis ( V l l I(-

rrlovetl About t i l l tilrle 01 tlii lrst act of t l i t tlrii u n

my sorl you ccllrlcl I~arilly e11tcr a httcc1 I ti( st 11art ot thc city nrilllout I l ~ i c l i n ~~riorc o r I c ~ s coii)iiii~i~ agaillst tliis rlnu 8Iotl1cis ccl)iiil over i i c x i r lt~i~j-itlgs

laccraictl Ljiicks jlrijiig 111 secct iliirt I- niniici l i ~ ~ l

I lv i l l i ~ o ~ v 11crs tiici l o suu-eunitii~c sltiilgtc of t i ( tail] fi11Cloupii i l l liis oilicc 1 X I I I to d~ i i i i l ~ ~ l c ~ SIJYJ

out Iit 1 III to stao is i 1 c3 l i ~ ~ C X -dc~tc rn~i i~ed tiiis isted JIr Jlltlnicl I U I - L ~ ( L Coil-slicl LcLr( trc S(loc11 rniicc t l ~ ~ t C O l i ~ ~ iIlc sl~ould rcslr(t to iiiivc gtr I ~ I I O V -

ed cry ~ I I L I ~ Iii~cl~c(i co~~si( icrcdi i~r l ~ c II~is ~~~t i ( r s real csfitc it~l iisci~ fic Ier cci~t i i i i l~ic siicxc 3Ir Clougir cirllc lo tiriii clool ll ~c~icr lrirc1 oI111is sys-

tell1 oi i~is t ruct io~ is ((1 Lcrielitrl~crc cruticy ~)i~ci[i ~i tilose i l l rfiIuc~ice Iliis ~ i i i ] i c ail-~or~tIcii~ir s ~riil~tl peared to IIC to be aOs11lb~ti li i i l l ~ciilis rcxi citie N(gtv tlrc ~vritcr of tiiis i11 CLIXII)II ofy a i t l ~a ILI~)c~ otllcr plc~rts (lo 11rctctt ii i I l l gt ~ soici~~ tilaliner ag~ilisi lingtiiig our cI~ilcciis l)icls liccricd i i j the

maliner 11cy liave bccn f i~r tlrc jilirilogte o i riiiii he valuc o r rtiil esttltc to L)ciiclit ~ l r c ricir 3 c x t ci)rrcs 9 3 r ParB~ii l ~ e r~idc a strrnu~ls clbt t o slitii~ hlr Clougir i11 so11citiig nnlircs I wiil nciliori wiit toolt

place wit11 a liv 1l1it lie crIictl rijiuil-li cziltcl it olie place il l a grcat ~ I L I I I ~ a l ia)~r i ~1is iiiii lid r i t l l stiys BTr---I w~irt yori 10 [itit your 1inltc to ilii tire gentltgtmc~nI)cir]g i)iiy--llicr gt wort1 or lvo I sii~cd i t lino~villg I~irx to be n rc~i)cctnlgtc Bll~cn tiliv gcrlr~iii~~ ger~ t ic r i~n i~ n ~ i dcnrllc to liilov vlllt tlic Drs oJ(lit IS

the prllport o f liit ~)iier11 fi~1 t l ~ilrto 1usc and dernttn 1 his 1liirlc Iror~ that pai~c rigtI iiriels the D o ~ t o rto mtIi( us( ol l~ i s natrie in any lnarilicr or siipu

I

7 4

i i s i T i l e E7i goes t o ~ n a t I ~ c rpincc ]is Ken-

tlculalls 1i111grligr as lilis 1)r ~ I I ~II XI ) lave~ o u collie t o ~ I I ( l~ l Ol lg 1 1 ) ~ iort ( I I I I C I I ~ I I V 112~lgt~il( l l~~ l t~ q my c y r s lrnvc Y I gt ( I I 1iiit J l r CIOIIIIis 11cit I -italc r11ln to Itccl) III sili(ol 11r1t n tisg~cc to t l ~ c r i ~ i i o goes t i aii)tli~ a~tl 11c i ~sct ~ed tliat n l r Cic1itg11was not l i t to Ile a l ~ ~ j gt t i lt r l l i i itall( I ( ii h l r in F L ~ S

C1011glt I I I I I ~ 0 1 ~ 111yI J ~ I ~ Y C T S I I( clki 31 r Ja-l ~ ~ t ~

q~ii i l l s cl~il i l ~ I C v ) I I ~ ICIIl ~ i t ~ I I P i ~ lt ) ts o t11 s I lt ~ L I ~ bc able to go trii cl11is 5lilc ~ i t o t ~c rr~l~iscclLo singt

urilcss tlrc coiiiIiic~tis crl t o ~ct~icvcli ir~ouf itic c i ty 211csc rte t i ~ c ~IIJII(~s to tiit or~ ~ c I I 1 ~ liy a kw tklc l l l l ~oi - t ll~t~ g O i l i x t t I ~ l l l oilly-or~ I ~ ~ I I I i ) ~IILI C

se l f ail4 rrccivcd tllc aiiineis tilut c rc gic~l t o 110 Jgtoctor irrtl t l ic co~icnit sIo~~i t o t he olJct for llnlf the ic I)iitir i3 t8igtliil h l r Ci j~il~ illso c~t ronnrl ill tlic silatl of llic c-siiii~ itti L ]n)er i t ] l i i j Itnild to ~ o i i c i ti ~ i ~ i ~ ~ ~t t o l i i t ~ ~to s a y t11iy sl ioi~ld I(

C I I I I I I ( I ~ S011 tliis it sj~lts iLi ilsell--ouly tiiat Ilc got d i su l i igto i~~ tcd sirtric D o oi M r irl llltcs citllt tile 1 3 n r l i ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ sany ciiidrcll to tlic JIu~tzu ~ 4 c l ~ o o l sciitl 4 n s KO

I will now c r n ~ ~ i t c or rcTcr to n picco in tile innston Iatriot iignctl ii C i t i zc i~ (I ictiiiois ~ ~ a r i i c - a s ~ a ~ ~ i ~ ~ - i i I i ~ ~

when i t is t~ir(Ii~ 11011cr I I I ~ L I I S this wri-c ~ ~ i ~c t c r ) te r says 1111t to oi t l ~ c cor~~iri l t ce m c u snitl tiiat tho i n on 1 I I ~ I ~s o 1 1 I I I I I XOW if t ~osc two l11c11 t l i c l ~y so tlirji silid t11rt 1v11ich was not t rue f i)r tllcy 11ei~id tilt t c ~ i ~ l ~ o ~ r y i l l givcri 11y a rc-6l)onsil~lc rlitn tlilt tile blootl was oozi1g G I I ~ollris bacli and the 1)oys ririct ~ s i ~ c u olFtilnt ~ i i g l ~ t sput-tiilltc~l IS

ted rvil~ l~lootl Ti to only co~lr~r i i t tcc 11iri1111lt cvcr saw

my sons Lincic J I r ~ l ~ l o s t l o ~ i g were aitd 9Ir E~aersoa

14id these ga~~ l l l cmcn calculnle to irn~c~cl n ~ ywilncsscs or dicl tllcy itltcrrcl to i~ils otlrer urcu~ers ill tlic Lintil tie-

cision by rnaltiirg such n stltcrl~cnt I I I ~ V C r1o apology to ~ n a i i e to cit l le~ of t l ~ c s e gel~l ler r icr~ tlity wtro parti- zans oi 1111C l o u g l ~ Yllen cacti of tlrcil~ Iliti cotni~liitrts rnadc to t11ct11 of ampI Clouglla cluclty lrotn i~ i i~ l i t l lto mollt11-wlint (lid tllesrj trvo gcntlciilen do to s t o l ~ such cruelty M r A r ~ ~ l s t r o r ~ g 3Ir Irrrpp i i itold t l ~ e c i ~ s c of l ~ i sclliid tlrat h e would s top it--t111t nits ill lie did do A nuurbcr o l cascs occurred aftcr-1 nii n ~ c ~ i t i o n n few o the r stitcrnerits councctcd nil11 tIrtsc trvo conlirriltce men It was su1111oscdby jutlicious [crsc~ls tlllt X r Elncrson would not conscrrt to starid br a r~civ c lcc t ion i t seenls Ilc (it] and tlie gc[itlcrrtan icccivetl il)out ~ l i i lc ty votes o u t o r titcc or fbui Iiulidrcd-so rrlnil1 fLr being ussociiitc~l witll M r C ~ l o u g l ~ i l l r i2rnritroug vas n cnri- d idate for tile Legis la ture tile escitcrrlclit i l l Xa1d 5 was so g rea t tgaillst I~ i in tlrat Ile rcccived iS I iltistlio not n little over GSty votes ~v1ic1e Jic c~ircc olt i i ined th ree o r 7vi1r liuutired 1 cvrile ~lorv to I L I O I ~ I ( I pcrson (Mr C l o u g l ~ was put Iris trurups t ~ i ~ d to four~d Iiirnscll tottcritlg lie 11ad ~ n e n to n o r k towards t l ~ e i io~t l r part of t h e city cndcnvorirrg to ~ r o c u r c tiariics)--ll Illcll BTr T l ~ o l l ~ a s (ivllo scnd3 n o1 3 a l 1 1 ~ ~ cl~ildrci to tllis s~ o I ) R gent1cmln tl1tt ~~ lcdc l i c swit11 lobodjs business to show tile i ~ ~ f l u c r r c c of tiiis tnnn at tliat section of tlro city 1113acknowieilgctl to tne bclrc w i t ~ ~ e s s c s t 1 1 ~ t lie t l i d go rourld ancl procured tllrce ivllolo naoles ibr -$itC l o ~ ~ i A fciv o ther st ~tcnients aird I will close tllc su11jict of

cruel ty A ampft S~nliicl11til L son beat 2t this s c i ~ o o l with a r aw cow I~it le a u J cu t u p froin Ilia s i~oul t less t o his l e g 11 M r TotIliill Iliitl a soit cu t L I ~ J wit ) a r aw COW Iliile rrom his neck to his lilclcs in tilc saiiic s c l ~ o o l and wiat as to l~is l les eve ry ollc I liavo coavcrsed with

is thc trifling oflcnces coinmitted 11y said h o y s - E o ~ ~ seven ycal-s old 11i1rc bccn ivlil)pcd so tlley colild not lay on their bicls aiid lroiv tllcrc a r e n k w (hut a s~nn l l 1)ait of tllc co~nrnlnily it liirg() llrat want to su5- tail] Dlr C I I I L I ~ I I a~icl v i r~di~ t ivc ill all Ilis irt~jt~st c r i~cl ty Shame or] joii--ti clisgr-ac~to tlic ngc it( l i c in and a stain on olr oncc ftitrled city or our free scllools

I ~ v i i l1ow 111ovc to 11iy illlpnitial nliir M r C l o u g h ~ rulgrity i i l rlic-rlaniirig sci~ol lrs 341sSIiI(r split a son to tliis sclioo Mr Cloligii i i icl i- l~~~letl Iiini Ilnslinu wilh iiro l r ~ i l s tllo boy I)ecl~re ciissatisficd i n I)(iig clIlcd so and 3rs S la tcr vrs obiictl to tile lirr s o n array

M r Ea r l lint1 I soli t l ~ a t nis called Co~ciclampgtnrl t he boy wts very rnuclr agriiist goin to sclruol to I( ~ i i c k -nalned Ijy tlrc rnistcr 11111111 l ~ a d to t a k e Iris son away $I 1$11rlreclcIIILI n soti n l~r~cs l l ~ y titis g rca t instructor d _ I ~ ~ ~ ~ r i z ~ ~ ~ - l ~ c i ~ ~ L l c ~ ~ - - i t boysworltctl ui~orl tile fcclirlg to srcIr a dcg rcc tlrrt lc told liis nlotilcr Irc did not vtrit to o to Stliool ally more Iiis n)tllcr ttrlcl him to go to sil)oi xlid if tire rnaiir csllvd l r i l l i Iliirncr-Iilndlc I I I ~ I ~ I O I C l l i ~ l ~ [lot to alivCr t l ~ c 1)oy I V C I I ~ and in n day or trvo RIr Clougli cnllcd l l i r i i out by t he name of ~ I ~ I I I ~ I ~ ~ ~ - I I ~ I ~ C ~ I ~ 110 i~isvcr 1 ~ ~ s giver] lie callcd him again nrltl igiiri rio arismcr Blr Cloilglr ~ t lvu r~ccd tn-

wards l~ i rn a r ~ d said ~ 1 1 y do111 you airsv(r r~rc-lIi~t is not nly lillrio Yil--r~~y t I l O ~ l l ~ I tolil llle i f y o ~ l calletl me harn~~~o-hni t l lc to I f t l l i s is notrgairl riot $rlswrr yo11 a meall illld dirty ac t i l l iiicllt-nnrr~illg cliildrcrl call it what you plcasn I ni o11ly rnclrtion otic ou t R~JIJL~ of a nilnrbcr--Cotl~c up Ilcre y r ~ u I f c ~ l r y Tlllrr and I will ticiltlc yourfi ir 1111s mould se t tile boys a Iiuoh-ing atid tl~orr sonic of tlrclrl mould ge t n trcr-rrerrdous floggi~lg S I I C ~ Itistory of two y e a r r is il pirt o f I~ 1 ~ 0 i t at the Illrlyliew Scliool

Possil~lysomc of tliesc cllnrgcs may bc ngnirlst Xl r C u p c h

P I )

A ease 51lilrs BinncYs 1 will mention far the bcncfil otti public it ore iiard upcn t ~ v oI c I ~ R Irs iil~ncys

l rns j ~ i d a ~ c t lto s tay 11 oic 011 nccrlrl of I l l u r i ~ ~

sett ict l i r i [is Icp iivc oi six ~ lt ( 5 lilc n w ~ l i tto

sclrrol ailill ltltI 2(i SOJJlr (gt lt)L~~ l i i ~ ~Iiy I$

lgtljg t ~or~~lt--t l~tgt110y i( id lii a 7 J ltgtI($ (gt SC~I

t I i i i ig lvay y(it tlwir to T s i l i i ltti 1vlc1 gl~jip y01r old c011iti ~i~c~~r jI I ~ ~ C gtiorlg

rrrl iiilclclcd as a tli_iic( I I Igt tltl ily nrls

allis t l l ~ ta Ciilndlcr 1oy iir tii I ] Cliit ad 1v1iipccl soilc t i i~iniicc ( 7 r~ ( r lt~ro i ir [gtlilaclcts piicc frol t l ~ oj ~ - r s j i iitcl t i

I ) i rs J3ickicy i 3 i I -iiidcij gtLCili

r0 ro~cid IV~L I tliis ~ J I ~ Iii I i i I blt- lt gt t lt ~ t 1 will iiot tuclticil licrc ltj1)~ gtIlt lt 1 ~ O L Y i ~~ I gt I C T1

cilc]i f~cflllc~~lt I o r - i c c 1 ii)iili3s $ l iei 1

ca~ io t c o i ~ c c i i c t o 01 bill i a LO tl

r-g1iiliy o fp i I t i ~g I I V O ~ I ~ I1) SI t ) I ( I) i i i ~ r

c i i i~ l re ~tit scIi1111IS I[ Lti lto I I P

tic ~( i i ~bi i~i aiist (isi i~+t~ i ( tltr~ ~ I ~ S C c4I iccgt~ ~ ~i ty ~ t i 110

is ltigi~ I[ 1 ~~gtibttgt lt 2 a ~ l dL I O ~ i-~(I s t i ~ i c l 11iil ttc poiiv ~r c l ~ - t i ~ l s - ~ l ~i i i ~ t l ~ r c W z jc not in gtI oi( 2

a j i d t o

l e ~ ~ v c to prcvit a l ( ~ t ~sr1aii j

- --- Z I S ~ ~

a Ccv -~tt o cri~n jil ( l t q ~ i t~- U J ~ y ~ $ 2 I

that clistrict zgtrir-L i ~ wii t b ~ a ~ ~ J ~ ~ ~- 7

I I I I I i i lt i l l Ui-

li c ~ ~ r i t yto clicirgt--~~~~~i f i J t 1 1

coirqiiitclt t i ~ ~ tvcll 0 1 1 l i gt c I lt i( ~vp t t t

diytn u r ~ L I ~ C I I lc lt q

J it Airavay fcti

C l o ~ r ~ i i ss o i c r c ccici -a i-amp

f il at1 csainiiinliolr n -it i t tiii i r ~ ~ ~ I sub-corn[nittcc a c i gt i ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i i t t ( gt c iro 7Gis ~(gt I I A ~)I 11

j 8W-nls~E s q ntla~1~1c 2 1 - a ~td+aa ic~l

p ~ ~ l i ~ l c i l Gozct te about sllaltirrg tile bai-in th f Eison

l o t boxes ovcr 11catl Fuch allusions before n comtrlittec to 1lclr tcsticry i iirr r hat1 taste n l r I-clis 1 did not supigtoc)a nou1J go out of your corlrsc of d u t y to hit 111c it srit a litllc CI(iigilisl~ but I call assure you I

gto~riil tar Lo Tt-3rd (5you uil1 feel tl1c ef-

feels ol t l ~ c lot 1oscs 011 t11c iirst election I presume if y o u 11ti a ciiilil l(kit by 9 i r C l o u g l ~a s bad a s I kinve

you ~IIIlt )c foirrid oil rile o t l ~ c rsidc oitlle Iiouse D o you ~e~ltillllti ~ l l i l kL ililli bcfb1e t h e genclal corn ~ n i t t c e1iI iil tlt iufir an co121d not ge t any jug-t i cc l)eibica SrIio)I C(iii~ii(c 1 nili to ask tlie com-niiinity oilo clac~slioii31r~~gto~ir~ Otis ort l ~ cI t o n X11 my r ~ c r i i ~ ~ ~ l ~ r 5 I Ycilt1sq 11(1 1lcl n c l~ i ldf i i ( 111i~

bent Ilt i r k i ~ ~ gt is 1iri ils oiie prcnts I-c-r+ro~i(lt n i r Cl l~cL c c ~ lIticLcd o u t of ~ r ~oc i

witlicti L j ~ ~ T

igtc ~ICLlt

lt icuriciv ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~ l c n nrcibct o r io W ~ I 1 3 0 1ilci

Co111111itttc I A (gtti tIi ycliiiol siltnc( by 1icar h u t -f i u ~ ~ d r c dcitigt v i ~ ~ it o tl~i oC7-z~l n-8tr~cl ~ f l r i i lt I lt ~ I c it O L I ~ ~ t o ii(L ~ Y lt -ltI t~-

der i t t i - I 1 c lty 3 ~ L I k t

1 Oly 5jlt) v ) ~ gt i i a lti)gti lt [I z v c r in lli O Y ~ gt ~ ~ c t gt r L g 11 i l 2 a c[i-

t i o l ~ ~ ~l) c i - 1 L S V ~ I t p~ I i icy~ I

fii f i- lt lt 1 I 1s

coriiii - B t lt i t c 362$it

Raj 1 ~ 1 -gt gt )s i

A lt - 2 i I i 3 i

i 1 3 - lt lt -Lr7

ci31i

8 r-a ~ - - - - ~- A lt q 1 lt- - 1o f r

Uatilcr t T p c l lt 6 t c lt- c tLtt 1

crrcot be ~ a ~ ~ t i

1 applied to ~ l d c r m a n Russel l a few days after the investigation had closcd Inr llis 1)rivafe ntilrs t aken wheu tlle witlicsses were c s a n ~ i i ~ c d N r I i u s ~ c l l ob- ~ e r v c d tliat Ire put Ifis Rotcs irrto his dl-aivcr and a day o r ttvo a f t e r ]le went to Iooli for thcrn but fliey were gone I icave it to the public to juclgc Ilow tliose No tes disallpcurcd out of Mr Russells dl-awcr 1ct it be re-merr~lleted that hldermnrl Russell voted ngrir~st ampIr Clouglls cruelty as it detcrrnincd by n iew o f Mr C l o ~ ~ ~ l r sptrtizans t11at no record slrould be fur~nd here- afler of this irlvestigation K B P e r h a p s it is lot

gencr i~l ly known tllat each AAltle~n~ari a privateIlnvc drawer in t h e Mayor and A l d c r l n a i ~ ~ room

T t r e following i s a copy o f a let ter s cn t to Mr E m e r -aon respect ing iriy son-he was t h e Cllairtnan o f t he sub- comrnittce o f Mr Clouglis scliool

BOSTONOCT 11 1831 Nt-E l ~ t e ~ s o n

D e a r Sir-I shall declixle to mcct t h e School com-mittee to-rrrolrow a s l)rc~l)oscd by yon I have o n e or trvo reassr~s-first if nly son is n o better to-trlorrow than h e has Icen to d ~y h e rvill not be ablc to attend I am afraid 11e llas tal icn cold to day llis back arid s l~ou l -ders a r c very stiK) a i d illy follrs a1 th is mornelit are batltirlg Ilirn

I wish to ask i f y o u have not had complaints enough already against t h e s ame person for his s avage barbar i ty to children and what docs it avail-Ilas this monster in human slinpe been renroved No 1Ils tile sc l~oo lcorn-mittce deigned to mnlie any ccnll~laint to him in person M r A r n ~ e t r o n g yes terday and yourself to day liad evi-dence by my sons back of his siivage cruelty T h e in-dignation in th is neighborliood for h is cruel ty to m y son

is g rea t and the tirnc 1 tlriuli ha s nrrivcd t o c ry alo~rtl for j~ r s t i cc T h c r e is n sc~nc nkicrc tliat ~ cs[~o~ls i ) i l i ty has been rrcglcctetl ntld il ttlc1e is n o low to protect eclrolar-s against iris [lrIr Clorlgli] btuliIity I nil nfl~cxl to tlrc colrirr l~~r~ity it 1al i ~ ibr ~cdrcss

4esl~cctSi1liy yours BlOSKS JAQUITII

Rca JIr JSII ICYSO~

JCstract from n lct tcr ivrilcn by my son onc llundred and tltiriy n i i l c ~ frorn th is city to liis oldest s i ~ t c r

I attcntl Piclrool every day-tlie joys all liltc tlre mns- tc r lic dont beat tllc 11oqs a s 3I r C l o u g l ~ clid

file fc~llowing Pcti i ion was rcccntly scnt in to have 3 l c s~ i - s CIIIII nritl Capcll re~llovcil sigrlcd by ilenr four IiijntI~cd citizeni

i h e urir1crsiglctl ilrl~abitr~tsof tlrc City of i los lon fully ~ ~ l r cc i r t i r l g tile vxst irnl~ortaricc of tlic systcm of

public cdricrrion nrd ficlirig a tlccp irrtercst i r ~t l ~ c l ) r ~ i ~ l i c b ~ l r o ~ i s tlint t l ~ c public ofilie ci ty 1)rg lcae to rc t~~escr i t Will trld scnllncils irr ~ c I ~ t ionto tileir i i ~ ~ t r n c t i o ~ ~ slloiltl 1)c consulted I ~ n v c its proper ~ rc ig l r t aritl irl- f luer~cc It is a l l - i r r~ j l c~ i ln~~ t tile Mcrl clroscn totlrnt p tcs idc ovcl tlrcsc Sc~~iilarics sli(~iiltl 11c l r ~ c r ~ o r talcrtts ant1 of virtue--7Irt i1icy ~lro~iIdLe Iii~ninrrc jutlicicn c apn l~ lc and ccry n-I- cllialilicd t o fill ~ I I C P C s t i t i o~ i~ Arid bclievirrg tlrat tlic c o i ~ r s c ltctctc~Sore ~ ~ l i v s i ~ c d 113 trc 1)rcscrit I n s t r~ rc ro r arid Iris i l ss is tnr~t o r tlrc R l a y l ~ e ~ r hcliool a r c r ~ c i l ~ c r no~ j l id i~io t l s toI L Z O ~ ~ C L I L ~ nor suclr a s eiltitle tlrern to tire r c s l ~ c c t o f I of ihc in-11ige ~ i u i ~ ~ e r Iiabitarits and cxcrcisiirg tllc riglit to rcmoistralr W Q

do v n o ~ c s ~ longer in o f i ce against their be ing c o n t i ~ ~ n e d and pray they rnay be rerliovcd accordingly

Fritlccy Vozcl~jber 18-Ttie 13onrd proceeded upon tile coilsitleration o f t h e subjcc l of tile accusa t io~ i s against I1Iessrs Ciortglr ancl Capcn mas l e r and sub-nl~ter of tlic R lnp t~cw Scliool llie followir~g motiori was n ~ a d e i)y nrr Viliiarns

u12csolued A s tlie s ense of this Board thnt unclcr c x - istifig C ~ T C I I I ~ I S ~ ~ ~ J C ~ ~ S t he public i t~ t c re s t s r rq~ i i l e the re- nlov~l o l l l ~ c master and otthc assistant o r s~~b-m t s t c r of tlic I$Iayliev School from t l ~ e i r respective stations anci that tiicy be riotilied fofoltlr~itll of t he p i s s ~ g eof this rc-soi~vc

E c v M r Ganne t moret l tire follo~ving nrnerldrncnt to etliltc out all tile mortls afier 1Pesolvcc1~ arid in licu t l l r rcot to ilracrt tile fullcrugting viz

Yliiit a l ic r a long atid pa t i rn t examination of t hc 01com~~lai11ts u b n l i t t ~ d I)y tile ~iicrnoralists and

cjtilcrs gaitt I l r Clorrgii th is colnrnit t t ~do not find s~ficicil i rclron t o dismiss liir~i from of ice

At tiic s a i r~e tirnc tliey tliirrii projler t o cspress to I r i r r l tiro~ill tigt Clrailmnn tha t h e has in tlreir opiuion cxcced rd tiic I~ount ls of t h e jutlicious exercirc of nu-

Liiority intcliccd to b e conkrrcc l by 31-ticlc 6 cilnp I PC ltL

A c1iciion of tlic question be ing ~ c r l r ~ i r e d also tlic ycis ard i-inys tile qestion was talrcn rlpon tile ntloi~-t i i ~ i lci tiic Crst paragrapll of t he ~ l~ oposedar l ic l ld i - i i~ i~t~ and it was clccidctl in t1e aflirrnativc

- C U S - - ~ ~ ~ S ~ I gt Br tns t rong BcltOtii MClcnrp Iliiry l l ~ r ~ i s Sirectol Sllipley Enlerson Ytliu Sic verlsoil C i a i ~ t ~ c t t ~ and lia1es-13

~~vrjs--31essrs Oliver l lusse l l Lit t le TYilliams a u d 1Ia11-5

~ ~ l d c r i i l i t r ~Oliver made tllc folionling niotioli wiiic11 was r t~ i t laid ordcrctl to be laid on t l ~ c triilc

O~~l-rti plinisl~nicritT l i a t t h e 1)lacticc of corlioral I )c I i~rc i r tc r dil~c~rsctl ~vit l i arid t l ~ a t111 icg~ilitic~is01

tlic sc~ool coii~rliittcc I I O W in force iliconsiitcut ~ v i t l t tii2

orclcr he aitd t l ~ c slrlre iicrcliy a r c rc)calcd Adjoriiiictl to Yctlncstliy liext 3 P 81 111 tlic comri~it tcc ycstt lrday tlie hbrdcr proposed iig

Ald~i111ii Oliver was s~ibtn i t tcd t o a col~iiittco

631111c t i i i r tcc t~ tiiat voted to rctain 311 C l o r ~ g ~ sorne Irnvc b(cn L I I I I ( ~ uut ofoilicc by tlie pcoplc arid cti lels i i i~vc rcig11((1

TIICillovit~g is froin tiic U o i o n C a z c t t c oSitrunry JG32 AitiorrgIt tile iv1iicr l t ~ r i ~ t dcsigiitctl ic Scllooi I 1ivc asccttirii~ed it is agiiist filress~i Glorigli a ~ t t l G n p r n o f tlrc 3lay1~v Scirool a n c l tllc nullor i i~

niill o f ~ c s l ~ o ~ l ~ i i r c stnnciitig in tllc coirirli~~t~iy-ILe iilr s i l l e ~tilrcn his citild aivLy i i o ~ n tliat S ~ i l o o l

OC71 ILriSblC SCTPOOLS

O n e of t l ie firhl aild I ~ I O ~ ~ i l ~ j c e f ~inji(~rtal~f t o ~ i i ~ i c i i tllc at tcr~tioii of t t t~ r r i t l v City G O ~ O ~ I I I I I ( I I ~ wi Oc ciie(l is (]at trforir Pi~l)ic Sciioois Jhc rrriiv(rsi~ (iiltcotlti~t a)( tlisiiisiltction of t l ~ c c i t i zc t~s sliow illat llc slii1jtlt tlcinarltls iir~inctliil( i l t c~ l t i o~ t Pliey tsaiit it cast two nr1oic coi~i~ctcirt t c l c l~c r s irr each o f t i~c Q r i~ l~ ~~ r r scliotlis --oir 1)oy tcrcIiinr a t ~ d nornl govcrrtrilc~t nrllou~it i o notliitig nlrl vorsc t11iri r ~ t ~ t i ~ i i ~ g 41oys nre i icot~~~ecii t to tliis tlrllt--tiicy m i ~ y licar a lessor rccitcd u ~ l d o rtlie supwlvisioti of a ~ ~ ~ l s t c r t l ~ c y a r c unfit to tlclertnine b u t w l i c ~~a sc l~o la r is fittoil f i ~ s his stiilldii~ 111 t11c fiwL placc they 11rrle I vtst deal of tligt~ity to s i ~ ~ ) ~ ~ o r t - ~ l i u 1cist disrc~spcct l o 11y t ra i~l l ing t11e t l~crn is ~ ) u ~ ~ i s l i c d scioiar irllpetidilrg his progress ~ ~ i o s t i f i i n giiirn nitd

iccpit~g llitr~ back and I~rcalt ir lg tlatvn his courngo il

scl1111 is 11i1t )rrti~ittctl to rccilc i r ~sorrle of tlrc sollools accol t i t t~g 111 l l i i I~ook-littt i n I )irrcuiar l lo tie ~ I i i c l ~ tllcsc i i i ~ ) ~ as t l ~ e s c I~oy tfncll- di~cbct lrorrr (lily to tliy ~ t r t l

cr t ~ r y aliiioit evcry t l ~y I ~~ro i i i~ r~ t r cc~c lltit is t igllt to- d ~)- is vrilnA tto-l~t~rrov t ~ recrsi 11cxt (lily soatitl t11t Lsc11oltr wlro corilil rccilc a 1i101i a t orle tlr~c~i-ll l c s so t~ I I ~ S I ( T ~ I I l ( v l~ tot8er I j c i ~ r i t 1 tlis tliotI( cr~lil~g and r ~ i l ~ ~ l ~ t ~ i i r g fi0111 dny to ci~y Ilic s i i i ip i t i the n-111111i1to i ~ i ~ o t ~ ~ gt y i t ~ I i ir~-tc~dofis vcry i t ~ l~ititli i ~ i ~ j s 11ioi1 lirtl is rrr~cll rniirc extrarlgiiit l ~ c t l tlic aillount c t i t t ~ t r t t ( ~ t i o ~ ~ict~ i5 C O I ~ ~ ~ J I I ~ ~ I I

r 1I I r c t v ~ i l e r curl ~ t i ~ l c otic i t~ t i i l~cc of tllc nnrolt~ltand VLLIOof iti~trit~tioi of scIro(~1~A boy i1lJ i t 1 ( I I IC ~ J ( C

bcc11 tIrri~~iglr ll ~isd~ l l s tlrc t l l r o ~ ~ g ~(~ttcsti i~rls IIIIIIS ~ ~ L L I I I I I I ~ I I I ( I ~l1ttrr1pl1s c l - ~ I Is c c t i ~ ~ ~ o I C ~ J I ~ I I L ~ ~ I I S

i ~ i t l t t r i ~ t i ( l i r i v i ~ ~ ~ t s tlrk s r i c ~ i ~ l IIS )ecr~ ti) e~rtcri t~ 110

i i ~ c r c lt(ltl t (Ir~~irilli~r liiltt~l~ qtiatitrr~ i~~urt I I I I ~ I ~ I

r c t ~ t t lt ~ i ~r t t ~ ~ i t ~ ~ I I I ( ~i t ~ o t ye t I I I At i ~ r i~~ t j r r r r ~iccit i n C ~ t ~ ~ l i ~ i ~ r t ~ ~ ~ t~ul11~1 I I C J ~IIltltII to go~ r i l~ t i~ ( - t i c ~ ~ l o w c lt l I I I t i - 1 I I t oi1cc11 i i l lL~~cti I i t I I n a~oijt tit-co t i i t i i i cStilct I ~ I J I ti ti^^ tit I I ~ ~ I I I ~ ~ i t 1 ~ t110~ i l i y I I C 113s I I I I ( ~cv(11i115lt 111rol1g11 IIC d i t o ~ r i ~ l l ~ y tcri tirircs 1110rct I i 1 1 1 I 1 i i 4 R O I I C ~ I I Y C I L I ~ ~ t l ~ i r t ( lt ~si~ti~~ij C i~ Ic l i~ t i r ~ ~ 11i g o t ~ o 01 ~ ~ I ~ I ~ I I I I C I I C t l ~ r o r r ~ ~ l 11(l tI~i(~tlil Irost~ illIi I ~ I ~ I I I ~ ~ I c gt c r r i s ~ s prslI l r lt t lt(I s l l ~ l lt s [ ~ ( ~ ~ r lt ~ ~ I iligt~O-sc(lll~ +-)gt(l(boampr r y I I ~ IiiFI~idl Iristory of i t l t l o therrhr~c~ricl e ~ ~ f t l I b~igtiil i ~ i l ~ feliltxl~ t i ( t t itrVilg 1 0 lC ~ l t i 1 j t i 1 1 ~t l j ~ i l l

i1try t i i t r r i i r r t Ilvc ilrlly tticti Lo i i x t Iiov 1 1 1 i l ~ ltllcy co11~11gtr(~~c3rt I beicl-lt t11ij i I frit Sam- 11ij I c ~ r t ~ i ~ l q jc oi tilt a r ~ ~ o i r ~ ti t ~ t r ~ ~ c t i o t ~ i l l 1111s s(Io(J 01 give11 Yilt ~ x ~ l i l c SO I i i i C i O L I ~ is C X -t v i i l jr~tlgt wietllel I I I~ ) ~ ( Y ~ c I I ~ ( ( t l ~~vircli t (IS t i ~ c l ~ ~ ~ i l i c i i ) ~

It Iln iccil sitid tllat oilr sili(gtoli llnvc lrcrcti~forc bcc11 to^ c r p [ ~ u ~ i v c lilt I t l i~iki l l l loit~t of ccotlorrry too

lnucll r1oncy cn~rno t bt e x l ~ c t ~ d e d toin giving i t~s i r l~c t ior~ ill ~ ) r o v i t l ~ ~ l l l ~ c air~t)t]nt 13 so a sc u i ) c r t ~ l c ~ l to give tho ~ u o s t irlstrllctioi~ tlr~t t l ~ c S L I I I I is capi)lc olaffb~tiing-Illat ij triiu cs l c r~( led is slvcd i t ] 1)oor rates i r ~jallu it1 ex~euscs of crir i~iual proseculior~s ill s ta tc prison ex-

I

~ i e n s r and more llinn treble in the genera l jirospcritb arid tiic valuc o l cduc ~ tcd over ul~cducafd I ~ l ic i~

IIBXCOC6

1 inti 1)cin sitnlilo cnor~gl l in tilrres ~instto siipjlosc tit ( i ~ i r pulllie siIrools were good 11l1ccs l i ~ r ciiiiclrerr aitl I i i l i i~ lg 110 dcsirc 1 0 s e e ~ni i re ii11-e tliilc~crrtly S r o ~ r ~ tlrosc oliiiy Iirrlt~st ~ i c~ ig l i l~o r s dctrr~ii i i let l to nvi111 iysoll o f s~ l c i ii r i~ t r~lc t iu i~ 1 scllt tllo o111y cliild IS t h c y liliirtc~tl 1 lrltl vlio was old cllo~igli to go A (1i~ilIit~r l i ( l r I ycir or liiorc 11111 tlic Z i~~~r l t l~ t siie wit11 tuIciii11~ good lircli Slit its aiici-ivircls b ro v - l~cn [ i~~ iiuwcvcr inti ~ I ~ ~ - - I i i l I I ~ c l t i [ ~ j ~ e d A convt ~s t f iu i~ wit11 ilir t~icllcr convircctl rllc tililt lic 11id 1)unisIlcd h e r ~~it l~orrt iuy lirovocntio~ hliis cliiltl litld b c c r ~ irti((r tile c a r e 0 otlior icirclierc ivjio Iind all rr~inirIcc~l rlrt

h e r ( l ~ s ~ ~ o s i t i o ~ i ~ v a srr1ilt1 arid i~i~i lI) lc I I I ( ~slicir(l itcvcr tjnfhrc rcceivctl n I~ low at 11ornc o r illoatl 1 t l io~lgl t tlro ca se n crncl one )rot on actooilt oStlic I~otlilp irljurg iniiicl~c Iilrt o ~ r aceourit of 111~ I ~ n r lcli_ct 1litt a I)rrtcl nirtl r ~ i i ~ x ~ o v o l ~ ~ d 1ll)crn ilie of nil innocc~i tii(ilt ~ ~ c r s o ~ i clliltl inlist ricccsarily prolricc u p o n llcr rrritrd A I(-

cciit tl(cisiotl o l t l ~ o 1litlitrs ciftllc tovil sliows ~viint i s t o bc csiiectctl froiii t1iil (lrl~itc~ oc~asi011Illion S I I C I I LII

t l ~ elc t f 1 1 1 ~ICI~(C ) i ~ ( ~ ~ i t no rc111r(1y t l i~ r ( - i~f l i~r t l s I 11~1s

fiirc 1)iit 111 rigltt l r i~ t i~c l i ~~ iontile spot i n olictlicilce to fl1o- l ~ ( ~ i i l i l i l i x ~ it iiicli tcaclr cvcry oito 10 dc-0 1 iiuc fciltl iii o-il ollliilg And vllo sli~ll say tlrat t i~isic liot a i l l ic~ s dirt) I f violcrlcc a~r t i 11r11tc i)i3cc 1111lst i)rcv~ilji t is 21 I ) O lt J ~ t l ~ t r tiv1111t fi70rIi 1)011 Y~I) s ~ I ~ I C

U I x i ~ iiiquiry I I~uul thtt litany oliier ~~~~~~~~cri Iraamp fiirflt norsc r l ~ ~ iriiic Yiio [iic~lts were zricrcd i ~ i i c t

e s ~ s ~ e r ~ l c t l i ~ i ~ ~ r l c l r c c t o oij-bril corild not c ~ c r t cirogli tin n sililal)ic atleiltioit to tllcir case foixl~Iiiifs too I discovcrctl vtro cc~ually loud rro~ir otl lrr sclltrnls

I vas cvciituilly cor11)ccd a- Ili~ndrctls Irtvc ~ I ~ O I IIic-fore to f i I ic I ~ I Cclilc tIIViiyj i~ild tllrfi 1lcsr iiito [ I I C 4tr(ltl9 or scild he r at cot l s idc~~al) ic n lirivito scIlo~l e spcnsc to Tliilst l i r o scc~~ l i r i gnly incj~iiry orlc iirsti~icc ol scIio~i ciisci~lii~c calilc t o 111y hnoirlctlgc Srom tilid a~ ido t ib t t~d

2 B

8011CC tilit I will mentiol for t he aiusetncnt o f t he Scllool Coillliiittcc

11oor i i ~ i lcailcd by mis t ~ i ie upoli n ~ i r ~ ~ c r i t ~ c i ~ t l ~ n t (JS11c 111 iiiilr) S C ~ I ~ ( I ~ S ~ I I ~ Ia C O I I I ~ ~ ~ ~ I Lt1itt 11is sorl lad I c l l I TI(cliild was I a S ~ I I I I I ~ ~ ~

viih I l i i i l t i t i i+tluvccl his Ilalld r i l i t Iiitl bocii (aten url-t l it ias 11iick a i ~ d swol11li b i t 1 1 t l lc b ~ u i q e s itid ilie s i~e l l r i l g (utci~dtcl lo t i ~ c elbow iitl nho-c it to sucli a dogrcc tiixt tllc l l i ~ ~ i d l i r i t l r (~ r s ( ~ n i f c ~ ~ -arid ar111 could l ~ c cl lor ul-c11 tIlc tlitlicr i11o is n o t L baiilc ilirctlor 1or III e s q ~ ~ i ~ e )11tI I ~ I -ccxrl a11 l i o ~ ~ ~ r a l ) l c ~ LII u~i t i t icd iridivi(iua1 v l~u (lr~ t ILK i l iv i i~gVISi i i i i~~l-ltlt~r t re-c ~ u c s t d to g~ to orc ol t l ic sciio v i t ~ l i i ~ c ~ ) r l ~ ) l ~ i i t com~rl i l tce lro 11vcd r l ra r it lr~rid B llcn tile laine wn i r ~ e r i o ~ ~ c d Nu suit1 t l ~ c f ~ t l i o r~ 1oor 11 i i l ia viil get n r ) jilsticc tiirir will g ~ ) illd tacc illy ~uris lct ion O L ~0 1 1 1 1 ~ I I I J L C ~ S iiidc wht~ I L I I I ~ ] i I e IVIS ci i~iic~ii ty r e ~ t r a i i i c d lroril scciiiiig this oirly pr~clicii)Ie triode (11 rctlrc b u t at Iclitl~ co~cliidltd a s I t l iois i~iJ t)IIi(r~ l~ l ivc doilc (my I I O ~ J L s~xlt lrrioig tlic r rb t ) 1 0 J o ~ l ~ ~ tt11e abusc mi tt~icIii boy iloinc l i i ~ tVLS iI1(2 rcsit l t

cillgcd i t 1 t l ~ c Ilrriviiig c ~ n ~ i l o ) ~ ~ ~ c i ~ t s ollicitirig tiitl3ssci mid ctclinj s i ~ i c l ~ s

I i t l ~ i s n e1c a solitai y cnse i t n-oid Lc )at1 cnor~fgil I lxt ot11~r3of I more iuwiivated 11aulc sic very corn- iC 3 411 I

f ~ L I Sit i tiat 1nlny cltizcria 1$110 coiiiiiii~ t~ th( ~ I I J ~ I C~iitl arc i1iirl)le to c ( ~ i c aiy ~ c i i c i t ircgtrl i t villo t es ~n - i i rg tiitir cllil~lrcii ti 1e iililrt crrciy 11cat- c] tiltr tiilci Illti-cs A~i l Ilcrc it i rli ioitiy of ~c- I~III[LIiit I ~ I I Slilf ( i t Y ziiit11oriti~svIlt) irrcst a1(1 ~ ~ I I C

i~lcivi(llidilth r c r~ i e l ly vli i i)pi~ig c1111i txi11111~ 110 ~ i i ) ~ d ~ ~ d l e ~ i l l cases vlc~e tlic I I I I I I I I I i ~ I I Idvi~c i t ] tiic shxic oL poor IIIII S cIiid is rl~iil~eltI liyt1i1J l i clt~igttc~l

I rct n c icXvcr lien 01 I rniiis t-nlir~g Igt i+tgt i1ij1ry lit]) o r to ( l i ~blcI I ~ I to t ~ c O I I ~ ~

~ gt $ L I I VVIIO a r c wi l t re thoMIIII-t i ~ ~ r ~ c e s trot v l i ~ t i n ~ zc i~o l l ) c i~ Iicjr~~c crillccl hr clays niid nceis by is setit ill0 scourging of tliecc c l lose i~ guardians of his te~i r fcr

Tl l c rc nre f i ~parents wlio car1 convci~icnt ly affi~rd to se l id tllcir cliii(1rer1 to a private school vIlo 2rc now lvil-l ing to put t11etn v l~e rc tlroy a rc su re ofrrotliitlg b u t a wliipl)irg or iilrly thing uscfi~l i u ~ c q r ~ i r c d to bc obtnin- ed o ~ i l y riiltler [lie i~ i i l i~e i i cc of botiily Icar to say notl~irig of tlie ci lkci tiint tilcsc daily es1lii)rtioris of i i i i~~ l l i c r~ce sovciity aid vint ofsc l l~cor i~nrarrd in~rs t t i i t ~ c upor1 tilu child s cisosition t l ~ r o ~ r g l ~ life

I l e t ei -cry I I I R I I v110 h a rr cliild to scrid to sciool or ever expcct3 to Ilavc orre aslt llimscll tlris qucsiior~--fj it is ~ i o i712j b i i s i i ~ e s sto see italo this j~aile ~ c i i i s c1ircciness is if gtgt (iPLUfiIliLS~l1

I n ai eslrrir~ition of comi)1iliiits liciiirc tlie School Eaar t l agains t RIr Claugll t h e Cilairtnar~ (tlic lltro A l r Otis) ol)srrvcd if tlre1c was any other Inan 11id cliargcs to i i~al tc to come fornord I havitig a 1iht of nulncs to prcvcnt any C O I I ~ L I S ~ O ~ Ii l l tlie bi~irress--Spolto in a low voice nI r Sucl~-a-one (nainc f i~rgot T i ~ i u privilege was granted to M r Cior lg l~ i t l i ~ i ~ tany o l ~ j c c - t ion) T l i c cljalrrrran M r Otis obsc rve~ l to I I I C Mr Jaqui t l l yon sl~oulcl not coirle Ilcrc to prcvert Irin

from gcttirlg i ~ i s brcail (Tliis rclnarlc causecl somu sIitrp sioctitlg bet -cen nn i i ldcrman ant1 11c CIiairnni~) rB7 iic ~icairirig I conceived to be this if Air blorgl~ was turned orit cl otiicc I I C lrad no o t i ~ c r rncnrs of ~ ~ i p p o r t (1111 Clougll rvouiI take it an irisult ii ally one shoirlcl ra te llirli r~nt lcr fivc t l ~ o l ~ s a n t l ) Conccivillg such re- marks fron~ a ge~ i t l e i~ r a i~of 3Ir Otis sf antling a s unbo- corniil arid r~rrjust indi~cct l m e t o write tire ibilowinp letter to tiic Sciool Conni~~i t tcc ~ v l i i c l ~ delivered tciwas Mr Oti with niy own h a n d

b ihe Cenejal lloarl of li e Sthocl Conitnile City rlf Ooslon

Ger~rrrrrx-Tn t l ~ ccxanlirrltion of witnesses on 1ri- day 1lut bcii~l-o your bonttl ~ ~ g a i ~ i ~ tJFcssrs Ciough and caper^ it was observed by tile Cliaiimnn that I

~i~ci i i ldriot cu r~ lc ti1rc lo p r e v c ~ i tn pelson from g r t t i ng klis bicld o r noicls to 1 i i i t cfiict N o w gci~ticnrcn it is a riotorion hct tiicct I caiiic t l icre i t 1 1 s o i ~ ~ eof roy fc~llow c i t i z c ~ ~ l ~ tu sirliiiliitc striocis c~itgcs igairist Blcssrs Clougil oucl Gallell as s c t iortll iir our die-n ~ o r i a l

P r c s ~ i ~ n i n gt1at I sliould liarc t11lt tcspcct slro~vn file wricir cvcry gaud citizcri is etititlctl to ciitlcnvoriiig rriy- fiell to sliow tliit 1cs1)cct to y o r ~ r 1)ori ti tiiat every good citizelr oogllt to riicit xciriirIlt ~ Y O I I I tile ( l i ~ i r i n z ~ ~ wountl(d itry fkclinys it1 s o i ~ i c dt~gicc lrr iriy Iiuiiil~lc oi)i i~ioijit 1~ s 1cj1igig t l ~ c ca sc i)cli)ic your I)oa~t l is r ~ s ol)crvcd i)y ~ritiiiy gci~ticrncn aicr tlio I J I ~ ( ~ ~ I Irad I j o i r r c l I l y o ~ l r bo~rtl sl~oultl iliiillc ~)ro i c rt o taiio any notice oiticis co~iii irur~icntion 1 sliould Ijc wi l i i l~g at x n j r titile to rcccive it lioiil your buard a s j o u 11iny tlriiilc just

Iii my oi)iiiior~that rcninilc from tlic Crniiri~al n0111tl mot hnvc bceii ri~liic ~g i i ~s t a cililtei~ of ~veai t i i and high staicing p r r s~ i i~ l i i l g a poor niau i s cirtitictl to astlilt rriuclr I C P I ) C C ~a s a ricli inart i f I I C COI I LIC~S l i ir i~sclf as n good c~ticrl I ~ c ~ ~ ~ c c t S i c I l ~

3ICiSIS JI~QUITZI Boslon NUV15 1831

I 1 h e p l ~ l ~ l i c ~ v i l lol jscrrc 1)y tlie a l ) r~vc le t te r t ha t I lind x n-eri~l ir i~l~goiiist ngriirst iir )efi)rc tltc tlecisiori ws t c r ~ ~ ~ i i i a t ( c l ant1 I vls cil imilc tiixt ifI scnt this lcl ter to tile bo~id i ~ e f o r c tic tlcciiiori i l rvoirlcl riot lrcllt lrry cairse biit ~ctircr I( ngaili5t nic-l tlctcil~ii~cclto xct iir n sti ~igli t f i~rwzrtl coiirse a i ~ d Itriovi~g llry CIIISO

to bc iilst l grc tllc I(tlcr to 3 i r Ois a ill irijurcd n ~ n r ~ i)r t l ~ c fiical decision trusting to iris nrngnnicnity

1 ~vili riov ~ r ~ e i ~ f i ~ ~ ifiict tliis tt~tle- oiro c c ~ i i r i ~ r r ~ i ~ ~ g man irr tile c ~ s c o i b l r Glrcr~diers ciiiid BIr Otis told lltln itid tlie ger~t lcc~lr l i n ~ i t i ~i11it nerit Irii-i~llrat s ~ i c l l criicity to a ciiltl was u si~rilia and tha t ~ o i i r e t l i i ~ ~ g should llc done to stop it h o w ~)leiso to ol~servc-all t e r i l nuiribfr of rirorc ca ses had occ~ i r r e t l at tiic s~itie scliool nntl rirore azji i ivati~igii l 11arl)arity arid c i~uei ty tllis sonlo nirl votetl t o kccp this g rca t instructor in oflice 1 s this consistency to tell a man ouo day t h i ~ t

21

hc Fvoull stop slcll cruelty aritl say it n a r n sltnrilc t o see a cllild so c t~ rc l ly citt 1 ) a1(1 tlicri vote to retniil this saltre nlnri in oliicc t l i ~ t ilrflictetl tile crriclty nftcr 11e t t r t l rcpe~tctl l11c siirric ol1iiiccs o~c r ngnili ailtl a g a i ~ I s c I I ~ t~ (llrc rcltl(r is rcgtcrictl to XI ~I i i~ t l t l t r ~ s l io~v tvllilt t l l e~ lJ I ~ C ( C to 3 i r Gtis snit1 respertiir iiis clliltl )

-hil t i + tire ~ c ~so i l t11lt soruc of orlr ricll nerr- S O I I R

a r c 1101 filtri~il ~ I I I I I ~ I I I I ~ I I I C Sro~it ~11oi~l v i t l~lootl lri(i- liii o r ~ t ot tlicir b~clta a as ~ i l i c~sc oiliiic ij it bcclriso L I I I ~ ill( aiiy better ilk scilooi t11lo ~ I I C [ I ~ I J ~

t11~111s cl~il t l Ijicl itoi i t -(gtvery o i ~ c (IS XI ( OI ~I Iicssc 1~li1t0vlet1~c sciii11 I~ok~ri bci~ic tile 1i1it ity so11 l a lt i l ootI I~oy--iic tllc iiiuriiti~r01 tiic clilss LC-

J ~ r ~ ~ ~ I( ~J~C~ ~ l I C I I C~ c L J I I I I lt I~ ~ c ~ ~ i ttt~ ~ I I I ( I + I c c ~ I ~ G Y s I I ~~ I I ce~iltl njt s ~ull t l I ailel s tc~rc~tiitri l l t l ~ t tor( tli~t ilc a so crucIy iizat fr [lot 1)roiluttllciilg

lrogtr ritr 13o10lt C ~ Z I T Y E G 3 ~ 2

70 t h e f ~ ( ~ i l o ~ s L l ~ eI gtgt lo) tG~iz~Llc ficrik~i11111-1IYI i~ f i~r~~r t e l J (~terd~yt l ~ t Ir 17

(iotiir igtistcr oIt11c prii~lie sc11c111l i t 1 i l ~ ~ ~ i i i ~ s - ~ t ~ ~ ( ~ ( ~ Iiild col~ittctl ( ldlgtci o ~ I I I ~ ( err O ~ I C o f i l i ~Y I ~ I I I gtciiiI-ars I I I ( I t l i ~tt l i c cast oti Llid 11s ~ I I I I ~ ~ I ~ii COII-i i t

t n i ~ i ~ i ( ~ t i o t ~ 1 I I H li~(l tI1it i t is r111k cttlircly l~~r ~ i t (~t r - - I n ctijlcr I S iO iic vis 111ost aiiriiciiiiiy iiti(-il ti-I) gctlc~iriii rho slv hid l)ihIi allr tr iio 11rtl iit~scc

I I i11a11y ~ I ( ~ I J I I ~ i l l I I I ~ I I ~i3~i ampI) i l i l ~ l ~ c ( l A$(~lc-~l~~ccL

~ t ~ i t l t l l r t i i ~ ) hi3 IIJClt loollt(( i110re like t i t~ s (~ I ~ I ) ~ I I I I I cor~lt l cliiparc it to I I J n t i 1 1 I ij rhiItl wa5 ttic~r to t he JTitjors rrtn~il 11s llci ~ ~ i l l l ~ l [ ( I ills I I O I I ~ I I a t ] ( c~tilcrs-tlie gtlayor stiitl it ~vi l - J ~ I I I C ~ L I ~ and o~lIlt trot to l ~ csr~ l i rc~i -~onrc~l i l pItoriltl i~c dolie xi~tv v ~ ~ tI1ii ~ C C I I ( l o ~ i ( gt Lbiti~~y le111g I J O I ~ I 11hur-in I I I I I I do t ~ o t l ~ i i ~ ~ t t ~ l ci1~11~1 LIIIC i~ ~ei 1 1 r 1 t 1i11 )ir it-- l i ~ tit ~cr11s t11kt L l i t l ~ c r i l l ( l~~c 111y~eIfI I O I V z r l ) ~ ~ IIIII vllosc clliltl Iins l~ce t l n~usetl ilns (tic l)ctoi-c tlic [rub-lit aigttl csposcd tllc v t i i ~ ~ ~ t l o r 1 1i11~1c It i l l i ~ e iirltl re-

J O Y I U C C I J Q ~ ~ ~ ~ I I S e r ~ ~ i s n ~ ~ ~ i N j--rinlic o f t l r c g r ~ l t l e i ~ l e n icntrcferrcd to o

wi t ] l mr to tllc 31ljors rvollls cart tic Ilad 1)) calliilg ori me in lalarjkiall s lrcet

81-iS yo11 i ~ i ~ r c y o ~ iI I C I ~ lost ~ 1 1 i tlittle I i ~ i ~ r ~ z ~ i ~ i t y c r c r did posscss I lc_r oi joir to sto j i 11xt1 11ar1sc a Sew ~ I I ~ I I gt I I ~ S coisitcgtr i i a t crlrcIiy you 11ivc irtiiictcil on I 1 1 1 l r 1I I r i t i I O I I dliiltlrc~r 11l~cb c c ~ ~ i l l neclts to tlrcirctlt r j l ) yor11 Sci~ocil lrorn t l~cir o r~c l e s ns was 1)riitrcI to tilt Sc i~oo lCo~t~nrittcc-mcrunds I I I r 1 1 c I i t i Collsidcrr t r i c ~ ~ ~ r i ~ c c X r Cioltgll 1111 lilnriy angry Ilill~oredby litticf ~ o l i i ~ ~ s c i ~ i l d r c ~ l~g i i l l y o ~ i dtiic~iiI~ a srllal still voicr i t wi l l ie Ilcard Iay--n~u~~ya i lnrc~i l s 1icalt 112s bled f i r

your ~rnji lst c r u e l t ~ TJlinlc of tltc cliildrcn that hatre

beet1 clrivcrl fro111 ~ O L I I SC ICI~I~ sonle lo be ii~ttlid on tl10 whnlves ~ r l t o ror~ld otltcrvist 11arc 11cctl it] tile sciotl

I 11tre Lvcn told t l ~ ~ t no c11iliI Ilas beell si tucii ill pollr sclcol to leave a miirk s i l ~ c e tltc itivestigitior~-ifso I ~eioicc t11lt good hls corile clut ot it f i u t is it not t ~ r o ~ ~ g l ~Scar illat 11as c ~ r b t d I I I I~ 11lt1sgtion flitit O ~ I C ~

l i t ~ c w rlo bounds ISt11~1c ntnlt i i ~ tlie collnrliur~ity t ha t bc l ic7~ca tile sci~olirs any bctlcr no tiiajl six ~ r ~ o ~ i t l i sago

I t)cg of you ol1cc rnorr to subtlrlc nnd corltro~ll titnt evil liti c r i ~ c ltiirpocitiou otyorrrs l i ~ r X cii~ditliv I~c i i e r e il ycl~i s l~ou ld ilijilrc i t i io t l l~r cllild a s you ditl trinc all 1111 S c l ~ o o l Cortltliittccs i ~ i1Eostoli ~ o ~ i l t l rtot slrc y c ~ i l

larosn~s~1cicr4lr P S-8Ir E1ir1)cclc l ~ n d n son n1irsctl n i i ~i l n Y g

airicc for n tritlitrg cause--tile ititlicr Iiud an i~gtt t r ie~v cvitl~ tile gc~i t Ier l i ~ l l it1 tlie sci1lt1o1 yard i~oi~sc 11 is sn ic i tha t t i ~ i s l ~ r i i ~ ~ i t t i ~i n i t r ~ ~ c t c r sc o i ~ ~ i t e l ~ t ~ ~ cc1111g~d very c1uicr to a tleadly ilalt

T o the Cellera1 School Co21ia1illcc cflie Cily ojIjosl~~l G E S ~ ~ E I I S

1 worritl propose for your consit lc~ntiori tilc pril)ric- t y of a b o l i s l ~ i i ~ g tltc hi fliit fill Clorigil I ~ n s n sh r~ i~ led iri ~ ~ i c I i ~ i ~ ~ r l i r i g in riglit t ~ l t 110scl~(l t~r~ 111s iil~ool i~

otltcr Irinstcr ever i~ratisrtl to liiy l i~~cgt - I c t I~ltgt 11 is rint ortiv disgraccfi~l 11irt n i ca r~ n~rtl c o ~ i t c u ~ [ i t ~ l ~ l c ~ to give i~

nicltrlarrle to In intioretit s c l ~ o l n ~ to gr~tiij tliis i~rstttlc- tors g1c 111i11tl-no onc l ~ u t 33r Blloi~glts slrinl) ~ v o ~ t i l l be g i ~ i i t y of S I I C I I corttl~tct Sciiolii~-s1are bie~i tacl~ arxy lioin tlic l T r ~ ~ h e ~ uschool otr t l ~ i +nccorlit

I1 yoar I i o ~ ~ o r a l r l o sl~orritl trinr i n r sp r t l i en tfioritl i t t o il)olisl~ cor11nriI ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ i ~ l i r r ~ c r ~ t scltools 1in tile mo t~ ld solicit you r scr ious i t t ( t n t i ~ l ~to t l ~ e cvil illat xi11 r c s u i t i t1 n p i ~ ~ ~ i s i t r i ~ c i i i schrystcsnl of col])o~~l inltulttcel lo Iliintls as Im Cl~~tlt--n l r i i i r ~ [)as-o f ~ i r gr~~ol~i l t r lc~ s i o l ~ s n mnn t l l ~ t strilics littic ci3ildrci1 tricc l i l t 1 iiiiico nncl tllon s ~ y s h c (lit1 not sttitc bill o r ~ r c $-ill you r l i o ~ ~ o r l i ) l cUo~i-d cottsidcr tltc g rea t evil trtit is ~ t t c t~ t l -ed by r i i c l i l~n i~~ ing n e w otc l i i ldrc~l in school-n 111c1lol

Jlnsnn $larch 121 1131

P

T O T E T E PllilTC IZGiIlN

1 n i n i l n ~ y ~ c l i o i i l l i s op j io r tu r i i t y to t11r E11111ir~ to a n 7 i l l a t tI1i3 LIOOJlt i5 o111y a 11rcfi1c(tt o t 1 1 ~~IITCS 1111t car1 i gt c Lro11t fi)rvt~tcI s t t l ) ~ t ~ ~ t t ~ ~ i e ~ I Tflr~ I I I ~ taiiist I HI~IKI as t ir irc s t i l l i l iiv I i i ~ t c r ~ t l g i o a1) fnite ~ I I ~ P It+iiii +Iitcric~lto f l l c f l i b l i c l i in l l l l i c csciit OIIC ~i kci l ~ a f i i ( l i v ~ t s ~

scl iool I~ ~ I I oio ol t l i lt II~IG-(IS ibictl i111 11t 11c I IZ~ I~ pl iyltltl i ~ t t ~ ~ i t ~ I I C II IltX1i~Jl i~ r ~ I I ( gt I I I J ~~~J I I i ~ ~ i gt i ( ~ 110t ~IILJ(~( i i l gtt~t 11t1t t l ~a l l i i q gt ~ i (gtn t s t i l t k tx ~ ~ ~ ~ i ( ( l ~I(gt~IIC J i ~ t h i ~ l a s t r r i i~st gttlt( l t11(gtl r f gt Ii1(1it111 l i ~ i yper-sistctl t hx t i ~ c 11itl l io t i t r IIIL~I~~ n i t I i lt i ~ t f1111crin-I I I t i t i i f I I I a I (i11010 ~ i i I tI a I o t o t t I t I nlst crriiiy niic11 ti^ 1gtoy v i i i l ~ i occ t ~ to t i le ct i r i~t- 11e l h t l ~ t ~ ri t 1 t t l i~t t i t l ~ i s Y+ IIIL(IIalIklttoc17 (lo b ~ c r v c c l tii IIC IIII~IJCI~ltlog ts I l i s c l ~ i l t l vis 1)citcix VOIICI I

~t lC l 0s h j r h ~ ~ l l l d i l ~ ~ ~ 11yIlrs)llS IS l i i c ~ i - t ~ ~ i ~ l ~ ~ lt ~ 1 1 I O f 1 I c l l lw cilizr71in 13llnt do yor i t l k i i ~ i i oi t he cor id i lc t ol il~ CIltLI~II 1s it sLc

ti) l l~(gtri 1 1 1 ~s11l111ortol irly ratio1)11 II~II Y i i t i c lor r(~iJIl r i l l a l low m e t o say nlore i i t pl-ee~it

an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif

TIIPla te decision o f t h e Sc~ool Conln~ittee and the injustice of tha t decision has induced rile to lay tile following pages before you I Ilavc two olbjectc in v i e w F i r s t in showing what c rue l barbarity has b e e n carr ied on in tlic Naylrcw School fbr tlic last two years under Iflr Clough-and secondly t o sllow tlrc ilielns t h e manne r and mctltod madc nse of by a Sew ooi 3rr(llougliu

t o sustain llirn in otficc aga i r~s t tlie wslres oi t h e people i n tha t district TVitli tllcsc o1jects i n icv 1 proceed with t he case of n OIL

P r e v i o ~ ~ qto the Mouitorial Sys lcm goi-ig into o ) c ~ a t i o r ~ my son mcnt to tllc Dernc-s t rcc t Sclool Grtcca o r eigll- ecen ~nontlis under tile inn1ruction of 3Ir ko)insor nuid Rir liitney-during illis tiinc Ilc u7as r evcr s t ruck a blow to leave a marlc by t l ~ c s c riiastcrs lie 1cnrit Ilorc rn t11~ first t l ircc montlis under tircse instructors ellail Iic did undcr Mr C lo i~g l l in one yelr llci~tlic boys syslenl vent into ope ratio^^ lie ~ J S tratgtsScrrcil to t h e

f i l a y l ~ e wScllool unde r RTr Clougli 11ctc re t~ld t o pass througli scncs of liurnilintion and dcgrnd~iior s ~ l c i i ns

being w l ~ i l ~ ~ ~ e c l a new rrrling (Slicok tiifor riot Setcliin day the olcl one was fillcci anti fi)r 11ct gciirig lilrcl ics-soris tha t n o boy could ge t ant1 n nurl~icr of lirinoi oKcnccs Tlc stood it from nlnntll to )110t1 1anti1 hi fatal day arrived that almost scaled his ire-On tlt ti^ Ile was re i ld i~ig and calnc to tlre wovtl cl~~ictc~iickind could not pronounce it t he boy liad i~~r~ziitrcntnn i ~ his s p e e c l ~ (born s o ) h e was s c ~ tu p l J r r Cloi~t~ and bent I I ~ s tarted ou tthis in l~nruan lnnn until tlo ilicii

of his back through tlriclc clotllcs Ilow tllc boy g31





































I

7 4




















P I )

















a j i d t o


- --- Z I S ~ ~







J it Airavay fcti










witlicti L j ~ ~ T

igtc ~ICLlt









A lt - 2 i I i 3 i

i 1 3 - lt lt -Lr7

ci31i

8 r-a ~ - - - - ~- A lt q 1 lt- - 1o f r











Rca JIr JSII ICYSO~






































I


IIBXCOC6









2 B























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif





































I

7 4




















P I )

















a j i d t o


- --- Z I S ~ ~







J it Airavay fcti










witlicti L j ~ ~ T

igtc ~ICLlt









A lt - 2 i I i 3 i

i 1 3 - lt lt -Lr7

ci31i

8 r-a ~ - - - - ~- A lt q 1 lt- - 1o f r











Rca JIr JSII ICYSO~






































I


IIBXCOC6









2 B























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif









P I )

















a j i d t o


- --- Z I S ~ ~







J it Airavay fcti










witlicti L j ~ ~ T

igtc ~ICLlt









A lt - 2 i I i 3 i

i 1 3 - lt lt -Lr7

ci31i

8 r-a ~ - - - - ~- A lt q 1 lt- - 1o f r











Rca JIr JSII ICYSO~






































I


IIBXCOC6









2 B























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif







witlicti L j ~ ~ T

igtc ~ICLlt









A lt - 2 i I i 3 i

i 1 3 - lt lt -Lr7

ci31i

8 r-a ~ - - - - ~- A lt q 1 lt- - 1o f r











Rca JIr JSII ICYSO~






































I


IIBXCOC6









2 B























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif









Rca JIr JSII ICYSO~






































I


IIBXCOC6









2 B























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif

































I


IIBXCOC6









2 B























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif























21




























P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif















P






an JIiQvl-rr

0001tif

0002tif

0003tif

0004tif

0005tif

0006tif

0007tif

0008tif

0009tif

0010tif

0011tif

0012tif

0013tif

0014tif

0015tif

0016tif

0017tif

0018tif

0019tif

0020tif

0021tif

0022tif

0023tif

0024tif

An appeal to the public: in a case of cruelty, inflicted ... on a cexid ofm3r=jaqux'bb, at t11e...

Documents

Transcript of An appeal to the public: in a case of cruelty, inflicted ... on a cexid ofm3r=jaqux'bb, at t11e...