A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller,...

17
AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. B l a n k e n s h i p & S i l l e r A E R 2 0 1 2

Transcript of A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller,...

Page 1: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICEDr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D.

Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed.

Page 2: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

OUTLINE FOR TODAY

1. Discuss impact of the essential assessments for children and families.

2. Resources found in the Essential Assessments Rubric.

3. Highlight quality and content rubrics for improving instructional practice

4. Hands-on session with FVA/LMA/ECC reports.

Page 3: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

WHAT DO WE KNOW?

We have no standards of practice for completing or writing up an Essential Assessment (EA) QPVI is working on standards at current sites

Page 4: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

COLLABORATIVE STUDY WITH AER (N=163)

Representation from the NE, SE, SW, NW, MW, and 1 Canadian 54% have taught more than 11 years Most worked in a school district (38%) Most had 20 or less students on their caseload (17.2% 5 or

less) When asked if state required Essential Assessment (EA)

94% FVA 95% LMA 68% ECC

Participants were asked about each component of the EA rubric and the majority of participants included all component areas (79.8%-98.2%) with near/distance acuity having the highest ratings. The lowest rated components were ECC screening tool and formal reading/listening skills (79.8% & 81.7% respectively)

4 teacher efficacy questions were asked Most participants had the skills necessary to complete a quality EA

and interpret the results

Page 5: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

Effective Instructional Continuum Assessments Educational Programming Research-based Instruction Ongoing Evaluation

A research-based effective instructional continuum always begins with quality assessment data that drives both educational programming and instruction for all students with varying acuity and ability levels.

Page 6: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

EFFECTIVE INSTRUCTIONAL CONTINUUM

Data-Driven Service

s

Assessment

Program Planning

Instruction

Ongoing Evaluation

Page 7: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

Essential Assessments (EA) for eligibility, programming, instruction, and ongoing evaluation for children/youth who are blind or visually impaired Functional vision assessment (FVA) Learning media assessment (LMA) Expanded Core Curriculum (ECC) assessments in

the priority areas: The ECC Screening Tool allows for a strengths-based conversation around each of the 9 areas with the team choosing 2-3 priority areas to assess and address each year. In addition, the ECC screening tool found in the FVLMA (APH) allows for discussion in all 9 areas.

Page 8: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

A rubric is an authentic assessment tool used to measure professional’s work. It is a scoring guide that seeks to evaluate a professional’s performance based on the sum of a full range of criteria rather than a single numerical score.

Two Types of Rubrics Holistic Analytic

Page 9: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

What is a Rubric Authentic assessment tool Scoring guide based on a full range of criteria Working guide for teachers, administrators, &

families Why use a Rubric

Experts believe that rubrics improve professional's practice and end product

Page 10: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

What are the advantages to using a Rubric? Rubrics improve professionals’ performance by

clearly showing how their work will be evaluated and what is expected of them.

Rubrics help professionals become better judges of the quality of their own work.

Rubrics allow assessments to be more objective and consistent.

Page 11: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

What are the advantages of using a Rubric continued? Rubrics force the teacher to clarify his/her

criteria in specific terms. Rubrics promote professional awareness about

the criteria used in assessing peer performance. Rubrics provide useful feedback to the teacher

regarding the effectiveness of the assessment. Rubrics provide professionals with more

informative feedback about their strengths and areas in need of improvement.

Rubrics are easy to use and easy to explain.

Page 12: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE

Essential Assessment Rubrics (holistic/analytic) Adheres to the RIOT model

Review of records Interviews with families, students, and professionals Observations in multiple environments over multiple

opportunities Testing both formal and informal

Developed using two extensive literature reviews, input from Dr. Randy Jose, and continued professional dialogue and learning

Includes tips and resources for staff development

Page 13: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT RUBRICS TO IMPROVE PRACTICE Navigating the Rubric

http://earubric.com/

Page 14: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

EA RUBRIC

Page 15: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

NEXT STEPS

With a partner apply the rubric to your sample essential assessment report and complete the scoring sheet

Page 16: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

Page 17: A UTHENTIC A SSESSMENT R UBRICS TO I MPROVE P RACTICE Dr. Karen Blankenship, Ph.D. Mary Ann Siller, M.Ed. Blankenship & Siller AER 2012.

Bla

nke

nsh

ip &

Sille

r AER

20

12

RESOURCES Essential Assessments for Children with Visual

Impairments: Rubric Project found at earubric.com Karen Blankenship, Nashville, TN

[email protected] Mary Ann Siller, Dallas, TX

[email protected] Coy, Jackson, MO

[email protected] Prause, Columbus, TX

[email protected] EVALS, www.tsbvi.edu Resources for the ECC (RECC) at

www.tsbvi.edu www. familyconnect.org (student and parent ECC audio

messages @ teen section)