AB 617 Update: San Joaquin ValleyShafter and Fresno

Cesar Aguirre, Central California Environmental Justice Network and

Kevin D. Hamilton,RRT, Central California Asthma Collaborative

Valley Steering Committee(s) Have Vision● The South Central Fresno and Shafter Steering Committee(s) quickly saw the

opportunities and possible threats from pollution sources outside but adjacent to, the

initial boundaries, and the existing source inventory accuracy against ground truthing.

● The SCF SC has come to a consensus believes AB 617’s geographic boundaries to

include the top 1% of CalEnviroScreen AND to capture Marks to the west and American

to the south.

● The Shafter Area SC came to consensus early on to expand emissions inventory to 7 mile

diameter .● Both Shafter and Fresno Steering Committee’s have demanded the inclusion of Pesticide

monitoring. Additionally, Shafter is adjacent to a number of large dairy operations and

demands Dairy emission monitoring as well.

Community Steering Committee Update● There have been 4 Steering Committee(SC) meetings to date.

○ Air District, SC introductions, overview of process, work toward clean air to date,

AB 617 SC process and planning and proposed meeting schedule. Initial

governance model was proposed.

○ Charter discussion and adoption was accomplished in meeting two .○ Meetings three and four were primarily boundary discussion and source review.

Community recommends expansion to include top 1% CES census tracts in

Fresno and a seven mile diameter circle centered in downton Shafter. The

Steering Committee by majority vote, adopted the expanded boundary (see

maps) in both communities.

Community Steering Committee Update (cont.)● Early on EJ groups from both Shafter and Fresno reached out to the district to meet and plan the initial

meeting. A commitment was made by both to continue this process.

○ In a subsequent SC meeting residents expressed concern that these meetings were taking place

without resident input. As a result, residents and all committee members were invited to future

interim meetings.

● There have been numerous conflicts between the District, residents and EJ representatives. Governance,

interpretation and translation problem.● Residents have expressed concern regarding the apparent lack of cultural competency and sensitivity by the

facilitator and some air district staff.

○ We suggest the District and facilitator participate in an EJ led training to address this.

South Central Fresno

Rohrlda

"' ..,

J

rodon

. ~

J i ,.; z

w ..rm ...

z Sicmi Sky Parle W HwNlon Aw

Wkl !Aw

" w

0

W~lw

Gordon

UC! .,, DIA W UlAlU

z i

Glorierta "?. . C1ovis J <"l.OVtSLUI

j S..,_WAVl,.UI

Tarpey Vlllage

Ai.hllll'IA.., r,.

0

0 -Y<> nl

Alrpan

loams

A 0

Cecile __ ...,__,..,...,. Star

< 0

CalEnviroScreen CES3.0 Percentile

.......

lvesta

Wolf

99th pctl 90th pctl

z

Clotho

z

-r PM2.5 Emissions (lbs/yr)

I • sa,aaa - 63,999

- 30,000 - 49,999

• 15,000 - 29,999

0 8,000 - 14,999

0 4,000 - 7,999

0 2,000 - 3,499

PM2.5 Emissions (lbs/yr)

• 60,000 - 79,999

40,000 - 59,999

• 20,000 - 39,999

10,000 -19,999

0 4,000 - 9,999

0 2,000 - 3,999

0 1,000 - 1,999

0 500 - 999

.- • · Penny-Newman rain • -~·; j:i.;i••-: Pacific S:hmce ,

r·~,,.;~·· ~. ' =·~ ~ ---=-:~-:;f::._.~f\?..,~. I ·. t:::-, " I .-:. I ,~-·~ ... ..I r ! " :, .. ~ ... • .., • • • ;ti:sj . t,.~--. - . .

': J k'sr-,,1i o,1••·• • __ ., , ~ -- •--- ~-- J I•· ac •'- -.:. ~ . _...._ M-11· •·.&!J. .. I ; •

,. ! ! ,J

' ,i .: ~ I·.· ... . ~ 7.

' • ~ -•Grur acorp~ t'• Miller, ,mg _. •· • ! .•. ,....,,.,____ ·-•rt "-, Foste~F rms • 11 • __ (t-.p , ,._.,. u· 1

• _ .- _

11

~ ,.. t

·..-,: ., ,1 1~ 1'_. --- f:"'; IJ-••fs ttl·n•g•..:_ ~ ~;--,r, - 11,..... I.· .. ,_. --~ ·1:.,,, • - • ' .,..- I"! •• I • • Peps, o ! .,., , ,.., 'I. , . . ·- ._..., ~ !

\ r rudential Ove! al~I Supp ~ illHII ', ,,:'\,. "1 ·-~\I-~~ ; i;;i ~~~--i dl io Bravo ~ I r-: "a(' . JI ·:• ,•,•• --· ~. --:~ • -·: ,-'-- • J • I , Beef Packers•.,.,... . ,, ,..,.e,; • - .,, •-•• --: --~l ' ~ • ''Stra~ oods ', 1·. . GI (PPG}

- , _.... L ~-I . ...., 11 "' • · ' e ~- •'• • .. ~.- .,_, ~ 1 1tro Flat ass • •;,t . ~ - ~ ' ! a ~r· ..., ... • Cemex.a •• • • \• ~

1 - ,.

1

Cedar Ave Recyde,1

•• i "! w~;tro~k: •• ::a- ,. I 11

" . . . t -. I at·~ ... J - • :Iii • 4,. •1 .

Ammonia

Aldehydes

Styrene

::.. I . ~, ·t1 • i ··=- • ~" .~. 1..:•'-"• . t . r-. - , ·--·~~- . .,,. l "-~ . ;; . • l: •e: ,:,,_. .. .. j~. :';io __ _ :L.,c- •-[ . • Tesse. nderro- I ' I ' .... I..... . ... ,. .. .,..,. . ' ·~l.,,_.,, Ill I .• j ".;, - · -"c:1,;.rn, Maw;als< , \· ·•• .

1 • I _ ,. ' • O ' ~

·-p. I • , . • • •· ,. ~ 't, !•1,. •,-.· Wj estCoast.cf~Fera_~e i

I W M1chelesenPaca g,ng ~ _ _ ,. ~ -~ - ":"~.,.•"t•i i,~,: . • •!"'"':ii ' -t. - ' ~.1"'i: . ., ... ... • I

' '"!••:• .,.. ' .. . • 1 I f • ,. " · •·· -, r. • ..=_ -; ~ .. ] .-..,~E··- •.. =- -; ..... , "··• -- - - .,. Gas Vapor

IIIJll'i ... . l - ~ __ _.:.,:_......,L'~ -· 1,,........,....,.,,.,...,,. __ _ , I --: -- .. ·~· -r, . :J - - -1 .... - ·'· ~ • " . ~ .;. - __.._ ..... __. ----­- •- ·.,·-

• Purple Air Monitors

I t: !-.u

PM2.5 Emissions (lbs/yr)

• 50,000 - 63,999

- 30,000 - 49,999

- 15,000 - 29,999

0 8,000 - 14,999

0 4,000 - 7,999

0 2,000 - 3,499

o 1,000 - 1,999

··,-··

' ,,-,. l ~ .. --.::·.-; -· . _i·

., J -{

__ J: I I I •I

I .. . .

- - I - -. Beef Packers • , •·• ....

··• .;~~

l !

I

' -- - --: ­M1chelesen Pacl grng·

! a _

's, ......... ";J' ....

~ I l

nta Fe Pacific Pieeline

, ..... , .... ,_ ·- - - - -

.... • ~-.,.i,_ ·-·

8tlmon1 Avenue - -t (

, --------1

'"''"'Chaff~'\' <I ·, •• , ! #-~ ~, =_-_ -_ -_ -_- J .... ~-....----,, --~ \ 8elmontAv1nu• Belmom Avenu. ~,nut

~+J> j ® ~ i

., ;c

i

@

!:2 ~ s I Dtvi.sadero Si E Tulare Av•

i;;

; E Hun.1iogton ~vd E Hun1ilngton Ave Ii(

E Klno• ~nyon Rd Fresno

®

E TularaAvt

~ IM--- I --; ., W KHrnoy Blvd

f E Butl-tr Ave EButlarAve

WChurchAve

West Park

WNorthAve

.,

j !

I L

!

-WJennnAve

WCllifomi:,Ave

-,, l - --.

I I

W Cernrat Ave

w Amenc1n Ave .,_,.____~

----+- , .. .-n . __ ,, .. 1.-........ ,-.

Goldleaf

. i

Legend

D c.y~-m43...,.. • Cly~-2.017 19....-..

D S(Jl~-1.053.1$"""

e

Central Ave

rlcanAvt

E KJngs canyon R•

Lone Star

., I E North Avt

!

EC

EAm1

Air District vs Community Position-Fresno1. CARB approved boundary cannot be modified to this level.

a. The community proposed boundary is home to the most disproportionately burdened neighborhoods in the entire state.

2. Too large of an area to expand.a. Compared to other selected communities, Fresno would not be the largest.

3. We have a tight timeline and we need to keep going. No time to bring new people up to speed.

a. We agree. The process needs to keep moving. We are willing to help bring people up to speed and meet more often to meet the deadlines.

4. Southwest is its own community and we can try again another year.a. Fresno will likely not be selected anytime soon again.

Shafter Area

Palmo ._,,. ..

-.... --t

(.m .. ~

I

' 0 ~b

~~ t '\.

,:

MaicMr"• Aw J 0

f

r M~cks . 0 Corner

~ ' I . f 0

WTWl'f' Avt z.

...........

Shaft•r

WllrdoHwy r E .... doHwy

.... _St .. ] u) 0 _ ..

Cheroke• Strip _,.s,

0 0 -

Shafter

Wasco

Source :CDPH

@

Legend

D 100mbutter

D 500m butter D 1kmbutter

D 2kmbutter

Dairy locat,ons by cattle population

50-3,625

• 3,625 - 7,201

• 7,201 - 10,ns • Cities

D Counties Census - Population

0-7,490

7,491 • 14,980 14,981 • 22,471

22,472 • 29,961

- 29,962 - 37,452

+A LEGEND

Generators of Hazardous Waste

h 'Tl I

♦

Permitted Hazardous Waste StorageFacilities

bHazardous WastePercentile

... > 90 t o100... > 80 t o90... > 70 to 8 0

> 6 0 t o 7 0

, C f ' \ t , , . . . C . f \

?

Bureauof LandManagement Esri HERE Garmin USGS NGA EPA USDA NPS

-

I

+ ~

t I I

_ _ _ • I • • I

• -, --. I - II' • II .......

A LEGEND

Toxic Release Facilities

/

Toxic Release Facilities

(Mexico)

•

Toxic Releases

Percentile

• > 90 To 100

• > 80To 90 / • > 70To 80

• >60To 70

>50To60

..... ·-- ~-

/

Bureau of Land Mana ement, Esri, HERE, Garmin, USGS, NGA, EPA. USDA. NP; ~,•~1

PM 2 .5 Results

Census Tract 6029004101 has 4,917 people.

The indicator represents the average concentration of fine particulate matter, or PM2.5, in the air. The data is from 2012 to 2014.

This census tract has a concentration of 18.760 micrograms per meter cubed (18.760 µg/m3). The PM2.5 percenti le for t his census tract is 100, meaning it is higher than 1000/o of the census tracts in Cal ifornia.

A LEGEND

PM 2.5 monitors used in 3.0

• PM 2.5 Percentile

... >90 to 100

... >80 to90

... >70 to80

... >60 to70

> SO to 60

>40 to 50

> 30 to 40

> 20 to 30

R, ,ro::, 11 nf I ::,nrl M::,n ::,aomont F<ri HFRF (;::,rmin I l<;r;<; l\lf'.;A FPA I l<;f)A l\1P<;

Original Inventory V. 7 Mile inventory

District Permitted Facilities Within Shafter Boundary NOx Emissions (tons/year)

DISTRICT ACTM

FACIJTY NAME FACILITY DESCRIPTION PERMITS ID

COUNT

"" APSG 'M-tOLESALE AUTO IOO'I' SIIM'I' COArwG m , AT-T 111081LITY TCLlCDMM\#IOCATIONS

DISTRICT DISTRICT ACTIVE

REGION ID FACILITY NAME FACILITY DESCRIPTION PERMITS 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

COUNT

.... AT-T MOBH.JTY TCLCCJ:IMMUHICATIONS

'"' AUKEIIAN DAIRY ait.a:YfMMS ,.,, CHt:MICAt. lCaMHG. STOIUGC AHO MTlllUT"ICW s 2183 AHDI ENTERPRISES CORP OBA SHAFTER SHELL GASOLINE DISPENSING 1 ,.,, AGltlCUl~MXIUCJS...acus,NG 02822 0.2822 02907 0.0232 0.0232 s 8291 BROWN· BRYANT SOIL ANO GROUNDWATER REMEDIATION 1 ,.. BAYER COTTOHaN#<IJNG

s 1737 CAUFORNtA RESOURCES PRODUCTION CORPORATIOII CRUDE Oil ANO NATURAL GAS PRODUCTION* 41 4.0695 3.3446 5.9591 15.3949 2.9923 ,,., SIOART AGIIICUl.f\J4W. NOOuCTS

s 3701 CITY OF SHAFTER GOVERNMENT SERVICES 2 0.0083 0.0054 0.0031 0.0032 0.0118 ..,, SKSfD CENTER INC ac.,tlCUl.TIJUJ. Hl00UCTS Hl'AAATIOH

s 3745 CITY OF SHAFTER GOVERNMENT SERVICES 2 0.0038 0.0018 0.001 0.003 0.0054 "" DI.AND GAS flCLD lllt'ACU

s 3362 CITY OF SHAFTER GOVERNMENT SERVICES 1 0.0016 0.0209 0.0034 0.0343 0.0273 "'61 feLltiU.SSMAT MAM.f"ACtlJliNCi CftlAOON 0 002!I 0.0010 00010 0.001' 0.001' s 3364 crrv OF SHAFTER GOVERNMENT SERVICES 2 0.0011 0.0 138 0.0138 0.0052 0.0256 ,.., CAL COAST ACIDIZ1NQ SERVICE Oil & GU flClO SlltW:U

s 3365 CITY OF SHAFTER GOVERNMENT SERVICES 2 0.0904 0.0457 0.0457 0.0052 0.0193 ,m CAUFORHlA PAPER PRODUCTS UC ASl'tW..TfllTSAHDCOATlHGS 0 4 247 0 42'7 0.31M s 2599 CODE PRECAST PRODUCTS INC CONCRETE BATCH PlANT 2 .... CJTY Of SHAFT£R G0\11.ltNMCNTSI.VOS 00041 0.0080 00369 00318 00597 s 7322 CON..fAB CALIFORNIA LLC CONCRETE PRODUCTS 7 0.1933 0.1673 0.2305 0.0309 .... CJTY Of SHAFTER G0\41tHMCHT SIIMCIS 00090 0.0827 00109 0.0108 00370 s 8952 FOREVERBOARD CALIFORNIA INC DRYWALL MANUFACTURING 1 "" CITY SHAFttR G0\11.ltNMCHTSlll'VK:ll

s 2139 FOX PETROLEUM INC. GASOLINE DISPENSING 1 .... CLEAN ENERGY SYSTEMS INC. (LlCfbC,owtltr.fNEltl.TIOfril

s 6593 GLOBAL FABRICATORS METAL FABRICATION 3 .... M£TA.L,AITSAHDNOOUCTSCOATWGOPl.lATlOH

s 8071 GOLDEN LIVING CENTER · S HAFTER SKILLED NURSING CARE FACILITY 1 0.0027 0.0027 0.0027 0.0027 ,.,. -""'°""'° s 8067 GREG'S PETROLEUM GASOLINE DISPENSING FACILITY 1 ,.,, ASl'MlTJlLTiANOCOANrtCidi " 0 4269 0 39112 0 41133 03741 0 4132 s 3474 HELENA CHEMICAL COMPANY AGRICUL TIJRAL CHEMICALS 1 "'' ..... • s 2369 JACO HILL 1 - ~ffllTSAHOCOAT\NGS

s 2417 J EFFRIES BROTHERS INC 1 .... .,.., ltfAO'I MJl COf,Ot(l[

s 239 JIFFY'S STORE 1 .,., lGltlCUL TUW. CKM.OLS s 3681 JOSE LUIS ALBERTO AUTO BODY COATING OPERATION 1 ..,., MITAL PNITSAND NOOUCJS COATING s 2443 KERN COUNTY FIRE STATION 11132 FIRE PROTECTION 1 s 105 MEYER'S BIG STOP GASOLINE DISPENSING 1 s 7801 OMNI FAMILY HEALnt illlvr 0.0153 0.0153 0.0038 0.0034 0.0034 s 1167 PACIFIC BELL TELEPHONE CO DBA AT-T CA 1 0.016 0.0154 0.014 0.0132 0.0149 s 1288 S • J QUICK STOP 1 s 1732 S&AMARKET N 1 s 7834 SHAFTER COLLISION PAIR AND PAINT SHOP 1 s 539 SHAFTER-WASCO GINNING COMPANY COTTON GINNING 2 s 7041 SHAA CRAFT INC, SPECIAL TRADE CONTRACTORS 4

s 7674 VERIZON WIRELESS "NORnt SHAFTER'" TELECOMMUNICATIONS 1 0.0064 0.0036 0.0045 0.0043 0.0021 s 1301 W!LBUR•ELLIS COMPANY AGRICULTURAL CHEMICALS 1

*Includes emissions from equipment spread over a wide area, not all within !he Shafter boUndary.

"" ~sowo tJ......_OI.ISnNG .,., AUTO MXIY 5".t.Y (OATlNG , .... G.t.SCl.ld:DISl'lNSN.

17" COMMU"-IC.AnoN SlMCD 00001 ,m ~tlCll lttlUl:US

14-ll CU.OfTUNION 00132 00073 00073 00078 00083 ,.,. A11tASN1 llAl.llNG».DSHAY,AUilf...:i

"" ---"" OllJllLOSHYUS .... AGIIIIC\AltJMlOO, NOUOUCJION .. ,.,, OllMDG.UllllDU.IMCU

rAUaCATl~•IOM~ ,.,, MITA&. 'Alll AtG NIOOUCU COATIHG OHUnoH

U II S(W(IU,(il ffll(t,I 07340 05222 08312 05707 0-u u ...... , ..... .... (i,l,_ltM.JMMi.,_~,uo, .,,. INC AVI0 IOOY s,tt.\'t COATING 0 11313 05708 03729 0 41133 0 4933 .... CiAOCINH wtt0UW1 0 3411 0 3417 oms 0111118 031:ie

"" CONSTl.ucnc)N WAfIIIM.S ,.,, G.AiCXM DdllJrrd--.

" MATUU1G.4SN(X)U(TION ,. 12 1825 108231 109332 107aoD 116312 .... SMO AtlDC.lAWl ll - ILICT.,.SO\"ICIS .... caUCt 01. '1lO)U(llON .... 0611a1Utl0N UNTO

IS2t 01$TfMU'IIC)N aNlllt 0 1176 0 1117

'" ~TMUCYhlUU 00047 00047 00047 00041 00047

" H"TIIOLIUM """1.INH 00040 00156 00405 ... J(l)(IM.~IU\IM(Hll(SU,IICH 00025 00025 00018 00018 ,,.. ......, ..... JtU LLC JUfNUfS

"" AS "'"°" .. "" ~n.llW.NOOUCTS NOCUSU«. 00175 00175 00041 0003t 000311 .... DO .... IMOfflTO'lt 0 11112 0 11153 02408 022n 0115.2 ... o.ut,,.wt..s .. "" flL[C0MM\.INlt.t.00N\ 00044 00000 00000 00040 00022 w, MATHERfORD ARTlftClAL Uf'T IYITE:MI, U C OII.AHOGASllllOS,(A\'ICC ,.., GASCUC~l~ ... , WOHDUIPUL OftCHARDS LLC ~~HIIOOUCJ"S ~

Air District vs Community Position-Shafter1. Boundaries should be expanded.● Committee members expressed interest in expanding boundaries to protect surrounding

communities

2. Voting and consensus needed reform

● During the first Committee meetings, community members felt overlook and lost as to aproper voting system within the committee.

3. Some members in the committee may have an conflict of interest

● residents feel their opinion is washed out by potential special interests on the committee that benefit from a slower/non inclusive process to reduce emissions

4. Distributing meeting prep materials in a timely manner

● Due to time restraints during the meeting, residents have asked for prepmaterials/agenda with enough time before hand to properly prepare

Thank you Any questions?