AGENDA - wcboe.org
Transcript of AGENDA - wcboe.org
AGENDA
• REVIEW PROJECT BACKGROUND & PURPOSE• REVIEW PROJECT FINDINGS• REVIEW THE 4 OPTIONS DEVELOPED• OPTION COMPARISONS• REVIEW PROJECT SCHEDULE• COMMUNITY COMMENTS / QUESTIONS
TEAM
Becker Morgan Group, Inc. (architectural and site systems)
Gipe Associates, Inc. (mech./elec./plumbing systems)
Morabito Associates, Inc. (structural systems)
Wicomico County Board of Education
Mardela Middle & High School Staff
Citizens of Wicomico County
PROJECT BACKGROUND & PURPOSE• MMHS identified in WCPS Facilities
Masterplan as next major project• First step in the process was to
undertake Feasibility Study• Understand building is functioning
now, looking for systemic & programmatic items that need to be addressed
• Develop Options for addressing needs and completing the Feasibility Study
FEASIBILITY REPORT REQUIREMENTS• MD School Construction Program Section 203
• Applies to all new construction and major renovation projects• STATE REQUIRES A MINIMUM OF TWO OPTIONS BE
EXPLORED AND ASSIGNED COSTS• Forty-year life cycle cost comparison of each option considered
• CONTENTS• Executive Summary• Summary Educational Specifications• Proposed Budget• Proposed Project Schedule• Existing Facility Inventory Data• Existing Condition of Site & Building Components• Other Planning & Design Considerations• Major and Minor Educational Program Advantages for all Options• Local Board of Education Action
FLOOR PLAN: BUILDING TRANSFORMATION
SITE PLAN – AERIAL
EXISTING SITE
SURVEY FINDINGS
SYSTEMS:• Building envelope does not meet current energy code.• Limited athletic event parking.• Inadequate grading around building/portables.• No major structural concerns.• Mechanical systems at end of useful
service life.• No fire suppression system.• Outdated fire alarm and life safety systems.• Inefficient/high consumption plumbing
fixtures.• Electric gear beyond useful service life.• Inadequate ceiling systems and lighting
levels.
SURVEY FINDINGS
PROGRAM:• No secure entrance vestibule (Planned for construction in 2019).• Poor campus security.• No separation of buses and vehicles.• Nine portables support current instruction.• Difficult to separate Middle and High School populations.• Inadequate space to accommodate instruction and support
services.• Gym Lobby used to support P.E.
program activities.
FLOOR PLAN – FACILITY FUNCTIONS
SPACE COMPARISONSSpace Description
Administration
Guidance
Health Suite
Instructional Programs
Instructional Support
Family and Consumer Science
Art Education
Computer & Business Education
Technology Education
Music Education
Physical Education
Media Center
Student Spaces
Foodservice
Building Services
Total NSF:
Circulation & Wall NSF
Total GSF:
Existing
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Proposed
3,700
1,300
960
24,100
9,750
1,700
1,600
2,000
2,900
7,140
22,650
5,200
2,200
6,800
6,190
98,190
41,976
140,166
Total existing NSF includes 9,330 SF in portable classrooms
OPTION 1
SITE UPGRADES• REVISED PARKING LAYOUT – SEPARATE BUS/VEHICLE TRAFFIC
BUILDING UPGRADES• HAZARDOUS MATERIAL ABATEMENT• COMPLETE MECHANICAL SYSTEM UPGRADE
Air-Cooled Variable refrigerant Volume (VRV) System• COMPLETE ELECTRICAL AND LIGHTING UPGRADES• COMPLETE FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEM UPGRADES• SELECT BUILDING ENVELOPE IMPROVEMENTS• SELECT ADA UPGRADES• ADD WALLS TO ENCLOSE 2 OPEN CLASSROOMS
OPTION 1 SITE
OPTION 1 FLOOR PLAN
SPACE COMPARISONSSpace Description
Administration
Guidance
Health Suite
Instructional Programs
Instructional Support
Family and Consumer Science
Art Education
Computer & Business Education
Technology Education
Music Education
Physical Education
Media Center
Student Spaces
Foodservice
Building Services
Total NSF:
Circulation & Wall NSF
Total GSF:
Existing
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Proposed
3,700
1,300
960
24,100
9,750
1,700
1,600
2,000
2,900
7,140
22,650
5,200
2,200
6,800
6,190
98,190
41,976
140,166
Option 1
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
OPTION 2
SITE UPGRADES• REVISED PARKING LAYOUT – SEPARATE BUS/VEHICLE TRAFFIC
BUILDING UPGRADES• ALL OPTION 1 SCOPE UPGRADES • CONSTRUCT ADDITIONS AT MUSIC, GYM, AND ADMIN. AREAS• RENOVATE SPACE FOR RELOCATION OF SOME BUILDING
FUNCTIONS
OPTION 2 SITE
OPTION 2 FLOOR PLAN
SPACE COMPARISONSSpace Description
Administration
Guidance
Health Suite
Instructional Programs
Instructional Support
Family and Consumer Science
Art Education
Computer & Business Education
Technology Education
Music Education
Physical Education
Media Center
Student Spaces
Foodservice
Building Services
Total NSF:
Circulation & Wall NSF
Total GSF:
Existing
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Proposed
3,700
1,300
960
24,100
9,750
1,700
1,600
2,000
2,900
7,140
22,650
5,200
2,200
6,800
6,190
98,190
41,976
140,166
Option 1
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Option 2
3,414
1,390
1,060
24,694
3,592
1,807
1,674
2,056
3,433
6,132
21,673
2,622
-
6,408
5,162
85,117
21,656
106,773
OPTION 3
SITE UPGRADES• REVISED PARKING LAYOUT – SEPARATE BUS/VEHICLE TRAFFIC
BUILDING UPGRADES• ALL OPTION 1 & 2 SCOPE• DEMOLISH MEDIA CENTER AND CLASSROOM WINGS• CONSTRUCT A 2-STORY ADDITION FOR MEDIA CENTER,
CLASSROOMS & SUPPORT SPACES• FULL ADA UPGRADES THROUGHOUT
OPTION 3 SITE
OPTION 3 FLOOR PLAN
SPACE COMPARISONSSpace Description
Administration
Guidance
Health Suite
Instructional Programs
Instructional Support
Family and Consumer Science
Art Education
Computer & Business Education
Technology Education
Music Education
Physical Education
Media Center
Student Spaces
Foodservice
Building Services
Total NSF:
Circulation & Wall NSF
Total GSF:
Existing
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Proposed
3,700
1,300
960
24,100
9,750
1,700
1,600
2,000
2,900
7,140
22,650
5,200
2,200
6,800
6,190
98,190
41,976
140,166
Option 1
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Option 2
3,414
1,390
1,060
24,694
3,592
1,807
1,674
2,056
3,433
6,132
21,673
2,622
-
6,408
5,162
85,117
21,656
106,773
Option 3
3,575
1,390
1,060
26,264
10,290
1,807
1,674
2,056
3,433
6,132
21,673
5,200
2,600
6,408
7,700
101,332
41,761
143,093
OPTION 4
NEW SCHOOL• NEW SITE REQUIRED• LOCATION TBD / SITE UTILITY IMPACTS UNKNOWN
FLOOR PLAN• CONCEPTUAL LAYOUT ONLY• 140,166 GROSS SQUARE FEET PER IAC STATE REQUIREMENTS• GEOTHERMAL HEATING & COOLING MECHANICAL SYSTEM
OPTION 4 FLOOR PLAN
SPACE COMPARISONSSpace Description
Administration
Guidance
Health Suite
Instructional Programs
Instructional Support
Family and Consumer Science
Art Education
Computer & Business Education
Technology Education
Music Education
Physical Education
Media Center
Student Spaces
Foodservice
Building Services
Total NSF:
Circulation & Wall NSF
Total GSF:
Existing
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Proposed
3,700
1,300
960
24,100
9,750
1,700
1,600
2,000
2,900
7,140
22,650
5,200
2,200
6,800
6,190
98,190
41,976
140,166
Option 1
3,484
971
442
23,806
2,564
1,807
1,674
2,435
3,433
5,786
16,480
2,622
-
6,408
4,862
76,774
20,195
96,969
Option 2
3,414
1,390
1,060
24,694
3,592
1,807
1,674
2,056
3,433
6,132
21,673
2,622
-
6,408
5,162
85,117
21,656
106,773
Option 3
3,575
1,390
1,060
26,264
10,290
1,807
1,674
2,056
3,433
6,132
21,673
5,200
2,600
6,408
7,700
101,332
41,761
143,093
Option 4
3,700
1,300
960
24,100
9,750
1,700
1,600
2,000
2,900
7,140
22,650
5,200
2,200
6,800
6,190
98,190
41,976
140,166
BUDGET / SCHEDULE COMPARISONS
Estimated Total Project Cost:
Estimated Escalation (3% @ 4 yrs Option 1&2 / 3% @ 5 yrs Option 3&4):
Estimated Total Project Cost with Escalation:
Potential Project Start Date:
Potential Project Duration:
Estimated Gross Square Feet:
OPTION 1
$23,105,000
$2,899,881
$26,004,881
2022
18 – 21 months
96,969
OPTION 2
$31,358,000
$3,935,705
$35,293,705
2022
30 – 33 months
104,909
OPTION 3
$61,948,000
$9,866,710
$71,814,710
2023
33 – 36 months
143,093
OPTION 4
$75,206,000
$11,978,366
+$87,184,366*
2023
21 – 24 months
140,166
* Site acquisition and utility upgrades excluded
Option 1: Limited Renovation
$26.0 M96,969 SF
Option 2: Renovations / Minor Additions
$35.5 M104,909 SF
Option 3: Renovations / Major Additions
$71.8 M143,093 SF
Option 4: New Construction / Replacement
$87.2 M + Site/Util.
140,166 SF
OPTION COMPARISONSProgram
• Accommodates space types, quantities & sizes
• Accommodates all program spaces under one roof
• Accommodates preferred function adjacencies
Facility Environment
• Existing structure constraints
• Site Circulation
• Building circulation efficiency
• Location
Construction Logistics
• Phased construction impacts to costs/ Swing space required during construction
• Project start date / Duration of construction
• Site costs
• Overall project costs
PROJECT SCHEDULE
COMMUNITY INPUTWAYS TO PROVIDE INPUT
• MAKE COMMENT TONIGHT
• EMAIL SUGGESTIONS TO: [email protected]
• VOICEMAIL MESSAGE ON THEPUBLIC INPUT LINE BY CALLING:
410-677-5251